Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep. 149- Rupert Holmes, The Tony Winning Songwriter, Talks RBG, Writing Books, & Pina Coladas!

We love Rupert Holmes. He has inspired us to keep going and keep working! Rarely, if ever, will you find someone with a Best Selling Novel on the NY Times Best Sellers List, a new show about "RBG" set to go on tour, Tony Awards, Platnium Selling albums, TV shows, and more going on at the same time, but then again that is Rupert Holmes!.. Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

34 mins
3/9/24

About

We love Rupert Holmes. He has inspired us to keep going and keep working! Rarely, if ever, will you find someone with a Best Selling Novel on the NY Times Best Sellers List, a new show about "RBG" set to go on tour, Tony Awards, Platnium Selling albums, TV shows, and more going on at the same time, but then again that is Rupert Holmes!

We have a great deep chat about his connection to Ruth Bader Ginsberg and what moved him to write his new show on tour, how that Pina Colada song came to be, and how he manages to literally do it all! This is a chat not to be missed!

Make sure to catch "RBG" on the road and if you are having a rough day, just stream some Rupert and I promise you, a smile will be on that face! Cheers to getting "caught in the rain!"

_______________________________________________

Check out “The Roundtable with Robert Bannon” everyday right here on The Broadway Podcast Network!

www.RobertBannon.com

Follow on IG @RobertMBannon or @theroundtablewithrobertbannon

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Robert Bannon: Are you ready? It's the round table with me, Robert Bannon.

[0:15] Robert Bannon: Well, ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the round table. My name is Robert Bannon, and I'm so excited you're listening to us on the Broadway Podcast Network or you're watching us on our virtual talk show. I have really, let me tell you, I've been in a lucky position to do this show 300 times, and very rarely does someone come on that I can very succinctly remember being a very important part of my life. I remember the album. I remember the words because my father has been in love with this album and the Pina Colada song, Escape the Pina Colada song by Rupert Holmes since I was born. I'm born in 1983, so I can literally remember growing up. And then we went and saw all of Rupert Holmes' musicals.

We saw Curtains, we saw The Mystery of Edwin Drood, we've seen them all. He has a book on the New York Times bestsellers list. He has a song that Barry Manilow recorded that I will resing the entire song, even every single word to Studio Musician. And we're gonna talk about Ruth Bader Ginsberg. I don't think Rupert Holmes sleeps. Rupert Holmes is here. Welcome to the show.

[1:21] Rupert Holmes: This is my equivalent of sleep, Robert. I have a way of doing interviews and also sleeping at the same time, as you'll tell when I don't actually respond directly to any question, but just give you pre-recorded answers.

[1:34] Robert Bannon: Well, Rupert, I don't mean to consult you, but you would not be the first Tony winner that I would have put to sleep in an interview. So I am so excited. Last night we were, we were, what is it, it is Valentine's Day. We are up and putting this up on Valentine's Day because you've written a love song or two in your day. And I came home and I have had the chance to talk to such amazing people, and I saw my father for Super Bowl Sunday, and I said, "You'll never guess who I'm gonna see. I'm going to see Rupert Holmes." And he instantly sings the song because the song is, and your body of work and all the albums that any it have been a part of many people's lives. And we recall the moment when we hear them or a love that we shared the song, et cetera. What is it like when people come up to you and all these years your music means so much to them?

[2:22] Rupert Holmes: It's amazing. First of all, your father owes me six cents royalties for when he did that unlicensed, and he can mail them to me in pennies, we take pennies, okay? It's an amazing thing. Robert, seriously, the wonderful thing about the fact that the song has been just around so long. I mean, it was, I wrote it one night three years before you were born. And it's still, and people still know it. So the way I have come to view it, because you know, it's not maybe my proudest achievement, it's a three-minute ditty, but people like it. And what I love about the song now for me is that when people hear it or I sing it, they smile. And I know one of the reasons they're smiling is because they're remembering some time in their life, some experience when they either maybe the first time they heard it, a vacation they were on, someone, and it's as if I'm a bookmark in the lives of people, millions of people I've never met.

[3:35] Rupert Holmes: There's the album, Partners in Crime, and it was one of the last cuts I did for the album. I wrote it at the very last minute, wrote the lyric at 1 a.m. the night before I recorded it. And by the way, the lyric originally went the morning I went to record it, it was going to go, "If you like Humphrey Bogart and getting caught in the rain." And at the very last minute, as I was about to sing the song on mic, I thought, that's not the right, Humphrey Bogart is not the right metaphor for these people in this song. They want an escape. They want something exotic, they want something new, like they're on vacation. And I thought, well, when you're on vacation, how do you sing? Well, you order a drink.

The first day you're in the islands, you order a drink. You're never gonna order a beer. You're gonna order something that announces to the world that you're on vacation. I thought, what are the vacation drinks? I thought, Daiquiri, Mai Tai, Pina Colada. I thought, if you like Humphrey Bogart, no, if you like Pina Colada, and I said, that actually works better. And thus I and the pineapple industry were forever intertwined.

[4:46] Rupert Holmes: But your father brought you up well if he played that song for you. That's a fine American upbringing. I think every child should be forced to listen to it every day and dream of the day when they too can drink a Pina Colada.

[5:01] Robert Bannon: And the Pina Colada industry, like you said, like the pineapple industry is so grateful to change those lyrics for sure.

[5:08] Rupert Holmes: I a hundred percent agree. And like you said, we at least owe you, I mean, in the years, at least you know, with streaming, maybe 15 or 16 cents now at this point. You do so many things. You are a songwriter, you are a performer, you are a playwright, you are an author. How do you departmentalize your life? Is it a day where you wake up and say today's an author day, today's a music day? Do you just do it as it comes? How do you schedule all of this?

[5:27] Rupert Holmes: It's deadline day. Each day is what is the thing that if I don't turn it in, someone will break my neck? Who is about to assault me if I don't give them the novel, short story, play, musical, TV episode, whatever it has to be that day? And what's interesting about it for me, Robert, doing so many different kinds of operating on so many different platforms over the years before we had the word platform, you know, is that each thing that I write, whether it's a novel or a play or what kind of a play it might be, a comedy thriller or in the case of Ruth Bader Ginsberg, our play All Things Equal, it's a biographical drama with a lot of comedy in it, by the way, and music. Each project has its own set of tools that are required to achieve it.

So I have to figure out what do I, as a storyteller in general, and what do I, as a composer and an arranger, need to bring to this assignment today? Writing a novel is a completely different experience from writing a musical. Writing a TV episode, it's a completely different audience that you're aiming for than a short story.

[7:06] Robert Bannon: Well, all of the projects are listed at RupertHolmes.com. So while we're here, you can go there and get all the information, all the albums, all the television, all the everything that is there.

[7:16] Rupert Holmes: And I'm there right now. As we speak, I'm there at RupertHolmes.com. And if you go there, I'll be there personally to greet you.

[7:23] Robert Bannon: Yes.

[7:23] Rupert Holmes: No.

[7:24] Rupert Holmes: There you go. And as you said, Ruth, the RBG, the RGB, the Ruth Bader Ginsberg, Ruth Bader Ginsberg, RBG.

[7:38] Robert Bannon: Right, thank you.

[7:40] Rupert Holmes: RBG. As I second guess myself, go to ScottStandard.com backslash RBG if you want all of the dates. It's the second leg of the tour. We love Scott. I love Scott and Scott and his wife and daughter and his whole family do such a great job with all of the work that they do. I read an article, an interview that you did where you said you got the idea that because you thought her legacy was becoming kind of a joke. You were seeing her...

[8:04] Rupert Holmes: Yeah, I, I, that's right. Perhaps joke is a little harsh, but she was very quickly, shortly after she left us after so many dedicated years and so many valiant years fighting cancer, successfully for many decades. So she gives us all hope in that department. Within days, I thought, you know, she's becoming a meme. She's becoming this notorious RBG, a feisty old lady. And I thought before she becomes, I think the thing that came to my mind was Granny from Beverly Hillbillies. You know, we don't, this was an amazing woman who accomplished historic stages of progress at a time when the world was completely tilted against her, and who was a voice for reason and human rights at a time when such voices were being drowned out.

And she is as memorable for her dissents and the power of her dissents as she is for her many victories. And I thought, let me make sure that people know this human being because, you know, we have lots of movies featuring superheroes. Seems like every other movie you go to the film movie theater to see is a superhero movie. And that takes away a lot from real human beings who accomplish superhuman tasks against overwhelming odds. Those are the superheroes we really need to pay more attention to because they're real and they're something we can aspire to be. We're not gonna be Green Lantern. I've tried, God knows. But we can learn from a real human being who took on the world and said, I'm going to change things not only for myself, but for women to come. I'm going to live the dream that my mother was never allowed to live.

[10:13] Rupert Holmes: And that's what she did, Ruth Bader Ginsberg. Her mother was a parallel to her own life, except that her mother had to give up any hope of ever going to college, even though she was a brilliant woman and was able to leave high school in her mid-teens. That just wasn't done in those days. And Ruth was the one who went to college. She not only did that, but went to Harvard while her husband was at Harvard, and the Dean of Harvard turned to her and he threw a party for all the women attending Harvard Law School. It must have been a huge party because there were nine women out of 500 students, nine women. And the dean of Harvard said to her, "How do you feel? How do you rationalize taking the place of a man who might be here learning?"

And she thought he was joking. She thought he was having a funny joke. And she laughed. And she looked and saw he was dead serious. And she said with that dry humor that she had, "Oh, well, my husband is also learning to be an attorney, and I thought I should study it too, so I can understand what his job is." When she graduated, Magnum cum laude from Harvard from Columbia Law School.

[11:26] Rupert Holmes: She could not get a job in any law firm in the United States. She couldn't get it. She couldn't even get a job as a clerk, as a judge's clerk. She said, because there were three things against her. She was a woman. She was Jewish, and probably amongst these three, the most difficult things, she was a mother. Because she attended Harvard and became an attorney there, got her education, her legal education there, while she was taking care of her husband, who had in his youth come down with cancer and was being treated for it in days when the treatments were pretty difficult. And also raising a daughter while you're attending Harvard, becoming a law review student, doing all that, an amazing achievement.

And with all that, she couldn't get a job as an attorney and had to become a teacher of law. And she came about getting into the law, into the profession that she wanted to practice in front of the benches of an almost entirely male court system, through her own strategies. She decided that the way she could fight for women's rights was by fighting for men's rights, places where men were denied rights that women had, special benefits that men were denied, but that women were allowed. And she thought by fighting for the men in those cases, she could then make the point, if she could win, of saying, and should it should also work the other way around, shouldn't it? That's all she wanted. She wanted all things equal. That's why I called the play that.

[14:00] Rupert Holmes: With someone who disagrees with you politically. And they would go to the opera and cherish Puccini and Verdi together. And one of the reasons I wanted to write All Things Equal was that I wanted us to be reminded that it is possible up until very recently, it was completely possible for people to respect divergent political beliefs and to not resort to terrible insults, name-calling, and just out and out lies. She was always civil, and she was always composed, and she wrote eloquently about the things she cared for and could acknowledge what was right, what she could agree with in other people's arguments. We don't have that on the landscape right now. And as the show tours the country, I'm hoping that it's reminding people that it doesn't have to be the way it is right now. It could be otherwise. We could get along.

[15:02] Robert Bannon: I don't think it could be said better. You know, watching documentaries about her being a political science major myself, I'm obsessed at the strategy, like you said, the strategy and the thought process, the foresight that she saw and the way to wiggle your way into it. I ended up, I left Juilliard at 18 because I was too scared of the musical theater world, and I went into the next best thing instead of showbiz, if you want to put on a show, which is politics. And I think sometimes you need, and then I'm back here, so there you go. But I think that there's something to be said about this, the brains, the smart, the foresight to see a way in relationships and work. How did you research this show so that you could be accurate? That must have been a lot of time to learn about her life and the inner workings of her world.

[15:48] Rupert Holmes: It was. I mainly, the part that was the most intriguing, most time-consuming, but so rewarding was to study all of her cases, all of her pleadings. Remember, she pled before the Supreme Court, as well as issuing opinions from the Supreme Court. So she knew what it was like that we bring to All Things Equal a lot of dramatic scenes, even though it's a one-actor show, there are lots of characters in it, and you hear their voices and you see the situations. And we have her first time standing in front of those that row of grumpy men who basically said, would you settle for us putting Susan B. Anthony on the dollar? Would that make you happy? How condescending. And she said, No, we don't accept tokens.

So the learning what her reasoning was, her seeing a room with no doors in it, and her trying to figure out how can I create a door out of this room, how can I create a ceiling that I can break through? What argument is there that the men that I come in before in the courtrooms that they will grasp from their own bias, and that and I'll say, ah, so I have you, you acknowledge A, so therefore shouldn't B be possible? So the way she took on cases and devised, I mean it makes Perry Mason look like a featherweight. She really could get to a problem and say, I know a way around this just as easily. It makes suits look like overalls.

[17:46] Rupert Holmes: Well, the show is touring across the country. It's got a big West Coast tour dates from literally the south everywhere. So when you go online where it is, if it's in a neighborhood in performing arts center, you're not just gonna get a history lesson and a biography of, you're gonna be thoroughly entertained throughout the whole thing. You are no stranger to writing shows about real life people. I mean, Goodnight Gracie ran for a long, long run, a beautiful run, and still is done around this world. How did the transition from pop singer-songwriter to sitcom writer to author to Broadway composer, Tony-winning musical writer? Like, how did that happen?

[18:34] Rupert Holmes: I don't know. I'm waiting to find out. I'm so looking forward to it. It's kind of exciting to think I have that on my horizon. No, you know, Robert, it's I always wanted to tell stories. In high school, I was faced with a dilemma, which was I was a trained classical musician in high school. By the way, my father was a Juilliard graduate. So you and he, I have the Pina Colada song in common with your father, and you have my the Juilliard, it's kind of classier association. I did end up going to the Manhattan School of Music, which is on a level with the Juilliard, and they honored me three years ago by giving me an honorary doctorate, which is the most stunning thing in the world. But I had this problem, which is I loved telling stories, especially if they could have humor or mystery in them.

And yet I loved music since I first knew what music was and wanted to write songs, maybe musicals, whatever, whatever I could compose. And I thought, how can I do that? How can I have my cake and eat it too? How can I be a writer telling stories? And how can I also get to write music? And I noticed that a couple of the songs that I really liked from the American songbook, classic songs, were told stories. They had little narratives embedded in them. They were narratives that sometimes might go a surprising place, and you ended up at the end of the song in a very different place than you were at the beginning.

[20:35] Rupert Holmes: Now guessing your computer has come back to life, I gather. There we go. There we go. That's good. Literally they could go taking over. That's okay. I'll pick up where I was. So sure. So I realized that there were songs that told stories that were somewhat different from songs about she's my girl or you're not my person. And I thought, well, if I could tell stories in songs, then I could be both a composer and a kind of mini novelist. Each song could be a movie, each song could be a short story. And I started writing songs that told stories. And eventually, a number of songs that of mine that ended up on the top 40 of Billboard were songs with plots. The one that hit the biggest was Escape, the Pina Colada song, which is not about Pina Coladas at all.

It's about a couple and it's got a twist ending that you hopefully the first time you hear it, don't guess before you get there. Eventually, Joe Papp came to me, and he was the legendary producer, as you know, of Chorus Line and so many and Shakespeare in the Park in New York City, and he saw me telling these stories in song form at Rodney Dangerfield's nightclub where I was headlined. And he said, you know, what you're doing up there is theater. Do you have you ever thought about writing a musical? Well, I had, and I had been thinking about it for some how many years? I'm doing the math now. For about 15 years, based on a book that is on those shelves right back there, written by Charles Dickens, an unfinished mystery novel.

I thought it would be an interesting idea to have the audience try and finish the mystery each night with a different possible murderer and different lovers, so that you could have multiple endings. You could see a show eight times in a row and see a different ending each day. That what would be what could be more theatrical?

[22:51] Rupert Holmes: So the next day I went to his office and pitched the idea to his wife, Gail Merrifield, and to Joe Papp himself, set out to write it, and he said, Who's gonna write the book, the script? You know, we of course you'll write the songs, but who will write the script, the dialogue, the plot. I said, Well, I thought I would. He said, Can you do that? I said, Well, I you know, I've been telling stories for 10 years now, and I have to get the story done in three minutes, and it all has to rhyme. So if I could write a story that doesn't have to rhyme, and I have two hours, an hour and a half to tell the story, that should be such a relief not to have to compress it into three minutes. So that was how I suddenly found myself being allowed to be a um the author, composer, lyricist, and orchestrator of a Broadway musical, which won the Tony Award for Best Musical.

That's sort of those Tony Awards that I won. I was the first person in theater history to win them. Well, you're pointing over my shoulder. Yeah, I was the first to win Tony's. Uh the first sole individual to win a Tony Award for both book and music and lyrics. And the musical itself, as I said, won a Tony. That gave me permission to write plays. I thought, well, um, now let me show people that I can write something that isn't a musical, that is a thriller. That one got me an Edgar Award from the Mystery Writers of America. Uh, that's their Oscar. And since then, I've basically been able to get the opportunity to write 56 episodes of a TV series called Remember When, um, nine Broadway shows, another 20 that have been in major venues all around the country.

And someone who, like your father, always liked my work on albums, said the same thing. When Joe Papp said to me, you know, have you ever thought about writing a musical? Well, he came to me and said, Um, I'm with a major publisher. Have you ever thought about writing a novel? I thought, yeah, there's time for that. Let me do that. That novel became a movie. Uh, it's called Where the Truth Lies. It became a movie with Colin Firth and Kevin Bacon. The next one, I went back to trying to work music into the act. I wrote a novel called Swing about a big band arranger who discovers a murder at the World's Fair of the Golden Gate International Exposition of 1940. And I decided that since there were so many musical references to big band songs that the band was playing, not real songs, but songs I sort of invented in my head, I would record a CD of that music and then close it with the novel.

So that was again me being a storyteller and me being a composer, in this case, also an arranger, coming together in one work. So my new novel that you see over my shoulder there, Murder Your Employer, which is the first in the series about the McMasters conservatory for the applied arts. Thank you for that lovely close-up. Um, that's been optioned by a wonderful set of producers, possibly to be a streaming TV series. And they've asked me if I would like to write the theme. So if I write the theme music, once again, I'm just I'm trying to get my cake and eat it too. Big big fan of cake.

[26:22] Robert Bannon: Yeah, me too. And you are a one man band. You do it all. And you know, we talked about, you know, you talk about um some of the shows, like you were telling, we're talking about the mystery of Edward Drew. We curtains was brilliant. We went we because you wrote it, we sat front row with the fam uh one Christmas Eve because that you know, we are fans of yours. And then your work, like you said, if you're writing sweet potato musicals with our friend Melissa Manchester, writing, you know, redoing Pirates of Penzance, which is gonna be coming back to Broadway next spring, spring 2025. And it's oh it's so exciting. And we've got David Hyde Pierce and Ramin Karamlu already cast in the two of the leads, and working with the fellow I most love to work with in theater, which is Scott Ellis, director, Roundabout Theater.

So buy your tickets now when they become available in about a year. Blow up all over. And then, you know, one of the greatest songwriters and orchestrators and composers is the late great Marvin Hamlisch, and then Nutty Professor lives on as well. I mean, Rupert, you don't, like I said, you don't, you must not sleep. But when you love what you do and it shows through with all of your work, um, it's so inspiring.

[27:38] Rupert Holmes: I'm the luckiest person in the world. I am the luckiest person in the world because um what I do for a living and have done for a living for it's I hate to say how many, it's over 50 years, easy. Um, I would do for free. And the big accomplishment of my career, Robert, has been to not let my employers know that I would do it for free. That's the hard part. Because basically, it's just such a thrill to work with those. I work with 12 notes and 26 letters, and I get to arrange them in different orders, and all these characters and all these storylines emerge. And I like to think that in my, for example, in All Things Equal, my play about Ruth Bader Ginsberg, I think that you can feel the fact that I love the characters that are on stage, that I appreciate them.

If I don't love them, then I can't ask the audience to. But the audiences for this, we just had a sellout run at the Colonial Theater in Boston. We're coming to the current theater in San Francisco, Balboa in San Diego. Sales are going nuts. And the audience from about, oh, I don't know, like 11 seconds from when the curtain goes up, they're with Ruth Bader Ginsberg. They're having this private coffee clutch with her. They're in her office, and she's telling them stuff about her life, and you become her ally, her champion, and her friend in the course of the evening. So I think the joy that I have in being with these people, the ones I invent, or the ones who are real that I get to put upon a stage, um, the joy of their company, I think is something that I hope comes back to the audience a little bit that they know that the author felt honored and delighted to be in their presence. Maybe some of that rubs off on them as well.

[29:44] Robert Bannon: I sure know it does, and I definitely know. Go to rupertholmes.com for all the updates. Get the book, stream the music. Murder Your Employer, out in paperback in May. On the New York Times Bestsellers list and all, and then RBG, go see the show about the one and only Ruth Bader Ginsberg. I would be remiss before I let you go because you've been so kind and generous with your time to say as the world's biggest fan, I’ve seen him marry 23 times, one of the most gorgeous and he writes a mean song himself, but one of the most gorgeous verses of a song is I am the strings that enter softly or three guitars that glitter gold or a thousand trumpet lines that were an afterthought intended as a way to get a dying record sold.

That song is a cinematic masterpiece and then his arrangement is gorgeous with the way that the instrumentation comes in. But as a musician myself, the way the homage you pay to the studio musician and the song and songwriting and storytelling in that song is stunning. I adored that song since I bought the live Barry album back when I was a young kid and I have listened to it and loved it ever since, so thank you.

[30:58] Rupert Holmes: My pleasure. It's interesting how that came about because Barry and I were both sort of that kind of musician at the beginning of our career and our paths crossed numerous times. We were in competition for the same American Airlines commercial and I loved the American Airlines commercial that I wrote. It didn't get used and I thought I want to turn this into a song and I thought, well I'm gonna turn this into a song about the fact that I keep going in and doing sessions that say Pepsi 30, that means a Pepsi Cola commercial that's 30 seconds, Coca-Cola 60, 60 seconds, and I'm asked to put everything that's in my head into their product. I do a session that lasts maybe 45 minutes to an hour. I leave.

I'll maybe hear it on the radio. And I don't make any more money from it. I get paid for the session. And is this what I'm gonna do with the rest of my life? Am I never going to get to tell a story that isn't about floor wax or chiclets, you know? So I wrote this song about being a studio musician who has to be an instant genius and come up with the licks and the trumpet lines, God knows how many trumpet lines I had to add to records. And Barry, I think when he heard the song on my album, my second album called Rupert Holmes, I don't know how I came up with that title, um, he heard it and he probably thought that's me. And he recorded it on his live album back in the 70s, and then he re-recorded it just recently with a gorgeous symphony orchestra in London on his latest live album.

He's been very, very kind to me over the years, and he's a marvel. When he plays a medley of his hits, that's 90 minutes right there. You know, it's astounding. He can play his songs, and you'll know every single one of them. Quite a force.

[33:06] Robert Bannon: I see you're very shaken by all this, Rupert.

[33:10] Rupert Holmes: Well, I thank you, Mr. Bannon, for rolling with the punches with us. Thank you for we had some technical difficulties, and he's a pro. And I appreciate his time. As you can tell, I didn't have the lyrics to the song. I don't need them. I can sing these songs to you from top to bottom.

[33:29] Rupert Holmes: It's a great compliment. It's a lovely thing when someone recites your lyric and there's clearly no crib sheet in sight. Thank you for that. I appreciate it greatly.

[33:42] Robert Bannon: Thank you. Yes, thank you. And um everyone, get your tickets, follow the information, go to rupert holmes.com, be on top of everything, and then make sure you see all the work whenever the work is anywhere. Thank you so much for being here. It's such an honor.

[33:56] Rupert Holmes: Lovely to be with you. Thank you.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred