Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Ep 656- Keith Varney Talks Ten Times I Should Have Known I Was Autistic!

Star and writer Keith Varney joins Robert Bannon to open up about his powerful and deeply personal solo show Ten Times I Should Have Known I Was Autistic... Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

19 mins
10/28/25

About

Star and writer Keith Varney joins Robert Bannon to open up about his powerful and deeply personal solo show Ten Times I Should Have Known I Was Autistic. With heart, humor, and honesty, Keith shares his journey of self-discovery and late diagnosis, reflecting on how his art, relationships, and everyday experiences suddenly made sense through a new lens.

Robert and Keith talk about the courage it takes to turn vulnerability into art, the importance of representation, and how storytelling can help others see themselves more clearly. It’s a funny, heartfelt, and inspiring conversation about identity, acceptance, and finding your voice—on stage and in life.

Ten Times I Should Have Known I Was Autistic takes the stage at Theatre Row – Stage 1 in New York City on Tuesday, November 4, 2025, at 7:00 PM, as part of the United Solo Theatre Festival.

Available now on BroadwayWorld, Spotify, iHeart, Apple, and YouTube.
www.RobertBannon.com | IG: @RobertBannon
#TheRoundtable #KeithVarney #TenTimesIShouldHaveKnownIWasAutistic #Theatre #SoloShow #Neurodiversity #RepresentationMatters #AutismAcceptance #DetroitMeetsNYC

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Robert Bannon: It's the round table with me, Robert Bannon. So here on the round table, one of our favorite things, everybody, is when people do solo shows. So if you're listening to us on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeart or Spotify, what I know for a fact is it takes so much courage and bravery to do a solo show. It takes a certain kind of insanity to do a solo show, certainly. And this solo festival is something that we've been talking about and really love and enjoy so much because it's the place where you see all the up-and-coming great solo shows, a piece of humanity, a piece of heart, and the United Solo Theater Festival is coming. It's this November. And my next guest, everybody, has a show called Ten Times I Should Have Known I Was Autistic. Talk about a personal journey. Talk about timely. Talk about me in the middle of a school right now. I have students that Keith Varney is here. Keith, welcome.

[0:59] Keith Varney: Oh, thank you so much for having me. And I'm really honored to be here and excited to talk about it. And I think you put it exactly right. Doing a solo show is a very particular flavor of insanity. And I'm just going through that now. I'm like, oh yeah, this is a crazy thing to do. But Keith, you are a—if I'm wrong, please correct me—you write, you're a songwriter, you're a playwright, you are a writer, and have written, and your shows have been all around the country. Are they always— is this show based on you?

[1:33] Keith Varney: Yes, this is a completely autobiographical show. So this is—so my—I’ve had a couple of other autobiographical shows, but that's not all. I write plenty that aren't. But this is my first autobiographical work that is not a musical, and the first one that is a solo show. So I don't know what I'm putting myself through. While we're talking, before we get too deep in the woods, as they say here, Theater Row at Theater Number 1, 410, West 42nd Street. It's November 4th at 7 o'clock, and you can get your tickets at autisticshow.com. The link will be below us. So if you're listening to us or watching us, autisticshow.com. Reading this press release, I'm fascinated because much has been made. I'm a teacher, so I spend my days talking about kids and helping them.

And you are not somebody who was talking about autism at 12. This is something that came into your life at a different time and place. How did you come to it? And why do you feel the need to tell us about it, Keith, publicly?

[2:34] Keith Varney: I mean, that's a very good question. Yeah, so I didn't know that I was autistic until I was deep into my 40s, which was quite—it was—I describe it as being a complete shock to me and to no one else in my life. But it was—yeah, I mean, it's interesting you talk about being a teacher and dealing with neurodivergent kids probably all of the time, and the difference between the experience of neurodivergent kids today versus what I went through, because the type of autism I have was definitely not diagnosed in the 80s and 90s when I was growing up. So it's been a really fascinating excursion into my life and a way to understand myself in a way that I've been in therapy on and off for 30 years and always felt like there was this missing piece of information, this black hole of data in the back of my head that I had, you know, experiences I couldn't explain, feelings I didn't understand, and it was very frustrating to do all of that introspection and not know it.

And so discovering that I was autistic, it was like one of the biggest aha moments I've ever had that retroactively reframes every experience I've ever had, every relationship I've ever had. And so it's been this wonderful thing to discover and recontextualize one's life. And so, you know, and obviously, as a high masking autistic or level one, I don't know what people call it these days, because guess what? I'm new to all of this. This is all within the last year, so I am not an expert, I am not a doctor, I have a degree in operatic singing, so take everything with a grain of salt. But, you know, as somebody who masked this so well, even from myself, I feel like I have something to say to other people like me, right?

And I realized that as I was writing this show, and it didn't start off as a show. The way that I work through my life and I work through my experiences, my therapy is to write. I'm a writer, that's what I do. So I sat down and started writing these experiences and all that, and then I realized somewhere in between, like, oh, oh, this is a show, and then to figure out, well, what kind of show is this? And so—and realized almost to my sadness that it was a solo show. But it was—for me it was like I have this opportunity to open the door and welcome other late diagnosed neurodivergent in the same way that I was welcomed into that world, and you know, it's a world that I've always been a part of, but didn't know it.

And when I sort of—when this dawned on me, I sort of went up on TikTok and I found this community of other people who were just like me, who might have spent most of their entire lives feeling a little bit strange, feeling a little bit not normal and working so hard to hide it. And then we've built this community where we're all sort of teaching each other what it means to be autistic in this way and in this time. And so, you know, my primary goal with the show is to be entertaining, right? It's to have fun. It's not a dissertation. We're trying to have fun, but also I think there's a lot of experiences that I think people will find a little bit universal. And maybe there's some—well, I know that there are a lot of other folks who were just like me a year ago who were neurodivergent and didn't know it.

And I would love to provide a welcoming space for more of us to find each other and, you know, build this community. People, there was no word. I'd never heard of autism in school. I remember one student being taken out of our classroom and put into the, you know, the stereotypical other room and the stigma that was behind these kinds of things. I just spoke to a really good friend of mine who has a son and said, "My son feels like a square peg in a round hole. It can't try, doesn't fit in the way that he's supposed to." Has this always been something you felt like? I didn't fit in right? I didn't act the same way as everyone else. What were the signs that you now see, the ten times you could have known something that you didn't talk about or no one did talk to you about?

[7:06] Keith Varney: Oh, yeah. I mean, I absolutely felt that way my whole life, and it was sort of—I just felt just a little bit strange, a little bit abnormal, a little bit in a way that I felt behind everybody because I struggled a lot when I didn't understand what to expect. What were the social rules? What were the practical rules? And any time that I was uncomfortable because I didn't, you know, I didn't pick up on the social cue or the rules that were obvious to everybody else were not obvious to me. And so I would really feel so much anxiety and spent so much of my life pretending that I knew what I was doing and pretending that I knew, you know, what to expect when I didn't. And I think there was so much hidden and masked social anxiety that I was right from the very beginning.

Because I instinctually knew to mask it, nobody had any idea that I was in a room full of people all having a good time, pretending to have a good time so well that everybody thought I was having the best time, and I was the most comfortable person in the room, and I was definitely not. You know, so that—so obviously the social anxiety was a big part of it, need for routine. You know, as an adult now, I can recognize I'm somebody who functions really well within a structure, within a routine, and that I, you know, it is hard for me to break out of it, so I can build my life around having a really clear structure and routine. Obviously, I had very intense special interests was another—not surprisingly, if you can see the ridiculous amount of Star Trek action figures behind me.

I don't know how that—I don't know how a man can be 40-something and have a lit display of Star Trek action figures and not know he's autistic, but here I am. I love it. It speaks to my language. And you know, and I had the whole really the same relationship with theater.

[9:19] Keith Varney: So my special interests were super intense. Um, my sense of justice was super intense. I was a very polarizing kid because I also didn't really have much time for social hierarchy. Um, and so it just a lot of things that had I known that I was autistic, and again, you're a hundred percent right. There was no word for what I was at that time for what I was was difficult, right? And I was either anxious or challenging authority in a way that they did not understand, and so, you know, so it was there are a lot of challenges that come along with that. You know, there are also some benefits, right? Because it frequently comes with, you know, some the way that I look at the world, the way that I process information, you know, my musical obsession and abilities were right there from the very beginning.

So it was, you know, it was really hard to say because I can only speak for myself as opposed to what anybody else's experience, and every single neurodivergent is completely unique, and so my experiences are not going to be the same as other people's experiences, but it has been incredibly and I'm still at this point looking back into my childhood, into my life, and thinking, oh, that's why this was difficult, or that's why this was easy, or this is why, you know, this person didn't understand you, or this is why this teacher loved you, or this is why this teacher detested you. That's real life. I mean, I speak with a lot of colleagues, and I love this subject because I think we all need to be more educated on it.

I think there's a huge stigma about it. I think that there's a lot of misinformation about it. I think people think that there's a face and an image about it, and they don't understand the complexity of this. And there's so many adults who come from a generation where this wasn't talked about and they don't know what's going on. And now, was there shame and fear? And were you upset when you found that you had a very interesting way of finding out? I certainly did. I mean, it was sort of an accident, right? So it was for me, I found out through my best friend growing up. We were friends since we were in preschool, and he called me up and he was just like, hey, so I've just discovered that I'm neurodivergent, and just thinking, as we have a tremendous amount in common, have you ever considered that you might be too?

And you know, it's one of those things where people had been telling me, I mean, my ex-wife had been shouting it from the hilltop for a decade and a half, like, hey, you're autistic, and I'm like, what? I never even considered it. But that sort of kicked it off for me, and I don't know what made me think about it in more serious terms at that moment, but then I started digging in and then, you know, doing all of the research and speaking to folks and coming to terms with it. But to answer your question about like, was it scary? You know, I have had my first fear at the beginning was imposter syndrome, right? Which is a neurodivergent curse is imposter syndrome. You feel like you're a kid, you know, dressing up with a fake ID to buy beer on everything as an actor, as a writer, even as an adult, I feel like an imposter.

And so my first fear was that people wouldn't believe me. That people would think I was faking it or faking it for attention or something like that. And it was sort of like, oh, am I not autistic enough to count? Am I too good at masking? Um, and so that was what I dealt with at the beginning. You know, today this I started writing this show ten months ago. Well, a lot has happened in the last 10 months. And so the fear of being public about this is different than it was a year ago. And it is, I'll admit it is a little bit scarier every day to be putting this out there. But I also feel like there were so many people who had discovered they were neurodivergent a year ahead of me who reached back and welcomed me and taught me who I am, right?

And I think I feel it is my duty in some way to open the door for other people because I know how good it was for me. I know how meaningful it was for me and life-changing it was for me to understand this about myself and the other people around me because it doesn't just recontextualize your life. You look at everybody else in your life, and you know, neurodivergence, like many other types of people, whether or not we know it, we find each other, and you realize, oh, my whole community is like this, and it changes how I look at everybody and how I treat everybody, and more importantly, how I treat myself. So yes, it is a little scary, and I've been surprised by some people's reactions. You know, sometimes it's the people you least expect to be a little bit less welcoming or more challenging, and some people have been like, yeah, totally get it.

And so, you know, I, as a privileged straight white dude my whole life, it's a new, I will admit stepping out of the privilege into a community that people have not great feelings about sometimes, like it that has been a bit of a surprise and a bit of a challenge, but primarily it has been people have been very supportive. Um, and I'm excited to share it. It is for everybody, right? There's no like secret neurodivergent code. We're gonna be speaking in ones and zeros, right? It's a human story, it's a story about my growing up and lots of embarrassing stories and embarrassing childhood pictures. So be prepared for that, I say to myself. Um, but it is for people who are neurodivergent, people who might be and don't know it, which is my favorite audience, but it's also for everybody else, right?

So there are people who do have a really good understanding of a 2025 understanding of what neurodivergence means, but there's, and for them to see what it was like for people who didn't grow up in a world where, you know, maybe looking at your parents, maybe your, you know, your uncle, like what was it like for them who may or may not know that it was a different experience. Also for, like I said, for people who don't know they are who might be, but also for the generation behind that for our parents, you know, like my parents will be there, right? And to talk about like, you know, what it was like to grow up in that environment and to help in a welcoming and loving way. Uh, teach is the wrong word, but like sort of explain, hey, this is what was going on in my brain.

This is what might be going through the brains of other people that you love, and here's how you can support them a little bit, and create a welcoming, safe environment that becomes a little bit more inclusive for people with neurological differences, and whether it's autism, whether it's other types of neurodivergence or anything like that, we as a society have to our credit become much better at finding ways to embrace physical differences. But the, you know, we're still feel like we're in the very baby steps of understanding and accepting neurological differences, and I hope to create a fun, welcoming way to explore that a little bit. Um, so you know, but more importantly, it's hopefully it's just a fun time.

It's not a musical as a solo show because I'm already scared enough to have to add singing to it. It's terrifying. Um, but look, I write music. I write, you know, I work through my feelings and my thoughts through music as well. So will music be a part of this at some point? I don't know. Maybe. I hope that it has a life moving forward. Maybe I do an album about this. Maybe I work it into the show. Uh, you know, I have to hire a stunt person because I, you know, so I'd have less stage fright. But I come from the singing world. That's what I do.

[17:54] Keith Varney: So you told me you studied opera. I mean you were a classical singer.

[17:59] Keith Varney: I am, yeah.

[18:03] Keith Varney: And my first show, I got fired. I played myself and sang it as the musical. So maybe someday.

[18:12] Keith Varney: Maybe someday. Well, thank you so much for letting me talk about it. I really appreciate the opportunity. It's been a lovely chat.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred