The Beach Boys have a musical featuring their music, but maybe lacking in their incredible storytelling abilities... Read More
From the show: Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast by Ebony Vines and Pamela Shandrow
About
The Beach Boys have a musical featuring their music, but maybe lacking in their incredible storytelling abilities.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Ebony Vines: Welcome to Theatre Geeks Anonymous, the podcast about Broadway flops, scandals, and new work.
[0:08] Pamela Shandrow: I'm your host, Ebony Vines.
[0:10] Pamela Shandrow: And I'm your host, Pamela Shandrow.
[0:13] Ebony Vines: Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe to the Theatre Geeks Anonymous Podcast on the Broadway Podcast Network and all your favorite podcast listening apps.
[0:23] Pamela Shandrow: Thank you.
[0:25] Ebony Vines: Okay, Pamela, I've got something to say to you.
[0:27] Pamela Shandrow: You ready?
[0:28] Ebony Vines: Tell me.
[0:29] Pamela Shandrow: Happy anniversary of our podcast idea.
[0:32] Ebony Vines: Oh my gosh, it really is.
[0:34] Pamela Shandrow: It's President's Day.
[0:35] Ebony Vines: It is!
[0:36] Pamela Shandrow: Isn't that fun?
[0:38] Ebony Vines: I didn't even think about that.
[0:43] Pamela Shandrow: Wow, so where it? What was it? This is Conception Day.
[0:47] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[0:49] Pamela Shandrow: Jeez.
[0:50] Ebony Vines: I know.
[0:50] Pamela Shandrow: That's nuts.
[0:52] Ebony Vines: There are marriages that don't last this long.
[0:57] Pamela Shandrow: Really?
[0:58] Ebony Vines: I feel like we've had—have we had more than I know?
[1:03] Pamela Shandrow: I know, uh, we've—I think every couple has their growing pains.
[1:08] Ebony Vines: Every relationship has their times.
[1:10] Pamela Shandrow: And most of ours was happening in the very conception days when we were dealing with all of the technology issues, and like we hadn't learned how to talk to each other yet.
[1:20] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[1:21] Pamela Shandrow: Or how to communicate, and I think that was huge. Once we figured that out, it was like, oh, okay, we're good.
[1:27] Ebony Vines: Well, and it was freaking technology.
[1:31] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[1:31] Ebony Vines: Was like breaking us.
[1:33] Pamela Shandrow: It was awful.
[1:34] Ebony Vines: As human beings.
[1:35] Pamela Shandrow: It truly, I mean, truly, because it was like it should—it's something that should have been the easiest thing in the world. Plugging in a microphone and talking and having it record was like—like Alexander Graham Bell did this in the, what, 1800s?
[1:50] Ebony Vines: I don't even remember.
[1:51] Pamela Shandrow: Or anyway, it doesn't matter. I'm gonna sound stupid when I say that, but it's fine.
[1:56] Ebony Vines: It's been a long time since I was in school.
[1:58] Pamela Shandrow: Um, like we couldn't figure it out to do one tiny little podcast.
[2:03] Ebony Vines: So it definitely got into the—it got into the foundation of our friendship for a little bit, but we figured it out.
[2:12] Pamela Shandrow: Trial by fire.
[2:13] Ebony Vines: Definitely.
[2:16] Pamela Shandrow: Oh my gosh. Uh, happy anniversary. I was gonna sing the happy anniversary song, but I'm not going to.
[2:22] Ebony Vines: Not gonna hurt and pain all of our listeners by—I appreciate that kind of thing.
[2:28] Pamela Shandrow: And I don't want that ear—but—earwig in my ear.
[2:31] Ebony Vines: Ear—earbug, earworm.
[2:35] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, you're right.
[2:38] Ebony Vines: Oh Lordy. We just started, you guys. This is gonna be really fun.
[2:44] Pamela Shandrow: So, okay. So I know the last episode you guys listened to, we kind of explained that we had taken a nice hiatus.
[2:55] Ebony Vines: Oh my gosh!
[2:58] Pamela Shandrow: Everything is in the weirdness zone today.
[3:01] Ebony Vines: Welcome!
[3:03] Pamela Shandrow: What's up, theater geeks?
[3:05] Ebony Vines: What is up? What is up? What is up? What is up? What is up? What is up?
[3:10] Pamela Shandrow: Did you like that?
[3:11] Ebony Vines: I kind of liked it.
[3:12] Pamela Shandrow: I was like, today we're back to the Sarty—sorry. We're back to our OG ways today.
[3:17] Ebony Vines: Yes, we are going back to where it all began and talking about Broadway theater that flopped.
[3:25] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[3:26] Ebony Vines: But today this is kind of exciting though, because we haven't done a lot of contemporary shows. Mostly the shows that we do are much older, but today we're gonna do one that happened in the 2000s.
[3:38] Pamela Shandrow: Should I announce it?
[3:39] Ebony Vines: Please do.
[3:42] Pamela Shandrow: Talking about all our technical difficulties, and now we're coming back with another huge technical difficulty. Listen, I tried to do a little drum roll.
[3:50] Ebony Vines: I'm not gonna do that again.
[3:52] Pamela Shandrow: I had to switch to my computer microphone. We're gonna see how this goes. Sorry if there's bad quality right now.
[3:58] Ebony Vines: Ebony informs me that it's fine.
[4:00] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. It sounds fine so far.
[4:01] Ebony Vines: Okay, got fingers crossed, then say a prayer.
[4:04] Pamela Shandrow: I guess spit over your shoulder three times.
[4:07] Ebony Vines: I wish I had salt.
[4:08] Pamela Shandrow: I know, I know. We're all salty.
[4:10] Ebony Vines: We're a little salty.
[4:11] Pamela Shandrow: We can use that.
[4:14] Pamela Shandrow: So the musical that I'm doing today is GOOD VIBRATIONS, which is the musical based on the Beach Boys jukebox soundtrack.
[4:23] Ebony Vines: Very exciting.
[4:24] Pamela Shandrow: It is exciting. I had fun doing this one, and you know how I like to wait until the last minute. So this was done.
[4:30] Ebony Vines: I know.
[4:31] Pamela Shandrow: I did this basically—I started about 10:30 this morning. Um, had to put it on pause a little bit when I had the plumber come in and then got back to it.
[4:40] Ebony Vines: But it's fun, and surprisingly, because I know that we have run into these issues before, um, I was actually able to find quite a lot of information about the show, uh, which sometimes doesn't happen a lot with the more contemporary shows.
[4:54] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[4:55] Ebony Vines: As far as like background.
[4:57] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, it is strange because you'd think they'd be all over the place. But I think too, with the implementation of social media, uh, these companies and shows and productions are able to like really cultivate the information that they want to have out there.
[5:11] Ebony Vines: And anything else, they have deleted.
[5:13] Pamela Shandrow: So our loss sometimes, but not in this case.
[5:18] Ebony Vines: So, uh, as always, I'm gonna tell you who I read and where I got most of my information, including, of course, Wikipedia, because it usually has a wealth of information that you can then fall down rabbit holes about.
[5:31] Pamela Shandrow: Um, I also found some information on IBDB.com.
[5:34] Ebony Vines: Uh, I love IBDB, and I will say that for these newer shows, the information they have on there is enormous. Like there is so much stuff, so that's good.
[5:44] Pamela Shandrow: Uh, Broadway World and also Playbill.com. Those will just name a few, and then I've got some listed later on.
[5:51] Ebony Vines: Okay.
[5:51] Pamela Shandrow: So awesome.
[5:52] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[5:53] Pamela Shandrow: First preview for GOOD VIBRATIONS was on December 20th, 2004. Opening night being February 2nd, 2005, and it ran all the way until April 24th, 2005 at the Eugene O'Neill Theater, having 50 previews, that's five zero, and 94 performances.
[6:10] Ebony Vines: Okay.
[6:11] Pamela Shandrow: Good vibe.
[6:11] Ebony Vines: I know.
[6:12] Pamela Shandrow: It actually does seem like quite a bit, but it was considered magnanimously as—or unanimously, I should say, as a flop.
[6:20] Ebony Vines: Oh, I remember.
[6:25] Pamela Shandrow: I don't because I was still living in Illinois at the time.
[6:28] Ebony Vines: Oh, okay.
[6:29] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[6:31] Ebony Vines: Mm-hmm.
[6:31] Pamela Shandrow: So good.
[6:35] Pamela Shandrow: GOOD VIBRATIONS is a Broadway jukebox musical conceived and directed by John Carafa, featuring the music of Brian Wilson and The Beach Boys.
[6:43] Ebony Vines: The Beach Boys, of course, are an American rock band that formed in Hawthorne, California in 1961. The group's original lineup consisted of brothers Brian, Dennis, and Carl Wilson, their cousin Mike Love, and a friend Al Jardine.
[6:58] Pamela Shandrow: Distinguished for their vocal harmonies, adolescent-oriented themes, and musical ingenuity, they are one of the most influential acts of the rock era.
[7:07] Ebony Vines: They drew on the music of older pop vocal groups, 1950s rock and roll, and black R&B to create their unique sound, and under Brian's direction, often incorporated classical or jazz elements and unconventional recording techniques in innovative ways.
[7:23] Pamela Shandrow: Brian Wilson is mentioned specifically and individually here, and that's because in 1961, he actually began his professional career as this member of the Beach Boys, but he was serving as the band's songwriter, producer, co-lead vocalist, bassist, keyboardist, and de facto leader.
[7:42] Ebony Vines: John Carafa, the director, is an American theater and film director choreographer, best known as the two-time Tony Award-nominated choreographer of the Broadway musicals Urinetown and the 2002 revival of Into the Woods.
[7:56] Pamela Shandrow: He was also the media choreography honors award winner for the Robert Zemeckis film The Polar Express. He was a dancer and assistant to Twyla Tharp before becoming a choreographer and director for Broadway, film, and television.
[8:10] Ebony Vines: And I should also say that in addition to directing GOOD VIBRATIONS, he was also the choreographer.
[8:17] Pamela Shandrow: So the plot, it's gonna be a very small read here.
[8:23] Ebony Vines: The plot follows a group of high school pals desperate to escape their one-factory New England town and drive to California. Of central interest to the plot are David Larson as Bobby and Vane and Pop—oh, the vain and popular big man on campus at the small-town high school, and Kate Raindreers as Caroline, the mousie class valedictorian who has had a crush on Bobby since the fourth grade.
[8:49] Pamela Shandrow: Dreading the prospect of life working at the local factory, Bobby and his pals, the engaged Eddie, Titus Burgess, and Shallow Dave.
[8:58] Ebony Vines: I know.
[9:00] Pamela Shandrow: Uh, Shallow Dave, Brandon Wardell. They con Caroline into driving them to California in her new red convertible.
[9:08] Ebony Vines: Once they reach the West Coast, however, things don't turn out exactly as any of them had planned.
[9:14] Pamela Shandrow: Though the simple storyline and the Beach Boys music give the show a 1960s feel, the tale is not set in any specific year.
[9:22] Ebony Vines: GOOD VIBRATIONS uses more than 30 songs written by Brian Wilson and the Beach Boys. Some are heard in their entirety and some are just in snippets, but they include "Fun, Fun, Fun," "Wouldn't It Be Nice," "I Get Around," "Don't Worry, Baby," "Surf City," "Surfin' USA," "California Girls," "Help Me, Rhonda," "God Only Knows," and of course, the titular number, "GOOD VIBRATIONS."
[9:44] Pamela Shandrow: I know.
[9:45] Ebony Vines: All earworms.
[9:46] Pamela Shandrow: Right? They're all earworms.
[9:48] Ebony Vines: Pamela, I freaking love the Beach Boys.
[9:51] Pamela Shandrow: I love them.
[9:52] Ebony Vines: And it's even before doing this episode. I will sometimes just get in the mood to listen to the Beach Boys, and I will put them up on my radio. And it does not matter how bad a mood I was in before starting to listen.
[10:05] Pamela Shandrow: They just have a really great way of uplifting you in that moment.
[10:09] Ebony Vines: I love them.
[10:12] Pamela Shandrow: Now this is the point in my research where I tell you about the creative team, but there are very many—there's just too many names to list.
[10:22] Ebony Vines: So I encourage you all to check out IBDB.com to see who was all involved in this production.
[10:28] Pamela Shandrow: However, the cast on opening night starred Kate Raindeers as Caroline, David Larson as Bobby, Titus Burgess as Eddie, Brandon Wardell as Dave, Jessica Snow Wilson as Marcella, David Riser as Dean, and Sebastian Arcellus as Jan.
[10:44] Ebony Vines: You've also got Janet DeCall, and I don't know if I'm saying that correctly, so I apologize, Janet.
[10:50] Pamela Shandrow: Sarah Glendening and Krista Rodriguez, who all made their Broadway debuts in this show.
[10:54] Ebony Vines: I know, isn't that Baby Krista?
[10:57] Pamela Shandrow: Very baby Krista.
[10:59] Ebony Vines: GOOD VIBRATIONS received many harshly mixed reviews that condemned its plot as being superficial, predictable, and bland, contrived around incorporating as many Beach Boys songs as possible.
[11:11] Pamela Shandrow: Since the songs were not tailor-made for the musical, critics complained that songs did little to progress the plot or give insight into the characters.
[11:19] Ebony Vines: Therefore, despite an energetic cast and a soulful score of favorite tunes, the general verdict was that GOOD VIBRATIONS made for a nice concert, but a poor example of true musical theater.
[11:32] Pamela Shandrow: So part of, I mean, there were quite a few critiques that you can find online. I'm gonna read one from a Playbill.com article by Robert Simonson on April 19th, 2005. So this was shortly before they closed. And this is just an excerpt here. The show began December 20th, 2004 and opened February 2nd. Though its run will have been a mere 50 previews and 94 regular performances, many observers expected its visit to Broadway to be even shorter. The Jukebox musical, which is directed and choreographed by John Carafa, was dogged by remarkably bad buzz even before it gave its first performance. Opening night reviews were almost uniformly negative. The new show arrived on Broadway without the luxury, and I'm gonna repeat this very loudly, without the luxury of an out-of-town tryout.
It was to have premiered on January 27th, and indeed the opening night party remained on that day, but the unveiling was pushed back to February 2nd while the creative team honed their work. In early January, experienced New York director David Warren was brought in to assist in the staging. Warren reportedly began work at the O'Neal on January 6th, and John Carafa, though, he remained the official director and choreographer on the project. I couldn't find anything else written about David Warren. So there wasn't any kind of like gossip behind the scenes that had been written down and left on the internet, unfortunately, because that would have been exciting to read.
[13:07] Ebony Vines: Now, in another article announcing the full cast on Broadway.com, it mentions that the show premiered at Vassar Powerhouse Theater, where it ran from July 29th through August 1st in 2004. So that kind of contradicts the idea that it didn't have an out-of-town tryout.
[13:25] Pamela Shandrow: Well, it's like so that is like a um it's not a tryout like a workshop. A show would go to yeah, it's more like that because it's not a tryout like how shows will go to La Jolla and that one. It is, it's just like a workshop. Like Hamilton was there for a minute, but it's like proper tryout would have been the public theater, you know.
[13:47] Ebony Vines: Gotcha. So that makes sense. Um, I couldn't find a lot of information about this particular production, but I did find out that um Titus Burgess and David Larson both uh continued in their roles from that production.
[14:00] Pamela Shandrow: Okay. Um, I also read that Megan McGuinness was in the role that Kate Rangers took, but she was in Little Women at the time, so she had to go and do that. That was the same year as this, 2005. Uh, let's see. Oh, so I did say I couldn't find anything else. But then I came across a book called The Complete Book of 2000's Broadway musicals by Dan Deeds. It's super fun and a little bit snarky. I'm just gonna read from it. This is a fun, it's a fun read. It's pretty long, but bear with me because I think you're gonna enjoy it as well. The Jukebox musical, GOOD VIBRATIONS featured songs by the Beach Boys, and no doubt everyone associated with the show thought, count three and pray Mama Mia. But lightning didn't strike twice, and the show was one of the most vilified of the decade, losing 7.7 million and closing after less than three months.
Although the program's vague here and now description didn't say much, the here was clearly California and the now was a kind of idealized 1950s and 1960s limbo of surfing, swimming, splashing, sunbathing, suntan lotion, and sunglasses, in which only surfer guys, beach guys, beach kids, uh chili dog kids, and giggle girls, as well as a bikini girl, a cowboy, and a country dude were allowed.
[15:23] Ebony Vines: The show also borrowed a dollop of grease for its slender plot about the high school romance between a rebel-like bad boy and the nice and respectable girl. The musical also included a mixed race couple and a gay or two. Characters one suspects wouldn't be found in authentic beach party flicks of the 1960s. Ben Brantley in the New York Times said the rickety musical was a singing headache, but noted the show had a purpose because its reason for existence was to make all other musicals on Broadway look good. The season had thus far offered such clunkers as Dracula, Brooklyn, and Little Women.
[16:03] Pamela Shandrow: But these shows now seemed like Brooklyn.
[16:06] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[16:06] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, you don't remember it?
[16:08] Ebony Vines: No.
[16:09] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, interesting. That was one of those. I feel because I was living in Chicago at the time, and Brooklyn was huge with the theater kids of Chicago. And I think it's because it was meant to be like it was this kind of like small, small fish made it big kind of storyline, as far as the actual musical was concerned.
[16:28] Ebony Vines: I who was in the lead? I think it was Eden Espinoza.
[16:30] Pamela Shandrow: Oh.
[16:32] Ebony Vines: Was in the lead. I totally remember Little Women.
[16:36] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[16:37] Ebony Vines: And Dracula, yeah.
[16:38] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[16:39] Ebony Vines: But I don't know. Brooklyn.
[16:41] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. Um so these were the clunkers that they had in 2005, but these shows now seemed like a high point of professionalism, according to Ben Brantley. The book was block-headed comic strip, and the direction and choreography were sloppy. The costumes were a popery of styles and eras that could give uh oh that could have come from a mass market department store. The over-accessorized sets included beach balls, galore. The cast had apparently spent more time in the gym than in the rehearsal studio, and the sum effect was a lumbering brainless Frankenstein's monster stitched together from stolen body parts and stuffed into a wild bikini.
[17:23] Ebony Vines: Yikes, he didn't pull any punches there. Uh David Rooney in Variety said the amateurish musical didn't approached the staggering tedium of the look of love, but was so inept it made Mamma Mia look like Sunday in the park with George. The show wasn't just cheesy, it was Velveeta cheesy, spread thick on white bread, and the performers weren't beached but entirely at sea. One cast member did herself no favors by relentlessly channeling Kristen Chennewith. Rooney also mentioned those beach balls that the cast occasionally tossed into the audience, and he wondered what would come first, the show's closing notice or a lawsuit over broken eyeglasses.
[18:04] Pamela Shandrow: Clive Barnes in the New York Post also used the B word and noted that the show was beached with the drab book, ugly decor, and conventional costumes, and he concluded that GOOD VIBRATIONS was the wrong time, the wrong show, and the wrong beach. In the same newspaper, Michael Riedel reported that the two Tony voters complained about the beach ball assaults, and Riedel noted that instead the audience that should have been throwing that the audience should have been throwing things at the cast. Because here was a show that made footloose once the gold standard of awfulness and Dracula look like masterpieces of the American musical theater.
[18:45] Ebony Vines: Songs cut during previews were Catch a Wave, Do It Again, Let's Go Away for a While, Little Deuce Coop, Little Honda uh oh, Little Honda.
[18:56] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, I didn't realize that was one too.
[18:57] Ebony Vines: That's funny. Uh Surf and Safari, uh, Wendy, and a couple of others. Um, earlier the musical that had been presented at the Vassar College's Powerhouse Theater in July of 2004, and those songs were all included. The debacle of GOOD VIBRATIONS apparently made everyone forget about New York's first Beach Boys musical. This was when I was like, what? So, although perhaps the word suppressed is more accurate, uh, yes, Surf City, subtitled the Beach Boys Musical and originally titled Surf in USA, was scheduled to open off Broadway at the Intermedia Theater on April 9th, 1985. And one of its co-producers told the New York Times the show was inspired by the idealized lifestyle of the California myth and the feelings, spirit, and fantasies epitomized by the Beach Boys music. That the fantasies went only so far, and the one and a half million dollar musical shuddered after 11 previews.
[20:01] Pamela Shandrow: I had no inkling at all that there was another musical.
[20:07] Ebony Vines: So here's my hot take, because I love finishing off with a Pamela's hot take. My biggest problem to date with these so-called jukebox musicals is that reason exactly, right? Just because a song is great, and by that reason, I mean no real storyline to follow.
[20:28] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[20:28] Ebony Vines: Uh based on the ideas that the critics presented. Um, just because a song is great, it doesn't mean that it's meant to progress the story.
[20:36] Pamela Shandrow: And in musical theater, that's the most important thing.
[20:39] Ebony Vines: Yes, yes. But why was Mamma Mia an exception to this rule? Is it simply because it was the first?
[20:45] Pamela Shandrow: I would argue that in America at least, the Beach Boys were much more critically acclaimed than ABBA.
[20:54] Ebony Vines: Certainly the two bands.
[20:55] Pamela Shandrow: Right. Certainly the two bands that are listen, they're both worthy of all of this notoriety because they're both incredible bands, right? But where one of these shows was touted and praised as uplifting and fun, campy, nostalgic, the other was dismissed as being the singing headache and cliche.
[21:13] Ebony Vines: Also, and this has not a lot to do with the actual shows, but I was watching this video interview online. You can all find them. It was the very first video that popped up when I put in GOOD VIBRATIONS musical into the Google search. The director, John Carrafa, tells us that he had callbacks in bikinis.
[21:20] Pamela Shandrow: Okay.
[21:34] Ebony Vines: But then the interview cuts back to all of these cast members now talking not about the show that they're in rehearsals for, but about how they're doing crunches in between scenes and they're not eating carbs anymore, and they're all at the tanning salon every chance that they get. And it just reminds me again how little progress we've made in regards to inclusivity and representation. There was only one black body I saw in that rehearsal footage, and that belonged to Titus Burgess, and no bodies that would indicate that fat has ever even existed in this world.
[22:07] Pamela Shandrow: The lead actress is trying to convince herself that her character wouldn't care about stomach wrinkles when she sits, so it'll be okay.
[22:19] Ebony Vines: That's part of the book.
[22:21] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, that was part of the interview. So Kate Rangers gets up there and she's like, you know, it just, you know, I feel like my character is so self-assured, and she's like so confident, so you know, she doesn't care that when she sits, you can see stomach wrinkles, and she doesn't care about walking across the stage in a bikini, so it's gonna it'll be fine, like I don't have to worry about that.
[22:46] Ebony Vines: Rendered speechless.
[22:48] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah, a little bit. And this is, and I, you know, it's equal parts sad and disappointing and anger-inducing, and I would have hoped that we might have changed even slightly in the intervening 17 years.
[23:03] Pamela Shandrow: But we just haven't. So Good Vibrations doesn't leave me with very many good vibrations, to be perfectly honest. As much as I love the thing is, this is what I hate. Okay. And we've talked about this before, but I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna simmer a little bit more. Entertainment wants us to believe that if you are anything other than what is represented on stage and on screen and in magazines, that you are other.
[23:35] Ebony Vines: Right.
[23:36] Pamela Shandrow: That you're not normal. But that's not the case. Right. There are a lot more people of color in this world than would be indicated on film.
[23:46] Ebony Vines: Well, that's why we call ourselves the global majority, because we are.
[23:50] Pamela Shandrow: Yes. There are also, and correct me if I'm wrong, but this that the last view, the average size of a woman in America was 14.
[24:01] Ebony Vines: Yeah.
[24:02] Pamela Shandrow: Which is also sadly considered plus size, which it is not, but that's a whole nother issue. So you can't tell me that there isn't a single woman with curves and fat on a beach in California. You can't tell me that. Because that's a big fat lie.
[24:20] Ebony Vines: That's... and I just thought of this. Because you know how we used to watch, we watched those movies on TLC and on Turner Cl or TCM and AMC, uh, of you know, like the Annette Funicello beach movies, right?
[24:39] Pamela Shandrow: Oh yeah.
[24:41] Ebony Vines: They never worried about every woman being stick thin and every man having a six pack in those movies. That was the 1950s, right?
[24:41] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[24:41] Ebony Vines: And at some point we like lost the ability to see what is right in front of our face and what should continue to be represented. Yeah, it just kills me. And then I think of like renaissance pictures, like portraits, right? Because my body is all over those paintings. I see myself everywhere.
[24:41] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[24:41] Ebony Vines: And I just saw TikTok actually with a black man putting up beautiful black renaissance paintings too of these people of color in Renaissance garb and I was like, I didn't even know those existed, which I'm glad I saw the TikTok of that because I think that was his point in the first place. But I was like everyone has been represented up to a certain point in this world and then we got to the 20th century and suddenly I don't know what that's about, but there's a conspiracy there.
[25:44] Pamela Shandrow: I know, I get a drink of water.
[25:47] Ebony Vines: I know, yeah, I yeah that's wow. I didn't know about Surf City. I want to go down that rabbit hole performances. Listen, I was so close to like typing it into the Google and I was like no no I have to just leave it here for now because there was so much on the actual show that we were doing, but yeah that is really interesting.
[26:11] Pamela Shandrow: I'll have to see if it's included in Not Since Carrie or if it's in the other book that we have, Mark Robinson's book.
[26:19] Ebony Vines: Yes.
[26:20] Pamela Shandrow: It's a musical misfires.
[26:22] Ebony Vines: There it is. Thank you. And to see if there's any information otherwise. That'd be really interesting.
[26:26] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[26:27] Ebony Vines: I'm sure. I wonder if it's in Second Act Trouble even too, which I have here.
[26:38] Pamela Shandrow: Ebony, I just had a resurfaced memory. What while I was doing my research, I saw the name Ken Mandelbaum attached to the cast, but not it was one of those, like here the cast has been announced, but it wasn't entirely confirmed at that point. But like people like Justin Guarini were mentioned in it, but Ken Mandelbaum was mentioned in it as well.
[27:02] Ebony Vines: And he wrote Not Since Carrie.
[27:04] Pamela Shandrow: I just had that memory in Surf City?
[27:06] Ebony Vines: No, no, in GOOD VIBRATIONS.
[27:09] Pamela Shandrow: Does that make sense?
[27:10] Ebony Vines: I don't think that makes sense though. Because I feel like the cast was all very young. Like I don't even think they had their token old people.
[27:19] Pamela Shandrow: Okay, okay.
[27:21] Ebony Vines: So maybe it's just maybe it was like, because sometimes when you search for stuff, Google Books will pop up with like excerpts from those. So maybe it was just like maybe, yeah, okay, not from Not Since Carrie, yeah. I'll just maybe edit this part out then so no one gets excited.
[27:44] Pamela Shandrow: That like thinking about Surf City and GOOD VIBRATIONS, and then it's like then why then did we also decide to do Escape to Margaritaville? Which is like the same feeling.
[27:54] Ebony Vines: Well, and also feeling, but it's different music and it's a different artist completely. Like it's still, I get it. Well, why did we even decide to do any of these jukebox musicals?
[28:09] Pamela Shandrow: Cause it, I mean, there's uh, there was the Elvis one. What is that one called?
[28:14] Ebony Vines: It's, it was, I just went right through my brain. Shoot it, it's one of his songs.
[28:23] Pamela Shandrow: Is it jail something?
[28:26] Ebony Vines: It's not the jail one.
[28:27] Pamela Shandrow: Oh, somebody's gonna be like, What the hell, Ebony?
[28:30] Ebony Vines: I know they're yelling at us right now.
[28:32] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah. It's like with G, there's a G word. Let me just Google it.
[28:41] Ebony Vines: I don't know.
[28:43] Pamela Shandrow: Uh, I 'cause I feel like there's just like a handful that have worked or have done well. Like Carol did well. Jersey Boys did well, which actually All Shook Up.
[28:50] Ebony Vines: Sorry.
[28:50] Pamela Shandrow: All Shook Up.
[28:58] Ebony Vines: But that's also, wasn't that also in 2005? I feel like that was also it, they all happened right at the same time.
[29:05] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[29:06] Ebony Vines: Right in the early 2000s. Well, it's the same with the Donna Summer musical. Because like it opened and then Cher was opening right after.
[29:20] Pamela Shandrow: And it's like the same concept of like the three women playing her at three different parts of her life.
[29:25] Ebony Vines: I mean it's interesting how remember also that um man, my brain stopped working. Um remember how is it another jukebox musical?
[29:45] Pamela Shandrow: No, it's the two Wild Party.
[29:48] Ebony Vines: Both Wild Parties came out in the same year.
[29:50] Pamela Shandrow: Yes. That was come on, you guys. You're like, seriously, you couldn't just wait to see maybe if that one would flop and then come out with yours.
[29:58] Ebony Vines: Like at least.
[30:00] Pamela Shandrow: But no, I feel like that always happens. Everything is kind of cyclical that way.
[30:03] Ebony Vines: And so ideas will, you know, and you'll notice too, like regional theaters will all tend to do the same seasons each year. Like there'll be one or two shows that are on everybody's season in one given year.
[30:16] Pamela Shandrow: So I'm not sure why that works or why they end up doing it, but not for me to say I'm just Pamela.
[30:24] Ebony Vines: Just a lowly dog groomer.
[30:28] Pamela Shandrow: Slash podcast host.
[30:30] Ebony Vines: Right.
[30:31] Pamela Shandrow: No, but it is interesting. But I will because you mentioned Jersey Boys, which isn't in the same, it's not in the same vein. I don't even think you should really call it a jukebox musical.
[30:42] Ebony Vines: Like anyone should call it a jukebox musical because yes, they use the music of the Four Seasons, but it's about their life.
[30:50] Pamela Shandrow: Right, right. It's a biography.
[30:51] Ebony Vines: If any biographical musical, yeah, it's a biographical music. So is Cher and Donna.
[30:58] Pamela Shandrow: Right, exactly. The Donna Summer musical. I was always calling it Donna too.
[31:06] Ebony Vines: Um, but anyway. I just yeah, there I think it worked once with Mamma Mia, and then everyone tried to get that.
[31:16] Pamela Shandrow: And I don't know why it worked. We've already had this conversation before. Like it's neither of us like Mamma Mia.
[31:21] Ebony Vines: It's awful.
[31:22] Pamela Shandrow: Yeah.
[31:22] Ebony Vines: It's awful.
[31:23] Pamela Shandrow: Anyway, but it worked.
[31:25] Ebony Vines: It is terrible. Now, mind you, I've not I didn't see GOOD VIBRATIONS.
[31:30] Pamela Shandrow: I also didn't either see the first one, Surf City.
[31:30] Ebony Vines: Surf City.
[31:37] Pamela Shandrow: Um, I actually also haven't seen All Shook Up, although it is oh, but that's about Elvis' life, yeah, that's Elvis.
[31:45] Ebony Vines: Okay, that's but so that's different.
[31:47] Pamela Shandrow: Um, but I have seen Mamma Mia, and the only thing I can say about that is like, no, I don't like it. I don't care if you come for me.
[31:55] Ebony Vines: I don't care.
[31:56] Pamela Shandrow: I like ABBA, but I hate that musical.
[31:58] Ebony Vines: Right.
[31:58] Pamela Shandrow: But I'll go home and I'll listen to the soundtrack of, oh not the soundtrack. I'll listen to the soundtrack of Mamma Mia. I'll listen to ABBA music all day long.
[32:07] Ebony Vines: Well, what I was gonna say though is that remembering the plot, it does seem to like I loved the 2002 when they did it at the Tony Awards, they did like this little montage of songs.
[32:28] Pamela Shandrow: My favorite part was the money montage, and it did seem to like they figured out a way to get it to kind of move the plot forward because she is like at that point trying to figure out how she's going to keep her in or whatever the thing is open.
[32:46] Ebony Vines: I'll agree with that, you know, and so, but again, I had never saw GOOD VIBRATIONS, you know.
[32:53] Pamela Shandrow: But I think the one, the biggest complaint for these kind of shows outside of Mamma Mia is that the music was kind of spackled around the songs and it didn't move the plot forward.
[33:04] Ebony Vines: So yeah, you I guess you could argue that perhaps the ABBA songs did move the plot forward, whereas these other ones didn't, and that might have just been because oh it's popular right now. Let's get our musical out there.
[33:16] Pamela Shandrow: Right.
[33:18] Ebony Vines: And maybe they just didn't take the time to kind of really think about it's a good idea.
[33:23] Pamela Shandrow: Have a decent book, yeah.
[33:24] Ebony Vines: Right.
[33:26] Pamela Shandrow: All right. Well, that's it. That's the musical. GOOD VIBRATIONS with the Beach Boys music.
[33:34] Ebony Vines: Thank you for listening, friends.
[33:35] Pamela Shandrow: Yes, thank you.
[33:38] Ebony Vines: Thank you for listening to our podcast, Theatre Geeks Anonymous.
[33:44] Pamela Shandrow: You can follow us on Instagram and Twitter at TGABW.
[33:50] Ebony Vines: And on Facebook at Theatre Geeks Anonymous.
[33:53] Pamela Shandrow: And if you want to tell us how much you love us, or you have a great story about one of the shows we've talked about, drop us a note at TGABWay at Gmail.com.
[34:06] Ebony Vines: You can also support us by going to patreon.com forward slash TGABWAY.
[34:13] Pamela Shandrow: Until next time, geeks.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
