What does it take to champion an artist's body of work while navigating the evolving landscape of nonprofit theater?Emily Shooltz, Artistic Director of Signature Theatre in NYC, joins Jennifer to discuss her winding journey from dramaturgy and new play development to artistic leadership... Read More
From the show: Empowered Artist Collective Podcast - for actors, singers, dancers, writers, creators and performers
About
What does it take to champion an artist's body of work while navigating the evolving landscape of nonprofit theater?
Emily Shooltz, Artistic Director of Signature Theatre in NYC, joins Jennifer to discuss her winding journey from dramaturgy and new play development to artistic leadership. With a passion for new work and emerging artists nurtured over 14 years at Ars Nova, Emily shares how her dramaturgical roots inform her approach to leadership and collaboration. Together, they explore Signature's unique residency model, championing multidisciplinary artists, and navigating what Emily calls an "elegant contraction" while staying true to an institution's mission.
From cultivating your artistic taste and articulating why work resonates with you to balancing creative vision with the realities of leadership, Emily offers insight into what it means to support artists and their evolving careers. It is a conversation about artistic curiosity, intentional leadership, and creating space for artists to thrive.
Emily Shooltz has been the Artistic Director of Signature Theatre in New York City since fall 2024. She has two decades of experience identifying, cultivating, and mentoring artists and arts administrators. She spent 14 years as the Associate Artistic Director at Ars Nova, where she worked to grow the non-proft from a fedgling development and producing organization to New York City's premier hub for emerging artists in live entertainment. In her years with the organization, she was integral to the commissioning, development and production of critically-acclaimed and award-winning shows including the Broadway musical KPOP, Dave Malloy's Tony Award-winning Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812; Heather Christian's multiple-award winning Oratorio for Living Things; Jennifer Kidwell and Scott R. Sheppard's Obie Award-winning Underground Railroad Game; Bess Wohl’s nationally acclaimed Small Mouth Sounds; César Alvarez and the Lisps’ Lortel Award-winning FUTURITY and new work with music-theater stars The Bengsons, Sky-Pony and Andrew Butler, among many others. She also co-created and oversaw Ars Nova’s slate of artist development programs, where she worked with hundreds of emerging theater, music and comedy artists each year. Emerging playwrights and projects she fostered in Ars Nova's Play Group and resident artist programs have gone on to win every major theater award, including Tonys, Pulitzer Prizes, Obies, MacArther Genius Awards, Whiting Awards, Drama Desk, Lortel and Outer Critics Circle Awards. Prior to Ars Nova, she served as the Literary Manager at Manhattan Theatre Club, where she oversaw the new play commissioning program and facilitated season planning for their Broadway and Of-Broadway theaters. She has held staff and freelance dramaturgy positions at the Wilma Theater; Centerstage, Baltimore; Yale Repertory Theatre and the O’Neill Theater Center; has guest lectured at schools including NYU, Williams, Columbia, Yale, Montclair State University and The New School, and served on the selection committees for the Kesselring Prize and Princess Grace Award. She also consults on theater & television projects, live events and philanthropic work and has served as an adjunct faculty member at Montclair State University. Emily holds an MFA in Dramaturgy and Dramatic Criticism from the Yale School of Drama. Her work with emerging artists and writers has been profled by Playbill Online and The Interval.
Download the FREE Monologue Selection Toolkit: www.jenniferapple.net/freebie
Want to coach with Jennifer? Schedule a session here! www.calendarpa.com/@jenniferapple
Learn more about Jennifer Apple: www.jenniferapple.net
Jennifer Apple’s IG: @JenniferApple_
EAC IG: @EmpoweredArtistCollective
EAC TikTok: @EmpowerArtistCollective
Learn more: https://www.empoweredartistcollective.com/
Sign up for our newsletter: https://www.empoweredartistcollective.com/newslettersignup
Check Out Our Merch: https://empoweredartistcollective.threadless.com
Any thoughts you'd like to share? Email us at EmpoweredArtistCollective@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Emily Shooltz: Hi, I'm Emily Shooltz, and welcome to the Empowered Artist Collective Podcast.
[0:07] Jennifer Apple: Hello. Welcome to the Empowered Artist Collective Podcast. I'm your host, Jennifer Apple, actor, coach, monologue whisperer, writer, dog mom, and creator of the Empowered Artist Framework. And I believe there's another way to build a creative, sustainable life in the arts that doesn't involve losing yourself. I'm so glad you're here. In this episode of our Artistic Director miniseries, I sat down with Emily Shooltz, whose career has taken her from dramaturgy and new play development with 14 years at Ars Nova, championing emerging artists and original work, all the way to Artistic Director of Signature Theatre in New York City. Emily shares her winding journey to artistic leadership, how her dramaturgical roots inform her approach to collaboration, and what it means to champion an artist's evolving body of work rather than a single production.
We explore Signature's unique residency model, embracing multidisciplinary artists, how to cultivate your artistic taste, ways to balance creative vision with leadership, and what Emily looks for on the other side of the audition table. This conversation is a reminder that artistry is constantly evolving, and championing artists means remaining curious about who they are, what they're creating, and who they have the potential to become. This episode is powered by Welcome to Times Square.com, the billboard where you can be a star for a day. Enjoy.
[1:19] Jennifer Apple: Emily Shooltz, welcome to the studio.
[1:24] Emily Shooltz: Thank you so much for having me.
[1:26] Jennifer Apple: Oh my god, I'm so grateful that you're here.
[1:27] Emily Shooltz: It's so great to be here.
[1:28] Jennifer Apple: Thank you. For anybody who does not know you, who are you today?
[1:33] Emily Shooltz: Who am I today? What a good question. I mean, I think the reason you're talking to me today is because I'm the Artistic Director at Signature Theatre. Beyond that, I'm like a—I'm like a theatre creature.
[1:46] Jennifer Apple: A theatre creature. You're like, not a theatre human, a creature.
[1:49] Emily Shooltz: Yeah.
[1:50] Jennifer Apple: Why that particular word?
[1:52] Emily Shooltz: Yeah, it's like I burrowed in at some point early on in my life and haven't found my way out of the burrow. I've had a kind of windy journey to artistic directorship. I think there are some people who always know that that's sort of like the North Star that they're headed towards. My path has been a little more circuitous to that. And it's like, you know, and I think coming into a new institution, it's like putting on a coat and being like, does this coat fit me? Is this somebody else's coat? Is it the right color for me? Maybe I need to tailor it a little bit.
[2:28] Jennifer Apple: I'm so excited to dive into that coat of many colors or no colors or a single color. I am curious about your winding road to get there. And arguably, that is, you know, over the past season, specifically when we had our artistic director miniseries, talking about the many different ways that people end up to these positions that they think perhaps have some sort of straight linear path when they don't. So I'm curious for you how that became even a hat that you were desiring to take or even knew was possible and also just like the artistic theatre creature journey that took you on that path.
[3:03] Emily Shooltz: Yeah, it's so funny. I was doing, you know, just like a sort of coffee informational interview with a young producer sort of just out of undergrad the other day. And she was very crystal clear. I want to be an artistic director. So how did you get there? Yeah, it's like, well, I don't know that you can replicate any one person. And also, like, it's interesting, because I know for myself growing up, that wasn't, and maybe I wasn't hanging out in like the circles of people who were saying that. But that wasn't something that people were like, I know that this is a job, even it was that amazing clarity that she was sort of reflecting at me, because I certainly did not have an awareness of that when I was coming out of undergrad. I mean, I like everyone, I started by acting and directing in high school and undergrad. I, you know, I was fortunate enough to learn early on that I was not going to be an actor professionally.
[3:47] Jennifer Apple: Was somebody else's telling you that? Or was that—
[3:49] Emily Shooltz: Oh, yeah, I had a professor who was like, very clear, like, you have other talents. And you're, you know, you're very bright. And let's figure out what the internalizing that and demoralizing you. You're like, actually, it was total relief, because I knew I think you know, and to the degree that you can know at that age that it wasn't the right fit. So I started directing and then I kind of like fell backwards into a dramaturgy internship after undergrad. Second stage in Baltimore had this amazing internship program where they gave you housing and it was like a whole cohort of 10 or 12 of us. So it was almost like a little grad program. You know, I had peers and they were all in the different departments and that institution was so big that I got to learn by just absorbing how a big not for profit ran.
And that's how I started to figure out that there were all these different jobs that weren't just acting or directing that there were these administrative jobs in all these different teams that people could do. And I had some amazing mentors there who were really generous with me and generous with their time. And I really loved dramaturgy. I particularly loved watching the people who I was, you know, being mentored by talk to writers. Yeah. And they were doing a lot of new work there at the time. So I went from there to the Wilma in Philadelphia, which was also an incredible experience because the Wilma was at that point, they had just moved into their new space. They were very small. So center stage.
Wilma was tiny. And because I was kind of eager and willing, I ended up in a lot of rooms I had no business being in. Did you ask or were you just like brought along because they were like, you're here?
[5:26] Emily Shooltz: Both. Okay, I think both things happen. There were times when something just needed doing and I sort of said, I'll go do that. Yeah. And then there were other times where people invited me in. But I was assisting the artistic directors, I was assisting the dramaturge, I was assisting the casting director, I was assisting the director of education, like I really was allowed to take on real work. Amazing. And from there, decided that I wanted to pursue dramaturgy mostly because I love new plays so much. Okay. And I went to graduate school at Yale for dramaturgy and spent my first year sort of like flailing around trying to figure out why I had ended up in grad school. And then once I realized that and the program at that point really did have a sort of threefold focus.
There were folks who were really interested in getting their doctorates and becoming academics and becoming professors. There were people who were really interested in critical writing and becoming writers and critics. And then there were those of us who really wanted to focus on production dramaturgy and new play development. And once I learned that it was okay for me to really just mostly be excited about the new play development track and the dramaturgy track for productions, I found my happy place. And the best thing about being there was that I was with this incredible community of artists and sort of learned by doing with them. So anyway, long story short, I graduated, I needed health insurance and a way to pay off my student loans.
Who doesn't? I had a short stint working as an agent's assistant in the city and that's what brought me to New York. But I really miss being around production. And then I had had when I was an undergrad, an internship at Manhattan Theater Club, like a summer internship. And I had stayed in touch with people there and they had a position open up in their literary office. And so I transitioned over there and I spent four years as the literary manager at MTC. And that was like a crash course in reading every play that had ever been written in English. Yeah. For better or for worse.
[7:34] Emily Shooltz: For better or for worse. And I saw a ton of work and I really got the lay of the land in terms of what was being produced at every theater in the city and around the country and in England. And it was like a whole next step education. And I started there right when they opened the Broadway Theater, then Biltmore, now Freedman. So also being at an institution that was suddenly going through a major growth moment was a really informative chapter of my life as they and we learned how to program for Broadway. And so I spent four years there. I felt like I learned a ton. And then I had the opportunity to join Ars Nova when Ars Nova was a very fledgling, tiny, baby not-for-profit. Jason Egan had just become the first artistic director.
And they had had this beautiful venue on 54th Street, but it had mostly been operating as a space up until that point. Jason and John and Jenny were curating. But this artist community had started to grow really organically and they had started to develop more things. And it felt like the right moment to actually put some systems and some programs in place. And so I joined up with Jason and a very small, I think there were six of us when I started, maybe five and a half. And we started from scratch, really. And we created programs and started producing full productions and runs of shows and commissioning things. And I was so lucky to inherit the sort of first version of what became the Ars Nova play group there.
Kim Rosenstock had invited a group of amazing writers. I mean, it was like, it was Meriwether and Kyle Jarrell and Lemuel Miranda, and it was just like all these incredibly talented people. And we kind of formalized that and made it a two-year cycle. And so there was the play group. There were the other artist development programs that were really supporting music and comedy artists. And then the full productions that we started doing on 54th Street and then in other spaces around the city. And that was a 14-year adventure. A long time. Yeah. And I feel like I, you know, that job was 17 different jobs over the course of that time. And I really grew with the organization and the organization grew with me. And then we had a global pandemic.
[10:03] Emily Shooltz: Did we? And, you know, along the way, I got married. I had two kids. I was in a really different place in my life, kind of coming out of COVID than I was when I started Ars Nova. And it felt like the right time to step away. Both because it was the right time for me, but also because it was the right time for Ars Nova. Ars Nova really thrives on new ideas, fresh energy. It's all about the early career artists coming in the door and it was time for someone else to have something new to offer for the wave that was coming in now. And they're under amazing leadership now. And, you know, it's so cool to see the place thrive in a new chapter that's different because it feels like that's what we built into the DNA of the place was to be able to be adaptable and not precious and responsive.
And so then I took three years away from institutional theater. I was consulting and I was focusing on some family stuff and really stepped back and wasn't sure whether I would have another institutional theater job at that point. I wasn't sort of gunning to go back into an institutional theater job. But when I was watching across the industry, as I'm sure you've talked to other leaders about, there has been a lot of changeover in artistic leadership in the city. And a lot of my peers and colleagues and pals who I came up with stepping into some of these leadership roles. That's been the most beautiful thing, actually, of the people that I've spoken to and the overlap of people sharing each other's names of like, we've all come up together and we're watching each other grow and also supporting each other's work. And also just because of that, the networking, and not in a gross way, but the networking of community. It's almost like a weaving.
[11:55] Emily Shooltz: Exactly. It's quite gorgeous, honestly. Yeah. It feels like I stepped into a net of folks who are already in community and in dialogue and really trying to raise each other up, which we can talk more about. I think stepping into one of these jobs in a time of scarcity has led to some really beautiful partnerships and collaborations. But anyway, the short version of a long story is when the Signature job opened up, Signature is very special to me as a young arts administrator and particularly someone who had new work in my blood and also writers are my great love. Watching Jim Houghton build this temple on the mountain when I was a young arts administrator, I'm going there and having that experience. I saw seasons when they were over further down on 42nd Street and then going to the center for the first time and feeling what it did for not just
[12:57] Emily Shooltz: It's not just the reputation of a writer, but the breadth of understanding of an artist's work when you get to be in dialogue with multiple productions, when you get to see someone take the form and turn the form, and the way in which that's impacted what we consider the contemporary canon. It's a really special and really unique thing, that residency model. When I think about my skill set, what I bring to the table, it actually felt like, of any of these jobs, this one is probably the right fit. So, here I am.
[13:36] Jennifer Apple: I love it. We talked about having you on last season. You were like, I'm new. I need a moment to sit in. So, I am curious for you how it's been.
[13:48] Emily Shooltz: I think the first year feels like being shot out of a cannon for anyone stepping into a leadership role, and particularly for me, because I had been at one institution for so long, and it was a place that I helped build. So, I created the systems that made sense to me. It was very tailored to my way of doing things. Coming into an institution with a 35-year history is completely different. Trying to simultaneously listen and learn and absorb and level set where things were, while simultaneously trying to make it yours, set a course, have a vision, have the confidence to know where you want to take it next. Sometimes, those things are really in conflict, or there just isn't enough breathing room to do both.
[14:45] Jennifer Apple: Or I would imagine also maybe the infrastructure isn't also potentially built yet for the changes you might want to implement down the line or the resources. Are you able to talk more about that, as in when you came into Signature, what were some of the things or are some of the things that you're hoping for in the next whatever seasons of its existence, and what you inherited that you were like, okay, this is the shoulder upon which I'm moving, and how do you incorporate those two things?
[15:15] Emily Shooltz: Yeah. I mean, I knew coming in, and I had thought a lot about it during the conversations I had leading up to being offered the job, I knew that the residency model was central and that right now, because everybody is contracting mostly, it was important to think I keep using this phrase to the point that now I feel like I've overused it, but what is an elegant contraction? How do you contract with purpose? How do you contract with clarity? The stupid metaphor I use is we're all running around saying, I can't afford pants, I have to cut off my legs. It's like, what about shorts? Can we talk about a skirt? Yeah, or a dress. Maybe there's another way through this that feels a little more thoughtful.
I knew the residency model felt crucial for Signature at a time of contraction, because it is the thing that makes Signature unique. If you're out there trying to talk about your story as an institution in an ecosystem where there are many not-for-profit theaters trying to tell their story and set themselves apart, and you're trying to fundraise and attract audiences, that's what makes Signature special. So I knew I wanted to keep the residencies. I felt like we could simplify them. There had been, over the history of Signature, a number of different versions of the residencies with different parameters. We've simplified that down to they're just Signature residencies now. It's still an upfront commitment to at least three shows with each artist.
Those can be a tailored combination of commissions and world premieres or revivals or re-examinations of a piece that maybe didn't get enough exposure the first time out, or maybe approaching it with new collaborators. So we'll be having that dialogue with each resident artist and figuring out what body of work they choose to share. So there will definitely still be some revivals. There will definitely still be new plays and probably everything in between.
[17:25] Emily Shooltz: I talk about it like expanding the definition of who could be a Signature artist, but if you actually look at the folks who have had Signature residencies, it's not really that new. But in inviting Heather Christian in as my first resident, who I was choosing, Heather is a multidisciplinary artist. She is thinking about live theater as a communal experience in a slightly different way. She's really pushing on the form. She's a performer. She's a composer. She is a playwright. I think there's a history at Signature of embracing the Bill Irwins and the Martha Clarks and the Negro Ensemble Company. It has not all been playwrights writing single-authored texts. I'm interested in continuing that, of looking at some of these multi-hyphenates and seeing what happens when you put them in proximity with someone who's writing a more traditional play.
This season was the first season I curated. I was producing last season, but this was my first season. You'll see that the other thing I want to try to do is to bring the productions closer together again. So the early days of Signature, it was one playwright one season. You'd go see the August Wilson season or the Tony Kushner season. That let you have that deep dive experience. I'm not sure we'll ever get back to that, but I do think that having the shows closer together, there are threads that you can connect between those shows. There are ways in which each of them is richer for having experienced the other.
[19:07] Jennifer Apple: I love it. As a coach, I often give folks monologues for their BFA, MFA audition stuff. That's a huge thing that I do. I think the most beautiful thing that happens is when I give a monologue that I've chosen specifically for them, and it's from a playwright that they don't know. Then all of a sudden, it brings them down a huge deep dive. I'm like, hey, check out this playwright. They're on the Kilroy. Look who else is on the Kilroy list. See what else. Where have they been produced? What other artists are being produced at this theatre? There's a certain kind of aesthetic or a vibe that clearly this theatre is into this kind of work if you are. It's a really beautiful moment when somebody is exposed to an artist and the work that they do.
Then they fall in love with them, and then they get to see that evolution. For me as a native New Yorker, having grown up seeing Signature work, that has been something that's allowed me to learn about artists that I never would have otherwise known and really have gotten that thread of it over a little bit of time. It's been beautiful to find new people that otherwise maybe wouldn't have the same kind of platform or are doing it in smaller different kinds of ways. To champion that, I think, is a really special thing.
[20:17] Emily Shooltz: It's been such an interesting move too of when I was coming up, not aging myself, but it was very much like pick a lane and stick in it. There is certainly a movement now of embracing the multi-hyphenate, the multidisciplinarians of our craft in that they are bringing things that, not to say that somebody who is really, really good at what they do in the one lane isn't worth celebrating, and to be able to champion that as its own celebration feels very important and necessary. I think it's great that you guys are giving somebody like that a platform and other folks like that as well. You don't have to pick, like, if I'm a playwright, I have to do it this way, and therefore, this is the only thing I'm doing. It's like, no, actually, my other artistry is supporting the work that I'm trying to create.
[21:10] Emily Shooltz: Yeah. I think we'll do more of that next season. We'll start a residency with Issa Davis, who is also a multi-hyphenate. I was first introduced to Issa as an actress, as a performer, but now many people know her because of Warriors and some of her other work as a composer and as a writer. She has these beautiful plays, and she's amazing. She's luminous, and I can't wait to have the opportunity to show all those different parts of her residency. I think the other thing that's really cool about the residency is that we sort of learned in real time this year is that when you are revisiting a second production or third production with an artist, they know the staff. They know the team. They're very embedded in the organization already, you build muscles and systems and ways of communicating that you get to use again, which is really fulfilling for everybody, I think, because it doesn't feel like starting from scratch every time.
[22:09] Jennifer Apple: I'm curious how you find these artists for you. What is your process? Are people submitting to Signature? Are you going and scouting people? Is it at this point, yeah, the net that you are a part of, you all talk and you're like, have you seen this person? Oh, I went to see your show here at this thing, blah, blah, blah, blah. Where are you finding your folks and then the work that is inspiring you?
[22:37] Emily Shooltz: Yeah. It's an interesting question for Signature because since we are based on a residency model, I'm really not accepting submissions and programming a season the way some of my peers are. We're only doing three shows a season right now. I inherited six or seven residencies that weren't done yet. Lauren, for example, who's amazing. There will be a process over the next few years of finishing out residencies with people who are mid-process. It's going to be a slow roll of inviting new residents in. We had Heather this year. Issa will start a residency next year. Then beyond that, I'm not sure because it's going to depend how soon some of the work comes in from the other resident artists who are still active, which in some ways is very freeing because it means that when I'm in conversation and in dialogue with writers and with artists, it's by necessity like a long-term conversation.
It's not a promise of next season I can X, Y, or Z or submit your draft to me and maybe I'll program it. It's really about like let me get an understanding of the arc of your body of work and let me come to see all the things that you're doing at other places. Then when the stars align, if I have the opportunity to invite a new resident and it feels like the right moment for someone because it's kind of intense to sign up for that kind of long-term relationship, then it will kind of more organically be right.
[24:18] Emily Shooltz: I think that's what's interesting too. Again, naming the fact that no institution is doing things the same way and therefore every artistic directorship is doing something very differently in the way that they operate. I'm curious about your day-to-day. What are you doing? What is the skill set? What would you say like high level and then like low level but for you in conjunction with that, what are the skills that you are like this is what is allowing me to serve in this capacity the best way that I know I possibly can?
[24:52] Emily Shooltz: It's an interesting question. I'm sure you get a million different answers because the answer probably everyone gives you is no two days are the same. I'm a dramaturge by training. I'm not a director. I am not a writer. I don't have a generative practice of my own. A lot of what I do is facilitate conversation whether that's with artists or staff members or potential donors or board. It's a lot of figuring out how to translate between different constituencies so that if I'm in a room with an artist and they're talking about the thing that they're trying to make that I can take that information into a meeting with folks who are budgeting or fundraising or marketing or I can take that information to the board and try to communicate the spirit of what it is so that everyone is on the same page and working in tandem towards the same goal.
[25:56] Emily Shooltz: Sometimes that means being in a budget meeting and talking about what the priorities are when we're trying to balance a budget that will hold the heart of what the artistic objective is. And sometimes that means sitting with a funder and trying to explain why X, Y, or Z program that we are seeking funding for is so crucial to the heart of the mission and the work that ends up on the stage. Sometimes I'm in a hiring process and so I'm trying to communicate what the culture of the company is and what skill set we really need to raise the bar on whatever position. I think the thing that probably every artistic director will tell you is that it's very schizophrenic because you're hour to hour in so many meetings and you're in dialogue with different people and all of those conversations feel like they have a slightly different context.
And having the kind of mental nimbleness to jump from, after this I'm going to go and watch a reading of a workshop that we've been workshopping this week and then talk to the artists about their piece and be in that mode and then go straight from there to a meeting with a funder and straight from that to a pre-show copy. It requires a lot of stamina and adaptability and flexibility, I would think. But also I think for me, I find the only way I can approach it is with a lot of humility of like, I can only be in the conversation that I'm in and try to be really present and meet whichever conversation it is on its own terms and understand what the person I'm working with in that moment needs. For folks who either are like that girl that you knew that was like, hey, I want to do this, or folks that are like, I love this industry.
I have really good x, y, and z skill sets. I think this might be something that I could pursue. What, and knowing full well that there is no linear way to do it, are there certain things that you find or have seen would be like helpful for folks to at least have in their back pocket or skill sets to develop in the process of potentially pursuing it that tend to be maybe more universal artistic director qualities or skill sets that everybody, the intersectionality and event diagram, at least they all kind of share that?
[27:10] Emily Shooltz: Yeah. I mean, I think it requires a lot of kind of open curiosity. And I mean that broadly, like curiosity about the work. Who's making something interesting? Where can I go see something I haven't seen before? How is this artist making work in a way that, how can I support that? Like not getting too ossified in any assumptions or systems or beliefs, but just like kind of staying open. I think developing your own taste is, it's an intangible, but it is a vital, crucial piece of the puzzle. And the best advice I can give on that is to see as much as you possibly can. Like even if it's bad, particularly if it's free, if someone offers you a ticket, if you're a young person in the city, there is so much to see.
And you can do it affordably if you're willing to kind of jump through some hoops. And then even better than just seeing it, if you can force yourself to write about it, because writing is thinking. And if you jot down notes in a journal or send yourself a notes app or whatever, that will force you to start to articulate what you did and didn't like about something and why. Because it's very easy to say, I hated that. But it's much harder to try to drill down on what about it wasn't for you? Or what about it did you feel was lacking in craft? Or what about it offended you? The gut reaction can be really powerful, but being able to clarify with more detail is a skill set that if you can develop it is so in demand.
And then having confidence, once you do that long enough, you start to have confidence about what you love. And then you're able to articulate with passion why. And being able to know that this thing is not for me, it's not my cup of tea, but it's very successful on its own terms. And it might actually be this person's cup of tea. That's another incredible skill set. As you're chasing artistic jobs, you're probably going to end up in an institution. And the artistic leader may not have the same taste that you do or may have a sort of version of taste. Or there may be an institutional sort of brand that you may love something, but it may not be right for whatever reason. Or you may not love something, but realizing that it might be right and it's probably worth passing up the chain.
If you feel like on its own terms, it is successful. I hear the de-centering yourself in some kind of way while simultaneously honoring your own experience. There's an understanding of what it is that you like, what it is that you don't, the discernment around the why, and then being also simultaneously able to recognize that just because you feel that way doesn't mean that you can't also share space with other folks with different opinions. And I think it's always worth naming that art is subjective, ultimately.
[31:39] Emily Shooltz: Completely. And it's just, yeah, we're so many folks, certainly young folks, and we're taught this in some capacity of the good and the bad in the world that we live, of this is good, this is bad. And it's like, no, this is maybe your cup of tea and not my cup of tea. But ultimately, we're all in the same shared ecosystem. And how do we support all those things? Because it actually makes the entire ecosystem run. I think it's a balance. And also, sometimes it's just the necessity in whatever job you're in. I mean, you know, these jobs are not always the perfect fit for your artistic alignment early on. But that doesn't mean you can't be successful in that role. And also, how do you thrive in that, too?
I think that in and of itself is a really interesting exercise not to put yourself necessarily in that. But yeah, how do you own what you know and love and care about while also honoring somebody else? And how do you both then support each other in that is collaboration, I think sometimes, too. And I think the other thing that is important to remember is that we're especially in the not-for-profit sphere, we're in this very strange, we've created this incredibly strange system where we are both a product and a service. And it's this uncanny valley of just like, we are not-for-profit because we are supposed to serve the public good. And we believe that art is a public good and that we are putting something out into the world that is for the benefit of our communities.
But my product looks the same as commercial theater's product. And the average audience member who buys a ticket doesn't parse that. And that's a real challenge right now when the economics of the industry have gotten so burdensome. And with the rise of commercial off-Broadway, and there's some great work happening in commercial off-Broadway, but it looks very similar to what a lot of us in the not-for-profit sphere are doing. And we're trying to tell a story about why I don't just want you to buy a ticket, I also want you to make a donation and why. And so I think another skill set that is very important for artistic leaders is to be really good storytellers, to be able to, with passion and with genuine belief, explain why you think what you're doing is important.
Because most people can smell it if you're faking it. And if the whole institution is telling the same story, and again, I come at things as a dramaturgist, I'm thinking a lot about storytelling and I'm thinking a lot about the arc of a narrative. You have your best shot at creating a compelling case for why you should be supported philanthropically in addition to having people buy a ticket to come see the work. And then the last thing I would say is most people don't get management training in our industry. That's just not a thing that happens. And then you see a lot of people, and over the course of my career, I've watched a lot of people fail up. They get promoted into a job because they're really good at one thing, and then they get promoted into a job that mostly involves managing people who are doing the thing that they were really good at without the training to know how to do that well.
So there are lots of ways to go about that. Obviously, there are management training classes, there are great books out there, but I think finding good mentors and really asking them substantive, tangible things about how they are successful in those management roles as they've risen through their career. If you feel like they're a good manager, what are they doing that is successful? What do they think they're doing that is successful? What would you say? I don't think there's a template.
[35:31] Emily Shooltz: For you, at least. What do you think your skill set is in that? I mean, you'd have to ask the people I work with to get a candid answer. Maybe you should. That would be a whole other series. But I try to enter most conversations as a listener first. And then when it's time to make a decision, I try to make it decisively. I think people want to be heard, and I think it's important to not just pay lip service to that, to actually take it in and have people feel like they have a seat at the table and a voice in the conversation. And then I also think at a certain point, leaders need to be decisive and steer the ship. And then figuring out that balance is a day-to-day project.
[36:15] Jennifer Apple: What do you feel as a woman in this industry, or how does it feel in the current ecosystem, in the world that we live? I mean, obviously, this is your experience. You don't know anything other than that. But how is that, if it feels like anything specific?
[36:40] Emily Shooltz: I don't think it feels like anything specific. Also, strangely, I came up under female artistic directors, Irene Lewis, Blanca Ziska, Lynne Meadow. I worked with a lot of very strong women. You shared that with Lisa McNulty, who I had on. It was just like I had incredible women that showed me the way.
[36:59] Emily Shooltz: Yeah. And I have an incredible peer group of smart, hardworking women who are leading institutions now. There are women who have been doing this much longer than I have, like Lisa McNulty, like Susan at New George's, like a number of incredible folks across the city. And then there are some of us who are stepping into these roles now. We are all navigating. But I really do feel like I have only lived in this body. I have only experienced the trajectory of my career as a woman. And so I don't know how to compare. What I will say is that I have a family. I have young kids. My kids are 10 and 13 now. And navigating this industry as a parent is a whole other layer that I did not have a lot of models for.
And so it really has felt like a constant trailblazing within my own life, day to day, week to week, year to year, learning how to balance wanting to be present as a parent and wanting to be present in my career. And sometimes it feels like it's going okay. And sometimes it feels like you're failing at everything. And I don't know that that ever goes away for me.
[38:15] Jennifer Apple: Yeah. For artists who are navigating a balance of some sort, what have you found to be some, I guess, maybe guiding pillars for yourself in terms of being able to give how you can give from where you can give from the well that you have and also the way in which you replenish that well? Where does that balance come in play?
[38:46] Emily Shooltz: Do you mean specifically as it relates to parenting or just in general?
[38:53] Jennifer Apple: Podcast is brought to you by Zola Levitt Ministries and by Zola Levitt Ministries.
[39:00] Jennifer Apple: Zola Levitt Ministries is a non-profit organization that focuses on helping people with disabilities and also within myself of how do I think about, how do we think about our lives holistically as opposed to exclusively in these buckets because ultimately we are the vessel through which all of it's happening and you are the person who has to live through all of these things and also these different buckets inform the other buckets. If your personal life isn't feeling the fulfillment or the things that you need from it, then how are you showing up for the art and vice versa? I'm always fascinated by the way in which people ground themselves and come back to themselves and find themselves when it is really noisy and busy.
It's a practice. I think that I'm still continuing to learn and grow as well, but I think it's one that as I've gotten older certainly just thinking about, okay, because I take a break or because I go on a vacation, because I go on a hike or snuggle with my dog doesn't mean that somehow all these other things are going away. It just means that right now this one is the priority or coming to the forefront and I'm able to give my attention and full body energy to the thing in a way that doesn't fully separate me into multiple little parts. It's a hard thing to continue doing when there's so much to be done and so much to give ourselves to, especially when we care. Well, and also all those buckets have holes in them and so you will never fill them. They will continuously demand filling.
[42:30] Emily Shooltz: Very, very much. Be kind to yourself. When you've sat behind a table and you've watched folks audition, what has been either or both the wildest and most impactful audition you've ever seen and also the most bizarre or horrifying or jaw on the floor experience you've ever witnessed?
[43:02] Jennifer Apple: I'll start with those because they're very memorable and the simple answer is it's very challenging when someone comes in and improvises a monologue or text when the writer is in the room. I mean, it's excruciating for everybody. If you don't have it memorized, just read it off the page. It's totally fine. No one has any problem with that. And I had an experience where someone, it was a beautiful monologue from a new play and they fully improvised the whole thing just top to bottom and that person's not going to have a successful audition. So it's totally fine to read off the page. What about for you when you are sitting behind a table, what catches your heart or spirit or mind the most when you see somebody in front of you?
Or let's say somebody messes, I think this is maybe arguably the larger question is when somebody messes up, many artists are like, and I butchered the entire audition and I'm never going to recover. And arguably that's, I would imagine most of the time you're like, oh, there's a human being and who am I seeing?
[44:14] Emily Shooltz: You have to remember, I'm sure everybody says this, you have to remember that everybody sitting behind the table wants you to succeed. It is the best thing in their day if somebody comes in and is wonderful. And so when you mess up, it's fine. They still want you to succeed. They're ready for you to recover and try again. And there's nothing wrong with that. And I've had people nail auditions after saying, I'm so sorry, could I start again?
[44:43] Jennifer Apple: Yeah, I literally did that yesterday. I don't know if I nailed it, but I was like, oh, I've done this monologue for a long time. And for whatever reason, I can't get it. And I'm going to interrupt myself.
[44:54] Emily Shooltz: Yeah, yeah. That just what I'm watching in that moment is someone exercising their craft and using their tools. And that's an interesting thing to learn about a performer is how they recover after something doesn't go the way they planned for it to. So, yes, those moments are human. Everyone behind the table is human. I've had performers be very moved by work that they were doing and be very apologetic about that. And it's like, no, you were moved by the words or you were you were locked in. And we're people, too.
[45:28] Jennifer Apple: Yeah. I mean, I wish we could all be kind to each other like everyone lived through a global pandemic. We are living through an incredibly challenging moment in our country and globally. And I feel like we are all just like scratched raw in terms of how reactive we are and how tense we are and how tight everything feels. And I think one of you know, Sarah Ruhl calls theater our oldest existing empathy machine. It's like it's it's devised to help us feel together. And I think as makers, we are very vulnerable and expose those of us who operate in this industry. And so when everything is so heightened, it can be hard to remember that we're all doing our best and to sort of take a breath and be kind. I think we're we're all pretty raw. And the more that we can approach each other with the assumption of best intentions and try to be kind, I think that would be really helpful.
[46:36] Emily Shooltz: And then a little bit of grace, a little bit of grace. Yeah, we're all reinventing the wheel every day right now. And then the things that I would love to sort of leave you with about Signature in particular, that I always want to make sure people know, one of Signature's founding principles is access and affordable tickets. And we have a variety of access programs that are designed for people to be able to see our shows. So we have $20 student tickets. Anyone who is in the education system at any age can have a free student membership, $20 tickets to all the shows. We have a $30 ticket for anyone under 35. So please take advantage of it. And then we have our access membership, which is sort of the same criteria as TDF, if people are familiar with that.
So it's teachers and not-for-profit workers and artists and a whole bunch of other entry points for that one. And that's $40 tickets. Amazing. So we don't want cost to be a barrier for people coming to experience a show at Signature.
[47:38] Jennifer Apple: And the other thing I would love for people to know is that we're doing so much amazing community programming. Shout out to Gavin, who is our manager of community outreach and events. And we've just been doing all these really great pre-show events, artist talks in the lobby. We have jazz nights once a month in the lobby. Our lobby is a public space. It's open during the day. You can bring your laptop. You can write there. Have your coffee. Have a design meeting. We have nice, clean bathrooms and a water fountain. Very true. Free Wi-Fi. And we love when people take advantage of that space. It's not that far from Times Square, I promise. We're just past Playwrights Horizons. And you can come hang out and take advantage of that.
And at any given moment, there are usually three shows going on in the center. We're sharing space with Second Stage now. We have some other rental partners in the space. And so there's just a lot going on. And we would love for people to come visit.
[48:35] Emily Shooltz: I love it. I showcased my MFA at Signature in one of the theaters. I have ushered at Signature at various points when ushering was open to volunteers. So I've seen shows in that capacity. I was just in a show on Theatre Row in the fall. And I was in that lobby memorizing all the time because it was gorgeous. And the environment was just warm and collaborative. And people were being artists around you in all sorts of capacities. And you're like, okay, this is a thing. So I've definitely been in that space for all sorts of reasons. And it is. It's a very special environment to be a part of, in addition to going to see the shows. So I love that you're offering more use in that space, too, for folks to just be a part of it.
[49:25] Jennifer Apple: And Noah, our bar manager, is killing it. We have these amazing drink specials. And just come by and have a drink, even if you're not seeing the show. It's a nice place to be. So we would love to have people come hang out with us.
[49:37] Emily Shooltz: Amazing. For anybody who would like to check out the work, to find more information, to, in theory, potentially within your own boundaries, reach out to you, what are the various ways that people can find you?
[49:50] Jennifer Apple: Well, our website is SignatureTheatre.org. Not to be confused with our peers in DC. We get each other's patrons all the time. People showing up to see shows that are, in fact, in a different city. We are SignatureTheatre.org. Yeah, and the best way to find me is through the website. So go to that SignatureTheatre.org, and you can find me there.
[50:13] Emily Shooltz: Amazing. Thank you so much for being in this space.
[50:16] Jennifer Apple: Yes, I'm so happy to be in your in-person series with you. I'm very, very honored and privileged. And I'm just so grateful that you've, A, taken the time, but that you were creating innovative, gorgeous work in New York, and championing artists and the craft that they have, and really giving them space and time to develop and create more deeply. It's really special. And I'm so, so grateful to have you here, to be able to amplify that. And hopefully people can come and support more that Signature is doing.
[50:52] Emily Shooltz: Yeah, come see the work. Woo-hoo! We'd love to have you. Thank you.
[50:55] Jennifer Apple: All right. Thank you. I hope this episode empowered you to take one small step forward. Make sure you're subscribed to never miss out. And while you're at it, kindly leave us a review. It's one of the best ways to help other artists find the podcast and join in on the conversations. Be sure to tag at Empowered Artist Collective and at JenniferApple underscore, so we can see what's landing for you and keep the conversation going. As always, thank you for being here. Thank you for listening. And thank you for being a part of this incredible community. Remember, whether it's a small shift or a big breakthrough, every step forward counts. Keep creating and keep thriving. I'm Jennifer Apple. Until next time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
