Skip to main content
BPN Logo
OSLO and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

The conflict between Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East erupted yet again in May 2021. The violence and fight for land and rights goes back thousands of years, though the State of Israel was established in 1948... Read More

From the show: Why We Theater

1 h 38 mins
10/14/21

About

The conflict between Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East erupted yet again in May 2021. The violence and fight for land and rights goes back thousands of years, though the State of Israel was established in 1948. Meanwhile, thousands have lost their lives and more continue to suffer. It’s considered the unsolvable conflict. But is peace in the Middle East truly impossible?

Tony Award winner J.T. Rogers, experts Aziz Abu Sarah (National Geographic Explorer, TED Fellow, peace-builder) and Libby Lenkinski (New Israel Fund) and host Ruthie Fierberg discuss the approach to peace in the context of Rogers’ play and HBO film Oslo, how things have changed since Oslo Peace Accords, possible solutions, and, most importantly, how to ease the suffering of Israelis and Palestinians now.

Read the play here.

Watch the film adaptation here.

Create the change

From Palestinian authors:

  • Palestinian Walks by Raja Shehadeh
  • The 100 Years War on Palestine by Rashid Khalidi
  • Salt Houses by Hala Alyan
  • Justice for Some: Law and the Question of Palestine by Noura Erakat
  • Memory For Forgetfulness by Mahmoud Darwish

From Israeli authors:

  • All the Rivers by Dorit Rabinyan
  • The Art of Leaving by Ayelet Tsabari
  • Sadness is a White Bird by Moriel Rothman
  • The Wall and the Gate by Michael Sfard
  • To the End of the Land by David Grossman

From non-Israeli/non-Palestinian authors:

  • Kingdoms of Olive and Ash edited by Michael Chabon and Ayelet Waldman
  • Apiergon by Colum McCann
  • Dinner at the Center of the Earth by Nathan Englander
  • Can We Talk About Israel? by Daniel Sokatch (out October 19)

About Our Guests:

Ruthie Fierberg, Host

Ruthiefierberg.com

IG: @whywetheater / T: @whywetheater

IG: @ruthiefierceberg / T: @RuthiesATrain

J.T. Rogers, playwright

JTRogerswriter.com / Twitter: @stagewriter

Aziz Abu Sarah, guest expert

Azizabusarah.com / @AzizAbuSarah

Libby Lenkinski, guest expert

NIF.org / @libbylenkinski

Read full bios here.

Referred to in this episode

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Ruthie Fierberg: I'm Ruthie Fierberg, and this is Why We Theater.

[0:05] Ruthie Fierberg: The podcast that digs into the onstage works we love to make the off-stage change we need.

[0:12] Ruthie Fierberg: After all, that is why we theater.

[0:17] Ruthie Fierberg: Today we welcome Tony Award-winning playwright J.T. Rogers and experts Libby Lenkinski and Aziz Abu Sarah to discuss J.T.'s incredible play-turned HBO movie, Oslo.

[0:30] Ruthie Fierberg: I first saw the play off-Broadway at Lincoln Center in 2016, and then again during its 2017 Broadway transfer.

[0:38] Ruthie Fierberg: Often labeled a political thriller, Oslo dramatizes the true story of back channel talks between Israelis and Palestinians that led to the actual 1993 Oslo Peace Accords.

[0:51] Ruthie Fierberg: Tyarod Larsen is the director of independent research organization, the FAFO Institute, and his wife Mona Yule is a Norwegian diplomat in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

[1:02] Ruthie Fierberg: Together, they arrange for secret talks between leaders of the PLO and unofficial representatives for the Israeli government beginning in 1992.

[1:12] Ruthie Fierberg: The goal was to bring peace to a region ravaged by conflict, particularly since the establishment of Israel as a Jewish state in 1948.

[1:20] Ruthie Fierberg: So a little bit more history.

[1:22] Ruthie Fierberg: Both Israelis and Palestinians lay claim to the land that to this day still remains divided into regions that include Israel, the Palestinian territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

[1:35] Ruthie Fierberg: Tensions have re-escalated recently.

[1:38] Ruthie Fierberg: We are not here to solve the conflict in a single podcast episode.

[1:42] Ruthie Fierberg: What we are here to do is discuss approaches to peace, how things have changed since Oslo, the event, and the play, possible outcomes that could suffice for both sides, and most importantly, how to ease the suffering of Israelis and Palestinians, right now.

[1:42] Ruthie Fierberg: J.T., I'm so excited to see you.

[2:11] J.T. Rogers: It has been far too long.

[2:13] Ruthie Fierberg: The world has been topsy-turvy since we saw each other, that's for sure.

[2:17] J.T. Rogers: It really has, but it's so funny, you know, how the seasons of theater work because I feel like, you know, in 2017, I probably was seeing you once a week for two months, and then now I haven't seen you for years.

[2:31] Ruthie Fierberg: It's a little crazy.

[2:32] J.T. Rogers: It's true.

[2:33] J.T. Rogers: I'm glad that Oslo has brought us back together.

[2:38] Ruthie Fierberg: Me too.

[2:39] Ruthie Fierberg: So I actually want to start at your beginning.

[2:43] Ruthie Fierberg: And I read about your upbringing a little bit, and I know that you've mentioned that your parents were very politically engaged.

[2:51] Ruthie Fierberg: Your father was a political science professor.

[2:53] Ruthie Fierberg: You talked politics around the dinner table, very different from my home.

[2:58] Ruthie Fierberg: Um, how much did you know growing up about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?

[3:05] J.T. Rogers: Was it of particular interest in among discussion?

[3:09] J.T. Rogers: The short answer is I want to say yes with the big caveat of not being Israeli or Palestinian or living in the region.

[3:15] J.T. Rogers: So there's only so much expertise one can have about anything without living and breathing the air and having that experience.

[3:21] J.T. Rogers: So I want to be very.

[3:30] J.T. Rogers: My family, especially my father, who raised us a lot.

[3:33] J.T. Rogers: Um, my parents divorced when they were when I was young.

[3:36] J.T. Rogers: Um, he was a political scientist, and this is what we talked about, and this is what interested us, him, and it was passed on to me.

[3:43] J.T. Rogers: And I think in hindsight, also what affected my work and work I've always done as a playwright now, uh television and film writer is I lived for a number of years in rural Malaysia and rural Indonesia as a child, um, where I was the, you know, I was the in Malaysia literally the first white person that many people had ever seen.

[4:04] J.T. Rogers: And you had to adapt.

[4:05] J.T. Rogers: You had to adapt to a world where you could learn the language, you had to go to school, you had to take, uh classes and things you didn't understand, you had to be times bullied just because you were the outsider, you had to make friends and find a way, and I think it was um I'm very grateful for it now.

[4:20] J.T. Rogers: I mean, uh, deeply grateful because I had the experience of being the outsider as an American, and sort of that experience I think is filtered through the work that I do.

[4:30] Ruthie Fierberg: Hmm. How does being an outsider filter specifically through Oslo?

[4:36] J.T. Rogers: Well, I think it filters in that people I I get asked a lot, well, why on earth would you write a play, you know, about Norwegians and Palestinian Israelis when you're not Norwegian Palestinian Israeli?

[4:47] J.T. Rogers: Which for me isn't really um it never crossed my mind because it's I'm always interested in a story that grips my heart and my mind, and also it needs to be something that makes you think, well, I could never achieve this.

[4:59] J.T. Rogers: This is a terrible terror, it's too big, it's too big.

[5:01] J.T. Rogers: And then, of course, that's the project you end up working on.

[5:04] J.T. Rogers: But I'm interested, I'm interested in to use an analogy.

[5:10] J.T. Rogers: There are actors that play versions of themselves, and there are actors that need to slip out of themselves.

[5:18] J.T. Rogers: And I'm just a writer who needs to slip out of himself.

[5:21] Ruthie Fierberg: Hmm. It's also really funny that you mentioned like it's the biggest thing you could possibly tackle because obviously with Oslo focusing on Israel, Palestine, Blood and Gifts was also your play about the struggle for control of Afghanistan.

[5:38] Ruthie Fierberg: So do you ever worry that what you're trying to tackle is too big for a play?

[5:45] J.T. Rogers: You end up making the work that you feel is beyond you and too big and too um hard simply because it pushes you to become better.

[5:55] J.T. Rogers: I'm pausing for a moment because I don't want to equate remotely talent when I use this analogy because I'm it's less of an analogy and it's a um a yardstick.

[6:04] J.T. Rogers: The thing I love about Shakespeare is you can read the entire canon and uh have no earthly idea what William Shakespeare thinks about things.

[6:14] J.T. Rogers: You just have a universe of voices and characters that in which every point of view is rock solid, in which every character is legitimate, in which people's beliefs as they speak them are not questioned by the author, and that to me is is the goal is to put people on stage and in movies where the audience goes, I may or may not agree with you, but I see you as a human being, and your argument is completely defensible.

[6:43] Ruthie Fierberg: That's fascinating. And how do you so looking at these massive subjects that I mean your cast was really huge for a play, the play is in three acts.

[6:58] Ruthie Fierberg: How do you make it manageable to make it a beginning, middle, end story?

[7:06] J.T. Rogers: You're looking for the road that the audience can follow you into a larger story.

[7:09] J.T. Rogers: You're not and Oslo is not a play about Israel-Palestine.

[7:14] J.T. Rogers: I mean, my goodness, what what would that be?

[7:16] J.T. Rogers: You can't, that's that's would be terrible.

[7:19] J.T. Rogers: It would be impossible and be terrible.

[7:20] J.T. Rogers: It's a play about a moment and an event and characters, personal stakes, personal stories, human beings set against a vast historical political event.

[7:31] J.T. Rogers: So for me, it's always what is the personal that is set against the larger political.

[7:36] J.T. Rogers: Um, because I'm described often as a historical or uh often in the States as a political playwright, and I I'm always a little uncomfortable with that, but unsure if that's really correct, because the politics I I'm interested in characters whose lifeblood is politics and idea ideas, you know, that are the ideas are life and death to them.

[7:58] J.T. Rogers: But it isn't that you're setting out to make a political point, it's you're trying to capture voices and people and tell a story that captured me.

[8:04] J.T. Rogers: So in this case, it was you know, you you have a long list in my mind at least as a writer, I was like, wouldn't it be great to set a story against X?

[8:12] J.T. Rogers: This fascinates me, why?

[8:15] J.T. Rogers: And so in the case of Oslo, in the back of my writer's head for many, many years, there was what could I do sometime that would that would quote unquote deal or address or brush up against this vast, incredibly complicated, naughty, painful reality of Israel-Palestine.

[8:33] J.T. Rogers: And always thinking, why?

[8:34] J.T. Rogers: You can't.

[8:35] J.T. Rogers: You can't the moment you start talking about the United States, somebody says this and somebody says that, and everyone stops listening.

[8:40] J.T. Rogers: And if everyone stops listening at the second line of your play, then your play can't work.

[8:44] J.T. Rogers: So for me, the sort of the revelation or the moment that I'm grateful for is discovering that about the back channel, the Oslo Peace Accords, and that it was started by Norwegians.

[8:56] J.T. Rogers: And I was, for my sins, did not know that.

[8:59] J.T. Rogers: Someone who, as you said, you know, grew up with politics.

[9:01] J.T. Rogers: And so I was sort of fascinated and embarrassed and and dug into it.

[9:06] J.T. Rogers: And for a brief second, I thought I discovered something that, you know, America, oh, of course, no, it's documented all over the world, just the United States as usual.

[9:12] J.T. Rogers: We're only interested in ourselves, so we don't know about this.

[9:16] J.T. Rogers: Um but again, this is all in hindsight.

[9:20] J.T. Rogers: But then the bec the the aha moment was, oh, well, if the entry point is Norway into the Middle East, and again at this moment, you're just thinking about I'm writing a play for Lincoln Center for my home theater, and who that audience is, how am I gonna get them to open their hearts and uncross their arms?

[9:35] J.T. Rogers: Because neurotheater audiences always come in with their proverbial arms crossed.

[9:39] J.T. Rogers: How do you get them to open and leave?

[9:40] Ruthie Fierberg: Yes.

[9:41] J.T. Rogers: And I thought, well, that might flummox everybody enough that they would listen.

[9:45] J.T. Rogers: That might be that might be my entry point.

[9:48] Ruthie Fierberg: Um I mean in in the simplest terms, yeah.

[9:51] Ruthie Fierberg: I mean, as the story goes, I know that um Tyarod Larsen, who is you know, the central he and his wife Moni Yule are the central Norwegians in the play, um, that he was coming to speak to your actors for Blood and Gifts, um, to give them some real life character research.

[10:14] Ruthie Fierberg: You end up at PJ Clark's across from Lincoln Center, and he starts talking about this back channel of negotiations, and you say, Wait a second, this is interesting, this is fascinating, maybe I should be writing about this.

[10:28] J.T. Rogers: What is the first thing that you do after that conversation?

[10:33] J.T. Rogers: I think actually the the next thing has happened is that he introduced me to Shimon Peres.

[10:39] Ruthie Fierberg: That Shimon Peres is in terrorists.

[10:40] J.T. Rogers: Oh, you should meet Shimon Peres.

[10:42] Ruthie Fierberg: So wait, wait, wait.

[10:43] Ruthie Fierberg: For those who don't know, Shimon Peres served Israel in many capacities, first as prime minister, then Israeli foreign minister, then prime minister again, and later president.

[10:54] Ruthie Fierberg: But at the time of the Oslo Peace Accords, he was the Israeli foreign minister, and Yitzhak Rabin was prime minister.

[11:01] Ruthie Fierberg: And we know from history that he was instrumental in these talks, just to give people context.

[11:07] J.T. Rogers: So I and director Bartlett Sher, who knew Larson and pushed him towards me in his wise way, um, you know, we had a brief, it was almost like we were ushered into a there was a hotel in downtown Manhattan, and the whole restaurant had been cleared out for safety reasons, and there were bodyguards, and he was sitting in a a corner, the enormous table by himself, elegantly dressed, and we were brought to him, and there was an enormous glass of red wine on the table, which I clocked and is in the play and in the film.

[11:36] J.T. Rogers: Um, and it was sort of like you were brought before the king, and the king blessed your venture, and then we were gone.

[11:42] J.T. Rogers: It was really rather um what was helpful about was to get a sense of him as his energy as a human being.

[11:47] J.T. Rogers: You know, if you're ruthlessly as a dynamicist, always trying to read people and what details could you take.

[11:52] J.T. Rogers: Um, so that was I think literally the the next step unexpected.

[11:56] J.T. Rogers: And then it really was on me to I started researching, you know, and I and I discovered through the you know the glory of the internet all of these memoirs, not only larger historical books, but but the gold mine was the memoirs of the participants who were actually there.

[12:13] J.T. Rogers: And what was and so I started reading everything ferociously, and something that was really helpful in in trying to overcome oh goodness, how could I ever do this?

[12:23] J.T. Rogers: Was you know, usually in a historical venomous magnitude, you would think there would be the Rashomon effect, you know, from the great Kurosawa film, where everyone's got a completely different idea of what actually happened in the room.

[12:33] J.T. Rogers: So, you know, in the room where it happened, so to speak.

[12:36] Ruthie Fierberg: Yes.

[12:36] J.T. Rogers: But what's interesting about the participants who were the lifeblood and the engines, the Israeli, Palestinian, and Norwegian, but especially the Israeli and Palestinian officials who, you know, acted with such bravery for me and courage.

[12:53] J.T. Rogers: Um there's great arguments about what happened before.

[12:57] J.T. Rogers: There's enormous arguments about whose idea it was originally, certainly in the Norwegian side.

[13:01] J.T. Rogers: Uh, and then, of course, the great raging debate still of was it a good idea?

[13:07] J.T. Rogers: And what what it should it be blamed for or celebrated.

[13:11] J.T. Rogers: Um, but those nine months, it's extraordinary how much they tell the same story.

[13:18] J.T. Rogers: Who came when, who said what, who said the same joke, who liked the chicken.

[13:25] J.T. Rogers: Um, really, really interesting.

[13:27] J.T. Rogers: So that was like, oh, there's a there's a spine here, you know, as I knew that you know, it is a play and a documentary, so I'm going to all the languages mine, but I tried to scrupulously stick to the the things that were, you know, the events argued in the play are what was argued and debated in real life.

[13:44] J.T. Rogers: And I wanted everyone to take have the liberty to create, again, like the great master Shakespeare, to create your version, your fictional version of this, because it's play filtering through me.

[13:53] J.T. Rogers: Someone else would write a play about the Oslo Peace Accords radically differently.

[13:57] J.T. Rogers: And you each each character that's in my play, you could make an entire play about them.

[14:01] J.T. Rogers: They're so interesting. Truly. Truly. The one rule was nobody could say anything on stage and now in the film that was politically what that character in real life doesn't believe. Because I felt that that was violating something. Right. Wow. Okay. So many questions percolating in my mind just from that. So had you decided from your meeting with your first meeting with Taya, like I am writing this play? Was it after meeting Shimon? Was it did you have to convince yourself? Imagine being a playwright, right? And some, you know, and someone says, hey, I've got a uh uh there's a story. Do you know this story? What story? Oh, did you know that um my wife and I and other members of the Norwegian Foreign Service, you know, with five dollars and some spit and polish, met secretly with members of the PLO and the Israeli government in a castle outside of Norway, and everyone was spirited in secretly and people's lives were at risk, and we drank Johnny Walker Black and talked about our family and tried to make peace.

You've obviously spent a lot of time with Taya. You have this meeting with Shimon. I like you're saying, you go through all these memoirs, but did you meet any of the other characters? You know, it it's the real life people who are the characters. For me, it was an interesting process because I I met with Larson. He, you know, uh he had even in telling the story, sort of saying, but the the Israeli and Palestinians, that is their is theirs, you know, they are the they are the the people who did this. We were the facilitators, but you should know about this. Um I met him, I flew to Norway a few months later, and I interviewed him, and he took me to all of the sites. So I, you know, I got to meet the cook and bottle washer who were in the play.

I got to actually meet them. I got to meet one of the two still living security guards who's in the in the play. Um, I got to walk the hall, you know, sit in the bedroom where they had this and sit on the couch where they drank that, and you know, and and see other sites, which I didn't include in the real life, there were three locations they they mostly negotiated. So, you know, in distillation of storytelling, it all became the one center place, which was the one that was most close to the heart of the Israeli and Palestinian delegation. So that was important to me as well. Um, and then I realized when I came home, I said, Oh, I have to stop meeting people because I'm I I need to hear the language the engine and power of a play is the rhythm of speech.

And I need to be able to write in the voices that I hear and not become an auto uh duck drama. Who were you capturing that you know was like that in real life, and who did you find was disparate from from your own artistic portrayal? Uri Savir was purposely, you know, I was told these extraordinary stories about how when he first showed up and freaked everybody out because he was, you know, poker faced and all in black and being a tough guy, and then he put the mask down. But I thought, oh, the the story needs that. The story needs a character who will grab it by the scruff and shake the play. So I'm gonna give myself license for that to make a really meaty more theatrical role. But basically take the real person, if I'm correct, uh, and and put them on steroids, so to speak.

Um but then I thought I was uh um uh uh Asfor, uh Hassan Asphur, who in real life was only in some of the negotiations, but I wanted him to be all the way through so the audience, you know, and I wanted the Palestinian duo to be as important as the Israeli characters, so we had we cared politically and with our hearts about both sides. I thought, well, I'm I'm making a lot of these things up, but then discover people who knew and said, Oh my gosh, that's that's I know Hassan. I grew up with Hassan. That's that's Hassan. As artists, we search for truth, whatever that whatever that means. Um do you feel that being farther from the real life people allowed you to go more to the essence? Like, does that enhance authenticity for you?

Did it did you ever feel like it jeopardized authenticity for you? For me, as an artist, there's one for William Gaddis quote from his um essay blue, in which he says, art like light needs distance. And for me, I need distance from something to be able to see with any clarity in hopes of writing something of value. Um, I also think, you know, I've given a talk a number of times in the pre-COVID world when we would fly around and give talks, you know, um, which I had titled only somewhat cheekily, um journalism is fine, but the theater is truth. And what I mean by that was there are that the thing that that fiction, be it on the page or on the stage, can do is find some emotional truth or some almost irrational truth or some spiritual truth that that the most brilliant journalism can't, because that's what art is.

And you're also talking about, you know, the art as the distillation of um a historical moment. I mean, I'm all uh and I want to bring our experts in on all of this, but what if anything, do you assume that the audience knows coming in? Yeah, you know, my my my perhaps foolheartedly, perhaps, but my goal was that you could come sit down, you know, on this in in in the in a the house, the midst in the first place it was done, the Mitsunos Theater at Lincoln Center, or now sit, you know, streaming the film that I've written on HBO and not know anything. You not know anything about um Israel Palestine. Now I think I think in reality there is a limit. I I screened, I've just been in Tokyo for eight months filming a project, and I screened the film version of Oslo for my Japanese crew and collaborators.

And many of them literally, you know, it's a it's another world. They don't, they couldn't find Israel and Palestine on a map. And I don't mean that disparagingly. And so it was fascinating to one, it's always great to be somewhere like, oh, right, not everyone has your obsessions. Good to know, Rogers. But also to see their response, to be like, oh my goodness, I had no idea. What is the PLO? Yeah. Um, so in some ways they were the actual perfect audience that I that I had envisioned in my mind. I was gonna say, I think I I think with the film and HBO Max, you might get more of those people, whereas on the upper west side of New York City, it's a different, it's a different audience coming to Oslo.

Speaking of everyone's an expert, I want to bring in our experts for today who have really lived this, who have been on the ground. Um first, I want to welcome Libby Lenkinski, who is the vice president for public engagement at the New Israel Fund, which is committed to building a more democratic Israel for all peoples. She previously worked as the director of international relations for the Association for Civil Rights in Israel. She is a founding member of Zazim Community Action and the Whistle. She is of Israeli descent and has spent her life, you know, between North America and Israel. Welcome, Libby.

[21:23] Libby Lenkinski: Thank you, Ruthie. It's so nice to be here with you and with JT.

[21:28] J.T. Rogers: Absolutely, we're thrilled to have you.

[21:30] Ruthie Fierberg: And our other expert for today is Aziz Abu Sarah, who is a National Geographic Explorer, a TED Fellow, the author of Crossing Boundaries, A Traveler's Guide to World Peace, and the co-founder of Medji Tours, which focuses on peace building through tourism. Aziz, I'm so glad to have met you. He is a Palestinian born in Jerusalem and is doing work all over the world with conflict resolution through connection. So the perfect person to talk about, Oslo, both of you. Welcome, Aziz.

[22:04] Aziz Abu Sarah: Thank you. Thank you, Ruthie, for having us.

[22:06] Ruthie Fierberg: Absolutely. So I want to start first, Libby. I know that you saw the play twice. What was your reaction to the play? What felt true to life for you, and what did feel dramatized for the art?

[22:21] Libby Lenkinski: Thanks for the question. Yeah, I really loved this play, as I mentioned earlier. And for me, um, I think I think a few things, just if I can tap back into my my reaction right after seeing it, which was a few years ago now. Um the first is that I did know some of these people, and I worked with them pretty closely at the Paris Center for Peace and Innovation. And so I was trying during watching to say to myself, kind of like JT was just talking about. Like, it does it matter if this person feels exactly like Ron Poundak felt when I was in the room with him. Did this feel does this person feel like Uri Severe? But then at some point, maybe it was after those first 15 minutes or somewhere along the way, I just stopped doing that.

And I was just with these characters as the characters, which is a pretty tremendous accomplishment since I I know the people well. And then I'm watching somebody who's supposed to be Uri Sevir, and I'm no longer even trying to match them up with Uri Sevir anymore. I'm just with this Uri Sevir doing this thing on this stage. And that I I thought about that a lot afterwards. Um, and the other thing that I kept thinking about um is that you know, in our work in peace building and uh uh uh and civil society work in Israel Palestine, one of the one of the big challenges is that the language is really coded, and um words get thrown around a lot and used as shorthand, and sometimes they mean what you think they mean, sometimes they mean other things.

Um and one of the things that that this play made me think about a lot after seeing it was Oslo, that is a real place where real people live, that happens to be where the Oslo happened. But Oslo, when you say it in our context, doesn't mean that. It means a whole set of political things, and the play situates Oslo as also the place where Norwegians are and where people from Israel and Palestine traveled to to have these conversations, and that felt very big to me.

[24:33] J.T. Rogers: You know, let me it's so interesting about Oslo, even though I'd been to Oslo for the first time ever to do the research, in some ways I didn't really even understand that until I went to see the play relatively recently at the National Theater of Oslo. And so you're sitting there and with and I realized that intermission, oh heavens, the people in the play are sitting behind me. Um, but also to be in a place where everyone, you know, this is an unknown story in the United States, and it means it certainly me is passionately debated and understood in Israel-Palestine in many different ways. But an Oslo, it's sort of part of their pol their historical foundation for this, whether they people think it was a good idea or not, because you know, this is a moment of incredibly punching above your weight, shall we say, as a small Nordic nation state.

And so everyone knew the story. So you're watching a thousand people and they're all like, uh-huh and then that's gonna happen, and that's gonna happen, and that's gonna happen. And then they're all weeping for the last 30 minutes of the play because they have this emotional. And so that was um that was really unexpected and incredibly moving. You know, obviously it's meaningful for us, but of course, if you're a Norwegian growing up in politics, uh, this is a big historical moment. But for Israelis and Palestinians, I think, like for Americans, that was very remote until they were standing facing a Norwegian who was saying that to them.

[25:50] Libby Lenkinski: Um, it's interesting because I had exactly similar feelings to you, Livvy, as I was I didn't see the play, but I read it, and I had the same feeling exactly as as you were mentioning matching people in the play to people we know in person, and I was doing the same thing. In some cases, I have to say some of what you've written was better than I think some of the side.

[26:20] J.T. Rogers: Um, we get to rewrite, that's the thing, right? You get to make everyone sound really good because you rewrite and rewrite.

[26:26] Libby Lenkinski: Right.

[26:26] J.T. Rogers: So you get the chance to refine every every sentence and every things they say. So that was for me that was actually fun. Having been a facilitator and mediator in conflicts before, I was often thinking finding myself thinking, oh what would I have done in this situation? Where would I be? How what how would I have dealt with these uh disagreements if I was a third party and um yeah and that was very interesting for me is just looking at it And what was what was your answer?

[26:58] Libby Lenkinski: How would you have dealt with it if you were the third party?

[26:58] J.T. Rogers: Yeah I'm not sure I have an answer for that. And partially because the play is well written so it's it's uh I I I guess I was matching it a lot of the work I was doing in in Afghanistan between different groups there and being in this situation where people were having strong disagreements thing.

[27:25] Libby Lenkinski: So reading it not only as here's what happened Oslo, but I was reading it as here's a peacemaker work. Here's what you do in negotiations, here's maybe where I agree or disagree. Just off what you said is easy I I um the whole element of the of the play, these sort of the the engine in some ways of of conflict resolution again entertainingly is when I very first fur heard the you know the origin story for me of of hearing in in a nutshell what it was and then starting to dig into it again only in hindsight I realized oh what the the sort of Eureka idea behind this was we're gonna personalize a a a f a incredibly largely formal scrutinized process and we're going to make it private and personal and everyone has to be there every day and everyone has to work together and no one is allowed to not be there and it all is add out in the open.

[28:23] J.T. Rogers: It is all to create swiftly intimacy and trust among strangers who can then take a risk together.

[28:30] J.T. Rogers: And I thought, oh, like rehearsing a play. Oh, I understand that. But I understand the spirit of that.

[28:42] J.T. Rogers: Yes. Which is exactly what I was going to ask about that, you know, Tyra Larson's approach to the Oslo Peace Accords and therefore what we see in the work of Oslo shows that philosophy that getting personal can lead to intimacy, which leads to trust, which can lead to peace. I'm wondering to the experts in the room, do you agree with that approach? Is that the path to peacemaking, making it personal?

[29:16] Aziz Abu Sarah: Uh I do. I think it is very helpful when you are negotiating to make it very personal. I think if you jump right away into lines and where things are, it doesn't really get things done. And I can tell you from a real story I was told from one of my colleagues who negotiated a peace deal in Mozambique a couple of decades ago. Say one of the challenges he had was when he had these two groups fighting with each other come to the room, is they wouldn't shake even hands with each other. And he knew until they get to have some contact to actually see each other, touch each other even hands. This is how far they were, they were not gonna move forward in these negotiations. It was a waste of time. And so he started orchestrating how to get them to enter from different points, how to not be in the middle.

So they almost forced to shake their hands out of embarrassment. And if through these steps of getting them to meet again and again, getting them to know each other more, getting them to eventually shake each other's hands, which they succeeded at, getting their personal lives involved in it, only then they were really able to start moving forward in those negotiations.

[30:40] Libby Lenkinski: Yeah. Libby, what about you?

[30:41] Libby Lenkinski: Yeah, I mean I think that I also agree with the approach and I think that relationships are at the heart of the work that I do and I know at the heart of the work that Aziz does as well in the region. And I think we can't you cannot skip over that. And I think one of the things that Oslo got right was that aspect that it's about eating together, breaking bread together, forcing yourself to be in the room through the hard moments and building trust in that way. I think that the place where that approach falls short is that it's behind closed doors and it's only such a small group of people. And of course hindsight is 2020 but we also know that part of why Oslo didn't work the way it was originally envisioned is because they didn't have the will of the people behind them.

[31:39] Libby Lenkinski: Right. And you know, if I I'll tell you just a quick story that I'm in a long-term study and strategy group with a group of Israelis and Palestinians. We studied together in South Africa with a group of South Africans. I had the opportunity to meet a couple named Leon and Linda Levy, who were big ANC activists. Leon was a young white Jewish lawyer in the 1950s who helped write the what was called the Freedom Charter in 1955, where it was a long process of about two or three years, where they went and met with all the different kinds of communities around South Africa, different tribes, different, totally different languages, different ethnicities, and talked to them about values and vision, and then organized it into this freedom charter.

They were then, of course, jailed, put sent into exile for 35 years, and only returned to South Africa after Nelson Mandela was freed. But then Leon Levy was part of then drafting the first constitution post-apartheid in South Africa together with Albi Sachs and Arthur Chaskels and Zikonoli Baja, and that constitution is among the most progressive and innovative still today in the world, and also is very widely accepted by the South African people. And I believe that a part of why is because of the initial process all those decades ago wasn't just in a closed room of six men building relationships with each other. It included that, and that is so important, and again, that's where Oslo got it so right, in my view. But that other process outside of the room of building relationships and trust and buy-in is equally important in a process like this.

[33:33] Libby Lenkinski: Um, and we keep forgetting that in the region. We keep forgetting the question about who's in the room. In Oslo, it was men. And also what happens outside of the room to support those processes being really, really integral.

[33:48] J.T. Rogers: Yeah, I mean, because it's devastating at the end of the play, which I feel okay spoiling because it's just history. So just you know, when I mean, well, because it is history, that you know, you have this amazing signing at the White House, and you know, the PLO and the Israelis shake hands, and is this moment that you think would never come and it comes, and then you know, just a little while later, there is, you know, an attack of the people on the ground that makes the violence and you know re-agitates all of the feelings on the ground, and it's because, like you're saying, Libby, like it was only of that small concentration of people that those relationships were built. But so I guess I'm I'm wondering, and maybe Aziz, you can speak to this, if this is such a crucial part of the peace process, is it scalable?

If you like really, like when you're thinking about, you know, the eight million people that live in Israel, like how are you supposed to, you know, go? Are you supposed to go one by one by one and create many of these groups and you know, in 40 years, we'll eventually have made it through everyone? Like what what's the philosophy behind that?

[35:15] Aziz Abu Sarah: Yeah, it feels like that's what we're doing right now because of the absence of an institutional way of doing it. But it is I fully agree with Libby. I think that the failure of Oslo was not being able to translate what happened in those rooms in the negotiations on the ground. I mean, nobody, no community leaders were involved, no religious leaders were involved, no, you know, the way the Palestinian community worked, tribal communities, there were leaders, community leaders, youth leaders of the intifada underground. None of those people were really involved. We just got the news and were told this is it. And I think it was the same on the Israeli side. And it wasn't only Oslo, to be more fair, this continued after Oslo.

This continued in through the 90s, and eventually with Barack and Arafat meeting, there's this famous story of how they talked about, you know, when they were I think I heard that from Rabbi Melchior when he mentioned you need to bring some of the community and religious leaders here. And he said, no, those people we lock in a room until we finish the agreement. And the reality is you can't do that. So how would you do it? I would say you reach out to you know, they're not hard to find. There are influencers. I know this word now influencers is misused, but there are influencers in each of these communities. I can point to you the ones in Jerusalem, the ones in Hebron, the ones in Ramallah, who are not in government, who are well respected, who are trusted by people.

And if they give their input and if they are part of this process, when there is an agreement, people will be interested in that agreement. That's one. But second, you have to also work on eradicating the hatred that we've been spreading in both communities. And by getting the buy-in of those community leaders, you can set up programs that's not just nonprofits are able to do, but actually institutional programs in schools, in universities and communities that can help us overcome some of the hatred that has been spreading. And unless we do that, you're not gonna it doesn't matter how great the agreement is. And it's a struggle because some nonprofits are really trying hard to do it. But you know, I work with the bereaved families forum in Jerusalem, and yeah, we did a thousand meetings in high schools, but the thousand meetings was one time a year, each one of these meetings, a drop in the pocket when you look at the whole country.

And then I remember being actually at J Street for a conference once and meeting with a politician who negotiated in the 2000 negotiations, and he was so patronizing, telling me what you guys doing, this peace work on the ground with people, it's all nice and cool, but eventually it's only us who can make that change. Well, you failed, so not really. You failed again and again and again. You might want to rethink that thought.

[38:21] J.T. Rogers: So, this idea, Aziz that you were talking about, where this negotiator said, you know, peace only comes from politicians, but knowing the very real reality that that has to filter down to the people. So, for your money, is there like what is the joint approach? How does it happen so that we can get to a point where you know where we're moving in the same direction, both politicians and people?

[38:56] Aziz Abu Sarah: Um I think they're not mutually exclusive. You have to do at both at the same time. Right now, unfortunately, there is nothing happening on the track one on the politician side. So most of the work happening only on the people to people work. And the people to people work isn't always just let's get together, have a good time, you know, get to know each other, but it's also can be pushed to becoming a co-resistance thing. Co-resistance working for justice together. And that changes the whole paradigm. So for me, I don't really see the Israeli-Palestinian issue anymore as Palestinians versus Israelis, Arabs versus Jews, any of that definition. To me, it's those of us who are fighting for justice and for peace, and those who are not there yet.

That's how I like to see it. So, you know, I don't see Libby as on the other side because she's Jewish. I don't see my Israeli Jewish colleagues on the other side because they Jewish, because you create a paradigm where we are actually on the same side and you try to push that upwards. So since we the ones now who are moving for that agreement for a better future, and since politicians are not, then we have to work to try to push one, our constituency, our community to move in that direction and push politicians. It's an uphill battle, it's hard. We also have to push some of us to go into politics and maybe try to change from within, which which is happening. I see a couple I know a couple of activists who are in the government right now. I know an activist who ran for the Jerusalem municipality. I was gonna say, I know I think we all now know someone who ran for mayor in Jerusalem.

[40:52] J.T. Rogers: Right. So that's another way to cause change. But you know, that run for mayor was totally orchestrated by me and a few friends who are all peace activists and many of them are Israeli peace activists who decided with me that this would be an important step to push for a change of how people think about Jerusalem. So we knew my chances of making it happen is pretty much zero, but we did it so we can push the upward level that track one to reconsider what is happening. And that's that's a change of how we even in the civil society think of not just how do we work among the communities, but also how do we influence change in government.

[41:39] Libby Lenkinski: Yes. I totally agree with that. And I think that there's like a few things that I want to like pause on that you said that I so so so agree with. One is that the sort of the sides and the way that we think about bridge building has changed since the 90s.

[42:02] Libby Lenkinski: Um and I think one of the big changes that I can see in myself and in my colleagues on the Israeli left is this real understanding that when we that there's something very powerful about people being around the table, and what J.T. talked about in his own writing process of insisting that the Palestinian negotiators be present in every scene also to balance that. But what we really know is that it is completely asymmetrical in reality on the ground. And so part of if we were talking about what to do now, um that would be different from what was done in the 90s. Um I think it is addressing this not as a conflict of two equal sides. There is a conflict that needs to be resolved, and Palestinians must be around the table to resolve that conflict.

Sham deals like with the UAE that tried to skip over Palestinians to establish peace in the region are not going to work. So that's on that side, but uh but the occupation and the systemic oppression that Palestinians face, um that is not symmetrical. There are not two sides to that, and so that's a that's that's a really important part, and it also in some ways changes the role of uh Israeli Jewish activists, peacemakers, justice seekers, um, like Aziz was saying, to figure out a way to be in co-resistance and not um thinking that we're on two symmetrical opposing sides in our work. Um the other thing is we were talking we were joking about influencers, you mentioned influencers earlier, but I do think that um even in the 90s, you know, there's people to people work, and that work has changed.

Um, and there's there's the track one, but there's a lot of there's a lot of in-between space that's about shifting the discourse on mass through the media now through social media and through other kinds of um other kinds of uh broader broader audience efforts and I think that you know Itzak Rabin Zihonali Vracha understood that intuitively he worked in that way when he was trying to advance peace one of the really clear ways that I remember was when he sat with with uh Yasser Arafat uh Zichon Ali Brachah as well um on national television in Israel and he made a joke he joked with Arafat Arafat said something and Rabin said oh you're almost Jewish what you said it's it sounds like he said something neurotic or something like that he said you're almost like a Jew that was like this it was the side thing it was this little harmless joke it is so important that he did that he understood intuitively that he needed to humanize Arafat he needed to take him outside of the frame of terrorist or violent resistor in the eyes of Israelis he needed to make Arafat seem approachable to the Israeli public and he did that in very subtle intuitive ways like that joke about hey you're almost a Jew you wouldn't say that to a terrorist that you're terrified of you would say that to somebody who you could imagine being a partner for peace and I think that those kinds of um narrative changes, um subtle public facing um uh moments go a very long way go a very long way public opinion is fickle and you know there's a famous um a famous statistic of Israeli public opinion in nineteen seventy nine about peace with Egypt was like twenty percent supported eighty percent didn't support Sadat lands in Jerusalem photo up in Jerusalem whoop the next week it flips these movements are extremely important I I think Rabin understood that they they didn't have the tools or the framework to go all the way with it but I think today with our technology and our social media um and the the next generation of people who grew up with all of that at their fingertips there's a lot that can be done in addition to the people to people one to one which is limited in its ability to scale and in the track one you know only politicians can handle this there's a lot in between um and those are the places that are very exciting.

[46:31] Libby Lenkinski: That's also the place where arts and culture comes into the peacemaking arena.

[46:37] Ruthie Fierberg: Yes absolutely and I want I mean Libby there are so many points that you just made that I want to dig into but in the interest of you know this idea of the personal and humanizing I I'm hoping that each of you can tell us just a little bit about your personal story, your upbringing and what brought you to this co-resistance and the peace work. Aziz perhaps you want to start.

[46:59] Aziz Abu Sarah: I grew up in Jerusalem I got introduced to the conflict through the first intifada where I was seven years old when it started and it was terrifying even though I didn't really understand. I think people often assume you're kind of born knowing the conflict, and you don't. I didn't understand why there's soldiers, why we don't speak the same language. Like when you're 6'7, you don't fully get the whole story. And I there are a few incidents that made me understand the conflict, and one of them was going home one day after soldiers tear gassed my my school after we had uh some some kids had clashes with the with the soldiers, and I told my mom, I'm quitting school. I I made my mind, my decision that school is not worth dying for.

And I made the argument for my mother, and she obviously did not agree with me, and she's like, You're seven years old, eight years old, you can't make those decisions. So she she gave me an onion and told me every day when I go to school, like take an onion with me, which for those who don't know, I'm helping you if you go to a riot. Take an onion if there's tear gas, it's supposed to help you not suffocate. And that was my first like one of my first introductions of the whole Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the occupation, what does it mean to be tear gassed? And this continued uh two years later, my brother was killed out of torture in Israeli prison, and I grew up very angry, very bitter, very much uh seeking revenge until I was 18, and that's when I went to study Hebrew for the first time in an Ulpan, which is where Jewish immigrants go to learn Hebrew.

Um, and that was my first time meeting Israelis as an equal, as a student in a classroom, not as uh somebody passing through the checkpoint where the soldier is the nice soldier will give you, you know, will be making you a favor by letting you go without checking it for having power dynamic is very clear. Right, and as nice as a soldier can be, you can't have really a dialogue with somebody carrying a gun. It's just not not realistic. And it was that classroom was different. I was very lucky because my teacher was an amazing person who welcomed me first day with a big smile. I was not happy being there. I did not want to be there. I thought I'm there only to learn the language, not make any friends, I'm not talking to anyone anyway, they hate me.

That was what was going in my mind. And she welcomed me with this big smile and welcomed me in Arabic. And I was the only Palestinian student in the classroom. And that was the first time I think I had an Israeli person see me as a human being, and it made a huge impact on me. Didn't change me immediately, but that moment just got so stuck in my mind. And through that time of learning Hebrew, I got to learn the culture, the history, the language, the so many things, and get to know people. And that's where I decided that this concept of us versus them doesn't work for me anymore. And that when my brother was killed, I was on a path of revenge. I felt that I had no choice except revenge. And when I was in that close classroom, I realized that's not true.

You don't control what other people do. I couldn't control the person who killed my brother, but I could control my own actions. And every time I chose to want revenge, you know, I thought it was justice, but the line between justice and revenge is very thin line. And in reality, now thinking about it, it was it was definitely revenge. Every time I chose that, I was being a slave to the person who killed my brother. And being freed from that is is very liberating. And so that's what took me onto this path. And I ended up joining an organization called Brief Families Forum, bringing Israelis and Palestinians who lost family members in the conflict and later another organization called Combatants for Peace. Bringing people who fought against each other in the conflict. And it's um it it changed my life upside down.

[51:18] Ruthie Fierberg: Hmm. Thank you so much for sharing that. And yeah, I think that's also important to note that there are these like you said the middle ground Libby of of people coming together um in organized groups whether it's combatants for peace or the parent circle or you know all of these uh different things that they're reconciling. But Libby if you could talk a little bit about how you came to to this work and your upbringing.

[51:46] Libby Lenkinski: Thanks. Um and I'm just I'm a little emotional. I've heard your story a hundred times Aziz, including at the bar and also on huge stages like Ted. And just hearing it right now, I think after the last couple months that we've been through just hit me in a different way. So thank you for sharing it in that way and you're such a brilliant and beautiful storyteller that I'll I'll remember the words from right now. Um how did I come into this work? Well I um I also come from a a long line of left wing Jews um on my Israeli side and my non-Israeli side. So my family's quite political. My mom's Israeli and my dad is Polish Canadian. So I was also kind of born into it. Um but like Aziz, I was in a very um like I I thought I knew, but I there was just a lot that I didn't know as a as a young person.

Um I did I was like a pretty hippie ish kid, and the peace movement was happening in Israel, and I felt really, really connected to it for those years of the 90s. Like that was when I came of age politically and understood that there's a bigger world around me, and the input that I was getting was like a lot about Oslo and the peace movement and the peace process, and I was very that was I was all about it. Um and but I I had never thought about Palestinians. Um I didn't know any non-Jews until I got to college, so it was funny to hear you say, Aziz, that you started to take the Hebrew class when you were 18. When I was 18, I went to Montreal to start university, and I met non-Jews for the first time basically.

Um, and a lot of those I gravitated towards Arabs. There's like a lot of Jews at McGill, and also a lot of Arabs, including a lot of Palestinians, particularly from French speaking like countries in the Arab world, and um I remember my second year of college, I was walking home with one of my dear friends, a Palestinian Lebanese Canadian. Um, we were in a women's studies class together, and she took out a keychain to open her apartment, and there was like a key on the keychain it said intifada, and I saw that, and I was I grew up left wing, and I was like a pretty left wing person already as like a an older teenager, and I saw the word intifada on her keychain, and she's Palestinian, and I I went pale, I was frozen.

It was as if somebody had taken out a keychain that said Holocaust on it. And I said, like, what is that? And she said, that's the freedom fight of my people, babes. And I had it was I I still remember it. I was I mean, that was already like 25 years ago. Um, I remember everything about that moment because it was a moment of like the first cracks forming in my own narrative about I it was as soon as that went into question, like, wait, why did I why did I react like that to the word intifada? And why was it so casual for her? What does it actually mean? Oh my gosh, there's this whole other people, and they have this whole other thing going on, facing my own privilege of understanding that it's just one narrative among so many, um, among so many other Jewish narratives and Israeli narratives, and then so many Palestinian and diat, you know, just that um I just grew up, I think, really feeling like the story that was mine that I was told was the story, and once that once that sort of took place for me at 19, I just started to see things really differently, and I moved to Israel in my mid 20s um because I fell in love with an Israeli guy. I married him and divorced him and stayed there for another eight years after that.

[55:51] Aziz Abu Sarah: Um, and but even when I got there to live and work, I thought that I kind of knew what I was doing. Um, and then I ended up on a trip to the West Bank with an NGO, an at the time very young new NGO called Yeshdine that does the anti-occupation work, mostly like legal advocacy channels. Um, and we went out to investigate an incident of settler violence, um, where settlers had come into a Palestinian village and burnt trees and things like that, and Yeshdin would go and take testimony from Palestinians and then launch complaints and things like that. And um I learned on that trip about how much um impunity Jewish settlers are able to act in with their violence against Palestinians and things like that in the West Bank.

And that was another really, really shocking moment for me. I should not have been shocked. It's embarrassing how shocking it was to me. But it got under my skin in a deep way because I grew up in a religious school and I just hadn't had no experience of like Jewish religious extremism. And it was embarrassing and awful to me that that was happening, and it was particularly embarrassing and awful that they had the support of the state. That I think that was the first moment for me where I understood that my struggle is against the state that I'm a citizen in, the state that my grandparents helped found, is it it's about reshifting, realigning the dynamic of the state of Israel that is on the wrong side right now.

[57:37] Libby Lenkinski: I mean, what this is bringing up for me is it's funny when I was in college, um, I went to Barnard College at Columbia University, and um I am an American Jew. Um I am part Ashkenazi from Eastern Europe, but I am also part Sparti um from Syria and Egypt. So definitely not Palestinian or Israeli, but you know, feel very connected to Arab roots and um, but also very cognizant of my personal desire and the narrative that was taught to me of the need for a Jewish state, um, often tied to the Holocaust, that you know, this could happen again anywhere. We are kind of, you know, America as like a almost a temporary situation, and that you have to have Israel as a backup. And um, and I took a class called Reacting to the Past, which some people, some listeners out there may have heard me speak about, where it's a history seminar, but instead of being lectured to and writing papers, um you there's a moment in time and it's like a scenario reenactment almost, and everybody is assigned individual roles, and your individual roles have objectives, and then your faction also has objectives, and your papers are speeches that you make to your classmates to persuade them to your side.

A lot of the time, I would even say most of the time, the outcome of the history seminar does not reflect actual history, but the workings reflect history because you learn, you know, I learned when I was 19, oh, history is all made on these personal decisions and personal relationships in which politician liked the other politician. But I um was part of the scenario of Israel-Palestine 1936. And as um a Jewish student, I was put on the Palestinian faction side. And I was a Palestinian moderate known as Musa Alami. And I will never forget, like, sit standing in class screaming at the top of my lungs about how there could not be, and of course, this is pre-the-existence of Israel in 1948, you know, we're in 1936, screaming about how the Zionists were totally wrong.

There cannot be a Jewish state here. We're happy to welcome Jews as people and as citizens and live side by side, but no way. While in my real life going, wait, wait, wait, but like, but I but this is a thing that I I think I do still need, and reconciling those two things is a really it feels a little bit like you're being torn in half of like I believe this is a the Jewish state needs to exist, but I also am not happy with the way they're existing. Um and that, like you said, Libby, the both sides of it all, yes, there are two sides, but they are not two equal sides, and so I'm wondering like how do we begin, how do we begin to reconcile that?

[01:01:13] Aziz Abu Sarah: If someone wants, I don't know, chocolate ice cream and someone wants vanilla, and there is no way, no matter how much they get to know each other, the other one is not gonna want chocolate, and the other one is not gonna want vanilla, like what do you do? I don't think that our desires are opposing, and I think that one of the things that I've been thinking about a lot in the last few weeks, um, during the recent crisis and since, which I still think we're in. Yes, is um I'll go back to the Bible since Aziz moves towards religious leaders and religiosity sometimes in his storytelling, too, and say it's to me it's become just so it's become simpler. It's treat others as you would want to be treated in a very broad sense.

And in the last few months, in this crisis, um, when we've seen this incredible move in this country, in Israel to a certain extent, but I see it very much in the United States, centering Palestinian voices in the media and in public spaces, Palestinians telling their reality, their desires and hopes and frustrations directly and not mediated through Israelis, Jews, or others, um, that what what I heard, um, and I know many, many Palestinians and work with many, many different kinds of Palestinians for many years, but I've never seen a moment where their voices are so prevalent in the American public space. It's a welcome and incredible shift that I see as really connected to last summer and the centering of people of color voices during the George Floyd protests and and Black Lives Matter and the amazing um culture change that has been happening in this country around that, that now is also um echoing into other issues like this, like this one.

Um, but in listening to diverse Palestinian voices speaking during the last few months, I hear a massive call for defragmentation and for peoplehood. And this is something I relate to as a Jew. I grew up on the idea of peoplehood, on the idea that I as a Jew am connected to other people around the world just by virtue of the fact that we're all Jews, even if I've never met them. And it was an incredibly powerful and important part of my identity formation and of my politics. I hear Palestinians saying we are one, we are one people, whether we live in Sheikh Jarach, whether we live in Haifa or in Chevron or in Boston or in London. And I I don't I see that call as something extremely relatable, and I know how I wanted the world to accept Jewish peoplehood when we needed to make that call for ourselves. And I want to accept Palestinian peoplehood the way I wanted the world to accept Jewish peoplehood.

[01:04:23] Libby Lenkinski: You what you said kind of reminds me of when I read the news now and I see something went on violence or a statement, I've started asking myself always what if I switch the roles? If it was, you know, a Palestinian committed violence against Israelis or the Israeli committed violence against Palestinians. I started to always flip the roles to see if my feelings would change about it. And if it does, then something is wrong with how I'm viewing that situation. And I think that's how you deal with this where do I stand and things and really check if am I really for human rights, for equal rights, for what regardless of what somebody's ethnicity, religion, nationality, whatever they are, it doesn't matter who they are, am I really supporting this only based on a national identity?

Or is it I'm really believing this is justice? And by flipping the roles, it helps us realize when we are being prejudiced. And we all have biases and we all have prejudices. So I still catch myself and in that situation, in that place where I'm like, uh uh, that's wrong, my feelings I shouldn't be supporting this or I should be infuriated about this. I should be angry about that or shouldn't um and that I found to be very helpful for me in figuring out what do I stand for and whatnot.

[1:05:58] Aziz Abu Sarah: Um I think we've been and this is an international I guess the thing it's in the US we've been sold this like your commitment first comes to a national group to an ethnic group to a religious group that's to somebody who looks like you and I reject that idea. I I don't think that's that's the right that's the right way to build alliances. That's not the right way to build relationships. That's not the right way if you believe in injustice or in human rights. And I understand that everybody does but I think there are enough people who do but still kind of influenced heavily by this lie of you know our commitment comes to nationalism first.

[1:06:44] Libby Lenkinski: Yes. I mean that is such a tangible tool that we can all use of you know reading these stories, reading the news, flip-flopping and see if that changes our minds or our hearts and and examining that bias within ourselves. What is your ideal in terms of the land dispute, shall we say? Is it a two-state solution? Is it a one-state solution? Is it another option?

[1:07:18] Aziz Abu Sarah: I think we we might be arguing sometimes too much about what's the solution, but not the but not you can end up with one state, two state, confederate, federal, which I have my preference, but I think it's about how the solutions also implemented, and unless a solution is implemented with a mindset that does create justice, opportunity, uh real peace. Because yeah, we had a you know, we had the Oslo agreement before, and some were for it, some for it were against it. But if it's not done with the mindset and the focus and putting all our really our minds, our resources into how do we change not only the signing of a paper and making an agreement, but how do we really make the change on the ground and how do we make how do we get people to see that justice is really being implemented, that equality is coming?

I I don't think then it matters which solution you end up with. Now, personally, I like the Confederate aspect because I think it works uh the confederal system, I think, works the best of the current reality, not because it's the most ideal. I think one state solution is the most ideal. Democracy, full, you know, one person, one vote. But I think that's hard to achieve. I think also two-state solution now is very hard to achieve. So I think Confederal makes more sense.

[1:08:49] Libby Lenkinski: What does Confederal look like?

[1:08:51] Aziz Abu Sarah: So Confederal is almost a mix between one state and two states. You have one land, you have two states kinda, but no borders, uh, in the sense that Israelis can live in the West Bank and Palestine and Palestinians can live in Israel, but they can be residents, not citizens in that country. And therefore, you still get the people who feel I want a Jewish state or I want an Arab state. You still get those people to feel comfortable enough that that's happening, but you're also dealing with the reality that we have uh 600,000 settlers in the West Bank, that you're not gonna be able to evacuate all of them, and you're still dealing with the fact that many religious sites for Jews are in the West Bank, and many Palestinians have strong roots and connections to places like Akka and Haifa and Yafa and all these places that they want to go and live in it. So it gives you the almost the best of two worlds.

[1:09:49] Aziz Abu Sarah: Obviously, it has its own other challenges, but I like that ability where you know I'm not asked to forget about our families and our history's connection to these places that end up within Israel, and you as a Jew or Israeli not being asked to lose any connection you have to a place in the West Bank. So that's what I like about it.

[1:10:16] Ruthie Fierberg: And in that scenario, is there a separate because like you're saying, there's citizens and there are residents. So in Gaza and the West Bank, is there a separate government for those citizens?

[1:10:33] Aziz Abu Sarah: Yeah, it'd be a Palestinian government in Gaza and the West Bank, Israeli government, they'll have two parliaments, but there'll be a lot of joint stuff because there are no real borders. And obviously the idea is being developed still, but this is where I'm hoping we heading.

[1:10:53] J.T. Rogers: I know. Let's take a chance on a concept that has never worked anywhere in the world in history, and let's try it out on the most hot-buttoned conflictual 2,000-year-old concept. But literally everything that has worked has not worked for us.

[1:11:11] Aziz Abu Sarah: I was gonna say that's the thing, nothing else has worked. So I 100% I agree. I agree with everything that you said, and including I remember maybe 10 years ago, I was on a speaker tour with Noam Shazaf from 972 magazine, and Noam had just which Aziz was one of the founding members as well, and Noam had just written a big piece about moving from a sort of solutions policy approach to a rights-based approach when thinking about what we're fighting for, and making it simpler in that what we are fighting for is full equality and human rights and dignity for all people, from the river to the sea, and that needs to be the starting point and the end point, and everything in between is how we get there, as opposed to how do we reach a two-state solution. Maybe that's not the ultimate.

[1:12:23] J.T. Rogers: And I really loved that. I love that also because I think that one of the really hard things about this issue is that a lot of the language and a lot of the concepts are even coded where they aren't we're not using them to mean their direct meaning. We're using them to situate ourselves on a political map.

[1:12:48] Aziz Abu Sarah: So it used to be that saying, I believe in a two-state solution, I believe in Palestinian statehood situated you firmly on the left. But over the last two decades, the two-state solution has in some ways using it has like been gutted of its meaning. Like we mean really different things than a tinyho means when he says it, but he also says it. And so saying a two-state solution now situates you in a more moderate or even right-wing place, and being by national curious or being open to thinking about a non-two-state solution places you on the radical left because it means that you might be willing to give up on the idea of a Jewish state. I'm not, and so I end up falling in a more similar place to what Aziz was talking about, but I think the important thing is not repeating these things as mantras, actually assessing the present day reality for what it actually is.

[1:13:49] Aziz Abu Sarah: My ideal is that there's full equality including to you know the right to national self-determination for all people. My perception is that for Israelis there is a priority that a Jewish state exists, right? Now what that Jewish state looks like, there's a lot of flexibility, but I think that that's an overarching thing. And then I see on the Palestinian side that there has been a precedent of like we don't want a Jewish state to exist because you took our land and you keep pushing us out and you have with taking our land you have taken our rights which I acknowledge is absolute like those are truths and those are facts. But so if one wants a state by a religion and one wants a more democratic state by no religion like where can the overlap happen like would a Jewish state be acceptable to Palestinians if it is if it is one citizen one vote and if Palestinians are considered citizens of course one state you meaning with the West Bank in Gaza?

[1:15:11] J.T. Rogers: Yeah. Being a Jewish state I would say most Palestinians would say that wouldn't make sense because we would be half of the population and yet we wouldn't be equal. Because if you look what what does a Jewish state mean, at least today, for the current Israeli government, which is supposed to be pretty much in the center, not even as far as Netanyahu, when you look at what it really means, practically it's discriminatory in its essence. I'll give you one example. The most recent law about Palestinian marriages and people who are married to people in the West Bank, Israeli citizens who should be equal before the law. If you marry somebody from the West Bank now, you're not allowed to get them into your country to get citizenship.

There's a law that singles out only Palestinians from being able to get unification, family unification with their spouses. So, and that's how when I look at this, why you have a problem with Jewish state. I look at these laws and I say, This is why. And when you read, you know, I'm not gonna quote Netanyahu, who had some stuff about it, I'll quote Yahir Le Pete, who when he asks about this, we shouldn't hide that the main reason we do this is because we want a Jewish state. That's his justification for this. And so when I hear, look, we want a Jewish state, it often comes with the same sentence of we don't want you here. So I can't imagine a one state rever to the sea being a Jewish state that I would be treated in equally if it's a Jewish state.

It needs to be a state for all its citizens. And this is a crazy thing. When I talk to Israeli Jews about a state for all its citizens, in most places in the world, that would be looked at as yeah, that makes sense. If you're a citizen in a country, this is your country. In Israel, that's sometimes looked at as radical. Oh, this is a Jewish state, not a state for all its resistants. So what do what do I do if I'm there? What what's my rights? Where are my limits? What's the sky ceiling for me? And those are there are issues that we would have to deal with.

[1:17:31] Libby Lenkinski: Libby, I'm curious your response to it.

[1:17:35] Libby Lenkinski: I mean, I think that to me the question is less about one state, two state, Jewish or and or democratic, and more about the question of supremacy. So I and I think this is something that's being challenged and examined and revolutionized around the world is this question of white supremacy and supremacy in general. And I don't think that a Jewish state inherently has to be a state that is built on Jewish supremacy. But okay, but I believe that right now, as Aziz is describing, a lot of what how we think about maintaining a Jewish state does involve Jewish supremacy. And I don't I'm looking for the solutions that allow a Jewish character and Jewish tradition and Jewish history to be safe in Israel without having a structure of Jewish supremacy throughout the land.

And right now, for example, I think we do have a structure of Jewish supremacy throughout the land in today's setup. I would want a solution that takes care of that. That to me is a problem. And that's not because I want there to not be a Jewish state. It's that I don't think that inherent and having a Jewish state means supremacy.

[1:19:16] Aziz Abu Sarah: Yeah. And I think that that's where kind of where the creativity has to come in as kind of as Aziz said to come off. Like it sounds crazy, but nothing else has worked. So why not try this new thing? Because I really do think it's going to have to be like the atoms hitting each other to create the big bang that never happened before. Because, like Aziz was saying, if you if you make it one state and it is a Jewish state, it's a little bit strange that it's a Jewish state when at least half, if not the full majority of the population is not Jewish. But for Israelis and Jewish people around the world, in fact, it is hard to think of a multinational state that isn't tied to some Jewish character like you're speaking about.

[1:20:14] Ruthie Fierberg: You know, I imagine that there are some people who will listen to this who are, like you say, firmly on one side or the other, a little bit more based on nationalism or just the way they were raised, whether that is no, the Jewish state must absolutely exist and I will not stray from that, or no, the Palestinians are absolutely oppressed, and I will stand by them no matter what. What is what would you recommend the first step for some of those people who feel a little bit more concrete in their beliefs, a little less flexible at the moment? What is the first step for them to open up without feeling like they're abandoning principles they've had for their whole life?

[1:21:04] Aziz Abu Sarah: I think first thing, I and I'll say it from my own background, is opening yourself to kind of something Libby said earlier, opening yourself to other voices, to voices that are not comfortable for you to hear, voices that will challenge what you believe in. And if you're so afraid of those voices, then you already know that something is wrong with the ideas you are holding. If you're afraid to hear someone who will challenge you, you know something ain't right. So you can find that through reading media outlets that will not give you everything you believe in. You can read a book about Palestine that's actually written by a Palestinian, maybe, and there are many good ones that are out there.

For me, that's why I started my company is giving people the option or the ability to learn the other narrative without feeling that's the only thing they're learning, but also still learning their own narrative. So you get the Israeli and the Palestinian tour guides together, so you get that debate. But allowing yourself being in uncomfortable situation, allowing yourself to be in a place of contradictions, not everything has to fit perfectly. Get comfortable with cognitive dissonance. I'll tell you an example. I went on a tour that was run by Israeli settlers, and I did it, they didn't know I was Palestinian because they wouldn't let me join them if I did. But I did it because I wanted to understand what goes in the mind of an Israeli settler.

I don't agree with Israeli settlers, but I still wanted to understand that. And those moments of being in this uncomfortable situation, you know, I read the Hebrew Bible maybe ten, twelve times. And I did it in the beginning, I did it out of I want to understand what religious people think, and the same with the Bible, and the same with the Quran. But eventually I actually learned a lot of things. And when now when I talk to religious groups, I do these talks to even ultra-orthodox Jews now. And I start quoting the Bible, and they look at me like, how do you know the Hebrew Bible? I'm like, oh, I've read it, I actually like this book, and I like this interpretation, and it makes people feel also when you do that appreciated, or they're willing to listen to you.

I would say don't always listen to argue, listen to understand, to hear, to hear what the other side says, and then if you want to say something later, that's fine. But don't always try to poke holes in every argument you hear.

[1:23:52] Libby Lenkinski: Well, yeah, I um I agree. And I the only thing that I will add to Aziz's advice to your question, Ruthie, is um is is I would tell people to put away the phone for a second, give yourself a beat to actually experience something and a transformation or a new idea or a change yourself before you jump to tweet about it. I I actually believe that personal transformation is one of the keys here. I think both Aziz and I have talked about that in our own personal stories, and and to a certain extent, so did J.T., and so did you, Ruthie, from your your course at Barnard, which by the way, I really want to take that class now. Um I really wonder what I would do. Um but um phenomenal. Yeah, it sounds amazing.

But I but I think part of why it's amazing is because we know that as you as we've been talking about like politics and and big picture decision making ultimately comes down to people and the choices that they make, and in order to have any modicum of clarity, I mean, Aziz was talking about Palestinian authors reading Raja Shehadeh, I I let the story wash over me and let it sit with me and wonder what does it mean to me about my own grandparents. The first 20 years of my political consciousness was entirely shaped around the idea of stopping the settlements and promoting a two-state solution. To to shift away from that as an it is an acknowledgement that the settlement enterprise won. They won.

We weren't six we didn't succeed in stopping that, and now it's so big that we have to like deal with it as a new reality. This is not casual, this is not happy, this is not, oh well, whoops, we were wrong, and now we're it's just about the painful facing of like facing the painful truth of what's happening on the ground.

[1:25:52] J.T. Rogers: If anyone can be neutral, you know, you are neither like you said in the beginning, you're neither Israeli nor Palestinian, Jewish nor Muslim. How did your thinking about the conflict change before you started writing the play and after you wrote the play and now adapted uh the screenplay for HBO Max? The truth is, Ruthie, that you're so focused, or I'm so focused on telling a story and erasing yourself when I'm making a a play, that some of these profound questions I never even ask myself to the end. So it was a process late in the rehearsal process. So one of the actors sidled up to me and said, So, hey, J.T., do you think it was a good idea that they did it? And I thought, I've never asked myself that.

I'm an artist, and the act of making art is inherently optimistic. My bias is towards that, not towards Israel, towards Palestine, towards Islam, towards Judaism. And so I have to I have to own that. So when I say that if any what I did feel or think, perhaps a better word by the end of writing this process and living these people in and is that whatever happened afterward, whatever can be seen as mistakes, small or gigantic or misunderstandings of what the Oslo process was that became certainly American media, it was presented as something it was not at all, which I think caused a great deal of consternation down the road. All of his things and so well said by Libby because he's die you know dissected.

Again, from my point of view as an artist, I don't know how you can't not try. I don't know how you can not that that in some way without in any way diminishing the heartbreak and the bloodshed that has continued, um in the last 30 years. That going back to what Libby was saying about X only happens because four years earlier Y happened, I do believe, admitting my bias freely, that this is if nothing else part of a long chain of events that I hope to lead to peace.

[1:28:04] Ruthie Fierberg: I have a thousand more questions for both of you, and I wish I could go on and on and on, but I will I will end with this question that is a little, you know, the the peace process, we call it a process because it is ongoing and we look, you know, to the future in the moment of right now. What is the some of the best ways that listeners can ease the suffering of Israelis and Palestinians in this moment?

[1:28:36] Libby Lenkinski: This podcast and this platform is about theater and about Broadway. And I in terms of easing suffering, um, I really I really do believe that art is um is a really important part of this picture. Um it's important in terms of changing hearts and minds, but it's also important um because I I think that one of the sources of pain that can be in some way addressed abroad when by people who are not necessarily on the ground and experiencing violence and and those kinds of stakes, um, is making the stories heard, is putting the stories on stage um I think that I think that people in the region and people who have experienced firsthand like Aziz has and like I have the losses, the personal losses, the death um often these things get really flattened in the stories that are told abroad.

There's a lot of um comfort and satisfaction and empowerment that comes from seeing yourself, your stories represented on the big stage on the big screen on the big earbud. Um and I think that's I I I don't think that that's a small thing. I think it might be among the more important things is people feel feeling seen and heard being known that their story and their perspective is known and appreciated around the world.

[1:30:21] Aziz Abu Sarah: Um yeah I I'll stop there. Yeah we agree. That's what I was thinking of as well. I I I know um one of the main gurus in in conflict resolution peace building Jean Paul Lederach he was asked when things look so dire and you feel there's nothing you can do what's what's left there. What what can be done? And he said keep telling the stories and I think it's very true. Um humanizing people hearing about not just the stories of the suffering but also who they are, the the culture, the that you know, for me as Palestinian, I I don't want people to see us only also as victims, although that's part of it being a victims of occupation, but it's not only that, seeing us as a human being, people who have dreams, people who have goals, people who want to achieve things in life, I I think that's very important.

But also for those who have more of the time, connect with some of the organizations. Some we mentioned, you know, from New Israel Fund to the Combatants for Peace to Parents Circle. There are so many amazing organizations. Connect with them if you have time to help them in some of their programming. There are people who come to the states from there all the time to do to meet with people, tell their stories, be there for them, help them reach more audience. Um, that's how transformation happened, it's through these meetings.

[1:31:54] Aziz Abu Sarah: Maybe I'll end with this. My my father is kind of the person I fight with the most, but the most kind of interesting person in our family for for stories, because he's uh troublemaker, he's eighty four years old now, and keeps causing trouble every time I take him somewhere uh with me. But I invited him to a meeting of the Parent Circle Bereaved Families Forum. Uh, and that was I was then the chairman and I invited him because I thought he'll be proud of me, and you know, I knew he wasn't into the peace work at that point yet, but I thought he'll come anyway because I was organizing this conference. And he came, listened to everything, and at the end they asked if anybody has questions, and he raised his hand.

And I knew at that moment I did the biggest mistake in my life to bring him to this event because he was gonna ask something horrible, and he did. He stood up and said, I do not know if the Holocaust really happened. So, this Holocaust thing is a real or not. And you know, if anybody starts anyway a question with this Holocaust thing, um, you know it's not gonna be a constructive comment. And it was a moment of silence. Nobody knew how to answer him. Even though I would argue every Palestinian almost in that room had the same question, and every Israeli in that room knew that this question is looming in Palestinians' mind. But we were we were too nice to each other to wanna upset each other.

And eventually a guy named Rami Elhanan, whose daughter was killed by a Palestinian suicide bomber, stood up and said, I don't expect you to believe in something you never learned about. So I will have my dad, his father, who's uh a Holocaust survivor who was in Auschwitz, take you to the Holocaust Museum and tell you his story. And they did that. My dad went with him, but not alone. 70 other Palestinians who all had family members lost in in the conflict, ended up showing up to that meeting, going with Rami's dad through the Holocaust memorial, having probably one of the hardest days of dialogue we ever had, tons of hard questions where people decided we're not gonna hide our questions, we'll be honest, we'll ask what we have.

And that was, I think, one of the most powerful meetings I ever expected, uh ever attended, but also the biggest transformation I've seen, and it happened because of a story, because of a question. That's what stories can do, and a result of it, the Israelis in the organization said, You were willing to listen to our story, we want to listen to yours. Not to compare, not to compete, but to really know you. And so two weeks later, we ended up taking about 70 people from the Israeli side to a Palestinian village that was destroyed in 1948 with people who lived in that village. And again, it was another just transformational event. And we did it not through telling history in 1948 as heaven. It was through telling the story of members of the organization.

When you hear the story, it goes through you. It affects you, it changes you. While facts and numbers, as important as they are, unfortunately don't inspire us to change, even though they can be very important. And yes, we need them and we need to learn them. They don't usually inspire us to change. Stories do. So tell those stories.

[1:35:27] Ruthie Fierberg: Wow. Thank you so much for sharing that. Thank you both for sharing all of your expertise. I mean, like I said, I could go on for hours and hours, but instead, we will just put in the show notes where people can find more of your work and your writing, and um, you have to watch Aziz's National Geographic series Conflict Zone. It is incredible. I can't wait for the day I can go on a MEDJI tour. Like I have so many plans for the future. One of the reasons that I make the work I do is so I get to meet people that teach me things, and I'm just listening to you, Libby and Aziz. It's just such a privilege. I'm like, oh yeah, let me write that down. Ooh, let me write that down. That's a really interesting idea.

So thank you both for more. I mean, your kind words about my play is lovely, but really just getting a chance to hear your thoughts is as experts in the you know, I am the you know, as the artist, you get to you get to play in the sandbox, then you leave, and you move on to something else, and uh you are not an expert. Um, so anyway, thank you for that. Thank you for sharing time with me. I am just so grateful to you, and um, so thank you, J.T. and Libby and Aziz for being so generous with your time and your knowledge and your hearts.

[1:36:42] Ruthie Fierberg: Thank you so much, Ruthie.fm slash WWT or Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. And don't forget to leave a review and tell your friends. Our theme music is by Benjamin Velez. Why We Theater is recorded in part on the traditional lands of the Wapinger and Lenape peoples. I acknowledge this land was unjustly taken from them, and pay my respect to elders both past and present. Special thanks to Dory Berenstein, Alan Seales, Lee Silverman, Patrick Taylor, Tony Montaneri, Wesley Birdsall, Elena Mayer, and Suzanne Chipkin. For more resources for change, info about our guests, and more, visit us at YWeTheater.com.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred