Carey Sharpe joins The Roundtable with Robert Bannon to talk about her thrilling new project Blood/Love, now playing in New York City! A true multi-hyphenate, Carey not only stars in the production but also co-wrote this bold, stylized piece that blends passion, drama, and a deliciously dark sense of theatricality... Read More
From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon
About
Carey Sharpe joins The Roundtable with Robert Bannon to talk about her thrilling new project Blood/Love, now playing in New York City! A true multi-hyphenate, Carey not only stars in the production but also co-wrote this bold, stylized piece that blends passion, drama, and a deliciously dark sense of theatricality. We dive into the inspiration behind the work, the creative process of building a show from the ground up, and what it takes to bring something so fierce, fearless, and unapologetically camp to the stage.
We also talk about the magic of creating original theater in NYC, embracing big storytelling choices, and why audiences are loving the wild ride of Blood/Love. Carey brings humor, heart, and serious star power to this conversation — and trust me, the energy is everything. Theater lovers, downtown scene fans, and anyone who enjoys bold, exciting live performance will want to check this out!
Watch The Roundtable with Robert Bannon on BroadwayWorld, YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and all major platforms.
🌐 RobertBannon.com
📲 Follow on Instagram: @RobertMBannon
The best is yet to come.
#CareySharpe #BloodLove #NYCTheatre #OffBroadway #NewYorkTheater #BroadwayWorld #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon #RobertBannon #TheatreLife #NewWork #WomenInTheatre #CampTheatre #NYCArts
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Robert Bannon: Are you ready? It's the Roundtable with me, Robert Bannon. Welcome to the Roundtable, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon. You're listening to Sub Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeartSpotify. A while ago, I talked to our next guest. And now our next guest took a show that was written into an album, into an idea, and it's coming to New York for a full-blown giant run. I want to like boohoo cry for Carey Sharpe. Because you know what the odds and the chances and the fact that this hours in blood, sweat, and tears—no, no pun intended—blood, sweat, and tears into this show. Please welcome back to the show Ms. Carey Sharpe. Congratulations.
[0:46] Carey Sharpe: Thank you. Thank you very much.
[0:49] Robert Bannon: Do you feel is it surreal to have a show coming to New York City that's your baby? And it's gonna be a real giant, beautiful, incredible run.
[0:59] Carey Sharpe: I mean, certainly it is beyond my wildest dreams, to be totally honest. I really did not think or intend to take it this far, honestly. But now that it's here, it is kind of—it is simultaneously very surreal, but also it feels very right. You know, it just feels like we're doing the right thing; everything feels really great. I feel like I'm in the right place. So it's kind of both things at once.
[1:23] Robert Bannon: Well, look, bloodlove.com is where you can get your tickets. Tickets are on sale. The show's up running, and you know, it's good. There's a show tonight that we're recording this right now. So you better get your tickets and head on over to Theater 555. Tell me, it's right on 42nd Street.
[1:37] Carey Sharpe: Yep.
[1:38] Robert Bannon: And you have an incredible cast of people. Would you tell us a little bit how'd you find them? What'd you do? Who are they?
[1:46] Carey Sharpe: Yeah. Um, well, yeah, we've got an amazing team for this run, which you know, part of the reason we wanted to come to New York is undeniably, that's where all the theater people really are in New York. I mean, it's just kind of such a wealth of talent, and I don't just—not even just, you know, stage talent, all the behind-the-scenes designers and crew, and just everybody is really in New York. Um, so we've assembled a team that is like honestly just kind of unreal. And sometimes I—that is what has been a little overwhelming for me is just being surrounded by these professionals that have so much experience, and you know, I am still relatively new to this. Certainly at this level, I'm new to this. Um, so just being kind of forced or just having to kind of like rise to that occasion has probably been the biggest challenge for me. And but it's been really humbling to be with such an amazing group of talent.
[2:43] Robert Bannon: Well, when you see the pictures of them on the website, everybody, this is like the most grown and sexy, amazing.
[2:50] Carey Sharpe: Yeah, we were looking for people that brought an authenticity to the roles and just to the cast. We wanted it to reflect like, yeah, like a sexiness, but just like a really—authentic is probably the word that I would use the most to describe our cast. Um, and everybody just gets to kind of embody themselves in a way. Um, I think that resonates, you know. Everybody just gets to kind of go out there and be their best selves.
[3:17] Robert Bannon: What I love about the show and the idea, we could listen to the music and get ready to see it, go to bloodlove.com and get your tickets, is that A, if you don't love musicals, traditional musicals, if you're into horror, if you're into comic books, if you're into Marvel movies, if you're into the supernatural, if you're into relationships, love, etc., then this is for everybody. This is not your old razzle dazzle musical, but if you love your old razzle dazzle musical, there's music and there's storytelling for that as well. You really created something that crosses genres, and that's rare, Carey.
[3:50] Carey Sharpe: Yeah, I mean, we definitely set out to create something that kind of defied the typical theater expectations. Um, and I think we certainly have done that. You know, I think what something that we're doing now is we are bringing it more into like a theater realm. You know, we are trying to exist in an off-Broadway space that has some, you know, guidelines, I guess you would say. So we're constantly trying to like find that line of sort of fitting in while also pushing the boundaries and doing something that feels very unique. And I feel really good about where we've landed for this production. It is certainly different than what you typically would see in the city. Um, it kind of almost feels like a cool music video for a lot of the show.
Um, and there's elements of it that feel much more like ballet or, you know, we call it a pop opera because it is almost entirely sung through. Um, and that is still somewhat, you know, you don't see a lot of shows that way these days. Um, so it's fun to kind of like bend these genres and you know, the music, although it, you know, it's like operatic in style or in form, the style of the music is very modern, pop, rock, kind of even some like sort of dance music, you know, there's a little bit of sprinkling of theatrical kind of numbers, but it really is an interesting blend of all those genres.
[5:12] Robert Bannon: You worked on this for, I don't know, six years plus, co-wrote this. So tell me about it. Where did the idea come from? And how do you describe the story of the show?
[5:20] Carey Sharpe: Yeah. Um, so I started writing this in 2020 with my co-writer Drew DeCaro, who also he kind of like leads the band, he plays guitar in the band, and um, so he's still involved in the show. And um, we just, you know, I went out to LA. I just had an idea of wanting to do like a vampire show. I wouldn't even say like a musical at that point, just like some sort of theatrical experience. And so we just started taking a stab at writing some songs. We didn't have a plot; we didn't—we knew we wanted to have a female central character, which was loosely slash sometimes quite literally based off some of my experience, some of the songs I've written about my own personal life. Um, but we just kind of started writing songs, and then over the years—because now we are, you know, this is technically we're almost in our sixth year here—we just have started shaping the story, and now it's all pulled together in a cohesive plot line.
Um, we've written some specific stories for that even for this iteration; we've written I think three entirely new songs, and there's a couple reprises and just like, you know, changes we've made to existing numbers. So, um, yeah, it just has kind of continued to evolve, but most of that is really just music.
[6:32] Robert Bannon: Well, it's at bloodlove.com. You have aside the music, which I mean the story, which is what hooked me when I first heard about this and when you guys were first talking about this is the world's first vampire. Yeah, a thousand years she's out here ruling the night and now she won—like it's just such a great premise. And I know that in film and television so much has been done and in theater about the mystique of a vampire. Why are we obsessed with vampires? Why are we as a society in love with the Edwards and the True Bloods and the Draculas of it all? Why do we care so much about a vampire? Why do you?
[7:06] Carey Sharpe: Well, I—I mean it so I'm 42 and I talk about this a bit, but you know, I think as you get older, and all of us really at any age, there is this like appeal of like living forever, right? I mean, obviously we all have to face our own mortality. That is the reality of life. But there's something very alluring about, you know, not having to have that struggle. But also, you know, so we've contemplated many times over the year, like what is the flip side of that? You know, if you really truly do live forever, your life starts to not have meaning. And we part of what makes human lives important is that they are limited. So you have to make the best of the time that you have. If you have unlimited time, that shifts.
So we talk about that a bit in the show, touch on that. She's kind of becoming tired of her—you know, she's a thousand years old at the top of the show; I'm not giving anything away. She turns a thousand years old in the opening number basically. Um, and she's just sort of like I've done everything. There's nothing left for me here. What is my purpose? Um, so she kind of goes on a journey and meets somebody who kind of sparks something inside of her to make it change. But yeah, so that—but then also, I mean, vampires are just sexy, and it's a very easy and interesting character to embody. Often people will kind of come in like vampire attire, you know, just sort of get into that vibe when they come to our show, and that's fun, you know?
And it doesn't—we have historically done the show during the Halloween season. We very intentionally pulled it out of the Halloween season because it's not really a Halloween show. There's nothing about it that's specifically Halloween. And so instead, this time we opened it Valentine's Day weekend because there's a lot of love in the show. There's—she's basically in kind of a love triangle between the devil, who's kind of her true love, and this man that she meets, a rock star that she meets, named Anzic. So there is kind of like this romance and like sexiness to it that I think is very appealing to people.
[8:53] Robert Bannon: Bells are ringing. It's exciting because of the excitement of the—all of the—I've tried to mute it, Carrie, in time and missed it. So I thought when you see that this show is appealing to different age groups, different genres, different whatever, who do you hope comes and buys the tickets? Who did you write this show for? Besides every human being with money and the time and the energy and the access to go to New York City. But who is it—a date show? Should I take my significant other? Should I bring, you know, my best friend? Should it be a girls' night out? Who should come check this show out?
[9:24] Carey Sharpe: I mean, honestly, I think that one of the things that's great about the show is it does have wide appeal. Um, I mean, I wrote it kind of for somebody like myself, right? You know, kind of middle-aged woman. I mean, the protagonist is kind of having her own version of a midlife crisis. So I think that that resonates with women my age, certainly.
[9:42] Carey Sharpe: But I mean, I really think that there's something for everyone. I mean, my kids come to the show and they're seven and ten and they love it. It's I say it's PG 13, it's not PG, but it's PG 13. So it is certainly appropriate for older kids, and you know, my kids have no problem with it. So I think really, I mean, my parents love it and they're in their 70s. I mean, they're biased, of course, because they're my parents. But I, you know, I really I think that it has a wide appeal. And we did that on purpose because we want it to feel inclusive. We don't want it to feel like so niche that only a certain type of person is drawn to it. Now, what I will say is if you are a very, very strict like theater traditionalist, this definitely breaks some of those boundaries. So you have to come in with an open mind that we are trying to create something new here. Um, but I think we've done it very successfully.
[10:30] Robert Bannon: What does that mean? How do you just without giving it away? What kind of boundaries did you try to break?
[10:36] Carey Sharpe: I love that. So break them all, Carrie. Break them all and rebuild them. What did you do that goes against the grain, so to speak?
[10:41] Carey Sharpe: Well, one thing is we're 80-something minutes. It's a one-act show. That has been something that's been really important to me. I love theater, but like almost universally, these shows are too long. It just becomes a really, really long night. You know, I like taking my daughter, but like sometimes we won't get out until after 10 o'clock, and it's just too late, you know. So we wanted to create something that was like a little bit more just like pun intended, you know, just one bite of a show, and we also build momentum in the show in a way that would be very interrupted if you had an intermission. So, you know, we broke that boundary for sure. Um, and I think we actually successfully tell the tale within that time frame.
I don't know what our current runtime is up. It's like 80 something minutes. We're trying to keep it at 90 minutes most, but I think it's a little under that. Um, but then again, like you know, it's almost entirely sung through, which you don't see a ton of these days, um, which means that you have to get a lot, you have to get a lot of the storyline by really listening to the lyrics, and the lyrics are complex, they are poetic, they are not just we're not spoon feeding the plot really. Um, so we did things like we have a printed libretto, so everybody that comes to the show can read all of the text, including kind of a plot synopsis that kind of helps you understand. You know, like when you go to the ballet and they sort of give you a little idea of what's going on, so even though there are no words, you can follow along.
We kind of are giving a little bit of that just to make sure that you know there's multiple ways to understand what's going on, and then even just like the set and the staging, and you know, that's all very modern, and like I said, it kind of feels like a music video. There's not a lot of literalism anywhere. We're trying to make the whole thing kind of feel surreal.
[12:20] Robert Bannon: I'm excited. Look, I remember going to Les Mis at 12 years old and reading the libretto and having the insert to help me follow along the story. I still didn't understand the story, but I loved the music and you loved the storytelling. And this story I'm sure is not you're being very kind. It's gonna be easy and breezy to understand you're gonna love it. You're not even gonna need the libretto. You're gonna fall in love with the characters and the story.
[12:41] Carey Sharpe: No, it's true, yeah. You know, I have ADHD bad I can't sit to an hour and a half show no more. I don't wanna go to the movies that's two and a half, three hours long. I mean give me 90 minutes, no intermission, and let me go home.
[12:52] Robert Bannon: Carrie, are you me? You are the same age. You're born in 1983?
[12:57] Carey Sharpe: I am, yeah, yeah so I'm a Halloween 83 baby.
[13:01] Robert Bannon: So of a certain age when Carrie said she is midlife I am gonna fight you.
[13:08] Carey Sharpe: We are just getting started.
[13:13] Robert Bannon: I don't debate that at all. But the beginning.
[13:16] Carey Sharpe: Yeah, but you do reevaluate your life at a certain point. And as I think I probably told you this when we talked a while ago but I had a complete career shift and have found myself now back in music which is really delightful and kind of a surprise I didn't really anticipate that I would end up here. But um, you know it was at that point kind of that I was like I something is missing and I need to do something different and I've really found that for myself here in particular in New York I really feel at home in this community and all the wonderful people that are involved in this production like I just that's where it feels very surreal. Like it feels um yeah it's just very special to be able to be to do this after maybe thinking when I was younger that I never could.
[13:51] Robert Bannon: Bloodlove.com you what she's talking about, everyone. If you didn't see our past interview, which is still up, and you can still check out and see, is that Carrie comes from a whole other world where she was a pediatric nurse practitioner.
[14:10] Carey Sharpe: Yeah.
[14:10] Robert Bannon: And you were very honest and open about your own health struggles and your own things that you've gone through that made you be inspired to be that, but you also fell in love with music. And why I love Carrie is because I teach I'm a school teacher who also fell in love with music and gave up my music ideas to go into teaching elementary school and middle school and then come back to this at our early middle age.
[14:31] Carey Sharpe: I'll say early middle age.
[14:32] Robert Bannon: Yes. That's fair.
[14:33] Carey Sharpe: That's fair.
[14:35] Robert Bannon: It has to be surreal for you to think that just a few years ago you were working in this nine to five, the regular kind of life, and now you have a show that's opening on 42nd Street in New York City. Do you give yourself time to process that?
[14:48] Carey Sharpe: Yeah, I mean, I do. I've I know that's I miss my old career too. That's something that I had to mourn the loss of something that I really loved. Um, and that took a lot of time to be able to kind of I guess move on. But um, so now at this point, I've you know it's it's really fun that I've come this far, and it feels like I made the right choice because it was hard at the time to give up something that I'd worked really hard at. You know, I had spent many, many years getting to that point that I was at. So yeah, it's but you know, that's what life is it just has all these twists and turns, and that's kind of a way that I relate to my character, Valerie. And um, she's lived all these lives over a thousand years, she's been all these things, she's had probably every career under the sun, everything she wanted to do, she's been able to do, and like that's such a beauty about life.
Like you can gear shift if you want to. Um, and many people do, and I think that's really cool. And I mean, I I think it was brave of me to like just do something. It was hard. Um, and it's still hard, but uh, you know, I think that's something that can resonate with people that see the show too.
[15:49] Robert Bannon: It's the bravest, most inspirational thing that you were able to put away the schooling and the time and the steady paycheck to take a risk and a chance to make something, and I want to let you know that it worked and you're gonna inspire a whole generation of people when they hear your story to maybe dream bigger and take a risk and take a chance. And look, your nursing license will always be there.
[16:09] Carey Sharpe: You can, you know.
[16:09] Carey Sharpe: I do keep it I do keep it um up to date. I do I still have it.
[16:14] Robert Bannon: Well, actually. We're obsessed with vampires in my house. Maybe it's because I'm a Halloween baby, but you know, we love a vampire story. We love the idea of living forever and being vain and we're gay, Carrie. We want to be young, hot forever.
[16:25] Carey Sharpe: So we all do.
[16:29] Robert Bannon: Everybody does. We are excited for this new original, unique, no shade to Broadway and theater out here, but we've seen all the movies made into musicals, we've seen all the books made into music. It's time for original work, original music, and original stories to be told on stage, and that's exactly what Blood/Love is going to be. You need to get a ticket, find your date, find your friends, get a ticket and head on down to see the show. You can get tickets, you have an interesting run. Your times are interesting. You have the ability to see shows sometimes when there are no shows to see. So there's availability for you to be make sure you can head over to the theater and see a show.
[17:04] Carey Sharpe: So the show's up, you haven't put it on the stage. How's it felt to just be able to have an audience that has been able to see the full production?
[17:12] Carey Sharpe: Oh, it's really fun because and we're still in previews right now, and I am after this I'm heading over to the theater for four hours of tech before we have our show tonight. And I already know today we're making some big changes again, and that's great. You know, everything, every change we've made has been good, you know, like it's in the right direction. But you know, doing that every day and then performing at night, often with some pretty big swings in changing material, that has been exercise for me and learning how to learn real fast, you know. And I think I've been doing a pretty good job, but that's um it is it's tough. So I'm looking forward to when the show is locked and we can just really start to settle into what we've you know ended up with and um yeah really feel how the audience is responding to it is very rewarding.
[17:55] Robert Bannon: Well you can see shows Sundays at five o'clock and you can see shows on Monday when other theaters dark at seven o'clock so if you have nothing to do on a Monday you have the Monday blues you have the perfect opportunity to go check out this brand new show bloodlove.com Carrie congratulations when I see you I want you to check my blood pressure and then you know just make give me a little physical backstage.
[17:55] Carey Sharpe: I can do that and done done and done congratulations I'm so excited when I saw this press release and all the work that you've done I can't tell you how much joy it's given me that you've taken this leap and risk and given the world this art and that the show is up and out and I hope you know that you're giving so much joy and excitement to so many people congratulations.
[17:55] Carey Sharpe: Thank you yeah we feel it in our cast too everybody's just really happy and it's it's such a wonderful thing to be part of like a group of people that are just it's just filled with joy and love and that is really the most special part of it I think.
[18:49] Robert Bannon: Let's go go get your tickets every what are you doing? You have nothing to do go get your tickets right now.
[18:54] Carey Sharpe: Yeah it's cold out come come sit in the theater and watch a good show.
[18:57] Robert Bannon: That's it. Congratulations and I'll see you soon.
[18:59] Carey Sharpe: Oh you'll have something else up your sleeve you're gonna just you just got started Carrie 40 is the new 20.
[19:04] Carey Sharpe: Oh totally I still feel like I'm 20.
[19:07] Carey Sharpe: I really do so we look good.
[19:10] Carey Sharpe: Yeah I mean I'm a vampire so you know I'm gonna look like this is a lot of pressure. I will say that that.
[19:16] Robert Bannon: That's a lot of pressure. I'm like, oh no.
[19:18] Carey Sharpe: Congratulations.
[19:19] Carey Sharpe: Thank you so much for being here.
[19:21] Carey Sharpe: Thank you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
