Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 105: DANCE A LITTLE CLOSER

Ebony drops the deets on this show, which from all outward appearance, should have been successful. But, as you know, we wouldn't be discussing it otherwise... Read More

From the show: Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast by Ebony Vines and Pamela Shandrow

1 h 3 mins
12/20/22

About

Ebony drops the deets on this show, which from all outward appearance, should have been successful. But, as you know, we wouldn't be discussing it otherwise.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Ebony Vines: Welcome to Theatre Geeks Anonymous.

[0:05] Pamela Shandrow: The podcast about Broadway flops, scandals, and new work.

[0:08] Ebony Vines: I'm your host, Ebony Vines.

[0:10] Pamela Shandrow: And I'm your host, Pamela Shandrow.

[0:13] Ebony Vines: Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe to the Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast.

[0:19] Pamela Shandrow: On the Broadway Podcast Network and all your favorite podcast listening apps.

[0:23] Ebony Vines: Thank you.

[0:26] Pamela Shandrow: Welcome.

[0:27] Ebony Vines: What's up, Theater Geeks?

[0:29] Pamela Shandrow: What is up?

[0:30] Ebony Vines: It's been almost two months. I think the last time we published something was Dodie and Diana in like the middle of October.

[0:37] Pamela Shandrow: All right. Well, we're gonna dive in.

[0:40] Ebony Vines: I think so. I mean, so this week's episode, Geeks, is about a musical called Dance a LITTLE CLOSER, which I don't believe is too terribly obscure because I know a lot of people like songs from the show.

[0:57] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.

[0:58] Ebony Vines: And um, there were like so much material on this musical. Great that was one of the shortest lived musicals that we have ever spoken of.

[1:11] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.

[1:12] Ebony Vines: Oh, I'm intrigued.

[1:13] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[1:14] Ebony Vines: Like the music is sort of in the canon. I mean, it's Charles Strauss and Alan J. Lerner, right?

[1:19] Pamela Shandrow: So it makes sense.

[1:20] Ebony Vines: Yeah. But it's just so interesting how short lived this show is.

[1:25] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[1:27] Ebony Vines: So here we go. Dance a LITTLE CLOSER is based on Robert Sherwood's play, Idiots Delight.

[1:35] Pamela Shandrow: It's from 1936.

[1:38] Ebony Vines: Um, uh, as usual, one of my sources is gonna be Wikipedia, but I also have used Not Since Carrie, Second Act Trouble, The Rutledge Guide to Broadway, The Happiest Corpse I've Ever Seen, The Last 25 Years of Broadway musicals by Ethan Morden.

[1:55] Pamela Shandrow: Um, a lyricist Letters, The Letters of Alan J. Lerner, Frank Rich's New York Times Critique from May 12th, 1983, and also the book Our Musicals, Ourselves by John Bush Jones.

[2:08] Ebony Vines: For other uh resources, I'll be referencing them within the um within the course of this conversation.

[2:18] Pamela Shandrow: Awesome.

[2:19] Ebony Vines: So um, but there was just a lot. It was like it. I know it was like so fascinating to see so much.

[2:28] Pamela Shandrow: Okay. So according to Wikipedia, Idiots Delight is a 1936 Pulitzer Prize winning play written by Robert E. Sherwood, and it was presented by the Theater Guild.

[2:40] Ebony Vines: The play takes place in Hotel Monte Gabe. I'm sorry, Hotel Monte Gabrielle in the Italian Alps during 24 hours at the beginning of a world war.

[2:52] Pamela Shandrow: The guests are trapped in the hotel by the sudden onset hostilities from Germany and France between United States and Britain.

[3:01] Ebony Vines: It was the original play was directed by Pretend Windust. The cast starred Alfred Lunt, who played Harry Van, and Lynn Fontaine, who played Irene.

[3:11] Pamela Shandrow: These two were married.

[3:14] Ebony Vines: All right. Yeah. And the play was essentially like a vehicle for the two of them to do something together.

[3:21] Pamela Shandrow: Cool.

[3:21] Ebony Vines: Um it also starred Sidney Greenstreet as Dr. Waldersea and uh Francis Compton as Akeel Weber.

[3:31] Pamela Shandrow: The play was nominated for the 1936 New Year Drama Critics Circle Award for Best American Play.

[3:38] Ebony Vines: And um PS like this was the first of four Pulitzer Prizes for Sherwood.

[3:46] Pamela Shandrow: Oh wow.

[3:47] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[3:48] Pamela Shandrow: Nice. Well, I mean, we're getting off to a great foot here because this sounds like an awesome play.

[3:53] Ebony Vines: I know. I know. And so a little bit about the production of the original play. Idiots Delight had a pre-Broadway tryout at the National Theater in DC.

[4:05] Pamela Shandrow: It started on March 9th of 1936 and premiered on Broadway at the Schubert Theater, running from March 24th to 1936 to July 4th, 1936.

[4:17] Ebony Vines: I guess it opened a few times because it says, and from August 31st, 1936 to January 30th, 1937, for a total of 300 performances.

[4:29] Pamela Shandrow: The play won, like I said, the Pulitzer Prize. He had won those four Pulitzers, three were for drama and one was for a biography.

[4:43] Ebony Vines: The Pulitzer jury wrote of the play we're absolutely in complete agreement in recommending Idiots Delight. It is a first-rate play full of dramatic invention.

[4:52] Pamela Shandrow: And one or two of the comedy scenes have a Moly Moli Molière.

[5:02] Ebony Vines: Ah okay.

[5:04] Pamela Shandrow: Moliere.

[5:05] Ebony Vines: Okay.

[5:07] Pamela Shandrow: It feels like Molière.

[5:09] Ebony Vines: I cannot get this word. Apologies.

[5:15] Pamela Shandrow: It's cool. Don't worry about it.

[5:19] Ebony Vines: Oh goodness. Uh Sherwood adapted his play into a nineteen thirty-nine film of the same name, starring Norma Shearer and Clark Gable.

[5:29] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, called Idiots Delight.

[5:31] Ebony Vines: Yes, it is. It's called Idiots Delight. And you can actually rent it for $2.99 on Amazon.

[5:38] Pamela Shandrow: Nice. I bet that was really good. I like those two actors.

[5:42] Ebony Vines: I do too. I do too. A bunch of the other cast members are really cool as well.

[5:47] Pamela Shandrow: Nice. The New York City Theater Company presented a revival at New York City Center from May 23rd, 1951 to June 3rd of 1951.

[5:57] Ebony Vines: That was directed by George Schaefer. The cast featured Lee Tracy and Ruth Chatterton.

[6:03] Pamela Shandrow: The play was produced at the Kennedy Center in the Eisenhower Theater in DC in March of 1986, directed by Peter Sellers.

[6:12] Ebony Vines: You'll note that this is three years after the musical because the musical took place in 1983.

[6:19] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.

[6:20] Ebony Vines: So they did the play again.

[6:22] Pamela Shandrow: Yes. They were like, let's cleanse the palate.

[6:26] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Yeah. And um as I go on, like you'll also learn the musical has uh many changes, so it's like it feels like the play, but it's also much different and it's put in a different time period and other things.

[6:43] Pamela Shandrow: So that makes sense.

[6:45] Ebony Vines: I'm interested to hear that because it seems to me that the importance of that play is that it was the day that this war was started.

[6:53] Pamela Shandrow: Right, right.

[6:54] Ebony Vines: Okay, so this will be interesting.

[6:56] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[6:57] Ebony Vines: It shall be. So as I stated at the beginning of the pod, the music is by Charles Strauss and the book and lyrics are by Alan J. Lerner.

[7:09] Pamela Shandrow: Alan J. Lerner had been developing the idea since 1971, but it was officially announced in May of 1981.

[7:18] Ebony Vines: He said in an interview, there's not much to say except we're doing it and love it and are optimistic about it.

[7:26] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[7:26] Ebony Vines: The show was intended to be a vehicle for his wife, Liz Robertson.

[7:31] Pamela Shandrow: Now she was his eighth wife and 36 years his junior.

[7:36] Ebony Vines: Oh my goodness. But also, this was the last one.

[7:42] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[7:44] Ebony Vines: Because he just got tired or because this was a love match.

[7:48] Pamela Shandrow: Well, he I mean, he he passed away.

[7:51] Ebony Vines: Oh, okay.

[7:52] Pamela Shandrow: So he they were married until he passed away.

[7:55] Ebony Vines: Gotcha. Yeah. Uh, when okay, so he was developing it, and then he read an article in Variety that said, like the creative team had like been put together and the casting had been put together, and he was like, none of this has happened.

[8:17] Pamela Shandrow: Why is this in a gossip column in Variety?

[8:21] Ebony Vines: None of this has happened. So he wrote the producer, Frederick Bison, and he asked him to keep everything quiet, and I'm gonna read the letter.

[8:31] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[8:34] Ebony Vines: All right, to Frederick Bison Bryson from November 30th of 1981. Again, this is from the book I mentioned, the lyricist letters, the letters of Alan J. Lerner.

[8:46] Pamela Shandrow: Dear Freddie, I noticed a story in Variety about Idiots Delight, which included the names of both Herb Ross and Twilith Arp. Even James Coburn's name snuck in.

[8:56] Ebony Vines: I feel very strongly that that as much as is possible, we should keep the publicity under wraps and only publicize the facts when they become facts.

[9:07] Pamela Shandrow: As you know, Twilight Tharp, who incidentally impressed Charles and me very much indeed, also wants to direct as well as choreograph.

[9:15] Ebony Vines: Whether she's short or not is unimportant at this moment. But we did tell her that we would not be showing the play to anyone else until we meet again on February 8th.

[9:26] Pamela Shandrow: And she is given the complete first act to read.

[9:30] Ebony Vines: If her enthusiasm is such that she becomes involved emotionally with the project, it will be easier at that time to discuss what her function will actually be.

[9:40] Pamela Shandrow: But I certainly don't want to seem like a liar when I tell her no one else has seen the play until that date.

[9:47] Ebony Vines: Neither Charles nor I said anything about James Coburn, but I believe he has been telling people about it, which is his business, I suppose.

[9:57] Pamela Shandrow: If the press at any time ask any of us about it, I think we should merely tell the truth, which is that there has been a discussion with him, but nothing is definite.

[10:08] Ebony Vines: As of this moment, all that I know to be true is that Charles Strauss and I are writing it, you are producing it, and Liz Robertson will be the leading lady, whether it be done in America first or in England.

[10:23] Pamela Shandrow: The truth of the matter is I would probably not have written the play in the first place if it hadn't been for my desire to write a vehicle for Liz, whose talents, as you will see from her television show, are vast and varied.

[10:37] Ebony Vines: In fact, I say this quite objectively. I don't know anyone on either side of the ocean who can do everything from operetta to raunchy pop the way she can.

[10:49] Pamela Shandrow: Charles and I finished another song while I was in New York, which makes seven so far.

[10:54] Ebony Vines: My plan at the moment is to be back in New York mid-January for a month, and then Charles will return to London with me for a month mid-February.

[11:02] Pamela Shandrow: It was good talking to you, and I look forward to seeing you a week from Thursday, which turns out to be December the 10th.

[11:08] Ebony Vines: Bondley, Alan.

[11:10] Pamela Shandrow: He's a good letter writer.

[11:12] Ebony Vines: I know. I mean, he is a he's a screenwriter, like a playwright, but that was good.

[11:18] Pamela Shandrow: That was well written.

[11:20] Ebony Vines: Yes. It got to the point. It was not emotional. And I love how he spoke about his wife. I think that that was awesome.

[11:25] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah. He really, he really adored her.

[11:30] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Um, and I'll read just like a little snippet from another letter later on where he talks about about her after, you know, you all know this show, so you know what's gonna happen, but like it's quite beautiful, uh, something that he says later after you know what happens.

[11:48] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[11:50] Ebony Vines: Spoilers. In February of 1982, which is referenced in that letter, it was decided that Lerner would direct the production.

[12:01] Pamela Shandrow: He said someone has to look down the road to see what the play should be, and I think I have that vision.

[12:06] Ebony Vines: He had taken over Camelot before and Gigi, but without credit. So Dance a LITTLE CLOSER was his first official directing credit.

[12:14] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[12:15] Ebony Vines: Now I will also add that this was also his last musical that he wrote.

[12:22] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[12:23] Ebony Vines: Because he then passed?

[12:24] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.

[12:34] Ebony Vines: Well, I when I get to like the choreographer and all of that, you know, you'll know. But definitely she didn't direct it.

[12:44] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[12:45] Ebony Vines: So the show was supposed to be put into rehearsals in August of '82, and then it was meant to arrive on Broadway that following December, but unfortunately it wasn't ready. Also, Bryson was struggling to find backing for the show. He stated in an interview that he'd done 21 shows on Broadway, and this was the first time he wasn't overcapitalized.

[13:15] Pamela Shandrow: Huh. That's kind of a slap to the face, isn't it?

[13:19] Ebony Vines: No. Especially when you have, you know, Strauss and Lerner.

[13:24] Pamela Shandrow: Right. Well, it's also like I'm I for him to say while he is looking and asking for money that he's surprised that this one isn't ha like it kind of like makes me lose confidence. If I had money to spend on a show, I'm not sure I would have confidence in this show if I was hearing the producer saying that he was having so much trouble.

[13:49] Ebony Vines: Yeah, you know. And you know, maybe I think about the year, right? We're talking '81, '82, '83. And you know, he uh th this was not a good time for New York City. Like New York City was about to be um on the brink of like bankruptcy.

[14:06] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[14:13] Ebony Vines: And you know, I mean, I've heard stories of you know, kids who had school running between avenues so they didn't get mugged.

[14:23] Pamela Shandrow: Wow.

[14:24] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Like obviously friends who are adults now, but when they were children, they had to do that. Well, I mean, and there is something to be said about New York in the '80s being a real cesspool as far as just it being overrun by degenerates and otherwise bad behavior.

[14:43] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.

[14:45] Ebony Vines: You know, and the story that I'm referring to about running, I mean, that was happening where the theaters were, right? Like that, like literally on Broadway. Who wants to come into New York City and see a show and then potentially lose all your money? That would be really awful.

[15:01] Pamela Shandrow: Right, and if they're doing that to children.

[15:05] Ebony Vines: Right.

[15:06] Pamela Shandrow: Mm-hmm.

[15:09] Ebony Vines: Oh gracious sakes. So I'm sort of like not super surprised he's having difficulty, but I'm also like, but it's Alan J. Lerner and Charles Strauss, and like they both have this storied past with like a lot of musicals that were quite successful. So it's sort of like a mixed bag because some shows were still successful in the '80s.

[15:32] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[15:33] Ebony Vines: I mean, it really wasn't until '86 that everything was like '86 was the year of flops.

[15:40] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, really, really was.

[15:42] Ebony Vines: But I feel like up until that point it really wasn't like that. I mean, yeah, it was like a good mix of good and bad. There wasn't really any standout, but there wasn't any real flop flops, you know.

[15:52] Pamela Shandrow: Right, right. Mm-hmm. Yep, that's true.

[15:57] Ebony Vines: All right, so opening night cast was Len Carew as Harry Aikens.

[16:03] Pamela Shandrow: Ooh, and this was like right off of Sweeney.

[16:08] Ebony Vines: Like immediately after. Okay. Liz Robertson, as I stated, she played Cynthia Brookfield Bailey. George Rose was Dr. Joseph Winkler. Uh Brent Barrett was Charles Castleton.

[16:24] Pamela Shandrow: Ooh. Don't know. How old was he then?

[16:28] Ebony Vines: Uh he's been around a long time. I didn't realize he did, but he was like doing it in the '80s. I honestly don't know.

[16:36] Pamela Shandrow: Okay. We would have to look that up.

[16:39] Ebony Vines: But yeah. Maybe I'll just I'll just ask the Google machine while you keep talking.

[16:43] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[16:44] Ebony Vines: Don Chastain was Roger Butterfield. Noel Craig was Captain Mueller. And I am Hobson was Reverend Oliver Boyle. Cheryl Howard was BB. She was one of the delights, which was like this singing group that um that sang with um Len's character. But I'm gonna give you all a synopsis of the musical. Don't worry.

[17:08] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[17:09] Ebony Vines: And I'm just gonna interject here. He was born in '57.

[17:13] Pamela Shandrow: Oh. I did not realize that.

[17:16] Ebony Vines: Well, there you go. He's older than I thought. Anyway, I love him. That's all. Been working a long time.

[17:27] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, no kidding.

[17:30] Ebony Vines: Uh, and then Elizabeth Hubbard was Contessa Carla Piriano, Jeff Keller, Edward Dunlop, Joseph Kalinski, Henrik Holloway, Diane Pennington, Shirley, another one of the delights, Allison Reed, her name was Elaine in the show, and she was also a delight.

[17:53] Ebony Vines: And so for the production staff. So it was produced by Frederick Bryson, as I've said before. The music was orchestrated by Jonathan Tunick. Already told you who the lyrics in book were by. So, or muse I'm sorry, musical director. There we go. Then dance music was Glenn Kelly. Yes, directed by Alan J. Lerner. Musical staging by Billy Wilson, and it was choreographed by Billy Wilson. So that tells you what happened.

[18:39] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay. Maybe she didn't want any part of it after like she didn't if she wasn't directing. Because I do remember Twilight Arp was kind of like it's all or nothing, right? She wanted she had consistently been director and choreographer at that point.

[18:55] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Or at least maybe that's when she was starting to do that.

[18:59] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. That's a good idea. Or maybe she wasn't maybe she just couldn't get an emotional investment.

[19:04] Ebony Vines: It's possible. Yeah. I know. I watched her documentary, and um, there's also like a part where I don't know what when this was, but that like she was in her home upstate for quite a while. There's these like wonderful videos of her like very pregnant, dancing in her attic. Um, she was just continuing to like produce, direct, choreograph it, you know, as much as she could then. And so I mean, who knows? That I will say I uh there's lots of information, but I didn't dig into the Twilight Tharp situation because there was so much other stuff.

[19:45] Pamela Shandrow: Sure.

[19:47] Ebony Vines: Uh but um, you know, there could be you know several several reasons for it. Um, and then also important is scenic design was by David Mitchell, costume design by Donald Brooks, lighting design by Thomas Skelton, sound design by John McClure, and hair design by Joe Tubins.

[20:09] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[20:10] Ebony Vines: Lerner stated that he tried to maintain the overall structure of the original play, but update it for the current times and replace some characters with ones that would be more relevant for today. So now I will give you all just like a brief summary of uh synopsis of the show.

[20:31] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, this is from Guide to Musical Theater.com.

[20:36] Ebony Vines: Usually theirs are really short, so I don't actually usually read theirs because I like something uh it's got a little bit more heft, but this one's pretty good. Okay, and it's not forever long. Okay, it is New Year's Eve again at the Barclay Palace Hotel in the Austrian Alps in the avoidable future, but not so uh-huh. That's what they call it in the avoidable future, but not so very far from the hotel in the Italian Alps where Robert uh Sherwood served up Idiots Delight almost 50 years earlier.

[21:10] The intentional situation is still deteriorating, and the jet set crowd is dancing on the brink to the music of Harry Aikens and the Delights. Harry's love life is reflected in his act. It is a checkered record that was generally fun. A New Year's past invades Henry's memory with a particular woman he could not possess. There had been an attraction, but not for her. At this point in the present, who should appear but a double for the woman in Harry's past, the exotic Cynthia Brookfield Bailey. She appeared to feel that one is worth it. The kiss Kissinger-esque Dr. Joseph Winkler. So if you remember, there was a Kissinger like actual character, like I talked about in the play and the movie, but this guy like that, but not named Kissinger.

[22:03] Ebony Vines: Um, and his name is Dr. Joseph Winkler. When Cynthia denies ever having known Harry, he joins the left-wing student Halloway in bemoaning the perfidity of governments and women. Cynthia's liaison with Winkler is not without its own questions. How much of an influence does Winkler have over the gathering war clouds? How much of an influence does Cynthia have over Winkler? Is she merely a woman who thinks Winkler is wonderful, or is she the woman from Harry's past who has always obsessed him? Two of the other guests at the Barclay Palace Hotel believe in love, although not perhaps in the traditional mold. Charles and Edward wonder why the world cannot just leave them alone. In an ideal world, this might just happen, but then Harry isn't leaving Cynthia either. Her resemblance to the Cindy of his memory is too marked.

[22:55] Pamela Shandrow: Cynthia and Cindy. Come on, y'all.

[22:58] Ebony Vines: Oh wow. It's not very innovative. Um is too marked, and her relationship to the roving Winkler too apparently tenuous. Cynthia keeps denying that Harry was a part of her past or that he is likely to be a part of her future. As for Winkler's famous wanderings, he always returns to Cynthia. By the time his nightclub act goes on that evening, however, Harry is convinced that he is a new girl. When word arrives that the frightening international situation is threatening to erupt in war, Cynthia turns momentarily to Harry. He is now certain that Cynthia is the girl of his past, even though she denies it. Act two opens with the hotel guest preparing to evacuate to safer climbs as war appears to be imminent, and an airbase in the valley below is a likely military target. The delights trio is glad to be heading home, but Harry is angry at the cancellation of the tour. Mad at Cynthia, who has run back to Winkler and mad at humanity in general.

[24:17] Pamela Shandrow: I don't know, but everyone else that there's a whole song called I don't know.

[24:21] Ebony Vines: But you might know that because you like the show already.

[24:24] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[24:24] Ebony Vines: I actually didn't.

[24:25] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay.

[24:26] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Uh-huh. It's it's it's jaunty.

[24:33] Pamela Shandrow: It is.

[24:33] Ebony Vines: It's like, you know. Um, it actually it kind of reminded me of Judy Garland's I don't care.

[24:41] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, yeah, totally.

[24:42] Ebony Vines: Yeah, it kind of reminded me of that.

[24:44] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[24:45] Ebony Vines: Anyway. But everyone else has an opinion to offer. The boy's commitment leads Cynthia to seek a commitment from Winkler, but he departs. Almost at the same time, Harry, tortured by Cynthia's denials of the past, declares he never wants to see her again, which leaves Cynthia stranded in her seeming glory, but alone.

[25:06] Ebony Vines: As the last bus leaves for the border, Harry returns. Whatever happened to the rest of the world, if he is to have a future, Cynthia must be a part of it. As the first air raid sirens sound, these two at least have found the potential for a personal peace. That's the show.

[25:24] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[25:25] Ebony Vines: I'm not sure that that sounded anything like the original.

[25:30] Pamela Shandrow: Well, I mean, in that, okay, so it is in that it's World War II in the OG one, right?

[25:39] Ebony Vines: Instead of like, uh, avoidable future when a potential World War III.

[25:46] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[25:46] Ebony Vines: And Cynthia went from being like a girl faking being Russian to a girl faking being British.

[25:54] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[25:55] Ebony Vines: And there's another huge piece where you have an LGBTQIA couple. And I did like, I mean, that was really an interesting, uh, tidbit when you mentioned that. I was like, oh. So that was cool.

[26:07] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[26:08] Ebony Vines: And that there is a whole song dedicated to that plot device, which is kind of, uh, really fascinating to me, especially in the early 80s.

[26:19] Pamela Shandrow: Totally. So, um, I'm gonna read a little bit from the Happiest Corpse book just to give a little bit more, uh, understanding of the changes, right, from the original play and movie to this musical.

[26:38] Ebony Vines: Okay.

[26:40] Pamela Shandrow: All right, so, um, Ethan Morden says updating from the 1930s to something like 1983, the year of Dance a LITTLE CLOSER's premiere means upgrading the potential disaster from World War to Nuclear Suicide. Why not forget Sherwood and make a musical out of Doctor Strange Love?

[27:04] Ebony Vines: I don't, yeah.

[27:06] Pamela Shandrow: Then I have nothing to say to that. Um, he said, then too, following the play faithfully in 40s, 50s fashion means that one's action in this case will be locked into a two-character play for one's final 15 minutes. Surely Jerry Herman wouldn't let a libretto trap him into anything so naked, so spoken, so spoken play.

[27:30] Ebony Vines: Strauss and Lerner are left with nuclear war and no magical stars, because he felt like the Lunts were, you know, the reason why the original play was so great.

[27:42] Pamela Shandrow: This writer.

[27:44] Ebony Vines: Um, said, yeah, magical stars. That's what he means by no magical stars. Um, but he, this writer's, he says he's an inherent adherent of the 40s and 50s musical play, which reached its climax, like it or not, with Camelot.

[28:03] Pamela Shandrow: Um, I have another piece that I would like to.

[28:10] Ebony Vines: Okay, so this is from the book Our Musicals Ourselves, which talks, this part talks a little bit about the change that was made with the LGBTQIA couple.

[28:20] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[28:22] Ebony Vines: Uh, Lerner's open depiction of homosexuality in a Broadway musical for general audiences cannot go unremarked. Lerner transformed what had been the heterosexual honeymoon couple of Sherwood Subplot into two gay male airline stewards and gave them their special moment in a sincere love duet called Why Can't the World Go and Leave Us Alone.

[28:43] Pamela Shandrow: The 83-year-old Lerner said he—

[28:43] Ebony Vines: So he wasn't 83.

[28:52] Pamela Shandrow: Lerner.

[28:52] Ebony Vines: Yeah, I don't think that part's right.

[28:58] Pamela Shandrow: That's what it says in the book.

[28:59] Ebony Vines: Okay.

[28:59] Ebony Vines: Right.

[28:59] Pamela Shandrow: Um, he was older though.

[29:03] Pamela Shandrow: Um, he said he risked doing this because, and this is his quote, I wanted to make a statement about love being essential to all lifestyles. I have to admit, some people have been critical of my including the two boys in the story, but I found you have to write something because you believe in it.

[29:20] Ebony Vines: Oh, I like that.

[29:21] Pamela Shandrow: I know. That's awesome. Good job, Alan.

[29:25] Ebony Vines: Good job.

[29:26] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. Um, all right. So I'm gonna keep going with my notes here. All right, so it's in previews. I haven't gone to when it's opened yet. And if it's any indication about how it was liked or disliked, um, there was, you know how people have like mean nicknames when you're in high school, and they keep calling you that forever and ever.

[29:52] Ebony Vines: Um, I have to say, I was thankfully, I didn't have to deal with that, but like I know people who've had to deal with that.

[30:00] Pamela Shandrow: I was Spammy.

[30:01] Ebony Vines: Oh, honey.

[30:03] Pamela Shandrow: Sometimes Spam, sometimes Spamula.

[30:07] Ebony Vines: Yeah. They thought it was cute.

[30:14] Pamela Shandrow: Like that, like it's some, some kids are clever, but kids, that stuff is dumb.

[30:21] Ebony Vines: Like I've never heard a good one.

[30:24] Pamela Shandrow: Me neither. It's just why? Why? And they just think it's so funny. And it's like if you tell them when they're grown-ups, they're like, oh my goodness, I was a dummy.

[30:35] Ebony Vines: Yes, we all were. I mean, like, honestly, we can all go back and think of, uh, 10 things just right off the top of our heads that we did that were just completely stupid when we were young.

[30:45] Pamela Shandrow: Stupid, but like mean. Like that's also mean.

[30:47] Ebony Vines: Yeah, you know what I mean? It's like, of course I did stupid things, but like to perpetuate continued meanness in that way is like, uh, that kind, yeah, that bullying behavior. That's not cool.

[31:00] Pamela Shandrow: No.

[31:02] Ebony Vines: So unfortunately, something similar happened to Lerner and Strauss.

[31:07] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[31:08] Ebony Vines: So Dance a LITTLE CLOSER was mercilessly dubbed CLOSER a LITTLE Faster.

[31:13] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, by who?

[31:18] Ebony Vines: See, it, that phrase was in so many books, but it was like who started it.

[31:25] Pamela Shandrow: I don't know.

[31:26] Ebony Vines: Uh-huh. It was in like three of the books I read.

[31:30] Pamela Shandrow: Well, and I, you and I have, I think discussed this before, or maybe it's just in my own mind that we did. But it seems to me that a lot of the times that you and I feel like a show should have succeeded.

[31:45] Ebony Vines: Yeah, it doesn't because a critic put a thought into an audience mind and then it just wasn't popular anymore. You know, like Frank Rich could say something and absolutely destroy a show. And especially back then when the internet wasn't a thing and you really only had the newspapers to believe and to listen to. And if you're spending that amount of money, you're gonna take Frank Rich's word for it because he only cost 25 cents to read when it when it costs, you know, 25 dollars to go see a show at the time.

[32:23] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[32:24] Ebony Vines: But that's so sad.

[32:26] Pamela Shandrow: I know. It's like you didn't even like give it a chance. I mean, I will say it made the mistake that we always complain about is not trying out.

[32:34] Ebony Vines: Yeah, absolutely. And so if it wasn't good in previews, it's like we're not ready, you maybe need to try it out. They had a workshop, uh, that went really well, but like a workshop was like one, you know, it's that's not enough to like get the kinks out.

[32:54] Pamela Shandrow: Question.

[32:56] Ebony Vines: I mean, like, and this and this is really truly for shows that do have out-of-town tryouts and that don't have out-of-town tryouts, okay. So you have these previews for a reason, but if the previews are not well received, the show still opens.

[33:12] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[33:13] Ebony Vines: And that always confuses me because it's like the previews should be another opportunity for you to be like, okay, hang on. We're just gonna go back here, we're gonna finagle a few things, and then we'll come back and open for real, you know.

[33:26] Pamela Shandrow: And I guess, you know, money is obviously an issue. You don't want to lose out on the theater that you've rented, you know, like all of that stuff comes kind of comes into play.

[33:35] Ebony Vines: But what's the point of having previews if they're not for the purpose of making the show better?

[33:43] Pamela Shandrow: Like that, I don't know. I mean, am I silly in saying this?

[33:47] Ebony Vines: I don't get it.

[33:48] Pamela Shandrow: No, I mean, to me that makes sense. I mean, that's why I think some of the shows that we've done, like they closed in previews, like they didn't even go on.

[33:56] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[33:57] Pamela Shandrow: But I also wonder if it's a little bit of like the Fiddler on the Roof effect, right? Because Fiddler on the Roof had bad tryouts and they had bad previews, but like they kept working on it so hard.

[34:08] Ebony Vines: It's like I, um, but didn't, but they didn't, it wasn't like a, it wasn't the same show from preview through. Like they were so much work.

[34:15] Pamela Shandrow: So much work.

[34:18] Ebony Vines: And so much work at the tryout and the preview.

[34:21] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.

[34:21] Ebony Vines: And it had, I mean, it was like I heard, um, Austin Pendleton was my directing teacher, and so he told us like the story of it in tryouts as it got all the way to Broadway. And like it was a mess.

[34:42] Pamela Shandrow: And they were like, like they're in their hearts, they're, they all felt like this could be good, but they had so much trouble getting there.

[34:51] Ebony Vines: Yeah. And so sometimes I wonder if like people, you know, I, I, it doesn't seem to me from what I've read, you know, that Strauss and Lerner were just like, we're done. It's done. But you know, it's that thing of like you keep trying and you keep hoping, but you just still can never get it quite right.

[35:17] Pamela Shandrow: Now, I will also mention, because I just was thinking about this too, that there are shows that we've talked about that changed things so much during the previews, and even to the point of changing directors, yeah, that then they also didn't succeed for that reason as well.

[35:35] Ebony Vines: So I guess it's, yeah, it's just really, you, I don't know.

[35:42] Pamela Shandrow: It's just like you don't know how it's gonna come out, but I, I mean, I agree with you, like there's a lot we've done where I'm just like, why keep going?

[35:53] Ebony Vines: Yeah, except that you know, you do have a promise to your investors.

[36:00] Pamela Shandrow: Yes.

[36:00] Ebony Vines: You know, I mean, yeah, I, I don't know, yeah, yes. There's a lot, there's a lot of good arguments as to why to just continue, but then on the opposite side of things, there's an argument for stopping, right? So, yes, you have this promise to these investors, but the promise to the investors is a successful show, right? And so if you can say to the investors, hey, listen, our previews are not great, we're gonna take two weeks to change things up, re-rehearse, and then come back again though, time is hard because theaters sometimes are a commodity that does not come around very often.

[36:42] Pamela Shandrow: And if you have a theater that wants your show at this particular time, and you say we're not ready yet, they might say, okay, well, this show is, and we're gonna go with them.

[36:52] Ebony Vines: So there is kind of that kind of pressure from that end too.

[36:58] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. Absolutely.

[37:00] Ebony Vines: I don't know the answer.

[37:02] Pamela Shandrow: No.

[37:03] Ebony Vines: I'm just a lowly podcaster.

[37:06] Pamela Shandrow: I did hear this statistic though this week.

[37:09] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[37:10] Pamela Shandrow: Where, you know, because we always were like 75% of shows don't see a profit. So we have like lots and lots of material.

[37:18] Ebony Vines: Yes.

[37:18] Pamela Shandrow: But it's up to 80 or 85 now.

[37:24] Ebony Vines: Whoa.

[37:25] Pamela Shandrow: That's the statistic I heard from my friends who are producers this week.

[37:40] Pamela Shandrow: But I mean we but I we don't even have as many right now because like it's true.

[37:44] Ebony Vines: Well, they're all closing now.

[37:45] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[37:46] Ebony Vines: Like the only one because Phantom, even though it pushed, you know, pushed its date, it's still closing.

[37:46] Pamela Shandrow: It's still closing.

[37:53] Ebony Vines: But you've still got Wicked and you've still got Lion King.

[37:56] Pamela Shandrow: Those are the two anchors.

[37:57] Ebony Vines: I guess it reminds me very much of like a mall where the anchor stores are like Macy's and Bon Mar and Sears, right?

[38:06] Pamela Shandrow: And wait, what's one you said?

[38:09] Ebony Vines: Sears, Bon Mar.

[38:11] Pamela Shandrow: What's Bon Mar?

[38:13] Ebony Vines: It's just another big department store.

[38:15] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, maybe that's just an Illinois.

[38:17] Ebony Vines: Well, I know it's in the Midwest.

[38:18] Pamela Shandrow: So maybe it is just a Midwest thing.

[38:21] Ebony Vines: Okay. Um, but you know, like if you if a mall loses any one of those anchor stores, it's just a ghost town.

[38:28] Pamela Shandrow: And so, like going back to Bloomington, Illinois, the mall there, well, there's two malls. College Hills did the good thing, right?

[38:35] Ebony Vines: So their mall used to be an indoor mall, just like every other mall in America in the 80s and 90s. They decided they're gonna completely redo it. It's an outdoor walking mall, so you've got all these little stores in clusters that you just walk from cluster to cluster, or you drive and park, you know, whatever.

[38:52] Pamela Shandrow: And Target is within the vicinity, so that's kind of the anchor, and you in Target's not gonna go anywhere, right?

[38:52] Ebony Vines: Right, right.

[38:59] Pamela Shandrow: Eastland Mall, on the other hand, is an absolute ghost town.

[39:03] Ebony Vines: There are maybe a dozen stores still open, not a single anchor store.

[39:10] Pamela Shandrow: Well, unless you consider Old Navy an anchor store, and I don't.

[39:13] Ebony Vines: No.

[39:14] Pamela Shandrow: But it is, it is the only big, like big brand store that's still there.

[39:21] Ebony Vines: It's crazy.

[39:24] Pamela Shandrow: And a little sad.

[39:25] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[39:26] Pamela Shandrow: Well, it's like a Manhattan Mall.

[39:29] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[39:30] Pamela Shandrow: I used to go there all the time, and now it's just gone.

[39:33] Ebony Vines: Anyway, we've gone off subject, but I know.

[39:37] Pamela Shandrow: Y'all are used to it.

[39:39] Ebony Vines: You're used to it.

[39:40] Pamela Shandrow: This is why you tune in.

[39:42] Ebony Vines: It's true.

[39:45] Pamela Shandrow: Um, okay. I have I so this other book um called Show and Tell by Ken Bloom is from 2016. There's it's so funny because the headline says four stories, but it's not four stories.

[40:05] Ebony Vines: It's like one story from Dance a LITTLE CLOSER. Um, I am gonna read it because it might also kind of help a little bit of understanding of it.

[40:15] Pamela Shandrow: Everything wasn't smooth.

[40:19] Ebony Vines: Sailing, literally, that sailing will be a little bit of a pun when you hear this. When writing with Frederick Lowe, Alan J. Lerner sat by the piano while Lowe was composing. Lowe never liked composing. So Lerner would instruct him to just noodle on the piano. And when a worthy tune came up, Lerner would alert Lowe and they'd try to fashion it into a song.

[40:44] Pamela Shandrow: So when Lerner was writing with Charles Strauss on Dance a LITTLE CLOSER, he asked Strauss to do the same since he was in the habit of working that way. Strauss found himself in a rowboat on the day on the bay of Naples going out to see Alan J. Lerner on his yacht for a working session on the show. As he approached the yacht, Strauss asked himself, What am I doing here? Both Sondheim and Bernstein had warned Strauss about working with Lerner.

[41:15] Ebony Vines: Strauss had two rules about collaborating. One, never take drugs. And two, never get involved with the director or co-author. Never get involved when the director or co-author is married to the leading lady.

[41:30] Pamela Shandrow: Did he break both rules here or just the one?

[41:32] Ebony Vines: Oh, okay. Well, both.

[41:34] Pamela Shandrow: I mean, I don't know. Listen, I don't I don't judge people.

[41:39] Ebony Vines: So while writing Dance a LITTLE CLOSER, Strauss both broke both rules.

[41:43] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, okay. Lovely.

[41:45] Ebony Vines: Uh-huh. Yeah. Um, and so he said he was he was stricken with a bad back and was in great pain. Lerner was constantly on speed.

[41:51] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.

[41:56] Ebony Vines: Supplied by Max Jacobs, aka Dr. Feel Good, which we've heard of. Uh-huh. So he offered Strauss a drug to alleviate the pain. Strauss soon found himself in a fetal position on the floor of the bathroom, wanting to die and asking that his family be brought in one by one so he could say goodbye.

[42:15] Pamela Shandrow: I mean, he didn't die. What did they give him?

[42:19] Ebony Vines: Speed.

[42:20] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, they okay.

[42:23] Ebony Vines: He was high on speed. I know Lerner was high on speed, but the I just assumed it was a different medication because you said it was for his back pain.

[42:31] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my gosh.

[42:32] Ebony Vines: He said so. He offered Strauss a drug to alleviate the pain. It was the speed.

[42:39] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[42:41] Ebony Vines: That's awful.

[42:42] Pamela Shandrow: Uh-huh. And then it said, and rule number two, Alan J. Lerner was married to the show's leading lady, Liz Robertson. Right?

[42:49] Ebony Vines: So both.

[42:51] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. Now I will say, in that, I will completely agree with Strauss because it does not matter how talented that actor or actress is when there is an emotional and also marital tie to anyone in the creative company, it's just never gonna work out well.

[43:12] Ebony Vines: Ever.

[43:13] Pamela Shandrow: Their personal business is gonna be all up in it.

[43:16] Ebony Vines: Totally. I mean, and Lerner was directing.

[43:20] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[43:20] Ebony Vines: I mean, that's a real that's a role. You need a separation.

[43:25] Pamela Shandrow: There needs to be a separation of church and state there.

[43:30] Ebony Vines: A separation between the creatives as far as the playwright and composer, and a separation between them and the director. Like there just has to be because there's there's too many ideas flying around for one person to have so much control.

[43:45] Pamela Shandrow: And in fact, another sidebar, there have been shows that we've talked about, and I can't think of any of them offhand, but that where there has been one person that has done everything. They've written it, they've directed it, they were starring in it, and those shows never really last very long, do they?

[44:01] Ebony Vines: The only one I can think of that did was David Cameron Mitchell in Hedwig and the Angry Inch.

[44:06] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[44:07] Ebony Vines: Well, also Lynn.

[44:09] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, yes, yes.

[44:10] Ebony Vines: But that was different because he didn't direct it, right?

[44:14] Pamela Shandrow: No, he didn't direct it.

[44:16] Ebony Vines: I mean, he wrote it and was in it, but he gave someone else the control of the overall picture.

[44:21] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[44:21] Ebony Vines: The directing and the choreography were, you know, they're part of the cabinet.

[44:25] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[44:26] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Um, so I mean, this is pretty much the end, right? Where at if it if it's being called close a little faster.

[44:39] Pamela Shandrow: The show opened on May 11th, 1983 at the Minsk Theater. It closed after only one performance at the Minsk Theater.

[44:48] Ebony Vines: And as I stated, it was Lerner's last show, and he passed away three years later of lung cancer.

[44:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[44:56] Ebony Vines: That's sad.

[44:57] Pamela Shandrow: It is.

[44:58] Ebony Vines: It is. He'd had like unfortunately a string of shows that didn't that were misfires.

[45:05] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.

[45:06] Ebony Vines: So um he was really trying and hoping, you know, this would be the one. And as I stated, I mean, he'd been working on it since 70 when I say one. It was a long time.

[45:17] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[45:19] Ebony Vines: Yeah. So it's, you know, it's sad.

[45:23] Pamela Shandrow: It is sad. It takes well, I mean, I think it's always sad when someone's dream and someone's art doesn't, you know, doesn't find a place, doesn't find uh, you know, a shelf to sit on. It just it just made it just sprinkles a little more sadness on it for me when like they also die like shortly after.

[45:42] Ebony Vines: I think they don't really yeah.

[45:45] Pamela Shandrow: Uh I mean, listen though, he did have a huge amount of success with a career. He had three Tonys and three Oscars. It's like he's fine. I'm not right about him. He's fine.

[45:54] Ebony Vines: He's fine.

[45:59] Pamela Shandrow: And and the original playwright had four Pulitzers. Everybody is fine.

[46:03] Ebony Vines: Yeah.

[46:05] Pamela Shandrow: The only ones who are not fine are us.

[46:11] Ebony Vines: Also, Charles Strauss had Tonys. Everybody.

[46:13] Pamela Shandrow: Everyone did.

[46:15] Ebony Vines: Is that no, listen, and that I guess that's why it was also kind of disappointing is because you look at it from the outside and you see all of these big people, these big, incredibly talented and incredibly creative people all coming together to do a show based on an amazing script and an amazing idea and a Pulitzer winning script at that. And it just doesn't it fizzles out.

[46:34] Pamela Shandrow: It doesn't pan.

[46:36] Ebony Vines: No. But I will say, you know, it was totally it was panned by critics.

[46:42] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[46:43] Ebony Vines: But one of the things that was so consistent in the critiques was, you know, the change to want to make it more relevant. And they were like, why didn't you just set it in the time period of the forties?

[46:57] Pamela Shandrow: That's my big question.

[46:58] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Cause it would have had a much more impact emotionally and historically if they had just kept it there.

[47:06] Pamela Shandrow: Because even it like I wasn't born in the 30s or 40s, but I know the impact of World War Two.

[47:13] Ebony Vines: Of course.

[47:14] Pamela Shandrow: I think everyone does because we're taught it like crazy in school, and like it's affected us generationally speaking, certainly, because the boomers were uh the direct generation the direct descendants of the people that fought in that war.

[47:28] Ebony Vines: Right.

[47:28] Pamela Shandrow: And then their parenting style was, you know, anyway. Let's not talk about generational trauma.

[47:34] Ebony Vines: But it's, you know, it is impactful.

[47:38] Pamela Shandrow: So the idea that you would change it to something more abstract.

[47:43] Ebony Vines: Doesn't quite like I guess I don't I it would be it would be much harder as an audience member to invest myself in a story that's abstract than it would to invest myself in a story that I know I know how it started and I know how it ended, and I know that I know the impact of it on the world.

[48:05] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[48:06] Ebony Vines: Right. Not just these couple of people in an in a Swiss Alps um resort. You know what I mean?

[48:12] Pamela Shandrow: Like it's that's true.

[48:15] Ebony Vines: And then just to add some more fuel to that, another thing that they chose to do in the musical was a large part of the plot and sort of the tension of the play and the film were the main couple, like we didn't know whether they had actually known each other previously. Where he's like trying to figure out like, is this her or not? But what they chose to do in the musical was you knew there was a flashback, so it ruined all of that tension.

[48:42] Pamela Shandrow: It's it's interesting.

[48:56] Ebony Vines: I mean, if you really look at a piece of art, whether that be a painting, whether that be a photograph, whether that be a TV show or a movie or a stage production. There has to be something within that artwork or within that whatever it is that pulls your focus and creates an emotional tie to it.

[49:18] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[49:19] Ebony Vines: Whatever that is. I mean, if you're looking at a piece of art, that's going to affect you in a different way than the next person, right? But that's that's the amazing part about art. When it comes to a stage show, it is so difficult because you don't have the same tools as you do in a movie or in a TV show to create those heightened senses of emotion, right? You have to do it with the words and with the music, if it's a musical, but you have to do it in a way that makes the audience want to root for you.

[49:55] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[49:56] Ebony Vines: In whatever way that is, root for you to fail or root for you to succeed. But there has to be some investment.

[50:03] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[50:04] Ebony Vines: And if you've told us she's lying from junk, then I don't care.

[50:09] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[50:09] Ebony Vines: I can't trust anything she says.

[50:13] Ebony Vines: Right. But if we come in and she says that she's not the person, but it's a big ol' wink wink, you're like, oh, oh, how do you think? You're like, right, right. Because we don't know. Is she telling the truth? Is she not? Absolutely. Absolutely. Well, and I don't, I mean, like I want Winkler and his relationship with her to have an impact on me. But I also want Harry's relationship with Cynthia to have an impact. Like I want, and yes, you're right about that tension where you're like, oh man, who is she gonna choose? Is this guy gonna find out? What is he gonna do when he does find out? What if he finds out that she was lying? It's not actually her. Is he gonna have like a mental breakdown? Like, what is gonna happen?

I don't know. It's and if you don't have that, if everything is so obtuse that there are no real answers at the end, like how unsatisfying is that to get to the end of the movie and not have any closure. Do you know what I mean? Like, yeah. How many times have you like left a theater and you're like, I hated that? Because like, what was the point? You know what I mean? Like, I who cares? You leave and you're like, uh, that was two hours, I'll never get back. And so, like, I feel like it's even more so when you go to see a show and you leave that way because you're like, oh, like, oh, I want it because we all want them to succeed. That's the disappointment, I think, for everybody, and that includes critics too, which I think is why critics are so they're so black and white. Yeah, they either love it or they hate it. Like, everyone wants you to succeed, and so when you don't meet our expectations, it can be such a disappointment.

[52:06] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, no, it's truly uh, and I we were talking about critics. I just thought about like Terry Teachout used to say that so often when I listened to him on Three on the Isle. Because he also was a playwright, but he wasn't like one of the embittered ones, okay, you know, who writes like he he he was doing it, you know? And so because he was still doing it, he had like a there was like a sensitivity there to sure and and also he was like sort of a theater geek on the inside, yeah. And so he wanted everything to succeed and and and came at it from this perspective. I've also heard Peter Felicia say the same thing where you know they want it to be good. Yeah. And sometimes they were like, if it's just because it's not for me, doesn't mean it won't be for somebody else.

[52:54] Ebony Vines: Yes. And so it's my duty to say, you know, if it wasn't for me, these are the reasons why it wasn't for me. But this, you know, it could be for other folks. There's some people who are just mean.

[53:05] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. And that's a whole other story.

[53:08] Ebony Vines: Yeah. I just, I mean, that a lot of the critiques here were like, I said the tension that we just talked about. Um, there's also critiques on uh people not so there's also was like a whole skating rink that was there, and this whole like other piece of it with like professional skaters, and it just seemed to muddy the story and add bulk to the set that like the critics were like, we don't need this, yeah. Um there was also um critiques about the costumes feeling like hodgepodgey, it just kind of didn't feel cohesive, is what I'm really picking up as a common theme between multiple reviews from critics, so you know that but that's like the show, and as we said at the top of the pod, the music just continues to live on, and that was also something in a lot of the critiques where people were like, but the music and lyrics are great.

[54:17] Pamela Shandrow: Well, there's no denying that both Strauss and Lerner are incredibly talented at what they do, so I'm not surprised that the music stands.

[54:27] Ebony Vines: Yeah. Because they both of them, together and apart, Lerner and Low and Strauss and um Who did he It's not coming. It's not coming. Keep going. And I'll go look it up. They're yelling at us right now. Um and Strauss and his other partner that he used to work with.

[54:50] Pamela Shandrow: Their music is Mehan.

[54:53] Ebony Vines: Me thank you. I'm sorry. So right. Um but their music not all of it, but certainly they've got their little pinpoint songs from each show that standalone and that are beautiful melodies and beautiful lyrics that that don't need a show to support them.

[55:17] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[55:18] Ebony Vines: So I'm not surprised at all. Even if it's a lot, there's a lot of flops that we've talked about where this there are certain songs from those shows that are in all of the standard audition books. Do you know what I mean? Like there's, you know, that that's just I think that's uh that just that just tells me that the talent level was there. It just the stars didn't align for whatever reason.

[55:45] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.

[55:45] Ebony Vines: No, that that and I, you know, the book could have been it's like, could you, if the lyrics were changed, could you create a new book based around the original that kept it in the 40s, right?

[56:01] Pamela Shandrow: I was actually gonna ask you that question.

[56:03] Ebony Vines: I mean, nobody's done it yet, but like it feels like you know, because Dance a LITTLE CLOSER is something that most of us know the name of the show, but we don't know a lot about it, and nobody I mean, most the people our age haven't really seen a production.

[56:19] Pamela Shandrow: Well, because I mean, even this homosexual relationship within the show could be kept in the time and place that Sherwood placed it in originally because if you consider that the Nazis were not just after Jews, they were after homosexuals, they were after uh gypsies.

[56:43] Ebony Vines: Um I know they're not called gypsies anymore, Romani people. They were global majority. If you were anything but Aryan, you were anything other than blonde and blue-eyed bye.

[56:53] Pamela Shandrow: And yeah.

[56:55] Ebony Vines: Uh, and so yeah, I think that would I think that would add an element of of real fear, like an underlying real fear. Like, have you ever you I'm sure you have. Have you ever watched the Diary of Anne Frank?

[57:09] Pamela Shandrow: Of course.

[57:11] Ebony Vines: There is this tension that sits under the entire show, even when they're laughing and talking and having and having good relationships with each other, there is still this underlying tension, and it's because we know the ending before it starts.

[57:30] Pamela Shandrow: That's right.

[57:31] Ebony Vines: And there's something about that that is impactful. And I think in this case, if they had just kept it, there would be that tension underlying because we know what's about to happen, and we know what the cost of that will be.

[57:49] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[57:50] Ebony Vines: And even though they don't, their love triangle or their, you know, coming to terms with who is who and who who did I love and was it you? And do I love you now? Like that kind of stuff.

[58:06] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[58:07] Ebony Vines: Can be even more, I don't know, like uh energized because of that fear, because of that unknown quality that we know, but that they don't.

[58:20] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[58:21] Ebony Vines: Yeah. I mean, they did. They it was uh like I I was when I was reading the synopsis of the musical, it felt like they had turned a period piece into a dystopian piece.

[58:34] Pamela Shandrow: And there's a place for that.

[58:36] Ebony Vines: Right. I I love the idea of doing a dystopian musical. Metropolis is a complete dystopian musical.

[58:44] Pamela Shandrow: And I think it was also may have been a flop, but I loved that thing. Like that was a that was a cool, but it was also based on a book, so it had that source material.

[58:52] Ebony Vines: But the book was dystopian too, right?

[58:55] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, yes.

[58:56] Ebony Vines: See, that's the thing that I'm sort of getting at is that to turn something that was historically yeah, it was based in in something that happened into a dystopian future.

[59:09] Pamela Shandrow: It destabilizes it, but not in a way that I feel serves the piece.

[59:17] Ebony Vines: But I'm the psychology of humans and how they how they react under certain stimuli, like that is fascinating to me.

[59:29] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, yeah.

[59:30] Ebony Vines: This was a good one. I I recommend uh like all of these books were great.

[59:37] Pamela Shandrow: So they all sounded great.

[59:39] Ebony Vines: So that's it for Dance a LITTLE CLOSER, friends. I uh oh, just so you know, the cast recordings on Spotify, if you all are interested in listening to it.

[59:49] Pamela Shandrow: I really love the overture.

[59:52] Ebony Vines: Great. I could listen to that on repeat. I love a good overture. So I'm I'm just gonna read to I'm just gonna end and reading the beginning of Frank Rich's critique because it's actually pretty positive the beginning.

[1:00:06] Pamela Shandrow: Um although Dance a LITTLE CLOSER, the no the new musical at The Min Scoff numbs the audience with almost every step.

[1:00:13] Ebony Vines: I won't pretend that I didn't get it didn't get to me. That happened just before the second act when the able conductor Peter Howard led his band in a brief medley of the score.

[1:00:25] Pamela Shandrow: Listening to Charles Strauss's music as lively orchestrated by Jonathan Tunick, anyone can plainly hear that it contains some pretty melodies.

[1:00:33] Ebony Vines: Remembering some of the Alan J. Lerner lyrics that accompany them, especially those for the romantic title song, I was reminded of why Lerner is one of our musical theater's top professionals.

[1:00:44] Pamela Shandrow: And then it gets he gets into the rest of you know, which is not great.

[1:00:51] Ebony Vines: Wow. But you know, this is why we do this show right, is because Alan, like I said, he had three Tonies and three Oscars. Like we all know Charles's most famous show, Annie, right? And so, like, if there's people who we can look at and say they were extremely successful, but they didn't succeed at everything.

[1:01:13] Pamela Shandrow: Right.

[1:01:13] Ebony Vines: And failure didn't stop them. Because like I said, this was like Alan had had a string of misfires, and he still was like, but no. The thing is, the longer your career, the more opportunity for you to fail.

[1:01:26] Pamela Shandrow: That that's the truth.

[1:01:28] Ebony Vines: Geeks, I'm sorry, I did meant mention a like a little piece of a letter that I was gonna read after um Dance a LITTLE CLOSER misfired.

[1:01:38] Pamela Shandrow: All right that Alan sent to one of his friends who is a book author, and she sent him an early copy of his book, and he was lauding how much he loved the book.

[1:01:48] Ebony Vines: He said, For myself, you know, alas. I would rather have Liz than all the hits in the world.

[1:01:59] Pamela Shandrow: Aw.

[1:01:59] Ebony Vines: That's lovely.

[1:02:01] Pamela Shandrow: Really sweet.

[1:02:01] Ebony Vines: Yeah, that's nice.

[1:02:06] Pamela Shandrow: Yay!

[1:02:07] Ebony Vines: Ba-dump bump.

[1:02:08] Pamela Shandrow: And again.

[1:02:10] Ebony Vines: We'll see you next time.

[1:02:12] Pamela Shandrow: Yay.

[1:02:13] Ebony Vines: Bye.

[1:02:15] Pamela Shandrow: Cast.

[1:02:15] Ebony Vines: Theater Geeks Anonymous.

[1:02:17] Pamela Shandrow: You can follow us on Instagram and Twitter at T G A B Way.

[1:02:24] Ebony Vines: And on Facebook at Theater Geeks Anonymous.

[1:02:27] Pamela Shandrow: And if you want to tell us how much you love us, or you have a great story about one of the shows we've talked about, drop us a note at T G A B Way at Gmail.com.

[1:02:40] Ebony Vines: Until next time, Geeks.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred