Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 82: It’s A Hit! Part One

On this week’s show, Jamie and Rob launch a special three part mini-series looking at some of the biggest Broadway musical hits of all time, beginning with 1943’s landmark “Oklahoma!” and continuing through today’s juggernaut “Hamilton”... Read More

From the show: The Fabulous Invalid

1 h 25 mins
6/24/20

Featured Shows

About

On this week’s show, Jamie and Rob launch a special three part mini-series looking at some of the biggest Broadway musical hits of all time, beginning with 1943’s landmark “Oklahoma!” and continuing through today’s juggernaut “Hamilton”. Part One focuses on the biggest hits of Broadway’s golden age.

This week’s music: “Guns & Ships”, “Yorktown”, “It’s Quiet Uptown”, from “Hamilton”, “Kansas City”, from Royal National Theatre’s “Oklahoma!”, and “Out Of My Dreams” from “Oklahoma”, “Overture” and “I Could Have Danced All Night” from “My Fair Lady”, “Put On Your Sunday Clothes”, “Before The Parade Passes By” from “Hello, Dolly!” (Channing), “Hello, Dolly!” by Louis Armstrong, “Before The Parade Passes By” from “Hello, Dolly!” (Martin), “Before The Parade Passes By” from “Hello, Dolly!” (Midler), “Tradition”, “Fiddler on the Roof”, “Traditsye”, from “Fiddler on the Roof - 2018 Cast, in Yiddish”, “The Man of La Mancha” by Linda Eder, “Dulcinea” and “The Impossible Dream” from “The Man of La Mancha: New Cast Recording, 2002”, “Helpless” from “Hamilton”.

Find us on Twitter & Instagram: @fabulousinvalid

Facebook: www.facebook.com/fabulousinvalid

Rob’s reviews: www.stageleft.nyc

Email us at: info@fabulousinvalid.com

Jamie Du Mont

Twitter: @jamiedumont

Instagram: @troutinnyc

Rob Russo

Twitter/Instagram: @StageLeft_NYC

Jennifer Simard

Twitter: @SimardJennifer

Instagram: @thejennifersimard

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:19] Jamie DuMont: Welcome to the Fabulous Invalid, Broadway's podcast where we present essential conversations with a curated roster of the best, most important, and innovative theater makers working today.

[0:28] Rob Russo: From actors to writers, directors, designers, and everyone in between.

[0:32] Jamie DuMont: We took our name from the title of a 1938 play by Kaufman and Hart that has since become a loving nickname for Broadway itself.

[0:39] Rob Russo: Always deemed on the verge of decline, yet always bouncing back the fabulous invalid.

[0:44] Jamie DuMont: I'm Theater Savant, Jamie DuMont.

[0:46] Rob Russo: And I'm Rob Russo, writer and theater critic with StageLeft.nyc and Stage Left the Podcast.

[0:52] Jamie DuMont: Hi, Rob.

[0:53] Rob Russo: Hi, Jamie.

[0:54] Jamie DuMont: Here we are.

[0:55] Rob Russo: Yeah, we're back.

[0:56] Jamie DuMont: Uh well, you know, it's been so wild during this time of quarantine and self-isolation and COVID-19 to think about how in 2018, when we picked the title of the show, we had no idea that it would take on such added meaning in just two years.

[1:13] Rob Russo: You know, The Fabulous Invalid. Broadway's always in decline and always bouncing back. We're in the decline right now, but we will be bouncing back.

[1:21] Jamie DuMont: But yes, it is sort of ironic that the world has taken this terrible turn.

[1:28] Rob Russo: But um, yeah, you know, it's interesting to read on Twitter or in the media, people are now using the term the fabulous invalid to talk about the theater.

[1:37] Jamie DuMont: And um I, you know, as you were alluding to, I feel a little vindicated because as we've mentioned before, it's a weird title.

[1:44] Rob Russo: It is a weird title.

[1:46] Jamie DuMont: I understand that the word invalid is a touchy word.

[1:50] Rob Russo: Yeah.

[1:51] Jamie DuMont: And words matter and they have meaning, and I get that. But I love what this means.

[1:57] Rob Russo: I've always loved the idea of the theater being this sort of cyclical thing, that it has its ups and its downs. And that's actually the point of these episodes.

[2:06] Jamie DuMont: First with our flops, and now we're going to focus on the hits with a three-parter.

[2:11] Rob Russo: So it's gotten even bigger. And it's so interesting how intertwined these two things are.

[2:17] Jamie DuMont: And in doing these shows, how thin the line is between a flop and a hit, and how it really can go either way.

[2:26] Rob Russo: And we certainly learned that with flops, and we're gonna learn that with hits today. But we're gonna focus, like we did last time, on the modern era of musical theater, beginning around the time of Oklahoma.

[2:36] Jamie DuMont: And to avoid making a list that is too presentist, we didn't just use the number of performances as our metric because, you know, obviously, hit shows are running now longer than ever before.

[2:48] Rob Russo: In fact, 13 of the top 20 longest-running Broadway shows opened in the past 40 years alone. And only 121 shows have ever run more than a thousand performances.

[2:57] Jamie DuMont: But as of March, nine of those shows were still running on Broadway. So things are running a lot longer than they ever did before.

[3:05] Rob Russo: So we're not just using length of run as our only metric in building this list. So we decided to pick a combination of the biggest, longest-running, and most culturally important hits since Oklahoma revolutionized the musical, each laying some claim to being the Hamilton of their time.

[3:22] Jamie DuMont: Yes.

[3:23] Rob Russo: And just like last week, we used Carrie as our lens to kick off the way we were gonna look at flops. I think it's helpful to think of Hamilton, you know, as being the same sort of lens for all the shows that we're gonna look at, you know, simply because it's something that we can wrap our heads around today in understanding sort of the magnitude of what a gigantic hit on Broadway looks and feels like and what it does for the culture, you know, writ large.

[3:46] Jamie DuMont: And I think that's, you know, part of what makes Hamilton so unique is that it is a show that has sort of penetrated the culture of America and globally to become sort of a household name. And that's kind of gonna be the same case for every musical that we're gonna talk through on this episode.

[4:02] Rob Russo: Well, it's interesting that we're already talking about Hamilton in the context of being one of the greatest hits ever in Broadway's history, and it's only in, you know, it's still in the infancy of its run, really.

[4:14] Jamie DuMont: If you think about it, it's what's it, what is it, five years into the run?

[4:17] Rob Russo: It's been running for five years now, just under 2,000 performances.

[4:20] Jamie DuMont: Alexander Hamilton.

[4:23] Rob Russo: Troops are waiting in the field for you. If you join us right now together, we can turn the tide oh, Alexander Hamilton.

[4:38] Jamie DuMont: I have soldiers getting healed for you. If we manage to get this right, they'll surrender my early life will never be.

[5:25] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah. The thing that's the biggest tell about Hamilton is that in just five years, it has grossed around $622 million. By comparison, The Phantom of the Opera, which has been on Broadway for 30 years, has grossed 1.2 billion dollars in that time.

[5:45] Jamie DuMont: So Hamilton has made almost half as much as The Phantom of the Opera in five years. And that show has been running for 30.

[5:52] Rob Russo: So it's already the seventh highest grossing show in Broadway history and has cleared, you know, or will clear 2,000 performances shortly after coming back, whenever Broadway's back. So by any measure, it's clearly, you know, one for the books.

[6:06] Jamie DuMont: The world's side.

[6:11] Rob Russo: The world turned upside.

[6:21] Jamie DuMont: The world's got beat the book right.

[6:38] Rob Russo: We won, we won, we won!

[6:40] Jamie DuMont: We won!

[6:40] Rob Russo: The world's not sure.

[6:47] Jamie DuMont: We got into trouble with Hamilton a little bit last year, right?

[6:52] Rob Russo: Because when we did our best of the decade, that's right.

[6:56] Jamie DuMont: We both of us left Hamilton off of it and inadvertently, yeah.

[7:01] Rob Russo: Well, inadvertently, but also, I mean, I think I'll speak for myself, it just didn't come to my mind.

[7:06] Jamie DuMont: So even though that's that, I guess that technically that was not by design, but also it was by design because I don't think of it that often because, you know, as much as I love it, and I actually listened to the album today because I hadn't heard it in a while.

[7:22] Rob Russo: So I put it on and it's magnificent. But it's not, it's, and I've seen it three or four times.

[7:25] Jamie DuMont: I've seen it three times actually. And I love it, but it's not part of my daily routine.

[7:35] Rob Russo: It's not in my soul.

[7:36] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I mean, it's interesting because a lot of the shows that we're gonna talk about on this episode, we sort of grew up with, right? We either experienced them when they first came out, or, you know, we've spent years and years living with them, and they've become sort of a part of our DNA.

[7:50] Rob Russo: Whereas, as you said at the top of this, Hamilton's only been around for five years. And in those initial five years, it's really hard to access, right? I mean, you can listen to the album, you can engage in all the fan culture around it, but to actually sit down at the Richard Rogers Theater costs a lot of money, and you have to wait a long time, and that's still the case.

[8:08] Jamie DuMont: So, you know, it's unlike some of these other shows, I think for us as theatergoers, as frequent theatergoers, because, you know, you've seen it three times, I've seen it twice. And, you know, it's not something I plan to do in a long time because I don't want to shell out that money. I'd rather see, you know, four other shows for the price of what it would cost me to see Hamilton.

[8:29] Rob Russo: I agree with that, and I think it's a marvelous show, and I think it definitely deserves its place in the history and the context in which we're framing all of this.

[8:39] Jamie DuMont: You know, one other thing I will say, and I'm sort of a bad person in a way, to be doing a show about hits because I'm a natural underdog person, which is why the flop show really spoke to me.

[8:51] Rob Russo: I'm gonna not love some of these hit shows because I tend to love the underdog, you know, and I've actually gotten some flack in doing this show, our show, over the last 83 episodes. I've gotten some flack about, you know, my taste in theater and what I like to promote and what I'm drawn to.

[9:08] Jamie DuMont: And you know, that's fine. I mean, I think that's the wonderful thing about theater. There's something for everyone.

[9:13] Rob Russo: Um, and I'm not gonna, you know, I'm not gonna spend a lot of time shitting on these wonderful shows. But it is funny to me that I'm such a contrarian and I tend to really like the things that don't, I tend to resist things that I'm told I need to love because they're part of the cultural zeitgeist.

[9:33] Jamie DuMont: Right, a hundred percent. Well, that's, you know, sort of what I was getting at, you know, the sort of the flip side of the fact that we've lived with some of these shows for so long is that because of that, you can sort of take them for granted or come to resent them because, oh, you know, it's a show that gets done all the time, or oh, that's what tourists see, or that's what, you know, that's what high schools do, or whatever, right?

[9:53] Rob Russo: Um, but there's a reason why you get to the point where it's a show that tourists want to come see because, you know, it's very successful. And that doesn't always mean that it's, you know, meritorious critically, um, or that it represents some achievement artistically.

[10:06] Jamie DuMont: Um, but you know, a hit can come in many different ways, just like a flop can come in many different ways. You know, what I saw Hamilton for the first time was the day after it opened on Broadway. And so I, no one had heard the music yet, no one knew what it sounded like.

[10:19] Rob Russo: There was no cast album, you couldn't experience it except for sitting in the theater. And I sat back at the end of it, I was somewhat overwhelmed because it's a lot to take in on one viewing, especially if you don't know any of the words or music going into it.

[10:30] Jamie DuMont: But what I said to my friend Maya, who was with me, was more so than representing any sort of innovation in the musical theater, because I don't think that Hamilton actually does represent any sort of innovation in the musical theater. To me, what it represents is just the perfection of the form, right?

[10:47] Rob Russo: It's a testament to when you have a really incredible artist, Lynn Manuel Miranda, and he's given the space and the time to develop something, which is what the Public Theater provided off Broadway. Um, you can create something as magnificent and gorgeous and celebrated as Hamilton.

[11:07] Jamie DuMont: And to me, that was its greatest accomplishment as a piece of theater, is that it represented sort of the apotheosis of the musical theater form. Um, you know, obviously in a specific genre that it's working in, it's not Hello Dolly, um, which I would also say represents that same apotheosis.

[11:25] Rob Russo: Um, but you know, it's almost now, as you were alluding to, becomes kind of like uncool to like Hamilton because it's so cool, you know.

[11:34] Jamie DuMont: Well, okay, so as long as we're telling my first Hamilton story, um, you know, I went, I saw it early in the run, but I showed up, I sat in my seat, and I folded my arms across my chest, and I thought to myself, prove it.

[11:47] Rob Russo: Right.

[11:47] Jamie DuMont: Break some ground, Hamilton. Show me how good you are. I will admit I had a little bit of an attitude about it, and I have to say, within seconds of it starting, I was swept away and taken by it.

[11:58] Rob Russo: And I think what was so surprising to me in that first viewing of Hamilton, as groundbreaking as it is, or revolutionizing the form, or whatever you want to say about it, it's really just a good old-fashioned musical.

[12:12] Jamie DuMont: Well, right, and it, and it, which is what you were saying. And I that wasn't what I, I was not expecting that to happen. I was expecting it to be all these things I thought it was, and what it really is is just a very good traditional musical.

[12:28] Rob Russo: It's quiet up to forgiveness.

[12:34] Jamie DuMont: Can you imagine forgiveness?

[12:42] Rob Russo: Can you imagine if you see them in the street walking by side, talking mother side happy.

[12:57] Jamie DuMont: They are going through the unimaginable.

[13:12] Rob Russo: Once it sort of made the leap and permeated pop culture, I sort of had, I sort of bristled any time, you know, someone who doesn't really know musicals would point out to Hamilton, I'd be like, okay, great. Now that you know the Hamilton, there's all these other great musicals you can discover that are also just as well crafted and, you know, are also good representations of what you can do with this form.

[13:32] Jamie DuMont: But I will say it is certainly, and I agree with you a hundred percent, it is one of the few times in my life where something lived up to the hype. And I saw it, I saw it two years later in 2017, and I walked in with the arms crossed, you know, sort of prove it, prove that you're still worthy of this, and I was like crying five minutes in, you know, so it totally, totally proves its worth and holds up.

[13:58] Rob Russo: And to add to that point, and then we'll I think we'll then move on. Yeah, I saw it about a year plus after it opened on Broadway in San Francisco.

[14:09] Jamie DuMont: That's right.

[14:10] Rob Russo: And I had an even better experience the second time around. I absolutely loved that. And of course, it's the same production with Jeff, but I loved it so much more. And I think part of it is because by that point I was more familiar with the score, and I had gotten, you know, I'd fallen in love with it. But I think it was also that was a wonderful company, just like the Chicago company and so on and so forth. And I think that again, like all theater, it changes with the actors and with the environment and with this the San Francisco audience was really extraordinary. So there's so many different interesting sort of things whirling around what makes something a success and what makes your experience of that what it is. And I think we should um move on to our very first show.

[14:58] Jamie DuMont: Let's do it.

[14:59] Rob Russo: Yeah. Well, so just like with the flops, we're gonna break these down into categories. So our first category, it's it's it's Jamie's way of sneaking in multiple shows per category.

[15:08] Jamie DuMont: So we're not just doing dead.

[15:09] Rob Russo: We're not uh look, I'm complicit. I'm with you on it.

[15:11] Jamie DuMont: Way to throw me out of the bus, Rob.

[15:15] Rob Russo: Because it's your innovation. I want to celebrate your cleverness, Jamie.

[15:19] Jamie DuMont: Wow. Is that what it is? An ode to Jamie.

[15:22] Rob Russo: Yes.

[15:22] Jamie DuMont: No, so this first category is gonna have two shows in it. Um, and I labeled them the OGs.

[15:29] Rob Russo: Well, when I saw that, I thought, God, that's so not Rob Russo to say OGs.

[15:34] Jamie DuMont: But it fits well, it's and and it's you know, it has double meaning because they're they're they're such not gangster shows.

[15:40] Rob Russo: Right, exactly.

[15:42] Jamie DuMont: Or they're so not gangsta. But in a way they are, in a way they are because what we're talking about.

[15:47] Rob Russo: Yes.

[15:48] Jamie DuMont: Right. A lot of people have said that Oklahoma, which no surprise to anybody listening, is the show we're gonna start with. People say it was the Hamilton of its day. And although I don't love that description, um, it's accurate.

[16:01] Rob Russo: You'd you'd rather people say that Hamilton is the Oklahoma of now, right?

[16:05] Jamie DuMont: Girl, you'd rather sat around.

[16:07] Rob Russo: Yeah. You know it. Well, we we've talked about Oklahoma on this show before. Um, once or twice.

[16:14] Jamie DuMont: Once well, well, just about every other episode. Um, but we did a whole episode um around the revival with Mary Testa and Alice Broker as guests. Um, go and check it out. Um, can I I have to stop for one second because I thought you were actually billing that Oklahoma is Mary Testa's Oklahoma, which I think is, you know, for me, that's pretty accurate.

[16:33] Rob Russo: Yeah, for a certain uh genre of fan, that was the case. Yeah, you were there for Mary Testa. Sorry, I just I I gotta get a little Mary Testa love in. Sorry.

[16:41] Jamie DuMont: We always we always do. Anytime her name is mentioned, uh brings a smile to my face. Um, but uh Oklahoma, right? Um, was the first collaboration of Rogers uh and Hammerstein, um, the first piece that they worked on together, but you know, launching this partnership that revolutionized Broadway, right? So it makes sense that it would it would be first, and uh what we've talked about on the show before, and I've I've sort of vented to Jamie before, as like he's like my therapist, um, is my whole life. I was always like, okay, so what is the big deal about Oklahoma? Like, really, what is it? What is it about Oklahoma that made it such a transformational moment in the American theater? And I I never really got a satisfying answer until I read the Todd Pertham book, Something Wonderful, and he articulated it so well.

[17:29] Rob Russo: Um, because there's so many, you know, you can point to any one innovation in the show, and you can find some other show that did it before them, right? So it's not necessarily that Oklahoma was the first to do any of the things that it did, right? To to sort of eschew conventions by having an opening number that was very, you know, modest, to uh to have uh a ballet sequence, right? The dream ballet at the end of Act One, um, or to you know, tackle serious subject matter. Like all of these things had happened before. What made Oklahoma so groundbreaking is that it was the first to do all of these at once, and you know, and in service to serious character development. Um, and of course, with outstanding success, right? I mean, you had you couldn't just do the innovations, you had to do them really well.

[18:17] Jamie DuMont: Um, and that's what they did. You know, they they integrated dance into drama, they broke with all the musical comedy conventions of the 20s and 30s, and you know, took this play, Green Grow the Lilacs by Lynn Riggs and completely elevated the material with the addition of their just incredible score. I love this story, and I just have to tell you now the whole reason the idea of musicalizing Green Grow the Lilacs came about. There was a production at the Westport Playhouse, and they did a revival of the play, and there was a uh woman from the theater guild by the name of Terry Hellburn, who was in the audience that night. And one of the devices that they did with this production was they brought in a young dancer by the name of Jean Kelly to stage some of the musical numbers.

And those musical numbers were there was like a hoe-down, and there was like a square dance, and there was a little bit of dancing that was part of the story. And Terry Halburn from the Theater Guild was in the audience that night, and she had this flash that it should be a musical. So she started trying to make this happen.

[19:22] Rob Russo: And the response that she continually got, musicals don't have murderers in the second act.

[19:27] Jamie DuMont: Right. Which I love. Because now they do.

[19:30] Rob Russo: Now they do, right? Yeah. Talk about innovation. It's like what you were saying earlier. I mean, it's 40 minutes before there's a huge dance number, right? Kansas City comes at about 35 minutes into the piece. That was unheard of, along with all the other unheard of things you mentioned a moment ago. Like that just was so crazy, and yet it works so beautifully.

[20:16] Jamie DuMont: Let's go.

[20:46] Rob Russo: Right. And that's and that's how he how he would justify any sort of break from what, say, you know, some other uh songwriting duo or or musical theater duo would have done. Um is you have to let, you know, sort of this is what Steven Sondheim reduces to, you have to let the content dictate the form, right? And right, and that is what he did. And it's it's actually, I've never done the analysis, but uh I've read that the musical follows the play pretty closely. I mean, even down to even down to lines of dialogue that are just transposed right from the play.

[21:21] Jamie DuMont: Right from it, I think the like one of the major differences is that Judd is called Jeter, right? Like that's one of the big changes.

[21:30] Rob Russo: And and 808. That was a good change.

[21:32] Jamie DuMont: That was a good change. And 80 Annie is sort of a frumpy wallflower kind of character. She's not the big, you know, because they needed, you know, there were some conventions they had to hollow. But I think you make a very good point because in in that in those days, the convention was to have the form dictate the audience needs. And what Oscar Hammerstein did, as you so smartly put it, was flip that, right? Change that whole paradigm and make it about the piece. And he understood that audiences, I I think probably because he had had some success with Showboat years earlier. Yes, that he understood that audiences were smarter than they were given credit for. And I think also credit is to um Ruben Mamoulian, the director, who who had, let's face it, hadn't done a uh hadn't done a Broadway show in in uh in uh 15 years or something like that. He had gone out to Hollywood and made movies, but he had directed Porgy and Bess, which also didn't take the audience's intellect for granted.

[22:36] Rob Russo: Right. And and I think those are huge things, but I agree with you, it's Oscar 100% who drove that home. Mm-hmm. And this was 1943, you know, there was we were still in World War II. And the show ran five years and two months, which was completely unheard of. I mean, you know, a musical typically didn't run more than one season, and this was a show that ran five years at the St. James Theater. It broke the record within like two years of being the longest running um uh show and and held that title of longest running musical for 15 years, which is the longest, you know, time that any show has held that title in the modern age. Um so, you know, it it wasn't just that it was big in the moment, it was big for the next two decades, right?

It held that place um and really changed the terrain of Broadway. Um, it won uh sort of a special Pulitzer Prize in 1944. There were no Tony Awards yet. Um, but I'm willing to bet that had there been Tony Awards in 1944, they would have won all of them. Um willing, because you can name another show from 1943.

[23:45] Jamie DuMont: I mean, I can't.

[23:47] Rob Russo: No, I can't I yeah. And well, they would have been reviews largely, right? They would have been these things, an heiress marries a prince and her jewelry gets stolen. You saw on Broadway.

[23:58] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, absolutely. Um I I do have to say, uh this I love that um when it opened out of town in New Haven, um, Walter Winchell wrote, No legs, no jokes, no chance.

[24:12] Rob Russo: Ha! This is something else I love from that from that run in New Haven. This was actually, I think, on the first performance. Uh the producer Max Gordon was so nervous uh that during intermission, he started hitting up investors that he heard speaking positively about the show to see if he could um divest his own investment in the show. And he was quite successful at at it to the point where he almost completely got out of the show. And thank God for him, I guess he didn't because he, you know, ended up making a lot of money on it. But can you imagine? Like so didn't believe in his own thing that he wanted it out of it. And that's amazing.

[24:52] Jamie DuMont: Well, you know, the the total budget of the show was $83,000, which you know for the time was, you know, a pretty penny. Today you can't do anything for $83,000. I mean, literally, right? Um but you know, it's a good thing he didn't completely divest himself because um investments in the show received a 2500% return, right? A thousand dollars became 2.5 million in return.

[25:18] Rob Russo: I I don't know if you know the answer to this question, but what other show has that happened on? Is that just seems so unusual?

[25:25] Jamie DuMont: I think we're we're about to talk about one.

[25:27] Rob Russo: Right. In fact, should we should we transition or do you have anything else you want to speak about?

[25:32] Jamie DuMont: I have two.

[25:32] Rob Russo: No, I have two. Well, you know, I love Oklahoma. I know we can talk about Oklahoma all day.

[25:36] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, well, we've done a whole show on it.

[25:37] Rob Russo: So but um, which you should listen to, it's very good. Um, but two other things. I did not know this, and I know a fair amount about Oklahoma. The original person they wanted to play, Lori. Do you know who it was?

[25:49] Jamie DuMont: No.

[25:49] Rob Russo: Shirley Temple.

[25:51] Jamie DuMont: Oh my gosh.

[25:52] Rob Russo: Shirley Temple, who was 15 or 16 years old at the time.

[25:56] Jamie DuMont: And her old child.

[25:58] Rob Russo: So that's a whole nother level of like, you know, weirdness, and also it's a different time and whatnot. I and granted, she was a big star, so I understand why you were upset. But I also think they they I think I think Rogers and Hammerstein thought she could really pull it off. I don't they were very smart about casting, you know, they didn't do stunt casting. Um, ever. And I th her parents were the ones that thought it was not appropriate for her brand. Um although I don't think they called it a brand in 43. But um, and then the one final thing I have to say, because I would encourage everyone listening to this show to go to the YouTube. Type in the University of North Carolina's Restoration of Oklahoma, if only to see what it actually would have looked like in its day.

So this university, several years ago, they found as much information as they could about the original production, and they reconstructed it perfectly. It's impeccable. It's and it's so like not what you think it looks like. I liken it to Oz. You sort of like you you step into this world where the colors are just so bright, and you're like, what is going on? You would never design a show like this today. Never. And it uh in one way it looks so phony, and yet in its day, it was so revolutionary, so mod was so modern. And um, so it's really worth looking at it, even if you only watch it for a few minutes. I suggest you watch the ballet because it's magnificent.

[27:26] Rob Russo: Yeah, um, but it's really we haven't mentioned her yet, Agnes DeMille.

[27:30] Jamie DuMont: No, and you know, she was apparently quite a handful on this production, you know. She was very, it was her first kind of big thing in theater. You know, she she'd had a career in the dance world, so it was kind of a a risk or a chance they took on on hiring her, and apparently she gave them all a lot of hell. Um, God love her though, she stuck to her guns, and um, you know, the proof is in the pudding.

[28:25] Rob Russo: We this day, Oklahoma remains the 34th longest running Broadway show, which is not bad considering, you know, how long shows are running since Oklahoma, right?

[28:44] Jamie DuMont: Five years now, you say five years, it's like, okay, that's a healthy run for a hit musical. But, you know, at the time, of course, that had never happened. And it's still, you know, it still makes the list. Um, and of course, there have been five revivals, uh, of which I've been fortunate to see two. Um, and I know Jamie's obsessed with the 1979 revival.

[29:02] Rob Russo: Well, it was perfection. And it was the it was the thing that turned me on to Oklahoma. You know, it was not it was not my high school production. You never forget that Oklahoma that turned you onto Oklahoma.

[29:15] Jamie DuMont: No, never, never, never. And and I mean Christine Andreas, yeah, Christine Ebersol, all the Christine. I mean, it's it's it's it was a magnificent production.

[29:26] Rob Russo: Yeah. Alrighty. Well, moving on to our second show, our second OG of this category. Uh, we already alluded to it uh gently, and that is My Fair Lady.

[29:37] Jamie DuMont: Yes. Which, yeah, which you know is the most successful musical of the 1950s. Um also ended up being uh the longest-running show on Broadway, a title it held from 1961 until 1970. Um, and uh has you know spawned four revivals.

[29:53] Rob Russo: So it's it's it's never it's never long before you see another revival of My Fair Lady. Um and I guess there's there's a certain reason for that. Um Jamie, do you want to go first or should I go first in in telling our truth, our collective truth, our shared truth?

[30:08] Jamie DuMont: Rob, I think you should fall on the sword first.

[30:10] Rob Russo: I'm gonna fall on the sword, and we're gonna get some hate mail. I don’t care for My Fair Lady. I really did this show. I just it does nothing for me.

[30:20] Jamie DuMont: I agree with Steven Sondheim. They painted a lily. It has no reason to be a musical.

[30:25] Rob Russo: I I don't understand why it's a musical. I I don't find it enchanting, I don't find it romantic. I I've never, I mean, I enjoyed the Lincoln Center revival because it was Lincoln Center, and you know, they do a fabulous job with everything they do. It was a gorgeous production. Lauren Ambrose, I thought was actually pretty great.

[30:42] Jamie DuMont: I liked her.

[30:43] Rob Russo: Yeah, and Laura Benanti was a superb replacement. Um couldn't go back.

[30:48] Jamie DuMont: Uh really.

[30:49] Rob Russo: Yeah, I just I just don't care for it. I understand, you know, uh all the reasons why I should love it, and I just never have. Um, but that's that's me. But you know, look, it was the longest-running musical on Broadway for 10 years. It was the Hamilton of the 1950s. Like, you know, clearly there was something there that people loved in the time and continue to love because it keeps being done.

[31:11] Jamie DuMont: Well, okay, now we should say some nice things about My Fair Lady. It does have a fabulous score, and I think that part of its enduring legacy has a lot to do with the film.

[31:20] Rob Russo: There was a very successful 1964 film adaptation with Audrey Hepburn.

[31:25] Jamie DuMont: Some might argue she was miscast. You know, a lot of people thought it should have been Julie Andrews. Although, if you don't know this, and I can't imagine you don't know this.

[31:33] Rob Russo: Things worked out pretty well for Julie Andrews because she ended up doing Mary Poppins that year, and she won the Academy Award, beating out Audrey Hepburn.

[31:43] Jamie DuMont: So, you know, she's quite happy with how that all worked out.

[31:46] Rob Russo: Yeah, yeah. Well, it's kind of funny that she got her her her award in the end because when I was doing research for this, I realized I didn't know this, that she didn't win the Tony that year.

[31:55] Jamie DuMont: You know, it won six Tony Awards, including Best Musical, but she lost to Judy Holliday for Bells Are Ringing.

[32:02] Rob Russo: Well, I think we we look at it through the lens of what we know and what we tend to forget is that back then she wasn't Julie Andrews yet.

[32:11] Jamie DuMont: No, no.

[32:11] Rob Russo: This is what made her Julie Andrews.

[32:13] Jamie DuMont: Right.

[32:13] Rob Russo: Right. Judy Holliday was a big star in a in a vehicle. The star vehicle that was written for her. And if you know anything about Bells Are Ringing, you know it's a really tough show to do if you're not Judy Holliday.

[32:25] Jamie DuMont: My Fair Lady, you know, the thing that I find so interesting about it is that it opened at the Mark Hellinger Theater, which is now the Times Square Church. Um I'm sorry I had to say that sentence, but you know, I had to share that knowledge.

[32:36] Rob Russo: Um then it moved to the Broadhurst Theater, which is obviously much, much smaller.

[32:39] Jamie DuMont: Um, but then it moved to the Broadway Theater, which is huge.

[32:43] Rob Russo: Right.

[32:44] Jamie DuMont: And I find that so funny. You would never do that today. You would never move a hit show to a smaller theater, then move it to a bigger theater, right?

[32:51] Rob Russo: Well, today you really don't move shows.

[32:53] Jamie DuMont: We're gonna we're gonna talk about a lot of shows that did a lot of moving over the years.

[32:58] Rob Russo: It was a really, you know, it was a it was a it was a thing that would happen. And uh it doesn't happen so much anymore.

[33:04] Jamie DuMont: Very rarely.

[33:05] Rob Russo: Well, the last thing I'll say about about My Fair Lady, uh, then we can move on. Uh, you know, sort of as an example of how big of a deal the show was and and how it had this cultural crossover into the mainstream.

[33:17] Jamie DuMont: It was the best-selling album in the country in 1956.

[33:20] Rob Russo: The cast recording of My Fair Lady was the best-selling album. Not the best-selling cast album, the best-selling album, period.

[33:39] Jamie DuMont: Let's go.

[33:56] Rob Russo: No, maybe, maybe Hair got close.

[33:59] Jamie DuMont: I don't, I don't know.

[34:00] Rob Russo: We'd have to look.

[34:01] Jamie DuMont: Um, I will say a couple things I I find interesting.

[34:04] Rob Russo: Okay.

[34:05] Jamie DuMont: This is this is another show that everyone said couldn't be musicalized, primarily because there's no central love story in the plot, which, you know, again, this in a way, it sort of broke that convention, um, which I think is interesting.

[34:21] Rob Russo: Um, as we mentioned, I think before on this show, um, that Rodgers and Hammerstein decided not to adapt this musical, and it then went to Lerner and Loewe, who couldn't find their way in, they couldn't quite figure out how to make it work.

[34:34] Jamie DuMont: And in those days, the show was actually controlled by Chase Manhattan Bank, who had the rights or had they they controlled the estate of Gabrielle Pascal, who who was the original film producer of Pygmalion, which was what they based My Fair Lady on.

[34:51] Rob Russo: So the bank had the rights, and the bank had wooed a studio in Hollywood to make a musical of Pygmalion, and that got Lerner and Loewe interested again in trying to adapt it.

[35:05] Jamie DuMont: They figured out a way to do it, and without having the rights and knowing they didn't have the rights, they said, let's do it and see if we can win it.

[35:13] Rob Russo: Which I think is. I mean, talk about like knowing your strengths and just going for it. I love that story.

[35:19] Jamie DuMont: All righty. Well, should we should we move on to the 1960s?

[35:23] Rob Russo: I think it's time for you to put on your Sunday clothes.

[35:26] Jamie DuMont: Oh my gosh. Well, so in our second category, we're gonna look at three shows that we are calling the Titans of the 1960s. And Jamie, kick it off with our first show.

[35:36] Rob Russo: Well, I think it'll be no surprise that our first show is Hello Dolly, which is a show that I can say with great assurity, Rob Russo and Jamie DuMont love.

[35:48] Jamie DuMont: I'm just obsessed with Hello Dolly. I have been, you know, I've I've said on the show before, it's the reason that I fell in love with the theater. Um, you know, I saw the Long Beach High School production in 1998 and was hooked. Um but this, of course, obviously is you know the Jerry Herman musical from 1964, um, based on Thornton Wilder's uh farce, The Merchant of Yonkers, which was a flop in 1938.

[36:14] Rob Russo: Um, and he later revised it into the much more famous and well-known uh play The Matchmaker in 1955, uh, which had been produced by David Merrick, who um optioned the play to become a musical, and then um uh called in Jerry Herman after seeing Milk and Honey, uh Jerry Herman's first Broadway show in 1961, and basically had him audition to be the composer for uh Hello Dolly.

[36:43] Jamie DuMont: Um and I always loved the way that Jerry tells the story. I can't tell it, you know, better than he could, but um, you know, David Merrick's chief concern, having only seen Milk and Honey, was whether or not Jerry Herman was American enough to write Hello Dolly, which is you know such an American story, because Milk and Honey, of course, is set in Israel.

[37:03] Rob Russo: And the music, that sounds kind of anti-Semitic to me.

[37:06] Jamie DuMont: Well, yes, it certainly does.

[37:08] Rob Russo: Uh side of the time.

[37:10] Jamie DuMont: Sounds like a euphemism for something else.

[37:12] Rob Russo: Uh-huh.

[37:13] Jamie DuMont: Yep. Uh, but Jerry didn't bat an eye, and he said, Mr. Merrick, uh, let me prove it to you. And he went home, and over the course of a weekend, he wrote four songs and came back on Monday morning, played them for David Merrick, and David Merrick famously sat back in his all-red office and said, Kid, you've got the job.

[37:31] Rob Russo: And of course, those four songs, uh, three of them would end up being in the final show.

[37:36] Jamie DuMont: Um, and you know, it's just a testament to the genius of Jerry Herman that he locked himself in his West Village apartment and wrote three songs that are enduring classics over the course of you know a single weekend uh to audition for the project.

[37:51] Rob Russo: What I love about that story is that he wrote Sunday Clothes as one of those songs, and the version that he wrote for this audition is the version that appears in the show. Not a word, not nothing was changed.

[38:05] Jamie DuMont: That what he wrote that weekend is exactly what ended up in the show.

[38:12] Rob Russo: Put on your Sunday clothes. There's lots of world out there. Get out the brilliant teen and dime the cigars.

[38:23] Jamie DuMont: We're gonna find adventure in the evening. Girls in white in a perfume night where the lights are bright as the stuff.

[38:34] Rob Russo: Put on your Sunday clothes. We're gonna ride through time in one of those new horse-drawn open cars.

[38:44] Jamie DuMont: We'll see the shows that El Monaco's and we'll close the town in our world.

[38:50] Rob Russo: But we won't come home until we kiss the girl.

[38:56] Jamie DuMont: This was a terrible experience for Jerry Herman, though.

[38:59] Rob Russo: He did not have a good multiple times, and he has an excellent biography, which I know Rob has read.

[39:06] Jamie DuMont: Um and he talks about um how terrible Merrick was, how he was constantly, you know, worried about losing his job.

[39:13] Rob Russo: Merrick would I Merrick was sort of there's a great biography on Merrick called The Abominable Showman. If you haven't read it, you should.

[39:20] Jamie DuMont: But he Merrick was also famous for pitting people against each other and also trying to, you know, his tactic was I'll scare the shit out of you and get you to work better.

[39:28] Rob Russo: So he was constantly bringing in, you know, a new director to, you know, a director to look in on rehearsals and scare the director, or you know, whatever the choreographer.

[39:38] Jamie DuMont: And he did that with Jerry Herman. He brought in um Charles Strauss and a couple of other people to Shamaryl, I think.

[39:43] Rob Russo: Bob Merrill, exactly.

[39:45] Jamie DuMont: And uh what I love about this is that during that process where Herman was sort of being scared, I guess, to work better. That's when he wrote um Before the Parade Passes by.

[39:55] Rob Russo: And he truly feels that that not only is at the heart and soul of the show, but it also is the song that saved his job.

[40:03] Jamie DuMont: It was the song that he wrote that Merrick finally went, okay, he's got it. We're good.

[40:08] Rob Russo: Before the parade passes by.

[40:15] Jamie DuMont: And taste Saturday's high life before the parade passes by.

[40:23] Rob Russo: I'm gonna get some life back into my life.

[40:28] Jamie DuMont: I'm ready to move out in front.

[40:33] Rob Russo: I've had enough of just passing by life with the rest of them with the best of them.

[40:42] Jamie DuMont: I can hold my head up high, for I gotta go again.

[40:48] Rob Russo: I've gotta drive again.

[40:50] Jamie DuMont: I'm gonna feel my heart coming alive again before the parade passes by.

[41:02] Rob Russo: It really is the spine of the show, and it's a perfect example of you know the value of going out of town, right?

[41:06] Jamie DuMont: I mean, they were out of town when they added Before the Parade Passes by to the show, and it became, you know, obviously sort of the anthem and like I said, the spine of the show.

[41:16] Rob Russo: Um, it also I think very importantly sets up Dolly so that you fall in love with her irreparably.

[41:26] Jamie DuMont: I mean, you you from that moment on, you are on her side a thousand percent.

[41:30] Rob Russo: I mean, you love her from the very first minute, and there have been a lot of people, we'll talk about all the famous Dollies.

[41:36] Jamie DuMont: But it's a beautiful character, and she starts out very strong, but it's in that moment where she becomes a uh a whole person, and and you really really get to know what her what her motivations are and and and and her struggles, and it's it's beautiful.

[41:52] Rob Russo: Look at that crowd up ahead.

[41:56] Jamie DuMont: Listen and hear that brass harmony growing.

[42:00] Rob Russo: Look at that crowd up ahead.

[42:04] Jamie DuMont: Pardon me if my old spirit is showing all of those lights over there, seem to be telling me where I'm going when the whistle blows and the cymbals crash and the sparkles light the sky.

[42:25] Rob Russo: I'm gonna raise the roof.

[42:27] Jamie DuMont: I'm gonna carry on.

[42:29] Rob Russo: Give me an old trombone, give me an old baton before the parade passes alive.

[42:38] Jamie DuMont: We focused on Jerry Herman, of course, because you know, name a better score than Hello Dolly, you can't. Um, but the unsung hero of Hello Dolly, I think is Michael Stewart, who wrote the book, and um it is an extraordinary, extraordinary book. It is so airtight, it is so smart, it is so funny. Um, I actually have read The Matchmaker. I was curious. I read The Matchmaker, um, and I know Hello Dolly very well from having seen it um a redacted number of times on Broadway. Um, and you can really see the artistry and the craft behind how uh Michael Stewart took that play and put it on stage, particularly around the Dolly character. You know, she's not in the play, despite the fact it's called The Matchmaker, she's not in the play as much.

She's not the through line that she is in the musical. And the biggest thing he did was take one monologue that occurs at the end of the play, The Matchmaker, and cut it up so that it occurs throughout the musical. Um, basically every time Dolly's out on the passerelle and you know, speaking to her late husband, Ephraim Levi, um, you know, that each of those moments is part of what is one monologue in the play. Um, and it's just, you know, an example of someone who, whether through intuition or you know, through studying, just had such an innate sense of how to structure a musical and how to deliver all the beats that you need to have to tell a story successfully. And when we sat with his sister, Francine Pascal, who did the book revisions to Mac and Mabel, she mentioned to us how Michael, Michael, like I know him, Michael Stewart, how Mr. Stewart likened the book of a musical to train tracks.

Um that is that you know, they're when you're on the train, you don't see the train tracks, but you know they're there and they operate, you know, they do their job and they operate seamlessly. If a book is great, you don't think about it, right? It's it's it's so good that it's invisible. If you can talk about the book, which is you know, perhaps why we led with the score, um, you know, nine times out of ten, it's because it's problematic, right? Um and Hello Dolly is just it's just a perfect book.

[44:55] Rob Russo: I agree with that. And I think the The Last Revival is the best example of that because glorious. It just it it every joke lands, it it moves so quickly, and there's a fair amount of book. There's a very long sort of book scene. There are a couple of sort of long book scene moments, and yeah, they just fly by. And and some of Dolly's speeches are really touching and really, really smart. So I agree with you. Um, Rob, how did Hello Dolly get its name?

[45:30] Rob Russo: Well, um, you know, it was originally titled Dolly, a damned exasperating woman. What a title for a musical. Uh, and then of course, there has to be an exc exclamation point in there somewhere. Somewhere, right?

[45:44] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.

[45:44] Rob Russo: And then they changed it to Call on Dolly, which of course is the first lyric in the whole show. Not a bad titan. Um Dolly. You know, um, at the top of uh the show. Um, and then um, which is fascinating to me, they gave the the song, Hello Dolly, um, uh, to Louis Armstrong to record um before the show even uh came to Broadway, right? This is before it was even out of town, I think. And it was released and was instantly became a hit. And so David Merrick changed the name of the show to Hello Dolly simply because of the success of that song.

[46:26] Jamie DuMont: Dolly Gellas. Have little faith in me, fellas. Dolly, never way, Dolly, never way again.

[46:44] Rob Russo: And then of course it became sort of an anthem for for in in in many different contexts, right? Uh, this was in 1964, the show opened, and it was an election year, and Jerry Herman did a different version of the song with different lyrics uh in support of Lyndon Johnson's campaign. Right. Uh Hello Linden, right? And then, of course, famously did another version of it for Oscar Meyer that was Hello Deli. It was uh uh the Delhi meet commercial. Um, and he sings all the versions of it um in his his nightclub show, uh, An Evening with Jerry Herman, which you can find on Spotify. And it's so delightful to hear Jerry Herman tripping through these lyrics.

[47:27] Jamie DuMont: Hello, Deli. Dally Chaste is here today. Dolly taste the homeway. Delly you'll never be the shady.

[47:36] Rob Russo: And there actually is a deli on 53rd Street called Hello Deli.

[47:41] Jamie DuMont: Ah, that I did not know.

[47:43] Rob Russo: Yeah, I pass it all the time, and I think, oh, you know, I wonder, I mean they have to have made the connection. There's no other reason why it would be named Hello Deli without knowing that that that pun. Whether it's officially sanctioned or not, who knows.

[47:55] Jamie DuMont: Right.

[47:56] Rob Russo: But yeah, yeah. Uh well, Hello Dolly ran uh 2,844 performances at the St. James Theater from 1964 to 1970. It's a seven-year run. Um, it won 10 1964 Tony Awards, including Best Musical. It holds the title today of being the 20th longest-running Broadway show. Uh, it's had four revivals, of course, most notably uh worse recently, the 2017 revival of Bet Midler. But speaking of Bet Midler, Jamie, why don't you share with us some of the the famous women who have played the role of Dolly Levi?

[48:26] Jamie DuMont: Well, in the original run, obviously Carol Channing, Ginger Rogers, Martha Ray, Betty Grable, Phyllis Diller, and then Ethel Merman closed that original production. But also, probably the most famous of the Dolllies in that time period outside of Carol Channing would have to be Pearl Bailey. Um, which in its day was quite, you know, quite innovative. They they they recast the show with an all-black cast. They put in Pearl Bailey, who and it's recorded. You can hear it. You can hear how marvelous she was. And look, this this whole show was written for Ethel Merman. I don't think that's a surprise. I think most people know that. She turned it down because she wanted a normal life. She wanted to be able to, as she said to David Merrick, I want to be able to eat dinner at eight o'clock like a normal person.

And she ended up obviously going back into the show. She couldn't be normal for too long. Right. But um, but Pearl Bailey, I think, really, I think it's hard to, I think you have to give her a lot of credit in terms of the popularity of the show, the legacy of the show, the enduring quality of the show. That was, she really pushed it to the next level.

[49:39] Rob Russo: Oh, yeah. And and, you know, despite the fact we've already pointed out David Merrick's um latent anti-Semitism, or perhaps just wearing it on his coat sleeves. Um, it was pretty, you know, bold of him as a producer. You have to give him some credit for in 1967, you know, sort of height of the civil rights movement, um, putting an all-black cast in a musical on Broadway. I mean, that, you know, in a musical that wasn't um, you know, sort of written uh by African Americans or or meant to take place, you know, or or dramatize a specific milieu or community. It's not like Porgy B Porgy and Bess, right? Or shuffle along, right? Shows that were written by African Americans or were meant to depict an African American community.

This is Hello Dolly, which um, you know, does not have an explicit sort of racial um uh uh lens to it. And to to do that, to put an all black cast uh in the show was was pretty bold and ended up paying off, right? I mean, it it was a huge success. They they recorded it. Um and Pearl Bailey toured with it and brought the show back to Broadway in 1975, and its first revival was Pearl Bailey.

[50:42] Jamie DuMont: Yeah.

[50:42] Rob Russo: Um, back, you know, back on Broadway. She's she is as entwined in the legacy of this show as as anyone else. And then I also have to mention my personal favorite, Mary Martin, who did Dolly in Asia, but also in the West End. And that production was recorded too. And it's a it's it's the recording I listen to. It's my go to recording.

[51:07] Jamie DuMont: Primarily, yes.

[51:08] Rob Russo: Well, I'm I'm not shy about it. Primarily because in the big hello dolly number, she yodels.

[51:40] Jamie DuMont: Look at the old gown now, fellas.

[51:56] Rob Russo: If you're Mary Martin, you gotta yodel. Um but it's a fabulous, fabulous recording. Um it's very different. Uh her take is very different. In fact, you know, I have to say I was never a big Mary Martin fan. I never quite, you know, on recordings, obviously, I never saw her. I didn't quite get it. And then when I heard this recording, I instantly understood why she was the star that she was. It all made sense to me. She's absolutely magnificent.

[52:21] Jamie DuMont: I do also have to say there were a couple of interesting replacements. Um Ernestina was replaced. There was a replacement of Ernestina that was Mabel King, um, with obviously with um Pearl Bailey. I love that. Um there was a Mini Faye replacement to Georgia Ingall and Leland Palmer.

[52:39] Rob Russo: Oh my gosh, wow.

[52:41] Jamie DuMont: So I just had to say that. And then of course we have the revival that was helped by Miss Bette Midler.

[52:49] Rob Russo: Oh my gosh. I I as I said, I saw that show a redacted number of times. And um saw all the Dollies. Jamie and I were very fortunate to be able to see not just uh the Broadway Dollys, uh Midler, Donna Murphy, and Bernadette Peters, um, but to go on tour and see Betty Buckley in Boston, who was just incredible, and Caroline Carmelo in Philadelphia. Um I think I've said this before. When when they announced that the show was closing on Broadway, my first thought was, oh no, I'm never gonna get to see Carolee Carmelo do it. And then, of course, uh, you know, she was the replacement on the tour. Um, and there's any number of people I would I would still love to see play this role. Uh Audrey McDonald, excuse me.

Uh, but uh the ones we had in this last revival to me were just and you know every one of them brought something to the role and made it her own. Um and it was so fun to see there. And I'm so happy we got to go to Boston to see Betty because I mean her performance, it was so different, and it was so exciting to see you know an artist of her caliber take on an iconic role and and do her version of Dolly, right? And and all of them did that. You can say that for all of them, whether Bernadette Peters or Beth Midler, of course, or Donna Murphy, who is just, I mean, you know, all hail Donna Murphy.

[54:18] Jamie DuMont: Hail Donna Murphy, you know.

[54:20] Rob Russo: I mean, just they were all the women who we love and adore, and they it was such a thrill to see them all excel on in in this role.

[54:28] Jamie DuMont: I I I agree with everything you just said. I had the great fortune of seeing Betty Buckley do it twice. I saw her do it in San Francisco.

[54:34] Rob Russo: That's right.

[54:34] Jamie DuMont: Yes. And then we we traveled to Boston specifically to see Betty Buckley, which was a marvelous evening. I have to say, the thing I loved about Betty's performance was that she and she was the only Dolly that truly did this. She was part like freight train and part Fragile Bird. And and sometimes in the same moment. And it was such a beautifully nuanced performance. And it's again, I look, I feel like we should turn this into the Betty Buckley Love Fest in our show. Um but it's true, and it was really remarkable. And and thank God that we got to see her do that because it was so extraordinary.

[55:14] Jamie DuMont: And then I just have to say about Carolie Carmelo, who was also brilliant. Rob is a huge Carolie Carmelo fan.

[55:20] Rob Russo: And she was meant to play this one.

[55:21] Jamie DuMont: She was meant to play this.

[55:22] Rob Russo: Yes, absolutely.

[55:24] Jamie DuMont: But when we saw it in Philadelphia, oh, as the trolley's coming out, and Rob knows that Carol Lee is behind one of those newspapers.

[55:33] Rob Russo: Yeah, I could just feel the warmth emanating from his body.

[55:37] Jamie DuMont: He sat up straight, he got a smile.

[55:40] Rob Russo: I it's the and I've sat next to you a lot in the theater.

[55:44] Jamie DuMont: So, and I've never has that happened.

[55:47] Rob Russo: I mean, it was really extraordinary. Um, and she and she delivered.

[55:51] Jamie DuMont: Oh yeah, God, that was a great performance.

[55:53] Rob Russo: They all did, every single one of them. I don't mean to single out Betty and well, because they're all so different, you know.

[55:59] Jamie DuMont: You can't.

[55:59] Rob Russo: That's when when people would say, Who was your favorite? I'd say, I can't answer that question. That's an impossible question because they were each my favorite in different ways.

[56:07] Jamie DuMont: Right.

[56:07] Rob Russo: And I think again, and we should we should move off of Dolly in a second. The other thing that's so extraordinary about this production was that it not it paid tribute to Carol Channing and to all the Dolllies that came before, but it actually freed us of that because these women were all so different and also magnificent that it had a it allowed the show to breathe and become a new thing again. And that's hard to do. And yet it was such a faithful, faithful production, right?

[56:41] Jamie DuMont: It was just so it honored what the original production I imagine was. And that's huge. I'm gonna carry on. Give me an old trumbol. Give me an old baton to be for the parade has five. And uh, I guess we'll find out when Broadway comes back uh with the music man. Um we'll get to see them work together again, which I'm really excited for. But moving on to our second 1960s Titan, uh, which was just one season later, which is unbelievable to think about. Um, it's the embarrassment of riches, you know, going from hello dolly in 1964 in the spring of 1964 to the fall of 1964 at the Imperial Theater, you could see Fiddler on the Roof.

[57:36] Rob Russo: Oh my god.

[57:52] Jamie DuMont: Which is Jamie's favorite musical.

[57:54] Rob Russo: Is that true? Or is it the King and I?

[57:56] Jamie DuMont: No, it's not my favorite musical. It's it's I think it's the greatest musical.

[57:56] Rob Russo: Okay.

[58:03] Jamie DuMont: Right. So which are different things.

[58:05] Rob Russo: I think Absolutely.

[58:06] Jamie DuMont: Fiddler on the Roof is the great musical of all time. I think it's a perfect musical. I love it. It's not my favorite musical. And you, you know, you Rob, you always say, oh, anyone can whistle is Jamie's favorite musical.

[58:05] Rob Russo: Right.

[58:19] Jamie DuMont: Follies is Jamie's favorite musical. King and I, I mean, yeah, you know, this is the we're living in this thing. I do. I, you know, I don't have one, I have 20. Um which is what we're doing today. Literally. Literally. Um, but I do think Fiddler on the Roof is is the great musical of all time. And I think that um Joel Gray said it best uh about the success and why it endures.

[58:36] Rob Russo: Yeah.

[58:44] Jamie DuMont: And Joel said, everybody thinks it's about them.

[58:44] Rob Russo: Right.

[58:49] Jamie DuMont: And I think that's sums it up perfectly. I think that's that to a T. That was the great sort of surprise of the whole thing, right? Um, how Prince, the producer of the show, legendary producer of the show, um, you know, was told by a lot of by a lot of people, you know, are you crazy? No one's gonna see the show beyond Jews in New York, right? And once you've once all the Jews in New York who go to the theater have seen it, it's gonna close, right? It's too parochial. And it was Jerome Robbins, uh director or choreographer uh on this piece who who you can really credit for for taking you know the stories of Shalom Alechum and uh and pushing the the uh writers of the show, so Jerry Bach and Sheldon Harnick, um, who wrote the the score, and Joseph Stein, who wrote the book, um, to to tell the story in a way that it could be true, as Joel Gray said, that everyone could think it's about them.

[59:49] Rob Russo: And the key to that, and this story has been told so many times, it's probably apocryphal at this point, but that while they were working on the show, they would meet, and Jerry would would push his collaborators and say, What is this show about? What is this show about? And you know, in every meeting they would answer, well, you know, it's about Tevya the Milkman and his daughters. And he'd say, No, that's this, that's the plot. What is it about? What's the idea? What's the and finally, in one of the meetings, and everybody claims that it was somebody else, someone said, tradition, it's about tradition. And Jerry Robbins sat back, sort of smirked and said, Yeah, that's your opening number.

[1:00:31] Jamie DuMont: Tradition. Tradition, tradition, tradition. In doing that, in in starting the show, you know, because originally as written, it started with a song called We Never Missed a Sabbath Yet. It was the family getting ready for the Sabbath, which is now the second scene of the show, right? But in the first scene, it now starts with the song Tradition, right? Which describes, you know, all the members of the community and their roles, and through that process, not only sets up all the characters, not only creates the world that you're living in, which is you know, 1905 Russia, um, but also builds the bridge to the audience so slyly, because every single person in that audience is a papa, a mama, a son, or a daughter, right?

And you instantly identify yourself. You're not realizing you're doing it, but you you're you're called upon to do it. And from that moment on, you're hooked. And it's got to be the best opening number in Broadway history, at least the most effective, um, in setting up the entirety of the show.

[1:01:39] Rob Russo: And then from there, it's the train tracks, you know, it's the it's Joseph Stein's book is just perfection. Well, I I might a little later in this show pick an argument with you about what the greatest opening number is. There's there's 50 of them, right? There's 50 of them. But for the moment, I'm gonna, I'm just gonna let you have that because I don't I don't disagree. But you are absolutely right. There really isn't there isn't a number I can think of that better sets up everything that's about to happen and also prepares the audience for what they're the journey they're gonna go on. And it I I do agree with you. I can't think of another opening that does it quite as as brilliantly as that.

[1:02:20] Jamie DuMont: And I didn't know that, I didn't know that story actually. I love it.

[1:02:23] Rob Russo: I know, I you know, it's funny, you know, when we do this preparation audience, um we we do a fair amount of prep work individually, and then we kind of marry our things together, and most of the time there's a lot of crossover. We you know, we we we want to talk about the same things, but every once in a while, um I say something you've never heard before. And I I love that story.

[1:02:46] Jamie DuMont: That's isn't it incredible? It's great. You know, it's also like there is no fiddler without Jerome Robbins. I mean, that that I more so as we have now learned than his his involvement with Westside's story. I don't know that you can extract Jerome Robbins from Fiddler in in at all, like completely, like you can with the revival of Westside Story, it was an all new choreography. I don't think I don't think Fiddler would be successful if you stripped everything that he did out of it.

[1:03:21] Rob Russo: I I just contributions are just baked into the DNA of it, right? I mean he's truly the author of the piece, even though he didn't write any of it. His fingerprints are all over it. And no matter what, no matter what version you want to do, I mean we just saw the glorious revival that that Joel Gray uh directed. How many times did we say that? Again, redacted, but um you know and even that which had a different director and a different choreographer and its own vision and was in a different language you still felt the presence of Jerome Robbins. And that's not a criticism of anyone it's it's a celebration of of his contributions to the piece.

[1:04:00] Jamie DuMont: Yes. It's so intrinsic to the to the piece. And of course, you know it it it was this phenomenon on Broadway, right? I mean a block away from Hello Dolly, uh half a season later, you have another gargantuan hit lines around the block because in that in those days you couldn't buy tickets any other way than showing up at the theater, right? And I think this is the the the story is that you know the day after it opened their line was so long that Hell Prince had um had caterers come and set up coffee and bagels to to feed the people waiting online to buy tickets because it was so long and they were waiting for so long.

[1:04:40] Rob Russo: I think I will say my husband has stolen on multiple multiple.

[1:04:45] Jamie DuMont: You learn from the best.

[1:04:46] Rob Russo: You learn from the best.

[1:04:47] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. You know, it would go on, of course, to run uh 3,242 performances from 1964 to 1972, uh, over seven years and 10 months, becoming the longest running musical on Broadway, a title it held from 1971 until 1979, and has had five Broadway revivals. Not to mention the off-Broadway revival we just saw, which ran longer than you know, probably uh at least the last two revivals that have been on Broadway.

[1:05:18] Rob Russo: Zone!

[1:05:34] Jamie DuMont: There's that legendary, you know, he was he was a difficult man to work with. Apparently, this was a very contentious uh rehearsal process. Right. Robbins and Zero Mostel fought quite a bit. There was lots of lots of things going on. There's that famous story of Jerome Robbins falling into the pit. You know, he's yelling at the he's yelling at the actors on stage, and he's backing up and backing up and backing up until he falls in the pit. And he was so disliked during that process that nobody stopped him to say that he was about to fall into the pit.

[1:06:04] Rob Russo: That has been assigned to Westside's story.

[1:06:06] Jamie DuMont: B.

[1:06:07] Rob Russo: Arthur has always told that it happened during Fiddler.

[1:06:10] Jamie DuMont: Well, maybe it happened multiple times. Who knows?

[1:06:12] Rob Russo: Dancer Deborah Jowett claims that it was during 1945's billion dollar baby. So who knows when it really happened? I think it's most attributed to Fiddler, but I I think it's even in that documentary Miracle of Miracles. But regardless of that, they certainly put a spectacular show together.

[1:06:31] Jamie DuMont: Oh my gosh. Yeah. And you know, there was a string of of Tevias in that original production, of course, starting with the famous Zero Mastel and um, you know, going on to Luther Adler and Herschel Bernardi, Harry Goss, uh Paul Lipson. Leonard Nimoy did it.

[1:06:45] Rob Russo: Leonard, there you go.

[1:06:46] Jamie DuMont: Not on Broadway in Boston, but still.

[1:06:50] Rob Russo: Okay.

[1:06:50] Jamie DuMont: Okay, okay, okay. And then revivals, right? So there was the 1971 film with uh Topol, and he headlined, you know, a tour and then the 1990 revival on Broadway. Of course, there's the 2004 revival with Alfred Molina, who was replaced by Harvey Feirerstein, who was on both of them.

[1:07:07] Rob Russo: I did too.

[1:07:08] Jamie DuMont: Yes. I actually saw Topol do it.

[1:07:10] Rob Russo: Oh, really?

[1:07:11] Jamie DuMont: I did. I I have to, I actually worked on the tour with Topel and Marsha Rod. And then the 2015 revival with Danny Burstein, who, you know, I know that revival was not necessarily praised, but I actually I loved it. I thought it was gorgeous. It was the Bartlett Scher production. And I thought Danny Berstein, talk about a role that someone was born to play. I thought he was magnificent. I thought Jessica Hecht was great. I I thought it it didn't. I thought the first act was really magnificent. And then it sort of wandered a bit in the second act for me.

[1:07:41] Rob Russo: But you know, people had the the Alfred Molina, there was a lot of criticism about the David Laveau production, yeah. Right. About the, you know, how it was just full of Irish Catholic girls, you know.

[1:07:51] Jamie DuMont: Right.

[1:07:52] Rob Russo: Lack of authenticity.

[1:07:53] Jamie DuMont: Right. And and I loved that revival. I again, I understand that argument, and I don't think anybody was wrong in saying that, but um, but they were all magnificent. I mean, you know, I'll watch Sal Murphy do literally anything.

[1:08:05] Rob Russo: Well, it's amazing. You know, the original production is so iconic, and and um, you know, part of the iconography of the show is the use of the Shigal paintings as inspiration for not just the logo design, but the set design itself. And Boris Aronson, the famous um set designer, um, you know, created that set. And amazingly, you know, the show won nine 1965 Tony Awards, including, of course, Best Musical. The only award it lost uh was for set design, which is so tragic. Because the set was, you know, so praised, right? But what I thought, speaking of the set of the show, you know, which has become part of the way that people think of the show, what I liked about the last revival is you know, there's always this the last Broadway revival, there's always this looming sense of you know what happens to the characters after the show, right?

Because it's 1905 and they're being forced out of Anatevka, and you know, it's a story of the Jewish people, right? And you know, of course, that the ones who go to Europe just 40 years later are you know facing genocide. And that looms over the show, and of course, you know it. And for audiences in 1964, it was very real and very visceral because you know, you had a real temporal tie to those times. But what I liked about the 2015 revival, the way it was designed is there was sort of imagery used throughout the piece in very subtle ways that sort of nodded to the Holocaust. And it was very eerie and very unsettling, but not heavy-handed. And I I thought that was tremendously effective.

[1:09:34] Rob Russo: And then not to mention the total reimagining of the show with the um National Yiddish Theater Volksbina's production that Joel Gray did, which you know was its own very different, very pared-down production that also, I mean, sort of is the answer to the question or the criticism of the 2004 revival in terms of authenticity, right? Not just because of the language, but the the way that the characters are more faithfully sort of portrayed based off of the original stories.

[1:10:03] Jamie DuMont: And Steven Skybell will always be the best Tevy I've ever seen. I I cannot imagine someone being a better Tevya than him.

[1:10:12] Rob Russo: I agree with that entirely.

[1:10:15] Jamie DuMont: And I think that Revival for many reasons is my favorite. And I've seen Fiddler many, many, many times. Um I worked on it, uh, as I mentioned earlier. Um and it there was just it was so beautiful. And we've we've said this before, but I think it bears repeating. The fact that it was in a language that you didn't speak or that I don't speak really to lean in and focus on the emotion and the storytelling in a way that I never have before. And it was such an extraordinary experience.

[1:10:51] Rob Russo: And I think that, um, I think in some ways there'll never be another production quite like that. But I can't wait for the next production because there's going to be another brilliant production that figures out another way to help you lean into the story in a new way that you haven't done before. You know, I have to say there's a there was a documentary called Miracle of Miracles that came out about the sort of the legend and the lore of the show. Um, it's a fine documentary, I believe it's streaming, you can watch it. But they make a claim, and now this is pre-COVID the world, right? So this is pre-everything shut down. But they made a claim, uh, that said that ever since Fiddler debuted, um, on Broadway, uh, September of September 22nd of 1964, the show has been performed every day somewhere around the world.

Now there's no way to corroborate that necessarily without doing a lot of research, and I don't think it's absolutely true, but what a lovely sentiment. How like just I want it to be true. I want it to be true because I think and I think it's not far off from being true, but um, but well, you know, to put a pin on this conversation, you know, I think the reason why it's performed so much, the reason why it resonates, the reason why everyone sees themselves in it. Um, it is, you know, as Jerome Robbins pointed out, tradition. Um, but to me, you know, the show will always be relevant because it's about change. Yeah, you know, and and human beings' societies change. And and at its core, you know, that is what it's about as a reflection of tradition, right?

I mean, that's you know, obviously the other the yin and the yang, right? Um, and you know, it will always be relevant because children will always be rebelling from their parents, and you know, minority groups will always be, you know, persecuted or fighting for, you know, for inclusion and respect and equality. And you know, there's so many thematic tie-ins that will just always remain relevant so long as human beings roam the earth. Sadly, racism will always be part of our world. Well, you know, I mean, like to hope it wouldn't be, but yeah.

[1:12:56] Jamie DuMont: Um, okay, so uh let's talk briefly about our third Titan of the 1960s, um, which might be one that folks are not expecting. Um, but in going through and doing the analysis of you know, sort of the biggest hits of the 60s, this was in fact the third biggest Broadway hit of the 1960s. And it's a musical that I personally just absolutely adore, and that is Man of La Mancha.

[1:13:19] Rob Russo: Yes, the impossible dream.

[1:13:22] Jamie DuMont: The impossible dream, yeah. Quite an interesting musical. And what a part of the history that I find so fascinating about it is that it was first developed as uh as a as a TV play for CBS in 1959. And it's, you know, if you know the show, it's you know, it's inspired by Miguel de Cervantes and his 17th century novel Don Quixote, but it's not a strict adaptation of that work. And I, you know, over the years, I think the writers of the show have responded to criticism or just, you know, uh confusion around the fact that they created their own thing, right? Inspired by, you know, the story of the mad knight, Don Quixote. Um, but the whole thing is a play within a play, you know, with Cervantes himself as a character.

And I find that structure to be so fascinating and you know, quite not just impressive, but you know, an innovation in its time, right? I mean, it's very much a product of that ethos of the 1960s of pushing boundaries and challenging, you know, conventions. And the score is very unconventional in that regard. I mean, there's there are no stringed instruments other than plucked guitars. It uses some Spanish instrumentation, which of course was something, a different sound to be heard on Broadway. And the whole thing premiered at the Anta Theater in Washington Square, which, if you know Manhattan, you know that Washington Square is not in the theater district.

[1:14:44] Rob Russo: And that is correct.

[1:14:46] Jamie DuMont: It is downtown. And this was a theater that was built as a temporary theater, uh sort of as a prototype for the Vivian Beaumont at Lincoln Center, and housed by the American National Theater and Academy, and was destroyed in 1968. Man of La Mancha was the last show to play there. But you had this show that was sort of a first-class Broadway production, but at this downtown theater. So it already had sort of this outsider, you know, artsier kind of edge to it from its very inception. And you know, show opened in 1965 again, that same season, you know, the next season after Fiddler, and uh, you know, won Best Musical in 1966 and would run until 1971, five years and seven months, and still holds its title today as the 31st longest-running Broadway show.

[1:15:31] Rob Russo: Well, it's not a show that I have a lot to say.

[1:15:36] Jamie DuMont: Tell I'm watching, we have a video set up right now. I'm watching Jamie's uh lack of interest.

[1:15:41] Rob Russo: My eyes blaze over.

[1:15:43] Jamie DuMont: Um, the reality is it's not a show I'm particularly fond of. Um, in fact, I've seen it twice, and I actually have zero memory of either. I saw my husband worked on a production with Raoul Julia and Sheena Easton that toured that I saw Broadway. I think in San Francisco or LA, I can't remember where, and I have almost no memory of that. I have more memories of the sort of backstage squabbles of that production, which wasn't a very particular uh it wasn't particularly popular. And um, I've got some stories about her that would curl your toes. Um, but that's another podcast. And I saw, I'm pretty sure, correct me if I'm wrong, Rob, didn't Marin Mazzie go in and take over the role for the revival um that was done with Brian Stokes Mitchell? Am I making that up?

[1:16:30] Rob Russo: No, I don't remember.

[1:16:32] Jamie DuMont: It was Mary Elizabeth Master Antonio at first, but I don't know who replaced her.

[1:16:36] Rob Russo: It might have been Mary.

[1:16:37] Jamie DuMont: I think it was Marin Mazzie. I think that's why I went. And again, I have no memory of that of that of seeing it, although I know I went because I can clearly see Marin, unless I'm conflating and making up, which is possible. I will say my real knowledge of that show comes from Linda Eder's spectacular rendition of the man of La Mancha. That that's that's not only is it without question the best recording of that song.

[1:17:08] Rob Russo: Oh my god, yes.

[1:17:09] Jamie DuMont: It's it's spectacular, but that's really what I know about the show and what I remember and what I relate to. So I again I I can't be um particularly helpful in this.

[1:18:03] Rob Russo: You mentioned the Raoul Julia. Most of them with Richard Kiley.

[1:18:06] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, I was about to say Richard Kiley, who created the role, and then it sort of became his, you know, sort of like Yul Brynner and the King and I. It sort of became his meal ticket for the rest of his career. He did it on Broadway in 1965 and then in 1972, and then in 1977. Um, but the 2002 revival with Brian Stokes Mitchell um was the first time I saw the show, first time I ever encountered the show, and I was blown away, and I listened to that recording, you know, once or twice a year, which is not often enough, but when every time I do, I sit back and I think, Jesus Christ, no offense to anyone who that's offensive to. What a gorgeous score. Every single song on that album. It's one of those no-skip albums. I listened to it from start to finish. There's not a single song I would want to skip. Dulcinea, I mean, what a gorgeous song.

[1:19:03] Jamie DuMont: I see heaven when I see thee. And thy name is like a prayer. An angel whisper.

[1:19:27] Rob Russo: That is pretty.

[1:19:28] Jamie DuMont: I will say, I listened, so I listened to this uh recording um in the last couple of days. Uh primarily because it was Brian Stokes Mitchell, and also primarily because when I put it on, I was convinced it was Marin Mazzie, and I found out I was wrong. Um, so I might just be making this whole Marin thing up. But uh I will say I had forgotten what a beautiful song Little Bird, Little Bird is. I mean, that is a gorgeous, gorgeous ballad. Um I I'll say something I find interesting about this show is that it was translated into over 20 different languages.

[1:19:54] Rob Russo: Dulcinea.

[1:20:01] Rob Russo: Wow.

[1:20:01] Jamie DuMont: And that's a lot. I mean, you know, there's you know, Mame might be up there. Hello, Dolly. I don't, I don't know. Fiddler, of course. But that's 20, 20 languages is a lot.

[1:20:10] Rob Russo: A lot.

[1:20:14] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. But I think this show, I think what's this now, again, I can't count myself as one of these people, but I am one of these people. I think this show resonates with people because it's about a dreamer. It's about an underdog. It's about, you know, everybody loves a uh a prostitute with a heart of gold. Like I it's it's but it I think it resonates with people because it it it it speaks to that like that thing we all have, which is you know we we all we all want to dream we all want to fight we all you know we all have that in us and I think it's very very powerful um yeah and I think look at look at what happened recently in our shutdown Brian Stokes Mitchell singing that uh and it has an anthem right like everybody's down for an anthem but he even Brian Stokes Mitchell singing impossible dream out of his window during the beginning of the shutdown that was a huge boost to people's morale that was that video went everywhere and even when you couldn't the first video where you couldn't quite hear him that went everywhere and I think that's part of the power of the show is that it speaks to so many people who want to fit in who want to belong who wanna who want to you know pursue their dream fight for what they think is right and will be better for this that one man scorned and covered with scars still strong with his left outcome oh my god, Brian Stokes Mitchell I I can't even with that voice.

[1:22:28] Rob Russo: No, no. And that recording is iconic. And then, of course, you know, he still sings it. Uh often it's become one of his signature songs for good reason.

[1:22:37] Jamie DuMont: Rob, you're selling me on Man of La Mancha. I can't believe it. What have you done to me?

[1:22:41] Rob Russo: If I've done nothing else with this podcast alone. This was all a ruse to get you to love Man of La Mancha.

[1:22:48] Jamie DuMont: Yeah, and thoroughly modern Millie, but that's a different that's a whole nother topic.

[1:22:53] Rob Russo: How about that? Well, I think uh we should pause here for this week, uh, and we'll pick up next time uh with the swinging 70s and the biggest hits of that uh that that time period.

[1:23:04] Jamie DuMont: Golly, Rob, leapin' lizards. Do you think the sun will come out tomorrow?

[1:23:09] Rob Russo: Little preview there, a little preview there.

[1:23:11] Jamie DuMont: Yeah. Don't want to give anything away too much.

[1:23:13] Rob Russo: Well, God, I hope I get it, you know.

[1:23:15] Jamie DuMont: Ah, there we go.

[1:23:16] Rob Russo: All right. Well, on that note, I think this is a perfect place to leave it, and uh, we will be back next week with more.

[1:23:33] Rob Russo: Well, that's our show. Thanks for listening. At this difficult time, please consider making a donation to the Actors Fund at ActorsFund.org. The Fabulous Invalid is a production of OM etcetera and the Fabulous Invalid LLC, and a proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network. Our theme music is by Lucky Chops. Today's episode was edited and engineered by Charles Van Kirk. Find us online at thefabulousinvalid.com and on social media at Fabulous Invalid and on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever you listen to your podcasts. And be sure to tune in Wednesday.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred