Skip to main content
BPN Logo
What Is Lighting Design? A Genealogy of People and Ideas

Discover the history and artistry behind stage lighting in a conversation with Michael Chybowski, author of What Is Lighting Design?: A Genealogy of People and Ideas... Read More

From the show: The Drama Book Show!

51 mins
12/5/25

About

Discover the history and artistry behind stage lighting in a conversation with Michael Chybowski, author of What Is Lighting Design?: A Genealogy of People and Ideas. Chybowski traces 500 years of innovation—from the Renaissance to today—showing how ideas, technology, and artistry have shaped the craft of lighting design and its role in performance. A celebrated freelance designer and Associate Professor at the University of Connecticut, Chybowski brings his extensive experience in theatre, opera, dance, and film to this illuminating discussion of how light transforms the stage.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:18] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Hello and welcome to The Drama Book Show.

[0:20] David Rigano: My name is David Rigano.

[0:21] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And today we are talking about "What Is Lighting Design? A Genealogy of People and Ideas" by Michael Chybowski.

[0:29] David Rigano: I don't know, Mark. What is "What Is Lighting Design? A Genealogy of People and Ideas" by Michael Chybowski?

[0:35] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I was hoping you'd tell me, David, as your dad is a lighting designer.

[0:38] David Rigano: My dad was a lighting designer.

[0:40] David Rigano: He did design the lights for our show.

[0:42] Mark-Eugene Garcia: He did design the lights for our show, "The Holy Cows of Creden, South Dakota."

[0:45] David Rigano: Yeah.

[0:46] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And it was in the Planet Connections festivity.

[0:48] David Rigano: Yes, he has come out of retirement for me twice.

[0:52] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Okay.

[0:53] David Rigano: Once was when I stage managed an off-Broadway production of "The Fantasticks" in 2005.

[1:01] David Rigano: And the other was for "The Holy Cows of Creden, South Dakota," which another fun thing about that was that it ran in the month of June, and we had a performance on June 13th, which is your birthday.

[1:14] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And his birthday.

[1:14] David Rigano: And his birthday.

[1:15] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Which is why you always call me dad.

[1:17] David Rigano: Yes.

[1:18] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Speaking of, you said that he's come out of retirement twice for you.

[1:21] David Rigano: Yes.

[1:22] Mark-Eugene Garcia: When are you going to come out for him?

[1:29] David Rigano: So we've had your dad do our lighting design.

[1:33] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[1:33] David Rigano: But it made me think of what are other shows that had some really stellar lighting design.

[1:38] Mark-Eugene Garcia: "Greyhouse."

[1:39] David Rigano: Oh my god, yeah.

[1:40] Mark-Eugene Garcia: That was so creepy.

[1:42] David Rigano: So creepy.

[1:43] David Rigano: I actually called my parents after I saw it, and I was like, I have to see this play again because there are threads that I need to follow, and then I never got to.

[1:53] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Not just the threads that were hanging on the stage or coming out of his leg.

[1:56] David Rigano: And I was like, but you, I was like, Dad, especially, you need to see this because there is so much that they did with lighting that felt like it was for mood, and it turned out that it was magic tricks.

[2:10] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[2:12] David Rigano: Like you would have a scene that was fully lit and you would see all of the walls, and then you would have a gloomy nighttime scene with lots of creepy shadows, and they were removing a wall so that someone could pop out of a sh and surprise you and scare the crap out of you.

[2:29] Mark-Eugene Garcia: It's interesting because I think what I know when I write, I don't think about lights usually.

[2:34] David Rigano: Uh-huh.

[2:35] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Unless it's like light shift to this scene or something like that, or if like a transition, but I don't really go into that process of it because it's not my forte or my part of the storytelling.

[2:44] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But then when I see it being used in something I've written and see the storytelling that happens in that lighting change, it's oh man, like you forget that it's part of the storytelling, it's not just the additive, it's not just it's oh yeah, an actual piece of the puzzle.

[3:01] David Rigano: But another thing is I think of "Goat Blood," yeah, in particular with yours, where lighting is oh yeah, so integral because you have a character who's not on stage, or at least who's not seen on stage for a minute.

[3:16] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So you that's a show where you want to have shadows to keep your audience guessing if the character is there or not, because the noise not just out of sight could grab you in a heart in a moment.

[3:27] David Rigano: Exactly.

[3:27] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And but I also I've frequently said, and I've said this to younger writers when I've been mentoring people, I don't think that it is our responsibility to write the lighting to the show.

[3:44] David Rigano: Just as I don't think it's our responsibility to write the sets or the staging.

[3:48] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And I think people are used to reading, especially older scripts where stage manager notes went into the published copies.

[3:55] David Rigano: So they're used to reading that someone crosses stage left.

[3:59] Mark-Eugene Garcia: They're used to reading that the light and I, I will do little things like stuff that is specifically supposed to happen in the dark, or like one of my plays has a very theatrical thing that we keep going back to, but every time the lighting has opened up a little bit.

[4:16] David Rigano: Well, that's really cool.

[4:17] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But I, but even then I really try not to tell the lighting designer how to do because they know better than they know, and they're gonna have better ideas.

[4:25] David Rigano: It's like telling an actor what to do.

[4:26] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Like you give them the idea of what to do, and then they add make it a fully three-dimensional thing.

[4:31] David Rigano: And that's what the lights, too.

[4:33] Mark-Eugene Garcia: But if you put out there, if you really put in the stage direction that it feels moody, even if you say there are shadows and we don't know what lurks beyond them, your lighting designer is then going to figure out how all of the things that we know nothing about, all of the tricks of the trade, that especially this is something my dad has always said if the lighting design is done well, you frequently don't notice it.

[5:02] David Rigano: Yeah.

[5:02] Mark-Eugene Garcia: True.

[5:03] David Rigano: That's what I feel theater is.

[5:04] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[5:05] David Rigano: Like a book writer doesn't get credit unless it's bad.

[5:07] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Um when he talks about what we do, unless it's a bad review.

[5:11] David Rigano: And so it's that too.

[5:12] Mark-Eugene Garcia: It's like you're, it's just part of the story.

[5:14] David Rigano: You're watching a musical number and the lighting is happening, like whether it's changing a location, whether it's flashing just for the spectacle of it all, it's part of the choreography.

[5:24] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Whether it's just calling your attention for a brief moment to someone else so that you can see someone's reaction to what's like that kind of little stuff.

[5:33] David Rigano: Again, you might not even notice that you were clocking it when it happened.

[5:38] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Exactly.

[5:39] David Rigano: Or even just color.

[5:40] Mark-Eugene Garcia: We recently saw a play that had a very happy musical number, and you're cheering along, and then at one moment the entire mood changes, and the whole stage turned red.

[5:52] David Rigano: Yeah.

[5:52] Mark-Eugene Garcia: For a very dark moment.

[5:54] David Rigano: And just that.

[5:56] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Like it changed the mood of the room and changed the mood of everyone in the audience who was cheering.

[6:03] David Rigano: It was very much "The Book of Mormon" when you're cheering along to that fourth song, and then you realize what it means, and like everything changes, and that's what it felt like.

[6:10] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And lighting will do that.

[6:12] David Rigano: Like music, like anything else, like any other spectacle, it is part of that storytelling.

[6:17] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And what I think is really great about this book is that we tend to think of lighting as such a 20th century thing.

[6:25] David Rigano: And he is explaining that theater makers have utilized light in whatever way they could harness it since people have been making theater.

[6:38] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah, yeah, no, truly.

[6:39] David Rigano: It's can it's focusing where the story is.

[6:41] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Let's focus on letting him tell us his story and jump on in.

[6:48] David Rigano: So thank you so much for joining.

[6:50] Mark-Eugene Garcia: I want to start by just asking the question on all of our minds.

[6:55] David Rigano: What is lighting design?

[6:59] Michael Chybowski: You have to read for 11 chapters first.

[7:02] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Okay.

[7:04] Michael Chybowski: There's two quotes that I think are important.

[7:06] Michael Chybowski: One is from Jean Rosenthal. What she said about it in a nutshell is lighting design is the imposing of quality on the scarcely visible air through which objects and people are seen.

[7:22] Michael Chybowski: That's I think that sums it up pretty well.

[7:25] Michael Chybowski: The only thing I would add from my own point of view is lighting design as the art or high craft of using light to show things to people in the way they are meant to be seen.

[7:41] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah, it did make sense to me.

[7:43] David Rigano: I like the way that they are meant to be seen.

[7:45] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Especially because I think in from theatrical situation to theatrical situation, what the way that they are meant to be seen changes.

[7:53] Michael Chybowski: Exactly.

[7:54] Mark-Eugene Garcia: So my second question is what is lighting design? Can you tell us a little bit about the book and why you decided to write it?

[8:00] Michael Chybowski: It was a little bit of a circuitous when I was in college.

[8:03] Michael Chybowski: No, I used to think I wanted to be a mathematician when I was in high school.

[8:07] Michael Chybowski: And but when I was a senior, I was in the theater one day, nobody was there, and I was on stage, and I looked over and there was this little ladder on the stage left going out to this door that I hadn't noticed before.

[8:19] Michael Chybowski: And it looked a little door going up there.

[8:22] Michael Chybowski: So I climbed up the ladder and I walked in the door, and there was this giant electrical panel.

[8:28] Michael Chybowski: And it was obviously like a big old auto-transformer board.

[8:31] Michael Chybowski: And I'd never seen such a thing before.

[8:33] Michael Chybowski: And I thought, wow, this is cool.

[8:36] Michael Chybowski: I never had a chance to do anything with it when I was there, but when I got to college, I just registered for all my math classes the first day, and I looked at the campus map and found the theater and wandered over and walked in, and I said, I want to learn about lighting.

[8:51] Michael Chybowski: And they said, okay.

[8:55] Michael Chybowski: And then I think a year and a half later, I designed my first show and quickly found out that I didn't know nearly as much as I thought I did.

[9:03] Michael Chybowski: And spent about a month digging myself out of it and thought, if I can have this great a time, having this shitty a time, then there's got to be something to this.

[9:15] Michael Chybowski: I hadn't been doing my math homework anyway, so I switched majors.

[9:20] Michael Chybowski: But I always wondered who thought of all this mathematics stuff anyway, like where did all this come from?

[9:26] Michael Chybowski: I think when I was in graduate school, the third year we didn't, we could drop one design area.

[9:31] Michael Chybowski: So I had all this time, so I looked it in the catalog and stumbling through it, and it has happened upon a course in the history of mathematics.

[9:39] Michael Chybowski: And it was like, oh, I can finally find out.

[9:42] Michael Chybowski: So I took it and quickly found myself if I had a couple of hours off, I would wander over there and just pull a book off the shelf and start to read it.

[9:52] Michael Chybowski: And it was like so much fun.

[9:54] Michael Chybowski: And then at about the same time in the Yale Drama Library, there we I pulled a book off a shelf that was written by Joel Rubin called "The Development of Lighting Technology in the United States from 1900 to 1950," which was his PhD thesis.

[10:12] Michael Chybowski: It's an amazing book.

[10:13] Michael Chybowski: And these sort of history of mathematics and this sort of looking at each other.

[10:19] Michael Chybowski: And the history of mathematics, I started reading more about it, and then that led to the history of nuclear physics, and then the history of quantum mechanics, and then the history of modern cosmology.

[10:32] Michael Chybowski: And then I said it's like, I wonder if lighting design is the same way.

[10:37] Michael Chybowski: And so I started looking into it, and of course it is.

[10:40] Michael Chybowski: Because it's not just like one person thing.

[10:43] Michael Chybowski: So there's a lot of people think about the thickness of this, and it's all cumulative.

[10:48] Michael Chybowski: And the more I just looked into the history of the lighting design, the more I learned about what it was and did.

[10:54] Michael Chybowski: And so I started teaching it to my students, and then eventually I assembled enough to where I actually thought I had something to say about it.

[11:03] Mark-Eugene Garcia: And that's it.

[11:05] David Rigano: And you do intend for this to be used as a textbook.

[11:08] Michael Chybowski: It can be.

[11:09] Michael Chybowski: I'd use it, it seems to be helpful.

[11:12] Michael Chybowski: At least a minimum to give people an appreciation that this didn't just drop out of the sky.

[11:21] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[11:22] David Rigano: So when you're talking about all of this, starting with the history of math and everything that comes out of math, and then moving over to the history of lighting, what were some of the things that you learned in the writing of this book?

[11:37] Michael Chybowski: I think one of the I have notes, just to make sure I don't forget anything, but one of them is that the use of light has been a response to the cult what the culture of each period thought was important.

[11:59] Michael Chybowski: During the Renaissance, light was associated with joy and freedom, intellectual freedom from the church.

[12:17] Michael Chybowski: And they had parades, and the princes of all the city-states paid for festivals of light to show off their power and to celebrate the fact that they were free, intellectually, things were good.

[12:30] Michael Chybowski: And it was all, it also coincided with the development of single-point perspective.

[12:36] Michael Chybowski: And like the court artists who were designing these festivals were also engineers, mathematicians, they designed the fortifications, they were sculptors, they did, and they were the nexus of all of the learning that was pouring in from like when the Constantinople collapsed, all the classical texts came from there to Italy.

[12:56] Michael Chybowski: The artists read them, and it took about 250 years to develop single-point perspective. But it seems natural that these people who spent all this time learning geometry and codifying how perspective worked would move it into the theater for these festivals, the blow that has human in it. And the light was used to enhance the spatial qualities of paintings, as well as to promote joy to show the audience this ideal world, that this matter were more pure somehow than the one we have. So that was the first impulse. After Newton came along, and this original impulse had sort of run its course on the Baroque, the Newton caused people to think that the entire universe would be explained as long as we look closely enough, like the whole clockwork universe.

So the cultural impulse changed to examine nature, horrified everything. So light now became used as people now want to use natural light. Like how to use natural light. 150 years were spent trying to figure out how to use natural light from about 1750 to about 1900. And then it shows when electricity had first come along, and we weren't like this close to actually being able to make natural light. Another generation went screw that's not what we want. So like the symbolists, like the whole world view changed in Western Europe between about 1890 and about 1920. People were more interested in what happens up here and how we perceive things than what happens out here. Symbolism, cubism, suprematism, all the all those isms in painting.

And there was a quote here from about I think this is from an art critic about 1895. Space composition differs even more widely from ordinary composition in its effect. Space composition is much more potent. The direct effect that of space composition is not only almost as powerful as that of music, but it's brought about in much the same way. But people, that's this is the beginning of when it wasn't just a stage anymore, it was a stage space. That's that this period is where that comes from, as far as I can tell. Awesome. I want to, at this point, we've been talking about a lot of stuff about the history from we stopped right when the electrical lights that not even those that we know came into play.

I want to open it up to the audience just based on what you've heard so far. Do you have any questions about the book about the compiling of the book about what lighting design is, how lighting design works, how it used to work, how it can work in the future, all those good stuff. It's fine if not yet. I have more. But I wanted to open it. Keep thinking.

[16:31] Audience Member: I have a question. Yes. No, we have the book we haven't read it yet. But how far back do you go?

[16:39] Michael Chybowski: About there's brief mention of the Greeks. Ah. But I mean it really gets starts to get detailed about 1490. And if I may ask, what what were I think that we all learn like around the Elizabethan period, for certainly for the Greeks and the amphitheaters and around the Elizabethan theater, we just all learned, oh, the shows happened in the day because they needed the sunlight. But what was going on around 1490 in terms of harnessing light?

[17:09] Michael Chybowski: The funny thing is, to me at least, the many cultures around the world didn't bother moving performances indoors. Like a whole lot of the cultural traditions in the Far East, especially all the performances are outside. So they ever had to do this. I don't know if it was an accident or what, but the early Renaissance designers decided that things would look a lot better if they moved inside and like a control the light. There's this little passage from about 1560 where one of the princes who was financing this festival or a performance was complaining to the designers. He said, I don't want I don't want to spend all this money on the candles. And the dividers said, you don't have enough money to make this look good outdoors. There's too much light out there. It doesn't matter how much you spent. So do it indoors, you have to spend less in the long run. So that it's just it's just a matter of you have much more control over how you see things.

[18:18] Audience Member: Anybody else. So going back to the book, what who are you hoping that this book reaches?

[18:30] Michael Chybowski: Part of this is a joke. When you're at a party, if you're a lighting designer, people walk up to you and go, What do you do? And you say, Oh, I'm a lighting designer, and you say, Oh, that's cool. Oh, the weather's great. It's for those people. It's also for anybody who's curious. Number one, I think that there's certain people who just don't know how to talk about it. Even very experienced directors and choreographers and people like that think that kind of what we do is a little bit like boo. They know when they don't like it, they know when they like it, but they don't know the middle part. So this is an attempt to under to explain not how to do it, but what label designers think about more than anything else. So that people can hopefully find a common way to communicate.

[19:28] David Rigano: And you said that you would have used this in your classes. I know, yeah. What do you when you use it? Are there specific things that you want to focus on for your classes? What do you hope that your students get out of this?

[19:41] Michael Chybowski: I use it as either a follow-up to a decision where the session may be a little bit theoretical or esoteric for somebody who hasn't heard of some of these things before, where they can just go read it on their own and think about it. Or I can I use it as a read this before we talk about it so that there's enough foundation to actually have a very deep discussion about it. And in terms of the history part of it, I said especially the beginning line classes so that they understand that a lot of people have thought about this for a long time.

[20:21] David Rigano: Yeah, looking at the full history and going back to soft 1490, what would you say is the biggest, and I also know that George Abbott, the director, Mr. George Abbott, was asked once what was the biggest change in the theater, professional theater in his lifetime, and he said electricity. So I'm going to say you can't say electricity, you can't just say answer. But what would you say is the biggest change from the way that people were first trying to harness light for the sake of theater to the way that we're using light in the theater now?

[20:59] Michael Chybowski: I touched on it with the cultural shift. There's distinct ways that each culture thought about it. The weird thing is that none of that has gone away. You can still design in Renaissance style, you can still design in realistic style, you can still design in for want of a better word, more abstract style. All of those style is just like shorthand for visual communication. And all of those shorthands still exist. I think that the one way to think about your question is the when the contemporary way of thinking about this kind of settled in, or was I rather just starting? The people who were doing realism were like, what is this? What's wrong with like trees and sunlight that in other players were like what why do we have to why do we have to do this?

And the in some ways that whole argument between realism and not realism, whatever you want to call it, has never ended. It's that it's two snakes. Sometimes or a sliding scale or both. You just pick like a realistic or not realistic for any given show. And a lot of plays these days are written where they're just twined around each other. So I don't think the argument has ended. I think it's just everybody, everybody can just bounce around depending on what they want to accomplish.

[22:30] David Rigano: Cool. Okay, thank you. I want to open it up again.

[22:33] Audience Member: I don't know if this is a question, Michael, but the Delacoric work, how do you reconcile those two things together? Like when you approach it conceptually. Because you do have natural light, you always start out in natural light, and then you end up in something else.

[22:48] Michael Chybowski: Right. I think it's just uh it's it's one time I just wanted to find out what would happen. So I came in the afternoon and there were about 750 lights on in the plot and I just turn them all on at four o'clock in the afternoon and nobody knows. The building shook a little bit. But that was about it. So okay there's a lot of light out there. It's I think it's magical when those when it goes darker darker you slip into a show nobody notices. But it's certainly it's certainly it becomes magic. And I don't know if that's a technical thing at all. It just I think it just is for me. It's just it's really fun to wake up during intermission and go, oh we're somewhere else.

[23:37] David Rigano: If I may just bounce off of that, on the one hand do you think about the design differently earlier in the show when you know that it's going to be more dusky versus how you're designing later in the show when it's dark now?

[23:53] Michael Chybowski: Part of it is it's pragmatic part of it is I'm not going to worry about this. Uh huh. And part of it is the sun is going to be over there when we start the show so maybe I should reinforce that. So later on in the summer when the sun is setting earlier it'll just be visible sooner.

[24:12] David Rigano: Uh-huh and you that kind of answers my second question which is are there any ways that since you have the natural light that you utilize the fact that it's going to be getting darker or in the case of what you just said where the sun's going to be to enhance the design.

[24:28] Michael Chybowski: I'm not sure it works that way. I think it's just you can do something or you can't. Uh-huh. Because the you can't compete with the volume of light that exists in the world.

[24:38] David Rigano: Yeah.

[24:39] Michael Chybowski: Pragmatically, as you get later in the summer and the sun sets earlier, like you either leave instructions or you have to go back because the first half hour of the show is like ridiculously bright.

[24:52] David Rigano: Uh-huh.

[24:53] Michael Chybowski: Right. So it's something you have to like either either redo the cues or just have them take the master data 20%. So you've got it's not much glare.

[25:03] David Rigano: Uh-huh.

[25:04] Michael Chybowski: Okay. Yeah, I hadn't thank you for bringing that up because I had not even thought about. And I've seen plenty of shows in the Delacourt that I never went to. I wonder how they anybody else.

[25:14] Audience Member: I have a question, Michael. So certainly when you I imagine any ear the earliest historical references to light are almost inevitably metaphorical. When you go to religious texts or I think even the Lisco cave works have torch drawings in them for memory serves.

[25:39] Michael Chybowski: There's obviously a historic point where you've moved somebody has decided to move from metaphor to one of control, one of harnessing the idea and using it for use. And that would be, you could argue the first ever lighting design. Is where do you find that historically? Is there like a historic reference that you can hang on to that says here's a person who's the beginning of this field? Maybe this is what I mean about it being cumulative. I've never found any this is the guy kind of thing. His name was Og. I can imagine, and I'm sure you can too, of everybody sitting around the fire and somebody hearing the story, and the shadow behind them on the cave wall becomes a character. We still do.

Yeah, but pretty close, or somebody walking between the fire and the audience and being in silhouette and suddenly there's some but that's not a different thing. I think that happened. Um it still happens. And then I have no like firm like research to back this up. But when you read the beginning of the Oresteia trilogy, when Agamemnon comes back from the Trojan Wars, it starts at night, the Agamemnon wheedles into town, and you can imagine the sun rising. He comes with the song, and then he's led into the palace by his wife, and then Cassandra is left alone outside, and you can imagine the sun continually rise and not like screaming past through her where she's saying, This is gonna be terrible, we're all gonna die. And I think the symbolism is built in. But I think that I don't I can't imagine that the Greeks weren't deliberate about that.

[27:44] Audience Member: One more. I'm sure you don't, or I think you probably don't deal with it in your book, but since lighting technically has changed somewhat with LEDs and whatever, do you think that lighting is more effective now than it used to be?

[28:05] Michael Chybowski: I've talked a little bit about I did a podcast last week, and maybe that was this something similar to this came out. For my money, the only thing we have now that we didn't have in the 1990s is more control. All of this technology is still using the same ideas that were developed in the 1930s. We're still using the soil reflectors, parabolic reflectors, spherical reflectors, something as close to a point source as possible. We still point it at things, we still shape it, put color in front of it. Now we have motors that do it for us. You can make them change really fast and do things together, which is a really powerful thing. But I don't think that besides from edging into spectacle more readily, I don't I'm not sure that we can do any more.

It just is a lot more complicated and a lot more like the detail can be ever finer about what we do. The thing that I'm I think I've got a glimpse of what this might be, but I think that we're gonna have to wait for when the culture changes again and it works for something else. But just like we have the Renaissance had one value that they gave to light, the period after that had another value that they did to light. The current Europe, which are borrowing something from the modern age of abstraction has another value that they give to light. I think there's gonna be another thing where we're gonna see we're gonna value light differently and wants it to do something else. But I'm not sure I don't know what that is. Because it takes a lot of people to want something like that. Listen, that's my guess.

[29:57] Audience Member: And you had a question as well?

[29:59] Audience Member: Yeah, I did, I actually guess. I come from the world of opera, and I always knew that one of the reasons that Puccini wanted to make a butterfly was because between the end of the second act and the play, you saw the play here in New York. There was this amazing effect where the little humble house where Madame Butterfly was living, was it was at dusk. It then became night. There were fireflies. This is 1900, right? Or 1898.

[30:31] Michael Chybowski: I know exactly what you're talking about.

[30:33] Audience Member: And then suddenly the sun came up. And this inspired Puccini to write a marvelous three or four-minute interlude describing what it's on stage. How the hell did they do it?

[30:46] Michael Chybowski: A guy named John McCleague.

[30:48] Audience Member: Oh, I'm kidding. Was he like a carpenter? Was he like one of the guys working backstage?

[30:56] Michael Chybowski: There were two Pleague brothers. One was John, and I can't remember the name of the other one. But they found a Pegal Brothers lighting around 1885. And it was like the biggest lighting shop in New York City. And David Belasco did that production. So he was very meticulous about his effects. And he wanted to do this. And he was pretty obsessed with realism.

[31:18] Audience Member: Yeah. Very realistic.

[31:20] Michael Chybowski: Very nervous. Yeah. So he had just hired this electrician named Lewis Hartman, who didn't quite wasn't quite at the speed yet, so he asked John Klegel to help him. And John Klegel built this, what we would now call a scroller out of silk. But then have radiated colors. And we're on a crank. And you just put it in front of a light and show stuff. The screen. And the Belasco has specially composed music for the interlude. And it was another article that the original silk color scroller that John Cleveland made. I guess Fegel Brothers used to have a ground set in the 50s where they stored all this stuff. And when they moved to Long Island City, they were missing a photo dumpster. And Joel Rubin came by to try to rescue something. He rescued that scroller.

[32:30] Audience Member: Wow. Where is it?

[32:31] Michael Chybowski: That I don't know. Joel's still alive.

[32:34] Audience Member: I see that I'm going to come back to you, but I really want to quickly, since you bring up Lewis Hartman, you also gave me a quote to read from Lewis Hartman that I thought. Now would be a good time. This is Lewis Hartman was pioneering stage lighting realism whose work foreshadowed the advancement in motion pictures. And the quote is up to the present time there has been no stage lighting method devised that can be adapted to suit all purposes. But this may be a blessing in disguise as it keeps stage lighting from becoming a mere matter of scientific formulae. It should be esteemed and approached as an art, employing electricity as a means of expression and forcing those of us who profess to be artists to extend constructive thought.

Expend, pardon me, to expend constructive thought. Nothing gets over the footlights to an audience as speedily as thought. Audiences are quick to perceive the presence of whatever intelligence has devised or conceived. Correct thinking forms the basis of their perfect understanding. So would you like to expound on what he was talking about?

[33:38] Michael Chybowski: I think that I really love that because that was written in 1932, and I think it still applies to what we do today. And I think it pairs in my mind with a quote that Appiah wrote about 1895, where he said, the realism of lighting, therefore, is not the same as the realism of forms arranged in space, since these are set up in imitation of a particular phenomenon. Well, light is based upon the existence of an idea. Which just I think is that's it.

[34:11] Audience Member: Awesome. And he had a question in the back.

[34:13] Audience Member: Maybe this will build on that, but I was curious in the previous answer, you were talking about these different value sets that are embedded in different moments. And I was wondering if you could expound upon what you think our current moment is. Like, what is the value set that most drives theory lighting right now?

[34:29] Michael Chybowski: I think that the way like fundamentally the Jennifer phrase lighting space is pretty much at the core of how we approach it now. And the fact that three-dimensional space and it's the way it can speak to us is very powerful. I think though we're still approaching everything that way. One thing that came to me while I was writing this is the uh maybe you don't like in quantum mechanics, the when you try to measure like where an electron is, right, it's like it drives it crazy because there's a non-zero probability that the electron could be anywhere in the universe. And it's not until you actually try to measure it that it decides I'm gonna hear it. So there's an analogy with lighting for that.

If you can if you imagine a dark cube in your brain, it has that dark cube has an infinite amount of potential to be seen in an infinite amount of ways. And it's not until you turn on one light in the cube that infinity collapses down into this kind of space. And I think that's kind of I think that is how we operate.

[36:00] Audience Member: What do you think the value attack to that?

[36:03] Michael Chybowski: It's I think it's pure communication. Like how you need to see something. Like what makes that angle better than this I hope for those occurrence and what you're trying to get across. And it could be non-verbal. It's not, it's not it's not a message necessarily or a lesson, but it's more it's it speaks to you in the same way as music does, I think.

[36:31] Audience Member: And if I may bounce off of that, I'm glad you brought up music, because bringing up the Hartman quote, when you talk about this particular angle being the most effective, how much of that is scientific formula and how much of it is art? Because obviously also music is you your background starting in mathematics. Music at its core is mathematics that hit our ear is sound, and this is science that hits our eye is light. So what is where do those two some of it is strict scientific formula and some of it is art? Where do those two meet?

[37:11] Michael Chybowski: I don't think that there's a sharp dividing line necessarily. I think that the if you read the book. There's a chapter on the fundamental properties of light, and there's a discussion that each individual angle has found in a standard dance repertory plot. And it's if you sit there and look at it, like different kinds of angles do discrete things. Like some are like diagonals, or better if you want to suggest natural sources, for instance, because they're they engage all three dimensions more readily. They're much more original, and people are more apt to go, oh, it's the sun or the moon, or the light of God, or something like that. So I think that the value of a given angle probably depends on the individual, so I guess it is because the different people think in different ways.

[38:15] Michael Chybowski: I happen to, I'm wired to think of geometry. I sometimes jokingly refer to myself as a human section because I walk into a theater and I look at and see a wireframe diagram for all the lights, you know, how the light travels. Because I dump so many sections. But other people, there's another lighting designer who does use a bangle, and I go, how the hell do you think of that? And it works. It's everybody is wired differently. Some people come at it from color first, some people come at it from an angle, some people I don't know. It just depends on how your brain behaves. So I guess you could say it is entirely individual. What does your process tend to be when you're going from the concept or the director saying, I want it to be like this, and but I have no idea how to make it look like that? And what's your process from coming up with a concept to executing?

[39:07] Michael Chybowski: I don't really think of concept as like a hard and fast thing. I think I tend to think of concept, I think the way it's comfortable for me to think about it is sandwich. Uh-huh. There's things that suggest themselves that they're going to be useful. And it's oh, okay, I'll remember that. And I tend to think of it more as you're building a scaffolding and you're getting pieces that fit together, and the end goal is to be able to have somebody walk on the scaffolding without it falling apart and falling out. And I and for me there's a definite feeling of euphoria when the last piece when I find the last piece of the staff like it clicks together and it's like, okay, I know what to do. I just wouldn't do the entire show. I know how to think I know how to think about this. Awesome. Do you have any other questions?

[40:08] Audience Member: Yeah. In terms of like building that scaffolding and especially working with other creatives, how do you slot yourself amongst a creative team and work with other designers? And also with the prevalence in the rise of projections, how does lighting compete with or help with projection and video?

[40:31] Michael Chybowski: I think there's both maybe two different questions, or related questions. Working with a whole with a team of people, I tend to think of it as we're all there to support the end goal, and probably the hardest part of working with Google is agreeing on what the end goal is. So the people throw around the rural word collaboration a lot, and everybody has a different definition of what that means, which makes it really tough. But I tend to just think about I don't I try not to use that word anymore. I just try to say you're just working with people, and we're all trying to it's like what are we trying to do? If you can reduce it down to like simple sentences like that, I think it's very helpful.

Like what's the end goal when we all think is the best thing to do? And it turns out projections, yeah, yeah, I think they're really bright. But one of the things that I learned working with Lori, and also with the SWAT dealer, who have a different slightly different style, is that the I hate projections that are used as postcards, and Lori doesn't do that. And what I try to do is pick elements of the projection composition and use light to extend those into the space of the performer that's living in. So it's you're trying to make a three-dimensional world for them to exist in rather than having to stand for a screen. That's how I tend to try to work with that kind of thing.

[42:04] Michael Chybowski: Does everyone know who Laurie is?

[42:07] Audience Member: Lori Anderson.

[42:10] Michael Chybowski: She's really good. And have you worked where like maybe the set designer comes to you and says, I would like this to light up, or you go to the set designer and say, I think that it would be really cool if the light came out of here? It's or some something like that.

[42:25] Michael Chybowski: Oh, yeah, that happens all the time.

[42:27] Audience Member: Yeah.

[42:28] Michael Chybowski: So what's I think I'm going back to Archer's question, what's what's the process then when you're working with two it's not just the lights making the set visible or the right part of the set visible or telling the right part of the story on this part of the set, but the two elements of design interacting with each other as a storytelling device?

[42:49] Michael Chybowski: I don't know. I think Neil Patel, who's here tonight, is a perfect example of that. When we're working on shows together, I walk into a studio and he's not done yet, but he's done talking with the director and he'll say, Let me show you the model. Or here's the plan. Look at them. Tell me if you need them. That's I think that's a good example of how it should be done.

[43:08] Audience Member: Yeah.

[43:09] Michael Chybowski: Because if you have a request, people don't have to say yes. But no, it's just fun to work with people. And just said, you know, well, what if we did this? Would this be fun? Yeah. Would this help us? Yeah, I did a show out in Chicago that had projected sets, and I think it was the lighting designer went to the set designer at one point and said, There's the scheme of eyes in the show. I think it would be cool if I put light up eyes. If I hid them inside the set. And then it became the question of how do you to what end? Would it be cool, yes? Or when.

[43:45] Audience Member: Yeah, exactly.

[43:46] Michael Chybowski: Really quickly, if anyone else have so I'm just gonna say, with this book now going into people's hands, what place do you hope this book has? You've talked to us about like modern lighting design as we know it goes back to around you said 1930.

[44:08] Michael Chybowski: Yeah. So we're looking we're at almost a hundred years now. And I really like that you said that the only change big changes in there are how we control it, but we're utilizing the same way. What do you hope this book could be for the next hundred years of lighting design?

[44:26] Michael Chybowski: I don't know. I guess the root impulse for the book was to see if I could help people understand what this is. Yes, I like what I'm I'd love it. Uh-huh. And most people look at me like, okay, fine, if that's what you're saying. But the if it comes around to people wondering what comes next, then I think that's all for the good. Because I guess I'm I personally I'm sick of postmodernism. Uh-huh. Because it's like you it's a lot of old ideas thrown in a box and you shake it, and then some come out and some and I'm a little tired of all that. But I would like to have something new to get in past it, Dan. But it's I think it's gonna take more than lighting designers or anyone's. I think it's gonna take some new discovery and how to see things.

[45:16] Audience Member: And you were mentioning you especially I love that you call the book a genealogy. And you said that on your website you have a genealogy of lighting designer.

[45:27] Michael Chybowski: Okay, talk about oh, yeah. It's a little bit the publisher didn't make it the easiest thing in the world to find. The first appendix of the book is a genealogy chart of American lighting designers starting from the first three in the 30s, they further genius called Eddie Clark, and going through who trained who, who worked with who, who looked from who, who branched who branched out from where completely is going to manage in about three or four years. And of course, when I got there tonight, there were a couple of people telling me that I missed. If you go to the Ravlich website and go to the page where the book is in the bottom that says support materials, and if you click that, there's a little thing that says PDF, and you can download it and have your very own copy.

[46:21] Michael Chybowski: And you had mentioned that since some people have come up to you and said, Oh, actually, that you consider that to be a living document.

[46:28] Audience Member: Yes.

[46:30] Michael Chybowski: My last question about moving forward with this: how much do you feel that this is a living document? And do you think this is going to be something that you maybe come back to if there's anything that needs to be added to it?

[46:43] Michael Chybowski: Certainly if there's if people want it. Yeah, people can buy it. One thing that did come up, I did a podcast last week called Light Talk with the Lumen Brothers, and one of the questions they asked me was what advice would you give for young lighting designers? And I had never thought of that when I was writing this. And I guess the first thing that popped out of my mouth was don't be shy. And the second, I think, was don't think about what you should do first, think about what you can do.

[47:18] Audience Member: Yeah.

[47:20] Michael Chybowski: I don't have a question, but I just want to say I haven't read the whole book. I've read here and there in it, and I just find it so beautifully written and warm and human and enlightening. Many things that I never thought of or knew before. And it will be a companion, and I'm sure many people will love it.

[47:43] Michael Chybowski: Thank you very much. That means a lot, especially coming from you. That's very touching.

[47:49] David Rigano: I think a wonderful note to end our evening on. So once again, thank you all for coming. Once again, help me in thanking Michael.

[48:08] Michael Chybowski: Um yeah, thank you for coming out. Thank you for coming and supporting the drama bookshop. Please come by during open hours, peruse our shelves, see if you like something. Again, we would love to see all of your places at more events. So please subscribe to that event right page so you can always see what's coming up next. And you reserve some spot for that. Please follow at Drama Book Shop and at Drama Book Show Podcast so that you can find out all of the things that are going on here and when you can hear this event on our podcast.

[48:40] David Rigano: And now we're gonna ask that you stay right where you are for just a moment as our resident Disney live leader Mark is going to organize you all. Michael and I are gonna head up to the front of the store, and then Mark will line you up so that you can bring your books over to get signed. And I'm gonna smoke a half a cigarette.

[49:08] David Rigano: Welcome back. That was informative conversation. Would you call it?

[49:13] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Illuminating?

[49:15] David Rigano: Yes.

[49:17] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Lighting puns. From there, I would like to jump back a little bit to one of our first events that we had.

[49:25] David Rigano: Yeah, this was an early one.

[49:26] Mark-Eugene Garcia: This was an early one.

[49:28] David Rigano: Well, it was also a pretty early show.

[49:30] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[49:31] David Rigano: A little bit of the history of being on the road with Hello Dolly.

[49:35] Mark-Eugene Garcia: Yeah.

[49:36] David Rigano: Louis J. Stadlin, who played Horace Van der Gelder in his recent Hello Dolly tour, wrote a book about his experience. And he talks about not just like his experience with that production of Hello Dolly, but his experience with theater. With theater and with Hello Dolly as a show. Having met David Burns, original Horace Vandergelder when he was a kid, and all sorts of stuff. If you don't know Lewis Stadlin's work, you do, you just don't know.

[50:09] Mark-Eugene Garcia: You do not know it yet.

[50:10] David Rigano: Yeah. We're gonna jump into that in our next episode. And until then, please follow us on Instagram at Drama Book Show Podcast. Please subscribe to the drama bookshop on Eventbrite so that you can be notified when we add in-person events. Give us a rating and a positive review, because you know you like us on your whichever podcast streaming service you use. And remember that all the books we talk about can be found here at the drama bookshop. And so can we. And we will see you at the bookshop.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred