Adam Feldman is the Theater and Dance Editor and chief theater critic at Time Out New York, where he has been a staff writer since 2003. He is the president of the New York Drama Critics’ Circle. To keep up with Adam, his cabaret performances at Club Cumming, and more ... Read More
From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport
About
Adam Feldman is the Theater and Dance Editor and chief theater critic at Time Out New York, where he has been a staff writer since 2003. He is the president of the New York Drama Critics’ Circle.
To keep up with Adam, his cabaret performances at Club Cumming, and more . . . go check him out on Twitter @feldmanadam.
This week’s #SongwriterOfTheWeek is Michael Mott! If you enjoyed the outro song in this episode, go on over to www.michaelmott.net or check him out on Instagram @michael_mott.
Enjoy and thank you for coming back to our new season!
Keep up with me @KenDavenportBway on Instagram.
Check out my blog for daily content: www.theproducersperspective.com
This episode was produced by Mary Dina.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Adam Feldman: I actually get a lot more blowback for positive reviews of shows that someone didn't like. Someone would be like, I can't believe you like that. It's so stupid or so pretentious, you know. But if you don't like something that they did like, they often just think that you're smarter than that, you know, that you have higher standards, you know.
[0:14] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway.
[0:21] Ken Davenport: You're listening to the Producer's Perspective Podcast with your host, Tony Award winner, Ken Davenport.
[0:27] Ken Davenport: I'd like to propose a toast incomes company.
[0:40] Ken Davenport: Hey everybody, it's Ken Davenport. You are listening to the Producer's Perspective Podcast, and this week I'm sitting down with a critic.
[0:48] Ken Davenport: I know. I'm just as nervous as you are. Stay tuned for Adam Feldman from Time Out New York to give us his insight on what makes a fantastic show and what gets a terrific review.
[1:02] Ken Davenport: Hello, everybody. Welcome back to the Producers Perspective Podcast. My name is Ken Davenport. We're gonna get a very unique perspective on the podcast today. Because are you ready for it? I've asked a critic to join us.
[1:12] Ken Davenport: Ooh, spooky music, spooky music. I've gotten the garlic out, everything's gonna be fine. Don't worry. Please welcome to the podcast, Mr. Adam Feldman. Welcome, Adam.
[1:22] Adam Feldman: Hello, I'm glad to be here.
[1:24] Ken Davenport: So Adam is the national and theater dance editor and chief theater critic for Time Out New York. He is the president of New York Drama Critic Circle, was a co-host on Theater Talk, and just a regular man about town. You're like seen at piano bars all over town every week.
[1:38] Adam Feldman: Seen and heard. Actually, let's start there.
[1:39] Adam Feldman: So I was a piano bar junkie when I was in school at NYU and used to actually do like a little bit of a gauntlet seeing which one was best. What's your favorite piece of the book?
[1:50] Adam Feldman: Yeah, I am too. I was a duplex addict for many years. Uh, and uh that's in the West Village on Christopher uh and uh and seventh. And if you haven't been there, it's uh it's a lovely place.
[2:01] Adam Feldman: I used to go there really four or five times a week. Uh they have a pianist, people get up and sing. It's sort of a little bit in the live karaoke mode, in that uh it's it's solo artists, solo singers, amateur singers at the microphone in the front of the room.
[2:15] Adam Feldman: Uh, there's also an upstairs bar where there are sort of drag performances and things like that. There's also just across the street from there is Marie's Crisis, which is a different model, and that's just sort of downstairs in this dank old basement, and there's one piano and everyone gathers around it and sings together like like Christmas Carolers.
[2:33] Adam Feldman: And that's a very different feel. That's more of a community singing experience. Um, and uh that can also be great fun.
[2:40] Adam Feldman: Lately, I have been a regular on Monday nights at a club called Club Coming in the East Village that's uh co-owned by by Alan Cumming.
[2:49] Adam Feldman: And on Monday nights there, there's a an open mic show tune extravaganza with a really fun group of people. You know, there's really a community of friends there who go every week and they have different themes every week, and people sometimes will go all the way.
[3:06] Adam Feldman: They will dress up, they will bring props, they will rehearse group numbers, and so it has a it has a spunky feel, but it's definitely very show tune geeky, which I like, but it has a more downtown feel as well.
[3:18] Ken Davenport: So it's an interesting mix of things that you won't necessarily find at the duplex or Marie's. What's your go-to tune?
[3:24] Adam Feldman: Boy, I have a lot. I have a lot of I have a lot of went to tunes. I have a lot of tunes that I used to do all the time.
[3:31] Adam Feldman: Um, one of the nice things about Club Coming is because they have a different theme every week, it's really been drawing out some other sides of me. You know, you know.
[3:39] Adam Feldman: So I I instead of just doing the ones that I had gotten down in my muscle memory, I've been trying out a lot of new material.
[3:45] Adam Feldman: And sometimes it's uh successful, and sometimes uh less so. But it but it is it is like shows in general, so right, exactly.
[3:52] Adam Feldman: Can't win them all, and if you can't win any of them that you don't try. And you know, I I certainly have a a type of song that I was doing for a while.
[3:59] Adam Feldman: It's a long story, but I short version is I lost my voice completely about 10 years ago for a year and a half, and I had all these uh surgeries on my vocal cords, uh 11 of them.
[4:12] Adam Feldman: And uh I didn't know if I would ever be able to talk again. Um, and so when it when it when this disease went away, which was very sudden, uh, I found that I was able to sing again.
[4:23] Adam Feldman: And my voice had changed a little bit in a way that I I liked, uh, but it had become kind of rougher, and I started singing a different kind of song.
[4:29] Adam Feldman: I had sung show tunes really almost exclusively before this when I had sung it all. And now I started singing more pop music and trying to put my own sort of aesthetic stamp on it.
[4:40] Adam Feldman: And so a few songs came out of that. I definitely have a repertoire from that period. But now I'm I'm trying other things, and I might put together a little show one day. We'll see.
[4:48] Ken Davenport: I will be there for that for sure. So do you obviously started as a performer? Was that what where your origin story began?
[4:55] Adam Feldman: I guess I I think it would be more accurate to say that I started as a fan. I started as a as an enthusiast.
[5:00] Adam Feldman: I saw shows when I was a kid at Summer Camp or at my local community theater, and I they were musicals especially, unauthorized abbreviated musicals.
[5:09] Adam Feldman: Uh, you know, like 45 minutes of Pippin performed by 13-year-olds. Uh and uh it was enough, it turned out, because I I really did fall in love with a lot of that stuff.
[5:18] Adam Feldman: And then as I got older, I did some of those shows myself in summer camp or in local community things. And then I did some some theater when I was in college.
[5:27] Adam Feldman: I went to Harvard, so I did side work. They didn't have a theater program at that time. But they did have a lot of well-established theater groups, including the Hasty Pudding Theatricals, which I was in.
[5:38] Adam Feldman: It was a formerly an all-male show, so there was a drag element. I think last year they finally went co-ed after 150 plus years.
[5:48] Adam Feldman: So when I was in it, I I did uh play women in those, which was uh a great deal of fun. And then I moved to New York and I did do some theater here as well.
[5:57] Adam Feldman: I did some off-off Broadway theater. I did Shakespeare in the parking lot type stuff, and uh it was uh again really uh very fun, but not what I was intending to pursue as a career at any point for various reasons.
[6:11] Adam Feldman: But I did end up I still was going to the theater a lot. I lived in New York. I thought this is you know what to do in New York.
[6:18] Adam Feldman: And I started writing my thoughts online. I got into these uh discussion groups about theater on uh on the internet.
[6:27] Adam Feldman: Uh this is in the late 90s, it was on Unix, so it was a little discussion group called Rec Arts Theater Musicals.
[6:33] Ken Davenport: I was on that group.
[6:35] Adam Feldman: Yep, so there you go. So I we probably corresponded.
[6:37] Ken Davenport: I'm sure we did.
[6:38] Adam Feldman: I didn't all read or disagree.
[6:40] Ken Davenport: I'm sure we agreed about everything.
[6:41] Adam Feldman: I'm sure.
[6:42] Adam Feldman: Um but yeah, I signed all my names.
[6:44] Adam Feldman: Yeah, Jeff Marks was, and lots of other people, some people that I've stayed in touch with. I was a really good gang.
[6:49] Adam Feldman: And at a certain point, a publication called Show Business Weekly was starting up again, that's sort of a backstage type publication, and they wanted people to write for them.
[6:57] Adam Feldman: And uh they liked what I had been writing online, and someone contacted me and said, Hey, you know, would you have any interest in writing reviews for us?
[7:04] Adam Feldman: And I thought, well, sure, that sounds like fun. I had a day job, and I started doing that, and uh and it kind of took.
[7:09] Adam Feldman: So I ended up writing after that for Broadway.com back when they had reviews, and I did some features for them as well.
[7:15] Adam Feldman: And then in 2003, Jason Zinneman left Time Out to go to the New York Times, and they had the position open, and I applied for it and they gave it to me, and here I am, 16 years later.
[7:26] Ken Davenport: 16 years. Just for the record, no one ever contacted me to write reviews from based on my music.reck.arts.musicals.
[7:34] Adam Feldman: Uh, but that was such an outlet for uh us theater fans, avids back.
[7:39] Adam Feldman: It was, and it, you know, you can learn so much from those people there.
[7:43] Adam Feldman: Um in their ranks, not everyone, but there were it included a lot of people who were so serious about musical theater and had such uh deep knowledge and had these collections and uh had all this information.
[7:55] Adam Feldman: And this was when the internet was not quite what it is now, so it was harder to find a lot of that stuff.
[8:00] Adam Feldman: It was a trove of connoisseurship that I really valued at that time.
[8:05] Ken Davenport: I was gonna ask this later, but since we're we're there now, I mean, look, rec.arts.tater, whatever those those bulletin boards were, were the old chat room or the old all that chat or Broadway World message boards.
[8:18] Ken Davenport: How different are those today from what we had? And are do you participate in those?
[8:26] Adam Feldman: I read those occasionally. I participate uh very occasionally.
[8:29] Adam Feldman: I used to participate more, but it's uh it's a little tricky when your your own work is being discussed, whether you're an artist or whether like me, you're you're someone writing about the art, but in a public space, people will have opinions about it.
[8:43] Adam Feldman: And you're not quite at liberty to get into a full discussion about it because you're in my case, uh, you know, I've said what I want to say about the show, and uh, I don't necessarily want to get into a back and forth.
[8:56] Adam Feldman: It's if it's positive, it makes you look like too much of a super fan. If it's negative, it makes you look mean.
[9:01] Adam Feldman: And if they're criticizing you and you're responding, it makes you look defensive. And it's very hard to navigate that tone online.
[9:08] Adam Feldman: And so I uh I do interact on Twitter, I will I respond to people. I like I do like that on Facebook.
[9:15] Adam Feldman: I like a back and forth, but those tend to be on territory that is a little more comfortable for me.
[9:23] Adam Feldman: Like if someone is just a jerk on Facebook, I can delete their comment, you know, and I can't do that on um all that chat.
[9:30] Ken Davenport: Do you think they're good for the business? Do you think they're good for the things?
[9:31] Adam Feldman: I think they can be. I mean, certainly like any any amount of enthusiasm and fandom uh is is good.
[9:39] Adam Feldman: I mean, you want to have that conversation that includes when people don't like things. It, you know, uh, you want people to care about it enough to like it or not like it.
[9:47] Adam Feldman: It's that indifference is the opposite of love, you know. If it's when people stop talking about it that you should be concerned.
[9:54] Adam Feldman: I think that those those chat groups have themselves have have had ups and downs and have had waves of uh periods when they are very interesting and then less so.
[10:04] Adam Feldman: I think right now there was a there was a for me, it seemed like there was a peak period for those chat rooms, and now they have slightly ebbed.
[10:15] Adam Feldman: But you know, uh they'll come back or there's or some other thing will come back. And there's still a huge community of show fans and a growing one, I think.
[10:23] Adam Feldman: One thing that has changed a little bit is that people's candor has ebbed.
[10:29] Adam Feldman: Uh and uh that it makes it the the this the current culture of obligatory supportiveness can be a little stifling, especially for other artists.
[10:41] Adam Feldman: When when artists come out and they say they didn't like another piece of art, they are they are you know, people descend on them and as as though they had betrayed the art form.
[10:50] Adam Feldman: And I don't think that they have. I think that uh that kind again, I think that kind of discussion it can be very helpful.
[10:58] Ken Davenport: You mentioned responding to an ad for the Time Out critic position. If you were writing an ad for a critic position today, what would it be? What do you think the role of a critic in 2020 is?
[11:11] Adam Feldman: Well, I think those are different questions. I I don't um I think you would probably try to sell the position as well as you could if you were writing an ad for it.
[11:18] Adam Feldman: I think the actual position is uh quite tricky one right now. As you know, there are fewer critics at professional posts these days than there used to be.
[11:27] Adam Feldman: Many media institutions have fallen away, and those that remain are sometimes operating on much slimmer budgets that do not accommodate a wide range of coverage, including arts editorial coverage.
[11:42] Adam Feldman: And so there are fewer and fewer professional critics in New York and in the country in general. And that's a real challenge.
[11:47] Adam Feldman: I think in part that's a real challenge for those of us who are left because uh we have more and more responsibility, and I don't really believe necessarily in, you know, I don't like to think of myself as being the end all be all of all critical thought on any subject.
[12:04] Adam Feldman: I would much rather be part of a larger discussion. And uh I don't I don't relish the responsibility of of having to seem like the only opinion in town.
[12:16] Adam Feldman: And so it just seems like a healthier world in which there are a lot of critics working on a professional level and who are being listened to and read, and then they can get a kind of an overall consensus, and you can have some people who have more unusual outlier responses as part of that response and as a healthy part of that response.
[12:37] Adam Feldman: When there are fewer of those voices, you get a more limited chord. And so it's a challenge. And I wonder sometimes whether it will exist at all in the current trend, whether there will be any theater critics in 20 years. Oops. Picked a wrong job to get into that. That's a big statement. Yeah, no, but I think unless people take steps, and that includes, you know, readers and includes editors, and it includes advertisers and includes the shows, unless, or if some grant organization or something, unless someone comes in to rectify the situation, I think that as a career path, it is in real danger of disappearing.
[13:20] Ken Davenport: So if you could get all the media publishers into one room and give them a reason why they should not only keep the number of critics but grow them, what would you say?
[13:31] Adam Feldman: Well, I would have it would have to come if you're talking about it from a business perspective, then it would have to come from a place of profitability. And for it to come from a place of profitability, there would have to be advertising or some other kind of support that is tied to these positions. And I think that as advertising dollars are being allocated elsewhere by productions, there's a lot of, you know, a lot of the money now goes into social media campaigns and other forms, less into advertising in media organizations. Media organizations are not blind to that, and media organizations are not charities, and ultimately, even if many of them are committed and would love to continue having this particular kind of coverage, they at a certain point might not be able to if the books don't line, and they can't keep subsidizing it.
[14:29] Adam Feldman: So that's what's been happening basically is that media companies have been making less and less money, and with that less and less money, they have to make sometimes very difficult editorial choices.
[14:40] Ken Davenport: Can you describe your process of reviewing a show? Do you take notes? Do you how many days before it opens? Do you give yourself to write a review? And has that process changed in your 20 plus years?
[14:48] Adam Feldman: Well, I will see a show several days usually before it opens. So as you know, there are press performances prior to the official opening night of most shows. And that is different from how it was 50 years ago or 40 years ago. If you back in the day, you know, if you were Brooks Atkinson or whatever, you would go to the show on opening night, and they would seat you on the aisle, and that tradition still exists. They were still seated on the aisle. But the reason that they were seated on the aisle is so that at the end of the play they could bolt out of their chairs and run off and write a review and send it in like a sports writer. That's not how it does anymore. And that's a very good thing, I think, because in part I think that was a response to the fact that plays were getting more difficult.
I think if you were writing about plays in the 1920s and 30s, plays tended to be a certain kind of thing. It was a drama, or it was a musical review, or it was a comedy. And you can basically have a few things to say about that, but it was sort of like, did it work, did it not work? You know? Was it funny? Who stood out, you know? And you would write that kind of thing. Now that for a lot of reasons, theater has become more complicated and often more aesthetically ambitious and difficult. You don't necessarily know how to respond to something when you first see it. You often have to parse it out in your head, and you don't want to just throw up your hands and say, "That was something." I was like, I saw a bunch of things tonight.
I'm not sure how I feel about them. That's not a useful review. So I mean it can be, but mostly it isn't. So we have a few days. I try to go to the earlier press performances so that I can give myself as many days to marinate on it as I can. I don't always have that choice because again, we have different we have a print publication and we have an online version, and the review will go live on the online version on the night of opening night when the embargo lifts. But we also go to print, and sometimes we go to print days before that embargo lifts. And so sometimes the review has to be written earlier. Sometimes that means I have to see the show. I only have a day or two. You know, I'll see the show on Thursday night and I'll write it on Friday morning.
And that's not something I particularly like to do. I like to be able to think about things. I like to be able to write draft notes and see what is gonna fit in there. I write fairly short reviews usually, sometimes very short, sometimes less short. And that can be its own challenge. Although it looks sort of easier, it actually has required the development of a particular skill set, and that is managing to pack as much information as you can into those two or three paragraphs, so that someone who's reading it can get a sense of what the show is, what they're trying to do, what your response to what to it was, who the major artists are, all of that stuff, but compressed in ways that are both dense and somehow also entertainingly readable. So that's, you know, something that has taken some years to, I think, get down. Luckily, I've been doing it for 16 years. So I've gotten a little used to it.
[18:12] Ken Davenport: What's the most common criticism you have of a new play or a new musical? In other words, the most common notes you would give to writers that you see.
[18:22] Adam Feldman: Well, I don't know that there is a number one. The thing that I can say I have my own, you're asking how I review it. I do go to I go to the show, I do take notes, I take extensive notes. My handwriting is almost completely illegible even to me. So the note-taking is more about somehow reinforcing an idea in my head as I do it. Later I'll sometimes go pouring over these notes and I won't be able to understand anything I've done. If I know that there's something that I need to get back to, then I will sometimes write it in all caps or put a star next to it and give myself clues about how to find it later. But mostly I'm just sort of tracking my response to something as it's happening. Am I interested in am I engaged?
Where is my eye going? You know, what do I think is gonna happen? Any particular details, visual details, or design details that I worry I might not get right. You know, they usually do give us a script, so that has saved a great deal of stenographic work for us. And it makes it easier to be sure that you're quoting a show correctly. So that's all very important. And you can also look back, and if you've if there was something that you didn't understand, you can see if it was there and you just happen to miss it somehow. So that's useful. But especially for visual things or musical things, I will want to take notes to remind myself of what I'm seeing. To go back to the question you asked about what note I would give, I think it really does depend.
Every show is different, and every show is good or bad or both in its own ways. I feel like what I respond to particularly negatively is when I feel like something is really on the nose, when I think something is really obvious. And when the joke is obvious or the explanation, a lot of times there's exposition at the beginning of the play, and the way that that kind of exposition is worked in will have a lot of effect on me, whether it feels organic to the interactions that the characters would be having, or whether it feels tacked on on behalf of the audience. Because I like to be engaged as an audience member, I like to be filling in information as it comes down the pike. And so you have I'll like I like to have a few people on stage talking, and one of them might mention Jerry and later will figure out pretty clearly that Jerry is the character's brother.
But if the character says, "Well, as you know, my brother Jerry is coming over today," and he's talking to his wife. His wife knows that Jerry is his brother, why would he say my brother Jerry? Like it doesn't make any sense, and it takes me out of the realism of that moment. I'm talking about naturalistic plays at this point for this kind of point, obviously. There are plays in which that wouldn't matter at all because the entire style is meant to be artificial. And so there isn't a hard and fast rule, but that kind of stuff. And the same goes with music that's too obvious or rhymes that are too obvious, or rhymes that are both too obvious and not great rhymes. The perfect rhyme question is a separate thing, but I'm not saying everything has to be a perfect rhyme.
But there are standards that apply, and sometimes if it's an ear thing, I guess ultimately, but if it's a really bad rhyme and it sits in an obvious way on the music, then it can be really clunky. If it's an either obvious rhyme or a not quite rhyme, that makes it even worse. So little things like that. I don't like being preached to by a show, even if it's a show whose message I agree with. I like for there to be complication in the shows. And I think most people do as well. I mean I know that I think on some level I'm acting as a surrogate. I may be a more informed surrogate, I may have more experience. I've seen a lot more shows, obviously, than most people. But I think basically my responses are the responses of a discerning audience member.
[22:35] Adam Feldman: So I think that the success of shows like Hamilton, Dear Evan Hansen, The Band's Visit, Fun Home, even The Book of Mormon. These are shows with complicated things happening in them. Complicated and original stories, you know. And for all the talk of jukebox musicals and movie adaptations, and there are a lot of those happening on Broadway right now. But if you look at the ones that have been the business, you know, the big breakout successes in their seasons, they're almost all original. Almost all original music, they're almost all original stories or adaptations of non-obvious film sources or dramatic sources. I just wrote about this a couple weeks ago about how the musicals that have recouped in the last five to ten years are the musicals that I would bet at some point during the development of those musicals, someone said to the creators, "This should never be on Broadway."
Hades Town, Dear Evan Hansen, Hamilton, Fun Home. Right. Or Avenue Q, right? Book of Mormon. Book of Mormon. These are Dear Evan Hansen is a tricky show about a tricky young guy who makes a terrible mistake, who acts very poorly. And I know what's interesting to me is you see these think pieces sometimes, and this is part of the healthy discussion. But I see these think pieces that are like, "I don't like Dear Evan Hansen because the hero is a jerk." Yeah, the hero is a jerk. He is. That's one reason that the show is so interesting, because it gets you inside the mindset of someone who does this jerky thing. It doesn't mean he's an evil person, it means he does a bad thing that he's not thinking about enough. And then by the end, he has thought about it. And we also have thought about it with him.
[24:25] Adam Feldman: But if you just say, I don't want to see it because he does a bad thing, then it's like, I don't want to see Sweeney Todd. He's mean. Yeah, he kills people and eats and serves them to other people to be eaten. Um, but that's park that can be part of what's interesting in theaters, right? Especially I think it gives you an opportunity to explore humanity in a deeper way and in a less judgmental way. Um that's uh I mean I I don't want to reduce any negative responses to Hansen just to that. I know that it takes place in a larger cultural context, and I know that a lot of the criticisms are specifically about who gets forgiven in this kind of story. And that's a that's a more general aggregate point. But um, when you hold larger general points against particular works of art, then that's where you sometimes I think can end up undervaluing certain works.
[25:20] Ken Davenport: Do you think that artists should read reviews, whether yours or anyone else's, or would you encourage them to?
[25:20] Adam Feldman: I think that's entirely up to them. Um I think some artists find it um very disturbing, and uh I don't mean disturbing, I I mean it interrupts their process. It makes them self-conscious about certain aspects of their performance, whether it's a positive review or or a negative one. If someone says, Oh, you know, he delivers this particular line in such a perfectly hilarious way, then when when if you read that and you get to that line, there's a little snag maybe for some people. And so I think also the especially negative reviews, uh, it can be very demoralizing. And if you're if you're in a show, you need to go and give it your all. You need to be giving the show the best version of you that and the best version of itself that that it can get.
Uh I'm I mean that the director and writers and designer's work is is already done, so it does it's a little bit less tremendous. But for people who are showing up every day and doing it live, they need to believe in what they're doing. And yeah, I wouldn't want to, as an actor, I wouldn't want to undercut myself if I wouldn't want to read bad reviews of it.
[26:37] Adam Feldman: And but this is the thing, sometimes when people talk about negative reviews, sometimes they'll get mad if I've written something uh very negative. And I will say I have different kinds of negative reviews that I write. And uh there's a certain kind of slash and burn tone that people very much enjoy reading, but which I don't actually enjoy writing very often, because uh mostly I feel bad for the artists involved. And I I'm not a sadist, you know. Uh, but there are certain kinds of shows that I think I have to sort of break out the big guns for. But the truth is a lot of people really like reading those reviews. It's a dirty secret in the theater industry, not that much of a secret.
[27:13] Ken Davenport: Is it always been that way?
[27:14] Adam Feldman: It's always been that way. Uh people, I I actually get a lot more blowback for positive reviews of shows that someone didn't like. Someone would be like, I can't believe you like that. So stupid or so pretentious, you know. Um, but if if you don't like something that they did like, they often just think that you're smarter than that. You know, that you have higher standards, you know. So uh that's a weird that's a weird thing how that works. Um but but if they do get mad at at negative reviews, they'll sometimes be like, why couldn't you just be more productive? You know, why couldn't you be more constructive in the criticism? And the problem is that that is job, that's not my job. Uh I'm not the dramaturg, I'm not the consultant, I'm not the investor, I'm not the friend of the artist.
And nothing I say, even if it's the best clue to how to fix the show, is gonna happen because by the time I've seen it, it's already frozen. And, you know, the if anything, it would just make it more infuriating for everyone involved.
[28:09] Adam Feldman: Oh, there, that's how we should have done it. Back in the day again, when they used to have out-of-town pre uh tryouts more often. Uh, that was a great way for people in Boston or New Haven to give uh criticism that really could be constructive to a show as it was um wending its way to Broadway. Now there are fewer of those critics because of what we were talking about before. There are fewer out-of-town critics, uh, there are fewer out-of-town tryouts. Uh a lot of shows come out differently. They either come from overseas or they or they debut on Broadway right away, or they come up through the off-Broadway system. Um, so there's uh there's a little less of that constructive stuff. I wish sometimes that I could work as a consultant.
I'll see shows and there are things in them that seem soluble to me. There are problems in it that don't need to be there. And I wish I could just go back in time and have a different job and say, hey guys, I know you've been workshopping this for two years and you don't see this anymore. You you're you just you're too in the show to see what's working about it. And here's an outside perspective. Take it or leave it. I think I could help a lot of shows that way. I think everyone's probably feels that way, but I think I could. And uh sometimes it can be frustrating to see something like that where you there are just mistakes that don't need to be there, and then that could easily be fixed.
[29:29] Adam Feldman: One great experience, sorry, and uh just to go along this one thing, one great experience where that did happen was the show Next to Normal, where they opened it off Broadway, and it wasn't quite they do they had been scrambling on it a little bit at the end, and it wasn't quite there. And everyone wrote pretty much the same review, which was there's a lot of great stuff in this show, but this, this, and this don't work. And to their credit, they went back to the board and they went out of town again. They went down to Washington and they cut some stuff and they replaced some stuff, like changed about a quarter or third of the show. And they brought it back to Broadway in Triumph and it won the Pulitzer Prize. It's one of the greatest stories of developing a musical in the last couple decades, I think, the Next to Normal story.
[30:13] Ken Davenport: Yeah, and it's really um encouraging, I think, for artists and and for producers, for ambitious producers who believe in and understand the quality of the product that they're offering. Uh it happened also, although with a less happy ending with Scottsboro Boys, which was much better on Broadway than it was when it was at the Vineyard. Uh it was very good at the vineyard. It just there were there were snags in it that took you out. And and that's the funny thing about musicals is that a few little things that aren't going right can really just throw the whole shape of the show off. And sometimes the fixes can be surprisingly in retrospect, it's can be surprisingly simple. The one that people talk about all the time is funny thing happened on the way to the forum.
Just the addition of that opening number to set the tone for what people were seeing, um got the odd crowd with the show for the rest of the show. Um, a show that hadn't been working. Sometimes there is something like that that you can do, and sometimes the problems are not soluble.
[31:15] Adam Feldman: So I'll tell you a story of my own theater going experience. I went to see Mama Mia for the very first time, and I was like, I don't I don't like this. This is not so great. I don't quite get it. And then I went to see it a couple of years later, and I was like, you know what? This is fun. I'm having a good time. Does that ever happen to you?
[31:33] Ken Davenport: It does, especially with a show with shows of that type. You know, a good example of this right now is is is Ain't Too Proud. Uh I I saw that last year, I reviewed it. There's a a lot that I really enjoyed in it. There's a lot of terrific music, and there's there were some of the performances were fantastic. I didn't think that the show itself was taking very bold narrative pathways. So you're in that space where it's sort of like, well, I had a good time at it. I sort of recommend it, but I also don't think it's a great show. And when that's a tough thing to write, I ended up kind of cheating it in my star application for that one, because we have a five-star system. Five means it's one of the very few best things I will see all year.
And one means I hated it. And two, I mean, and I was like offended by it in some way. And two is also pretty much I hated it. So then you've got this little range between three and four. Um, and that can mean a lot of different things, three or four. Uh four was traditionally the space where we would start giving our little check marks to recommend a show.
[32:40] Adam Feldman: Um, but we don't have half stars, which is just the bane of my existence because there's so many shows that I want to give three and a half stars or two and a half stars, you know, uh, or four and a half stars. Um, but you can't, and it really just forces your hand. I have developed, oh, I shouldn't be talking, I shouldn't be saying this. Maybe they'll maybe they won't let me do it anymore. I have developed a little cheat for three and a half stars, which is a three-star review with a recommendation check. And so it will show up. We have a page that is critics picks, and that is designed to show the ones that have the checks. So formerly that would only be fours and fives, and so now sometimes there are a certain kind of three-star show, like Ain't Too Proud, um, which I would be happy to recommend to someone.
If someone said, I want to see a bun of you know, a big entertaining Broadway show tonight, I'm bringing my family, what we gotta say? I would happily say Ain't Too Proud. Like it's a it's a really enjoyable show for that. It's not a serious work of musical theater. It's not Next to Normal.
[33:35] Ken Davenport: No. No, it's not.
[33:36] Adam Feldman: And so I think because I think part of my job is to look at it with added value for that part of musical theater, to look at it seriously, to take it seriously as musical, and not just try to anticipate what an audience's response will be to it. But to say, how does this stack up aesthetically? How smart is it, and how original is it, and and all these uh these particular criteria that I want to bring to it in a serious way. Um, but certainly there are shows that I'm happy to see later. And there are shows that grew on me, Wicked grew on me. Um when I saw Wicked the first time, I thought, what an amazing book. And it's too bad that well, you know, what amazing performers. It's too bad that's only really like four songs in it that I like.
And then maybe just through endless repeat exposure, um, I've I've uh come to like a lot. There are still some dog songs in that show, but but I've come to like a lot more of the songs, and I've gotten to know them more, and and and just the fact of its success argues in its favor at a certain point. It has tapped into something, and you want to revisit it maybe and say, What did I miss that has made it this enormous popular success? Because it is speaking to people, it's not just on the strength of some weird marketing thing or whatever. It it people love it.
[34:53] Ken Davenport: Yeah, people say that the definition of a classic is something that stands the test of time. Do you think that applies to musical theater? Does that mean that Wicked is a classic, Cats is a classic? These shows that resonate like they do, does that make sense?
[35:08] Adam Feldman: I don't think that I don't know. It's hard because nothing nothing stands the test of time, baby. Time, time gets all of us. Uh, you know, at a certain point, even you know, the sun will stop existing and the world will never, the universe will have no record of William Shakespeare. You know, that the everything everything goes. I want to sound too dark, but uh I think things can be classics based on their quality and how they work in the moment.
[35:32] Adam Feldman: Um for musicals and for comedies, and even for dramas, really, things things can work differently at different times. And that's a big part. That's one reason it's so difficult to revive comedies on Broadway, is that our our sense of humor has changed so much. And it's not that we look at these shows and we think, oh, they're not funny. No, but they but they were funny. I mean, they obviously were funny when they were written. People laughed at them a great deal. They ran for years. So our idea of what is funny is is what has changed. And in some cases, it it's changed partly because of those works, because of the success of those works. Those works were so funny that they were widely imitated until that thing was no longer funny.
It was no longer surprising and fresh. And so now we look at and we think, oh, that joke again. No, that was the first time that it did that. Neil Simon plays and when they were attempted to and they tried to bring those back and didn't work, I think it's a perfect example of that.
[36:29] Ken Davenport: Yeah, that can happen. It's gonna be interesting to see what happens with Plaza Suite this this season, because you know, uh like musicals, good new directors and performers can find ways to make things fresh even if they're no longer in style.
[36:43] Adam Feldman: And so when you're doing a revival of an old musical, the music will sound different from what most people listen to today. And as we get farther and farther away from those things, even songs that we consider to be obvious classics are less and less well known to audiences, to younger audiences in particular. And not just those songs particularly, but the whole styles of songs, you know, in which they were written. This sort of great American songbook style doesn't sound like most music today. You might know it from advertising and you might know it from Christmas songs and things like that. But Christmas is the only time of year when people listening to the radio or in malls are going to hear songs that were written before 1960. People's ears aren't set to that now, so it will sound strange to them. They're not coming out of the same places that audiences were in, you know, 1943.
[37:39] Ken Davenport: What were some of those few five-star shows that you've seen over the last couple of years? Like what are your favorites?
[37:49] Adam Feldman: Last year was the first time I had done a top 10 list in which there were no Broadway shows on the top 10. I love Broadway. And I felt sometimes that I had too many Broadway shows on my top 10. But this year, although I liked a lot of shows that were on Broadway, and although I gave good reviews, positive reviews to a lot of those shows, none of them at the end of the day ended up being in my top 10 shows. The things that were on my list this year, there was a show called Heroes of the Fourth Turning that was at Playwrights Horizons. There's a show called Greater Clements that I loved at Lincoln Center. There was a Strange Loop, the musical at Playwrights Horizons as well. I mean, maybe these things will go to Broadway.
To be fair, the two shows that were on my list last year were on Broadway this year. So they weren't on it because they were on last year. You know, the revival of Oklahoma and Jeremy O'Harris' Slave Play were both on my top ten last year. So maybe they would have been this year had they opened; they probably would have. But they already made it last year, so they were grandfathered out. I think a lot of the best stuff, and when I say best, I mean best if you're a serious theatergoer, the stuff that will give you the most to chew on, a lot of that stuff is happening off Broadway or at least originates off Broadway. And then sometimes, if we're very lucky, someone will bring it, and sometimes if we're extra lucky, it will be successful, and then that will be encouraging for others to do the same.
[39:33] Ken Davenport: How many shows a year do you see?
[39:37] Adam Feldman: It depends what you count as shows. Do you count cabaret shows? Do you count down shows? I mean, I will see at least a couple hundred shows a year.
[39:41] Ken Davenport: Does that get exhausting at certain times of year?
[39:44] Adam Feldman: Yeah, absolutely does. I'm just coming off of a period. The early January and early February are quiet times. I sometimes will use it to catch up on shows that I missed in previous rushes. But then we get, as you know, we get into March and April, and March and April are insane because half of the Broadway season is crammed into a six-week period. And you're seeing too many shows. I mean, I see a lot of shows; not all of them I review. I review two or three shows a week, but then I'll usually see, you know, a bunch of other shows. But around that time of year, there have been times when I'm seeing eight or nine shows a week during those weeks and turning around reviews of them. Broadway reviews are the marquee reviews.
They're the ones, you know, I know we have traffic reports now, so I can see exactly how many people are reading what reviews. And for better or worse, Broadway shows command a lot more attention. People are interested in them. They've already heard about them. They're, you know, they tend to be bigger productions. There are more seats available. So it's something that they're more easily able to consider going to see. By the time you hear about something good off Broadway, part of the problem is it's very hard to get seats. So anyway, yeah, you want to write well. These are sort of the times when people are looking, you know. You want to write smartly and well about these Broadway shows, even the ones that you don't have much to say about. And when you're writing four of those a week, that's tiring.
[41:17] Ken Davenport: How do you keep a fresh perspective when you've just seen something the night before? Do you find yourself comparing to like, oh yeah, this is good, but what I saw last night was amazing?
[41:25] Adam Feldman: That's honestly something that I have to guard against very actively. It's trying to take everything on its own terms. And there's a lot of different ways in which that takes place, in which that attempt on my part to distance myself from my response or to understand my response more fully, to be more accurate. And that involves a lot of things, like was I tired that day? Was I in a bad mood? What have I seen recently? Sometimes if you see a bunch of things, you write a bunch of bad reviews in a row, you sort of want to say something nice. It's a psychological tendency. Or if you, or vice versa, if you've written a lot of nice reviews, you want to be like, oh, I don't want everyone to think I'm just, you know, your kindly aunt at the talent show.
But at the same time, you don't want to punish artists and productions for that for happening to land in the middle of that trend. So I really try to step away as much as I can and take an objective look at it. Also, that's true of my taste and my particular experience, both as a person and as a theatergoer. You know, if something seems very unoriginal to me, it may just be because I see so much that I'm bound to have seen something. There's only so many notes in the scale, you know. I'm bound to have seen something like it. But that doesn't mean that it is a cliché. And so there's a difference between something that I happen to have seen and something that is overexposed. And that can be a difficult line to find. I'm sure I make errors of judgment of that kind all the time.
[42:53] Adam Feldman: Someone was asking me the other day, and I was thinking about it, about whether I revisit old reviews and think I was wrong about them. And this touches a little bit on the Mamma Mia question that you were asking. What I tend to find is not that I think I was wrong. What I tend to find is I think I weighed it out wrong or I weighed it out differently than I would weigh it out now. Because there are usually good things and bad things in most shows. And most of the time you're gonna end up with some variation on this about it was good, but unfortunately, this about it. Or even though this about it, this about it. And those are very different. Both of those are true in some sense, you know, they're describing things that are there or that I found were there.
But sometimes they overvalue good things or they over-penalize for bad things. So yeah, there's those kinds of things. And then there are just shows that you love. The best part of my job is when I love a show and I get to go out to the world and, you know, put it on my shield and run out into the public world and say I run the banner for, you know, Carolina Change or whatever it is, you know, especially when it's a smaller show that hasn't been getting its due. I mean, it's lovely to do that for Hamilton, but Hamilton doesn't need it. You know, Hamilton's doing just fine. Enough folks stumbling for that one.
[44:25] Ken Davenport: Okay, my last question. Have we been talking all this time? I know. My genie question. I want you to imagine the genie from Aladdin comes to visit you. Did you write a good review of Aladdin?
[44:34] Adam Feldman: I wrote one of those three mixedy reviews. Three to four to two to three, somewhere in there. I didn't check mark or no check mark. I don't think it's a check mark. But it was doing just fine. It's doing just fine without me. I liked it fine. You look up my Aladdin review when you get out of here.
[44:52] Ken Davenport: I'm gonna do that.
[44:53] Adam Feldman: If I recall correctly, I thought it had a lot of entertaining aspects and was colorful and lively, but didn't capture the magic that I wanted from it.
[45:05] Ken Davenport: Well, I'm sure you liked the genie part, which is why the genie is going to come pay you a visit and grant you one wish. Oh my gosh. What's the one thing about Broadway that drives you so crazy, gets you frustrated? You'd ask this genie to wish away in an instant.
[45:22] Adam Feldman: Oh boy, one thing. Just one, and no more wishing for other wishers crap. I mean, do you want like a very particular thing? Or do you want a general?
[45:33] Ken Davenport: I'm gonna say a very particular thing because there are trends and things that are too many to begin.
[45:38] Adam Feldman: What I want from the genie is the Mark Hallinger Theatre back. It's now the church of something. And on one hand, I'm glad that they have been taking care of it. It still looks beautiful if you go in. It's pristine and it's ready to go back into being a gorgeous Broadway house any day that we can get it back. I think that was a terrible mistake in the 90s to sell that place away. And at least it wasn't bulldozed, like the Indian graveyard theaters on the bottom of the Marriott. But it's there, and if I could snap my fingers, bring it back and put beautiful shows there.
[46:15] Ken Davenport: That is one of the best wishes we've had. So specific. I love it. Thank you so much for joining us today. You know what I love about talking to critics is you just are so reminded that you are all in it for the same reasons we're all in it. You love the theater.
[46:27] Adam Feldman: Yep, a lot of the time.
[46:29] Ken Davenport: So go check out his reviews, see if he's given something one, two, three, four, five stars, and a check mark at Time Out New York. Also, go check him out at Club Cumming every Monday night.
[46:41] Adam Feldman: Monday nights. I'm almost always there. I can't guarantee I'll be there. But even if I'm not there, you'll see a lot of really fun stuff.
[46:48] Ken Davenport: Awesome. Thanks so much for being here. We'll see you all next time. Thanks again to Adam Feldman for sitting down with me today. If you're excited about this new season of the podcast, do me a favor and review us on Apple Podcasts. It helps other theater makers and theater fans like you enjoy these conversations and frankly just find them. And that helps get the word out about theater all over the world. If you're looking for more theater podcasts, check out Broadway Podcast Network, the brand new community and platform for Broadway-themed podcasts and all sorts of other online content. To find more about me and learn about the projects I'm working on on Broadway, off Broadway, and all over, you can find me on Instagram at KenDavenportBway, or check out my blog at the ProducersPerspective.com.
[47:28] Ken Davenport: And now this week's hashtag Songwriter of the Week, one of my favorite things to do every week is break a new songwriter. And this week's songwriter is Michael Mott. Check out his song "Her Embrace," sung by Jeremy Jordan. This is from Michael's musical In the Light, a Faustian tale. Check out more of Michael's music at @Michael_Mott on Instagram and www.michaelmott.net. We will see you next week with a brand new episode of the Producer's Perspective podcast.
[47:59] ♪ Musical number: "Her Embrace" — performed by Jeremy Jordan ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
