Renowned singer-songwriter Susan Werner has long been celebrated for her wit, charm, and incredible ability to tell stories through music. Now, she’s taking her talents to the stage in a whole new way with Bull Durham, the beloved baseball classic reimagined as a musical, coming soon to Paper Mill Playhouse... Read More
From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon
About
Renowned singer-songwriter Susan Werner has long been celebrated for her wit, charm, and incredible ability to tell stories through music. Now, she’s taking her talents to the stage in a whole new way with Bull Durham, the beloved baseball classic reimagined as a musical, coming soon to Paper Mill Playhouse. As the composer and lyricist, Susan brings her signature blend of humor, heart, and Americana spirit to this exciting new production.
In this Roundtable conversation, we talk about the journey of bringing Bull Durham from screen to stage, the challenges and joys of writing for musical theatre, and what audiences can expect from this iconic story’s fresh new life. With Susan’s trademark warmth and wit, it’s a chat that’s equal parts fun, insightful, and inspiring—much like her music itself.
Available on BroadwayWorld, Broadway Podcast Network, Spotify, iHeart, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
Learn more at RobertBannon.com and follow on Instagram @RobertMBannon.
#SusanWerner #BullDurhamMusical #PaperMillPlayhouse #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:14] Robert Bannon: Well, welcome to the round table, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon. And listen, I'm really excited because during COVID, we had a show called Quarantine Cabaret and Cocktails, and Susan Werner came on twice. And I kind of fell in love with Susan Werner's voice. And when you talk about songwriting at its best, she does it. Like if you love songwriting, that's real songwriting, she does it the best. And I have some friends who fan out about her. Look, I got this as a wedding gift. I got Susan Werner dental floss in the card. Look, I got it as a gift at my wedding because my friend Todd and Amy are such fans and they go on the cruises and they go on her shows, but they're too embarrassed to talk to her because they don't want to fan out.
But I tell them to say hello because she's so nice. Well, let me tell you, she now wrote a musical. And not only is she writing a musical, it's gonna be at Paper Mill with like Carmen Cusack and Nick Walker. Like some of my favorite voices in the entire world. Bull Durham comes to Paper Mill and Susan Werner is here to tell us about it. Welcome back. You're back.
[1:17] Susan Werner: Woo!
[1:19] Robert Bannon: Susan, you've written like 500,000 songs, and now you have a musical.
[1:27] Susan Werner: Well, it didn't happen overnight, but yeah. I've been working on this musical for about, I mean, at least 13 years. And yeah, it's going up at Paper Mill Playhouse in Milburn, New Jersey, October 2nd to November 2nd. And you know where that is. I mean, you know where that is. I haven't even been there yet. I know it's a big deal, but I haven't been there yet.
[1:44] Robert Bannon: Okay.
[1:47] Susan Werner: But I'm so excited that it's happening, and I'm excited for you to come see it and all your viewers to come see it because, yeah, Carmen Cusack's amazing. Nick Walker's amazing. These are great talents. Look, firstly, if you don't know about Paper Mill, New Jersey, New York, everyone, there's a train that leads you right there. There's lots of good restaurants, like the best restaurants.
[2:05] Robert Bannon: This is good to hear.
[2:07] Susan Werner: Fancy, dancey, beautiful theater. So many shows have gone from Paper Mill to Broadway. It is the number one place on the East Coast to see the streamline of shows that go from Paper Mill to Broadway, and they do top-notch, amazing work. It is the best theater you will see, absolutely bar none. It is Broadway and New Jersey, truly.
[2:28] Robert Bannon: Yeah, I'm happy to hear about this. Like it's easy for people to come from the city out. It's certainly easy for people to come from anywhere in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Connecticut to come over and see it. And we did it last year at Duke in Durham, North Carolina, where of course, you know, the home crowd cheers for itself. But it was already in pretty good shape. And as we get closer to opening night here, which is less than a month away now, it's fun now to know that the big building blocks are in place. And what we're dialing in on as writers, me as composer and lyricist and Ron Shelton, the director and screenwriter, who wrote the movie and also wrote Tin Cup and White Men Can't Jump, he knows how to tell the story.
So what we're working on now is really the tiny details. This line here, this joke here. And I gotta tell you, Robert, this is really the fun part. I mean, the hard part is like working in the dark for years, right? You don't even get a reading, you don't know you got it, you don't got it. And then you're like, oh god, I gotta fix half the songs, I gotta rewrite them, right? And now we're like starting to get into the, you know, just the little, and it's so exciting because the spaceship is flying. It's flying, like it's flying. And look, I'm not trying to say it's not flying in, you know, the little corner coffee shop. It's not flying in like it's flying at the Paper Mill. You people, it's at Paper Mill.
And bells and whistles, all the bells and whistles. And our director is Mark Bruni, who just did Great Gatsby on Broadway. And before that, he did Beautiful the Musical, which some of your audience probably saw. And he knows how to operate the bells and whistles, the lights, the sound. He knows how to, you know, make the pie higher, I guess is how you say it. And yeah, this is a fun part of it.
[4:24] Susan Werner: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Woohoo! This is a fun part, Robert, because really it is about, you know, taking the thing and just like turning up the intensity of it. And it's exciting for all of us on the creative team because now is where you feel like we're sprinting, we're just sprinting, galloping to the finish, right? And we know what it is, what it takes to get from here to there. So I encourage your audience to come see it because even if it goes to Broadway, which there's a real chance it will, you might want to see where we're at now and what songs we got in there now, what the characters are doing now, what these actors are doing now, and how that may look different the next time you see it, wherever you see it.
Listen, all you theater people out here, especially here on Broadway World, that go in the message boards and you want to see the first preview and what changed between the preview to opening night, and this is your chance to see a show build and evolve before it is as out, and wherever it's gonna be next. Papermill.org is where you can get your tickets, and they make tickets affordable, but they sell out, so you really need to go and get your tickets now because there's an incredible arts community there that goes to see everything.
[5:34] Robert Bannon: How did this start? How did you folk? I don't know what to call your style of music because you do folk.
[5:40] Susan Werner: I'm a songwriter, I do folk music, I do jazz, I do cabaret, I do, you know, I'm a weirdo. So it's like all these things, right? Hybrid weirdo. It's more that I just write songs, I just try to write good songs in whatever style they come up and to make them engaging, make them easy to understand the first time. That's probably why the producers, the first time around got interested in my writing because I write songs you understand the first time you hear them. They're not like, you know, oh, like you know, six years later, I finally understood Pink Moon by Nick Drake, right? It's like there's no, it's not like there's layers of dream that you have to be on. Like, is this funny or not funny, right?
Are we having this conversation now or we're not having? We're having it right now? And the songs should read that fast if I do them right. That's how I do it anyway. And producers came to me in 2010 and they talked to me after the show. I didn't know they were there, and they said, you know, have you ever thought of writing a musical? And I said, no, I don't, I haven't. And they said, well, we think that you could do that because your songs have a narrative to them, and what this means for your musical theater fans, and Robert, I'm sure you know this, but like a musical theater song starts in one place and ends in another place. There's something that's revealed in the middle of it that makes the end different than the start.
[7:11] Susan Werner: Here's an example, okay? The Beatles, "I Want to Hold Your Hand" is just I want to hold your hand. It begins, I want to hold your hand, and it ends, I want to hold your hand. We haven't learned anything new, really, in the three minutes that went past, and that's what a pop song is, right? Okay, so there was a goofy guy named Tom Lehrer in the 60s who wrote a song called "I Hold Your Hand in Mine." Sounds very similar, but it begins by him saying, I hold your hand in mine. And by the end of the song, we discover that he has cut off the hand of this dead woman. He's holding it. Okay, so right, it's a little gruesome, but you get the idea, right? That it ends in a different place than it starts. And that's what makes musical theater writing musical theater writing. There are no cutoff hands in Bull Durham. There will be no cutoff hands, no. But there is a good time. There's a real good time.
[8:09] Robert Bannon: So were you a fan of the film? Do you like baseball?
[8:12] Susan Werner: Oh yeah, I'm a lifelong Cubs fan. I played softball as a kid. We played baseball, softball on the farm, all of that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All of it. And so I understood, I understood going in that I was gonna like it. And then when I met with Ron Shelton to talk about the show for the first time, I mean, this is a big deal. This guy's, you know, quite a success, and I was a little nervous about it. I'm like, how do I do this? So I bought a wiffle ball and bat, and we went out into the alley before dinner and like threw a little baseball around, right? And then during dinner, I'm like, how do you throw? How do you throw? Show me how to throw a curve. It's like this, right? And so that was the conversation, right?
Instead of being about sort of, oh, what have you done? Oh, god, right? Any of that kind of business crap. It's like, do we have something to talk about here? Can we talk to each other? And right away, yeah, we can talk to each other. And he's hilarious. And this has been, I mean, it's a lot of work. But if you do it with fun people, and what's right? There's no people like show people? There's none. If you do it with fun people, it is the best possible work you could ever do with your life. And it's a bit of a blast. This is a joymaker of a show, I gotta tell you.
[9:21] Robert Bannon: Is there truly a formula to musical theater? Did you have, did you have like a story? Like, how did you find this? We need an opening, we need a big ballad, we need a showstopper, we need a closing. Like, how do you fit the holes of the story with a song?
[9:35] Susan Werner: Yeah, there's a great book by Jack Fertell who used to teach at NYU. He taught musical theater. And he was also creative director at Jujamcyn Theaters. He wrote a great book that your audience may have heard of already, or if they haven't, you'll want to get this. It's called The Secret Life of the American Musical. And you can get it at all booksellers online, et cetera. But again, The Secret Life of the American Musical. And he talks about all the big pieces that usually go into musicals and why they're necessary, how they function, why they have to happen in a certain order, why there has to be a conflict within the first 20 minutes, why there's always a big noise at the beginning of the second act, right?
A big loud, noisy, grotesque, obscene, whatever it is. You'll now that I told you this, you're gonna notice this that the beginning of second acts is often this big, funny, goofy or loud and grotesque or violent, something big, because people have just gotten back into the theater, right? They just got back into the theater after the act break. And so, how do you get them back in? You gotta make it easy. You can't do something subtle, small, thoughtful. It's always gonna be like garbage cans thrown across the stage, right? It has to have that because there's a reason over the course of two hours. That's our attention span. That's the narrative we crave and how we stay engaged. So I can't recommend this book highly enough to your fans. You'll read it, you'll be like, ah, that, oh, that, oh, that's why that. Yeah, Secret Life of the American Musical.
[11:12] Robert Bannon: I'm going through my head of some of the greatest musicals, and I'm thinking about that second act, and they usually come in with some, like I took Rent, for example. You're breaking in a house, they're banging down the doors, there's something to jar you back into, oh, what does Susan Werner have up her sleeve for Bull Durham?
[11:30] Susan Werner: You'll see. You better get a ticket, everybody, while we're talking about SusanWerner.com if you're around the country and you want to see her on the road. I mean, you do a lot of dates besides writing a musical that's coming to Paper Mill. You're, you hit the road, you sing.
[11:41] Susan Werner: Yeah, I perform about a hundred dates a year. I'm gonna do Erbidium in New York in October 23rd. I'll be out in LA at Santa Monica at McCabe's on November 15th. You know, I run around the country, but I have a nice quality of life. I do it as I enjoy it. But I want to tell you, you mentioned Carmen Cusack. Robert, I just want to tell you what a pleasure it is to be in the rehearsal space with these people. Like these are magicians. And you know, Nick Walker is with us. He's doing Phantom at night, right? He's Phantom on Broadway at night. And then he comes in and rehearses with us. And the boundless energy he has, you're just like, what? How can anyone do that? I just feel like working with people like this is like they're just, I feel like they're not from the same planet as me.
Like, I need a nap, man. Like, I can't keep that up all day and all night. But to see the moments they figure out how to communicate feeling that's visible from 1200 seats away, right? And we were 600 seats in Durham. This is twice as large. So whatever gesture for your actors in your audience, whatever gesture you make, whatever choice you make, I guess this is the language, it has to be readable from that far away. And Carmen comes up with, I mean, there's a reason people in your audience know Carmen.
[13:15] Susan Werner: She's an absolutely magical, magical talent. You know, she can break your heart by just picking up, you know, even if you say, Carmen, break my heart with an earbud, you know, she would find a way, you know, either something, right? Something she would do that would communicate feeling, but readable from so far the back seats, the balcony, the astonishing, and then she opens her mouth, and then it's done. That's a wrap.
[13:45] Robert Bannon: Yeah, forget it. It's all right, and Nick is such a good guy. And if you if people watching, if you don't, Nick is spam a lot, he's Hamilton, he is done, he writes his own amazing television shows and work. He is a talent, like you all are going to fall in love with them as actors, and then fall in love with the music and the story.
[14:04] Susan Werner: When you had to research these, there you you have a template. I mean, this is based on a movie and based on a writing and all of that, but you have to then fall in love with these characters and express themselves. So, how do you get in the head of Crash? How do you get in the head of some of these players and there and the other people in the show so that you're not writing from Susan Werner's perspective? You're writing from theirs.
[14:23] Susan Werner: You're writing from theirs, you're using their language, right? So I'm happy you're talking to me, but honestly, if we do this right, you know, you're seeing these characters, these archetypes really up on the stage. And Crash Davis, who was played in the movie by Kevin Costner, but you won't think much about Kevin Costner when you come in. It may be part of what you enjoyed about the movie, but when you come in, you'll be like, you'll see this guy late in his career who's running out of time, who's trying to figure out what to do with himself and what matters the most, right?
[14:56] Susan Werner: Well, guess what? Some of us have already been there, right? Uh there's a 20-year-old uh phenom right hand uh pitcher who has, as one coach says, a million dollar arm and a five cent head, right? Not so clever yet, right? But he can really throw. And he goes from single-a Durham all the way up to the Baltimore Orioles in one season just because of talent. And so Crash Davis is looking at Nuke Lelouch, like, how can life be so unfair? Like it just, you know, he got a thunderbolt for an arm. How did that happen? And what do I do with that information that life is unfair? And how do I behave in the face of that, right?
[15:34] Susan Werner: And then there's uh Nuke Lelouch, who's like, you know, who's found this woman who's, you know, late 30s and totally captivating. But you know, what does he know that he hasn't learned in like Playboy, right? He doesn't know anything about like really getting it on. And she's super powerful in her personal realm, but also in the realm of knowing about baseball, a savant, and how to coach out your performance by having you get distracted by breathing out your left nostril and out your right eyelid. Right.
[16:06] Susan Werner: Which any of us have taken vocal lessons, it's like, you know, think about think about pinching. I remember this one teacher said, think about pitching it pinching a nickel between your butt cheeks. What? Another guy, another guy told me pear-shaped tones, see orange when you it's like, what the hell? Right? I've been to those. It's like, what? Oh, they're just trying to get you not to think about whatever you're thinking about, right? Anyway, so these again, these characters, if we do it right, and I'm beginning to suspect we are doing it right, are large in these ways that everyone can see themselves in it.
[16:44] Susan Werner: Um, and you just forget about even the movie that got you in the door, and now you're on this ride that actually speaks to you about your own life and things that you yourself have been through. Do you uh I'm so excited. I I don't even know how to explain how excited I am for you because I know I've I've had friends who have written musicals, and it I know what a heartbreaking long, arduous process it is, and that it takes a step, it takes a step back. It's years on hold. It's we'll maybe get it on next season, which is gonna be 15 months from now. And what I'm what are you it is a real, it's not like you can go and into a studio and record an album and get it out. Like, this is a labor of love.
[17:19] Susan Werner: And it's collaborative, which means there's other people's efforts involved, but you also have to get a theater. Um, there's money, uh, there's so much that's out of your control. It's sort of like a spiritual teacher, one of these things, because you just gotta relinquish all control over it or hope of control. But then when it, you know, when it comes back to you, like Jonathan Livingston Seagull, like you know, if you let it go, it comes back to you, it was yours. Um, if you let it go, and then it comes back and it's happening, right? And I it is happening.
[17:50] Susan Werner: I'm really excited to talk to you about it, Robert, because I've known you a long time. A long time, and you've always been so kind to me and my talent. And this is really a fun, a fun moment that this is gonna go out and just and bring a lot of people just a great night out. Well, what I love is that when I first met Sue when I first talked to Susan, and when I first talked to your manager Patty, Patty said to me, What I love about your crazy show, this is years ago. What I love about your crazy show is you can put on Susan, you could put on Dora Williams, you could put on a recording artist, but then you put on a Broadway person, and people love music and art, period.
[18:25] Robert Bannon: Like art and music is art and music, and that it's you're not just the singer-songwriter show or the Broadway show. And that's what I love about you. Because if you go back to your you have a gospel album, you have an or you have a Brock album, you have a you have a you have an album that's more country or more jazz or more cabaret, and you can write a musical because music is music. Music is music. If you understand patterns, if you're good with patterns, I think that's what really has allowed me to to pick up on how to write a musical. Is um you like uh I remember there was a picture of Lynn Manuel Miranda with both books by Sondheim, right? Both of those, and that that's been really helpful to me too, because you see you see the patterns, you hear the patterns over the course of three minutes, five minutes.
[19:08] Susan Werner: And if you are nimble with patterns, and then you begin to bring the story, the narrative you're trying to tell, these characters, their feelings, their motivations, together with patterns, you can put it together. You're not working from total scratch, right? You're not working from total scratch. Uh, and uh, especially when you're handed a screenplay as good as this one. Um, it makes a lot of the work so much easier than it could have been well maybe it's easy for you but i don't i don't know you're a genius at writing a song you really got it together i i do what i can i do what i can i can't write a i i have to chat gpt of a valentine's day card to my husband pull that creative muscle out your brain everybody and do something amazing so when my friends Todd and Amy who write me every time they go to see you they see you everywhere and they go on every cruise and all the things and they buy your merch like the like the dental floss I love the thing I saw you when you were introduced me okay so yeah that's um this year's floss uh merch is floss and I did this this cruise with songwriters kind a Kayamo cruise which is big fun it happens every year out of Miami and um that was my merch this year and I sold like a thousand dollars worth of floss on this cruise ship because I think half the people forgot floss and then some people just wanted like the weirdest merch ever so I'm proud to think that I'm in you know bathrooms I'm in vanities across this across listen I got married in May and I got a card and I got a beautiful gift from them they came and taped to the card was the sorganza band and this dental flow so when I got home I looked at it and I saw Susan Werner I said did they put did they put a sticker did she put a and you sell dental and that's brilliant because I care for my audience I care about your dental and uh heart health.
[21:01] Susan Werner: Absolutely you know your your heart is tied to your teeth, people. They've gone to every Cliamo cruise except one, every single one. And um and I told them to just go up to Susan Werner when you see her and say hi and not be weird. But they they're they're starstruck. They don't want to say hi. That's okay. They'll get one of these days they'll get close enough and then they'll figure out I'm just you know I'm I just I need my teeth floss like everyone else.
[21:26] Robert Bannon: You you got your dental floss like every opening night of your show. So maybe they'll see you there. Woo hi. So who should get who should buy tickets before I let you go who should buy tickets who's this show for is it for families is it for couples is it for people who love baseball is it's a love story like who's who's gonna go out there and get their tickets I don't think it's frozen.
[21:45] Susan Werner: No I wouldn't I wouldn't bring your seven year old necessarily and not because they're gonna be you know extremely upset by what they see but I think they just won't get it right it's like taking three year olds to Paris. Why are you doing that? You know like what they just want to go to the pool right at the holiday in uh uh I think uh I think it's like a 13 and over right okay 13 and over uh but it's for everybody 13 and over and I gotta tell you it works for everybody and you would think this show does not have um it does not have an openly gay character but the nature of the challenges the nature of the challenges that the nature of that is universal and Annie even makes a comment about you know these two guys who are talking to each other and she says well maybe this is late in homosexuality channeling itself and I'm all for that like there's there there's acknowledgement of these two guys and that you know athletes are often you know very close to each other in various ways and uh I think there's a kind of openness that allows all of us to find ourselves in these characters.
[22:50] Susan Werner: And as a queer woman, it's like, oh, I kind of wish, you know, this that there would be that that element in this show. But I think that's another show. The universal of this applies to everyone, but it is not personal in terms of how I live my personal life, but it is universal in terms of unfairness. In terms of hoping to find someone who really gets you. These things carry. And um and it's it's got great choreography. Josh Burgast did our choreo and he just did Smash. Uh he did it on on TV, of course, and also on Broadway. And the physicality of the Choreo is like what? It's so great.
[23:35] Robert Bannon: There's not maybe I'm uh I'm giving my best gay life, but dancing baseball players, somebody sign me up. In tight pants, some with their shirts off. I think, yeah, plenty to look at. But and I I love, I'm sorry, I'm a Yankees fan through and through, Susan. I know you're from the Midwest. Cubs. We could fight about the Cubs and the Yankees. But I what I would love is that you know, baseball is something that brings families together. And even if you don't love baseball, this love story and the triangle and the trials and tribulations that's going to be is for everybody. So, husbands, this is the musical for you. And wives, I promise there'll be plenty for you to love about it as well. And everybody, come on down to see the show.
[24:11] Susan Werner: Robert, thanks for having me. This was so again, it was really great to talk to you under, you know, under these circumstances, right? Under really uniquely happy circumstances. And um, I just appreciate what you do for the Broadway community. Thanks for, you know, bringing eyes and ears to all the things a lot of us are doing out here. Some of us flying below the radar. I saw this advertisement and almost fell off my chair. I am so proud of you. And listen, people, wherever you listen to music, however you get to your music, make sure you go into the deep dive, go back into Susan's catalog and listen to her amazing, beautiful albums and her work on her own, and then get tickets to see the show and see her when she's coming to your neck of the woods.
[24:48] Robert Bannon: It's a concert. It's a day, you're somebody who could sit at a piano by yourself or or and and play and just do what you don't need. There's no, you don't need a firework. You don't need uh dancing girls, you don't need any. You just got Susan that voice and those stories and songs. Good night.
[25:02] Susan Werner: Thanks, Robert. You're you're the best. Thank you. That's it. SusanWerner.com. Everybody's where you can get tickets and information about her. And then papermill.org is where you can get tickets. Go to papermill.org, but they're gonna sell out. Bull Durham comes to my home, state of New Jersey. Come on, Jersey. Let's go. Paper Mill Playhouse is the place to look. You gotta go to the Millburn Deli. It's so good.
[25:26] Robert Bannon: Hey, I want this intel. It's look, it's a Milburn deli. It's so good. They have something famous called the Gobbler. I don't know with what you eat and what you like, but it's a turkey sandwich that's like Thanksgiving, and it is so delicious and amazing. Yeah. It is the spot. It's the cutest place in the Millburn Deli.
[25:42] Susan Werner: Thanks for that. I'm putting that on my calendar right now. Check it out. Check it out. Look, my friend Mike is around the corner in Millburn. If you need a ride, if you need somebody to give you the scoop, I he'll hook you up. I promise.
[25:53] Robert Bannon: Thank you. You're very jersey. You know, I got a guy who lives around the corner. Break legs. I'll see you there. I'm so excited to make this happen for you. I'm so excited for people to check it out. Thank you, Robert.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
