Today’s episode is the second half of my recent discussion with author Grace Barnes whose fascinating new book it titled: National Identity and the British Musical — From Blood Brothers to Cinderella... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
Featured Shows
About
Today’s episode is the second half of my recent discussion with author Grace Barnes whose fascinating new book it titled:
National Identity and the British Musical — From Blood Brothers to Cinderella.
In this conversation we explore how British national identity has, and often has not, been dramatized in British musical theater, and among the topics that we discuss are the musicals Blood Brothers, Mama Mia, Billy Elliott, The Last Ship, Bend It Like Beckham, and the current smash hit SIX, and, of course, the tremendous impact and domination that the mega musicals of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Cameron Mackintosh have had on the British musical theatre industry.
We also discuss why UK critics so seldom give any serious consideration to musical theater , the near complete absence of female voices in British musical theater, and the future of British musicals.
Grace Barnes is an independent scholar, director, and playwright who has worked as an associate and resident director on productions of My Fair Lady, Fiddler On the Roof, Into The Woods, Sunset Blvd, The Witches of Eastwick, Martin Guerre, West Side Story, and Guys And Dolls in the United Kingdom, Germany, and Australia. She has a PhD from the University of Technology in Sydney and her previous book is titled Her Turn Onstage — The Role Of Women In Musical Theatre.
Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Patron Club members including one of our newest members: Lois Hunter.
If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.
If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!
For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.
All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:03] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.
[0:18] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and today we have the second half of my recent conversation with Grace Barnes, whose new book is titled National Identity and the British Musicals, From Blood Brothers to Cinderella.
[0:31] David Armstrong: On today's conversation, we explore how British national identity has and often has not been dramatized in British musical theater.
[0:40] David Armstrong: And among the topics we discuss are Blood Brothers, Mama Mia, Billy Elliott, The Last Ship, the current smash hit Six, and of course the tremendous impact and domination that the mega musicals of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Cameron Mackintosh have had on the British musical theater industry.
[0:58] David Armstrong: We also discuss why UK critics so seldom give any serious consideration to musical theater, and also the absence of female voices in British musical theater.
[1:09] David Armstrong: If you missed the previous episode, you may want to catch up with that before embarking on this one.
[1:14] David Armstrong: This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our patron club members.
[1:19] David Armstrong: If you would like to help support the creation of this podcast, I'll have information at the end of the episode about how you too can become a patron.
[1:28] David Armstrong: Here we go.
[1:52] Grace Barnes: So did you hear the story of the Johnston twins? As like each other as two new pins of one womb born on the selfsame day. How one was kept and one given away. And did you never hear how the Johnstons died, never knowing that they shared one name? Until the day they died, when our mother cried, my own dear sons lie slain. And did you never hear of the mother? So cruel as a stone in place of her heart. Then bring her on. And come. Judge for yourselves how she came to play this part.
[2:39] David Armstrong: So let's talk about Blood Brothers, because that's one of the centerpieces of your book. You have a whole chapter around it and come back to it time and again. What do you see as the significance of Blood Brothers in terms of this subject matter?
[2:52] Grace Barnes: Oh, I think it's hugely significant in that it sort of encapsulates a lot of things that I talk about. It came from that socialist tradition of plays with music. I mean, people who don't like musicals say, well, I like Blood Brothers because it's not a musical. Well, it is a musical. But it also drew on that tradition of folk music. When it premiered, Barbara Dixon, who played the lead, played Mrs. Johnston, was a well-known folk singer and made a name for herself around the folk robes.
[3:24] Grace Barnes: A merry mad at dance. And now we came on with the chats. There you go. I think you're a blue. He said me eyes were deep blue pools, my skin was soft as snow. He told me I was sexier than Madeline Monroe. And we went dancing. We went and sing. Then, of course, I found that I was six weeks over chew. We got married at the registry, and then we had a two. We had Kelly salmon sandwiches, and how the ale did float. They said the bride was lovelier than Madeline Monroe. We went dancing.
[4:26] Grace Barnes: But it was also absolutely the first musical, really, that was holding a government to account in the genre of musical theatre and was saying, in the way that at that time it was the 80s, this is the Thatcher government, that plays were doing. But this is the first time a musical had actually gone. This is the result of your cuts. This is what it's doing to the working class, to the average working class person in Liverpool, which was a city which suffered enormously from the loss of industry, the loss of mining, the loss of trade, the loss of empire, you could argue. And Liverpool had been an enormously wealthy, prosperous, important city. And so for it to come out of Liverpool, for me it would have been the same for it to come out of Glasgow, that it was a city that had been glorious and was now mired in social deprivation.
[5:10] Grace Barnes: And Willie Russell was holding up a mirror to society, but doing it through musical theatre, which had never been done. And I think that Billy Elliott wouldn't exist if Blood Brothers hadn't existed. Everybody's Talking About Jamie wouldn't exist. I do feel that when you look at Girl from the North Country and compare it to Blood Brothers, you can see the similarities. It's going back to that socialist tradition of a play with music. I think Blood Brothers is enormously important. And I do to say in the book, it's the one musical that is on the school curriculum. So that if it's the only encounter that students have with a musical, it's Blood Brothers. It's still on the curriculum. It's not the curriculum in England. It's not on the curriculum in Scotland. I can't speak for Wales. And of course, as you point out, the major topic of British culture is class. And Blood Brothers is entirely about class or centers on the issues of class.
[5:59] Grace Barnes: And the theatre it came from, Liverpool Everman, I mean, that was Liverpool, North of England, Scotland, had this enormous tradition of socialist theatre, and Liverpool particularly, so Willie Russell was well versed in those techniques where narrator is breaking the fourth wall, the band is on stage. Mickey, don't shoot Teddy. He's your brother. You had a twin brother. I couldn't afford to keep both of you. His mother couldn't have kids. Why didn't you give me away, Mum? I could have been him. I could have been him! And do we blame superstition for what came to pass? Or could it be what we the English who come to know as class? Did you ever hear the story of the Johnston twins? It's like each other's two new pins.
How one was kept and one given away. How they were born and they died on the selfsame day. It was very John Littlewood, 20 years later. There's a handful of other cities it could have come out of. It's like Everybody's Talking About Jamie could really only have come out of the north of England. The context of class is so important. Does that answer the question?
[7:18] David Armstrong: I don't think it does.
[7:20] Grace Barnes: Absolutely. Maybe ironically, I'm not sure what the right word is, but it becomes a giant hit. It runs for how many years in the West? But not the first time around. So the first time it goes into the West End, it was very, very sniffy critics. Billington saying, more or less, why is this even on stage? It was a bit of the interlopers, you know, the people who were coming down with their working class theatre and putting it into the West End, and we don't really want this. It's quite an interesting story. It was taken up by very, very popular Radio 2 BBC, very middle of the ground radio station, started playing Barbara Dixon's Tell Me It's Not True. So that song became big. Tell me it's not true. Say it's just a story. Something on you. Tell me it's not true. Before me. Say it's just a dream. Say it's just a scene. From an old movie. From an old movie with Mamelone.
[8:49] Grace Barnes: But the initial show did not run, and it closed after three months, I think. Willie Russell was very bruised by it, the whole company was very bruised by this complete battering that they had had in the West End, except from Time Out, a sort of a younger audience were latching onto it. And they closed it and it disappeared. And producer kept going to Willie Russell and saying, please let me do this again. Please let us do it again. And it went on tour, but he kept saying, I don't want it to go into the West End until finally Bill Kenwright and the director Bob Thompson persuaded him to come and see it and say you need to see the audience reaction to this. In cities that had a big working class population, he agreed that it could go back into the West End and it ran, I think it's 25 years.
It's not that long since it closed. During the entire mega musical era, it's still there. Standing defiantly in the midst of all this excess was this one show about working class Britain that was putting in the same way as verbatim theatre does. It was putting a real story on stage that people identified with because they didn't see it and they didn't see it anywhere else.
[9:52] David Armstrong: And do you think it had a different audience from the Mega Musicals, or how much crossover was there?
[9:57] Grace Barnes: I think it had a different audience in the beginning, but I think once people started going to theater because the mega musical brought them in, Blood Brothers became another thing they went to. I often wondered what American tourists made of Blood Brothers in London. I've often wondered if they understood what it was doing. I saw the Broadway production with Patula Clark at one point. It had Sean Cassidy and David Cassidy in it as the two boys, all of whom were terrific. They gave fantastic performances. But it was a little mystifying, I have to say, for an American. I didn't quite, of course, I understood the story and I understood what it was about, but it didn't connect, I think, with Americans in the same way.
And I think they were smart to put stars in it. So you could appreciate, and of course, they had some terrific songs in it, and there was so much about it that was good. But I do have to say for myself at least, I didn't fall in love with it or was emotionally devastated by it or anything. I think it reflected and there was huge anger in sections of the country that had lost mining, had lost the steelworks, they'd lost shipbuilding. There was huge sections of the population that were very, very angry in the 80s. And I think Blood Brothers gave voice to that. It gave voice to a section of the population that did not have a voice, and certainly did not have a voice in musical theater. Audiences in Liverpool or Newcastle or Glasgow were seeing themselves reproduced on stage in a musical in a way that they had never seen before.
[11:20] Grace Barnes: Which is possibly why it baffled Americans.
[11:23] David Armstrong: I think so.
[11:24] Grace Barnes: It was very specific to the British experience. We have class issues here as well, but they're not the same. And anyone who had lived through Thatcher absolutely understood what Willie Russell was doing and applauded it or not.
[12:24] Grace Barnes: And just to follow up on something you said earlier, those kinds of issues were happening in non-musical theater, were being embraced by non-musical theater and by the critics of non-musical theater. So it's really the fact that this is now being taken up by musicals that is the disconnect with the establishment and with the critics.
[12:41] Grace Barnes: Sure, I mean, drama at that time was absolutely searing condemnations of the government and the disenfranchised of a section of the population that was getting bigger and bigger. You know, we talk about the angry playwrights at the Royal Court. You know, there's always an angry play at the Royal Court about society. And you would find that in Liverpool, in Glasgow, in Sheffield, they were producing working-class drama, which was absolutely holding up a mirror to society and saying to the government, this is what you've done. Why are we accepting this? But Blood Brothers was the first time a musical had done that. So openly.
[13:28] Grace Barnes: Interestingly, as I said earlier, Billy Elliott was not produced at the time of the minor strike. Again, it's nostalgia. It's 20 years since the minor strike that Billy Elliott comes on scene. Once we build visions on round reviews, we read up justice and of men reviews. All people equal in all things. We once were heroes, there's been a refashioning of the minor strike as something noble. And that's very important in the socialist history in the socialist context is that it's become this noble fight that ultimately they were defeated. So we won proudly and we will throw together, we will go as one. The ground is enemy and both as hell, but we all go together when we go.
[14:37] Grace Barnes: So that there's a very different context for Billy Elliott. And also in those 20 years, the mega musical has drawn many, many more people into theatre of a much wider class range. So people who 20 years ago would have said, theatre's not for me, unless it's the Panto, were going to theatre, were going to see musicals. So you have an audience that is now watching Billy Elliott, and it's a completely different audience that would have watched it 20 years before because they wouldn't have watched it. They would not have appreciated this refashioning of the minor strike as noble because at the time it was absolutely not depicted as that. But the people who were seeing Billy Elliott came from the generations whose parents were minors, you know, whose family were minors of generations, or were the shipbuilders that was The Last Ship, you know, The Last Ship didn't go to London but played in places in the north where those were shipbuilding families for generations that now had no shipbuilding. So there was an appreciation on a different level.
[15:35] Grace Barnes: And do you think that makes it less impactful or more impactful? I mean, in one way, it's being seen by a much wider audience and much more diverse, I guess, at least in terms of a larger segment of society, is seeing the show than probably saw Blood Brothers even during its 20-year run.
[15:52] Grace Barnes: Well, I think with Billy Elliott, Billy Elliott is an interesting one because an audience member could divorce themselves from the context of the minor strike and focus on the story of a little boy who wants to dance. But someone who had lived through the minor strike, perhaps even been a minor, will latch on to much more viscerally, the opening of Act Two, which is the Working Man's Club and the parody of the government at the time.
[16:23] Grace Barnes: Hey, Santa Wata! Can you hear it in the district? Can you sense farm? Is it old Rudolphia? Is it Santa on Eastlea? It's heading up to Eastern. It's coming down the tight. Oh, it's bloody Maggie Thatcher. And Michael Hessel Tai. So Merry Christmas, Maggie Thatcher, may God's little free with you. We all sick again out in one breath. Woo! Merry Christmas, Maggie Thatcher. We all celebrate today because it's one day.
[17:12] Grace Barnes: I mean, people still loved that, but they're getting a very different meaning from that number than a 15, 16-year-old who is engaged in the story of Billy wanting to dance, whereas the father, the grandfather, mother, maybe going, that's what it was like. I remember that. That's that government that we all hated and still despise. They're all getting a big dose of history in the process. Sure. But some of them may have lived through it. So have a visceral connection to that in the same way as I've talked about with The Last Ship. If they've lived through, if they're ex-shipbuilding families, that show has a particular resonance that it's not going to have in London or with American tourists.
[17:47] Grace Barnes: Or in America. It's interesting because Billy Elliott was a big hit everywhere, in spite of having very specific British politics at the center of it, and large segments of the show involved in things that Americans would mostly know nothing about. They, of course, know who Margaret Thatcher is and the idea of Margaret Thatcher and what she did because she was hand in hand with Reagan doing a lot of the same kinds of things. You can divorce yourself from the politics of Billy Elliott and engage in the story of the little boy. The Last Ship is more difficult to divorce yourself from it because it's what it's about. And also Billy Elliott had the advantage of being based on a very effective movie. And when you're writing a new story, which The Last Ship was an original story, that's a much bigger burden.
[18:30] Grace Barnes: I always tell students, most musicals are based on something existing source material. Sure. It can be done, it's been done, but that's why it's so rare. It's really hard. So, you know, and Sting, as a great songwriter, but not an experienced musical theater songwriter, may have suffered from that if everyone's having to create something original here without a story spine that you know is gonna work, even if you have to translate it into a different medium.
[19:06] Grace Barnes: Sure. Follow get to the shipyards, I'll end up in jail, and the last ships wall through the trails and the cracking of chumbers. The noise at the end of the world in your ears, and Yuri is as a mountain of steel, makes its way to the sea, and the last ship sails. What have I done? And what about the station life you become? In the name of the Father, in the name of the Son, and no matter the weave of this life that shifts one on the earth are in heaven. Under the sun, when the last ship sails, the chains and the cracking of chumbers, the noise at the end of the world in your ears, as a mountain of steel makes its way to the sea, and the last ship sails.
[20:29] David Armstrong: Grace and I will be back right after this quick break.
[20:58] David Armstrong: In fact, you title one of your chapters that we don't hold up Broadway as being incredibly successful or filled with women creators. But I have to say, in comparison, there's nobody in British thing. And you know, I wrote a whole book about this, about I didn't, no. Oh, I have a book called Her Turn on Stage, which was not my title, which is about the place of women of musical theater. There's a few things that contribute to it. One is, and I talk about in the book, one is that theatre in the UK is still run mainly by white middle-class men. It's like the Tory party, you know, they were all at school together and they give each other jobs. It's not a world where women have been in the UK, apart from Joan Littlewood, who incidentally was the first woman to be nominated for a Tony as a director, director of a musical. It's a world where women don't really exist.
[21:45] Grace Barnes: These men have been at all-male schools, they then go to elite universities. Women are not really part of that. And I think musical theater, there's two things with musicals. One, the irony of the lack of the female voice is look who goes to see them. It's women. Women buy the tickets, and women are being sold and marketed to, but they're being sold a product that has a male voice all over it. And very often these shows are about women, ostensibly about women. I'm watching a show going, Well, this is your version of what women are, which is nothing like myself or my friends, but everybody's buying it because there's nothing else for us to go to, which I think absolutely explains the appeal of Mama Mia and the longevity of Mama Mia, is an all-female team who know exactly who they were talking to. They knew exactly who that audience was and how to tap into that.
[22:31] Grace Barnes: I think there is, I'd have to look it up because I can't remember her name in the book, a United Nations investigator who said that there is a pervasive misogyny in the UK. Now, I think that is apparent. It's the culture of you know, kicks like a girl, dresses like a girl. I think there is a misogynistic undertone, certainly in that quite upper middle-class echelon. I also think that the mega musical has a lot to answer for in terms of keeping women out. Because societal power, a lot of it is dictated by financial power. Now, the mega musical produced such enormous profits for a handful of men. They're not going to share that. They're certainly not going to share that with women. It's a much wider societal thing. We still talk about the gender pay gap. If you have access to money, you have access to power. So keeping women out of that is deliberate.
[23:18] Grace Barnes: And I do think, I mean, I have written about this, I've engaged in study of it for 20 years. I don't think that the lack of a female voice in the UK musical theatre scene is coincidental. I think it is absolutely deliberate. I mean, I was very often the only female in the room, but it is deliberate. There is a belief that women can't handle a musical. Maybe it's to do with the budgets, or they don't understand it. Where the irony is it's a female audience being given an inauthentic depiction of women on stage, and they accept it because there's no option. I mean, I think we talked earlier about Maiden Dagenham. I mean, that is the classic example. An all-male creative team is telling a story about female empowerment.
And I say in the book, we've come leaps and bounds in terms of race. We agree that it is no longer appropriate, it never was appropriate for a show that is not white to be told by a bunch of creatives who are white. But it's perfectly acceptable for men to be in control of the female voice and female stories. The reason it continues in the UK is because the critics don't see musical theatre as worthy of serious interrogation as to the meanings it's producing. Of course, the big exception, and possibly the only exception, to what we were just talking about is Mama Mia. And you mentioned that earlier, but that is entirely the creation of a female team and very much about things that are of concern to women that women can readily clearly identify with.
I've produced that show, I've seen that show. Women go crazy for it. And what is baffling is that Mama Mia spawned endless jukebox musicals, but it didn't open the door for any creative women to enter musical theater.
[24:54] Grace Barnes: You'd think that producers would go, they know something that we don't, bring them in. But no. And I think it has got worse. It's got far worse. Part of the problem in musical theater in the UK not being regarded as culturally significant is that this is not interrogated by the critics. If the national put on a play with an all-male, all-white creative team, a critic would pull them up for it. But musical theater is not regarded, who cares? Is the attitude. Whereas you're seeing time and time again all male, all white creative teams on musical theater in the UK, and no one picks up on it. No one comments on it. But if it was an all-white team in charge of a black story, that wouldn't happen.
But it's perfectly acceptable to have men in charge of women's stories and voices. And no one seems to think that there's anything wrong with this. And I do talk about something that no one picks up on except Frank Rich way, way, way back in the days of Starlight Express. There is a veil of misogyny that underlines Andrew Lloyd Webber's work that no one ever picks up on. No one discusses. I think we're all aware of it, but no one actually calls anybody to account for it. I mean, the fact that in a 40-year career he's worked with one female director and two book writers, and Cameron would be the same. The national has not had a woman in charge of a musical on the main stage. So it's not coincidental.
And I also have to say that the female characters at the center of those shows are in great contrast, I think, to the women in American musicals. In my course, I just spent a whole day talking about the one of the major themes of the Broadway musical is transgressive women. Women at the center of shows who do not do what society wants them to do in the time period of the story or even the time period of when the musical was made. That the musical was always centering itself around these women who are quite astounding when you put them all together. You look at 40 shows that all do the same thing. Exceptions to that are the British musicals. Well, you've got Mrs. Johnson and Blood Brothers, which is 1982, and then you have 20 years later, you have Donna and Mama Mia, which is 20 years later.
That's it. I argue that that is an absolute result of an all-male team. Whether it is deliberate or not, the women do not have agency. I mean, for me, the most recent example would be everybody's talking about Jamie. You go, here's this character, that's fine, that's all that story, but the women around him have absolutely no agency, completely conforming to outdated tropes. I mean, I think Stacey Wolfe talks about that with Hamilton, saying, because there's such strides taken in how we're approaching race, we are failing to notice that the women are completely irrelevant to the story, and actually we're just reproducing outdated victim narratives. And no one picks up on it. And of course, all the shows that I'm talking about also played in London.
Most of them were giant hits during the last hundred years, and yet somehow that didn't rub off. That's so interesting. For the other book I wrote, I interviewed the late great Gillian Lynn, and she said to me, she said, I do believe that men in England don't really like women. And I thought that was very interesting. I would tend to agree. I also think it is another aspect of the class divide. When you've got a sort of boys' club, an exclusive white boys' club, that door is not going to open to women, even now. Even now, it still doesn't. I mean, the Almeida just did Tammy Faye Baker, all male creative team, all male banned, telling a story about a woman. And I'm going, well, are you really the right person to tell that story? I would dispute that you are, as I am not the right person to tell a story about Bob Marley.
[28:22] Grace Barnes: So we understand that, but the gender one doesn't matter. That Cinderella. So sad, Cinderella. She's a loner, she's a loon, a loser, that's all me. Go from the gutter, unpleasant peasant, no one a nutter, unwelcome present, cruel tones you mutter, every insult that you utter middle. Call me back, Cinderella Nazi goes. Your unkind nurse and shun me. Well forget to you. You have an entire chapter, as would be expected, about Andrew Lloyd Webber and about his long history. You know, you have to give him credit, it's an amazing history of what he has been able to do. And yet, in some ways he's the opposite of what the topic of your book is about. Because you contend his shows do not reflect the national identity of Britain, and not really of England either.
[29:44] Grace Barnes: No, and actually, his refusal to engage in that debate is interesting in itself. The stories are grand sweeping narratives. The only time that he twice sort of went near British identity was the Beautiful Game, which was, well, the whole other issue about the beautiful game, which is him being establishment and England telling a story about Northern Ireland, Catholics, possibly not the best person to tell it. And then the Stephen Ward musical. And let's just make sure everybody understands those shows, because those just shows, of course, didn't come to the United States. The beautiful game is centered around football, right? Soccer. Beautiful Game was 2000, and it was set in Northern Ireland and focused on a Catholic football team.
But it was written by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Ben Elton, neither of whom are Northern Irish or Catholic. At a time where the troubles were only, we were only, I think, two or three years beyond the Good Friday Agreement. It was possibly not the right time to be telling that story, and they were not the right people to tell that story. And it became what I argue is an English view of one of the smaller nations without ever actually engaging with that nation. It was cultural appropriation at its worst, I feel. That's my opinion. Then Stephen Ward, the profumo affair was a political scandal from the 60s, where a cabinet minister had been having an affair with do I say Kolgorl? Yes, who was also having an affair with a Russian spy and it ended up he had to resign.
And I think we saw that in one of the episodes of The Crown. Well, it's rehashed and rehashed and rehashed. Everybody knows the profumo affair. My issue, of course, is that we never see it from the girls' point of view. That those two young women, their lives were ruined, completely ruined, and they were dismissed as money-seeking, you know, the worst of society. Whereas they were completely manipulated by Stephen Ward, and this musical was basically putting a case forward for Stephen Ward, who was brought to court and was never tried because he killed himself, but was brought to court for soliciting. And the book it was based on I actually got it here. How the English Establishment Framed Stephen Ward is by Caroline Kennedy and Philip Knightley, so it was Americans.
That was sort of making a case that the establishment got off because they blamed Stephen Ward for it. And you go, well, they were all particularly unpleasant people. That was Andrew Lloyd Webber's sort of one foray into let's reflect British society. But again, it's 50 years ago that scandal happened. It's been told and told, and I don't know what the point of was retelling it. It didn't last very long. He's very English establishment. He ingratiated himself with the royal family. He has a title. He sat in the House of Lords. It's sort of everything that is the antithesis of Catholic Northern Ireland for a start. Does he reflect British society? No, I don't think he does. I think I say in the book, possibly his most authentic reflection of British society was his requiem. Certainly a British ecclesiastical tradition, a choral tradition.
[32:31] Grace Barnes: And what about cats? It's based on a set of poems that in America we don't know anything about. So I assume those poems have some place in the hearts of British people of a certain generation at least. I don't know. I can't answer that because I certainly was not aware of them. But I grew up in Scotland. I knew T.S. Eliot was, but I don't know that they are ingrained in British society as Alice in Wonderland is. I don't know. He certainly made them popular. I could be wrong. I just assumed that was a popular childhood memory that he that other people shared. No, I mean I would have thought it would be A.A. Milne, it would be Winnie the Pooh, it would be Beatrix Potter before that. I don't know, I could be wrong.
I certainly had never heard of it. Yeah, interesting. Now and forever, David. Now and forever. Exactly. It didn't quite go that long, but almost. I remember I lived in New York during all the 80s and the 90s, and that giant above the winter garden theater where they have the largest billboard in New York, and it just said now and forever, therefore what seemed like forever.
[33:32] David Armstrong: Yeah, we thought it was a joke.
[33:33] Grace Barnes: To the point where you believed it might happen.
[33:35] David Armstrong: Yeah. No, when it first went up, people were like we're rolling their eyes, and it's like, well, I guess they knew something we didn't know.
[33:41] Grace Barnes: Utterly. The thing with Lloyd Webber is yes, you could say he rescued the British musical from obscurity, but did he also then create a monster which is now very difficult for us to get beyond because he's so inexorably linked with the British musical. So what is the future of the British musical? What do you see?
[33:57] Grace Barnes: Um, Andrew Lloyd Webber is on his way out, who knows how soon he could very well ride another giant hit. But you know, both he and Cameron Mackintosh are of a certain age and are probably winding down their careers. Certainly based on the lack of success of bad Cinderella, it will be interesting to see if he has an opportunity to come back after that.
[34:20] Grace Barnes: Well, you see, I don't believe either of those men are winding down. I think the grip is as ferociously tight as ever. And I end the book by talking about, oh, I think it was Britain's Got Talent, and then it was just after lockdown and Cameron's going on saying, you know, the British musical is back, but it was all his shows. There wasn't anything he hadn't produced that was a segment. And I don't think either of them have any intention of going quietly into the night. I think they will keep their hold on theaters, which affects, as I said earlier, affects what shows go on. They will keep reproducing, not even reinventing, just redoing the old shows. I mean, Saigon is about to come to Australia at the opera house.
I cannot see a time when Les Miz is not open. Phantom is still on in London. I don't think they're going anywhere. And I think that without those gates being opened to other voices, and that there seems to be no sign of that happening. I mean, the RSC did The Boy in the Dress, which again, all white, all male creative team. Nothing's changing in the British musical. And nobody's demanding change. That's the sad thing. And there's nobody waiting in the wings that you can identify as even the potential future.
[35:26] Grace Barnes: No, I could be wrong, and I'm probably way out of the loop. But I'm not aware of any of the rep companies, apart from Sheffield and Jamie, producing new work that is going to make an impact. That's another issue I'd bring up in the book is that the regional theatres, what we call the rep companies, are creating work to appeal to a very specific audience. Now the audience in Sheffield, which produced everybody's talking about Jamie, is a very, very different audience to the audience of Chichester, which produced Flowers for Mrs. Harris. Two completely opposite poles of the class spectrum. Either of those produce work that goes into the West End, it's only representative of a very particular brand of society or section of society.
So there is that issue as well. The proclaimer's musical in Scotland is not going to make money in the West End. Americans would be even more baffled by that one. So I don't I don't know what the future is. I think maybe the future is going back, certainly in Scotland, going back to the play with music. I mean you could argue that was War Horse.
[36:25] Grace Barnes: Yes. It certainly felt like a musical. But was billed as a play. It was a play, but the experience of it, certainly the visual experience of it, the staging of it felt like a musical to a great extent. Well, I was resident director on Warhorse. The person who wrote the music, John Tams, came out to rehearsal, and I mean he absolutely comes from that socialist folk music tradition, which is very evident in Warhorse. I think maybe that will come. I mean, I think the huge success of Girl from the North Country, even though technically it's not British, I mean, he's Irish and Bob Dylan is American, but that to me is a play with music. And struck a chord with British audiences in a way it didn't really in America.
[37:01] David Armstrong: Oh, really?
[37:09] Grace Barnes: But it was last season on Broadway and only ran a few months. Of course, Phantom now is closed on Broadway. There's no Andrew Lloyd Webber show on Broadway anymore for the first time in forty-something years. So I think my perspective is gonna be different than sitting there in the UK and seeing that still dominance of the West End. Les Mis is still running. Les Mis hasn't been running in New York for 20 years. It's also had an impact on what the British audience expect from a British musical. They expect either a jukebox show or they expect this huge extravaganza. Everybody's talking about Jamie, I think he's a grandchild of Blood Brothers. Very modest show in that regard. And also it's set in working class Sheffield.
You know, that school is the antithesis of Goodbye, Mr. Chips. It's been taken up by a younger audience in a way. I mean, I think the show to me is hugely problematic because of its treatment of women, but it has become a major hit. It is reflecting a section of society that does not usually have a voice in the British musical, which may account for its success.
[38:11] ♪ Musical number: "Six" — performed by Grace Barnes ♪
[39:35] Grace Barnes: One other show that people might point to as the future, certainly a giant hit in both the West End and Broadway right now, is Six, which I know you are not a big fan of. Well, my argument with Six is twofold. One, I would dispute the term musical. I don't think that is a musical. It's a concept. There's no script, there's no delineation between the characters. The songs do not move. There is no plot for the songs to move on. My bigger beef with Six is that I dispute its feminist credentials. I don't think that is a feminist voice. I don't think it's an authentic female voice either. And I think that what keeps getting ignored is that at its inception there were more men than women on the creative team.
That is not an authentic female voice. To me, Six is hugely problematic in terms of if that's the British musical, God help us. I think it's become a huge hit in the UK. I think it is an exercise in box ticking. It's very, very useful to present a front of look how open we are, look at all the women in musical theater. Whereas if you actually analyze how those women are portrayed, they're all over-sexualized victims. But I cannot deny that women love it. I don't know why. I don't get it. Some of the music is very catchy. I don't get it that they're being presented with over-sexualized victims and told this is feminism. It's that blurring between visibility equals agency. I don't think it does in the case of Six.
I don't think any woman is being empowered by Six, although the audience are. I can't deny that. And it may be the same issue because since each of those queens is based on a pop star, a big, you know, their persona and their style of dress and the way they sing. It's the same issue. You know what's interesting about Six, when it was originally produced, the women wore jeans and t-shirts. They were absolutely androgynous. And to me, that was far more empowering than when you have these hyper-sexualized female bodies on stage saying this is feminism and going, ooh, is it? Is that power or is that what men want to see? I think you're playing into what men want to see. But that's a whole other issue.
But I do dispute that it's a musical. I don't think you can say that that's a musical in the way that Hamilton's a musical. I'm sorry. I actually think it's a concept musical, and it's very much along the lines of you can sort of trace a line from A Chorus Line to Cats to Six, which basically all have a very similar form and all have a sort of contest at the center of them, which I think is germane to A Chorus Line and weird in Cats and even weirder in Six. But even in Cats, the cats had different personalities. We knew who they were. If you just listen to the songs, you'd think the same person was singing it and say, that's no real delineation of the character. We can talk about over-amplification and all those kinds of things.
So give us some hope. Can we end on some hope for the British musical theatre? Is there anything that you are—and there may not be? I don't need to. Maybe there is no hope. Is there hope? God, I hope so. I think if there was a return to the play with music, I think it's depressing that there is no real diverse voice. Although one show we didn't talk about was Bend It Like Beckham. That to me was real hope for the British musical.
[42:37] ♪ Musical number: "Bend It Like Beckham" — performed by Grace Barnes ♪
[45:04] Grace Barnes: Yes, and why isn't it touring? It seems like never toured. Yeah, never toured. I do know of a couple of theaters in America that were trying to do it. Also, that had again that had Howard Goodall. Now, Howard Goodall, I mentioned very early on, was the hired man. Howard Goodall, I believe, is the great British musical theatre composer who got kind of suffocated by the mega musical and went on often did other things. But if you listen to the soundtrack of Bend It Like Beckham, you can hear that these are people who know exactly what the musical form is and what it's supposed to do. I've feeling once you're ready to rescue risk having nothing to show. You'll have nothing. You don't have nothing to show.
Can you better your best? If not, then you're aiming to love. Wanna be stronger, wanna be stronger, want to sustain, want to sustain, gotta keep wishing, or keep pushing, gotta keep straining, gotta keep training, target, trying. Even when you're dying in pain. Love the pain. Gotta dream all you can dream. Gotta do all you can do. Gotta take it for the team. The big line of makes go perfect. We did end with a positive note. We did end with a positive note. Something for myself is who get to know that musical much better than I do. And I suspect a lot of the listeners will do so as well. What would be your go-to British musical? You're talking recent shows or the big mega shows, or um, what would what would be a musical for you that you go that is quintessentially British?
I see. Oliver. It's probably Oliver. I would say me and my girl, actually. Now I only saw that revival, which is in a way part of the mega musical era because I think it came to Broadway because of all the Brit hits happening. But I thought the show was completely delightful, and the comedy aspect of it was really, really funny and reflected that music hall sensibility, I think. Yeah, and I think that's not lost, which is a pity. And he was sensational in that. Robert Lindsay was phenomenal in it. So great. But it's a long time ago. That's the problem. That was a long time ago. That's been 30 years ago, hasn't it? 40. 40. Wow. Anyway, thank you, Grace Barnes. It has been such a pleasure to talk to you about national identity and the British musical from Blood Brothers to Cinderella. Thank you. I've really enjoyed our conversation. Thank you. Likewise.
[47:38] ♪ Musical number ♪
[48:00] David Armstrong: Now here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation. A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast dot supercast dot tech. That's Broadway Nation Podcast dot S-U-P-E-R-C-A-S-T dot tech. Or click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway National is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
