Robyn Goodman is a producer and actress, known for The Rehearsal (1974), One Life to Live (1968) and Smash (2012). She won Tony Awards for Best Musical as producer of Avenue Q and In the Heights. Her other Broadway productions include Metamorphoses and West Side Story... Read More
From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport
Featured Shows
About
Robyn Goodman is a producer and actress, known for The Rehearsal (1974), One Life to Live (1968) and Smash (2012). She won Tony Awards for Best Musical as producer of Avenue Q and In the Heights. Her other Broadway productions include Metamorphoses and West Side Story. She is a producer of Avenue Q at New World Stages, and produced Altar Boyz Off-Broadway. She is a founding Board member of The Ride and Artistic Consultant to Roundabout Theatre Company. She was co-founder of Second Stage Theatre, serving as artistic director for 13 years.
In this week’s podcast, Robyn talks about producing partnerships (including her very successful ones with Co-Producers Kevin McCollum and Jeffrey Seller) and a bunch more including:
- How she (literally) survived her first producing project. (Wait until you hear what the Playwright wanted to do to her.)
- How she convinced the Writers of Avenue Q to skip the screen and take the show to the stage . . . and to let her be the one to help.
- The delicate art of giving notes to Authors (and let me tell you – Robyn is a master of this!).
- What she does when a show doesn’t work.
- What it’s like being a powerful female Producer in the “old boys’ club” of Broadway.
Keep up with me: @KenDavenportBway
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway.
[0:07] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer.
[0:10] Ken Davenport: Hey everybody, just a quick thank you to all the folks out there that joined the Producers Perspective Pro last week. We had a fantastic launch, brand new webinar in the archives, all sorts of sample documents. Join the Producer's Perspective Pro. You're gonna love it. On with the podcast.
[0:25] Ken Davenport: Hello, everybody, I'm Ken Davenport. This is the Producer's Perspective Podcast. Super excited to have as my guest today, someone very near and dear to my heart because she is the first producing partner I ever had. Welcome to the podcast, Tony Award-winning Broadway producer Robyn Goodman.
[0:40] Robyn Goodman: Thank you, Ken.
[0:41] Ken Davenport: So that show Robyn and I partnered on was Altar Boyz, which opened 11 years ago now, 2005. I know, but that's just one little blip on her incredible producing resume. Most recently on Broadway she produced Cinderella on tour as well, the performers Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo, and of course that little show that could Avenue Q and a whole bunch of Off-Broadway shows. It's one of the reasons that Robyn is one of my favorite producers because she's had such a long resume on both Broadway and Off-Broadway. Bat Boy, Tick Tick Boom, and of course Altar Boyz. She also is a co-founder of Second Stage. Now she's the special artistic consultant to the Roundabout, and word has it that she spent some time on a soap opera. But we will get to that.
[1:24] Ken Davenport: Oh shame. So, Robyn, why don't you just tell us how you got started in the theater biz?
[1:31] Robyn Goodman: Ah, well, when I was four and a half, my mother took me to my first show because my mother had been an actress and a writer on radio, and she wanted me to be in the theater. And so I went to the theater all through my childhood. We lived in New Jersey by then. We started in Brooklyn, went to New Jersey, and I got the bug. I wanted to be an actress, I wanted to be a famous actress, of course, not just any actress. And I went to college and I studied acting, I went to Brandeis and studied acting and came to New York as an actress, actually, and acted for a good seven years, making a living, you know, eating a lot of spaghetti. But I ended up getting a job rehearsing some plays that were going to London.
Three plays, three new American plays. One by the man who raised the money and was producing it. The other two was a play, one was a play by Susan Miller called Flux, and one was in the boom boom room by David Ray, and we were a company of two women and I think three or four men. And right before we were supposed to get on the plane, this guy came in and said, "Gee, I really want you to go, and the theater's waiting for you, but I don't have enough money to get you there and put you up." So the woman and I said, "Well, we're going." We don't spend all this time rehearsing. And we went out and raised at that time, this was 1976, right? Yeah. We raised $3,000, brought the boys on the plane, got on the plane, didn't know what the hell we were doing.
We went to this little French theater, and we ended up producing this and being in this season of three plays, which Michael Billington of The Guardian later said changed the tide of new American plays in London. So I really liked taking credit for that because I had no idea what I was doing. But the plays were very successful. And I stayed on and acted in England for a while. But it sort of gave me the producing bug, even though I was probably terrible at it at the time. And when I came back, I met Carol Rothman, I had auditioned for her, and I had taken another job, but I fixed her up with her husband, and we—
[3:29] Robyn Goodman: She owed you one.
[3:44] Robyn Goodman: Yeah, or I owed, yeah, she owed me one. She came to me and said, "I want to start a theater, and you're the right partner." And I said, "Can't we just produce shows? Wouldn't that be more fun?" She said, "No, it's more fun to know you always have another show you can produce in an ongoing institution." So we spent a long time planning Second Stage, and we found something that nobody else was doing at the time, giving contemporary plays another production, and we spent a year planning it actually, and put a board together and raised money enough to do the first show. My favorite story about Second Stage is that the first show, and I suppose people can Google it, but I'm not gonna say what it was because it was a disaster.
The playwright, who was a military guy, threatened our lives. Our lawyer at Paul Weiss said, "Don't leave your apartments, you're in danger." The director quit, the two lead actors quit, the lighting designer quit. And the next thing I know, Carol and I were like in the fetal position in front of Joe Papp saying, "What do we do? We have we'd send out all these invitations and everybody in the press and blah blah blah, and we're on the Upper West Side." And Joe said, "Get back up there, Carol, you direct it, Robin, you do everything else." And so we said, "Oh my god, we have to find some actors." So Carol called this young actor who she'd worked with at Circle Rep. His name was Jeff Daniels, and he came in and an actress that I knew named Lynn Milgram, and we did everything and we got the play up, and it actually got decent reviews, which is amazing.
Because you know, we really didn't. Carol knew how to direct, but we didn't know anything else. So the second play we did was a huge hit. There were lines around the block, and equity shut us down because at the time they were trying to put a lien on the authors to pay the actors in the future if the plays went on, right? And Michael Weller said, "I have to stand with my guild." And it was just the worst thing that ever happened to us because we were making money and it was Brooke Adams and John Heard, and you know, it was a wonderful production. Polly Draper was great. And we were really upset until I think two days later we were on the front page of the New York Times. "Young Second Stage Shut Down by Writers Guild."
You know, so you never know what's gonna make you put you on the map. But suddenly, I mean they shut us down because they thought we were a bunch of kids, you know, they weren't gonna shut Playwright's Horizons down. Next thing we knew, everybody knew what Second Stage was because there we were, and actually it was illegal what they were trying to do. So about two weeks later we went back on and we finished the run of the play. That's how we started our theater, and it was a huge success. And everybody, certainly in the business by that time, knew Second Stage, but everybody on the Upper West Side suddenly knew what we were.
[6:37] Ken Davenport: No such thing as bad press, I guess.
[6:39] Robyn Goodman: Exactly.
[6:39] Ken Davenport: I have to ask why the playwright threatened your life.
[6:43] Robyn Goodman: Because he was bringing piles of rewrites every day, and the director would call us at night and say, "This guy's insane. I mean, these rewrites don't make any sense, and he insists I put them in." So it was probably me. I probably called him and said, "You can't, you have to stop writing. You have to let the director and the actors own the script and own the play right now." And he went berserk.
[7:04] Ken Davenport: Well, I will definitely not ask you the name of that play or that playwright. I will Google it later and include a link in this podcast blog.
[7:13] Robyn Goodman: No. Well, it's all true, it's all true.
[7:15] Ken Davenport: Okay, so well, how do you come back from all that? That's those are really two your first your first success in London. Okay, great. Then you have you start a theater company, these two things, and they both don't go well, but they put you on the map.
[7:28] Robyn Goodman: Yeah.
[7:28] Ken Davenport: And then you're like, this is great. I'm gonna sign up for this.
[7:32] Robyn Goodman: Well, you know, it was exciting. I was, you know, I was young and it was exciting and it was challenging, and I was suddenly realizing that I had a sensibility. I was reading plays, and I actually knew which ones I liked and which ones I didn't like, and God bless Frank Rich, he was the critic. I know everybody called him a butcher, but Frank Rich was about our age and he shared our sensibility. I tell you that we had all those years that I was there, 13 years, Frank was reviewing us, and he didn't always give us great reviews, but he got it. He got what we were doing, and he really liked the work we did. And that was a part of our success. I really believe he was a big he was the third wheel on our success.
And that's just luck. That's just luck, you know, because sometimes you have critics who just don't get what you're trying to do or have different taste. Because taste is something you can't explain, and you can't teach it, it's just something you have inside you, you know. But 13 years it's a burnout job. I Carol is amazing that she's still doing it, actually.
[8:34] Ken Davenport: You mentioned that you knew which plays you liked, and you knew which plays you didn't like, and certainly we'll talk about this a little later. It's what obviously your special artistic consultancy with the Roundabout is about, and certainly I know you as a devourer of plays and your the dramaturgical work we did on Altar Boyz, and your comments were so insightful, I remember. So, what is it that makes you go, "Oh, this is a play I like" or this like what do you look for when you look for a new—
[8:57] Robyn Goodman: I look for a fresh voice, someone who writes in a way that is completely individual. I also love to read something that I think I've never seen on stage before, either just a whole event or a character or a way of looking at the world. It's that's what the underground is for me. Underground is like a soul feeder for me because I love doing that, and I love helping people bring out in a play what they're trying to say and what they're trying to do, and I would say if you looked at the list of plays in the underground, they all have originality to them and something special, and all those writers are working somewhere in film and television and theater, Stephen Caram, of course, is on Broadway. You can just feel it in the writing. It's got a kind of energy and freshness, I think.
[10:00] Ken Davenport: So 13 years at Second Stage, and then as you said, it was a burnt-out job, and you decide you're gonna go out on your own.
[10:07] Robyn Goodman: No, I decided that I needed to make more money. Honestly, I think I was making thirty thousand dollars a year, and I was in my late thirties, and that's too old to be making thirty thousand dollars a year. And I told everybody I was leaving, and people thought I was insane, and I said I needed a job, and a woman named Jean Pasanante, who had run New Dramatists years ago, had a job at ABC, and she was leaving it to become a soap writer for a million dollars a year or something like that. And she said, "What would I like to interview for her job because they want another theater person?" I said, "I've never watched a soap opera in my entire life." And she said, "Oh, it doesn't matter, believe me, you'll pick it up."
So I got the job. I more than doubled my salary, which was my goal. And I worked in the corporate part of ABC, overseeing daytime and bringing writers in, and overseeing All My Children and One Life to Live when you know I knew a lot about acting and writing and directing, but I didn't know anything about soap opera or cameras or anything like that. So that was a good point. To Linda Gottlieb came in as the executive producer. She had just done Dirty Dancing and Citizen Cohen and all these movies, and she wanted to completely change the way soaps were done. She brought in editing and music editing and novelists and Lonnie Price and real directors, Casey Childs and people from the theater, and she said, "I want you to be my supervising producer."
I said, "Please get me out of this corporate environment because I'm not functioning well here." So I went over six months into my job. I went over to One Life to Live, became the supervising producer, and did that for four and a half more years. And it was a seven-day-a-week job, and I never went to the theater for four and a half years.
[12:00] Robyn Goodman: Wow, it was really strange. But I loved it. I learned a lot, and I think it improved my dramaturgy.
[12:06] Ken Davenport: Well, that was gonna be my next question. Before we get even into the dramaturgy, is there anything that television does that theater could learn from that they actually do better than we do?
[12:18] Robyn Goodman: Well, now I'm I don't think I'm not sure about soap operas, but the writing on television now is I mean, I think those people should have been staying in the theater because they're such original writing now, as you know, on television, in even in network television, cable and everywhere.
[12:36] Robyn Goodman: It's extraordinary. You just don't have enough hours in your day. The great thing about working in something like a soap opera or an hour drama, especially if it's an overarching story, like our head writer wrote a story, a six-month story, they call it. It was the first gay story on television, and Ryan Felipe played the gay boy. He was like 16 or something. He brings this story in; it's like pages and pages, it's wonderful. As a producer, you get to sit in the writer's room and divide it up into weeks, days, and scenes. You work with the writers, and everybody's throwing the best idea wins. What happens is you start to see storytelling in a very incremental way, how you keep the audience interested, how you build an arc over a long period of time.
I think it's definitely helped me, even though I think dramaturgy is more of a gut thing than anything else. You can feel it, or I can feel it anyway. I think doing that job for four and a half years improved my skill of storytelling.
[13:45] Ken Davenport: Is that clear?
[13:46] Robyn Goodman: Yeah, absolutely. In fact, I'm again remembering all of the experience, especially with writers on Altar Boys.
[13:52] Ken Davenport: Oh wow, yes.
[13:54] Robyn Goodman: That was quite something. We were brave, Ken. We were brave. We just didn't give up because the music was so great. We said, we're gonna nail this puppy if it's the last thing we do.
[14:05] Ken Davenport: Certainly did.
[14:06] Robyn Goodman: One of the things I really learned from you is how you deal with writers on that. Tell me a little bit about what you think an ideal producer-writer relationship is or how you go about giving them notes or not giving them notes.
[14:20] Robyn Goodman: Yes. Respect is, of course, very important. I interviewed Hal Prince one time, and I said, "Let's talk about how we give notes, okay, because I have a theory about it." He said, "Well, you tell me your theory first." I said, "Well, I don't think a director hears more than three notes. So I try to start with the largest notes and give three of them, and maybe one is about the set or the lights or an actor, but whatever it is, if it's a dramaturgical note, it's got to be the biggest one first." Then I never talk like, "This line doesn't work." I wait, and then I just work my way through each time we get to talk. Hal said, "That's funny. You know what I do? I go to the rehearsal room and I take pages of notes and pages of notes.
Then I give the director about a week, and I check off the ones that I have that he or she is already doing, and then I slowly start to deliver them in small doses." I think that's, as a philosophy, a good idea because when you start giving people a ton of notes, they just don't hear you. I remember saying to Stafford and the writers on Altar Boys, I said, "Look, it's gotta be you just gotta have those boys on the stage and a band, and you need to have an event that breaks them up and then brings them back together again. That's all I know." I told the writer and told Kevin the same thing and figure it out how to do it because we haven't been able to. They did. But usually, I ask questions, and I rarely get prescriptive.
If I give them an idea, I say, "This is not meant to be on the page, but here's the way I can express what I'm thinking, and if you had the character, blah blah blah." But I don't like to do that if I don't have to. I like to swing wide, and then if they're not hearing you, each time you get more and more specific. You know what I mean? I can't write the way they write. They're gonna come up with something better. So I have to have faith in them, and they have to have faith in that what I'm saying is right.
[16:27] Ken Davenport: So you are at this job which has doubled your Second Stage salary, and then you decide, huh? I'm just forget all this stuff. I'm gonna go hire myself in a way, right? That's what producers I think do.
[16:39] Robyn Goodman: Well, first I went to Manhattan Theater Club, you know.
[16:42] Ken Davenport: I did not know that.
[16:43] Robyn Goodman: Yes, just because I didn't know what I was gonna do. I hadn't seen theater for a long time, and it seemed all of a sudden there were these partnerships between commercial producers, and we had never had one at Second Stage and not for profits. I thought, I have not seen five years of theater; I don't know what's going on. At just that moment, Lynn Meadow and Michael Bush called me and said, "Can we talk to you about coming in and helping us?" Because Lynn is building a theater and she doesn't have time, and some of our literary manager is leaving, and we need someone to both run the literary office and produce some of the shows. I said, "It seems crazy when I had my own theater that I would go to your theater."
She said, "Well, I'll give you some freedom." So I said, "Well, I'll do it for two years so I can get the lay of the land," which is what I did. I started a reading series, and out of that reading series came Proof, which I produced for her, and I met David Lindsay-Abaire. We did Funny Mirrors, and we did a lot of good work. I met Scott Elliott, and I met a lot of people. In fact, I met Scott Rudin, who I later produced a show with there. He was wandering the halls for some reason. Daryl Roth and Kevin and Jeffrey, I met them again. I had met them during Rent because I produced Jonathan Larson's first workshop of Tick, Tick... Boom! They had asked me if I wanted to come into Rent, and I was doing the soap, making a lot of money, so I thought I'm not gonna do some off-Broadway show.
That was a miss. I did that for two years, and I had a lot of fun. It was very interesting, and I read a lot of plays, and they replaced me with two people actually when I left the literary office and the producer. It was very good because I understood what was going on by the end of that, and that's when I put out my shingle. I still had some savings, and I said, "I'm going to do musicals eventually because that's where you make your money, but I'm going to try to learn first as I'm figuring out what I'm going to produce." The first thing I did was Class Act with Lonny Price, and Lonny knows more about musicals than most people in the world, and so I learned a great deal from him. Then I raised a little money for Bat Boy and did that.
Meanwhile, right as I was leaving Manhattan Theater Club, I went to BMI workshop and saw two guys, three guys, and some puppets singing songs, singing four songs, and I fell in love, and I had to convince them that I was the person to produce a musical. They wanted to do a TV show, and they didn't want to do a musical, and they were going to do another presentation of these songs. I said, "I'm telling you, this is a musical. I'm inviting my theater producer friends." I invited all those people that I mentioned earlier. Jeffrey Seller was the one who called me the next day and said, "I wanted—I haven't had belly laughs like that in a long time. I want to do this with you." Once I had the Rent Boys, Kevin and Jeffrey, as I like to call them, the Rent Boys, all of a sudden they were paying attention to me, Bobby and Jeff. So we started on that journey from scratch, really, finding a book writer, finding a director, the whole team. It was just a wonderful, wonderful journey putting that show together.
[20:05] Ken Davenport: Do you remember what you said to the writers to convince them that this was a musical even before Kevin and Jeffrey? What was I finding? This is, of course, a lot of what producers have to do. We have to sell, persuade to our point of view.
[20:20] Robyn Goodman: If I remember correctly, because I think I was at that same presentation, that's one of my misses. I remember having those incredible belly laughs but hearing, "Oh, they want to do a TV show," because South Park had just hit. This seems perfect for that. I said to them, "You know, you'll get a TV show if you do a musical on Broadway. That's the path. You're not just gonna get a TV show because you have some funny puppet songs. It's not enough. And you haven't got a writer, really a book writer or a TV writer. I said, 'This is the way you should start.'" Of course, they were all in love with theater, so it's not like it never would be seductive to them, but they just thought that they would make a lot more money if they could just sell it as a TV show, I think.
Also, I was just me, and they didn't know about Second Stage. They didn't know what my history was. They didn't know I was just a woman, you know, to them. It wasn't till Kevin and Jeffrey came aboard that they agreed, actually. That's fine; I don't care what reason they had, but I was adamant about it. I said, "This is a perfect musical. I can see it. The only thing you have to promise me is that you'll put a love story in it. It's gotta have a love story; it's a musical." They said, "Oh, okay."
[21:44] Robyn Goodman: The cut tune, the terrible—throw it away. Funny song.
[21:50] Ken Davenport: Well, you just mentioned something that I was actually gonna get to later, but since you brought it up, you said, "I was a woman." Do you think it's harder to be a female producer?
[22:01] Robyn Goodman: I don't think now it's as hard as it was when I started, and it was 2000, but it seems like a sophisticated time to start. I think it's a man's world because men own all the theaters, you know, and that's where you have to beg. I do think that it's changing because there are so many smart women on Broadway now, but I felt it. I felt that it was—and also, people like Bobby and Jeff, I think they felt differently about it in the beginning, not by the end, but until they get to know you. I think it's easier to trust a man in a producing position than it is to trust a woman for certain people. It's a fight we all have all the time. It's true. I mean, now I find, well, I've done so much now that I don't have that experience as much, but at the beginning, yeah, I think so.
The people who knew me—I mean, Tick, Tick... Boom! came about because I had worked with Jonathan and the estate, and Victoria Leacock said, "We want you to do this for us." But things didn't come to me like that so easily, you know. I had to work, and Metamorphoses, you know, it was because Second Stage, because there were other people who wanted to move it.
[23:21] Robyn Goodman: Sounds like relationships. Relationships are so important, you know. My father told me always be nice to everybody, and he was right. It's one of those things, you know. It comes naturally, hopefully, but treat people well because that person who's an intern in your office, Bernie Telsey, or he was an intern, or Richie Jackson, you know, it's like he begged me for a job, and I said, "You're too smart for this job." You never know in the future where they're gonna turn up, and you could need something from them. But even so, it's a nicer way to go through life being nice to people, I think, than just assuming the best of them. Kindness, like Cinderella always says, kindness is important.
[24:07] Ken Davenport: Anything we can do to encourage more female producers to get into the game?
[24:13] Robyn Goodman: I think they're getting the message. I know a lot of young women who are interested in producing, and every time I do a class at Columbia, there's a lot of women there. I think sometimes they want to run not-for-profit theaters, which is great. Sometimes, you know, if they have the ability, I mean, the problem with, as you know, Ken, if you're not a rich person or you don't have a rich husband or wife, it's a tough business because you spend a lot of time developing something. Even if you pay yourself ten thousand dollars for three years, you know, it's like what? Or whatever, you know, whatever you pay yourself. But it's like you. I have three jobs; you have fourteen. But I mean, I still have three jobs, you know, and I do it because I'm afraid I'm afraid that I'm not gonna get a musical up in time or a play up in time or something that's paying me real money.
[25:07] Robyn Goodman: Although I don't think plays pay real money, but musicals do, and they take a long time to develop.
[25:14] Ken Davenport: Tell me about how you've cultivated and found investors over the years. What's that process for you? Do you enjoy raising money?
[25:22] Robyn Goodman: No, I don't. I wish I did. I have met some wonderful people though, I have to say, some really lovely people. You know, at each show you do, you widen your investor base and they're attracted. There's so many people out there who are interested in getting involved in producing. They all have more Tonys than I do. God bless them. And I like the nice ones. You know, I know some to stay away from, but you know, they're attracted to the material. Like I mean, I have friends who I love and have invested in everything but one show, you know, because they just didn't turn them on. And I've never forced people, never, ever, ever. I brought Ruth Hendel and Steve Hendel into investing in shows on Tick Tick Boom, and we've had a wonderful journey, but now they do their own shows, which I think is great, you know, and I still invite them to my readings and stuff because I love them.
But I don't necessarily do enough. I don't only go to lunches or dinners with people I really like. I don't know if I do enough networking. I try not to steal other people's big investors, you know, because I don't think it makes me feel uncomfortable unless they approach me. It's a tricky thing. I mean, I would hope that whatever I'm producing is good enough to attract people that they're interested in. And I always invite a lot of people that I feel good about. It's, uh, I'm trying to get Stephen and Josh, who are my partners now, to do more of it because you know I've done it for so many years, second stage years and producing years, and I, you know, it's tiring and it's not my favorite part of the job.
[27:12] Ken Davenport: Is it your favorite?
[27:14] Robyn Goodman: No, I mean look, I can get myself into it. You know, I can rev myself up because I think, oh, if I do this, then I'll be able to get to that opening night and I get it. It'll be magical. But I don't know many people who like it. But you know what I admire about you that I can't do? If somebody says no, I can't call them again and ask them again, and you can, and I'm sure it's worked for you too. And I think that's great that you can do that. I get embarrassed. I just I think they said no, and I assume people mean no, but obviously they don't always.
[27:49] Ken Davenport: Well, sometimes when I call them back, they hang up a lot faster.
[27:52] Robyn Goodman: No, but I think it shows passion. It shows that you really care about it and you're really trying to make it work. Although, you know, I've had a show where it was so hard to raise money that I should have listened to my investors. Do you know what I mean? And not done the show, probably. Sometimes when you can't raise the money, it's a message.
[28:12] Ken Davenport: You want to tell us what show that was?
[28:13] Robyn Goodman: No.
[28:14] Ken Davenport: I don't.
[28:15] Robyn Goodman: Well, let's talk about that for a second. Every producer out there working has had shows that don't work. I mean, that's the way it happens. More often than not. Some are heartbreaking. Well, uh, so how do you deal with that heartbreak?
[28:32] Robyn Goodman: Oh, High Fidelity was the biggest heartbreak I had, I think, because I loved it and I loved the people involved. You cry when you tell people you're closing it. I do. Um, I think the most important is that you know is to make sure the creative team realizes that there's a reason the show didn't work. It doesn't mean they're not talented. You know, they were turned out to be hugely talented. Tom Kitt won a Pulitzer and a Tony on his next show. Um, and he was eviscerated by the Times. So that was a major coup for him. But um, I was depressed for six months on about High Fidelity. I was really depressed, and Jeffrey Seller and I used to get together and say, let's analyze what was wrong with it.
And we finally figured it out, and uh, I mean, it was probably obvious to everybody else, but you cannot have an unlikable hero at the center of your musical. Pal Joey, Sweet Smell of Success, High Fidelity. If you don't like the guy or the gal, uh, the musical's not gonna fly. It's just not. No matter how interesting it is or how interesting the story is and how cool it is, and all that, it's not gonna work. There is a serious dramaturgical truth bomb for all of you writers out there, because I totally agree. Totally agree.
[29:54] Ken Davenport: Well, let's talk about Broadway for a second as a whole. If Broadway was a patient in a hospital right now, how would it be doing? Would it be doing okay, about to be released? Would it be in critical condition? What do you think the state of our business is?
[30:10] Robyn Goodman: I think it would be doing well, but it would be gaining a lot of weight and getting diabetes. I worry because you know, when I grew up, you saw plays on Broadway and they weren't necessarily filled with stars. You know, they were just great actors that you discovered when you went and and now you it's really impossible. Well, please God the Humans breaks that because uh it's a wonderful play and it doesn't have a big star in it, it just has great actors in it. Um, but um, I think that you know that everybody says oh Broadway's gonna become a theme park. I don't think that. I think there's always gonna be artistic people working on Broadway trying to do good. Everybody's trying to do good work.
But it's also gotten a little corporate and a little, uh, let's do the next movie or let's do the sequel or let's do the brand, or you know, and not that I'm not thinking about those things too, but I sort of come at it from a different angle, I think. It's like if it's not good, I'm not interested. And I just hope that people still want to take risks. I mean, in some in big ways, Hamilton was a risk. Avenue Q is a risk in the Heights. Um, when I did in the Heights, uh, everybody said don't move that that little Latina who showed a Broadway. They said don't move that little puppet show, you know. How can you do a show called Hamilton with people of color? Somebody said to me. Um, so you know, don't listen to the other voices.
I mean, if you believe in something, do it because it's the things it's the purple cows, right? It's the purple cows that uh thank you, Gladwell. Um, that really break the form and are successful, I think. You know, I although you know, sometimes bad shows succeed because they have a great brand, and that depresses me, honestly.
[32:00] Ken Davenport: Me too. I know. I know.
[32:00] Robyn Goodman: I love Spring Awakening. I think it's one of the best things I saw this year.
[32:04] Ken Davenport: Thank you very much.
[32:04] Robyn Goodman: I really, I really do. I thought it was totally artistic and beautiful and just wonderfully produced and all that.
[32:11] Ken Davenport: Thanks.
[32:12] Robyn Goodman: Biggest change you've seen on Broadway over the last couple decades?
[32:18] Robyn Goodman: The cost. We did Avenue Q for $3.5 million.
[32:23] Ken Davenport: My gosh. Can you believe you can hardly produce a play for $3.5 million?
[32:27] Robyn Goodman: You can just about produce a play without any advertising. It's frightening. The cost is the biggest change I've seen. It's just unbelievable to me that we pay so much money to do plays in musicals. You know, I should find a producer who's open enough to take their musical like that and see what it would cost today. Like rebudget Avenue Q for 2016 and see how much it would cost.
[32:53] Ken Davenport: At least.
[32:54] Robyn Goodman: At least. At least. And what's happened? What's changed? It's you can't I guess you could blame it on the unions and the real estate. That's about, you know, it's certainly not the actors and the directors and the, you know, the artists who are involved. So it's gotta be the union people and the real estate, I think, mostly.
[33:15] Ken Davenport: But you know, supply and demand, Ken. Supply and demand.
[33:21] Robyn Goodman: Okay. Last question. I lied. Second to last question.
[33:26] Ken Davenport: Okay.
[33:26] Robyn Goodman: As you look back on your career so far, anything you do differently?
[33:32] Robyn Goodman: No. How do you like that? I think I'm so fortunate that I was able to do so many different things and now run Bucks County Playhouse and do the Roundabout Underground and what I do on Broadway. I think I've had a charmed career. You know, I'm very fortunate. I came here with 500 bucks in my pocket when I came to New York and got work as an actress and then, you know, went on from there. Not that my father didn't help me out a couple of times, but I made my way in the theater in different ways and learned something in television. So I feel very fortunate.
[34:09] Ken Davenport: Okay, now that last question. It's my genie question. I want you to imagine that the genie from Aladdin comes to your office, knocks on your door, and says, Robyn, not only have you been a fantastic producer on Broadway, but I loved you in that show in London when you were an actress.
[34:26] Robyn Goodman: When I was naked?
[34:27] Ken Davenport: Yes. Thanks for the channel.
[34:28] Robyn Goodman: Exactly. I was a big fan of your soap.
[34:31] Ken Davenport: So I want to grant you one wish. I want you to think of what's the one thing that drives you so crazy about Broadway that makes you angry. You are you listened to your dad about being nice to everybody. You're one of the nicest people I know. I remember this and tried to learn from you when we worked together. What makes you mad angry that you would ask this genie to change with one snap of a finger?
[34:56] Robyn Goodman: Wow, that's a great question. Let me just think about that for a minute. Um, you can't you can't wish for people to have better taste, I suppose. Which would be one of my wishes. If I could change one thing. I don't know the answer to that, Ken. I think I really do wish that we could make Broadway less expensive, both for the people buying tickets and the people producing theater. And I would have to brainstorm with the genie to figure out how to do that, because I think we've shut out a whole lot of audience by the prices, and I understand why we charge them. No one understands it better than I do and you do. But, you know, 20 seats at $25 is not enough to bring in another generation. And my core value when I started was to bring young people to the theater, but I don't know how they can afford it.
And that makes me very sad. So I would say probably that would, you know, I don't know about the costs, they're probably always gonna go up. But I would say, what can we do about the next generation of theatergoers and how can we make it affordable and how can we get people's sensibility, including them, and not doing, you know, every revival in the world, you know, or things that they don't relate to. That's why Hamilton is so exciting, because they're actually paying for those tickets, which is wonderful, even if they see one show a year. I guess that's what I would care about.
[36:23] Ken Davenport: It's a very good wish. I want to thank you so much for everything you do on Broadway, also everything you did for me when we started. I learned so much by that show and partnering with you, so thank you so much for that. Next up on the podcast, ooh, we're gonna start doing something different at the end when I reveal the next guest. We're gonna play how many degrees of separation between the guest in front of me right now that you're listening to and the next one. And this one there's only one degree. Next up on the podcast is Bobby Lopez.
[36:52] Robyn Goodman: Ah, creator of Avenue Q, Book of Mormon, and Egot winner.
[36:56] Ken Davenport: So make sure you tune in to the next episode to hear everything that Bobby's got to say and hear his perspective. Thanks so much for tuning in. We'll see you next time. Don't forget, join the Producers Perspective Pro. You can get it on the blog or at the Producers Perspective Pro dot com. Look out Broadway here I come.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
