In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss the 1982 concert Showstoppers: The Best of Broadway... Read More
From the show: Cast Offs with Ben and Daniel
Featured Shows
About
In this episode, Ben and Daniel discuss the 1982 concert Showstoppers: The Best of Broadway. The evening is hosted by Tom Bosley and features Broadway favorites such as Ethel Merman, Barry Bostwick, Susan Browning, Len Cariou, Nell Carter, Diahann Carroll, Carole Demas, David Haskell, Glynis Johns, Donna McKechnie, Robert Morse, Pamela Myers, Stephen Nathan, Jerry Orbach, Anthony Perkins, Debbie Reynolds, Alexis Smith, and Ray Walston.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] Ben Rimalower: Broken records, the albums you wouldn't shut up about.
[0:06] Daniel Nolen: Broken records.
[0:07] Ben Rimalower: The music our guests can't live without like Judy, Barbara, Liza, Bett, Daddy, Audra, Bernadette.
[0:14] Daniel Nolen: We broadcast this podcast with hopes that someday we might get Patti LuPone.
[0:33] Ben Rimalower: Welcome to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World.
[0:37] Patti LuPone: I'm Patti LuPone.
[0:39] Daniel Nolen: Oh, and this is Daniel Nolen.
[0:41] Patti LuPone: Hey y'all.
[0:43] Daniel Nolen: Um today you get just another, you know, girl on girl action with your two co-hosts today, Daniel.
[0:52] Patti LuPone: Scissor fuck our way through.
[0:54] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[0:55] Patti LuPone: What's it called?
[0:57] Daniel Nolen: Showstoppers, the best of Broadway.
[0:59] Patti LuPone: Showstoppers.
[1:00] Daniel Nolen: Also known as that's singing.
[1:03] Patti LuPone: That's singing.
[1:05] Daniel Nolen: I prefer that because, uh, especially since two or three of these numbers were just extended dance sequences.
[1:12] Patti LuPone: Don't even get into it.
[1:13] Daniel Nolen: Do not even start yet.
[1:14] Patti LuPone: We are so not there yet.
[1:15] Daniel Nolen: Although I do think it should be with a question mark.
[1:17] Patti LuPone: That's singing?
[1:20] Daniel Nolen: Oh god.
[1:22] Patti LuPone: Um, but enough about Susan Browning.
[1:25] Daniel Nolen: Um, the first thing we need to talk about is Stars in the House, Seth Rudetsky, and James Wesley.
[1:35] Patti LuPone: Um, with special guest Randy Rainbow and extra special guest Donna Murphy, and extra, extra special guest, Patti Ann.
[1:44] Daniel Nolen: Wait, I don't think I—I was just watching it before this.
[1:47] Patti LuPone: I don't think I got to the part with Donna.
[1:49] Daniel Nolen: I mean, Donna came first.
[1:51] Patti LuPone: Oh, okay. Well, I only watched. I was watching Shut Up LuPone's Insta story, so that's why I only saw the parts that they were.
[1:58] Daniel Nolen: Shut up, LuPone.
[1:59] Patti LuPone: I mean, and you know, coming from me, take this as you will. Shut up, LuPone has a very narrow focus.
[2:07] Daniel Nolen: Truly.
[2:08] Patti LuPone: Um, but I did watch the part where Randy was talking and then they like suddenly dropped Patti in as a surprise.
[2:14] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[2:15] Patti LuPone: Did you see the part where they name checked me?
[2:17] Daniel Nolen: Rather, he did not.
[2:19] Patti LuPone: Patti, you didn't say, you watched what, like 25 seconds?
[2:22] Daniel Nolen: I watched the first third of it.
[2:24] Patti LuPone: No, uh that, uh, they talked about me right away.
[2:27] Daniel Nolen: She didn't say anything, he said me.
[2:29] Patti LuPone: Um, he was like the Ben Rimalower hour, and she was just like dead face, stony and cold.
[2:37] Daniel Nolen: Traumatizing for her.
[2:41] Patti LuPone: But I was actually scared because, um, the thing he was—Seth was like, Did you ever meet Patti before?
[2:48] Daniel Nolen: And Randy, um, said that, uh, or that he knew that a friend of his, a mutual friend had shown Patti his stuff, and then had—and the friend had shown Randy an email of Patti saying he's great.
[3:05] Daniel Nolen: Oh yeah, I did hear that.
[3:06] Patti LuPone: But that they didn't say your name, did they?
[3:08] Daniel Nolen: No, no, then he didn't. Then when Patti came on, they started talking, and then Randy said, Well, what happened was, uh, my friend Ben Rimalower showed me your email where you said that's great.
[3:20] Patti LuPone: Oh, okay. So, but the reason it made me uncomfortable was because also earlier in the week there was, um, or like earlier in the day, every day's a week now in quarantine times.
[3:32] Daniel Nolen: But, um, there's this guy on Twitter and Instagram and stuff, uh, named Tyler, um, Tyler Millady, fuck me, what's his last name?
[3:44] Patti LuPone: Jones?
[3:46] Daniel Nolen: Um yes, Tyler, Tyler, Tyler Murray Jones.
[3:49] Patti LuPone: Patty videos.
[3:50] Daniel Nolen: And, and yeah, he's in this hilarious Patty videos.
[3:52] Patti LuPone: And so then I sent it to Patti, and she said he's great, or something like that.
[3:57] Daniel Nolen: I love it.
[3:57] Patti LuPone: It's just like it's one of those stock responses on Google on Gmail. She probably just clicks it and pushes to send.
[4:04] Daniel Nolen: But so the thing is, so I sent—I copied, I screen grabbed that for him, and then he posted that, right? Now as you know, I have been down the valley of the shadow of death a couple of times.
[4:17] Patti LuPone: I did not give him Patti's contact information, you know.
[4:21] Daniel Nolen: Right, right.
[4:22] Patti LuPone: Um, but I was a little worried that someone would show her that his post, and that she would be like, Ben sent him my email.
[4:31] Daniel Nolen: You know.
[4:32] Patti LuPone: So I was like, I was like calming down, thinking like, okay, hours have gone by, my family didn't get COVID, and Patti didn't yell at me for like thinking that I gave her email out, right?
[4:44] Daniel Nolen: And then I'm watching like Stars in the House, like, you know, and then Randy says, Oh yeah, Ben Rimalower showed me your email.
[4:54] Patti LuPone: I was just waiting for her to be like, stop showing people my email.
[4:57] Daniel Nolen: No, Ben.
[4:58] Patti LuPone: Um, but anyway, uh, she was amazing and just eating the whole time.
[5:06] Daniel Nolen: I love it.
[5:07] Patti LuPone: It's, I mean, you need—oh, I'm so mad you didn't watch it with Donna Murphy because you have to take the journey through Donna into Patti, and then when it's Donna and Patti, and then saying hi to each other.
[5:20] Daniel Nolen: I mean, you missed the whole thing.
[5:22] Patti LuPone: We should just cancel everything.
[5:24] Daniel Nolen: Well, I was watching it right before we started this, so I would have—we would have had to have delayed this, uh, session.
[5:31] Patti LuPone: I mean, I would be happy to delay endlessly.
[5:34] Daniel Nolen: I mean, when else do you get to see Patti and Donna have like an awkward social interaction totally in like a Zoom session with Seth and his husband and Randy Rainbow?
[5:44] Patti LuPone: And, um, I love that. She did drop, she did, uh, talking about Randy's show, she didn't say Bernadette, which I was, you know, and so you missed the context for that because he had just said that he's like, you know, he was saying what an amazing week he'd had doing the show, and like one night, um, Joanna Gleason came, and one night, uh, uh, Donna Murphy came, and one night Bernadette Peters came.
[6:10] Daniel Nolen: And then Patti's like, um, she's like, Well, well was it what when was the show when when Bernadette and um and Joanna Gleason and and and somebody else came, somebody else was Donna Murphy that was like there on the show.
[6:24] Patti LuPone: Um, but she was like when she was like Bernadette and like Seth and James like fell off their chairs like dying, and then no, I saw that and then, uh, uh, and then Donna came in and, and Patti's like hi Donna.
[6:45] Daniel Nolen: And, and Donna was like, hi honey, how are you?
[6:49] Patti LuPone: I just—I love it.
[6:50] Daniel Nolen: I was living for it.
[6:53] Patti LuPone: I just wanted Randy—I mean, no, Randy and Seth want the same things we want, you know.
[6:58] Daniel Nolen: They were dead silent.
[6:59] Patti LuPone: I think you'd think their screens were frozen because they did not want to impede the conversation between Patti and Donna.
[7:05] Daniel Nolen: But it didn't continue long enough.
[7:07] Patti LuPone: Um wait, but but Patti and Donna don't have beef.
[7:11] Daniel Nolen: Well, okay, they don't call her all beef Patti for nothing.
[7:15] Patti LuPone: Okay.
[7:15] Daniel Nolen: Like it's true.
[7:18] Patti LuPone: Patti and Donna like are, you know, in the range of Patti's relationships with like her fellow divas, they are on good terms.
[7:27] Daniel Nolen: They did the workshops of um or readings rather of War Paint together.
[7:31] Patti LuPone: Right, right. As a matter of fact, uh, when I went to see Patti uh do The Lady with the Torch at 54 Below, Donna was there at the VIP VIP booth with um like, uh, Michael Grife and and Scott Frankel and Michael Corey, or I don't know, Michael Grife and and a couple of the other ones, Doug Wright, maybe.
[7:51] Daniel Nolen: Um, but you know, it's um, you know, I feel that it's tenuous with any woman that with any leading lady with any leading lady.
[8:03] Patti LuPone: I mean, you know, if they're under a certain age or over a certain age, it's okay.
[8:07] Daniel Nolen: That's so true.
[8:09] Patti LuPone: You know, but, uh, I mean, uh, what was I just thinking of?
[8:15] Daniel Nolen: Well, I told you about um, did I tell it on the pod already about um replacement Ava?
[8:20] Patti LuPone: Yes, you have.
[8:22] Daniel Nolen: I can't believe it's my favorite story, but tell it again for any new listeners.
[8:26] Patti LuPone: No, no, no, we're not recycling pod stories.
[8:29] Daniel Nolen: Um, but I do feel that what's that?
[8:32] Patti LuPone: I said since when? Terrible anyway, I do feel like Patti has a file on all actresses' worship.
[8:40] Daniel Nolen: Truly.
[8:40] Patti LuPone: It's like that, it's like that Joan Rivers joke file. Like Patti just has a little mental index part of everyone who's wronged her.
[8:46] Daniel Nolen: And it's not just like Bernadette and Glenn Close, like everybody came around.
[8:50] Patti LuPone: They have their own cabinet.
[8:52] Daniel Nolen: No, no, no, for sure. There's like a—there's like the theater, you know, the barn, and then there's like the Bernadette room.
[8:59] Patti LuPone: Bernadette basement.
[9:01] Daniel Nolen: But I feel that the files are on people you would not necessarily think would be like an issue, you know.
[9:07] Patti LuPone: Like, I mean, I'm talking about like the Judy Blazers, and you know, like I think it's deep.
[9:15] Daniel Nolen: Um so funny.
[9:17] Patti LuPone: Um anyway, those pretty nuts.
[9:21] Daniel Nolen: But I will say for Patti that um, like, you know, I mean, it's just funny to you have to watch it because you have to watch Patti and Donna because they're they're both crazy divas, and then they're also both real human beings.
[9:38] Patti LuPone: Yeah, but the ways in which they're a crazy diva and the ways in which they're a real human being are different, right?
[9:45] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[9:45] Patti LuPone: So, like there's some things about Donna there that are very like, uh—
[9:54] Daniel Nolen: Uh oh wait, hold on, Daniel. Let me call you right back.
[9:57] Daniel Nolen: Okay.
[9:57] Patti LuPone: Okay, we're recording now.
[10:01] Daniel Nolen: Okay, so I was saying that both Patti LuPone and Donna Murphy.
[10:05] Patti LuPone: Well, let me say, let me say what while you—you were running to the elevator to do something just now, and in that time, I quickly switched over to YouTube and watched the Patti and Donna interaction.
[10:18] Daniel Nolen: So I'm up to speed.
[10:20] Patti LuPone: Well, you know, they each have an aspect of their personality that is a grand, uh, diva, and they each have an aspect of their personality that is like a down-to-earth human being.
[10:31] Daniel Nolen: And it's just funny because those they're not the same.
[10:35] Patti LuPone: The ways in which Patti is human are different than the ways Donna is.
[10:39] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[10:40] Patti LuPone: And the ways Donna is human, you know, et cetera.
[10:42] Daniel Nolen: And the ways Patti is human is asking for more popcorn, and Donna's is, uh, not having a good Wi-Fi connection.
[10:49] Patti LuPone: Well, it's but also it's like, you know, so Donna has like proper lighting, she's wearing a beautiful dress, like it's simple, her hair's done.
[10:57] Daniel Nolen: You know, Donna, and she's like, even though she's in some sort of box office.
[11:02] Patti LuPone: Well, no, they both have like some little corner of their apartment or house or wherever where they record shit and where their printer is and all that crap, right?
[11:10] Daniel Nolen: So Donna turned on her lighting and did the whole thing as if she was doing a self-tape audition, you know.
[11:15] Patti LuPone: I mean, she could be going on Rachel Maddow and she would have given it the—give Seth Rudetsky the same treatment.
[11:21] Daniel Nolen: Patti's like, what? Seth wants me to call in and talk to Randy Rainbow. Oh, he's a hoot. Matt, give me the popcorn. You know, Matt's walking around in the background, I don't know what the fuck he's doing, you know.
[11:30] Patti LuPone: There's like no lighting whatsoever. I mean, Patti says she's pantsless.
[11:35] Daniel Nolen: You know, I mean, Pat—her thing is like, you know, there's a little bit of a sense, I don't want to say too cool for school because she's actually like being sort of sweet and lovely and generous, but there's just the sense that like she's like gracing us with this.
[11:47] Patti LuPone: Whereas Donna's a little more like Seth is my peer. I'm here to like appear on his show, you know.
[11:50] Daniel Nolen: Like Donna pays a little more respect to that, you know, whereas Patti's like, ah, honey, like we don't have to do that. We're all friends, you know.
[11:59] Patti LuPone: It's a little more like neighborhoody or something with Patti, but there's all—it's like a double-edged sword. On one hand, that makes Patti more down to earth and like, you know, there's a Yiddish word hemisha, like we're all just friends.
[12:12] Daniel Nolen: But on the other hand, it's a little bit more like grandiose because it's a little bit like, well, surely I don't have to like present for Seth Rudetsky.
[12:21] Patti LuPone: Right?
[12:21] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and I think that's—and it's—I see what you're saying, but I feel like that's a very like Ben Rimalower, like deep knowledge of Patti take on things.
[12:30] Patti LuPone: Cause like for me, just watching it, I was like, oh, like Patti is coming off as so human and just like lovely, and just one of the boys, you know, like in her sweats and eating popcorn, um, you know, in front of her, like, you know, uh PC or whatever.
[12:48] Daniel Nolen: And, and Donna's a little more like, you know, like Joan Crawford said, like, if you want the girl next door, go next door, it's like Donna seems like an actual, like she put in some work, she's actually presenting as a diva.
[12:59] Patti LuPone: Whereas Patti is a little more like proletariat, you know.
[13:03] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[13:03] Patti LuPone: Uh it's funny.
[13:05] Daniel Nolen: It is Patti is proletariat.
[13:07] Patti LuPone: She is proletariat.
[13:08] Daniel Nolen: I mean, also, um, I appreciated, I felt like Patti was right there with Randy. Like, no matter what Randy said, and Randy was like making some sharp turns and throwing stuff back in Patti's face.
[13:20] Ben Rimalower: He's just so smart.
[13:21] Daniel Nolen: But like Patti was able to like get it right away, whereas with the Donna interview, it felt a little more like there was like a digital delay and it was like nobody knew what the other one was talking about, you know.
[13:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.
[13:32] Daniel Nolen: Well then again, you know, Patti also has it served her on a platter.
[13:35] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Patti comes on and you know, Randy's like practically in tears, although Patti cried like four times, but you know, Patti cries anyway.
[13:43] Daniel Nolen: That's just Patti.
[13:44] Ben Rimalower: You know, but but but Randy's like right away, you know, you are my number one.
[13:48] Daniel Nolen: I felt uncomfortable that Donna was sitting there, you know.
[13:51] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.
[13:52] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I don't think he would have said that if Ms. Peters had been in the group soon.
[13:55] Ben Rimalower: No, no, no, no.
[13:58] Daniel Nolen: But then again, of course, Patti and Bernadette wouldn't have been in a Zoom together, you know, not for Seth Rudetsky, not for Rachel Matto, not for no one.
[14:05] Ben Rimalower: Right, right.
[14:07] Daniel Nolen: Um, yeah, I mean, yeah, I and I think, you know, Patti, I've been thinking a lot about Patti as we all know.
[14:14] Ben Rimalower: Oh my gosh.
[14:15] Daniel Nolen: What a what a cool winking.
[14:17] Ben Rimalower: Because, you know, on the Rosie broadcast, a lot of um what these actors were talking about, like they kept bringing up this idea of like, well, actors are insecure, you know that, Rosie.
[14:31] Daniel Nolen: We're all insecure.
[14:32] Ben Rimalower: That's part of it.
[14:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[14:33] Ben Rimalower: And Rosie's like, yeah, girl, I know.
[14:35] Daniel Nolen: And but that's that's something I never get from Patti.
[14:39] Ben Rimalower: I always just get this kind of, you know, even if it's it, even if it's from a place of of um, I don't know what the word is, like uh, you know, well, fuck them.
[14:50] Daniel Nolen: But it, you know, I never get the the sense that Patti is like trying to prove herself or like trying to impress someone.
[14:58] Ben Rimalower: I always, or or even, or even just, you know, she's scared of what people are gonna think or say.
[15:03] Daniel Nolen: I just always get the sense that she's very confident, very secure, and uh just a good time gal.
[15:11] Ben Rimalower: You know, she's a good one.
[15:11] Daniel Nolen: Well, she is a good time gal.
[15:13] Ben Rimalower: I mean, I think the thing about Patti where she doesn't have those kind of like performer type insecurities, comes from like as far as musicals go and singing, you know, she was not just the star of all her shows as a kid growing up, but she was the one that you know they all said was most likely to be famous, and that was like, you know, the domineering personality in the town or whatever, you know.
[15:36] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[15:36] Ben Rimalower: So I think Patti always had a sense, you know, she says it, like, you know, I knew that I belonged on the stage, then my career would be on the Broadway musical stage, you know.
[15:45] Daniel Nolen: So that's her as far as musicals and singing.
[15:47] Ben Rimalower: And then as far as acting, she isn't a rare, as far as American actors go.
[15:53] Daniel Nolen: She, she having gone uh through the acting company uh in the 70s, and back when it was really, you know, I guess it maybe still is, but being, you know, in that repertory theater company with that was uh such a high quality one where she was with Kevin Klein and you know, I don't know, Sam Schudrivis and you know, all those wonderful people.
[16:15] Ben Rimalower: Or the Rosato, who's the one that they always talk about, though, that that uh anyway, it doesn't matter.
[16:19] Daniel Nolen: Uh oh, um David Um uh three names from MASH motherfucker.
[16:26] Ben Rimalower: Anyway, it doesn't matter.
[16:27] Daniel Nolen: You know, she was in really good uh she had a kind of acting training that was so practical that was really about I think for so many American actors, and um, you know, there's this sense of I think they were a little bit poisoned by the era of um method acting, in the sense I don't mean in terms of a way that gets in the way of their art as actors, because maybe that works for some of them.
[16:54] Ben Rimalower: But but I think as far as their insecurities, there's this idea that acting is like voodoo, and that like there's no that there's no real measure of what a performance needs to be, and that everything is just completely unknowable, and that it's just a mystery, you know.
[17:09] Daniel Nolen: But but but even more than feel yeah, it's like there's you know, whereas I think Patti has something that's a little more common, like in Europe, because she came from that repertory background, that it's very much like no, these are the skills.
[17:21] Ben Rimalower: Like you want to do Shakespeare, you have to learn Iambic Pentameter, and you have to learn to sword fight, and you have to learn to walk in this kind of a skirt.
[17:27] Daniel Nolen: And you want to do the Greeks, you have to learn this.
[17:29] Ben Rimalower: And you want to do Chekhov, it's all about the vowels, or you know, whatever the fucking tricks of the trade are.
[17:34] Daniel Nolen: You know, they learn them all and then applied them all doing theater, repertory theater on the road, you know, for four years, where they would do, you know, however many plays they did in a season back to back on different nights of the week all across the country, having to adapt it to different spaces where they really were able to, I think, to get outside of their own heads and just you know, there was just a matter of delivering.
[17:55] Ben Rimalower: If you were playing the three sisters in two different cities in the same week in very different theaters or whatever, it was it became less about this like abstract sense of do I have the magical calling, you know, and more just about like, did I get the job done?
[18:13] Daniel Nolen: And ultimately, I think what that really gives them is a real sense of what the job is.
[18:18] Ben Rimalower: So I think Patti has like a real confidence in a basic skill set that she has that even other American actors that might have that skill, might even have it better than she does, might not just have such a very um cut and dry practical appreciation of what that is.
[18:34] Daniel Nolen: And then she has, I think the sort of um the confidence and even ego of being just kind of like a like, you know, the her birthright being this just kind of like you know, musical theater kind of like goddess status that was always like sort of destined for her, you know.
[18:51] Ben Rimalower: Well, and she's also, you know, she's uh Italian, and and I've you know been watching uh the Soprano rewatching The Sopranos, and I'm like literally I'm like, which I'm like, which character um which which character is the Patti LuPone of The Sopranos?
[19:08] Daniel Nolen: Literally all of them Tony, Janice, Uncle Junior.
[19:12] Ben Rimalower: I'm like, they're all Patti.
[19:13] Daniel Nolen: She's very Uncle Jin.
[19:14] Ben Rimalower: You know, she was very close to getting Janice.
[19:16] Daniel Nolen: Oh, I know.
[19:17] Ben Rimalower: And I every time, I mean, especially in the later seasons, which is what I'm on now, uh, there's a lot of Janice uh material, and I'm like, oh fuck, I can totally see Patti.
[19:26] Daniel Nolen: But I love Aida Turturro.
[19:28] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I do too.
[19:29] Daniel Nolen: She's brilliant, brilliant.
[19:31] Ben Rimalower: And talk about like a unique performer who just there's nobody like Aida Turturro, you know.
[19:37] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[19:37] Ben Rimalower: And I mean, her portrayal of Janice Soprano is just oh, it's just like, you know, just like um, what's the word?
[19:48] Daniel Nolen: No, no makeup, no, it's it's just yeah, warts and all.
[19:52] Ben Rimalower: Warts and all, baby.
[19:53] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[19:54] Ben Rimalower: So speaking of warts, let us begin to talk about that singing.
[20:00] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, speaking of um not being the opposite of the soprano, which is Ethel Merman.
[20:07] Ben Rimalower: Now, okay, let me just say that I grew up on this video and I haven't watched it.
[20:11] Daniel Nolen: Did you?
[20:12] Ben Rimalower: I just watched it last night, but I hadn't watched it in at least 20 years, maybe 25 or 30.
[20:18] Daniel Nolen: And I feel like I've learned so much about myself from this video.
[20:24] Ben Rimalower: Like, and so that so what this was, for the people that don't know, was uh it was originally called Showstopper's The Best of Broadway, and it was a one-night uh television special that was a live concert filmed fatally at the La Mirada Center for the Performing Arts, just a hundred miles outside of Los Angeles.
[20:45] Daniel Nolen: In 1982.
[20:47] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[20:48] Daniel Nolen: 82.
[20:49] Ben Rimalower: It was such a weird time.
[20:50] Daniel Nolen: Such a weird time.
[20:52] Ben Rimalower: It's it's the worst because it's it's it's so basically what it is is like the 70s, it's that point in the 80s when it's still the 70s, right?
[21:01] Daniel Nolen: The real 80s haven't started.
[21:03] Ben Rimalower: And even if they've started in the East Village loft where Madonna is like, you know, giving blowjobs for studio time, yeah.
[21:10] Daniel Nolen: They have not started, they have not started in the mainstream of like televised show business, let alone televised musical theater show business.
[21:19] Ben Rimalower: So it's still the 70s, with none of the new wave cool rock and roll punk 80s moment that's about to happen.
[21:27] Daniel Nolen: And yet, none of the 70s coolness is still on.
[21:31] Ben Rimalower: It's all come off.
[21:33] Daniel Nolen: This is not the 70s of, you know, fucking like Studio 54 and Andy Warhol and Cher and Patti Smith.
[21:42] Ben Rimalower: This is not that 70s.
[21:43] Daniel Nolen: This is Tom Bosley, you know, five wins to his success as as the as yeah, as as Mr. Cunningham on Happy Days.
[21:50] Ben Rimalower: And like it's just so unbelievable as a US American in the year 2020 to watch this and like, and I grew up on Happy Days.
[22:01] Daniel Nolen: Like I understand that Tom Bosley is like a television like major personality who is like extremely popular.
[22:08] Ben Rimalower: Well, see, and I only know him from Murder She Wrote.
[22:10] Daniel Nolen: So literally, I was like, oh, this is like Sheriff Amos Tupper, like hosting this night of uh Broadway singing?
[22:17] Ben Rimalower: What?
[22:18] Daniel Nolen: It's so weird, right?
[22:19] Ben Rimalower: Like you're just like, in what universe today would they choose like a middle-aged man?
[22:25] Daniel Nolen: 100%.
[22:26] Ben Rimalower: I was so weird.
[22:28] Daniel Nolen: And I love him, but their whole broadcast is like, I this is so badly directed and produced.
[22:35] Ben Rimalower: Like 100%.
[22:37] Daniel Nolen: So badly directed.
[22:38] Ben Rimalower: Like they're trying to.
[22:41] Daniel Nolen: I think that you have to like, if you're gonna capture like a live musical theater performance for TV, you want to capture the excitement of being there live.
[22:51] Ben Rimalower: Which they don't make it feel like an event.
[22:54] Daniel Nolen: You want to feel like the goosebumps of sitting in the audience, right?
[22:57] Ben Rimalower: Which is exactly what Scott Ellis did on the My Favorite Broadway that we talked about last week.
[23:02] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[23:02] Ben Rimalower: But this, they're trying to kind of have it both ways, and they really want to make it feel like a TV special.
[23:08] Daniel Nolen: So there's people singing like into a close-up in the camera a lot.
[23:11] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[23:12] Daniel Nolen: And like almost they show them like walking around weird parts of the set, which by the way is like overly elaborate.
[23:19] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, and like um Jerry Orbach is like backstage for half of his song.
[23:23] Daniel Nolen: It's so terrible because you feel that the audience is not engaged in what's happening, so you are not.
[23:30] Ben Rimalower: It's like that, you know, and I guess it was different.
[23:33] Daniel Nolen: Like, I know that in 1982, this was already a dead thing, but maybe the culture they were still responding to of like the Merv Griffin show and Dinah Shore and like what had been in the 60s and 70s.
[23:46] Ben Rimalower: Maybe in that world, somebody could sing in close up into the camera on a TV special, and like it was just that would have been enough to make a connection, but it dies a thunderous death.
[23:57] Daniel Nolen: Yes, 100%.
[23:59] Ben Rimalower: So that said, there's it's an incredible lineup of stars, and it's very exciting to have some of these performances beginning, and I mean there's really unbelievable.
[24:09] Daniel Nolen: It begins with Ethel Merman singing everything's coming up roses, which is just astonishing in itself because like some of the people that are in this are still around, like Chita Rivera, and of course the younger ones.
[24:20] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Barry Bostwick, Donna McKechnie.
[24:22] Daniel Nolen: I mean, we know Donna McKechnie.
[24:23] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, so it's amazing to think of them being in the same world as Ethel Merman.
[24:28] Daniel Nolen: Because to me, Ethel Merman now I think of Ethel Merman the way I think of like Ben Franklin or like Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
[24:35] Ben Rimalower: She is the Ben Franklin of uh Broadway for sure.
[24:39] Daniel Nolen: With the same hairstyle.
[24:40] Ben Rimalower: With the same hair.
[24:42] Daniel Nolen: Listen, that was like I would say 20% of my notes that I've written down are about Ethel's wig, if that is a wig, or maybe it's that that's her real hair, but I feel like I glimpsed a little bit of lace.
[24:52] Ben Rimalower: It has to be her real hair because why would you put a wig so far back?
[24:57] Daniel Nolen: Well, I mean, I don't know, was she losing her hair or something?
[24:59] Ben Rimalower: Like that was her natural hair.
[25:02] Daniel Nolen: I mean, it's Ethel Merman as we saw her in the movie Airplane.
[25:06] Ben Rimalower: It's literally the same year that Airplane came out in 1982.
[25:09] Daniel Nolen: And that wig though is not doing her any favors, or that hair is not doing her any favors.
[25:15] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's it's she by the way, she's young.
[25:19] Daniel Nolen: I kept thinking she was in her 80s, but uh she was born in 1908, so she was 75, so she was the same age as Bette Midler is today.
[25:31] Ben Rimalower: Wow.
[25:31] Daniel Nolen: Which in some ways stands to reason because she has the same body type and physicality in this as Bette Midler does today.
[25:39] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[25:40] Daniel Nolen: Like you want to think like Ethel's all fat, but she actually has like a tight, square little body.
[25:45] Ben Rimalower: It's very square.
[25:47] Daniel Nolen: And um, and she's actually like rather agile moving around.
[25:53] Ben Rimalower: And like she's agile, but I mean, I mean, she definitely like is like what's the word?
[25:59] Daniel Nolen: Like, um, there's something pendulous about her steps.
[26:03] Ben Rimalower: I mean, you also you want to make fun of her vibrato, like it's so far apart or something, like, but I mean the voice technically on paper, you can't really complain about the performance, so I'm not sure why it is so empty and meaningless to me.
[26:20] Daniel Nolen: The thing I will say about Ethel, her voice to me sounds the same as it ever has, but um I've I've recently come to a realization about Ethel, and it's I also last week I watched um for the first time It's a Mad Mad Mad World with Ethel in it.
[26:35] Ben Rimalower: And I like I love listening to her on all those old cast recordings, like of course Gypsy and Annie Get Your Gun.
[26:42] Ben Rimalower: But watching her perform, even in movies, I'm like, it's very vacant to me, and she's not like an actress, you know. It's like she has this big belty voice, which I'm sure was thrilling to see from the balcony, you know, of whatever, let alone the front row. But it's like there's really not a lot of intimacy that she creates. Have you seen, although people say that I mean that movie is not that well regarded, but people say that her performance in It's a Mad Mad World is one of her best screen acting performances.
[27:17] Daniel Nolen: Oh, really?
[27:18] Ben Rimalower: Have you seen the movie of Call Me Madame?
[27:23] Daniel Nolen: No, I need to.
[27:24] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's pretty enjoyable to watch, first of all, and it's her playing one of her bigger successes pretty much around the time when she did the show, you know. So it preserves what was special there, you know. But I mean, it definitely leaves something to be desired the way you're describing. And the other movie that I really love her in is There's No Business Like Show Business.
[27:49] Daniel Nolen: I've never seen that either.
[27:50] Ben Rimalower: Uh oh, you would love that. It's like Mitzi Gaynor and Marilyn Monroe, and it's like a big romp, you know. But the thing is, like, there's definitely something she's got going on in those movies that she ain't got here in this video. I mean, my favorite moment of Ethel Merman's in this video is when she says, our host, Mr. Tom Bosley. And something else I was thinking as Ethel was performing, like, I was kind of squinting, and I was like, if you kind of squint just the right way, she has a very Vivian Vance quality to her, which I'm like, this is what I mean, Vivian Vance, I think is much more lovable in like a human way. And yeah, especially because we know her as Ethel, like the faithful sidekick. But I was reminded of when I was reading the Vivian Vance biography, I think it's called The Other Side of Ethel Merman. And they, of course, they talk about how Vivian Vance was Ethel Merman's understudy on Broadway for Anything Goes.
[29:00] Daniel Nolen: I never knew that. Isn't that incredible?
[29:01] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, if Vivian Vance, if I mean obviously she had her huge break as Ethel Mertz, but like if she had had a different career trajectory, she could have been like an Ethel Merman type back in that day. Even though she didn't quite have, I don't think, the great belt that Ethel had. Like she's a little bit more than a little bit of a little bit. I mean, even if she did have a better voice. I mean, Ethel Merman was literally like completely alone. I mean, there was nobody.
[29:26] Daniel Nolen: That's right.
[29:26] Ben Rimalower: But to be fair also though, the quality of this upload is a little like fuzzy. And for some reason, Merman's like mannish face and like large forehead, like it is especially hard to like connect to. And also they film her in a lot of wide shots for obvious reasons, and also because they want in one of the few halfway smart decisions they made directorially was to like, you know, capture the grandeur of Ethel Merman singing there's everything's coming up roses. Like, you know, they're wide shots because it's, you know, supposedly filling a space. But you know, although PS La Marata Center for Performing Arts is a perfectly fine place to see, like, you know, a summer stock production of Kathy Rigby in South Pacific, but it's not, but it's not, um, it doesn't have like the, you know, the convatic sense of like a Carnegie Hall or like a real, it doesn't feel like an event, you know. Anyway, but it did have that vibe of like a performing arts center in like some, at best, but the wide shots don't help her to come through on camera.
[30:38] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[30:39] Ben Rimalower: So she introduces Tom Bosley, and one of my favorite lines in the whole thing is when he says, Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, thank you, Ethel Merman. She does not fit in either category. Just like that. He says her whole name. But my note on that moment was musical theater in 1982 was not glamorous, it sure was not.
[31:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, and that's the thing. It's like it's so show, like this whole thing is so showbiz, but it's so like, um, it's like tired, lacking like culturally irrelevant showbiz. Yeah, it's so clear that like the art and like excitement at the center of culture in 1982 was far from what was happening in this television production.
[31:32] Ben Rimalower: That's right, and the next number is a further indication of that. Why did they then go to a fucking dance?
[31:38] Daniel Nolen: No, I mean, I have to say, I wouldn't have been able to answer if you had said to me 48 hours ago, like, you know, American Dance Machine. Why is that so triggering to you, Ben? I would have been like, I don't know. But now I know. Because every time they introduce the fucking American Dance Machine, what does that mean? It means like a generic company of like talented young dancers are gonna come dance a piece of musical theater that they have no connection or to or affinity for.
[32:08] Ben Rimalower: Or two hours. Just completely like divorced from any story or context.
[32:12] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, these numbers. I mean, I, it's, I have had nothing but love for the musical Can Can since I saw Patti's absolutely heroic performance in the City Center Encores production in 2003 or four. Obsessed with what she was and that whole show. But seeing a number, a dance number, by the way, not the song Can Can, it's the fucking song quadrille of all the like boys and girls like screwing around or whatever. Like, for no, why would they put this on this broadcast? This video is the reason that I hate dance.
[32:49] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. Truly is like the worst of that idea of putting dance on TV. And I mean, the one thing I can think of is were they trying to appeal to like a younger audience? Because they did a lot of later in the show, they do a lot of stuff from Greece and they try to really.
[33:05] Daniel Nolen: No, they do one song from Greece. It just goes on for so long because it's a piece of shit with middle-aged people that have no business singing those songs.
[33:12] Ben Rimalower: But we will get there.
[33:13] Daniel Nolen: We will get there. And then there's the other dance now. I don't know. I'm just like, in that in the context of the early 80s, like what was their end goal? Like, what was their, what were they trying to achieve?
[33:24] Ben Rimalower: Well, they keep talking about dance. I mean, at the end, you know, when Tom Bosley says something like, you know, well, we'll always have the music, the lyrics, the shows, the dances. I mean, you know, people think of dance as a big part of musical theater as it is.
[33:44] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[33:44] Ben Rimalower: But this is just like, it's dance that only has value for dance's sake.
[33:53] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[33:54] Ben Rimalower: And even that is like a very like vanilla, not exciting.
[34:05] Daniel Nolen: It's just right.
[34:06] Ben Rimalower: So that happens, and then to like kick things into high gear, you would think really reward us. My lover and life partner from last week's episode, Mel Carter, is back to sing my favorite song that she did in Ain't Misbehavin', Cash for Your Trash.
[34:25] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[34:26] Ben Rimalower: But even this does not electrify. When you and I are going to watch the video of the original production of Ain't Misbehavin', and maybe even do that on the show. But when you see her do Cash for Your Trash in the original, it is like watching, like, you know, young Patti sing Buenos Aires or something, or like Andrea McArdle sing like maybe. But something about it here, I don't, I feel like she's, I was thinking like she was, I know she had like bad substance problems, and I was thinking she seems like she's all drugged up and fucked up. But then later when she sings Mean to Me, it's heartbreaking and fabulous and everything.
[35:06] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[35:06] Ben Rimalower: So I don't know what to do.
[35:07] Daniel Nolen: Well, this number seemed a little unfocused to me. It was just a little, it was so broad, and I mean, it kind of seemed a little like a drag. I mean, I kind of wrote my notes like, is, oh no, I wrote in my notes. I need, I want to see Latrice Royale do this number, but with like, you know, death drops and like backflips and that is like that already is like so like not what it was supposed to be like originally.
[35:33] Ben Rimalower: Right, exactly. But like, but like, you know, Nell's kind of like running around the stage a lot and like swirling her dress and stuff. And I mean, it did seem, it almost seemed like she was doing like Liza or something. It was just so high energy and like a lot of kind of movement and hand motions and stuff. But it also felt kind of like heartless and meaningless. And like, you know, the stuff that she would do, like, real bonds, like you know what I'm talking about, honey. Like all those little asides, which by the way are scripted, or at least they're the same ones she was doing for years in that song. They feel so rote, you know.
[36:14] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[36:15] Ben Rimalower: By the way, another horrible decision made by the producers is that there's a laugh track, like in addition to whatever actual response they get from the good people of La Marata, there's also like canned laughter, which really fucks it up. But the next number, which is still not as wonderful as you want it to be, does have the first performance of the night to break through. And it might be because she's the only person whose eye makeup translates through the grainy video. But Donna McKechnney and You Could Drive a Person Crazy finally is thrilling.
[36:49] Daniel Nolen: Well, first of all, she looks, I, they said Donna McKey, but I was like, is that Joanna Gleason? Looks like Joanna Gleason. And also, there's, she looks like Joanna Gleason for some reason, like the hair color, just, I don't know, through the grain. But I think this is the only time I've seen Donna McKechnie without her Donna McKechnie hairstyle that she still has to this day.
[37:15] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[37:15] Daniel Nolen: I was like, who, what is that? And then Donna McKechnie eyelashes on though.
[37:21] Ben Rimalower: She sure do.
[37:23] Daniel Nolen: She loves her so much for it.
[37:25] Ben Rimalower: Amazing. She looks like, fuck her. Do you want to know how Michael Bennett was married to her? I watched this video and I am like, gimme dat ass. Yeah, I like got so horny, even more so than I am watching this. And first of all, I love this song from Company. I would say the more times I see Company or see this song performed, except for what was it? Was it Marriage Story where they tried to perform this number and I hated it?
[37:49] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[37:49] Ben Rimalower: But I love this song so much. This is one of my favorite songs from Company, the musical Company. It's exciting to see the original choreography.
[37:59] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah.
[38:00] Ben Rimalower: And it's funny because, I mean, go ahead, sorry.
[38:04] Daniel Nolen: No, no, it's just it seemed like, I mean, Donna looks so good and she's so wonderful. I mean, and she does get the heavy lifting. I mean, Donna, totally in addition to being the soprano part in the trio, she gets the bridge or whatever you call it, middle section, which is, you know, I mean, and it just sounds amazing and it's just, yeah, so wonderful and so bright and cheerful and high energy. By the way, I love Tom Bosley's like dumbing it down for Middle America 1982 description of Company. It's about a bachelor who drives everybody crazy.
[38:40] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[38:41] Ben Rimalower: A nice segue. Why didn't they use that to market the show? But it's fun to see Pamela Myers looking less freakish than she ever did before or after. Because like young Pamela Myers was like, you didn't even recognize her. She was such a weirdo as a youngster. And she's definitely like assumed that sort of like, um, what's the woman from like Mary Tyler Moore that was in The Drowsy Chaperone?
[39:07] Daniel Nolen: Yes, I was just about to say that.
[39:09] Ben Rimalower: Um, Georgia Engel.
[39:10] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[39:11] Ben Rimalower: She's assumed as a middle-aged older woman, she's assumed her Georgia Engel fabulous daffiness. But for this one brief moment in 1982, with like her long hair and like really, really like slender body, she just kind of seems like someone's like wife or something.
[39:27] Daniel Nolen: Like, yeah, I mean, she's just like, she's just this like attractive, like young actress.
[39:32] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally. Well, it's so funny you said that about MTM because I wrote down like Donna McKechnie has such Mary Tyler Moore energy in this number. And then I was like, oh, and Susan Browning could kind of be Rhoda.
[39:44] Daniel Nolen: Oh, and no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. How dare you, Georgia? Wipe that off your face. Susan Browning could not be Rhoda.
[39:54] Ben Rimalower: I apologize on behalf of Valerie Harper.
[39:57] Daniel Nolen: Susan Browning is everything that was. Physically, not even physically. That you only think that because she looks fat in this video. Susan Browning has like never been like she was always thin in the 70s. She's just terrible. I never understood why Susan Browning got those parts. Susan Browning is so awful. And then there's that, that I mean, she's you watch her in Company, and you're just like, I mean, it's 1970. You have to wonder if like Betty Buckley and Bernadette Peters showed up to this audition. How did they not choose them? You know, like, and then like, you know, and she's she sings, you know, Barcelona, you know, and he and uh and and he's like, and he's like, June, and she's like, April.
I mean, she can't, she can't belt. Her soprano voice is ugly. There's that Stephen Sondheim evening from like the museum or whatever that's recorded. It's got like Angela as the special guest, and it's George Hearn and um Judy Kaye. Uh, and you've just got Susan Browning like stinking it up. Wow, it's even a touch of nerve. I'm just well, I just I and it bothered. I was already mad at her when this video started because they do the stars names at the beginning, like it's like this like night of a thousand stars, but they do them alphabetically.
[41:12] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[41:13] Daniel Nolen: So they're like Tom Bosley, good for her. Susan Browning. And like, I'm like, no, as soon as I hear that name, my heart just goes plummeting. Yeah, half of America is switching the channel. I mean, and you watch this, and I just I suddenly was filled with like a knowledge from my teen years of this video, where I was like, I am going to get to see Donna McKechnie again. That's the good news. The bad news is I'm not going to see Pamela Myers again. She does not get a number after some crazy. But the good news is that Susan Browning does not get a number. My goodness. Um I'm sorry, I had to get that off my channel. Oh, by the way, it shocked me when they said I can understand a person. If a person was a fag.
[42:00] Ben Rimalower: Like, I don't know why.
[42:02] Daniel Nolen: No, that's so funny. I rewound it like three times, and for me, like I was expecting that, but I swear, whatever version I watch, they dubbed it over with drag.
[42:13] Ben Rimalower: Oh, maybe so, because that would make sense.
[42:15] Daniel Nolen: Because like I also remember like Sondheim at Carnegie Hall in 1992 when Dorothy Loudon does her amazing mashup of you could drive a person crazy. I'm losing my mind to drive a person crazy. She's like, I can understand a person if it's not a person's bag, I can understand a person. If a person was a drag. And like the little pause and like thinking of the word is so genius. And the audience like went crazy. And I remember in 1992, well, actually it aired on PBS in 1993. I remember thinking like they're clapping at her comedy, but they're also thanking her for not saying fag.
[42:54] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[42:55] Daniel Nolen: Um, but there's no thanking Susan Browning for that because she said it. Listen, Dorothy Loudon can say fag for all I'm gonna do.
[43:02] Ben Rimalower: Oh my god, Dorothy Loudon could gabe at me with a stick and I would write a thank you letter.
[43:11] Daniel Nolen: Alright, so um next up is Bobby Adler.
[43:17] Ben Rimalower: Wait.
[43:18] Daniel Nolen: Bobby Adler 100 to the max. But first of all, I want to say, just a side note, um during the show, they keep they have all these Hirschfeld like cutout murals that keep lowering from the ceiling, and I fucking love that.
[43:34] Ben Rimalower: It's so good.
[43:35] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[43:36] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.
[43:38] Daniel Nolen: And I love the set. Even actually, they don't they don't establish it well in the beginning. It's it's like it's still not good.
[43:44] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, and it's not really carried through fully, but um I also the set is so beautiful, even though the weird way they filmed through the chairs is weird.
[43:52] Daniel Nolen: But um the set in itself, just I'm like, that could be my bedroom, and I'd be so happy.
[43:58] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, but it shouldn't be your gala concert.
[44:01] Daniel Nolen: Right. You know what it the set feels like it's taking place during the daytime. Like you want an event like this to feel like it's happening at night.
[44:09] Ben Rimalower: Broadway happens at night.
[44:12] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, nightlife. I love the nightlife.
[44:17] Ben Rimalower: Um, okay, so yeah, next up. My first thought when she came out into the La Mirada Performing Arts Center was I thought of Chad Michael's line as Cher in um Snatch Game of Why do you keep booking me on these chicken shit gigs?
[44:33] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally.
[44:35] Ben Rimalower: But I do feel like how is Debbie Reynolds an Oscar winner having resort to this.
[44:42] Daniel Nolen: Listen, that's so Debbie though. You know, she was up till her dying day, she was performing at that weird little like casino outside of Vegas every month.
[44:52] Ben Rimalower: Oh, totally.
[44:53] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I'm sure she needed the like money she got for this gig too, you know.
[44:57] Ben Rimalower: Totally.
[44:57] Daniel Nolen: Uh yeah, to buy all that Hollywood memorabilia.
[45:00] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[45:01] Daniel Nolen: Um, I mean, first of all, no one plays to the camera like Debbie Reynolds.
[45:07] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I by the way, everything I said about playing to the camera has nothing to do with obviously Debbie Reynolds is absolutely flawless.
[45:14] Daniel Nolen: I mean, she it's down to a fucking sh an art form with her, and she knows exactly when to switch to the other camera. Like, I don't know if they rehearse that or she just knows where where to look for the light.
[45:25] Ben Rimalower: I don't know how that works.
[45:26] Daniel Nolen: But she does this in the case. And that's what's way. And it's so like, no one could get away with. I mean, the talk about, you know, last week we talked about Liza pulling out all these tricks. Debbie has all these tricks, but they're so much more like just like old school showbiz tricks that she picked up from like Louis B. Mayer in the you know 50s or whatever.
[45:49] Ben Rimalower: They're more or more like vaudeville.
[45:51] Daniel Nolen: I feel like her tricks, they're kind of like the tricks Elaine Stritch would do, except Elaine Stritch had no voice.
[45:56] Ben Rimalower: Right.
[45:57] Daniel Nolen: You know? So it's like, but it like, I mean, just like all that, you know, you got the brand that kisses that right. I mean, no one, I mean, just milking this little standard for all it's worth, and just cleaning that dress. I mean, just when you think, okay, I mean, this is obviously the big finish. She has one more, like, oh.
[46:22] Ben Rimalower: I mean, and this song literally has like five words.
[46:25] Daniel Nolen: I mean, this song is not like it's not like verse after verse after verse. It's but she just keeps building, she keeps building. It just keeps getting more and more like vulgar and like it's so joyful.
[46:42] Ben Rimalower: I literally so joyful, and she is just great.
[46:46] Daniel Nolen: She sounds great, although I realized listening to her singing this song, I was like, you know what? Debbie has like a pretty voice, but it's like not a uh, you know, um a huge instrument.
[47:00] Ben Rimalower: Instrument, you know, it's like a it's not like a barn.
[47:03] Daniel Nolen: But that's why she uses the tricks.
[47:04] Ben Rimalower: Yes, that's totally different.
[47:06] Daniel Nolen: I mean, where Liza uses the tricks because her voice is now broken, Debbie's using the tricks because she Debbie probably did the song exactly the I mean she did it in Irene when she started in the 70s with her. But I mean, even if you saw her sing in a club in the 40s or something, she probably would have been exactly the same.
[47:24] Ben Rimalower: Totally, totally.
[47:25] Daniel Nolen: I mean, she's so old school showbiz in that it's like, I mean, talk about training, it's like this is she knows how to work it. She knows how to work for an audience and how to deliver.
[47:35] Ben Rimalower: But to deliver on the it's, I mean, she's maybe in a way in a class by herself in that presentation because she understands how to perform the song live to delight the audience in the room she's in.
[47:35] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[47:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[47:35] Daniel Nolen: How to perform the song for the cameras to delight the audience that's going to be watching this TV special at home.
[47:57] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[47:57] Daniel Nolen: And even cutting through the limitation. It's almost like she knows how bad the directors and producers are.
[48:06] Ben Rimalower: But like she's been doing terrible TV specials for years.
[48:10] Daniel Nolen: Like she knows how you still come out smelling like a rose.
[48:15] Ben Rimalower: Totally.
[48:16] Daniel Nolen: You know, it's funny. I recently, like a couple weeks ago, I recently rewatched uh Bright Lights, that documentary about her and Carrie on HBO, which is so good. But there's that moment where you know, Debbie was as a kid, uh, Debbie tried to get Carrie to be a singer and she wanted her to kind of follow in her footsteps, and Carrie was such a rebel and she didn't want to do that.
[48:35] Ben Rimalower: But there's footage of Carrie singing, there's that moment where she sings Bridge Over Troubled Water, and it's just like amazing.
[48:42] Daniel Nolen: And Carrie had like this real vocal talent, just like this, you know, kind of deep, belty voice. And and Debbie, you know, it cuts to Debbie in the interview, and she's like crying, and she's like, I wish I love that voice. I wish I had that voice, you know, and and it's and it's so it's just so interesting to think about now, especially seeing Debbie in this in this moment in the show, because it's, you know, she she's doing everything, doing it Debbie's way.
[49:10] Ben Rimalower: I think that's her workout video title.
[49:13] Daniel Nolen: Um which is fabulous if you've never seen it. Hi, Debbie.
[49:21] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, she goes, hi Debbie, which is so Debbie!
[49:25] Daniel Nolen: That was a good Debbie.
[49:26] Ben Rimalower: That was almost as good as Jason Powell's Debbie.
[49:28] Daniel Nolen: Oh, thank you.
[49:30] Ben Rimalower: Um my first taste of Debbie Reynolds was the animated version of Charlotte's Web where she voices Charlotte.
[49:37] Daniel Nolen: I think that probably was mine. I don't think I even knew that was her at the time, but yeah, and I remember that there's that one song she sings.
[49:45] Daniel Nolen: Um he turns the seasons around, and so she changes her gown. Mother Earth and Father Time. And for some reason that ballad really wrecked me as a kid.
[50:00] Ben Rimalower: Oh, that's so sweet, Daniel.
[50:02] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I was really that that whole story was very emotional and touching and instrumental in my life.
[50:08] Ben Rimalower: I love that movie.
[50:09] Daniel Nolen: And I I love I love that movie so much.
[50:11] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, me too.
[50:12] Daniel Nolen: It me too. It really taught that in Wizard of Oz taught me how to feel.
[50:17] Ben Rimalower: Wow.
[50:18] Daniel Nolen: Um, anyway, but isn't that a Sondheim lyric? Teach me how to feel.
[50:21] Ben Rimalower: You know what I was quoting though? Hold my hand.
[50:25] Daniel Nolen: Wait, what is that?
[50:29] Ben Rimalower: Anyone?
[50:32] Daniel Nolen: What? Did you hear me sing?
[50:35] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[50:36] Daniel Nolen: What what song is that?
[50:37] Ben Rimalower: Oh, uh, take me to the world.
[50:40] Daniel Nolen: It's very uh appropriate for the isolation times.
[50:44] Ben Rimalower: Well, and Kelly O'Hara sang that wonderfully in the Rosie special.
[50:47] Daniel Nolen: Yes, Barbara did.
[50:48] Ben Rimalower: So Barbara.
[50:50] Daniel Nolen: Barbara Tru sang it in not wonderfully in her uh uh movie Potna Scene Broadway.
[50:57] Ben Rimalower: Um Bernadette sang it wonderfully on Mandy Patinkin's album Dress Casual, where the two of them perform the entire Evening Primrose score.
[51:05] Daniel Nolen: And anyone that hasn't uh listened to that ought to, because it's pretty spectacular, both of them.
[51:13] Ben Rimalower: But what I was I uh I was quoting was Love Actually, when Emma Thompson is talking about Joni Mitchell, and she's like, she told your cold English wife how to feel.
[51:25] Daniel Nolen: Alan Rickman is like Wait, I feel like you do a good Alan Rickman.
[51:28] Ben Rimalower: Where were we the other day? And you were doing No, I wasn't doing Alan Rickman.
[51:32] Daniel Nolen: You just thought whatever I was doing sounded more like Alan Rickman.
[51:35] Ben Rimalower: Wait, what were you doing though?
[51:37] Daniel Nolen: You were doing Judy.
[51:38] Ben Rimalower: I think you're doing Judy.
[51:40] Daniel Nolen: Do do the Judy and see if it sounds like Alan.
[51:42] Ben Rimalower: What do you want me to say?
[51:44] Daniel Nolen: Um just do like intro broken records or something.
[51:51] Ben Rimalower: Um talk about Debbie Reynolds. Welcome to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World.
[51:59] Daniel Nolen: I'm Ben Rimalower.
[52:06] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, it is sound like Alan Rickman.
[52:09] Daniel Nolen: It's like Alan Rickman like du playing gay.
[52:14] Ben Rimalower: Um which he did.
[52:15] Daniel Nolen: Which he did.
[52:16] Ben Rimalower: Wait, how do you think?
[52:19] Daniel Nolen: In real life, he's still alive, isn't he?
[52:22] Ben Rimalower: No. Remember, he died tragically several years ago.
[52:26] Daniel Nolen: Wait, wasn't he in the movie with um who am I thinking of? What's the thank you for what's it called where she forges the thing with Melissa McCarthy?
[52:37] Ben Rimalower: Uh can you ever forgive me?
[52:39] Daniel Nolen: No, you're you're thinking of um oh god, what's his name? Alan Rickman's the one in Harry Potter, Snape.
[52:47] Ben Rimalower: I thought that was Snape in the movie of Melissa McCarthy.
[52:50] Daniel Nolen: You're thinking of Richard E. Grant.
[52:52] Ben Rimalower: Oh, they're different.
[52:55] Daniel Nolen: So funny. Richard E. Grant.
[52:56] Ben Rimalower: You learn something every day.
[52:58] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, he's gonna be a good one.
[52:59] Ben Rimalower: We should move on.
[53:00] Daniel Nolen: We should move on.
[53:00] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[53:01] Daniel Nolen: Because we're as exactly as happened to me watching the video last night, when I pushed pause to see how many more minutes were left, I realized I was only about like one seventh into the entire project.
[53:13] Ben Rimalower: Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay. Yeah, we'll uh okay. We have to do that. Well, next up there's some Fakakta story about which at first I was like, why is Tom Bosley telling a story from like tr when he was in Summerstock and Charlie's Aunt. But then it actually was kind of sweet to know that he and Jerry Orbach had been in Summerstock together, and Jerry Orbach was just an apprentice. He calls in his little apprentice, which I thought was neurotic. Um, and then uh and then Jerry Orbach. They're both on huge TV shows, too, because Jerry Orbach got Law and Order eventually, and Tom got Murder She Wrote. Well, but but Tom was in the middle of his um no, Tom's TV claim to fame was Happy Days. Right, but Murder She Wrote was like what was it it set the record for like the longest running?
Was he a regular on Murder She Wrote? Yeah, he was Sheriff Amos Tupper. I mean the whole run of the show? Yeah, I mean, you know, every like fifth episode was set in Cabot Cove and he was in those episodes. Okay, but no, but Happy Days was a major hit and sitcom that ran for years and years and spawned many um a primetime sitcom that spawned many spin-offs, and he was the lead. And I mean, Tom Bosley's most famous for Happy Days. And Jerry Orbach hadn't done Law and Order yet, but he was starring in 42nd Street, as they say, the new hit show on Broadway. Yes. But he sings Try to Remember from the Fantastics. And I realized that, well, first of all, they fucked it up with that weird staging of him starting off stage or walking around the perimeter of the Yeah, I don't know what the fuck that was.
And like sucked. I was like, I realized that try to remember. I don't know if it's that I love the music, but I don't love I think I love the music. And I love it. But I don't think the but I don't think the lyrics to try to remember, maybe I just don't understand it, or maybe they don't mean what I want them to mean. But I keep like not quite having the journey with that song that I want to have. But also Jerry Orbach, he's singing it like what's the character, like El Gallo, the character. Um doesn't he like intro the show with that song, and it's kind of like setting the scene. I mean, I don't really know because I've never seen the show, but I feel like that's you know, the narrator like setting the scene or whatever, and like yeah, that it's like taking us back to like a simpler time.
Yeah, you need to find a way to like deliver that song out of that context, and I feel like he's just like, oh, I'm used to doing it this way, so I'm just gonna keep doing it in this way. But I was like ready to take that journey. Like I was thinking about the simpler time before COVID-19, you know? Like I was like when life was slow and oh so mellow, like I was just like, I was just wanting to be in that, but somehow I just couldn't quite get all the way there.
[56:07] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, I mean, he was he should have been singing it to someone like you. Like, I'm seeing this as I'm comforting someone. I'm I'm I'm this is uh an act of service I'm giving as like you know, this this source of comfort, but instead he was being like, you know, was like the narrator in Into the Woods once upon a time. Like he was very like uh uh just the I mean I know that's his appeal too, is that he's sort of like effortless and like um you know, he just has he just has that sort of like easy masculinity, like without any like pomp, you know. Um anyway, it's a beautiful song, and then the next number is a mixed bag because on one hand it is another pointless fucking dance number with the American Dance Machine exploring.
Wait, I wrote this down so I'd get it exactly right. I said, mid-century phony heterosexuality is just so boring. When uh totally, I mean, it and it lasts on so long. But we get Cheetah. You get Cheetah, and it's amazing to see Cheetah, who by the way, at this moment in time did not have a Tony Award, if you can believe it. So crazy. The woman had already starred on Broadway in the original casts of West Side Story and Bye Bye Birdie, and Chicago, not to mention quite a few others, right? And had not a Tony to her name. So weird. And those kicks, those high kicks. I mean, I don't care about dance, but I care about dance if it's Cheetah. Well, and the thing also I realized about Cheetah watching this was like she's so good at like physical comedy.
Oh my god, yeah. Just like, you know, she knows how to get a laugh, she knows how to use her body to get laughs. Oh my god. My my note on Cheetah was dat ass dough. Yes. But seriously, like I kept being like, I can't watch this number. I have to watch it for Cheetah. I can't watch this number. But I want to say, and I do mean this as a big fuck you to the American Dance Machine, ultimately, I did fast forward. Well, I didn't fast forward, but I did like, you know, go refill my beer or whatever. And but I kept waiting. I kept, you know, want it's such blue balls because I was like, okay, when's she gonna sing? I wanted to sing, I wanted to sing. And then she never gets to sing. I mean, I would like to quote the great Seth Rudetsky who said, Cheetah, famous for her dancing.
I loved her for her belting. Yeah, yes. It's so true. It's like I love watching her dance, but like also knowing what we know of her, and like, girl, we want you to sing. She does get to do some good belting later in the broadcast. Yeah. Um anyway. Okay, anyway, um next is like really geriatric summer nights that we were discussing. Uh very much. I mean, first of all, maybe this is generational because, you know, I mean, I was born in 76 and the Grease movie came out in 1980, but obviously, like, I don't remember like the Broadway musical show from like my like, you know, toddler years. Um maybe not obviously, but as a point of fact, I do not. Um, so the Grease that I knew as along with the Grease that everyone else born after that knew, was the movie, which is a huge movie and a great movie.
And I'm sorry if the original production was something different, that was a parody, a spoof of the 1950s. But like, who the fuck cares? That's not what the movie was. The movie was something else. I mean, and the movie created these archetypes of John Travolta as a perfect Danny Zuko. Yeah. And Olivia Newton John as a perfect human being and perfect Sandy. And Stockard Channing as The Witch in Into the Woods. Yeah. I mean, Stockard is so good. Olivia, watching it now, I'm like, ooh, she's she is that is not the face of a high schooler. No Tino Shea, but wasn't she like 30? No, they were all 30. Stockard was like 48. But like, no, but Olivia was flawless, and Olivia sang in that voice that was wonderful.
Belty as Patty, and like as country as Dolly, and like as beautiful as like Rebecca Lucre. I mean, Olivia Newton John is like wonderful. Everyone should want to be Olivia Newton John when they sing if they're not gonna just be like Ethel Merman, you know. And she is wonderful. I'm she doesn't look like a high schooler, that's all I'll say. That's all I'm gonna say. How can you none of them look like high schoolers? She looks more like a high schooler than John or Stockard. Um why are you picking on Olivia? Well, I don't, I don't necessarily, I mean, maybe Stockard, because yeah, but Stockard was literally 50. But I think John, John, I I bought as a like a young rascal. No, you bought John as a hooker because he had money and he had the night free, but anyway.
But that's that defined Grease for us. So I really don't want to see people play those parts who aren't those types, to be honest. And I certainly don't want to see people that are like in their, you know, like late 40s. And just like just the way they did I take notes, there was some weird vocal thing. I mean, Barry Bostwick is the least of the numbers problems. Also, it's like Barry Bostwick and Carole Demas, whose other claim to fame, by the way, Carole Demas's other claim to fame is like being fired from the baker's wife and replaced by Patti LuPone. That's your claim to fame. Fresh on the heels of being fired from the baker's wife. Here's Carole Demas. But like, but also too, uh fuck, I forgot I wasn't gonna say.
Well, one of them says they say horny at the beginning, which I thought was crazy. I was like, oh my god, can you say horny on 1980s? No, but this is the thing. Who are those other people? Okay, the original cast of Grease had like all kinds of crazy people in it, like like Mary Lou Henner and Adrienne Barbeau and shit, you know, not to mention that it like toured forever with like everybody from like Randy Graff to Judy Kaye. I understand that may not be that big of a range in some people's minds, but to me it's a lot. But but the thing is, like, this is like I'm pretty sure this is the American Dance Machine playing all the other parts. Yeah, totally. I don't want to see some like random bitch be like, Cuss he sounds like a drag.
Like, I mean, that isn't I need a Rizzo. I don't want summer nights without Rizzo. That's like a night without stars. Well, so what I just also I just realized I may have to like completely go back on what I said earlier about fag, because I think this is the song that I wrote the fag note about because the part where Rizzo says he sounds like a drag is the lyric, not fag. Okay, well, well, see, I thought for some reason I was getting that mixed up with um You could have crazy sense. Totally because I knew there was some song uh that that had fag as the original lyric. And so listening to this song, I was like, wait, did they just did they just dub out fag and say drag instead? Confusing about that one.
So maybe that was where I was coming from earlier. I can't remember. I'll do that. And my best friend Marissa's wedding, she had an after party that was like karaoke. And um, we were doing summer nights, and I was Rizzo, and like when we got to that, and I was wasted, and we got to this is like two in the morning or whatever, and like in Maui, and we get to um that part of the song, and I was like, because he sounds like a fag. And in my mind, in my drunk mind, I thought everybody was gonna like burst out hysterically laughing. Of course, it was like a drunk loud two in the morning, like karaoke party, and every it was like a huge room like packed with people, nobody noticed. But I turned to the person I was standing with, and I was like, is that bad that I said fag?
And they were like, look at the groom. And my friend Ryan was um holding his microphone like a penis, and you try it to like butt fuck everybody standing near it. So I didn't ruin the wedding. But I but I but I also thought of that lyric as being either way. Yes, um, anyway. Um so this is a travesty. Wait, I you I love by the way. I I no, I was talking about Grease. Um I do really appreciate um Tom Bosley making his little statement about the longest running show. Oh, when he introduced Grease when he's like the longest running show. Isn't that crazy? He's like, it wasn't My Fair Lady, and it wasn't uh, I forget what the second one was. And he's like, uh, and it wasn't West Side Story, and I'm like, West Side Story ran for like two years tops, Tom Bosley.
Yeah, good. But um whoever wrote this. But really he but really he was just making a joke about Happy Days, which made me happy because like I felt oh by the way, I was wondering, do you as a millennial American, um, like did you even like do you even know Happy Days? I mean, I watched the odd episode, you know, back in the late 90s on Nick at Night between I Love Lucy and Mary Tyler Moore, but I never really got into it. It's like a dagger. You know, it was like the friends of the early 80s. Well, there was, you know, it was like a male focused show, and that wasn't my mystery. It was not a male-focused show. Yeah, I mean, like Fonzi, Ron Howard, you know, those were like the the main characters.
Wait, who are the female stars of that show that I would know? Well, Erin Moran. I mean, now she's a crazy Christian, no offense to your family, but like. But she uh, but she was Joni, and she and Scott Baio, who's really crazy, but they were like the romantic like young leads. So Erin Moran was a big deal. She was like a sex symbol of the early 80s, you know, like in those like Sergio Valenti jeans. And Mrs. Cunningham, uh, what's her name? Marion Ross was like the ultimate like TV mom.
[1:06:32] Ben Rimalower: She was like, she she, oh, she was like, now I'm not glamorous like Shirley Jones. Thank you. I was scared you wouldn't laugh, but it was just the digital delay. I love a good one. But no, Marion Ross was like so lovable. Like Marion Ross made me wish I weren't Jewish and like I had like a real mom who like baked cookies and like had read. Um also, and there was all Ron Howard's girlfriends who were like, you know, including it full circle, Crystal Bernard, who toured in Annie Get Your Gun featuring Lena Hall. Yeah, real, real for full circle. We talked about that with her, remember? Yeah, full circle to like four months ago when we interviewed her. That's when my life began. Um waiting for life to start. Um, okay, so next waiting for life to begin. Next. House of Flowers. Sleepin' Bee by Diahann Carroll, which I fucking love this number. What did you think?
[1:07:38] Daniel Nolen: Oh, tell me why.
[1:07:39] Ben Rimalower: Well, okay, well, I love her. I love watching her. I think she's a thrilling and deep and moving and beautiful performer. She's just so aesthetically pleasing in every way. And like, I just always like I love that like her like physical aesthetic um is just one of like beauty and like gentle grace. And yet, and yet, you know, I loved her and got to know her first on Dynasty, where she was like the black Joan Collins, and she was just like, I mean, she was a little nicer than Alexis Carrington in her character, Alexis Colby in her character as Dominique Devereaux. But um, but she was still pretty much like a hard bitch. But so, but and you hear that too, as much as her voice has like this beautiful, like almost kind of soprano-y upper register, her belt is much more like angry Judy Garland. Um I love to watch her and to hear her. And I wish I'd seen her in Sunset Boulevard.
[1:08:41] Daniel Nolen: Yes, I don't know what's wrong with me.
[1:08:44] Ben Rimalower: You know I'm a Harold Arlen queen. But I have never liked this song, and I just can't get into it, no matter how much.
[1:08:51] Daniel Nolen: I knew you didn't like it.
[1:08:53] Ben Rimalower: First of all, I love this song. This is like Make me Love It. Teach me how to feel. I mean, Barbara Streisand sang this is the I think I don't know what track it is, but it's on her first album, and she sings this arrangement. Uh, and it's it's so I just love it so much. And and there's that story um that people tell about Barbara about, you know, before she had recorded anything, before she was a singer, before she was even at the Bonsoir, she was kind of toying with the idea of uh using her singing abilities to make money while she studied acting. And she's got to pay for those baked potatoes.
[1:09:34] Daniel Nolen: That's right.
[1:09:35] Ben Rimalower: And so she sang this for a couple of friends of hers, but she told them to turn around and face the wall because she was too nervous and she didn't want them to look at her when she was singing. So she just sang this song, A cappella, and then when they turned around, they had tears in their eyes and they were crying, and they're like, oh my god, that was amazing. You have to sing. And so that, you know, was when she started booking these club gigs, and this became a staple of her repertoire. But I just love this song. I don't know what it is.
[1:10:05] Daniel Nolen: Like, like um, you know, it's a good one. I get so bored listening to it.
[1:10:10] Ben Rimalower: I don't know. I just think it's like such like young, youth innocence, like, and it's so beautiful, especially when with someone like Barbara or or Diahann Carroll, where it's like they just use that kind of innocence and grace to like communicate that kind of don't look innocence and grace are my brand. And don't talk to me. Shut up.
[1:10:35] Daniel Nolen: Okay. Um, but I'm glad that it worked for you.
[1:10:41] Ben Rimalower: Well, I I I love this song, but also I love I loved Diahann Carroll. Like, I thought she first of all, her the hair is just the same as Rupert's wig in the Brady Bunch. Like, and it's truly just it is. It's truly, it's truly the same hair as Chita Rivera in this very concert, just like scaled up a bit. Um and the red dress, but it's like way you can't, I mean, Chita, I mean, I'm kidding, but it's like you look at Chita and you're like, well, Chita, like you Chita actually was like way less pretty when she was younger. Yeah, she hadn't really settled into like her her like pixie that's not even a pixie that she has now, but whatever the haircut she has now.
[1:11:26] Daniel Nolen: That's Chita.
[1:11:28] Ben Rimalower: Chita grew into her face in her 60s when she was in Kiss of the Spider Woman.
[1:11:32] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally, totally. I love stars that have to grow into their face.
[1:11:38] Ben Rimalower: And I mean, in fairness, she had several faces to grow into. But Diahann Carroll's flawless. We love her.
[1:11:45] Daniel Nolen: Okay, so next speaking people that we want to have sex with, yes.
[1:11:50] Ben Rimalower: Yes, Tony Perkins. Um pretty sure he has like full-blown AIDS in this video.
[1:11:55] Daniel Nolen: I was thinking that.
[1:11:55] Ben Rimalower: I was like, this so it's so weird that this was the early 80s, like pre-AIDS, but yet most of the gay men in this special probably had AIDS already. And most of all, Tony Perkins was probably like the patient zero. Patient zero singing. Um, it's kind of impressive. And I'm not saying that he sounds good, but it's kind of impressive how good he sounds considering that it's 25 years since he did the musical that it's from, and how hard of a song it is, and the fact that he really has not been singing much since then.
[1:12:28] Daniel Nolen: Well, yes, and hearing him sing this, I was like, first of all, he's kind of like a faggy Dean Jones. Like it's very that's very Dean Jones. I think I think that well, I believe he was Sondheim's boyfriend at some point in the late 60s. Oh my. And I believe at some point he was possibly going to do Company. Like maybe it was before it was even Company when it was still like kind of the same idea as Follies, and they hadn't like parsed it all out yet or something. You know, I'm not sure how early in the in the the um evolution that was, but it uh that was something that kind of was on in talks at some point.
[1:13:07] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Um yeah, but I you know, this song Never Will I Marry, I mostly know it because of Barbara. I think it's is it the second, the second album?
[1:13:18] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:13:18] Ben Rimalower: No, no, I think it's the third album.
[1:13:20] Daniel Nolen: Third album.
[1:13:21] Ben Rimalower: So Never Will I Marry. I'm like, this truly speaks to Barbara's genius because like, and uh Peter Matz, who who arranged all her songs in those albums, but like this, Anthony Perkins delivers just such a straightforward um reading of this song. Whereas Barbara like really takes it to the next level and creates like a whole like three-act play with it.
[1:13:45] Daniel Nolen: Well, so does Judy.
[1:13:47] Ben Rimalower: But the problem is that like the song is untenable. I mean, unless you're Barbara Streisand like in her early 20s, you pretty much can't sing this song. I mean, this song has such a wide range. Like, why does it have to go like uh never never never will I marry? Well, I don't want to uh never never will I marry. Why do you have to go up there?
[1:14:09] Daniel Nolen: It does not love to go up there.
[1:14:11] Ben Rimalower: It does thrilling. It's thrilling when Barbara does it, right? Because when Barbara does it, it's like it's one of the few intervals so wide that even young Barbara shows the thrill. Like it's so wide that even like Superman like young Barbara Streisand still has to like accommodate the interval. Yeah, you know, and then Judy, Judy, it's just like thoughts and prayers, but like it's thrilling because it's Judy. Whereas Anthony Perkins, it's almost like someone singing it off. I mean, it's such a different register, it's almost unrelated to what's happening in the rest of the song.
[1:14:48] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[1:14:49] Ben Rimalower: And he's like, never, never, never will I marry he like changes his accent. He sounds like he's from the Midwest, and then he sings the high note like he's Richard Kind. Yeah, it's very Dean Jones. Um, but I mean at the end, even Barbara even changes it, uh, born to wander until I'm dead, and she sings it real high and to the breaking point. Um but it's a it's a choice. I I mean, can you imagine? Or you can, but can you? It's so weird to think about Barbara's like reckless uh but ultimately genius choices back in the day, and now just like the safety of the safety and subsequent lackluster delivery of uh movie partner sing Broadway.
[1:15:41] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:15:42] Ben Rimalower: Now, um speaking of Broadway, um, I realized what I hate about this video is the opposite of what I love about Patti LuPone, which is Patti LuPone always creates the feeling that tonight is the most important night, and this is the most important audience, and we are in the we are privileged to be watching her, you know, bring the house down to give us you know the highest possible stakes. And there's something about this whole thing. I mean, I feel like Tom Bosley plays it like he's like smoking a pipe in an easy chair.
[1:16:29] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:16:30] Ben Rimalower: When he introduces Godspell, it's all just so like that this like cozy dad, he might as well be wearing like a cardigan. It is so the opposite of like a thrilling event, you know.
[1:16:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, yeah, but I feel like that was it that was just very in keeping with the time. You know, it was like they were trying to, they were like, well, we're you know, coming where where where did this originally air? Like PBS or something?
[1:16:55] Ben Rimalower: Probably, yeah.
[1:16:55] Daniel Nolen: So it's like in 1982, it could have been on Showtime, you know.
[1:16:59] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. But it's like they're coming to, you know, Middle America in their easy chairs, winding down after a day's work. It's like I don't know. I mean, in my mind, I'm like, what what were the you know meetings that took place before this? What was like the tone they were trying to set? Who knows? I don't know. Anyway. But um, the Godspell number is fun, and all I could think about is that this is Carolee Carmello's favorite song.
[1:17:25] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:17:26] Ben Rimalower: Yes, and truly one of my favorites as well. Like I wrote down. It's a fabulous song. I fucking love this song. But just I just kept thinking like how much I want to hear Carolee sing, like Turnback Oh Man, or like Day by Day, or like By My Side, and she wants to be like some man not born to live at ease, doing what they please, ritual than the bees on me. Um, so then after this, moving right along, is Nell part two, where she is showing the judge's versatility, honey, because this song is the highlight. And I and I really and I really got Nell. Like we're talking about it. I was thinking that you might. Yeah, this really did it for me.
[1:18:10] Daniel Nolen: I'm so happy to hear that.
[1:18:11] Ben Rimalower: It's so, it's so beautiful and so moving, and you just hang with her on every word.
[1:18:17] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes, and the fact that she's she's like sitting on the edge of that weird like landing on the stairs, and it's it's uh she's just so grounded and and and in it and just telling the story. It's she's just I mean, she just has such a rare gift because when I watch Nell Carter sing like this, it's like on one hand, she's an actress and she takes me every single word. I'm just hanging on it. It's like watching, you know, I could be watching Judy Davis do a monologue or something, you know. You know, it's like, it's so uh I said Judy Davis, but I meant Judy Dench. But Judy Davis too. Like, um, you know, I it's you know, it's just I'm just so hanging on the words.
[1:19:05] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, but then, but then musically, I could be listening to like Ella Fitzgerald or Aretha Franklin. Like it's I'm absolutely hearing like an S-O-N-G.
[1:19:18] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, totally.
[1:19:20] Daniel Nolen: Well, that was the very experience I had watching her in this number. I was like, I am hanging on to every syllable, every word, every phrase, every line she says.
[1:19:31] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Um, so I love that. And I also love this song, uh, which I also should say, I love the Bernadette version of this song.
[1:19:39] Daniel Nolen: Yes, the Bernadette one is beautiful.
[1:19:41] Ben Rimalower: Yeah. Beautiful. For anyone that hasn't things, I know I say my things about Bernadette and people get their panties in a bunch. But I let anyone come for me about Bernadette after looking at my iTunes.
[1:19:52] Ben Rimalower: I guarantee I'm a bigger Bernadette fan than they are. I just don't, as Elaine Stritch would say, I just don't agree with all of her choices. But Bernadette's the C I know I said that came out as Patty, but it's in the lane line. I just don't agree with some of her choices. But uh but uh but you know, Bernadette's first two albums uh from I don't think it was like 78 and 80 or 79 and 80 or 70 and 79. It was Bernadette and Now Playing or sorry, it was called Bernadette Peters, and the second one was called Now Playing, were only ever released on a CD called Bernadette that combines almost all the tracks. Um but it has a uh what is it? What's the medley? It's mean to me together with I don't know why I love you, I just do.
Is that the combination? I don't know, but I haven't I don't know why I love you like I do I have it on Final. Um anyway, uh but anyway, those the for anyone that thinks they're a Bernadette fan but doesn't know that album, and by the way, I love Bernadette's other albums. I mean not the Rogers and Hammerstein thing that much, but I love uh the album called I Love I'll Be Your Baby Tonight, and I love uh Sondheim, etc. and Sondheim, etc. etc. So even as much as I love those albums, I will tell you that Bernadette is her best album. And her mean to me is um worthy of being discussed along with Nell Carter's. Totally, totally. Um, hold on, I'm looking it up right now. Yeah, it's called it's called Bernadette, and it's um the CD is called Bernadette.
I don't know, I don't or the way it is on Spotify or whatever is as Bernadette. Yeah. I don't know why I just do into mean to me. Yeah. And um I don't know why I love you like I do. That's such a that album is so spectacular. Number two, don't um number number ten, other lady. Oh my god. I mean but every every single track, only wounded. I never thought I'd break Pearls, a singer. I could write a book about Pros the Songs. It's all I mean, and and for no good reason, Broadway Baby also spectacular. Also spectacular, top of the top of the list. Top of the list. And by the way, you want to hear Bernadette's best belting, it's on that album. Between uh, I mean, the last note in Broadway Baby is absolutely thrilling, and the high belting in other lady.
I mean, it's it it's spectacular. Oh, sorry, Only Wounded is the other one with the crazy high belting. They're all spectacular. Anyway, we're off topic because Bernadette unfortunately is not in this broadcast.
[1:22:40] Daniel Nolen: Straight into Robert Morse. And you have to say, but he introduces him. Mike, I mean, I have my complaints. Um, but but the fact is you can't complain. I mean, you're getting Robert Morse recreating his original, you know, star making performance from How to Succeed. But I feel a little bit like he already did the movie of How to Succeed. So why would he want there to be a video of him looking way less cute doing a slightly less good and very truncated out of context version? Yeah, yeah. It does seem like there's a lot of And I I think I only want this song done by Twinks. I really don't want creepy. And you know what? I think I don't like Robert Morse. I mean, he's one of the two that we were bitching about in drag in my favorite Broadway.
Right. Well, and but I'm remembering now, I saw Wicked in San Francisco before it got to Broadway. And Robert Morse was the wizard, and then they fired him and they replaced him uh with uh uh I want to say Joel Gray, but it wasn't Joe Gray, wasn't it? John McMartin. Joel Gray was the original Wicked cast. Yes. So they're fired him and replaced him with um with Joel Gray. Uh both of whom, by the way, I find a little too like old and creepy for that part. Like I wish it had been like George Hearn or somebody. Yeah. Um but especially Robert Morse. I hated him when I saw him in Wicked. It really dragged the show down for me, and I thought it was such a good choice that they got rid of him. And um, were you like him here?
Mad Men watching. Yes, he was fabulous on Mad Men. So there's a difference between playing a weird, creepy old character and playing a musical theater character that isn't supposed to be like that. Right. And I think watching him in uh I've never seen how to succeed, but watching him in this number, I was like what you're saying. I was like, you really because he's not like a singer singer, you know, he's like one of those old school, like can carry a tune, but like really doesn't have a lot of like vocal talent. Um but he can't. But I feel like when he was like young, it probably was more like in the pocket, you know. Well, but he and he could also deliver it because he was young and cute and like a little quirky and eccentric, but like you're saying.
But go on. Okay, switch it. But you know, when you age, when you age out of that, like you're saying, it becomes a little creepy and like I know. I'm so scared of what's gonna happen when I start aging out of my cuteness. That'll never happen. Thank you, honey. Um, bottom line is I just wish Liz Callaway were singing it instead.
[1:25:24] Ben Rimalower: Yes, please lead the discussion on the next number. Someone who could never age out of just fabulousness is Alexis Smith coming on to sing Could I Leave You, although I didn't like it. Thank you. Okay, well, first of all, through no fault of hers, or at least through, you know, not really her fault, um, she's the one who's filmed in the most egregious camera close-ups singing into the close-up that really make you feel like you're in a studio and not in a live performance, and it just feels like so odd that she's doing this like stagey Broadway number in to the camera. I mean, this song is really devoid of any emotion or or um, you know, what everything you want from this song. I mean, it's so meh.
I mean, I I literally down, she's I literally wrote down meh, and then I wrote down she's just singing it like it's almost like she's she's doing a cold read. It's like she's doing every rhythm so as the part that she won a Tony for that launched the second act of her career. And I keep thinking I'm the problem, like an abused child. I'm like trying to like find fault in myself. Because I'm just like, give me the humanity of Jan Maxwell. Yeah, give me the genius musical comedy panache of Donna Murphy. Yeah, you know, a little bit of. I don't want this. I don't want to hear somebody be like, sweetheart, I have to confess. I don't want that. I leave you. Yeah, it's it's it's I want a fucking singer.
It's a musical. Why are they giving me Glenn Close? Oh in fairness, Glenn Close couldn't hit that note if her life depended on it. No, she certainly couldn't, but I feel like Glenn would at least like give you, you know, a little bit of meat to chew on. I feel like Alexis Smith is just like thrown by the camera, or I don't know what, but she's an old time movie star. Yeah, but she just seems so like uncomfortable and and just not so out of it. She's just not not in it, not in the L. So yeah, we don't we don't know what the problem is, but it does not work. But the dress, I will say, I was like No, she looks like a zillion dollars. She kind of looks like Rue McClanahan, but with like a with like a B Arthur dress.
[1:27:48] Daniel Nolen: That is not what I was thinking at all. I thought she looked glamorous and beautiful. You don't think Rue's glamorous? In like a trashy, like my grandma Dotty when we went on a cruise on the dress up night kind of way. You know that's all I care about. I mean, me too, but like I was trying to like speak to like the audience. Right, right, right. So is she. Um, anyway, moving on. Well, let's just skip right past the next number because I do not need to see the American Dance Machine do a big band number. I don't care if it's Donna McKechnie. I was about to watch this for Donna because I love her so much and she's in such good form. But you know what? There are so many good videos you can watch of Donna McKechnie dancing.
You do not need to watch the American Dance Machine do a big band number. I mean, it was truly like and by the way, if I were gonna jerk off to big band dance numbers, I'd want to see people dressed in the fabulous frocks of the 40s, not this fucking rompa room nonsense costumes that are in this TV special.
[1:28:50] Ben Rimalower: That was beautiful. I like that uh fabulous frocks of the 40s alliteration. I love you so much. Um you don't have to say it back, it's okay. Wait, sorry, what'd you say? I love you so much. Oh, I'm so sorry. I love you. Uh I I seem to be. The moment's gone. Anyway, someone we both love is Chita Rivera coming up next. Finally singing for us. And she's singing. Little old New York, although in the set list it's called Little One New York, which is fine. Little old New York is plenty good enough for me. She's so funny. It's from a it's from a show called Tenderloin, which I've never heard of in my life. I have to say that when she does this number, at the very beginning, she only gets to sing like two phrases before it immediately becomes a duet with Rene Zabios, who's another fabulous performer, but not that great of a singer.
But yeah, yeah. Chita in her two lines at the beginning of the song manages to transform this shitty thing into a thrilling event. When she starts singing, suddenly you feel the excitement in the room. The hairs on your neck stand up, and you suddenly feel like a little person in a big room filled with other little people watching a lady triumph. I love that. That's all you want to see. She makes it theatrical. She makes it theatrical. All of a sudden it gets theatrical when she just starts singing. And and it makes that number sustain. And maybe because it's about the gay 90s, it's far enough back that it's like more fun to watch the American Dance Machine do their thing as opposed to trying to be like cool in the contemporary material.
Right. But this number is watchable. It's watchable. And and Chita, like I said before, she's just so funny. And and I never really thought about her musical, uh, sorry, her physical comedy talents before, but it makes sense, you know. She knows how to use her body. Now, speaking of knowing how to use your body, the next number is Len Cariou singing Pretty Women from Sweeney Todd as a solo. And I want you all to think about the fact that this is a man who has had sex with both Glenn Close and Lauren Bacall.
[1:31:15] Ben Rimalower: Really? Yes. How do you wait? How do you know that? I mean, do they told me? No, everybody knows that. It's like a fact. Okay, cool. No, I mean it's like well documented. They were like a thing. You know, he I think he was married to Lauren Bacall. But I but he and Glenn Close were together for like some time. I love that. I'm loving Glenn's Instagram videos, by the way. Like I look forward to them every day. Anyway, so anyway, so Pretty Women, I I have to say, I love this song. It is so much. I mean, I know it's like, you know, breaking news. Pretty women's a good song, but it was breaking news. Like, I love it in the show because it's a dramatic piece. Totally, totally. The only the only two ways I've ever experienced this song.
Don't even. I've either experienced it with Barbara being angry that she's ruining the ladies who lunge with this song. Or I've experienced it in Sweeney Todd, where I thought it was like a dramatic, perfect piece of writing for the moment. Totally. When he was singing it out of context, I felt like, is this one of Sondheim's most beautiful, ravishing romantic ballads? Oh. I mean, absolutely. Not romantic in the sense of like a love song to a person. But just ravishing, you know, just rapturous. Like romantic composer. Yes, like the music was just soaring for me, you know. And I just felt like, I mean, for a minute, I actually went down this rabbit hole in my mind where I was like, is this Sondheim's most beautiful song? I I did the same thing. That line, Proof of Heaven. I was just like, oh, this song is Proof of Heaven. Jeez. It really, it was so lovely. I really, really loved. I really, really loved him doing it.
[1:33:07] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, same.
[1:33:09] Daniel Nolen: Um now, unfortunately.
[1:33:13] Ben Rimalower: The next number was another Sondheim original cast star turn.
[1:33:20] Ben Rimalower: It was fucking Glynis Johns singing Send in the Clowns.
[1:33:24] Ben Rimalower: Now let me tell you something. He wrote the song for, basically. When you see a star perform a song from their original show some years after the fact, very often you have to balance in your experience the thrill of seeing them recreate their magic to the extent that they do the natural diminishing of their gifts over time.
[1:33:48] Ben Rimalower: Glynis Johns only ever had a broke down croak of a voice. So what difference does it make that 10 years have passed since A Little Night Music? It shouldn't make any difference at all. So why don't I like this performance?
[1:34:04] Ben Rimalower: Um, I didn't mind it. I mean, I think the first thing I thought was, am I music driven?
[1:34:15] Daniel Nolen: Uh I mean, maybe I feel like you're getting more music driven the older you get.
[1:34:21] Ben Rimalower: No, that's not true at all. As I'm getting older, I've always lied about being lyric-driven, and it's becoming more true as I get older.
[1:34:30] Daniel Nolen: Oh.
[1:34:31] Ben Rimalower: Like, I mean, let's be honest, I never liked Patti for her lyric interpretation.
[1:34:37] Daniel Nolen: Well, yeah, you got me there.
[1:34:40] Ben Rimalower: But if you want the lyrics, read the libretto. Um but um she never said that.
[1:34:46] Ben Rimalower: But um, but no, but you know what actually killed me from the get-go with this is that I really need Send in the Clowns to start with that um like um do do do do oh the the like or I need that musical phrase.
[1:35:09] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes, yes, that's what I need.
[1:35:11] Ben Rimalower: That's what I need. It's like I don't care if it's piano only or if it's the New York Philharmonic, I need that phrase.
[1:35:19] Ben Rimalower: And this had some kind of bullshit, easy listening swell that weren't that. And then and maybe that hurt her too, because I feel like in the original, she's very like, me here at last on the ground.
[1:35:37] Daniel Nolen: You admit it.
[1:35:39] Ben Rimalower: Ah, the clowns.
[1:35:41] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:35:41] Ben Rimalower: Send in the clowns, and here she was like, me here at last on the ground, you admit it.
[1:35:50] Ben Rimalower: Like she was holding the fucking notes for the full length, and it didn't sound good, and it felt wrong and bad to me, and I was hating on my life.
[1:36:01] Daniel Nolen: Well, so I had I actually didn't mind it, and I and I wrote, you know, um, first of all, I kept thinking, is this I mean she is such like the old lady Haley Mills, it's so crazy.
[1:36:14] Daniel Nolen: It's like both that like old English training.
[1:36:16] Ben Rimalower: But uh Yes, I think Haley Mills eventually did play Desiree, but gone.
[1:36:20] Daniel Nolen: Totally, totally.
[1:36:21] Ben Rimalower: Um But this, the thing about this song is I I've said to you many times, this is like not one of my favorite Sondheim songs.
[1:36:30] Daniel Nolen: And actually, it is one of my favorite songs.
[1:36:32] Ben Rimalower: I don't love this Sondheim. I don't love this song, you know, I I don't hate it, but it's not one of my favorites.
[1:36:40] Daniel Nolen: But it's because I need to hear it.
[1:36:42] Ben Rimalower: I like it when it's being sung by like an older woman of a certain age.
[1:36:47] Ben Rimalower: Like I love the um the Judi Dench version. I love that Elaine Stritch version from The Carlisle.
[1:36:53] Daniel Nolen: Yes, yes, that's my favorite the Elaine Stritch one.
[1:36:56] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:36:57] Ben Rimalower: And this one I loved because it was like this, it, you know, as much as as as as good as Bernadette sung it, and as, you know, Judy Collins made it famous, but like I hate her version because it's so like, it's just like this young girl, like longs.
[1:37:14] Ben Rimalower: Like, no, I need to hear like an old broken down has-been star singing this song um to provide some sort of you know weight and context.
[1:37:25] Daniel Nolen: And and I feel like Glynnis, you know, for all of her vocal um limitations, I still I still loved it, and I thought this is the type of person who should sing this song.
[1:37:38] Ben Rimalower: Well, that's for sure.
[1:37:39] Ben Rimalower: Although to for the record, I actually enjoy, I mean, I love her original recording.
[1:37:43] Ben Rimalower: And I actually do enjoy the Judy Collins one and the Barbara Streisand one and the Betty Buckley one.
[1:37:48] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I like a lot for I like the Frank Sinatra version.
[1:37:51] Ben Rimalower: I like people doing vocal versions of the song.
[1:37:55] Ben Rimalower: Um but I also and I also really love the Judi Dench version and the original Glynnis recording.
[1:38:01] Ben Rimalower: But I I didn't like this Glynnis performance.
[1:38:03] Daniel Nolen: Although I did, she did win me back over when she did the reprise duet with him, or even before that, even when she just did the part after the um special material written by Barbara Streisand.
[1:38:16] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:38:17] Daniel Nolen: It was very Barbara Streisand partners, and no one else didn't.
[1:38:21] Ben Rimalower: Why did they do this weird truncated version?
[1:38:23] Ben Rimalower: All of a sudden we're doing like so much dialogue.
[1:38:26] Daniel Nolen: It was so weird.
[1:38:27] Ben Rimalower: Well I was like, in some world, would like would it be possible that Glynis Johns was like, I really need this dialogue to get me into character, you know, to give me some like motivation for the next verse.
[1:38:38] Daniel Nolen: I mean, obviously the audience felt it because they gave her a full standing ovation that no one else had gotten by.
[1:38:45] Ben Rimalower: I mean, the audience who they chose to ovate in this evening was so puzzling to me.
[1:38:51] Daniel Nolen: Totally.
[1:38:52] Ben Rimalower: I mean, those are the same things.
[1:38:52] Daniel Nolen: That could be the editing choices.
[1:38:54] Ben Rimalower: Yeah, I guess that's true.
[1:38:56] Ben Rimalower: Um, okay, we have to move along.
[1:38:58] Daniel Nolen: So next is Ray Walston singing Those Were the Good Old Days from Damn Yankees.
[1:39:03] Ben Rimalower: And I don't know any of these words, but um what's funny is that like when he when that when I realized that was the next number, I was like, I don't even remember this being on the broadcast.
[1:39:14] Ben Rimalower: And I was like, I I was like, I don't know why Ray Walston is so famous to me because I definitely saw the movie of Damn Yankees a few times as a kid.
[1:39:24] Ben Rimalower: But like I feel like I know him as well as I know Vivian Vance, which is obviously like far from true.
[1:39:30] Daniel Nolen: And I know that he had like a big hit sitcom like called I think My Favorite Martian, but I have never seen it.
[1:39:38] Ben Rimalower: Well, I know him from the 76 movie Silver Streak with Gene Wilder and Jill Clayburgh, which is fabulous.
[1:39:46] Daniel Nolen: And he plays like a villain.
[1:39:47] Ben Rimalower: Wait, was he in Twin Peaks or am I confusing him with somebody else?
[1:39:52] Daniel Nolen: Uh I don't know.
[1:39:54] Ben Rimalower: Wait, I'm looking it up.
[1:39:56] Daniel Nolen: I don't know.
[1:39:56] Ben Rimalower: I suddenly am like him up last night.
[1:39:58] Daniel Nolen: Wait, I think he was on Twin Peaks.
[1:40:00] Ben Rimalower: Was he?
[1:40:01] Daniel Nolen: I mean, he's very I was.
[1:40:02] Ben Rimalower: Wait, that would explain it.
[1:40:05] Daniel Nolen: The player.
[1:40:07] Ben Rimalower: I think Marker Lewis can't lose.
[1:40:09] Daniel Nolen: I mean, there's a guy on Twin Peaks that's very him, but no, but I don't see it.
[1:40:15] Ben Rimalower: I don't know.
[1:40:17] Ben Rimalower: And he just feels so familiar to me.
[1:40:20] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I know who he is, but he feels so like more than familiar.
[1:40:23] Daniel Nolen: I feel like he's like an actor that I've like somehow like grown up with or something.
[1:40:28] Ben Rimalower: And the last thing on Damn Yankees is like the straightest musical that I do not give a fuck about.
[1:40:34] Daniel Nolen: If I didn't care about it with like Jane Krakowski and Sean Hayes and Cheyenne Jackson and Randy Graff, I'm certainly as sure as shit not gonna give a shit about this.
[1:40:45] Ben Rimalower: Nonetheless, I couldn't stop watching it.
[1:40:47] Daniel Nolen: I just loved him.
[1:40:49] Ben Rimalower: Really?
[1:40:50] Daniel Nolen: I don't know.
[1:40:50] Daniel Nolen: I think this is one of the one of the numbers I went to the bathroom during.
[1:40:54] Ben Rimalower: But um what I did write down is he's very he has a very like David Hyde Pierce quality.
[1:41:01] Daniel Nolen: How nice.
[1:41:02] Ben Rimalower: No.
[1:41:05] Ben Rimalower: Uh they say it's wonderful is another like weird, um, like weirdly non-moving Ethel Merman performance.
[1:41:15] Daniel Nolen: Which is yeah, coming up, which is next.
[1:41:17] Ben Rimalower: And um uh yeah, they're gonna.
[1:41:21] Ben Rimalower: They say it's wonderful.
[1:41:22] Ben Rimalower: And this is when I wrote down wig question mark because I swear I saw a little lace front action happening in the front.
[1:41:28] Daniel Nolen: But she was.
[1:41:29] Ben Rimalower: I was definitely like more looking at Grindr on my phone at this point than looking at Ethel Merman.
[1:41:34] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, totally.
[1:41:36] Ben Rimalower: Um and this.
[1:41:38] Daniel Nolen: Wait, was this the end song?
[1:41:40] Ben Rimalower: No, this is the second to last song.
[1:41:42] Daniel Nolen: Yeah.
[1:41:42] Ben Rimalower: And then the closing number is uh Jerry Orbach singing Lullaby of Broadway.
[1:41:48] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:41:48] Ben Rimalower: And um Bette Midler has ruined that song for me though, because if Oh god, I love her version.
[1:41:55] Daniel Nolen: I know, and so I no, that's what I mean. I can't hear it not have that excitement.
[1:42:01] Ben Rimalower: Oh god, Bette's version is so good.
[1:42:03] Ben Rimalower: I um and then Ethel gets the final bow of the evening.
[1:42:07] Daniel Nolen: As well as she should.
[1:42:08] Ben Rimalower: As well as she should.
[1:42:10] Daniel Nolen: And is it just me or was there like two intermissions for this show?
[1:42:14] Ben Rimalower: Like they're not sure.
[1:42:15] Daniel Nolen: I mean, I took like five intermissions.
[1:42:17] Ben Rimalower: Yeah.
[1:42:17] Ben Rimalower: But they did like curtain down blackout like twice um during the broadcast.
[1:42:24] Daniel Nolen: Anyway.
[1:42:25] Ben Rimalower: Um, yeah, so that was thrilling and and you know, it introduced me to many uh Broadway stars who I've never really been exposed to.
[1:42:36] Daniel Nolen: So I I felt educated, and I hope our our listeners will as well.
[1:42:40] Ben Rimalower: You can find it um on YouTube Showstoppers, right?
[1:42:44] Daniel Nolen: Is how it's listed on YouTube.
[1:42:46] Ben Rimalower: Oh yes.
[1:42:46] Ben Rimalower: It's called on YouTube, it's called Showstoppers: The Best of Broadway.
[1:42:50] Daniel Nolen: And it'll be on our our Broken Records uh podcast playlist.
[1:42:54] Ben Rimalower: 100%.
[1:42:55] Ben Rimalower: And yeah, again, uh we've gotten lots of good feedback from y'all.
[1:43:00] Daniel Nolen: Um, but do you know what we forgot to do last week?
[1:43:03] Ben Rimalower: What?
[1:43:05] Daniel Nolen: Dolly concert kill Audra, Marin, Judy.
[1:43:09] Ben Rimalower: Oh, of course.
[1:43:11] Daniel Nolen: Oh god, that's so good.
[1:43:13] Ben Rimalower: Um, okay, for me, I would have to say.
[1:43:19] Daniel Nolen: Oh god.
[1:43:20] Ben Rimalower: I mean, Audra, Dolly.
[1:43:24] Daniel Nolen: Um.
[1:43:27] Ben Rimalower: Oh god.
[1:43:28] Ben Rimalower: This is.
[1:43:29] Ben Rimalower: Mmm.
[1:43:30] Ben Rimalower: It's so hard.
[1:43:31] Daniel Nolen: I mean.
[1:43:33] Ben Rimalower: Audra, Dolly, I guess.
[1:43:36] Daniel Nolen: You want to pay extra respect to Marin because she's not like us.
[1:43:39] Ben Rimalower: But she's already dead, so it's easier to kill her than like poor Judy, who like his team so much for the progressive cause.
[1:43:45] Daniel Nolen: That's right.
[1:43:46] Ben Rimalower: I I'm more into Judy's voice, and I would I would probably rather sit through a Judy concert because I love her so much.
[1:43:54] Daniel Nolen: True.
[1:43:54] Ben Rimalower: I know that sounded so negative, but I didn't mean it that way.
[1:43:57] Ben Rimalower: I would rather um, you know, uh it's in a you know, Marin and Judy would both be wonderful, but I think I would have to choose Judy just because I love her voice and it's so perfect and unique.
[1:44:10] Daniel Nolen: But I have I've seen Judy several times and I've never seen Marin, but I'd have to say Judy if I had to.
[1:44:17] Ben Rimalower: Sorry.
[1:44:17] Ben Rimalower: I mean, it's I feel like it's gauche to say that, but sorry, killing.
[1:44:21] Ben Rimalower: Best of all from from this week's program.
[1:44:26] Daniel Nolen: Uh uh, Dolly Concert Kill, Donna McKechnie, Pamela Myers, and Susan Browning.
[1:44:35] Ben Rimalower: Oh, I mean, I guess I would kill I mean I know I would kill Susan, and I guess I would say Donna McKechnie for Dolly and Pamela Myers.
[1:44:45] Daniel Nolen: Pamela Myers for concert.
[1:44:47] Ben Rimalower: I see I would do Pamela for concert because I think she's so funny.
[1:44:51] Ben Rimalower: For Dolly, because I think she's so funny and quirky.
[1:44:54] Ben Rimalower: And Donna, I just want to see in eyelashes and just like, you know, I choose the set list.
[1:45:02] Daniel Nolen: Yeah, well.
[1:45:03] Daniel Nolen: Um, who would you choose for Audra, Marin, and Judy?
[1:45:08] Ben Rimalower: Same.
[1:45:09] Ben Rimalower: I mean, you're kind of like backed into a corner with that one.
[1:45:12] Daniel Nolen: Right.
[1:45:13] Ben Rimalower: Alright, well.
[1:45:15] Ben Rimalower: Um, well, we'll, and we're gonna still think about what to do next week, but um, yeah, if you have any suggestions, please reach out.
[1:45:25] Daniel Nolen: Yes.
[1:45:25] Daniel Nolen: Slide into the DMs.
[1:45:27] Ben Rimalower: Yes.
[1:45:27] Ben Rimalower: Daniel loves when people slide into his DMs.
[1:45:31] Daniel Nolen: I do, honey.
[1:45:33] Daniel Nolen: It's it's getting lonely out here in Bed-Stuy.
[1:45:37] Ben Rimalower: Just in bed.
[1:45:39] Ben Rimalower: Uh the that always, but we love you.
[1:45:43] Daniel Nolen: Love you, Ben.
[1:45:45] Ben Rimalower: No Ben.
[1:45:47] Daniel Nolen: Bye.
[1:45:50] Ben Rimalower: Thanks for listening to Ben Rimalower's Broken Records on Broadway World.
[1:45:54] Ben Rimalower: For more episodes, visit Broadway World, iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever podcasts do be.
[1:46:00] Daniel Nolen: This episode was edited by me, Daniel Nolen.
[1:46:03] Daniel Nolen: Thanks to Emmy winning composer and lyricist Lance Horn for the Broken Records theme song.
[1:46:08] Daniel Nolen: Follow us both, Ben Rimalower and Daniel Nolen on all y'all's socials.
[1:46:11] Ben Rimalower: That's Ben Rimalower. B-E-N R I M A L O W E R.
[1:46:17] Daniel Nolen: And that's Nolan with an E, not Nolan with an A.
[1:46:20] Daniel Nolen: Because Nolan with an A is an ass.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
