On this week’s episode, Jamie and Rob are joined by Ben Brantley, co-chief theater critic for The New York Times. A consummate journalist and celebrated writer, Ben talks about how he came to the Times, his tenure there since 1993, his writing process, what theater criticism means to him, and why he loves the theater... Read More
From the show: The Fabulous Invalid
About
On this week’s episode, Jamie and Rob are joined by Ben Brantley, co-chief theater critic for The New York Times. A consummate journalist and celebrated writer, Ben talks about how he came to the Times, his tenure there since 1993, his writing process, what theater criticism means to him, and why he loves the theater. A bit later in the show, Rob gives a look into the career of experimental playwright and director Richard Maxwell through the lens of a Ben Brantley review.
Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid
Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid
Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc
Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com
Jamie Du Mont
Twitter: @jamiedumont
Instagram: @troutinnyc
Rob Russo
Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC
Jennifer Simard
Twitter: @SimardJennifer
Instagram: @thejennifersimard
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ben Brantley: I'm Ben Brantley, and this is the Fabulous Invalid.
[0:13] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast, where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today, from actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.
[0:28] Jamie DuMont: We took our name from the title of the 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.
[0:35] Jamie DuMont: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back, the fabulous invalid.
[0:41] Rob Russo: I'm Theodore Savant, Jamie DuMont.
[0:43] Rob Russo: And I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with Stage Left at NYC.
[0:46] Rob Russo: Hi, Rob Russo.
[0:47] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Jamie.
[0:48] Rob Russo: How are you?
[0:49] Jamie DuMont: I'm very good.
[0:49] Rob Russo: How are you?
[0:50] Jamie DuMont: I'm very, very well.
[0:52] Jamie DuMont: Well, I'm excited for today's guest because if I can share with our listeners, um, share.
[0:58] Jamie DuMont: Ben Brantley is someone who we have wanted on the show from day one, right?
[1:03] Rob Russo: From before we even recorded.
[1:05] Jamie DuMont: Recorded.
[1:06] Jamie DuMont: We were like dream list, he's the guest we want.
[1:09] Rob Russo: And we got him.
[1:10] Jamie DuMont: We did.
[1:11] Jamie DuMont: Well, in the truth of the matter is we got him right away.
[1:15] Rob Russo: That's true.
[1:15] Jamie DuMont: And we had a different idea of what we wanted that show to be.
[1:19] Jamie DuMont: And then for a variety of reasons, it didn't come to fruition.
[1:23] Jamie DuMont: And Ben was very gracious about saying, I will uh come on, and we finally made it happen.
[1:29] Rob Russo: Yes.
[1:29] Rob Russo: And you know, while he's not a theater maker per se, um, it's hard to argue with the idea that he is one of the most influential and important people in the theater writ large.
[1:40] Jamie DuMont: And why is that, Rob?
[1:41] Rob Russo: Oh, well, Jamie, I thought you'd never ask.
[1:43] Rob Russo: Um, well, if you don't know somehow, if you live under a rock, if you don't live in this world.
[1:43] Jamie DuMont: In this world.
[1:49] Rob Russo: Ben Brantley is the co-chief theater critic for The New York Times, um, where he's been uh on staff since 1993, um, and uh became the chief in 1996, um, which is a remarkably long time to be at the helm of that division of arts criticism.
[2:08] Jamie DuMont: Longest ever, right?
[2:09] Rob Russo: For the paper of record.
[2:10] Jamie DuMont: I'm not sure if it's as long as ever, but it certainly must be the longest in modern, you know, history.
[2:17] Rob Russo: Right?
[2:18] Jamie DuMont: I don't know.
[2:18] Jamie DuMont: I mean, I don't know how long Brooks Atkinson was writing for the Times.
[2:21] Rob Russo: I don't think that well, that we have we'll have to find out.
[2:23] Jamie DuMont: We'll have to look in the world.
[2:24] Rob Russo: Tweet at us if you know.
[2:25] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[2:25] Rob Russo: Um, but uh before coming to the Times, um, you might not know that uh Ben was a staff writer for The New Yorker and Vanity Fair.
[2:33] Rob Russo: Um, he reviewed fashion for Women's Wear Daily, where he was the Paris Bureau chief and European editor.
[2:39] Rob Russo: And he reviewed movies for L Magazine.
[2:42] Rob Russo: Um, he's originally from Winston-Salem, North Carolina, and graduated from Swarthmore College.
[2:48] Rob Russo: Uh, and over the course of his career, he has edited two books of New York Times theater reviews.
[2:53] Jamie DuMont: Um, I have one of them.
[2:54] Jamie DuMont: I need to get the other one.
[2:55] Rob Russo: I'm shocked you don't have the.
[2:57] Jamie DuMont: I'm shocked they're not sitting on the table.
[2:59] Rob Russo: I know.
[3:00] Rob Russo: I should have brought it to have him sign.
[3:01] Rob Russo: Um, but uh he's he's he's edited those those books and reviews, and he's also the recipient of the prestigious George Jean Nathan Award for Theater Criticism.
[3:10] Rob Russo: Um, so we have with us today one of the most celebrated uh writers about the theater, probably ever.
[3:18] Jamie DuMont: You know, he's I agree.
[3:20] Jamie DuMont: He's on that list of you know, Walter Kerr, Brooks Atkinson, Ben Brantley.
[3:24] Rob Russo: And I think he's a man that people don't know a lot about.
[3:26] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[3:27] Jamie DuMont: So I'm excited to talk to him.
[3:28] Rob Russo: Yeah, me too.
[3:29] Jamie DuMont: Should we do it?
[3:30] Rob Russo: Let's do it.
[3:37] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Ben.
[3:38] Ben Brantley: Thanks for coming down and joining us.
[3:39] Ben Brantley: I'm happy to.
[3:40] Jamie DuMont: You've worked at several publications before coming to the Times and in different capacities.
[3:44] Jamie DuMont: So I'm curious to start us off.
[3:46] Jamie DuMont: If you could share with us how you came to be a theater critic for the Times.
[3:50] Ben Brantley: Well, it was a uh a very circuitous road. I uh first I'd worked for the Village Voice when I took a semester off when I was at in college at Swarthmore. Uh, but that was just basically, you know, uh an intern position. And the first job I had out of college was at Women's Wear Daily, NW.
[4:08] Ben Brantley: And uh I covered fashion for them and uh out of New York in Paris. It was a great job to have in your early 20s. I mean, it was just it was like sort of a Siborites graduate school. Um, but you learned a lot too, and you learned to look at things very quick.
[4:23] Ben Brantley: In any case, through all this, yes, I'd always loved theater, et cetera, et cetera. I grew up with it. Um, there was a great theater program at the university where my dad worked.
[4:33] Ben Brantley: Um, and I studied acting. I did like local commercials and so forth. Uh, and in college I realized I had a I was a much better writer than I was an actor.
[4:43] Ben Brantley: And also I come from a family of journalists, so that was sort of the path of least resistance. First interview I ever had with John after college was with John Fairchild, then the publisher of Women's Wear Daily, and he said, if you could have any job in the world, what would it be?
[4:56] Ben Brantley: And I said, theater critic of the New York Times. That was many years ago. And I I don't think either of us thought it was quite well very likely to come true.
[5:05] Ben Brantley: But uh so Women's Wear, I was there for seven years. I became I ended as the Paris uh editor and publisher.
[5:13] Ben Brantley: Uh, I quit because I thought my life should perhaps take a different direction. It was probably the bravest thing I ever did.
[5:19] Ben Brantley: But I did. I walked out without another job, but soon found work uh at uh under contract Tina Brown first for Conday Nat uh first for the Vanity Fair, and then she took me with her to The New Yorker.
[5:31] Ben Brantley: At the same time, I was doing on the side movie reviews for L Magazine. My first editor there was a woman named Alex Wichell, who was going out with a guy named Frank Rich.
[5:41] Ben Brantley: And when they were looking for a new second-string theater critic, this was some time after she'd left the magazine.
[5:46] Ben Brantley: She said, um, maybe we should ask Ben Brantley.
[5:49] Ben Brantley: So uh Frank called and said, Do you want to audition for this? And I said, Oh, yeah, right.
[5:53] Ben Brantley: And then it happened very quickly. And that was 27 years ago.
[5:57] Jamie DuMont: Yes, you've been there ever since.
[5:59] Ben Brantley: Wow.
[5:59] Jamie DuMont: And then you became the chief in 1996.
[6:02] Ben Brantley: Yes.
[6:03] Jamie DuMont: So yeah.
[6:03] Ben Brantley: The best part was the first two years.
[6:05] Ben Brantley: That was seven.
[6:06] Jamie DuMont: Why was that the best part?
[6:07] Ben Brantley: Because you know, I mean, once you got over that initial hump of what people's expectations or prejudices might be, you got to see so much fresher stuff.
[6:16] Ben Brantley: It wasn't stuff that had been processed by a thousand producers and you know, massaged into shape and glossed up.
[6:24] Ben Brantley: And there it was, and I I loved going into a hole in a wall and seeing someone like Richard Maxwell for the first time.
[6:31] Ben Brantley: Um, that was um that do you all know who he is, right?
[6:35] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, that was that was the thrilling moment.
[6:38] Ben Brantley: Um this I love doing this now, but um, and um it's it's been fun being a chief critic.
[6:45] Ben Brantley: But uh, and it means I get to go to London often, which is nice too.
[6:49] Rob Russo: But everything is opening on Broadway this season.
[6:51] Ben Brantley: I've already seen exactly what I feel the same way.
[6:54] Rob Russo: I I took a couple of trips last year, and I'm like, well, I guess I can save my pennies, you know, I've already seen everything.
[6:59] Ben Brantley: Well, there's one or two shows, perhaps, that will be new to you.
[7:03] Jamie DuMont: How many shows a year do you see?
[7:05] Ben Brantley: I don't know. When I'm in New York, probably four or five a week in high seas, and maybe three on an average in slower times.
[7:12] Ben Brantley: When I'm in London, I'll do as many as 10 a week because they stagger the matinees.
[7:17] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[7:17] Jamie DuMont: It's easy to do that.
[7:18] Ben Brantley: It's easier to do that there than here.
[7:20] Ben Brantley: It is because yeah, because of the way things are scheduled, absolutely.
[7:22] Jamie DuMont: That's nice.
[7:23] Jamie DuMont: So this is sort of the the big question.
[7:25] Jamie DuMont: But why do you write about the theater?
[7:29] Ben Brantley: Um, well, I theater, although I sort of glossed over it earlier, theater was really the first thing I fell in love with.
[7:34] Ben Brantley: It's been an obsession of mine since I was pretty much since I could talk, certainly since I could read.
[7:40] Ben Brantley: Uh, my granddad taught Shakespeare.
[7:43] Ben Brantley: Um, and uh my probably my most natural predilection is for like writing um papers for English classes, but you can't make a living doing that all your life.
[7:56] Ben Brantley: And um, and this sort of is translating that particular skill that I owned um really all through my life.
[8:02] Ben Brantley: Along with my my my journalism background.
[8:06] Ben Brantley: I I was also writing for papers since I was like 10 or something, because my mother was on the um the afternoon paper, and I interned there.
[8:14] Ben Brantley: I covered the Miss North Carolina pageant.
[8:17] Ben Brantley: Um and theater was the constant though, theater and and books.
[8:22] Ben Brantley: Uh when I was in Paris, I'd get to London as off as I could.
[8:26] Ben Brantley: I didn't actually familiarize myself as I should have with the French theater, but I wanted to escape every weekend, and I and I went to London, so I saw a lot then.
[8:34] Ben Brantley: And it's so gratifying to write about in a way.
[8:39] Ben Brantley: I mean, movies, I love movies, and obviously they affect you when you're watching them in a very visceral way often.
[8:47] Ben Brantley: But with theater, it's just so much more intense because it is living people, and it could all go so wrong in a second, or you know, just soar into the heavens in a second, too.
[8:56] Ben Brantley: I still find that's why I haven't gotten bored.
[8:59] Ben Brantley: I I still find it exciting.
[9:00] Ben Brantley: Even when I don't like something, you're trying to figure out why you don't like something, and you're where is the energy sort of uh misplaced?
[9:08] Ben Brantley: Um and um it makes you into a great observer generally.
[9:13] Ben Brantley: Um it's just and if I could write about anything, yeah, it would it wouldn't be books, it wouldn't be film, and also so much of film is seen on tiny screens now, too.
[9:22] Ben Brantley: Um so I don't think it's quite the same communal experience.
[9:26] Ben Brantley: Um but um theater is also one of the last, you know, great uh gathering places for um well, I was starting to say for many sorts of people, but for many sorts of people with solid bank accounts who can't afford that, right?
[9:42] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[9:42] Ben Brantley: I also think only a theater person or a lover of theater would flee Paris for London for a few days.
[9:48] Ben Brantley: There's no other reason to leave Paris.
[9:52] Jamie DuMont: Is there a major difference between writing for film, writing about film and writing about theater?
[9:56] Ben Brantley: Well, when I was writing about film, it was for L Magazine.
[10:00] Ben Brantley: It was I had 350 words, 400 words, maybe I think once I wrote once wrote 500 on Miller's Queen.
[10:07] Ben Brantley: Just nothing, really. Not by time standards.
[10:09] Ben Brantley: And I was used, of course, to the more long form piece.
[10:12] Ben Brantley: Uh I mean we were given thousands of words at Vanity Fair.
[10:16] Ben Brantley: And um, so um they were it was kind of like doing um haiku, you know, you really had to boil it down.
[10:24] Jamie DuMont: Yes.
[10:24] Ben Brantley: Uh when I came to the Times, I was allowed to uh expatiate more.
[10:28] Ben Brantley: I could describe, you know, plots, name characters.
[10:31] Ben Brantley: I mean, you really were doing sort of Morse code when it was shorter, but that was very good training, too.
[10:36] Jamie DuMont: So when you're writing a review, who are you writing for?
[10:40] Ben Brantley: Um, I'm really, I like to think of myself as kind of a window, ideally.
[10:45] Ben Brantley: I mean, obviously, there's, you know, there's some frame.
[10:48] Ben Brantley: There's the lattice work, which is your perspective and and what you bring to it.
[10:53] Ben Brantley: But ideally, I'm trying to create for people who either think or thinking about seeing this, but also people who will never get a chance to see what I'm writing about.
[11:01] Ben Brantley: I'm trying to recreate the experience of what it was like for this person to watch that at this moment in time to make it as um as much of a sensory experience as I can through words.
[11:16] Ben Brantley: So it's almost like a like it.
[11:17] Ben Brantley: I mean, obviously they're historical documents because you they're in print and you're writing for the paper or record, but you're but that's also your perspective when you're when you're writing these reviews, as if as if it's for somebody who's not gonna see it.
[11:29] Ben Brantley: Yes, but but also to keep it as a piece of a lit like a living piece of history.
[11:34] Ben Brantley: I mean, I really enjoy sports writing too.
[11:36] Ben Brantley: I mean, I don't really enjoy watching sports mostly, but I do enjoy sports writing.
[11:40] Jamie DuMont: Why is that?
[11:41] Ben Brantley: It's because of the passion of it, and I think it's really analogous to theater criticism.
[11:45] Ben Brantley: I was editing a Book of Times review some years ago, and you have people, you know, Brooks Atkinson or later Clive Barnes or Walter Kerr, especially in the early days when you've also got like um Alexander Woolcott, it's oh my god, did you just hear what happened last night?
[12:05] Ben Brantley: Theater will never be the same.
[12:06] Ben Brantley: It's like, you know, holy cow, he's hit a homer again.
[12:10] Ben Brantley: It's there was a real kind of uh I was there, uh a witness to this great excitement.
[12:18] Ben Brantley: And I think it's harder for theater criticism to be like that now because uh, well, for social media, for one thing.
[12:25] Ben Brantley: So as soon as a show is in previews, and sometimes even before people start posting things about it, and it kind of dilutes dilutes the climate.
[12:33] Jamie DuMont: Do you try to block that all that out?
[12:35] Ben Brantley: Do I try?
[12:36] Ben Brantley: Oh, yeah.
[12:36] Ben Brantley: Yeah, yeah.
[12:37] Ben Brantley: Oh no, before I go into a show.
[12:39] Ben Brantley: Also, I mean, who's posting this stuff anyway?
[12:43] Ben Brantley: Do you know?
[12:43] Ben Brantley: You have to be a little suspicious.
[12:46] Ben Brantley: No, I I learned long ago that none of that stuff can be um can be taken at face value.
[12:52] Ben Brantley: And I don't, I I don't spend a lot of time.
[12:55] Ben Brantley: Well, I don't spend any time in chat rooms.
[12:57] Ben Brantley: Uh, you know, tweets, even though I don't tweet myself, I had to be on Twitter because someone was impersonating me.
[13:04] Ben Brantley: And the only way you can get your name back is to post it is to be yourself as yourself.
[13:09] Ben Brantley: So occasionally I get tweets bounced towards me on subjects that it's kind of kind of hard to ignore.
[13:15] Jamie DuMont: Well, you just talked about the nature of observation and how you know essential that is to theater criticism to writing about the theater.
[13:22] Jamie DuMont: Um, one of the things that strikes me about your writing as as a fan of your work and as a consumer of it, is the way that you capture a performance and describe an actor's performance.
[13:32] Jamie DuMont: Um, how did you develop those skills?
[13:35] Jamie DuMont: Is that is it purely from doing, you know, fashion and and and film before or no?
[13:39] Ben Brantley: I mean, I I did act for many years as a kid. I wasn't good. I mean, I was a really good kid actor because I don't think that's true now, but I think at that time no one expected children to be authentic. They uh sort of impersonated an idea of what a child should be. And I was pretty good at that. Uh as I got older, I realized that acting required a certain nakedness in public that I wasn't willing to present. And I don't mean taking your clothes off, obviously. I mean uh emotional self-exposure. I think it's really brave when they do that and when they do it really well. I mean, someone like uh oh Mary Louise Parker. I mean, it's it's extraordinary that she can pull that off every night. Uh so but anyway, having studied acting, I you do I think anyone who's studied acting and is or has been on stage at all, you do recognize when people are coasting, especially if you're with Shakespeare.
Um, you know, um, oh what a rogue and peasant, and then you just land on certain words, you know, and you make your your tones plummier, but then you think they don't know what they're saying uh sometimes. Um and um and there are people who get by on charm, I think you're aware when when all the muscles are working though, that's that's really exciting. And and you see it on screen too, but it's a very different, it's a very different thing because the level of projection is is so different. I don't know if you saw uh the Richard Nelson production of Uncle Vanya at Hunter. Did you see that?
[13:58] Jamie DuMont: I did not.
[15:07] Ben Brantley: Oh, that was so beautiful. But that, I mean, what he's done, I mean you've probably seen if you've seen any of the uh like Rhinebeck plays, the Apple plays or whatever, is he he's devised a system of tiny microphones, they would be coming down at us like this, like little tiny chandeliers, and they pick up everything. So if you're doing Chekhov and you don't want to be screaming, you want to say, you know, Sonya, yeah, I don't I'm not the person that I was. I do not know why I feel this. So if you want to say it in that sotto voce, it's really, really exciting. So that kind of blurs the boundaries a little bit, except that it's still alive. And when you get that kind of intimacy when you're that close, I mean with real people, I mean, um, Chekhov lives. Just have to take a second and let that up. We didn't let that sit in the room because that's well said.
[15:55] Jamie DuMont: Talk to us a little bit about your writing process.
[15:59] Ben Brantley: Um because I worked as a daily journalist for so many years, I always loved words, and I always would like to give titles to things in my mind, or you know, um uh extravagant names to ordinary people as I was growing up. So I was always applying words to things. So when I started doing journalism, it became very natural for me to think of of leads very quickly. I remember when I was an intern at a paper in Winston-Salem, all that summer I was thinking, I was turning like he brushed his teeth. He brushed his teeth that morning, little knowing that I mean it was just everything automatically turned into um into journalese. So I still have that to a certain extent. So when I'm watching, I probably will have a tentative lead in my head by the end of the first act.
And then the second act may surprise me, or something else may seem incredibly important, or it wasn't as good as I thought it was going to be. Uh it may, it may displace it. But usually, and usually I write the next morning. I never just go home and write. I might write down a few notes and I'll um I'll write it the next day. Uh if I have time, if I have the luxury of a couple of days, I like to write something and come back to it more often, I'll just write it and and send it in. And we're sort of like reviews are kind of like, you know, uh bailing hay as far as you know the people at the Times are concerned. You know, so oh, here's another one, get it on the truck, send it out. It's because you know, there's just so much copy coming in, and there are fewer editors now than there were before than ever, in terms of um actually, you know, hands-on editing. So it's it's it's tough for them.
[17:35] Jamie DuMont: Um so that's why I often send it in early so they can have it if they have a spare moment in their well. I've um I've sat behind you or around you before at the theater, and I I noticed that you never take your eyes off the stage. And I don't know if that's an intentional thing or if it's just because you're so invested in what's going on. Um which also means that as you're taking notes, you don't seem to be looking at your notebook. Is that a skill that you've developed?
[18:02] Ben Brantley: No, no, no, I wish it were. I I mean I I I really I could write just for you now. I could write, you know, the first line of the Constitution and uh and you wouldn't be able to read it. So when I'm taking notes, it's ridiculous. I'll occasionally star something and write something in big capital letters like death, you know. And um, but basically it's just when you're there's some sort of motor y connection going on, um, motor connection going on uh or perceptual thing where when you write something down, it's almost like you tattoo it into your into your memory. So whether you actually can see what you were saying in notes afterwards. Um when I was first in the job, I would type up my notes uh every morning, and I would have researched the thing for like you know, three afternoons at the Library of Performing Arts. But um if I were still doing that, I I would probably not be alive.
[19:00] Jamie DuMont: How does the decision get made as to which critic reviews what shows? And do you have any say in that process?
[19:05] Ben Brantley: Oh yeah, no, Jesse and I um just uh we should be doing it actually like today or tomorrow. Uh we uh either meet for lunch, or if our schedule is don't allow, we just uh we talk on the phone for like an hour. It's it's a fun conversation. And uh we're fairly deferential uh about who gets gets to do what. I mean, I knew for example last season I said, all right, I'll be doing The Ferryman because I saw it in London, which means you have to do To Kill a Mockingbird, because those were the two plays of heft, although only one was nominated for a Tony Award. Go figure. But um we're still talking about that.
[19:47] Jamie DuMont: Um so when you see shows in London, does that mean and they come in, which they frequently do, as we said earlier, and then yeah to Broadway.
[19:55] Ben Brantley: Yeah, so you typically want to re-review those shows. Usually, I mean, if you get especially if you've given it a really positive review, you know. I mean, what if Jesse saw it and went, ugh? I mean, it's which you know, you don't it's I don't rule out the possibility of our changing as well. Oh, for example, when uh uh uh Freestyle Love Supreme moved to Broadway, Jesse had done it off Broadway, but he had another Broadway opening that week, so so I took it. And I think it was safe to say that you know who who wouldn't respond to that, you know, with an open heart, really.
[20:27] Ben Brantley: Um I uh I I let him do or didn't let him. I told him he should do Tina, which I had done in London, because I had the feeling that our takes would be fundamentally the same. Um that's interesting though.
[20:40] Jamie DuMont: Do you ever consider that your takes will be different when you talk about who's gonna review what show in terms of yes, I mean it's not something we yeah, I mean to some extent, I think you you know that you know, and we have our our definite predispositions and and fondnesses, and if it's a writer that uh one of us is championed for a long time trying something new, I think it should be the champion who who who writes the piece.
[21:05] Ben Brantley: But um that's interesting. I don't think a lot of people would would think that or know that.
[21:11] Jamie DuMont: Right. That's that's actually really interesting. This is sort of beside the point, but I'm just curious. Can you predict what other critics might think about something based on what you know about the way they review?
[21:20] Ben Brantley: Um no. I think people are so surprising generally. It's um uh and you know, I I kind of love that. Can you believe she liked that? You know it's uh I mean we're all so passionate and personal about it, but it is just one's person, one person's opinion. And um when you read accounts of of how a play was received years later, if if you were there, or even if it were many decades ago and you actually read the initial reviews, it's not always represented as it was written. It's like this kind of aura of opinion seems to float from the way it's it's recalled, oh, it was a disaster, no one liked it, and then you look up and say, well, you know, actually, I don't know. I mean, was Good Vibrations as bad as we thought it was then? Maybe yes. Yes, it was.
[22:10] Ben Brantley: Well, interestingly enough, and I actually just said this when we recorded a few days ago. I for uh for a variety of reasons went back and read the original reviews of Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? Yeah. They're not particularly good.
[22:23] Jamie DuMont: No, which is I was so surprised.
[22:25] Ben Brantley: So you're right, you never like you, you know, you you we forget time sort of and it shakes out, you know. And of course, now when everyone anyone writes about, you know, whatever it was, 63, 64, the year that Virginia Woolf blasted Broadway.
[22:40] Jamie DuMont: I am still shaking.
[22:42] Ben Brantley: Right. Well, you know, a publicist wrote that.
[22:45] Jamie DuMont: Exactly.
[22:46] Ben Brantley: Exactly. Um well, it's interesting because you know, you're obviously aware, as we all are, that the Times occupies a very special place in the world of of theater criticism and journalism. Um and there are some, you know, in the industry who, you know, are professionals who sometimes lament, I'll use the word lament, the the power that they believe the Times might have in terms of shaping the box office, but also influencing the tone of how a particular show might be perceived. How do you respond to that critique as you know one of the people who is who is writing the reviews?
[23:20] Ben Brantley: Yeah, I mean, I don't see it as a critique so much as a statement of a fact of life. Um I mean you can't win in this argument. People will say, oh, it's such a shame. The Times doesn't have its power anymore, and then oh no, the Times is too powerful. And they cancel each other out as far as I'm concerned. And the only way, and I uh from the very beginning, you put on blinders, you try to describe as accurately and entertainingly as possible what you saw the night before a couple of nights ago. But um no, if I no, I I think I would have had a breakdown if I'd every morning go, oh my god, right. Where am I? What am I doing? No, I I don't feel too existentially challenged in that way. I think most people, when they do their jobs, just do their jobs.
[24:06] Jamie DuMont: Right. Right. I mean, unless you're a plutocrat. Okay, so on that note, continuing that thought, what is harder to write? A rave, a pan, a mixed review?
[24:18] Ben Brantley: Um, the reviews I'm proudest of are generally mixed reviews. Uh uh raves are the easiest to write. I mean, unless it's a unless it's sort of an esoteric person or a group uh that you're trying to explain to people who might not normally venture into those you know surreal precincts. But um, but generally a rave is just oh, you feel so good doing it because you are enthusiastic. I mean, if you if you really feel it, I mean, I think faking it is not a good idea. I think you can always tell when a critic's faking it. And um uh a pan, I know I don't like, I mean, they're easy in another way because it's so easy to score all things, but I think you really have to think about why you think something doesn't work, and then give, I mean, the fun part of a pan for me is giving the physical feeling that well, not even a pan, a rave too, any kind of play.
Because plays do operate on you physically because uh they're live and there's an exchange of energy going on between the audience and the and the performers, and it's kind of fun. I mean, I can you can feel when you don't like something, and it does have you know, you might have been kicked in the stomach, you might have been just drained of your blood with all the vampire, and there we're so many bad vampire musicals all at once. So I mean that aspect of it is fun. The reviews I'm proudest of are probably the mixed ones where you actually said, This is interesting for this reason, it doesn't work for this reason, but it has something. Um, because it's it's harder to achieve that balance. And you also know readers don't want to read mixed reviews.
We're a thumbs up, thumbs down culture. Did you love it? Did you hate it? I mean, it has to be one or the other. And if we're absolutely honest with ourselves, we don't ever respond unconditionally to anything. All emotions are mixed by nature. I mean, that's just that's just the way it is. But anyway, so you're lying to some extent when you say perfection was reachable, of course, you're right. But uh, I mean, it's uh hype, it e everything is hyperbole. It's always a broader statement of what you feel than what you might have really felt. I think very, very few writers, and I'm I don't think any writers in journalism have that kind of crystalline quality of getting down to that core of ambivalence and everything. And no one wants to hear about it. We want clear signals.
[26:43] Jamie DuMont: Right. Right. So do you ever experience when you're writing a review that the idea that you have about the show um as you're expressing it might actually change. You know, you think you you thought you loved it, or you thought you had a certain reaction, but actually it turns out on further thought, well, maybe no, maybe it was a little forced or it was.
[27:00] Ben Brantley: Yeah, I mean I mean it usually I wind up going back to my initial response, because that's what you've got to go with is the gut of what you were seeing when you were watching it. And but then you know, you may think, I probably didn't think it was that funny. And then but then I've seen scripts where I'm just going, ah ha like every every other page. Right.
[27:20] Ben Brantley: So it's um and then I'll think, no, it was as good as I thought it was.
[27:23] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[27:24] Rob Russo: Yeah.
[27:24] Ben Brantley: Well, you said um I was doing a little research and I found something you had said about how you judge new works in particular. Um I'm gonna read this. Can you tell us a little bit more about that?
[27:43] Ben Brantley: Yeah. I mean, I think um I mean, what you're most looking for when with a new play is an original voice. It's not so much tell me something new as show me something new or something old even, but from a perspective I haven't seen before. And when that happens, that's really exciting. And I I think it's been happening a fair amount in in recent years. Um Jackie Sibley's Drury, I mean, I just think that's yeah, that's and she changes with each play, the way Carol Churchill does. So I I think that's exciting. Um but yeah, I mean it the one of the hard I think one of the hardest things to do in theater, because there are so many moving parts, live moving parts, is creating a production in which everyone is on the same page and it's a self-contained universe that abides by its own rules.
And obviously the play has to be have has to create a consistent reality to begin with. Although some directors can make you believe that the playwright has done that when she or he hasn't necessarily.
[29:56] Ben Brantley: And with him, it's like it's straight from the id. It's um it's the worst things you think. Um God. I mean, like the Nazi brother and sister in the bathtub. They're um, but it's it's very much his own vision. And you know, you can throw this stuff out just to shock, and some people do, and sometimes it seems really gratuitous, like you know, nudity and noble coward. But uh but but there are when something truly shocks, I think that means that's good. It's not it's not too easy to be shocked, right?
[30:30] Jamie DuMont: No, but it sounds like what you're talking about, there's a truth in in what's shocking. It's not gratuitous, as you said, exactly.
[30:35] Ben Brantley: It's honest, which is a big difference. No, and by shock, I guess I don't mean, you know, um, well, I was starting to say eating babies, but then I thought blasted's a really great play. But for other reasons, Sarah Kane was one of the most shocking playwrights ever to emerge. I mean, the way Ibsen must have been perceived, was perceived at the end of the 19th century. And but that's because it's it's questioning assumptions uh and and questioning things that make you comfortable. I think Edward Alby in the early days did that too, very much so. Um and um and that and in that case, I don't think it's shocking for shocking's sake. No, shocking's for shocking's sake, is I mean, it that's what a lot of the 60s movies were, I think, too. That you look back on them, you go, oh no, it's just you know, thumbing your nose or um, you know, pulling down your pants.
[31:28] Jamie DuMont: Right, and they don't hold up in the same way.
[31:30] Ben Brantley: No, no. Well, when when when thinking about new work in particular, um because you have a deadline and you have to write something in a relatively short amount of time. Um do you ever have the experience of of writing a review about something and then the play stays with you and you keep thinking about it, or you even revisit it maybe a month or a year later and you find that what you initially wrote doesn't tell the full story of how you feel about it, or I mean I but I also think it's how you feel about it on those different occasions too.
[32:03] Ben Brantley: It's it's what are you bringing to it that night that you see. I mean, I never if I look back on what I wrote, I uh I don't ever think, oh, that wasn't what I was feeling. If it was when it was what I was feeling, I feel I I did a decent job. But the great thing about theater is that it is chemistry. I mean, you could have a second date that just works, even though it's the same people involved, and in a way, in a way it didn't the first time. Yeah, I mean, there is some argument argument that for for critics seeing something more than once, but I'm not sure that's fair either, because again, one of the joys of a theater is that it's sort of a singular experience. But um, yeah, and also, I mean, for example, the musical once, um, when I saw it at New York Theater Workshop, I thought the music was lovely.
And I thought what um Stephen Hoggett did with the staging with with John Tiffany was was was quite beautiful. But I didn't love the book. Uh and uh it was Endo Walsh, a playwright I really like, who does much more sort of outre things most of the time. And he's also done one for the one that's coming in now. Sing Street. Right, Singh Street. And um uh but when I saw anyway, Grace, when I saw once, I I liked it, I thought that it the it was a little precious, especially up close. When I saw it on Broadway, I thought, you know, it really benefits from the distance, because those are very striking images. And and and I somehow I bought um Kristen Milliotti's character much more. This, oh you like my vacuum cleaner. I mean, once you kind of get past that.
[33:42] Jamie DuMont: Do you think she'd be allowed to be cast today?
[33:44] Ben Brantley: Oh, that's interesting. That's a good question. Probably not. No. No, I guess. Probably not. And that wasn't that long ago. Yeah, things happen very quickly.
[33:53] Jamie DuMont: That was certainly not even a decade ago, was it?
[33:53] Ben Brantley: No. No. Like eight years ago?
[33:57] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.
[33:58] Ben Brantley: One thing that I think is um incredibly hard to write about is direction. And I wonder if you could share for us a little bit about how you go about assessing a director's work, because it's one thing that's literally not on the stage, right?
[34:13] Ben Brantley: Yeah. I mean, there are the um the auteurs, uh which you tend to find more in experimental theater. Uh and when you're working seeing something like uh Richard Foreman, who's not working anymore, but when I was covering his stuff early early on, I mean, that is a director's vision. That's a very specific vision. What do you get with Elizabeth Lecomte, and even though it's a collaboration, the Worcester group, it's a very, very specific vision, as specific as you know, a Scorsese or uh uh um and any number of other um David Lynch, uh distinctive directors. You know, you're more aware of directing when it's bad than when it's good. Uh unless it's a director, unless it's something like, you know, uh a revamped uh an inspector calls where it's just whoa, who thought to do that?
You know, and I or Eva von Hova, obviously, you have to talk about the directing, because that's very much he's reshaping the world in a very particular image of his own. Um otherwise, I mean, some of the best are seamless. Uh, and uh, I mean, Joe Mantello is generally a seamless director who doesn't call a whole lot of attention to what he's doing, and in that case, you don't know what choices he steered the cast towards, for example. So you can't really say, uh, and you know, I mean you can I mean sometimes I think I say, you know, he uh the director, she or he uses the cast in a certain way, um, or seems to show the compassion of the writer or something like that. But unless you're you know in the room when it happens, uh it's uh you don't know exactly what has been achieved. There are often directorial visions, especially with Shakespeare, uh where everyone feels like they sort of have to have their own imprimature.
[35:54] Ben Brantley: You mentioned earlier, and I know Jamie was struck by it, um, the idea of a critic as a champion of a certain artist or a certain work. Um now I may have misspoken in that sense. I see what you mean. I mean, I would have said 20 years ago that I was a champion of David Mamet, but in that sense, only that I really really admired his work and the fact that he was able to put a new language on stage. Uh I still remain very hopeful as far as David Mamet's concerned, but I have been personally disappointed again and again and again since. So it's maybe it's more that a someone has a sensitivity to to a certain artist or an affinity with, I think, which means which means you're more likely to under possibly understand, but then they may change directions. I mean, the that's why I'm not friends with any of these people. I didn't even know any of them really.
[36:48] Jamie DuMont: Right.
[36:50] Ben Brantley: It would just um, you know, uh, it's it's not a personal relationship. On the other hand, one does respond very personally, and and if you feel angry, if it's someone you think is really talented who's let you down, who is sort of you know coasting, uh non-automatic pilot. I think you that's when I think you do have to pull back and cool off. I don't think you want to write a splenetic review about that. For because you don't want to run the risk of it getting personal, or or you just want to make sure that it's a level-headed Oh, you want it to be level-headed. You want it to be if someone comes back and says no, that's not right, that you at least have laid your argument out carefully. Uh, I I mean, you know, rage and passion are are very dramatic emotions, uh, but they don't really advance a critical argument very well, I don't think.
[37:40] Ben Brantley: You just mentioned um that you know you you don't know these people personally, no. And I guess there is a question of whether or not critics are considered part of the theater community, or whether they are, you know, their own sort of outsiders who are looking in or or assessing from the outside. Um, and you actually you said in Matt Winman's book, I don't hang out with theater people, it's not my world.
[38:01] Ben Brantley: No. Um, so you it seems to you you've drawn very clear line in their life.
[38:05] Ben Brantley: Yeah, I think that comes from my parents being journalists, also, and there was just a certain code of what you you could and couldn't do. Women's wear, on the other hand. I mean, everyone was in bed uh with everyone else, not literally, um although in some cases probably literally as well. But it was um, you know, you were expected to have lunch with the designers and get gossip from them, and um, and these are the people you might crucify in the in the pages the next day. So perhaps that thickened my skin. Um, but also, that was very much the editor's sensibility. That was John John John Fairchild. But no, I uh I once went to a dinner for Simon Russell Beale. Uh you've heard this story, right?
[38:43] Jamie DuMont: I have not, I have not heard it.
[38:45] Ben Brantley: This is my party anecdote. A friend of mine, he was doing um something with the bridge at Bam. I think it was Vanya and maybe 12th night. And um this friend of mine who loves to give dinner parties um called me when the my review came out and said, um, oh thank god you liked it. Can't you come for my dinner for him? And I thought, eh, I know he's English. I've never said anything bad about him. I mean, how bad can it be? And um, so I went, you know, and there were um, you know, people were gathered in the little uh whatever it is, the you know, cocktail area, and um uh Simon and I were were talking politely, and uh someone said, Hey, you guys aren't even supposed to be in the same room, are you? And someone else said, No, it's okay. Didn't Ben say he was the greatest uh uh classical actor of his generation? And Simon Russell Beale said, no. He said, perhaps the greatest classical actor of his generation.
[39:46] Jamie DuMont: There you go.
[39:48] Ben Brantley: Well, I think you've just answered our next question.
[39:52] Jamie DuMont: Which was, you know, you're you many people know your name, right? Because of who you write for and and and and the longevity of your career. But I think a lot of people don't know who you are, and I don't think you probably get recognized on the street um very often. I could be wrong about that. And is that all by design? I mean, do I want to be a brand name all in myself? No. I mean, do I want to market my personality? No. No, I'm um I came from a rather private family. And um, I mean, I answer any questions happily, but I'm I I lead a boring life. I am kind of protective of my um friends, but um, you know, when everyone you know is an organized crime, you can't talk about it all.
[40:41] Jamie DuMont: Well, that's very true. That's very true. Do you find though, you know, because you're you're called upon by your profession to bring your you know your critic hat to the media that you consume. Do you find that when you're not on assignment, you're able to maybe perhaps approach things without such you know the the scrutiny or the rigor that you might bring to you?
[41:00] Ben Brantley: No, no, I mean if I watch something like Knives Out, I'm not gonna be, you know, um, or I just watched the um uh the BBC Dracula.
[41:07] JamieDuMont: Have you seen that?
[41:09] Ben Brantley: Um I hear it's quite good.
[41:11] JamieDuMont: Yeah, it is it is it's so do you like Sherlock is that sensibility?
[41:15] Ben Brantley: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[41:16] JamieDuMont: It's bloody too.
[41:16] Ben Brantley: Uh very bloody.
[41:18] JamieDuMont: Um but yeah, you know that stuff I can I can sort of veg out on.
[41:23] Ben Brantley: Uh I mean, obviously there's a part of you that you're always gonna have an opinion. I mean, we're just built to have opinions. Um but it's kind of a relief not to have to be quite so analytical about it. On the other hand, I can let my attention wander, which I would never do if I was reviewing a play, uh, which means that you can't be bored. If you're paying attention, you can't be bored because you're trying to figure out something while you're watching it. So, you know, I can be bored by the third season of The Crown.
[41:50] JamieDuMont: Because you well, I have two questions actually. Do you have a word count at the Times?
[41:52] Ben Brantley: Um, I mean, on the budget, you know, saying what's going in. Uh usually, uh I think Jesse and I are down for like a thousand words.
[42:03] Ben Brantley: Uh sometimes I go over. I think the one tomorrow is 1,065.
[42:08] JamieDuMont: And no, it's no one's gonna call you out on that.
[42:11] Ben Brantley: No.
[42:12] Ben Brantley: No, and also if it's something like, you know, um the uh the Inheritance, it's I mean, that's six hours of theater. I mean, you do need some space to spread out on that, and no one's gonna see. You should be almost allowed two thousand words for six full hours.
[42:29] JamieDuMont: Well, because you have a deadline.
[42:31] Ben Brantley: Yeah. Um, and so by virtue of that, you there is a time frame in which you have to file your review.
[42:36] JamieDuMont: Right. Do you ever find that you file a review and then you continue to think about a work and then maybe even revisit that work and think maybe my review didn't fully capture my experience or capture what I wanted to say?
[42:48] Ben Brantley: Well, I think it did capture the experience of how I felt about it that night. I mean, whatever I write. It's uh because I mean it's not a static work of art. So, and we aren't static people. You're gonna see things a little bit differently every time.
[43:05] Ben Brantley: Um there are um I mean, going back and seeing Caroline, or Change in this production, it impressed me so much more than it had the first time.
[43:16] JamieDuMont: Um You mean the original production.
[43:18] Ben Brantley: Yes.
[43:19] JamieDuMont: Yeah, with the George C. Wolfe.
[43:21] Ben Brantley: Right, right.
[43:22] Ben Brantley: Um so um, I mean, on the other hand, going back to A Bright Room Called Day, I didn't feel like I'd missed something the first time around.
[43:31] JamieDuMont: Well, let me ask you this, because there is this real thing in theater that shows you know, shows get shows get reviewed sort of fairly early on in the process. Right. And then they tend to come into their own, you know, six months or so is there is why isn't there a second review? Or why why doesn't a critic go back and look at something a second time?
[43:52] Ben Brantley: Well, I mean, I think we would if we had more time. There is so much opening right now, and even and we have you know, a wonderful uh group of um of stringers of uh of other critics uh who I think bring a very particular and piquant viewpoint to you know each of their reviews.
[44:08] Ben Brantley: Um but even so it's tough. Um I mean I you know there we used to more routinely, I mean, um go back and see how you know the musicals were holding up. They usually didn't want us to come.
[44:24] JamieDuMont: Yeah, yeah.
[44:25] Ben Brantley: Well, I guess it depends on the show, right?
[44:27] JamieDuMont: But other things I remember going back and um I mean I've been asked sometimes to go back and see things a second time. There was a production of The Best Man that I actually that really had they really had gotten it right further on for further down the line.
[44:41] Ben Brantley: Um was this the most recent or the one before that?
[44:44] JamieDuMont: No, it was the one before that.
[44:45] Ben Brantley: Yeah, yeah.
[44:46] Ben Brantley: Yeah. Was that a little that was the Jeffrey Richards production?
[44:48] JamieDuMont: It was something like that.
[44:49] Ben Brantley: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[44:50] Ben Brantley: Yeah. With Chris Ebersoll and a bunch of people.
[44:53] JamieDuMont: Yeah, yeah.
[44:54] Ben Brantley: Oh, yeah. Chris Eversoll is sort of well, not Pat Nixon. She was, she was Jackie Kennedy, wasn't she?
[44:59] JamieDuMont: Yeah, yeah.
[45:00] Ben Brantley: And sometimes people do settle into it. And sometimes you can sense it's there's kind of a nervousness uh abroad. I mean, when you see things in in the summer, and I do like to go to some of the um the various uh outposts, summer theater outposts, but Williamstown or whatever, um being the most obvious, you think they had two weeks to put this together.
[45:20] Ben Brantley: And yet sometimes when um uh Sam Sam uh Rockwell and you know Ariana did Fool for Love, I mean, they stepped into those parts at the last minute. The original cast wasn't wasn't they bowed out, and they were sensational. I mean, it was just, and I think they kept that kind of rawness and spontaneity when it came to Broadway, and that was a play no one went to see.
[45:41] JamieDuMont: Yeah, I saw it.
[45:43] Ben Brantley: Yeah, sometimes the stars align and then everything else doesn't.
[45:45] JamieDuMont: Right.
[45:46] Ben Brantley: Oh, I do think Sam Shepard will ever actually do well on Broadway.
[45:51] JamieDuMont: You don't think he ever will, or you think he'll sorry?
[45:53] Ben Brantley: I think he'll, I mean, he's he's I mean, it's like Beckett, do you know what I mean? It's just, it's it's it's not what I mean, audience Waiting for God though did open here, and it opened on Broadway and it got respectable reviews.
[46:06] Ben Brantley: But basically, the most important playwrights, all being an exception, aren't are not necessarily box office.
[46:12] JamieDuMont: Well, I guess we know we've we've talked now for uh a good amount and we've covered a lot of ground. But one question that we haven't really talked about is what is the purpose of theater criticism?
[46:23] Ben Brantley: Oh theater criticism. I mean, I love reading criticism, I always have. Um my um uh sort of tutelary god when I was a kid was Pauline Kael. I my parents subscribed to The New Yorker, and I I read her most avidly, and I think she's probably had more influence on me than uh at least among critics than anyone else I I read.
[46:45] Ben Brantley: But I did realize early on that my response was not going to be the same as hers. Uh it's I I like to think that I was also a person of taste, but then I thought, no, I I I don't agree with that. I mean, and you shouldn't be ashamed ever of how you uh react to something unless you've really been had, you know, like a by a systematic systematic button pushing.
[47:07] Ben Brantley: But I loved reading her. I loved her passion. I love being able to have the conversation in my head with her or George Bernard Shaw or Kenneth Tynan, uh, James Agee, Frank Rich. I mean, those are just um, they're fun and they're passionate voices with strong points of view.
[47:26] Ben Brantley: And if they make you mad, that's good too. You want to make people, I mean, I as I say, part of my job is to um is to provide a window onto theater for people who might not go otherwise, uh, or might not necessarily be tempted to go otherwise, uh, and to recreate that moment historically.
[47:46] Ben Brantley: But mostly it's for people who like theater, like me, who have their own ideas and want to talk back. And I don't think you have to have that conversation online. Uh, I think it can be uh an internal conversation as well. But that's just the way I grew up reading.
[48:01] Ben Brantley: Um, I mean, I don't think I couldn't imagine myself at 10 going, Pauline Kael about this.
[48:09] JamieDuMont: You said the blah blah frame.
[48:11] Ben Brantley: Right, right. Is there in all your years of reviewing, is there one show that sticks out as being particularly memorable or transcendent more than any other?
[48:21] Ben Brantley: Uh everyone asks me that every time it changed, I give it a different answer every time. Uh today.
[48:27] Ben Brantley: Today's answer is uh the Globe Theater production of Twelfth Night with Mark Rylance.
[48:34] Ben Brantley: Uh I just I saw it first at the globe itself, and it's one of those things where I just started crying five minutes into it and pretty much didn't stop.
[48:43] JamieDuMont: That's the one that came to Broadway.
[48:44] Ben Brantley: Yeah, yeah.
[48:45] JamieDuMont: Yeah, that was that was magical.
[48:47] Ben Brantley: There's something about candlelight.
[48:49] JamieDuMont: Yes, that's true.
[48:50] Ben Brantley: Yeah, there's something about candlelight. None of them look today over 30.
[48:56] Ben Brantley: Oh my gosh. Well, um, as we round to the end of our of our conversation, um, what is something about being a professional theater critic that most people don't know that you wish they knew?
[49:09] Ben Brantley: Um, oh gosh. I think the less they know the better.
[49:15] JamieDuMont: Okay.
[49:16] Ben Brantley: Well, there it is.
[49:17] JamieDuMont: There it is. That's fine.
[49:18] Ben Brantley: Well, we have one final question, and this we ask every single person.
[49:22] JamieDuMont: And that question is was there a particular show or moment in your life that made you want to be a part of the theater?
[49:30] Ben Brantley: Uh, it was probably a Wake Forest College that was then production of My Fair Lady in the Round.
[49:39] Ben Brantley: I went backstage, and the smell has always been very seductive for me. You know, I haven't been backstage in so long. I don't know if it smells the same.
[49:47] Ben Brantley: Uh, you know, the hot lights and the grease paint and the sweat and the it does, yeah.
[49:52] JamieDuMont: Well, it's a little more electronic, right?
[49:55] Ben Brantley: But yes. Right.
[49:56] Ben Brantley: Um, and um it was it was totally magic to me. It always was um just to be, and I I think I love books for the same reason, uh, which is just someone saying, I'm going to create a world for you now.
[50:13] Ben Brantley: And to actually have that taking place before your eyes in the flesh. I mean, I think it appeals, I mean, it's a good being a child is a great being as a child, it's a great time to fall in love with the theater because there is something it taps into that is very childlike in the best sense, which is that sense of tell me a story.
[50:45] Rob Russo: Rob here with you may be wondering. To be honest, my head is still spinning from our conversation with New York Times co-chief theater critic Ben Brantley. During that chat, he mentioned Richard Maxwell a couple times. You may be wondering, who is that? Well, Richard Maxwell is an experimental theater director and playwright based in New York, who currently serves as artistic director of the New York City Players, a theater company he founded in 1999, primarily as a platform for his own work, but though the company has also had partnerships with other artists and companies over the years.
[51:15] Rob Russo: Born in West Fargo, North Dakota in 1967, Maxwell studied acting at Illinois State University and began his professional career with the Steppenwolf Theater Company in Chicago. He's also the founder of the Cook County Theater Department in Chicago. In his work as a playwright, Maxwell is known for creating narrative-driven works that incorporate the repetition and artificiality of the theater.
[51:36] Rob Russo: I suspect that Ben Brantley had Richard Maxwell on his mind when we spoke because he had just written a review of Maxwell's latest play, Queen's Row, which consists of three monologues by women set in the aftermath of a civil war in a near future America. In that review, Brantley calls Maxwell the most complete American theater auteur of his generation.
[51:55] Rob Russo: He goes on to report throughout more than two decades of experimental playmaking, during which Maxwell has become an august presence in international theater, he has aspired to almost Olympian neutrality. His plays have depicted all sorts of archetypes in classically extreme situations: boxers and adulterers, cops and crooks, lonesome cowboys and wandering knights, with an air of deadpan detachment.
[52:17] Rob Russo: In recent years, he has focused on mortality, in both a personal and general sense, with works of elegant distillation and subtraction. Brantley goes on.
[52:27] Rob Russo: Queen's Row is ultimately a portrait, not just of what is lost when a world ends, but of what remains. And he closes his review with the following observations.
[52:35] Rob Russo: Ultimately, Queen's Row is a testament to the forms of faith, from the eloquently religious to the more inchoate and instinctive that allow human beings to endure amid unspeakable loss and privation. That summing up would probably be too sentimental for Maxwell, who carefully resists the clichés of uplift and consolation.
[52:53] Rob Russo: It's true that his women are all so irrevocably solitary, you feel that they would be devoured by the shadows at any moment. But it's not darkness in which we end the show. Or not unconditional darkness anyway.
[53:05] Rob Russo: The production ends with a sly concluding vision of ineffable beauty, in which slender columns of light slice through the pitch blackness. They're barely perceptible, but they're there. They almost feel like hope.
[53:14] Rob Russo: And on social media at Fabulous Invalid.
[53:47] Rob Russo: The Fabulous Invalid is a production of Owen M, etcetera and the Fabulous Invalid LLC and a proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network. Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Aaron Kaufman and Charles Van Kirk.
[54:01] Rob Russo: And be sure to tune in next Wednesday.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
