Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Karin McCracken & Simon Leary Check In To HEARTBREAK HOTEL!

Karin McCracken and Simon Leary are here diving into the wildly original and emotionally electric Heartbreak Hotel, now playing Off-Broadway at the DR2 Theatre!.. Read More

From the show: The Roundtable with Robert Bannon

18 mins
Mar 27

About

Karin McCracken and Simon Leary are here diving into the wildly original and emotionally electric Heartbreak Hotel, now playing Off-Broadway at the DR2 Theatre! Created by acclaimed New Zealand company EBKM, this hilarious and heartfelt two-hander follows one woman navigating the aftermath of a six-year relationship—while Leary brilliantly transforms into every man in her life along the way. Packed with lo-fi covers of iconic breakup songs, awkward Tinder dates, and raw honesty, this 75-minute ride blends comedy, concert, and catharsis into one unforgettable experience.

In this conversation, Karin and Simon open up about building this deeply personal yet universal story, the surprising role of science and emotion in the show, and how heartbreak can actually bring humor, healing, and connection. From synth-driven storytelling to sharp, witty writing and transformative performances, Heartbreak Hotel is the breakup story you didn’t know you needed—until now. Trust us, you’ll laugh, you’ll feel, and yes… you might text your ex after this one.

Watch The Roundtable With Robert Bannon On BroadwayWorld, YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, IHeart & More!
For More: RobertBannon.com | @RobertBannon

#HeartbreakHotel #OffBroadway #KarinMcCracken #SimonLeary #Theatre #NYCTheatre #BreakupStories #LiveTheatre #BroadwayWorld #TheRoundtableWithRobertBannon #TalkShow #EntertainmentNews #TheBestIsYetToCome

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Robert Bannon: Well, welcome to the round table, everybody. My name is Robert Bannon. You're listening to us on Broadway World over here on the Broadway Podcast Network, iHeart, Spotify. I am excited because HEARTBREAK HOTEL. Firstly, when you tell me you give me a show that's 75 minutes of theater at its best, my ADD says, yes, I need that. I need 75 minutes. I am so excited to talk to it. It's a limited engagement from March 20th till April 19th. You can get tickets right now at Heartbreakhotelplay.com. I believe we have some of the people who are gonna tell us all. I know that you both are here. You both know a whole bunch about it, and you're gonna give us the full scoop about who should see it. Welcome to the round table.

[0:47] Karin McCracken: Thank you so much, Robert. Good to meet you.

[1:04] Simon Leary: And I am Simon Leary, and I am Karin's co-star in the play. I'm a working actor from New Zealand, Aotearoa, New Zealand, at the bottom of the world.

[1:17] Robert Bannon: I want to go there. I want to, okay. I'm coming to your house, and I'm gonna stay on your couch.

[1:24] Simon Leary: And if you come out over and when if you need a couch to stay on, please come stay with me.

[1:28] Robert Bannon: Done. You and Karin and Eleanor are in something called the EBKM. What is that? Can you explain what it is?

[1:39] Simon Leary: M is just our initials together. So Eleanor Bishop and Karin McCracken. It's our theater company that we run down in New Zealand. Calling it EBKM was probably the least creative decision we've ever made, but at the time it felt right. So we did that. But yeah, we run a theater company, we make shows and we tour them internationally.

[2:03] Robert Bannon: So for a show like this, Simon, you both are coming from far, far from New York and now having a show here in New York City running off Broadway. Simon, when did you first read this? How long have you been a part of it?

[2:15] Simon Leary: Yeah, I think would it have been 2023 when it started? Yeah, I got on board just they needed an actor to basically hear it out loud for the first time. So Karin and I were very good friends and we've worked together a bunch. Did we live together at that stage? No, we didn't.

[2:37] Simon Leary: So just like, hey, we'll chuck you 50 bucks, come down and read. And then, yeah, by the end of the read-through, it got to the point where they were both looking at each other, going, so has this thing got legs? Like, what do we think about this? Simon, did this part make sense? And then they looked to me and I'm just leaking. Can I just have five minutes because you've just written a play about me. Yeah, is what it felt like. The beauty of this play is it feels so, I mean it feels very specific to the character that Karin plays, but also just incredibly universal as well. Just the emotions and the stories that she's able to touch on.

[3:21] Robert Bannon: Well, Karin, is that the intention of the show? What’s the show about? You tell us what how do you describe it?

[3:27] Karin McCracken: Well, I wouldn't say the intention is to make the audience leak from the eyes.

[3:31] Robert Bannon: I think you make grown men cry, Karin. That's what you're trying to do.

[3:35] Karin McCracken: Yeah, I should say from the eyes.

[3:37] Robert Bannon: From the eyes. Oh, that's good.

[3:41] Karin McCracken: Well, what I wanted to do when I was writing the show was to write a piece of work about heartbreak that took heartbreak seriously as a physiological and emotional condition that we go through, that almost everyone goes through. And I think there's a lot of voices in the culture that sort of minimize heartbreak as a kind of twee or almost childish event that you just need to spend two days thinking about and then getting over. And that was simply not my experience of heartbreak. And when I was trying to find things in the culture to soothe me, it was very hard because either they were really inauthentic and not true to my experience of heartbreak, or as far as I could tell, other people's experiences of heartbreak, or extremely grim and like it's like a kind of like and you'll never recover, and that's the end of the story.

And so I was really looking to write something that felt true and felt honest and also was funny. Because lots of heartbreak is funny. So and what it does to your body. So a big part of the research was the sort of the scientific processes that your body goes through when it's dealing with grief.

[5:02] Robert Bannon: Oh, I'm obsessed because I'm a happily married, my husband is around the corner. But when you go through your once you get through the heartbreak, there are so many at a certain age, I'm 42 years old, and you go through the litany of things that have happened, you really can find a lot of humor and laughter, but you also remember how devastating and sad and the physical reaction that you have to heartbreak as an illness, as you literally feel sick or do not feel yourself. So it's a universal feeling that we all have gone through. So I'm sure there's something for everybody to hear and see and laugh and cry about in the show.

[5:39] Karin McCracken: Yeah, yeah. And it's definitely not a show that's just for people who are heartbroken. Although we do find that people who are heartbroken do tend to find the show, which is great. But yeah, I mean, if you've ever been through it, I think you'll find something that's resonant in it for you. Yeah, I think we've had people talk to us before as well who saw it and then loved the show, whatever, then came back to us six months later or whatever. They were happily in a relationship at the time, and then they broke up with the person after having seen the show. Not it didn't make them break up. But then they had actually received a whole bunch of tools from the show to go, oh, here's what I'm experiencing. I'm in this phase right now. This will pass, but acknowledge these moments.

[6:30] Simon Leary: Simon is not telling you that you will break up with your partner and leak. That is not gonna happen. Unless that's what you're looking for, then come on down.

[6:40] Robert Bannon: Look, even if you bring your boyfriend, girlfriend, partner, husband, wife, whomever, then you just look at them when the show's over and say, Don't do that to me. Make sure you treat me right, have a good moment together. Simon, how many people do you play in this show? Because you play all the men.

[6:52] Simon Leary: Yeah, I should, I really should count, but I think I think it's five.

[6:59] Robert Bannon: Yeah, not all men.

[7:01] Simon Leary: Oh, spoiler alert.

[7:03] Robert Bannon: Spoiler alert.

[7:05] Simon Leary: I would say five or six, yeah.

[7:07] Robert Bannon: So, Karin, how does the show come to New York City? Who saw it? How did they find it? And what's that been like for you as the writer and one of the people in it and have spending so many years working on this?

[7:21] Karin McCracken: Yeah, the journey's been interesting. So we've done a bunch of touring with the show. But the thing that led us here directly was we did Edinburgh Fringe in 2024. And Ryan Lechworth and Krista Scott Reed from Occasional Draw were in Edinburgh and sold a show then. And pretty quickly after that, they started talking with us about the possibility of coming to New York, which we were very excited about. But obviously when you're living in New Zealand, it's not always totally straightforward, but they've made it kind of as straightforward as possible. And lo and behold, here we are, and we're so excited. I mean dream come true kind of stuff.

[8:06] Karin McCracken: It's yeah, yeah. Just walking around New York and going, oh, here's all this stuff you see in media, like there's that charging bull. That's extremely specific because we're staying down in the five hours.

[8:20] Robert Bannon: I was gonna say that's very Wall Street.

[8:22] Karin McCracken: That's very, very. I want people while we're talking to be able to go get their tickets. You can go, like I said to Heartbreakhotelplay.com right now, you only have until April 19th, so you better go get your tickets. It's playing at DR2 Theater, which is down on 15th Street, hence why they're over by Wall Street because they're downtown. And you can get tickets. What I love about what you all are doing is that a lot of times people say theater outprices them, they can't afford to go see a show. But these tickets start at $29 and then they don't go up past $129. So if you want to sit dead center front, front, front, you got a hundred bucks on you, you can do that. And if you only got 29 and you can you could get a slice of pizza and go see original new creative work then you're not outpriced to see this show everyone can see it. How important is it for you, Karin, to make theater accessible that people can come see this without having to, you know, spend 500 to see Harry Potter in a play they can come with 30 bucks?

[8:57] Karin McCracken: Massively, hugely. I mean, yeah, anyone who's involved in making theater knows that if they're making theater it's because they love theater and you at some point you've probably been really broke and not being able to afford to go and it absolutely sucks and theater should be a place where everyone can spend time together and that means it needs to be financially accessible.

[9:39] Simon Leary: So I'm so thrilled that occasional draw has made that choice. I love that too. So Simon, it says in your bio that you are a core collaborator with eBKM. What has it been like to work with them, and what's it been like to be somebody who there's only two people in the show, right? So what's it feel like to be the person that Karin has flown over the oceans and across the continents to bring to New York City? Yeah, well, genuinely, it has been life-changing. Well, just the scope of this company as well, the way that they're able to look out. I've been very blessed to get a lot of work in one of our local theaters back in Wellington, New Zealand, which has been incredible just for getting the hours on the boards.

You learn so much just by getting up in front of an audience and having a plan, doing so many different texts. But what ABKM can do is create these big shows with a lot of scope and, I guess, tourability as well. So it's kind of been my ticket overseas. It's been a ticket to some of the best theater I've felt I've ever done. And yeah, it's just honestly my favorite people to work with as well. Just being on stage with Karin is, yeah, she does a lot of the acting for you, which is quite good, you know? Like you're being fed constantly, so it's so easy just to come back at her. I feel like we've got great chemistry, so just an awesome touring partner as well.

[11:15] Robert Bannon: And Karin, you could have recast Simon. You could have found some American, you could have found some Broadway superstar, but you chose to find Simon and put him up in his home room over by the Wall Street and send him to New York. Only let him look at the charging bull. That's the way I see the charging bull.

[11:36] Simon Leary: I'm happy, I'm happy.

[11:37] Robert Bannon: I better see your Instagram, Simon. And I want a selfie with the bull. If there's not a selfie with the bull up on social media, then I don't even believe you're here in the United States.

[11:46] Simon Leary: I'll be riding it.

[11:48] Robert Bannon: Yes, please, that's what you need. So why can't we keep Simon, Karin? We could have broken up with him. You could have broken up with him; it would have fit the show.

[11:56] Karin McCracken: Um, it's true. No, Simon's really like second to none. He's very modest and humble, but he's an extraordinary actor, and yeah, I think kind of the best actor in New Zealand, probably. But also a fantastic person to have in the room. Like he knows when to pipe up and to be like, this line isn't quite... I think there's another line, or his instincts are really, really strong, and he's great to travel with and to spend time with, and we're like very, very close friends. Um, yeah, I would hate to have to recast or ever do the show without him.

[12:38] Simon Leary: And that's on the record.

[12:40] Karin McCracken: On the record.

[12:40] Simon Leary: It's on the record.

[12:41] Robert Bannon: Now I need Karin and Eleanor to get on the bull with Simon, because you all just seem like three amigos, three musketeers. So what's it like to work? Uh, that you co-artistic directed this, Karin. Co-artistic director is this. Simon, what was it? What's it like in terms of the artistic part? Eleanor directing and co-directing this as well. Has it changed when it comes to a new space? Is there a lot of new adjustments, or do you re-examine the script, or do you take it as is and just put it up there? Hit me with a spotlight and let's go.

[13:12] Simon Leary: Yeah, right on. Um, well, yeah, I mean, Eleanor, again, somebody with incredible instincts and, um, yeah, just ways to just like, she's definitely not an oppressive director at all. I think she loves the people that she's got in front of her and is going, here's where you're winning. And what if we tried this? Let's go. Um, yeah, and so yeah, she's got the way her mind works is incredible. Um, in terms of all the different seasons, because what are we up to now? 73 shows or something like that that we've done or something over a bunch of different seasons. Um, yeah, now she'll go, hey, can I, can you receive a note right now? And it's always yes, of course, of course. Let's play. Um, but yeah, no, she's very delicate with us. Uh, and yeah, just great feminine energy. Uh, she knows what she wants and is very playful as well.

[14:16] Karin McCracken: I love it. I think it sounds like such a wonderful night of theater. It's a time where you can go get a ticket and see the show. The shows are usually, uh, it looks like they're like seven or eight o'clock. You have a 75-minute show, you can still have dinner beforehand or dinner after, have a drink, take a special night out, bring your friends, bring your relationship, and go see the show. Karin, for you, um, it must be based, I'm assuming, in something that happened to you. Uh, it must be, is it triggering or traumatic to talk about breakups every night, or is there a no?

[14:47] Karin McCracken: She's like, I break up with people on a daily basis.

[14:50] Karin McCracken: No, no, no. Every day. No, no. What it is is, uh, no, it's fun. It's fun, and it's um, not triggering. I mean, people want to talk to us about their breakups all the time after the show. People also want to have a drink with us and laugh about the insane things they did when they were heartbroken. Um, but it's also that thing like when you do something enough times, you know, you have quite a little distance from the immediate, like personal elements. Um, so yeah, no, I definitely wouldn't say it's traumatic or triggering. Um, yeah, we get to yell at each other and cry on the show and like be best mates, like dancing in a club on certain drugs. And I really would stress it, uh, it's certainly for the first half of the show, people are laughing a lot more than any other kind of reaction. So that's very fun for us.

[15:52] Simon Leary: Yeah.

[15:52] Karin McCracken: And I love them. The music seems to play a very intricate part in the show as well. Uh, it talks about like famous breakup songs in lo-fi, which is what all the young kids listen to. And my students in my high school do their work to it. And it gets, I realize how old I am because I mean, no, I mean, I'm glad to hear what the kids are up to. I don't know what they're up to, so it's good that you have like a finger on that pulse. You're on the pulse because you wrote a whole show with the music that they're listening to.

[16:20] Karin McCracken: Yeah, I mean, I guess that's like a happy accident. Um, all we wanted to do when I was writing, I love watching performers work really hard at something maybe they're not organically very good at, and I'm not a musician, and so it's like what if I learned the synth and played the synth for people, and they can see that it's hard for me, and I'm really trying to do something. Um, and then we just had really a great time picking famous breakup songs and then me learning them.

[16:49] Robert Bannon: Well, you did it. You did it.

[16:51] Karin McCracken: Done.

[16:53] Robert Bannon: Thank you. It's a wrap. I want people to know that you can go to HeartbreakHotelPlay.com. Get your tickets. The show is running until April 19th. It says this one's for the young hearts, the old hearts, and the broken hearts. So that means literally anybody. You're old, you're young, you're happy, you're sad, you're in love, you're broken up with. You may find your next great love next to you at the show. You don't even know.

[17:15] Karin McCracken: You know, oh, this is it. Congratulations. Thank you for being here. Welcome, welcome. See, welcome to the states. Welcome to being here off-Broadway. I hope you have an incredible, amazing time. I'm sure this is not the end of it. I hope, Karin, you got more shows written up your sleeve. You're ready to come back.

[17:31] Karin McCracken: Working on it, definitely working on it.

[17:33] Robert Bannon: I know it. The best is yet to come. Thank you both so much for being here. Congratulations.

[17:40] Karin McCracken: Thank you so much, Robert.

[17:42] Robert Bannon: Get your tickets, everybody. Grab them, grab them while you can.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred