Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#76: 'The Color Purple'

"The lord works in mysterious ways..." This week Jess & Andrew take a look at "The Color Purple" They chat about how dark the content within this musical is, how the story was adapted from the original book, and much more-- don't miss out!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

50 mins
2/13/20

Featured Shows

About

"The lord works in mysterious ways..." This week Jess & Andrew take a look at "The Color Purple" They chat about how dark the content within this musical is, how the story was adapted from the original book, and much more-- don't miss out!

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Jess on Twitter

Andrew on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Jess on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Andrew DeWolf: Why, hello there. I didn't see you come in. Well, while you're here, I should let you know that today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.

[0:09] Jess McInall: Andrew, tell us a little bit about Patreon.

[0:11] Andrew DeWolf: Patreon's a place you can go if you'd like to support us and help us keep the show running, as well as receive some extra content like commentaries and after parties for certain episodes and some other stuff.

[0:23] Jess McInall: Alright, our current patrons are Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Lat Max Lunig, Benjamin Learher, Lily Accles, Mackenzie Horner, John Donna, Terran the Duck, Melissa Goldman, Jess Lightning, Ewan Casty, Hailey McDonald, Task Gear, Callin McLeod, Fire of September, Mina Maneary, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Hailey Murray, Alison Wonderland, B Way Flix, Michael Johan, Lathaniel, Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, and Luna Rox 222.

[0:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um every time I say m see Michael Johan, I want to say Michael Jordan, which is bad. Um, but they give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patron only commentaries, our episodes a day earlier or even earlier, come join us over at Patreon. Andrew, is there anything else you want to say before we head on into the show?

[1:10] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you, Michael Jordan.

[1:11] Jess McInall: Yes, thank you, Michael Jordan. Come on and slam. Welcome to the jam. Alright, let's get back to the show.

[1:21] Jess McInall: Hello, I'm Jess McInall.

[1:24] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf. And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater. How are you doing today, Andrew?

[1:30] Andrew DeWolf: I'm doing fantastic. How are you doing today?

[1:33] Jess McInall: Quite well, quite well.

[1:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's excellent.

[1:36] Jess McInall: Oh yeah, you're good.

[1:37] Andrew DeWolf: That's excellent. It's really good to hear. You you have nothing nothing that you want to say that's wacky or anything like that.

[1:44] Andrew DeWolf: No, there's nothing wacky to say about today's subject. Uh would you agree?

[1:48] Jess McInall: Um, oh my gosh, my my shirt, it's it's what color is it?

[1:52] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it's purple.

[1:54] Jess McInall: No, actually I can see you right now. It's more of like a white.

[1:55] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck off!

[1:57] Jess McInall: Like a tan, like a tan.

[1:59] Andrew DeWolf: It's definitely not purple.

[2:01] Jess McInall: Okay, okay, we're talking about The Color Purple this week. There's nothing wacky about this topic, Jess, okay? If you think The Color Purple and you think, man, this is something that could be full of humor, this is like a funny topic. Like, I don't know what to tell you. There's nothing funny to say about The Color Purple.

[2:15] Jess McInall: I disagree. There's a couple funny moments.

[2:18] Andrew DeWolf: Ain't no need to discuss it ain't what the big boss whatever come. To us is in God's hands. When I lay me down to sleep, I will say my prayer. That God love me so deep, he will promise our souls to keep together.

[2:40] Jess McInall: I'll say all foreign. The Color Purple is a musical with a book by Marsha Norman and music and lyrics by Brenda Russell, Allie Willis, and Stephen Bray. Based on the 1982 novel, The Same Name by Alice Walker, and its 1985 film adaptation. The th the musical follows the Journey of Seely, an African American woman in the American South from the early to mid 20th century.

[3:06] Andrew DeWolf: The original Broadway production ran from 2005 to 2008, earning 11 Tony Award nominations. An enthusiastically acclaimed Broadway revival opened in late 2015 and ran through early 2017, winning two 2016 Tony Awards, including Best Revival of a Musical and Best Actress in a Musical.

[3:24] Jess McInall: Which is a pretty big thing considering this was the year of Hamilton, where it was less Hamilton fever, so yeah, that's great. Andrew, what is your what is the plot of The Color Purple?

[3:34] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, well, going into this, I didn't I've never seen The Color Purple movie or read the book or known anything about it whatsoever, other than that it's like it was a very famous movie, I think.

[3:47] Jess McInall: Directed by Steven Spielberg, yes.

[3:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Which is the wrong choice for that movie, but we'll talk about that later. I mean, he did that Holocaust movie, right? That that doesn't mean you can tell The Color Purple from like a meaningful place. But either way, what is the plot of The Color Purple?

[4:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, okay, well, there's the girl. There's like a bunch of girls, actually. There's two sisters, and they live somewhere in the south, Georgia. In the s in yeah. And the girl's daughters or children or babies get taken away by her dad, I think.

[4:29] Jess McInall: Her dad is also the father of those children. Fun fact.

[4:31] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, well, I didn't know that. And that fucked up. I mean, that's fine. That's fair. It's fucked up, but yeah, that's fair. I guess that makes it his right to take those kids and throw them in the dumpster or wherever he puts them. I don't know where he ends up finding them. He basically kind of sells them for work, seems like.

[4:50] Jess McInall: Yeah, he sells them and then they end up in Africa, but that's later.

[4:54] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Um, then he sells his daughter into marriage.

[4:59] Jess McInall: Yes, into marriage with a meat big meanie named Mr.

[5:03] Andrew DeWolf: Meanie. His name's Mr.

[5:06] Jess McInall: His name's Mr. Jackass, beats his wife, piece of shit. Eats his wife, rapes his wife, terrible person. Tries to rape his wife's sister. Lots of this guy's full of good deeds.

[5:19] Andrew DeWolf: He's a hero. No.

[5:22] Jess McInall: Um. And the other sister is gonna teach her kids. She wants to teach. She becomes a missionary in Africa.

[5:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. And tries to teach people things. There's some other characters, but they don't really do anything, so I'm not gonna mention them.

[5:36] Jess McInall: Well, Seely, who is our lead character, is forced into this marriage of Mr. who already has a bunch of kids already, and so she has to help raise these children, and they go through high drinks. Like his son Harpo, like falls in love with this voistress intense woman called Sophia.

[5:54] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and he doesn't know how to control her, and so Seely is like, you should beat her. And so when he tries, apparently she beats the shit out of him worse. I mean, that was not a good idea. He shouldn't have done that.

[6:06] Jess McInall: Um, so yeah, she gets pissed at Seely for telling him to beat her, and then she goes off for a while to let off some steam, and in that time, Harpo finds another woman that Andrew loves so much.

[6:20] Andrew DeWolf: I think her name's Squeak.

[6:22] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: Whose dog's louder, mine or yours. Let's fight. Dog fine, dog fine.

[6:30] Jess McInall: Um basically, Squeak has the worst voice I've ever heard in anything ever, and I don't know why they would intentionally have someone talk that way.

[6:38] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think it's that bad because of the voice itself. I think it's worse because it seems fake. Like, there are some squeaky voices out there, like Steve Urkel. Like, but that comes from an actual place in his like register, and most of the actresses who play Squeak are just going way out of the register to sound kind of annoying, as opposed to like, like I generally just have an annoying high-pitched voice, and so when I kind of pitch it up like that and all that, it kind of feels natural. Where it's like, ah it just feels weird.

[7:08] Jess McInall: I hate it. It was probably the worst part of the show for me. Like every single time that character opened their mouth, I was like more I hope she dies or something. Like Oh my god.

[7:20] Andrew DeWolf: Holy shit. I no, I mean I can't I can't handle that. It's annoying. And she wasn't even she didn't even really have that much of a character. She was in it for like two scenes.

[7:31] Jess McInall: She wanted to be a singer, Andrew.

[7:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, well, she's not allowed to talk, let alone sing, in my in my eyes. Um, what do you think about the main the the love interest of this story?

[7:43] Jess McInall: Sug Avery.

[7:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um as played by Grizabella the glamour cat.

[7:47] Jess McInall: Yeah, she's alright. I I don't know. Feels like she doesn't have that much of a purpose for a lot of it.

[7:53] Andrew DeWolf: Ah, it it is complicated because in this musical and in Steven Spielberg's movie, they really tone down how explicitly Seely is romantically and sexually engaged in a love affair with Sug Avery.

[8:08] Jess McInall: Yeah, I mean they just kind of kiss, and I thought that was like out of nowhere, and it wasn't even sure it was romantic or not.

[8:14] Andrew DeWolf: And then that was like the only thing that happened. Okay, let me tell you a bit about the book. Like, so Seely describes every sexual experience she has as like someone going to the bathroom. Like, I just lay there and let them be done with it. And then Sug Avery enters her life, she's like, sex is great, and she's like, You ever look at your vagina before? And then they go into this scene where she pulls out a mirror and lets Seely look at her own vagina, and she describes it as like wet rose petals.

[8:40] Jess McInall: Like that that's some specific things from the book, and it's a little bit more like very they're kind of settling down together and they're kind of married, but hiding their actual intentions. So that when Sug Avery goes off into the night, like I wanna have one last fling, it means a lot more. Like, you just I'm not enough for you. You need to go fuck someone. Whereas here, since it's more like subtle, it's more than they have in the movie, which is nothing at all.

[9:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean it's a little bit more, but they kiss, they hold hands, they talk about sex and how nice it is. And Sug Avery has a song in the musical called Push the Button, which in the book is the way that she describes the clitoris, where she's like, uh above your vagina, there is a button that you just gotta push to make things feel good.

[9:27] Jess McInall: And so kind of side-eye, they make an entire song about the clitoris.

[9:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's like Book of Mormon.

[9:35] Jess McInall: Yes, exactly. Um, and I think that that number, despite be my knowledge making it a little kind of like, ah, that's that's a little dirtier than I think they're intending it to be.

[9:46] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think they're intending it to be dirty, but just dirty, but like without saying it.

[9:50] Jess McInall: Right, right, right. I don't know. It kind of feels like they shy away from the whole thing and it basically ruins that aspect of it.

[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: A little bit, honestly.

[9:58] Jess McInall: Because it's like if it's not if you're if you're making something that is that explicit and you're adapting it with but like removing almost all of it, like but they also have scenes where she's like naked and bathing her, and she's talking about how ink she feels tingles down her spine just by touching her body and all that.

[10:15] Andrew DeWolf: Like they have stuff like that.

[10:16] Jess McInall: In this?

[10:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they do.

[10:18] Jess McInall: In this.

[10:19] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I remember that.

[10:20] Jess McInall: Yeah, it's the first time Sug comes on and she's like has to take her out of her dress and bathe her.

[10:25] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, yeah, you're right.

[10:27] Jess McInall: She's like, oh my god, this woman feels incredible, like, unlike any of the other girls I've seen. Like, there's more than nothing, but it still doesn't feel like enough.

[10:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Man, this story is just not up my alley.

[10:40] Jess McInall: Just cause you don't know how to make jokes about it, or just no, it's just not something I'm interested in anyway.

[10:47] Andrew DeWolf: Why?

[10:47] Jess McInall: I don't I usually don't I don't like content that is explicitly sexual and especially that type of thing is a little uncomfortable and you know, I don't know.

[10:57] Andrew DeWolf: I think you're just lame.

[10:58] Jess McInall: I'm a prude I'm a prude. But you didn't like the character of Mr. and his redemption arc so to say because he does have a legitimate redemption so more than most people do more than Kylo Ren did.

[11:09] Andrew DeWolf: But he's not redeemable though is the problem.

[11:11] Jess McInall: Yes, they take him so far that he's not redeemable, but they he tries.

[11:15] Andrew DeWolf: He tries to put the effort in.

[11:17] Jess McInall: I suppose but like it's too too little too late, you know.

[11:21] Andrew DeWolf: He gives Seely the emotional catharsis in the end to bring her sister his sister back.

[11:26] Jess McInall: Her sister back to her. But he's the one that drove her away in the first place.

[11:30] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. It's very Tony Stark of him to be like I fixed I saved the day from the problem I caused.

[11:37] Jess McInall: I caused the issue and now I fixed it. And I also did all these other things that I didn't fix, but I fixed this thing. It's like great. Good for you, Mr. Also what was with the curse thing? Like was he actually cursed? Is there like real voodoo magic going on or I mean I think it's just in his head more or less like his life was on a downhill turn anyways and she also just cursed him so he thinks there's a correlation so to say.

[12:04] Andrew DeWolf: That's kind of how I interpreted it but it it made it seem like there was actually like a real curse and it was weird.

[12:10] Jess McInall: It was weird. Um in the book it is very interesting how this book is written. Because it takes place from the point of view of Seely. And it's written within her mindset, so there's the same misspellings that you would expect from someone of her, I don't want to say her level, but like someone of her reading level that probably wasn't able to go to school, like unlike her sister Nettie. So her reading and writing comprehension skills are rudimentary, and she has like her own language, like instead of saying are they or they just say is like we is gonna be this, like, and most of the words are spelt wrong, lowercase and all that.

[12:46] Andrew DeWolf: And it's a very interesting way that adds a lot of verisimilitude to the story and gives you a lot into your protagonist's eyes.

[12:52] Jess McInall: It's weird when they talk like that in the musical.

[12:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no. Well, I don't know. I mean, that's probably how that character would actually talk.

[13:01] Jess McInall: They didn't go to school, they didn't, they don't understand.

[13:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I guess. But to me, it's just like to my, like, you know how she says "dear God" and like she's constantly saying letters to God.

[13:12] Jess McInall: It's weird in the musical, but in the book that just she doesn't want to say "dear diary," so she's literally writing these words out to God.

[13:20] Andrew DeWolf: It makes it seem, it does make it seem more like she's actually writing to God.

[13:25] Jess McInall: Yeah, as opposed to just talking to God. I mean, what's your thought on the whole story and everything?

[13:31] Andrew DeWolf: Well, the story itself, I think doesn't work. I was frustrated with this musical because I felt like all the emotional beats are happening, they're just nowhere near as satisfying as they are in the book.

[13:43] Jess McInall: Yeah, that's kind of how I was feeling. I was like, this story feels like it should be really connecting with me, and it's not at all connecting in the world.

[13:51] Andrew DeWolf: And let's add the caveat that we're both white men and we probably don't understand a lot of the nuances here.

[13:57] Jess McInall: So let's add that caveat right there.

[13:59] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough. And I think that the story is very well told in the book. I think it's badly told in the movie. I think it's better told in the musical, but still all those emotional beats aren't quite there yet.

[14:10] Jess McInall: It just, yeah. I think the musical feels meandering. Like it doesn't feel like any of these characters are quite as present as they should be.

[14:18] Andrew DeWolf: Like, what do we know about Harpo aside from the fact that he feels scared by his wife?

[14:24] Jess McInall: Basically nothing. You don't know much about his wife other than that she's loud.

[14:29] Andrew DeWolf: Well, she's loud and she does. I think she gets more development than Harpo does because she says, I think more. I have to fight through everything and all that, and like I'm not gonna fight in my own goddamn house.

[14:41] Jess McInall: You really don't know much about any of the characters, like even the main character is just kind of there, it feels like a lot of times.

[14:49] Andrew DeWolf: I disagree. I feel like she gets the most. She has a very clear cut goal. I want to see my sister or want to see my child, but I'm ugly and no one will ever love me. And then in the end, she's like, I get my children back, I get my sister back, and you know what? I am beautiful, and I'm good enough to be here and live on my own. She has a very clear arc.

[14:50] Jess McInall: She gets the most. Everyone else around.

[15:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and he gets the villain arc in Redemptive villain.

[15:17] Jess McInall: Sort of. He tries his best.

[15:19] Andrew DeWolf: Redeemed in a way, although I would still say that as a person he is a piece of shit, yes.

[15:26] Jess McInall: Absolutely still a piece of shit, whether he fixed it or not. But I, the thing is.

[15:32] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you also have these other characters like Squeak, who is just nothing. I mean, Squeak and, uh, in the son, Mr. Son is just, what was his name? It was, uh, Harpo. Harpo, we just said it. They're both just like nothing characters.

[15:46] Jess McInall: Like you're not sure. But the thing is, they work when you're actually seeing it from the point of view of Sealy writing it down in a journal. Like he's gonna see this girl, like that kind of thing. A character like that works, but in a narrative story told on stage where your stage time is precious, and it's not like this is a super long musical, like compared to our other stuff, it's pretty short.

[16:09] Andrew DeWolf: Under two hours, I think.

[16:10] Jess McInall: Yeah. So honestly, I think we could trim her up, give Harpo and Sophia a bit more time to grow together.

[16:17] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.

[16:17] Jess McInall: And maybe a little bit more sugary time.

[16:20] Andrew DeWolf: Definitely more shug time. Because honestly, I feel like she wasn't even well developed. I feel like they were afraid to develop her, and that's a weird thing to say.

[16:28] Jess McInall: Yeah, it's like they didn't want to touch her. It's like they don't want to go near that, because they probably understand that it's a topic that doesn't really work well with the mainstream audience, so yes.

[16:42] Andrew DeWolf: But one of the interesting, or at least in a Broadway audience, which is weird because, you know, I mean it probably could work, but they probably were afraid to do it wrong or anything like that.

[16:52] Jess McInall: Especially in like 2005 when the show premiered.

[16:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's like if they didn't do it right, it would get a huge amount of backlash, and it's just like better to just not do it. And then I think it's done very well in the book, though. I'll say that.

[17:03] Jess McInall: You guys have a blueprint right there, just follow the fucking blueprint.

[17:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. But Alice Walker is probably one of the best writers of all time, and it's hard to live up to that. I get that.

[17:17] Jess McInall: Yeah, it just, it kind of meanders. Um, the story just doesn't feel well told. Um, but let me say some things I enjoy about the source material in general. When you hear "The Color Purple" and you think, what would that story be about? It's about, um, black people in the South in the early, I want to say eighteen, nineteen hundreds, maybe like nineteen late nineteenth century, early twentieth century.

[17:44] Andrew DeWolf: There's definitely an actual time period, but I don't really know exactly when it is.

[17:48] Jess McInall: Oh, I'm sure it's written down somewhere in my synopsis. Mid, it's the mid-20th century, so, but they don't really deal with racism. They don't deal with white people bringing them down or anything like that. That's not the story.

[18:01] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that's good, honestly.

[18:03] Jess McInall: Like, well, I mean, it's a different subject matter because, I mean, we have plenty of stories about racism and about that, so it's different. It's doing something different, which is nice.

[18:11] Andrew DeWolf: That's kind of what I'm saying. Like, that's one of my favorite things about "The Color Purple," is it's kind of how often do you see a story about African American people in the mid-20th century and not have anyone like say some racist stuff and then everyone bands together and be like, we will not stand for this.

[18:27] Jess McInall: And as much as those stories are great and wonderful, can't we just see them living their own lives, being lesbians and having parties and arguing with each other like actual human beings do?

[18:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and the one thing with those stories too is that it's always putting, it's always a story putting black people in the perspective of white people hate them or whatever, which is like, it's like can't they have their own thing that isn't based on how white people feel about them?

[18:52] Jess McInall: Yeah, can we have a story that is about black people that isn't about how white people feel about them?

[18:58] Andrew DeWolf: Right, and not that that doesn't have its place, but like something like "Hairspray," I think I'd prefer a lot more if it just like wasn't so direct about like racism, like in this specific TV studio comparing racism to being a fat white girl, which no, no, that's not how that works.

[19:17] Jess McInall: Yeah, I mean that's a little bit iffy, but okay.

[19:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so I like this. I appreciate that in this story, both in the book and in this musical, that at least even at its highest is mostly subtext.

[19:31] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[19:31] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and if it was there even a little bit, it's mostly just to stage the setting for you.

[19:36] Jess McInall: Well, yeah, because I mean obviously that still is a major part of their lives, I'm sure, but it's not the only thing that the story needs to be about. It can be about the other stuff that happens.

[19:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and I'm glad it's just not a story about misery in the sense that they're miserable throughout the entire time. Seely has a hard life and is given a lot of shit to deal with, and it's disgusting what happens to her. But she ends up on top, owning her own business and being successful and happy in the end.

[20:05] Jess McInall: And that's fucking great.

[20:06] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's a good story. I'm, I think more so talking about the musical, though. I'm not sure how well the musical does it.

[20:11] Jess McInall: Yes, and that's kind of where I'm sitting. Um, but the one thing I think the musical really does bring to the table that is fantastic is the actual music.

[20:23] Andrew DeWolf: And want to go into a mid-show and talk about that after it?

[20:26] Jess McInall: Yeah, sure.

[20:31] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we gotta shill at you. Our current patrons are Stephanie L, Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Lear, Lily Accles, Mackenzie Horner, John Donna, Terren the Duck, Melissa Goldman, Jess Lightning, hashtag the best dress, Ewan Casty, Haley McDonald, Tess Gear, Callin McCloud, Fire of September, Mina Maniri, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Haley Murray, Alison Wonderland, Sean O'Neal, B Way Flicks, Michael Johan, Lathaniel, Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evan Green, and Lunarox 222. They all give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, such as patron-only commentaries, our episodes a day earlier or even earlier, come join us over at Patreon.

[21:14] Jess McInall: Alright, you ready to get back to a show, Andrew?

[21:16] Andrew DeWolf: Absolutely.

[21:22] ♪ Musical number ♪

[21:49] Jess McInall: No matter what life brings us in God's head.

[21:53] Andrew DeWolf: I want to talk about our prayer because I love this song a lot.

[21:56] Jess McInall: Sure. It is basically Neddy and Seely's song together that ties them and it keeps reprising every time they come back.

[22:04] Andrew DeWolf: And it doesn't feel patronizing either. Like a lot of those little kids, like we're growing up together, we're happy songs feel really patronizing. Specifically the one I'm thinking of is a deleted song from "Frozen" where it was like, it's so high to be a princess, da, and they have like this slap clapping thing, and it feels so pedantic.

[22:26] Jess McInall: Well, I mean they already have "Do You Wanna Build a Snowman," which is already kind of the similar thing.

[22:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, even that kind of feels a little too like patronizing.

[22:36] Jess McInall: Yeah, whereas this is just like I just like saying a prayer with you and going and hanging with you.

[22:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like a call and response type song, like "Do You Wanna Build a Snowman," but it feels natural and of the world.

[22:49] Jess McInall: Yeah. I want to say before we even get into all the songs that I like. I like the music style they went with.

[22:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[22:56] Jess McInall: It's like a kind of jazzy gospel type feel.

[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: Is that a, do you think that's a good way to describe it?

[23:03] Jess McInall: It's a type of thing where you can cheer in the middle of it and it feels so natural.

[23:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think that is especially for the setting and the characters, is very fitting.

[23:15] Jess McInall: Um, so I think that works pretty well. A musical style that I don't know I love about this is it feels like they kind of have a Greek chorus within like themselves where they're like describing what's going on, like, oh he beats her like a dog, you know, those types of storytelling characters.

[23:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't much care for them. I kind of would rather just the story unfold without them spitting the story at me.

[23:38] Jess McInall: I'm wondering if that's just them having trouble taking the book and putting it into a narrative when based on how you're saying the book was written, that's not really an easy thing to do.

[23:49] Andrew DeWolf: And I can see that too. I just, if that feels like I'm being spoon-fed and I don't particularly like that all the time, that's kind of how I feel in "Evita" with Che, despite the fact that I kinda like Che, but it is kind of spoon-feeding you either an opinion or plot.

[24:06] Jess McInall: It does make this story a little easier to follow, especially for someone who doesn't know the story at all.

[24:11] Andrew DeWolf: Right, right. But it's like instead of just saying he beats her like a dog, just have her like have him beat her or something like that.

[24:18] Jess McInall: I mean, that sounds terrible, but...

[24:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, that's what you said, that's what you want her to him to do.

[24:23] Jess McInall: So no, no. It's a lot of the things that happened in this maybe are better left unseen and said instead, but a lot of it just feels like a series of vignettes instead of a story until the end it turns out, hey, you were in a story.

[24:37] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, if you're gonna tell the story and you're gonna shy away from showing us all the stuff that happens, I mean, why even tell the story?

[24:46] Jess McInall: Because it's a musical, and we go to a musical.

[24:49] Andrew DeWolf: Come on, forget your troubles, come on, get happy.

[24:51] Jess McInall: That kind of mindset.

[24:52] Andrew DeWolf: And I get that mindset too. Who's going to "The Color Purple" to get happy?

[24:56] Jess McInall: Hey, there's some fun songs in here.

[24:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, sure, but the story is depressing.

[25:00] Jess McInall: It, yeah, it is not the most fun story in the world, I agree. If I'm going to a musical to get happy, this is not the one I would see.

[25:07] Andrew DeWolf: What would you see?

[25:08] Jess McInall: Beetlejuice.

[25:10] Andrew DeWolf: Too late, you can't see that no more.

[25:12] Jess McInall: I know.

[25:13] Andrew DeWolf: Sad I'm actually sad about that.

[25:15] Jess McInall: You got you gotta go see the music man starring huge jackass.

[25:19] Andrew DeWolf: I hope they bring back Beetlejuice.

[25:21] Jess McInall: Uh, I don't think the story's over.

[25:23] Andrew DeWolf: It'll be in community theaters and all that.

[25:25] Jess McInall: I hope they tour with it or something.

[25:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, they will.

[25:27] Jess McInall: That's already been announced.

[25:28] Andrew DeWolf: I wanna see it.

[25:30] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: Speaking of great things, let's talk about hell no.

[25:33] Jess McInall: Oh wait. Well, what y'all to do is bash Mr.'s head open and think on heaven later.

[25:39] Andrew DeWolf: You can't stay here, girl!

[25:41] Jess McInall: Sister!

[25:46] Andrew DeWolf: Hell no!

[25:48] Jess McInall: Hell no!

[25:49] Andrew DeWolf: Hell no!

[25:51] Jess McInall: Hell no!

[25:52] Andrew DeWolf: Let's go!

[25:54] Jess McInall: Gonna be all right!

[26:08] Andrew DeWolf: Take my hand!

[26:12] Jess McInall: Don't be no pole!

[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: Don't win your time!

[26:22] Jess McInall: Hell no.

[26:23] Andrew DeWolf: That's Sophia's big song. I mean, it's big and boisterous like her character, so.

[26:28] Jess McInall: Mm-hmm. And that's a straight-up quote from both the book and the movie, because I remember Oprah Winfrey played this role in the movie.

[26:34] Andrew DeWolf: I think it was like her first film role.

[26:36] Jess McInall: Man, these dogs, somebody's just gonna off them.

[26:38] Andrew DeWolf: Somebody's gonna just take them and throw them off a cliff.

[26:41] Jess McInall: The dog fight. Bark bark. Shut up.

[26:47] Andrew DeWolf: No, Hell No is a really good character song, and it definitely embodies her character better than anything else.

[26:54] Jess McInall: And it's just like we need this moment. We need this moment of someone standing up for themselves.

[27:02] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna deflect, I'm gonna take it all in. Like I this is my life and what I gotta go through. Everybody's just completely been passive the entire show so far.

[27:12] Jess McInall: Well, I guess this is what this may as well happen, is basically what our main character has been doing. Then she sees Sophia be like, no, I am not gonna let anyone beat me or touch me or hurt me. I am gonna fight back and leave if I need to. And Seely's inspired by this to like start growing some backbone and become a resolve.

[27:32] Andrew DeWolf: And stop telling people to beat each other.

[27:34] Jess McInall: Yeah, don't don't tell people to beat their wife, please. It's not a good thing.

[27:36] Andrew DeWolf: Especially not when you're in that situation as well.

[27:41] Jess McInall: But then again, if you're it's hard for me to speak from the point of view of the abused. Well, I'm just giving advice. I'm just saying don't do that, you know.

[27:47] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just saying I'm right, you know. I mean, I am right. Always shouldn't do that. I mean, I think that is an objective point. You shouldn't tell people to beat their wives.

[27:59] Jess McInall: Fine. Yep, I I'm willing to agree with you there.

[28:01] Andrew DeWolf: So I am correct in this situation, so.

[28:04] Jess McInall: I mean it is to bring down this cow.

[28:19] Andrew DeWolf: She got this town.

[28:23] Jess McInall: No, no, no. She's back in town.

[28:27] Andrew DeWolf: That should no she don't. Shug Avery coming to town.

[28:31] Jess McInall: That's a fun song. That song is really fun. And it like when it makes you really want to see her, and then you see her, and it's Grizzabella the Glory Hammer Cat, you're like, whoa!

[28:40] Andrew DeWolf: You're like, wow, is she gonna sing meme?

[28:43] Jess McInall: Meme.

[28:44] Andrew DeWolf: Like that's meme.

[28:46] Jess McInall: She does not sing memory, by the way.

[28:48] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. She sings other songs, and she's a lot of fun to watch, and it's good to have like a woman with sexual agency not portrayed as like a slut.

[28:58] Jess McInall: Yep. She's not just like, I wanna fuck everyone, like in the way of like usual kind of promiscuous characters on Broadway.

[29:06] Andrew DeWolf: Who are you thinking of?

[29:07] Jess McInall: Um, I'm thinking a lot of like the prostitutes from Le Miz specifically.

[29:12] Andrew DeWolf: I glove lay light days, blah blah blah blah boy.

[29:15] Jess McInall: So you're not thinking of Rumtum Tugger or he is also a slut.

[29:21] Andrew DeWolf: Uh let's see, what else is good to talk about? Push the button, push the butt, push the buttons if you wanna come in.

[29:34] Jess McInall: Oh push the buttons, give me something.

[29:40] Andrew DeWolf: Baby know me, and no listen. If you wanna peel the train of card, go baby push the butt and pull the window shall listen all you red high lovers.

[29:59] Jess McInall: You ought to know.

[30:01] Andrew DeWolf: I want to talk about push the button.

[30:03] Jess McInall: Go ahead.

[30:03] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I have anything to say about this song, to be honest.

[30:06] Jess McInall: It's about masturbating.

[30:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, that's good. We should have more songs about masturbating. It's an important part of the wood. There's a lot of there's a lot of people that masturbate, namely everyone. And anyone who says that they don't is lying.

[30:19] Jess McInall: I have never touched myself before in my life, Andrew DeWolf.

[30:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, well, I mean, maybe someone like Jess who doesn't have hands doesn't masturbate, but everyone else does.

[30:28] Jess McInall: Hey.

[30:29] Andrew DeWolf: So we should have some more songs. Some people can't can't come, you know. That's a thing. Especially a lot of women have a lot of trouble with that, so that's you know, performance anxiety is a serious problem.

[30:41] Jess McInall: You know, some men have innies and not outdies.

[30:43] Andrew DeWolf: Man, remember when we talked about twisted?

[30:45] Jess McInall: It's been too long.

[30:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. We should do another Star Kid one and just talk about all the jokes we liked.

[30:50] Jess McInall: You know, have the most boring episode in the world again.

[30:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Alright, well, push the button. What did you like about this song?

[30:56] Jess McInall: It's just a fun number, like a fun, like sexy number that isn't like slut shamey. Like a good sexual number that feels like kind of soulful and gospel-y.

[31:07] Andrew DeWolf: Lyrically, what did you think of it though?

[31:08] Jess McInall: It's fine. Do you think they could have had more masturbation puns?

[31:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, they could have had more masturbation puns. You can always have more masturbation puns.

[31:15] Jess McInall: That's kind of what I was thinking. They didn't really play it up enough. Have you have you listened to Lady Gaga's dancing in circles?

[31:21] Andrew DeWolf: Like, come on, that's how you do a masturbation pun.

[31:21] Jess McInall: That's how you do it. Gotta listen to the Lady Gagas.

[31:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I love Lady Gagaz.

[31:34] Jess McInall: Like a honey up connected like wanna fall.

[31:42] Andrew DeWolf: I'll a part of me like the collaboration.

[31:50] Jess McInall: Where do you come for all? Open up your eye.

[31:58] Andrew DeWolf: Look what God has done.

[32:03] Jess McInall: The color purple, you know.

[32:05] Andrew DeWolf: The title number.

[32:07] Jess McInall: I it didn't have that much impact on me, I'll be honest. I like it because of its view of God.

[32:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um basically it starts with Sha Seely describing her vision of God and like how God has forgotten her and how terrible her life is. And Sho's like, you know what? God isn't a guy, he's not a person. He's just everything that you see. Like from like a blade of grass to the actual shade of the color purple. It's not a man, it's an idea, and it's like everything we create. And it's like it's weird to hear a gospel-y song that isn't that is about God, but not directly about God the man, but God the idea, which is to me, very kind of I don't what's the word I'm looking for? Like subversive.

[32:50] Andrew DeWolf: It is a subversive twist on that idea. So I think it's as like the title number for this show and how it kind of makes me feel. I think it's super powerful and interesting. I suppose lyrically, I think the music is kind of just eh, didn't really leave me with a huge impact. I can hum it, like it sticks with me, and I haven't I don't like listen to this song a ton, but I do like it, and I can hum it.

[33:15] Jess McInall: Yeah, it's uh it's okay. Never see nobody I know ever again. Nobody to put up with me, nobody to mess with me, nobody to push me around, nobody to tell me what to do. Nobody expects something of me. Nobody to tell me who I am and who I Nobody I got plenty to blame. My daddy beat me for my own goodie sake. My first wife got killed when she ran away. My kids is all fools, my crops is all dead. Only woman I love won't lie in my be. A black man's light can get any worse. Lest he wasting away on the Miss Sealy's kill.

[34:05] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you want to talk about the Mystic song?

[34:07] Jess McInall: I just want to talk about how weird this song is because it's like he's cursed.

[34:13] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. So explain the situation of the song.

[34:16] Jess McInall: Mr. gets cursed by Seely when he when she leaves, and then bad stuff happens to Mr. And he thinks he's actually cursed, and that's this song. But he also gives history, like he's like, my dad beat me when I was a kid.

[34:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like I know.

[34:31] Jess McInall: Oh, yeah, it's like he's trying to redeem himself and stuff. Describing why he's such a bad man that rapes his wife and beats his wife and beats his kids and beats everyone because he's a bad person.

[34:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[34:41] Jess McInall: Basically, he's like, My dad was a bad person, and the people around me were bad people, so now I'm a bad person. And it's okay that I'm a bad person because I have this sad, sad backstory, don't you know?

[34:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Although I guess eventually he realizes that that's not true, and that he doesn't get to just be a bad person because everyone else was bad to him.

[35:01] Jess McInall: Right.

[35:02] Andrew DeWolf: And that's a lesson he has to learn, and he makes actual amends with it. Unlike other people that just kind of in other stories where it's like, I'm a good person now, believe me, I'm gonna be nice to you. Where he's like, he asks Seely to marry him properly again, and she's like, No, we should just be friends, and you actually believe that they're decent friends now.

[35:19] Jess McInall: And in the book, it's much more like that, where they are just kind of buddies after despite having been married.

[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, and I mean the initial marriage was kind of a farce.

[35:31] Jess McInall: Oh, a hundred percent a farce.

[35:33] Andrew DeWolf: So although I guess back back then that may have been more of a actual way to get married.

[35:38] Jess McInall: Yeah, you just get sold.

[35:40] Andrew DeWolf: Just get sold into marriage.

[35:41] Jess McInall: She likes a fiddler on the roof kind of thing.

[35:44] Andrew DeWolf: You get a cow with your wife.

[35:46] Jess McInall: Ugh, I get two cows and one go.

[35:48] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man. I know the musical says it, but it's not cool when you say it.

[35:54] Jess McInall: No.

[35:56] Andrew DeWolf: Uh um take a deep breath. Gonna hold my head up. Gonna put my shot us back and look astray. I'm gonna flirt with somebody when they won't buy home but I sing I have inside of me everything gotta be to live about it for the hello, hello standest tallest, the tallest tree.

[37:15] Jess McInall: But most of all. One song I want to talk about.

[37:32] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, what do you guys I'm Here might be one of my favorite musical theater solo numbers like of all time.

[37:38] Jess McInall: It is incredible.

[37:40] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[37:41] Jess McInall: It is a powerhouse performance that anyone that performs it truly owns this.

[37:46] Andrew DeWolf: It's Rose's turn, basically.

[37:48] Jess McInall: Rose's turn is very good, so I think this is as good as Rose's turn and as a tour de force of performance.

[37:55] Andrew DeWolf: Because basically, what happens is she is rejected by the one woman she thought loved her.

[38:00] Jess McInall: And then she's like, what do I even have if I don't have her? And she's like, okay, I've got my sister. I haven't seen her in Europe, but I know that I've got her. I've got my kids, and I got my house, and then throughout this song, she realizes I don't need anyone to prove to me that I'm worth it.

[38:17] Andrew DeWolf: And she comes to terms with like, I'm beautiful, I'm wonderful, I'm great, and I'm here, and you people are gonna get used to me being here because I'm fucking great.

[38:27] Jess McInall: And for two uglies like you and me, that's a good message.

[38:31] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, yeah, it's definitely a good message.

[38:34] Jess McInall: And it's emotional. Like, um, Cynthia Erivo, who performs this in the most recent production, breaks my heart, and now she's nominated for an Oscar this year for playing Harriet Tubman.

[38:45] Andrew DeWolf: So like I think this song number alone is what led to her big breakout film career and how great she is now.

[38:52] Jess McInall: And I think this song is part of the reason why this show has lasted so long, because this song is so fucking powerful that by the end of it, you're like, I just had an experience.

[39:03] Andrew DeWolf: And I feel like this song would resonate a lot more with me personally if they had kept all the emotional beats found in the book, as opposed to cutting so much and focusing a little too much on the other minor characters of the book.

[39:16] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[39:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think a lot of the songs would resonate better if it had focused more on the case. It is an interesting character dynamic. You have this woman who's forced into marriage to this guy, and this guy is in love with this woman, and the woman falls in love with his wife.

[39:32] Jess McInall: That is the plot of this, if we're focusing like on the that's an interesting plot.

[39:37] Andrew DeWolf: But there's never really any emotional interaction between Mr. and Shug and Seely, except for them just telling us that they're in love, which is a problem.

[39:49] Jess McInall: You want to see him, aside from just getting dressed nice when Shug comes around, you want to see him doing things for her that he never did for Seely, and then her doing things for Seely that she never did for Mr.

[40:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and instead they just focus on, they focus a lot on Sophia and on Harpo, and it's just like these characters that don't even matter.

[40:10] Jess McInall: Like Squeak doesn't even show up in the second act, I don't think.

[40:13] Andrew DeWolf: She's there. She goes, she's not very much.

[40:15] Jess McInall: She leaves when Seely leaves alongside her and Shug.

[40:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, I didn't even remember that.

[40:20] Jess McInall: That's how unimportant she is.

[40:22] Andrew DeWolf: Just like, I don't know. It's like the story, the emotional beats are like there, but they don't play it up at all.

[40:32] Jess McInall: And it just leaves you kind of wanting more.

[40:36] Andrew DeWolf: So let me rephrase my context for this. So I read the book when I was in high school, and I listened to the musical right after that.

[40:43] Jess McInall: And I never watched the musical until the revival came out many years later.

[40:48] Andrew DeWolf: So I just heard the songs and put the pieces in together where the book hit it.

[40:52] Jess McInall: So I assumed that the book hit the musical hit all the same beats as the book.

[40:56] Andrew DeWolf: And I was wrong. When I finally did watch it, I was really disappointed.

[40:59] Jess McInall: And I'm still kind of am.

[41:01] Andrew DeWolf: And I know that's like me saying like the source material is better, but no, these songs are great.

[41:06] Jess McInall: It's just like make more of the source material with these songs, and we're good.

[41:11] Andrew DeWolf: And I think that's what they're gonna do with the Oprah Winfrey and Steven Spielberg produced movie of the musical that's coming out soon, apparently.

[41:18] Jess McInall: Hopefully.

[41:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because I think that is a great opportunity to rework some of this to make it as emotionally resonant as possible.

[41:25] Jess McInall: Yeah, because I feel like it could have worked.

[41:28] Andrew DeWolf: And like I know I've already said that this material's not exactly up my alley, but that doesn't mean I don't think I could have enjoyed it.

[41:36] Jess McInall: I just, as it is right now, it didn't really resonate with me in any real way.

[41:40] Andrew DeWolf: Because Andrew's a hater.

[41:42] Jess McInall: Yeah, well, I don't know. And I can't say I loved it, so I say that I really wanted to love it, and that's kind of why I'm sitting here more disappointed with it.

[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: So what's, I mean, I was just gonna ask, what's your overall thoughts on it?

[41:56] Jess McInall: I think it has some great music.

[42:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it tries very hard to adapt the content of the book and keep some of the stylistic choices that the book makes, but I feel like the emotional beats still kind of fall hollow compared to like how they hit in the book.

[42:14] Jess McInall: And it feels like a lot of the action isn't driven by the character's development as much as we're told this thing happens, so that causes the next thing to happen.

[42:24] Andrew DeWolf: Like we're told something, and so the characters have a reaction to that instead of showing the thing and having them react to it.

[42:31] Jess McInall: And that storytelling thing makes the emotional beats not as resonant to me.

[42:36] Andrew DeWolf: But these songs, these songs are powerhouses and they're great.

[42:40] Jess McInall: Yeah, I think that overall it's a disappointment, because I mean, I mean that I what I said about the music style, and I feel like a lot of the songs do they could have a lot of emotional weight to them, but the story doesn't lend it well. The story does lend itself to it, but the way they tell the story doesn't.

[42:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and I don't really know if that's the problem with like the medium of theater, and maybe it might just be that.

[43:07] Jess McInall: Like unless it's a good thing.

[43:08] Andrew DeWolf: It very well could be like some that line. Some stories can't work on stage, you know?

[43:14] Jess McInall: But I will admit, when I did re-watch this most recently, just today, to prepare for this, I did get a little emotional when Nettie showed up at the end.

[43:23] Andrew DeWolf: Like I felt like a little bit just because I remembered how it felt in the book.

[43:28] Jess McInall: Yeah, I guess I didn't have that at all because I just kind of was just following with this and I didn't have any real emotional attachment to any of the characters already.

[43:37] Andrew DeWolf: So did you feel the plot was hard to follow or easy to follow?

[43:40] Jess McInall: Because I found it hard to follow when I read the book.

[43:43] Andrew DeWolf: I think that in the first act especially, yes, because it feels like there's a lot of characters, and there's just stuff happens to each character, and it's like, what is okay, so this is here, and he's his son, and then they're together, and these two are together, and it's just there's a lot of stuff introduced really quickly that is tough to follow.

[44:05] Jess McInall: But I think once you get to act two, it's a little bit easier.

[44:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I see that.

[44:09] Jess McInall: But then we have this title character of Celia.

[44:13] Andrew DeWolf: Seely, not Celia.

[44:14] Jess McInall: Um, and she's great, but you don't really know how the rest of the family unit sees her.

[44:20] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I think her and Harpo have like one interaction with one another.

[44:25] Jess McInall: Yeah, I didn't even know that. I didn't know that she was trying to raise him, honestly.

[44:30] Andrew DeWolf: She was brought in to raise his kids.

[44:33] Jess McInall: Yeah, like that part of it didn't hit at all.

[44:36] Andrew DeWolf: So he's obstinatively his mother, and yet in the book it's like a really tense relationship where he treats her basically the same way Mr. does until they're much older and they kind of get a respect for one another.

[44:50] Jess McInall: And here they're fine, they act decent to one another throughout.

[44:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like that's a kind of dynamic, like the very specific growth throughout the story that they just didn't focus on.

[45:00] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[45:01] Andrew DeWolf: So at that point, if she, if Harpo isn't affecting Seely much, why is he here?

[45:05] Jess McInall: Because frame it from the way that we have Seely and the world's reaction to everyone in the world.

[45:11] Andrew DeWolf: And if the world's not touching her or affecting her, why is it there?

[45:15] Jess McInall: I feel like Harpo is honestly only there because they wanted to have Sophia be there, and without Harpo, there's no reason for Sophia to be there.

[45:22] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly.

[45:23] Jess McInall: And then you also have to have the Squeak thing, and it's, I don't want to complain because it's not bad.

[45:30] Andrew DeWolf: It isn't a bad musical.

[45:31] Jess McInall: From it's far from that. I just, I think it's a missed potential.

[45:35] Andrew DeWolf: I think it honestly would be better if they just cut it down a lot and had it be like Celia or Seely?

[45:41] Jess McInall: Seely, yeah.

[45:42] Andrew DeWolf: Seely, Nettie, Mr. and Shug.

[45:45] Jess McInall: Oh my god. I can't even talk right now because I'm my throat.

[45:50] Andrew DeWolf: But have it be those four characters and that's it.

[45:53] Jess McInall: Mm-hmm.

[45:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like just cut down everything else.

[45:56] Jess McInall: Because the other characters just don't need to be there.

[45:59] Andrew DeWolf: Or if you are gonna have them there, have them have a reason to be there.

[46:02] Jess McInall: Either cut 20 minutes or add 20 minutes.

[46:05] Andrew DeWolf: There are pros and cons for both.

[46:06] Jess McInall: I'd say the better is to add 20 minutes and flesh these characters out with Seely.

[46:11] Andrew DeWolf: Because basically Harpo and Sophia are the only ones that talk to each other.

[46:16] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[46:16] Andrew DeWolf: And that makes it not compelling at all.

[46:19] Jess McInall: Um, just Andrew, what is her cheese rating and your overall thoughts?

[46:24] Andrew DeWolf: I think we've pretty much already given our overall thoughts at this point, but I think it needs work.

[46:29] Jess McInall: Um, I think the songs are generally very good though.

[46:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and the music style is very fitting.

[46:36] Jess McInall: But the story just could have been told a lot better.

[46:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, cheese rating.

[46:40] Jess McInall: I don't know. Give it a like goat cheese.

[46:43] Andrew DeWolf: Great.

[46:44] Jess McInall: Okay.

[46:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I am very conflicted about this because I really want to like it.

[46:49] Jess McInall: Cause I think the staging is great.

[46:51] Andrew DeWolf: I think the actors are great.

[46:52] Jess McInall: I think the performances are good.

[46:54] Andrew DeWolf: I think the songs are great.

[46:55] Jess McInall: I just, that story, like I've seen it in a way that it was so compelling.

[47:00] Andrew DeWolf: And for this, I don't know why it just didn't compel me as much.

[47:03] Jess McInall: It's like the reverse way I feel about Jane Eyre, where I feel the book is very dull and very plain, but when Paul Gordon adapted it into a musical, suddenly a lot of it hits a lot harder and more for me.

[47:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, do you think it's the, do you think it's the book?

[47:17] Jess McInall: Like not the, the book, like the book for the musical.

[47:20] Andrew DeWolf: Like, do you think it's the talking scenes and everything between the screen?

[47:24] Jess McInall: There's not many talking scenes though.

[47:26] Andrew DeWolf: The ones that they're all like maybe that's it.

[47:28] Jess McInall: Maybe we do need some like actual dialogue scenes or either more or less.

[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think it would hurt to have some more dialogue scenes.

[47:36] Jess McInall: Yeah, and I think you need that connection to people.

[47:40] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I think you need some silence, so to say, to take in like some of the darker shades of this.

[47:47] Jess McInall: Because if everyone's like singing out, like as much as I love singing in as much of a release it can be, it's hard to have tension while you're singing.

[47:57] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, cheese rating.

[47:58] Jess McInall: What do you got?

[47:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I would give it some very nice French cheese, like some of the brie, like, you know, it's good.

[48:08] Jess McInall: Like you put in your mouth, it's really good, but it crumbles a little bit and a lot of it falls off the cracker.

[48:13] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.

[48:14] Jess McInall: Like, oh, I like this, but no, no, we need more.

[48:17] Andrew DeWolf: Come on, come on, I need a little more.

[48:18] Jess McInall: Come on.

[48:19] Andrew DeWolf: And you're just trying to shove it all on the cracker, but you get some on and the rest falls off.

[48:23] Jess McInall: That's how I rate it.

[48:25] Andrew DeWolf: Like, oh, you're so good, but it's frustrating.

[48:27] Jess McInall: Uh, yeah, you know what? I'll agree with that.

[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, so thank you guys for listening.

[48:34] Jess McInall: I hope we didn't piss you all off because we have some interesting thoughts on The Color Purple.

[48:40] Andrew DeWolf: But you know what? Give us a review on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese, or on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. Our Patreon is Musicals with Cheese, our Instagram is Musicals with Cheese, our YouTube page is Musicals with Cheese, our email is musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com.

[48:54] Jess McInall: Send us some hate mail because of what we said about The Color Purple.

[48:57] Andrew DeWolf: We love hate mail.

[48:58] Jess McInall: Um, our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco.

[49:02] Andrew DeWolf: Go send her some love at Jolene Casco.

[49:04] Jess McInall: Andrew, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap up?

[49:07] Andrew DeWolf: We love you all.

[49:08] Jess McInall: Um, and I'm sorry I've been sick.

[49:10] Andrew DeWolf: Hopefully, hopefully next week we'll get some really top-notch recordings out there.

[49:15] Jess McInall: Yep.

[49:16] Andrew DeWolf: You know what I gotta say, Andrew?

[49:18] Jess McInall: What's that?

[49:19] Andrew DeWolf: Hey Andrew, what you gonna do?

[49:21] Jess McInall: Going down by the river, gonna play with you.

[49:24] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, promitty.

[49:27] Jess McInall: Man, I really hate being sick though.

[49:29] Andrew DeWolf: I just can't, I can't voice myself like I want to.

[49:32] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[49:33] Andrew DeWolf: He looks so frustrated.

[49:35] Jess McInall: The last two episodes were rough to get through, but we need to hit our deadlines.

[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: But next week we're gonna be back in our A game, folks.

[49:44] Jess McInall: Yep.

[49:44] Andrew DeWolf: Watch me be sick.

[49:46] Jess McInall: I'll be able to talk at full volume again and maybe actually laugh as well without coughing.

[49:52] Andrew DeWolf: I mean me? I always cough when I laugh.

[49:55] Jess McInall: Well, that's different.

[49:56] Andrew DeWolf: I don't.

[49:57] Jess McInall: Jesse, you're dying.

[49:58] Andrew DeWolf: That's probably, we're all dying.

[50:00] Jess McInall: Yeah.

[50:01] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred