Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#9:  Falsettos

Give these handsome boys a hand, welcome to Falsettoland! This week Jess & Andrew cover William Finn's masterpiece FALSETTOS!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 1 min
11/2/18

Featured Shows

About

Give these handsome boys a hand, welcome to Falsettoland! This week Jess & Andrew cover William Finn's masterpiece FALSETTOS! Throughout the podcast, Jess & Andrew chat about the strange structure of the show, what the world would be like if Whizzer was actually a Wizard, whether Marvin is an irredeemable character, why this show works and Rent doesn't, and whether or not the Lesbians from next door are completely necessary characters. What a world we live in!

Links:

Listen to Falsettos the Musical

Social Media:

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Jess on Twitter

Jess Cook on Twitter

Musicals Theatre Lives on Instagram

Jess on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Jess Cook: Hello, I'm Jess.

[0:06] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.

[0:08] Jess Cook: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:12] Andrew: And we get drunk on uh hard cider.

[0:15] Jess Cook: Yes, we do.

[0:17] Jess Cook: Hey, Andrew, you want to hear a joke?

[0:19] Andrew: Of course I do. I always want to hear a joke.

[0:21] Jess Cook: Okay. Um, four Jews, two gays, and two lesbians walk into a bar.

[0:27] Andrew: Okay.

[0:28] Jess Cook: AIDS.

[0:33] Andrew: Never, never invite AIDS to a party.

[0:36] Jess Cook: Alright, well, we're talking about Rent again this week, so no, no, Andrew, what are we really talking about this week?

[0:45] Andrew: We're talking about Falsettos, man.

[0:47] Jess Cook: This is Falsetto's Falsetto's land right now.

[0:50] Andrew: Four Jews in a room plot a crime.

[0:55] Jess Cook: I'm bitching, he's bitching, they're bitching, we're bitching, bitch, bitch, bitch, bitch, funny, funny, funny, funny, bitch, bitch, bitch, bitch, bitch, bitch.

[1:07] Jess Cook: So let's talk a little bit about Falsettos and what exactly it is. You ready for the very brief history?

[1:12] Andrew: Oh, run it by me.

[1:16] Jess Cook: Falsettos is actually two one-act plays that were squeezed together to make the full two-act musical. It is the second two parts of a trilogy. Um, the first being In Trousers. The first first show is called March of the Falsettos, which was released in 1981 and written by William Finn's and directed by James LePine. The second one was called Falsetto Land, which was released many years later in 1990. Um, written in reaction to the newly developed AIDS crisis, which took over a lot of things. Um, so he figured just pick up those same characters as opposed to telling a new story.

[1:49] Andrew: Or opposed to telling um a brand new story with brand new characters.

[1:54] Jess Cook: Yeah, I mean, I think it's pretty obvious when you watch it too.

[1:57] Andrew: Yeah, it feels that way in the same way that Into the Woods feels like two very distinct stories put together.

[2:04] Jess Cook: But I don't see them as very disconnected. I feel like one kind of accidentally sets up the other very well.

[2:13] Andrew: In this one?

[2:14] Jess Cook: Yes, I feel that the entire um full musical entitled Falsettos, which is the two one acts squeezed together, um, even accidentally, despite them feeling very disconnected, um, accidentally foreshadows one another despite not always being intentional.

[2:32] Andrew: I could see that.

[2:34] Jess Cook: But the show went on to get um Broadway as a full musical on April 29th of 1992 and closed on June 27th of 1993, after four hundred and eighty-seven performances, twenty-three previews. It won the Tonys for Best Book of a Musical and Best Original Score, which is pretty good. And it covered the topics of um homosexuality and the AIDS crisis many years before Rent did, and much better than Rent did.

[3:00] Andrew: Wow, you're really bringing out the high praise. Are you saying this is better than Rent?

[3:03] Jess Cook: Yeah, it's better than Rent, believe it or not.

[3:05] Andrew: Better than Rent.

[3:07] Jess Cook: Yeah, better enough that it even had a revival in September of 2016, starring Andrew Rannells, Christian Borle, Stephanie J. Block, Anthony Rosenthal, and Brandon Uranowitz, which is the version that you and I have watched.

[3:20] Andrew: Rent didn't get a revival because it got evicted because they never paid the rent.

[3:24] Jess Cook: Also because it ran for ten years and it didn't really need to be revived that soon.

[3:28] Andrew: Oh.

[3:30] Jess Cook: That's the much sadder reason.

[3:33] Andrew: The much sadder reason, he says. Um, so instead of talking about Falsettos as a whole right away, I figured the best way to talk about these is to talk about their individual plays. And Andrew, do you think that's the best way as well?

[3:47] Andrew: No, you're throwing a curveball at me. It seems like these are just really cohesive and should be talked about as one.

[3:53] Jess Cook: We'll do that at the end, but right now let's just break it up into sections.

[3:57] Andrew: My father's a homo.

[3:59] Jess Cook: My mother's not thrilled at all.

[4:04] Andrew: Father homo.

[4:06] Jess Cook: What about chromosomes do they carry?

[4:09] Andrew: Well, they carry who's the homo now.

[4:12] Jess Cook: My father said that one day I'll grow up to be president.

[4:16] Andrew: And that idea's not so wild.

[4:19] Jess Cook: I'd only the life of a normal child.

[4:27] Andrew: So let's talk about March of the Falsettos. It takes place in 1979, New York City, and involves Marvin, his psychologist Mendel, his wife Trina, and his son um Jason. And of course, his boyfriend Wizzer.

[4:39] Jess Cook: Wizard.

[4:43] Andrew: Wizzer.

[4:44] Jess Cook: It's Wizzer.

[4:45] Andrew: Wizard, not Wizard.

[4:47] Jess Cook: I I'm telling you though, for the entire at least the first half, I thought it was wizard.

[4:53] Andrew: Like I thought he was freaking Gandalf.

[5:00] Jess Cook: I'm really I'm not I'm literally not kidding. Like, this isn't a joke. Uh, it's just funny because now I just see Andrew Rannells as Gandalf saying, you shall not pass.

[5:14] Andrew: I guess that is kind of funny, but I really thought that was his nickname.

[5:18] Jess Cook: I thought he was Wizard.

[5:20] Andrew: No, his actual like name was Wizard Brown.

[5:23] Jess Cook: That is his birth name.

[5:25] Andrew: Uh, I'm gonna name my kid Pisser.

[5:29] Jess Cook: But Marvin's main goal, as he states at the very beginning, is he wants to have a tight-knit family with his ex-wife, his son, and his new gay lover.

[5:38] Andrew: That's not awkward at all, I'm just gonna be honest. That's like that's perfection right there.

[5:43] Jess Cook: But the irony is that Marvin doesn't see the reason why that would be messed up in any way. He wants this the way it is, so I want it, therefore that's what it should be, right?

[5:55] Andrew: Uh no, actually, that's not how reality works. That's not how uh racial relationships work, I don't think.

[6:01] Jess Cook: And that's the way that Marvin's brain works throughout the entirety of March of the Falsettos. I want this thing, why can't you let me have this thing the way I want it specifically?

[6:11] Andrew: It's like a game of chess.

[6:14] Jess Cook: And uh while he's dealing with that crisis of wanting that family unit, his son is dealing with whether or not he's gonna be a homosexual too because his dad is gay, as well as several other issues.

[6:27] Andrew: Yeah, so he's feeling like really worried about like if my dad's like this, does that mean I'm like this, and the way that they live is not the way I've ever seen anyone live, and it's weird and I don't like it? Like, so far as just because his father finds like the pitcher at a baseball game attractive, he's like, well, they that's what caused them to lose the game, thanks, Dad.

[6:47] Jess Cook: Can we talk about how creepy everyone is in this?

[6:50] Andrew: We can, but let's bring out the creepiest character of them all.

[6:54] Jess Cook: Okay, yeah, let's bring him out.

[6:56] Andrew: Bring him on down.

[6:57] Jess Cook: Alright, Dr. Mendel.

[6:59] Andrew: Or Dr. Mendela, as some people call him.

[7:01] Jess Cook: He is Marvin's psychologist who then st immediately starts treating his wife, who he has very overt sexual feelings for.

[7:10] Andrew: Well, I mean.

[7:13] Jess Cook: He's creepy.

[7:15] Andrew: I think it's partially how he's portrayed, though.

[7:19] Jess Cook: I think that they want him to be creepy.

[7:21] Andrew: I don't know. It's my opinion that that role has never ever been cast right, so everything that he says comes off as flamboyant as opposed to neurotic.

[7:30] Jess Cook: Um, everyone gets like these skinny, like big broad actors like Chip Zion and Brandon Uranowitz, who are very talented, but I don't think are right for that role.

[7:40] Andrew: I think someone like Dan Fogelman, um, I think that's his name, um, the guy from Spelling Bee, or even Josh Gad when he's reined in a bit, would be really good choices for that. Someone big with that like innate masculinity to them.

[7:54] Jess Cook: The way he's portrayed right now, he just seems like he's kind of like uh just creepy.

[8:01] Andrew: Just straight creepy.

[8:02] Jess Cook: It's just the whole thing is portrayed creepy.

[8:05] Andrew: It's strange. Like he's using his position to try to get closer to Trina and her son, as well as like um it's it's uncomfortable.

[8:17] Jess Cook: It really is uncomfortable.

[8:19] Andrew: Does she sleep naked?

[8:21] Jess Cook: Like his unprofessionalism almost makes me like he is easily the least likable character in a uh show full of flawed characters.

[8:31] Andrew: Well, the thing is, I would say that's only for the first half, though.

[8:35] Jess Cook: Yeah, his character entirely flips as soon as he marries Trina.

[8:39] Andrew: Yeah, like the whole thing, it's like, oh it's not creepy anymore. Now he's married, it's fine.

[8:44] Jess Cook: It's like, what?

[8:48] Andrew: Like, if you deliver those lines a little bit more reined in, I feel like they could uh really work.

[8:53] Jess Cook: Like, if he's like actually trying to slip those like cues in a bit more subtly and you're trying to hide it, and Marvin sees through the bullshit.

[9:01] Andrew: Like that could like lead to like more cringe comedy that's like a little bit more realistic as opposed to the very broad, very broad, like serial killer comedy.

[9:13] Jess Cook: Yeah, it's less like a it's less like a cringe comedy and more like just dark comedy. Because if you're going into this blind without knowing exactly where it's going, you think that this guy is gonna like stalk this poor woman that's gone through enough and trying to deal with both her gay ex-husband and her crazy son.

[9:30] Andrew: I didn't I thought he was gonna be the villain. I thought he was like the guy like really I'm not even kidding.

[9:40] Jess Cook: The first time I watched it, I was like, oh my god, this guy's fucking creepy.

[9:46] Andrew: It was like it's and like when he proposes, I'm like, no, no.

[9:55] Jess Cook: What are you doing?

[9:58] Andrew: Hey, can I come talk to your son?

[10:02] Jess Cook: Uh no.

[10:05] Andrew: No in my house. Please don't come into my house.

[10:08] Jess Cook: But together, Trina and Marvin want their son to see a psychologist because of all the things that are running through his head, and therefore that brings Mendel closer into their lives.

[10:20] Andrew: A psychiatrist.

[10:21] Jess Cook: Yes, what did I say?

[10:23] Andrew: Psychologist.

[10:24] Jess Cook: Sorry. Psychiatrist.

[10:25] Andrew: They're two very different things.

[10:27] Jess Cook: They are, but they sound way too similar, and a lot of people mess it up.

[10:30] Andrew: Yes.

[10:31] Jess Cook: Including myself.

[10:32] Andrew: You specifically.

[10:33] Jess Cook: Okay, I mean, but he's creepy.

[10:36] Andrew: I think he was the creepiest.

[10:37] Jess Cook: He's creepy, but it like fades away and he becomes like.

[10:41] Andrew: It's strange.

[10:42] Jess Cook: Like, everyone's flawed in this.

[10:44] Andrew: Like, everyone is very, very acutely flawed in this show, but none of them feel quite as like we're supposed to feel like Marvin's the dangerous one, but really Mendel feels the most dangerous.

[10:56] Andrew: Ah.

[10:57] Jess Cook: Um, but he's not the only one, I don't think. Like, Marvin does feel creepy.

[11:01] Andrew: Well, Marvin doesn't feel creepy as much as he feels territorial.

[11:06] Jess Cook: Yes.

[11:08] Andrew: I think the only person that doesn't seem creepy is Wizzer.

[11:11] Jess Cook: Wizzer and Jason.

[11:14] Andrew: No, Jason's creepy too.

[11:16] Jess Cook: Jason's a different type of creepy, though.

[11:18] Andrew: Jason's like a horn dog, okay.

[11:22] Jess Cook: He's not a horn dog until the next play.

[11:24] Andrew: Oh, you're right, you're right.

[11:25] Jess Cook: But he comes out there and he starts laying down that locker room talk, man.

[11:36] Andrew: Yes, he yes, he does. While Mendel is seeing Jason for his psychiatric work, um, he falls in love with Trina, and Jason basically takes the father figure role onto Jason and or onto Mendel, and's like, hey, this is a good deal you're getting out of this. You won't hurt my mom like my jerk-ass gay father did, so go go and take her.

[12:02] Jess Cook: Then we're gonna talk about how Marvin is trying to force a Wizzer into the homemaker wife role, when really that's like removing all autonomy in Wizzer's life.

[12:12] Andrew: Wizard is basically a playboy that wants to go out, have fun, and party. And Marvin's like, I want you to make me dinner and have it ready while I pay for the bills. Um, yeah, Marvin's uh abusive. Like, not just like he's both mentally and physically abusive, and by the end of the show, Wizzer leaves him because he's like, I don't need this shit right. I don't need this. Good for him. Which really that's the best part of the show, and Lisa my favor my second favorite song and act um in March of the Falsettos. I mean, he beats his boyfriend and his wife. Like, what is wrong with this guy? His he's just straight up abusive. He's like a bad person.

[12:57] Jess Cook: He is, and it's interesting because in this time, like in the late mid-80s to early 90s, all gay representation had them as like these godlike figures, the gay best friend, or if like angel from Rent who does no wrong despite killing a dog, but is viewed in the eyes of the viewed in the eyes of the writer as this perfect thing, because in those days, if we are gonna have gay representation, you have to make them perfect. And that's why falsettos, like everyone is flawed. Everyone is either a dick, very flawed, suicidal. All of them are have their issues, and that's what sets them really apart.

[13:35] Andrew: Except for Wizard.

[13:36] Jess Cook: Yeah, Wizard Wizard has issues.

[13:40] Andrew: Like what?

[13:41] Jess Cook: Um AIDS. Um, no, he's a bit of a floozy. He cheats on Marvin.

[13:48] Andrew: I don't remember that part.

[13:49] Jess Cook: It's like an off-handed line, like, Wizard doesn't know how to see what a joy's monogamy, what a joy is saving one's joy for one man. Wizzer screws too much to see what a joy's monogamy. What a joy is saving his joys for one man.

[14:06] Andrew: Oh.

[14:07] Jess Cook: Yeah. I guess I didn't catch it.

[14:08] Andrew: It was fast, it was one line. I mean, isn't maybe that's not true though? What if you didn't cheat on him?

[14:14] Jess Cook: I don't know. That's how I interpreted it. But the thing about William Finn's dialogue is, or lyrics, is that they're very there's multiple ways to interpret them. Like that could just mean that he was a he was somebody who slept around, and then you know, and that's just bringing that back, you know.

[14:32] Andrew: Mm-hmm.

[14:33] Jess Cook: And then um, after Mendel proposes to Trina, Trina is very confused about how she's feeling because all these men in her life literally act like assholes are children.

[14:45] Andrew: Yeah.

[14:46] Jess Cook: And then we go into the song that everyone loves.

[14:55] Andrew: March, March, March of the Falsettos, March of the Fosettos. We is man enough to march to March of the Fosettos. Come here. One foot following the other. Teach it to your brother. Make him march, march, March of the Falsettos, March of the Falcettos.

[15:22] Andrew: Oops. I want to say I didn't like this part.

[15:26] Jess Cook: Alright.

[15:27] Andrew: This part was it was too weird. It didn't make any fucking sense.

[15:32] Jess Cook: Describe what happens for the audience.

[15:35] Andrew: Uh well, at the beginning, Alice is chasing a white rabbit, and then she gets sucked down a rabbit hole, and that's when Tweedledee and Tweedledum and Tweedled Derp and Tweedledimp all come out. And they start singing this song. Um.

[15:55] Jess Cook: It's uh everyone's Yeah.

[15:59] Andrew: It's hard to describe it, Jess. Can you can you come in and help me out here?

[16:04] Jess Cook: So Trina has this conflict where she doesn't know if she should accept the proposal. She goes a little crazy, and then she sees a vision of four men dressed all in white with their faces hidden. Um, singing about the March of the Falsettos. And singing in a falsetto.

[16:22] Andrew: It's a little bit annoying.

[16:24] Jess Cook: Well, it's supposed to be.

[16:25] Andrew: Um, it's supposed to represent how men are basically these childish, useless things.

[16:32] Jess Cook: It definitely does portray them as annoying.

[16:36] Andrew: But it kind of annoys me.

[16:40] Jess Cook: The song itself is like a playground taunt, and they're all singing in like a high-pitched annoying voice on purpose, and it's like, uh, it's it actually is annoying.

[16:53] Andrew: Well, March of the Falsetto is in description of the writer William Finn's sees it as like this masculine thing of marching as militaries do, being done by these men who are dressed goofily and singing as high pitched as they can and turning it on its head.

[17:08] Jess Cook: I suppose so.

[17:10] Andrew: And I can see that, and I applaud them for the creativity. But I didn't like it.

[17:16] Jess Cook: That's fine.

[17:17] Andrew: I'm that's fine. But at the end of it, Trina decides to accept Mendel's proposal, and Marvin goes a little crazy.

[17:25] Jess Cook: Tell me, Trina, what was the infamous? Sorry, Trina, look in my eyes. Really, Trina, this is ridiculous. Jesus, Trina, how I despise your need for stupid conversation. You are trying to ruin my sleep. I'm sure you chosen to make me look bad. How could you ever deny what we had?

[17:40] Andrew: Is this the part where he beats her?

[17:42] Jess Cook: Yes.

[17:43] Andrew: Yeah, that wasn't cool.

[17:46] Jess Cook: It's very weird when the first act of a musical's climax is literally a man beating his ex-wife.

[17:51] Andrew: What I always wonder here is how does he keep getting back into her house?

[18:01] Jess Cook: Really, though, he's like always there.

[18:05] Andrew: I mean, he has legally he has to be able to see his son. I imagine it's like on one of those dad weekends where he's supposed to come and pick up his son because he does mention later that he does get his son on the weekends. Um, and he just shows up and goes on a crazy raving rant as soon as he gets like his wedding the wedding invitation of his ex-wife to his psychiatrist.

[18:25] Jess Cook: How difficult would it be for Trina after she gets hit in the face by this guy to just get full custody?

[18:33] Andrew: I don't know.

[18:34] Jess Cook: In 1979.

[18:36] Andrew: It's all fucked up, is all I'm saying. This whole fucking thing, this whole first act is really fucked.

[18:42] Jess Cook: Yeah, but then she admits that she never regrets being in love with him and just says, hey, let me go, everything will be fine. And that's I'm not gonna lie, that's actually my favorite song. It's just I love how all everyone's voices mesh together so well.

[18:57] Andrew: Yeah, but do you think that she should have forgave him for for beating her?

[19:01] Jess Cook: I don't know. It's complicated because they have a son together.

[19:05] Andrew: But it probably not.

[19:06] Jess Cook: Probably not. Do you think it's okay that the uh second act just completely ignores this?

[19:12] Andrew: I don't know if it's okay, but it's two very different stories, and in the end, it feels like almost immediately after it happens, Trina forgives him.

[19:22] Jess Cook: Marvin is unforgivable.

[19:24] Andrew: Marvin kind of is unforgivable. Mendel's a weirdo. Um the whole first part feels like a like a dark comedy that they somehow try to spin into like a like an uplifting story almost.

[19:44] Jess Cook: And then after all that is done, Marvin finally has the heart to heart and connects with his son. He discovers that all this relationship bullshit has can't hold a candle to the love that he feels for his son. And he finally actually shares the stage with him and looks at him in the eye and gives him like advice.

[20:09] Andrew: Be my son. What I've done to you is rotten. Say I was scared. Marching in time to a tune I'd forgotten. I loved you. Is love when we're talking. Face to face.

[21:11] Jess Cook: And then that is how the March of the Falsettos ends. With uh father and son finally connecting.

[21:19] Andrew: Okay. Can we talk about chess?

[21:21] Jess Cook: Yeah, let's talk about the representation of chess in the first act.

[21:24] Andrew: That's dropped in the first one. What the hell does chess what the hell does chess mean? I want to hear your theory.

[21:31] Jess Cook: I don't have a theory. I don't think it has a meaning in this. I think they just use it. Um one is that chess represents sex.

[21:42] Andrew: And it's weird that Jason is having doing sex by himself masturbating, and everyone thinks that that's weird because you don't know who your partner is. Whereas Wizzer and Marvin, when they're playing chess, it is obviously like a sexual experience where they're kind of one-upping the each other.

[22:01] Jess Cook: So you think chess is sex?

[22:03] Andrew: I think it could be. Because I'm trying to tie it back to Jason's theme of not knowing who he is sexually. I would be honest though, the second the first one makes the second act really creepy.

[22:35] Jess Cook: Alright.

[22:36] Andrew: Um just because of how how it ends.

[22:39] Jess Cook: Right.

[22:40] Andrew: Okay, yeah. I know what you mean. Um, let's talk more about the first one, because I I think I have more to say about the first part.

[22:50] Jess Cook: I'm sure you do.

[22:51] Andrew: Um I wanna talk a little bit about the structure of it. Because it really is structured like um almost like a Charlie Kaufman story. Where it kind of meanders and the narration church, and how everyone kind of just starts in these relationships, and the only relationship that really develops from beginning to romance is um Mendel and Trina.

[23:18] Jess Cook: Um actually there's also Marvin and Jason.

[23:22] Andrew: Yeah, that's that's there too. But we don't know anything about how their relationship was before Marvin left the family for Wizard.

[23:33] Jess Cook: Yes.

[23:33] Andrew: Which I feel like is underdeveloped just because I'd like to know what how they were before he became a homosexual, and that really isn't exported in trousers either.

[23:44] Jess Cook: Would it be interesting if he had left for Mendel?

[23:47] Andrew: No.

[23:48] Jess Cook: And then Mendel went for Trina, and then they were all just a hey, I'm happy family.

[23:53] Andrew: It would have been perfect.

[23:55] Jess Cook: It would have been way too complicated.

[23:57] Andrew: And we would have lost Wizard, who is a fun character. Wanna talk about a few of the songs real quick while we got the second to talk about the first act?

[24:05] Jess Cook: Yeah, let's do it.

[24:06] Andrew: Let's do it. Um, I really, really liked um Um Trina's song. Um, not the song entitled Trina's song, but her song I'm Breaking Down.

[24:25] Andrew: It's just he's so damn happy that it makes me so damn mad. I wanna hate him, but I really can't. It's like a nightmare how this all proceeds. I hope that wizard don't fulfill his needs.

[24:42] Jess Cook: Don't is wrong. Sing along! What was the Nanak? I do like that song, but it's also one of the darkest parts of the whole thing.

[24:51] Andrew: How so?

[24:54] Jess Cook: I mean, it's fucked. The whole thing is fucked. But it's so funny.

[25:01] Andrew: Jess, what do you think chopping up bananas represents?

[25:06] Jess Cook: Chopping off a man's dick, obviously. How is that not fucked?

[25:15] Andrew: It's funny. It's like so dark.

[25:18] Jess Cook: It's hilarious.

[25:19] Andrew: I wasn't laughing, I'm gonna be honest with you. That was really fucked up.

[25:26] Jess Cook: But her voice, Stephanie J. Block is so fucking talented, dude. It feels like that song should have been in the the part the in in trousers section, though.

[25:40] Andrew: It was. It was, and then they moved in here because it was a good song. Fun fact.

[25:45] Jess Cook: Oh, okay. So what I'm trying to say is it's out of place.

[25:48] Andrew: And I guess I'm right.

[25:54] Jess Cook: I think it fits pretty well, and it lets us get into her head, and I feel like it gives us a well-needed explanation of both her opinion on the wizard and her opinion on the new dynamic that her husband her ex-husband really wants.

[26:07] Andrew: It doesn't make sense in terms of Mendel, though.

[26:11] Jess Cook: How so?

[26:12] Andrew: Because during that section, she's falling in love with Mendel. Or I think she is. It doesn't make sense that she's saying she's breaking down.

[26:25] Jess Cook: Yes, but you can't just hide away your feelings for your ex-husband. Like, I believe she genuinely loved Marvin. And they have a son, which means that she can't just cut Marvin out completely.

[26:36] Andrew: So any time that she wants to like have her son see have a relationship with her father, she has to see the man that her husband left her with as the reminder of what she isn't.

[26:46] Jess Cook: She does not have a banana.

[26:48] Andrew: No, and that makes her so angry she wants to destroy his bananas.

[26:52] Jess Cook: I think it fits pretty well. Like, I understand what you're saying, but I think moving it into falsetto or March of the First Falsettos was a good move.

[27:01] Andrew: Well, I think it fits structurally into the storytelling, and that the story would be lesser without it.

[27:06] Jess Cook: I suppose. Because we got Trina's song later where she's like, I'm tired of all the happy men who rule the world and all that, which is beautiful, but I don't think it gives us really an opinion on the entire situation.

[27:20] Andrew: She gets really upset at men.

[27:22] Jess Cook: Rightfully so, like, have you seen the men that are in her life?

[27:26] Andrew: I wanted to love you. I only wanted to see my face in yours.

[27:32] Jess Cook: Jason's wild, save this child.

[27:38] Andrew: He adores and case me.

[27:41] Jess Cook: It really killed me when you took those vows.

[27:44] Andrew: Don't misunderstand. I'm into man.

[27:47] Jess Cook: And anyhow, we're through.

[27:50] Andrew: I never wanted, I wanted, I never, never, never, never, never, never wanted to love you.

[27:56] Jess Cook: I never wanted to love you.

[27:59] Andrew: I never wanted to love.

[28:03] Jess Cook: Alright, so Andrew. Overall, what is your thoughts on just March of the Falsettos as a one act play?

[28:11] Andrew: I feel like they should have gone darker.

[28:13] Jess Cook: Like, how dark would you go?

[28:15] Andrew: If Andrew was writing March of the Falsettos, what would it be?

[28:18] Jess Cook: I I'm not sure where I would have gone with it. But I feel it it it begs to be a dark comedy.

[28:27] Andrew: Um, but it never goes there. I think March of the Falsettos is a really effective Charlie Kaufman-esque like family dynamic story that is really brave, especially considering the time it was released, and I really appreciate very specific elements of it, such as the fact that it represents homosexuals as something flawed and actual human beings as opposed to like these devices made for the main characters to feel better about themselves.

[28:56] Jess Cook: I think, especially in the Lincoln Center performance, it is amazingly well performed in that every song is solid and really it goes by so fast and tells the story so concisely and so perfectly that I don't have very many complaints with it.

[29:12] Andrew: Yeah, I want to uh elaborate that I don't think it's bad. I think it is uh it is pretty good.

[29:20] Jess Cook: Um, and I liked it a lot more than I liked the second part.

[29:24] Andrew: Which is surprising, because most people prefer the second part.

[29:28] Jess Cook: Which is surprising to me.

[29:33] Andrew: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the podcast, but we're here to shill at you.

[29:38] Jess Cook: Yay!

[29:39] Andrew: That's my favorite thing to do. That's that's my uh that's my game.

[29:42] Jess Cook: Alright. Please subscribe to us on iTunes and leave us a review. It's our way of getting viewed and getting up there on the new and noteworthy list.

[29:49] Andrew: We really want that. Also, find us on Spotify, Stitcher, and all the other podcast websites.

[29:55] Jess Cook: Uh, check us out on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals.

[29:58] Andrew: On Instagram at musical theater Lives.

[30:01] Jess Cook: YouTube, Musical Theatre Lives.

[30:04] Andrew: And please, if you have any questions, recommendations, thoughts, or just anything that you want to say at us, email us at musicaltheaterlives@gmail.com.

[30:13] Jess Cook: We always read them and we will respond. We'll probably respond to them on the show.

[30:17] Andrew: Also, a reminder that we are currently having a raffle for anyone that is gonna leave us a review on iTunes.

[30:24] Jess Cook: If you leave a review, you'll be automatically put into a raffle for a $20 Amazon gift card.

[30:29] Andrew: So if you leave a review, you have a chance to win.

[30:37] Jess Cook: Just letting you know.

[30:38] Andrew: Exactly.

[30:40] Jess Cook: So thank you for listening, and let's get you back to it.

[30:43] Andrew: Lovers come and lovers go. Lovers fight and sing for discipline. Give these handsome boys a hand.

[30:49] Jess Cook: Welcome to Falsetto.

[30:51] Andrew: Lancy Reagan. Meanest and thinnest of the first ladies moves into the White House.

[30:58] Jess Cook: It's the ADA.

[31:12] Andrew: Welcome to Falsetto Land. The year's 1981, and we pick up the story basically a few years after we left off with two new characters, Dr. Charlotte and her lover Cordelia.

[31:24] Jess Cook: Um, so this is a very, very different in tone for the first act, but very similar in a lot of ways, too.

[31:32] Andrew: Um, similar how.

[31:34] Jess Cook: I'd say similar in both like song structure. Like the songs very much feel connected to the first one, as well as the narration being tied by Marvin's point of view.

[31:46] Andrew: I know it's a follow-up to the first part, but it kind of just ignores the first part in a lot of ways.

[31:52] Jess Cook: I feel like I think it addresses it in a lot of ways.

[31:57] Andrew: I feel like it feels like two separate episodes of a TV show where they'll reference things that happened last time, but it won't like really bring it up.

[32:06] Jess Cook: Like, Trina doesn't bring up the fact that Marvin hit her ever. That's never brought up.

[32:10] Andrew: There's a lot of different stuff that's never really brought up.

[32:14] Jess Cook: Well, then there's things that I think are paid off really well, like um Marvin, who is like such like this competitive asshole in the first half with Wizzer.

[32:24] Andrew: Then when they get back together and they start playing racquetball together, um Wizzer finally finds a game he can beat Marvin at, and it just pisses Marvin off so much, which I think is a really good like reference to the chess playing in the first act.

[32:38] Jess Cook: Let's kind of get into the story here.

[32:40] Andrew: Alright, the story basically is um Marvin and Wizzer get back together while because uh basically their mutual relationship with Jason.

[32:50] Jess Cook: Jason invites Wizzer to one of his baseball games, and through that Marvin and Wizzer get back together.

[32:55] Andrew: And basically everyone has their individual happy couples. Cordelia, Dr. Charlotte have like their great couple.

[33:02] Jess Cook: Um Mendel and Trina have a good marriage while has its bumps all together.

[33:09] Andrew: Like he can't even stay up for sex anymore, and she's still very jealous of the fact that Wizzer and Marvin are a thing.

[33:16] Jess Cook: And Marvin and Wizzer actually seem to have a healthy relationship now.

[33:20] Andrew: Yeah, like everyone's happy, which means that everything won't be happy very long.

[33:27] Jess Cook: Everything will not be happy because of AIDS.

[33:33] Andrew: Yes. They're all planning Jason's bar mitzvah, like trying to get that together and the backdrop.

[33:40] Jess Cook: But over time, Dr. Charlotte finds out there's this disease that is killing a lot of homosexual men.

[33:47] Andrew: And of course, of course, the man who has been absent from this family unit who just came back now has that disease.

[33:56] Jess Cook: Why couldn't it have been Marvin?

[33:59] Andrew: Or Mendel.

[34:01] Jess Cook: Not men.

[34:02] Andrew: Why wouldn't Mendel have AIDS?

[34:04] Jess Cook: Just because fuck him.

[34:07] Andrew: I mean, in the second part, I think in the second part, he's very likable.

[34:11] Jess Cook: I think Mendel like grows a lot, and I think like his relationship with Jason is very, very compelling in the second part, where in the first part it felt like a tool.

[34:22] Andrew: I feel like this is one of the big disconnects is I feel like Mendel is a completely different character in the second part, basically.

[34:29] Jess Cook: Just like not even the same character whatsoever.

[34:33] Andrew: Or when he settles down, he becomes much more of a human being as opposed to like a giant cartoon flamboyant character.

[34:41] Jess Cook: I mean, you could say that, or you could say that they just fucked up the writing and accidentally forgot that he was creepy.

[34:48] Andrew: Or they just never thought he was that creepy to begin with.

[34:52] Jess Cook: Which may be worse.

[34:56] Andrew: So Wizzer, we discover that Wizzer has AIDS when he basically passes out while playing racquetball with Marvin.

[35:03] Jess Cook: And he takes him to the hospital, and Angel Randall's performance where he literally like.

[35:09] Andrew: Because in the first act and like most of the second act, um, he's like this very polished, dressed beautifully, um, uh, always poised, always with grace, um, character, and then you just see him in like that hospital gown, wearing that shitty beanie that they make them wear, and like there's a lot of cool theatrical tricks used, like um, when he plays racquetball the first time, he's it's like super tight on him, and then when we see him playing racquetball again, they give him like looser clothing, so it looks like he lost a ton of weight.

[35:41] Jess Cook: Yeah, and that goes the way that you'd expect.

[35:45] Andrew: Um, Jason doesn't want his bar mitzvah because his um father's boyfriend's dying, and he doesn't want to lose a good friend.

[35:52] Jess Cook: So they decide to have the Jason's bar mitzvah in Wizzer's hospital room, and at the end of that, Wizzer basically walks off stage and dies.

[36:03] Andrew: Marvin and him have a last duet where we see Wizzer dressed exactly how he was at the beginning, and he dies leaving Marvin alone again.

[36:13] Jess Cook: Rest in peace, Wizzer.

[36:16] Andrew: Um do you think he'll come back as Gandalf the White?

[36:34] Jess Cook: Can we talk about um one interesting thing with your synopsis of this second part?

[36:41] Andrew: Um did you notice that you didn't mention uh certain set of characters whatsoever?

[36:48] Jess Cook: Um, I did. I mentioned them once when she's the doctor that discovers there's AIDS.

[36:54] Andrew: Oh, okay.

[36:55] Jess Cook: Yes, yes. Um, why were they added to the story?

[36:58] Andrew: They were added, so we'd have the doctor character that could have AIDS, as well as a caterer for Marvin and Trina to fight over.

[37:06] Jess Cook: They are so pointless, and I think they should just be cut out like entirely.

[37:13] Andrew: I I don't see why they're here at all.

[37:16] Jess Cook: I just don't get it. Because you're saying either cut them out of the second half or add them into the first half somewhere.

[37:22] Andrew: Honestly, I would prefer just cut them out of the thing entirely because they have no plot relevance really.

[37:29] Jess Cook: I love their addition to unlikely lovers because I love the harmonies in that song.

[37:34] Andrew: And I feel like, oh, that's worth it. I just I would I feel like it would be better if it was just more focused on the same characters from the first part.

[37:42] Jess Cook: I mean, it's not like the second half doesn't focus on them.

[37:45] Andrew: There are cutaways though, to like there's like they cut away for like a couple scenes, like maybe two scenes, to just these two new characters that we know basically nothing about.

[37:55] Jess Cook: They're Marvin's friends, and they are Jason's godmothers.

[37:59] Andrew: Yeah, that's what I'm talking about. They're Jason's god.

[38:02] Jess Cook: Who are these people?

[38:04] Andrew: They live next door, and they are lesbians.

[38:07] Jess Cook: You've known them for at you've known them for at most like what two years, and they're the godmothers already.

[38:13] Andrew: Get the fuck out of here.

[38:16] Jess Cook: Do you think they're people like I'm very interested in like how Marvin knows these people?

[38:22] Andrew: Like, were they Marvin's friends or were they Trina's friends? Or did they just like walk into his house one day and he's like too afraid to tell them to leave?

[38:32] Jess Cook: Just like Marvin just walks into Trina's house.

[38:35] Andrew: I don't know. I'm not like super upset about it, but it really just it already feels like a jumbled kind of mess a little bit, and it just now you have these two additional characters that are like not even really needing to be there at all, and it's okay.

[38:55] Jess Cook: Now you say you're you prefer act or March the Falsetto's two far falsetoland. Why is that?

[39:04] Andrew: Um it feels like a more cohesive story.

[39:07] Jess Cook: It feels more uh is everything that's introduced in that is pretty much resolved at the end of it.

[39:14] Andrew: There's no there's no loose ends really.

[39:17] Jess Cook: It like the second act basically feels unnecessary.

[39:22] Andrew: Yeah, but it's got Andrew Randall singing, you gotta die sometime, which is amazing.

[39:29] Jess Cook: Uh yeah.

[39:30] Andrew: But like I I prefer his ending in the first part where he he's like, okay, I'm I'm free from this asshole.

[39:39] Jess Cook: Well, he's definitely free from that asshole now.

[39:43] Andrew: He gets back with that asshole and he misses him and then he dies, and it's like, okay.

[39:48] Jess Cook: That sucks.

[39:51] Andrew: Marvin feels like a very different character in act two than act one as well.

[39:56] Jess Cook: Yeah, suddenly he's not a dick.

[39:58] Andrew: Suddenly he's much less violent.

[40:02] Jess Cook: He's like a little bit of a dick, like when they're playing racquetball, but that's about it.

[40:07] Andrew: It's not nearly as bad.

[40:09] Jess Cook: He's just competitive, really.

[40:10] Andrew: That's it.

[40:12] Jess Cook: Yeah, like I feel like all the nuanced flaws that they had in act one is kind of removed.

[40:18] Andrew: I I hate to say it. This part, the second part reminds me much more of Rent than the first part does.

[40:26] Jess Cook: Ooh, you said it, and I don't like it.

[40:29] Andrew: I mean, it you know how you were talking about all of them have flaws in the first half?

[40:35] Jess Cook: Right.

[40:37] Andrew: They don't in the second half.

[40:38] Jess Cook: I mean, Trina falls in Trina is damned a lot in the second half.

[40:43] Andrew: Like, her character is really damaged in act two.

[40:47] Jess Cook: Like, she's just wife figure.

[40:49] Andrew: She is an archetype.

[40:52] Jess Cook: Yeah, and then you have the the two lesbians who I I feel like they basically function as the two perfect gay characters.

[41:01] Andrew: Um, I would agree if like Cordelia wasn't such a failure at like making stuff, but she and she's jealous of her wife and her career.

[41:12] Jess Cook: Yeah, but the girlfriend. The Doctor one is essentially angel.

[41:17] Andrew: I mean to an extent.

[41:20] Jess Cook: I I don't think that Doctor One murdered a dog.

[41:24] Andrew: Not that bad.

[41:25] Jess Cook: Okay, I'm not saying it's as bad as Rent.

[41:28] Andrew: All I'm saying is that I think some of the flaws that we put onto Rent, this does show.

[41:33] Jess Cook: Maybe you're just thinking it's more like Rent because one of the actors from Rent is in it.

[41:38] Andrew: I didn't even notice that, I'm gonna be honest with you.

[41:41] Jess Cook: Joanne was the doctor.

[41:43] Andrew: If you disagree, that's fine. I'm just I'm just throwing it out there that I I feel like they did go and remove a lot of the um character from all the characters in the second half.

[41:57] Jess Cook: But then again, like they're thrown into crisis.

[42:00] Andrew: When crisis comes, you can't really worry about the petty things of like the shit going on.

[42:08] Jess Cook: Well, maybe this story shouldn't have been about AIDS.

[42:13] Andrew: Well, I think it needed to be about AIDS, but maybe it shouldn't have used these same characters.

[42:19] Jess Cook: I agree.

[42:20] Andrew: But then again, like, as just this one act thing, like ignoring the first half. Does it work?

[42:28] Jess Cook: I would say it works okay.

[42:31] Andrew: It does not work as well as the first half.

[42:34] Jess Cook: What did you feel about the ending? Because I remember seeing this in theaters and being surrounded by sobbing, like sobbing teenagers.

[42:41] Andrew: Did you feel emotional at the end? Like anything.

[42:43] Jess Cook: Not really.

[42:47] Andrew: Man, you're a soulless monster.

[42:50] Jess Cook: I mean, I I obviously I was upset a little bit, but I wasn't like.

[42:56] Andrew: I wasn't that invested in Wizard's character because it didn't feel like the same character that I had watched in the first half.

[43:06] Jess Cook: Hmm.

[43:07] Andrew: You're just committed to calling him wizard now.

[43:11] Jess Cook: I I literally committed to it.

[43:13] Andrew: But I that character wouldn't have gotten back with Marvin because that character learned that he didn't want Marvin.

[43:23] Jess Cook: Like you feel like the second half is just negating his arc in the first half?

[43:27] Andrew: Essentially, yes.

[43:30] Jess Cook: It negates it hard.

[43:31] Andrew: Like it's a hard negation.

[43:33] Jess Cook: It's like, oh yeah, everything he learned in the first half, fuck that.

[43:40] Andrew: Uh he loved Marvin from the beginning. What would he have done without him?

[43:48] Jess Cook: Now let's talk about the songs in the second half.

[43:48] Andrew: The songs in the second half?

[43:54] Jess Cook: Yeah.

[43:55] Andrew: I liked the baseball game song.

[43:57] Jess Cook: That was that was a uh fun, a fun song, I thought.

[44:00] Andrew: Mm-hmm.

[44:01] Jess Cook: I like the rhythm aspect of it.

[44:03] Andrew: Yeah, you're a big fan of like the Sondheim sick syncopation type patter songs.

[44:09] Jess Cook: Yes.

[44:10] Andrew: And I find that interesting, and I'm a big fan of the more melodic ballads, which I think make is why this dan dynamic works between us.

[44:19] Jess Cook: Okay.

[44:20] Andrew: Cause you like very different songs than I do.

[44:25] Jess Cook: We're watching Jason play baseball.

[44:27] Andrew: We're watching Jewish boys who cannot play baseball, play baseball.

[44:32] Jess Cook: We're watching Jewish boys who cannot play baseball, play baseball.

[44:36] Andrew: I hate baseball.

[44:37] Jess Cook: I really do.

[44:38] Andrew: Um, what was your favorite song then?

[44:40] Jess Cook: Um let me guess it was the ending song.

[44:42] Andrew: No, no, I do love the ending song.

[44:44] Jess Cook: Oh, okay.

[44:45] Andrew: My favorite is uh you gotta die sometime.

[44:47] Jess Cook: That was your favorite one?

[44:48] Andrew: Yeah, where I'm not sure if it's being That was a good one.

[44:51] Jess Cook: I will say that was a good one.

[44:52] Andrew: I'm not sure if it's like half performance, but Andrew Randles just fucking destroys that song and his like personification of death, like describing it as someone that just takes him in his arms and kisses him until he's dead.

[45:05] Jess Cook: Like, oh that that would be a good that like I've never heard it sound death described so romantically.

[45:12] Andrew: Death's a funny pal with a weird sort of talent.

[45:15] Jess Cook: He puts his arms around my neck and walks me to the bed.

[45:19] Andrew: He pins me up against the wall and kisses me like crazy.

[45:23] Jess Cook: The many stupid things I thought about with Fred now Delive.

[45:30] Andrew: Then the scene turns to white.

[45:33] Jess Cook: Okay.

[45:35] Andrew: You can't have a bar mitzvah in a hospital, can you?

[45:38] Jess Cook: I don't know what would be stopping you.

[45:40] Andrew: I had a birthday party in a hospital once.

[45:42] Jess Cook: What the fuck?

[45:44] Andrew: Please tell me that story, Jess.

[45:47] Jess Cook: Um, my grandma was dying of cancer. It was my birthday, and that's where we spent my birthday.

[45:52] Andrew: Oh no.

[45:55] Jess Cook: I guess it was technically a hospice center inside of a hospital.

[46:00] Andrew: Jess, now everyone's gonna cry.

[46:02] Jess Cook: No, they aren't.

[46:04] Andrew: Uh but yeah, we had like ice cream like cups that we threw around the room, and everyone had them with like the fucking wooden spoons.

[46:13] Jess Cook: Like the hoodsie cups?

[46:14] Andrew: Yeah.

[46:16] Jess Cook: I like hoodsie cups.

[46:17] Andrew: I used to get them in school.

[46:19] Jess Cook: I mean, they don't taste like ice cream.

[46:21] Andrew: They taste like what Martians would try to make if they were trying to make ice cream.

[46:27] Jess Cook: They taste like uh like what Jeff Goldblum when he teleports uh ice cream through his teleporter in the fly.

[46:33] Andrew: That's what it tastes like.

[46:36] Jess Cook: It tastes like your grandma's dying in a hospice center.

[46:39] Andrew: Oh no.

[46:44] Jess Cook: Happy birthday to you.

[46:48] Andrew: Happy birthday.

[46:53] Jess Cook: You gotta die sometime, Jess.

[46:55] Andrew: I know.

[46:56] Jess Cook: That's such it's so dark.

[46:59] Andrew: Thank you.

[47:01] Jess Cook: Okay.

[47:07] Andrew: Please don't cut that whole thing out.

[47:08] Jess Cook: Don't you gotta leave some of that in.

[47:12] Andrew: Okay.

[47:12] Jess Cook: Which part?

[47:14] Andrew: Your grandma's dying.

[47:18] Jess Cook: Okay, let's talk about the whole thing as a whole.

[47:21] Andrew: I feel like I've already done this a little bit, so let's not like with it ourselves too much.

[47:26] Jess Cook: Let's talk about falsettos as a whole.

[47:30] Andrew: Um, I think falsettos as a whole works better than either individual part on its own.

[47:37] Jess Cook: And I'm sure you're gonna disagree with me just to be contrarian.

[47:40] Andrew: I'm not going to disagree with you to be contrarian.

[47:43] Jess Cook: I'm going to disagree with you for reasons that I've listed before, where I think the first half works better without the second half.

[47:51] Andrew: Um, because the first the second half ruins the first half.

[47:56] Jess Cook: I don't think it ruins it, but I feel like the second half doesn't work on its own in the same way that the first half does.

[48:02] Andrew: And I feel like you can't have the second half without the first half.

[48:05] Jess Cook: Like the second half, like all the character development we have in the first half is very, very important for act two.

[48:15] Andrew: Okay, what I feel like is that the second half would work better with a different first half entirely.

[48:23] Jess Cook: Okay.

[48:24] Andrew: And then the first half works well by itself.

[48:26] Jess Cook: So you think that William Finn's should have written like the second half about AIDS and all these characters about completely different characters with a little bit of a different first half.

[48:35] Andrew: I think that the AIDS part in all that needs foreshadowing.

[48:40] Jess Cook: The characters that you add in need to have characters.

[48:43] Andrew: But in life, um, it does life doesn't have foreshadowing, sir.

[48:48] Andrew: Sometimes shit just happens for no damn good reason, as Mendel says.

[48:52] Jess Cook: Okay, well, stories have foreshadowing because foreshadowing is a good storytelling element.

[48:59] Andrew: I feel like you don't need that.

[49:01] Jess Cook: Life isn't a good story.

[49:03] Andrew: Life is a boring, terrible story that's a good thing.

[49:06] Jess Cook: Yes, but you can have mini stories within life, and you know what? You don't have the foreshadowing within it.

[49:11] Andrew: Like, the story that I have this week is gonna be it's not like it was foreshadowed four weeks ago when I had the different story four weeks ago.

[49:20] Jess Cook: Well, if I wanted to watch life, I would wake up and go outside.

[49:24] Andrew: But you don't see me doing that, do you?

[49:26] Jess Cook: Never. So I wanna have a story that is cohesive in, you know, if you put a gun on the table in the first act, you see it in the second.

[49:40] Andrew: You know that shit.

[49:43] Jess Cook: Well, some uh I can't wait until you watch Into the Woods.

[49:46] Andrew: I'm not even gonna lie.

[49:48] Jess Cook: Like, I'm real, I'm super excited for what your thoughts are gonna be about that.

[49:54] Andrew: Oh, it's gonna be bad, isn't it?

[49:55] Jess Cook: You it's gonna be like this but times fucking six.

[49:59] Andrew: No, because it's like this, but with the stuff that you want.

[50:03] Jess Cook: Oh, okay.

[50:04] Andrew: So maybe it won't be.

[50:05] Jess Cook: So that's why I'm super interested. Like, I know the fans are like, I I know what he's gonna think, and I'm like, no one's ever gonna fucking know what Andrew's gonna think.

[50:13] Andrew: I think a lot of people are probably gonna think I'm gonna like this one really like a lot.

[50:17] Jess Cook: And uh I'm not sure that's true.

[50:22] Andrew: You have to ruin everything, Andrew.

[50:24] Jess Cook: That's I mean, that's fine.

[50:27] Andrew: Uh I'm just trying to be honest here.

[50:29] Jess Cook: It makes the show more interesting if I'm not just like if we're fighting with one another.

[50:35] Andrew: The whole thing was great. I loved it.

[50:40] Jess Cook: I want that podcast.

[50:44] Andrew: Or every week it's literally the same audio recording, except you change it.

[50:48] Jess Cook: The whole thing was great. I loved it.

[50:51] Andrew: This week I'm reviewing Little Shop of Horrors.

[50:54] Jess Cook: The whole thing was great. I loved it.

[50:57] Andrew: Please, please donate on my Patreon.

[51:01] Jess Cook: The whole thing was great. I loved it.

[51:06] Andrew: I had not seen you.

[51:10] Jess Cook: Who would I feel?

[51:16] Andrew: Once I was told that good men get better with We're just gonna skip that stage.

[51:30] Jess Cook: There are no answers, but what would I do if you had not been my friend?

[51:40] Andrew: There are no answers, but what would I all I know is Falsettos is a great piece that I enjoy greatly.

[51:48] Jess Cook: It gives me emotions.

[51:50] Andrew: I do uh like you prefer the first half to the second half.

[51:54] Jess Cook: But I do ex like there are parts of the second half that I like better than the first half, but it does not equal a better whole, if that makes sense.

[52:05] Andrew: I like pieces of it.

[52:08] Jess Cook: I think the first half is good.

[52:11] Andrew: Uh the second half, I just feel like there's just not very much drama in the second half, to be totally honest.

[52:19] Jess Cook: You say that, but a character dies.

[52:22] Andrew: I know, and that's what's uh that's weird about it.

[52:25] Jess Cook: Is it a character dies in the second half, but I still feel like there's just not much happening.

[52:31] Andrew: You have even more characters, but there's only one character that anything actually really happens to, and the rest of them are just like I'd argue three.

[52:39] Jess Cook: There are three characters that really get affected by it.

[52:42] Andrew: Yeah, and then you have two more characters that are basically just there.

[52:48] Jess Cook: Um, and then that's about it.

[52:54] Andrew: Like in the first half, there's literally nobody that that doesn't have an arc of some kind.

[53:00] Jess Cook: Everyone in the first half has an arc.

[53:03] Andrew: In the second one, it's just like really like two people have an arc, two people nothing, like three people nothing happens to, one person isn't even a character anymore, and one person dies.

[53:28] Jess Cook: I mean, that's fine.

[53:30] Andrew: You can turn on me.

[53:31] Jess Cook: I I'm right.

[53:35] Andrew: He isn't right.

[53:38] Jess Cook: Okay.

[53:38] Andrew: Well, what's your interpretation then?

[53:40] Jess Cook: How many characters do you think have an actual arc in the second half?

[53:44] Andrew: Alright, alright.

[53:45] Jess Cook: Maybe an arc doesn't implicitly mean quality.

[53:49] Andrew: But it does mean character development.

[53:52] Jess Cook: I think there's character development, like Wizer grows to be back with Marvin, Jason grows to be an adult and accept that, like, and instead of going down the footsteps of Marvin, like wanting what he wants the way he wants it at the way he needs it, is learning like fuck, life doesn't work at my schedule the way I thought it would.

[54:14] Andrew: And well, Jess, in the context of the full musical, though, him growing to like Marvin again is him shrinking because he's losing the thing that he learned in the first part.

[54:27] Jess Cook: Well, maybe Marvin grew as a character and was deserving of a second chance.

[54:44] Andrew: But did he?

[54:45] Jess Cook: Because as we see in the racquetball thing, he's just upset that he can't beat him.

[54:50] Andrew: Yes, but he's not an asshole about it.

[54:51] Jess Cook: He's not mean.

[54:53] Andrew: He's not aggressive in the way that he was.

[54:55] Jess Cook: He's not fighting.

[54:58] Andrew: I mean, he does.

[54:59] Jess Cook: Just not as much.

[55:01] Andrew: No, I think it's just like kind of like he's grown to be a better sport about things.

[55:07] Jess Cook: Okay.

[55:08] Andrew: Like I think that's a sign of Marvin's growth.

[55:11] Jess Cook: I mean, that's not for real to the side.

[55:15] Andrew: I mean he he was really bad.

[55:19] Jess Cook: Yeah, he was really bad.

[55:21] Andrew: I think if if this happened in real life to one of your friends, you'd be like, you need to dump that guy again.

[55:25] Jess Cook: What are you doing?

[55:29] Andrew: Don't go back with your abusers, guys.

[55:32] Jess Cook: Definitely get back with your abusers.

[55:34] Andrew: I mean they they definitely deserve a second chance, I would say.

[55:36] Jess Cook: I mean it's been two years.

[55:41] Andrew: You hear that, Rihanna?

[55:43] Jess Cook: It's been two years, guys.

[55:45] Andrew: I'm sure he learned his lesson.

[55:47] Jess Cook: He probably sang a song.

[55:53] Andrew: Jess, what are your overall thoughts on Falsettos?

[55:58] Jess Cook: There's a lot of parts I liked.

[56:01] Andrew: The Honestly, I liked most of the music a lot.

[56:05] Jess Cook: Uh just the structure of it was I thought was just really poor.

[56:10] Andrew: Uh and I feel like it could work better with a lot of rewrites.

[56:16] Jess Cook: Like keep the same songs, but then rewrite a different like story around the songs.

[56:22] Andrew: That's the one thing is it's like it's hard to rewrite something like this where there's music written for it, you know.

[56:28] Jess Cook: What would be your version of Falsettos if you were rewriting it?

[56:35] Andrew: I feel like I would just drop the second half and make uh add more songs to the first half and make it longer and have it end where the first X ends.

[56:47] Jess Cook: Alright.

[56:49] Andrew: Alright.

[56:50] Jess Cook: What is your cheese rating for Falsettos, Andrew?

[56:54] Andrew: It's like a block of cheese that someone hasn't cut up yet.

[56:58] Jess Cook: Half of it is like pristine, the other half is kind of falling apart.

[57:03] Andrew: No, it it's it's just like a a full brick of cheese that you can't really eat it because it's not cut up.

[57:09] Jess Cook: Like someone has to prepare it.

[57:11] Andrew: Like no one's prepared the cheese.

[57:13] Jess Cook: Hmm.

[57:15] Andrew: You know what you get what I'm saying?

[57:17] Jess Cook: Yeah, I understand.

[57:18] Andrew: I, on the other hand, I know no one comes here for my opinions.

[57:21] Jess Cook: I love Falsettos.

[57:22] Andrew: It is a very important part of musical theater history as well as representation of homosexuality in the theater world.

[57:29] Jess Cook: Um I it has specific things that I really like, and I feel it does a lot of things that Rent tries to do a lot better in a more effective way.

[57:38] Andrew: Is it perfect?

[57:39] Jess Cook: Probably not.

[57:41] Andrew: Now, I'm not saying any of the things that you just said are not true.

[57:45] Jess Cook: I'm just saying that I didn't like love it.

[57:49] Andrew: I think the songs by William Finn's are 100% the strongest part of it altogether.

[57:56] Jess Cook: Yes.

[57:57] Andrew: And I feel like it is emotionally compelling and builds on the characters enough that even though the second half does is a bit more detrimented, I feel like you're still willing to carry it on and you still have the emotions uh by the end of it.

[58:12] Jess Cook: And you're all you're all fair game to agree with Jess on this one and post all the negative shit about me in the comments.

[58:20] Andrew: Just remember the premise of this.

[58:21] Jess Cook: I love musical theater because it is the genre that I was raised on and adore.

[58:26] Andrew: Andrew is new to this world, and this is just like it's a fun experiment of him reacting to things that we think are normal and commonplace.

[58:35] Jess Cook: So if you're gonna get angry, remember the premise of this show and take a breath.

[58:40] Andrew: Well, nevertheless, thank you guys for watching.

[58:43] Jess Cook: I'm really appreciative that you've got through us this far to our ninth episode.

[58:48] Andrew: Wow.

[58:49] Jess Cook: Next week is lucky number 10.

[58:51] Andrew: Man.

[58:51] Jess Cook: Yeah, we're uh we're on our way.

[58:54] Andrew: Yeah.

[58:55] Jess Cook: Um please, if you could, um, write us a review on iTunes.

[59:00] Andrew: Tell other people to write reviews.

[59:02] Jess Cook: We've got a couple great reviews.

[59:03] Andrew: In fact, we're starting up a contest for iTunes.

[59:07] Jess Cook: For all the reviews that we get on iTunes, um at every five episodes, we're gonna do a drawing of the reviews.

[59:15] Andrew: We're gonna give whoever wins the drawing a $20 Amazon gift card.

[59:18] Jess Cook: So write a review, you could be a winner.

[59:21] Andrew: Be honest in your review, don't just say it was great, but be honest, and even the negative reviews can win.

[59:28] Jess Cook: Yeah.

[59:29] Andrew: And I mean, consider this.

[59:31] Jess Cook: There's barely any reviews for this, so you're pretty much guaranteed to win.

[59:35] Andrew: Yeah, I mean.

[59:37] Jess Cook: If you go up there and review, you're more than likely gonna win.

[59:41] Andrew: So by episode 15, we're gonna pull a drawing and see who wins.

[59:47] Jess Cook: So be sure to keep listening by episode 15 so that you know if you're a winner.

[59:51] Andrew: And if we read your review, be sure to send us your email at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com.

[59:58] Jess Cook: And uh try not to be too negative to me.

[1:00:00] Andrew: Go easy on me, boys.

[1:00:02] Jess Cook: Yeah, especially about this.

[1:00:03] Andrew: Um, please, we're also on Spotify Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese.

[1:00:08] Jess Cook: Follow us on Twitter.

[1:00:10] Andrew: Tell us what you thought of this episode.

[1:00:11] Jess Cook: We're at cheesy musicals, follow us on Instagram at musicaltheatrelives, our YouTube page, Musical Theater Lives.

[1:00:18] Andrew: And thank you guys for watching.

[1:00:20] Jess Cook: We're really appreciative that we're just k keep on growing and things are getting better with every episode, and we're getting more and more response and interest.

[1:00:29] Andrew: We got some amazing things coming up, like episode 11.

[1:00:33] Jess Cook: I know you guys are gonna get a real kick out of.

[1:00:38] Andrew: Uh, I'm excited.

[1:00:40] Jess Cook: We're all excited.

[1:00:41] Andrew: We're all excited, and we'll see you next week.

[1:00:44] Jess Cook: I'm Jess.

[1:00:45] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.

[1:00:47] Jess Cook: We'll see you around.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred