Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep 541- The Cast & Creatives of 'Mother, May I Have A Kidney'  Fresh From Tribeca!

You know we try to stay on top of things here at The Roundtable! Well we are telling you, this is the next TV smash! We caught this at Tribeca and had to share! Mother, May I Have a Kidney?.. Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

27 mins
6/28/25

About

You know we try to stay on top of things here at The Roundtable! Well we are telling you, this is the next TV smash! We caught this at Tribeca and had to share!

Mother, May I Have a Kidney? is a heartfelt comedy-drama about Doug Andrews, a thirty-something navigating a full-blown midlife crisis when he’s hit with even worse news: he needs a kidney transplant. The only viable donor? His estranged mother, Rhonda — a sharp-tongued, boundary-challenged woman he hasn’t spoken to in over a decade. As Doug attempts the most awkward reunion of his life, old wounds resurface, expectations clash, and long-buried family secrets threaten to derail the one thing that could save him. But in the awkward, often hilarious process of orchestrating this unwanted reconciliation, Doug might just discover that healing a relationship can be as life-saving as the organ itself.

The series features a talented cast including Doug Plaut (Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, Hurricane Bianca franchise), Tina Benko ("The Greatest Showman," The Rehearsal, for which she won an EmmyⓇ for Best Supporting Actress in a Digital Series), Darius de Haas (The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel), Charlotte Ray Rosenberg (Sneaky Pete, FBI: Most Wanted), Troy Iwata (Dash and Lily, "Summoning Sylvia"), and features Myra Lucretia Taylor, Lydia Gaston, and Drew McVety.

We have the stars, the director, and the writer all here to tell us all about it! Do not miss it!

__________________________________________________________________

Check out "The Roundtable with Robert Bannon" here on BPN on the daily, on YouTube, Broadway World, and on social media! Like, comment, share, & subscribe!

For more info on Robert- www.RobertBannon.com

Follow Him on IG- @RobertMBannon

TikTok-@RobertMBannon

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:14] Robert Bannon: Well, welcome to the round table, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon, and you're listening to us on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network.

[0:20] Robert Bannon: And every single June, we're so honored to be a part of the Tribeca Film Festival, and we're honored to be able to be on the red carpet and do virtual interviews with some of the newest and best creators out here. Over 10,000 projects have been submitted to Tribeca this year. And out of all of them, only a few are chosen. So it's such a great honor. This is the next best art that you're about to see out here in the world.

[0:41] Robert Bannon: And I read about a series, Mother May I Have a Kidney'. If that name doesn't make you say, what? Who? Whose kidney would you want? I would want my mother's kidney. My mother is a very clean, healthy person. I would take her kidney, absolutely, out of my family. I'm so excited to talk about this series and this I've heard it's amazing. It's fun, it's funny. Veronica went to U of M. I'm in Detroit right now. I could literally I'm down the street. I could send her a sweatshirt. I want to know all about everything that's going on here with this film and how it all came to be. So Veronica, welcome to the show. Doug, welcome to the show. Welcome to the show. And Paul in the car, even in the car, Paul is out here and gonna sell this show. Paul, welcome to the show.

[1:31] Paul: Hello.

[1:33] Robert Bannon: So Veronica, congratulations.

[1:36] Veronica: Thank you.

[1:37] Veronica: Thank you so much. So tell us, this is your baby.

[1:42] Veronica: Well, so it's really Doug's baby in the sense that Doug commissioned me to create him a show. And so, um, yeah, so you know, when we initially talked about the concept, uh, you know, Doug had given me a couple details about his life and was really kind to just say, you know, let's I sort of explored some creative elements, things from my own life and mixed mixed with his.

[2:07] Veronica: So um Doug has shared this on several interviews. Uh, he is actually estranged from his mother, which this concept was um Doug is a st you know, Doug's a character is estranged from his mother, and uh finds out he needs a kidney and the perfect matches his mother.

[2:22] Robert Bannon: So wait, Doug, tell me, uh see, I'm not show busy like you go all here now. I just do my show and go home. Doug, you commissioned Veronica, so that means you had an idea or an idea, and you say, Veronica girl, write me a sh write me a Tribeca film right now, right?

[2:39] Doug Plaut: So initially I had written um myself a pilot that um was a it was uh it was about two 11-year-old boys. This was back in 2019, and um it was about um two eleven-year-old boys who were in a uh community theater production of The King and I in Greenwich, Connecticut, and um their relationship, and as I was thinking about it, two AAPI characters sort of came to the core of this, and I think I wanted in that instance to sort of explore what that family life would be like, and I didn't feel comfortable doing that myself as a white person.

[3:19] Doug Plaut: And so I asked a couple of friends uh if there was anyone who they knew who was sort of a burgeoning writer who would want to talk to me about this, and they both mentioned Veronica. And as things developed, and I sort of got to know Veronica, um her ambition and her work ethic. This is the story that I will always tell about Veronica.

[3:39] Doug Plaut: And I remember it's what we were we had just seen, this was probably December of 2022. We had just seen a very, very um play. And um, we were walking up the street, and it was like I would say it was probably 10 degrees outside, and um she was so into talking about this show and what it could be, and there was this and there was that, and all of these things happening.

[4:05] Doug Plaut: And then as we were walking, um, there was a homeless woman who I Veronica had, I think lived near Veronica, and so and sort of had Veronica had sort of had a relationship with her. So Veronica paused for about 90 seconds to take care of this person, and then that was done, and then she went right back into it. And I thought, wow, the ability to sort of have that uh that dichotomy of you know, going right into very caring relationship and right back into this sort of ferocious, um ferocious creative, you know uh brain space was um really special, I thought.

[4:44] Veronica: Yeah, so it's it's very unique. Veronica, for you, what was it about Doug that you said, like, okay, he I that's incredible. And you're and and obviously you have obvious chemistry with each other, your series is out, and and and I so it's it's obviously you you did the damn thing. So, what was it about Doug's idea that you said, okay, okay.

[5:05] Veronica: Well, interesting. So, like I love the idea, you know, because Doug also is all about his original idea was about musical theater, and I have a background in musical theater. My first show was Rent, and I I did a you know, just a a number of musicals after so we we actually did craft um so we we did a reading of Doug's version, and then I wrote a half-hour version that was slightly same same concept for Doug that Doug had but just changed it up and made it a half hour and then actually Doug Doug had sent the first draft to Melissa Joan Hart and you know and then it was this whole like we went on this journey of like wow she she said she wanted to direct it and she was you know she was like I love this and you know I was a little mortified like no one wants their first draft to be seen by anybody like showing your slip but um but then you know uh then she ended up getting a show um and then you know I've been friends with Paul for many years I interned at Hopkins Fifth Barden where uh initially I met him and he was an assistant there before uh they split to become Barn Chine and Christy Street Casting.

[6:10] Veronica: But so I I approached Paul um and just said, you know, here's the script. And you know, Paul can tell the rest of this story, but I think he was looking for something he you know, he encouraged us to craft something a little bit more well, they had some more dramatics and depth, and that was then uh in December 2022, but then uh January 2023, I wrote a new outline, a new treatment, and this time a full series, you know, a treatment for a full series, which is the concept that we had made and now is premiering at Tribeca, but yeah, I scripted it, and then by April, really fast furious process by April we were already in prepo.

[6:48] Robert Bannon: Wow.

[6:49] Robert Bannon: Wow. So Paul, tell us what did you when when you first saw this, what made you say, like, okay, I'm in, let's do this.

[6:55] Paul: Um well, like just to clarify really quickly, I worked primarily as a casting director, which is what Veronica was referencing when she was our intern/slash gal of a thousand trains. Um, I really liked, I mean, the first draft, the first version that Ronica described was really, really funny. I did think though that there was a little bit of room for exploring the relationship, excuse me, with the with the mother.

[7:21] Paul: And you know, in this case, it happened to be that the main character, Doug, needed a vital organ. I mean, to be honest, I we've talked about this a lot. It could have been any catalyst to sort of take them both on this journey of reconciliation or potential reconciliation. So I was just very interested in the the idea that there's a family, and there uh there's a character also of the sister who he needs to reach out to and perhaps reconcile with as well in order to get to the mother.

[7:51] Paul: And so I was always just taken with this idea of a family who you may not think on the surface cares that much for each other anymore, but you know, they do, and they just really have to navigate how to sort of interact with each other as adults, using this sort of um the idea that they still love each other as a family, but have to figure out some you know, kind of navigate some bad previous pre music's got you.

[8:24] Robert Bannon: Thank you, Paul. And as we're sitting here and we're talking, I I love the fact that we have the mom here as well. Tina, all the way from Italy, right now she's in Italy.

[8:40] TIna Benko: Well, I was saying blame blame Paul because casting director, he asked me in this film that is shooting in Bari at night.

[8:50] Robert Bannon: So thank you again to Paul.

[8:52] Robert Bannon: Oh, how Tina, how tough. What a tough life out there to be working on this film in Italy, Paul.

[8:59] Paul: Where's I'm gonna send you my headshot and resume after this.

[9:02] TIna Benko: Absolutely. I'll send you a monthly postcard because I know casting I love that casting director.

[9:12] Robert Bannon: So Tina, when you when you got the script, what did you what did you feel about the relationship and this character behind her in you?

[9:20] TIna Benko: Yeah, I loved it. I immediately loved it. I liked the tone. I think what Veronica and Doug have done is very difficult and slippery because I do feel very broad comedy and full hearted love. And uh I think that's weird to navigate to have us there, but keep this broad company intact.

[9:43] TIna Benko: It's sort of like Bridesmaids. I think it's very interesting that a family member maybe would not be immediately saying yes to give you a vital organ. I think they're I can definitely relate and identify with people who feel that they've spent their life.

[10:06] TIna Benko: Oh, am I still on?

[10:07] Robert Bannon: You are.

[10:09] TIna Benko: Okay. My screen went blank, but um people who have worked their whole life as this character has Rhonda and has this pull yourself up by your bootstraps, kids mentality, and then to think that you know to just give away something.

[10:26] TIna Benko: I think she really believes things should be earned and that she's she's worked so hard. Why should she give something else? She's already sacrificed for these kids. Why should she sacrifice something else? You know, she's she's um a self-made woman, and I think that something about that generation, those generational values uh can sometimes see things through the lens of oh, these young kids don't know how to earn it, or they don't know hard work, or they don't know how to suffer, or they don't know how to deal with with trauma or or challenges or crisis.

[11:02] TIna Benko: But this, of course, is it is a kid. I think there's the shame in that she, unlike your beautiful mother, is not the healthiest. Um, I think she probably is seeing her own mortality with this request, and and a lot of that is fear and guilt about her job as a mother, whether she's failed in her opinion, and also if she gives up one kidney, what does that mean for her health and her drinking and her longevity now that she can finally maybe stop working so hard?

[11:43] TIna Benko: You know, so there I think there's a lot of fear and guilt tied up in Rhonda, and I like the complication of that. I like that she doesn't immediately say yes to her own son, and what it and and we use the word that Paul used. Is there forgiveness there? Is there reconciliation? Is there sometimes births and deaths are the thing that can you know change alter these relationships, these family relationships?

[12:10] TIna Benko: And I thought that was really fascinating. And I also just thought she had so many lines that were really funny, and that the sibling relationship was very interesting and um felt honestly rendered in a in a in a prickly bumpy way that you know siblings can function in that thorny way, but at the end of the day, we are blood.

[12:39] Robert Bannon: Yeah, I love I love that. So while we're talking about this uh whole experience here, do you do you understand when you were writing this? Did you understand that this was going to always be a series?

[12:54] Robert Bannon: I mean, we know you from comedy.

[12:56] Robert Bannon: I should I should also just jump in right there.

[12:59] TIna Benko: Please finish your question.

[13:00] Robert Bannon: But I did not write this, Veronica.

[13:02] Robert Bannon: What I'm saying, when Veronica, right? But when you came up with the idea, and the idea of the original idea was going to be that it was going to be a series, and you come from comedy.

[13:10] Robert Bannon: I mean, we've seen you in Kimmy Schmidt, we've we've had Titus on the show, we've we've talked about, we've seen your work. When you had this idea, did you come up with the idea that it was always going to be a comedy?

[13:21] Robert Bannon: And the idea behind it, this idea of the kidney. Is there something that triggered you? Did you see something? Is there something in life that made you come up with this particular treatment? Or was this something that how did this all for you?

[13:32] Doug Plaut: You asked Veronica, I don't understand how it works.

[13:34] Robert Bannon: No, I can ask Veronica to write something, and she came up with the kidney.

[13:39] Doug Plaut: I can answer this. So I think that um definitely Veronica and I batted things back and forth, a lot of different different ideas.

[13:49] Doug Plaut: Um, I think that and Veronica will correct me if I'm wrong. I believe the kidney idea was hers, and the title was mine. I think that's how that one worked out. So the title is my idea, but it came from her idea of the kidney as the organ. So, and I think that for me, you know, I've I have a pretty deep bench behind me of things that are relatively zany and um off the wall. And I'm I wanted to see for me, and this might be a little bit of me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me, but I wanted to see if I um there was a way to sort of take that and just bring it way down and see if uh the comedy could come from maybe a more um hum a more human place, and uh which is which is I think a lot more uh Veronica's world is a lot more contemporary than mine is.

I mean, I spend it's so rare that I see anything in my personal life when I'm like watching TV that was made after 1972. So um, so I think just definitely I think what Veronica wrote, and I think what we did is a lot more contemporary, and that the humor is so we don't really have traditional setups and then punchlines. I think the humor all comes from character and per and performance and the sort of arc of the scene itself. Got it. Is that yeah, I think that's fair to say.

[15:20] Veronica: Explain to us what because when I came on and I said, This is your baby, you say no, it's Doug's. And then Doug says, but Veronica wrote it. So for us regular Schmidt people, what the hell how does Hollywood so Doug commissioned me, but then um, yeah, so the concept of the kidney. So at the time that we that like we had uh talked about this concept, um, and we're moving from like the half-hour comedy to this developing a series, my father had been diagnosed with kidney cancer, and I think that bled into, I mean, actually, it's funny. When I watched the series, and I've, you know, we've had three screenings so far, I feel like it's like slumdog millionaire tell you each one of these scenes where they came from and why, you know, even down to there's a squirrel scene uh with uh Doug and another actor, Troy Iwata that's just brilliant.

And I, you know, that came that came directly from just like me living in New York City. Um, but so the kidney idea was just uh I just thought a lot of my scripts have sci-fi and medical uh stuff because my mom's a doctor and she has a photographic memory. He's actually the first script pilot script that I wrote. Um that's actually how my writing career started, and I got it started getting noticed by the writing community and and started um working as a writer. But the kidney idea was to me uh really interesting. I've actually had a cousin and an aunt who died on dialysis waiting for a kidney, and it's a it's a it's a serious issue. I will just plug that the National Kidney Foundation has endorsed us as a show and come on board to say, you know, what I would I loved about how they endorsed this, they said, you know, so many of the things that we shared are factual and real scenarios, but there is humor to it.

And a lot of the questions that I had Rhonda asking about when you're donating a kidney are actual questions that people have. Um so for me, uh the kidney issue was just a solidified way as a storyteller to make sure that these two people who are estranged, which is another concept I wanted to explore. I think more frequently, more more now than ever, I think people I'm hearing the stories of friends that are estranged from family. And I I wanted to explore what that looks like for two people to have to come together and make amends. I've read like three or four books on forgiveness, and it just floors me the whole concept of making amends. And and you know, somebody told me one time forgiveness doesn't mean friendship.

So what does that actually look like? And so, yeah, so that's all the things there's just so many themes I wanted to explore in this. But yes, the kidney came partially from my life and just experiences, and then also I just thought it was a really good uh story element that required, you know, two people can avoid each other for the rest of their lives if nothing necessary pulls them together. But this is a life in death situation. Fascinating. I love it. It's fun, and uh what an interesting way, and as actors it's a fun uh premise to play for sure.

[18:23] Paul: Paul is back. Paul, um, when you're when you're when you get the script and you start working on this, you living in the casting world and in the directing world, tell us about the casts of this of this of this piece. Tell us what it was like to find all the pieces that made this the magic that it is. Um, it was in a lot of ways. I mean, my casting associate Rachel Dolman, who works with me on freelance on a lot of projects, actually sort of handled the bulk of the casting in terms of auditioning people and so forth. Um there were a few, I've known Tina for a long time, there are a few actors I did not know. And you know, it's from the casting lens, it's just putting together the puzzle in a way that makes sense and believable.

And yes, of course, in this case, I was sort of thinking obviously directorially as well, and so it was interesting and strange to be sort of on the other side of the table, so to speak. Uh um, you know, because I trusted Paul. We may be losing. Go ahead, Paul. Are you back? I suppose. Oh, I'm here, sorry. Did I say something brilliant? Yes. No, yes. Sorry, I don't know when I went where I went out, but what I was saying was it was just interesting to fill all the pieces as a director and not only the casting director, but sort of have both hats on at the same time. It's just awesome.

[19:49] Doug Plaut: So for Doug and Tina, for you both, tell us what it was like last set to not only say Veronica's words, but also to work with Paul as a director. Tina, tell us.

[20:00] TIna Benko: It's so collaborative. A joy, you know, and if if you if you stop finding the joy in the work, even in even in the dramatic uh sections, uh the whole team was so collaborative and um but also had a strong vision. Um and I loved working with Doug. He's just he's joy, and I we're we're we are very similar to peas in a pod. I I only pretty much watch Turner Classic movies, and we just can sit around and and reference, you know, films from 1938 and live in film noir. Um so that was uh just a complete and utter joy. And Paul has such a beautiful shorthand because he's he directs all the time in his casting sessions. He gives you what I call like the the nugget. He gives you like the perfect little note, and you do the take again, and then he's you know sends you to the callback.

So Paul has perfected that that way of giving an actor a note in a really playable positive way where you don't get uh in your head. And um, and Veronica as well. She was she was just there, sort of making everything brighter and lighter and more joyful, but also as Doug referenced, such a strong work ethic, there ready to go, ambitious, wanting it to be the best. And so you rise to that, you rise to that, and all of the actors. Um, you know, Myra, uh we had just brilliant legends on set as well. So um, but but again, Doug, Doug is just a delight and hilarious, and um I'm so lucky.

[21:49] Doug Plaut: I'd like to if I echo everything Tina just said, I'd like to tell. I talked about that story with Veronica. I'd like to tell a little story about Paul and a little story about Tina, if I may. Okay, so so the first time I believe I met Paul, it was, and Paul will correct me if I'm wrong. I think it was for um he was casting a Hulu pilot um called Crash and Burn. And it was about, I believe I could be wrong about this. It was about a high school student who I believe um was the shooter in a school shooting, and for some reason was allowed back to the school. I could be wrong about that. Um but you're right, roughly speaking, you're correct. Yes, okay. So at the time I can say this, and I'm I'm open to talking about it, but that's okay.

The show never went to went to Hulu anyway. It never got aired, so but at the time, um I was I was in the middle. We're we're all good now, but I was in the middle of a pretty intense um thing with anorexia and stuff like that. So I weighed about 95 pounds. So I went in there, I read this thing. They were like, who, what, how? And then the next day they said um they called and they said, so he's not getting that, but there is this 15-year-old anorexic girl in this pilot. And we're gonna see if we can sort of change it to um the character's name from Kara to Carl, I believe. So I came in and I read that again, and it didn't quite work. But I always thought that for me, who I sort of feel like doesn't really exist in any one category as a person.

Um it really takes a great deal of um excuse me, open-minded thinking and stuff like that to um really see actors, and Paul certainly did that. So I certainly felt very safe walking into this process with him that was so personal and so new for me.

[23:46] Doug Plaut: And the story I want to tell about Tina is um okay. So my favorite play in the entire world is The Little Foxes. And if you know that play, it's about at the center of it. Tina's gonna be like, where is he going with this? But I'm gonna get out figure it out. Okay, so if you know that play, there's a woman at the center of it who is so strong and so tough, and she's spicy, and she says things like, 'I hope you die,' and all of these things. And if you get to know Tina, you would sort of think her sort of energy and ferocity and the way that she can elevate the words that she says is perfect for that. But Tina did not play that part when I saw her do that in 2010, which was the first time I saw her.

She played Bertie, who is sort of this recessive, very shy character who um is abused by her husband. Spoiler, if you've never seen it, and um I remember when Tina walked on stage, I think she had on a little red dress because it was a contemporary retelling of this story. And at first it's like, oh, who's that? Because she was, she's not shy or recessive. And it takes about seven seconds for um you to just sort of say she is that lady. And I think that that's a real mark of brilliance that um someone who can both transform into a character and also just sort of by the power of her will make any character sort of melt onto her. And so my mentor says that I have a little like um five, they're all actresses really, but five actresses sort of in my brain who I'm just they're my clients. I'm almost more invested in their success than I am in my own. So I'm getting to do this with Tina was just magnificent for me. So I love I love it, and I love the relationship you all have.

[25:36] Veronica: So in our last moment here together. How can we support this show? How can we help get the word out that this exists, and what can we do as people out here in these streets to talk about this show?

[25:51] Veronica: So we have one more screening on Sunday, June 15th at 6 p.m. The tickets are sold out, but there is a rush line. The other thing that people could do is review it, the people who have seen it, review it on IMDB Pro and give it five stars if you enjoyed it a lot. And then also just putting the word out on social media, getting friends to talk about it. Um we we have had some distribution offers, but we're still in meetings and trying to figure out where this will live after 25. So everybody, that means follow everybody. All the links will be below us. You can follow them to stay up the update on what's gonna happen with this, because I'm sure you're gonna see it somewhere. Watch out, y'all. It's gonna be somewhere.

And then we'll stable all of the work that's still to come and all the things that you have to do. Thank you for giving you gave us a lesson in how TV shows are made. You gave us a lesson on great ideas and a lesson on how to have a collaborative, beautiful set to make great projects out here for the next future. Filmmakers, TV makers, and actors and writers and directors out here. Thank you all so much for spending congratulations out of all the all of the stuff that's been sent to Tribeca. Your work is there. You did it. And everybody be an organ donor.

[27:01] Doug Plaut: Absolutely. Thank you all so much. Congratulations. Thank you for spending time with us this morning.

[27:05] Robert Bannon: Thank you, Robert. Thank you so much.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred