Did you know there was a show called Legs Diamond? Did you know it was based on a real person? Ebony did, and she is gonna tell it!.. Read More
From the show: Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast by Ebony Vines and Pamela Shandrow
About
Did you know there was a show called Legs Diamond? Did you know it was based on a real person? Ebony did, and she is gonna tell it!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Pamela Shandrow: Welcome to Theatre Geeks Anonymous.
[0:03] Ebony Vines: At this time, we ask that you turn off all cell phones.
[0:06] Pamela Shandrow: Unless, of course, you're using them to listen to this podcast.
[0:09] Ebony Vines: In which case, please keep it on.
[0:11] Pamela Shandrow: And please refrain from any flash photography, as it is dangerous to the performers of this podcast.
[0:18] Ebony Vines: And now sit back, relax, and enjoy the show.
[0:26] Pamela Shandrow: Don't you see? It's so simple. Step one. We Google the biggest flops on Broadway. Step two. We find the crazy stories behind them. Step three. We see how they lose millions of dollars. Millions! Broadway isn't cheap. A lot of fancy people want to be producers. Step four, find out why the show won't go on. Step five, end this episode and head to Times Square.
[0:48] Ebony Vines: Times Square! That'll never work. Only Broadway successes are in Times Square.
[0:54] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, ye of little faith. Welcome.
[1:01] Ebony Vines: I thought I'd try a different welcome today.
[1:04] Pamela Shandrow: Hey, Theater Geeks.
[1:06] Ebony Vines: Hello.
[1:07] Pamela Shandrow: This is Pamela.
[1:08] Ebony Vines: And this is Ebony.
[1:09] Pamela Shandrow: Welcome to Theater Geeks Anonymous, where we talk about Broadway flops, uh, scandals and new work. Who fails, who sues, we tell their story.
[1:17] Ebony Vines: We are gonna tell it.
[1:20] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, guys. Oh, how did your week go?
[1:23] Ebony Vines: You went on vacation.
[1:24] Pamela Shandrow: I was on vacation.
[1:25] Ebony Vines: I was like, from the city. It was amazing. Gulf Shores, Alabama.
[1:30] Pamela Shandrow: Um, this is really telling. My parents like to go to the Hangout Music Festival, um, which happens in Gulf Shores every year, but it's relatively new. I think it's just like eight years old or something like that.
[1:42] Ebony Vines: But my dad and mom have been going every single year. And then, like, they'll add family members here and there each year, but every year they'll rent a beach house, and they'll go to the music festival over the weekend, and then the rest of the time we'll just hang out.
[1:55] Pamela Shandrow: But like, I'll send them off to the music festival and I'll wrap myself up in all of these little, you know, different layers of sun protection and go out on the beach and read. It is so relaxing and lovely. I always, I just love it there.
[2:09] Ebony Vines: That's awesome. That sounds very nice.
[2:10] Pamela Shandrow: It was nice. So if I talk like this, that's because I'm really relaxed. What's the show we're gonna talk about today, Ebony?
[2:21] Ebony Vines: Oh, today we are going to talk about a gangster musical.
[2:27] Pamela Shandrow: What?
[2:28] Ebony Vines: Well, is it Bullets Over Broadway?
[2:30] Pamela Shandrow: It is not Bullets Over Broadway.
[2:32] Ebony Vines: Oh, is it Guys and Dolls?
[2:33] Pamela Shandrow: It's not Guys and Dolls, because that was a hit.
[2:37] Ebony Vines: That's very true. I was just trying to think of all the gangster musicals. Oh, is it Bonnie and Clyde?
[2:42] Pamela Shandrow: It is not Bonnie and Clyde.
[2:43] Ebony Vines: Well, all right. So today's musical is called LEGS DIAMOND.
[2:45] Pamela Shandrow: LEGS DIAMOND.
[2:50] Ebony Vines: The musical. Like, that's what it's called.
[2:54] Pamela Shandrow: Awesome. Um, so LEGS DIAMOND the Musical was a passion project for Peter Allen. And, uh, some of you will know Peter Allen because you will know Hugh Jackman.
[3:08] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[3:09] Pamela Shandrow: Who did, uh, was it a one-man musical? Or was it which show?
[3:14] Ebony Vines: Um, when he did, uh, oh crap, what's it called? Not The Boy from Oz.
[3:19] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, The Boy from Oz was all about Peter Allen's life.
[3:22] Ebony Vines: Right.
[3:22] Pamela Shandrow: It's not a one-man musical. There are other characters in it, but yes, I mean, it did, I mean, really honestly, it kind of played that way because nobody told us about the show itself. They just said Hugh Jackman was in it.
[3:33] Ebony Vines: Right. Yeah.
[3:34] Pamela Shandrow: Okay. So, so yeah, The Boy From Oz, which was, uh, the show that Hugh Jackman did a few years ago, was based on Peter Allen's life, and Peter Allen was Australian, but he was sort of like New York's Liberace.
[3:50] Ebony Vines: Like he was very, um, flamboyant.
[3:52] Pamela Shandrow: Very flamboyant, shiny, sparkly. Um, he did concerts mostly. He wasn't known for being in a musical.
[4:01] Ebony Vines: Okay.
[4:02] Pamela Shandrow: Um, so, uh, the LEGS DIAMOND musical was going to be his first, like, foray into an actual, like, Broadway show.
[4:10] Ebony Vines: Cool.
[4:11] Pamela Shandrow: So, uh, what had happened is he had seen this movie from the 1960s, um, about LEGS DIAMOND, and I'll just give you, uh, a little backstory. So the musical, uh, is also known as the totally fictitious musical history of LEGS DIAMOND.
[4:30] Ebony Vines: So if you can imagine with me, um, you're in a Broadway theater and some shiny sparkly lights come down and it says LEGS DIAMOND. I mean, like bright, shiny, colorful lights, and then underneath that a whole nother set of lights and letters come down and it says the totally fictitious musical history of LEGS DIAMOND.
[4:54] Pamela Shandrow: It's like I'm there.
[4:55] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Uh, and if you would like to do this to yourself, which I did, there is an extremely bootleg version that you can watch on YouTube. Guys, it's so bootlegged, somebody's head's in the way.
[5:13] Pamela Shandrow: It's grainy, and you can see like it's VHS. I mean, this is some old school stuff.
[5:20] Ebony Vines: Uh, and, uh, real to real. It's, it's, it's painful. But I, I, I did it, and I mean, you can, here's the thing is you can kind of make out humans.
[5:34] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[5:34] Ebony Vines: Like all the white people are kind of white, shiny, colorful blobs, and all the black people are like darkness, and then you can see a costume moving. So you figure that must be a person.
[5:46] Pamela Shandrow: That's a person in there.
[5:48] Ebony Vines: Okay. Awesome. Okay, so, um, the LEGS DIAMOND musical used the film The Rise and Fall of LEGS DIAMOND from 1960 for its source material. Uh, the demise of the musical we're gonna speak about is also, uh, the origin story of the Times Square Church. So we'll talk about, uh, both of those today.
[6:13] Pamela Shandrow: Cool, cool. Uh, LEGS DIAMOND was a real bootlegger gangster from the Prohibition era who worked mainly in Philadelphia and New York City.
[6:22] Ebony Vines: Um, his first, his first name was Jack, right?
[6:27] Pamela Shandrow: So it's Jack Legs DIAMOND. He was born John Thomas DIAMOND, uh, in July of 1897.
[6:34] Ebony Vines: Did he have gorgeous legs?
[6:36] Pamela Shandrow: Well, we'll get into how he got the nickname LEGS DIAMOND, but as a child, he was just John Thomas DIAMOND.
[6:43] Ebony Vines: Um, which is a cool last name, right?
[6:45] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. Um, so Jack had a younger brother named Eddie Diamond, and Jack and Eddie both struggled through grade school. Um, and their mother Sarah suffered a lot of health issues, and then in December of 1913, she passed away from complications due to high fever and bacterial infection.
[7:04] Ebony Vines: So John Sr., John Diamond Sr., their father moved them to Brooklyn shortly after.
[7:09] Pamela Shandrow: How old were they?
[7:11] Ebony Vines: Um, so if he was born in 1897 and she died in 1913, and they left, uh, a few months later, uh, math. Let me just get my ninety-seven, so three years.
[7:30] Pamela Shandrow: So ten, he was ten.
[7:31] Ebony Vines: Ten, he was ten. Um, that was really fast for me.
[7:34] Pamela Shandrow: Good job.
[7:35] Ebony Vines: Thank you. I do musical things. I mean, this is like simple math, too. And I'm like, um no, I can't. Um, his father was, uh, an Irish immigrant.
[7:49] Pamela Shandrow: Um, and so they moved to Brooklyn from Philadelphia.
[7:55] Ebony Vines: Okay.
[7:56] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, so Brooklyn from Philly. Uh, DIAMOND soon joined a New York street gang called the Hudson Dusters. Diamond's first arrest for burglary occurred when he broke into a jewelry store in February of 1914.
[8:13] Ebony Vines: So he was about 11 years old.
[8:14] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my gosh.
[8:16] Ebony Vines: And he's already been arrested.
[8:18] Pamela Shandrow: I know your mother died, but behave yourself.
[8:22] Ebony Vines: Uh, okay, wait. Wait, cut 'cause it's saying here when he was seventeen.
[8:29] Pamela Shandrow: February fourth, nineteen fourteen, he was seventeen.
[8:33] Ebony Vines: When was he born?
[8:34] Pamela Shandrow: This is eighteen ninety-seven.
[8:38] Ebony Vines: I think we might have done some bad math.
[8:58] Pamela Shandrow: So it turns out we did bad math.
[9:00] Ebony Vines: Okay, sorry everybody. So when I told you that I'm musical theater and not a mathematician, that is because I don't do math well.
[9:07] Pamela Shandrow: So he was not 10. He was 16.
[9:09] Ebony Vines: 16.
[9:10] Pamela Shandrow: Okay. Sorry. Continue your story.
[9:14] Ebony Vines: So he was 16 at his first arrest. He was 16 when they moved. And then at 17, he had his first arrest for um jewelry theft.
[9:25] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[9:26] Ebony Vines: Uh, DIAMOND served in the U.S. Army during World War One, but deserted in 1918 or 1919, they're not sure of which year, and was then convicted and jailed for desertion.
[9:37] Pamela Shandrow: How long?
[9:39] Ebony Vines: Um, let's see. Uh, it was only a few months.
[9:43] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay.
[9:44] Ebony Vines: Because, uh, the next thing is once he got free from jail, um, he became a thug and later a personal bodyguard for Arnold Rothstein, and that happened in 1919.
[9:56] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[9:56] Ebony Vines: So he was only in jail a few months for desertion.
[9:59] Pamela Shandrow: Wow.
[10:01] Ebony Vines: Uh, so in October of 1927, DIAMOND tried to stop the murder of little Augie. Uh, his name was Jacob Organ. Um, as Organ and DIAMOND were walking down a street on the lower east side, three young men approached them and started shooting.
[10:17] Pamela Shandrow: Organ was fatally wounded and DIAMOND was shot two times below the heart.
[10:21] Ebony Vines: Diamond was taken to Bellevue Hospital, um, where he eventually recovered.
[10:26] Pamela Shandrow: So this is very important because one of the, uh, sort of legends surrounding LEGS DIAMOND is that, you know, he had like nine lives like a cat. It's like impossible to kill him.
[10:42] Ebony Vines: So, and this is the first time that he almost died.
[10:45] Pamela Shandrow: Wow.
[10:46] Ebony Vines: So this just like continues throughout his life.
[10:48] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[10:49] Ebony Vines: Uh, so the police interviewed DIAMOND in the hospital, but he refused to identify any suspects, and the police initially suspected that DIAMOND was an accomplice and charged him with homicide, but the charge was later dropped.
[11:04] Pamela Shandrow: Um, Jack Diamond was also known as Gentleman Jack.
[11:09] Ebony Vines: Uh, DIAMOND survived a number of attempts on his life, as I just said, and it was between the years of nineteen sixteen and nineteen thirty-one, causing him to be known as the Clay Pigeon of the Underworld.
[11:20] Pamela Shandrow: His nickname, Legs, either came from the swiftness, uh, with which he created, he created crime.
[11:27] Ebony Vines: No, created crime. I think I was supposed to say he like fled or escaped them.
[11:34] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[11:34] Ebony Vines: Um, evaded.
[11:38] Pamela Shandrow: Or his ability to be a great dancer.
[11:41] Ebony Vines: It's one or the other. But apparently, like he really was a good dancer. Like this is like a real thing.
[11:48] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[11:48] Ebony Vines: Um, if you watch the movie, you'll see like it's a huge part of the movie.
[11:53] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, how fun.
[11:54] Ebony Vines: Um, but that, I mean, honestly, that leads itself to be a fantastic musical.
[12:00] Pamela Shandrow: Well, I mean, you would think in a way, like you would say, you know, this man, this man had this talent, you know, for, but I saw the movie and I thought I hate this person.
[12:16] Ebony Vines: Well, he's a thug.
[12:18] Pamela Shandrow: Right. But I feel like I have seen other shows. Case in point, Bonnie and Clyde.
[12:23] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[12:24] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, it's like I wa, I listened to it because I didn't have the pleasure of being able to see the musical, but I listened to it and I still felt for them.
[12:33] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[12:33] Pamela Shandrow: You know, I felt for them constantly getting into trouble. Like even when I saw Bonnie and Clyde, the movie, you know, um, the one with, uh, Faye Dunaway and Warren Beatty, and you're just like kind of want them to succeed, even though they're doing horrible things.
[12:49] Ebony Vines: Right.
[12:50] Pamela Shandrow: Or not like you, you know that this isn't actually what they'd want to be doing, right? Especially Bonnie, like that's not what she wanted to be doing. She wanted to be famous and go to Hollywood, but they were poor. You know, they had no money, and, um, you know, it, it, it was also, uh, during the Great Depression.
[13:12] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[13:12] Pamela Shandrow: So there's, you have to have some sympathy for a character in order to sit with them for two and a half hours.
[13:20] Ebony Vines: Absolutely, there's gotta be something in them that is redeemable enough or that you can connect with, and I just sat there and I was like, No, you're just Satan. That's all.
[13:32] Pamela Shandrow: Yep.
[13:34] Ebony Vines: So, um, so yeah, so then, uh, in December, we'll go back to the story. Uh, DIAMOND was also a womanizer, and he was best known, his best known mistress was a showgirl and dancer named Marion Kiki Roberts.
[13:50] Pamela Shandrow: Call me Kiki.
[13:52] Ebony Vines: The public loved DIAMOND; he was upstate New York's biggest celebrity at the time. So he was all over New York, just not New York City, or not only New York City, sorry. Uh, and uh Philadelphia. December 1931, DIAMOND had been staying in a rooming house in Albany, New York, while on trial in Troy, New York on kidnapping charges. Oh my. On December 17th, DIAMOND was acquitted. That night, DIAMOND, his family, and friends were at a restaurant at 1 a.m. Diamond went to visit his mistress, Mary and Kiki Roberts. At 4:30 a.m., DIAMOND went back to the rooming house and passed out on his bed. Two gunmen entered his room around an hour later. One man held down DIAMOND while the other shot him three times in the back of the head. Oh my goodness.
[14:40] Pamela Shandrow: Was this his second life?
[14:42] Ebony Vines: No, this was it. This was it. So that was a thing; there had been multiple attempts on his life. And this time they were like, you know, we're doing it for real this time. They weren't messing around. Sheesh. So speculation as to who may have killed Legs. They thought maybe local politicians may have gotten together to get rid of him in order to prove they had a handle on the city and no one would disrupt the image they were so proud of making. Others speculate it was the chief of police who received a promotion right after Legs was killed. And many have believed he received that promotion because he took Legs out. It is thought that it may have been his arch nemesis Dutch Schultz who wanted him out of New York City so that he could have free reign over the territory.
[15:25] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[15:26] Ebony Vines: Legs is now buried at Mount Olivet Cemetery in Maspeth, Queens.
[15:33] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[15:34] Ebony Vines: So he's in Queens. Not too far away from us.
[15:36] Pamela Shandrow: No. We can go visit his grave. Do you want to?
[15:40] Ebony Vines: I think that's the song that Sarah Bareilles wrote, "The Cemetery in the Center of Queens."
[15:45] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, yeah, yeah.
[15:46] Ebony Vines: It's a great song.
[15:47] Pamela Shandrow: It is a great song. I love that.
[15:49] Ebony Vines: I wanted to actually get that song together for auditioning.
[15:51] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, you should. Maybe I still will. It's a good song.
[15:54] Ebony Vines: It is a great song. It's a really old city. I freaking love it.
[15:59] Pamela Shandrow: Totally. I listen to it often.
[16:02] Ebony Vines: Alright, so the movie was produced by Warner Brothers Studios, which is important because that's who Peter had to get the rights from in order to write this musical.
[16:13] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[16:14] Ebony Vines: And it was directed by Bud Baldchear and written by Joseph Landon. The cast included Ray Danton as Jack Legs DIAMOND, Robert Lowry as Arnold Rothstein, Karen Steele as Alice Scott, Legs' wife, and Warren Oates as Legs' kid brother Eddie Diamond.
[16:37] Pamela Shandrow: Um, so as I was just complaining about how I didn't like LEGS DIAMOND and there was like nothing redeemable about him in the movie, I read an article that talked about this and said that gangster movies of that era failed to make the characters likable.
[16:53] Ebony Vines: Oh, there you go.
[16:54] Pamela Shandrow: So I was like, boom, that's why I hated him. Um, and so within like the first 10 minutes of the movie, I was like, uh, DIAMOND is putting stolen goods in a woman's purse, whom he literally met five minutes before. And I was just like screaming at the television and saying he was a jerk.
[17:14] Ebony Vines: Okay, so that musical theater life. Here we go. The players. Peter Allen. I already talked about him. Harvey Fierstein and Charles Seppin. Charles Seppin was actually a famous costume designer.
[17:30] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[17:30] Ebony Vines: So he was Peter Allen's costume designer. They had been good friends for a long time. But he set all the rhinestones onto his capes. And so he actually wrote the first incarnation of the book, and then Harvey was brought in to help rework it. But then they felt like it was going in too dark of a direction. But it was still Harvey and Charles. So Charles Seppin was the first and only librettist to also win a Cody Award for women's wear design.
[18:19] Pamela Shandrow: And those plays were The Slab Boys and Bent.
[18:21] Ebony Vines: Okay.
[18:22] Pamela Shandrow: And by all accounts, they were pretty good.
[18:24] Ebony Vines: Yeah. So musicals are different.
[18:28] Pamela Shandrow: Completely different.
[18:29] Ebony Vines: Completely different. David Mitchell was the set designer and Michael Sean was the choreographer.
[18:37] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, previews began for the LEGS DIAMOND musical on October 25th of 1988.
[18:45] Ebony Vines: So here's your first problem. There were no tryouts.
[18:47] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.
[18:50] Ebony Vines: LEGS DIAMOND had no out-of-town tryout.
[18:54] Pamela Shandrow: No, no.
[18:55] Ebony Vines: Are you talking about you thought? Okay, you thought there was like no audition.
[19:00] Pamela Shandrow: I was like, what did they do? Did they just roll around there?
[19:03] Ebony Vines: No, you're talking out-of-town tryouts.
[19:04] Pamela Shandrow: Out-of-town tryouts.
[19:06] Ebony Vines: So there was a workshop.
[19:07] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[19:07] Ebony Vines: Um, and so they basically just used the same cast from the workshop.
[19:11] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[19:11] Ebony Vines: But they didn't have an out-of-town tryout. For people in our audience, workshops and tryouts are completely different. A workshop is really just like a one-off, like maybe one or two performances in front of an audience, and it's sort of how the material goes. It's not even like fully staged. But like a tryout would be a complete, fully performed production where you get real audience members, not just friends and family, like real, and being able to really figure out whether or not this show works and in what areas where they need to be changed.
[19:45] Pamela Shandrow: So for them not to have a tryout is really unprecedented.
[19:48] Ebony Vines: It's really unheard of. It's not a great idea.
[19:52] Pamela Shandrow: No, because it gives the writers and the entire creative team so much more time to work out the kinks before you bring it to Broadway.
[20:03] Ebony Vines: That's true, it's true. Uh, you know, so even if you're not gonna do an out-of-town tryout, a lot of places will at the very least do an off-Broadway.
[20:11] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[20:12] Ebony Vines: Alright. So previews began October 25th, 1988. Uh, as I stated, the first book was darker than they felt was best for the show. Um, the set that David—so part of the reason that there was no out-of-town tryout was the set that David Mitchell had created apparently was too elaborate to like move.
[20:39] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[20:40] Ebony Vines: Um, so it made a tour impossible.
[20:43] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[20:44] Ebony Vines: Um, I mean, I know. And I'm just—and I also read that like the Netherlander organization, they were just like so hot to get something in their—
[20:56] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[20:56] Ebony Vines: —because this was the Mark Alendor Theater, which was riddled with problems for whatever reason, all during the '80s to actually have like a successful run of a show. I mean, and this is the theater that had shows like My Fair Lady in it. So originally it had, you know, just hit after hit after hit, but for some reason—and I'm sure economics had a lot to do with it because you had in like 1976, you had a chorus line just bringing Broadway back to life. And so all through the '80s, it was still basically trying to find its footing.
[21:32] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[21:33] Ebony Vines: So unfortunately, the Mark Elinger was one of those theaters that just could not get a hit to stay inside of it. And so here you have LEGS DIAMOND, and they're just trying to get something in. Also, it was the first new—it was sorry, the only new book musical set for the 1989-1990 season.
[21:56] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[21:57] Ebony Vines: So if you also look to a season pressure.
[22:01] Pamela Shandrow: It is.
[22:02] Ebony Vines: I mean, if you also look to the year that Sunset Boulevard first came out, it was also the only new book musical for that entire season and won the Tony Award for best new musical because it was very well.
[22:14] Pamela Shandrow: Well, it was the only musical.
[22:16] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[22:16] Pamela Shandrow: Like the only other one was a review.
[22:19] Ebony Vines: So that doesn't have a book.
[22:20] Pamela Shandrow: Yep.
[22:20] Ebony Vines: So it just didn't, you know, so like I said, the '80s and like very, very early '90s were sort of a difficult time. Alright, so here's where I mean, already we'd had a bumpy start with no out-of-town tryout. The set's too elaborate and bulky, so you can't do one. Uh, then Michael Sean, the choreographer is fired and replaced by Alan Johnson because they don't feel like he's getting like the real feel of the show.
[22:52] Pamela Shandrow: The show saw several opening night postponements and ended up having, which is unheard of, an eight-week preview cycle.
[23:01] Ebony Vines: So there was eight weeks of previews.
[23:05] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my goodness.
[23:07] Ebony Vines: There's never—guys, guys. There's never eight weeks of previews.
[23:10] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe two.
[23:11] Ebony Vines: Maybe. But even that's pushing it. Eight weeks of previews is a few years.
[23:16] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe they were using previews instead of tryout.
[23:19] Ebony Vines: The tryout.
[23:20] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[23:20] Ebony Vines: No, because the thing about a tryout is that usually when you're gonna do one, you do multiple.
[23:29] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[23:30] Ebony Vines: And you have weeks in each location and full audiences so that you have plenty of time to work out all of the kinks. It's like if you listen to the Annie episode, and when they went back and did Annie Warbucks, they had all that time at the Goodspeed Theater. And so first they went to DC, it wasn't working in DC, so they shut the whole thing down and then they went to Goodspeed and then reworked it. That's what you just need time because without an audience, you can't figure out like what works and what doesn't work. But like once you're on Broadway, like people expect it to be ready.
[24:12] Pamela Shandrow: It's supposed to be ready. Fully fleshed out, all kinks gone, you're on Broadway.
[24:16] Ebony Vines: That's right. But people—it's New York. We don't mess around.
[24:19] Pamela Shandrow: It's not messing around here.
[24:22] Ebony Vines: Well, it's a lot of money to spend on something that isn't fully—like if I'm going to a tryout in Boston or in Philly, that's what I'm paying for. But if I'm paying for a Broadway ticket, my expectations are gonna be much higher.
[24:35] Pamela Shandrow: My expectations are that you already did your work.
[24:38] Ebony Vines: That's right. And I can sit in the audience and enjoy what I'm about to see. And then with this being the only new book musical slated for the entire season, it had a lot of buzz and anticipation surrounding it.
[24:51] Pamela Shandrow: And so you had a lot of audience members who were, you know, excited to see something new, see something fresh, see something that wasn't a revival.
[25:01] Ebony Vines: And so when, you know, when people have that anticipation already in their minds, and you know, you're going and you don't actually know what this show's gonna be, like this, it doesn't make—it doesn't make—it's not a good sign.
[25:21] Pamela Shandrow: No, this is not a good start.
[25:22] Ebony Vines: No, alright. So unfortunately, during the eight weeks, there was a lot of bad mouth already.
[25:30] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[25:30] Ebony Vines: Um, not surprised, right?
[25:33] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[25:34] Ebony Vines: Um, and it has been likened to that of the whole Merrily We Roll Along saga, which Merrily We Roll Along went into previews in 1981 and had to undergo radical changes because of such dismal word of mouth.
[25:48] Pamela Shandrow: So they're likening it—can you imagine? I mean, like the '80s we didn't have social media; like today, the show would be dead in the water in an hour.
[25:58] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[25:58] Pamela Shandrow: Twitter, Facebook.
[26:00] Ebony Vines: Because that kind of word of mouth, I mean, oh, it goes down fast. Um, so major cash changes occurred to LEGS DIAMOND. So the role of Legs' wife, Alice, which was played by Christine Andreas, was eliminated.
[26:19] Pamela Shandrow: I love her.
[26:20] Ebony Vines: Do you? Scarlett Pimpernel?
[26:22] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, yeah, yeah.
[26:23] Ebony Vines: Oh, she's good.
[26:25] Pamela Shandrow: And then Legs' brother, Eddie, played by Bob Stillman, was also eliminated.
[26:31] Ebony Vines: Oh, wow. If you see the movie, Alice and Eddie are integral.
[26:37] Pamela Shandrow: Integral to the story.
[26:41] Ebony Vines: And as I read the synopsis, you know, the short little history of the actual Legs' life, like they are very important.
[26:50] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.
[26:51] Ebony Vines: So, I mean, those cuts were to me, those cuts show they just didn't—they were grasping.
[27:01] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[27:02] Ebony Vines: You know, because they were like, oh, I don't know, we just have to cut somebody. They didn't know what they were doing.
[27:07] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, yikes.
[27:09] Ebony Vines: Uh, Peter Allen's attempts to play so totally against type as a suave Lothario and his inability to act were—they tried to remedy it with rewrites, adding monologues for him to speak directly to the audience because people were so used to his cabaret shows.
[27:25] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[27:26] Ebony Vines: So even though that maybe could quell the problem of his inability to be a great actor, it still doesn't help.
[27:46] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Like, imagine Liberacci on stage trying to woo women and be a person that women just fall all over.
[28:00] Pamela Shandrow: Maybe that's why they cut the wife.
[28:01] Ebony Vines: Maybe they're just they couldn't create that chemistry. Well, the thing is though, they still had all the mistresses.
[28:07] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, that's true.
[28:08] Ebony Vines: So it wasn't even, it was like, okay, so Alice is gone. Alice the sort of backbone.
[28:14] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[28:14] Ebony Vines: But like we're gonna leave all of these other women that he's supposedly and so and so that did not work.
[28:22] Pamela Shandrow: No.
[28:22] Ebony Vines: Um so opening night was December 26, 1988, and Frank Ridge commented that the evening's most compelling drama was watching Alan figure out what to do with his hands. It opened the day after Christmas and ended up closing February 19th, 1989.
[28:45] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[28:46] Ebony Vines: After how many? So if we say it went into previews in October trying to do math again.
[28:55] Pamela Shandrow: Y'all figure it out.
[28:56] Ebony Vines: Preview started October 25th, 1988. It opened December 26th, 1988, and then it closed February 19th, 1989.
[29:07] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[29:07] Ebony Vines: And if you do eight performances a week, you do the math, you'll figure it out. Okay, so um I listened to the soundtrack.
[29:17] Pamela Shandrow: So if you're at all also interested, I already told you about YouTube, but you can listen to the entire um cast recording on Spotify.
[29:26] Ebony Vines: What did you think?
[29:30] Pamela Shandrow: I I will Okay, so at I was doing research for LEGS DIAMOND and doing research for Leap of Faith, and we were gonna do Bonnie and Clyde this season, but we're pushing it for next season. And so I was like on the train and I would just be listening to all these recordings on Spotify.
[29:49] Ebony Vines: Spotify. If anybody from Spotify is listening, bless you for your cast recording. Thank you very much.
[29:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, yes.
[29:57] Ebony Vines: Um, and so I was like, well, it's not as bad as the Leap of Faith recording.
[30:04] Pamela Shandrow: Like Oh dear.
[30:06] Ebony Vines: Yeah. It it and it was, you know, there were songs that kind of really got stuck in your head. There were like lines from songs that got stuck in your head. So I wouldn't I wouldn't say that it was, you know, I feel like uh I would say a decent musical at least has a songs get stuck in your head.
[30:27] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, that's true.
[30:29] Ebony Vines: And Peter Allen's voice and songs were they were. They were lodged in my brain for weeks after I listened to it. Um, but I was annoyed by the the female characters.
[30:43] Pamela Shandrow: Like I do feel like I am a feminist in one way.
[30:47] Ebony Vines: Sure. And so I was really frustrated with how, you know, of course, they completely lost their there was no the Bechdel test was blown to smithereens.
[31:00] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, so that's number one.
[31:02] Ebony Vines: Like just blown to smithereens. And so all any woman sang about was how much she was in love with LEGS DIAMOND and how messed up he was, and like the names they called themselves. I just know I was unhappy, unhappy.
[31:23] Pamela Shandrow: And I get it in terms of the fact that LEGS DIAMOND was a Lothario, he was a player, he didn't treat women with respect.
[31:33] Ebony Vines: Right. So, okay, so it stands to reason that you know he would not be treating women with respect, and the women would be singing about how they were disrespected.
[31:44] Pamela Shandrow: But they weren't even singing angrily about being disrespected.
[31:48] Ebony Vines: So I was like, at least get pissed off.
[31:51] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[31:51] Ebony Vines: Something. I need something, ladies.
[31:53] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, more than just the Joe eyes.
[31:56] Ebony Vines: No, I can't. I couldn't, I can't abide.
[31:58] Pamela Shandrow: Well, maybe they used that as a device, though, so that the audience had some indication that LEGS DIAMOND was likable. Do you think?
[32:06] Ebony Vines: I mean, it didn't work one way or the other.
[32:09] Pamela Shandrow: It didn't work at all.
[32:10] Ebony Vines: That's too bad. Okay, so just so you can see just a little bit of why I was upset. Uh, there were songs with lyrics like, if you love me, put your knockers away.
[32:30] Pamela Shandrow: I think I'm blushing.
[32:32] Ebony Vines: Oh, okay. And then um, there's another song called I Was Made for Champagne.
[32:39] Pamela Shandrow: So it's one of those girls and she's just singing. I mean, she's basically like this Marilyn Monroe, gentlemen prefer blondes.
[32:46] Ebony Vines: Um, what's another movie? Mary How to Marry a Millionaire.
[32:50] Pamela Shandrow: Isn't that a movie?
[32:52] Ebony Vines: Yeah, Marilyn Monroe.
[32:54] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, oh yes, I think so, yeah.
[32:57] Ebony Vines: Um DIAMOND are a girl's best friend. So I was made for champagne is very much like that.
[33:02] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[33:03] Ebony Vines: And then uh the song Only an Older Woman.
[33:08] Pamela Shandrow: So that's like What is she 30?
[33:11] Ebony Vines: Right? So fresh. She so she's like this older woman who's just like lamenting about how much she loves legs, and only a woman of her age could really understand and love him the way that he would need to be.
[33:26] Pamela Shandrow: But like he doesn't care about anyone.
[33:28] Ebony Vines: So it's just really frustrating to listen to. So after the failure, the failure failure was so total.
[33:36] Pamela Shandrow: Mm-hmm.
[33:37] Ebony Vines: Um it compelled the Netherlander organization to sell uh the Mark Callender Theater. And so Times Square Church had already been wait, based on that show.
[33:49] Pamela Shandrow: That was like the last show they did because it was just a series of total failures.
[33:53] Ebony Vines: That was just the final nail on the coffin. So uh Times Square Church had already been renting the Netherlander Theater, which is still in use now.
[34:04] Pamela Shandrow: Uh War Paint is there right now.
[34:07] Ebony Vines: They had been renting it uh for their Sunday services, and so they already had this um relationship with the Netherlander organization.
[34:17] Pamela Shandrow: So they entered into a I think it was it's it's a funny lease. It's like a hundred-year lease or a thousand-year lease, like something really funny like that um with the Netherlander organization for the Mark Aller Theater, and they've kept it in really excellent condition.
[34:38] Ebony Vines: It's beautiful. Have you been there?
[34:40] Pamela Shandrow: Oh yeah, oh yeah.
[34:41] Ebony Vines: And that they also allow you to take tours.
[34:43] Pamela Shandrow: So if you're not a churchgoer like Pamela and I are, who've actually been there for service.
[34:48] Ebony Vines: For service, yeah, it's really neat. Um, you can just take a tour of it, and it's it's really it's beautiful.
[34:53] Pamela Shandrow: And I think I mean it's a large theater. It's like a 3,000 seat theater.
[34:55] Ebony Vines: It's a very large theater, and they pack that thing.
[35:00] Pamela Shandrow: They do and they have another services.
[35:02] Ebony Vines: Yeah, it's really incredible.
[35:04] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[35:05] Ebony Vines: So you know what? It's like I I am glad that the theater is still in beautiful condition and is still, you know, this church.
[35:16] Pamela Shandrow: I I love it because this church has said we also like we see the value of theater.
[35:21] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[35:22] Pamela Shandrow: Like, so we are going to keep this theater in good condition, and we're going to recognize that there's a beautiful history there, and we will still allow people to come in and to partake and to see like where theatric theater history was made.
[35:37] Ebony Vines: And we're also going to, you know, worship God.
[35:41] Pamela Shandrow: So that's what happened to the Mark Elinger Theater.
[35:44] Ebony Vines: Um the sets and costumes were basically thrown into the Hudson River.
[35:52] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my god.
[35:52] Ebony Vines: Like a dead body.
[35:54] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[35:55] Ebony Vines: Wow. I was like kind of a fitting end, though.
[35:59] Pamela Shandrow: It really is.
[36:01] Ebony Vines: Did they tie the clothing and sets to like cinder blocks?
[36:03] Pamela Shandrow: I know.
[36:05] Ebony Vines: I know, right? It's the weirdest thing. Like I read that and I was like, are you kidding me? But no, they just they were like, uh they were just like all trashed, and so they're like they're in a landfill at the bottom of the Hudson River.
[36:21] Pamela Shandrow: Uh you know, because Kelly, I think Kelly was one of the shows too that we have done on this podcast.
[36:28] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[36:28] Pamela Shandrow: That the sets and costumes all ended at the landfill as well.
[36:32] Ebony Vines: Maybe I'm getting them confused.
[36:33] Pamela Shandrow: But it well, no, it wasn't the Hudson River, though. There was no Hudson River involved.
[36:37] Ebony Vines: If I'm wrong, I will be back on the mini soats to to uh say that.
[36:44] Pamela Shandrow: But yeah, I'm pretty sure they were all destroyed.
[36:46] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Um not only that, but it was very it's very difficult to find the orchestrations.
[36:52] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.
[36:53] Ebony Vines: Wait, so um in 2012, yeah, it just said uh LEGS DIAMOND got a reading in December of 2012, but they did have difficulty finding the orchestrations, so they had to basically create them from what they heard from listening.
[37:09] Pamela Shandrow: Oh yeah.
[37:10] Ebony Vines: So that they could do so that they could do it.
[37:12] Pamela Shandrow: Well, wait though, because I mean I'm assuming that they got the rights to perform it.
[37:16] Ebony Vines: Right.
[37:17] Pamela Shandrow: So why wouldn't the orchestrations just weren't available?
[37:19] Ebony Vines: Yeah, no, like isn't it? Like it's like they they can't find them. Like they contacted the Peter Allen estate.
[37:26] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[37:27] Ebony Vines: And they could not get the orchestration. So it's just one of those weird things.
[37:31] Pamela Shandrow: It really sounds like for him, this was such a dismal failure, and just was so disheartening.
[37:39] Ebony Vines: Delete it delete it completely. Just like pretend it didn't happen. A bunch of the songs were used in The Boy from Oz, though.
[37:46] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[37:48] Ebony Vines: Uh so and this is like a weird, weird foreshadowing.
[37:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[37:56] Ebony Vines: Like really creepy foreshadowing. So the beginning of the second act in the LEGS DIAMOND musical.
[38:03] Pamela Shandrow: So creepy, you guys.
[38:05] Ebony Vines: I'm just LEGS DIAMOND is dancing on his coffin.
[38:11] Pamela Shandrow: And he said it he sings, I'm in Showbiz, only a critic can kill me.
[38:19] Ebony Vines: Well, that's and that's what happened.
[38:21] Pamela Shandrow: That is what happened for the show.
[38:23] Ebony Vines: That's what happened.
[38:24] Pamela Shandrow: Yikes.
[38:25] Ebony Vines: And uh, I mean, it really did kill his Broadway career.
[38:28] Pamela Shandrow: Like there was no there was no more broadband.
[38:32] Ebony Vines: So that's the story of LEGS DIAMOND, the musical guys.
[38:35] Pamela Shandrow: That is a good story.
[38:37] Ebony Vines: I mean, it's always it. I think it's always sad when someone's dream dies.
[38:42] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[38:43] Ebony Vines: I mean, it's not like Peter Allen had a terrible career. You know, he was known for his flamboyance and for his uh fire and his energy.
[38:56] Pamela Shandrow: And his charisma and his career.
[38:59] Ebony Vines: Not known as a Lothario.
[39:01] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[39:01] Ebony Vines: So it's like play to your strengths.
[39:04] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[39:05] Ebony Vines: Right? And like know your audience, which I've said so many times on this podcast is people not understanding and owning who they are.
[39:14] Pamela Shandrow: And so when you don't own who you are and you know, play to your strengths, you know, you're lose you're gonna lose.
[39:23] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[39:24] Pamela Shandrow: I don't want I don't want people to leave thinking that we that we want you to stay in your own little box, that you shouldn't, you know, branch out and try something that you want to do that's different from what you're used to.
[39:35] Ebony Vines: But when you try something new, you can't expect to just dive into the deep end and have success.
[39:44] Pamela Shandrow: You really do have to have an idea of what you're doing and how to do it.
[39:48] Ebony Vines: And you need to surround yourself with people that have that kind of experience.
[39:52] Pamela Shandrow: Otherwise, you don't have a foundation that's strong enough to really compete.
[39:58] Ebony Vines: So I want to remind everybody to rate, review, and subscribe on iTunes when you listen to this podcast.
[40:06] Pamela Shandrow: Um tell your friends about us.
[40:07] Ebony Vines: Uh if you would like to, you can also like, share, and follow on Facebook at Theatre Geeks Anonymous.
[40:12] Pamela Shandrow: You can follow us at on Twitter at T G A way.
[40:20] Ebony Vines: T G G A B U A at Gmail.com. If you've got any questions or comments, or if you've got any stories, we want to hear them.
[40:27] Pamela Shandrow: We can do a little intermission sode.
[40:29] Ebony Vines: Yeah. We yeah, we need you to send us any questions about these episodes that you have.
[40:34] Pamela Shandrow: We need if there's any corrections and omissions.
[40:37] Ebony Vines: Totally. If you know any of the answers to the questions.
[40:42] Pamela Shandrow: If you can do math, we'll take that.
[40:45] Ebony Vines: That's a big one. We might need to hire someone to do math for us.
[40:48] Pamela Shandrow: I uh I really just hope that you'll stick with us.
[40:52] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[40:52] Pamela Shandrow: Because we we like to tell it for the stories, and the story is there.
[40:56] Ebony Vines: So if you like hearing stories about theater, about flops, about new works, about you know that kind of interesting information backstage, stick with us.
[41:05] Pamela Shandrow: We will get better as far as the technology and uh sound quality is concerned.
[41:11] Ebony Vines: Um, but yeah, tell your friends about us too, because even if they aren't fully knowledgeable on musicals, uh, they'll like it anyway.
[41:20] Pamela Shandrow: Right, it's and they'll gain that knowledge because we're gonna let them know.
[41:23] Ebony Vines: All right, guys.
[41:25] Pamela Shandrow: And scene.
[41:26] Ebony Vines: Bye.
[41:27] Pamela Shandrow: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
