Happy Pride! This week Jess & Andrew will be covering the dark comedy adaptation of "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" -- Tarrytown. They are joined by the musical's incredible composer Adam Wachter! Donate to Black Lives Matter here. Listen to Tarrytown... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
About
Happy Pride! This week Jess & Andrew will be covering the dark comedy adaptation of "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" -- Tarrytown. They are joined by the musical's incredible composer Adam Wachter!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess McInally: What are you doing here? You're supposed to be in quarantine. Get out of here!
[0:02] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you've used that joke already, Jess. If you're here. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Andrew, what's Patreon and who are our donors?
[0:12] Jess McInally: Yeah, well, if you don't know what Patreon is, is this is this your first episode? But uh it's where you can go if you'd like to donate to us. We have a Glee podcast that was currently running. We have commentaries on things like Annie and all Annie related properties. Um we had a full Annie Mump. And our current patrons, and and this may take a little bit, but here we go. Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Learer, Lily Accles, John Donna, Terran the Duck, The Fantastic Just Lightning, Ewan Cassidy, Haley McDonald, Teskier, Fire of September, Mina Maniri, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Haley Murray, Alice in Wonderland, B Way Flix, Lithanial Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Lunar Rocks 222, Eric L. Drew, uh White, Carrie Ahern, Christine Malmadell, Mezzanine Theater Diary, Mary Lou Choquette, Anne Nunnalee, Cole Birchfield, Sam Caulfield, John Vanels, Holy Stacality, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Grace, Andrew Van Barsen, Emily Stack, Kyle Summers, Mr. B, Janae C, Kyle, Christina Francis, Jessica A, Skyler, Liz Lim, Cory, Wilmarth, and Alison Stuller.
They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks such as patron only commentaries, our episodes a day earlier, even earlier, and so much more. Come join us over at Patreon. Alright, we shilled enough. Let's get on to the show.
[1:43] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.
[1:45] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[1:46] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I tried to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[1:51] Andrew DeWolf: He tried to he tried to jump in.
[1:53] Jess McInally: I tried to jump in and introduce myself.
[1:55] Adam Wachter: And then you just kept talking. I was gonna say, I'm Adam Wachter.
[2:00] Jess McInally: Well, I was gonna give you a wonderful introduction. I was gonna give you this beautiful introduction. We have with us once again, he's basically becoming a third host of the show. It's him or Brent. When J dies or goes to prison, it's gonna be one of them.
[2:18] Adam Wachter: Ooh.
[2:20] Jess McInally: So Adam, you're gonna be between the biggest.
[2:25] Adam Wachter: Yes, we have once again the incredible composer and just everything in the world. You'll probably know him from Disney Plus on Encore, Adam Wachter.
[2:34] Adam Wachter: Yay, copy for myself.
[2:37] Jess McInally: Yeah, yeah. Welcome back, Adam.
[2:39] Adam Wachter: Thank you.
[2:40] Jess McInally: So what's been new in your life since November? Anything big?
[2:45] Adam Wachter: Well, Encore came out. Uh COVID 19 happened. Uh Black Lives Matter really took off. And uh that's about it. And Terrytown came out, the CD.
[2:58] Jess McInally: Yeah, and it's that one!
[3:01] ♪ Musical number: "Morning in Terrytown" — performed by Adam Wachter ♪
[4:00] Jess McInally: Um, I've I've been a fan of Terrytown since before I've even met you, which is now kind of a surreal thing that you and I are kind of buddies, and I've just always loved this album separately from the city. It's a great album.
[4:16] Adam Wachter: Yeah, but it's not like, you know, an ubiquitous sort of musical for people to know of.
[4:21] Jess McInally: Well, it's about to be a little bit more.
[4:22] Adam Wachter: It's no about to be.
[4:24] Jess McInally: This is what skyrockets did. Our show is what brings it up into the the upper echelon.
[4:30] Adam Wachter: That would be great.
[4:32] Jess McInally: That's the idea.
[4:33] Adam Wachter: That would be wonderful.
[4:34] Jess McInally: But something else is happening pretty soon, right?
[4:36] Adam Wachter: What?
[4:36] Jess McInally: Is there something else happening?
[4:38] Adam Wachter: Didn't you say there was a live stream of it coming out in like a couple weeks?
[4:42] Adam Wachter: Oh, no, it's not a secret.
[4:47] Jess McInally: Well, I don't know when this is when is this coming out this episode?
[4:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um, a week from Friday.
[4:51] Adam Wachter: Oh, that's perfect. I think it might be out then. It's not a live stream. It's um the the world premiere production that happened in San Diego two years ago. They sh they uh filmed it for archival purposes, the theater company, Backyard Renaissance Theater Company in San Diego, and they are streaming it online for I think like three days only, and you have to buy tickets to see it. Um, but do please do so if it interests you. It was a it was a really great little production, and they're a wonderful nonprofit theater company, and this is going to support them because obviously they can't produce any live theater at the moment. Nobody can. Um, so if this musical piques your interest and you'd like to see an actual production of it, you can do that in a couple weeks. Go to uh their website, maybe or their Facebook or something like that.
[5:37] Jess McInally: There will be a link in the podcast description.
[5:40] Adam Wachter: There will be a link in the podcast description.
[5:42] Jess McInally: Yay! Over the next hour or so, we're gonna convince you that you need to buy tickets.
[5:48] Adam Wachter: All right, or convince you not to. One or the other.
[5:51] Jess McInally: One or the other.
[5:52] Adam Wachter: All right, or the other.
[5:53] Jess McInally: Without further ado, this week we are talking about Adam Wachter's Terrytown.
[5:58] ♪ Musical number ♪
[6:07] Jess McInally: Here is three paragraphs that Adam likely wrote himself that I'm about to read. The biggest fan of Terrytown wrote this. The only fan of composer writer. Terrytown, a contemporary story loosely based on Washington Irving's The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, written and composed by some guy named Adam Wachter, is a funny, tuneful, and intense musical drama in 90 minutes for three singing actors. It's world premiere production opened at the Backyard Renaissance Theater Company in San Diego, California on November 30th, 2017. It was nominated for five 2017 San Diego's Critics Circle Craig Noel Awards and won Best New Musical. I did not expect the title of that award to be as long as it was a surprise.
A reading was presented by MCC Theater in New York in 2018, directed by Michael Michael Arden and starring Jeremy Jordan, Andy Mientes, and Krista Rodriguez. The same all-star cast is featured on the studio cast recording, now streaming on Spotify, Apple Music, iTunes, Amazon, or wherever you find music. The album featuring orchestrations by Brian Yusuf was released on May 11th, 2020 to benefit the Actors Fund COVID-19 assistance programs. I did it alright. I give myself a C minus.
[7:38] Adam Wachter: I did. You know what? I did write that. I did write that. I should have been an ad man. What a wonderfully uh No, I don't know. That was terrible. Um, Adam, I am not gonna ask you this question. In fact, I'm gonna avoid asking you this question. Andrew, okay. What is Terrytown and what is it about?
[7:56] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I would love to know. Oh boy, Terrytown. Oh, I'm the perfect person to explain this, obviously. Uh we have no one else who could ever explain what this is about. One more thing. Happy Pride Month, guys. It's Pride Month I've brought my podcast network, and this is integration. Let's go. Alright, Andrew, go ahead.
[8:14] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um, it's well, I mean, not to just uh run through your description again, but it's loosely based on the Legend of Sleeping Hollow.
[8:22] Jess McInally: Read the name of the award again.
[8:25] Andrew DeWolf: Is it is his name Icabod Crane, or is it just Ichabod?
[8:28] Adam Wachter: It's Inkabod Crane.
[8:29] Jess McInally: Yeah, it is Ickabod Crane. I I I didn't catch his last name, I don't think.
[8:33] Adam Wachter: They don't she literally says Ickabod Crane! That's the first one.
[8:37] Jess McInally: Right, right, right. How about instead of Andrew describing it, Jesse? You just perform a one-stand production of it.
[8:44] Adam Wachter: We have three people here, we can do it.
[8:47] Jess McInally: Get your wig. I legit almost asked you if we could do this because I really do what? Perform it. Yes, I was about to d pay for Andrew to come here and do a live thr staged reading of this and have force like a full encore one week. We have to put on Terrytown at the end of it.
[9:04] Adam Wachter: Wow. That is something that nobody would like to see.
[9:08] Jess McInally: I will go one out. I will rope one out to that. Either way, Andrew, sorry interrupted. Continue.
[9:14] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. So Ichabod Crane uh move moves into a new town, Terrytown. Is Terrytown a real location, by the way? I I'm It really is.
[9:24] Adam Wachter: It really is. It's Terrytown slash Sleepy Hollow is like one um municipality or something.
[9:31] Andrew DeWolf: It sounds like a fake name, but I guess if it's real, then it's real.
[9:35] Adam Wachter: It's super old, too. It's been there like, you know, it sounds like a Gilmore. And Washington Irving is um buried there in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery, which is also a real place.
[9:43] Andrew DeWolf: That's very cool. Yeah. I want to go there someday because Sleepy Hollow is a very good thing.
[9:46] Adam Wachter: You should go there. It's you can just get on that Metro North train in New York, and it's like 45 minutes from New York. It's a great little they do like you know all kinds of Halloween stuff, obviously, with oh yeah, headless horsemen, and they've there's like mansions you can tour, and it's a it's a really cool historical little town.
[10:03] Andrew DeWolf: But Ichabod Crane moves into Terrytown, and he is a music teacher. Um, and he makes friends with um a is it she works at the school, right? She's the principal or something, secretary, secretary. She's like the principal's assistant, yes, principal's assistant. Yeah, yeah. And then she invites him over for dinner, and they all get together with uh her husband, her, and Ichabod, and uh her husband and Ichabod become gay lovers. Am I is this is this correct?
[10:37] Adam Wachter: Can I can I say one thing here? Please do. Um I do enjoy that interpretation, actually. You do cite your sources here with The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, but there's one source you didn't cite. Um it was a Pornhub video, which is girls girl's gay best friend meets husband and converts him. Like, you know.
[10:56] Jess McInally: I thought you don't watch porn because you have to be in love with the people to be attracted to them. Jess! You lied to us.
[11:05] Adam Wachter: Wait a minute. I can confirm, because I could I I converted Jess. I told him I was gonna rope one out. I was gonna rope one out to some football one time, and he was instantly on my lap. Instantly in love.
[11:18] Andrew DeWolf: What does that mean? Rope one out? Is that like rub one out?
[11:21] Adam Wachter: I thought that's what he's that's what the husband character says in this uh in the show.
[11:25] Jess McInally: No.
[11:26] Adam Wachter: Rub one out, not rope one out.
[11:28] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was like rope one out like like uh is like a rope, you know?
[11:35] Adam Wachter: I think you need to go see a doctor, first of all.
[11:38] Jess McInally: It you hang yourself with it. A rope. Hope you're listening, Disney. Disney Mr. Disney himself Walt Disney Rub One Out is a phrase. I know that.
[11:49] Adam Wachter: Oh, okay. I just I thought that that's what he said. I was like, did he really just say that? That's a weird way to say that.
[11:56] Jess McInally: Do you remember that fake do you remember that fake boy band Together from MTV?
[12:01] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[12:01] Jess McInally: Or children. The early 2000s or the late 90s.
[12:05] Adam Wachter: Oh yeah, you probably weren't alive yet.
[12:06] Jess McInally: No. There um there was a MTV had like a TV series called Together with the number two, and it was a like a parody of a boy band was like a mockumentary about a boy band, but then they actually like formed this fake boy band, and they had albums and everything. And there was one about rubbing one out or something, I can't remember, but I used to love that TV show. That's just a tangent. That's not about anything that we're talking about. And I'm sure Adam will hope that that's cut out, but it won't be.
[12:32] Adam Wachter: Yeah, exactly.
[12:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. So continuing on in the plot, because I didn't even get to finish. Jeez.
[12:39] Jess McInally: Yeah, we didn't get to the ropey part.
[12:41] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't get to the ropey part. Well, actually, we did get to that. That's where we stopped.
[12:46] Adam Wachter: Um, okay. The I I'm sorry, I'm so bad with character names sometimes. There's Katrina Brahm and Ichabrones.
[12:55] Jess McInally: I know, I can't even remember the woman's name.
[12:58] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't read the book!
[13:00] Jess McInally: You've never read the book?
[13:01] Andrew DeWolf: No, I've watched it.
[13:02] Jess McInally: You didn't even see the Chris No Christopher Walken movie?
[13:05] Andrew DeWolf: No, I've seen the uh like the animated short that Disney made.
[13:09] Jess McInally: Oh yeah.
[13:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um that's about it though.
[13:11] Jess McInally: Okay, but Katrina doesn't like Brahm anymore, sort of.
[13:15] Andrew DeWolf: She doesn't know, and she wants to leave with Ichabod, not like lovers, but like live with him as a friend.
[13:21] Jess McInally: Her new gay best friend.
[13:23] Andrew DeWolf: Her new gay best friend.
[13:24] Jess McInally: And she does that, and Brahm gets super mad and is like, oh, meet me at the graveyard, because we're totally gonna be gay lovers, but also I'm gonna murder you as a ghost.
[13:36] Andrew DeWolf: This musical sounds amazing.
[13:38] Jess McInally: I should have written this one.
[13:40] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, am I wrong here?
[13:42] Jess McInally: Where am I wrong?
[13:43] Andrew DeWolf: Where does he go wrong?
[13:45] Adam Wachter: Well, it's just um, it's just all a little more subtle than that, I think.
[13:52] Jess McInally: I'm not really good with subtlety.
[13:55] Adam Wachter: Okay, alright.
[13:57] Adam Wachter: No, I mean that's that's I guess sort of the gist of it.
[14:00] Adam Wachter: It's a little more naturalistic.
[14:01] Adam Wachter: It sounds a little it sounds a little soap operatic when you say it like that, maybe, but that's not a bad thing for a musical either.
[14:07] Adam Wachter: So I mean it's more Charlie Kaufman than most things.
[14:10] Adam Wachter: Like it feels like real family stuff more than it feels like like Falsettos feels a little too melodramatic and this feels a little too real.
[14:18] Jess McInally: Yeah, it's pretty yeah.
[14:20] Adam Wachter: I mean it's it's like modern day and it's you know, it's it's just uh about people, really.
[14:26] Andrew DeWolf: But then yeah, and a headless horseman.
[14:29] Adam Wachter: But is it really a headless horseman or is it Brahm dressed up as a headless horseman, or is it uh a sort of um nightmare hallucination that Ichabod has because he's tripping on drugs at the time?
[14:41] Adam Wachter: You know, who can say, really?
[14:43] Adam Wachter: Um, and the drugs, because the drugs are given to him by Brahm.
[14:47] Andrew DeWolf: Are they like laced with something in your world of because this is your world of creation?
[14:51] Adam Wachter: Like did Brahm add a little something to it, or do you just get it from someone like Yeah, and well, in an old script in like a first draft, I think it was like bath salts.
[15:01] Andrew DeWolf: Remember bath salts?
[15:02] Adam Wachter: Oh yeah, the stuff that they make you uh into cannibals, right?
[15:06] Adam Wachter: Yeah, they would find people like eating the faces off other people because they were so messed up.
[15:10] Adam Wachter: That was like an old draft.
[15:12] Adam Wachter: I don't honestly know exactly what they are.
[15:14] Adam Wachter: I assume I assume, yeah, it's some kind of Molly or or um some kind of ecstasy or something that's then laced with yeah, some kind of acid-based hallucinogenic or or mushroom or something.
[15:28] Adam Wachter: He's he's tripping at the end of the day.
[15:30] Adam Wachter: And Brahm doesn't necessarily know what they are either, because I think he confiscates them.
[15:33] Adam Wachter: I can't remember because it's been a while since I've read the script that I wrote.
[15:37] Adam Wachter: But he confiscates them from like a student who's also really crazy.
[15:41] Jess McInally: Yeah, yeah.
[15:42] Adam Wachter: So there's drugs.
[15:43] Adam Wachter: But we're getting ahead of ourselves, aren't we?
[15:45] Jess McInally: No, this is kind of.
[15:46] Adam Wachter: No, oh, we're starting at the end.
[15:48] Adam Wachter: I know that Jess is gonna ask this, so I'm gonna ask it first.
[15:52] Adam Wachter: What uh what is the authorial intent of the ending?
[15:55] Adam Wachter: W which one of those three is it?
[15:57] Adam Wachter: Oh, I couldn't tell you that.
[15:58] Adam Wachter: That would be that would that would ruin it for you if you ever saw it on stage.
[16:02] Jess McInally: That is fair.
[16:03] Jess McInally: I am my own interpretation, and I don't care what you think.
[16:07] Jess McInally: So you can tell me what you think if you want.
[16:13] Andrew DeWolf: What is your interpretation?
[16:15] Andrew DeWolf: Because I have mine too, so I'm very curious if we differ.
[16:17] Adam Wachter: Well, let me just say though, but nobody knows, not even Ichabod, the person, the character who's experiencing it, which is the point.
[16:25] Andrew DeWolf: He doesn't know if it's a he is tricked into thinking it's a ghost by his drug-induced hallucination sort of state that he's in.
[16:34] Andrew DeWolf: And so he doesn't he he thinks it's a real ghost.
[16:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and that's where I'll leave it.
[16:39] Adam Wachter: I mean, it could be a real ghost too.
[16:41] Adam Wachter: Well, yes, it could be any any of three real possibilities.
[16:45] Jess McInally: I mean, what do you guys think?
[16:47] Jess McInally: What do you think?
[16:48] Andrew DeWolf: Built in this story.
[16:49] Andrew DeWolf: I I'm doubting it's a real ghost.
[16:51] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[16:52] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, there's nothing in it that says ghosts aren't real.
[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: It's just, you know, I I would love you to use that excuse in any other like family drama film.
[17:00] Andrew DeWolf: Air Bud, nothing in that story says that ghosts aren't real.
[17:00] Jess McInally: Okay, if anything Air Bud implies that ghosts are real.
[17:08] Andrew DeWolf: There's one possessing the dog.
[17:13] Jess McInally: I've never seen it.
[17:14] Andrew DeWolf: That's that's a good thing, honestly.
[17:16] Jess McInally: Okay.
[17:17] Andrew DeWolf: All of them are on Disney Plus right next to your face, so don't worry.
[17:20] Andrew DeWolf: I think I think it was Brahm, and he just kills him.
[17:24] Jess McInally: I think that that's that's my interpretation.
[17:26] Andrew DeWolf: See, I don't take Brahm as a murderer.
[17:28] Andrew DeWolf: I take him as like an asshole sometimes.
[17:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but I think everyone is a murderer if you're pushed far enough.
[17:35] Jess McInally: I don't think he was pushed far enough.
[17:37] Jess McInally: Because I think that he honestly just wanted to get Ichabod real fucked up and then just kind of abandon him and break his heart, so to say, hurt his feelings.
[17:45] Jess McInally: I don't think he really wanted to murder him, and then Ichabod just got so in his head that he fell into the water and maybe died.
[17:53] Andrew DeWolf: Who knows?
[17:54] Jess McInally: Well, that's another good point.
[17:55] Jess McInally: We don't know, I think a lot of people assume that he dies, but that's also not spelled out.
[17:59] Andrew DeWolf: That's also a question mark after he gets pushed or flies or jumps or whatever off that bridge.
[18:05] Andrew DeWolf: Then what happens?
[18:07] Andrew DeWolf: Tarrytown 2, Ichabod's revenge.
[18:12] Jess McInally: I'm gonna get back at my old boss, the bulimic bitch.
[18:16] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a ghost now.
[18:17] Jess McInally: I'm a ghost.
[18:18] Andrew DeWolf: Now I'm a headless horse boy.
[18:20] Jess McInally: I'm gonna fuck up those baddies and Dairy Queen.
[18:23] Andrew DeWolf: Let's go.
[18:25] Jess McInally: Wow, quoting the lyrics.
[18:27] Andrew DeWolf: I know every word of the show am.
[18:29] Jess McInally: It's really good.
[18:30] Adam Wachter: See, thank you.
[18:31] Adam Wachter: I will tell you, I've been really, it's been, you know, the the this the album that came out in May, which is I guess how now most people know the show, was never really meant to be an album.
[18:42] Adam Wachter: It was really just a demo, like a high quality demo that I was gonna try to use to sell the show to theaters to get a production happening.
[18:49] Adam Wachter: And then it was only because all this, you know, terrible situation with the pandemic, and I was looking for a way to raise money, and I thought, oh, what can I put out there?
[18:59] Adam Wachter: I don't have anything to value.
[19:03] Adam Wachter: But I thought oh, I have this demo, and I emailed Andy and Krista and Jeremy, and they were so generous in saying, yeah, absolutely, put that out there and and all the proceeds are going to charity.
[19:12] Adam Wachter: So that's what it's gonna be.
[19:14] Adam Wachter: But now that it's out, people have obviously discovered it, and there's some amazing like fans on Tumblr and Instagram and all these places that I don't understand because I'm too old.
[19:24] Adam Wachter: But they do like fan art, and there's somebody who writes all this fan fiction stuff about the characters that's fascinating for me to read.
[19:33] Jess McInally: Ooh, fanfiction.
[19:34] Jess McInally: Like what's the best story you gotta tell us?
[19:37] Adam Wachter: Oh my god, there's a bunch.
[19:38] Adam Wachter: There it's all like it's weird.
[19:41] Adam Wachter: Like back in my day, fan fiction meant like really sexual stuff, and this is not sexual, it's like just fiction, but like set in the world of the show.
[19:50] Adam Wachter: So it's just like like Brahm helping Ichabod move and things.
[19:54] Adam Wachter: It's like very mundane sort of stuff, but it's really well written, and then there's like arguments, you know, in the chat rooms about what's canon and all these things.
[20:03] Adam Wachter: I just I'm really tickled and amazed by the whole thing.
[20:06] Jess McInally: I love it.
[20:07] Jess McInally: You built a world, Adam.
[20:08] Adam Wachter: Think about that.
[20:09] Adam Wachter: You built a world that people I was saying, it just in the real world, but I guess they are fictional characters, so good for them.
[20:15] Jess McInally: I love it.
[20:16] Jess McInally: Now, I've got a question.
[20:18] Jess McInally: Were you actively trying to make every character some level of unlikable and real?
[20:25] Adam Wachter: Wow, what a question, Jess.
[20:27] Adam Wachter: I hate every character in this show.
[20:29] Jess McInally: Now, was that on purpose?
[20:31] Adam Wachter: Honestly, well, sort of.
[20:33] Adam Wachter: I mean, it was the kind of well, I wanted to make them real and real people have faults, and also the real the real struggle for me writing it was that there were only three characters.
[20:43] Adam Wachter: So, how do you make 90 minutes of conflict happen if just three likable people are like sitting around being nice to each other?
[20:50] Jess McInally: That's not gonna work out.
[20:51] Jess McInally: Yeah, it's a lame story.
[20:54] Adam Wachter: I like them all.
[20:55] Adam Wachter: I don't think that I think they all do some not great things necessarily, but it all comes from a place of wanting to be loved and be accepted, and I think that's why most people do bad things, because they maybe don't like themselves that much, and so they, I don't know, have to act out on it.
[21:13] Jess McInally: Now, Adam, here's another thing I want to talk about.
[21:15] Jess McInally: Mostly I want to get your permission to talk about it beforehand, because you were gracious enough to lend me a script to read through as well as a read-through.
[21:24] Adam Wachter: Um that gave me a lot of context and recontextualized a lot of things that weren't in the album.
[21:30] Adam Wachter: Sure.
[21:30] Jess McInally: Do you want me to talk about some of those, or do you want to leave those still mysterious for a bit?
[21:35] Adam Wachter: Uh let's leave some of it mysterious.
[21:38] Adam Wachter: We can talk about anything like, let's say in the first two-thirds of the show.
[21:42] Jess McInally: Oh, okay.
[21:43] Jess McInally: But there let me just say there's a specific reveal, because I I've loved this album for a while, a long time.
[21:49] Jess McInally: Um, it was on your SoundCloud, which is where I listened to it for a good chunk of my experience with it.
[21:56] Jess McInally: Um, because I I knew you who you were for a while.
[22:01] Jess McInally: Like I was like outwardly like stalker.
[22:04] Jess McInally: I am.
[22:04] Jess McInally: Let's just frame it like that.
[22:06] Jess McInally: I am a stalker of people who do art I enjoy.
[22:10] Adam Wachter: That's a that's that's a fair thing.
[22:12] Adam Wachter: I think we all have to we all are to some extent.
[22:14] Jess McInally: I try to keep an arm's distance where I'm not like just Anya every day, but I'm like, I like this, and I'm gonna just listen.
[22:20] Jess McInally: Um but nevertheless, so uh my version of the story was very different and contextualized only by the album.
[22:26] Adam Wachter: Really?
[22:27] Jess McInally: Well, yeah, because of course the album is I think 17 songs, but the show itself has some more.
[22:33] Jess McInally: I mean, nothing like reprises and things, and there's obviously scenes and there's things that you don't hear on an album.
[22:40] Adam Wachter: The one that had me floored that recontextualized a bunch of songs in the second half and made my heart just fall out of my chest hearing about it, is things with Katrina and uh things you learn in a song that you find out more about later that I'm like, oh no.
[22:56] Adam Wachter: Oh yeah.
[22:57] Adam Wachter: Yeah, there's stuff in there.
[22:59] Adam Wachter: So I would tell you if you are just a fan of the album and don't um you can you can just stay that way in blissful ignorance, or you can watch the uh the video taped version the Backyard Renaissance is doing or petition your local theater once they open to do a production of Tarrytown so that they can be sent to Perusal script.
[23:17] Jess McInally: Spicier and spicier.
[23:20] Adam Wachter: I mean I mean, yes, and honestly, if you know the album, you don't you don't know the whole show.
[23:25] Adam Wachter: Like when you're oh gosh, now I gotta pull up the song because I don't want to get it wrong.
[23:30] Adam Wachter: When you're near, I had it right in my head.
[23:32] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[23:32] Adam Wachter: Um, that song just comes off as perfectly sincere on both ends when you're listening to the album.
[23:38] Adam Wachter: But when you watch the show, it is very much not that way.
[23:41] Jess McInally: And my question is, and this really isn't much of a spoiler, does Brahm return any of those feelings to Ichabod at all, do you think?
[23:50] Adam Wachter: I think that's possible, but I don't think that Brahm would ever admit that to himself.
[23:57] Adam Wachter: So I don't I don't think at any point Brahm finds himself falling for Ichabod, no.
[24:04] Jess McInally: No.
[24:05] Adam Wachter: He's already in love with football.
[24:07] Jess McInally: Exactly.
[24:08] Adam Wachter: He's got his own left hand.
[24:11] Jess McInally: Is the kiss reciprocal from Brahm, um, in the way you envision it?
[24:17] Adam Wachter: I think it's uh reciprocal only in the sense that he is doing it as a means to an end, which is to convince Ichabod to go to the cemetery.
[24:27] Jess McInally: Gotcha.
[24:28] Adam Wachter: Um, um, I don't think it's coming from a place of passion or or feelings like that, no.
[24:34] Jess McInally: Okay.
[24:35] Jess McInally: Just things that, like, once again, I thought he would just naturally felt it and then just couldn't go to the cemetery.
[24:44] Adam Wachter: Interesting, yeah.
[24:45] Adam Wachter: No, I think Brahm's certainly heterosexual at the end of the day.
[24:50] Jess McInally: Rum wanted to commit murder by ghost.
[24:54] Adam Wachter: Kind of, and the kiss was the way to make that happen.
[24:57] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, murder by ghost is the most effective way to do it.
[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: Because no one can no one would catch you.
[25:02] Adam Wachter: No one can catch you.
[25:03] Adam Wachter: The ghost didn't.
[25:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, the ghost did it, exactly.
[25:06] Andrew DeWolf: Ghosts don't leave fingerprints, I've been told.
[25:08] Jess McInally: It's true.
[25:09] Jess McInally: Uh, alright.
[25:10] Jess McInally: I think there's a ghost in my house.
[25:13] Andrew DeWolf: Are you there, ghost?
[25:15] Jess McInally: We are speaking to you through the cookies.
[25:16] Andrew DeWolf: Who's got a spirit box?
[25:19] Adam Wachter: Well, when I first came to look at this house, there was um a shrine set up in the corner to the woman who had died in it.
[25:25] Jess McInally: Oh god.
[25:26] Adam Wachter: So what was her name?
[25:28] Adam Wachter: I can't remember.
[25:28] Adam Wachter: It was Russian.
[25:29] Adam Wachter: She was a Russian woman.
[25:31] Adam Wachter: She was quite old, and um she passed away, I think in the house with about 12 cats, and uh she's no longer with us, but I so I never got to actually meet her.
[25:41] Adam Wachter: But maybe one of these days she'll come back and push me over a bridge.
[25:45] Jess McInally: Hopefully not.
[25:46] Adam Wachter: And you know what?
[25:46] Adam Wachter: You know what'll make it all better if she does come back?
[25:49] Jess McInally: Just take her in your car and go pick some apples.
[25:54] Adam Wachter: Apple picking is a great idea for fall.
[25:56] Jess McInally: I would rope one out for some apples.
[25:58] Adam Wachter: Oh god!
[26:02] Jess McInally: On that note, let's go into a mid-show announcement.
[26:05] Adam Wachter: What's the announcement?
[26:07] Jess McInally: More patrons.
[26:08] Andrew DeWolf: Oh Jesus.
[26:10] Andrew DeWolf: They never end!
[26:11] Andrew DeWolf: They never end, Adam.
[26:17] Jess McInally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we gotta shill at you.
[26:21] Jess McInally: Today's show is brought to you by your extremely kind donors over at Patreon.
[26:24] Jess McInally: Let's read through the list.
[26:25] Jess McInally: Um, our current patrons are Terry Needleman, Max Lunig, Benjamin Lehrer, Lily Ackles, John Donna, Terry and the Duck with Fantastic Just Lightning, Ewan Casty, Haley McDonald, Taskier, Fire September, Mina Maneiri, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Haley Murray, Alison Wonderland, B Wave Flakes, Lathaniel, Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Lunarocks 222, Yuri Gale, Drew A.
[27:07] Jess McInally: They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, Musicals with Cheese. If you'd like to join them in supporting us, you get tons of perks such as patron-only commentaries, our episodes a day earlier, even earlier. Let's just come on over to Patreon. We got a lot of shit. Alright, let's get back to the show.
[27:22] ♪ Musical number: "Tarrytown" — performed by Adam Wachter ♪
[28:27] Jess McInally: Let's talk about the opening number, which I 100% know every word to and I love. Isn't that just a weird thing to say to someone who wrote it? So, what was your mindset behind this? What were some of your inspirations behind the opening number of Tarrytown entitled "Tarrytown"?
[28:43] Adam Wachter: It is, yeah. Um, well, I knew it was one of the earlier songs that I wrote. I mean, I've been writing this thing for like 10 years, you know. This has been it's not like I just sat down and wrote Tarrytown one day. It was it's been a long, long road. But this was one of the earliest ones. I think the first one I wrote was "When You're Near," and then I wrote, um, yeah. So that so I wrote it early on, and um it I needed a mu uh song to set up the world of the show and our uh main character. And I thought, well, he's probably walking through the town, and he can just comment out loud on the things he sees, and that'll be a nice description of the town in case the theater can't afford a set.
[29:27] Jess McInally: Wow. Wow. I wonder if Sondheim gets that in depth. If you had just described what he what he thought you were thinking while writing this, it definitely would have not been that.
[29:38] Adam Wachter: Oh, 100%. Um and now I'm gonna do that. Um, I honestly, I feel like this is like a classic, like opening number, so to say, like both setting up character, not exactly character intention, but character like within this world and as a representation. Outsider in here, and I love the content dictates form, Sondheim-esque world that you put this in, where you are listing very specific things. Cause at its heart, it kind of is just a list song. Or it's like the Dairy Queen, like that feels like very small town, very unlike New York City. Like I think all those things are.
[30:22] Andrew DeWolf: And this is this is the place where the story takes, and you get a little bit of terror of Ichabod backstory, and then you get a little bit of character motivation. It's sort of like an opening number crossed with an I Want song, which is like just sort of sets him on his way.
[30:36] Jess McInally: Did you go to Tarrytown for research?
[30:38] Adam Wachter: I did go to Tarrytown for research.
[30:40] Jess McInally: How was that?
[30:41] Adam Wachter: It was super fun. I just went once. It was I was living in New York at the time, obviously. Um day I just yeah, I I got on the train at Grand Central and uh went up to Tarrytown for the day. Just walked, just walked everywhere, took a lot of notes, took a lot of pictures, stopped in places. Um the tea shop that I referenced in "Dinner for Three" is as I had lunch there, you know, and uh yeah, just try to get some ideas. At the time, I think I'd already done one draft or or or almost a draft of the show. And so I just went and like got some more specific stuff, sort of just you know, think okay, what is like what a what a gift to a writer to really visit the world of the show that you're writing. You know, Sondheim couldn't really go back to Victorian England and study for Sweeney Todd, but I could sure go to present-day Tarrytown, and I did. And I recommend it. It's a very charming little town.
[31:36] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm. Alright. I think that's that's great. Andrew, what'd you think of this song? Did you see any faults?
[31:39] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Jesus. Oh, it was awful. Absolutely terrible. Some sort of hack must have written this. It's just no, I I don't really have anything more to add. I mean, what else do you add to that? You have the input of the actual writer here.
[31:59] Adam Wachter: I mean, that's I think the bridge, isn't the bridge like uh doesn't it quote a song later? Isn't it quote part of "When You're Near"?
[32:04] Jess McInally: I think it does.
[32:06] Adam Wachter: Yeah, where it's like that and needle or something.
[32:11] Jess McInally: Yeah, oh yeah, that's the same. That's the same tune and and chord structure as "When You're Near," which is Ichabod's big song, but a big 11 o'clock romantic number coming later in the show. So it's just setting that up at the same time.
[32:22] Jess McInally: Funny you should mention that, because I have this literally written down on a notepad right here. Um, which came first, um "When You're Near" or uh "Tarrytown," and did you We already answered that? "When You're Near" came first.
[32:37] Adam Wachter: Did that like were you thinking of using that for like a song cycle originally, or was it always for this specific piece?
[32:43] Adam Wachter: It was always for this piece, um, but it moved around a lot within the piece, and now it exists sort of in two chunks. He sings part of it earlier on in the show. On the record the cast recording, it's condensed back into one full song, but in the show itself, he sings part of it first at the school when he first sort of decides he's gonna try to pursue something with Brahm and then sings the rest of it later on Halloween.
[33:08] Jess McInally: And I was a little thrown off guard when I got to that in the script, in all honesty. Like, wait, that the there's more to this song, I know it.
[33:16] Adam Wachter: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Alright. No, I think we're that's all we have to say about "Tarrytown," because that's all right.
[33:20] Jess McInally: Well, it was nice talking to you both.
[33:24] Adam Wachter: That that first opening number. We got oh we have a lot more songs to go.
[33:27] Jess McInally: Oh, yeah, okay, great.
[33:30] ♪ Musical number: "My New Gay Best Friend" — performed by Adam Wachter ♪
[34:01] Jess McInally: Yeah. I was skipping Katrina's welcome song. I get it. I mean it's just not good. We have a lot of songs to go through. All right, all right. "My New Gay Best Friend," yeah. What is there something you wanted to say specifically about Katrina's welcome song?
[34:18] Adam Wachter: No, god no, no, no, no. Well, there used to be a I mean, no, I could do this for every song. It's been through it's been through so many birds, so many like drafts and things. I could tell you like all the old stuff, but no, nobody cares. So moving on.
[34:34] Jess McInally: Man. Now everybody is gonna be on Twitter saying, why didn't you let him talk about that song?
[34:39] Adam Wachter: Well, they can ask me. I'm on Twitter all the time. They'll they just message me and I'll respond to tell you the whole story. I can send people old drafts. I don't care.
[34:46] Jess McInally: I remember getting like on Twitter, someone saying, like, I dreamed that I met Adam Wachter last night, and all I could say was he is my favorite guest on Musicals with Cheese. And then I
[34:56] Adam Wachter: Oh yeah, I saw that.
[34:57] Jess McInally: And then I added you because I thought it was funny, and I feel bad because I feel like I outed that person that did not tag you for a reason.
[35:06] Adam Wachter: Oh my god. No, I love I love that so much. People do that with Encore all the time, where someone will just post something about me, and then someone who actually knows me will tag me in it, and they'll be like, Oh god, I didn't think you'd actually see this. You can anything that strokes my ego, I am down for. And yeah.
[35:26] Jess McInally: But no. Yeah, that's great. "My New Gay Best Friend." Um, I'm wondering, is this based on any true events outside of like this podcast where you are obviously our gay best friend?
[35:37] Adam Wachter: Of course. Of course. I think it's just based on every, you know, that dynamic that feels very uh Will and Gracie, which you know, is a girl and her gay best friend. I think you find it a lot. And I think you especially find it um maybe with women in this is generalizing, but in smaller towns or somewhere where well, this you're too young again, but like back in the 90s, it was like very much a trope that gay men were best friends with girls and they would like do each other's hair and things, and that all gay men were good for was like decorating and gossiping and things. Yeah, so and then Will and Grace came along and sort of opened so many doors in terms of representation, but also kind of um um it'll solidified that stereotype idea. So yeah.
[36:24] Andrew DeWolf: Well, living in a small town right now, I can say there's not a ton of gay people that are around to become best friends with. So this is they're there, you they just haven't come out.
[36:35] Adam Wachter: Well, I mean, I mean I'm not saying they don't exist, I'm just saying that they're not out in the open all the time about it.
[36:43] Jess McInally: I mean, Andrew, now who are you gonna talk about blowouts and blowjobs with?
[36:47] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. I can talk about it.
[36:48] Adam Wachter: I want to say that I suggest them them. I'm very proud of the lyric. One of my favorite lyrics of the whole show is in "My New Gay Best Friend." When at the end she says, My new friend will take me shopping at Macy's the will to my grace. He's my new gay best friend. That's a good song time. You're welcome.
[37:04] Jess McInally: Yes, that is a great lyric.
[37:05] Adam Wachter: Thank you. I'm not proud of most of my work. I I tend to really second guess myself and and judge my own work, but that's that's objectively good, I think.
[37:07] Jess McInally: I think I think the whole song is objectively good, but it almost reads it's a villain song to me. She seems very mandatory. She seems very good.
[37:24] Adam Wachter: Sure. Yeah, it's that's fair. That's fair. She immediately latches onto him as like, This person is gonna make my life better.
[37:32] Jess McInally: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. She's very self-centered, which you get a lot through the show. She's very much in her own head and dealing with her own things, but it comes off in like a very selfish way the entire time. Even when she, which I don't think is on the album, but she's the one who um first gets Ichabod to break his sobriety. It's not Brahm, it's her when she offers when she finally gets up the courage to leave her husband and then offers Ichabod champagne to celebrate and convinces him to break his sobriety. It's all it's it's always the Katrina show.
[38:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Katrina is actually the horseman.
[38:03] Adam Wachter: Exactly.
[38:05] Jess McInally: What if what if the what if it what if the horse is like one of those costumes where like Katrina is the front and Brahm is the back and they're walking around?
[38:11] Andrew DeWolf: What if Katrina, Katrina and Brahm, like the the sequel to this is just they're still there, and there's a new character that shows up, and they just like to kill people.
[38:19] Adam Wachter: Do you know what? Do you know what? That's very uh clever of you to say so because one of the drafts that was the thing. That was after the after I did the first reading. A friend of mine saw it and said, You know what should happen is at the end there should be a reveal that like they do this every year with the new music teacher who comes to town. And I very briefly wrote that as a draft, and then I it immediately, and then you have the final song, another Halloween, I I could see that working. It's just it happens again. And maybe that's the one the thing that like rejuvenates their marriage every year is this. Like that's the one reason why they keep staying with.
[38:56] Jess McInally: Well, it's very like that. Isn't that the plot of Virginia Wolf, basically, who's afraid of Virginia Wolf?
[39:00] Adam Wachter: Yeah.
[39:01] Jess McInally: Man. It's been done. Simpsons did it.
[39:05] Adam Wachter: But in Ichabod's mind, yeah, Katrina is the villain throughout every single step. Like he she is the hindrance to between him and Brahm, which is set up in his opening number and his I Want song. He wants to meet the love of his life and like all that and all that. And Katrina's in the way of that. He wants to stay sober. She fucks that up. And the really Katrina is the catalyst that leads Brahm to killing him, quote unquote.
[39:30] Jess McInally: Yeah, but at the um on the other hand, I think that Ichabod genuinely likes her and feels sorry for her and appreciates her friendship, the the friendship that she invests in him.
[39:39] Andrew DeWolf: So that's why that's why Man of the Middle happens.
[39:42] Adam Wachter: Because he's no, I think he's manipulators.
[39:45] Andrew DeWolf: I think he sees that she's vulnerable. See, this is all about character reading.
[39:48] Jess McInally: Oh, you think you think she wants to get he wants to get her away from his love.
[39:53] Adam Wachter: Yes, I honestly think that he has equally as terrible implications behind this.
[39:59] Andrew DeWolf: Because only because of one line, and maybe Adam can tell me whether that's intentional or not, when he literally refers to Katrina as a laughing hyena in the end, like gay Oh, I always thought that was just sort of a throwaway, like because she's so deep reading.
[40:15] Adam Wachter: No, it's just because her whole thing is she talks, talk, talk.
[40:18] Adam Wachter: She gab gab gab gab gab. You know, she's just very gabby as a, as a I don't know. I would never refer to any friend of mine, no matter how chatty, if I didn't like that kind of throw.
[40:28] Jess McInally: Yeah, but that's because you don't have a friend named Katrina that you have to rhyme her name with.
[40:31] Andrew DeWolf: Otherwise you would.
[40:32] Adam Wachter: You're right. He's got a point. If your friend's name was Debra, maybe you would call her a zebra.
[40:39] Jess McInally: You know what? Wouldn't it be Deborah?
[40:41] Andrew DeWolf: You've sold me. I'm still angry about this, and I still stand by that. I think Ichabod is manipulating her.
[40:46] Adam Wachter: They're trying to manipulate each other in a sense. They're all, but that's isn't that what we do as humans? Are we all trying to manipulate the world around us to get what we want? It's all self-interest.
[41:04] Jess McInally: I'm not doing that.
[41:06] Adam Wachter: This is a very Randian piece.
[41:13] Andrew DeWolf: I've never read any Ayn Rand.
[41:15] Adam Wachter: That's probably a new thing. Are you a fan of objectivism?
[41:18] Jess McInally: Oh god. I don't know what that is. What is it?
[41:21] Adam Wachter: Are we going in the incredible? We're getting very philosophical.
[41:27] Jess McInally: Not now, hon. The game's on.
[41:28] Adam Wachter: Watch now, see them crumble. Ref calls it a fumble.
[41:32] Jess McInally: So cue the new coach's wine.
[41:35] Adam Wachter: Holy shit, he missed it. Kick her barely kissed it, and yet you just sit benign.
[41:41] Andrew DeWolf: You might think it's corny, but this makes me horny.
[41:44] Adam Wachter: I could rub one out just fine.
[41:47] Andrew DeWolf: Once more in slow motion.
[41:49] Adam Wachter: Jesus grab the lotion.
[41:51] Andrew DeWolf: Four down to the ten-yard line.
[41:55] Adam Wachter: Who's this guy? What's his deal?
[41:57] Andrew DeWolf: What's this awkwardness that I feel?
[42:02] Adam Wachter: When he's near, when he's close. There's a flutter of fear that I can't diagnose.
[42:10] Andrew DeWolf: I'm offline trying.
[42:15] Adam Wachter: Alright. There's so many songs I still want to talk about.
[42:18] Jess McInally: Let's I got a question.
[42:19] Adam Wachter: Okay.
[42:20] Jess McInally: Four downs to the 10-yard line. Did you know anything about football before writing that?
[42:24] Adam Wachter: Nothing. Did you learn because of the University of Michigan?
[42:27] Adam Wachter: No, I went to half of a game the entire time, the entire four years that I was in school at the University of Michigan. That's about it.
[42:33] Adam Wachter: And I had a C as a freshman, you get first dibs on like a season ticket, which I guess is like a very high value item for people. But I had that and I didn't even ever use it.
[42:43] Adam Wachter: Um but no, four downs. I knew I needed, I wanted, I knew I wanted to write it. I didn't know anything about football, but I thought that would be a cute song for them to sort of bond over.
[42:54] Adam Wachter: You get this like very the theatrical gay guy, and then this very straight sports-oriented straight guy. And I thought that'd be fun.
[43:03] Adam Wachter: So I had my friend, I asked my friend Brian Patrick Murphy, who is a very big sports fan and a heterosexual man.
[43:10] Jess McInally: What?
[43:11] Adam Wachter: And I uh took him to I know, can you believe it? I said, I will buy you dinner if you will go with me and explain to me everything you know about football and how it's played and everything about it and what you love about it.
[43:24] Adam Wachter: And I recorded the conversation and took notes, and I basically turned that conversation into four downs of the ten-yard line.
[43:30] Andrew DeWolf: So he likes to jerk off the football.
[43:32] Adam Wachter: Yeah. Well, no. I wanted to I wanted no, he does not. That I know of, that I know of. I don't know, I haven't seen him in a while.
[43:40] Adam Wachter: Um, I wanted to sexualize Brahm also. Obviously, like the there's all the football stuff in the song, but the other half of the duet is Ichabod singing about his like immediate lust for this man.
[43:51] Adam Wachter: So I wanted to sexualize him in a way, and that's uh he doesn't actually like whip it out and start jacking off when he's watching football. He's just saying like he loves it so much, it turns him on in every sense of the word.
[44:02] Jess McInally: Yeah, and a lot of heterosexual men do tend to sexualize everything and turn everything into sex because they like to remind people of their heterosexuality in a way that I find a lot of bi or gay people don't often do.
[44:15] Adam Wachter: Okay, that's a take. I'm not really sure about that one.
[44:18] Jess McInally: No, because I definitely do see that because a lot of heterosexual men I know are very overtly sexual and willing to sexualize most situations.
[44:26] Andrew DeWolf: There's a reason why they draw dicks any chance they get.
[44:29] Jess McInally: Who's drawing dicks? What who are you hanging out with? Jess, are you hanging out with third graders again?
[44:35] Adam Wachter: I told you not to do that.
[44:39] Andrew DeWolf: No, did they draw a dick on your forehead when you fell asleep?
[44:43] Jess McInally: Don't fall asleep first in the sleepover.
[44:47] Andrew DeWolf: With third graders.
[44:49] Jess McInally: Oh my god. Alright, we're done with that.
[44:52] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like I'm getting picked on here.
[44:55] Jess McInally: You're getting bullied.
[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: You bring it on yourself.
[44:57] Jess McInally: I do, I do.
[44:59] ♪ Musical number ♪
[45:31] ♪ Musical number ♪
[45:34] ♪ Musical number ♪
[45:38] ♪ Musical number ♪
[45:41] ♪ Musical number ♪
[45:50] ♪ Musical number ♪
[46:00] Jess McInally: Um, let's talk about "Down the Stairs."
[46:02] Adam Wachter: Yeah, the big hit.
[46:04] Jess McInally: Was this really the big hit?
[46:05] Adam Wachter: I think this is like the most well-known song from the show for sure.
[46:08] Jess McInally: That is shocking. All right.
[46:10] Adam Wachter: This song is this is the only song, as far as I know, that has like made multiple appearances on the audition circuit in New York where girls are singing this song.
[46:19] Jess McInally: All right, tell me your artistic inspirations behind this piece.
[46:24] Adam Wachter: This piece, this song did not exist in the first couple of drafts of "Tarrytown" that I did private readings of just to hear it out loud and show it to some friends and things. This song was not there. There was another song that was like "Back Home," which is sort of this little interstitial song that Ichabod sings in the middle of "Dinner for Three." There was another version of "Back Home" that came right after "Apple Picking" song that Brom and Katrina sang as a duet, and it was about Katrina like wondering if she should go back home and Brom wanting Katrina to come back home. Anyway, that got cut. And "Down the Stairs" I wrote, I remember I was in Washington, DC at the time, doing a show somewhere.
I can't remember which show I was doing. And I knew Katrina needed a song, and it started with this four-note phrase that just repeats the entire time. It's really just the whole song is B-da-da-da. It's just that over and over and over again, and it either just beats up or slows down, but that is the accompaniment the entire time, and I realized I could play that figure and it would sort of embody this idea of her stepping down a step and then back up a step and being unsure of whether to go down or up. So it was just playing with down and up. She goes down and then she goes back up and then she goes down and then that just gets faster and it goes da-da-da. And the chord changes underneath it and she sings and that's "Down the Stairs." And she belts high and everyone loves it.
[47:56] Jess McInally: Krista Rodriguez does her Christian Rodriguez thing.
[47:59] Adam Wachter: Mm-hmm.
[48:00] Jess McInally: She sure does it's good.
[48:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's really good. It's so it I know I what am I trying to say here?
[48:08] Jess McInally: Why did you choose this as the kind of interstitial prologue of the show too? What is what?
[48:13] Adam Wachter: Because that da da da oh that's that's they sound the same but they're different. That prologue was written way before "Down the Stairs" actually. I mean the I tried to make everything in the show well almost everything. Obviously like some songs don't sound like anything else like "Man in the Middle" is sort of its own thing and "Legend of Sleepy Hollow" is its own thing. You don't hear a lot of that again. But "When You're Near" and "Down the Stairs" and the prologue and the opening number they all quote from each other and I did that purposefully mostly because I did want it to feel like one piece and I also think that audiences get very satisfied when they get to revisit musical ideas as opposed to hearing one song and then never hearing it again. So everything hopefully in the score feels like a little bit related.
[48:58] Jess McInally: But it's very obvious that you wrote separate songs for each where you just borrow pieces. It's not like, say, an Andrew Lloyd Webber musical where I'm pretty sure he writes three songs, repeats it a thousand times, and then calls it a musical.
[49:09] Adam Wachter: No, no, that's true. It's not that sort of style of that's more like an operatic style. But no, this song is like it's hard to say something about something that's just generally good and like sounds beautiful. Like, um, I and I'm not just trying to blow smoke up your ass. We we kind of yeah, we are I'll take it. I like anything blown up my ass, let me tell you.
[49:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um smoke gets blown up your ass as it come out your mouth, or is that a misconception?
[49:40] ♪ Musical number: "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" ♪
[51:22] Adam Wachter: Alright, "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" is probably the most different from what it originally was. Um I I can send you an old demo that I have of the original "Legend of Sleepy Hollow," which was an eight-minute long song, and it was a vastly detailed story about a German Hessian soldier. Um it went on and on and it told this whole thing, kind of like how Tim Burton's "Sleepy Hollow" movie does, where they really get into the backstory of of the horseman as a character. And it was really long, and um when Backyard Renaissance decided to premiere the show, that was one of their one of their only notes, really. They said, Can you take a look at that song? It just feels like it's too long, and it stopped the show not in a good way.
Um, and it's just too late in the show at that point to be like telling the story. And honestly, story songs, nobody ever likes a story song. Like I do. I uh I'm lame. Well, "Someone in a Tree" is one of the best songs ever written, so No, "Someone in a Tree" is good, but like the "Schmuel Song," or like you know, just one of those songs. But just like the "Schmuel Song" is a great song, but in the context of the show, it's like you're invested in the story you're watching. You don't want to hear another story told to you. And that's what "Sleepy Hollow" felt like. So I shortened it and um I don't remember how the current version goes anymore. But then um, but then because it was Jeremy Jordan actually changed again and and all those like crazy high notes and stuff, we added that in together because he wanted to sing higher and could.
[52:58] Jess McInally: Yeah, he's Jeremy Jordan.
[53:00] Adam Wachter: Um Jeremy Jordan, he's known very well for singing both the Schmuel song and the legend of Sleepy Hollow.
[53:05] Andrew DeWolf: That's right.
[53:06] Jess McInally: Yeah, that's right.
[53:07] Adam Wachter: I forgot. Um he's honestly incredible. He's probably like one of the most talented people I've ever worked with. And specifically in the album recording, he just drips masculine heterosexuality in this song more than like four downs in the ten-yard line. Like he's very intense here.
[53:21] Jess McInally: Yeah, very intense, very sexy. I think probably because he doesn't get to sing this low a lot. You don't hear the side of him that much and stuff because 'cause he can sing high so well that of course everyone has him do that. But when he sings that low stuff, it is it is hot, even when it's about a 18th century German soldier.
[53:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was I was gonna talk about that. Like, um, what kind of did you intend for this to be a Christopher Walken portrayed Hessian soldier when you wrote it?
[53:52] Adam Wachter: No.
[53:52] Jess McInally: What?
[53:53] Adam Wachter: What do you mean?
[53:54] Andrew DeWolf: When you described as Hessian, is he played by Christopher Walken?
[53:57] Adam Wachter: Oh no, in my head, he's young. In my head, I was and then the I can't remember if it's in the new version of the song, but in the original, there was like all these parallels to him, like at the time, um, like Abu Ghraib and everything was happening. So I was thinking of these young soldiers who I because he wouldn't have been Christopher Walken's age at the time. These Germans came over to fight in the revolutionary War, and they would have been young guys. They would have been like sixteen to you know, early 20s, probably, because they were soldiers. Uh so I would think he would be young and sort of misguided. And um, he's not the one that cuts off the head. It's the it's the other soldier that does it, the American, right?
[54:35] Jess McInally: Yes.
[54:35] Adam Wachter: I can't remember. You Jesse, you know the songs better than I do at this point. I haven't heard them in so long. Um, no, I'm thinking I was thinking they'd be sort of strapping young soldiers.
[54:43] Andrew DeWolf: Gotcha. I I still envision Christopher Walken as the Hestian.
[54:48] Adam Wachter: Okay, that's fair.
[54:49] Jess McInally: Because that's just what that character is to me. It's Christopher Walken.
[54:52] Adam Wachter: I mean, he's so good. He's so good in that movie. I mean, you know, the whole inspiration to write this Tarrytown show came because I saw uh Canadian television movie of the legend of Sleepy Hollow starring Brent Carver as a kebab crane.
[55:05] Jess McInally: My god, that is perfect casting. Like I know.
[55:08] Andrew DeWolf: The nerve.
[55:10] Jess McInally: Man, Brent Carver needs to be in more things.
[55:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, whatever.
[55:13] Jess McInally: Where is Brent Carver? What are you up to?
[55:15] Andrew DeWolf: Where when's that parade reunion happening?
[55:18] Jess McInally: Yeah. Come on, Seth Rudetsky. Reunite the cast of parade. Everyone's favorite show is parade, right?
[55:25] Andrew DeWolf: Everyone's. That bucket of laughs parade.
[55:28] Adam Wachter: Oof.
[55:29] ♪ Musical number: "When You're Near" ♪
[56:17] Jess McInally: That song is incredible. Like this song is That's the first one I wrote. And you feel it. Like sometimes you listen. Sometimes you listen to a musical and then you get amateur. No, no, no, no, no. Sometimes when you listen to a musical, especially a song cycle or something like that, and you get to one song and it's like, this is the reason the show exists. This is the big thematic idea that everything was building to. And when you hear that this is the reason why the show is written, or the first thing that was written, it makes complete sense. And I feel that's very true here.
[57:00] Adam Wachter: Yeah, yeah. I mean, this is what everything stemmed from. That was the first one I wrote. This is where the prologue theme comes from. It's in the accompaniment. And that phrase echoes over and over. And this is similar, and this is like showing you what a what a lazy composer I am. But again, the same as in Down the Stairs, and the same that's coming up at another Halloween. I like to get one really good figure going, and then I just sort of keep it going through the song. So in when you're near, you get and it just repeats over and over and over again.
[57:36] Jess McInally: And uh what made you make this a solo and not any form of duet, so to say?
[57:41] Adam Wachter: Well, that's a good question. I don't know. I think maybe I thought at that point Ichabod earned his solo, and we wanted one from him. And I also I don't know that Brahm would sing in that moment, because I think that Brahm is in such a different place. There's you know, dramatic irony going on because we as an audience know at that point that Brahm is not interested, and we know that Ichabod is, and we know that Brahm has this sort of plan happening. So I don't think it would be honest for Brahm to like join him in any sort of love duet, because I don't think that he is a sophisticated enough sort of plotter that he would he's not a schemer type.
[58:25] Jess McInally: No, exactly.
[58:25] Adam Wachter: Thank you. A siren, like he basically is like the siren, like hauling him to his death by water, so to say.
[58:33] Jess McInally: Yes, but he doesn't do it in a sophisticated way, he does it with just like some sort of heavy-handed flirtation and some booze and some drugs, and then death by ghost, some empty promises, and potentially death by ghost. But I don't think he's like singing a love duet with him. I don't know, it just felt like a good also like it just felt like a musical theater solo song. It sounds like solo number, you know, runaway with me and all those contemporary music.
[59:02] Adam Wachter: Exactly, exactly.
[59:03] Jess McInally: I mean, Lord knows Animandis then gets like another seven-minute solo immediately afterwards.
[59:08] Adam Wachter: That was the reason.
[59:09] Jess McInally: But that's a very different thing.
[59:10] Adam Wachter: That's the reason why I was asking, because then you have two very Ichabod-centric songs, and I was wondering if there was ever uh consideration of making a duet, which is it's not a bad idea, and maybe in the future I will.
[59:24] Jess McInally: I'm not criticizing.
[59:25] Adam Wachter: No, no, no, I like it's not a it's not it's not a bad idea, it truly isn't, because then you do get so much solo Ichabod, but I guess I think he earns it because it is ultimately his story, so he wraps it up with his and when you're near such a different number, Ichabod things are happening, and and he's going through something, and when you're near is just a full-on musical theater orgasmic explosion of love.
[59:50] Jess McInally: I was shocked because I feel in my brain when I listened to this, I thought Brahm had come out with like some attempted heterosexual's version of a gay seduction before that, and like that's what prompts this song, and it really doesn't in the story and in the script, so to say, so I was shocked, and I was like, well, maybe at one point this was a duet, so yeah.
[1:00:14] Adam Wachter: No, it never was a duet, but one day might be.
[1:00:17] Jess McInally: Hey, I'd love to hear it. I I think their voices would blend into the code.
[1:00:20] Adam Wachter: Why don't you just play the recording and then you sing along the duet part with it?
[1:00:24] Jess McInally: Um, it would sound bad, that's why.
[1:00:27] Adam Wachter: I can I can confirm.
[1:00:28] Jess McInally: Well, nobody has to hear it. I'm just saying do it on your own.
[1:00:31] Adam Wachter: You think some of the singing in Encore is bad? Ha! Just wait.
[1:00:37] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, do you watch Encore?
[1:00:38] Andrew DeWolf: No. I haven't seen it, no.
[1:00:40] Jess McInally: No, that's alright. I've thought about like before we started the Glee show, I was like, we should do like the Encore, like episode by episode. Then I was like, uh, that might get weird because Adam's there is an Encore podcast episode.
[1:00:52] Adam Wachter: I know, and they're great.
[1:00:53] Jess McInally: And I didn't want to rip them off either, but also it's behind a paywall, so I'm like, if people are paying for it, I don't I don't care if I'm ripping someone off.
[1:01:00] Adam Wachter: What's behind a paywall?
[1:01:02] Jess McInally: They're a podcast?
[1:01:03] Adam Wachter: Yeah, our Glee podcast is behind a paywall.
[1:01:05] Jess McInally: Oh, your Glee podcast is would have been a g Encore podcast once upon a time.
[1:01:11] Adam Wachter: Oh, I see.
[1:01:12] Jess McInally: Before we decide on Glee. And then Glee luckily became in the news again recently, so thank God for that.
[1:01:18] Adam Wachter: I'm sure you have plenty of stories heard secondhand.
[1:01:22] Jess McInally: I have some first hand stories, but I will not divulge them here.
[1:01:25] Adam Wachter: That's fine. You don't have to.
[1:01:27] Jess McInally: Great. Cut that out from the episode.
[1:01:30] Adam Wachter: I will. That will be cut out, but I think my face said it all.
[1:01:34] Jess McInally: Yeah. Um, we should have him on as a guest on our Glee podcast. That'd be fun.
[1:01:38] Adam Wachter: Who me?
[1:01:39] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[1:01:39] Adam Wachter: Oh god, I haven't seen Glee since I well, first of all, I never saw anything past the first season. And then I haven't seen the first season.
[1:01:46] Jess McInally: Oh, good. Well, I haven't seen it since it originally aired. Is that alright?
[1:01:49] Adam Wachter: Yeah, that's fine.
[1:01:50] Jess McInally: We'd make you watch the one.
[1:01:51] Andrew DeWolf: I've never seen one episode we're doing that week out of context, and we talk about it.
[1:01:55] Adam Wachter: This is what I'll say about Glee. Is I saw it has nothing to do with Glee, really, but I saw Amber Riley play Effie and Dream Girls in the West End, and it was one of the best performances. Live one of the cleanest live vocal performances I've ever witnessed. It was phenomenal.
[1:02:12] Jess McInally: There's a reason she has a career, and other unnamed people do not really have one anymore.
[1:02:16] Adam Wachter: Alright, another Halloween!
[1:02:18] ♪ Musical number: "Another Halloween" ♪
[1:03:31] Adam Wachter: Another Halloween is a funny story because I remember being in my apartment in New York. Um, my oh well, now I don't live in New York anymore, so I guess they're all my old apartment, but not my most recent apartment. The one before that, not that anyone knows what I'm talking about. But if you know me, you know that I used to live on 47th Street, and I had this little studio apartment. New Yorkers. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And uh um, and my uh best friend Paul was coming over and we were going to have sushi, and um he stopped by and came, and right before he stopped by, I had played on the on my piano this again, two-note figure that I figured would be a good one to please repeat, which is just a fourth going bum bum bum bum.
And then he came in and he said, All right, let's go to dinner. And I said, wait just a second, I have to write this down or record this because otherwise I'll forget it. And he was like, Oh, what is it? A new melody, something exciting. And I went to the piano and just went bum bum bum bum. Okay, I got it. Let's go to dinner. Like literally, it's nothing. It's two notes, but I didn't want to forget it. I get paranoid because these things enter my brain, and then if I don't record myself playing them or humming them or write it down in some way, then they're lost to the ages. And I was like, no, that's good, that's good. So yeah, it's just those two notes going it going forever, and then I changed the root underneath it, and that's it.
That's another Halloween. I'm I don't think another Halloween gets enough love. You know, it's the last song in the show, so people, I guess, like maybe don't make it all the way through. They already got their playbill up, they're getting their jacket on. I I am very proud of another Halloween. I think it's very pretty. Um, yeah, I don't know.
[1:05:10] Jess McInally: I think specifically in the first email I sent you asking you to be on our show for that merrily. I mentioned that another Halloween makes me cry.
[1:05:19] Adam Wachter: Oh, I think maybe you did, and that made me so happy. Because I do love this song, and it was probably the one I listened to the most. Like, right, it's right neck and neck to the legend of Sleepy Hollow because those two sorry sorry, Andy Mientus. You're great, but uh who knows who knew the Andy Mientus didn't get all the great songs. I thought he did. I just Jeremy Jordan and Krysta Rodriguez, I love that family drama stuff. Yeah, another Halloween is very sad, but it's also very pretty, and I like I've always liked that dichotomy. I think to write like a sad song and have it just be very minor and down is not is not human and it's not interesting. I think you to have something beautiful be sad is more interesting. It's a real depressing message, like about monotony and getting like your lot in life and all that.
[1:06:06] Adam Wachter: It hit me hard, specifically right after post-college graduation, where I'm like, what am I doing? I'm in the workforce, and is this my life now forever? Yes, yeah, is every day just another Halloween?
[1:06:23] Jess McInally: I wish every day's worse than Halloween.
[1:06:26] Adam Wachter: Can I tell you something? This is a big reveal, but I hate Halloween. It is my least favorite holiday. I can't believe I wrote an entire musical about it.
[1:06:34] Jess McInally: You wrote like never liked Halloween musical.
[1:06:36] Adam Wachter: I wrote, yeah, maybe the only Halloween musical.
[1:06:38] Jess McInally: Well, there's the Halloween number in Mean Girls.
[1:06:40] Adam Wachter: I guess that would be the other one.
[1:06:41] Jess McInally: That's a sexy number.
[1:06:43] Adam Wachter: That's true.
[1:06:44] Jess McInally: Um I don't know how to do it. I'm not I am not a Halloween fan. I do not like dressing up in costumes. I don't like seeing other people dressed up in costumes. I don't I hate scary things.
[1:06:54] Adam Wachter: Please say costumes again.
[1:06:56] Jess McInally: Is that how I say it?
[1:06:57] Adam Wachter: Costumes.
[1:06:58] Jess McInally: Costumes.
[1:06:59] Adam Wachter: Costumes.
[1:07:00] Jess McInally: Costumes.
[1:07:01] Adam Wachter: How do you say it?
[1:07:02] Jess McInally: I uh very mid Costumes.
[1:07:04] Adam Wachter: And you're like, costumes.
[1:07:06] Jess McInally: Those sound the same to me. Am I crazy?
[1:07:08] Adam Wachter: There's like a third syllable that you put in the case.
[1:07:10] Jess McInally: Why does everyone have an accent except me? Andrew, say costumes.
[1:07:14] Andrew DeWolf: Costumes.
[1:07:15] Jess McInally: Oh yeah, I guess that's only two syllables.
[1:07:18] Adam Wachter: I can't say anything properly though, so you're probably right on this one.
[1:07:22] Jess McInally: No, I doubt it. Mine's like a weird.
[1:07:24] Adam Wachter: I mean, which one of us has written a musical?
[1:07:27] Jess McInally: Um, he's saying it right.
[1:07:28] Adam Wachter: Uh that has been a good thing. Writing a musical does not mean you're smarter or better than anybody else.
[1:07:33] Jess McInally: Um you're right. Look at Adam Gettle.
[1:07:36] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh.
[1:07:37] Adam Wachter: Well, was that was that a hot take I just put out there?
[1:07:39] Jess McInally: I don't know what it was, but it seemed very um rude.
[1:07:43] Adam Wachter: Very acidic.
[1:07:45] Jess McInally: Uh he he said some stuff.
[1:07:47] Adam Wachter: That's true.
[1:07:52] Jess McInally: And just writing a musical doesn't mean all your opinions are right, or that you say costume correctly.
[1:07:57] Adam Wachter: You say it the same way I do.
[1:07:58] Jess McInally: I just said it like you as a joke.
[1:08:00] Adam Wachter: Oh, I see.
[1:08:02] Jess McInally: Guys, I was only pretending to not know how to say it.
[1:08:10] Adam Wachter: But no, you hate Halloween. You hate costumes and I yeah, I don't like scary things. The only thing about Halloween I like is the candy because I love candy.
[1:08:19] Andrew DeWolf: There's candy and there's scary things, and those are both great.
[1:08:22] Adam Wachter: I don't know how you like.
[1:08:23] Jess McInally: I don't like scary things. I love autumn, and I love um the whole sort of vibe of autumn and like.
[1:08:29] Andrew DeWolf: See, that's what's great with Halloween though, is you don't have to celebrate Halloween. You can just do Octoberfest.
[1:08:34] Jess McInally: But that's why I wish Halloween wasn't there to ruin autumn for me.
[1:08:37] Adam Wachter: It's Halloween.
[1:08:39] Jess McInally: Like leaves are turning colors and chill in the air, and pumpkin spice is back at Starbucks, and then for a week I have to worry about being scared wherever I go and it ruins it.
[1:08:49] Andrew DeWolf: Oh that's out there scaring people on Halloween.
[1:08:52] Adam Wachter: Everyone.
[1:08:53] Jess McInally: I've never been in Pittsburgh and New York.
[1:08:55] Andrew DeWolf: I get it.
[1:08:56] Adam Wachter: And Michigan, which is just scary in a different way.
[1:08:58] Jess McInally: Yeah, exactly.
[1:08:59] Adam Wachter: Yeah, I just I I don't have to deal with that. If I want to get scared, I have to turn on a scary movie or something.
[1:09:04] Jess McInally: No one's willing to scare me.
[1:09:05] Adam Wachter: Or Fox.
[1:09:06] Jess McInally: You know what I love? This is really lame, but I was just telling a friend about this because he was telling me that he didn't like scary movies either. And my saving grace with scary movies because I think there are scary movies that are like really excellent films and that I enjoy watching, but I get so worried about the jump scares that I can't enjoy them.
[1:09:22] Adam Wachter: So there's this website that I found called Where's the Jump.com, and they tell you exactly where every scare is in the movie, like at what minute and second and what the scare is and what level of scare it is.
[1:09:34] Jess McInally: It's cheating, and I'm sure the filmmakers would not want to know that I was using that.
[1:09:38] Adam Wachter: Absolutely cheating.
[1:09:38] Jess McInally: I don't like I don't like jump scares.
[1:09:40] Adam Wachter: I don't my I'll take gore, fine. Blood and guts, perfect. Violence, sure. It's jump scares.
[1:09:46] Jess McInally: I hate them.
[1:09:47] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Adam.
[1:09:48] Adam Wachter: I'm scared like you where just loud noises freak me out in general, like in life. Like anytime there's like a prop gun that has to be fired in like the Phantom of the Hour or anything, I can't handle it.
[1:10:00] Jess McInally: But jump scares don't bother me.
[1:10:02] Adam Wachter: For some reason, I'm just able to disconnect between the two.
[1:10:05] Jess McInally: Hold on one.
[1:10:06] Adam Wachter: Okay, never mind.
[1:10:07] Jess McInally: Yeah, that doesn't bother me.
[1:10:09] Adam Wachter: Okay.
[1:10:09] Jess McInally: Um, guys, what are our thoughts on Tarrytown and our cheese raid?
[1:10:15] Adam Wachter: Um, I'm gonna make Andrew go first.
[1:10:17] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy.
[1:10:19] Adam Wachter: Hang on, I'm googling.
[1:10:23] Jess McInally: He really is the third host of the show.
[1:10:26] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so I thought uh I thought it was pretty good, actually. Pleasantly surprised. I looked up the composer and I wasn't impressed, but you know, it was okay. I like I like all the uh legend of sleepy hollow stuff quite a bit. The headless horseman mythology is really fun, and uh the love triangle sort of thing is realistic and grounded enough that it doesn't feel like a just a huge cliché.
[1:10:54] Adam Wachter: Um, so I'm kind of into it.
[1:10:56] Andrew DeWolf: And uh music overall is very uh very good. So thumbs up from me.
[1:11:01] Jess McInally: Thank you.
[1:11:01] Andrew DeWolf: Uh check out the album.
[1:11:03] Jess McInally: Uh cheese rating.
[1:11:04] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, I looked up Tarrytown cheese because I'm lazy. Um there's a place called Second Mouse Cheese Shop, which just sounds great. So I'm gonna give it second mouse cheese.
[1:11:16] Jess McInally: Okay, all right, Adam.
[1:11:17] Adam Wachter: I I wonder this is cheating. What is your overall thoughts on Tarrytown?
[1:11:22] Adam Wachter: My overall thoughts on Tarrytown is uh is pretty wrong. No, I think it's good. I don't know, it's may you know. Jess, this is like an unfair question to ask somebody, honestly.
[1:11:34] Jess McInally: I know, that's why I'm doing it.
[1:11:36] Adam Wachter: I ask all the uncomfortable questions here.
[1:11:38] Adam Wachter: You can't ask an artist, I'm very proud of it.
[1:11:41] Adam Wachter: I yeah. I it's been now that it's been through so many drafts when it first started, it was not great. But um this the the most recent draft.
[1:11:50] Adam Wachter: Do we hear that sound? Someone is like shooting someone outside my house.
[1:11:53] Jess McInally: Well, it might be fireworks, I don't know.
[1:11:55] Adam Wachter: It's Pittsburgh.
[1:11:56] Jess McInally: It's Pittsburgh, it could be anyone's guess.
[1:11:58] Adam Wachter: Oh god. I'm very proud of Tarrytown. It's come a long way. I think it is um, if nothing else, I think it's it's well crafted and unexpected and tuneful, and all the other adjectives I use on my website to describe it.
[1:12:14] Jess McInally: I would love to see another production of it because I do think that the audiences really enjoy it, and obviously so do the fans.
[1:12:21] Adam Wachter: And um, yeah, I don't know. I think it's good.
[1:12:24] Jess McInally: And your cheese rating.
[1:12:25] Adam Wachter: And I rate it something that I've just googled, which is called apple cheese.
[1:12:31] Jess McInally: That sounds disgusting.
[1:12:33] Adam Wachter: Yes, it does. It is apparently, but you know, there's a lot of apple picking references in Tarrytown.
[1:12:41] Jess McInally: Um, and so there's something called apple cheese.
[1:12:44] Adam Wachter: And what uh Atlas Obscura says, at first glance, apple cheese looks a bit like charcuterie, but it's not meat or even cheese at all.
[1:12:53] Jess McInally: To make what the fuck is it?
[1:12:55] Adam Wachter: It's apple cheese to make it. Cooks combine sliced raw apples with sugar to draw out the juice, then they reduce the liquid and stew it with cinnamon and apple chunks.
[1:13:06] Jess McInally: What?
[1:13:07] Adam Wachter: What?
[1:13:08] Jess McInally: So I guess it's just like stewed cinnamon and apples, which actually sounds delicious.
[1:13:12] Adam Wachter: Come from then.
[1:13:13] Jess McInally: I don't understand.
[1:13:14] Adam Wachter: I don't know, but there's literally videos that say like how to make apple cheese.
[1:13:17] Jess McInally: All right, we're gonna make some apple cheese for the next episode.
[1:13:20] Adam Wachter: No, we're gonna go to Pittsburgh.
[1:13:21] Jess McInally: We're gonna go make some apple cheese with Adam.
[1:13:24] Adam Wachter: I could make apple cheese.
[1:13:26] Adam Wachter: I have these ingredients, it's just apples and cinnamon and sugar. I've got all those things in my house right now.
[1:13:31] Jess McInally: I can make some apple cheese tonight and have a whole themed evening.
[1:13:34] Adam Wachter: Well, listen to some Tarrytown, all proceeds of which, by the way, remind you, go to the actor's fund.
[1:13:39] Jess McInally: So uh go give it a listen, everybody.
[1:13:42] Adam Wachter: I I know I am.
[1:13:43] Jess McInally: Uh yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:13:45] Adam Wachter: Um once again, Tarrytown is great. The album is one of my favorites. It's honestly one of my top things on my Apple music now, especially now that it's on Apple Music and I don't have to pull up fucking sound cloud every time I want to hear another Halloween.
[1:13:57] Jess McInally: Sure.
[1:13:57] Adam Wachter: Yeah, yeah. Absolutely.
[1:13:59] Jess McInally: And honestly, I don't have much complaints about it. I'm still kind of reeling from the new revelations from reading the script and re watching a read-through that Adam provided.
[1:14:08] Jess McInally: So all these new painting of the context is a bit jarring for me, to be honest. Not that it's bad, it's just different.
[1:14:17] Adam Wachter: And it portrays Katrina specifically very differently for me, and the entire Brahm Ichabod relationship um a a lot more sinister.
[1:14:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um nevertheless, I am giving this specifically. Did you guys know that in Las Vegas, Nevada, there is a Sleepy Hollow themed restaurant called Ichabod's?
[1:14:39] Adam Wachter: And yes.
[1:14:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um they do sell mac and cheese bites.
[1:14:44] Adam Wachter: So it's specifically mac and cheese bites from Ichabod's restaurant.
[1:14:49] Jess McInally: Wow.
[1:14:50] Adam Wachter: Are they open these days?
[1:14:51] Andrew DeWolf: I think Vegas is open.
[1:14:53] Adam Wachter: Um they're a 24-hour family-friendly smoke-free restaurant from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. Full menu and lounge open 24 hours a day.
[1:15:00] Jess McInally: Who brings their family to Las Vegas?
[1:15:03] Adam Wachter: They're open from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. but they're gonna be able to do that.
[1:15:05] Jess McInally: I've just read you exactly what it said.
[1:15:07] Adam Wachter: It's crazy.
[1:15:08] Jess McInally: Or are they only smoke free from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.?
[1:15:11] Adam Wachter: Is that what it's 24-hour family-friendly smoke-free restaurant from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. full menu and lounge open.
[1:15:15] Jess McInally: It's one run-on sentence.
[1:15:20] Adam Wachter: Okay, the the full menu is 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
[1:15:23] Jess McInally: Oh.
[1:15:25] Adam Wachter: But they're open to the phone.
[1:15:26] Jess McInally: I thought it was only smoke-free.
[1:15:28] Adam Wachter: I wish I could show you the way this is like specifically worded.
[1:15:33] Jess McInally: It is a mess.
[1:15:34] Adam Wachter: Crazy.
[1:15:35] Jess McInally: But do you guys know what isn't a mess?
[1:15:37] Adam Wachter: Our patrons.
[1:15:39] Jess McInally: Our wonderful patrons! Thank you guys for listening. Um you can find us on Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. Our Twitter is Cheesy Musicals. Our Patreon is Musicals with Cheese. Our Instagram is Musicals with Cheese. Our YouTube page is Musicals with Cheese. We have a patron only podcast, Glee with Cheese, pay five dollars a whatever, and you can come join us with that podcast.
[1:15:57] Andrew DeWolf: We're we're gonna talk some shit about Leah Michelle.
[1:15:59] Jess McInally: Um email us at musicaltheaterlives@gmail.com. Our title card was created by Jolene Casco. Go send her some love on Instagram at Jolene Casco.
[1:16:08] Adam Wachter: I know you've got a lot of things you want to promote, so promote them out there for the world.
[1:16:12] Adam Wachter: I don't have that many things. I've got two things, Tarrytown and Encore. That's about it right now.
[1:16:16] Jess McInally: Promote Tarrytown. What is this thing that they're that you need to promote?
[1:16:20] Adam Wachter: Yeah, we just talked about it for three hours.
[1:16:23] Jess McInally: I've never heard of this Tarrytown thing. Tell us.
[1:16:25] Adam Wachter: Don't listen to it. It's streaming everywhere. You can buy it on iTunes. All profits are going to the Actors Fund for COVID relief.
[1:16:33] Jess McInally: Um please enjoy.
[1:16:34] Adam Wachter: Let me know if you have questions about the plot.
[1:16:37] Jess McInally: And uh Disney Plus.
[1:16:41] Adam Wachter: No, yeah, Andrew's got it.
[1:16:43] Jess McInally: Tweet him at heyductor. Because you know him.
[1:16:45] Andrew DeWolf: He tweets all the time.
[1:16:46] Jess McInally: I am a constant just chatterbox.
[1:16:50] Andrew DeWolf: I never stop.
[1:16:51] Jess McInally: What do you do all day long, Andrew, and whenever you live upstate New York?
[1:16:54] Andrew DeWolf: I work at a bank.
[1:16:59] Jess McInally: How on earth did you get roped into this?
[1:17:01] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[1:17:03] Jess McInally: He's known me for way too long. That's how he's gotten roped into this.
[1:17:08] Adam Wachter: I would Andrew, I would love to know. Like, now that so many episodes have gone by, what is your opinion, like of a musical theater as awesome as an art form?
[1:17:17] Andrew DeWolf: It really just needs to stop.
[1:17:19] Jess McInally: No. In a couple weeks, we're gonna hit episode 100. Fun fact.
[1:17:22] Adam Wachter: We are very cool.
[1:17:24] Jess McInally: And it's coinciding with Hamilton dropping on Disney Plus, so it's advantageous.
[1:17:29] Adam Wachter: Oh great.
[1:17:30] Jess McInally: While you're there, turn tune into Encore.
[1:17:32] Andrew DeWolf: He actively won't.
[1:17:37] Jess McInally: I might.
[1:17:37] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I don't watch TV shows very much, though.
[1:17:40] Jess McInally: I don't I don't like uh I don't like serialized things.
[1:17:43] Adam Wachter: These are these are standalone episodes.
[1:17:45] Jess McInally: You don't need to watch them in any order.
[1:17:47] Adam Wachter: They are just on there's a little one hour, just watch, you know.
[1:17:51] Jess McInally: I highly disagree.
[1:17:52] Adam Wachter: They are very serialized into how fluffy Adam's hair gets.
[1:17:56] Jess McInally: Does it get fluffy?
[1:17:57] Adam Wachter: Yeah, it gets fluffier and like I think they they were still in a different order than they were shot because it grows then shrinks, then grows again.
[1:18:05] Jess McInally: No, I just got haircuts.
[1:18:07] Adam Wachter: I got haircuts.
[1:18:09] Jess McInally: You know how people used to get haircuts?
[1:18:11] Adam Wachter: I got some during the shooting of Encore.
[1:18:13] Jess McInally: Look at Andrew. Has he ever heard of a haircut?
[1:18:15] Andrew DeWolf: No, I guess not.
[1:18:16] Jess McInally: Look at all of us though. Look how long that this is like Encore pilot length into the woods time.
[1:18:21] Adam Wachter: Oh my god.
[1:18:22] Jess McInally: All right, we gotta wrap this up.
[1:18:23] Adam Wachter: We're an hour and 20 in.
[1:18:25] Jess McInally: Thank you guys for listening. Um please send you for having me.
[1:18:28] Adam Wachter: And thank you for loving Tarrytown, everyone. It is wonderful.
[1:18:30] Jess McInally: Um, please, after this episode, go send your fan art, um, your dick pics and everything to Adam at zebra adam on Twitter.
[1:18:38] Adam Wachter: Just give him all of it.
[1:18:41] Jess McInally: Um draw your fan art on your dick and then take a picture and send it to me.
[1:18:46] Adam Wachter: Get a tattoo of Tarrytown on your dick and then send it to Adam.
[1:18:50] Jess McInally: Oh my god.
[1:18:50] Adam Wachter: These heterosexual men will never stop drawing dicks on everything.
[1:18:55] Jess McInally: Exactly.
[1:18:56] Adam Wachter: It all comes together.
[1:18:58] Jess McInally: It all comes together just like you do when you watch football.
[1:19:01] Adam Wachter: See you guys next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:19:05] Jess McInally: Go rope one out to Tarrytown.
[1:19:07] Andrew DeWolf: Rope one out to Tarrytown, kids.
[1:19:09] Jess McInally: Pretend you're watching football.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
