Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Joe Fox Talks Don't Cry For Me, My Yeshiva! Here On The Roundtable!

Joe Fox is bringing audiences laughter, music, and plenty of heart with Don't Cry For Me, My Yeshiva!, his acclaimed autobiographical musical memoir. Raised as the adopted son of an Orthodox rabbi, Fox takes audiences on an unforgettable journey through faith, family, identity, and self-discovery... Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

23 mins
Jun 12

About

Joe Fox is bringing audiences laughter, music, and plenty of heart with Don't Cry For Me, My Yeshiva!, his acclaimed autobiographical musical memoir. Raised as the adopted son of an Orthodox rabbi, Fox takes audiences on an unforgettable journey through faith, family, identity, and self-discovery. Packed with clever musical parodies, touching personal stories, and Broadway flair, the show explores what it means to find your voice while honoring where you came from.

On this episode of The Roundtable with Robert Bannon, Joe opens up about the real-life experiences that inspired the show, including his unique childhood, his path to embracing his identity as a gay man, and the surprising twists that led him from documentary filmmaking to the cabaret stage. We discuss the power of storytelling, finding humor in life's challenges, and why audiences of all backgrounds have connected so deeply with his deeply personal and universally relatable tale.

Don't miss this inspiring and entertaining conversation with a performer proving that sometimes the most powerful stories are your own.

Follow Robert @RobertMBannon or visit RobertBannon.com for more interviews, entertainment news, and conversations with the artists shaping culture today.

#JoeFox #DontCryForMeMyYeshiva #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon #Broadway #OffBroadway #Cabaret #LGBTQ #Theater #MusicalTheatre #BroadwayWorld #Entertainment #Podcast #Interview #NYCTheatre #ArtsAndCulture

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Robert Bannon: Are you ready? It's the Roundtable with me, Robert Bannon. Well, welcome to the Roundtable, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon. You're listening to us on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeart and Spotify, wherever artists talk about art. And I have a fun one for you here tonight and today or whenever you're listening to that, it could be in the middle of the night. I'm just grateful you're here. Don't cry for me. My yeshiva is coming to the—I can't even say it without laughing. It's the most clever fun title to the 92nd—laugh away—the 92nd Street Y, iconic building. Most of the most incredible speakers, artists, actors, work is done there. And now Joseph Fox has got this one ready to roll into town. Congratulations. Welcome to the show.

[0:47] Joe Fox: Thank you. So glad to be here. I am excited that people can come see this show at 92ny.org and you could get your tickets to see it.

[1:01] Joe Fox: Well, that's a great question. So I describe my show as part musical parody and part memoir and part cry from the heart for us for everyone to be able to love the ones we choose. And it's about my life's journey. Um, in no particular order, I'm the gay adopted son of an Orthodox rabbi. It's not the easiest, as if you can imagine, it's not the easiest hand of cards to play. So my show is all about trying to find oneself. It's about trying to find one's place in this world. That's trying to make, you know, all those disparate pieces of identity come together. And it's ultimately, it's about landing at a place of acceptance. Maybe it's not a perfect place of acceptance, but it's still an acceptance of who you are. And it's very funny. How could it not be with a title like Don't Cry for Me, My Yeshiva? And very entertaining. Um, so you should all come and see it. How's that for a pitch?

[2:25] Robert Bannon: I think that was a perfect pitch to me. I think that that works for me. You are somebody who, in your career, life has made a lot of other works that are not on stage. Like you've done a lot of documentaries, and people may know you because you've kind of made some waves about same-sex marriage in Maine. And what—how do people—what is your—what that part of your story? How would people know you from Maine and what you accomplished up there?

[2:57] Joe Fox: Well, that would depend on who you ask. So, um, so the show is framed around my experience up in Maine when I was making a documentary on same-sex marriage. Um, it was a referendum battle. Um, they left it up to the people of Maine to vote whether or not we could have the right to marry or not. And in order for me—and that took place like back in 2009. So in order for me to gain access to both sides of each campaign, I had to end up going back into the closet at 48. So, you know, as I was making this documentary and as I was trying to sort of play it straight in the lobster state, I have no idea how anybody was fooled. Um, but they were. I mean, they bought it. Um, I felt a little bit like Nathan Lane of the Bird Cage, Mary Zava Gabor of Green Acres.

Um, so as I was trying—this is kind of a long-winded way of answering this question, but you know, not every story comes in a nice three-second package. Um, so as I was trying to connect to the other side, you know, I had a front row seat to the most incredible vitriol towards gay people. And it brought me back to certain places throughout my life of when I was starting out at my yeshiva, which is a Jewish school where I was basically indoctrinated that homosexuality—I grew up, you know, I'm not as young as I look. I grew up at a certain time when it's not the time that we're living in now. Um, it was the 70s, and you know, homosexuality—it's no picnic now either in some circles, but you know, homosexuality is drummed into you that it was a sin by my rabbis, and you could never be a good Jew if you were like that.

So that leaves a mark. And so here I was in Maine, trying to play once again, playing. So I went throughout my whole life, sort of as most people do, did sort of tamping down who I was and playing this cover story of who I wasn't. And then I got to a point where I kind of reached a certain kind of acceptance. And now here I was in Maine, and I had to end up reverting back to the place I was again. And that brought up a lot of, you know, you know that just—and I thought when I was doing this, like this whole like the backstory of my show should be the story of what it was like for me, you know, trying to, you know, be in the closet doing a sh—doing a documentary on same-sex marriage on a right to—on a right to marry.

But at the same time, the other element was I needed to connect with what I would call the other, which is a bad term to use because nobody should be called the other, but I needed to connect in a meaningful way to people from the other side.

[6:32] Joe Fox: And it was about how I needed to form an authentic relationship with people who did not see me as—who saw me as being less than human. So to answer your first question, how do people react to it? You know, when the movie came—the documentary came out, um, there was a lot of press. So, you know, the people who, you know, who were against gay marriage, um, I don't think—I mean, I think they saw it as my trying to get one over on them, but if one sees a documentary available on Amazon and Apple, um, called Question One, um, one will see that I really made such a strong effort to portray everyone with a sense of nuance. So I also thought this would make a great show. This would just one day does it make a great show?

And my cousin is Alex Edelman. I don't know, do you know who he is? So Alex Edelman did this one-man show that won the Yebby, won the Tony, won everything. Um, and that show is about how he, you know, amongst other things, how he infiltrated a Nazi meeting and he tried and he kind of went undercover and kind of pretended to be someone who he wasn't. And that kind of was—I always wanted to make this show, but when I saw this happening, I was like, well, all right, well, time to—this could be, you know, let me give this one a shot.

[8:14] Robert Bannon: And you did, and now it's here. And now people can get their tickets. It's June 21st at 7:30 at the 92nd Street Y. Go to 92nd Street Y's website, the link will be below. So you've been working—that was in 2009, the documentary. So this is 17 years later. So, how long have you been working on writing it? And what was it like for you to sit and write this story?

[8:41] Joe Fox: Well, I didn't really sit down in earnest to write this, you know, life happened. Um, I run a pretty successful documentary and film production company. Um, I made other documentaries other than that. I made a documentary on um, um, Japanese American internment camps during World War II. I did a documentary on um, you know, the first AIDS clinic in New York. Um, so I kept myself busy, and you know, this—the thought of this of doing the show came about maybe a couple years ago. I was taking a cabaret class, cabaret workshop, and at the end of each class you performed, and I thought, well, okay, let's—this could be my opportunity. So um, the actual writing of the show took me about three months to do.

Um, but I've been workshopping it a lot over the last couple of years. And once I put, you know, once I got my head around it, it really didn't take me that long to write it. But it's not just this—the book that, you know, that it's not just—it's not just a play. I also—um, I also took—um, it's also a part love letter to Broadway in a way. Like I took that Mot No Cry for me, my yeshiva, you know, so there—it's—I used songs, parodies to kind of create like chapter markers throughout the show. So I don't want people to think that my talent is just limited to the spoken word. They also wrote—I also wrote 10 songs.

[10:30] Robert Bannon: That's what I'm saying. He's got songs for you, he's got a whole everything. It has every—it won the 2025 Manhattan Association of Cabaret Best Director Award, has been nominated for a bunch of awards. So this is your opportunity to be able to see this show. I'm fascinated by your starting of this tip. Now you are a long story short, I'm assuming the happy ever after is you have a husband, you're out in Brooklyn, you're living a—you've been through the fire and trials of your growing up in life. Was it hard for you? And I know a lot of people don't—they say like the coming out story is done and they don't want to, but was it hard for you to finally come to accept yourself and come out after that childhood where you thought—because I'm Catholic and it's the same thing. You know, we were growing up in church, you're gonna go to hell if you're gay and you're—you know you're gonna grow up Jersey.

[11:19] Joe Fox: So I grew up in Jersey, Jersey.

[11:21] Robert Bannon: But did you grow up in like what part of it really does?

[11:25] Joe Fox: North Jersey, a month in Fort Lee, New Jersey.

[11:27] Robert Bannon: So right at the George Washington.

[11:29] Joe Fox: You saw the New York, able to see the New York Skyline jersey.

[11:33] Robert Bannon: Okay. How about you?

[11:35] Joe Fox: Where did I grow up? I grew up in um Boston.

[11:39] Joe Fox: Okay. Um I spent most of my adult life in New York, um, growing up there.

[11:46] Joe Fox: Um but you know, like a coming coming out, it's not just one and none, you know.

[11:55] Joe Fox: It's like, you know, the clock strikes 12 and you come out.

[11:59] Joe Fox: It's not like we're Cinderella at the mall.

[12:02] Joe Fox: Um so it was very, it was very difficult, you know, to do all of that.

[12:02] Joe Fox: It was very difficult to, you know, accept who you were.

[12:11] Joe Fox: It was very difficult to, you know, I also had the I'm also adopted.

[12:21] Joe Fox: So if being gay in an orthodox environment wasn't enough, I also had the adoption thing to deal with in terms of all these different pieces.

[12:32] Joe Fox: Um, but I think like coming out for me just took, you know, it was kind of like in pieces, you know, there were different, you know, events that happened that got me to a certain emboldened point where, you know, I just said, I don't know what your story is, but I just said, you know, enough is enough, and it's time to just, you know, what am I waiting for? Type of thing.

[13:02] Robert Bannon: Absolutely. Is it is it um very it must be very vulnerable? Is it freeing? Is it scary to stand on stage and sing and tell this story?

[13:11] Joe Fox: It's a very personal, vulnerable conversation that you're having up there and fun and jokes and all that stuff, but it's your baby.

[13:18] Joe Fox: Like this is your story that you're sharing.

[13:22] Joe Fox: I mean, it really isn't.

[13:24] Joe Fox: I mean the hard part was before you get on stage.

[13:32] Joe Fox: The hard part was I mean, I used to be an actor a thousand or two years ago.

[13:38] Joe Fox: So, you know, although this is my story, you know, the last thing that one wants to do is I mean, how many, how many self-indulgent one solo shows have you seen?

[13:50] Joe Fox: I've seen my share, you know.

[13:53] Joe Fox: So, you know, it wasn't about, you know, my going on stage and just bearing it all.

[13:59] Joe Fox: It was preparing to play a ver, you know, it's not playing a you had a I I wasn't I know I'm I'm like I'm not gonna tell you how old I am, but you probably know.

[14:11] Joe Fox: Um I'm not 16 anymore, but in order to authentically play a 16 version of myself, that was the hard thing of having to write journals and having to kind of get myself into the mind of doing that.

[14:26] Joe Fox: Once I get on stage, I wouldn't say it's easy, but it you know, just from this a technical point of view and having to hit what you have to hit.

[14:38] Joe Fox: And once I get on stage, it's just storytelling, and it's it's how the hard part is how do you engage your audience to come on board this ride and stay with you for 90 minutes?

[14:51] Robert Bannon: Yeah, and and entertain them and tell the story.

[14:53] Robert Bannon: I'm so fascinated.

[14:55] Robert Bannon: Yeah, I'm what a you have three things that are so universal yet unique that some so many people experience, but so many people don't experience, but maybe not every peop there's maybe not many people who experience all three at the same time.

[15:09] Robert Bannon: You're talking about growing up being adopted, being gay, being an orthodox Jew growing up.

[15:14] Robert Bannon: Was your real I don't try to be too personal, but I'm sure you talk about in the story.

[15:19] Robert Bannon: How was the relationship with your family?

[15:21] Robert Bannon: What was the was there was there a crux?

[15:24] Robert Bannon: Was it was there difficult times?

[15:25] Robert Bannon: Was the adoption part more difficult?

[15:27] Robert Bannon: Was the the coming at gay part more difficult?

[15:30] Robert Bannon: What was what was it like?

[15:31] Robert Bannon: How do you summise what it was like growing up for you?

[15:36] Joe Fox: Wow, that is one big question, isn't it?

[15:40] Joe Fox: Well, I'm so fascinated by your story.

[15:42] Robert Bannon: I may not get a ticket.

[15:43] Joe Fox: Well you're gonna come.

[15:46] Joe Fox: Um no, that was a serious question.

[15:49] Joe Fox: You're gonna come.

[15:50] Joe Fox: I'm gonna my show is on the 20th in New York City, so I'll be in New York.

[15:53] Robert Bannon: Oh, great.

[15:54] Robert Bannon: Okay, well, come, come, come, come.

[15:56] Joe Fox: Um much less entertaining.

[15:58] Robert Bannon: No, it's also entertaining.

[15:59] Robert Bannon: I won't I won't sell myself short.

[16:00] Robert Bannon: Go ahead, John.

[16:03] Joe Fox: Um so um I never told my parents that I was gay and never had that conversation, but not telling them that was hard, you know, but you know, I think the part about you know, I think it was my adoption that really was the toughest, was really the toughest thing in terms of how I needed to navigate who I was vis-a-vis my parents, you know, because um being adopted was its own coming out type of journey for me too, until I got to a point where I was able to it was like a like okay, it happened, but don't ever talk about it.

[16:54] Joe Fox: Um so it was kind of like a don't ask, don't tell policy of you know, you know, my my father was a rabbi, so you know everybody in this community knew that my mother just didn't show up one day nine months, you know, nine months with a baby, but it was one of those things where like just don't talk about it.

[17:12] Joe Fox: And um, you know, at that point where I was growing up, it was um, you know, my you know, it it wasn't like it is now, like with open adoptions and you know, um my parents viewed the adoption as being like something that happened in the past.

[17:37] Joe Fox: Let's forget about it and don't ever talk about it.

[17:41] Joe Fox: So, how does that when I wanted to go seek answers?

[17:47] Joe Fox: I wasn't exactly encouraged to do that.

[17:50] Joe Fox: So I think that was very challenging for me.

[17:54] Joe Fox: I think that's and the gay thing was no picnic either.

[17:58] Joe Fox: Just saying.

[18:01] Robert Bannon: What were the three things?

[18:02] Joe Fox: You said gay, you said you said gay.

[18:06] Joe Fox: No, it wasn't ascetic.

[18:07] Joe Fox: I grew up in an Orthodox modern orthodoxy.

[18:10] Joe Fox: Orthodox.

[18:11] Robert Bannon: Sorry, my apologies.

[18:12] Joe Fox: The Orthodox Jewish part, I mean, like you don't really know you grow up in that milieu.

[18:18] Joe Fox: You don't really really know what.

[18:21] Joe Fox: Although, you know, there was a rebel in me that when I was, you know, growing up, I would, you know, sneak non-kosher food, you know, right from an early age, it knew it wasn't quite for me.

[18:37] Robert Bannon: Joseph was a was an artist rebel rouser from the go.

[18:41] Joe Fox: Well, yes.

[18:43] Joe Fox: Yes.

[18:44] Robert Bannon: Exactly.

[18:44] Robert Bannon: If you feel like this story, and this is a good story, people, this is a this you got this story.

[18:49] Robert Bannon: Plus, you add how many you wrote 10 songs, 10 parody songs?

[18:52] Joe Fox: 12, if you must know.

[18:56] Robert Bannon: And you're and they're only charging $18.

[18:59] Joe Fox: I know.

[19:00] Robert Bannon: Really?

[19:00] Robert Bannon: That should be 180, right?

[19:02] Robert Bannon: I think this is before this is a movie, before this is a Broadway show, get it who get a ticket for 18.

[19:09] Robert Bannon: You can't get a pizza in New York for $18.

[19:11] Joe Fox: It's such a bargain.

[19:13] Robert Bannon: This is people should buy four.

[19:16] Robert Bannon: You should buy four and give them to friends.

[19:18] Robert Bannon: And you know this is Pride Month, everyone, and you are in New York City, which means you are gay, or someone you know, your neighbor is gay, or you're you know, someone is gay within or your doorman is gay, or your doorman is gay, or your husband is gay.

[19:35] Joe Fox: Hopefully, and what happens is my husband is also gay.

[19:40] Joe Fox: So when you know, Darius, I'm I hope I didn't spill the beans.

[19:44] Robert Bannon: So when you when you're all have something to do, you were looking for something to do at 7:30 at night, and it's going to be a Sunday night, and you're looking to celebrate but go home before you turn into a pumpkin.

[19:55] Robert Bannon: Then this is the night.

[19:57] Robert Bannon: This is the moment.

[19:58] Joe Fox: What's it been like to work for night with 92nd Street Y and them having you be a part of their their programming?

[20:03] Joe Fox: I couldn't believe it.

[20:05] Joe Fox: Like it was kind of flabbergasting.

[20:09] Joe Fox: Um flabbergasting, is that a word?

[20:11] Robert Bannon: You're the writer.

[20:13] Joe Fox: Fabbergast sure if I was flabbergasting.

[20:17] Joe Fox: Um it was really just um so unexpected, and just um just wonderful.

[20:26] Joe Fox: I mean, that's all I can that's all I could 92nd Street Y.

[20:32] Robert Bannon: Oprah.

[20:33] Robert Bannon: That's what I'm saying.

[20:34] Robert Bannon: Oprah and Joseph Fox are at the 92nd Street Y appearing at the same time.

[20:41] Joe Fox: See, this is Joseph.

[20:43] Joe Fox: This is why this story is so you this is an Oprah story, everyone.

[20:47] Robert Bannon: This is what I think.

[20:49] Robert Bannon: Oprah, are you listening?

[20:51] Joe Fox: Oh the song parodies.

[20:54] Joe Fox: I'm re Q the Barber Stry Sand, Gentle.

[20:57] Joe Fox: Okay, can you hear me?

[20:59] Joe Fox: Or can you hear me?

[21:01] Joe Fox: This is part two.

[21:03] Robert Bannon: I am excited for you.

[21:04] Robert Bannon: Congratulations.

[21:05] Robert Bannon: This is what an incredible, incredible story.

[21:07] Robert Bannon: Thank you for sharing your story because so many people are going to be able to be seen, so many people are going to be able to be heard, and so many people are going to be entertained and laugh and celebrate who they are.

[21:15] Robert Bannon: And that's because you shared your story.

[21:17] Robert Bannon: So it's wonderful and incredible.

[21:19] Joe Fox: So thank you for being here.

[21:20] Robert Bannon: Oh, thank you.

[21:21] Joe Fox: Yeah.

[21:22] Robert Bannon: Well get your tickets, people.

[21:24] Robert Bannon: Go right now.

[21:25] Robert Bannon: You can get a ticket.

[21:27] Robert Bannon: You all you gotta do is go click 92ny.org, and you can be right there on 92nd Street in Lexington at the legendary 92nd Street Y.

[21:36] Robert Bannon: And Oprah will want you to do that.

[21:38] Robert Bannon: Oprah over at Oprah will you might get a car.

[21:41] Robert Bannon: You don't even know what's gonna happen.

[21:42] Robert Bannon: You gotta go.

[21:43] Robert Bannon: What could be under your seat?

[21:46] Robert Bannon: Like, you know.

[21:47] Joe Fox: It could be anything.

[21:49] Joe Fox: It could be it could be anything.

[21:51] Joe Fox: Anything.

[21:52] Robert Bannon: I think this is anybody.

[21:53] Robert Bannon: Or any that's insert your own joke here.

[21:59] Robert Bannon: Okay.

[22:02] Robert Bannon: Happy Pride.

[22:03] Robert Bannon: Come one.

[22:04] Robert Bannon: Come one.

[22:05] Robert Bannon: Come on.

[22:06] Robert Bannon: Happy Pride, Joseph.

[22:06] Joe Fox: Thank you for being here.

[22:07] Joe Fox: Yeah, happy Pride to you too.

[22:09] Joe Fox: I look forward to seeing you and I'll be there.

[22:11] Joe Fox: I'll come to see your show.

[22:13] Joe Fox: Um, all right.

[22:14] Joe Fox: Thank you so much for having me.

[22:16] Joe Fox: Much love.

[22:16] Robert Bannon: Thank you for being here.

[22:17] Joe Fox: All right.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred