Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#56: 'Tick... Tick... BOOM!'

"Stop the clocks!" This week Jess & Andrew are joined by J. Collis-- author of "Boho Days." The trio come together to cover Jonathan Larson's autobiographical rock muscial "Tick... Tick... BOOM!" They chat about the musical stylings, Larson's history as a composer, and much more!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

51 mins
9/27/19

About

"Stop the clocks!" This week Jess & Andrew are joined by J. Collis-- author of "Boho Days." The trio come together to cover Jonathan Larson's autobiographical rock muscial "Tick... Tick... BOOM!" They chat about the musical stylings, Larson's history as a composer, and much more! Don't miss out!

Links:

Listen to "Tick Tick Boom!"

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Boho Days Book on Twitter

Buy Boho Days Book now!

Jess on Twitter

Andrew on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Jess on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Andrew DeWolf: Hi guys, today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.

[0:05] Jess McInally: Andrew, tell us a little bit about Patreon.

[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Patreon is a place where you can go and donate money to us if you'd like to.

[0:11] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, and we do offer special perks, like uh reading your name out on the uh opening of the show as well as in the middle of the show, um, like we're gonna do right now.

[0:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, our current patrons are Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Learer, Chris O'Kelly, Lily Accles, McKenzie Horner, John Donna, Taryn the Duck, hashtag actual duck, Melissa Goldman, hashtag actual goldman, Jess Lightning, the best Jess in the show, you and Cassidy.

[0:44] Andrew DeWolf: Haley McDonald, Taskir, Callum McLeod, Fire of September, Sam Bergman.

[0:56] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what? They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.

[1:01] Andrew DeWolf: If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, it's just Patreon only commentaries, our episodes day early, a few bonus episodes, and a bunch more.

[1:09] Andrew DeWolf: Come join us on Patreon.

[1:11] Jess McInally: Alright, let's get on to the actual show, Andrew.

[1:18] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[1:21] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.

[1:23] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[1:27] Jess McInally: And today, Andrew, we've got an extra special guest.

[1:27] Andrew DeWolf: An extra special guest.

[1:32] Andrew DeWolf: Is it more special than the rest of them?

[1:35] Jess McInally: Yes, always.

[1:39] Jess McInally: Today we have the author of Boho Days.

[1:43] Jess McInally: Um, author and Jonathan Larson's expert, J. Collis.

[1:47] J. Collis: Hello.

[1:48] Jess McInally: Hell is quite a title. How do you become an expert in such things?

[1:52] J. Collis: Um, you spend seven years writing a book.

[1:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god.

[1:57] Jess McInally: Have you ever even read a book, Andrew?

[2:00] Andrew DeWolf: I one time I read Treasure Island.

[2:03] Jess McInally: Did you like Treasure Island?

[2:05] Andrew DeWolf: Treasure Island uh was a good movie. I liked it.

[2:09] Jess McInally: That silence.

[2:10] Jess McInally: It was so deafening. Did you did you hear it?

[2:14] Andrew DeWolf: I uh I heard a tick, tick, tick, tick.

[2:18] Jess McInally: Did you guys hear it too?

[2:20] J. Collis: Um, yes.

[2:22] Jess McInally: You know, I've been watching the tick on Amazon.

[2:24] Andrew DeWolf: Is it has the tick encouraged you to buy some new spoons?

[2:28] J. Collis: Um, no, but he has told me that destiny has arrived and he wants me to review or talk about tick-tick boom, I guess.

[2:39] Andrew DeWolf: You just want to make out in my birthday.

[2:48] Jess McInally: Why can't you stay when I help you still feel like in your 22?

[2:59] Andrew DeWolf: What can you do?

[3:03] Andrew DeWolf: What can you do?

[3:09] Andrew DeWolf: What can you do? Tick Tick Boom is a musical written by American composer Jonathan Larson's, who won a Pulitzer and three Tony Awards for his musical Rent.

[3:18] Andrew DeWolf: Tick Tick Boom tells a story of an aspiring composer named John, who lives in New York City in 1990.

[3:25] J. Collis: Journalists were in the house.

[3:27] Andrew DeWolf: John is worried that he made the wrong career choice to be part of the performing arts.

[3:31] Andrew DeWolf: The story is autobiographical as stated by Larson's father in the liner notes of the cast recording.

[3:37] Andrew DeWolf: In the liner notes of the cast recording, Larson has been trying to establish himself in the theater since the 1980s.

[3:44] Jess McInally: So, J. Collis, you're the expert here. Why did you choose Tick Tick Boom?

[3:49] J. Collis: I wonder.

[3:50] J. Collis: Because I have a book to show.

[3:54] J. Collis: It's an interesting show.

[3:56] J. Collis: And it's interesting in part because of the show itself and the story it tells, and also because the show that people know is not necessarily the show that he wrote.

[4:07] J. Collis: And also because one of the interesting phenomena is over the years, a lot of people who don't like Rent do like this show.

[4:15] J. Collis: And I am one of those people.

[4:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[4:18] J. Collis: It's it's I think it's better than Rent in a lot of ways.

[4:22] Jess McInally: Now, what is your thoughts, J. Collis? Because you're the expert. Do you think this is better than Rent?

[4:27] J. Collis: No.

[4:28] Jess McInally: Why?

[4:29] J. Collis: Um, it's kind of weird. So the TL;DR, the sort of the very quick version of this is the show he wrote in the 90s is not the show you know.

[4:40] J. Collis: Um, they brought in another book writer to sort of do an overhaul because it was designed to be this one person thing that would be Larson himself sitting at a piano doing monologues and playing with the band, and they rewrote it to be about three people, or for three they rewrote it for three actors.

[5:02] J. Collis: And when they did the split, they restructured the show, and something just kind of has always felt a little bit off to me about it, and I couldn't explain what it was until learning about the original version.

[5:16] J. Collis: Um, I think it's a great score, but it just never quite sat with me the same way that Rent did.

[5:23] J. Collis: But neither of them are my favorite show by him either.

[5:26] Jess McInally: So what is that?

[5:27] J. Collis: Superbia.

[5:28] J. Collis: It's it's Superbia.

[5:30] Jess McInally: Um, I I know it's really horrible for everybody who talks about his wider work to say it's the greatest thing he ever wrote.

[5:39] J. Collis: And it might not be because Superbia is a mess.

[5:42] J. Collis: Um, he wrote that show for five years, and every edition of the show has a different ending, and none of them quite work.

[5:51] J. Collis: But the music was just incredible, and the ideas were ahead of their time.

[5:56] J. Collis: Um, and like Superbia is the one that I still listen to the most just for fun.

[6:02] Jess McInally: I get that. I've dabbled in Superbia.

[6:04] Jess McInally: Um, I wanna take a deeper look into it, especially after reading your book that covers it quite a bit.

[6:10] Jess McInally: Um, now my question to you.

[6:13] Jess McInally: Um, you brought up a point that uh you feel like they're kind of messing with the dead man's work with Tick Tick Boom because they basically wrote a new book around his original one-man show.

[6:24] Jess McInally: Did you ever consider that maybe all that Jonathan Larson's really needed? Like he I agree with you, he's a extremely gifted songwriter, one of the best, probably in musical theater history, just from everything I've heard.

[6:35] Jess McInally: But do you think he just needed a really good book writer to rein in like those rock songs and give them purpose?

[6:41] Jess McInally: And I feel like that is something that this version of Tick Tick Boom really does.

[6:45] J. Collis: It's difficult to say because he was learning in his last year on Rent, he was learning really quickly how to write a scene.

[6:54] J. Collis: Um, like the Happy New Year scene in Rent, he wrote very quickly, and um I actually use it as an example of how quick how he was learning to build a scene, get it sort of roughly fitting a scans in, and then hammer it into shape.

[7:12] J. Collis: Um, if you look at the Take Me or Leave Me song in Rent at the top of Act Two, he was struggling for years to make something work in that slot in the show.

[7:21] J. Collis: He knew he wanted to have a fight between those two characters, couldn't figure it out, was watching the actors improvise, and wrote that song in a day.

[7:30] J. Collis: Um, and then two days later rewrote one of the parts entirely to the song you know now.

[7:35] J. Collis: So I think it was having someone to bounce off of that is really what gave him uh the ability to start making that refinement.

[7:44] J. Collis: Um, Ira Weitzman, who had sort of followed his career and is now the guy who does musicals for Lincoln Center, had always said Rent, he didn't want to invest in Rent, but he knew whatever the next show would be.

[7:58] J. Collis: That was the one he really wanted.

[8:00] Jess McInally: That is the saddest thing I've ever heard of. Let's talk about Tick Tick Boom.

[8:03] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Tick Tick Boom. Andrew, why don't you describe the plot of Tick Tick Boom for us?

[8:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, this show is uh The Last Five Years, except for it's about Jonathan Larson's instead of what's his name.

[8:15] J. Collis: Jason Robert Brown.

[8:17] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, elaborate on that statement, please.

[8:21] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it's just an autobiography piece about a struggling writer.

[8:25] J. Collis: Mm-hmm.

[8:27] Andrew DeWolf: We've done a couple of them on this show.

[8:29] J. Collis: Yeah.

[8:30] Andrew DeWolf: And I think this is the most successful one.

[8:33] J. Collis: Yes, it's the one that doesn't uh it doesn't seem as egotistical as some of the other ones.

[8:37] J. Collis: Whereas I think that you brought up the childlike nature of Jonathan Larson's.

[8:41] J. Collis: I think he had a self-aware nature to him that didn't come across as much in Rent, but comes across very well in Superbia and as well as in Tick Tick Boom very well.

[8:52] J. Collis: He has like this self-deprecation to himself, whereas I think a lot of the folks in Rent see themselves as very self-serious because he is telling a melodrama, it's just required by the content he was given.

[9:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[9:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I mean, Tick came out of, you know, sort of this middle class traditional Jewish guild.

[9:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um, because the core of Tick Tick Boom um is that he's turning 30.

[9:16] Andrew DeWolf: This is the big thing is that he sees this milestone in his life, and he's like, I'm older than my father was when he had me.

[9:23] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, you know, I should have a career, I should have my own kids, I should have an apartment where the landlord hasn't turned the gas off rather than fix it.

[9:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and so that frustration and that kind of ugh is where this came out of.

[9:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, he was certainly a confident guy in his abilities.

[9:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you know, he loved his work, but he was at a point where you know his friends were getting real jobs, um, quote unquote real jobs, and starting to get ahead and settle down, and he's turning 30 and he's still waiting tables and still constantly being told no.

[9:59] Andrew DeWolf: And you know, that's a frustrating place for any artist, not even just artists, for anyone at that age looking to do something.

[10:09] J. Collis: Yeah, I mean, I think it in retrospect, it very much feels like what would be a millennial show now, though we're getting kind of past even for a Gen Z show now.

[10:19] Andrew DeWolf: Right.

[10:19] J. Collis: And I agree with you, it feels very modern.

[10:22] J. Collis: It despite it being specifically set in 1990, it feels timeless.

[10:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[10:29] Andrew DeWolf: Which is why I'm really excited for the movie that's coming out of it.

[10:34] J. Collis: Um, it's gonna be a movie.

[10:36] Andrew DeWolf: Certainly will be.

[10:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, directed by Lynn Manuel Miranda and starring Andrew Garfield by Last Night Checked.

[10:43] J. Collis: Um, I think so.

[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: I have no idea what the status is. No one tells me anything.

[10:48] J. Collis: Apparently it starts production about this coming out, yeah.

[10:51] Andrew DeWolf: Is it are they filming it over 20 years or is it coming out soon?

[10:55] J. Collis: Um, I have no idea. All I know is it's gonna be on Netflix.

[11:00] Andrew DeWolf: And yeah, that's about it.

[11:03] J. Collis: It starts production later this year, according to Lynn Manuel Miranda.

[11:07] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[11:07] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, if they're not if they're not filming it over 20 years and they're not in horrific cat CGI, I'm happy about it.

[11:14] J. Collis: Uh, the bar's pretty low, kids.

[11:20] Andrew DeWolf: I I'm wondering how they're gonna do parts of it because like my favorite scene in Tick Tick Boom.

[11:28] Andrew DeWolf: If they follow the original script for it, like it's not gonna film well.

[11:34] Jess McInally: What scene is that?

[11:35] Andrew DeWolf: But um, it's the monologue in the park.

[11:40] Jess McInally: With um, do we wanna like go should we do this song by song and figure out a way to sort of hit the beats of the show?

[11:49] J. Collis: Why don't we do our mid show and then we run through it?

[11:56] Jess McInally: Hi guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but I gotta show at you.

[12:00] Jess McInally: Um, today's show is brought to you by our extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.

[12:05] Jess McInally: Our current patrons are Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Lehrer, Chris O'Kelly, Lily Accles, McKenzie Horner, John Donna, Taryn the Duck, Melissa Goldman, Jess Lightning, Ewan Cassidy, Haley McDonald, Taskir, Cal McLeod, Fire September, and Sam Bergman.

[12:21] Jess McInally: They give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.

[12:25] Jess McInally: If you would like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, such as patron only commentaries, our episodes a day earlier, even earlier, and tons of other stuff.

[12:33] Jess McInally: Come join the Patreon family.

[12:35] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let's get back to the show.

[12:48] J. Collis: So the wizard blew off has come back on the street. Here are the voices, lost children. Making choices. Wicked witches, puppy field Goldman behind the curtain. Saga Lili's ruby slippers, Pancasteck, Bas for Sunday. Feel much more like doomsday nine East.

[13:19] Jess McInally: So let's talk about the songs for a bit. What do you guys think of "3090" as an opening number?

[13:24] Andrew DeWolf: I love "3090." It sets everything up really well, I think.

[13:29] Jess McInally: It sets up things perfectly. It sets up his plate perfectly. It is a perfect opening number. Like, in a way, all the ways that "Rent" isn't a perfect opening number, this is, in my opinion. I love the focus on turning 30 as like a milestone, because I think that is really relatable for a lot of people, especially right now.

[13:49] J. Collis: I love the bridge. Um, where it goes into Peter Pan and Tinkerbell.

[13:53] Jess McInally: Yeah, I agree. That sounds it's a it it's not just that it's melodic, it's this very vulnerable moment in the song. And he's, you know, and you can tell, like, okay, no, I'm really not sure what's going on. Um, yeah, you know, with my life and with everything else. And I mean, it's true, like you if you if you're working the freelance life at that stage in time, it's precarious enough to begin with, and then you kind of realize like, what have I done with the last eight to ten years? You know, and people think like, oh yeah, you know, you have seven housemates, and well, in his case, he had like two or three other people in his flat at any given time. You know, you're in your 20s, this is expected, and then you have this big moment, you're turning 30, and you're like, I'm supposed to be respectable now.

[14:44] J. Collis: Um, one of his notes always said, Stay up and coming, you'll never be a has-been. It is a very self-aware, very referential piece. Um, but it never feels pretentious. Even in the what I've seen of the original one-man show, he never feels self-important.

[15:02] Andrew DeWolf: No, he really tears himself down in it. Which is a really endearing thing, and I hate to keep bringing up "Rent." I wish people in "Rent" did that a little bit more. They did a little bit in some of the workshops, but the characters in Bohem never tear themselves down either. And I remember some of the early workshops, like when Mark is like, I'm a failure, like that line came from Mark talking about himself, and I think it was a little bit more effective in that form.

[15:28] Jess McInally: It can go both ways because it can also feel very on the nose. Right. Um, and and I think it's it's important that somebody does pull this character aside and smack him down a little bit.

[15:38] Andrew DeWolf: If you smack yourself down, does it really is it really a smackdown?

[15:43] J. Collis: I'll smack him down if you want.

[15:47] Jess McInally: Uh so um should we should we should we actually give people some context around these numbers?

[15:54] J. Collis: Sure, yeah.

[15:55] Jess McInally: Let's go.

[15:55] J. Collis: Definitely. Um yeah, so "3090." Um, I'll try and focus mostly, or we can all sort of focus on the version of the show everybody knows. Um, so his birthday in this version of the show is a week away, and his friends are getting him all trying to get him all psyched up, and his girlfriend tells him, like, it's gonna be great, all your friends are gonna be there, and you're gonna play happy birthday for yourself. He's like, What? Um, and that's sort of what sets up "3090." And it tells us, okay, we're a week away, and these things are about to happen. He's gonna, you know, try an office job, and you know, just sort of get through the week, and he's got a workshop coming up of "Superbia," and maybe it's gonna be really great, and you know, his show's gonna get produced, and he won't have to actually go do a market research job.

[16:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. So this is sort of the inner conflict about can I give this up? Will my art be successful? Honestly, who would want to play happy birthday for themselves? Like, I totally get that. Like, that's yeah. I tell people I'm a Jehovah's Witness for like the week surrounding my birthday.

[17:00] J. Collis: Wow.

[17:00] Andrew DeWolf: I'll have a birthday party, but I'm not gonna play happy birthday for myself. Somebody else. I'm not gonna make my own goddamn cake, what?

[17:08] Jess McInally: Let's find a chair where we can sit and talk.

[17:11] J. Collis: Oh get some fresh air, baby.

[17:13] Jess McInally: We could take a walk. Tell me what to get and talk about today. Tell me what to do out of anything is there.

[17:25] J. Collis: What a pleasure to unwrap clean dress.

[17:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh what I can do. Green green dress, dust Dustamiani. What do you guys think of "Green Girl," Jess?

[17:38] Jess McInally: Uh, I'm just asking. I'm throwing it out there for the world.

[17:41] J. Collis: I like that it sets up his relationship with his girlfriend. I like that the woman that Susan was based on was like, yes, this was like this super slinky sexy dress. Um, David Auburn, who did the rewrites for the 2001 version, really did not like this song. Um, but he couldn't find anything to swap it out with.

[18:04] Jess McInally: Wow, that feels like a good reason to keep a song in.

[18:07] J. Collis: Um, I mean, it wasn't. I just can't find anything to get me. Um but it bec I mean he always had that song there, and it's about sort of being in the moment and the idea of the good thing that's happening. And in the show, and in its context, it sets up the second conflict, which is his girlfriend wants to move away from New York.

[18:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[18:29] J. Collis: And leaving New York means not being in the middle of the theater business. It's another reminder that artistically things aren't going right. And it feels like giving up as soon as you leave. Like getting out of New York is giving up.

[18:42] Jess McInally: Yeah, there there is this sort of New York mentality where sort of you stop seeing past your islands and forget that there's like an entire world out there. New York City is everyone thinks of it as like tons of opportunity and everything, but I feel like it's so expensive to live there, and it's just a clusterfuck, honestly.

[19:06] J. Collis: And I mean it it wasn't that way in the n in the late 80s, early 90s. New York was kind of a dump in those days. And things were a lot cheaper, and you had these opportunities because there was no investment in the city for 20 years. And so you had all of these disused spaces that you could take over and do something in, uh, which is part of how Naked Angels got set up. Somebody in the group's, I think Uncle or cousin had like a publishing factory like the Lofton "Rent." Um they had like a publishing factory that they weren't using it so they converted it into a performance space and ran their friends group out of it. This was something you could do in those days that you can't do anymore.

[19:45] Jess McInally: Yeah it's it's too built up now and just if you're trying to do something new it's you're too late you missed it. Gentrification's the worst guys it's really bad.

[19:55] J. Collis: It is it's encroaching on my neighborhood and um yeah. It's great for tourists. Yeah I'll give you that but is it is it yes you know hey you won't get stabbed on your way to see "Into the Woods" anymore that's true but do we need another Olive Garden?

[20:02] Andrew DeWolf: You don't even have Olive Garden over here.

[20:19] J. Collis: It's actually pretty great I haven't walked into an Olive Garden in like three or four years.

[20:24] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to ever again I can't decide and you know who else can't decide? "Johnny Can't Decide" belongs to Myth she's through with competition Susan wants a Fember I like this song better than "Green Green Dress."

[20:57] Jess McInally: I I like it better with a little more oomph in the arrangements. So it's the morning after, and he's waking up early because he can't sleep, and he's laying out basically, you know, his best friend Michael has got a really good job and is moving out, but he feels like his friend is sold out because his friend used to be an actor, which is like the one big liberty with real person behind Michael, who was never an actor. Um he's like, you know, Michael's doing really great. Susan wants to leave New York and like have a more suburban, standardized life, but he actually likes living in the middle of the city and the hecticness, but he's also kind of like tired of being poor and being ignored.

[21:42] J. Collis: Um I was flipping through the net my through all of the notes in the archive papers, and the one note that I remember there were two things I took photos of on my phone, which of course is sitting on the charger and not near the computer. Um, but one of them was one of the lyrics in "Johnny Can't Decide" is "Compromise or Persevere," and one of his notes is tick means compromise, boom means persevere.

[22:04] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so that's basically describing the mantra of the show.

[22:08] J. Collis: Yeah. Well, I mean, there's a couple mantras in the show, but they come up as a um the other one is um it all it's love or fear. You know, this is this is a show about facing your fear, and it's a good mantra for life, have to tell you.

[22:21] Jess McInally: Where does this show fall on the love fear line?

[22:25] Andrew DeWolf: Shut the fuck up, Andrew.

[22:29] J. Collis: No, it's it's true. It's it's making the decision. If you look it, I mean, if you apply a meta filter to Larson's trajectory, "Superbia" is the fear show. He's afraid of what happens when you let everything be controlled by numbers and by economic forecast. And "Tick" is the show where you kind of make the decision to not be a part of that, and "Rent" is the confirmation.

[22:52] Andrew DeWolf: That's yeah, yeah, that's good. I think I think that's a good way to summarize that entire song into small segments.

[22:59] Jess McInally: Instead, they play on Sunday for a cool orange juice or a bagel.

[23:09] J. Collis: On the soft green cylindrical stools. Drinking cinnamon coffee.

[23:33] Jess McInally: In the blue silver chromium diner. Drips the green orange violet draw. I love the next song so much where he goes to work at a diner and he sings a homage. Homage to Steven Sondheim's "Sunday" and his own version of it. It's fun. It's hilarious. I love fun. Pretty relatable too, as far as like having a shit day job that you hate.

[24:06] Andrew DeWolf: And I heard this version before I heard Sondheim's version. Um this is always like the version whenever I hear "Sunday." Like this is what comes to my head before um "Sunday in the Park with George."

[24:20] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[24:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's not quite my favorite it's not quite my favorite shitty job song, but it's up there.

[24:25] Jess McInally: What is your favorite shitty job song?

[24:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it's gonna sound really horrible to say this, especially out of context of the show. It's "Lot's Wife" from "Caroline, or Change."

[24:33] Jess McInally: Actually, it's all of "Caroline or Change."

[24:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yep. Uh okay. My heart beats with that song. I can't can't disagree. Um God, I love that show. I'm so glad it's getting a revival.

[24:40] J. Collis: I love that show. I saw that revival in London.

[24:45] Andrew DeWolf: You are in for such a treat.

[24:46] Jess McInally: I'm so fucking pumped.

[24:49] Andrew DeWolf: All right, Andrew, do you have anything else to say about "Sunday"?

[24:52] Andrew DeWolf: No. I have no more to say about "Sunday." A lot of the songs are kind of similar to me in this show.

[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: Because they're all kind of that rock "Rent" style.

[25:03] J. Collis: So you're not a fan of that to begin with.

[25:06] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not a giant fan of it. I'm curious, Andrew, like we're uh because I've listened to a lot of the episodes. What actually is like your background on music and your general interest?

[25:18] Andrew DeWolf: I get the impression that you're really into classical, but like I don't know what you say, you know. I've got a craving to listen to some music. What do you put on sort of when you're just reaching for your musical comfort food?

[25:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, um, well, I mean, I used to be uh a big heavy metal junkie, um, but I'm not really as into that anymore.

[25:36] J. Collis: Um, but I would listen to like European metal a lot. Now I went to music school and I got a lot more into jazz and some classic stuff. So it's a big blend of all that type of shit now. And honestly, part of the reason I don't like the rock shows as much is because I've heard so much of it and I've heard heavier stuff, and I like that better. Are you familiar with a band called Avantagea?

[26:01] Jess McInally: Absolutely.

[26:02] J. Collis: I saw them in concert uh like three months ago.

[26:05] Jess McInally: Okay.

[26:06] J. Collis: Um I keep meaning to see them they are amazing.

[26:10] Jess McInally: Yeah, they uh they they they are, and they do sort of this big metal opera.

[26:15] J. Collis: Um yes. Uh did you listen to their recent album? Because I think it's maybe their best.

[26:21] Jess McInally: I haven't. The last the last thing I heard being the European-based gay that I am was um Mystery of the Blood Red Rose, because they put that up for the Eurovision a few years ago.

[26:31] J. Collis: That one was okay. A lot of neatloaf vibes from that one.

[26:36] Jess McInally: Yeah. Let's not talk about Bat Out of Hell, though. Um but yeah, I okay. Now I now I get a better like sense of things. Um band. Well, not really big in terms of like filling arenas, but really big in terms of like you say Marilli into a group of prog fans and they instantly know who you're talking about. Um I keep I keep waiting. There needs to be a bit like a really good progressive rock musical. It just seems like the form merging is there. There's so many concept albums, you could just make one of them into a musical and you're done.

[27:13] J. Collis: I've tried. Gotten the rights before. Uh if somebody wants to produce, hit me up on Twitter.

[27:18] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? You guys are talking about things I don't understand. I think I need some therapy.

[27:21] J. Collis: Therapy, next song. Let's go.

[27:23] ♪ Musical number: "Therapy" — performed by J. Collis ♪

[28:13] J. Collis: I got used to that. I fucking love therapy, guys. This is like the first song from this musical I got obsessed with. It's a great song. The first time I heard this song was on a really crappy tape of a concert from '97 and Ben Stiller did it.

[28:28] Andrew DeWolf: I feel bad.

[28:29] J. Collis: You feel bad about me feeling bad about you feeling bad about what I said about what you said about me not being able to share a feeling.

[28:41] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.

[28:41] J. Collis: Ben Stiller did it. Okay, so you have to remember back in the mid-90s, Ben Stiller was actually an actor with like a popular TV series. And like he was known as an he he was sort of breaking in as a comedic actor before he started directing.

[28:59] Jess McInally: Yeah, before the cable guy.

[29:01] J. Collis: Yeah. Um he was on Fox when Fox was still like hip and edgy. And now they're just edgy. He'd known Larson through Victoria. Um they actually did a number. He wrote in Larson wrote a number for Ben Stiller to perform at the opening night party for falsettos.

[29:17] Jess McInally: Holy shit.

[29:19] J. Collis: And it was a rap version of Jason's It was a rap version of Jason's bar mitzvah.

[29:24] Andrew DeWolf: That is the whitest thing I've ever fucking heard.

[29:29] J. Collis: Um is it white or Jewish?

[29:32] Andrew DeWolf: The whitest Jewish thing I've ever heard.

[29:35] J. Collis: They were both Jewish, all three of them were Jewish. Um Larson, Victoria and Stiller. We needed one more Jew.

[29:43] Jess McInally: William Finn.

[29:44] J. Collis: Ah, okay, and they'll put them in a room and tell them to bitch.

[29:48] Andrew DeWolf: I love that song. Um just had to put 'em in a room. And therapy kind of works along the same lines as that. Um, because it's this sort of very fast. I mean, originally it was just one person doing it and just playing it through he was Larson would just play it through as fast as he could.

[30:02] J. Collis: Oh God.

[30:03] Andrew DeWolf: In the build in in the build up.

[30:05] J. Collis: But he was and he was accompanying himself too. He's playing on the he was playing the piano part on it at the same time.

[30:10] Andrew DeWolf: I feel better than you I can't I can't imagine.

[30:13] J. Collis: I was uh Yep, not gonna work. Not today.

[30:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[30:16] J. Collis: Um so plot wise by this point, um this this is one of the big divergence points in the show. Um basically in the show that you'll see if you go to see it, Susan calls, like Lar Johnny Jonathan the character just had like a talk with his dad and found out like how amazingly well his sister's doing. Um and Susan's like, come over, it's really far, two subways and a bus. Take a cab. I can't afford a cab. Well, then we should like just talk about moving. Why are we talking about moving? And that and that sets it up. It's showing that they're kind of starting to they're on the out disalign.

[31:01] Jess McInally: Yeah, getting there.

[31:01] Jess McInally: The origin the original version of Susan did. Um, they rewrote a lot of the character and kind of her bass.

[31:04] J. Collis: Now is does Susan have a straight one-to-one like person in real life.

[31:07] J. Collis: Right. And the real Susan, real Susan, quote unquote, um, was his girlfriend. And it wasn't that she was like looking to get a dishwasher. She was a dancer. She spent a l spent a number of years um basically paying the bills by like typing up depositions and doing word processing for lawyers.

[31:31] J. Collis: And her thing was that she would kind of go off to an ashram and meditate and get away every so often. And in the original version of the show, the idea is either that she's gonna go up and stay for a long time or that she's offered a job at the ashram. Um so it's not about you know, I want a dishwasher and to be able to, you know, teach dance to children and all of that. It really is she wants a simpler cleaner's not quite the right word, but a simpler, more less hectic, more centered life.

[32:02] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I'd want that too. I can't blame her.

[32:05] J. Collis: Yeah. Um, so she didn't really like that change in the portrayal that they made her a little more materialistic.

[32:13] Andrew DeWolf: They made her they made her a shrew.

[32:17] J. Collis: She's not a shrew, but it's not her. It's not true to who this person is.

[32:22] Andrew DeWolf: Going down, going down.

[32:25] J. Collis: She don't care what I look like or how I dress. She never says no. Always says yeah. She's refined. She loans my mind. Sugar. She's got the power soothe my soul boy.

[32:55] J. Collis: Sugar might actually be my favorite song. Uh either sugar or 3090 is my favorite song in the show.

[32:59] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, explain why.

[33:01] J. Collis: Um, it's a really fun peppy number. Um, I have an obscene sweet tooth. So it's definitely relatable. Um, and it's a moment of levity that we kind of need at this point. Um, although originally it takes place way, way earlier in the show. Um, and and it it it's it's one of the few things in the final version of the show that really gets it sort of this childlike giddiness that he can feel at times.

[33:29] Jess McInally: Yes. I I was about to bring that up too. I think it's such a fun moment, and like the comedy works really well. Like, especially when it gets the like the really awkward office style comedy when he sees the girl.

[33:42] J. Collis: Yeah. Um Peppy. He played her so over the top in his original version. He's um and it and it's great. That's actually based on a real encounter that he had with someone he knew. And it it was like 2 a.m. She was with her boyfriend, and he just wanted to get away, and she keeps like drawing up the conversation. Um, and then she saw the show a couple months later when he did it as Boho Days, and she sees him afterwards and she like slugs him on the arm and he and is like, you know, yep, you got me. Um she took it in really good stride.

[34:22] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that artist types usually do find the ones that take it in good stride.

[34:28] J. Collis: Yeah. Um and it is just this really funny moment because it's like it's not that he needs a like a fix and he's getting like some quick energy, it's that it's a twinkie. It's like the lowest nastiest thing. It's a Ghostbuster show. Yeah, and then he gets caught up by someone he thinks is really hot. Um, and he's just like uh and um Yeah. Doomed, um, a carrot. I tossed my Twinkie to speed queen, man.

[35:01] J. Collis: This is where the three actor setup of the revival really is effective, where you get need all three of those people. Like they cut it down to the barest minimum they possibly could.

[35:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they actually tried to do it with two people for a while.

[35:16] J. Collis: Oh no, that would not have worked.

[35:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they originally wanted it to just be Jonathan and Susan, and they realized no, they had to pull Michael out as well.

[35:24] J. Collis: Yeah. It's it's a smart move, and they made it right.

[35:33] Andrew DeWolf: I just want to see her smile.

[35:39] J. Collis: Just want to see her smile.

[35:44] Andrew DeWolf: Just wanna see her smile.

[35:48] J. Collis: Just want to see her. Just wanna see her.

[35:54] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about see her smile.

[35:57] J. Collis: Let's talk about see her smile. Um, he actually cut this song. I don't blame him. Sorry, that was probably none of his transition. I don't blame him. It's my least favorite in the show.

[36:09] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[36:12] J. Collis: So I like it's it's not a bad song. Like, I don't dislike the song, but it feels slow and it kind of lags. It's such a dull low energy song after a high energy conversation, and we all know where it's going.

[36:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like, uh Yeah, the song, um, so let me give some context to the original version of the song that replaced it. So the song that replaced it is a song called Find the Key. And there's this moment um where Jonathan and Susan are kind of cuddling in bed, and it's like, I don't know what to do. I know. Uh I, you know, I don't want to go tomorrow, then don't. It's like they have this conversation, and it's very it's a very stick like gentle but staccato conversation.

[36:56] J. Collis: And the final line is like, I'm going. I know. Hold me. She's gone. That would have been far more effective. And then it goes into this song about and he sort of reprises um green green dress. Johnny can't decide. And then he does this song about how he's like struggling at the piano. Because the the piano is sort of his way of expressing himself and bringing this forward.

[37:22] J. Collis: And somebody who actually has a background in music theory should really be the person to analyze this song. But apparently it's got a lot of like key changes in it. And he's talking about like trying to f you know, he plays a dark C minor chord, and how jumping around the musical scale is sort of getting representing this jumble in his head, and he can't find the key of the song of his life.

[38:00] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe.

[38:18] ♪ Musical number: "Come to Your Senses" — performed by Jonathan Larson's ♪

[39:24] J. Collis: And then John sings a song "Why," which is probably the best song in the entire show by my book, because it is the slow ballad where it is reacting to all the negativity that has come onto him at this point. Everything—his show is not getting produced, his girlfriend left him, and the one solace of a friend he has is gonna die. So can I ask you a question? Would you think this song would still be effective in a different place in the show?

[39:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't think so.

[39:53] J. Collis: I'm half tempted to agree with you because originally it was in the middle.

[39:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[39:58] J. Collis: John, John. It was before Madison.

[40:02] Andrew DeWolf: No, it happened before Madison.

[40:03] J. Collis: It had another song leading into it. Um, the reason it's called "Why" is because you'll notice it's never there in the lyrics. There's a song before it where the Times Square scene. So when he's going to Madison Avenue, he walks through Times Square and he's reflecting on the state of Broadway. There's a song about that that he wrote that they didn't use. They used it in previews and they cut it. Um, you know, it's like where he's like, you know, write for the movies, write for TV. Who cares if it's crap? At least you won't write for free. Um, and at the end of that, he's "Why do I care?" And then he explains this is why he cares about the theater. Oh wait, God, what yeah, I'm mixing up versions of the show again. Um, there are multiple versions of the show.

[40:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I mean, it's a beautiful enough song that I think it works anywhere.

[40:48] J. Collis: But it's the only reason I don't like it here. It really is, but I like the monologue that precedes it afterwards.

[40:57] Andrew DeWolf: So you'd prefer the monologue to be afterward?

[40:59] J. Collis: Yeah, which is how it was originally set up. The monologue originally led straight into the final number. And he played the um riff from "Louder Than Words" under the monologue the entire time, and he just has this utter breakdown during it. I think that would be better.

[41:16] Andrew DeWolf: I can see that specific part.

[41:19] J. Collis: Yeah. Um, I mean, they—but Auburn agreed with you, obviously. He's like, "No, this has to be the 11 o'clock number. This has—this is what you centered the show around."

[41:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[41:28] J. Collis: Uh, yeah, and that's the best choice. What do you think, Andrew?

[41:31] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's gotta be right where it is. I don't—I can't see it being anywhere else. It should be the opening number.

[41:35] J. Collis: There you go.

[41:37] Andrew DeWolf: Opening, yeah, opening, yeah, open with this one.

[41:40] J. Collis: Put "Why" here.

[41:46] Andrew DeWolf: Which do you prefer?

[41:49] J. Collis: Ask the boy.

[42:11] J. Collis: Let's talk about "Louder Than Words," which I think is a great finale number. And just the phrasing of "Louder Than Words" is a summation of Jonathan, the character as well as Jonathan the person. Can't remember the details. "Actions speak louder than words" was a mantra he literally kept on a pinboard by his desk. And um, here's one of the other ones. Uh, "Simplify, Simplify, Simplify," which is one of Sondheim's mantras. And the other is, yeah, and the other is from an author named Richard Bach. And it's "Argue for your limitations, and sure enough, they're yours." Gorgeous quotes that he obviously went on to inspire John very well to create this. Was it always the final number?

[42:56] J. Collis: This, "Sugar," and "30/90" are like the three songs from "Tick, Tick... Boom!" that I will always happily listen to. Now why? Why's beautiful, but if I'm like just popping open music to listen to, it's not quite that song.

[43:13] Andrew DeWolf: You want the bops.

[43:15] J. Collis: I do want the bops. I'm a basic bitch like that. Um, "Why" is a beautiful song. It's just not like a casual listening song. It's so emotional and so personal, which is also funny because it's about how the Michael character being an actor, which is the one re—like again, the like one of the two big embellishments he made for that character. Because they also never lived together in real life. They were just close childhood friends and all that, but uh, you have to simplify and add things like that.

[43:53] Andrew DeWolf: I think it might be time for trivia.

[43:57] J. Collis: Holy shit!

[43:57] Andrew DeWolf: Good boy.

[43:59] J. Collis: Am I awake enough to do trivia?

[44:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um, we'll find out.

[44:03] J. Collis: I know I'm not. Jess is never awake enough to do trivia.

[44:07] Andrew DeWolf: Even at my knockout at trivia.

[44:11] J. Collis: Jess, I'm sorry I picked really bastard questions.

[44:14] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we'll go straight with the guest first here.

[44:16] J. Collis: Alright.

[44:17] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Uh, what actor portrayed Jonathan in the 2016 off-Broadway revival of "Tick, Tick... Boom!"

[44:25] J. Collis: Oh, that was after I moved. I actually didn't pay attention to that production.

[44:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[44:32] J. Collis: I'm an ocean away. Like, uh, I know there was a production. I know it was off-Broadway. I know it ran for like a year. I think it actually outran the original. But yeah, I would have to ask Auntie Google. I actually don't know. Jess, do you want to say this for me?

[44:45] Jess McInally: Um, Nick Blaemire?

[44:47] J. Collis: Blaemire?

[44:48] Jess McInally: Yeah, Nick Blaemire.

[44:50] J. Collis: Was it actually a good production?

[44:51] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Um, I know it had George Salazar as um, as Michael, which is great. I think that was fantastic. I did not see anything of that production.

[45:02] J. Collis: Yeah, like it ran for a while, but it was really under the radar.

[45:07] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't know it existed until I was looking at a Wikipedia. I was like, what?

[45:11] J. Collis: Yeah, I saw it in Vienna with Aressass. Um, it was like the whitest Michael you can imagine.

[45:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I picked a bastard question there too, so don't worry.

[45:26] J. Collis: In the bonus track on the "Tick, Tick... Boom!" cast recording, Larson sings his actual address. What is the building number?

[45:39] Jess McInally: You can always guess, Jess.

[45:41] Jess McInally: Um, something 87th Street. I don't fucking know. Um, 508.

[45:47] J. Collis: 508 is uh, if you want to start, you wanna stalk this guy who doesn't isn't alive anymore. That's his—that's his building.

[45:53] Andrew DeWolf: Is that the building he died?

[45:57] J. Collis: Yeah, it was uh, 508. I can't remember if it's Greenwich Street or Greenwich Avenue because it's New York and the name I don't know the naming conventions. It was a five-story walk-up. It was a dump. Like people romanticize his life in this flat. No, his flat was really like I've seen video from inside of it from that era. Like, yeah, it—no, you wouldn't want to live there. And it was across the street from a garbage truck depot. So it really was like this really shitty flat. Like when they talk about throwing the key down in "Rent," they had to do that. Um, there he had no heat. Um, they would chop up delivery pallets and illegally burn them. The bathtub really was in the kitchen. The walls were like kind of a gross dinge. You know, it—it was home.

[46:46] Andrew DeWolf: Jess loses.

[46:47] J. Collis: Congratulations, you're now the winner.

[46:50] Andrew DeWolf: So, what is your guys' overall thoughts on "Tick, Tick... Boom!" and your cheese rating? Andrew, you go first.

[46:56] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um, "Tick, Tick... Boom!" is uh, I think it's just like a better version of "Rent," the same music style, but the characters are more tolerable and relatable to me, which is really all that matters. Um, as far as a cheese rating, um, oh golly gee. I don't know. I'll give it like a New York style pizza.

[47:19] J. Collis: Great. What about you, J. Collis?

[47:23] J. Collis: Um, "Tick, Tick... Boom!" is really interesting. It's interesting and partly because it's about him. Um, and it does have this sort of universal appeal about what it means to find direction in your life. It's got a great score. Um, cheese rating, if we're talking about 2001, I would go with Cheese It's. They're really tasty. Yeah, they're really delish, but they've got a bit of high fructose corn syrup in them.

[47:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah.

[47:48] J. Collis: And they're a little processed. If we're talking about the original 90s version, um, definitely something raw with a bit of a tang to it. I love "Tick, Tick... Boom!" It is a much better version of "Rent." It has that—it speaks to me as an artist in the same way that "Sunday in the Park with George" and a lot of other things like that do. Um, it's about art, but in a way that doesn't feel pretentious. There's a self-awareness to this musical that I feel is lacking in a lot of art about art, and I think that's really needed. And my cheese rating is stick stick cheese.

[48:25] Andrew DeWolf: Terrible.

[48:25] J. Collis: Yeah, that was awful, Jess.

[48:27] Andrew DeWolf: Why?

[48:28] J. Collis: People give us money, Jess.

[48:33] J. Collis: Um, J. Collis, I know you got tons of stuff to promote. Start promoting it out there. Shill away.

[48:37] J. Collis: Yeah, so uh, so if you like "Tick, Tick... Boom!" um, if you hate "Tick, Tick... Boom!" if you like or hate "Rent," I wrote a book all about everything uh Jonathan Larson's wrote. It's called "Boho Days." You can pick it up for an affordable price um digitally or a less affordable price in hardcover. Um, I write Christmas pantomimes and other things as well. I have um "The Interstitials" coming up in a novel called "Forever Part 2" by a guy named Andy Gell, G-E-L-L. That'll be coming out in October, where I write about um, see if you can follow this and tell me if it's not too confusing. It's interstitials in "Forever" about a failed attempt to musicalize "Forever" as a jukebox musical. Um, the novel is—the books are based very heavily in Neo-Discordian lore. So there's a lot of very meta things going on.

[49:31] J. Collis: Um, I mean, one of the things we also didn't talk about is "Tick, Tick... Boom!" as a Memento Mori. And the fact that you kind of can't get out of the back of your head that this is about somebody who is on this cusp in this breakthrough but is going to die in five years. If you haven't thought about your death planning, you really should. Um, you know, get your paperwork in order, let people know what you want. Uh, I recommend buying a brick of moo and getting Moomufied. Uh, and then you can be part of a work of art forever. So go to MoomuVication.com. So check out.

[50:06] J. Collis: And you can find out all about that there as well.

[50:07] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you guys. Thank you for listening. Um, please rate us, review us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher. We're there at Musicals with Cheese. Our Twitter is at Cheesy Musicals. Our Patreon is Musicals with Cheese. Our Instagram is also Musicals with Cheese, as well as our YouTube page, that is Musicals with Cheese as well. But what isn't Musicals with Cheese is our email, which is musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our title card was created by Jolene Casco. Her Instagram is @JoleneCasco. Gentlemen, thank you for your time tonight. I understand it's very late for you. It's very early for another. Thank you all for dedicating your time and making this happen.

[50:43] J. Collis: Thank you for having me on.

[50:44] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you for coming on.

[50:46] J. Collis: Alright. Alright. Alright, folks. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred