Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#35:  "Carousel"

This week Jess & Andrew talk about the classically controversial musical by Rogers & Hammerstein-- Carousel. They discuss the value of Billy Bigelow as a character, which romance is more relatable, whether or not the incredible music makes up for the problematic material in the story... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

56 mins
5/3/19

Featured Shows

About

  1. This week Jess & Andrew talk about the classically controversial musical by Rogers & Hammerstein-- Carousel. They discuss the value of Billy Bigelow as a character, which romance is more relatable, whether or not the incredible music makes up for the problematic material in the story.

Links:

Listen to "Carousel"

Social Media:

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Jess on Twitter

Andrew on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Jess on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jess McEnall: Hi guys, today's show is brought to you by Audible.

[0:03] Andrew DeWolf: Audible is offering our listeners a free audio book with a 30-day free trial membership.

[0:07] Jess McEnall: Just go to AudibleTrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs.

[0:13] Andrew DeWolf: Download a title free and start listening.

[0:19] Jess McEnall: It's that easy.

[0:19] Andrew DeWolf: Go to AudibleTrial.com slash musicals with cheese.

[0:23] Jess McEnall: Also, a huge special thanks to our patrons at Patreon.

[0:27] Andrew DeWolf: Our current patrons are John, Donna, Stephanie L, and Terry Needleman.

[0:32] Jess McEnall: They gave us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.

[0:36] Andrew DeWolf: We appreciate it.

[0:41] Jess McEnall: But you get a few extra perks.

[0:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like we and Andrew are gonna do a commentary on the musical Cats pretty soon that is gonna be for patrons only.

[0:48] Jess McEnall: It's gonna be exciting.

[0:49] Andrew DeWolf: I can't wait to find out what Cats is about.

[0:53] Jess McEnall: So there's some stuff coming up, and it really is rewarding for you guys to become a part of our Patreon.

[0:59] Andrew DeWolf: Also, you will notice in our description that we have an affiliate link.

[1:03] Jess McEnall: So how often do you guys shop on Amazon.com?

[1:06] Andrew DeWolf: I know I do it at least once or twice a week.

[1:08] Jess McEnall: I buy all of my weird movies on there.

[1:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, exactly.

[1:13] Jess McEnall: So why don't you shop there with our affiliate link down there in the description?

[1:17] Andrew DeWolf: Buy yourself something musical theater related, send it to us on Twitter, it helps us out, it helps you out.

[1:23] Jess McEnall: Everyone wins.

[1:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's gonna be great.

[1:27] Jess McEnall: Alright, let's get on to the real show.

[1:33] Jess McEnall: Hello, I'm Jess McEnall.

[1:35] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[1:37] Jess McEnall: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast ride where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater more.

[1:42] Andrew DeWolf: Well, how are you doing today, Andrew?

[1:44] Andrew DeWolf: I'm doing pretty good.

[1:46] Jess McEnall: How are you doing, Jess?

[1:47] Jess McEnall: You know, I just lost my job as a carnival barker, and I don't know how to get another job.

[1:53] Andrew DeWolf: So you know how I'm taking out my anger.

[1:55] Jess McEnall: You know what? You should just like rob somebody, that'd be a good idea.

[1:58] Andrew DeWolf: But after beating my wife.

[2:00] Jess McEnall: I mean, of course.

[2:02] Andrew DeWolf: That was like a given.

[2:05] Jess McEnall: Uh, it's not funny, but apparently it is, because this week we're talking about Rogers and Hammerstein's Carousel.

[2:28] Andrew DeWolf: Jess has so much to say.

[2:31] Jess McEnall: I can see it in his eyes now.

[2:33] Andrew DeWolf: He's like holding it back.

[2:35] Jess McEnall: Alright.

[2:36] Jess McEnall: Carousel is the second musical by the team Rogers and Hammerstein.

[2:40] Jess McEnall: Basically, this is the second musical ever written in the way that we consider musicals.

[2:44] Jess McEnall: The first was Oklahoma, which set up like all the tropes that we now see, and this is the second one they have ever did, and I think this is their best.

[2:52] Jess McEnall: Like, their sophomore slump is their best work in a way, at least musically.

[2:56] Jess McEnall: So the 1945 work was adapted from Ferenc Molnár's 1909 play Lilium, transplanting its Budapest setting to the Maine coastline.

[3:08] Jess McEnall: The story revolves around carousel barker Billy Bigelow, whose romance with mill worker Julie Jordan comes at the price of both of their jobs.

[3:15] Jess McEnall: He participates in a robbery to provide for Judy and their unborn child.

[3:19] Jess McEnall: After it goes tragically wrong, he is given the chance to make things right.

[3:24] Andrew DeWolf: You know, that sounds very general, but it doesn't even bring up the like spousal abuse, the suicide, or the fact that God has to get his hand involved.

[3:33] Jess McEnall: That's, I mean, that does describe the whole plot.

[3:36] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, yes, it does.

[3:38] Andrew DeWolf: What kind of name is Billy Bigelow, Julie Jordan?

[3:41] Jess McEnall: I mean, who sounds like superhero names?

[3:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's true.

[3:46] Andrew DeWolf: What’s the name of the—There comes Billy Bigelow to save the day?

[3:49] Jess McEnall: Oh god, he just stabbed himself.

[3:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, uh, what’s the name of the uh kid in uh in Shazam?

[3:55] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like it's the same name right now.

[3:56] Jess McEnall: Billy Batson.

[3:57] Andrew DeWolf: Billy Batson, Billy Bigelow.

[3:59] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, what's the difference?

[4:01] Jess McEnall: Julie Jordan.

[4:02] Jess McEnall: I like the names.

[4:03] Jess McEnall: They feel musical in a way.

[4:05] Jess McEnall: Like the song "You're a Queer One, Julie Jordan."

[4:09] Jess McEnall: Like that just flows so beautifully because of that name.

[4:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's true.

[4:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's because everyone loves alliteration.

[4:16] Jess McEnall: But then you got people like Carrie Pipperidge, who isn't but still feels musical.

[4:21] Andrew DeWolf: And Mr. Snow, Enoch Snow.

[4:23] Andrew DeWolf: Like, these all are names so perfectly chosen.

[4:26] Jess McEnall: It's true.

[4:27] Jess McEnall: And I've never read Lilium, but I feel like that probably doesn't translate well.

[4:33] Jess McEnall: And it's so Americana as well.

[4:35] Jess McEnall: So Andrew, what did you think of Carousel?

[4:37] Andrew DeWolf: Your first just thoughts.

[4:38] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it feels like an old musical.

[4:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's got all the tropes that you'd expect there to be.

[4:44] Andrew DeWolf: They're all there.

[4:45] Andrew DeWolf: My main complaint is there's not very much carousel in it.

[4:48] Andrew DeWolf: In fact, I don't think we ever see a carousel in the entire thing.

[4:52] Jess McEnall: In the opening overture, but you watched—Andrew watched the Kelly O'Hara, Nathan Gunn, um, Jessie Mueller concert production that they had on Lincoln Center.

[5:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and there wasn't very much in the overture there.

[5:05] Andrew DeWolf: It was shots of outside, I'm pretty sure.

[5:07] Jess McEnall: I don't even understand.

[5:08] Jess McEnall: Like, is the carousel supposed to be a metaphor for life?

[5:10] Andrew DeWolf: Like we're just spinning, ride round, baby, ride round.

[5:13] Jess McEnall: No, definitely not.

[5:14] Jess McEnall: I think the carousel is—it's not really anything.

[5:19] Jess McEnall: It's just that's—it's in there.

[5:22] Jess McEnall: And they're like, What else do we call this?

[5:25] Jess McEnall: And they're like, Oh, we can't call it Suicide Island, or like the man who beats his wife.

[5:39] Andrew DeWolf: So let's call it Carousel.

[5:41] Jess McEnall: That's fun.

[5:41] Jess McEnall: That's a fun name.

[5:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that'll trick people into coming in.

[5:44] Jess McEnall: They should have named it Sardine.

[5:46] Jess McEnall: I have a lot of issues with this show that I'm gonna bring up later, but I want to talk about the things I like before I dive into this.

[5:53] Andrew DeWolf: Excellent.

[5:54] Jess McEnall: So Oklahoma was the first musical that Rogers and Hammerstein ever wrote.

[5:58] Jess McEnall: It set the standard for what musical theater is.

[6:01] Jess McEnall: It gives the I Want Song, the two couples, and all that.

[6:04] Jess McEnall: For classical musical theater, it set the standard.

[6:06] Jess McEnall: Except it has a lot of things where you understand, like from the original musical comedies of the like 30s and 20s and all that, where they just have a dream ballet right before Act One ends, and it just feels totally out of place.

[6:20] Jess McEnall: The narrative is not fronted by it.

[6:22] Jess McEnall: Where in Carousel, they found a way to get that ballet in there in a way that feels natural to the story.

[6:29] Andrew DeWolf: Kind of.

[6:29] Jess McEnall: They were—I think it feels—I—you haven't seen Oklahoma yet.

[6:33] Jess McEnall: It just is so strange.

[6:35] Jess McEnall: It's like a reenactment of Act One plus a little bit of like—it doesn't fit.

[6:41] Jess McEnall: Where in this one, at least it has a purpose of story, and you learn a lot of story through it.

[6:46] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.

[6:47] Jess McEnall: Structurally and understanding musical theater structure and the creation of structure, Rogers and Hammerstein finally figured it out, and it is perfect here.

[6:56] Jess McEnall: Now a lot of what it has to say as a play, I've got issues with.

[7:01] Jess McEnall: Doesn't have very much to say at all, I don't think.

[7:04] Jess McEnall: So around, I want to say September of last year, right before—right when we started this podcast up in earnest, I made a video about Carousel, just about how problematic it was.

[7:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I never watched that.

[7:16] Jess McEnall: And a lot of people are like, you don't understand.

[7:18] Jess McEnall: It's a sign of the times and blah blah blah blah blah.

[7:21] Jess McEnall: It doesn't support domestic abuse.

[7:23] Jess McEnall: And it's like defaming domestic abuse.

[7:26] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm, uh, I don't know.

[7:29] Jess McEnall: I would tend to agree on some level with that.

[7:32] Jess McEnall: And you do have to consider this was written in what, 1950?

[7:36] Andrew DeWolf: 1945.

[7:37] Jess McEnall: Yeah, I mean, like to the moon, right?

[7:38] Andrew DeWolf: Come on.

[7:39] Jess McEnall: I mean, it doesn't romanticize it, but they definitely want you to see Billy as the dashing, like, strong, uh, dangerous guy that everyone has a sexual inkling for.

[7:50] Jess McEnall: And then you've got Enoch Snow, who respects his wife, expects fidelity, and is independently wealthy based on his own things.

[7:58] Jess McEnall: And then by the end of the show, it's looking on him like he's some petty ass rich boy, and like, ah, if I had half a mind, I wouldn't have been with you, and all that type of stuff.

[8:06] Andrew DeWolf: It in the end it sides with Billy and not Enoch.

[8:10] Jess McEnall: I mean, I saw Billy as like a Gaston type for most of the show.

[8:14] Andrew DeWolf: But this Gaston gets to go to heaven in the end.

[8:17] Jess McEnall: Gaston goes to heaven.

[8:20] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, he a hundred percent is rotting in hell.

[8:23] Jess McEnall: Billy Bigelow's probably there too, then.

[8:25] Andrew DeWolf: Except for we get to see that he's not.

[8:28] Jess McEnall: Yes.

[8:29] Jess McEnall: Actively we get to see that he's not.

[8:31] Jess McEnall: So, Andrew, do you want to just walk us through the plot?

[8:34] Andrew DeWolf: We don't want to go step by step, but just the broad strokes of what happens.

[8:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[8:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, there's like two women, and they go to a carousel, and one of the women falls in love with the guy at the carousel, and the other one reveals that she's already getting married to someone else.

[8:54] Andrew DeWolf: She just met a guy.

[8:55] Andrew DeWolf: They don't get married until after Julie and Billy are married.

[8:58] Jess McEnall: Fair enough.

[8:59] Andrew DeWolf: But Billy freaks out when he's gonna have kids because he doesn't have any money, because he doesn't have a job, because he's a loser.

[9:08] Andrew DeWolf: Cause he quit his job to like have sex with this girl.

[9:11] Jess McEnall: Yeah, which I mean was a good idea.

[9:13] Andrew DeWolf: Great idea, good on him.

[9:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, but not really, though.

[9:18] Andrew DeWolf: You probably could have had a job and done that at the same time.

[9:21] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, he decides that the best solution to this is not to get a job, but just to um, steal from some guy.

[9:30] Andrew DeWolf: I think it was the mill owner that he's gonna steal from.

[9:30] Jess McEnall: Yes.

[9:30] Andrew DeWolf: The mill owner that fired his wife, yes.

[9:36] Jess McEnall: Yeah.

[9:37] Andrew DeWolf: So he did that, but he didn't do that because it didn't work, and he just kills himself.

[9:42] Andrew DeWolf: Because he ain't going to prison.

[9:44] Jess McEnall: I ain't going to prison.

[9:45] Andrew DeWolf: He's not going to prison.

[9:47] Jess McEnall: So instead he'd just rather be dead.

[9:50] Andrew DeWolf: And notice you didn't bring up the domestic violence at all here.

[9:53] Jess McEnall: I mean, it doesn't have that much plot relevance.

[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: It kinda does.

[9:58] Andrew DeWolf: He beats his wife because he's angry that he doesn't have a job.

[10:01] Jess McEnall: That's all we need to say.

[10:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so it doesn't really have very much plot relevance in that it doesn't actually be a good thing.

[10:07] Jess McEnall: It comes back later.

[10:08] Jess McEnall: It affects the plot when it's paid off later.

[10:08] Andrew DeWolf: It's paid off later in that Billy learned nothing and did it again.

[10:16] Jess McEnall: Yes.

[10:17] Jess McEnall: Exactly.

[10:18] Jess McEnall: So he gets to heaven and he meets what is essentially God, who is here called the Starkeeper.

[10:24] Andrew DeWolf: The Starkeeper is not God.

[10:26] Jess McEnall: You're entitled to go back to Earth for one day to like fix up shit.

[10:30] Andrew DeWolf: And he's like, okay, can I go see my daughter?

[10:33] Jess McEnall: And he's like, Yeah, but she grown up because up here, uh, one minute is one year, and it's been fifteen minutes.

[10:38] Andrew DeWolf: So she's 15 minutes.

[10:39] Jess McEnall: It's been fifteen minutes.

[10:42] Jess McEnall: So he goes down and sees his daughter, and she's like pretty much gotten bullied and ridiculed her entire life because her father was a thief who killed himself publicly.

[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: Oops.

[10:53] Andrew DeWolf: I wonder who did that.

[10:55] Jess McEnall: Oh yeah.

[10:56] Jess McEnall: Maybe if you had just gone to prison, you would have like, uh, not ruined her life as much.

[11:01] Andrew DeWolf: But either way, he meets her, and she's just like, strange man, why are you coming near me and like talking very close to my face and trying to give me gifts?

[11:10] Jess McEnall: I've got a wrecker.

[11:13] Andrew DeWolf: Then he answers.

[11:14] Jess McEnall: And then he—and yeah, and basically she's like, I don't want your star.

[11:18] Jess McEnall: Get away from me, scary creepy man.

[11:20] Andrew DeWolf: And he's like, No, just come here, and then he smacks her, literally learning nothing.

[11:25] Andrew DeWolf: Don't come any closer, you go away with your white face.

[11:27] Andrew DeWolf: You scare me.

[11:28] Andrew DeWolf: Don't chase me away.

[11:28] Jess McEnall: I just want to give you something pretty, something wonderful.

[11:30] Andrew DeWolf: See?

[11:30] Andrew DeWolf: What's that?

[11:31] Jess McEnall: It's a star.

[11:33] Andrew DeWolf: Go away.

[11:34] Jess McEnall: No, darling, please.

[11:34] Jess McEnall: I just want to make it.

[11:42] Andrew DeWolf: Couldn't go five minutes with meeting his daughter without hitting her.

[11:46] Jess McEnall: Yeah, I feel like that would have been a good, um, a good arc for him to have.

[11:50] Jess McEnall: Like, oh, maybe I don't do that.

[11:52] Jess McEnall: And then his wife barges out and he chooses not to be seen by her, and then she says one of the most baffling lines in musical theater history.

[12:01] Andrew DeWolf: So baffling that in the most recent revival, they just flat out cut it.

[12:05] Jess McEnall: What line is that?

[12:07] Andrew DeWolf: It is basically the daughter says, There was a strange man here, and he hit me hard!

[12:12] Andrew DeWolf: I heard the sound of it!

[12:14] Andrew DeWolf: But it didn't hurt, Mother!

[12:16] Andrew DeWolf: It didn't hurt at all.

[12:18] Andrew DeWolf: It was as if he kissed my hand going to the house, child.

[12:21] Jess McEnall: What's happened, Mother?

[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: Don't you believe me?

[12:25] Jess McEnall: Why are you telling me why you're acting so funny?

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: It's nothing.

[12:30] Jess McEnall: Is it possible, Mother?

[12:31] Andrew DeWolf: For someone to hang you hard like that?

[12:34] Jess McEnall: Real loud and hard?

[12:36] Andrew DeWolf: And not hurt at all?

[12:40] Jess McEnall: It's possible.

[12:42] Andrew DeWolf: For someone to hate you?

[12:45] Jess McEnall: Hit you hard?

[12:47] Andrew DeWolf: And not hurt at all?

[12:50] Jess McEnall: It's like I was hit by an angel.

[12:57] Jess McEnall: Like it is so bafflingly tone-deaf, especially because up to that point we are basically trying to—we see it as an anti-hero trying to learn his met lesson.

[13:09] Jess McEnall: But that was the moment when no, it's good that you hit your wife.

[13:13] Jess McEnall: You gotta keep him in line.

[13:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's a way of showing love is basically what that line is cementing.

[13:18] Jess McEnall: Jess, have you ever really loved someone?

[13:21] Andrew DeWolf: I'm about to love you if you don't shut the fuck up.

[13:24] Jess McEnall: Then I think she ends up taking the star, and I guess that helps something, right?

[13:30] Andrew DeWolf: No, sh—no, it does fucking nothing.

[13:32] Andrew DeWolf: It's pointless.

[13:33] Andrew DeWolf: He goes—she goes to her graduation, and suddenly the Starkeeper is there given the speech for some reason.

[13:39] Jess McEnall: Yeah, and then they go back up to heaven and Billy's happy.

[13:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because that's good enough.

[13:44] Andrew DeWolf: He like whispers in her ear, like, go be happy, listen to him, don't let my sins affect the rest of your life.

[13:49] Jess McEnall: And she smiles and sings along with her class, and somehow that's—that's an ending.

[13:54] Andrew DeWolf: Really, everything after he kills himself is not great.

[13:59] Jess McEnall: Garbage.

[14:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[14:00] Jess McEnall: I like the ballet.

[14:01] Andrew DeWolf: The sad part is I really like the ballet.

[14:03] Jess McEnall: I something that a lot of people who have watched me over the last ten years I've done YouTube and have listened to this podcast know. I am a big fan of plot-centric songs and storytelling and all that.

[14:14] Andrew DeWolf: Very true.

[14:15] Jess McEnall: This is the one musical that is the exception, where I will listen to the overture and love it, because this is just a gorgeous overture. As well as that ballet, just because the music is so fucking fantastic in this.

[14:29] Andrew DeWolf: Like it is their most Rogers and Hammerstein's most gorgeous score they have ever written.

[14:35] Jess McEnall: So much that I'm even willing to like overpass songs like It was a Real Nice Clam bake that are just brain dead moronic to have in here. But yeah, that ballet is incredible. Like, because just musically alone. And after that point, it's just like I'm I'm done. I don't need to hear you can walk alone because there's no good songs after that. The story that's there is offensive to me on a whole level and hurts my soul to even like see, as well as the resolution is just brainless.

[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: My real thought is why don't they just change it so he doesn't hit her? Like it's not even necessary to have in there. You could just change that section a little bit and fix it. There's too much lines of dialogue, and you i i i you you find with a lot of musical theater international is one of them, they don't want you changing the book at all with any restage version. It is history, and if we go changing history, then blah blah blah blah. It's like why wouldn't we change Shakespeare? Just make it so that it sounds more normal.

[15:39] Jess McEnall: The people have done that though.

[15:42] Andrew DeWolf: Have they ever changed a dialogue of Shakespeare, like and called it the same thing?

[15:46] Jess McEnall: Not called it the same thing, but there's been like revisions of it and things like that, for sure. And there's like a million reinterpretations of it. Like Nomeo and Juliet, which is one of the classics.

[16:00] Andrew DeWolf: Carousel as totals by gnomes.

[16:04] Jess McEnall: You can't put the word gnome into carousel is the problem, so that's why that won't ever happen. So, Andrew, out of all the characters in this, who do you like the most? It it could be like things people you d like kind of have emotion for, or just people you enjoy when they're on screen.

[16:20] Andrew DeWolf: I like Mr. Snow.

[16:21] Jess McEnall: You like Enoch Snow?

[16:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. He's got a lot of ambition. Somebody you can kinda look up to. Right? I mean, he kind he kinda is gased on, though. Like, hey, I I've got these plans and stuff, and you're gonna be my wife, and we're gonna have fifty kids, and I'm gonna like sail all the time. But he loves and respects his wife and expects fidelity from her, and he's emotionally open. I like him a lot until that last scene at the end of the show.

[16:50] Jess McEnall: Where he's just shown a snobby asshole because we need to like Billy.

[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but I mean, we I forget the whole ending, like whatever. Let's just pretend that doesn't happen.

[17:03] Jess McEnall: I mean, it's hard to because the end of a show is basically the message. It's where careful the things you say, children will listen. That's where you get the author's intent of it. And here the author's intent is go for the dangerous asshole. He loves you. He's the one that really cares, and one will be really good for you. The one that kills himself and leaves you alone with a daughter to raise on your own. He's the one that likes ya.

[17:26] Andrew DeWolf: My my thought is that the whole ending doesn't happen. You're you're just ignoring that it cutting that out.

[17:32] Jess McEnall: Yeah, basically the real story ends when Billy kills himself, and everything after that is just like a fever dream he's having while he's passing out.

[17:41] Andrew DeWolf: Jacob's ladder style?

[17:42] Jess McEnall: Yes.

[17:46] Andrew DeWolf: Uh fine. I mean, I'm f I'm fine with that too. It's a good interpretation, I think, right? And then basically the moral of the story is if you ki if you try to rob somebody, you're an asshole, and you'll die. You'll never see your child, and your wife will r be angry at you. Which I think is a good moral, honestly. That's a much better moral than what we got, I guess.

[18:09] Jess McEnall: On one hand, I'm like baffled that this show is still put on. But on the other hand, the songs are fucking so good.

[18:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, all the music in this is very solidly put together. I like Jigger a lot.

[18:21] Jess McEnall: And I don't know. He was the he was the villain, basically.

[18:24] Andrew DeWolf: He is. He's literally coming in and into every subplot and fucking it up somehow, and I love it. He almost fucking breaks up the uh secondary couple. Like, if I was to make my film adaptation of this, I would cast Andrew as Jigger.

[18:39] Jess McEnall: I would cast myself as Enoch Snow, and Billy wouldn't be in it.

[18:43] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, you gotta have Billy Bigelow.

[18:45] Jess McEnall: Even the most charming actors in the world who have played Billy Bigelow can't get past the shitty things that he does. Like Patrick Wilson is probably one of the most charismatic Broadway actors in the world, and he just hits her hard.

[18:59] Andrew DeWolf: You can't get rid of the hitting her hard part of the story. He just he just hits her right on the face. Now what do you think about the like how surprised were you that it turned into the fantasy world of going to heaven?

[19:12] Jess McEnall: Yeah, I wasn't expecting that at all. I was like, oh man, they're just gonna kill the main character. That's interesting. But then it was like, oh, now he's in okay.

[19:20] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah, it I don't like it. It seems contrived, I guess. It's like, oh, you get a second chance because you died. And then he fucks up the second chance because he's a idiot.

[19:33] Jess McEnall: Was there ever a point that you felt sympathetic to Billy Bigelow?

[19:36] Andrew DeWolf: Probably near the beginning. Like you liked him when he openly quits his job just so he can try to bang this little girl.

[19:43] Jess McEnall: Yeah, of course. Who wouldn't? I mean, he's charming. And I was really hoping that he would go somewhere positive from that, but no, that like that low level, like it just gets even lower as it goes. I mean, he starts out as somebody who's like hitting on girls at the carousel that he works at, and then he goes to uh a ghost who beats his daughter that he's never met.

[20:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that that's the arc.

[20:11] Jess McEnall: That's the arc. Like Billy Bigelow seems like the type of guy where even if he knew that that was his daughter, he would still try to flirt with her. Like, hey, you're pretty attractive.

[20:21] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, he kind of did. He didn't tell her that he was his her dad, so you know, it's like they could have gone anywhere from there. We don't really know. I feel like that is the type of human being Billy Bigelow is. Like, even knowing that's his daughter, if he got even the eighth of an arousal from her, he would try to you know.

[20:38] Jess McEnall: Is Billy Bigelow worse than Gaston?

[20:40] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Gaston only killed animals.

[20:42] Jess McEnall: It depends on whether or not you put like human life over animal life.

[20:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean Well, he didn't torture them. You didn't put him in a situation where they could Well, I guess Gaston beat Lafu who thought he was in a domestic partnership with Gaston.

[20:56] Jess McEnall: It depends which version you watch.

[20:59] Andrew DeWolf: In the original subtext in the remake, it's text.

[21:03] Jess McEnall: Lil'Fu I mean, he's a cartoon sidekick, though.

[21:07] Andrew DeWolf: He deserves it.

[21:08] Jess McEnall: You're a queer one. Lawful.

[21:11] Andrew DeWolf: No, that doesn't that doesn't fit. So, how did Julie and Bigelow have any money? Neither of them have a job.

[21:16] Jess McEnall: She had a job.

[21:18] Andrew DeWolf: She had a job?

[21:19] Jess McEnall: She had a job in the mill, but then they were also living with her aunt Nettie.

[21:22] Andrew DeWolf: I thought the mill guy fired her.

[21:24] Jess McEnall: Yeah, but you still can save money, you know.

[21:26] Andrew DeWolf: How long did they save money for? Like the description between when they meet, get together, and kiss, and married and about to have a kid is just it's as the book says, over a month later.

[21:38] Jess McEnall: Ah, over a month.

[21:40] Andrew DeWolf: That's a long period of time.

[21:41] Jess McEnall: Yeah, it's just vague enough to make no goddamn sense. Beyond domestic abuse, if you have any issues with the plot, if let's let's pretend that was gone. Is it still bad?

[21:49] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, so let's say Billy Bigelow is just an unemployed asshole that doesn't beat his wife, but Johnny doesn't drink.

[21:59] Jess McEnall: Yeah.

[21:59] Andrew DeWolf: If he was played by Tommy Wazoo.

[22:01] Jess McEnall: I did not hit her.

[22:03] Andrew DeWolf: I did not hit her.

[22:04] Jess McEnall: It's not true.

[22:05] Andrew DeWolf: I did not.

[22:06] Jess McEnall: Well, I mean, he c Billy does do that, doesn't he?

[22:11] Andrew DeWolf: I did not hit her.

[22:13] Jess McEnall: No, oh no, I did not beat her. I hit her.

[22:18] Andrew DeWolf: Actual line from the show.

[22:22] Jess McEnall: I didn't beat her. I hit her.

[22:25] Andrew DeWolf: Why'd you beat her?

[22:26] Jess McEnall: I didn't beat her.

[22:27] Andrew DeWolf: I would never beat a little thing like that. I I hit her.

[22:32] Jess McEnall: Why?

[22:32] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you see, we'd argue, and she'd say this and I'd say that, and she'd be right, and so I'd hit her.

[22:40] Jess McEnall: Are you sorry you hit her?

[22:41] Andrew DeWolf: I ain't sorry for anything.

[22:43] Jess McEnall: Totally relatable.

[22:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, hashtag. God forbid a woman be right in a situation.

[22:47] Jess McEnall: Hashtag relatable.

[22:51] Andrew DeWolf: I like a lot of the personality of Billy Bigelow. And it's it's just a small pile that stacks up. Like, probably his most hateable moment, even despite everything, is when he's about to rob this guy with Jigger, and they're just killing time, and he's like, let's play a game of cards just to pass the time. And he's like, Alright, I don't have money. He's like, how about you owe me credit for it? And then he exceeds the amount he was gonna get from this robbery anyway by losing and just keeps going. It's like, okay, now's the time you just leave, I think, right? Literally, the show takes initiative to pour salt on the wound and make you hate this guy.

[23:32] Jess McEnall: They they have that, and then they also have um that the guy who they were going to rob wasn't even going to the place that they were going to rob him from or whatever. Literally the most incompetent robbers in the world. Does Billy do one ro does Billy do one right thing in this entire show?

[23:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yes. Uh he kills himself.

[23:52] Jess McEnall: First try.

[23:53] Andrew DeWolf: First try. That's not funny, guys, okay? That's a joke.

[23:57] Jess McEnall: Yeah, suicide suicide is a real thing, and so is domestic abuse, and yet this show treats like throwaway gags.

[24:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[24:06] Jess McEnall: Not since uh uh She Loves Me have I seen a more flippant suicide.

[24:14] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, this is a lot like the room, the more I think about it.

[24:18] Jess McEnall: Yeah, no, because I mean Billy compared to Johnny is like a terrible person. Like Johnny's great. So fun fact when they were putting on the show originally, they did a bunch of out of town tryouts, and John Rate was the original Billy. And they're like asking the audience, like, was it well do you guys still like Billy? And like, especially women, they're like, Oh yeah, we love Billy. We were on his side the whole time. And they're like, okay, why? He's like, he was just so dreamy and such a man. I'm like, What? What? I mean, this was the age of the forties were the forties were a crazy time.

[24:58] Jess McEnall: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but I'm here to shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by Audible. Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese. This week I am recommending something wonderful, Rogers and Hammerstein's Broadway Revolution by Todd S. Pertom and narrated by writer Todd S. Purtam. To download your free audiobook today, go to Audible Trial.com slash musicals with cheese. Again, that's Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese for your free audiobook.

[25:40] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, folks, let's get you back to the show.

[25:42] Jess McEnall: Oh man, you did the whole announcement without me.

[26:06] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, so let's talk about the carousel waltz, which opens the entire show.

[26:11] Jess McEnall: Are you talking about the overture or the overture, yes.

[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: But they call it the carousel waltz. It really is such a soothing like punk experience where you get the feel of this world where this carnival that we start in. Like you just feel the power of this, like world that we're in.

[26:29] Jess McEnall: It's right up there with Gypsy, but in a much more melodic way. Like this is a very melodic piece, and like mostly it kind of focuses on its own themes. Like I don't remember any like themes that get picked up later in it, aside from maybe If I loved you.

[26:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. No, I think you're right. I think you are right about that.

[26:46] Jess McEnall: Like, it's its own thing, and it is so gorgeous to listen to. And when you see it on stage, it shows like Billy Bigelow flirting with the girls and all that, and it's starts with this dreamy world view that we have.

[26:58] Andrew DeWolf: And if you watch the version I watched, you get to see the outside of the theater.

[27:15] Jess McEnall: I want you to love if I love Probably one of the best, like, song scenes that both act as a scene and a musical number, If I loved you.

[27:34] Andrew DeWolf: It's a conditional love song between Julie and Billy when they're just kind of meeting and they've both given up their entire lives to flirt with one another.

[27:42] Jess McEnall: Yeah. Andrew, what do you think of that song?

[27:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's um It's a good song.

[27:49] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure I'm in love with the subject matter. Just because it's a little bit like, oh, I don't like you, I do like you, and it's just so on the nose about that. In musical theater, there is the thing called the conditional love song, where you don't want everyone falling in love at first sight without lampshading it. And Oklahoma, you have the song called People Will Say We're in Love, where it's like, don't do this, people might think we're in love, and I don't like you. And in this one, it's kind of the response where it's like, fine, if I loved you, will the world would be great, but it's too bad we don't. When obviously you've got these two people that are obviously in love that just don't want to admit it to each other because either they're nervous and all that. And Julie is very much like, I am in my own mind about beauty and stuff, and Billy is like, what if God isn't real? We're so small, we're so insignificant in this universe.

[28:43] Jess McEnall: Yeah, Billy has a bit of a crisis in this song. You can't hear a sound of the turn of a leaf, nor the fall of a wave in the sun. A tide creeping up on the beach like a thief, afraid to be caught stealing the land. On a night like this, I start to wonder what life is all. And I always say two heads are better than one to figure it out.

[29:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, when I first listened to the song that is outside of like the covers and all that, like the actual scene, I'm like, wow, you're having an existential crisis just because you met this girl.

[29:33] Jess McEnall: Yeah, but he f he, um no, he doesn't ever find his way.

[29:37] Andrew DeWolf: Well, he finds out what happens on the other side, I guess.

[29:40] Jess McEnall: I suppose he does. It's the closest thing to foreshadowing about that act, too. I still didn't see it coming.

[29:47] Andrew DeWolf: But it is gorgeous, it is a beautiful song. And it visually paints a picture, like the leaves or the flower blossoms on the trees falling down all by themselves, and like the fact that there's no wind. And you understand both characters very early on. Julie is a goofier like one, and Billy is like, I don't want you, I don't like this, I don't want to be in love, and you're gonna ruin my life if I were in love with you. You understand both of them in this scene, and I'm honestly a little disappointed it comes so early, because I don't think any song reaches the heights of this song ever again.

[30:25] Jess McEnall: There's still some nice songs in the rest of it though.

[30:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but none of them are quite as good as this. I mean, even the ballet, um, in the end, it's mostly based on this song.

[30:34] Jess McEnall: I think there's still quite a few songs I like though.

[30:36] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, there's tons of songs I like, but this is the best.

[30:40] Jess McEnall: Whatever you say, my man.

[30:42] Andrew DeWolf: June is busting out on over the meadow in the hill. What's the busting out of bushes and the rock and river pushes every little wheel that wheels beside the mill. Do you want to talk about June is busting out all over? Because you and I have been singing that literally all week.

[31:01] Jess McEnall: I like this song. It's fun. Sing a little bit of it for us.

[31:04] Andrew DeWolf: June is busting out all over. I think I missed that last note. I think I missed it. June, June, June. June, June, June.

[31:13] Jess McEnall: It is a fun song. I feel like this song comes back more than any other song. Why do you think you like this one so much?

[31:19] Andrew DeWolf: It's just a catchy fun one. I don't love it, but it's good. And what's the point of a song if you can't sing along, right?

[31:25] Jess McEnall: Says a man who loves the Muppets as much as he.

[31:28] Andrew DeWolf: Why don't you like this song?

[31:29] Jess McEnall: Oh, I don't dislike the song. I just don't. Once again, you know me, I love my plot centric songs, and this one is a little bit uh it's mostly based on its cadence, like and introducing a character that really doesn't have a place in the plot, aside from giving Billy and Julie a place to stay.

[31:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's still fun though.

[31:46] Jess McEnall: But does set up the setting.

[31:48] Andrew DeWolf: It does give you the setting, it gives you the world. Uh because basically, as much time has passed before this with Julie and Carrie and Billy, that's basically a prologue. This is the song that cements this is where we're actually starting.

[32:01] Jess McEnall: Yeah, in June. When the children are asleep, we'll sit and dream. The things that every other dad and mother dream. Now, what do you think about Mr. Snow, like when I marry Mr. Snow? And we'll just lump in when the children are asleep as well.

[32:23] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's fun and it has a huge amount of character for Mr. Snow in it. Like, even when you're just talking about him, like in When I Marry Mr. Snow, you get it. And then when you see him and he's just this big broad goofball sailor that's like, I want kids, I want a fleet, I want to make sardines. I mean, his sardine idea is great. And he's just kind of fun to watch. He's a goofy guy.

[32:50] Jess McEnall: You know what the it kind of reminds me of is what's that one musical we did where the guy invented something? He's like a side character who invents like uh something ridiculous.

[33:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, is that Merrily We Roll Along where he meant to the answering machine?

[33:05] Jess McEnall: He invents the answering machine. This guy invents what, sardines?

[33:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, sardines and becomes a millionaire. But that makes him the bad choice. Go for the dangerous poor guy.

[33:16] Jess McEnall: Oh no, go for the guy with the money.

[33:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, follow the money and see where it goes. Even if he becomes an asshole, you still get half the money.

[33:23] Jess McEnall: But you also gotta squeeze a bunch of kids at you, cooch.

[33:26] Andrew DeWolf: It's strange in a musical where the secondary couple is the more healthy couple.

[33:32] Jess McEnall: Is that not common?

[33:34] Andrew DeWolf: No, like in Oklahoma, we've got um what the fudge is her name? Eight old Annie, who basically is like, I wanna bang all the guys, and when my betrothed isn't here, I'm gonna bang everyone. And then her husband comes back and he's like, You can't be doing that. She's like, Oh come on. He's like, you can't be doing that. She's like, okay. And that that's the resolution of that plot line.

[34:00] Jess McEnall: Yikes.

[34:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Whereas Julie not Julie, what the hell is her name? Lori and Curly, they kinda hate each other and grow to like each other very she loves me style. But they're they they seem genuinely enthralled with one another when they get together.

[34:15] Jess McEnall: Yeah, no, they uh there's only that one scene where it's like super awkward, where it's uh jigger Julie and it's like, and then he comes out and he's like, Oh my god, were you touching somebody else? Oh my goodness, so what else is a really weird scene when Carrie gives Julie permission to kiss Enoch, and then Billy comes out and he's like and it's like really tense for no reason.

[34:46] Andrew DeWolf: I think they just needed they like wanted more conflict, and they're like, how do we how do we have more conflict? Gotta make it seem like Billy's gonna fight this guy so that we don't let them expect that he's gonna kill himself and go to heaven.

[34:59] Jess McEnall: I mean, they got it right, nobody expects it. She's gonna be shouted and burned under us with the best lot of money can hide.

[35:08] Andrew DeWolf: I never got money.

[35:16] Jess McEnall: I'll go out and make it.

[35:30] Andrew DeWolf: Let's move on to Soliloquy, which is Billy's big number and ends act one. I love this song. I really love this song.

[35:36] Jess McEnall: I knew you would like it.

[35:39] Andrew DeWolf: Why ha fuck you? How do you know I like it?

[35:41] Jess McEnall: Because it's all just character motivation stuff.

[35:46] Andrew DeWolf: What's wrong with that?

[35:47] Jess McEnall: Yeah, the music kind of takes a back seat sometimes.

[35:50] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it the music is so important, it drives the mood of the entire song.

[35:55] Jess McEnall: Yeah, and it's it's well done, but it's I mean, you can't really sing along with it unless you've listened to it a million times, I'm sure, like you have.

[36:04] Andrew DeWolf: My boy Bill I can see named after me. There he goes. My boy Bill, he'll be tall, as tough as a tree.

[36:16] Jess McEnall: Well, Bill. This one this one is in Jess's book, so But it is such a good, like, a moment where he's left alone and we finally get to see Billy when he isn't like around other people and he's open, he's playful. It is the most humanized Billy ever becomes in the entire show.

[36:33] Andrew DeWolf: And it's where he realizes that his daughter is gonna have to deal with people like him. Basically. He basically talks about Hey, my if I have a son, he's not gonna deal with any like teasing a bitch that's like a virgin whose blood's like water, I think is his exact who'll give him a kiss, a peck and call it a kiss. And then that was the moment he's like, oh god, I might have a daughter. And if I have a daughter, oh my god. You can have fun with a son, but you've gotta be a father to a girl.

[37:04] Jess McEnall: Why is that line not father to a daughter?

[37:07] Andrew DeWolf: I think it just feels if it's a m easier in the line, girl. It doesn't rhyme though, and it doesn't have the same a good float.

[37:15] Jess McEnall: It would have been better if it was daughter. I would have made a daughter to be a good one.

[37:18] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Andrew's mansplaining Rogers and Hammerstein. Come on up, m come on up, Richard Rogers and Oscar Hammerstein will fight ya.

[37:24] Jess McEnall: You can't mansplain to another man.

[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: But I think the song like it ends act one for a reason, and it is the first time Billy actually has any actual goals that aren't like beating his wife and ha trying to bang little girls.

[37:39] Jess McEnall: Yeah, now his goal is to make sure that his daughter doesn't get beat by his hus by her husband.

[37:45] Andrew DeWolf: Only I can beat my daughter. It's a good song, but it's kinda weird. It's got a weird kind of turn when he's like, Oh my goodness, daughter. I guess it just shows that he's such a bad character. He's such a bad guy. Plays gender politics and all that. But it sets up the reason why he's so dedicated to that like that robbery in act two.

[38:06] Jess McEnall: Yeah, I love that the resolution of that is my daughter might get treated poorly, therefore I should participate in a robbery.

[38:15] Andrew DeWolf: It's more like she needs to be able to he was thinking mostly monetarily, like I can uh a son will make it through, but a girl I want to buy her pretty dresses and make her look good. And I've never known how to get money, but by God I'll try, I'll go out and take it or steal it, or or what is it? I'll go out and make it, or steal it or take it, something like that, or die. And he said something he's gonna die because he doesn't do any of that.

[38:42] Jess McEnall: Why not just get a job?

[38:46] Andrew DeWolf: There ain't no jobs, damn it, Julie.

[38:49] Jess McEnall: He's had a job before. That person offers him a job again.

[38:54] Andrew DeWolf: I ain't going back.

[38:56] Jess McEnall: Shut up, Julie.

[38:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, whatever. He's a he's a bad person. This is maybe the worst main character we've ever talked about.

[39:05] Jess McEnall: I mean, we talk shit about Marvin, but this is like Marvin times 50.

[39:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like for real. Like, for sure. Do you think Wizard would have taken that shit?

[39:16] Jess McEnall: No.

[39:17] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Wizard would have been like, it's like being beat by an angel.

[39:22] Jess McEnall: I mean, hit by an angel. He didn't beat anybody. Let's be clear about this. Not beat. Very, very specific differences.

[39:35] Andrew DeWolf: We're hiding by the game. In musical theater structure, Act 2 should open with a song where everyone sits the fuck down and you don't really have to worry about the plot. And this musical has the worst one, which is it was a real nice clam bake. Literally just about like, yeah, that was a nice clam bake we had. I ate a lot.

[40:04] Jess McEnall: I mean, it sets up that they're at the clam bake. Kind.

[40:10] Andrew DeWolf: Is that it? That's that's it. I like the fact that I can make eye contact with you and see you avoiding eye contact with me.

[40:22] Jess McEnall: I hate this song. I really do.

[40:24] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't hate it. I get its purpose. But as soon as it's on, I'm like, God, fuck this.

[40:32] Jess McEnall: Well, it is it's like back to back, like, I really love soliloquy, and I was like, I want to see what comes next. Ah! Is it gonna do it? And then we it was a real nice clam bake, and we all had a real good time. I'm like, no, kill me.

[40:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but it was a nice clam bake. Are you denying this fact?

[40:53] Jess McEnall: You could say that in a line of dialogue.

[40:56] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, yeah, well, a line of dialogue is not gonna allow the people that forgot to have two dumps to sit back down. Call back to our SpongeBob SquarePants episode, folks. Remember, two dumps. Don't go in the in the mid-show.

[41:11] Jess McEnall: The intermission. The midshow intermission. What's the use of wondering? If he's good, or if he's bad. Or if you like the way he wears his hook. Oh wonder if he's good or if he's bad. He's your fella. And you love him. That's all there is to that.

[41:43] Jess McEnall: So there is another song that I want to talk about that pisses me off.

[41:47] Andrew DeWolf: Of course there is, Jess.

[41:48] Jess McEnall: Can you guess what it is?

[41:50] Andrew DeWolf: Is it what's the use of wondering?

[41:52] Jess McEnall: Yes. Like, literally the first lines of that song are what's the use of wondering if he's good or if he's bad?

[41:58] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like either of these two songs.

[42:00] Jess McEnall: Uh the one where they both where they sing, oh, there's nothing bad but a good man or whatever.

[42:07] Andrew DeWolf: And then all the ladies saying, Oh, there's nothing bad but a man in general.

[42:11] Jess McEnall: It's just I didn't like either of those songs. But the last line of this song is you're his girl and he's your fella, and the rest is all talk.

[42:18] Andrew DeWolf: He's beating you.

[42:20] Jess McEnall: Um I mean, somebody trapped in an abusive relationship may think that way, right?

[42:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but this song makes it seem like we should be on her side. Like, yeah, she's making good points here.

[42:30] Jess McEnall: You're right.

[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: I concede.

[42:33] Jess McEnall: I win!

[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: I win the podcast.

[42:37] Jess McEnall: Jess wins this podcast.

[42:38] Andrew DeWolf: I win most of them though, to be honest.

[42:40] Jess McEnall: Honestly, that is how the dynamic of the show is.

[42:43] Andrew DeWolf: One of us trying to win by the end.

[42:45] Jess McEnall: I usually try to think of good points, and then Andrew usually wins.

[42:50] Andrew DeWolf: I always win.

[42:51] Jess McEnall: Not this time.

[42:52] Andrew DeWolf: I'm conceding this time.

[42:54] Jess McEnall: Because I can't I can't defend a show where people are getting beat.

[42:58] Andrew DeWolf: I mean hit.

[42:59] Jess McEnall: They don't get beat. Nobody's beaten the show.

[43:19] Andrew DeWolf: Talk about like the pop song that came out of this.

[43:23] Jess McEnall: There's a pop song that came out of this. Um, you never walk alone is basically the big number.

[43:31] Andrew DeWolf: I would have thought June is busting out all over would have been the big number.

[43:36] Jess McEnall: Because busted makes me feel good.

[43:42] Andrew DeWolf: I should have known. It's also like way catchier.

[43:46] Jess McEnall: But we you'll never walk alone, is the one that everyone covered and everything else like that.

[43:50] Andrew DeWolf: Like everyone's covered it. Like now I gotta pull up.

[43:53] Jess McEnall: Gary and the peacemakers covered it. Um the Celtic woman, Josh Groben, Frank Sinatra, Roy Olberson, Barbara Streisand, Aretha Franklin, Michael Ball, Alfie Bo, Pavarotti, Renee Fleming.

[44:06] Andrew DeWolf: My god, you know it's good when Euretha Franklin covers it.

[44:09] Jess McEnall: The only thing that she's covered now is by dirt.

[44:12] Andrew DeWolf: I guess she'll never walk alone.

[44:13] Jess McEnall: No, she won't walk again.

[44:15] Andrew DeWolf: She won't walk again.

[44:17] Jess McEnall: Oh man, Jess, that was hilarious.

[44:23] Andrew DeWolf: I like how that started as an ironic appreciation and it became a genuine one.

[44:28] Jess McEnall: Fuck in Detroit, we hit was when they had they had her funeral in Detroit and you couldn't get down the fucking street, and I had to get to class and shit.

[44:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm like, oh, there's Aretha Franklin's fucking funeral.

[44:38] Jess McEnall: Jess hates Euretha Franklin.

[44:43] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't mind Eurethra Franklin.

[44:46] Jess McEnall: Euretha She did a lot of good for the world and she made great music, but goddamn, I had to get to class on time.

[44:57] Andrew DeWolf: What class did you miss because of her?

[44:59] Jess McEnall: Um, I had to get a hard drive to my teacher, so if she had one day to come back and fix that for you.

[45:11] Andrew DeWolf: Would you accept her star?

[45:17] Jess McEnall: No, she'd hit me.

[45:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[45:22] Jess McEnall: It's like being hit by an angel.

[45:35] Andrew DeWolf: Jess is fucking dying.

[45:38] Jess McEnall: Jess is gonna have to come back and finish the podcast.

[45:43] Andrew DeWolf: That's my unfinished business.

[45:47] Jess McEnall: I gotta do it fast because like a minute is a year up there.

[45:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. Don't take more than 30 seconds, Jess.

[45:55] Jess McEnall: Even that's half a year.

[45:57] Andrew DeWolf: Just go up there and be like, I wanna go back down.

[46:08] Jess McEnall: But a friend song.

[46:26] Andrew DeWolf: I've lost you.

[46:30] Jess McEnall: Soon I was. So Andrew.

[46:33] Andrew DeWolf: What is your overall thoughts on Carousel?

[46:35] Jess McEnall: Uh zero out of ten, not enough carousels.

[46:40] Andrew DeWolf: No. It was uh it was pretty good. Um if you can get past the fact that the main character is just terrible, um, you'll probably enjoy it because the music is very good throughout.

[46:57] Jess McEnall: There's some standout numbers, and in most of them are pretty good in general.

[47:05] Andrew DeWolf: Uh June is busting out all over is catchy. Uh blow high, blow low is pretty fun.

[47:13] Jess McEnall: And then there's some good plot-centric songs Jess will tell you all about.

[47:17] Andrew DeWolf: Uh but the ending doesn't make any fucking sense.

[47:21] Jess McEnall: And the main character is a dick.

[47:24] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, who hits his beat beats his wife.

[47:26] Jess McEnall: Sorry, I almost said.

[47:28] Andrew DeWolf: It's not beats.

[47:28] Jess McEnall: No, he he beats her.

[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: Uh so it's hard to get past that, but if you if you can get past that, it's it's it's fun.

[47:39] Jess McEnall: And I guess if you're really into musical theater, you should be able to appreciate its historic value probably as well.

[47:45] Andrew DeWolf: So you go, that's my thoughts.

[47:47] Jess McEnall: Well, yeah, I'm with you basically. I think the music is top notch. Like, this is Roger Hammerstein's best store best score.

[47:56] Andrew DeWolf: It is not their best show, because Sound of Music still exists, and we will get to that one day.

[48:01] Jess McEnall: Um I love it. I love the music, and I will turn this on while I'm at work and enjoy listening to it, but I cannot get over how terrible Billy Bigelow is, and how this story and the narrative supports him in a way.

[48:17] Andrew DeWolf: And shits on the gentleman that is supposed to be the representation of good in a relationship.

[48:24] Jess McEnall: Like, it bothers me a lot. And a lot of people say, like, no, this sh this does not support domestic violence. Then why is Billy Bigelow the main character and not Julie Jordan or Enoch Snow or even like Carrie?

[48:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um I know product of its time and all that, and that is a fair point, but I'm talking and for the rest of this show, let's just say we're not talking about the grand consensus.

[48:50] Jess McEnall: Neither of us are critics. We're just talking about our own opinions.

[48:53] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew doesn't know much about musical theater, and I do, and these are all our initial thoughts.

[48:59] Jess McEnall: We are not professional critics, so we aren't gonna analyze the fucking literary analysis of when it came out. That's not what we're here to do.

[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it is an uncomfortable watch, and it does make it hard to enjoy the gorgeous, gorgeous score the Rogers and Hammerstein came up with.

[49:15] Jess McEnall: When I watched it, I saw the date that it came out, and I was like, oh, that's why all this stuff is in there.

[49:23] Andrew DeWolf: So it's like okay. And you're able to contextualize it.

[49:26] Jess McEnall: But this is still being performed in 2018-2019. Unchanged as well.

[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: So and expecting us to put it right up there with wicked and all that other stuff.

[49:37] Jess McEnall: So it should be judged on those terms as well.

[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: I've got a question for you. Just out of curiosity.

[49:43] Jess McEnall: In the more recent production of Oklahoma that just premiered at the Circle in the Square Theater on Broadway, like a little less than a few weeks ago.

[49:52] Andrew DeWolf: It is brand new.

[49:54] Jess McEnall: They made changed all the songs to be contemporary. They didn't change any of the book, but they changed like a lot of the contemporary editions, made made it sexualized a little bit, made it a little bit more horny.

[50:06] Andrew DeWolf: So and everyone is like, why would you mess with Roger and Hammerstein's masterpiece like this? And I'm like, fuck you, people. You've had over 70 years of that show.

[50:17] Jess McEnall: Let's do something different with it.

[50:19] Andrew DeWolf: Change is good. That's what theater is for.

[50:22] Jess McEnall: I guess when something gets to a certain age and it's considered a classic, it's just untouchable.

[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: Because we've talked about before things getting changed in more contemporary shows, and nobody has a problem with it, really.

[50:35] Jess McEnall: Not very many people, anyways. Um, but like something like this, where it's an older show, I guess it's just people consider it, oh well, it's historic or or it's a classic, you can't you can't touch it.

[50:45] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, are you ready for your cheese rating of Oklahoma Oklahoma of Carousel?

[50:49] Jess McEnall: We haven't watched Oklahoma yet.

[50:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, why don't you go first with this one?

[50:52] Jess McEnall: Alright, my cheese rating is June Daisy Hoop Cheese, cause June is bustin' out all over. It's perfect for holiday mac and cheese, pimento cheese, or just.

[51:04] Andrew DeWolf: I wanna give it like a pepper jack or something like that.

[51:07] Jess McEnall: Or uh something sharp, something spicy.

[51:11] Andrew DeWolf: Something horse radish beat.

[51:14] Jess McEnall: Some horseradish cheese. Um, because there is a lot of spice to this show, but there's still a lot of cheese as well, so I'm okay with it.

[51:28] Andrew DeWolf: The cheese is good. The spice maybe burns your mouth a little too much.

[51:34] Jess McEnall: So it's hard to it's hard to really get the cheese down, you know.

[51:38] Andrew DeWolf: Did that make does that make sense?

[51:40] Jess McEnall: Makes dollars not sense.

[51:42] Andrew DeWolf: Either way, thank you guys for listening to our retrospective on carousel. Um, just a little reminder today's show is brought to you by Audible.

[51:52] Jess McEnall: Audible is offering our listeners a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. Just go to Audible Trial.com slash musicals with cheese and browse the unmatched selection of audio programs. Download a title free and start listening. It's that easy. Just go to Audibletrial.com slash musicals with cheese.

[52:08] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you guys for listening. Andrew, you know what we haven't done in a good long while.

[52:13] Jess McEnall: What's that?

[52:14] Andrew DeWolf: We haven't given any $25 gift cards for the great people that review us on iTunes.

[52:20] Jess McEnall: That's a really good point. We haven't done that in a long time.

[52:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so I want you to pick a number between one and twenty-five.

[52:27] Jess McEnall: Actually, 36, I lied. 36.

[52:29] Andrew DeWolf: One and thirty-six. We have 36 reviews, and I'm trying to cut out like the people we've already who have already won.

[52:36] Jess McEnall: I'm gonna pick three numbers, and I want you to pick a number from one to three.

[52:40] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, this is super randomization.

[52:42] Jess McEnall: Okay.

[52:43] Andrew DeWolf: I am gonna pick two.

[52:45] Jess McEnall: Uh, I am picking number 36, then.

[52:47] Andrew DeWolf: Number 36.

[52:49] Jess McEnall: Alright, that is Sango Demon Slayer 01. So if you are on iTunes under the name SangoDemon Slayer01, email us at musical theaterlives at gmail.com, and we will set you up with a $25 gift card.

[53:04] Andrew DeWolf: And that is a kick ass fucking name, Mr. Demon Slayer.

[53:06] Jess McEnall: Yes, Sango Demon Slayer. Um you specifically liked um when we talked about Next in Orwell, Falsetto, Spider-Man, and Love Never Dies.

[53:17] Andrew DeWolf: And you are excited to see us do Heathers and Lamez one day.

[53:20] Jess McEnall: So come on over. We're giving you $25 on the house. Just shoot us an email and we will set you up with it.

[53:27] Andrew DeWolf: Please follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. We're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. Our Instagram is Musicals with Cheese. Give us a follow.

[53:36] Jess McEnall: Please send us some money on Patreon if you think that we're really worth it. We're gonna be doing uh commentary on cats that only available for two Patreons.

[53:45] Andrew DeWolf: Cats is going to be fantastic. I've heard that it's about cats.

[53:49] Jess McEnall: That's the only thing I've heard about it. Nothing else.

[53:51] Andrew DeWolf: It is about cats, I I hear.

[53:54] Jess McEnall: Neither of us have seen cats before.

[54:02] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness. That is going to be a masterpiece, uh, us watching cats, then.

[54:07] Jess McEnall: You need to get that.

[54:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Only available to our patrons.

[54:14] Jess McEnall: So get to donating, folks. Our YouTube page is Musical Theater Lives.

[54:18] Andrew DeWolf: Email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com.

[54:21] Jess McEnall: Our incredible title card is created by Jolene Casco. Her Instagram is at Jolene Casco.

[54:27] Andrew DeWolf: Jess, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap up?

[54:32] Jess McEnall: If you're buying anything on Amazon, you can use our our link in the description, correct?

[54:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, we have an Amazon affiliate link. If you're buying things on Amazon, especially you $25 gift card winner, come on.

[54:44] Jess McEnall: Yep, use our link. Uh and uh outside of that, I want everyone to have a fantastic day at work because I know you are listening to this on your commute.

[54:55] Andrew DeWolf: Don't lie to us. That's where you're listening to this right now.

[54:58] Jess McEnall: Unless you're Brent, then you're listening to us in the shower.

[55:01] Andrew DeWolf: In the s it still applies.

[55:05] Jess McEnall: Alright. And the last thing I want to say is it's not true.

[55:09] Andrew DeWolf: I did not hit her.

[55:10] Jess McEnall: I beat her.

[55:11] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you very much.

[55:13] Jess McEnall: And that's it from Musicals with Cheese.

[55:16] Andrew DeWolf: Bum ba-da.

[55:19] Jess McEnall: Bom.

[55:21] Andrew DeWolf: That's a wrong note.

[55:21] Jess McEnall: You're fine though.

[55:25] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know if you know this, but I can't sing.

[55:27] Jess McEnall: Ah, fair enough.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred