Jeremy Beloate is powerhouse vocalist, recording artist, and performer who was a finalist on NBC’s The Voice. After his success on The Voice, he was signed by Snoop Dogg to Death Row Records and has continued developing an original sound that blends soulful vocals with deeply personal storytelling... Read More
From the show: When Lightning Strikes!
About
Jeremy Beloate is powerhouse vocalist, recording artist, and performer who was a finalist on NBC’s The Voice. After his success on The Voice, he was signed by Snoop Dogg to Death Row Records and has continued developing an original sound that blends soulful vocals with deeply personal storytelling. Jeremy recently made his New York stage debut in Midnight, the Off-Broadway musical written, directed, and choreographed by Todrick Hall. Midnight is now playing through January 3rd at the Daryl Roth Theatre.
This episode was recorded on November 17, 2026
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "When Lightning Strikes" — performed by Unknown performer ♪
[0:25] Jeryl Brunner: This is Jeryl Brunner, and you're listening to When Lightning Strikes!.
[0:55] Jeryl Brunner: Welcome to the podcast. Today's episode is brought to you by the New York City Opera House, a musical theater that blends soulful vocals with deeply personal storytelling. Jeremy recently made his New York stage debut in Midnight, the Off-Broadway musical written, directed, and choreographed by Todrick Hall. Midnight is now playing through January 3 at the Daryl Roth Theatre. Well, welcome.
[1:18] Jeremy Beloate: Hi, it is so lovely to be here. It's such an honor. I love your work. Thank you so much for having me.
[1:27] Jeryl Brunner: Oh, that means so much to me, Jeremy. Well, I love your work. Take me there when you sing, and what a gorgeous performance in Midnight. Tell me about when Midnight came into your life, because I know that you've been with it.
[1:43] Jeremy Beloate: Yes.
[1:44] Jeremy Beloate: Early, early, early on. So take me there when you first heard about it and connected with Todrick.
[1:51] Jeremy Beloate: Oh, yes. Well, you know, Todrick started writing this about five years ago. And so about four years ago now is when I started with the project because it was in its first iteration. We did it in Austin, Texas, and we had met through social media and he was just like, I love your voice. And he had heard a video of me singing when I was studying abroad in Denmark. I sang this Harry Styles song, "Falling." And he was like, I just love your voice. And so he had auditions in Austin, Texas, because he was just gonna like do a five, six week local iteration of it, have local people, but he didn't find the person to play Richard. And so he was like, okay, I'm gonna have someone come in and do Richard from New York. And so I was flown out and housed and everything. And I got to start with the project in its original iteration. And it was such a blessing then as it is now.
[2:50] Jeremy Beloate: And the first time I heard the music, he sent me like a voice note of it. And it was like him singing with like eight different parts of himself like on GarageBand or something. Or maybe it was like way more professional than that. I don't know. But even then I was like, oh, wait, this is like some of the best music I've ever heard. And like being a musical theatre kid who just graduated from college and everything, it's so exciting to be a part of new, original work that like, you know, you look up to musicals like Spring Awakening and Next to Normal and all these things and you hope and pray in your lifetime that you'll be able to be a part of something like that. And I feel like, knock on wood, like I get to be a part of something like that. So it's been such a dream come true.
[3:39] Jeryl Brunner: I mean, I think of the show just as a beautiful mosaic of styles of experiences. I mean, just the music alone. You have soul, you have rock music, you have pop, it blends all these beautiful genres. And if somebody were to ask you, how would you describe Midnight? What would you say?
[4:03] Jeremy Beloate: I think it's a message from the heart. You know, it does such a beautiful job at transcending the physical and it's just such a spiritual experience. Like, you hear gospel in the show, but also just like everybody's performances. I got to see it the other night, like the performances from the actors in the show literally feel like ethereal and the music that Todrick's written feels like something of like a song time. Just like, like this generational talent. And it just feels like a spiritual experience, something to really witness. But as a story, it's exciting to, it's a unifying story about so many different communities, for the queer community, for so many different communities. And it's such a beautiful experience to be at the front of that and the center of that and bring people together.
And at the end of the show, people are just in tears every night. And I've faced a lot of loss in my personal life. And getting to share this message of like, you know, there's this song in the show called "Home." And it's just about, you know, like, you know, we only get a handful of Christmases. And I think sometimes, especially in New York, we just are so fast-paced and all of that, we forget how, what a blessing it is to live this life. And really, in retrospect, it's such a short-lived moment. And we just have to wake up every day and enjoy it, even on the days that are hard. So it's just really been such a beautiful reminder of that.
[5:48] Jeryl Brunner: Tell me what Midnight's about.
[5:52] Jeremy Beloate: Yeah, so Midnight is a sung-through opera set in the Deep South during the 1800s. And it follows 12 characters, six black, six white, and it poses the question posed by Rao, the lead character, what it would be like if history was flipped on its head. And you meet so many characters along the way, you meet my character, Richard, and all of us are interconnected, almost like an Into the Woods. It's a really beautiful, unique show, where it does have leads, but it also is an ensemble show. And you really root for almost every character. I just saw it the other day. So I did, I felt that way. And by the end, you were just left changed and left really, it's a thought-provoking piece. And it's a beautiful spiritual experience. It's sung through, it's so many genres of music, gospel, musical theatre, pop. So it's a really unique night of theatre. And it's such a blessing to be a part of.
[6:57] Jeryl Brunner: Oh, that's beautiful. It really takes you on a journey.
[7:00] Jeryl Brunner: You get to see so many interconnections between so many characters. And it's just, it's a gorgeous story. And I think of just the concept of shoes and Rao not having shoes and what that means when Rao gets shoes. And that's a very, very special moment and so poignant. And then your connection is so heartbreaking, devastating, and so complicated. Can you talk more about what it was that just completely touched you about the show all those years ago, four years ago?
[7:41] Jeremy Beloate: You know, I think that as an actor living in New York City in this world, you're so desperately awaiting to be seen. And I think this is a two-part answer. Todrick just saw me, you know, and he saw me and he heard my voice and he was like, you're really special. And so he started crafting this character around me, which is like a dream come true. And it just really validated me as an artist. And then as a piece, I mean, it's not a frequent experience to get to be a part of something so deeply original in a time of so many musicals that are jukebox musicals or based off of movies, which those all have like, you know, those all are valid musicals as well. But it's just so exciting to be a part of something fresh and original.
And the music is just so special. I grew up in Memphis, Tennessee, and this music is so full of soul and heart and truth. And I think I really, really felt seen by that and just it resonated with me deeply. And also, it's just so exciting to get to do so many different genres of music and styles of music.
[9:01] Jeremy Beloate: That's, I mean, it's a marathon. It takes you on this incredible journey. And then the way it shifts, which I don't want to give away, I imagine you don't want to give away.
[9:10] Jeremy Beloate: I think that we can just say that, like, the biggest question that Todrick's character Rail poses is what it would be like if history was literally flipped upside down. And I think that Midnight does a great job at facing that. And just, you know, because at the end of the day, that could have really happened. It could have been completely different. The cards just were dealt how they were dealt in this lifetime. But even if it looked completely different and what that would be like.
[9:10] Jeremy Beloate: And I know he's talked a lot about like Black Mirror and all of those shows. And those are so fascinating to me because it really always poses that question like, what if and what would that be like and what would that look like? So, yeah.
[9:53] Jeryl Brunner: And I think about Richard's relationship with Rail, your relationship with Todrick in the musical is such an emotional anchor. And what do you think makes their relationship so compelling? And what do you hope that people take away watching them navigate love and identity and empathy?
[10:17] Jeremy Beloate: Yeah, it's a beautiful question. I think the most beautiful part of their relationship is that Rail makes Richard rise to the occasion and that he makes him become a better person and stand for what's right. Because Richard, with his words, says that he wants to do that. Rail requires him in his actions to become the man that he so desperately wants to be. And I think in many ways that means Rail gives Richard purpose. And I think that's so beautiful that a partner, whether it's a friend, romantic, whatnot, is the person to activate the purpose inside of you. And I think that it's a direct parallel between Todrick and I and our friendship. He has also made me as an artist and as a human being rise to the occasion and step into purpose. And it's been a beautiful parallel to draw those parallels between Richard and Rail's relationship and Todrick and what those look like, the similarities there.
[11:25] Jeryl Brunner: What do you love about him, about Todrick? What do you love about each other?
[11:30] Jeremy Beloate: Well, you know, last night we were literally in an Uber to go see The Fantasticks. And I was just like, I just want you to know there is literally nothing I wouldn't do for you. And he always tells me that. And I think it's so, so rare to find people in this lifetime that will really stand by your side. Come rain, come shine. I'm there for him. He's there for me. And I just I love I love that. And he is just like a football coach. I love the way he navigates these rooms on days you're tired. I'm like, okay, I think I can do it. He's like, no, you can do it. And you can do it even better. And he pulls out something inside of you that you didn't even realize. Before I started Midnight, or really in the beginning of Midnight, I was like, I think I'm an okay actor.
I think I'm like an okay singer, you know, whatever. But I was really deeply insecure. And I didn't know even how to physically hold myself in a room and command a room like a leading man should. And he just has really helped me navigate that and shape me into the artist I am today. And I'm just, I'm deeply, deeply appreciative and thankful to him forever. And I don't even know what I could ever do to repay him.
[12:42] Jeremy Beloate: So that's why I go out there every night. And even when I'm tired, I'm like, I'm going to give this every ounce of fiber of my being, every teardrop, every snot, everything because he deserves it. And so does the piece.
[12:56] Jeryl Brunner: It's so wonderful that he gives you that. And how he believed in you, you know, to craft this character. And I think about, we talked about how Midnight, you know, it's this beautiful mosaic as I see it with gospel and R&B and pop and rock and folk and opera and musical theater. I think about all the many genres you sing in, it's like this musical buffet, right? And with somebody like you with such a soulful contemporary vocal identity and musical styles, which one has really pushed you outside your comfort zone? Or is it all of those genres?
[13:56] Jeremy Beloate: The other side of it where it's like, I grew up singing Al Green and The Temptations and all of those things. So but then I started doing musical theatre and I also did a cappella and so like it's in choir and all these things. So I feel like, in a way, my sound is like a morphed cluster of all these random influences. But I think that anything that is guttural, I know that's a weird, like, I think that it's just emotional and, or beautiful. I always cling to like ballads, to be honest. Because I, I relate to things that are deep and honest. I love hearing you say what the world needs now. I love that song. A little insider thing about that is that the finale of The Voice, you get like, a few days to prepare that whole thing to pick songs, to learn them, because the songs that you pick, you don't even get like, you send them a list of 10 songs, and they can't get the rights to a lot of songs.
So I got these songs, I didn't even know that song. It was a song that I was like, that would be a cool idea. But then I was like, I knew the chorus. And so we like finished the round the night before and got home at like midnight or one in the morning. And then I had to be on set to sing on camera in front of Snoop Dogg at 7:30 in the morning. And I didn't even know it. So we had to make this like compilation of me being like, you know, and then it's like, two days later is the finale. So it's, I wish so bad I could like, go back and like, you know, for the for the some of the performances, because it really is like, high pressure, like, you don't get a lot of time, or, you know, it's so beautiful.
And it takes you to all the places. And I could see the ballads and where you know, crescendos and then it's, it's soft and beautiful. And then it gets like, you know, it's really gorgeous. I do want to talk about this, how you go into from The Voice to being signed by Snoop Dogg to Death Row Records. Can you talk about how that happened? And your reaction when you realize Snoop Dogg was, you know, I take an interest in your artistry. I mean, think about that debut and that all the chairs turned, you know, did young Jeremy think that would be part of your story? No, no. And it, it's just so crazy. You never know what is ahead of you, you really don't. And, and, and when I even found out about The Voice, it was just so funny how it happened.
Like, this is why I'm always like an advocate of like, never give up because I auditioned for The Voice my whole life. I even auditioned for that season that I was on online, you do like a portal to audition. And I never got a, you know, a callback or whatever. And then I was like, okay, and I started posting videos of me singing online on social media, because Todrick was like, you have to start doing that, you know. And then I had them reach out to me. And they were like, would you be interested in being on the show? And like, I was like, yeah, but I just auditioned. And they were like, Oh, really? You know, like, they don't even know because there's so many people auditioning online. Keep up with.
So then I ended up getting on the show, making it to the very end. And at first, I didn't pick Snoop Dogg, I picked Michael Bublé, which was also a beautiful experience opportunity to get to work with him. He's oh my goodness, a legend. I've looked up to him my whole life. And then there was a round that I didn't win my knockout round and Snoop Dogg stole me and took me on his team. And after my performance, my first performance on Team Snoop Dogg was The Impossible Dream. And then we had a two month break before the lives and he called me and he was just like, it is not by coincidence that we're working together. And he's a very spiritual guy. And so am I. And he was just like, we were meant to work together.
And after the show, I want to sign you. And I was like, oh, my gosh. And it was me and my mom. And I was like, mute it, mute it. Because my mom was like screaming. And I was like, put it on mute. It's you know, we don't want to act like too crazy. So we were both crying and freaking out. And then after the show, you know, we had to wait a second because there's like all these contracts and stuff. We have to sign for the show. And then I had moved to LA and I he had before we even signed contractually, like he had already started helping me out. Like he had flown me out to Nashville to work with producers and he helped me get signed with my management that I have today for music and he and his whole team, Sarah Raymaker, the president of Death Row Pictures.
They have helped me so much more than they probably even realize. Just really get started and really understand the industry and get connected so many different people. So they've been a huge blessing.
[19:16] Jeremy Beloate: It's so beautiful that he saw that. So how many times would you say you've auditioned for The Voice? Probably like eight. And what kept you intrepid? What kept you going back over and over and I know I think I think so many people would probably be like, whatever they're they don't know. Yeah, I think that you just learn in this industry. Like, you have to persevere. And to be honest, I it wasn't my time. You know, I think that's another thing. The older I get, the more that I realize, looking back in the moment, I was like, why didn't I get this? And then years later, whether it was I wasn't ready for that, actually. I wasn't ready to be showcased in that light because that's not where I'm at today.
I'm way beyond what that version of Jeremy was mentally, physically, whatever it is. But also, you know, sometimes it's just like I had, I had shared about this on social media, I had I had auditioned for years in New York. And I've still to this day, never gotten a callback for a Broadway show. I read that. And I, I was auditioning to be a swing in like a non union tour of this show that I'm not right for at all. But I just so desperately wanted a job and to be doing what I love. And I didn't even get a callback for that. And in hindsight, I would be a horrible swing. It's like the hardest job I've ever witnessed with people who were swings. It's like, I'm so incredibly in awe of them. But it's just like, oh my goodness, being in Midnight and getting to be revealed to the industry in this way.
Because so many people that I've auditioned for before, they come see the show. And they're like, it's nice to meet you. And I'm like, well, we've actually met. Listen to you several times. But I'm like, I'm so happy that you don't remember me because this is how I want to be introduced. And it's such a blessing. And now in hindsight, I'm like, oh, this was a part of the plan. This is the way I'm supposed to be introduced. So anyone listening, anyone auditioning and not getting the roles like keep going, keep persevering, because your moment is going to come and it's going to be specifically catered to you and showcase you in the best light possible.
[21:41] Jeryl Brunner: That's so beautiful. When did you know you could say, you know, here you were growing up in Memphis? When did you know that you had this beautiful voice?
[21:51] Jeremy Beloate: Well, that's very sweet. I mean, honestly, I started singing when I was four years old, probably before that, but I started like singing in a group at four. But I told my mom, at four, before I started singing in this group, I was in the back of her van, she tells this story. And she was like, you said, Mom, I can sing, and I'm good at it. And I want to learn how to sing or whatever. And I don't know if I said it like that, actually. But she says that I did. But I started singing in all these groups around town, singing Motown music at like retirement homes and all these different things. And then I just I think, when I was before my voice changed, I was like, Okay, I think I can sing because I was like, I was, you know, a high belter or whatever as a kid.
And then my voice changed. And I was like, Oh, no, I'm never going to be able to sing again. And then about 17 or 18, I was like, I think I can do this. So I went to college, and really like honed in. And over the past few years, I feel like I've tapped into something. And I'm like, yeah, I feel good about choosing to do this.
[23:03] Jeryl Brunner: What were those early songs that you were singing? What were you singing early on?
[23:07] Jeremy Beloate: Oh my gosh, the Sugar Pie Honey Bunch. I just woke up. So my boy, you know, I love you. I can't help myself. You know, yeah, I love that. I'm trying to think and then my girl, on a cloudy day. And then oh my gosh, the Boyz II Men. One, you're like a dream come true. Two, just want to be with you. And also we would do Michael Jackson. Yeah, we would just do so much beautiful, beautiful music. That honestly, when I look at music today, I'm like, I wish we had music like that.
[23:56] Jeryl Brunner: I know, I know. We talked about how it saved you in a way, I mean, that you were bullied, how that helped you, you know, how that was healing for you, especially as a queer kid and, you know, feeling different.
[24:14] Jeremy Beloate: Yeah, I think when anyone looks at their lives, even if they don't realize it, they're given some kind of gift that is almost an escape. And it's like a safe haven. It's like the thing that people can cling on to and feel comfort. And for me, it was music and singing and theater and being in the South and just being like, so misunderstood by so many people, not even just kids my age, but teachers like were bullying me and stuff like, I just, yeah, like adults. And I just didn't know. I was just like, I knew that there was nothing wrong with me because at my core, I've always been like, and I've always tried to be a nice person. Like I was always the kid that was chosen to like take the kids with special needs to their curricular classes or like the kids with diabetes, I would take them to the nurse to get their shots.
Like I was always that kid in class, but still I would be just so bullied. And I started singing and I kind of found the quote unquote, other weirdos or whatever you want to call them. And we all banded together and I was like, oh my gosh, this is where I belong. This is where I fit. And I think it's so beautiful because truly at the end of the day, everybody has a community. And if you feel othered, you just need to find others that feel the way that you do, you know?
[25:40] Jeryl Brunner: How do you feel?
[25:46] Jeremy Beloate: Sorry? I said from the wise words of Snoop Dogg, because we talked about this in our interview with GLAAD last year, first year. I was talking about feeling othered and he was like, well, you just need to find others that feel othered. You know, and I was like, he's just such a poet. Anyways, but yeah. And is it possible to put into words how you feel when you sing? When you perform?
[26:09] Jeremy Beloate: Oh my gosh, wow. When you're in Midnight, you know, playing Richard. I think it's, you know, in many ways, it's the closest I can feel to like, how I feel when I pray. Like it feels like a, if I, not to sound too like woo or whatever, but I'm just like this person. So welcome. But like, it just feels like a direct like line to heaven or to the sky or to whatever you believe in. Just something so holy and great. And it feels just like such a blessing. And it doesn't feel like mine, if that makes sense. Like it doesn't, which is really helpful, because I think sometimes we can get in our own way and get self-centered and be like, whatever. And I always feel like this isn't mine. This is like a gift and it's a blessing, and I get to use it for the time being. So yeah.
[27:13] Jeryl Brunner: And congratulations, you were extended, right?
[27:16] Jeremy Beloate: Yes, thank you so much. Come see us at the Daryl Roth Theatre until May 23rd. It's going to be a beautiful night. We're all mad for you.
[27:26] Jeryl Brunner: Yes. Thank you again.
[27:28] Jeremy Beloate: Thank you. So lovely to meet you.
[27:30] Jeryl Brunner: Lovely to meet you. Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
