Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Makers: Billy Eichner: Man on the Street, Risk Taking + Saying What You Need to Say

This week, Susan and Laura have the pleasure of speaking with Billy Eichner about his many creative endeavors, including Man on the Street, Friends from College, and making his singing debut on The James Corden Show... Read More

From the show: The Spark File with Susan Blackwell and Laura Camien

1 h 27 mins
2/1/21

Featured Shows

About

This week, Susan and Laura have the pleasure of speaking with Billy Eichner about his many creative endeavors, including Man on the Street, Friends from College, and making his singing debut on The James Corden Show. We even get a glimpse into the new gay rom-com he's writing, plus some truly helpful advice -- stand up for yourself, say what you need to say to get the quality of work you envision.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Susan Blackwell: When I bump into something that inspires me, I jump into my spark file.

[0:14] Laura Camien: Spark file.

[0:19] Susan Blackwell: To be something that I wanna make or how I wanna be, I pump it in my spark file.

[0:28] Laura Camien: I jump into my spark file.

[0:32] Susan Blackwell: Let's open up the spark file.

[0:37] Laura Camien: Welcome to the Spark File, where we believe that everyone is creative, but smart creative people, you know you don't have to go it alone, baby.

[0:44] Susan Blackwell: I'm Susan Blackwell.

[0:46] Laura Camien: And I'm Laura Camien. If you're joining us for the first time, welcome. But you may be asking yourself, what exactly is a spark file? Where do I get a spark file? What do I file in my spark file? These are such good questions, and we've got answers.

[0:58] Susan Blackwell: Yes, we do. A spark file is a place where you consistently collect all your inspirations and fascinations. And if you're anything like us and you're making stuff all the time, you already know that sometimes the wellspring of inspiration can run a little dry. We're here to refill it.

[1:16] Laura Camien: Yes, we're on the lookout for fresh ideas, images, and inspiration that spark our creativity and pique our curiosity. Things that inspire us to get up off of our asses and make things like this podcast.

[1:28] Susan Blackwell: Or a man on the street interview that will quiz you right in the face. Or a heartfelt performance of a song or an impassioned campaign of political activism. Or the voice of an animated meerkat. Or a television show celebrating your friendships and weirdness.

[1:45] Laura Camien: On today's MakerSode, we're gonna talk with someone who truly sparks us. And that special someone is Billy Eichner.

[1:50] Susan Blackwell: Billy!

[1:53] Laura Camien: Billy! Welcome to the Spark File!

[1:58] Billy Eichner: Hi.

[1:59] Susan Blackwell: Very excited to be sparked.

[2:02] Laura Camien: Strap in, sister. We're so happy you're joining us today. But we want to start by asking you where you are right now.

[2:16] Billy Eichner: Okay. I am in Los Angeles.

[2:19] Laura Camien: West Hollywood specifically.

[2:21] Billy Eichner: I won't give you my street address, but I'm sure West Hollywood is a shock to anyone that knows you. And uh yeah, I'm here. And what else did you want to know? How am I doing?

[2:33] Laura Camien: How are you doing? But for reals, how are you doing?

[2:36] Billy Eichner: For real, how am I doing? Yeah, I'm fine. I'm healthy. COVID, the COVID situation here is probably at its peak right now, the worst that it's been. We had it fairly easy early on when New York and other parts of the country were really struggling. And now it's our turn, unfortunately. But I'm lucky, you know, very, very lucky. I'm healthy, and I'm just trying to stay safe and work as much as I can. And you know, what else can you do? That's pretty much it.

[3:13] Billy Eichner: I've shot a TV show and it was fully like shields up masks and then all of a sudden, like it's almost like you're going into an operating room where everybody else is masked, and the actors have to like there's a moment right before where you have to take off that shield. And it feels weird and exciting because you haven't been around strangers unmasked in months.

[3:36] Laura Camien: How has it been for you?

[3:38] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I've done a handful of TV projects, just like a few days here, a few days there, since the summer. And yeah, it's exactly what you're describing. It's strange. On one hand, you're happy to be out of the house and happy to be working, and it feels more normal, and it's just good to get lost in something and have something to focus on. At the same time, actors are in a very peculiar position because we are literally the only people who for some reason everyone decided it was okay that we're in small spaces taking off our masks and performing with each other.

[4:17] Billy Eichner: And yes, everyone is getting tested and they take every COVID protocol they can. But you know, productions were shutting down left and right because people were testing positive. I'm on a show off and on right now that was supposed to start this week, but instead, you know, I think I now they don't need me till February, you know. Everyone is doing the best they can. I mean, I don't know, it's a tricky one. Like you want to work, people need to work.

[4:51] Laura Camien: It kind of tells you how much people need their content, right? They've gone through everything on Netflix.

[5:00] Billy Eichner: Well, it tells you how much of the economy in California is based on the entertainment industry, is what it really does. And also how powerful the studios are in terms of lobbying the government, but not that we need to get into that right now.

[5:15] Susan Blackwell: But this is the Spark File.

[5:16] Laura Camien: We'll get all the political on the Spark File.

[5:22] Susan Blackwell: All right, then I think it's time for the Spark File price of admission, Billy. Real quick, can you tell us a creative risk that you've recently taken?

[5:33] Billy Eichner: Yeah. Obviously, it's been an unusual year. So it's not like I've been performing all the time. But I did a cool thing which I was very nervous about and which definitely felt risky to me. I don't know if it's the riskiest thing anyone's ever done, but it felt risky to me. I so I um one of the few things I was able to shoot this year was I was part of Mariah Carey's Christmas spectacular on Apple.

[6:01] Laura Camien: All right. God, you and your new bestie Mariah Carey.

[6:05] Billy Eichner: She's really lovely and great, and she's a blast, and she was very nice. I feel like she really pursued your friendship.

[6:13] Laura Camien: Yes, we really can you blame her?

[6:15] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I mean again she just got she's got good taste, but I was like, God damn, Billy, I'm gonna be a very small story. I know it's funny, yeah. I mean, it's so unexpected. But she you know, she did Billy on the Street last year. She's a big, big fan of Billy on the Street, and then I was surprised out of nowhere when things were a little quieter COVID-wise, like back in September. Yeah, um, she asked me if I would be part of her Christmas special, which was very exciting and super fun and just silly, and it was the perfect thing to do because you know, it wasn't like a very serious, you know, project, but it was big and it was fun, and yeah, Mariah's a blast.

[6:57] Billy Eichner: But anyway, as part of promoting that, I did the James Corden show.

[7:02] Laura Camien: Yes.

[7:04] Billy Eichner: And they, you know, they asked me what I wanted to do, and I had an idea that I would sing, and part of that came from the fact that people don't know, but when I started out, literally as a child, the first thing I did that got me on stage before I even thought about acting or comedy was the fact that I could sing really well.

[7:25] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[7:26] Billy Eichner: As a kid. And then when I went to that's what I did as a kid, I just thought I would do Broadway. I was obsessed with Broadway. I grew up in New York, so I saw a ton of shows, plays, musicals. And then I went to Northwestern and I was in the musical theater program there. And then, you know, life took a turn. I went down the comedy lane, and that's kind of what, you know, got me my break, I guess you could say.

[7:50] Billy Eichner: Um and then last year I did a voice in the Lion King remake, and I was supposed to go on Corden and sing from The Lion King for that. But things got too crazy. There was so much press around that movie, and I was very nervous about singing. I wanted it to go well because you know, people are so snarky, and if the minute you try something new, you have to really do it well.

[8:19] Laura Camien: Of course because you were just running around doing press junkets and you couldn't prepare properly, yeah.

[8:30] Billy Eichner: Exactly. They wanted me to sing well, the song we decided that I would sing was Can You Feel the Love Tonight? Because I sing some of it in the movie, but it was ultimately in the movie being sung by like Beyoncé, and I was like, why am I? I'm gonna go on James Corden. Nobody wants this.

[8:49] Laura Camien: Yeah, exactly.

[8:50] Billy Eichner: So we didn't do it then, but when it came time to do Corden this year, I was just thinking, you know, what can we do that's fun? It came at the end of a terrible year. And I thought, well, now I have a time. I'm sitting around doing nothing, so maybe I can sing. And I was like, I can zoom with my vocal coach, yes.

[9:09] Billy Eichner: Exactly. And um, and I was in the Mariah special, which I don't sing in, but it's mostly music and it's the holidays, and I thought, okay, this feels organic for me to go on and sing. And you know, I sang, I sang this old Mariah song, this obscure ballad from her Christmas album. Like fully produced, like fully like I mean, like the lighting and the well, yeah, that part was surprising, and I have to say I was really grateful and appreciative because you know, I'm not known as a musical guest or a singer. So the fact that Corden gave me all that time, yeah, um, and allowed me to be the musical guest, and I got to go into the studio, and I got there, and they had like created a set for it and lights, and like you said, it was really beautiful, and I was nervous as hell.

[10:01] Billy Eichner: I mean, I think I was as nervous as I've ever been to do anything on TV.

[10:07] Laura Camien: Oh because it's singing, you know.

[10:11] Billy Eichner: Yes, yes, yes, of course.

[10:12] Laura Camien: Who are you talking to?

[10:14] Billy Eichner: Of course, yes, of course, of course. And people don't know that you sing. I'm singing a freaking Mariah Carey song. She's like the greatest singer in the world. You know, so I there was any number of things I could be worried about, but I decided to do it because ultimately I really wanted to.

[10:31] Laura Camien: And I actually realized that I realized that sentence you just said, I love it. You did it because you wanted to do it. I love that. Sorry, go forward.

[10:40] Billy Eichner: No, no, no, I'll wrap this up. But um, when I was doing The Lion King recording it, you know, I got to go into the studio and record the songs. And that was the first time I've ever sung professionally.

[10:54] Billy Eichner: Um and I had a couple of songs, and I wasn't when they hired me for Lion King, John Favreau, the director, he didn't even know I could sing. You know, they were hiring me to play Timon just because they wanted someone funny.

[11:07] Laura Camien: Were they gonna have somebody else sing your part or just do it comically?

[11:11] Billy Eichner: Auto-tune you where they can all yeah, exactly. They didn't feel, you know, I mean, Seth Rogan played Pumba, he's like notoriously not a singer, you know. So um, and you know, singing is not, you know, something that comes terribly natural to him. So they just they hired us because they thought we would be a funny pair, and they didn't think that Timon and Pumba, you know, you can talk through Hakuna Matata, you know, you can get away with it.

[11:34] Billy Eichner: And so then I went to it, yeah. Exactly.

[11:39] Laura Camien: Yeah, that's it.

[11:40] Billy Eichner: But then I went in and did it, and honestly, just the experience of recording in the studio was I was just shocked because I loved it so much.

[11:51] Laura Camien: You just took to it, and I remembered, oh wait, this is the thing that I wanted to do.

[11:56] Billy Eichner: Like and do you think you'll do more of it? Like, I'm so curious. Has this like opened up a little part of you that's like, yeah.

[12:06] Billy Eichner: Not much came out of me singing in The Lion King because you know, you're looking at a meerkat singing, you're not seeing my face.

[12:12] Laura Camien: That's right.

[12:13] Billy Eichner: So that's right. Unless you were a friend of mine who like were really focused on it, that people thought, Oh, yeah, he can carry a tune. But again, you know, that's not a big thing.

[12:21] Laura Camien: That meerkat can really fucking sing.

[12:23] Billy Eichner: Exactly. That's what they thought. Get me that meerkat on the phone. I was like, why are you making me lower in the mix?

[12:29] Laura Camien: Um but um wait, you want people to hear Beyoncé singing?

[12:34] Billy Eichner: Oh, okay.

[12:35] Laura Camien: But when I did Corden, you could see my face, and I'm really singing in a more like legitimate, non-charactery way.

[12:44] Billy Eichner: Too legit.

[12:44] Laura Camien: Yeah, yeah.

[12:45] Billy Eichner: I want to shout out to James Corden and his team because I love what you said about like it felt like a risk for you, but it also felt like he and his team were like fully supporting you, like you had this, yeah.

[12:57] Laura Camien: I don't know, this whole like cushion around you, like a net of safety that's like here, we're gonna build this around you. You will not, you know, there's no way you'll fail. We've got you, and also that was extremely we're gonna swaddle you in red lights, yes.

[13:14] Billy Eichner: I mean, yeah, it was very flattering lighting, so we all appreciate that, and it was just great. And I you know, we put a clip like everything else the night it aired, it airs at like 1:30 in the morning. I don't know who's watching, but of course, it's the next day when the clip goes online.

[13:31] Billy Eichner: That's right, and people, you know, in a in what is usually a very, very snarky social media world, especially when someone is trying something new, people were so nice about it, and so good. And I got such a great reaction, and you know, from strangers, from followers, from my own agents and managers and things, you know, like all because they just never you can really sing, yeah, exactly.

[14:00] Laura Camien: Can I can I ask you a real specific question?

[14:02] Billy Eichner: Yeah.

[14:02] Laura Camien: Because you just said it's one of the most nervous-making things you've ever done on television. How did you in the moment, in the moments leading up to it, in the moment right before, how were you managing your nervousness? For those of us who struggle with such things, what did you do about it?

[14:25] Billy Eichner: I don't have any particular process. All I can tell you is that it's not the first time I've been very nervous.

[14:34] Susan Blackwell: Um, but I know you do you're uh you're a uh you're a high flyer, you're a big wave rider. You do like big high visibility projects, but also I just think about like you uh doing Billy on the Street, where you are just like, I'm gonna wily coyote off this cliff full speed ahead.

[14:53] Billy Eichner: Yeah.

[14:54] Susan Blackwell: So I think your body is is accustomed to. I've always thought this, your body's accustomed to a uh processing a lot of adrenaline so that your comfort zone is a little more expanded than the average bear.

[15:08] Billy Eichner: But that's singing on 100%.

[15:10] Billy Eichner: That's 100% correct.

[15:12] Susan Blackwell: But I still think this thing that you did singing on James Corden, it's and I don't think I'm making this up. Like when I was watching the interview before the song, and you were like, you you were fully like, I'm nervous. That actually is a technique to be to just acknowledge it in a very human, authentic way is an approach. But I also was like, oh, you Billy really is nervous. Like you, I was like, you're legit nervous. And I just wondered, like in the moments before they were like, okay, we're back from commercial in five, four. I'm getting nervous just talking about it. Like, were you just like, I'm gonna take a breath and I'm gonna let it like what went through your mind?

[15:49] Billy Eichner: Well, here's what I had on my side. Number one, they let me do the song twice in a row.

[15:53] Billy Eichner: Cause it was awesome. It wasn't live, it you know, Gordon is obviously recorded the same day. So I think that's typical for them. They let the musical guests do it twice and they pick the best take. Um, so I knew if and here's the other thing. This was a weird COVID thing, which not which which would not have normally been the case, but there was no studio audience because of COVID.

[16:15] Billy Eichner: So of course, of course, was just me, a couple of camera guys who were like off in the dark. I could barely see them because it was like all that red lighting and they made it very moody and dark. The band was there, Reggie Watts, who's the band leader, and the band was sitting there, but they're off to the side, they're all in in COVID masks, so it's not like I could even see their faces. Uh, there are producers watching, but they're in monitors in separate rooms.

[16:42] Billy Eichner: So you're having a private moment essentially. It felt very Corden is off to the side, but I can't, he's not in my line of vision. It's not, I didn't feel like it was a private moment necessarily, but I felt like if I forgot a lyric, if my voice cracked, if I was super pitchy, I could just say, sorry, stop, gotta stop, let's go back.

[17:03] Billy Eichner: Which, if there was a studio audience there, I still could have done, but just all those people staring at you and the pressure.

[17:10] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, so it's way more pressure.

[17:12] Billy Eichner: So I it's good that my first time out, I got to do it in that situation. I think that was helpful. I knew I was still pretty much in control.

[17:21] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, yeah, totally.

[17:22] Billy Eichner: But yeah, I was nervous, and I don't what is my process? It's what you're saying. It's just that you it's like every actor, you know, you're nerve. I mean, I'm nervous when I have to go on set, especially like the first day starting a new project when you're still figuring out the character.

[17:39] Billy Eichner: I the first major talk show I did about I don't know, nine years ago was was Conan and I in the dressing room backstage. I mean, I've never been that nervous in my life. I don't think I've been as nervous since.

[17:57] Billy Eichner: Um, but I've done a couple of shitting yourself.

[18:00] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I mean, yeah, pretty much.

[18:03] Billy Eichner: Yeah. And then I looked over. I brought my friend Jamie, my old friend of mine, uh, Jamie Salka, who you you probably and and Jamie came, but I thought it would be helpful. But then I look over in the dressing room, and Jamie is literally sitting crouched on the floor in the corner.

[18:22] Billy Eichner: And I said, What is wrong with you? And he said, I'm fine, I'm fine. And I said, Well, Jamie. And then and then I went out and I did my guest spot and it went fine. Jamie having a panic attack.

[18:32] Billy Eichner: What the fuck? Jamie, I said to me, he Jamie said to me, I've never been more nervous for you in my whole life. Of course, Jamie, that's not helpful.

[18:40] Susan Blackwell: You're there for the stability.

[18:42] Billy Eichner: I have heard people say when something like that happens, when a dynamic like that occurs, sometimes the person in your position, Billy, in taking care of Jamie, yeah, a lot of your nerves can shed because you're like, Oh, I'm gonna make sure that Jamie doesn't pass out on the green room.

[18:59] Billy Eichner: Yeah, but what can you do? You know, you're a performer, you're always half petrified and saying, Why the hell am I doing this? Can't I should have done something else?

[19:08] Susan Blackwell: Like you know, it's so funny to hear you say that though, Billy, because you seem like somebody who, again, uh you're somebody who I admire so much for your swinging for the fences, big wave writing. Like you just seem seem fearless, but but it sounds like you're going through a version of what I'm going through, or Laura's going through, or the listeners are going through, which is just that.

[19:33] Billy Eichner: Like, why the fuck did I agree to do this?

[19:35] Billy Eichner: Of course, are you kidding me? I mean, no, I I mean, give you I'm inhuman, like, you just get nervous, but there's also underneath the nervousness is a feeling that I can do this, I'm prepared.

[19:52] Susan Blackwell: There you go.

[19:53] Billy Eichner: Yeah, that's the equation. I know what I'm doing. And if it doesn't go well, it'll suck for a few days, but that will pass too. You know, you'll survive.

[20:04] Billy Eichner: You'll survive, it's gonna be fine. Like people have bombed on talk shows before and still had a career, you know, like things like that.

[20:11] Susan Blackwell: I love that equation.

[20:13] Billy Eichner: Caviar knows I'm obsessed with it. The this feels like hell right now, but I know I can do this, or this is sucking balls for me in this exact moment, but I think it's gonna get fun in a second. Stuff like that is helpful to me.

[20:27] Billy Eichner: Or I'll be happy when it's over and people watch it and like it. You know, that's oh my god, yeah, that's the gift in the end.

[20:35] Susan Blackwell: You know, all those Billy on the Street segments. It's especially now that when we do these big celebrity segments, I don't have all day to shoot with them, you know.

[20:45] Billy Eichner: They they come and you know, they're published and they're happy to be there. I mean, that's the type of show you do it because you want to do it, you know, but you're working quickly, yeah.

[20:53] Billy Eichner: But you're they're usually in the middle of some press junket and it's being squeezed into a million other things, yeah. And you know, they only have an hour, they have 90 minutes, and I know in my head, like fuck, like this is a finite amount of time.

[21:07] Billy Eichner: I can't control what the people are gonna say on the street. Someone things need to happen magically in this short amount of time. And that makes me so nervous.

[21:17] Billy Eichner: And then on top of it, I worry about is the celebrity okay? Are they having a good time? Have they twisted their ankle? Yes. Are they nervous? Like blah, blah, blah, because such a weird thing to do.

[21:31] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.

[21:31] Billy Eichner: So you know, so I I get nervous, but then I think, you know, all right, well, come what may, in two hours it'll be over, and that'll be that.

[21:40] Susan Blackwell: That's so interesting. Like what you just described is like you've got your own nervousness, and then potentially a celebrity who is nervous about like, oh my God, am I gonna be able to come up with something funny and clever in the moment?

[21:54] Susan Blackwell: There's so much pressure because the show is always funny and clever. And what if I, you know, crap out in my in my moment? It, you know, I I just think like that's a lot for you to handle all at once.

[22:07] Billy Eichner: Yeah, no, it it definitely is. Um, I've obviously been doing it for years now.

[22:13] Billy Eichner: Yeah, so yeah, and I've done it with some really big intimidating people.

[22:18] Billy Eichner: Yeah, so if I can get through that, I know it's gonna be fine, you know.

[22:23] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, yeah.

[22:24] Billy Eichner: And um at this point, the show is a is a bit of a a known quantity for the celebrity who's showing up because they've at least seen it.

[22:33] Billy Eichner: It's not in the early days, they would show up and say, What are we doing? What the fuck are we doing?

[22:38] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, exactly.

[22:39] Billy Eichner: At least I don't have to deal with that anymore. But but what you do deal with is the expectation of it being funny, yeah.

[22:46] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.

[22:46] Billy Eichner: Okay, before we go any further, I just want to say you were officially admitted into the Spark file.

[22:51] Susan Blackwell: That was a hell of a price of admission.

[22:54] Billy Eichner: Um my god, that was only one question.

[22:56] Susan Blackwell: Are we done?

[22:57] Billy Eichner: That was it.

[22:57] Susan Blackwell: That was it. It is not a wrap. For people who don't know you, how do you identify creatively when people ask you, what do you do?

[23:05] Billy Eichner: What how do you answer? It's always some long-winded answer of which I'm sure you're shocked about.

[23:16] Billy Eichner: How much time do you have? I think, you know, I say I say actor, comedian, writer or something like that.

[23:23] Susan Blackwell: Um, that didn't take that long.

[23:25] Billy Eichner: No, it's true. I mean, I'm not the only one doing that, but um, I like to say actor because that is what I started off doing.

[23:36] Billy Eichner: And it sounds classy.

[23:38] Billy Eichner: And it sounds classy, and it also it kind of, you know, it it it that's that sort of describes everything in a nutshell. Because or, you know, really I'm a performer, you know, I've always really liked that word.

[23:52] Billy Eichner: Um Billy on the Street is not acting, um, but I'm also not being myself.

[23:58] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.

[23:58] Billy Eichner: So it's really a performance, you know. That's really what it is, you know, which combines a bunch of different elements of improv and acting to a certain degree because I am in character.

[24:10] Billy Eichner: Um, and writing too. Because, you know, I we have to think of those bits and the questions and all that.

[24:18] Susan Blackwell: But you know, I'm so curious. Just um, none of those singular words seem to encapsulate all that you do because you like you said you're not gonna do it.

[24:30] Billy Eichner: That's what we're here for.

[24:32] Susan Blackwell: That's what we're here for. We'll be the one to say that's not a big enough word. That container is not big enough for all that you do because you do write, you produce, you sing, and you're extremely politically active.

[24:46] Billy Eichner: So we're we're curious now. Like having heard you say that you started singing when you were young and then you started as an actor.

[24:55] Susan Blackwell: Was there a moment when you started to expand your own I guess your imagination of like what could be possible to you, what you could use your skills and talent for, because it seems so broad and big and juicy now.

[25:14] Billy Eichner: Well, in a way, I'm working backwards, strangely enough. Because my break, if you know, it's I don't know what other word to use. It was a slow burn. It was certainly not an overnight thing, but Billy on the Street is what brought attention to me.

[25:32] Billy Eichner: Um and it's what made me a a some sort of name. It also made me financially stable. It did a lot of things.

[25:44] Billy Eichner: Um, however, I didn't say when I was 10 years old or 15 or 25 or 30, oh, I'm so glad I'm screaming at people on the street for a living. This is exactly what I thought it would happen.

[25:55] Billy Eichner: Spot that's just one of those weird things that it happened, you know. It was a segment, as as you know, Susan, it was a segment in a live show I was doing in Manhattan going back to two.

[26:11] Susan Blackwell: Don't talk about that. Talk about Creation Nation. Like, how did you how did you make that?

[26:16] Billy Eichner: Um, well, Creation Nation was a live show that I did. We called it a live talk show, though it was really more of a like a hybrid of a talk show, sketch show, and variety show.

[26:26] Billy Eichner: Yeah. Um, and I hosted it and did most of the heavy lifting.

[26:30] Billy Eichner: And my best friend in real life, the actor Robin Lord Taylor, he was my sidekick, my my straight man, quote unquote.

[26:38] Billy Eichner: Um, and I ended up that's really where I discovered that I could really write um for myself.

[26:44] Billy Eichner: Yeah. And where that came, that came out of desperation. And like so many before me, I was just toiling away in New York, couldn't get arrested, was doing random shit with my friends here and there.

[27:01] Billy Eichner: No, and I went to some open call one day with my equity card for some regional production of God only knows what.

[27:11] Billy Eichner: And I got up at like you had to get up at five o'clock in the morning to get a spot, and then have to come back like six hours later to actually sing or whatever you were gonna do.

[27:21] Billy Eichner: And I I did that for a couple of years. I never got anywhere. I think maybe I got one call back one time, never booked anything.

[27:30] Billy Eichner: Um I've never in my life, uh I honest to God, I don't think since college I've gotten a part from an audition.

[27:38] Susan Blackwell: I swear to you.

[27:40] Billy Eichner: You made the work yourself.

[27:41] Billy Eichner: You did it.

[27:42] Billy Eichner: I made it myself, and then people saw it and just said, let's put him in this thing. I mean, that's that's that's what it is.

[27:47] Billy Eichner: And so anyway, so yeah, so I started, I looked around at this long line of actors in New York, and I said, This cannot be the answer for me because this is not going well for me.

[28:02] Billy Eichner: And I think that I'm talented, but this just I've I've gotta come up with something more clever than just sitting in a line of a thousand people.

[28:11] Billy Eichner: I can't just be one of a thousand people. And I thought, all right, what what differentiates me?

[28:18] Billy Eichner: Like what's you know, from other people? What do I do that other people can't do as often, right?

[28:26] Billy Eichner: And the fact is I was a good singer and I was a good actor, but there are a lot of good singers in New York, and there are a lot of good actors, and I thought that wasn't enough.

[28:35] Billy Eichner: The thing that the the rarest thing that I am is funny, and I should go where the funny people go and see what they're doing and put myself in that box because I think that I have that's where I'm like the most special, I think.

[28:57] Billy Eichner: And so I went to I took, and I've always I don't, I don't I don't want to say I loved school, but I was always a good student.

[29:07] Billy Eichner: So classes were good for me. So I took classes, I took this insane stand-up comedy class that I saw an ad for in backstage. That's amazing. I took an insane stand-up comedy class with so many friggin' weirdos. I mean, it was like a bad sitcom pilot. Um old ladies like having fun in retirement. I mean, I can't even tell you what was going on in this class, and those were the not those the ladies I liked. It was like the young, like wannabe Dane cooks that made me want to kill myself. Yeah. Um so I did that, and then I went to Upright Citizens Brigade, and I took all the improv classes, and I got a sense of what that scene was like. And I was good at improv, but it didn't just improv itself and didn't, I don't know, it didn't do it for me for some reason.

[30:00] Billy Eichner: So I started writing this sketch comedy show, this variety show for myself. And you know, we would do it once a month. We started doing it in tiny little black box theaters and bars in the East Village for 20 people, 30 people, 40 people, whatever it was. Eventually, we started doing it at this lovely off off Broadway theater that we all know and love called Ars Nova. And we would do it once a month for a couple of years, and that's where the Billy on the Street video started. I was developing that Billy on the Street style style of character on stage. I was getting just I would describe it as I'm getting irrationally worked up about pop culture, right?

[30:46] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.

[30:46] Billy Eichner: Just build these building rants. Just like, and I remember asking you at the time, I was like, How are you writing and memorizing these? Because they got really heightened and really fast. And I was like, How are you doing that? And you were like, Well, because I wrote it, like I kind of can't fuck it up. And I was like, I think I could find a way to fuck that up, but you did not. You were like, Oh, yeah, looking back now. I mean, part of it is that I had a 24, 25 year old's brain, you know?

[31:20] Billy Eichner: And I would I would sweet spongy brain. Yeah. Exactly. I would write these very long, oh my god, over the top, like intensely like passionate, rage, hateful, vicious rants about like the most random celebrities. Like, not never who people were making fun of in the tabloids. I never talked about Paris Hilton or Lindsay Lohan or Britney Spears. It was always about like, you know, Jodie Foster. And I would just, you know, come down hard on these extremely revered artists, you know, and that was the joke. But I would write it all. Sometimes they would go on, as like you're saying, they would go on for 10, 12 minutes sometimes. But like a slow burn, slow build.

[32:01] Billy Eichner: And the crescendo was bananas awkward. Like it was crazy. Yes. When you didn't think you could like dial it up anymore, it would dial up again. It was they were crazy. They were absolutely really insane. And the audience, I think it was a very New York thing. I don't know if that would play everywhere, but the New York audience, my goal, my goal when I sat down to write that show and those rants, but all of it, you know, there were musical numbers, there were videos, it was whatever I could think of that we could somehow pull off that month. And um I would, I always thought, okay, I'm gonna attract a very cynical, smart, sophisticated, theater-going audience.

[32:46] Billy Eichner: So how do I shock them? How do I turn their snarkiness and bitchiness and cynicism into something that they can't even fathom, right? Like, how do I stay one step ahead of them and also kind of comment on them at the same time?

[33:04] Susan Blackwell: You just come for Jodie Foster.

[33:06] Billy Eichner: I'm like gonna say it's Jodie Foster. That's how you do it.

[33:08] Susan Blackwell: That's how you do it.

[33:09] Billy Eichner: And so and then at one point, I had the idea, again, my friend Jamie, who years later would be not helping me in the Conan dressing room. Thanks, Tim. He was a dear friend of mine from our Northwestern days, and still a dear friend of mine. And he was directing my live show, and he would counsel me and advise me on the writing and help me put it together and all of that. And he also was the first person to go behind the camera and shoot these Billy on the street videos with me.

[33:38] Billy Eichner: And shit. It was just the two of us. And then my friend Robin who was at the show. He at one point, he at some point, Jamie had to like go get a real job. And so Jamie, uh Robin took over filming for me. And Jamie, you know, he edited the videos, and then I would come in and we'd work on them together. And that started off in this live show. And it was just an idea I had once. I said, you know what I think would be funny? I'm doing this crazy over-the-top pop culture self-obsessed character. What if the original idea was I'm gonna take my headshots?

[34:13] Billy Eichner: Now I don't know if headshots are as big of a deal now because everyone has a camera in their hands. Right. Um and everyone can sort of make their own face look pretty now. But at the time, you needed to go to a fancy photographer to do that. And the for the headshot culture was absolutely out of control in New York City, right? You had to go to the right photographer, and all of a sudden you were spending a thousand dollars, and it's like, wait, what? Okay, so my the joke was I'm gonna go and show my headshots to my dry cleaner and make her weigh in on them and tell me which one she likes best.

[34:51] Susan Blackwell: Oh god.

[34:52] Billy Eichner: We never actually did that. I can't remember why, we just never did. But what that evolved into was I'm gonna run out on the street, and New Yorkers who are walking around with blinders on to get wherever they need to go, I am going to break that invisible wall, and I'm gonna force someone to talk to me about the Oscars that week or or whatever. I think now because we've seen season after season of Billy on the street. We just go, oh yeah, of course. But I cannot understate to you, gentle listeners, how shocking it was to see those videos like for the first, second, and third time because we knew that you had to go and do that in order to get that footage.

[35:37] Susan Blackwell: That's right. Talk about shitting your pants. Like to me, that would be enormously risky. Do you remember the first time that you did it that you really went for it? What that was like?

[35:45] Billy Eichner: Vividly. We went, we we went and we shot in Washington Square Park. And in the beginning, and if you look, they're still on YouTube, my early grainiest videos. Like I mean, they're really grainy and it's funny to look at. Now, I mean, I'm I'm 25 in those videos, and I'm 42 now. Um, which is really insane. But um, just how long I've been doing it. But um, Robin came with me the first few times. He was going to be in the videos too.

[36:19] Billy Eichner: Um, and Jamie was filming it because we were in Robin was my sidekick in the show, and we just thought that made sense. And over time it just became clear that I was had a weird skill for doing this, and he wasn't thrilled to be doing it. And so he went behind the camera and continued to do the stage show with me, but I would, I was the only person on camera in the videos, and Jamie and Robin would kind of alternate shooting them. But that first day, we I needed to walk around Washington Square Park for like, I don't remember how long, like a half hour to an hour, just working up the courage to go talk to someone who was sitting on a bench.

[37:00] Billy Eichner: And I remember we we went to Washington Square Park because it felt quieter and more controlled. We weren't out on the street, and it was allowing me to just sort of see if this is something I could ever do. Because like many actors, and it sounds like a cliche, but like many actors, I'm not a wallflower, but I'm normal. I'm not the life of the party. I you know, never have and so it takes a minute for me to work up that you know, that chutzpah as my and that character too.

[37:32] Susan Blackwell: You you were doing it in the in that style of that rant, not as you know, normal person, like, hey, do you mind if I talk to you for a minute?

[37:42] Billy Eichner: Yeah, like in your brain.

[37:44] Susan Blackwell: That was the exactly, yeah.

[37:45] Billy Eichner: That was the first it did start out those early videos. They would like the rants, they would start out quieter, and they would actually start out with political questions, and then they would ramp up to pop culture questions because that was the joke that I was going outside to talk to people about important things, but I ultimately didn't want to talk about those things.

[38:06] Susan Blackwell: Oh my god.

[38:07] Billy Eichner: Anyway, most important things to pop culture. Here's a fun fact. I wrote jokes for the first season of Billy on the street, and while I was getting ready for our chat today, I was I was reading over some of the jokes that I submitted, and I have to tell you, some of them actually made me laugh out loud.

[38:21] Susan Blackwell: But didn't you go to bat with the censors over a joke I wrote for you?

[38:25] Billy Eichner: And I think I found the joke. Here's the joke.

[38:27] Susan Blackwell: Oh my god.

[38:28] Billy Eichner: Which one of these is actually a fragrance marketed by Kim Kardashian? A Vamp, B, Love, C, Hange, or D, Bloge.

[38:39] Susan Blackwell: Yes.

[38:39] Billy Eichner: Oh, Susan, I'm dying.

[38:41] Susan Blackwell: Okay.

[38:42] Billy Eichner: I'm totally dying. First of all, I remember that question, and I think it was on the writer sample that you submitted. And it's like one of the reasons I wanted you to write jokes for that first season because I just thought that was so funny. Um but they were not having it.

[38:59] Billy Eichner: The sensors were not having that joke.

[39:00] Susan Blackwell: No.

[39:01] Billy Eichner: No, they weren't. And I remember I had a lot of like arguments over the years with the, you know, the standards and practices people.

[39:08] Susan Blackwell: And oh my God, I totally forgot that.

[39:10] Billy Eichner: You're you're not part of the pun, but you're like blowing my mind with that reference.

[39:16] Susan Blackwell: I'm blogging your mind.

[39:17] Billy Eichner: You're bloging my mind. Yes. Hopefully the sensors are okay with that.

[39:20] Susan Blackwell: No, I thought that was so funny. And um that's so amazing. Uh God, I I totally, I totally forgot about that.

[39:27] Billy Eichner: But then if I remember correctly, if I remember, you were like, how arguing with them and saying, what is it? What does it mean? Bloge. It's a it's a silly word.

[39:39] Susan Blackwell: Right.

[39:40] Billy Eichner: I think I got my way.

[39:41] Susan Blackwell: I think you got your way.

[39:43] Billy Eichner: I I don't know if it aired, but I I think I was able to, they let me.

[39:48] Susan Blackwell: I know, no either.

[39:49] Billy Eichner: But I like that you went to bat for me. I really appreciate it. Thanks.

[39:52] Susan Blackwell: Oh, of course.

[39:53] Billy Eichner: Well, we know that type of work, hange and bloge is so important, you know.

[39:59] Susan Blackwell: We can't back down from that.

[40:00] Billy Eichner: I feel like it's advancing the culture.

[40:03] Susan Blackwell: You know what I learned doing that though? I learned I worked on that, and I just wrote hard jokes. And then I did a thing where I wrote this award show for Tommy Cale.

[40:14] Billy Eichner: And what I learned working on those things is I don't really like writing hard jokes. Like I like writing things and then getting in the moment and discovering what's funny in the moment, but writing hard jokes makes me want to go to sleep.

[40:29] Susan Blackwell: But you interesting.

[40:30] Billy Eichner: Interesting.

[40:31] Susan Blackwell: Yeah.

[40:32] Billy Eichner: I feel like you and there's so many people in your crew that are so good at writing hard jokes and uh you know have built huge successful projects around it.

[40:43] Susan Blackwell: And I'm just like, uh, I just want to discover it all in the moment, which you know people can't necessarily like uh write a check against that though.

[40:53] Susan Blackwell: Do you like it, Billy? Like, is that something like do you get enjoyment out of sitting down to like, hey, let's write some jokes?

[41:00] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I mean, I think I think with with Billy on the street and again with difficult people, which I didn't write, but Julie Klausner who wrote it created that show and and started in the city.

[41:12] Billy Eichner: Julie Klausner can write a hard joke, man. Well, Julie, you know, we were we were acquaintances, we were friends, we're fan, we we were like fans of each other's social media presence before Billy on the street, but I didn't know her that well.

[41:29] Billy Eichner: But when I started reading, I I think it was like her tumbler at the time. I was just bowled over because I thought, oh my god, I am laughing out loud. Like she because there were jokes and she was clever and the writing was sharp, in addition to the fact that there was a lot of overlap in the in the things we were interested in.

[41:49] Billy Eichner: But so one of the very when Billy on the street got picked up to be a TV show that first season, I was thrilled and it felt like it was saving my life, honestly. But I I panicked too because I thought, well, I can't do all up until then, I would I did it all by myself. I I thought, who's gonna share my sensibility enough to be able to help me generate content for this show?

[42:15] Billy Eichner: And I swear Julie was one of the first people I reached out to, and I said, I just sold Billy on the street as a TV show, they're making me go into production in like two months. Please come and write on the show. And thank God she did. And that led to a whole you know creative relationship in addition to a friendship between us.

[42:32] Billy Eichner: And then she wrote difficult people. And and one thing that Julie and I both share, in addition to this, you know, in fascination with the entertainment industry since we were young, is we love a hard joke. You know, I think there are certain shows which are more about the human condition and they're softer and they're funny and emotional.

[42:56] Billy Eichner: I love a hard joke too. They're just harder to craft. Like that shit is hard to craft.

[43:02] Susan Blackwell: Well, yeah, it is.

[43:03] Billy Eichner: And uh, and I think that's honestly why you don't see a lot of it because it's fucking hard to do. Like you need to be really smart, you need to be a good writer, and you know, you have to stay away from cliche, but also find that right word that makes it accessible enough for the joke to land on.

[43:22] Billy Eichner: You need timing, you need rhythm. And when difficult people, the series I did, the scripted series I did with Julie was coming together, she kept saying that.

[43:33] Billy Eichner: She's like, you know, they're shoving all of these quote unquote comedies on TV down our throats, but they're not, they're half-hour dramedies, and they're great, but they're not making people laugh out loud.

[43:46] Billy Eichner: We want jokes, we want to be smart, we don't want to be hack hacks, but we want jokes that literally make people laugh out loud.

[43:55] Billy Eichner: And yeah, when I was doing Billy on the Street, I always said to the writers, now, just to be clear, once I hit the street and talk to people, those interactions are not scripted in any way. Those are real people. We don't cast the show. But when I'm prepping to shoot, obviously, those games that I play, or thinking of, okay, what's the theme of the segment gonna be with John Oliver or Tina Fey or whoever the guest is, it's me and a handful of writers in a room for six weeks before we start shooting, writing all of that and figuring out what that's gonna be.

[44:31] Billy Eichner: And what I always said to the writers was it has to make us laugh out loud. I don't just want it to be theoretically funny or intellectually interesting, you know.

[44:42] Laura Camien: Uh-huh.

[44:43] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[44:44] Laura Camien: That makes perfect sense.

[44:46] Billy Eichner: And it has to be something that you can scream. I remember thinking this has to be so succinct that it has to be words like hand and bloge so that you can get it out successfully. Do you know what I mean?

[45:01] Laura Camien: Yeah, there's a pace to the show.

[45:03] Billy Eichner: Even the questions, because that type of question you wrote was for the multiple choice rounds we would play, where they went a little bit slower than just the running around segments. And I wasn't as loud in those segments for the most part, but still, those questions needed to go at a clip.

[45:20] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[45:21] Billy Eichner: You know, even as I was just saying it, I started subconsciously like snapping my fingers because that's just like the pace that needed to go at. And then when we were thinking of things, you know, occasionally the writers and I would see a headline or something like on Deadline or some entertainment industry blog or some entertainment magazine, some little phrase or something. And we would say, Oh my god, how funny would it be if you just, you know, I'm just gonna run up to a random person and just say this phrase and just see what happens.

[45:58] Billy Eichner: And what the writers and I would always tell people, because you know, to this day, and I don't shoot it as much anymore. We don't do half-hour episodes, I just do occasional segments. But we would always say back then, and we still say now, everyone's always like, Oh, he's the guy that shouts, and he screams, and that is true, but the show is not funny because I shout. It's not that I'm shouting, it's what I'm shouting.

[46:26] Laura Camien: That's what of course.

[46:29] Billy Eichner: It's cool. Uh having run the streets with you, there was a few times when you would invite some friends along for these to fill these segments, but it was fascinating to watch, uh number one, it looked exhausting, if I'm honest. It looked like you were doing it, it was almost like fishing, and you would know if you started to peel towards somebody and you were like not gonna work. Like you were just working so intuitively, and your mouth and your brain and your intuition were all working together. And I was just like, it was a thing of beauty to behold, honestly.

[47:04] Billy Eichner: Oh, that's nice. It was like improv at its highest pitch and level.

[47:10] Laura Camien: It was crazy.

[47:14] Billy Eichner: Leave it all alone, yes, Camien, that's it. That's exactly on the court. That's exactly it. It was athletic. You nailed it. That's it.

[47:22] Billy Eichner: Well, it was very nice of you to say. Well, again, in segments like the ones that we had sometimes, uh, what Susan's describing is that occasionally, you know, I would have friends of mine or our actors that I knew join me in the bit. Not the people I'm going up to on the street and talking to, but it would be.

[47:41] Billy Eichner: No, we were like yes, we were one time we were like the embodiment of an online, like just like a on, uh, you know, we had pitchforks and lanterns, and it was as if when you know when the internet comes for you, you wanted to embody it.

[47:56] Laura Camien: Right.

[47:56] Billy Eichner: So we were all in a costume like villagers. Yeah, I did a I did a thing called the bro lightning round, and I dressed up like a bro and totally changed my persona. And I wanted a group of guys to be with me so that we were bros. And so I got like it was me and this group of guys, and I and Jason Sudakis, who was the guest. So sometimes we had actors join me for those types of things. And for those segments, again, where there's a group of actors doing a bit with me where I know I only have them for a finite amount of time, or when there's a celebrity who I only know I have for a finite amount of time, I have to give it, no matter how tired I am, I have to give 150% for those two hours, or else I'm fucked.

[48:45] Billy Eichner: And there were many days on Billy on the Street, and part of the reason that I don't do it as much anymore, honestly. There are a couple of reasons for that, but part of the reason, a big part of the reason is that it is not a normal thing for one to do to themselves physically and mentally. Oh my gosh, what it takes out of me. I literally would shoot, I don't know, five, six hours. To like get into an ice bath. I would go home. I'm not exaggerating, and by the way, I'm not complaining because it's also the greatest thing that ever happened to me.

[49:16] Laura Camien: Yes.

[49:17] Billy Eichner: Yeah, yeah. That's true. I can feel that. Yeah. I would go home and I would pass out. Pass out. That's it. Pass out for hours. And then get up, and at like 10 p.m. or something, after napping for a few hours, like, prep for the next day.

[49:33] Laura Camien: Oh man.

[49:36] Billy Eichner: So it was. We're not kids anymore, Billy.

[49:38] Laura Camien: That shows exactly.

[49:40] Billy Eichner: That that show is just it's uniquely challenging. You know, it just you said also uniquely rewarding. You know, and I doubt there's nothing else like it. There's nothing else like it.

[49:52] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[49:53] Billy Eichner: I doubt you, you know, do it as long without feeling those rewards and the benefits and the joys of it. Yeah, we did a segment last year with um Chris Evans.

[50:04] Billy Eichner: And hot. He is extremely hot and extremely nice. And he shot with me again, you know, for a couple of hours. And at the end, he just and he was a big fan of the show, which is why he did it. And we were, we, you know, we were friendly, but he'd never seen me shoot the show. You know, he'd never been with me while I was shooting, obviously. And he looked at me at the end and he just sort of patted me on the back and he said, Fuck, you are working hard.

[50:33] Laura Camien: Yes, Chris Evans knows what's what.

[50:36] Billy Eichner: Yeah, Chris Evans got lies. This is hard. And I was like, oh my God, Captain America is telling me technically demanding job.

[50:47] Laura Camien: Yeah, he's saving the world when he goes on set.

[50:50] Billy Eichner: You know, yeah, he knows a little something about hard work.

[50:53] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[50:54] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I think people can't believe it sometimes when they actually come and see me do it. They're like, How the hell are you doing this? I think that's what I'm trying to describe, what it's like, and how it again, it was it was fascinating. It was like you were fish like going fishing, and you were like, I'm going. And we would be like, okay, he's going for it.

[51:11] Laura Camien: It Camien and to your point, it was almost like watching you take a run at the what do they call that in track and field cams when you jump.

[51:20] Billy Eichner: Javelin throw of it.

[51:21] Laura Camien: Like a pole vault or a high jump, where it's like, he's gonna go, he's gonna go, he's gonna go, and he's going. Like it was, and there were times when you also would take a run for it and you were like, Nope, nope, nope. And you would sort of like it. It was fascinating. Fascinating and my and my poor camera guys, who are the greatest camera people every year. The greatest crew going. They have these big cameras on their shoulders.

[51:46] Billy Eichner: You had a wired mic, too.

[51:48] Billy Eichner: It's and my mic too, my sound guy, Kevin, and they're he's running down the street with a boom, and they can't fuck up because if they don't capture what happens, yeah, shot. Then it was waste. Sometimes they are running down the street backwards to get the shot of me running forwards. It's a high-stakes game. It's a high stakes game.

[52:10] Billy Eichner: And then the PAs, the producers have to get people to sign releases on all of it. So it was it was so it was really heightened. It was really something, but when it comes together, it's goddamn magic. Because there really is nothing else like it. And you capture some of the greatest. Your performance is great and surprising, even surprising to you. And the people of New York that you capture are it's it's just like it's amazing. It's just a fucking delight. But it is, but also seems tiring as fuck, and I don't blame you for like go be a talking singing meerkat.

[52:48] Laura Camien: Yes, thank you. Appreciate it. Get that manny.

[52:50] Billy Eichner: Yes. Okay. All right. So I'm gonna shift gears. We try not to fangirl out too much on this show. But Suze and I just give a both really fucking love Friends from College.

[53:01] Billy Eichner: Oh wow.

[53:02] Billy Eichner: Oh, thank you. We both love it. And I actually gently, I accidentally broke it to Susan live on this podcast that the show wasn't coming back for another season.

[53:13] Billy Eichner: And ooh, it really it gutted us and it really dropped the energy on that episode. We were like, why go on? Why even the podcast?

[53:22] Billy Eichner: Oh, I love I love hearing that because you know it's such that show was great. It's fascinating because you know, that show the first season it came out, and I wasn't a regular on that show, I was recurring, although they put me in it more the second season. But I ended up there a lot. And it came out and it it got legitimately probably the worst reviews any show has gotten in the past 10 years. I mean it was it was be it wasn't just is that true?

[53:59] Billy Eichner: It did get better. I mean, a couple of critics revisited it the second season and said, Yeah, it got it got better, it's definitely better now, but it was too late, you know. It was too they didn't just dis they didn't say eh, this is mediocre, it's hit or miss. They went in when that show came out.

[54:16] Laura Camien: Big to differ.

[54:17] Billy Eichner: I bet to differ. But that's amazing because you know, then I see people like you guys, and you guys are, you know, you're very sophisticated, smart new. You were the best. You like the show, and there are people always on social media who are talking about how much they like the show. It's just it's just one of those strange things. You know, it's we had listeners who were like, 'We feel you, we're with you. We love that show.' I don't know.

[54:43] Laura Camien: Yeah. Interesting. Tell us what it was like to work on, and also can you tell us a story about Fred Savage?

[54:47] Laura Camien: Oh is that right?

[54:49] Billy Eichner: Yeah, just tell us about Fred Savage.

[54:51] Billy Eichner: Um Fred Savage. Well, first of all, I actually really loved working on that show. And I love that I didn't have to be involved in the writing or producing. That I'm not gonna just show up, show up, half remember your lines. What I what I loved about it is that it was a different kind of character for me because he was kind of the shy, awkward one of the group.

[54:52] Billy Eichner: Oh my god, yeah, yeah. Critics did not believe it.

[54:56] Laura Camien: But did you feel like it got better? Did it got stronger?

[55:19] Laura Camien: Yes, yes, you know, that's right.

[55:20] Billy Eichner: That was on the outside. They were, you know, Keegan Michael Key and Fred, and they were the sort of outlandish ones doing all kinds of crazy shit at the center of the story. And I was on the outside feeling a little bit more shy and awkward and vulnerable, being the one of them that did not, you know, wasn't part of their college group of friends. But now with Fred Savage, who was um as my husband, we we get married at the end of it. But I loved it because they trusted me to do something different and not just come in and try to, you know, shoehorn in the Billy on the Street persona to a scripted show, which I don't know. I wouldn't want to do. And when I'm attempted to do it, I think it's a very hit and miss affair.

[56:06] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[56:06] Billy Eichner: Um, and so I loved doing that show. And another interesting thing about that show is that because I'll be honest and say that although we all loved it, and it's great to hear that people like it, it was a, you know, it it was a I guess not ideal experience. It didn't go the way obviously the creators of the show wanted it to go in terms of only getting two seasons and you know, and and and it being on Netflix, and there's a potential to really score on Netflix if you score, but if you if you didn't, then it's a bummer, you know, all that stuff. But um, Nick Stoller, who created and wrote that show with his wife Francesca, um, who and who directed almost all the episodes. He's the one who cast me in the show. And I think he cast me in it because he thought I would be funny, but he didn't realize at the time that I actually wasn't just a comedian, that I had some acting skills even for the scenes that didn't work.

[57:08] Laura Camien: This is a theme for you. Surprising people.

[57:09] Billy Eichner: Surprising people who you work with.

[57:13] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[57:14] Billy Eichner: And what's what's really amazing is that after Friends from College was over, Nick Stoller, who for people who don't know has a long career uh writing and producing and directing big studio comedies. He wrote and directed uh Forgetting Sarah Marshall, and he directed Neighbors, and he's just done a ton of things. Um he's works with Judd Apatow a lot as his producer, and they go way back. So coming off of this kind of strange experience with Friends from College, Nick emailed me and said, Hey, I really liked working with you. I want to do, I want my next movie to be a rom-com, but I'm interested in doing it about a gay couple. Whoop, whoop, yes. He said, uh, but I'm not gay, so I can't write it by myself. He was like, You want to write it with me, and you'll star in it and I'll direct it.

[58:06] Billy Eichner: Oh my god. Is that happening? Yeah, I mean, knock on wood. We were supposed to shoot, we were supposed to shoot it in April, and of course we got shut down because of COVID. So now we are in the process of you know putting it back together again, hopefully to shoot next year. But Judd Apatow is producing it. And holy shit. It's um exciting. We did announce it. We announced that this is not like you're so A-list. It's yeah. I know it would be amazing if you scooped it on the Spark File podcast. By the way, I will, I would love to see something on the Spark File. Yes. Um, but that just shows you that even like Friends from College, which was fun for me and I love doing it, but you know, if you ask the way it blooms into people in the industry, they would be like, Oh yeah, that didn't do so well.

But then it became this other thing. Yeah, it brought a lot of joy. I love Nick Stoller's sensibility, and I love yours, and I love the idea of what you all are gonna make together. That's really I'm so excited and happy for you. That's so great.

[59:11] Susan Blackwell: Thanks. But what about Fred Savage? Enough about this.

[59:14] Billy Eichner: Yep, yeah. Jesus fucking Christ, Fred Savage. Since we're not working together anymore, and I think I can say he's super hot, actually. Yeah, his humor, you know, is we timing yes, yes, comedian timing. I thought he was so that he is so funny on that show. And the conceit that Cammy and I were both say so taken with is like he he's like, I'm gonna write. I'm gonna be a writer, and then he buys all the accoutrement, and then he's just like it's just I don't even like writing. And I I have to say, he's he's so lovely, he's so funny, just a uh has a ton of energy, is a doll to be around. And of course, I grew up watching Wonder Years, and yeah, there were moments when we first started shooting the show, and we were playing uh we were playing boyfriends who eventually get married. So occasionally, like we would kiss or something, and I just kept thinking, I am kissing Kevin Arnold.

[1:00:15] Susan Blackwell: Yes. That's the kind those are the kind of stories we're looking for.

[1:00:21] Billy Eichner: Oh, yeah. I remember thinking when I, you know, on one of the first episodes we we worked on together, Fred also, which I thought this was adorable. I think because he's straight and he's like very straight, um, and he was playing a gay character. I think he wanted to show me right away that he was not afraid of physical physical affection, right? And so he was almost like overzealous the first few days. Like he when we were shooting, not like off camera, but like when we were shooting, he would like throw in like kissing me on the cheek and touching me and all these like couple things, and I which was very sweet. And I was like, Fred, no real couple is that physically affected. I I get it. But I am magnetic.

Can I get it? I get it. I get it, Fred Savage. He has a line on that show that I'm sure Nick Solar wrote, which I think it's vampires with cancer, they live forever, they die forever. That I think is one of the funniest fucking jokes. So fucking funny. Yeah, that is. That is there was some really funny, really funny shit on that show. Like anyway, I won't go into it, but it's on Netflix if people want to check it out. Um what I was gonna say is um there was a moment when I thought, oh my god, if you had told me when I was 10 watching the Wonder Years with my parents, if you if you had told me one day, if someone could come from the future and said, one day you're gonna be gay, your mouth is gonna be on that. Your mouth on that me playing a gay couple and kissing Fred Savage. Uh insane. That's the stuff that dreams are made of.

[1:02:01] Susan Blackwell: So okay, Billy, this is where we get really real. There's a topic we're obsessed with. I couldn't even say it with a straight face. So there is a topic that we seriously, but seriously. This is true, this is actually true. For real, we are obsessed with talking about and understanding like how people process creative failure.

[1:02:25] Laura Camien: Uh-huh.

[1:02:26] Susan Blackwell: Or perceived creative failure. Um, have you ever felt like you failed at something? And can you tell us like how you faced it, how you processed it?

[1:02:36] Billy Eichner: I think um there are two examples that come to mind, but it's it's a very similar situation where in that that first time I ever did a talk show, that same Conan appearance, I took one of the rants from creation and basically had Conan set me up for it, and I did not the whole thing, but part of it. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And because I didn't know what else to do, and I just thought, well, this is tested material, and I want to do something I'm familiar with, so I'm comfortable. I'm not gonna try out new material on Conan. I'm not a stand-up in that, you know, I'm not like traveling around trying out material all the time. It's just not what I enjoy doing. So when I go on a talk show, I I'm writing special material for that appearance.

Um, which now is what I do, but that was my first one, so I wanted to rely on something that had worked in my live show and and all of that. But it went okay, but it was very divisive. Some people thought it was very funny, and some people thought it was just loud and crazy, and who is this guy that's shouting on my TV because there's no context for it when you're just sort of when it's coming out of nowhere, and it wasn't a disaster by any means. In fact, the Conan show called me the next day and said, Hey, you were great. Do you want to go do some on the street segments for us? Oh, yeah. Which I didn't I went to the Super Bowl and I made one with Madonna and a lot of amazing things out of that.

And those are actually some of my favorite Billy on the Street segments that I made for Conan. But but that first appearance, I was glad that they weren't alienated by it, but I really wanted it to be a home run, and instead it was divisive. Um similarly, and more significantly, I would say, um, the first major role I did in a scripted show, other than you know, beyond Billy on the Street was on Parks and Rec. And Parks and Rec, all the writers and Mike Scher, who's a genius who created Parks and Rec and produced The Office and made the good place and is just an all-around television genius. Um he DM'd me on Twitter one day and said, Hey, I think we have a part for you on Parks and Rec. And that's how that happened, you know.

And which of course I was completely in shock. I thought it was gonna be for an episode or two. And then I stuck around for the final season, final two seasons that they did. So again, they liked what I did, you know, but the character that they had me doing was essentially a version of Billy on the Street. Um there was a lot of shouting, pretty much every line they wanted me to shout. It's the way that it was written, and it I would do it during the table reads and it would kill. And it just for that show, which up until that point, the beauty of Parks and Rec is that it was a by network sitcom standards. Remember, this is pre-Netflix Hulu. This is pre getting things things getting a bit more sophisticated.

Yeah. So at that time, and and still when you watch Parks and Rec, it feels like a very elegant show. They do some silly things, of course, but it's gentle, it's not explosive. And so I think that they loved the curveball of me coming in and bringing that Billy on the Street explosive energy to a show that typically did not have that energy. I think the writers and the producers were really excited about experimenting with that. And again, like the Conan appearance. Of course, I said yes to it because I I had never, I mean, to just enter the world of scripted television on a show that was an already established fit with Amy Polar and all these actors that I love. I mean, it's a brilliant show.

Of course, I said yes. And at the time I didn't feel like I had enough I just, you know, I wanted to do what they wanted me to do. I wasn't gonna speak up. And to be honest, I didn't know how it would work myself because I had never tried putting that persona in a scripted environment. And again, like the Conan appearance, it was very divisive. And to this day, you can go on social media any day because Parks and Rec is still a very, very popular show on streaming. Yeah. Um, and you will find people who literally say Craig Middlebricks, who is my character, is the funniest thing that ever happened on that show and is like my favorite supporting character ever on the show. That is my favorite part of the final few seasons, and you'll see a lot of that. And you will also see a lot of why did you ruin Parks and Rec? Are you reading this shit, Billy? Do you read all this shit? Absolutely.

[1:07:39] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[1:07:40] Billy Eichner: Oh, Billy God, how do you drink? How do you drink the poison? That is so because I can because I can handle it. And I think that I'm not I look, that's the world we're living in. And I'm not saying it should necessarily affect your creative choices or your professional choices, what some like unsophisticated dope on Twitter thinks about you. Absolutely not. But I think it's interesting. Um I can compartmentalize it. And you know, on some level, yes, we're actors and we're artists, and that's wonderful, but we're also products. That’s just what the business is. And it's kind of just like sort of seeing what the customers think. And it's okay if not everyone wants to. It's market research. Do you like ruminate on it at all, though? Or do you like almost instantly compartmentalize it? Or does it like live in your brain for a bit?

[1:08:39] Billy Eichner: Here's the thing. Here's the thing with with that experience and that role specifically is that if the character was gonna keep going, which it was, which was not what I initially thought, and I was flattered and shocked beyond all comprehension that they wanted me to stay on the show, you know. The first my first day shooting Parks and Rec, I didn't know how the I didn't know where the cameras were. I didn't know that there were takes where the camera wasn't on you. I swear to God. I didn't know anything. I was so green about scripted television, right? Yeah. So I didn't, I just, you know, I just wanted to do a good job, and they all were telling me I was hilarious, and I went along with it, and I said, okay, if you're happy, I'm happy.

And on some level, that is true because it's their show. But as time went on, I was watching the show. And regardless of whether people were loving it or hating it, I was thinking to myself, this isn't this isn't working for me. Like after, you know, it because I'm just shouting, Billy on the Street is different. It's not just shouting. I there's context for it. Again, it's not that I'm shouting, it's what I'm shouting about. And it just works on Billy on the Street. It works in its natural habitat. Like that's where it is. It's the volume on the streets of New York makes sense. That whole show is so chaotic and crazy. But to sit in an office in in the middle of Indiana and start shouting, it just why would they keep that guy around?

It just didn't make a ton of sense to me after a certain amount of time. And so Mike, after my first season, invited me back to do the final season. And I did call him and say, number one, I love you and appreciate you. And I'm so grateful, and you're a genius. And I'm incredibly flattered. And of course, I want to come back and do whatever you want me to do. But I said to him, if I'm gonna come back, we need to bring the character down to earth. We we need to humanize him a little bit because I just think it's getting a little silly at this point. Um and I'm a real actor, I'm not just Billy on the Street, and I don't, I don't want, you know, I'm not I love Gilbert Gottfried, but I'm not Gilbert Gottfried.

And so, and he he it's so funny because I called him and he said, before you even called me, I knew what this call was gonna be about. Oh, he's and he said, Don't worry, I got you, and we're gonna figure it out. And he did, and the character was still silly, but you know, we we brought it down to earth. But I think that performance combined with Billy on the Street, those were the first things people saw me do. And I think it really it kind of people really saw me through that prism, and it's a very limited kind of persona. And so, you know, that's kind of one of those like double-edged sword situations. So, would I say that was a failure, not an outright failure. A lot of people really love that character, but yeah, it's something it made me sort of it made me, it was a learning experience.

[1:12:19] Laura Camien: Correct. Like that's a huge leap.

[1:12:22] Billy Eichner: Yeah. I want a shot glass of that. Just being like, this is market research, and I can take in this information without taking it personally. I think that is a I hope in this lifetime I get better at that.

[1:12:38] Billy Eichner: Well, maybe different people are just built differently and it burns my retina and it doesn't burn yours. But I love that it doesn't burn yours. Yeah, look, it's not my favorite thing in the world. I mean, just spend a Saturday afternoon just reading terrible shit about yourself. You're human, and you know, but honestly, though, the most extreme ones really make me laugh, you know. Like, you know, the ones where they really, really hate you. I think those are funny, you know, because they have really strong feelings about those. Wow, it's so absurd. Um, it's just so funny that you would, it almost is the Billy on the Street character, but they're real people. They're very upset about some pop culture.

Very upset. I'm always amazed. I'm like, you have this much time to have that strong of an opinion to actually take the time to write it. I know it speaks to a real void in a lot of people's lives, unfortunately. Yeah, sadly. And you know, that's an old story, I guess. All right, Billy. So you've been around the block a few times at this point. Um, do you have some good creative advice for our listeners?

[1:13:46] Billy Eichner: I would say stand up for yourself. Yes. Say more about this and raise your voice respectfully and politely, or at least try to. Sometimes, unfortunately, people don't listen unless you scream at them. Um, as I've learned on camera and all. Um, I would say, you know, the goal is to do it respectfully, but you have to hold your own. And if it's something that really means a lot to you, not every project will mean a lot to you, by the way. And that's fine too. Sometimes you just do it to make money and or you want to work, or you want to work with a particular person, even though the thing might not be that great. Whatever it is, and you just make the most of it, and that's it. I've done some mediocre things.

I knew they were mediocre going into it. I didn't get to set and try to rewrite it. I just said I'm gonna make the most of what this is. It is what it is. But when it's something that really means something to you, you have to fight, quote unquote, for your vision, for your creative choices, even if it, even if those are uncomfortable conversations, you know.

[1:15:02] Billy Eichner: Yeah, you just have to because if it was the conversation, the call with Mike Shore. Was that is that one of those that you were sort of like, uh, I but I have to say this. Mike Scher is an incredibly smart, intelligent, self-aware guy. So I had a feeling he would understand where I'm coming from. And if and and sure enough, he did. Like he told me he he knew what it would be about because he felt me already having reservations. And so no, I mean, so I I actually didn't. He's a really sweet, understanding guy. And so I thought he would understand. Um, but I've had other versions of conversations like that with Studio Execs or whoever it might be, and you just have to fight for your vision because it doesn't mean people are gonna love it, but if you're if people aren't gonna love it and something isn't gonna work, it better not work on my terms.

You know, you've gotta you you've you've gotta feel because if it doesn't work, you at least want to be able to say to yourself, well, yeah, people didn't like it, but I know why I made those decisions creatively. And if it didn't work out, it didn't work out. But the worst feeling in the world is when you go along with something that you know is wrong, and it's a project you really care about, and then sure enough, people don't like it, or the writing is bad, or whatever. Or you don't like it, you don't like it. You don't like it.

[1:16:36] Billy Eichner: Yeah, I should have. Before I ask you one of these last questions, I just have to, I'm having this memory of Billy. You were shooting American Horror Story, and you posted a picture of yourself online covered in blood. You were hosing yourself off after filming. You look like you had just slaughtered a cat, uh, cow. I mean, I probably have. I had I've never seen a happier look on your face. Covered in blood. I've never seen you look happier. I just wanted to say that. But here's a question. Here's a question we're obsessed with. You work so hard. You are you are working at the highest levels and you are working so hard. What is it all for?

[1:17:23] Billy Eichner: Oh Jesus. Um that's a good question, Susan. Um who's who's Terry Gross now? Yeah, exactly. Um what is it all for? Um I would say that I'm a pretty practical person at the end of the day, like a pragmatic person. And unless you are independently wealthy or born into money, which I was not, you need to do something in your life to make money. Um, and even if you are independently wealthy, you need to do something with your time that feels like satisfying to you. Um for me, if one has to have a job, then if you must. You know, it's it's it's it's still work. It's a it's a shitload of work sometimes. Yeah. Um, it's very hard to make it, it's hard to sustain it once you've made it. There's a mil all the cliches are usually true.

Um, there's a million things that are tough about it, but I like acting. I like being in things, I like being funny, I like people telling me that I'm talented. I like people telling me that I'm funny. I like singing. It makes me feel good. It's an emotionally creatively satisfying thing to do. If you're lucky and you know, occasionally, occasionally you'll get to work with your friends, you know, you get to work with other people that you like and you find smart and funny, and you're on set and you're exhausted and you really need a nap, but they're still really funny people, and you're making money doing this, and it's a fucking miracle that you're able to do it. And so it's what is uh what was your question? I don't even remember. Yeah, it's all for that. It's all for that. It's all for that. But it's like having some meaningful hard work in your life.

[1:19:38] Billy Eichner: Yeah. And the and the miracle of those adventures, right? I do like it. It's it's I know what the pieces of art, whether it's a movie or a song or a concert or a Broadway show, I the or you know, one particular performer or something, I know how much the ones that I've loved have contributed to my life, right? Yeah, it's a very, very, very big part of my life. Yeah. And as a as a fan, as a fan. And so if something I occasionally do has that effect on someone else, and I'm not sure it does all the time, but maybe once in a while, then I think that's cool. There's something cool about that to me. And again, I'd rather not work. I but since I have to. It's it's it's nice to have a job where where a lot of strangers are like, we love you. I'm like, wow, that's nice. And I got paid. This is amazing. Like, it's amazing.

[1:20:51] Susan Blackwell: Oh. Good answer. It's a good answer.

[1:20:54] Laura Camien: Yeah.

[1:20:55] Susan Blackwell: All right. Uh finally, Billy, what is, what or who I should say, is sparking you these days. You got anything good?

[1:21:04] Billy Eichner: Oh, there's so many things. I mean, I've watched a lot of great things lately, and I'm I'm I'm reading things, and okay. I am, I'm in the he can be a real dick, but it sparks you. But it's sparking me. This guy can be a real asshole like anyone in the theater world in New York has a love-hate relationship with. Where are we headed? But Michael Riedel has a book out.

[1:21:30] Billy Eichner: Oh, yes. Called Razzle Dazzle, The Triumph of Broadway. And it is this very well researched behind the scenes um dishy, but also like thorough. Uh well-researched look at Broadway in the 90s, which is when I was really falling in love with Broadway. Yeah. Um, as it is as it started to come out of the era of Angeloid Weber and into more homegrown American musicals. And it is fucking fascinating. I it's just, it just reminds me how much theater is really the best thing ever. Um and and theater in New York is the best thing ever. But also really, really fascinating because you know, you're reading about how Rent got to Broadway, or how Julie Tamor convinced Disney executives to make The Lion King this crazy avant-garde puppet show.

Yes, yes. You take it as a given that these things were successes, and you you think, oh, well, they were always probably brilliant, and that's how it was, and it was just a huge hit and was always going to be. But reading about the specifics of like how these producers got Rent to Broadway and how they chose the specific theater that they did, and some of it is just luck and timing, and some of it is just making a smart creative decision. Sometimes they're making bad choices. It's incredible. It's wow. I'm good. And it's a great endemic read. It's very juicy and fun.

[1:23:18] Susan Blackwell: Would you ever do a Broadway show? Are you a seven or eight show a week kind of person?

[1:23:22] Billy Eichner: Of course, I would absolutely love to. But or off Broadway. I mean, I hope so. It's at some point. Eight shows a week is as you know, it's that is really, really tough. Um, especially in a musical where you're singing. Yeah. And so, as you would know, so I think it would, I absolutely want to do it. And I'm just kind of waiting for something that I want that I love so much that I want to do it eight times a week.

[1:23:55] Susan Blackwell: Would you ever write something?

[1:23:58] Billy Eichner: Sure. But question more. Those are, I mean, writing a musical, that is a long process.

[1:24:06] Susan Blackwell: It is.

[1:24:06] Billy Eichner: I was just curious, just curious. I look forward to it.

[1:24:08] Susan Blackwell: You're right in the wrong thing.

[1:24:09] Billy Eichner: No.

[1:24:10] Susan Blackwell: That's right.

[1:24:12] Billy Eichner: And it has taken. I mean, COVID extended it another pro you know, over a year, but even so, it would have been like a four year process. Now it's gonna be like a five or six year process. These things take time. Script things of quality take time.

[1:24:28] Susan Blackwell: Yeah, yeah.

[1:24:29] Billy Eichner: They really do. But put it in the pipeline, put it in your pipe and smoke it. If anyone has any ideas, let me know.

[1:24:36] Laura Camien: Yes.

[1:24:37] Billy Eichner: How about you make that movie? You make the gay rom-com and then you make the musical based on the movie and you start it out on Broadway.

[1:24:44] Susan Blackwell: Boom.

[1:24:44] Billy Eichner: There you go. There's your spark. Wow. We got it all worked out. I'm ready. I'm ready. Someone write the songs, and I'll be there.

[1:24:52] Laura Camien: Careful what you ask for.

[1:24:54] Billy Eichner: If you're listening, if you're listening, composer. I'll be way too old by then. It'll have to be about an elderly game finding love for the first time. I mean, I'll take it. I mean, I'll do whatever to be honest.

[1:25:06] Susan Blackwell: There you go.

[1:25:07] Billy Eichner: At that point. Exactly. Just happy to be alive.

[1:25:11] Susan Blackwell: Billy, thank you so much for joining us. This has been a blast.

[1:25:16] Billy Eichner: Oh, thank you guys. Thanks for having me.

[1:25:18] Susan Blackwell: So that's it. This episode of The Spark File was made on Muncie Lenape and Seminole Land, and we hope it put another bunch of sparks in your file. Listen, if there is a spark you'd like us to explore, or if you've taken a spark and fanned it into a creative flame and you'd like to share that, we hope you'll email us at thesparkfile@gmail.com or submit it through our website, thesparkfile.com. We'll even happily take your feedback, but you know the price of admission. First, you have to share a creative risk that you've taken recently.

[1:25:48] Laura Camien: And be sure to subscribe to this podcast wherever you get your podcast. You can subscribe, you can rate it, you can five star review it. If you like this podcast, share it with your people you love. But if you didn't like it, I don't know, Billy, what do you say to your critics?

[1:26:02] Billy Eichner: Fuck them.

[1:26:04] Susan Blackwell: Yes, you do.

[1:26:05] Billy Eichner: Yeah.

[1:26:06] Susan Blackwell: That's exactly what you said.

[1:26:07] Billy Eichner: That's it. Fuck them.

[1:26:08] Laura Camien: Well played.

[1:26:09] Billy Eichner: Well played. If something tickles your fancy and gets your creative juices flowing, we're writing you a forever permission slip to make that thing that's been knocking at your door. It's your turn to take a spark and fan it into a flame. You gotta take it and make it make it.

[1:26:28] Susan Blackwell: Thank you, Billy.

[1:26:29] Laura Camien: Thank you, Billy.

[1:26:30] Billy Eichner: Thank you, guys. Thanks so much. Tell your critics go fuck themselves.

[1:26:33] Billy Eichner: Fuck them.

[1:26:33] Susan Blackwell: Exactly. When I bump into something that inspires me, I dump it in the sparkfile.

[1:26:42] Billy Eichner: Sparfest.

[1:26:43] Susan Blackwell: Could be something that I wanna take or how I wanna be. I'll pump it in the spark file.

[1:26:48] Billy Eichner: Sparflies.

[1:26:53] Susan Blackwell: I jump into my sparkfies.

[1:26:56] Billy Eichner: Sparfies.

[1:26:58] Susan Blackwell: Let's open up the sparkfies.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred