Skip to main content
BPN Logo
BONUS: Top 10 Best Episodes of 2022 (feat. Juliet Antonio)

For a special treat we are joined by our Keeper of the Cheese Juliet Antonio to talk about our best episodes of 2022! Come listen!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

36 mins
1/9/23

Featured Shows

About

For a special treat we are joined by our Keeper of the Cheese Juliet Antonio to talk about our best episodes of 2022! Come listen!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:42] Jess: Hello and welcome to an extra special bonus Musicals with Cheese episode.

[0:46] Andrew DeWolf: I am joined by Andrew DeWolf, Brianna Jones, and our keeper of the cheese, Juliet Antonio.

[0:53] Jess: And Juliet watches and listens to every Musicals with Cheese event thing that we do and keeps track of all of our cheese ratings, which means this person is the only one qualified enough to tell us what is our best episodes of 2022.

[1:09] Jess: Alright, Julia. Introduce yourself and what have we got?

[1:12] Juliet Antonio: Hi everybody. Uh so most of you who heard my name in the credits, but if you haven't seen me or heard my voice before, hi, I'm Juliet.

[1:19] Juliet Antonio: I'm the keeper of the cheese. I basically got this job after Jess jokingly said, what if someone made a spreadsheet with all our ratings?

[1:25] Juliet Antonio: And I said, bet, hold my beer, and then I sent it off to him, and I've been doing this ever since.

[1:30] Juliet Antonio: I've been with uh listening to the show since episode zero when Andrew and Jess reviewed the Tonies.

[1:36] Juliet Antonio: Now we are here at episode over 200 and something. I don't have the spreadsheet up right now, so sorry.

[1:42] Juliet Antonio: So we did a year in review uh last year. Jess asked me if I could do another one, and I came up with a list of uh the top 10 episodes since the last episode we covered, which was the last episode where we left off was the one before Little Match Girl, I believe.

[1:58] Juliet Antonio: So it's all the episodes since Little Match Girl on. So you've got the top ten for those, and we've got the top cheese ratings for this year as well, because I'm the keeper of the cheese and it's my brand.

[2:07] Juliet Antonio: So guys, uh just out of curiosity, do you have any predictions? Because I believe that question was asked last time.

[2:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[2:12] Jess: Andrew, why don't you go first? What do you think is one of our best of the year?

[2:16] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, geez. Of this year, I have no fucking clue. Uh you're Evan Hansen.

[2:21] Jess: We didn't do that this year.

[2:23] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't. I put that oh, that was last year. I had that last year for number three or four.

[2:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, it's been that long.

[2:30] Jess: I know any big event episodes this time.

[2:33] Andrew DeWolf: We had Uncanto, which was like our starting one. We had a lot of true hard work episodes.

[2:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like our Rankin Bass. Honestly.

[2:43] Jess: But everyone liked it, I guess. It was our most downloaded episode of the year, so maybe our most downloaded.

[2:48] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe everyone hated it though. Maybe we like locked those people out.

[2:51] Andrew DeWolf: We saw Dear Evan Hansen in 2021.

[2:53] Jess: Yeah.

[2:54] Andrew DeWolf: I thought 2022 was a shit year because I saw Dear Evan Hansen this year.

[2:58] Andrew DeWolf: I think that our Rankin Bass episodes were very good.

[3:02] Jess: Oh, yeah.

[3:03] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. These are very well done.

[3:04] Jess: Those were a lot of work, and we have a little while before we do anything quite that taxing again.

[3:11] Andrew DeWolf: But I don't know. When I think about episodes we've done this year, like the one that I really look back the most fondly on is our Mrs. Doubtfire episode.

[3:16] Andrew DeWolf: And I don't have a good reason why. I just think that you and I had very funny jokes in that one.

[3:22] Andrew DeWolf: We talked about it just the right amount, and we hit it right before it hit all that Broadway controversy where they shut down for a while.

[3:30] Andrew DeWolf: I also think our Funny Girl episode is a contender.

[3:32] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that and our Bridgerton episode.

[3:35] Andrew DeWolf: Uh now that I'm actually thinking about it, there's a lot of good episodes this year.

[3:38] Jess: Oh yeah.

[3:40] Jess: I'm ready to hear it.

[3:41] Jess: Let's see. We what do you have an actual guest?

[3:44] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry. I just realized I got Andrew and didn't get one from you because you said do you have an answer?

[3:49] Juliet Antonio: Um I think Home on the Range is a contender.

[3:52] Juliet Antonio: Um that one was good, I think.

[3:54] Juliet Antonio: That one was very good. I'm just kind of looking back.

[3:57] Juliet Antonio: I forget what we do.

[3:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[3:59] Andrew DeWolf: This was the most Groundhog Drive.

[4:05] Juliet Antonio: Um Funny Girl is definitely in there.

[4:08] Juliet Antonio: I'm sorry. Let's not spoil it.

[4:10] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay. I'm out.

[4:12] Jess: Alright. Julia, what we got?

[4:15] Juliet Antonio: Alright. So starting off the list at number 10, we have episode 217, Ride the Cyclone.

[4:23] Juliet Antonio: Oh, not a TikTok musical, but a musical famous through TikTok, as opposed to when you guys did Bridgerton and Ratatouille.

[4:34] Juliet Antonio: So what I really appreciate about you guys and the show is how you don't automatically give musicals that are popular with Gen Z the shaft because they're for the youths.

[4:44] Juliet Antonio: Um you go into it unbiased and critique it unlike some quote unquote critics.

[4:49] Juliet Antonio: And I think what set this episode apart was just this really bonkers premise about kids dying on a roller coaster and them having to appease this fortune teller theme park god with their lives so as to figure out who gets a second chance.

[5:03] Juliet Antonio: And Canadian theater is really a blind spot for me, but this is really cool to learn about and it just goes to show what can be done when money is thrown at art as evidenced by some B AL tricks that just described seeing some of the performers in the mid-air.

[5:17] Juliet Antonio: And the roller coaster stories at the end that you guys shared were hilarious.

[5:20] Juliet Antonio: And the plans to go to a theme park together were really great.

[5:23] Juliet Antonio: Also, side note, if anyone else out there liked this episode, I'm gonna recommend a book called Action Park, written by the son of the park owner, which is about the most infamous theme park in New Jersey where everything broke and everyone got hurt.

[5:35] Juliet Antonio: So go read that.

[5:37] Juliet Antonio: Um I love how you have this very detailed analysis and for an episode that literally began with Bree telling a story about a stripper having her ass called that was the episode?

[5:52] Jess: Yes.

[5:53] Juliet Antonio: It's one episode.

[5:56] Juliet Antonio: And I mean that's that's a good episode, right?

[5:59] Andrew DeWolf: We have a flashback in the middle of an episode that has never happened before.

[6:03] Juliet Antonio: It is one of our strangest episodes, and I'm so glad I made the list. Sincerely.

[6:10] Jess: What's gonna top that?

[6:11] Juliet Antonio: Oh, we're gonna have to see.

[6:13] Juliet Antonio: There's there's a chain of regression here. It's I always pick the weird ones.

[6:16] Juliet Antonio: You guys know that.

[6:17] Juliet Antonio: I remember last year for the number 10 spot, it was Jekyll and Hyde, and Jess just went, really?

[6:22] Juliet Antonio: And it was like a reason.

[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: Hold on.

[6:24] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember anything about that episode.

[6:26] Juliet Antonio: I'll have to God. One day I'll have to re-listen to Jekyll and Hyde now.

[6:30] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, the retelling of murder murder is hilarious.

[6:33] Juliet Antonio: Anyway, okay. So for number nine, we have episode 199, Winnie the Pooh featuring Grace Aki.

[6:41] Juliet Antonio: So we're finally getting Grace Aki on here, this time with her entry into the Five Timers Club, which was well deserved.

[6:47] Juliet Antonio: I feel like this episode had equal parts fun and unhingedness.

[6:51] Juliet Antonio: Uh fun because everybody got to relive their childhood memories of favorite Winnie the Pooh songs, characters, and movies, what character they were most like, and unhinged because of comments like hashtag twink ee or uh but I always love it when you guys discover uh not discover cover a musical for kids that either isn't a Disney property or isn't a well-known Disney property, and with Winnie the Pooh, it didn't feel like Disney's other Broadway cash cows, it felt like a show with heart, and everyone's inner child really came forth for a really heartwarming ride in the nostalgia train.

[7:24] Andrew DeWolf: No, I agree.

[7:24] Andrew DeWolf: That episode's great.

[7:26] Juliet Antonio: Like once again, I'm gonna talk about the editing thing, the cheeky underwear conversation, which is just me joking around at the start of that episode.

[7:34] Juliet Antonio: And then Bree's like, where am I gonna put this?

[7:36] Juliet Antonio: You guys reference it too much for us to not cut it.

[7:39] Juliet Antonio: So I'm like, just put it at the end.

[7:40] Juliet Antonio: Just put it at the end as its own conversation.

[7:43] Juliet Antonio: There you go.

[7:44] Juliet Antonio: And that was a cute little aside. I enjoyed it.

[7:45] Juliet Antonio: I thought it was a good conversation.

[7:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, I love that episode for all the reasons you do as well.

[7:53] Juliet Antonio: Um, yeah.

[7:54] Juliet Antonio: And it was weird um when we went to New York that they're just shoving those paperworks for at Broadway con at people to go see the Winnie the Pooh off Broadway show.

[8:03] Juliet Antonio: They were dressed up as Winnie the Pooh, and yeah, I was like, hey, I did promotion for you guys.

[8:08] Andrew DeWolf: Should I I should get some free tickets?

[8:10] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, get some free tickets.

[8:12] Andrew DeWolf: Grace could probably hook you up with that too somehow.

[8:14] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, she could.

[8:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[8:16] Juliet Antonio: Alright. Number eight.

[8:17] Juliet Antonio: We have episode 177, High Society, featuring Robbie Rossell.

[8:23] Juliet Antonio: Oh, this is a good one.

[8:24] Andrew DeWolf: I saw Jessica Safe.

[8:28] Juliet Antonio: High Society.

[8:29] Juliet Antonio: I remember we did not like this one, I don't think.

[8:32] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[8:32] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no, no, no.

[8:35] Juliet Antonio: So uh episodes about mediocre musicals can be entertaining, especially with the right guest.

[8:41] Juliet Antonio: And Robbie was a hoot and a half on this one.

[8:44] Juliet Antonio: And what we got to learn on this episode was sometimes how a musical project aimed at a star vehicle.

[8:51] Juliet Antonio: I forget what the lady's name was, but she wanted to do The Sound of Music, and then Rebecca Luker got it because this lady was like, no, I changed my mind.

[8:58] Juliet Antonio: I want to do my own thing and I want to do High Society.

[9:01] Juliet Antonio: It shows how these projects can go off the rails when said stars change their mind about what they want to do.

[9:06] Juliet Antonio: And we also learned how so-so shows can inspire about some creativity elsewhere.

[9:10] Juliet Antonio: There's uh Anna Kendrick's performance for the Broadway Leading Ladies concert, and Robbie's set list for his cabaret, which we hear a little bit of in the episode from his album.

[9:20] Juliet Antonio: And this brings us some comfort for people who make art in that musicals which are forgotten don't entirely go to waste and can be used for more than audition cuts.

[9:29] Juliet Antonio: And plus, we also had some great tangents with Robbie, since when a musical's so boring, there's really only so much you can beat a dead horse.

[9:36] Andrew DeWolf: And we were also introduced to an awfully designed poster from the 90s with the cats in a sailboat that now lives in my nightmares, rent-free.

[9:44] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[9:45] Andrew DeWolf: I really don't know.

[9:47] Andrew DeWolf: There's no reason why.

[9:49] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe it's because uh I'm not I don't even remember her.

[9:52] Juliet Antonio: Uh Tracy, yeah, Tracy or Grace Kelly.

[9:55] Juliet Antonio: She has to make her own gelical choice of which man she's choosing.

[9:58] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[10:00] Andrew DeWolf: Cats is on Broadway.

[10:00] Juliet Antonio: I'm trying to think of some logic here, but there probably is none.

[10:03] Juliet Antonio: They didn't need to be cats.

[10:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, they did not.

[10:06] Juliet Antonio: Great choice. Great episode.

[10:07] Juliet Antonio: We gotta have Robbie on again.

[10:08] Andrew DeWolf: This is just reminding me of people I need to email to have back up.

[10:11] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, please have Robbie on. He was so much fun and he was a delight.

[10:14] Juliet Antonio: And that episode of you guys uh discussing Broadway conspiracy theories is a really fun little side quest episode, too.

[10:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that was during the wandering years for Andrew, uh, where he had to leave for a couple weeks.

[10:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um I remember that.

[10:26] Andrew DeWolf: That was uh a bit of a rush to put together, and Robbie stepped up to the plate there.

[10:30] Jess: I am very grateful to Robbie Roselle.

[10:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, that episode was good.

[10:35] Andrew DeWolf: But now I'm also angry at it because it taught me that Mandy Patinkin fucks up um J. Hazel and the uh Secret Garden.

[10:35] Juliet Antonio: Secret Garden?

[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, if you look what was it?

[10:45] Andrew DeWolf: He forgot a word or something?

[10:46] Juliet Antonio: No, no, he came in too early.

[10:49] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, oops.

[10:50] Juliet Antonio: And I left it in the album.

[10:52] Juliet Antonio: And now I can't unhear it.

[10:53] Andrew DeWolf: Thanks, Robbie.

[10:54] Juliet Antonio: Hey, if it can happen to Mandy, it can happen to anyone.

[10:57] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[10:57] Jess: Alright, what's the next one?

[10:59] Juliet Antonio: Alright, number seven on the list.

[11:00] Juliet Antonio: We have episode 200, The Sound of Music.

[11:05] Juliet Antonio: You guys finally did it.

[11:06] Juliet Antonio: The Rogers and Hammerstein Behemoth that Christopher Plummer infamously called SNM.

[11:13] Juliet Antonio: Alright, so I understand why you guys space out class the classic musicals, but this was the first one we had in a long time, and I was so excited when we got this notification.

[11:23] Juliet Antonio: And here we get to compare and contrast the musical in its three versions, which isn't something that gets done a lot.

[11:28] Juliet Antonio: The original stage show, which I enjoy, frankly, the movie, which Jess correct, that is the best version, and the live TV adaptation, which I have mixed feelings on, like most people.

[11:38] Juliet Antonio: It's a rare example of the movie being better than the original source material.

[11:42] Juliet Antonio: And getting to hear unhinged letterbox reviews about an iconic piece of theater that's lasted through so many people's childhoods was hilarious.

[11:51] Juliet Antonio: I will say, um, the only part that made me raise my eyebrows and go, hmm, was Jess's opinion on uh Baroness Schrader.

[11:59] Jess: Because when I hear, I think of how she's portrayed in the stage musical, and I was like, I don't have much sympathy for someone who basically said, eh, the Nazis don't bother me that much, but I digress.

[12:08] Andrew DeWolf: Good episode.

[12:09] Jess: No, I get what you mean, but I think what I mean is in the traditional sense of narrative girlfriends.

[12:15] Andrew DeWolf: She's not the stepmom from the Parent Trap.

[12:18] Jess: She's the way that she kind of is in the movie.

[12:21] Andrew DeWolf: Gotcha.

[12:21] Jess: Alright.

[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: She's just kind of normal evil instead of like movie evil.

[12:26] Jess: Okay, I can get that now.

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[12:27] Jess: It's more sunny.

[12:32] Andrew DeWolf: That's a good one.

[12:33] Jess: I love that one.

[12:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm glad when those landmark episodes hit, I'm glad that they hit well with people that listen to the show, sincerely.

[12:41] Jess: I'm always worried, like is this gonna be 200 episode worry worthy?

[12:46] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that one is though.

[12:47] Jess: That one really is.

[12:48] Andrew DeWolf: You guys picked a good choice.

[12:49] Jess: Now, number six on the list.

[12:51] Andrew DeWolf: We have episode 207, The Pirates of Penzance.

[12:56] Jess: Um, so as Musicals with Cheese transition into its brief opera era, because I think after this was Magic Flute, and then kind of went away from opera for a while.

[13:07] Andrew DeWolf: The podcast covered its first Yes, Mozart Laparock.

[13:10] Jess: This podcast covered its first Gilbert and Sullivan with Pirates of Penzance.

[13:14] Andrew DeWolf: And I was happy to see this because Gilbert and Sullivan have soft spots in my heart with some of their pieces, but I'll be honest, it's not an era of musical theater I know too much about.

[13:22] Jess: And I was very impressed that you managed to find a review of Pirates from that era when it debuted.

[13:27] Andrew DeWolf: And another episode that shows how not all early musical theater ages poorly, and how it shows that thirst is eternal with Kevin Klein in particular.

[13:37] Jess: And it also points out how we don't always need to have modern references mixed into a show.

[13:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like with Pirate King Jack Sparrow, which why Anthony Warlow, why choices were made.

[13:49] Jess: Man, I'm glad you like that episode.

[13:51] Andrew DeWolf: I'm so glad you liked that episode.

[13:53] Jess: We gotta do more opera.

[13:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.

[13:56] Jess: Maybe we should do a proper episode on Lob OM.

[13:58] Andrew DeWolf: Because we kinda did one in our first run episode.

[14:01] Jess: Maybe that would be a good one for 2023.

[14:03] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like our first like three episodes we could just fully redo.

[14:07] Jess: Oh, I'm like, we were already redid Rent.

[14:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um we could redo the part of the Rent first episode where we did Lobo M.

[14:18] Jess: cover Labo M.

[14:19] Andrew DeWolf: We could redo that too.

[14:20] Jess: Yeah, Loboham's good.

[14:21] Andrew DeWolf: You could definitely find a pro shot of it somewhere, maybe even do bootlegs of the Boz Lerman one exist.

[14:26] Jess: That's not bootleg.

[14:27] Andrew DeWolf: There's a pro shot of that.

[14:28] Jess: It's just very hard to get nowadays.

[14:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, gotcha.

[14:31] Jess: Gotcha.

[14:32] Andrew DeWolf: Just as less open with how many of those I have.

[14:40] Jess: But I know we're talking about different kind of pirates as we discuss Pirates of Penzance.

[14:45] Andrew DeWolf: No one ever drew Andrew as a pirate.

[14:46] Jess: I'm a little upset.

[14:47] Andrew DeWolf: We put a call to action out there, and no one did it.

[14:51] Jess: Hey, if you guys want to draw Jess and Andrew and Bree as pirates, this is your sign to do it now, because it wasn't done before.

[14:57] Andrew DeWolf: So go do now.

[14:58] Jess: Yeah, yeah.

[14:59] Andrew DeWolf: We're gonna cry now.

[15:01] Jess: Cry your salty tears into the salty sea.

[15:05] Andrew DeWolf: Number five.

[15:06] Jess: Bree, you're correct.

[15:08] Andrew DeWolf: Episode 218, Home on the Range.

[15:10] Jess: Made it on first.

[15:12] Andrew DeWolf: Alrighty.

[15:17] Jess: Now, I remember before you guys officially covered this movie, Andrew would mention Home on the Range, and Jess was consistently trying to shut Andrew up, or at least put him off and talking about this movie.

[15:28] Andrew DeWolf: Considering this is an Andrew episode.

[15:31] Jess: The director follows Jess on Twitter.

[15:33] Andrew DeWolf: And I kept wondering, why is he not letting him talk?

[15:36] Jess: Is this movie really awful and just doesn't want the director to hear the comments?

[15:40] Andrew DeWolf: Then the actual episode came out and we learned that it is a solid, not bad.

[15:45] Jess: We got to learn about the movie development process, and I feel like this really gets swept under the rug because it's part of Disney's, I think you could say it's its second dark age.

[15:55] Andrew DeWolf: But I feel like some of the music is pretty good, which isn't surprising considering they got Alan Menken, no-brainer, and they got Katie Lang to perform for God's sake.

[16:03] Jess: I mean, Katie Lang should be more famous than she is, but that's for another podcast.

[16:08] Andrew DeWolf: And the idea of Andrew and Jess dressing up as Alameda Slim and his nephews for Halloween is hilarious, and it needs to happen one year.

[16:17] Jess: Also, I don't really have the look.

[16:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I do.

[16:20] Jess: And as an aside, I never put bonus episodes on this list.

[16:23] Andrew DeWolf: I don't put the live streams or the Patreons or the Patreon exclusive series.

[16:29] Jess: But the bonus interview with the director was really well done and shows how many movies are a labor of love, regardless of if they succeed or fail.

[16:35] Andrew DeWolf: And he was a pretty chill guest.

[16:36] Jess: I was really surprised, but pleasantly so.

[16:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, talk shit with D about Doug Walker.

[16:41] Jess: Like I set it up and he knocked those pins down.

[16:44] Andrew DeWolf: I appreciated that.

[16:46] Jess: Strike.

[16:47] Andrew DeWolf: Also, I'm just so sad that that short that he mentioned with Alameda Slim's nephews doesn't exist.

[16:51] Jess: That would have been fun.

[16:52] Andrew DeWolf: I almost want his sequel pitch to exist.

[16:55] Jess: What was the sequel pitch again?

[16:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I forget.

[16:57] Jess: I just remember liking it being like, oh, that sounds like fun.

[17:01] Andrew DeWolf: Alameda Slim like gets all of the animals he can yodel to when he gets out of jail or something.

[17:06] Jess: Well, he wanted to cause the January 6th Capital Riots.

[17:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um remember three days away.

[17:12] Jess: No Alameda Slim's coming.

[17:18] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[17:19] Jess: Alright, continue, Julia.

[17:20] Andrew DeWolf: Number four, episode 214, Over the Garden Wall.

[17:24] Jess: Ooh.

[17:25] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[17:25] Jess: Perfect for Halloween and for spooky month in general.

[17:28] Andrew DeWolf: I know some people say this doesn't really count as a movie musical, but I remember there was a local community college on TikTok putting this on for their spring show not too long ago, so I guess this counts.

[17:39] Jess: I believe this was the first time you guys covered a musical that was a mini-series, which is interesting to see how the songs are spaced out over the course of each episode, and considering each episode is less than half an hour.

[17:50] Andrew DeWolf: And it was cool to learn about how Over the Garden Wall was developed, its inspiration from Dante's Inferno, and original ideas that were scrapped.

[17:57] Jess: For example, making episode nine, how that was originally supposed to be the pilot of the show, which I'm glad they didn't go in that direction.

[18:03] Andrew DeWolf: And plus we got a fun little moment of chaos discussing the Star Wars holiday special, which considering how sobering Over the Garden Wall can be, given proper analysis, was a nice little reprieve.

[18:13] Jess: And this just goes to show that animation, we'll say it once and we'll say it again, doesn't necessarily need to be for kids.

[18:19] Andrew DeWolf: Looking at you, Academy of Motion Pictures and Sciences.

[18:22] Jess: Looking at you, Bob Chapek.

[18:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um I love this episode, yeah.

[18:28] Jess: Like I forgot I did this.

[18:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like I was like, we covered Over the Garden Wall.

[18:32] Jess: Literally was my first because that was during my COVID fog like months.

[18:39] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just like, I could be doing an episode, but I also could just be, you know, going insane.

[18:44] Jess: Um, but now I'm so glad this made the list.

[18:47] Andrew DeWolf: That makes me so happy.

[18:48] Jess: Like our, I'm always worried about our theme episodes, like when we do like Halloween episodes or Christmas episodes, because if you feel like you're forcing something into a time, then you kind of, it's hard to get the passion up, but I think this one worked.

[18:59] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, and especially because horror musicals are a genre that don't really get explored anymore, and I wish they did.

[19:05] Jess: I really wish they did.

[19:06] Andrew DeWolf: More horror plays, too.

[19:08] Jess: It's just a dearth in terms of the theater genre.

[19:11] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[19:11] Jess: Episode, no well, not episode number three.

[19:14] Andrew DeWolf: Uh number three in the top 10 stories.

[19:16] Jess: Top three is episode one hundred and ninety-four, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory slash Willy Wonka on the Chocolate Factory featuring Pushing Up Roses.

[19:24] Andrew DeWolf: Ah I love this one.

[19:26] Jess: Here I thought we had a great episode about what can get lost in transformation when adapting a beloved film/book into a stage musical.

[19:34] Andrew DeWolf: But not only that, we also get to see what gets lost in translation when a show opens on the West End and transfers to Broadway.

[19:40] Jess: And Roses was a great guest.

[19:42] Andrew DeWolf: It's fun to hear all of you commiserate about your childhood memories of this movie and to hear how those memories were ruined by this very imperfect show when even Christian Borle can't save.

[19:52] Jess: Not even Jack O'Brien can save.

[19:54] Andrew DeWolf: When there's a strong heart connection with the source material, it makes it even sadder when the stage can't do it justice.

[19:59] Jess: Yeah, that's a good episode.

[20:00] Andrew DeWolf: I still love it when they run around an empty room and pretend that they're doing something.

[20:07] Jess: Yeah, no set.

[20:08] Andrew DeWolf: Basically no set.

[20:11] Jess: I love when they literally murder the children.

[20:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's funny you should say that when you're talking.

[20:15] Jess: He sent me a TikTok of when the squirrels tear Veruca Salt apart, and he's like, did you know about this?

[20:21] Andrew DeWolf: This is theater.

[20:22] Jess: And I went, oh yes, I did.

[20:27] Andrew DeWolf: But I think they were going for the brutalness of Roald Dahl's books with how the bad guys always get their comeuppance in really violent ways.

[20:33] Jess: But just we're terrifying.

[20:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, killing kids.

[20:36] Jess: Andrew loves, for those who don't know, Andrew loves shows where children are murdered.

[20:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's a second thing in the whole world.

[20:44] Jess: Oh no, Julian.

[20:46] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't say that.

[20:48] Jess: No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

[20:51] Andrew DeWolf: She's, she's a, how old was she?

[20:53] Jess: She was a teenager when that happened, right?

[20:54] Andrew DeWolf: She was like, oh god.

[20:56] Jess: Okay.

[20:57] Andrew DeWolf: It's a real bummer.

[20:58] Jess: Wait a fake that turn, Jess.

[20:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um back onto our list.

[21:01] Jess: I agree with the topic.

[21:03] Andrew DeWolf: I think I love that Pushing Up Roses came on to this because this was a Patreon request, and because of delays, we kept pushing it back, and I felt so bad for that patron.

[21:11] Jess: I'm like, it's coming, but I promise you're gonna want to wait for this guest.

[21:15] Andrew DeWolf: This guest is worth it.

[21:16] Jess: And she was in every conceivable way.

[21:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um and she's now, I've had dinner with her.

[21:22] Jess: She's great.

[21:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, she's a good human being.

[21:24] Jess: Um, which is, and I got their art right there.

[21:27] Andrew DeWolf: Look at that.

[21:27] Jess: Oh wow, that's theirs?

[21:28] Andrew DeWolf: That's amazing.

[21:29] Jess: Yeah, but it's over.

[21:31] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, what we got.

[21:32] Jess: Number two, episode 176, Titanic the Musical featuring Ayana Prescott.

[21:38] Andrew DeWolf: Having Ayana on for this episode was an obvious no-brainer.

[21:42] Jess: I appreciated how we got to learn some history about the Titanic itself, along with the backstory of how the musical came to be, which I realized was much like the documentary that you watched just in preparation for this episode.

[21:53] Andrew DeWolf: And considering how iconic Ayana is on theater Twitter, I was really impressed, delighted, and relieved that she gelled with your senses of humor right away.

[22:02] Jess: And I always love it when you guys cover Yeston and Kopit.

[22:05] Andrew DeWolf: And this work, this work of theirs, it really gets overshadowed just due to the success of the James Cameron film and really poor timing.

[22:12] Jess: But thanks to this episode, Ayana's passion, you guys introduced us to a really gorgeous score.

[22:16] Andrew DeWolf: And what I also realized is unique about this episode is because Ayana was writing for Variety at the time, and so it was interesting to have around for reviews to see her reactions as a critic to the writings of Ben Brantley.

[22:31] Jess: Oh my gosh.

[22:32] Andrew DeWolf: Sometimes I'm amazed at some of the polls that we get on this show, especially this year.

[22:36] Jess: We had a lot of pretty cool people on that I, yeah.

[22:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um so this one was, it felt special in the moment.

[22:44] Jess: I agree.

[22:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I hope for that pr, uh Titanic revival soon.

[22:49] Jess: Oh my god.

[22:49] Andrew DeWolf: Let Ayana have a hand in it somehow, or I won't trust it.

[22:53] Jess: But uh yeah, hopefully.

[22:55] Andrew DeWolf: It's been God, how many years since it was originally like almost thirty now?

[22:59] Jess: Yeah, it was, it's been a long time.

[23:00] Andrew DeWolf: It was supposed to get a revival in 2020, but then the Pangea happened and the pandemic Lavato, yeah.

[23:06] Jess: Alright.

[23:07] Andrew DeWolf: Now, for the number one spot, we have episode 201, Sweet Charity featuring the band Phoenix.

[23:16] Jess: What?

[23:18] Andrew DeWolf: Trolling.

[23:20] Jess: No, I'm not.

[23:21] Andrew DeWolf: I'm really not.

[23:23] Jess: As soon as I heard this episode, I'm not even kidding.

[23:25] Andrew DeWolf: I'm like, this is gonna be my number one for the whole year.

[23:27] Jess: Even before Jess messaged me about this list, I automatically knew this is my favorite.

[23:31] Andrew DeWolf: So we got to meet Andrew's bandmates, Ben and Grell from the band.

[23:35] Jess: Thanks.

[23:36] Andrew DeWolf: And honestly, I really want them to come back on the podcast more because they were such great guests with great rapport.

[23:42] Jess: And it was also an important episode because Jess was right.

[23:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's been 200 episodes.

[23:46] Jess: We had to show what Andrew learned, and he did a great job of explaining Bob Fosse's legacy.

[23:51] Jess: And an episode that went back to the roots of explaining musical theater to some relative newbies, only with Andrew being a bit more seasoned as a musical theater aficionado.

[24:00] Jess: And plus you get to hear some music from the band at the end, which was really, really fun to listen to. Uh, any notes, Andrew?

[24:07] Andrew DeWolf: Do you I I think I d I agree with that. That was what I was expecting to.

[24:10] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say justice for By Jeeves.

[24:15] Jess: You really wanted By Jeeves to be in there?

[24:17] Andrew DeWolf: I want to By Jeeves on the list. I remember that I thought that that was last year, but I remember it was this year, and I I thought that that episode was hilarious.

[24:27] Jess: He's stewing somewhere right now for the fact that this isn't on the list. Sorry, Joseph, I love you, buddy, but Andrew.

[24:33] Andrew DeWolf: That's my honorable mention.

[24:35] Jess: Juliet was really big on the educational and like uh emotional attachment ones. And that was us trolling and fucking around for two hours.

[24:46] Jess: Trying, basically trying like hell to talk about anything except By Jeeves. I get why it's not on the list. But when do they get to the banjo factory?

[24:56] Andrew DeWolf: That was an episode where I got legitimately mad because as you guys were trying to explain the story, I was like, there's no way it can be like Bertie Worcester is very stupid, but there's no way this show could be like this show is stupider than Bertie Worcester is.

[25:09] Andrew DeWolf: Like, oh man, just uh Andrew Lloyd Webber just needs to stop, but that's for another podcast at another time. I don't want to bring down the mood.

[25:16] Jess: Um, quick question before we move on to cheese ratings. Do you feel that any of these episodes from this year has replaced any of the top ten you did last year for our all timers? You don't have to re-link your list, but I was just curious if there was like one that's like, oh yeah, that's that's taken in that full top ten place.

[25:34] Juliet Antonio: God, I don't know. I really that that first list was one that because this is my first time on the podcast, I spent a lot of days curating that and editing that and mulling over that, and it got to a point where I was pretty happy with with the results.

[25:50] Juliet Antonio: I mean, looking back, Jekyll and Hyde was like a really strange pick for me to do for my number 10, but every time I read my reasoning why, I'm like, no, in terms of a starter episode, that's pretty good. So, yeah, I don't know if I would merge these two lists. I think I'd just keep them as their own separate entities.

[26:02] Jess: Fair enough. Um, we have not done well enough to top anything we did previously. Alright, what's our cheese rating?

[26:09] Andrew DeWolf: Shut up.

[26:10] Jess: Okay. So onto the cheese. It's only getting worse, Andrew. So, as per usual, we have one for Jess, one for Andrew, one for Brie, and one for the guests overall that we've had in these seasons.

[26:21] Juliet Antonio: Okay, uh, I'll just go from the bottom up. So, for the guests, I am going with the best cheese rating from out all the guests was from Matt in the Nightman Cometh episode, because I thought his cheese rating was specifically apt. It was Cheese Whiz. Bad but with a certain charm, which I felt perfectly described that episode of Always Sunny in Philadelphia as an always sunny fan, and it perfectly describes the Nightman Cometh as a musical.

[26:45] Jess: Okay. That's a really good one.

[26:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Forgot we did that.

[26:48] Juliet Antonio: So uh now for these next two cheese ratings. Um they're shared by two of you but in different episodes. So Brie, your best cheese rating is Swiss cheese when you did the ranking best cinematic universe for the Little Drummer Boy because of plot holes that were not in the Bible.

[27:05] Andrew DeWolf: True.

[27:07] Juliet Antonio: No one just made me laugh when I heard it. And Andrew, your top cheese rating was also Swiss cheese, but it was for the Magic Flute episode when you picked Swiss cheese that is listened to the Magic Flute for 24 hours on loop. The fact that you found that on the internet was amazing.

[27:25] Juliet Antonio: It was perfect. And Jess, your cheese rating is from Notre Dame de Paris, when you picked string cheese that is, I don't even know what the notes are, but you were saying torn apart, and then you just went into the whole song. That was for that was that made me laugh.

[27:42] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough. Um because you put so much passion into it.

[27:46] Juliet Antonio: Um, I I that song is passionate. If you've heard it, it's like all passion rock. Um I don't disagree with any of these. I think Andrew's Swiss cheese that had the Magic Flute played in it. Like that is top tier. I I think that's hard to beat.

[28:01] Jess: Um, alright. Is there any other special ones? Are we uh for cheese ratings?

[28:05] Juliet Antonio: Uh no, that isn't for the cheese rating portion of this episode. We do have one last segment, and technically this is where a lot of folks may hear this, but Brie is leaving our show with not this show this week, but the show next week, which is Dream Girls, will be Brie's final show.

[28:21] Jess: Um, and because of that, Jules, you have compiled a list of your favorite Brie moments over the years.

[28:26] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, I have.

[28:29] Jess: Stop. This is so sweet.

[28:32] Juliet Antonio: So um Jess asked me to pick five, and I went through the spreadsheet and I remembered a couple episodes where you stood out, and I came up with it with a short list, short and sweet.

[28:43] Juliet Antonio: Okay, so I'm gonna go back to the Discord because Jess asked me to send him a rough copy originally. Uh just in case you're gonna do it. We were gonna record your last episode last week and things happen.

[28:53] Jess: Yeah.

[28:53] Juliet Antonio: Okay, so uh number five, Brie and Too Much Rum. So at the end of Sweet Charity, uh Brie, you briefly unmuted to comment on a great discussion, only admit to admit you had too much rum and you were gonna put yourself back on mute now.

[29:07] Andrew DeWolf: It's okay, Brie. You held your liquor really well.

[29:10] Brie: Thank you.

[29:11] Juliet Antonio: I did not did not remember that episode, I don't think.

[29:16] Andrew DeWolf: Could have fooled.

[29:17] Juliet Antonio: That'll do it. Uh let me see. Discord print is very small. Okay, number four. We have to give a shout out to just Brie Views in general. Because of you, Brie, we got a new segment that a lot of people quite enjoyed. And it's always fun to see New York City theater critics get taken down a peg.

[29:32] Juliet Antonio: And you, with your voice are able to make the high brown nonsense of Ben Brantley and Jesse Green sound palatable. Your incredulity at their stupidity also made the reviews a lot funnier.

[29:44] Brie: Thank you.

[29:45] Juliet Antonio: You're welcome. I can barely read 'em most of the time.

[29:48] Brie: It's fine.

[29:49] Juliet Antonio: It's fine. Like fun fact, the first half of every episode, I was reading and like searching pronunciations of words, so I didn't sound horrible. So if you're ever wondering what I'm doing, it was that.

[30:04] Jess: It's funny you bring up pronunciation of words because I'm gonna you'll see, it's all gonna be good.

[30:09] Juliet Antonio: All shall be clear.

[30:10] Jess: Okay.

[30:11] Juliet Antonio: I think I do because I know it it I'm not gonna spoil it.

[30:16] Jess: Yes, yes. I hooked up and Andrew agreed with me.

[30:19] Andrew DeWolf: I uh whatever.

[30:21] Juliet Antonio: Alright. Number three, um, childhood trauma. So in one episode, you admitted to not being able to see a certain musical.

[30:29] Juliet Antonio: I was really trying to go back through the episodes and find what it was, but I couldn't find it.

[30:32] Brie: It was Rent because you weren't.

[30:34] Juliet Antonio: It was Rent.

[30:35] Brie: Yeah, because you weren't allowed to see it as a kid, even though you really wanted to. So hopefully this podcast was able to give you some insight as to what you missed, and if you were able to see it, or if you're planning to go see it, I hope you enjoy it one day, or I hope you did enjoy it if you've already seen it.

[30:47] Brie: Thank you. I have come to the conclusion that I probably won't like it.

[30:51] Jess: Okay. Well, hey, at least you don't know how to finish it.

[30:53] Andrew DeWolf: Thanks, Andrew and Jess.

[30:58] Juliet Antonio: We spoiled another one.

[31:01] Juliet Antonio: Alright. Number two, falling slowly. So Brie, we know you're a talented editor, but much to our delight, we found out you were a talented singer as well.

[31:10] Juliet Antonio: And we all happily learned in the Once episode that fact when we heard a recording of you and your partner covering Falling Slowly, you guys sounded positively angelic, and it was a really sweet moment.

[31:20] Brie: Oh, thank you.

[31:22] Juliet Antonio: Welcome. I really enjoyed it. I was like, oh, it's so sweet.

[31:25] Juliet Antonio: Okay. Number one. Alright. So Brie. When they did Sweet Charity, you were made fun of during Letterboxd One Star or Five Star for mispronouncing the word F R U G F-R-U-G frog.

[31:39] Juliet Antonio: However, in the context of Sweet Charity, it is actually pronounced frog the way you pronounced it and not frog. You were right. Jess was wrong, because that is the way Bob Fosse insisted that it be pronounced when doing his show.

[31:55] Brie: You have indicated you're welcome. You were right all along.

[31:59] Brie: Thank you. I will leave now.

[32:03] Jess: This is her ultimate win of reviews.

[32:06] Andrew DeWolf: That's my ultimate win.

[32:11] Juliet Antonio: What if Bob Fosse was wrong?

[32:12] Andrew DeWolf: I like that, Andrew. What if Bob Fosse was the wrong one?

[32:15] Juliet Antonio: He's not always made the best decisions in his life.

[32:19] Andrew DeWolf: What if the last year I couldn't like sleep and I've been stressing and like uh killing myself over the fact, not killing, but like dying over the fact that I pronounced it wrong and you never told me.

[32:30] Juliet Antonio: Damn. That was my bad. Um no regrets. Very funny moment right now. Way to go, Jess.

[32:35] Jess: Um, I stand by my choices. Juliet, what a wonderful list.

[32:42] Juliet Antonio: That was fantastic. Um, you thought of so many episodes I forgot even existed that now I'm not gonna re-listen to them.

[32:48] Jess: But I will acknowledge that they exist now.

[32:51] Andrew DeWolf: You never re-listen to them, no.

[32:53] Jess: No, that's rough. Um I'm so grateful that you keep doing this. I I know it's uh a lot of work, especially a Rankin/Bass episodes. Those are probably a real bitch and a half to do.

[33:04] Juliet Antonio: You didn't know.

[33:05] Jess: I did shorthand for those.

[33:07] Juliet Antonio: You did such a you do such an amazing job. Um, sincerely, we're grateful to have you. Um, and it's always so much fun to ASMR your name at the end of every recording.

[33:17] Jess: Uh Juliet.

[33:20] Juliet Antonio: Um am I getting there? Will I officially like dame an audio?

[33:24] Jess: You wanna hire me? I'm a voice actor. I know some people we can make things happen.

[33:30] Juliet Antonio: I think that I uh as Rachel Chan once said, I could not sleep to your guys' voice.

[33:35] Jess: It's too chaotic.

[33:37] Juliet Antonio: I couldn't fall asleep to the episodes either. I did listen to them late at night, but they kept me up for an extra couple hours.

[33:42] Jess: So I don't know if that makes our show easier to listen to or harder to listen to.

[33:47] Juliet Antonio: But are too engaging to fall asleep to, yeah, that's what it is.

[33:51] Jess: Alright. On that note, Juliet, promote all your socials and things for people to find you at. Because I know you guys are all over the internet.

[33:57] Juliet Antonio: You can find me on Twitter at Juliet Thespiet. You can find me on Instagram at Aurora99. I have a podcast on YouTube called My Dad Listens to This, where my dad and I review albums in his music collection.

[34:07] Juliet Antonio: We recently reviewed the famous 90s J-pop group, Pizzicato 5, with their US debut album. And if you wonder why Jess whispers my name in ASMR, it's because I write scripts for ASMR voice actors on YouTube.

[34:19] Juliet Antonio: To name a few date audio, Darien Audio, Eastgate Audio, and one collab that might be coming up in the future. And if you ever want to check out my scripts, I try to sneak in at least one musical theater Easter egg per script, so see if you can spot them.

[34:31] Juliet Antonio: But other than that, that's my stuff. That's my spiel, and I will always be the keeper of the cheese.

[34:36] Jess: Hell yeah. Alright. We we will see you soon. Um, Juliet. Uh hopefully before next year, but we'll we'll see you. Um if there's another Patreon meetup, join the Patreon.

[34:48] Juliet Antonio: Oh yeah, join the Patreon. We're doing we're actually rebranding our Patreon when we're rebranding the whole show when Brie leaves. Things are gonna be changing around here.

[34:54] Jess: Um just because we have an excuse now. Um alright, we'll see you next time.

[35:02] Jess: On Musicals with Cheese. Bye, everybody.

[35:05] All: Bye.

[35:37] All: Happy New Year.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred