Skip to main content
BPN Logo

Featured Shows

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

The Doctor is most definitely in! Unpack your blanket and put down your book report because this week Jimi and Tommy are discussing “You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown.” This time around the block Tommy gives a brief history of Peanuts, the boys muddle over whether this show works in a big Broadway house without losing some of its integrity and they discuss the nature of kids playing adults playing kids. Good grief!

You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown (1999 New Broadway Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

Jimi got introduced to Vince Guaraldi in this podcast, if you didn’t know about him check out some of his iconic music here!

The peanut butter monologue is absolutely stellar. Finlay MacAulay, the actor playing Charlie Brown in Jimi’s production, even used it to get into drama school!

Do you agree with Jimi and Tommy that this is the perfectly structured musical revue? Can you even compare Company to YAGMCB? Come over to Reddit and discuss!

Did you see the recent Broadway revival? How did the small-scale sketches land in a Broadway house? Let us know on Twitter!

Who knew that Troy Bolton himself, Zac Efron, started life as Snoopy in a high-school production of ‘Charlie Brown!’

A NEWSCASTER QUIZ QUESTION

Our next show is Anderson Cooper’s only Broadway credit. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: Oh, this is an adorable picture of you.

[0:02] Tommy: I mean, come on.

[0:04] Jimi: Isn't that so sweet?

[0:05] Tommy: You do look like Anthony Rapp in You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown?

[0:09] Jimi: Exactly.

[0:10] Tommy: But literally it looks like Charlie Brown, the behavior of Missy Vampel.

[0:14] Jimi: I swear to God.

[0:15] Tommy: Unsurprising.

[0:20] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with Jimi and Tommy.

[0:27] Tommy: Kirsche is the drink in that one, right?

[0:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[0:31] Tommy: Yeah.

[0:32] Jimi: Have you been in Kirsch?

[0:34] Tommy: What is Kirsch?

[0:35] Jimi: Kirsch, it's like a cherry brandy.

[0:38] Tommy: Kirschwasser.

[0:40] Jimi: It's German.

[0:41] Tommy: Thank you.

[0:42] Jimi: Kirschwasser.

[0:45] Tommy: Kirschwasser, yes.

[0:46] Jimi: It's cherry water.

[0:47] Tommy: Sounds so angry.

[0:49] Jimi: As all German things do, apparently.

[0:51] Tommy: How can Germans make cherry water sound angry?

[0:55] Jimi: Kirschwasser.

[0:58] Tommy: It's actually really nice if you ever had it.

[1:01] Jimi: I'm trying to think of some that I've had it in.

[1:03] Tommy: No, I can't.

[1:04] Jimi: Like a cocktail, but it's really nice.

[1:06] Tommy: It's rich.

[1:08] Jimi: We have grenadine, which is not specifically alcoholic.

[1:13] Tommy: Yes, grenadine, reduced pomegranate juice.

[1:16] Jimi: Reduced cherry juice.

[1:19] Tommy: I think cherry or pomegranate, but it thinks traditionally pomegranate.

[1:23] Jimi: In America, if you asked for grenadine, you would get cherry juice.

[1:26] Tommy: Interesting.

[1:27] Jimi: Okay.

[1:28] Tommy: I've never heard it as pomegranate juice.

[1:29] Jimi: How fascinating.

[1:31] Tommy: Ooh!

[1:31] Jimi: I had a thing.

[1:32] Tommy: We're gonna go on a tangent here.

[1:34] Jimi: This is good.

[1:36] Tommy: In math, or as you say, maths.

[1:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:41] Tommy: Did you learn the order of operations?

[1:44] Jimi: Of course, yes, bodmas.

[1:46] Tommy: Bodmas!

[1:47] Jimi: Ah!

[1:50] Tommy: I saw this on a British game show the other day.

[1:53] Jimi: In America, it's PEMDAS.

[1:55] Tommy: I bet you're part of it.

[1:57] Jimi: What the hell's PAS?

[1:58] Tommy: I know.

[1:58] Jimi: Also, yours is ordinals and we call them exponents.

[2:06] Tommy: And then it mucks up the other letters.

[2:09] Jimi: That's so interesting.

[2:11] Tommy: Oh, I'm so excited you know Bodmas.

[2:13] Jimi: It like blew my mind.

[2:14] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[2:15] Jimi: Well, so wait.

[2:16] Tommy: I think it's now Bidmas.

[2:20] Jimi: Bidmas?

[2:21] Tommy: I can't ever so brackets and then indices.

[2:26] Jimi: Indices.

[2:27] Tommy: Indices.

[2:27] Jimi: Yeah, we call them exponents, but they're the same thing.

[2:30] Tommy: So but do you not have the laws of indices?

[2:33] Jimi: We probably have the laws of exponents, but I'm not great at math.

[2:37] Tommy: Interesting.

[2:38] Jimi: Interesting.

[2:39] Tommy: Because they're kind of mass.

[2:42] Jimi: Yeah.

[2:42] Tommy: Pedmas.

[2:43] Jimi: It's a yeah.

[2:45] Tommy: Uh PEMDAS.

[2:47] Jimi: Because we also we do we mix up the multiplication division.

[2:51] Tommy: Yeah.

[2:52] Jimi: Because it doesn't matter, it's from left to right, either one.

[2:54] Tommy: I guess it's just to make a funky acronym.

[2:58] Jimi: Yeah, uh-huh.

[2:59] Tommy: That is fascinating.

[3:00] Jimi: And who knew? Like, what a regional difference that no one knows about.

[3:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[3:07] Jimi: I think PEMDAS does sound nicer.

[3:10] Tommy: Bodmas always is just a bit weird, I think.

[3:13] Jimi: I was really excited to learn Bodmas.

[3:15] Tommy: This has been Jim and Tomic's mathematical happy hour.

[3:19] Jimi: Yeah.

[3:20] Tommy: I think we've actually done that one before.

[3:22] Jimi: We've like suggested that as an alternative.

[3:24] Tommy: So that's two for the maths one.

[3:26] Jimi: It's what's currently winning.

[3:28] Tommy: Um what are you drinking today, Jim?

[3:32] Jimi: Tell me.

[3:33] Tommy: Ah, hi.

[3:35] Jimi: I am drinking dog water.

[3:43] Tommy: Water from a dog bowl.

[3:47] Jimi: That's uh you couldn't.

[3:49] Tommy: You could be drinking eggnog.

[3:52] Jimi: You could be drinking great pumpkin juice.

[3:55] Tommy: They're all none of these things feature in the musical.

[3:58] Jimi: They feature in the universe.

[4:02] Tommy: Oh, I want to talk about that too.

[4:04] Jimi: Um the universe.

[4:07] Tommy: The space in general, humatomics space hour.

[4:12] Jimi: That'd be cool.

[4:14] Tommy: Why are we drinking these things?

[4:16] Jimi: I'll tell you, because it's my turn to talk about the quiz question.

[4:19] Tommy: It is.

[4:26] Jimi: It's true.

[4:26] Tommy: Some days I wake up early.

[4:28] Jimi: Um no.

[4:28] Tommy: Last week, our quiz question.

[4:30] Jimi: Um, our last show features a song by Mendelson, and he was uncredited in his writing of the song.

[4:34] Tommy: This show features a song by Beethoven, and he is very well credited.

[4:39] Jimi: What show could it possibly be, Tommy?

[4:42] Tommy: That would be You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown.

[4:47] Jimi: Oh, you're a good man, Charlie Brown.

[4:50] Tommy: You're the kind of reminder we need.

[4:54] Jimi: You have humility, probability and the sex of honor that a very indeed, Charlie Brown.

[5:05] Tommy: And we know you will go very far.

[5:08] Jimi: Yes, it's hard.

[5:12] Tommy: What a good man you are.

[5:16] Jimi: You are kind.

[5:17] Tommy: You are kind to all the animals.

[5:21] Jimi: And every little bird.

[5:25] Tommy: With a heart of gold.

[5:27] Jimi: You believe what you're told.

[5:29] Tommy: Every single solitary word.

[5:32] Jimi: You bravely face adversity.

[5:36] Tommy: You're cheerful through the day.

[5:40] Jimi: Your thoughtful dream and dirty.

[5:43] Tommy: And you also have some false butt for the moment.

[5:46] Jimi: Let's just say that.

[5:48] Tommy: So I'm still flemmy.

[5:50] Jimi: So I'm getting there.

[5:54] Tommy: I'm getting there.

[5:55] Jimi: Do you know what I've had really bad?

[5:57] Tommy: Post nasal drip.

[5:59] Jimi: Oh yeah, that's been me too.

[6:00] Tommy: You have what I have.

[6:02] Jimi: Oh, really?

[6:04] Tommy: I haven't had like an awful sinus infection.

[6:06] Jimi: So I didn't know this was a thing.

[6:08] Tommy: I heard it in Guys and Dolls.

[6:09] Jimi: I was always like, what is she talking about?

[6:11] Tommy: It's post-nasal.

[6:12] Jimi: But I can only imagine it's that thing.

[6:14] Tommy: So it's like there's a constant stream going down from the nose into the back of your throat.

[6:19] Jimi: Yeah, post-hitting the soft palate.

[6:21] Tommy: So it's just constant.

[6:22] Jimi: I'm just constantly like just like that.

[6:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[6:26] Jimi: Yeah.

[6:26] Tommy: I've never had it this bad before, so.

[6:30] Jimi: Hooray!

[6:31] Tommy: Hooray!

[6:31] Jimi: Hooray for sickness.

[6:33] Tommy: I'll do that a lot.

[6:34] Jimi: I'll do it because that's me, gang.

[6:36] Tommy: Excited.

[6:37] Jimi: And if I vomit, then all the great.

[6:40] Tommy: It'll be one of the strangest audio experiences of my life.

[6:43] Jimi: It really will.

[6:44] Tommy: Right, okay.

[6:45] Jimi: Good man Charlie Brown.

[6:47] Tommy: Yes, I am.

[6:49] Jimi: Um music and lyrics by Mr.

[6:53] Tommy: Clark Gesner.

[6:54] Jimi: Yeah, you know, good old Clark Gesner, all of his hit shows.

[7:00] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[7:01] Jimi: You can name them for us, right, Tommy?

[7:04] Tommy: I can only name one other.

[7:05] Jimi: And it I only knew it because of the musical theater quiz that I did in 2009.

[7:13] Tommy: Um, and it's called The Utter Glory of Morrissey Hall.

[7:16] Jimi: I have attempted to look for recordings of The Utter Glory of Morrissey Hall and have yet to be able to find one.

[7:25] Tommy: Yeah, no, neither have I.

[7:26] Jimi: I just only know of its existence.

[7:28] Tommy: Yeah, so this is Clark Gesner's one-hit wonder.

[7:31] Jimi: I know by and away.

[7:32] Tommy: But it sounds like he was just a really big fan.

[7:35] Jimi: Yeah.

[7:36] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[7:37] Jimi: Like, because he was what so he worked on the concept album for a couple years and was like trying he'd before he got permission to do it from the comic book syndicate company.

[7:49] Tommy: Um then he finally sent a recording off to Charles Schulz, who penned the Peanuts comic strip, who then loved it and was like, we must do this, and then it happened.

[7:59] Jimi: Excellent.

[8:00] Tommy: Um Total Passion Project.

[8:02] Jimi: He's the original Lin-Manuel Miranda.

[8:05] Tommy: Basically, many compare him to this day.

[8:10] Jimi: Um but no, I love I really love that.

[8:13] Tommy: Um then book by John Gordon.

[8:15] Jimi: Okay, so let's talk about this.

[8:16] Tommy: So uh people say that the book isn't by John Gordon, the book is by everyone.

[8:24] Jimi: I don't understand.

[8:26] Tommy: Yeah, it sounds like it was a very company-devised piece.

[8:31] Jimi: Um there are a bunch of non-sung vignettes in this that Gesner didn't write as a part of the original script, and uh although I haven't read this specifically anywhere, my sense is that John Gordon kind of corralled the actors into creating these vignettes.

[8:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[8:49] Jimi: Well, so in the in the it's in the blurb of this the script, in like the um the kind of director's note kind of thing, um, where it says that it's it's a big collaboration.

[9:01] Tommy: Um and then I was like so wait does John Gordon not exist?

[9:05] Jimi: Right.

[9:05] Tommy: Is John Gordon a person at all?

[9:07] Jimi: Or is John Gordon just the pseudonym for the cast where like all the letters of their names are who knows.

[9:14] Tommy: Right exactly but because like you know it it doesn't there's no Wikipedia link to John Gordon.

[9:21] Jimi: Yeah so I it's a great question forever the mysteries lost to the the the annals of time that might not be the right word um annals but we'll go with analysis because we're gay we're gay guys so a book a book kind of written by everyone and no one um and then it opened off Broadway in 1967 um tried to transfer to Broadway but didn't do too great but was a huge hit off Broadway yeah um and then was revived in 99 with significant revisions um by Andrew Lippa yeah almost a whole new show it's I I would love to talk about this because I find the changes in the original You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown and the revival You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown fascinating.

[10:10] Tommy: Yeah for sure.

[10:12] Jimi: And we will we will talk about it don't you worry, Tommy.

[10:12] Tommy: Good, I was worried for a second my heart was palpitating.

[10:19] Jimi: Absolutely.

[10:19] Tommy: Emperor palpitating.

[10:19] Jimi: That's funny I love that that's who I think Snoke is by the way I'm saying it that's I think it's I think it's palpitating Star Wars spoiler alerts, Jimmy.

[10:35] Jimi: I think it is.

[10:37] Tommy: I think he's a visit this moment in the in the podcast I think he's George Lucas.

[10:43] Jimi: I think it's just the embodiment of George Lucas.

[10:48] Tommy: Anyway, what's the one?

[10:50] Jimi: Sorry.

[10:50] Tommy: Yes.

[10:52] Jimi: We're getting off the rails right away.

[10:54] Tommy: What's this show?

[10:54] Jimi: What's the show about, Tommy?

[10:56] Tommy: Okay, so this is like you said earlier, this is a collection of vignettes.

[11:01] Jimi: It's almost a collection of comic strips, effectively.

[11:05] Tommy: Um of the Peanuts family or some of the Peanuts family.

[11:09] Jimi: Um it's kind of penned as a day in the life of Charlie Brown, but we do certainly get to see all the hijinks of all of his friends at the same time.

[11:19] Tommy: Yeah, for sure.

[11:20] Jimi: Um it is like a collection of comics.

[11:22] Tommy: I would say comic book adaptations for musical theater is an interesting subgenre that is larger than you think.

[11:32] Jimi: Um they are generally unsuccessful when they're about superheroes and successful when they're not.

[11:40] Tommy: Um so you've got You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, you've got Annie, which is technically based off of a comic strip.

[11:47] Jimi: Um and then in the unsuccessful category, you've got uh Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark, um, it's a bird displayed Superman.

[11:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[11:56] Jimi: But it's interesting to talk about these in the context of musical theater because comic strips are by design entirely episodic.

[12:04] Tommy: You know, you have three or four panels every week to make a tiny little joke for 50 years.

[12:11] Jimi: Yep.

[12:11] Tommy: Um, which is the Peanuts.

[12:13] Jimi: And so it is interesting to see this show as a show, as one collective, you know, one to one and a half hour evening instead of three simple squares in a newspaper.

[12:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[12:27] Jimi: But so, Tommy, in England, what's your experience of the Peanuts?

[12:33] Tommy: So I live in Scotland.

[12:35] Jimi: In Scotland where you live.

[12:38] Tommy: It's been a long day.

[12:40] Jimi: I'm the worst.

[12:41] Tommy: Same.

[12:43] Jimi: It's fine.

[12:44] Tommy: They're just the same, aren't they?

[12:45] Jimi: Aren't they connected?

[12:46] Tommy: They're the same country, right?

[12:47] Jimi: Yeah.

[12:48] Tommy: It's all just one big land island.

[12:50] Tommy: So I mean, well, we know we know Peanuts.

[12:55] Jimi: For sure.

[12:57] Tommy: Uh huh.

[12:58] Jimi: It's certainly bigger than Calvin and Hobbes.

[13:01] Tommy: Okay. But I would like to. Is it bigger than, say, the Wombles?

[13:08] Jimi: Yeah, well, the Wombles are just old hat now. Like nobody like Peanuts is kind of stood the test of time in that respect. Like the Wombles are just like vintage.

[13:16] Tommy: I just said now.

[13:17] Jimi: Okay. Yeah. But I'm trying, I'm trying that's quite a good little comparison though. Um, I think it's something that's British that has stood the test of time. I can't.

[13:27] Tommy: Yeah, I'm not sure.

[13:28] Jimi: Like the meal, but you don't know that.

[13:30] Tommy: Okay, I don't know what that is. I only have mild understanding of Wombles. Um but in the same, I mean, in this in the same way, like so where was Peanuts published?

[13:41] Jimi: It was in a newspaper.

[13:44] Tommy: Yeah. Um Saturday morning, Sunday morning newspaper cartoons. Um, do you have newspapers? Do you have comic stuff? I assume so.

[13:52] Jimi: Um Scottish specific ones. Like we've got the Brunes, we've got our Willie. Um and they are huge. Like that's a Scottish phenomenon. And again, still going to this day, everyone knows who they are. But that's very Scotland specific.

[14:07] Tommy: Um I'm just like I'm thinking, I don't think we ever got Peanuts in our papers.

[14:11] Jimi: Okay. That makes sense. You know, I do I think and I don't I can't I can't quite put my finger on why, but there is something that feels decidedly American about some of the content of Peanuts strips.

[14:25] Tommy: Um I don't quite know why, maybe something with Charlie Brown trying to unsuccessfully hit a football connotation. Um, you know, Charlie Brown is kind of the youth embodiment of the American dream, maybe, but we're getting kind of wanky and philosophical there.

[14:40] Jimi: Um yeah, but even just like you know, dog houses and uh lemonade stands. Um there's open American pictures and like you know, I mean, it's just it's a very Midwestern fantasy.

[14:55] Tommy: Yeah. But I I would say Peanuts, Charlie Brown is iconic as is as iconic as maybe Doctor Who would be. Um has been going on for as long, and certainly different genres, but is a stalwart of a character, and in it affects the world that this musical lives in because no one is going to see this show not knowing who Charlie Brown is, you know what I mean?

[15:21] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. And I would even say that here, like they definitely know who Snoopy is. You know what I mean? Um Snoopy's like Snoopy's find its way into like Top Shop.

[15:32] Tommy: Okay, it's like, oh, you've got your Snoopy brand thing, and like Vans have just done a uh campaign of like uh Charlie Brown inspired shoes.

[15:42] Jimi: Um that's oh there I mean, uh we might talk about it a little bit, but Charles Schultz would be rolling over in his grave.

[15:49] Tommy: Oh, absolutely. Um I mean it's it's totally and like they had them the movie, like the 3D animation movie recently.

[15:58] Jimi: I forgot that happened, yeah.

[16:00] Tommy: Uh but is that is that viewed as like a an American import or as just a movie?

[16:09] Jimi: I don't know, I guess that's a weird question.

[16:11] Tommy: Yeah, I know what you mean though, but no, it just is a movie. It's not like it's super specific.

[16:17] Jimi: You know, if the like the for example, like, um I might be digging a hole here, but like the tech, you know, the text just come on to Amazon.

[16:24] Tommy: Oh yeah, yeah.

[16:25] Jimi: The tech never really took off here.

[16:28] Tommy: Okay.

[16:29] Jimi: So that I feel like that is I don't know. I I don't know though. I'm not I've not got the great.

[16:32] Tommy: Right, okay.

[16:35] Jimi: Like I've not got like a great example of like it is it is hard to find something that is as popular as Charlie Brown is.

[16:43] Tommy: Um and that is as pervasive as Charlie Brown.

[16:46] Jimi: Oh, I guess I the other comic book musical I missed was the Addams Family.

[16:49] Tommy: Um that is another decidedly American group of characters.

[16:56] Jimi: Um, you know, you will recognize Uncle Fester immediately.

[17:00] Tommy: Um but I think even more so Charlie Brown, literally everyone knows who Charlie Brown and like to the point where you kinda don't know why you know about Charlie Brown.

[17:10] Jimi: It's just that pervasive.

[17:12] Tommy: Uh no completely. And like 'cause that's the thing is I couldn't tell you the first my first experience of the Peanuts comics, but I could tell you four of the characters.

[17:20] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[17:21] Tommy: Right. Exactly. Um and so it it's interesting to see a piece of work based on this.

[17:26] Jimi: But so um maybe we let's let's talk about the Peanuts chronology, shall we, Jimmy?

[17:33] Tommy: Give me a B!

[17:34] Jimi: Give me an A!

[17:36] Tommy: Give me an A!

[17:36] Jimi: Hey!

[17:37] Tommy: Give me an A!

[17:37] Jimi: Hey!

[17:38] Tommy: What do you got?

[17:40] Jimi: Very so team!

[17:42] Tommy: Like the best team!

[17:43] Jimi: Which is our team, right here!

[17:53] Tommy: Happy big time!

[17:54] Jimi: With the Mingly baseball stars!

[17:57] Tommy: For all we have to do is win just one more game!

[18:00] Jimi: And the championship is ours!

[18:03] Tommy: The Peanuts, um, they started back in the 1950s.

[18:07] Jimi: And Charles, like a lot of these things, Charles Schultz was using some of the same characters beforehand, like Charlie Brown had appeared in some earlier comics before that.

[18:15] Tommy: But the first time the Peanuts were in a comic strip was in the 1950s.

[18:20] Jimi: Um the drawing style was a little different, but the characters were about the same as you expect today.

[18:29] Tommy: Um so it becomes super popular through the 50s, and then the 60s are really if you imagine like that's where what we now view as Charlie Brown and his friends started to take off.

[18:42] Jimi: That's when Peppermint Patty came in, that's when Snoopy started flying his doghouse.

[18:47] Tommy: Like, they're all sorts of these typical Peanuts plots that happen in the 60s.

[18:55] Jimi: Um then this is where I think it gets really interesting about the inception of You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, the revival or the original versus the revival.

[19:04] Tommy: So a Charlie Brown Christmas, the Christmas special, happens in 1965.

[19:09] Jimi: Um, and that's the first time Charlie Brown talks and moves and has longer stories, and I think very importantly, has a musical soundtrack.

[19:19] Tommy: And so that's when Vince Guaraldi started composing music for Charlie Brown.

[19:24] Jimi: Um and you know Linus and Lucy, the song Ba-da-da-da-da-da-bum Ba dump da da ba-dum ba da ba.

[19:33] Tommy: Have you heard the song?

[19:34] Jimi: Do you know the song?

[19:35] Tommy: Sure.

[19:37] Jimi: Really?

[19:38] Tommy: Oh, so we don't get Charlie Brown Christmas.

[19:42] Jimi: No way.

[19:43] Tommy: Okay.

[19:44] Jimi: So this is a Christmas story all over again.

[19:46] Tommy: Like, so we might be all new stuff for you then.

[19:49] Jimi: Um Vince Guaraldi.

[19:52] Tommy: Um, do you know the Pink Panther theme?

[19:55] Jimi: I do.

[19:55] Tommy: I know that.

[19:56] Jimi: Um, or do you know maybe less uh more maybe more obscure, but the March of the Elephants.

[20:03] Tommy: Um Vince Guaraldi.

[20:06] Jimi: No, from a weird live action movie that I can't remember the name of.

[20:12] Tommy: Um Vince Guaraldi has a very jazz jazz sound.

[20:17] Jimi: Um it's very impromptu jazz, um, piano and saxophone and oboe.

[20:23] Tommy: Um and it became with a Charlie Brown Christmas, the Charlie Brown musical sound.

[20:30] Jimi: Um was in all of the TV specials afterwards.

[20:34] Tommy: So it's a great pumpkin, Charlie Brown, and um all sorts of um other there were like 30 Charlie Brown specials between the 60s, 70s and 80s, all scored by Vince Guaraldi in this kind of jazzy sound.

[20:49] Jimi: But without like songs, but without songs.

[20:53] Tommy: Um eventually they did You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown had an in-between step between um I think it was between the original production and the revival where they made an animated special of You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, which is a fascinating middle step.

[21:07] Jimi: Yeah.

[21:08] Tommy: Um, but so what this means is the original You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, which premiered in 19667, but ostensibly um Gessner was composing it far before that, was composed concurrently with all the Vince Guaraldi jazzy sound of Charlie Brown.

[21:28] Jimi: So he didn't know that this was to be the sound of Charlie Brown.

[21:34] Tommy: And I think, and maybe we'll talk about this later when we compare it, but that's why the original production sounds so different from the revival, because the revival existed in this world where Charlie Brown already had a musical sound.

[21:46] Jimi: Interesting.

[21:48] Tommy: Okay.

[21:50] Jimi: But so I think I'll I'll send you some Vince Guaraldi music after this.

[21:53] Tommy: But it is So that's like the da-da-da.

[21:58] Jimi: Yes.

[21:58] Tommy: Yes, exactly that.

[22:00] Jimi: That's Vince Guaraldi.

[22:01] Tommy: Um which does not sound like the original production, right?

[22:06] Jimi: No, but yes, I say yes and no.

[22:08] Tommy: But maybe I just don't know enough of his stuff.

[22:10] Jimi: But then I would also say that the revival doesn't sound like that either.

[22:15] Tommy: Okay, well, maybe we'll talk about that then.

[22:17] Jimi: So we'll talk about that.

[22:17] Tommy: Um so Charlie Brown had a bunch of television specials throughout this, and then was hugely popular and then well in syndication um for many, many years.

[22:28] Jimi: Um, and I believe Charles Schultz passed away in 2000s.

[22:35] Tommy: 2000, and it went pretty close.

[22:37] Jimi: I think he retired a little earlier.

[22:38] Tommy: I think it stopped being syndicated in 95 or 96, maybe.

[22:42] Jimi: Um and then he had a couple things that were published afterwards, like when he passed and things like that.

[22:49] Tommy: Um so, but the it's a 50-year saga of characterization and character development, and all in this kind of like deeply literature-influenced and psychological commentary on adult life through children.

[23:10] Jimi: Um, which definitely shines in the musical for sure.

[23:15] Tommy: Absolutely.

[23:18] Jimi: And that's all I have to say.

[23:19] Tommy: That's that's your peanuts rundown, Jimmy.

[23:22] Jimi: Thank you so much.

[23:23] Tommy: I feel nutty.

[23:24] Jimi: The only thing I know about Peanuts is it it comes from Heidi Diddy.

[23:29] Tommy: Really?

[23:30] Jimi: Is that where you got the name?

[23:31] Tommy: I don't actually know that.

[23:33] Jimi: It's the name of the audience in Heidi Diddy.

[23:36] Tommy: Okay.

[23:37] Jimi: That's my fact.

[23:39] Tommy: These are little no facts.

[23:42] Jimi: That now you know.

[23:46] Tommy: It's a beautiful rendition.

[23:48] Jimi: You could play Lucy right now.

[23:51] Tommy: I mean, I am.

[23:53] Jimi: Sally?

[23:53] Tommy: I never know which is which.

[23:54] Jimi: That was Lucy, yeah.

[23:55] Tommy: That was Lucy.

[23:57] Jimi: Alright.

[23:57] Tommy: I love Lucy.

[23:59] Jimi: Oh.

[24:00] Tommy: Oh, you see why I did that.

[24:02] Jimi: Another Americanism.

[24:04] Tommy: How dare you usurping our culture?

[24:07] Jimi: I'm steeped in them.

[24:08] Tommy: Um because it gives us fur for cults.

[24:16] Jimi: It also gives us wool in the winter time.

[24:19] Tommy: It's very interesting, Lucy.

[24:21] Jimi: I never knew that before.

[24:23] Tommy: This is an elm tree.

[24:25] Jimi: It's very little.

[24:26] Tommy: But it will grow up into a giant tree.

[24:30] Jimi: An oak.

[24:31] Tommy: You can tell how old it is by counting its leaves.

[24:35] Jimi: Oh, wait a minute, Lucy.

[24:36] Tommy: I don't mean to interfere with it.

[24:38] Jimi: But way up there.

[24:39] Tommy: Those fluffy little white things.

[24:41] Jimi: Those are clouds.

[24:43] Tommy: They make the wind blow.

[24:45] Jimi: And way down there, those tiny little black things.

[24:49] Tommy: Those are bugs.

[24:50] Jimi: They make the grass grow.

[24:52] Tommy: Is that so?

[24:53] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[24:53] Tommy: They run around all day long, tugging and tugging at every little seedling till it grows up to be a giant blade of grass.

[25:00] Jimi: Oh boy.

[25:01] Tommy: That's amazing.

[25:02] Jimi: Oh, good grief.

[25:07] Tommy: Thank you very much for that history lesson.

[25:11] Jimi: What I would like to talk about is with the show.

[25:16] Tommy: Yes.

[25:16] Jimi: So this is another one Jimmy's worked on.

[25:18] Tommy: I feel like the past fair few.

[25:20] Jimi: I've been like, ah, yeah, it's another one from my girls.

[25:25] Tommy: But so I choreographed for this one.

[25:28] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[25:28] Tommy: Um, and it was my good friend Stella who was directing it.

[25:32] Jimi: Um.

[25:33] Tommy: And now Stella could be a uh Peanuts character, and she won't mind me saying that.

[25:39] Jimi: Um, but she just in terms of her tone and her, um, her just general air, she has that very, very dry, very, very, um, uh cynical and slightly confusing, but really enthralling way about her, right? Um, she was in many ways like the perfect director for it because she instantly got what it was all about. Um, it's actually really, really difficult, I think, to put it on a stage.

[26:07] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[26:16] Jimi: Uh, because it's a really specific type of humor.

[26:15] Tommy: Yes.

[26:23] Jimi: Dressed up as a comedy show.

[26:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:28] Jimi: And it, it's easy to fall into the like child trap of it all.

[26:28] Tommy: Exactly.

[26:29] Jimi: Exactly.

[26:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:37] Jimi: And so, yeah, I think it's really, really tough. And I find it quite interesting in the, um, actual like chronology of the show and how it's structured. Um, we open with the, the kind of monologues.

[26:55] Tommy: Um, well not monologues, the like sentences, I don't know.

[26:58] Jimi: Um, from each of the characters saying mini soliloquies.

[27:02] Tommy: Yes.

[27:03] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[27:03] Tommy: Um, minilequies.

[27:06] Jimi: We'll go for that. Like, well done.

[27:09] Tommy: Thank you.

[27:09] Jimi: Uh, so obviously it opens with them, um, and then we have your good man Charlie Brown, our first song, and that's all good fun. Um, and then you get the first little vignette strip, um, which in the revival in, in the version that we did question don't know if you know the answer.

[27:30] Tommy: Can you still do the original version?

[27:32] Jimi: I don't know.

[27:32] Tommy: I have been unable to source an original script.

[27:35] Jimi: So I'm, while I can compare the cast recordings, I'm unsure what the vignettes look like in the original.

[27:41] Tommy: Okay, but can it be licensed anymore or is it just the revival?

[27:46] Jimi: I don't know.

[27:46] Tommy: I have no idea.

[27:47] Jimi: Okay. Because we, so we did the revival.

[27:49] Tommy: So that's what I'm gonna speak about because that's what I know.

[27:52] Jimi: Um, but I'm sure it's probably really similar. Uh, the only thing being so the opening monologue is, is Sally, um, so it's probably Lucy in the original.

[28:02] Tommy: That would make sense, yeah.

[28:04] Jimi: And it's this really, really short one, which is like my report on history.

[28:10] Tommy: Um, history and I can't remember the joke.

[28:14] Jimi: But it is just really, really short, and it's in its classic Charlie Brown style of like not really ending.

[28:21] Tommy: Right.

[28:22] Jimi: And she just walks up, you know what I mean? And it really, that kind of sets the audience right up for okay, so if you didn't like that, best time to leave.

[28:32] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[28:33] Jimi: But then it's all kind of made okay because you get the peanut butter monologue.

[28:40] Tommy: Um, which is filled with all of the nostalgia.

[28:45] Jimi: Um, you get to see oh, the little red-headed girl, um, and uh, uh, Lucy's in it, and well, Sally's in it as well, and um, it feels more like a normal scene.

[28:59] Tommy: Yeah, well, and it, it starts to s, it starts what through line there is of this show, maybe you know, uh, yeah, but is there a through line, Tommy?

[29:12] Jimi: Oh, Jimmy, I think this is the perfect musical revue.

[29:17] Tommy: I really do.

[29:18] Jimi: Yeah.

[29:19] Tommy: I think this is the most perfectly structured of this kind of musical revue, say separate from a song cycle.

[29:28] Jimi: Um, you know, we won't get in the weeds about that entirely again, but a show about certain themes where we don't need to stick to too close of a climactic arc about a specific character or something, um, but where we see it through.

[29:47] Tommy: I like I put your good man Charlie Brown up there with company as musical revue A plus.

[29:54] Jimi: Interesting.

[29:54] Tommy: Okay, can you talk a bit more about that?

[29:57] Jimi: Yeah, um, like it's, we're following all these disparate characters who are telling their own individual stories in tiny little moments, but we are still, there is like the sparkle of a theme throughout the whole thing that we're not, it is far from baseball bad over the head for the audience.

[30:16] Tommy: Um, but we're just, you know, we're just leaning into like what is it like to be a child?

[30:22] Jimi: What are these insecurities that human beings have to deal with no matter their age?

[30:27] Tommy: Do they go away when you're a child or not?

[30:29] Jimi: You know, like it's, it's Charlie Brown's monologue at the beginning.

[30:33] Tommy: Like, how could anything go wrong on a s, on such a beautiful day like this?

[30:37] Jimi: Alarm rings, oh no, I'm late.

[30:39] Tommy: Like it is that theme exploded across, concluding with, I guess it hasn't been such a bad day after all.

[30:46] Jimi: Happiness is, you know, finding a pencil pizza with sausage.

[30:50] Tommy: And like the whole show isn't explicitly about those things, but all of those things inform that ending moment.

[31:01] Jimi: And that ending moment wouldn't be as effective without all the moments in between.

[31:05] Tommy: Yeah, okay, okay.

[31:06] Jimi: Sorry, I thought you were meaning there's like a plot.

[31:10] Tommy: No, no, no, no, no, no.

[31:11] Jimi: But like, like, honestly, like company.

[31:14] Tommy: Um, company doesn't have a plot.

[31:17] Jimi: No, exactly.

[31:18] Tommy: It has a bunch of tiny vignettes, and I, I would call this as intellectual and as well structured as Steven Sondheim's company.

[31:25] Jimi: Yeah, I, I by the way, I'd totally be right there with you.

[31:28] Tommy: I, I adore it, I love the tone of it.

[31:30] Jimi: I do know a lot of people who hate it.

[31:32] Tommy: Um, and we find that with some of our houses.

[31:36] Jimi: Like they just weren't, they just weren't buying it.

[31:40] Tommy: Um, because they were there for a musical and they got a sketch commoditial songs.

[31:48] Jimi: And I get, I totally do totally get that.

[31:51] Tommy: But I feel it's probably in the same way that a lot of people don't like company.

[31:55] Jimi: Yeah, I guess that's true.

[31:57] Tommy: It's not you, you know, you have to do some work at it, which I think some people don't like when they're going to see a piece of musical theater.

[32:04] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[32:05] Tommy: They want to be led by the hand throughout the whole thing.

[32:08] Jimi: But what I feel like with Charlie Brown though as well, you don't have to do that much work because the characters are so consistent.

[32:16] Tommy: And I think that's us talking now.

[32:20] Jimi: I don't know that.

[32:21] Tommy: I think they are because with something like company, you don't get a lot of development of like I think Sarah.

[32:28] Jimi: Yeah.

[32:29] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[32:30] Jimi: She has her brief scene.

[32:31] Tommy: But this is, this is where it depends on where you're meeting the musical.

[32:35] Jimi: Like if you, if you come into this and maybe you know a little bit about Charlie Brown, but maybe you don't know too much about Linus.

[32:43] Tommy: You have to do, they don't, there's not a, you know, Linus's exposition song is already assuming that you know a lot about what Linus is and what Linus is about.

[32:54] Jimi: See, I don't know though, because I think, I think it's all there.

[32:58] Tommy: I really think it's all there.

[32:59] Jimi: Because by that point, Linus has had his moment of I'm a baby, but I speak like I'm 40 years old and have been working in the academia.

[33:10] Tommy: Um, I guess that's true.

[33:11] Jimi: But, and then obviously when you've got my blanket in me, it's a really, it's just a really simple song.

[33:17] Tommy: You get, oh, that's cute because he's a baby.

[33:20] Jimi: Um, and he loves his blanket, and he really loves this, you know.

[33:24] Tommy: I mean, and like that's a fun little thing.

[33:26] Jimi: Um, and you see his relationship then with Lucy, which is kind of built on as this, the rest of the show progresses till the end, you know what I mean?

[33:34] Tommy: Um, yeah, no, I guess that's true.

[33:37] Jimi: You might have to be.

[33:37] Tommy: So I think, I think actually, could it be better than company?

[33:41] Jimi: Could this be the best musical revue?

[33:44] Tommy: I think it's definitely more accessible than company.

[33:47] Jimi: Um, company asks a lot more of its audience than your good man Charlie Brown does.

[33:52] Tommy: Um, I do think also that, you know, it's a double-edged sword.

[33:58] Jimi: Because company is more obtuse, you can, it's e, like there's a wider margin for mistake in company.

[34:06] Tommy: You can lean into maybe not the best choices and still get away with it.

[34:11] Jimi: Whereas I think with Charlie Brown, if you don't hit the nail right on the head, it falls flat.

[34:16] Tommy: Like if you go, and I think the original does this with some of the revival with some of the like xylophone underscoring and like, uh, homework to start, um, the book report song.

[34:29] Jimi: Um, it's a little too like ha ha ha, we're children.

[34:35] Tommy: Um, and I do, I think the revival swings the pendulum even maybe a little too far in the other direction, where it's like, you know, we are all dressed in the same costumes of the similar characters that you might recognize from stage and screen.

[34:48] Jimi: Um, it there's, there's a thin middle line I think you have to land on for it to make your good man Charlie Brown work.

[34:55] Tommy: For to make your good man Charlie Brown work.

[34:58] Jimi: Yeah, I would totally agree.

[34:59] Tommy: Um, well, so hey, so you just mentioned the revival.

[35:03] Jimi: Yeah.

[35:04] Tommy: And that they're very different.

[35:05] Jimi: So let's talk, I think we should talk a bit more about that.

[35:07] Tommy: Let's clear that.

[35:08] Jimi: Let's do it.

[35:10] Tommy: They expect us to ride a ball before.

[35:18] Jimi: That's carrots and spinach and onions and fire and high and cabbage and shrinkings and parsley to come in.

[35:30] Tommy: Not to mention the extreme pressure exerted on him by his deeply rooted rivalry with Flopsy Mopsy and Cottontail.

[35:55] Jimi: And they were very, very, very, very, very, very happy to be on.

[36:05] Tommy: The um 9495 very port on Peter Rabbit.

[36:22] Jimi: So Jimmy, you had just discovered the original in this, in, in prep for this, right?

[36:28] Tommy: Yeah, uh-huh.

[36:29] Jimi: So because I knew it was there, but I'd never been able to find it.

[36:34] Tommy: What are your initial reactions?

[36:35] Jimi: What do you think of it?

[36:37] Tommy: Well, I just having listened to the revival first.

[36:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[36:40] Tommy: Well, I think it's sweet.

[36:42] Jimi: Um, and there are some real nice moments.

[36:46] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[36:47] Jimi: And I also think that it's good that you get more of the sketches.

[36:52] Tommy: Yeah, there's definitely more dialogue recorded in it.

[36:54] Jimi: For sure.

[36:55] Tommy: So that's something that the revival lacks.

[36:57] Jimi: But, um, I think I just, I just prefer the revival.

[37:02] Tommy: But is it just because I know it and say that?

[37:05] Jimi: Good question.

[37:05] Tommy: That's a good question.

[37:06] Jimi: I like, I, I encountered, I took them both out of the library at the same time.

[37:10] Tommy: So I heard them both at the same time.

[37:12] Jimi: Cool.

[37:13] Tommy: Back in high school.

[37:16] Jimi: And it's, I like the revival more.

[37:20] Tommy: I think the revival's jokes land better.

[37:25] Jimi: Um, but I think so.

[37:27] Tommy: I imagine a lot of people who are listening to this have heard the revival and not heard the original.

[37:31] Jimi: That seems to be the way people experience the show.

[37:35] Tommy: Um, the best way to, I think, describe the differences are to talk about the songs that are new in the revival.

[37:42] Jimi: And in the revival, almost every song is rewritten to a certain bit.

[37:47] Tommy: If it doesn't have just new underscoring, it has whole new sections or phrases or choruses, and then there are a couple new songs.

[37:55] Jimi: Um, the new songs in the revival are My New Philosophy and Beethoven Day.

[38:01] Tommy: Um, if I think the peppiness that those come with embody the energy that was given to the revival that didn't quite exist in the original.

[38:15] Jimi: Um, but I would pose that they are both products of their time.

[38:20] Tommy: Um, the 1960s original sounds like a 1960s musical.

[38:28] Tommy: Um totally does. And it's hard to pinpoint why, because you know, it doesn't sound like say Hair. Um but there is there is I like the 1960s, the 1967 version of this I would peg as a tribal musical. Um it's uh about a company working together, especially knowing that most of the company wrote the show, wrote the vignettes in the book to it. There's something about it that just feels like that. And like we are, you know, there are there are fewer buttons at the ends of songs to let you know when a joke happened.

[39:06] Jimi: Yeah.

[39:06] Tommy: Um the whole The thing that bugs me um at the very beginning is Charlie Brown's monologue exists, and I think it's such a beautiful monologue. How could anything go wrong on a day like this, and then nothing happens? The chorus comes in and it's like bump b-dump bum bum, you're a good man, Charlie Brown, and like it doesn't set you up with that reversal. Um but they are such products of their times, and it's a really interesting case study into some of the tiny tweaks you can do to a show that will entirely change its tone.

[39:43] Jimi: Yeah, completely.

[39:44] Tommy: Like they're different, they're different shows.

[39:46] Jimi: Oh, absolutely different shows.

[39:48] Tommy: And also it kind of it kind of questions like how does it how does it work?

[39:57] Jimi: That's not that wasn't phrased well.

[39:59] Tommy: Um question like which one works better.

[40:04] Jimi: Yes, yes.

[40:05] Tommy: Like w why did they make these choices in the revival? What are they trying to say?

[40:11] Jimi: Yes.

[40:12] Tommy: Because you know you you've seen their first draft.

[40:15] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[40:16] Tommy: So I've got a theory. It could be bunnies. Do you know that reference?

[40:18] Jimi: It could be bunnies.

[40:22] Tommy: I don't know that reference.

[40:23] Jimi: Oh, it's Buffy.

[40:25] Tommy: Okay.

[40:26] Jimi: The Vampire Slayer.

[40:27] Tommy: Yes, that's actually from the musical, Tommy, so you should.

[40:31] Tommy: I don't watch Buffy.

[40:33] Jimi: You should. You really should. Especially the musical episode.

[40:38] Tommy: Anyway.

[40:39] Jimi: Oh my god, I can't wait to not podcast on that.

[40:43] Tommy: Anyway, anyway. Um, we all know that the off-Broadway production, you know, ran for over a thousand performances and was hugely successful. It once it closed and it went on Broadway, it flopped. Um, that could easily be because of 50,000 reasons to do with money and you know recruiting costs. Size of house, like all sorts of things.

[41:06] Jimi: Yeah, but I think what it probably will be because um is because it just doesn't work scaled up.

[41:16] Tommy: Yeah. I can't see, and this is something that I I really do kind of struggle with, is that I can't see how you can you know allometrically just scale this show up into a bigger house because it's so like the content of it is so bare. Do you know what I mean? Like, and I don't I don't mean that in the sense that it's you know it doesn't do anything, just as in it's really stark, and that's the whole point. There's not a you know, there's not a lot of spectacle to it, it's not a gigantic story.

[41:49] Jimi: Not at all.

[41:50] Tommy: It's also it's not even like big in its simplicity, in a way that like maybe something like Evan Hansen would be where I know what you mean. Big story about one person. Um but I I think about have you've seen Kristen Chenoweth perform at I what I assume is the Tony's my new philosophy.

[42:08] Jimi: Yes, yes.

[42:09] Tommy: And like I love that song. I love Kristen Chenoweth, and something about that performance seems too big, you know?

[42:17] Jimi: Yeah, it just seems it just seems a little bit off.

[42:19] Tommy: So obviously, so when we did it, we did it at the fringe. Um and it is performed at the fringe almost every year. There's always someone doing it.

[42:27] Jimi: Of course.

[42:28] Tommy: Um it works, it works absolutely perfectly because you're working in a tiny little house and a really simple set. Um, you just kind of go with it, and it's all there. You don't need to try and you don't feel uncomfortable. Whereas you watch because you know, so this is performed by so many high schools all the time.

[42:50] Jimi: Oh, yes, hugely popular high school show.

[42:53] Tommy: Um, and you watch a lot of their productions, and you know, they're in their huge, ridiculous stages that you guys have. It's just silly. I thought I think it's just so silly because there's only so much you can do.

[43:07] Jimi: Yeah, and so what they have to what they do is they then overcompensate by making the characters stupid and like running around, and like at no point did that ever happen in any of the comics, yeah, other than like the cupy of themselves, yeah.

[43:22] Tommy: But even that, you know, it is I it's it feels like oh man, I wonder if I can change turn this into a you know truism about musical theater. But like this musical exists at comic book distance. Um you know, it's the distance from your face that you read a comic book, it's not movie distance, it can't be as big as a Marvel Cinematic Universe movie. It's not like right up at your nose, where it's like this intimate kitchen sink drama or something, but it is it is only just so far away from you.

[43:55] Jimi: And if you lose that, you lose an acorn that's important in the show, you know?

[44:01] Tommy: For sure. I really think so. I really think so. So I I mean like I've never seen it in a big Broadway house, and like it did really it did really well when it got revived. Um, but what they had to do was they had to change it, you know.

[44:13] Jimi: I mean, Andrew Lippa came in and gave it an injection of adrenaline to make it go.

[44:19] Tommy: Huge, huge. You compare even the songs, like even songs that remain relatively unchanged. The book report, um, I think the book report's a great example, actually. I think it's a really good example because it's it's only been ever so slightly tweaked, but tweaked in the direction of scale.

[44:38] Jimi: Yeah, it's crazy.

[44:39] Tommy: Like there's maybe 16 bars at the end that are new, but other than that, it's like it's like changes you could get away with without like just licensing the show, you know?

[44:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[44:53] Tommy: Like if you license the original production and we're like, we're just gonna up the tempo a little bit and change the inflection right here. You would it wouldn't be a new song, but it was it's enough.

[45:05] Jimi: Yeah.

[45:05] Tommy: And I d I mean I'm not saying it's I'm not saying it's bad. That's the thing, is it it's really good and yeah, it works. It it's just it's just stra I don't know, it's just strange.

[45:15] Jimi: I think it really strange.

[45:16] Tommy: I think I'd love to see the the the revival. I'd love to have seen it.

[45:19] Jimi: Yeah, and I'm sure someone out there who's listening to the podcast has seen it, so we'd really love to know their experience of it and how they felt like just particularly with this the sketches.

[45:28] Tommy: Like, how do you do a four-second long sketch? You know what I mean? I was drumping, I was jumping on Broadway, and then suddenly it all seems so futile, and then you walk off.

[45:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[45:37] Tommy: How how does that work in a Broadway house? How do you make that land?

[45:40] Jimi: Well, and one of the things that baffles me is that so many of these songs written not even for off Broadway, but just as you know, a concept album were able to be so subtly tweaked into something that seems wonderfully appropriate for a larger Broadway house.

[46:01] Tommy: You know, that that doesn't happen. I don't think there are a lot of shows that do that.

[46:08] Jimi: I think when you see off Broadway to Broadway transfers, you have shows that are slightly too big for off Broadway and that become either slightly too small or appropriately sized for Broadway.

[46:19] Tommy: You don't get a lot of shows that are like appropriately off Broadway sized and then successfully transfer.

[46:26] Jimi: Well, so so the one that kind of always jumps into my head is Spelling Bee.

[46:31] Tommy: Yes.

[46:32] Jimi: Because I feel and I feel like in many ways they're they're quite comparable, the two. Just because we're dealing with adults playing kids and you know the kind of themes that they're talking about of kids struggling being kids and how it's no, that's a good comparison. I've never thought about that, but yeah.

[46:48] Tommy: And obviously Spelling Bee hugely successful off Broadway going on to Broadway, it kind of became again a different show. There was lots more staging happened. Um it again it had that big shot of you know, 20 volts to go.

[47:06] Jimi: Um but I think what Spelling Bee has that's different, obviously, from from this, and that maybe would make it uh that maybe made it a lot more successful on Broadway, um, was the improv element.

[47:20] Tommy: Yes.

[47:20] Jimi: And I think that's that's its USP, you know. You know, I mean, that's the thing.

[47:24] Tommy: Yeah.

[47:25] Jimi: And I I think the part of why that doesn't exist in Charlie Brown, whether it's an improv element or that like new exciting energy to it, is because, you know, not that there are Charlie Brown trekkies aren't out there. Like I don't think there are a lot of people going to Comic Con dressed up as Charlie Brown characters, maybe, who are so there are certainly people who are passionate about these characters.

[47:49] Tommy: But it's still an external character who exists.

[47:53] Jimi: Um it's the same way that people have really um heartfelt opinions about how Harry Potter exists in the world, um and whether you're being true to this character that exists.

[48:05] Tommy: Um and with Spelling Bee, these characters don't exist outside the show. So however they exist in the show is how they exist.

[48:11] Jimi: Whereas Charlie Brown has a reputation, has, you know, there are traits that exist about Charlie Brown, and if they're not in this show, then it's not a good Charlie Brown show.

[48:22] Tommy: Um that's a a difficult thing to struggle against.

[48:27] Jimi: Yeah, I do I do find it, I find it really difficult. And I want to know why the revival was so successful.

[48:33] Tommy: I mean, well, obviously it wasn't like groundbreakingly successful.

[48:36] Jimi: No.

[48:37] Tommy: But it was it was still very successful.

[48:39] Jimi: Um I mean, it it did well where the original off-Broadway to Broadway transfer did not. You know?

[48:46] Tommy: Something something changed, whether it was people's perception about what a Broadway show is or the new changes they added to it, or my guess somewhere in the middle.

[48:55] Jimi: Um just, you know, stick Kristen Chenoweth in there, you're done.

[49:00] Tommy: Yeah, it could be. We're also we're we're talking late 90s, early 2000s. This these are the black years. Like Yeah, that's just this is a time when anything that's mildly good will be good.

[49:14] Jimi: That is also very, very true, Thomas.

[49:16] Tommy: No, no offense to you, Jerome Robbins, Broadway, but Jerome Robbins, Broadway, whatever the hell it I don't I don't even want to remember what it is.

[49:23] Jimi: That's okay.

[49:25] Tommy: Um But yeah, no, it's uh that's a very good point. Um But hey, it did launch Kristen Chenoweth's career, so it did, crazily.

[49:35] Jimi: You sure it wasn't her as the waitress and nurse number two in A New Brain?

[49:39] Tommy: Hello!

[49:41] Jimi: Hello!

[49:42] Tommy: Yeah, I think I'm pretty sure I'm the thin nurse.

[49:47] Jimi: I'm I'm reasonably, reasonably sure about that one.

[49:50] Tommy: Um baffling. Um yeah, it's it's it's it's tricky. That's what I would say. It's a good I I highly encourage anyone interested in musical theater, listen to both of these albums back to back.

[50:04] Jimi: Um it is a wonderful exercise in comparative musical theater.

[50:08] Tommy: And it's an opportunity that doesn't exist very often. You don't get big changes between originals and revivals like you do here.

[50:16] Jimi: People try and stick to the original a lot and like add one or two different things, but they change this whole hog.

[50:24] Tommy: And so it gives you a good sense of how perspectives and aesthetic changed between the 60s and the 90s.

[50:31] Jimi: And I would also say as well, if you if you're going to be directing this or it, you know, putting this on, um, if you're doing it in a small house, listen to the listen to the original.

[50:43] Tommy: Because the way that they deliver the jokes, they're delivering it for a small house.

[50:47] Jimi: Um I would say that they hit on the tone.

[50:51] Tommy: I think they hit the tone a lot better than I agree.

[50:55] Jimi: The Broadway.

[50:57] Tommy: Um I like the I like the acting in the original better and I like the music and the revival better.

[51:02] Jimi: Yeah, I would there we go.

[51:04] Tommy: That's it.

[51:05] Jimi: That's it.

[51:06] Tommy: It's the best of both worlds.

[51:09] Jimi: Oh god, Tommy. I don't want to podcast with Miley Cyrus.

[51:17] Tommy: Apparently she's good again.

[51:20] Jimi: What was she ever bad?

[51:22] Tommy: So if you're if you're putting this on, okay. Have you been in this? Have you been involved in a production of the city?

[51:28] Jimi: I surprisingly I've never been I have never in any capacity been involved in a production of You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown, which is baffling based on the amount of high school theater I've done. But no, I've never actually done the show.

[51:40] Tommy: Okay. Have you have you seen a like amateur production?

[51:42] Jimi: I've never I've never seen it. I've read the script, I've listened to the album, but I've never seen it performed.

[51:47] Tommy: Right, okay. Cause it's it is interesting because obviously, you know, traditionally, and by that I mean professionally, it's performed by adults. Um it has a huge life in high schools.

[52:00] Jimi: Yes.

[52:00] Tommy: And you have these very two different things. Um very similar to again to Spelling Bee, um, where it's adults playing kids or kids playing kids. Um I think it's a very important to acknowledge.

[52:11] Jimi: Yeah.

[52:19] Tommy: Because it changes everything.

[52:22] Jimi: Yeah. Well, it's I mean, I've always one of the one of the reasons I'm a high school theater teacher, um, is because I think high school theater is the last chance to do theater for fun. Anytime beyond that, you're doing it for fun and something else.

[52:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[52:39] Jimi: For fun and in preparation for a job, or for fun and as a distraction from your day job or as a profession. But high school is the last chance to do it just 'cause, and there's something fun about that. Um but as like a side tangent to that, high school is one of the last chances where you can play someone vastly different from yourself and everyone's okay with it.

[53:07] Tommy: You know?

[53:07] Jimi: No, it like when they do professional productions of You Can't Take It With You, old people play the old people, and young people play the young people. But when high schools do it, you wear old age makeup, you know, and like ridiculous old age makeup, and you play an 85-year-old, and that doesn't happen as much professionally.

[53:29] Tommy: You might be a 40-year-old playing an 85-year-old, but that's different.

[53:33] Jimi: Um I mean, I think you don't get to do that outside of educational theater. Um, and so to see it turned on its head with something like You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown or Spelling Bee, where kids are playing kids. Um I don't know. It falls in that category in my mind, and I find it fascinating. And I don't have I don't know what to think about it.

[54:01] Tommy: I know because that's the thing, is like you're like, well, does it work? And I'm almost inclined to say no. Because again, so you there's there's so many, there are so many high school productions on YouTube. Um there's a plethora, and some of them are actually really good. There's some amazing voices. It seems to attract some really good talent. Um there's a I saw um Zac Efron was on some late night talk show, and they hauled out his high school production of You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown with him as Snoopy singing something supper time or whatever.

[54:38] Jimi: Um notes that'd be good.

[54:42] Tommy: Yeah. Um yeah, the but so there's there's loads there. But they're always they're always kids. And this is this is yeah, it's gonna be really difficult to try and articulate any of this. So one of the one of the kind of key struggles you have when you're putting this on is getting that idea of you're being a child, but you're being childlike, not childish.

[55:05] Jimi: Yes, that is a great way to put it.

[55:09] Tommy: And it's really, really challenging to strike that balance when you're an adult.

[55:16] Jimi: Yeah. It's in the same way, you know, when you're when you act drunk, you know, it's it's not a case of being let oh. People who are drunk on stage are often trying hard not to be drunk. It's like you want to you if it's much more interesting to watch someone try not to cry than it is to watch them actually cry.

[55:38] Tommy: Exactly.

[55:39] Jimi: And so how do you do that when because you can't be like it's so much interesting to watch an adult try and not be a child, but that's effectively what they're trying to do, and especially with Peanuts, where you have these kids who are adults. Do you know what I mean? Because these kids who do adult things and talk about adult things, um but they are they are like 90% adult, and then you need the ridiculous 10% to come out effortlessly and not as a parody and not as a character caricature, but like completely in earnest. Just pu yeah, pure naivety. Um that's it's so tricky.

[56:17] Tommy: It's so tricky. It's hard.

[56:23] Jimi: So you would think, oh, okay, well, the solution for that would just be cascades. Yeah, when you class kids, they don't get that because they don't get that they need to have the naivety. What they just then do is just perform it.

[56:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:38] Jimi: And for them, you know, especially if you think high schoolers, high schoolers think kids and they think kids who are actually the age that the Peanuts are supposed to be, um like six, seven, eight, but the Peanuts don't act like six, seven, eight-year-olds at all. Um it's like, have you this have you seen the Rugrats?

[56:57] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[56:57] Jimi: It um it's you know, it's that they're kids, but it's the secret life of kids. Yeah.

[57:09] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[57:10] Jimi: Yeah. Completely I don't know. Like, there's no adults in this show.

[57:14] Tommy: Right.

[57:15] Jimi: You know, I mean, there's Miss B, that's that you know, someone who's off stage. Uh there are no There are no adults. And so is it a you know it's a silly question to ask, is it okay to do the show as a high school? Because everyone will continue to. But it does it does take an extra level of care. You know, it it the difficulty is I think the reason this is a popular high school show, in fact, I know the reason this is a popular high school show, is because it's kids, and there are many, many drama directors across the world who are like, if we just put the kids as playing people their own age or younger, they will have the life experience to do it justice. But that's a trap with this show.

[58:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:04] Jimi: Because it doesn't work well. And so you need to like mm double meta it. It's like when a when a British person is on an American show doing an American accent as their character and then pretending to be a British person for like a joke or a shtick or something, and then they have to do a British American accent.

[58:28] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:28] Jimi: There's like several layers.

[58:30] Tommy: Or it's like Helena Bonham Carter pretending to be Hermione Granger pretending to be Bellatrix Lestrange.

[58:36] Jimi: Yeah, precisely. You like there's a bunch of layers you have to incorporate to make it successful.

[58:42] Tommy: For sure.

[58:43] Jimi: Um it's just very, very it's difficult. It's difficult. It's filled, it it makes for a lot of not so great performances.

[58:52] Tommy: Yeah, and that's a shame I feel because I've I've seen a fair few productions of it at the fringe. Um I'm not gonna lie, I think we did really well.

[59:02] Jimi: I don't I don't say that about everything I do. I'm not gonna tilt my own horn here, but uh tell you why I think I know we did really well, Tommy.

[59:10] Tommy: No, you can't.

[59:11] Jimi: Um well tell the listeners, you can just go hawk your walkle.

[59:17] Tommy: Um so Anthony Rapp came and saw it.

[59:23] Jimi: No way.

[59:24] Tommy: Yeah, so this is quite weird. I I don't like so my best friend Finley, he was playing um Charlie Brown, um and uh Anthony Rapp's like a fan of his because he was there doing um what was his show called No Day But Today? What was the solo show another?

[59:41] Jimi: I don't know.

[59:45] Tommy: It was a line from Rent. Um so he was overdoing that at the fringe, um and he went to see Finley when he was doing Spring Awakening, he was playing um Moritz, and like stayed back after the show and was like to him like that was one of the best performances I've ever seen. Um he was like so obsessed with it, and like Finley's extremely talented, um so it's it you know it was all deserved. Um so anyway, so played Charlie Brown, and obviously Anthony Rapp played Charlie Brown in the revival, and um would kind of got his start there too along with Casey.

[1:00:21] Jimi: No, this is that's post-Rent.

[1:00:23] Tommy: Is this is this post-Rent?

[1:00:24] Jimi: Never mind that.

[1:00:25] Tommy: Yeah, his haircut throws me off.

[1:00:26] Jimi: I can't believe it.

[1:00:27] Tommy: I know he's he always looks the same, he has always looked the same forever.

[1:00:31] Jimi: Um and so he, you know, again say about and like said he really enjoyed it, and again thought Finley was amazing. Um so that's why I think we did quite a good job, Tommy.

[1:00:40] Tommy: Uh that's and hey, that's a high measure for success.

[1:00:43] Jimi: I I of musical theater performers, I think Anthony Rapp has very good aesthetic, like viewing musical theater. I don't say that about many musical theater performers.

[1:00:55] Tommy: I think it's no, he knows yeah, I think he knows his craft, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:01:00] Jimi: Absolutely. Um, but anyway, that wasn't just a free glow. I do have a point behind that. Um but like so I've seen I've seen others, and I think what and I'm just gonna I'm just gonna focus in on Finley because I think he really nailed it. What he he really had, he was never trying to be a kid, he wasn't doing anything to be a kid. Do you know what I mean?

[1:01:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:23] Jimi: He was being cartoonish.

[1:01:26] Tommy: Okay.

[1:01:26] Jimi: And I think that really helped it. Because what that did was it helps the audience get into this world of things not really making sense. Why is this tone weird? And for him doing these kind of pantomime cartoon things. You could just tell it wasn't, you know, that Haydn reality thing. But he wasn't doing it, it wasn't being a cartoon child. It was almost being a cartoon adult.

[1:01:56] Tommy: Okay.

[1:01:57] Jimi: As a child. It's different. I don't really know what he did because it's acting. But he did it very, very well.

[1:02:04] Tommy: Yeah, I see that.

[1:02:05] Jimi: Because it's like um what's the best way to phrase this? It it's like when you're doing comedy and you don't the the thing's not funny to you, it's funny to the audience. Um you keep it inside a little bit. That's not the best metaphor. But there's something, there's something right in the middle about this show.

[1:02:29] Tommy: It's a difficult tone to achieve.

[1:02:31] Jimi: It really is. It's such a fine line.

[1:02:34] Tommy: Yeah, and it's dangerous because it seems really simple from the outside.

[1:02:38] Jimi: It seems like emoting, it seems like using your hands and moving your face. Um but there's a lot more to it.

[1:02:46] Tommy: There's a lot of depth to all of it.

[1:02:49] Jimi: Um, you know, it it's like we talk about this with high schoolers all the time, because high schoolers are dramatic, partially because of hormones and brain changes. Um but the have you've heard the like there's a uh philosophical discussion that like the first second of your life is the most important of your second of your life. Like when you are born, the very first second is the only second you've ever lived, and so it must be super important because it's the only one. And then you live for a second second, and now you've lived for two seconds, and that second second is not as important as the first one.

[1:03:24] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:03:24] Jimi: And then you live for a full year, and the first year is the only year you've ever been alive, and so it seems like forever because it's all you know, because you've been alive for a year, but then you're alive for two years, and you're like, aha, well, here's another one, and now I've done it twice. And so then, you know, you extrapolate it to half a decade and then another decade. But by the time you're a high schooler, the stuff that seems super dramatic in high school is super dramatic to you because it's all you know, and that's as big as your world is. And it's easy as an adult to qualify that as silly or overly dramatic or you know, something stupid like that, but that's not true for a high schooler.

[1:04:17] Tommy: You know, seeing like a high schooler get totally down in the dumps because they, you know, broke up with their first significant other, and you're like, oh, how silly. But like, puppy love is real to puppies, and it's like that with your good man Charlie Brown. This world is as real and as serious to these children because it's all they know. And the audience sits in that kind of middle world, and you're trying to invigorate the sense that this is such a this is the end of the world. This is, you know, this is the last day. Clearly, some philosophies aren't for all people, yeah. For these children, but you and your adult brain know that's not true, and then the interest is where those two ideas meet in the middle.

[1:05:04] Jimi: Yeah, I love that actually. That was good. Good philosophy, Tommy. Yeah, I think that's the show. That's why this show's good. Yeah, that's why Charlie Brown's good. Um, so well, just one final question because I've not really talked about it, and people hate it when we don't do this. Um, what's your favorite song?

[1:05:22] Tommy: Um, I think the book report is musical theater genius. Um both the book report and the baseball game are really good. Um I've auditioned with the kite before. Um it's a great character piece. I'm sure it's overdone by now. Um, but it fits my character type very well. Um like second banana comedy selling a story.

[1:05:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:05:46] Tommy: Um I think Hyde. You'd also make a really good Horton. Have I told you that before?

[1:05:51] Jimi: I would love to play Horton.

[1:05:54] Tommy: Oh, that's good. Oh no, I would uh Horton, yeah. Horton's a lot of things. Do you all think they're thriller?

[1:06:01] Jimi: I do. I think that you know, they're dopey and optimistic with a pessimism. Um they're like the glass exists, you know, it's not half full or half empty. Um yeah, there's a I have a lot of I think it's those, and then any character in the producers are all very high on my list.

[1:06:21] Tommy: Yep.

[1:06:22] Jimi: Um, I totally I like I think the book report is stunning. It's so funny. It's so funny, and it's so real. I haven't even started yet. It's the best ending, and again, so that that was only included in the revival.

[1:06:36] Tommy: Thank you so much.

[1:06:38] Jimi: In the original, it goes, it goes, I haven't even s oh no, you're right, you're right. It says a book report on Peter Rabbit. Blink.

[1:06:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:47] Jimi: But it's not as funny as in the revival.

[1:06:49] Tommy: Exactly. I also find it weird that that's the act one finale.

[1:06:54] Jimi: Right?

[1:06:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:56] Jimi: No.

[1:06:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:58] Jimi: What's your favorite song?

[1:07:00] Tommy: My favorite song. So I as choreographer, I'd probably say blanket ballet. Uh the blanket ballet is probably the best thing I've ever done. Uh-huh.

[1:07:11] Jimi: Do you have a person as the blanket?

[1:07:14] Tommy: Uh-huh. Um why isn't there is there a bad You're a good man Charlie Brown blankets.tumbler.com.

[1:07:22] Jimi: There's bad Snoopies though.

[1:07:24] Tommy: That'll be in the show notes. Which is totally fair. Um so I do like that, but just that's just selfish. But no, I think from the agile song, I'd agree with you. I'd I'd probably say um book report, but I also love choir practice or glee club. You know, and now that I'm thinking about it, like there are times when happiness comes up on my shuffle, uh, and I still get a little like teary in the corner of my eyes.

[1:07:49] Jimi: Right, completely. It's a beautiful song, and it's so it that is a thing about happy uh happiness, is it just it encapsulates that 10% that we talked about before? Do you know what I mean? Adults could never sing happiness.

[1:08:03] Tommy: No, but like happiness is telling the time. Uh what tying it to lace. What a philosophical concept.

[1:08:11] Jimi: Like, oh, yes, it is.

[1:08:15] Tommy: Yes, it's yeah, it's so much is. It really is. It really it just these little, you know, oh yeah, they're just cute little nuggets.

[1:08:23] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:08:24] Tommy: No. Good good musical. I I have very few problems with your good man Charlie Brown, which is rare in a piece of musical theater.

[1:08:32] Jimi: Exactly. And it's one of those things, even with the problems, I love them. I'm like, oh problem away, guys.

[1:08:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:08:39] Jimi: Did you know? So I eventually downloaded this on iTunes very early in iTunes' life. Um it just l you know, I only knew it a little bit and listened to it a whole bunch. But apparently, my original download didn't include the song Supper Time at all.

[1:09:00] Tommy: Oh it just like missed it.

[1:09:03] Jimi: And then something like three years later, I got an email from iTunes that was like, Oh, we've noticed this problem in our system, and you have a nude free download awaiting of this missing song from this album you've downloaded. I was like, What is this? And so Supper Time feels like this weird bonus song to me in this show that like I've never I don't know as well, and that's just not true. That's not how it exists.

[1:09:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:31] Jimi: That's hilarious.

[1:09:33] Tommy: Isn't that weird? I cause I then to me Supper Time is one of those like uh do we have to sit through this song again? I will skip Supper Time.

[1:09:39] Jimi: Because it wasn't in the original.

[1:09:41] Tommy: Because it wasn't in the original, and it's a fine song, but like I wonder if it was in the original if I would have that opinion or not.

[1:09:47] Jimi: I sometimes skip Supper Time, so maybe you would um Yeah.

[1:09:51] Tommy: I sometimes skip Snoopy stuff. I don't really like Snoopy. Have you listened to his musical? Have you listened to the sequel? This is one of the fusicals with the sequel. Snoopy three exclamation marks.

[1:10:00] Jimi: Uh Snoopy.

[1:10:02] Tommy: Thank you. Um, yeah, I have. Um we'll talk about that when we talk about it.

[1:10:07] Jimi: Alright.

[1:10:10] Tommy: In twenty years.

[1:10:11] Jimi: In twenty years time.

[1:10:13] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:14] Jimi: No, we'll talk about because I do I have opinions about that.

[1:10:18] Tommy: Okay.

[1:10:18] Jimi: For next next Charlie Brown podcast.

[1:10:21] Tommy: You heard it here, folks. We're gonna go on till we're talking about.

[1:10:25] Jimi: Will this will this be before or after Subways Are for Sleeping?

[1:10:29] Tommy: Um That's a good question. I think after.

[1:10:35] Jimi: Okay, we gotta talk about the exclamation marks deserves that. I'm sorry.

[1:10:39] Tommy: Yeah, Subways Are for Sleeping also has three exclamation marks. They didn't make the posters, but it's a little known fact.

[1:10:51] Jimi: Thank you.

[1:10:52] Tommy: Thank you. Lovely say the best. Having a sister sharing a sandwich, getting along.

[1:11:03] Jimi: Happiness is singing together Wednesday.

[1:11:10] Tommy: And happiness is long to sing with you.

[1:11:18] Jimi: Happiness morning and evening.

[1:11:22] Tommy: Daytime and nighttime.

[1:11:26] Jimi: For happiness is anyone and anything at all.

[1:11:33] Tommy: That's loved by you're a good man, Charlie Brown.

[1:11:59] Jimi: Tommy, that was you're a good man Charlie Brown.

[1:12:03] Tommy: There was you're a good man, Charlie Brown. Just before we get into the quiz question, I wanna uh make a public service announcement. Um so we've been getting loads and loads of people um letting us know what shows they want us to cover.

[1:12:23] Jimi: And we're never gonna cover any of them.

[1:12:25] Tommy: And yeah, exactly. The second you ask, we'll never do it. No, that's not true. It's the opposite, actually. Um basically our rule with the podcast is nothing's off the table.

[1:12:35] Jimi: It's true.

[1:12:36] Tommy: Exactly. Um, but it's really good to it's good to know what you want us to talk about. Um but bear in mind we plan these generally months in advance.

[1:12:45] Jimi: Yes, really. We recorded this episode in 2008.

[1:12:49] Tommy: Um, exactly. Um do tell us. Send us your requests.

[1:12:56] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:57] Tommy: But don't expect them to happen the next week. It's basically know that we are we have a list, we are writing them down, and you can be very excited when it happens.

[1:13:09] Jimi: Yes, exactly. But do do let us know. We love to hear.

[1:13:13] Tommy: Yes.

[1:13:14] Jimi: And it's good to it's good to know what what you know what people are into out there. What's in the musical theater Zeitgeist?

[1:13:19] Tommy: Yes, and I don't know about you, Tommy, but I've been getting some unsung heroes into my DMs.

[1:13:25] Jimi: Oh, I've gotten a couple of slightly into my DMs. I've gotten a couple too. I'm glad we've both gotten some.

[1:13:29] Tommy: Hey, hey, hey. Get ready for the next one.

[1:13:33] Jimi: I think you're currently winning.

[1:13:37] Tommy: Aren't we tied?

[1:13:37] Jimi: I thought you won the first one and I won the second one.

[1:13:39] Tommy: Oh no, just on the second one.

[1:13:41] Jimi: Yeah, but I think this will will this be up by then?

[1:13:44] Tommy: Yeah, it probably will.

[1:13:45] Jimi: Yes. I've I've called it. Let's just say you win.

[1:13:47] Tommy: I win!

[1:13:50] Jimi: Well done.

[1:13:52] Tommy: Hooray. Um so yeah, we're we're one all.

[1:13:59] Jimi: One next.

[1:14:00] Tommy: All next will be the tiebreaker. Jimi, you know, at the end of um what is it, the piano lesson? What's that song called? You know, something Shrouder, Beethoven.

[1:14:12] Jimi: It's called um what's it called?

[1:14:14] Tommy: Is it called Schroeder?

[1:14:15] Jimi: It's called Schroeder.

[1:14:16] Tommy: Is it called Shrouder? Um and you know, Lucy says, My Aunt Marion was right. Never try to discuss marriage with a musician.

[1:14:24] Jimi: Yes.

[1:14:25] Tommy: Can you name any other musical theater Marians that might be discussing marriage with a musician?

[1:14:32] Jimi: Ah.

[1:14:33] Tommy: Gasp, yeah. Marion the librarian.

[1:14:36] Jimi: Marion, and so if it's Lucy's Aunt Marion, the implication is that Lucy is the daughter of Winthrop.

[1:14:48] Tommy: Interesting.

[1:14:51] Jimi: Which I don't think is intentional, but is oddly coincidental.

[1:14:55] Tommy: So does that mean Lucy Vampelt should probably be played with a lisp?

[1:15:00] Jimi: Probably. By a redhead, because Ron Howard has red hair.

[1:15:06] Tommy: I would love though, right, if there was a production who did that because of that thought. Like that three thought. And like if if Winthrop is the age he is in 1920s, Iowa, it is not inconceivable that Lucy is his daughter in the 1960s.

[1:15:25] Jimi: It's really not inconceivable. I think we've actually hit onto something.

[1:15:30] Tommy: That's what we call a head cannon.

[1:15:34] Jimi: There you go.

[1:15:35] Tommy: Oh man. You've got a quiz question for us.

[1:15:39] Jimi: I do. Okay, so.

[1:15:42] Tommy: It's actually quite short. I was gearing up for a big old speech. But no.

[1:15:48] Jimi: So our next show is Anderson Cooper, the Silver Fox himself, only Broadway credit. What could it be?

[1:15:58] Tommy: What could it be? Does he does he tap dance in it, Jimi?

[1:16:02] Jimi: He has a eight-minute tap solo. It's fascinating.

[1:16:08] Tommy: You know? Oh man. I'd watch that. If you if you want to get in contact with us, I'm Musical Mash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.

[1:16:17] Jimi: And I am As in Hendrix on Twitter and YouTube. And our show Twitter is Jim and Tomic, or you can go to our website at Jim and Tomic.com, which has a link to the Reddit discussion, and our Patreon, where you can do all sorts of wonderful things.

[1:16:30] Tommy: Exactly. Tell your friends all about us, and we will see you next week.

[1:16:37] Jimi: Bye bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred