Charles Isherwood is an American theater critic. He wrote for Back Stage West in Los Angeles. In 1993, he joined the staff of Variety, where he was promoted to the position of chief theatre critic in 1998. In 2004, Isherwood was hired by the New York Times... Read More
From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport
Featured Shows
About
Charles Isherwood is an American theater critic. He wrote for Back Stage West in Los Angeles. In 1993, he joined the staff of Variety, where he was promoted to the position of chief theatre critic in 1998. In 2004, Isherwood was hired by the New York Times.
He has been working at The Old Gray Lady for over a decade now, reviewing shows all over town (and the country). He sees hundreds of shows per year. Hundreds. You try that sometime . . . and then try to write a logical, coherent, and entertaining article about it. (What we forget about critics is that not only do they have to be super schooled in the theater . . . but they also have to be great writers – and whether you agree with Charles or not, no one can dispute his way with a few hundred words.)
Charles was generous enough to sit down with me and chat about the state of theatrical criticism and all sorts of other stuff, including:
- Why we’ll never go back to making reviewers review the opening night performance.
- What he thinks when he sees a quote from one of his reviews splashed an a marquee.
- Why Writers should NOT read his reviews.
- What he’s looking forward to this season.
- How he responds to “hate mail.”
Keep up with me: @KenDavenportBway
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ken Davenport: Hey everybody, wanted to take a moment to wish everyone out there, especially all those hardworking men and women in performing arts unions across the country a very, very happy Labor Day. Hope you're enjoying it. Now on with the podcast. I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway. I wanna be a producer.
[0:23] Ken Davenport: Hello, everybody. Welcome back to the Producer's Perspective Podcast. I am Ken Davenport. I am honored to have with us today one of the most important voices in theatrical criticism on the planet. Please welcome to the podcast, New York Times Theater Critic, Mr. Charles Isherwood. Welcome, Charles.
[0:39] Charles Isherwood: Thank you.
[0:41] Ken Davenport: So, Charles, which came first for you? Was it your love of the theater or your love of writing?
[0:47] Charles Isherwood: Well, I think I was a natural writer before I became a lover of theater because, uh, as a child I used to write lunatic stories. Um, I would be very embarrassed to read today, I'm sure. And theater really didn't come into my life until I was, you know, my early twenties. Because I grew up in a suburb in Northern California. We didn't go to the theater that much. That's what my parents did. They went to ACT and the kids stayed home. But I was a huge Pauline Kael fan, so, and I was a huge movie fan. I would start reading Pauline Kael and get more and more into movies, and somehow between having, I think, a certain natural writing instinct or talent and becoming obsessed with Pauline Kael, that ultimately led to my career, such as it is.
[1:35] Ken Davenport: And where did the career in criticism begin? Like where how did how did it start?
[1:41] Charles Isherwood: Well, I moved to Los Angeles after college, and, uh, I now call that the lost decade in Los Angeles. In fact, without that, I would never be where I am today because I started working in a magazine, which folded, and then Variety gave me a job as a copy editor. At the time they didn't have a reliable or regular daily, you know, Variety LA theater critic. And I'd gotten much more interested in theater by this point. And I sort of had my Ruby Keeler moment when I went in and said, "Hey, let me do this. I can do this." And, uh, it turned out well. You know, I started becoming the main daily reviewer for LA Variety, and then they moved me to New York.
[2:24] Ken Davenport: So you remember the first play or musical you ever reviewed?
[2:28] Charles Isherwood: Well, actually, I did write for Back Stage West in its infancy before that's how I had my Ruby Keeler moment. I had my little reviews to show. Five dollars I got paid for those reviews, by the way. And some reviewers are probably still getting it banned out. If I, I know, I know, it's sad. So, wait, what was the question?
[2:48] Ken Davenport: What was the first review you remember?
[2:50] Charles Isherwood: Oh, the first review, no. I think it was a small play in, uh, Pasadena called Murder for Rent that was of course impossibly bad. But, uh, you know, I got to cover a few interesting theories, Lips Together Teeth Apart in LA and it's the first incarnation. So, you know, I started small, but when I started writing for Daily Variety, you know, I got more attention, and then I started coming to New York much more often, and then they moved me here.
[3:16] Ken Davenport: And when you started writing reviews, did you think someday I want to be a critic for the New York Times? Was that a desire or a dream at that point?
[3:26] Charles Isherwood: Um, you know, it never really occurred to me until people started saying to me, "Oh, wow, you would be great at the New York Times." I mean, not that people were stopping me on the street or anything, but a couple of people, uh, when I first moved to New York and started writing for Variety said, "Hey, you're a very good critic and the Times would be lucky to have you," but I don't know if they feel that way at this point.
[3:48] Ken Davenport: And what was it like getting that call eventually and thinking you were going to work for the theatrical paper of record?
[3:55] Charles Isherwood: Well, I mean, obviously it was terribly exciting. At the same time, I'd been called by the Los Angeles Times to move back there and become their chief critic. That's always how it works. Until you're desirable to someone else, you're not that desirable to this one. So of course it was exciting. And, uh, tough choice to go between the two?
[4:15] Charles Isherwood: Uh, no, not really. I love New York. As I said, I feel like I'm a born New Yorker who just took a long time to get here. LA, much as I love the city now when I visit, it just was not the right fit for me. So I didn't want to go back.
[4:28] Ken Davenport: Tell me a bit about your process for writing a review. Do you take notes during the shows? Do you like to see them early or middle? Do you go home and write the review right away? What's, what's if you were going to see a show tonight after it was done or even during, what would be your process?
[4:45] Charles Isherwood: Well, I take notes, of course, they're illegible, but, uh, it really serves as more of a memory device. Like when you're writing on a particular moment or line of dialogue or image, it sticks in your memory more. So you don't even look at the notes necessarily, you still remember it because you've taken that note because it struck you. So I'll take notes, but I don't write the second I get home. That's when I have a drink.
[5:10] Ken Davenport: So the notes, let me just ask about the notes. Do you only note good or do you note bad as well?
[5:16] Charles Isherwood: Oh, I note everything. Everything. Anything that strikes me. I mean, you know, I wouldn't want to have my notes transcribed and put in an anthology anywhere. I think they're inane, of course, but also condemnatory in some ways.
[5:29] Ken Davenport: Yeah, well, let's not go there.
[5:33] Charles Isherwood: No politics everywhere. We're not allowed to, you know, express opinions. But no, I write the next morning. And of course, as you know in the theater, we usually have two or three previews before the show opens, so you're not under that crazy pressure that they are in London, where literally you have to write your review within an hour.
[5:51] Ken Davenport: But were you ever writing reviews at a time when you had to do that? Or has it all have you always had the cushion of a couple of years?
[5:58] Charles Isherwood: Well, no, in Los Angeles, they didn't have press previews. So you would go to the opening, and you would have to write by 10 a.m. the next morning. And then the crazy thing is, I couldn't believe I did this. I was still working as a copy editor, so I'd write a review in the morning, then go work an eight-hour shift as a copy editor, and then go to another show possibly that night and write the next morning.
[6:19] Ken Davenport: There was a, uh, lighting designer, Ken Billington, who was on this very podcast, and he said he missed the days of when reviewers had to go to opening night and write the review that night because he felt there was like a live or die energy in the room that made it more exciting for people. Do you think we could—
[6:39] Charles Isherwood: Everybody that even the people sitting in the house, we all knew that, oh, the reviewers are there, this is it, this is the performance that everyone's gonna see. His concern is, I guess, has been that what if a reviewer goes to see a matinee where it's a dead house on a Saturday afternoon or something. Do you think we could ever go back to that?
[7:01] Charles Isherwood: Uh, no, that's not happening. Um for anyone.
[7:04] Ken Davenport: I never knew you were so funny, Charles.
[7:06] Charles Isherwood: I'm quite funny when I'm sour.
[7:09] Charles Isherwood: Um, but, uh, no, that's not gonna go back. And I don't from my perspective, I think the criticism is actually much more acute and well written and perceptive when you have time to process the play, which you know, you have to do overnight sometimes. And also the truth is the performance on opening night with the critics there is not gonna reflect what you know is gonna happen two days later or three days later. In a weird way, I think when there are four previews that critics can go to, maybe you're getting a more accurate picture of what is going on stage every night.
[7:44] Ken Davenport: How long does it take you to write a review? You start the next morning?
[7:48] Charles Isherwood: Yeah, I mean, it depends. If you're in a passionate fury to say something good or bad, it'll take as little as 90 minutes. Of course, you can go back and refine and adjust. Um, sometimes you want to take it slower and do one paragraph here, one paragraph there, but usually I do them all and I'd say an average of three hours.
[8:10] Ken Davenport: And you mentioned adjusting and changing or rewriting, which of course something all writers do. How much the editors influence what you do in terms of space or language, or is it really your own review when it gets published?
[8:24] Charles Isherwood: Well, which editor? I've had five now, I believe. You know, they critics I think have more leeway than reporters to, you know, stand firm. This is what I want to say, this is how I want to say it. All my editors have been helpful in some ways, and, uh, you know, you do want that perspective. In general, I don't, I'm not heavily edited, I know Ben is not heavily edited. So we pretty much what you see is what you get, you know what I mean? We really are offering our fairly unvarnished opinions or excessively varnished opinions, however you want to read it, of what we saw. The editors do not meddle too much.
[9:07] Ken Davenport: How many shows a year do you see? Do you know the number approximate?
[9:11] Charles Isherwood: I lie awake at night trying to figure out that number. I'd probably see on average four shows a week. So that's what, 200 and I can't do math. That's why I'm in this business. But that's, you know, at least four shows a week. You know, because I see the shows I'm reviewing, I see the shows that Ben is reviewing. We sometimes try to see things that are far off your beat. So I'm out almost every night. But I'm a nocturnal person, so this is an ideal job, so you don't have to get up early in the morning.
[9:43] Ken Davenport: So you will see something that Ben is reviewing that is already chimed in on just to for your own edification or—
[9:43] Charles Isherwood: Well, and of course I have to, you know, at the end of the year we have to have our Tony predictions and picks and all this stuff, so I have to see a lot of shows. I often have this image of you and Ben at the office going back and forth about, uh, about a show. Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more?
[10:09] Charles Isherwood: Do you ever talk about this stuff? We occasionally have conversations, uh not personal conversations, but we do these to the paper where we talk about the season or whatever. But no, we rarely see each other. I mean, neither of us works from the office. And I usually don't see the shows he reviews until they've opened, so I don't read his review until after the show's open, so I don't want to be tainted. But of course, I have to have my own opinion. But you know, very often, obviously he's a very astute, smart critic and very good writer, so very often I don't have that many. It's not like I'm outraged every week at what Ben has written. So it's not really an issue. And those articles that have been done to conversations with you two about the season are some of my favorite articles of the year in the arts and leisure section, by the way.
[10:55] Charles Isherwood: Uh so 200 something shows a year. Now I find it I'm a Tony voter, and at the end of the year, as things start to pile up for me with shows, I literally will get tired of seeing show after show. And it starts to wear on me. Does the same thing happen for you? Is this a problem with our industry right now in terms of the backloaded heavy season?
[11:18] Charles Isherwood: Well, every season is slightly more end loaded, uh shall we say. Um, but uh yeah, April is a very, you know, it's a cliché, it's the coolest month for theater critics. Um but I don't cover so much Broadway, so I can take a little more time. I do find it baffling that this model still continues to exist that you know you'll have you know, there are what 36, 37, 38 shows opening in a season on Broadway, and 12 of them will open in one month or five weeks. Uh it doesn't do a great service for anybody, I don't know. But I don't see how it's going to change because there's also you know, proof that the closer you open to the Tonys, the more likely you are to get more attention and less Tony Awards and money.
[12:03] Ken Davenport: Is there anything else that producers could do to make things easier for the critics in terms of schedule or timing or things that you wish, oh, if they only like for example, we and maybe I'm not sure if you do this or not, but if you request a script now, we'll send you a script beforehand so you can really look at things. Is there something else that you wish producers or writers would do to make things your job easier?
[12:28] Charles Isherwood: Uh no, I don't think so. I think actually, you know, we have it pretty easy these days. It is I mean, I never read the scripts before I see the show, even if I get them. But it's nice to be able to consult them. I think critics are treated very well, actually. I don't have any complaints. I mean, it would be nice if, you know, there were twelve shows opening in one week in April or two weeks in April. But um, you know, at the times we touch wood metaphorically. Actually, I'm going to. Um, we do, you know, we still have two critics, so neither of us is having to cover everything. So that helps.
[13:04] Charles Isherwood: Now, obviously you're a theater fan as well, so and this is my job, but I'm also a theater fan. So you'll see me on the trades, Playbill or some of the other more just press some of the other websites that just push promotional material out for the shows to catch the latest video in rehearsal of this song or this new musical. Now, do you watch that stuff? Or do you try to block that out because just like you don't want to read this script, you don't want to get a taste of what you may see?
[13:30] Charles Isherwood: I don't watch it. I don't I don't read too much of that stuff just because you do want to have a clear mind, um, an open mind, shall we say. And you know, the gossip sides, I never look at those because they're always saying horrible things about me, I think. Or in my dreams they're saying horrible things about me. If only. Um But uh no, I don't I try not to look a little at a lot of that stuff. I'd rather be, you know, reading a book.
[13:56] Ken Davenport: So no chat. Not about theater. No, what what do you read books about? What's your other thing?
[14:01] Charles Isherwood: Oh, I mean I want to read novels over Henry James, I read Andrew James or eat them. Very important books, Ken. Very important books.
[14:07] Charles Isherwood: So no chat rooms, no social media, none of this stuff.
[14:10] Charles Isherwood: Well, I'm on Facebook. I I'm much more on Facebook, you know, just at the times we're encouraged to engage in social media as much as possible, but I'm not on Twitter yet. When I live in fear of the day, I must be. But I think Facebook is actually, you know, obviously it's a very powerful tool that the Times is trying to optimize in its own way for all sorts of reasons.
[14:35] Charles Isherwood: So obviously, you know that a review of yours can have a big effect on a show, opening, play, musical, whether it's here in New York, Broadway, Off-Broadway, wherever it is around the country. Is that hard when you write? Is it a lot of pressure as you put fingers to the keyboard?
[14:51] Charles Isherwood: You know, I don't think about it. I mean I I probably should more, but um, if you start letting those kind of considerations enter your head, then I think you're gonna compromise. Sound fancy. Compromise your critical integrity. Uh, because those things really you should put aside. And when you go in, you just, as a critic, you respond to what you're seeing on stage, not how your opinion of it will be perceived. Even though, of course, on a you know, conscious level, I know there is some influence that I have. But of course, it's been proven many times that you know the Times' vaunted power of making or breaking shows is not is semi-mythical. I mean, for certain shows, the more highbrow stuff, I think it's certainly the case. But I mean, Cats would have been a hit whether whatever anyone said about it.
[15:40] Ken Davenport: Do you ever write something and then think, oh, they're gonna quote that? They're gonna take that and slap that on the marquee somewhere?
[15:49] Charles Isherwood: Well, I mean, you start to notice it, and of course they're getting much more uh, shall we say, should I put it? Fraudulent, why not? You know, in selecting quotes and putting them together so you'll have an adjective in three different sentences and they'll string them together in ways and some of the publicists or the you know the bad people will run these bias and if they're egregious of course I'll say no. I mean my policy is if the words are in the review and they are not you know mangled in a weird way put together to misrepresent what I said, fine, it's fair game. You know if I said at one point magnificent even if I was referring to the Ottoman in one scene, you know what they want to put magnificent and that's it. That's their you know that's their prerogative.
[16:39] Ken Davenport: Do you ever get uh angry letters from writers, producers, feedback?
[16:44] Charles Isherwood: Mostly uh from readers who disagree with my opinion. Writers I I did get a very nasty email from Marsha and Norman once. It w it wasn't even about a play, it was about something else they'd written but then we had a nice exchange and I often find that if you know when you get one of these horrible attack letters if you uh if you respond in a you know not necessarily equally antagonistic way then they sort of they don't back off but they say okay well maybe you're not the horrible human being. I thought you were so you know I don't always respond but I do respond when I feel it's necessary or I'm really annoyed.
[17:25] Ken Davenport: You ever get uh thank you letters or positive letters from artists?
[17:25] Charles Isherwood: I've gotten a few yeah. I mean, it's probably about even. Well, actually I probably got more thank yous or you know, subtle thank yous from artists than complaints from artists, because I think most artists know that, you know, you're not gonna win complaining about to a critic. Although frankly, it doesn't really bother me either way.
[17:48] Ken Davenport: Okay. In your entire life, favorite theater going experience? The one that if you had to watch it every single day for the rest of your life, you could watch it.
[17:57] Charles Isherwood: I don't know that I can say that there is one. I will give you a couple. Before I moved to New York, and before I was really involved in theater, I was just starting to think about it to write about it. I came and saw John Ware's Six Degrees of Separation. And I stood in line and failed to see it when it was in the Missy Newhouse, and I made a trip back to see the Vivian Beaumont. And that was one of the most transcendent evenings of my life because I thought this was just an incredibly smart, funny, profound play in a perfect production. And I just w went out of that theater, you know, walking on air, as they say. Well, walking on the Lincoln Center Plaza, in fact. But that's one. Certainly, um the revival of Chicago that everyone, you know, went crazy for was also a very thrilling moment because it was a musical I didn't really know, and the style of the production was obviously fairly radical for the time, and it was from Encore.
And I was in LA at the time, so we didn't have that. So those are two that I can really point to. Also, but but discovering writers like Annie Baker, her play The Aliens, which is I think maybe the second, possibly the third that I seen of hers in this tiny theater in the West Village. You know, I came out of that. Just sometimes you get a little depressed, you see a lot of bad plays. This one I came out thinking this is why I'm doing this. This is a great artist, and her work needs to be known about, and I'll shout from the rooftops if need be. So those three are the first three that I think of.
[19:30] Ken Davenport: How do you think Broadway is doing today versus when you started writing reviews?
[19:35] Charles Isherwood: Well, I moved here in uh 1998, and it was already on an upswing, I think. Uh that was the season of the Lion, which obviously became a big blockbuster, and we hadn't had a lot of American musical blockbusters. Okay, granted, it was based on a movie, but of course it was a very inventive production. I think Broadway's really gotten much more adventurous in the past, you know, five to ten years. I mean, you wouldn't see even Hamilton, you know, ten or fifteen years ago that might have been produced off Broadway, gotten great reviews, but nobody would have thought of moving to Broadway. You know, this a rap musical about Alexander Hamilton with a multiracial cast. I mean, you know, that might not have happened.
[20:19] Charles Isherwood: Fun Home, who knew that that would be a success on Broadway. So even though it's still largely a commercial, you know, enterprise catering to tourists and offering up a jukebox musical every single season or two, I think it actually has gotten a little more adventurous. The one week area is new American plays, which don't really appear very often at all.
[20:42] Ken Davenport: And how has reviewing changed in the last 20 years for you? Do you find that it's your style has to be different now? Are you asked to write shorter reviews than you were when you started? What's changed about that process for you?
[20:56] Charles Isherwood: Well you know, there are changes coming at the Times because well, obviously, as you know, the publishing industry is not, you know, in robust health. I mean, the internet has really disrupted, to use the the shade charm, the business model. So we are trying to discover new ways of covering theater, and this fall I think we're gonna be introducing new features or changing the approach. In general, I mean, so far we have not had any mandates, you know, fewer reviews, fewer words, but um I think I don't know, that may come. What's most dispiriting is not what's happened at the Times, which is you know, generally just trying to adapt to a changing environment. What's happened elsewhere where theater critics are being laid off or not replaced?
I think that's really that's the most unfortunate thing in criticism, arts criticism across the board really, but theater for me is more personal. You know, there was a week over the summer where two theater critics got laid off, and then a month later another theater critic got laid off, so and the more voices the better. And uh so that's obviously it's not the cheeriest moment to be a theater critic.
[22:09] Ken Davenport: Where do you think we'll be in twenty years in terms of theatrical criticism?
[22:14] Charles Isherwood: Hmm. I really don't know. The trends are not upward, shall we say? One always hopes there'll be a reaction in the other direction. And of course now there are all sorts of blogs that cover theater, so but I don't really know that that is making up for the loss of professional theater criticism. I do think that, you know, if you're someone who's doing this day in and day out and it's your job and it's your passion, you should be paid more attention to than some, you know, random twelve year old who, you know, really loves the theater. And I refer to no one. I mean, I'm sure there are random twelve year olds who are blogging about theater, but I don't want to read them.
[22:54] Ken Davenport: What would you be doing if you weren't reviewing?
[22:56] Charles Isherwood: Sleeping. What would I be doing? I don't know. You know, it's one of these things when you can see various other paths your life might have taken, but at this point, you know, if I had to switch careers, it would be difficult. You know, I'm at an age where it's you just don't say, hey, I'm gonna go back to law school and start, you know, becoming a public defender or, you know, even an extra on Law and Order. It's too late. So I don't know. You know, what has happened has happened, and uh you know, of course if I lost my job I could possibly find work writing books or writing about other subjects, but you know, I hope that doesn't happen.
[23:35] Ken Davenport: What do you think about all the Hollywood stars that have come to Broadway in the last several years? Does some of them excite you? Is it just when you see a star-driven show you're like, oh it's just a purely commercial vehicle it can't have any real value?
[23:49] Charles Isherwood: Well I mean stars do not become stars because, you know, randomly, although some do, but you know most of them are very good actors, not necessarily great stage actors with a lot of experience. But I think on the whole it's been healthy for Broadway obviously commercially. What is dispiriting though is the fact that because new plays even revivals of course particularly revivals have to be larded with all these star names that we will never hopefully not never we won't it doesn't allow stage actors to emerge and become breakout stars on the stage. I mean, you know, Cherry Jones, I wonder if you know if she started her career twenty years later, would it be the same? It might have been much harder for her to rise through if more stars in those days were coming to Broadway, so it's a bit of a mixed bag.
[24:41] Ken Davenport: Looking forward to anything this season?
[24:43] Charles Isherwood: God, this season, I haven't thought about it that much. Ready for the big fall preview in the New York Times.
[24:48] Ken Davenport: Should we Yeah, I know we we know I have to I was gonna say you have to write to write an article about this.
[24:53] Charles Isherwood: I know. Well we may do a dialogue. I'm looking forward to seeing the Lynn Nottage play Sweat again. I saw it in Oregon and it's a really powerful play. I think maybe her best. I'm looking forward to seeing Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway, which is a lovely little musical that, you know, it's sort of a hard bet for Broadway, but it's more proof that Broadway is more open to off the beaten track shows. Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 19 whatever year it was is a lovely show. It'll be fascinating to see how that does on Broadway with you know how they're gonna make the uh a Broadway theater mimic the, you know, semi-immersive experience will be interesting to see. So the fall season I think has a lot of interesting stuff, but it's hard to find an overriding theme. Some seasons are better than others and you don't know until the end.
[25:44] Ken Davenport: Okay, I'm gonna say two things. I want you to pick one of them. Ready? Broadway or off Broadway?
[25:51] Charles Isherwood: Off Broadway.
[25:52] Ken Davenport: Plays or musicals?
[25:54] Charles Isherwood: Plays.
[25:55] Ken Davenport: New or revival?
[25:57] Charles Isherwood: New.
[25:58] Ken Davenport: Good. You pass. I mean that's mainly my beat so if you could get all the producers on Broadway, off Broadway in a room and could tell them one thing about criticism, about telling them to relax, whatever, what would you tell them about what you do that you don't think they know or understand?
[26:19] Charles Isherwood: Well, not necessarily producers. I think it's different for producers and artists. I mean, I think for artists, what I would tell them is, well, first of all, don't read reviews. Don't read reviews, you know.
[26:31] Ken Davenport: You would tell writers not to read your own reviews?
[26:36] Charles Isherwood: Yes. How come?
[26:37] Charles Isherwood: Because the fact is, you know, they're highly sensitive people. If they've made it this far, they are obviously have some talent. And I know from experience that, you know, a bad review can make you feel really bad. In fact, an opera singer once said this. She didn't read reviews and she said, uh I don't read them because the bad ones make you feel worse than the good ones make you feel good. And that's always stuck with me. It's true. Artists are sensitive people and you know what you you have to go by your own lights ultimately and you know it's not that I don't think I have interesting things to say or instructive ones, but I don't think ultimately I think artists have their own vision, their own voice, and they should pursue it no matter what anyone says.
[27:24] Ken Davenport: Are you friends with any writers? Any acquaintances?
[27:27] Charles Isherwood: Um I'm not writers no I mean journalists yes but uh I I don't really know any playwrights.
[27:36] Ken Davenport: Okay, my last question my big James is this gonna be the hard one this is the hard one it's the James Lifton question. I want you to imagine that the genie from Aladdin comes to visit you. Did you review Aladdin?
[27:50] Charles Isherwood: I did, yes.
[27:50] Ken Davenport: You did. I don't remember if you liked it or not.
[27:53] Charles Isherwood: I did much to my shock and horror. It's quite a fun show.
[27:59] Ken Davenport: Okay, so the genie comes to your office, your apartment, wherever you write and says, Charles, I want to thank you for my palatial mansion in East Hampton. I think that's what you meant.
[28:10] Charles Isherwood: That's exactly right. Yeah. The castle of theatrical reviewing where you sit on the throne. And the genie says, I want to thank you for your decades of service to the industry and your incredible critique of so many shows. I want to thank you and grant you one wish, and also thank you for the great review as well. He wants to grant you one wish. What's the one thing that you would change about Broadway? The one thing that gets you so angry would have you banging on this desk, screaming out loud, if only they would just change this. Broadway would be better. That's the one thing you'd ask them to do.
[28:47] Charles Isherwood: Ticket prices. I mean, I think that is a huge barrier to expanding audiences on Broadway. I mean, it's outrageous that $160 is the average for a musical ticket, I think something like that. Hamilton is now, I think, 199. And that just you know, and back in the day I hear tales where I sat in the balcony and you see Lorette Taylor from 25 cents or whatever. I think that really has become a huge problem. We're not going to really be able to develop huge new audiences without finding some way of you know making this crazy price point more accessible, you know, change, more accessible to more people. I mean, shows do lotteries, there's logical ways of getting discounts, of course, but in general, I think it makes harder to put on shows, makes it hard for audiences to see shows, but of course it's a very complicated question involving union issues, as you well know. So um, I don't know that I mean that's my genie wish. I don't expect it to happen.
[29:46] Ken Davenport: Well, thank you for that. Thank you for all the years you put into reviewing your show. I'm a big fan of uh all your writing, even the reviews of my shows that you that you haven't liked. They're always written for us.
[30:00] Charles Isherwood: Thanks so much for doing this. Thanks to all of you for listening, and we will see you next time. Have a great Labor Day, everybody. Whatever you're doing, I hope you're not working.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
