Director Caitlin Sullivan is here to talk about Calf Scramble, the darkly funny and deeply original new play by Libby Carr now making noise Off-Broadway with Primary Stages at 59E59 Theaters... Read More
From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon
About
Director Caitlin Sullivan is here to talk about Calf Scramble, the darkly funny and deeply original new play by Libby Carr now making noise Off-Broadway with Primary Stages at 59E59 Theaters. Set in an East Texas barn, the play follows five teenage girls as they raise calves and wrestle with faith, competition, survival, and what it really means to grow up. With its bold world, sharp humor, and emotional bite, Calf Scramble has quickly become one of the most intriguing new works on the New York stage.
In this conversation, Caitlin joins Robert Bannon to talk about building the world of this fierce new production, guiding a cast through its raw and layered storytelling, and what makes Calf Scramble such a powerful theatrical experience. It is a chat about collaboration, new work, and the kind of storytelling that stays with you long after the lights go down.
The Roundtable with Robert Bannon is available on BroadwayWorld, YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, iHeart, and more. Follow Robert at RobertBannon.com and on Instagram @RobertMBannon.
#CaitlinSullivan #CalfScramble #LibbyCarr #PrimaryStages #59E59 #OffBroadway #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon #RobertBannon #BroadwayWorld
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Robert Bannon: Are you ready?
[0:06] Robert Bannon: It's the round table with me, Robert Bannon.
[0:09] Robert Bannon: Well, welcome to the round table, everybody.
[0:11] Robert Bannon: My name is Robert Bannon.
[0:12] Robert Bannon: You're listening to this on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeart and Spotify.
[0:16] Robert Bannon: The ball, the boss of this production is here, everybody, the director, the one in charge.
[0:21] Robert Bannon: I love this theater.
[0:23] Robert Bannon: Let me just give you a little background here.
[0:25] Robert Bannon: Our next guest, Antiquities was a monster at Playwright.
[0:30] Robert Bannon: Like you, you talk about how brilliant the show was.
[0:33] Robert Bannon: You talk about what she has done.
[0:36] Robert Bannon: A theater maker, a director, somebody who knows a lot more about Megan Theater than I do.
[0:43] Robert Bannon: And I'm so excited to welcome her here because there's a show that I need you to know about and check out, but that is going to be running at 59 East 59 Theaters till April 12th.
[0:54] Robert Bannon: I think I kind of said it right.
[0:56] Caitlin Sullivan: I think you did.
[0:57] Robert Bannon: I think you saw primary stages at 5959.
[1:00] Caitlin Sullivan: Yes.
[1:01] Robert Bannon: Let's go.
[1:02] Robert Bannon: Calf Scramble is out and about and Caitlin is here.
[1:05] Robert Bannon: Caitlin Sullivan, welcome to the show.
[1:07] Caitlin Sullivan: Oh, thank you so much.
[1:08] Robert Bannon: Does it scare you when people think of you as the boss?
[1:11] Caitlin Sullivan: Are you the boss?
[1:12] Caitlin Sullivan: Like do you—
[1:13] Caitlin Sullivan: Oh god.
[1:16] Caitlin Sullivan: I don't think of myself as the boss, although I am very bossy.
[1:20] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, so yeah, no, it's my job, and I like I take it seriously, and I think it is like a privilege to get to lead a room.
[1:33] Caitlin Sullivan: And so um, it doesn't scare me, but I do think of it as like a big responsibility.
[1:38] Robert Bannon: Got it.
[1:39] Robert Bannon: So at what point did you always want to be a director, or did you want to be an artist, an actor, a doctor, I don't know, a foot surgeon?
[1:46] Caitlin Sullivan: What did you want to be?
[1:48] Caitlin Sullivan: I no, I'm just—I'm like a bossy oldest child.
[1:51] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, I thought that I was gonna be um, my parents were community organizers.
[1:58] Caitlin Sullivan: And then my uh father like went into politics and then nonprofit work and my um mom worked in education.
[2:07] Caitlin Sullivan: So I thought I was gonna do something like that.
[2:09] Caitlin Sullivan: Like I did not think of theater as like a job that grown-ups had.
[2:15] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, I started doing theater.
[2:17] Caitlin Sullivan: I grew up in Boston, and I—the my first um exposure to theater was like doing plays at my Boston Public Elementary School.
[2:25] Caitlin Sullivan: And that was kind of, I always did a little bit of theater growing up, but it was like one of many things I did.
[2:32] Caitlin Sullivan: I really loved it, but it was very much, I was not on a professional theater path.
[2:38] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, and so I think of myself as having come to directing very late, although I did kind of, I directed my first show, my senior year of college.
[2:50] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, and I was going to college, I was studying um political science, um, and then also was taking so many theater classes that it just made sense for me to do a theater political science double major.
[3:02] Caitlin Sullivan: And then I started making work while I was in college and undergrad with some of some other um fellow students, my friends.
[3:11] Caitlin Sullivan: We started making plays together and um got exposed to some other um of the kind of like what I would consider like the great ensemble theater companies of the 90s and the 2000s, you know, um Pig Iron and the Rude Mechanicals and um City Company and team, and was really like inspired by that work and um started wanting to make my own work.
[3:34] Caitlin Sullivan: So it was only when I started like making things with my peers that I thought, oh, maybe I'll—I could do this.
[3:41] Caitlin Sullivan: And I—that's basically what I pursued.
[3:43] Caitlin Sullivan: First, I pursued making things with my friends.
[3:46] Caitlin Sullivan: And then that kind of made its way into a directing career.
[3:53] Caitlin Sullivan: But yeah, I never in—well I say I never envisioned myself as a director but I also like as a child would—I was really obsessed with Peter Pan like the original Mary Martin original cast album.
[4:07] Caitlin Sullivan: And I would often play that album and then I'm the oldest of four make all of my siblings and neighbors like act it out.
[4:17] Caitlin Sullivan: So I like both—both have always been a director but like really did not think of myself one as one until much later.
[4:25] Robert Bannon: You've been a director then forever.
[4:27] Caitlin Sullivan: That's what I think, forever.
[4:28] Caitlin Sullivan: Yeah, I've made a—I’ve made a lot of directors mad in my musical theater—no, I'm kidding.
[4:40] Robert Bannon: I love your story about being a political science—I just had a conversation with the cast and Julia that's on tour and they were talking about a lot of them were poly sign majors and I was a poly sign major.
[4:49] Caitlin Sullivan: No way.
[4:50] Robert Bannon: And I said I left musical theater school to be a poly sign major because I thought showbiz and politics is the same kind of—I completely agree.
[4:50] Caitlin Sullivan: And I, you know, I did—I still think of myself as an organizer although I certainly not professionally and I certainly—I say that with great humility.
[5:11] Caitlin Sullivan: I know like real incredible community organizers, but I do do some organizing and I started doing that in high school and um I would say when I first started directing, I often say I was a better producer than a director first.
[5:25] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, and really I was a better organizer than I was a director first.
[5:29] Caitlin Sullivan: Like the thing about directing that I understood first, even though I was very insecure, I don't, you know, I have a liberal arts theater degree.
[5:37] Caitlin Sullivan: I did not go to conservatory, I did not go to grad school.
[5:40] Caitlin Sullivan: Like for a long time I felt like, oh, I don't know anything about how to do this technically.
[5:45] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, but I did understand like how to get a group of people into a room and get them to kind of like coalesce around the same being in pursuit of the same objective or goal.
[5:59] Caitlin Sullivan: And um that based—that is directing.
[6:02] Caitlin Sullivan: And yeah, I think like political science is really just about like how do people go figure out what they want?
[6:11] Caitlin Sullivan: How does the community figure out what's good for them, you know, or we wish that was what it was about?
[6:15] Caitlin Sullivan: And so yeah, I think there are so many, there are so many overlaps, and that's so cool that the cast of Anne Julia is all political science majors.
[6:24] Caitlin Sullivan: I love it.
[6:25] Robert Bannon: So tell me, I love it too.
[6:27] Robert Bannon: Tell me about this particular show because you talk about politics.
[6:30] Robert Bannon: So the what's the calf scramble, from what I understand, is your five teenage girls in Texas raising cattle.
[6:39] Robert Bannon: Now, when I read this originally, I think this show is being put up in New York City in a very divisive time.
[6:46] Caitlin Sullivan: Yeah.
[6:47] Robert Bannon: And when I see things like religion and I see queer romance in a conservative state and limited circumstances, I think there's a group of people that us in New York don't give credit to that exist because the whole state of Texas is not out here trumping it up for lack of a better word.
[7:10] Caitlin Sullivan: I—there are people there that have experiences and they have stories to tell.
[7:13] Robert Bannon: So why did this speak when you read this?
[7:15] Robert Bannon: Did you think, oh God, I'm not doing cattle girls in Texas plays?
[7:19] Robert Bannon: What led you to this?
[7:21] Caitlin Sullivan: Yeah, no, um, when I read it, I was obsessed with it.
[7:24] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, I—so the playwright is um Libby Carr.
[7:28] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, and they are uh just an incredible writer, and they are also um—they come from a dance background.
[7:38] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, they grew up in Texas in Houston.
[7:41] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, and the play, as you say, is about um five teen girls in Texas who are part of Future Farmers of America.
[7:51] Caitlin Sullivan: And um, the play begins with a this event that I was not familiar with, um, but um is a like a common event at many rodeos, and in our show, it's at the the Houston um livestock show called a calf scramble, in which um they release a bunch of calves into the arena, teens chase after them, they tackle these calves, they drag them across a line.
[8:17] Caitlin Sullivan: And if you get a calf, then um it goes a few different ways.
[8:22] Caitlin Sullivan: In our show, you then get to raise that calf.
[8:24] Caitlin Sullivan: Sometimes you get an amount of prize money that is um equal to the calf.
[8:29] Caitlin Sullivan: And so it is a way that um, I mean, like everything, uh future farmers in America has a huge economic component, and there's like rich FFA and FFA that is not as sponsored.
[8:42] Caitlin Sullivan: And so this allows you to raise um a cow to compete in future shows to win more prize money.
[8:51] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, so already, like that, I mean, right, you can't you can't not want to know more about that.
[8:57] Caitlin Sullivan: And when you watch these videos of the real calf scrambles, they're like truly, it's like gladiators.
[9:02] Caitlin Sullivan: It's like teen gladiators in uh in a huge arena, you know.
[9:06] Caitlin Sullivan: They're—they're um grabbing these calves where the Texans play.
[9:09] Caitlin Sullivan: It's like unbelievable.
[9:11] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, but what really hooked me about the script is that Libby, the core concept that is you know written into the the work is that the five actors will each play one of the girls and one of the calves.
[9:28] Caitlin Sullivan: And so the whole play is them wrangling each other, these teens, like actually literally physically wrangling each other's bodies.
[9:40] Caitlin Sullivan: And um, you know, when I when I first when Aaron Daly from Primary Stages reached out to me and asked me if I might be interested in this project, I it was coming up in a really tight window for me.
[9:51] Caitlin Sullivan: And so I kind of gave myself a little talking to beforehand, and I said, Oh, Caitlin, you have to love it or you can't take this meeting.
[9:58] Caitlin Sullivan: And I read the play, and I just felt like I, you know, I've said this a couple of times that you know, part of me was like, how does one stage this?
[10:06] Caitlin Sullivan: And the other part of me felt like I have to do it, I have to stage this, even though I have no idea how you're gonna—how I'm gonna do that.
[10:14] Caitlin Sullivan: And I think part of it was I found that conceit to make so much, yes, it makes a great metaphoric sense, and Libby is very smart and has threaded all of these things through the show, big macro um sociopolitical themes, but also like real kind of micro character-based things are really threaded throughout.
[10:37] Caitlin Sullivan: Um, but there was actually there, there was a deep emotional um sense that the play and the idea of the play made to me.
[10:47] Caitlin Sullivan: And it really, I felt like, oh, um it this rings against my own experience of being a teen girl, which you know, Libby and I were doing another conversation about the play, and they used the word baffling. And I was like, yes, baffling. That is how I found being a teenage girl. It was baffling to me. And um I I think the play, just the central conceit of the play kind of captures so much about that experience that is that is beyond words, really. I'm baffled because I a calf scramble, that's a real thing. It's a real, it's a real thing. It's a real thing. And these kids are, I mean, they're athletes. It's um it's unbelievable. U calf scramble is a real thing. Um, and there is so much, there's so much great content out there, FFA content in general.
Um, you know, Facebook pages and TikToks and Instagram, you can watch, you know, just kids all over the country who are like very engaged, not only who participated in the calf scrambles, um, but who are also very engaged in like raising livestock, um, both as like a passion as a career, but also as a kind of like educational extracurricular pursuit. And um this, it's it's really amazing. And so, you know, I realize I steered so far away from your question about about Texas and tackling a show about Texas. And I will say, one, like I I have a lot of friends from Texas. Um, and so I think in general, I I I just know from the people I know that there are all kinds of people from Texas. You know, there's a great arts high school in Houston.
And so I meet a lot of people. I think that's a great feeder into like theater programs all over the place, and just in general, I just happen to have a lot of friends from Texas. But you know, I'm also so there is that. I was like, I know there is more to this place than than we might imagine in popular culture. And I can see it just from Libby, you know, who is a queer person from Texas, like has handed it to me here. But I will also say, you know, I grew up in Boston, and um Boston is a place that can live large in cultural imagination, and I often feel um the stories that people tell about Boston to be only somewhat representative of the place that I grew up. Um and you know, um people might say that that um Boston is racist and homophobic and small minded.
And let me tell you, it can be, yes. Um, like all places, like this country, but it's also there's um there's just so much more to that place than I see represented, good and bad, than I see represented in kind of popular culture. So I think I kind of come at things with the perspective that like most places are more complicated than we perceive them to be.
[14:05] Robert Bannon: Look, I'm from Jersey, so I like I get it. And now my husband's from my husband's from Detroit, and people have a lot of things to say.
[14:12] Caitlin Sullivan: And I'm from Detroit, yeah. In the other way. So, so you know, like so we all, it's what's fascinating about art and telling stories is that we all get to learn about it something we've never I'll never forget what a calf scramble is in my life.
[14:24] Robert Bannon: Yeah. Tell me about the ladies and the and the actors and the people that are a part of this show, your cast.
[14:30] Caitlin Sullivan: My cast is amazing. Um my cast is amazing. So I felt pretty certain that I wanted a cast that that felt young, you know. Um, and that is, you know, there's there's kind of an incredible canon of of plays about um teenage girls. Um, and there are, and I've I've worked on some of those plays too. A few years ago, um Tileen Monahan and I did a play called The Good John Proctor, which is kind of a prequel to the crucible. And it has um in that play, Tilene has kind of um aged the girls in the crucible down to the ages they actually were nine and eleven and 14 and 17, and and written about what she thinks might have led to the events of the crucible. And so in that play, that play, which is in some ways a memory play, in some ways a reflection on childhood, in some ways about being an adult and trying to figure out what happened um and what your child body knew and felt.
Um, Tilene is really clear that like these children will be plays by adults and that there can be a real variety of casting. And so for that play, we we cast like young looking adults and who really could embody children. Charlene Cruz, uh the most believable nine-year-old you've ever seen, but but an adult playing a nine-year-old. And for this play, and that really worked for that play, and for this play, there was something about the way Libby has written these teens. As I always say, they're kind of like all back of the brain. They're all moving from the lizard brain. They're like impulse first, and everything else is catching up. And that was so clear to me on the page that I really wanted actors who had a direct connection to that sensibility.
And I had a hunch that those would probably be actors who are closer to that experience. So our cast, I would say is young, both in age, but also, I won't say in in life experience, but in professional experience. Four out of the five actors in our cast are making their off-Broadway debuts. And it's also Libby's professional debut. And I think that energy of people who are doing this for the first time feels like a really important part of the show, honestly. They are also extraordinarily hardworking, incredibly rigorous, very curious. They really know themselves as artists and as people. It begins with a massive physical set piece, it ends with a massive physical set piece. And in between, they are, you know, working in this barn.
They are coming in and out of Cow Body and doing these like really complex emotional scenes. And um they just ran at it kind of fullheartedly and fearlessly. And I really can't imagine having done it with anyone else. I'm like completely obsessed with this cast. I think everyone should go see them. Um, you're gonna be seeing these people on stages for like years and years to come. You want to say you saw them first. It is like it's it's a really they're giving really special performances.
[18:17] Robert Bannon: Oh, you gotta get a ticket, people. If this isn't get you to get a ticket, primary stages.org. You look you only have till April 12th, so you gotta get a ticket.
[18:24] Caitlin Sullivan: Yeah, you gotta go now. And look, you can't see five five cows and five rodeo or I don't know the word, but they're they're they're part of FFA. They're they're 60 bucks.
[18:35] Robert Bannon: Yeah, tickets start at 60 something. Like they're not, you know, this is you don't have to mortgage your house to come see good original new work and theater.
[18:43] Caitlin Sullivan: So you're on working on something else already.
[18:46] Robert Bannon: I am, yeah. Um, welcome to uh company artist housing at um South Coast Rep.
[18:52] Caitlin Sullivan: Yes, I'm actually um I'm here in Costa Mesa at South Coast Rep with um Tileen Monahan, actually, who I did the John Proctor with and who had an amazing um play, Meet the Cartosians this fall at second stage. Um, an extraordinary play. She's an extraordinary playwright and a dear friend, and we are working on her next world premiere, which is a play called Eat Me. Um, that is um going to be where we are starting our third week of rehearsal here, and it is um gonna be running at South Coast Rep in Orange County, and it'll also be part of the uh 2026 Pacific Playwrights Festival, which is an amazing new works festival that South Coast Rep does where they run two world premiere productions, but then readings of a bunch of new plays as well. So look up if you're in if you're in Southern California, if you're in California, you're gonna be out there, then you need to check that out as well.
[19:46] Robert Bannon: Yes, easy drive down from LA, up from San Diego, come on through. Or if you just like love new plays, there are only so many of these new play festivals left. So first week in a May, come see a bunch of new work.
[19:59] Caitlin Sullivan: I'm excited for you. The best is yet to come. I'm excited for what's next. I'm excited what what the road takes for you. We'll be following and sharing. And if you want more information about Caitlin Sullivan, her website is below as well. And all of the updates and information will be on the links below. Just click there, get your tickets to see all of this fun, incredible stuff. I'm so you taught me so much today about a lot of things.
[20:21] Caitlin Sullivan: Thank you. I'm gonna have to Google some calf scrambles.
[20:24] Robert Bannon: I mean, I'm telling you, you will go down such a you do well, you know, our our our whole team, some people, a lot of our team is from Texas. So a lot of people were really familiar with this, but those of us who weren't, like we all spent a lot of time uh watching these videos. It's it's incredible stuff. See the play, but also these it's you know, how have a have a time on YouTube? It's really fun. Primary stages go to go to primaries and support primary stages in all of these theater organizations that are putting up new original works. It's so important. It's more important than ever, truly. Primary stages.org.
[20:57] Caitlin Sullivan: Thank you so much.
[20:58] Robert Bannon: Break leading. Thank you so much, Robert. This was such a treat.
[21:01] Caitlin Sullivan: Back at you anytime.
[21:02] Robert Bannon: Anytime come on back.
[21:03] Caitlin Sullivan: I will I will anytime.
[21:05] Robert Bannon: Done, done. Thank you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
