Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#91 -  Carey Renee Sharpe

Carey Renee Sharpe stars in Blood/Love, a vampire pop opera she also wrote. Now playing Off-Broadway at Theater 555, Blood/Love was co-written by Dru DeCaro, features choreography by Natalie Malotke, and Dancing with the Stars pros Jonathan and Oksana Platero, and was directed by Hunter Bird... Read More

From the show: When Lightning Strikes!

21 mins
Apr 5

About

Carey Renee Sharpe stars in Blood/Love, a vampire pop opera she also wrote. Now playing Off-Broadway at Theater 555, Blood/Love was co-written by Dru DeCaro, features choreography by Natalie Malotke, and Dancing with the Stars pros Jonathan and Oksana Platero, and was directed by Hunter Bird.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] ♪ Musical number: "When Lightning Strikes" — performed by Unknown performer ♪

[0:28] Jeryl Brunner: Hi, this is Jeryl Brunner, and you're listening to When Lightning Strikes.

[0:34] Carey Renee Sharpe: Carrie Renee Sharpe stars in Blood/Love, a vampire pop opera that she also wrote. Blood/Love is now playing Off-Broadway at Theater 555.

[0:48] Jeryl Brunner: Welcome.

[0:49] Carey Renee Sharpe: Hi, thank you for having me.

[0:51] Jeryl Brunner: Thanks so much for coming on. I think about how you gave birth to Blood/Love. You developed it, you star in it. Your handprints are on every inch of this pop opera musical. So tell me what inspired Blood/Love. When did you think, oh, this is something I have to do?

[1:18] Carey Renee Sharpe: You probably know this, but I had a very different career prior to this. I spent 12 years working in pediatric critical care. I was an advanced practice nurse practitioner, specializing in acute care pediatrics. So like the ICU, but for kids and babies. Um, so I did that for a long time and I got burned out. So the thing that I did next then was I actually opened and renovated a historic theater in my hometown with my sister, Jenna.

[1:41] Jeryl Brunner: In Wisconsin, right?

[1:44] Carey Renee Sharpe: If you can hear it, sometimes you can hear my voice. I know I try to get better at it, but I know it's in my voice that you can hear I'm from Wisconsin. I was back in my hometown opening this theater, and I kind of got into like the production end of, you know, we were bringing in lots of shows, we were trying different things to kind of just see what unique creative things we could do in our own theater. And about a year and a half in, we did well, I love Halloween. So we did what's was very like a very um kind of high-end vampire Halloween party. It was a black creative black tie vampire ball. And we had original music, not written by me, but written by a friend, and original fashion show, and it kind of had like a little bit of a through line.

I called it a party with a plot line, almost like a murder mystery, but there wasn't like a murder thing. That was just sort of like a like there was a concept, a theme kind of running through the show. So we did that in 2019, and it was wildly popular, just invited friends and family. Well, there was maybe like 400 people there. It's a big big party, but like, you know, it's just all invite only. Um, and that was so popular that I said, you know, hey, I really want to build this into more of a show. And kind of got the bug that maybe I would like to start writing some of the music myself. Now I hadn't really formally I hadn't professionally been a musician at this point and had not really played my instrument for almost 20 years, because I stopped all per like actual training when I went to college.

So um it and then COVID hit, of course, and turned the world upside down, and the group that I was originally working with decided to get into TV and film. I really didn't have any interest in doing that. I still wanted to do this theater show. So I connected with a friend in my hometown and we went out to LA and met with some music producers. One of them was Drew DeCaro, my main co-writer. And we just hit it off, kind of just like had what I've heard described as creative alchemy. Um and you know, this two of us now have been writing together for six years, and sometimes we're like, how we don't have any more vampire songs in us. And then every time we still managed to write another really great song for our show.

So yeah, we've just we just kind of started honestly just writing songs that were kind of in the world. We knew we wanted to have a female protagonist, and that there was like this rock star character. And by writing from my perspective and writing for Drew's perspective, we were kind of able to write for these two lead characters. And then Cleo is very much inspired by Erin Baim, who was the one of our other co-writers. She played the part for a couple years. Um so she just like is Cleo basically. Um and then yeah, we just filled in with another friend, and so the character just kind of grew from there, but it almost started as like a little bit more of like a concept album that just sort of started to develop into a show.

We started just like by writing news that we loved that meant something to us that like felt emotional and resonated. And then it's just now it's you know almost six years in the making, so it is what it is now, but it's taken a few years.

[4:25] Jeryl Brunner: That's incredible that you know how it was born from this passion and how you morphed into this entirely different career. And I know you were you were a classical violinist, right? When you were very young.

[4:41] Carey Renee Sharpe: Uh yeah.

[4:41] Jeryl Brunner: If somebody were to ask you, what is Blood/Love about, what would you say?

[4:47] Carey Renee Sharpe: This is a story about. Well, the plot line is basically that my character Valerie, um, she is the queen of the underworld essentially, but isn't quite ready to take on that position. As you know, I joke, like, can you imagine being like Kate Middleton and how much weight that is to take on that responsibility? Um, so she left hell. So she's kind of like the little mermaid from hell. She didn't want to be in hell anymore, she wanted to seek the light and just like explore the world. She doesn't didn't feel ready for that responsibility and that weight. And she, in doing so, she really broke the devil's heart who loved her very much, and he kind of shunned her, you know, just said, Fine, you can go, but like it's never gonna be what you think it's gonna be.

And there she thereby becomes the first vampire because she isn't really from Earth, she's not a human, she's like, you know, a person from hell or whatever. Um, the underworld. And so she thereby becomes the first vampire, and she has a thousand years of experience, kind of has to make it on her own. She makes two good friends along the way. Um, and then she's the top of the show, I've basically given you the first two numbers. The top of the show is her 1000th birthday. So then she kind of goes on a journey of feeling like something's missing, you know, I've done everything I could possibly do in this life, and I just I need something more. Like, what am I gonna do next? And she meets a catalyst in Anzik, the rock star, he's a human, and she has an instant connection with him and doesn't quite understand why, and finds out that he has made his own deal with the devil, and that is how he's become like famous and you know, had had all this success as a rock star.

And so their past kind of collide, he's kind of desperate to get out of his deal, and she is like kind of looking for something more, and it just it kind of works, and I won't give away the ending, but um, they they just collide in a way that is sort of opportunistic for kind of both of them. It's and um, yeah, so it's it's kind of like her journey as a woman, of course, and especially because I am middle-aged, I'm 42, just kind of feeling like you know, you've had a lot of experience, like like Valerie. I've had a lot of experiences in my life, I've worn different hats, I've done had different careers, and you know, it's never too late to reinvent yourself. And but at some point, you're just like kind of always, you know, searching for deeper meaning in your life.

[6:52] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, I mean, I see it also as a lot of the I mean, it's about passion and transformation and a stretch of yourself and for love and your art, and then what's that cost?

[7:08] Carey Renee Sharpe: Right. There's a lot, and then the music is really how would you describe the music? It's really wonderful.

[7:15] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, it's I mean, I would definitely loosely define it as pop music. It's but under that umbrella, there's some that is definitely more in the rock category, especially Anzik songs, because he is a rock character. Even Valerie by the end has a pretty rocked-out song. Um but a lot of the songs are kind of, you know, they're like bops, like they're catchy earworm kind of songs, a lot of them. There's a couple that are a little more musical theater because we do need to tell the story. And we we consider this a pop opera. So there's very little dialogue. There's maybe like three minutes total of dialogue in the 80-something minutes. There's just not a lot of so we have to say a lot in these songs and to tell the story. So there are a few that are like a little bit more storytelling.

[7:53] Jeryl Brunner: So when I think about, I mean, my gosh, I mean, be a nurse practitioner, I mean, that has its own, you know, challenges, joys, being to writing and then performing when it was a struggle as a writer or as a performer. I imagine at some point maybe you're rejected or you hear the word no, or you get you you have roadblocks. What kept you going?

[8:22] Carey Renee Sharpe: Um that's a great question. I mean, I just do have a deep love of music. I always have. Um, everybody was very surprised that I did not go to conservatory. I had a scholarship to go to one in our in Wisconsin. There's a beautiful conservatory not that far from my house. And I just didn't see a path for myself in that career. Um, and it really truly would not have been until a few years ago that I had the um maturity and the life experience that I have to be able to do what I'm doing. I wasn't gonna come out of college and write a musical. I didn't want to audition for shows, I didn't want to play in an orchestra. I loved violin, but I never was in that orchestra path. That's just not for me.

So I didn't see a career for I didn't want to be a music teacher. I didn't want to try to be a pop singer because that's like near impossible. And you know, so I just I didn't really see a path until a couple years ago, and it did sort of happen organically. So I just feel so passionately about it that I'm willing, and you know, Drew and I just we want to create something different in this world of theater that I, you know, I love musical theater, but I think we all can recognize that there needs to be some new things coming into this world to keep it alive. And you know, Drew does not come from the musical theater world. I obviously don't because I wasn't working in this professionally. Our choreographers, Jonathan and Oksana do not come from the theater world.

And I think there's something about that, you know, creativity and abundance of talent in art, but kind of coming from different perspectives that have created something that feels very unique, and that's just really exciting to me. So I'm very passionate about it, and I just keep, you know, plugging for you know, keep moving forward with it.

[9:51] Jeryl Brunner: Yeah, and I love how you took agency over your career that you didn't wait for somebody, as you say, to cast you or to give you that opportunity. You said, I'm gonna create it myself, and I think about that courage. You know, more that's that's unique about theater and like orchestra and those kind of things. You have to like be asked to do something. Now, if you look at like singer songwriters, pop music, you know, just music in general, people just writing their own music and putting it out into the world.

[10:18] Carey Renee Sharpe: So they're not asking permission to like release music anymore. You don't have to have a record deal. You don't have to, so I kind of just like, well, my form of that, and I've often compared Valerie as my Lady Gaga because I don't perform as Carrie. I don't really want to. But being Valerie allows me to step into a character and perform songs that are really personal to me. I'm a lot, I can be very vulnerable on stage, but like because I'm channeling this character, I can't really do it as myself. It just allows a little separation for me. So, you know, to me, it's like I, you know, this is my music that I'm just instead of doing an album, I'm doing a musical. And I know that's unusual, but it just works for me, and it's how I've been able to come into this world.

[11:00] Jeryl Brunner: I'd love to know your lightning strikes moment when you knew you had to be an artist, you know, back then. Was it when you were a kid playing violin? Or when was it that you or the moments that you knew?

[11:14] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, I've always loved writing music. My mom has handwritten scores of music that I was writing in, you know, fourth grade, you know, piano music and stuff like that. So I don't know if I had like a lightning strikes moment just for my love of music. It has always been so part of me. But I will say when we did that show in 2019 that I did not write the music, I just was like, this is what I wanted. I was like, I want to do this, like I know I want to do this. Um, and so that really just turned like I finally, you know, we'd been doing different things at our theater, and when we did that, I was like, this is what I want to do. So, and then it took a totally different path than I would have expected.

Honestly, if I would have kept working with that same team, I probably, I don't know if I would have started writing the music. I probably would have stayed more on the producer side, and I'm obviously really glad that I've been able to write, you know, co-write music and perform because I, you know, it took a little while for me to get back into it, and even this, you know, even go every time we do a production, it's the biggest thing I've ever done. So, you know, even going off Broadway was a lot of pressure for me in the rehearsals is exhausting. Um, anybody who's seen the show, there's 26 musical numbers. I'm on stage for 23 of them, I believe, and I sing or play violin in 13 of them. So, you know, I'm just, there's just a lot for me, you know, especially somebody who doesn't do this all the time, um, to try to get up to speed.

And yeah, so I just, it's been really an interesting journey, and I'm really glad that I was able to push myself and keep doing that. But I don't know if I would have done that if it would if this like thing if the path wouldn't have gone in this way.

[12:43] Jeryl Brunner: But when you were in fourth grade, do you remember some of those songs you were writing? What were they?

[12:49] Carey Renee Sharpe: My whole family does because I was infamous, infamous is definitely the word, um for torturing my poor family with an annual musical that I wrote, and then like made my siblings and my cousins do with me. So there's some cute songs that have emerged from that that there's a couple that pretty much everybody in my family could still sing, so they're just little jingly songs.

[13:10] Jeryl Brunner: What are they about?

[13:12] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, one's about a ski trip. One's about a ski trip, because we were on a family ski trip at one point. Um, it's just about like diversity in the world and you know, people, it's called People Come and People Go. It's in third grade, so you know, not the deepest of lyrics there. Um, that was just kind of about world diversity and loving people. And then there's one about that was just called Valentine, and it's just sort of that's self-explanatory. You know.

[13:38] Jeryl Brunner: What about playing the violin? When did that passion become part of your life early on?

[13:46] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, you know, I was three when I started playing. I was a Suzuki kid, um, but went through all throughout that repertoire and beyond. So I, to be honest, it wasn't like something that I chose to pursue. I was just so young that, and I was the oldest of my, I've got two siblings and I'm the oldest. My mom decided to put us in Suzuki violin. So I frankly didn't really have a choice. It just, but it was so secondary to me that I, you know, I literally do not remember my life without playing before I played the violin, like I was too little. So it just became like so second nature to me that I just didn't really know anything else, which is part of the reason why I didn't pursue it in college because I had other things that I wanted to do.

Um, and like I said, I didn't see a career for myself in music or in violin. I loved them both, but I just didn't see a way to like make a living or you know, yeah. I just, and I kind of needed a break. That's all I'd really ever done. So I just felt like I needed to do something else. Part of the reason why I wanted to become a pediatric nurse practitioner is I have congenital heart disease. I have something called transposition of the great arteries. So I was very passionate about working with kids that were sick. So I did that for a long time, and then now I've gotten to turn my attention back to music, which has been really wonderful.

[14:56] Jeryl Brunner: Thank you for sharing that. Does that impact how you see vampires at all? This whole thing. I mean, living, what is it about vampires?

[15:04] Carey Renee Sharpe: Certainly, I mean, uh, I think we all have this, so I'm not unique in this, but you know, we all face our own mortality, and it's something that we all probably at some points question. You know, for me, again, like for me, I don't remember a time in my life because I was born with this that I didn't have this kind of medical issue that I had to, it's just sort of always in the back of my mind. And I've been really healthy, I've been really lucky, but it does pop up from time to time and it causes me to have some problems, and I end up in the hospital and I have, you know, issues. So it just kind of, it never really leaves me, and it's gonna be with me till the end of my life. So, you know, of course, there's, and then of course I'm 42, so I'm kind of middle age or whatnot.

And it's impossible to not think about those things. And I think that is one of the appeals of vampires. I think there is an allure to living forever. And what's interesting about our show is we kind of talk about like, well, there is a downside to that. And part of that is if you live forever, your life starts to have no meaning, and like you lose the consequence of life and in its limited nature if you live forever. And so that's kind of what she's struggling with. That she's just going on and on and on, and like, you know, it's just kind of lost, she's got nothing but time, but now it doesn't really mean as much anymore.

[16:10] Jeryl Brunner: And I want to go back to singing. How did you learn how to sing? And when did you?

[16:17] Carey Renee Sharpe: I mean, I was singing before I was talking. It's just been second nature to me. And I have been training my voice, you know, formally now for the last two or three years just to be able to do these longer runs of shows to, you know, to strengthen it. But I've always been a singer. That's always actually been my first love is singing. Um, and the violin is so beautiful as an instrument because it is the one that most similarly mimics the human voice. So I think part of the, you know, I played so young. I think to me, the violin always felt like an extension of my voice. Um, so yeah, and it's, you can't play and sing really. I mean, a few people kind of do, it's pretty tough. But I play and sing back and forth quite a bit in the show. So then that's been fun to do.

[16:54] Jeryl Brunner: That's incredible. And what were some of the early songs that you remember?

[16:59] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh gosh, I was a big Michael Jackson fan when I was really little. So, you know, I, you know, I'm born in '83, so I was a big Michael Jackson fan. Um, but then I listened to like my dad was really into like 70s folk rock because he's from that era. So I listened to kind of some like I love Fleetwood Mac, and you know, kind of unexpected Simon Garfunkel, like I just like kind of maybe a little bit unexpected music for a person of my age, but all kinds of I listened to everything, but those were some of my earlier stuff because that was the music my dad liked.

[17:29] Jeryl Brunner: I understand. And what do you hope people come away with after seeing Blood/Love?

[17:35] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, I just want them, I mean, no, first and foremost to have an enjoyable night. That the show is not long, I think it's like 83 or 84 minutes, and that's all that is our intention to always keep it under 90 minutes or certainly no more than 90 minutes, so it's just one act. Um, because I've heard many times, and I think it's true, that the show just like starts and then it just like goes. Like the energy just like continues and then it's over, you know, and I don't mean then in a bad way. It just kind of grasps your attention. So you're gonna be entertained. I don't think that you could come away from it not being entertained. But you know, for me, um, especially on the back end of the show, the songs do get a lot, it gets a little heavy, and there's a lot of depth and meaning and just struggle in my character in Anzik, and then even the friendship fractures and there's just a lot of things kind of fall apart towards the end. Um, so there's I think there's a lot of emotional connection that can be made with the show as well.

[18:26] Jeryl Brunner: Can you put it into words what it's like for you to be performing this, especially something you know that you've been working on for years that you either literally gave birth to, you know, created from scratch?

[18:42] Carey Renee Sharpe: Well, it's a dream come true, of course. But um, it is without a doubt the most vulnerable thing I've ever done. And it's, you know, it's I because I have touched so much of it, it is so much my show or whatever, you know, there's a group of us, but you know, certainly I'm playing the lead. Um, it yeah, it's just very, very vulnerable to be so responsible for the show, the, you know, the production, just everything that goes into it. Um, and there that's really rewarding and sometimes it's very scary. Um, I feel now we've been, I just counted and I'm half done right now of this run. So I feel very comfortable in it now. But you know, the first couple previews and stuff, I, you know, it just takes a little while to get warmed up into it. But I'm really proud of myself for doing it.

[19:30] Jeryl Brunner: And what's your dream for Blood/Love?

[19:33] Carey Renee Sharpe: Oh, I just, I, you know, the sky's the limit. I don't know. I, we have some ideas of where we're gonna go next. I, we're not done, that I can say for sure. I mean, honestly, of course we would love to go to Broadway at least for a period of time. I think that there's something to be said about being able to at least do that for a, you know, even if it was just for a limited run. Um, and again, just to bring something different to this world of theater that we all love so much, but you know, it could use some fresh life, you know.

[20:01] Jeryl Brunner: Well, it's such a joy to talk to you, Carey. Thank you so much for coming on.

[20:07] Carey Renee Sharpe: Thank you. Thank you.

[20:08] Jeryl Brunner: Have a wonderful day.

[20:10] Carey Renee Sharpe: You too.

[20:14] Jeryl Brunner: It happened to the greats, it still happens every day. When lightning strikes is the moment you know, the theme song was written by Tom McGovern. This episode was produced by Anna Strout. Lightning strikes.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred