"So much for our ever after!" This week Jess and Andrew chat about both "Bare: A Pop Opera" and "Bare the Musical" Honestly, they're pretty critical throughout the entire episode, so be ready for some pedantic whining.... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"So much for our ever after!" This week Jess and Andrew chat about both "Bare: A Pop Opera" and "Bare the Musical" Honestly, they're pretty critical throughout the entire episode, so be ready for some pedantic whining.. So dive into this episode and learn some stuff about "Bare!"
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess McEnally: Oh well hi, I didn't see you there.
[0:02] Jess McEnally: Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.
[0:06] Jess McEnally: Our current patrons are Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Larer, Lily Accles, Mackenzie Horner, John Donna, Terran the Duck, hashtag real duck, Melissa Goldman, hash man, hashtag real goldman, Jess Lightning, the best dress on this show, Ewan Cassidy, Haley McDonald, Taskier, Cal McLeod, Fire September, Sam Bergman, Mina Mineary, Monica Thereu, Ren Glaum.
[0:34] Jess McEnally: Haley Murray and Alison Wonderland.
[0:37] Jess McEnally: Um and this episode was requested by Mina Mineary, so just I hope you're happy, Mina.
[0:44] Jess McEnally: But these folks give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.
[0:49] Jess McEnally: If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patron only commentaries, there are episodes a day early, or even earlier, our after parties, and if you pay enough money like Mina Mineary here, um you can request episodes that we can do.
[1:03] Jess McEnally: And thank you for all your support.
[1:04] Jess McEnally: Is there anything else you have? Yeah, I guess.
[1:06] Jess McEnally: Um, anything else you wanna say, Andrew?
[1:08] Andrew DeWolf: You wanna thank them?
[1:09] Jess McEnally: I've already thanked them, I just did.
[1:13] Jess McEnally: Thanking Mina by name and say it right.
[1:16] Jess McEnally: Thank you, uh, Angel Moroni.
[1:20] Jess McEnally: Alright, guys, let's start the show.
[1:27] Jess McEnally: Hello, I'm Jess McEnally.
[1:30] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[1:32] Jess McEnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[1:37] Jess McEnally: How are you doing today, Andrew?
[1:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well, I mean I could be better. Uh my uh my secret gay lover just died randomly for no reason.
[1:46] Andrew DeWolf: And my ex-girlfriend is I heard that he took a lot of hallucinogens and uh like died on stage because of ODs.
[1:54] Jess McEnally: What?
[1:56] Andrew DeWolf: No, I killed him.
[2:02] Jess McEnally: What you did?
[2:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, this is not a bit. This has nothing to do with the show we're talking about.
[2:07] Jess McEnally: Oh, oh no.
[2:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, this is unreal.
[2:11] Jess McEnally: Oh this is unrelated, Jess. What show are we talking about, by the way?
[2:15] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[2:18] Jess McEnally: This week we are talking about Bare, a Pop Opera.
[2:22] Jess McEnally: Or as it was later retitled when it became a completely different new piece, Bare, the Musical.
[2:28] Andrew DeWolf: Man, I can't wait for Bare the Rock Opera.
[2:32] Jess McEnally: Or Bare the Opera.
[2:33] Andrew DeWolf: What about Bare, the movie?
[2:38] Jess McEnally: Ooh, Bare the Movie.
[2:39] Andrew DeWolf: And then, based on that, Bare the Movie, the video game.
[2:44] Jess McEnally: What about Bare, the movie part three, Brother Bear?
[2:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.
[2:55] Jess McEnally: Do you know?
[2:57] Jess McEnally: Well, of course you do what it's like to stand outside.
[3:01] Jess McEnally: To watch the world in which you didn't hurt so much you cry.
[3:05] Jess McEnally: I know I'm not the only one, and I know shouldn't care.
[3:10] Jess McEnally: But when I feel these things are real, I wish I felt you there.
[3:15] Jess McEnally: And if I did I'd ask you, how come life is so unfair?
[3:22] Jess McEnally: Do you know?
[3:23] Jess McEnally: Well, of course you do when it's like to be afraid.
[3:27] Jess McEnally: But nothing will become of all the plans you have made.
[3:32] Jess McEnally: So I'll watch the girls surround him and says it's just a game.
[3:37] Jess McEnally: Guess then I believe him, but it hurts me just the same.
[3:41] Jess McEnally: And I'm all about this stupid act.
[3:44] Jess McEnally: So who am I to believe?
[3:48] Jess McEnally: Are you there?
[3:49] Jess McEnally: Are you there to watch T Ware Cry?
[3:53] Jess McEnally: And if it's in your power, how can you send me by?
[3:58] Jess McEnally: Bare, also known as Bare, a Pop Opera, is a coming-of-age rock musical with music by Damon Intrabartolo, lyrics by John Hartmere, and a book by Hartmere and Intrabartolo.
[4:12] Jess McEnally: The story focuses on a group of high school students and their struggles at their private Catholic boarding school.
[4:18] Jess McEnally: The musical was later revived as Bare, the Musical.
[4:21] Jess McEnally: The revised musical returned to Off-Broadway for a limited run in June of 2013 at the York Theatre Company.
[4:27] Jess McEnally: This production was produced by Sponge Theatricals and Midtown Arts Common as a benefit for the LGBT youth homeless shelter, Trinity Place Shelter.
[4:38] Jess McEnally: The original production closed on February 3rd, 2013.
[4:42] Jess McEnally: Andrew, I can't even ask you what you think of this since technically you and I watched different versions of this.
[4:50] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I guess we can't discuss it then.
[4:52] Andrew DeWolf: Uh see you guys later.
[4:53] Andrew DeWolf: Bye.
[4:54] Andrew DeWolf: I'm waving.
[4:56] Andrew DeWolf: I'm waving right now.
[4:57] Andrew DeWolf: That's the episode.
[4:58] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck you, Mina Mineary.
[5:00] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't even watch your stupid show.
[5:06] Jess McEnally: No, no, no.
[5:08] Jess McEnally: So how we wanted to break this up, and I want to be fair, is usually I don't want to make Andrew watch more than one thing, because we have to record these both back to back.
[5:19] Jess McEnally: So I sent him the original Bare, a Pop Opera, where it was a full opera.
[5:24] Jess McEnally: And I decided I had watched Bare, a Pop Opera many years ago, but it's not really in my memory.
[5:31] Jess McEnally: But I had not watched Bare, the Musical, the revival version where they turned it into a basic book musical.
[5:37] Jess McEnally: So I decided to take a look at that because I was really on a Bare at Wilbur weed kick and I just dived into that.
[5:42] Jess McEnally: So that is where we stand and kind of where our difference is and where it's fresh in our mind.
[5:48] Jess McEnally: So now that we have that disclaimer, Andrew, what did you think of Bare, a Pop Opera?
[5:53] Andrew DeWolf: Um if I had to try to describe this, I would say it was very mediocre.
[6:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I was not blown away by anything in this in the slightest.
[6:05] Andrew DeWolf: And a lot of the music I felt like I have heard before from shows like uh Rent, Dear Evan Hansen, uh I mean I know some a lot of these some of the shows are afterwards, but like a lot of modern pop musicals sound very similar, uh if if that's fair to say.
[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um and the plot reminded me a lot of um well like Falsettos something like that.
[6:32] Jess McEnally: I disagree it feels nothing like Falsettos.
[6:35] Jess McEnally: It feels like Rent meets Next to Normal meets a little bit of Spring Awakening, which you haven't seen yet, but don't worry, you will.
[6:43] Andrew DeWolf: Thankfully I didn't feel the Rent as much in the plot as I did in the music um because I don't like Rent and I I didn't hate this as much as I hate Rent at all.
[6:54] Andrew DeWolf: Because the characters in this I actually did kind of like on some level.
[6:59] Andrew DeWolf: So whereas in Rent, I can't stand anyone in that.
[7:03] Jess McEnally: So this is got a bonus from that.
[7:06] Jess McEnally: It's it's a plus from that.
[7:09] Andrew DeWolf: I find the story in the original Pop Opera very, very difficult to follow.
[7:15] Andrew DeWolf: And even for me, someone who's used to like the musical theater techniques and storytelling.
[7:19] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm very, very interested in Andrew describing the plot really.
[7:23] Jess McEnally: I felt like I followed it, and I I and that's different because usually I feel like I didn't follow it.
[7:27] Jess McEnally: So this one I kinda actually felt like I did.
[7:30] Jess McEnally: Um but maybe I have the whole plot wrong, so like it might be just I don't know.
[7:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, how what had you think of the revision?
[7:40] Andrew DeWolf: Because I didn't I didn't really see much of that.
[7:42] Jess McEnally: You told me a little bit about what they changed, but I didn't get the whole rundown.
[7:48] Jess McEnally: So let me run down like what is on Wikipedia about what has changed, and then I'll tell you what exactly my thoughts are.
[7:55] Jess McEnally: So the creative heads analyzed the show with resulting changes that included making St. Cecilia's students' relationships more complex, changing or removing characters, adding and removing songs, and incorporating current technology and social media.
[8:10] Jess McEnally: Although Damon Intrabartolo did not have a real intricate role in the production, Shankel consulted him concerning the revisions in order to follow through with his primary intent.
[8:23] Jess McEnally: A team also added the start of Peter and Jason's relationship and took away the roommate aspect of their situation.
[8:30] Jess McEnally: So basically they meet and fall in love and start a relationship in the show, they don't just start as it.
[8:36] Jess McEnally: And the song "Roll of a Lifetime" no longer belongs to Peter, but they gave it to Jason instead.
[8:42] Jess McEnally: Um and remember the sister Nadia, um playing Jane Fatass, if you remember that song?
[8:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[8:50] Jess McEnally: Um, and you remember Luke guess the drug dealer in your version?
[8:54] Andrew DeWolf: N not really, no, but yeah.
[8:57] Jess McEnally: Basically, they merge those two characters together, and Nadia is now no longer overweight, and she is the school drug dealer and an angry outcast.
[9:05] Jess McEnally: She's still roommates with Ivy, but she is now the drug dealer, so they can cut out an entire character and give Nadia more to deal with.
[9:12] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[9:13] Jess McEnally: Because really, in your version that you watched, she kind of sits around and plays cello and bitches about her roommate and this guy masked.
[9:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she plays that one cello concerto that everyone plays.
[9:23] Andrew DeWolf: I played that. I performed that on electric bass.
[9:28] Andrew DeWolf: I forget what it's called.
[9:28] Jess McEnally: It's like it's a lot of people.
[9:32] Jess McEnally: Mm-hmm.
[9:32] Andrew DeWolf: Four.
[9:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't fucking know.
[9:35] Jess McEnally: But she's given a lot of active plot relevance, like she's the one that gives her brother the drugs that he eventually kills himself with.
[9:41] Jess McEnally: So she's tied a little bit more to the story instead of it feels a little bit less of a big advanced school where everyone kinda knows each other and feels a little bit more condensed, but also that's very important with storytelling, so don't bitch about that.
[9:55] Andrew DeWolf: Ivy has been made a transfer student and is now dating Matt.
[9:58] Jess McEnally: Reasons that provide a stronger basis for Nadia's anger.
[10:02] Jess McEnally: So really Nadia has much more reason to be mad at Ivy.
[10:06] Jess McEnally: Um the students that throw a birthday party for Jason instead of Ivy, since Ivy's the new student.
[10:11] Jess McEnally: The character of Peter's mother was also eliminated, so that entire coming out to your mother subplot is removed, which I kind of miss, but overall I get it kind of derailed the story a bit.
[10:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, a little bit.
[10:23] Jess McEnally: Although it did add a lot of conflict between him and Jason, but whatever.
[10:28] Jess McEnally: It's a different conflict in this.
[10:29] Jess McEnally: It's more about revealing yourself to the student body as opposed to coming out to your parents in this.
[10:36] Jess McEnally: Um, and a lot of the aspects of that mother character is brought into a new progressive nun, Sister Joan, who is played by Missy Pyle, who you guys might recognize from Gone Girl or Big Fish.
[10:47] Jess McEnally: So she more or less acts as like this moral center.
[10:50] Jess McEnally: She's cool, she's the hip nun that's gonna teach you about contraception and is okay with gay people.
[10:56] Andrew DeWolf: So not really in the priest is on the basically.
[11:01] Jess McEnally: Um also added is the character of Father Mike.
[11:05] Jess McEnally: Um both replace similar characters from the original production.
[11:08] Jess McEnally: The show's timeline is very different.
[11:10] Jess McEnally: Jason does not break up with Ivy right away after "Break and Kiss Your Broken Heart."
[11:15] Jess McEnally: Instead, they platonically date for a while.
[11:17] Jess McEnally: He breaks up with her right before "Pilgrim's Hands" and reconciles with Peter after "You're Not Alone."
[11:23] Jess McEnally: And it's just a lot more dramatic because everything's all interconnected and it feels like there's much more at stake.
[11:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.
[11:32] Jess McEnally: And since they get together on screen, you can actually see that Peter and Jason have developed their own kind of um cliques, so to say, so there's a lot more socially at risk if they fuck up.
[11:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.
[11:45] Jess McEnally: And they release up.
[11:47] Jess McEnally: It makes more sense to cut some of the characters, because like, I mean, I didn't even realize there was a drug dealer character.
[11:53] Andrew DeWolf: I think I missed that whole plot.
[11:56] Jess McEnally: His name was Lucas, he said that they were cool.
[12:00] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't s I didn't miss them, and I liked Nadia a lot more when she was given this characteristic.
[12:05] Jess McEnally: You felt that she was a lot more fucked up that way, in the way that you don't really feel like the Nadia from the original musical was.
[12:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[12:13] Jess McEnally: Or the original opera was.
[12:15] Jess McEnally: I mean, Nadia, I kept waiting for her to have something to do, like plot-wise, and it never really happened.
[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: So I don't know.
[12:23] Jess McEnally: Well, in this one, she's the one in my version, she's the one that outs her brother.
[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, there you go.
[12:28] Jess McEnally: Like, she see she goes through um hit her roommate's phone and finds a picture of him making out with Peter and then leaks it to Matt, who then confronts them both and outs him to Ivy, who's pregnant with their child.
[12:42] Andrew DeWolf: It's a fucking soap opera.
[12:44] Jess McEnally: But yeah.
[12:46] Jess McEnally: It's better done in the musical.
[12:48] Jess McEnally: And the fact is all the confusing music sections where everyone's singing is now turned to dialogue, so you're able to understand it better.
[12:55] Andrew DeWolf: There is a lot of shit that happens in this.
[12:59] Jess McEnally: Yes.
[13:00] Andrew DeWolf: If you didn't actually understand what I was saying there, don't worry. It won't make much more sense if you actually listen to it.
[13:05] Jess McEnally: Okay.
[13:08] Andrew DeWolf: So is this the part where I attempt to describe what happens in this?
[13:14] Jess McEnally: I mean, it probably would have been better if you had said it before I broke down the changes, but go for it.
[13:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah. Okay. Well, just stop me the second I get something wrong.
[13:24] Jess McEnally: I'll try my best, but remember I've seen two versions, and they're starting to blur together at this point.
[13:30] Andrew DeWolf: Jason and Peter.
[13:31] Jess McEnally: Okay, well, the thing is about Peter mostly, kind of, but it's also kind of about Jason.
[13:38] Andrew DeWolf: Jason is like this hot guy. You see, you see, you see, that's the biggest difference between your version and my version. Mine is mostly about Jason. But continue.
[13:45] Jess McEnally: Okay. Well, Jason is like this hot guy that all the girls like, and Peter is like a nobody kinda. But they're dating.
[13:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um. And then there's also these Secretly.
[13:58] Jess McEnally: Secretly, obviously, because they're Catholics.
[14:01] Andrew DeWolf: Because they're in a Catholic school.
[14:02] Jess McEnally: Yep. Which making them Catholic, I guess, allows this story to stay relevant for a longer period of time. Cause this wouldn't really work in some liberal arts college, I don't think.
[14:17] Andrew DeWolf: Uh fair. Then okay, and then there's another set of people, which is Nadia and Ivy.
[14:27] Jess McEnally: And Ivy is like a hot girl and Nadia is like not, and she likes musicals because she has a bunch of posters on her wall of musical shows. Like Hedwig and she really wants to play Juliet.
[14:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. And she really wants to play Juliet. But she won't because she's too fat.
[14:46] Jess McEnally: Sad cello. Play sad cello music for that.
[14:49] Andrew DeWolf: Can you bad cello?
[14:50] Jess McEnally: You see in my version she isn't given the role because her brother was given the role of Juliet or Romeo and they didn't want two siblings kissing.
[15:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[15:01] Jess McEnally: That's gross. Except for siblings kiss platonically probably all the time but whatever.
[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah my sister gave me a platonic hand job when I was seven it's fine.
[15:11] Jess McEnally: Me and my sister still shower together it's fine.
[15:14] Andrew DeWolf: Me and your sister still shower together it's fine.
[15:19] Jess McEnally: Okay. Okay then Hi Emily, I hope you're listening another character named Matt who is in love with Ivy.
[15:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[15:32] Jess McEnally: And Nadia is in love with Matt.
[15:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay I didn't really get that part but okay.
[15:36] Jess McEnally: That might just be in my version I think it is in the other version but I think I just kind of didn't get it quite.
[15:42] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly at first I thought Nadia was in love with Ivy and I thought it was gonna be like a weird I don't know. But she's not.
[15:51] Jess McEnally: Um see I'd like that better if it was how it was.
[15:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, um, okay. So it's kind of just like this big love square where Jason Ivy's in love with Jason, Peter and Jason are in love, but it's secret. Matt is in love with Ivy, but Matt can't get Ivy because Ivy wants Jason, and yeah.
[16:12] Jess McEnally: Eventually Peter and Jason break up. For some reason, I think there's too much pressure from having to hide it all the time.
[16:19] Andrew DeWolf: So Jason goes out with Ivy and gets her pregnant, but then they break up because well he's still in love with he's still gay.
[16:28] Jess McEnally: Peter. Okay, here's the question. Is he gay or bi?
[16:32] Andrew DeWolf: He's gay. I think he's gay.
[16:34] Jess McEnally: Alright, why why okay, because it is a little bit more blurred because he does say, I don't even know what I am yet. And he's like, You've made out with me, you're gay. And he's like, uh uh. Yeah. Maybe. I don't care.
[16:49] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I'm gonna say he's gay to make it easier on everyone listening. It just simplifies it a little more.
[16:57] Jess McEnally: I don't know. My thought was he's trying to go out with Ivy to like prove to himself that he's not gay, but it didn't work.
[17:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that was my thought. I don't know. Ivy gets pregnant, uh Matt, I think Matt reveals something, or Matt knows because like Peter kisses Matt or some shit.
[17:13] Jess McEnally: P Peter drunkenly whispered it in his ear.
[17:16] Andrew DeWolf: I remember this from your version. That he wa they were in a relationship.
[17:21] Jess McEnally: Yeah. It works much better when Nadia just finds out by looking through in Ivy's face.
[17:25] Andrew DeWolf: Doesn't that kind of make Matt's character like irrelevant though?
[17:29] Jess McEnally: What do you mean?
[17:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I felt like Matt was only in there just to be the guy that revealed the whole thing.
[17:35] Jess McEnally: I mean, he still is, because Nadia goes to Matt and says, Yeah, I don't know what to do, and then he just goes out and fucks it up.
[17:43] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a wreck it.
[17:44] Jess McEnally: I'm a wreck it. Matt has like the most generic I'm a I'm the bad guy haircut in my version.
[17:54] Andrew DeWolf: So I was like, yeah, he's gonna be the guy to find out and he's gonna reveal it, huh?
[17:58] Jess McEnally: And then he was, and it's like Can I give you a fun fact about your version?
[18:01] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[18:02] Jess McEnally: The one who played Peter in your version is the one that directed my version.
[18:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's interesting. Very cool.
[18:11] Jess McEnally: Very cool. Alright, keep going. We gotta get through this plot, so and then they actually do so the whole time they're doing Romeo and Juliet.
[18:21] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't even mention that because it's like almost not relevant until the very end. Um Yeah, but they're doing Romeo and Juliet.
[18:27] Jess McEnally: Yeah, at the very end, Jason, like I thought he just got drunk before the show, but I guess he took a bunch of hallucinogens, and they just show they just they all they show is he takes a swig of some alcohol, so I thought that that's all he did, but whatever.
[18:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um then he dies, and then Peter is sad and everyone's sad, and it's over. The end.
[18:47] Jess McEnally: Hey, hey, hey, you're forgetting a special important part where he goes to the priest and the priest tells him, just hide it forever, you're not gay, just put those feelings down in a bucket and crush it.
[18:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Elsa.
[19:00] Jess McEnally: I was quoting Book of Mormon, but that's fine.
[19:03] Andrew DeWolf: I was quoting Frozen.
[19:05] Jess McEnally: Frozen. I was referencing Frozen.
[19:08] Andrew DeWolf: I hate the ending. Did it just take me ten minutes to explain that plot?
[19:14] Jess McEnally: I hate the ending because he just he dies at the end for no fucking reason.
[19:20] Andrew DeWolf: Are you sad that he dies? Like did you just love him so much that you didn't want him to die?
[19:25] Jess McEnally: No. I just think it's stupid that he dies. It's such a I feel like it's almost a cop-out. Like they didn't know how to resolve all the stories that they created, so they're just like, he dies! The end.
[19:38] Andrew DeWolf: We got the gays, and the gays gotta die!
[19:41] Jess McEnally: Yeah, like okay. So we have like all these plots that are on Jason. Ivy's pregnant. What is he gonna do about that? He's in love with Peter, but he doesn't want to tell anybody. What does he do about that? Everyone found out! What does he do? And then he just dies, and it's like, okay, I guess nothing gets resolved, and that's the end. Cool.
[19:58] Andrew DeWolf: I guess when you've you're in a really rough situation, die on stage publicly in front of everyone, and that'll solve all your problems.
[20:06] Jess McEnally: It doesn't solve any problems, it just ends the story.
[20:09] Andrew DeWolf: It's just it's lame.
[20:10] Jess McEnally: Hey, he doesn't have to father that kid and he doesn't have to be in a relationship with Peter.
[20:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Cool. Great ending, guys.
[20:22] Jess McEnally: I don't like the ending at all. I feel like it would have been better if he was forced to confront the situation and actually solve something.
[20:29] Andrew DeWolf: And maybe he just diarrheas a whole bunch on stage and no one wants to talk to him.
[20:34] Jess McEnally: I feel like it's not a satisfying ending whatsoever. Maybe I'm in the minority here.
[20:39] Andrew DeWolf: Butrew, if you asked me to run away with you and you said no, I don't want to, I take a bunch of GHB and just die on stage performing the Queen Mab monologue, you know.
[20:54] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[20:55] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what I would say to that, Jess?
[20:57] Jess McEnally: What?
[20:57] Andrew DeWolf: Why the why the hell did you do that, Jess?
[21:01] Jess McEnally: You wouldn't even know.
[21:03] Andrew DeWolf: I cannot believe you've committed suicide.
[21:06] Jess McEnally: We it's strange how many suicides there are in musicals.
[21:11] Andrew DeWolf: It really is disturbing.
[21:13] Jess McEnally: I don't know. Someone. Um the same fella that did the um Miss Saigon, I can't believe you committed suicide.
[21:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yep, same same thing here.
[21:27] Jess McEnally: I don't know. At least in Miss Saigon, though, like her committing suicide didn't just abruptly end all the plot lines. Like that actually was built up to, and that was a resolution to the plot. Whereas with this, it just like, oh, we have all this drama and then it builds up and he just dies, and that's it.
[21:47] Andrew DeWolf: This doesn't feel like a story warranting suicide.
[21:51] Jess McEnally: No, it doesn't. It just it feels lame and it feels like they needed to actually come up with a real maybe what they happened is they wrote themselves into a corner and they were like, how do we actually solve all these problems that we created? And they're just like, we can't. I guess we'll just kill him.
[22:09] Andrew DeWolf: And you gotta really you gotta really feel bad for Ivy, because now, I mean, who's gonna raise that kid?
[22:14] Jess McEnally: Fucking nobody. Um do you really think that Jason would have been that good a father?
[22:19] Andrew DeWolf: He can't even figure out his own shit.
[22:21] Jess McEnally: No, I don't think he would have been a good father, but you know, now he's definitely not gonna be a good father.
[22:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, now he he's gonna be a good urn.
[22:31] Jess McEnally: Sorry, I was talking to your dad.
[22:39] Andrew DeWolf: No, I want to hear your more of your opinions on this. Like I just went.
[22:44] Jess McEnally: I just went through the whole plot here, and you got nothing to say, Jess?
[22:48] Andrew DeWolf: I went through the whole plot of mine, let's be fair.
[22:51] Jess McEnally: Okay.
[22:52] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let me ask you this. What what is the point of Nadia as a character in in the version I saw?
[22:58] Jess McEnally: She has absolutely no goddamn point in your version.
[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: She sings a couple pretty songs that a lot of girls like to pull out of the auditions and they're sad when those songs aren't in the new version where she actually has a point to be in the story.
[23:10] Jess McEnally: I feel like that Nadia is almost just in it because she's like the audience surrogate in a way like, oh this is this is who we think are is gonna like our show. Look, she has posters of Hedwig and the Angry Inch on her wall. You like that show, right? You like this character, right?
[23:29] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't like that show.
[23:29] Jess McEnally: I didn't like that show, no.
[23:31] Andrew DeWolf: Hey you never watched a show you only watched a movie we're gonna do a review of that so one day I didn't give it a thing you might get it. Although I'm pretty sure she has a I'm pretty sure Nadia has a poster of the movie on her wall, but whatever.
[23:45] Jess McEnally: I agree with most of what you're saying. In my version a lot of those problems are gone and the drama is mostly of the interpersonal but you also forgot to bring up a lot of the shit that didn't appear in mine.
[23:58] Andrew DeWolf: You're like you hit the broad strokes of all the things that appeared in mine. But you didn't bring up the fact that Peter wanted to come out to his mom and was begging um Jason to come home with him so he could do it which is what started their breakup that's true.
[24:11] Jess McEnally: There's also really bizarre stuff like uh Virgin Mary shows up and sings a song and that Peter brings that up and then it's like irrelevant after that and then who's the the sister has a bunch of songs and I I don't know there's just so much stuff that happens okay.
[24:39] Andrew DeWolf: So John Hartmere, who wrote the book and lyrics to the new version, said the biggest change is having more space to explore the characters, to know these characters a little bit better, you need more room. You need more room for book scenes, and I personally just wanted to get under the hood and investigate a little bit further.
[24:57] Jess McEnally: So I think he's mostly talking about Nadia there, who is this drug dealer, who which is much more active role in this. She's a much more sardonic, much more sarcastic, and she's not just poor me the entire time, and she is actively reaching out to Matt and trying to fuck him all the time.
[25:16] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like if that relationship, like if that was played up more as a secondary couple, in the version I saw, it might have one been more interesting to watch because it's not literally just the same drama over and over and over again. Um, but it also would have given it something to cut away to, other than just these filler scenes where you have like, oh, he has a dream sequence where he sees the Virgin Mary, uh, or or oh, the sister has a song where he she sings to Peter.
[25:47] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. It just there seems to be a lot of filler stuff that just doesn't need to be there. And you see, the Virgin Mary song is still in my version, except it's done more as a parody of Madonna, because you know, Madonna, Madonna, it's a dumb pun. Um, it is a little bit less plot relevant and just there for fun, and it's like more about how useless, like calling out to these merry people are, whereas the actual Mother Mary in your version is very plot relevant.
[26:19] Jess McEnally: Yes. She basically tells him what to do.
[26:23] Andrew DeWolf: If I remember quite a bit. Or in this one, it's like, hey, don't you're you're calling Mary, don't waste your chance, and then he wastes his chance.
[26:30] Jess McEnally: Yep. I'm actually genuinely upset that they kill him at the end. I really thought that that was a lame ending.
[26:37] Andrew DeWolf: I agree, and I'm not sure it's effectively done. Like I feel like a tragic end for a character like Jason can be effective, and it does have an effective resolution. Like I like the scene where Peter forgives the priest. I think that's well done, but I don't think it's earned.
[26:57] Jess McEnally: It's not earned, Andrew. It's not.
[27:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's really not. I think what they they really wanted, and I think the reason I compared it to Falsettos at the beginning is because I think they really wanted that big tear-jerking, like, oh he's dead. Oh my goodness, he's dead. Oh, it's all so sad, but I just don't think they I don't think they earned it at all.
[27:17] Jess McEnally: Would you say that Falsettos earned it better?
[27:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and I know I've been I have was famously really hard on that. I guess I don't think I really was that hard on it, but whatever. Uh I didn't think it was that sad personally, but I can definitely see how it was built up to a lot better than what they did in this, and how someone could actually could be genuinely affected by that death. Whereas with this one, if you told me that like you cried when Jason died, I I I feel like I I could not I couldn't relate to that. That's just like Hey, don't lie.
[27:47] Jess McEnally: Don't forget one of our $20 patrons requested that we review this.
[27:51] Andrew DeWolf: I don't care. I'm not gonna go easy on this just because Ain't gonna be a good one. I I love Mina Mani, and I think she's a really great and fun person to talk to, because we just had that live stream and she was great. Uh that doesn't mean I'm gonna go easy on this, because uh that's not who I am as a person.
[28:10] Jess McEnally: And that's not what she wants to see. She she's paying for a legitimate episode on this, and that's what we're giving her.
[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, speaking of legitimacy, let's go into a mid-show announcement.
[28:26] Jess McEnally: Hi guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Tell us a little bit about Patreon, Andrew.
[28:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh well, Patreon is where you go if you want to give us some money and see some extra features like uh after parties, uh, after every show, we record a little bit more just talking about what we uh discussed, or or just unrelated shit, which is what it most of the time is. Um, and also talking about the Batman casting.
[28:53] Jess McEnally: Yeah, we talk about Batman a lot for some reason.
[28:56] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to. Our current patrons, and I'm gonna go through this fast because we have a lot of them right now. But our current patrons are Stephanie L. Terry Needleman, Max Looning, Benjamin Lear, Lily Accles, Mackenzie Horner, John Donna, Terran the Duck, Melissa Goldman, Jess Lightning, Ewan Cassidy, Haley McDonald, Tuskier, Colin McCloud, Fire September, Sam Bergman, Mina Maneary, M Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, hi Brent, Haley Murray, and Alison Wonderland, which I really like that last name. And thank you, Mina Manary, for uh this episode, by the way.
[29:27] Jess McEnally: Big thanks. Thank you for making us watch this. But these folks give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patron only commentaries, our episodes a day early, or even earlier, come join us over at Patreon. Andrew, let's get back to the show.
[29:50] ♪ Musical number ♪
[30:45] Jess McEnally: Which is Jason and Peter's song. Basically cementing their relationship.
[30:50] Andrew DeWolf: Is this the one with the baseball bat?
[30:52] Jess McEnally: I think so. Yeah.
[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: That was some weird lyrics. I I was thinking, like, who calls their penis a baseball bat? You know? Is that a is that a normal thing that college kids do? I didn't I never really truly went to college. Like I never stayed in a dorm or anything like that. So I've never heard anyone call their penis a baseball bat, but maybe that's a normal thing.
[31:13] Jess McEnally: Hey guys, what is your penis look like? Leave a comment down on Twitter. Is your is your penis very small at the at the base and gets extremely large at the end? Just like a baseball?
[31:24] Andrew DeWolf: I shouldn't say that. Should not say that, Jess.
[31:31] Jess McEnally: I mean, let's take it either like Jess. Here's what I'm curious about, actually. How Yeah?
[31:37] Andrew DeWolf: Cause in in the U and I that I saw, um, they are already going out. In the version where they're not already going out, how does this song work?
[31:45] Jess McEnally: It kind of builds up to them starting to go out, if that makes sense.
[31:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[31:50] Jess McEnally: Like at one point he's wearing his Letterman jacket, and then they kind of switch shirts and then they kind of play around, and then they're making out by the end of the song.
[31:58] Andrew DeWolf: So they they get together very early in the show.
[32:00] Jess McEnally: They get together early in the show, but whereas in your version it's kind of implied they've been together for years.
[32:07] Andrew DeWolf: A little bit, yeah. In fact, I was I was almost a little bit confused as to like, oh, they're already I guess these two are just a thing, okay.
[32:15] Jess McEnally: Which is why I think it was a smart idea to introduce like that conflict early in the sh new version, because at least then you kind of get the idea of it.
[32:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah. Okay. Um, I think it works better in my version, just because I don't think the lyrics are as good in my version. Um, even with the baseball bat as a penis reference.
[32:39] Jess McEnally: Well, of course, I mean that's one of the best lyrics I've ever heard in my life. Andrew, that that is genius.
[32:44] Andrew DeWolf: That is. It's it's pretty good quality. I thought I honestly though, I thought it was funny. I I did laugh. It's one of those lines that is goofy. Like, uh one of the things I do appreciate about Bear is it isn't afraid to be funny, it doesn't take itself too seriously.
[32:59] Jess McEnally: Yeah, I think Rent could learn a thing or two from this.
[33:02] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Rent tries to be funny, it just doesn't work.
[33:05] Jess McEnally: Yes, that's what I'm saying. It's things like, oh, what's an Uber serious one? There's a lot of way too serious musicals out there. I don't know. We got all your favorites like Parade and Next to Normal.
[33:21] Andrew DeWolf: Parade's got laughs, next to normal has laughs, so fuck you.
[33:26] Jess McEnally: Jess, just because you're laughing doesn't mean it's funny.
[33:30] Andrew DeWolf: The audience laughs, Andrew. The audience laughs. So maybe you're the weird one.
[33:38] Jess McEnally: I'm the weird one. Okay, okay. Yes. Can we talk about the songs?
[33:44] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember what the name of the song is, but there's like songs, several songs where they're just singing Shakespeare lines.
[34:07] Jess McEnally: Some shall be pardoned and some perish.
[34:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I don't like it. Did they cut that in the rework? Because that would have been one of the first things I would have.
[34:21] Jess McEnally: I was gonna say that would have been one of the very first things I would have cut. I would have been like, then.
[34:25] Andrew DeWolf: It does sound pretty though.
[34:26] Jess McEnally: It does sound very pretty when you have all those voices working together.
[34:30] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think the music itself is bad with it. It's just like lyrically, them singing like you know, just random lines from Shakespeare works is like it's just weird.
[34:42] Jess McEnally: I thought you loved Something Rotten.
[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: Something Rotten never did that, I don't think, did they?
[34:47] Jess McEnally: Yeah. I mean they Now is the now is the winter of our discontent.
[34:53] Andrew DeWolf: I suppose they do it a few times, but it makes a little more sense when Shakespeare is an actual character in the show.
[35:01] Jess McEnally: Yes. You make a point. Let's talk about Role of a Lifetime.
[35:10] ♪ Musical number ♪
[36:05] Jess McEnally: So this is sung by Peter in your version, where he's basically preparing for his auditions and all that.
[36:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[36:12] Jess McEnally: And he's talking about how the role of a lifetime is pretending to be straight when you're really gay.
[36:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. And they give it to Jason in your version.
[36:21] Jess McEnally: Yes, and in your version, it's a it makes less sense because Peter's more wanting to be out. Which I am vacillating between these two choices is a sad thing. I feel like they both work as a choice because I mean him saying that it's the role of a lifetime still doesn't necessarily mean that he doesn't want to come out. But it could work as an I want song for why he wants to come out.
[36:45] Andrew DeWolf: It could, absolutely. So giving it to Jason might actually not make sense.
[36:50] Jess McEnally: Yes, which is an argument I've seen. And the placement is changed very drastically. For you, Role of a Lifetime for Peter is like the second song. Second main song. It's a closest one. Whereas for me, it is the s for me, it is the second song before the end of Act One. It's a last song before Act One closer.
[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that's a very big change. What so how do they do that?
[37:14] Jess McEnally: Um, all the stuff happens and it happens right after Peter and Jason break up.
[37:20] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Yeah, that's bizarre. So who has the I want song in that then?
[37:25] Jess McEnally: Nobody does, and that's a really weird thing. You and I act in the I want song place.
[37:31] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so it's like a couples thing, maybe. Maybe that's what they're going for.
[37:35] Jess McEnally: Nope.
[37:35] Andrew DeWolf: Like as a couple, this is what they want.
[37:38] Jess McEnally: Moral, I guess so, but then again, it is them discovering they're in love with each other instead of your version where they're already together.
[37:46] Andrew DeWolf: That is bizarre structure-wise. So I guess it is. I could see people disliking that change.
[37:52] Jess McEnally: I can too. There's a lot of changes in my version that I like, but that's one of them I'm not a hundred percent sure I love.
[37:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Do you remember okay? We're gonna move on from that because I think we said all we can say about that. Um, do you remember the song A Quiet Night at Home?
[38:06] Jess McEnally: I do remember that song. A quiet night at home. Just me and my good shepherd, he and I can count a million sheep. The quiet night at home, filling up the time to finally again to sleep.
[38:28] ♪ Musical number ♪
[39:12] Jess McEnally: It's kind of pretty and nice and sweet, right? It is, and it has the little cello solo thing that she plays. It's alright. It's cut entirely in my version. It's kind of irrelevant plot-wise, though. It's like it's just this side character singing about how she's alone again. Although, what I don't quite get about it is don't all of her friends just come over and like ask her to come and she says no, and then she's singing about how everyone left. Basically, it makes no sense. And I like it better when Nadia is only friends with people when she has drugs. Like that is a very visually plain shown, and it shows like her stresses about life very without having to give her a song about I'm sitting at home and it's sad. Oh, look at it, I could play cello, and cello's a sad instrument to hear.
[40:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't know, and I thought my first thought with that whole thing is all of her friends come over and are like, Yeah, come on out, we're all going out, and she's like, I don't want to. And then she sits at home and she's like, Oh, all my friends left me again. Like, like, so did what does you want them to sit in your room with you? Like, is that what the song's about?
[40:31] Jess McEnally: Who's out there?
[40:32] Andrew DeWolf: Matt?
[40:33] Jess McEnally: Yeah, are you alright?
[40:34] Andrew DeWolf: I'm fine.
[40:36] Jess McEnally: You have some wine.
[40:38] Andrew DeWolf: This is holy wine.
[40:40] Jess McEnally: Father hasn't blessed it yet.
[40:42] Andrew DeWolf: In that case, grab a chalice.
[40:44] Jess McEnally: Thanks.
[40:44] Andrew DeWolf: Much sucks. Here have the rest.
[40:47] Jess McEnally: So why'd you leave the party?
[40:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was getting kinda poor too.
[40:52] Jess McEnally: There's another reason.
[40:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[40:54] Jess McEnally: It sucks to be ignored.
[40:56] Andrew DeWolf: I know.
[40:56] Jess McEnally: I always fight to do what's right, and this is my remote.
[41:03] Andrew DeWolf: Are you there?
[41:04] Jess McEnally: Are you there?
[41:06] Andrew DeWolf: Can you make some time for me?
[41:08] Jess McEnally: They tell me that you're out there, and they tell me that you see.
[41:13] Andrew DeWolf: I tried to find the meaning guy. Here's another song I want to talk to you about and compare your version to my version.
[41:20] Jess McEnally: Are you there? Do you remember this?
[41:21] Andrew DeWolf: Between Matt and Peter?
[41:22] Jess McEnally: Yeah, this is uh is this where he tells him?
[41:26] Andrew DeWolf: In your version, yes.
[41:28] Jess McEnally: Yes, okay, yeah, I do remember this then. Tell me what happens in your version, more or less of this song.
[41:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Peter and Matt are both singing basically to God, asking why their life is so unfair after um well after Jason leaves Peter for Ivy, and basically Ivy doesn't go out with Matt, which is what he wants. So they're both upset that life is so unfair, and they sing to each other, and then Peter has like a moment with him for some reason, because like they're probably both drunk, I guess, and he tells them that he's gay with Jason.
[42:00] Jess McEnally: Let me tell you what happens to my version.
[42:02] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[42:03] Jess McEnally: So the musical starts with Matt and Ivy dating already.
[42:08] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[42:08] Jess McEnally: And then Ivy breaks.
[42:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it does.
[42:14] Jess McEnally: And she breaks up with him in a way that kind of makes you hate Ivy. Where she's like, You're a really nice guy, Matt. I wish we were in a place where that meant more.
[42:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yikes.
[42:25] Jess McEnally: That is.
[42:27] Andrew DeWolf: That is a big yikes.
[42:29] Jess McEnally: And hashtag nice guy syndrome.
[42:33] Andrew DeWolf: And was there a subplot in your version?
[42:35] Jess McEnally: It's been a long time since I watched your version.
[42:38] Andrew DeWolf: Where Ivy allegedly slept with her teacher at her old school.
[42:43] Jess McEnally: Um, no, there's not.
[42:45] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, that's a big plot point in this where Nadia just spreads that rumor, like wild fire, and Ivy denies it at first, but then later confesses to it.
[42:55] Jess McEnally: So it is it is actually true in your version.
[42:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[42:58] Jess McEnally: Um and Nadia.
[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[43:02] Jess McEnally: And Nadia wanted to spread it so that Matt would break up with Ivy because I or Nadia wanted to fuck Matt. You know, high school bullshit.
[43:12] Andrew DeWolf: And then they sing Are You There separately. They're not even in the same room. They just kinda sing it. Like there's two spotlights and they're just singing out to God.
[43:21] Jess McEnally: I guess Matt is more justified in singing it this time.
[43:24] Andrew DeWolf: Because yeah, right.
[43:26] Jess McEnally: But I kind of miss the bonding element between Peter and Matt.
[43:30] Andrew DeWolf: I honestly I like Matt's character, and I feel like they I wish there was more with him.
[43:34] Jess McEnally: There's a lot more with him in my version, let me tell you that. He doesn't really do much in this one.
[43:39] Andrew DeWolf: And then at the by the end, he's just kind of like bad person who revealed it. Haha, gotcha.
[43:43] Jess McEnally: I'm not gonna lie, um, I wanna say good kudos on the world for making the F slur like a lot less used. I remember when I was like a kid, I heard it all the time, but while re-watching this, I was like, uh, I don't like hearing that at all.
[44:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:02] Jess McEnally: So kudos on the world. Not using that word as much.
[44:05] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think they say it in the version I watched.
[44:08] Jess McEnally: Um, yeah, Matt had to scream it at um Jason at one point.
[44:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, maybe he did. I don't remember.
[44:14] Jess McEnally: Cause that's the main plot point.
[44:18] Andrew DeWolf: Don't worry, Jess. We'll just get other slurs that are gonna be just as bad, and we'll use those instead. That's just how language works.
[44:24] Jess McEnally: Okay, great.
[44:25] Andrew DeWolf: Great.
[44:26] Jess McEnally: Alright, so we're gonna talk about one more song in act one.
[44:29] Andrew DeWolf: So much for our ever after.
[44:33] Jess McEnally: I thought the good guys would triumph.
[44:36] Andrew DeWolf: I trusted the hero.
[44:39] Jess McEnally: I didn't hear his goodbye.
[44:42] Andrew DeWolf: I guess it was lost in the talk of a straight acting coward.
[44:49] Jess McEnally: Who are you to go and blame this all on me?
[44:53] Andrew DeWolf: You're the one who went ahead and changed the rules.
[44:56] Jess McEnally: What?
[44:57] Andrew DeWolf: You found your way and now it's all okay!
[45:00] Jess McEnally: Is it that simple then?
[45:01] Andrew DeWolf: Really?
[45:02] Jess McEnally: You're such a fool.
[45:04] Andrew DeWolf: It's time to wake up, Peter.
[45:06] Jess McEnally: Put away the fairy tales.
[45:08] Andrew DeWolf: Factor striking midnight, can't you hear?
[45:11] Jess McEnally: Not all tales have happy endings.
[45:13] Andrew DeWolf: We can't keep pretending, cause there's no such thing as heroes who are queer.
[45:21] Jess McEnally: Sure thing.
[45:21] Andrew DeWolf: And it's ever after for you.
[45:23] Jess McEnally: But in my version, it's I meant to tell you.
[45:26] Andrew DeWolf: They're sung it to the exact same melody, so they're basically the same song.
[45:33] Jess McEnally: I meant to tell you.
[45:36] Andrew DeWolf: I love you.
[45:37] Jess McEnally: I've been waiting to say it.
[45:41] Andrew DeWolf: As always, my timing.
[45:45] Jess McEnally: But they changed the lyrics.
[45:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, so what describe what happens in your version.
[45:50] Jess McEnally: This is where, like, doesn't Jason tell Peter that he's never coming back together with him or whatever the heck.
[45:57] Andrew DeWolf: Basically.
[45:59] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[45:59] Andrew DeWolf: So basically Peter is like begging him to come back, and and Jason's just like, no, we're done forever.
[46:05] Jess McEnally: I can't do this anymore.
[46:06] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.
[46:07] Jess McEnally: And he says, like, so much for our ever after, which is the phrase.
[46:12] Andrew DeWolf: And my version.
[46:14] Jess McEnally: Which I think.
[46:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah?
[46:15] Jess McEnally: Okay, go ahead.
[46:16] Andrew DeWolf: No, I want to hear what you were gonna say.
[46:17] Jess McEnally: Isn't isn't so much for our ever after a pop song that came out?
[46:21] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[46:23] Jess McEnally: I don't remember.
[46:24] Andrew DeWolf: Go ahead.
[46:24] Jess McEnally: But in my version, it's I meant to tell you, which is I meant to tell you I loved you instead of so much for our ever after.
[46:33] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[46:34] Jess McEnally: And I think the same thing, isn't it?
[46:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but your version is much more operatic and more unsaid, where this one's like, fuck it, we're being direct. We gotta get to the idiots in the audience and let them know what's going on.
[46:47] Jess McEnally: You know what? I'm an idiot in the audience, and I do like it when things are direct.
[46:50] Andrew DeWolf: I think in a story, I agree. If you're telling a story, be as direct so we know exactly what our characters want, because that's important in storytelling.
[46:58] Jess McEnally: But as a song, I think I prefer ever after as a song.
[47:01] Andrew DeWolf: Well, when you when you just sing a song by itself, you can be a lot more vague about things. That's why a lot of pop songs are in rock songs are just not about anything at all. It's just like, oh, love or something, you know.
[47:15] Jess McEnally: So much for our ever after.
[47:18] Andrew DeWolf: Did you sleep with her?
[47:21] Jess McEnally: No.
[47:23] Andrew DeWolf: Life is short and life is strange.
[47:26] Jess McEnally: Troubled now and troubled past.
[47:29] Andrew DeWolf: Times have changed, they're rearrange, and little girls grow up so fast.
[47:35] Jess McEnally: Feel it how it grows inside me.
[47:39] Andrew DeWolf: Swirling ball of anguished cries.
[47:42] Jess McEnally: Haunted, daunted, so unwanted.
[47:45] Andrew DeWolf: Feel its anger in me rise.
[47:48] Jess McEnally: Dream a dream, then dash another.
[47:51] Andrew DeWolf: Life is there to interrupt.
[47:54] Jess McEnally: Someone out there.
[47:55] Andrew DeWolf: Call my mother.
[47:57] Jess McEnally: Look at me.
[47:58] Andrew DeWolf: Mom all Ron.
[48:02] Jess McEnally: Alright, let's what what's next?
[48:04] Andrew DeWolf: All grown up sung by Ivy.
[48:06] Jess McEnally: And I really want to shout it out.
[48:08] Andrew DeWolf: All grown up.
[48:09] Jess McEnally: I want the world to know.
[48:13] Andrew DeWolf: You just brought it's actually pronounced all grown up, you illiterate creep.
[48:22] Jess McEnally: Each and every day is like a mini vacation.
[48:26] Andrew DeWolf: All grown up with you.
[48:29] Jess McEnally: Okay.
[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, I don't have anything else to say about this song.
[48:35] Jess McEnally: I was curious what the context was in your version.
[48:38] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, which song is this?
[48:39] Jess McEnally: Cause I don't really go by this.
[48:40] Andrew DeWolf: This is Ivy's song where she's like really sad and kind of vents out.
[48:45] Jess McEnally: Oh, is this after she's pregnant or whatever?
[48:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[48:50] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[48:50] Andrew DeWolf: There's not really much context to this, is there?
[48:52] Jess McEnally: She's she's pregnant and Jason says he's not gonna help her.
[48:57] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay, so that that helps me a bit. Alright, keep going.
[49:00] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[49:00] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, wait, no, this might be before Jason says that.
[49:03] Jess McEnally: Is it?
[49:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's not.
[49:05] Jess McEnally: I'm trying to remember when Jason says that he's not gonna help her.
[49:09] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's in the song following called Promise.
[49:12] Jess McEnally: It's either that or it's from the song Touch My Soul, but I don't think it is.
[49:16] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's later on.
[49:19] Jess McEnally: Yeah, no. So yeah, he she just found out that she's pregnant and she hasn't talked to him yet. So that's what the that's when this is.
[49:26] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let me tell you how what the song is about in my version. It's about her confessing um to Nadia that she did have an affair with her teacher, and it ends with her revealing that she's pregnant to Nadia.
[49:38] Jess McEnally: Is this the teacher's baby?
[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it's Jason's.
[49:45] Jess McEnally: So is Nadia the bad guy in the in the rework one?
[49:50] Andrew DeWolf: No, she really isn't though. She does some bad things, but she's not the antagonist.
[49:56] Jess McEnally: I would say straight up Matt is the bad guy in this version.
[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: He's the closest thing to a bad guy in my version, too.
[50:02] Jess McEnally: Oh, okay.
[50:03] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, he has the bad guy haircut and everything.
[50:06] Jess McEnally: He's played by the short guy from Be More Chill in my version, which I think is funny.
[50:10] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that's interesting choice.
[50:15] Jess McEnally: So this in in yours, she confesses everything to Nadia.
[50:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[50:19] Jess McEnally: What brings her to do that?
[50:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's interesting.
[50:21] Jess McEnally: Who else can she talk to?
[50:22] Andrew DeWolf: Because she can't get Jason alone.
[50:24] Jess McEnally: Probably anybody but the person who hates you, right?
[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: I it was kind of like I need to vent to someone, and that's your roommate, and she's always there.
[50:33] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[50:34] Andrew DeWolf: Mistake.
[50:35] Jess McEnally: Just like having a baby.
[50:38] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh.
[50:39] Jess McEnally: Take that pregnant mothers.
[50:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yo, all you Catholics out there, put your condoms on.
[50:46] Jess McEnally: Come on.
[50:46] Andrew DeWolf: Just just pull out and come on her tummy.
[50:49] Jess McEnally: That doesn't work, Jess.
[50:52] Andrew DeWolf: That's where the baby's made, anyways.
[50:53] Jess McEnally: You're just putting it in the same spot.
[50:58] Andrew DeWolf: Same result.
[50:59] Jess McEnally: In fact, it's actually easier to get pregnant that way.
[51:04] Andrew DeWolf: Jess, I got a question.
[51:05] Jess McEnally: Um, what happened?
[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: How does Ivy confess to Jason that she's pregnant?
[51:10] Jess McEnally: Uh in your version.
[51:11] Andrew DeWolf: I there's like there's like a song where they're going back and forth, and I think Jason thinks that she's just trying to get back with him, but she's trying to tell him that she's pregnant.
[51:20] Andrew DeWolf: And then eventually it finally comes out, and then Jason like loses it a little bit.
[51:25] Jess McEnally: Alright, so here's how it happens in my version where it's like, amp up the drama.
[51:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[51:31] Andrew DeWolf: So he has been ignoring Peter and Ivy for a while, and then he just misses Peter so much, he comes to see him for like something platonic, like getting his picture taken for the yearbook.
[51:42] Andrew DeWolf: They start making out, and he's like, I promise to be with you forever. I want to come out. Like, we're gonna be happy forever. And then Ivy comes in and is like, excuse me, Peter, can I have a moment alone?
[51:53] Andrew DeWolf: And then Peter's like listening into the door, and she tells him he's pregnant, and then Matt storms in and says, like, you're pregnant with his boyfriend's baby.
[52:03] Jess McEnally: And it's like that's a little bit goofy.
[52:10] Andrew DeWolf: It is, but it works.
[52:13] Andrew DeWolf: You're pregnant with his boyfriend's baby.
[52:19] Andrew DeWolf: But it explains it for the dum-dums, and I'm like, I'm keeping up the plot at least. Hey, I understand what's happening now. You know, and when do they get hit on the head with a coconut?
[52:30] Jess McEnally: For you, Jess, so you can laugh.
[52:32] Andrew DeWolf: That's how he dies in my version.
[52:35] Jess McEnally: I'll stray coconut.
[52:43] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about banners.
[52:46] Jess McEnally: Wait, so when when Jason dies, just Matt run out on the stage and he goes, He just died because he was upset. My boyfriend died from taking too many hallucinogens.
[52:58] Andrew DeWolf: But he's also leaving behind a pregnant girlfriend. Oops.
[53:04] Jess McEnally: And then the curtains.
[53:27] Andrew DeWolf: Please understand that I trust you. It's not a ball.
[53:35] Jess McEnally: So Bear, the song that he and Peter, Jason and Peter sing to each other basically right before he dies, like admitting that they always loved each other.
[53:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[53:48] Jess McEnally: I love this song. What about it?
[53:50] Andrew DeWolf: I love this scene real a lot. I think it would be better if he didn't die afterwards, but you see, this scene only works if he dies afterwards, in my opinion.
[53:59] Jess McEnally: I don't think the way he dies works. But if they're going for this Romeo and Juliet kind of theme they got here where they admit they die, but one of them is doomed to die because he did something fucking stupid.
[54:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[54:13] Jess McEnally: That's kind of how I feel during this. The same way that Juliet not or Romeo not realizing that Juliet's just faking. It's supposed to be that kind of situation. But and if it was better set up, it would have worked really, really well. Right now, I just think it works okay.
[54:30] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna counter with uh Romeo and Juliet dying at the end also sucks.
[54:35] Jess McEnally: Oh Romeo and Juliet sucks.
[54:38] Andrew DeWolf: Are you gonna say that to William Shakesman himself? Are you gonna tell William Shatner you don't like his play?
[54:45] Jess McEnally: Uh if he was if he was alive, I would tell him that Romeo and Juliet sucks and I don't like it. Just let him live happy ever after. What the fuck? Come on.
[54:54] Andrew DeWolf: Gay people can't live happy ever after before 2005, Andrew.
[54:58] Jess McEnally: Thanks, Obama.
[55:00] Andrew DeWolf: Obama let gays live in harmony. Didn't you know this, Andrew?
[55:05] Jess McEnally: And then the great Saint Obama came down and granted them happiness forever after. You see, Andrew, there is only three ways a musical can end. One of them is a marriage, one of them is a courtroom, and one of them is a funeral.
[55:21] Andrew DeWolf: Those are the only three ways that they can end. And since gay marriage wasn't legalized, there's no reason for gays to be in a courtroom, they all have to die.
[55:32] Jess McEnally: Um well, I mean, the gays could go to court to get gay marriage legalized. Could end it that way.
[55:40] Andrew DeWolf: That would make them active characters in their own story, and we can't have that.
[55:44] Jess McEnally: That's true. Or we could have it take place in 2019 and it could end with a marriage.
[55:48] Andrew DeWolf: That would have been nice.
[55:50] Jess McEnally: That would have been nice. Why can't we just have happy endings? Why can't all musicals just end with hello Donnie?
[55:57] Andrew DeWolf: Man, I I do like happy endings. I also like bittersweet endings, but this one's not bittersweet, it's just bitter.
[56:04] Jess McEnally: What do you think is the most bittersweet ending we've ever watched?
[56:08] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I'd have to think on that. I'm trying to remember. There was there was a few good ones that I did like, but I can't quite remember. I think Parade was one of them.
[56:16] Jess McEnally: You think that's bittersweet?
[56:18] Andrew DeWolf: I think that musical's just kind of a bitter ending.
[56:20] Jess McEnally: I think that one's just kind of straight bitter. Although that one it builds up to a lot more and it's a little more earned. Cause that one the whole entire thing is building up to him dying, basically.
[56:31] Andrew DeWolf: Whereas with this one, he just kinda dies at the end, and that's really it. I think that falsettos pulls off a bittersweet ending very well.
[56:39] Jess McEnally: I guess.
[56:40] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that one's just kinda bitter too, though.
[56:42] Jess McEnally: Well, it doesn't have it gives them their last goodbye and their last moment to love each other, whereas this one does that, but one of them isn't aware that the other one's about to die, so it kinda doesn't work as well.
[56:53] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like Dear Evan Hansen was a really bittersweet ending.
[56:57] Jess McEnally: Fuck you.
[56:59] Andrew DeWolf: Cause like, yeah, sure, get happily ever after, but Evan Hansen's still alive. So it's kind of bitter.
[57:16] Jess McEnally: It's a bittersweet ending for the audience. Knowing that Evan Hansen still roams out there in the world.
[57:27] Andrew DeWolf: It could happen to you.
[57:33] Jess McEnally: It's like it's like the when you watch a horror movie and the final title card says based on a true story.
[57:39] Andrew DeWolf: He can st he was never tried for his crimes. He is free to this day.
[57:52] Jess McEnally: Ah sh you're right. Ah, shucks.
[57:57] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Um, I feel like we've gone long enough on Bear. What what is your overall thoughts here?
[58:04] Jess McEnally: You know, Bear isn't great. I don't think it's terrible. I think the newer version is better. Come at me, haters. You're fucking wrong if you don't think it's more streamlined and more sensical.
[58:17] Jess McEnally: I don't care if you really like just plain Jane fat ass or like a quiet night at home or the way that you and I was originally written. It's story-wise, it is a more effective story told in a better way. And you know what? Don't act like Lucas is like some great character with some great development. Andrew doesn't even remember he fucking existed, and he watched that.
[58:40] Andrew DeWolf: I did watch the whole thing, and I actually don't remember that character whatsoever.
[58:45] Jess McEnally: So come at us haters. Get Andrew's ass. Um I don't know. Andrew, what is your overall thoughts on your cheese rating? What's your cheese rating? You didn't give one.
[58:57] Andrew DeWolf: Um, why should I? Whatever.
[59:02] Jess McEnally: Okay, do you want to know why she's rating? I can give you a cheese rating.
[59:04] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry.
[59:07] Jess McEnally: Sure. Um, I am giving my the cheese bare bones mac and cheese. Because, you know, bear.
[59:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but I get it. I get it.
[59:16] Jess McEnally: You get it?
[59:18] Andrew DeWolf: Bear.
[59:19] Jess McEnally: Yeah, I get it. I'm gonna give it um let's see. Well, overall thoughts. It's okay. I really don't like the ending if I haven't made that clear. Um I do like some of the drama stuff though. I like you know, I kinda I'm I'm into the whole uh love square thing. I think it's fun. I had a little bit of fun with that.
[59:39] Andrew DeWolf: I would have preferred if there was a little more focus on the second on like a secondary couple, which I think yours actually did get.
[59:46] Jess McEnally: Yes, so I maybe would have liked that better. Um but you know, I think it was it was interesting. Uh I wish it had more resolution and uh I feel bad for Ivy. Uh everyone send send your money to Ivy's GoFundMe to help her raise her child, please.
[1:00:02] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe I can get her pregnant.
[1:00:04] Jess McEnally: I you probably could, like in like a literal sense, but I'm not sure it you'd be a good idea.
[1:00:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um as far as a cheese rating. You're right, her teacher probably gave her an STD.
[1:00:16] Jess McEnally: Oh.
[1:00:17] Andrew DeWolf: I mean I wouldn't know. I didn't watch that version. Uh as far as a cheese rating, I'm gonna give it like uh Provolone for for literally no reason at all. I've just I'm giving it Provolone. I like Provolone okay. It's fine.
[1:00:30] Jess McEnally: There you go.
[1:00:33] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a little mad at this because I actually really like Provolone. And I think that's too kind.
[1:00:39] Jess McEnally: Okay.
[1:00:40] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, what do you want me to give it? Mozzarella?
[1:00:42] Jess McEnally: Mozzarella's too good.
[1:00:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's too good. I can't give it mozzarella.
[1:00:46] Jess McEnally: What's like that I'll give like stinky. I'll give it Parmesan. I'll give it Parmesan, because Parmesan is like it's good, but you'd really you'd only eat it like if it was on spaghetti or something like that. You're not gonna eat Parmesan by itself.
[1:00:55] Jess McEnally: So before we move on to shilling ourselves, can I ask you a question?
[1:01:01] Andrew DeWolf: Sure, sure.
[1:01:02] Jess McEnally: What do you got? So they're making a film adaptation of this. On January 2nd, 2018. It was announced that Bear would make be made into a motion picture, directed by Kristen Hangey and produced by Hillary Bouderak Weaver and Janet Billing Rich. Hangy will adapt the screenplay for the film, but no release date has been set.
[1:01:21] Andrew DeWolf: How the fuck do you make this into a movie? And how the fuck does it get released in twenty nineteen or 2020? Or how it doesn't fit in today's zeitgeist at all. It wouldn't work.
[1:01:31] Jess McEnally: I like honestly, the only way it works is if they really play up the cat Catholicism aspect of it.
[1:01:37] Andrew DeWolf: And yeah. I uh honestly I don't I don't get it. I don't understand why you'd make a movie out of this. Is there even that much of an audience for that? Like Am I wrong?
[1:01:47] Jess McEnally: I've never heard of this before. Like, I've heard of like rent. I've heard of that. Like, I understand why you'd make a movie out of that. I've never heard of this before. Is this a mainstream thing that I don't understand?
[1:01:57] Andrew DeWolf: It never made to Broadway. I don't know. That seems bizarre to me. But would they use my version or your version, do you think, from what you've heard?
[1:02:05] Jess McEnally: They'd be using yours because it's a movie. They they can't have it sung constantly. I mean they could, but it's gonna be a lot more work, and I doubt they're gonna do that.
[1:02:12] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, just wait for Lay Miz. Watch them try to pull it off.
[1:02:16] Jess McEnally: Well, I Miz is a pretty big name, so Alright, thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes Spotify Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. Our Patreon is Musicals with Cheese, our Instagram is Musicals with Cheese, our YouTube page is Musicals with Cheese.
[1:02:34] Andrew DeWolf: Our email is musical theater lives at gmail.com. We also have a second podcast.
[1:02:40] Jess McEnally: Two podcasts? Whoa! Gee, Billy, your mom lets you have two podcasts.
[1:02:46] Andrew DeWolf: Damn, son, where'd you find this?
[1:02:48] Jess McEnally: It's called Disney Plus Cheese. It's a sister podcast of this show where we talk about stuff on Disney Plus. It's a lot of fun, so why don't you go over there and leave us a review or something?
[1:02:58] Andrew DeWolf: Our title card was created by the absolutely incredible, Jolene Casco. Follow her on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Andrew, is there anything else you want to say?
[1:03:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, let's see. That's all, folks.
[1:03:12] Jess McEnally: Are you there? Are you there? I don't know if you are there.
[1:03:15] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? Maybe they're not there.
[1:03:19] Jess McEnally: Yeah, we can only hope God doesn't exist.
[1:03:22] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see you next time, guys. Hope you enjoyed this episode, Mina Maneary.
[1:03:26] Jess McEnally: We love you, Mina Maneary. Thanks for your money!
[1:03:29] Andrew DeWolf: Thanks for your money! Sorry we didn't love your show as much as you probably do, but you're f feel free to continue loving your show. It's fine. Feel free to think that we have terrible opinions. We're allowed to have terrible opinions. Everyone is allowed to have one terrible opinion, but everything after that is worthy of execution.
[1:03:46] Jess McEnally: Andrew, what's your terrible opinion?
[1:03:48] Andrew DeWolf: Well, um, let's just say that, and then we'll end the show right there.
[1:03:53] Jess McEnally: Okay, we're gonna cut right there.
[1:03:55] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, alright. Bye guys!
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
