Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Dan Weschler (PigPen Theatre Co.) on Collaboration Across Disciplines

In this College Deep Dive, Charlie and Dan discuss: Seeking ways to be present. How PigPen was formed. Ways to navigate the creative process and accolades in a larger group. Imposter syndrome in the writing process... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

1 h 14 mins
5/17/23

Featured Shows

About

In this College Deep Dive, Charlie and Dan discuss:

  • Seeking ways to be present
  • How PigPen was formed
  • Ways to navigate the creative process and accolades in a larger group
  • Imposter syndrome in the writing process

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.

[0:19] Charlie Murphy: As ever, I am your host, Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA.

[0:22] Charlie Murphy: That's Musical Theatre College Auditions.

[0:25] Charlie Murphy: And today we have got a filthy sty of a show lined up for you.

[0:30] Charlie Murphy: Dan Weschler of the Amazing Pig Pen Theater Company is on the show today.

[0:34] Charlie Murphy: And he is such an awesome guy.

[0:36] Charlie Murphy: Pig Pen is in itself an amazing achievement and took a lot of remarkable people like Dan.

[0:41] Charlie Murphy: And I think you can see in this episode how he was able to contribute to their success.

[0:46] Charlie Murphy: Dan is also married to MTCA's own Katie Whelan, all of us meeting at Carnegie Mellon when we were there.

[0:58] Charlie Murphy: On these Tuesdays, I'm not even thinking about the weekend.

[1:01] Charlie Murphy: So if God forbid this President's Day this weekend or something, I'm gonna miss that as well.

[1:06] Charlie Murphy: But I spent a really fun weekend reuniting my daughter and her mother and getting to see Elizabeth absolutely slay in Ragtime with the Boston Pops.

[1:16] Charlie Murphy: Um she uh played Mother in Ragtime.

[1:19] Charlie Murphy: She got a much deserved mid-show standing ovation after singing "Back to Before," and it was really cool to see her in her element with a whole new cast of great characters, making some new friends, etc.

[1:28] Charlie Murphy: I also got to see the incredibly talented AJ Shivley, MTCA's own, as younger brother in that same production, and he was great.

[1:35] Charlie Murphy: Um we are working through a few more days of solo parenting while Elizabeth finishes up up there, and then I'm gonna sleep for about two weeks.

[1:44] Charlie Murphy: Um also speaking of breaks, just a heads up that the pod will be taking a short hiatus this summer again.

[1:49] Charlie Murphy: We're gonna run a few rebroadcasts like we did last summer, previous interviews you may have missed, and it will be a shorter break than last summer, I promise.

[1:56] Charlie Murphy: But always good for us to kind of pause and refuel the creative juices as we moved into season three now of the podcast, any changes, editions we want to make, etc.

[2:05] Charlie Murphy: But before and after the break, we are gonna have a few Broadway luminaries.

[2:11] Charlie Murphy: I mean big names on.

[2:13] Charlie Murphy: So please stay tuned for the next few episodes.

[2:15] Charlie Murphy: Don't mean to drop these secret names, but they will be coming, some very exciting big artist guests.

[2:20] Charlie Murphy: I think you'll really enjoy.

[2:22] Charlie Murphy: Okay, let's get to this interview with Dan.

[2:23] Charlie Murphy: I think you're gonna notice we are occasionally joined by Dan and Katie's lovely dog on the pod.

[2:28] Charlie Murphy: So if you hear a squeal or two, this is one of the few times that is not Solvi in the background making that noise.

[2:34] Charlie Murphy: Um, but if you happen to listen really closely, see if you can catch MTCA coach Katie Whelan bipping and bopping around their apartment as stealthily as a cat.

[2:44] Charlie Murphy: Um, there's some really great comedy in watching her like slink under and then around the screen.

[2:49] Charlie Murphy: Because at one point she really thought the screen ended somewhere that it didn't.

[2:53] Charlie Murphy: So she was like trying to avoid an imaginary wall, even though she was fully on camera.

[2:58] Charlie Murphy: It was very funny.

[2:59] Charlie Murphy: So a great time will be had by all who choose to listen to the or watch the YouTube video, I should say, of this once we post that.

[3:05] Charlie Murphy: So I think you really enjoy.

[3:06] Charlie Murphy: But for now, some of his family, but mostly Dan Weschler.

[3:15] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by Dan Weschler.

[3:19] Charlie Murphy: Uh, Dan has a BFA from Carnegie Mellon and is a founding member and head writer of the amazing Pig Pen Theater Company.

[3:27] Charlie Murphy: Uh, for those who've not heard of Pig Pen, they're an amazing theater company.

[3:30] Charlie Murphy: They've done shows like The Old Man and the Old Moon.

[3:33] Charlie Murphy: They're currently developing Water for Elephants for an anticipated Broadway run.

[3:37] Charlie Murphy: Um, and they also function as a band.

[3:40] Charlie Murphy: They have released albums like Whole Sun and Bremen, um, which you can download wherever Dan will make the most money.

[3:45] Charlie Murphy: We'll get into there.

[3:47] Charlie Murphy: They've also done movies.

[3:48] Charlie Murphy: They just were in uh Ricky and the Flash not too long ago, a Meryl Streep um movie, which maybe we'll chat about the comedy of that.

[3:56] Charlie Murphy: Um and lots of other exciting stuff.

[3:57] Charlie Murphy: So please look up Pig Pen if you haven't done that yet.

[4:00] Charlie Murphy: Dan, welcome on the show.

[4:01] Dan Weschler: I'm great. Thanks so much for having me. I'm excited to talk to you.

[4:07] Charlie Murphy: The honor is mine.

[4:07] Charlie Murphy: And I think, you know, especially as soon as we started doing these little um deep dives on specific topics, you were immediately at the top of my list of someone I really wanted to talk about creating your own work.

[4:17] Charlie Murphy: I mean, I think you really have brought an artistry to your approach that I think many people talk about.

[4:22] Charlie Murphy: Um and they say this is what they want, but not everybody actually goes in and makes it happen.

[4:26] Charlie Murphy: So we'll dive into that today.

[4:28] Charlie Murphy: Um, but I'd love it if you take me back to when you started thinking about all this around 16, 17, maybe especially when you started thinking about college.

[4:36] Charlie Murphy: You know, what were you thinking about in terms of your career and what you might have wanted, or what you wanted specifically from a collegiate education if you didn't know for sure what the career was gonna go?

[4:45] Charlie Murphy: But how did you end up at Carnegie Mellon? What led you to wanting that as a school?

[4:49] Dan Weschler: By the time I was 16, I was already pretty certain that I wanted to pursue a career in theater. I could go into how that came to be, but that would take us back to like, you know, age five.

[5:01] Dan Weschler: I said 16, 17 and nothing before Daniel. Nothing.

[5:03] Dan Weschler: So we'll start right there.

[5:05] Dan Weschler: Um and was not a big fan of my public high school in Palmyra, Pennsylvania.

[5:13] Dan Weschler: Uh, and they didn't have a lot to offer in the uh realm of arts, although apparently since then they've gotten way better, according to my parents who see all of the shows there.

[5:23] Dan Weschler: Um they're still critics, they're still gonna let you know.

[5:26] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, certainly.

[5:27] Dan Weschler: So uh I started going to uh an arts magnet school um called the Capital Area School for the Arts which was then in like the basement of a church in Harrisburg.

[5:39] Dan Weschler: Uh but it was this really cool environment of just um cross-disciplinary you know there was like there were there was the theater department and the film department and the dance department but every year they would put on you know this big collaborative show that just kind of combined all of these different um disciplines into this weird collage of stuff.

[6:01] Charlie Murphy: And when you say different disciplines, just in case people don't know what that means like are you talking about music? Is it some of the stuff we'll talk about with Pig Pen with puppetry and dance and how many disciplines are we talking?

[6:10] Dan Weschler: Yeah so I think the departments were dance, theater, music, uh visual arts and film.

[6:19] Dan Weschler: So the visual arts department would be you know creating props or backdrops for things and then the film department would be creating projection stuff and all of these different worlds kind of colliding to make this big weird ungainly statement.

[6:34] Dan Weschler: And I think so that was like my first really exciting taste of total theater where everyone kind of had their hands on all of these different parts of the process.

[6:43] Dan Weschler: And then that continued I went to the Pennsylvania Governor's School for the Arts um which was a similar environment in that you know it was these siloed departments that really kind of got in each other's business and you know we were all seeing each other's work all the time and finding ways to kind of expand our comfort zones.

[7:04] Dan Weschler: And I think the feeling of that just sort of like full throttle creativity, where we were just making things really quickly and resourcefully.

[7:13] Dan Weschler: And uh and just the you know, the excitement of that, I think, is what really stuck with me as I started to look for uh schools.

[7:22] Dan Weschler: I think before that, you know, I had thought of myself as an actor primarily.

[7:26] Dan Weschler: Um then after those experiences when I went to look for uh college, you know, one of my priorities when I started the search was to find a program that would encourage or allow kind of multiple focuses.

[7:40] Dan Weschler: And I think initially I was really looking for somewhere that had, you know, like a dual um acting and directing or acting and playwriting.

[7:49] Dan Weschler: And there weren't a ton of those.

[7:51] Dan Weschler: I think you know, Boston University was doing something along those lines back then, and SUNY Purchase at least told me that they were they would, you know, accommodate that.

[8:01] Dan Weschler: Um, but uh at the end of the day, you know, Carnegie Mellon, who was very upfront about, you know, no, you're gonna be an actor, you know, if you come here.

[8:10] Dan Weschler: Um, my visit there and my observation of the school and and kind of the environment just sort of gave me the feeling that I was gonna get what I needed there, you know, even though on paper it wasn't that exactly.

[8:27] Charlie Murphy: It's so interesting.

[8:28] Charlie Murphy: And because that is such a, you know, our students uh just passed the decision day, so we're just sort of announcing all of our where people got in, and this episode we really air a little bit later.

[8:37] Charlie Murphy: But you know, so often we talk about the checklist and you write down your pros and cons.

[8:40] Charlie Murphy: And you know, what you've described to me so far, I would go, well, that's not a student who's gonna end up at a very conservatory-style school like Carnegie Mellon.

[8:47] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[8:47] Charlie Murphy: Especially a very focused on only acting as opposed to, you know, there are schools that have it speak more about interdisciplinary and and also just more liberal arts in general, which might give you more flexibility.

[8:57] Charlie Murphy: Um, but not at all surprising that you go, but the fit just feels right.

[9:00] Charlie Murphy: You know, I could have described this person and then this is the person I fell in love with.

[9:04] Charlie Murphy: And you know, that is what it is.

[9:05] Dan Weschler: Yeah, it's really true.

[9:07] Dan Weschler: You know, I think it's um and it turned out to be completely correct because I'm not even sure if I knew at the time about the student theater festival that they have there, the Playground Festival, which is, you know, pretty much exactly what I was describing before, where, you know, everyone just kind of makes stuff.

[9:24] Charlie Murphy: I wondered if that's what had led you to Carnegie Mellon.

[9:26] Charlie Murphy: I was like, it's because you guys, you know, we'll talk about it.

[9:28] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna give you more compliments later.

[9:29] Charlie Murphy: Don't you worry, but but Pig Pen really is like the golden child of playground and of any of these kind of um programs.

[9:36] Charlie Murphy: It's like this is what they're looking for is for seven people to get together, make incredibly artistic stuff.

[9:40] Charlie Murphy: And then of course it turns into something commercially successful, which is so cool.

[9:44] Charlie Murphy: But um I before we leave the the stretch for college, was there at 17 or at 18 as you're looking, was there any musical interest for you?

[9:52] Charlie Murphy: Because you ended up as an acting major at Carnegie Mellon, right?

[9:55] Charlie Murphy: But but you now sing and play instruments and are in a band and compose Broadway musicals.

[10:00] Charlie Murphy: So what was there anything part of you that was uh um musically inclined back then?

[10:04] Dan Weschler: Yes.

[10:05] Dan Weschler: Um I was in a band called Fairway uh in high school uh which was um kind of like a I don't know a pop punk heavy on the pop side uh light on the punk there was a little punk sometimes it was me and then everyone else in the band was from the music department of the the school that I went to uh so you know, I was kind of I I guess I couldn't find a single person who played keyboards in in the music department, which gives you a sense of how small that school was.

[10:38] Dan Weschler: Um that was like my first time being in a band and you know, touring around playing I don't know, ice rinks or wherever it was we were going.

[10:48] Dan Weschler: Um but you know, the everyone else in the band, I I was fine, but everyone else was really very good at their you know their instruments, and um so it was you know kind of this aspirational thing for me.

[11:01] Dan Weschler: Uh and so just the the feeling that I got from that kind of performance versus uh you know being in a play, being in a musical, I think was just even more concentrated and addictive than you know the usual um kind of uh experience.

[11:22] Dan Weschler: And I I was really I found I was able to kind of lose myself in a way that I have a much harder time doing uh when I'm you know acting when I'm doing a role.

[11:32] Charlie Murphy: I want to dive deep into Pig Pen, but before, even though we've had enough Carnegie Mellon grads, too many Carnegie Mellon grads on the thing.

[11:38] Charlie Murphy: Before we get to the Pig Pen side, I think just tell me a little bit about your kind of non-Pig Pen Carnegie Mellon experience.

[11:43] Charlie Murphy: Give me a couple words of what was the acting um training experience like for you, apps in Pig Pen.

[11:49] Dan Weschler: It was intense.

[11:51] Dan Weschler: Uh the first year especially was really um, you know, it could sometimes feel like throwing yourself against a brick wall, um just trying to figure out, you know, really how to just kind of get into this headspace that felt you know just out of reach.

[12:10] Dan Weschler: You were being giving all of these different tools, and I think at the time I thought that you know I had to like excel at all of them, you know.

[12:10] Dan Weschler: You know, I had to, you know, all of these different kinds of ways in to a role needed to be, you know, in my tool belt as you know, things that I could just pull out and use.

[12:29] Dan Weschler: And it wasn't until a little bit later that I realized, oh no, this was really like kind of like a tasting, you know, of all of the different ways that you can find your way in.

[12:38] Dan Weschler: And what I discovered is that there are certain ways of working that I just gravitate towards, you know, and a lot of that is um surprising for me.

[12:48] Dan Weschler: Movement-based, uh, I don't consider myself much of a mover, but you know, that's certainly the fastest way to get me to stop thinking is to you know make it.

[12:57] Dan Weschler: Outside in allows you to calm the brain.

[12:59] Dan Weschler: Yeah, outside in is definitely, yeah.

[13:01] Dan Weschler: And viewpoints, uh, which you know for those that aren't familiar is this kind of dance theatrical language of um different just focuses that you kind of let your mind settle on while you're you're doing these kinds of movement improvisations.

[13:18] Dan Weschler: Um, I found to be really inspiring and kind of um, you know, I it's uh when you're working creatively, I feel like you're always looking for, you know, you always have your epiphanies and in the shower, you know.

[13:33] Dan Weschler: It's never while you're like actually sitting down to write, you know, it's while you're doing the dishes or water is involved somehow for sure.

[13:41] Charlie Murphy: There's always it's gotta be water, yeah.

[13:42] Dan Weschler: You can be in the garden, whatever.

[13:45] Dan Weschler: But um, and I think uh viewpoints ended up feeling like that a way to get into that frame of mind, but with a focus.

[13:56] Dan Weschler: I think I was kind of socially awkward at the beginning of college, uh, which makes it sound like I'm not still socially awkward, but I absolutely am.

[14:04] Dan Weschler: Uh so I think you know, the kind of intense nature of you know, working with a scene partner, you know, extracurricularly was kind of a lot for me back then.

[14:16] Dan Weschler: Just uh um that kind of one-on-one, let's crack this together, uh, and kind of create a relationship was tough.

[14:26] Dan Weschler: Um, but rewarding.

[14:28] Charlie Murphy: Um, I love it. Something you said at the beginning, you're saying you're chasing, um, I think you said a state of mind. I'm not, it may not be, I'm paraphrasing you a little bit here, but you're sort of chasing a state of mind that was always outside of reach. Was that, do you think for you, what your, the weight of your own expectations, or was it about, I see classmates that seem to be in a place that I want to be? You know, was it, do you feel you're pulled by your classmates, or was it your own expectation that was sort of saying I'm just out of reach?

[14:54] Dan Weschler: I think it was both. It was certainly there are people that you watch in performance and they seem to have this ability, this sort of natural ability to surprise not just their audience but themselves, you know, and I guess that's kind of that's what happens when you're present. Um I remember one of the first pieces of I think it was probably Barbara Mackenzie Wood, who was the head of acting back then. Um she just talked a lot about you know being present and finding your way to presence and presence became this kind of like word that haunted me while I was you know busy planning all of the different ways that I could be present. Um in the future, you know, I'll be so present in a little bit.

I'm telling the ones that they're like, this is just freshman year, I've got three more years. Uh-huh. Acting in college was so much more about unlearning, I think, than it was about learning. You know, it was about finding the confidence and freedom to let go rather than, you know, build up this like structure of, you know, technical ability. Um, so well said. And I do think, you know, not surprising that that's where you were living for a lot of your years. So this conversation Ethan and I have both had, Ethan's uh one of my best friends who I host another podcast with. But um, I think, you know, as more intellectual actors, you know, if you approach it that way, it feels like you are always searching for that presence.

And I think if you're, especially when you're young, you can spend time going, oh, those are the good actors, those are the real actors. I'm this sort of intellectual fraud that like I'm just fooling them with my brain or whatever that they're they seem to really be in it, you know. And then I think as you grow, you also see like, I mean, there's elements of that that are true that there are people who are so incredibly in their body, so in the moment, who really plan very little, but that also there are flaws to that, that there are things for them to chase too of going, oh, I've really I've ended up in a weird rabbit hole because I didn't plan any of this, you know. Yep, and the grass is always greener.

The grass is always greener. Um, let's get into PigPen a little bit. So again, for anyone who isn't familiar, PigPen is this kind of amazing achievement. Um, you know, I I mentioned it's sort of the quintessential example of what the intention of a playground, or now many schools have these playground-like programs, these ways of going, how do we sort of foster creativity, right? We'll open up the possibility for people to create their own work. And it's like what percentage of people actually do create their own work. But you did. You guys did make and we'll talk about some of the specific work. But can you tell me a little bit about the formation, the foundation? Like it's did it happen with an intention of we are starting the three of us or the seven of us, excuse me.

Are we starting this right now? Um and making this, you know, this is gonna be what's a band or it's gonna be a theater company. Like what was the experience of forming it um as it started? It was really this festival that I think precipitated it because you know I think it was it happened in the um the fall that year. So it was like right after we got to school. And this was your freshman year of school. Yeah, freshman year. Yeah. We we hadn't really, you know some people had made friends, but you know I I kind of hadn't yeah I certainly hadn't and I had, you know, awkward as you were yeah no I had, you know, people who I sat next to in class but we weren't you know friends yet. Um and uh one of the guys in the company Matt Nuremberger uh I think he just sort of decided to grab an application and sort of just start walking around with it and saying you know, do you want to put your name on this uh let's make something um so you know the seven of us who wrote our names down ended up you know in a room trying to figure out what we were gonna do.

And uh I think we the very first thing we did together was you know like a campfire storytelling game where you know it's that like one sentence story game where everybody adds a sentence you know that was what we knew at the time and uh so we told this story uh it was like a ghost story um kind of an appellation feeling you know haunted tragedy thing and um, and then we set that aside and and and went to work writing a play together. And, you know, four days later, we had this absolute mess of nothing that had like the ambitions of a you know, like a fantasy doorstop novel and the actual coherence of a pudding. And we looked at that and we were like, well, we certainly can't do anything with this.

And somebody said, Well, that story we told at the beginning of the week was pretty good. What do we what did we just do that? So we did. We took that, which ended up being the plot of a show called The Hunter and the Bear, which we've since rewritten and restaged a couple times. Um and we combined that with just some of the exercises that we'd been learning in our movement class. Uh so we were doing viewpoints. Um, and you know, we discovered that some of us had some musical talent. So, you know, people would be playing along on guitar, banjo, and um, and I think we like, you know, pulled a couple of little cover songs from I think we did keep on the sunny side was the first song we played in a show together.

Um, because we were all big fans of uh Oh Brother Where Art Thou. Um then so we had this weird little 20-minute folk tale movement piece that had all of the um kind of elements of what would become our theater company. So it had music and it had shadow puppetry and it had puppets. The other thing that happened just before that was this great festival in Pittsburgh called the Festival of Firsts. Um was it the first it was what it was either the festival of firsts or it was called something else, but it was the you know, International Theater Festival, um, where all of these amazing companies came from all over the world and put on their shows, and we had saw we'd seen a show called um well, it was a company called Suitcase Royale from Australia, and it was a three-person theater company that played, you know, live music, very kind of Tom Waitsy sounding songs while telling this strange little folk tale and pulling out all of these cool little puppets made out of junk, and you know, their set was like a hollowed-out uh bureau, uh and which you know, they turned into like a submersible, you know, all of these different things that you know, and the whole thing had this kind of like lamp-lit aesthetic of you know, warm light and shadows, and uh and so we just pretty much tried to make something like that, and um and that that show, which happened in one of the rehearsal studios, uh, you know, we got you know, it was freshman year, so we weren't getting a ton of positive feedback yet.

And that's kind of part of the the game plan is you know, you can't you don't want you don't want students thinking they you know they've got nothing to learn, so you can't really you can't give them too A lot of B's and C's in freshman acting. Exactly. So we did this show, and the response from you know our faculty who saw it and from you know fellow students was, you know, this was awesome, and this is what theater should be. And we were like, oh, cool, uh whoops. Um let's do this forever, I guess. And you did from that moment, were you like, we are now doing this? Like I know it then each playground, it was like the anticipated thing. It was like, oh, you know, and I only I guess I overlap for two playgrounds with you, but it was like, this is then thing.

Oh my god. Like, but it really grew into being this what's pig pen gonna do for playground. But but was it then also expanding into the professional world already in school? Um for the first couple of years, it was really, you know, what we did with our free time, um, which gives you a sense of what what nerds we were. But um, you know, we would be, we'd get out of class and we'd, you know, hang out at someone's apartment and make little puppets and write songs and stuff like that. And uh I think it was after our it might have been after our freshman year. I think uh w one summer, a few of us went to a little theater in uh Chicago where um Matt had previously performed and you know, and workshopped a little show, which is kind of like an a apocryphal pig pen show because it only had three of us and it was um you know it had some of the same elements, but it was you know not quite the same.

And and that was, you know, I think we got paid a little bit for that, but uh our junior year, we took one of the shows that we had done and we submitted it to the New York City Fringe Festival, and uh and we went and did the show there, and and that was our first, you know, kind of trial run with you know, a quote unquote real audience that wasn't just our friends and family and professors. And uh we ended up winning, you know, I don't know what the what they called it, but you know, the like best show award for the the fringe. Top honor for play, two years in a row is what I read in the bio. Yeah, sure. So we did that and we met, you know, some producers, um, and we sort of started, you know, that we kind of had a tiny little foothold into, you know, New York City, which we were just so, you know, excited and uh amazed by.

And now this is right before senior year, you're about to go back to school. Yeah. And so we went back to school and then um and then we did the fringe again the next summer. Um But how does this relate to there are seven of you, right? Seven actors, all of whom auditioned for an elite acting school, some of whom may have had the designs on interdisciplinary some stuff, but at least some of whom might have been like, I want to be on TV or whatever, right? How did that mesh now? I'm having gone through that very like very stressful, very ego-laden, you know, process of you know, it's like you're announcing yourself to the world with a sh one of these showcases. If for those of you haven't done one of them yet.

How is that happening in the context of also announcing PigPen to the world? And I mean, it now it seems looking back, we'd be like, well, of course, stick with this incredible company, but it feels like back then there some people must have said, all right, well, that was fun in college, but I want to go be a TV star. I want to go, you know, do my professional acting career, which is not gonna have to do with PigPen. Well, was there any of that sort of stress or fret uh frustration or uncertainty? There was a little bit, but I think by and large, you know, one of the things we did when we went to New York for showcase was we we set up uh a you know, a weekend run of one of our shows um at um uh Barrow Street Theater, um because we had met uh the guy who who owned and ran that uh theater um and you know I think we were all talking at that time you know along the lines of you know showcase is great let's all you know do that um but we already you know we've got like a head start uh with this thing you know that's already um happened and you know had a little bit of press and so you know I think we were all thinking of it as just like the smart play was to take this this company and and keep you know working on it and we we actually had a you know our first job offer collectively for acting or whatever else was you know a run of one of our shows in Boston um with um company one and so you know at that point it's safe to say we were just following the money not that there was much money but you know there was a job and but there's interest professional interest yeah right so we did that.

[27:28] Dan Weschler: You say that's that's smart and I think it is smart, but I just do think it's not obvious. I think I think it is a rare group of seven people we're not at least two of them are gonna say great great great I gotta work on my own personal buzz because I'm not gonna be very true. I'm not gonna build my career through PigPen. But it I think it is a testament to you guys that you at least stuck together even if there was some of that friction at times that you you know that you did stick together through it all.

[27:50] Dan Weschler: Well we had a lot of positive encouragement and especially from other creators, writers, actors who we met you know in the business, you know, they all kind of told us, you know, this is what everyone's looking for is for people who they can work with who they trust and who are all kind of you know pulling at least in the same general direction. Um but that's not to say, you know, certainly uh some of the guys uh ended up going to LA for a couple of years um or at least a year um everyone was certainly you know pursuing their own things but uh PigPen just kind of kept pulling pulling us back together you know when you talk about the seven of you and how credit is shared I mean obviously it is impossible in a group of seven it's possible in a group of two or three but it's especially impossible in a group of seven to have exactly equal contributions or exactly equal shares of the limelight like it feels like you guys are a company that does this as well as anyone I know but still there must be some frustrations of going how do you do this how how do we share finances and how do we share you know credit and how do we share you know um because not everyone is doing everything the same you know how how did that work how did you have those conversations um I think early on um I you know I was probably the biggest proponent of you know let's just as an experiment you know and this is gonna sound culty uh let's just you know subsume our identities into the company for a minute here you know let's all like share the profits equally and share the credit equally and not really like give too clear a portrait of you know who does exactly what in inside because if we can get you know the company to stand out, then you know, all ships will rise.

[29:49] Dan Weschler: Um and uh and there's a lot of that that's true, you know, there's a lot of you know uh a lot of what we did together, you know, was very sort of collagey in that you know, everyone would write a little bit of something, and then you know, we'd do all of these improvisations together, and someone would throw a song out there, and and then you know, eventually it we fell into a rhythm where it you know I would collect all of that stuff and you know, kind of tie it together into something that you know felt more or less cohesive and and you know unified.

[30:30] Dan Weschler: You know, I never felt like my job was I I guess I I I felt like anyone could do that, and um, and sometimes did, you know.

[30:40] Dan Weschler: I I there were a couple of shows that I wasn't around for where you know somebody else would step up and take that role.

[30:45] Dan Weschler: It got more challenging as we went on together, uh, especially when it came to you know how we support ourselves uh financially.

[30:55] Charlie Murphy: Right, right.

[30:55] Dan Weschler: Once there's real money involved, I mean this a Broadway contract, if that's coming, uh these movie uh contracts, these I mean there's money there now, and how do you and and money and credit and claim and things that people you know things that tickle our egos and our bank accounts.

[31:09] Dan Weschler: As far as the like credit and acclaim goes, it it is it really does feel like nobody is like especially or at least obviously ego-driven in that regard.

[31:22] Dan Weschler: Like everyone seems to feel pretty good about letting the company take the accolades and letting you know the work speak for itself.

[31:30] Dan Weschler: Um, but the money is harder, you know.

[31:33] Dan Weschler: The money is um for a while we were just purely, you know, dividing everything that came in seven ways, because to keep track of exactly what work everyone had done at any given moment, you know, to keep that that balance sheet was just so complicated and difficult that we kind of just said at the end of the day, everyone's done, you know, the same amount of work.

[31:57] Dan Weschler: Um, and more and more, you know, we we tried to find other things to tie it to.

[32:02] Dan Weschler: So, you know, time and presence in a room was a big factor, you know.

[32:07] Dan Weschler: If you're in the room making something, then you're getting paid for that time.

[32:12] Dan Weschler: But even that has become challenging.

[32:14] Charlie Murphy: That's right.

[32:14] Dan Weschler: I think we're always in conversation about that stuff, and you know, we're never really we've never settled into a single model, I guess.

[32:20] Dan Weschler: Of these are incredibly difficult conversations to have in your 30s.

[32:24] Dan Weschler: I mean, in your young 20s, to be sort of adulting at that level is it's really impressive.

[32:29] Dan Weschler: And I think it's uh again, the reason I keep bringing it up is not because I'm like, where are your big egos? You should all have egos.

[32:33] Dan Weschler: If anything, you know, the last episode we just did with John Alan Krill, we talked a lot about generosity, especially on stage, what it is to be generous in terms of serving the story.

[32:42] Dan Weschler: And there's something that is again, it's laudable about the generosity to uh of what you just said of what can we lift up PigPen as opposed to lifting up ourselves?

[32:51] Dan Weschler: Because as soon as one person does the other thing, everyone's gonna be like, Well, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. But what about my credit? I did do this and I did that.

[32:59] Dan Weschler: And then, you know, the band breaks up and all those things that happen.

[33:02] Dan Weschler: But um, that there's something this clearly you guys were were experts at generosity, even while you're still figuring out what's actually fair and all those things, which sounds like it's still happening.

[33:10] Charlie Murphy: But yeah, um, it's just something worth lauding, I think.

[33:13] Charlie Murphy: Well, um, let's talk a little bit about, you know, we have many multi-hyphenate artists on the pod, uh, just like yourself.

[33:21] Charlie Murphy: Um, but it's you know, it's now I think normal enough to hear an actor, playwright, director as sort of a multi-hyphenate person, but really interesting from the perspective of a group, right?

[33:31] Charlie Murphy: Obviously, you have theater company in your name. So people are gonna think of you the theater company, but I think probably more people now know you as a band than as a theater.

[33:41] Charlie Murphy: I mean, my little brother who bought my dad a t-shirt of PigPen Theater Company because he's a fan, not for me, right?

[33:47] Charlie Murphy: I mean, I he may have from at CMU, but he listens to you guys as an indie band, you know.

[33:52] Charlie Murphy: He thinks of you like that's what you are.

[33:54] Charlie Murphy: Like it would be like, wait, they oh, they do shows, right, right, right, right.

[33:57] Charlie Murphy: But like he listens to you to his music.

[33:58] Charlie Murphy: So I guess how do you how do you sort of label the hyphens of PigPen and especially when you're pitching yourself to write a Broadway musical or you know, all those different things?

[34:08] Dan Weschler: Yeah, I mean, the band thing happened fairly early on in our professional lives together, and it quickly became, you know, a really fast way to just expand, you know, the fan base because theater is so slow and takes so long and is so tied to, you know, a single location.

[34:30] Dan Weschler: At that time, we were lucky enough to sign with an agency who was willing to represent us both for our theater stuff, but also for our music.

[34:43] Dan Weschler: And so we had, you know, a booking uh agent who, you know, was able to put together these tours for us where we would go out and uh, you know, play rock venues um around the country.

[34:56] Dan Weschler: And, you know, that was first of all, just you know, immensely cool feeling to do.

[35:02] Dan Weschler: Gave everyone again that full performance experience that you really can't match um with anything else.

[35:10] Dan Weschler: And it just gave us fans, you know, all over the country, you know, in in little pockets.

[35:16] Dan Weschler: Um and we've seen, you know, people who know our music, you know, come out from uh cities where they've seen us play uh to see our theater, you know, in one of the several you know, larger cities, theater markets that we've done our shows.

[35:35] Dan Weschler: Um the the line that we would give at our concerts for a long time was that we were a band and a theater company, which seemed appropriate.

[35:44] Dan Weschler: There was some surprising amount of confusion from at least the venues where we would go where you know we would show up and and you know, these places that were really like rock clubs, they didn't you know, they didn't put on theater, you know, would be like, all right, so what do we have to like load a set in, or what are what is happening now?

[36:07] Dan Weschler: And like, no, no, we'll be playing songs, let's be clear.

[36:10] Dan Weschler: There was, you know, I guess a little bit of identity uh confusion then, but mostly we just found, you know, uh at the beginning we were getting people who knew our theater to come to our concerts, and then eventually that kind of reversed, and we had people who knew our music coming to see our theater.

[36:33] Dan Weschler: And you know, it's it's obvious that why it's just you know so much easier to share music and uh and we you know, by doing these little miniature tours, which we were lucky enough to go out on.

[36:47] Dan Weschler: We we also had the opportunity to go on, you know, some you know, kind of music recording podcasts and radio shows and all of these things that you know we just wouldn't have had access to through just our theater alone.

[37:05] Dan Weschler: I think there's just like a wider pool of publicity around music in that way.

[37:12] Dan Weschler: And not right around YouTube and those kind of things, but not so far away, right?

[37:16] Dan Weschler: It it would only really started in college for us, so or for me.

[37:19] Dan Weschler: So you know, you'd be pretty new and you're putting Bremen out on YouTube or whatever.

[37:23] Dan Weschler: It's that's just when music is really being found that way and people are sharing stuff and all that stuff.

[37:29] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, very true.

[37:30] Charlie Murphy: Can we talk about the musicality of it all a bit?

[37:32] Charlie Murphy: So, you know, you said a couple of us played instruments, you were in a band in high school, right?

[37:35] Charlie Murphy: Um, as you sort of were discovering this in playground all those years ago.

[37:39] Charlie Murphy: But clearly given the level of musicality now now present within the group, unless it's all just masked and master masqueraded among different artists.

[37:48] Charlie Murphy: I was there a lot of like you have to go learn this instrument for the sake of our sound.

[37:52] Charlie Murphy: We need a banjo, we need a backup banjo.

[37:55] Charlie Murphy: We need like how did that work in terms of you guys creating that among the seven of you?

[37:59] Dan Weschler: Banjo was never a problem. We have a surfeit of banjo players for some reason.

[38:04] Dan Weschler: But we did have, you know, so everyone had some kind of background, everyone was in a band in high school, you know, at some point.

[38:13] Dan Weschler: But some people were, you know, more serious instrumentalists than others.

[38:17] Dan Weschler: And I think the the most the best example of someone who just like well, really Matt, I I'm gonna call Matt and Curtis out as the two people who really just went away and like learned their instrument from scratch.

[38:34] Dan Weschler: You know, Matt, I remember I was living with him in Shady Side, and I had like my dad's just beat-up, terrible, painful to play acoustic guitar sitting in my room gathering dust, and he just sort of took it one day and went away and came out a few months later a guitar player.

[38:58] Dan Weschler: And now, you know, I think he's probably just the most technical, you know, he's guitar one, and he's he's a really really good guitar player.

[39:09] Dan Weschler: And Curtis, uh, similarly, you know, I think I don't think anyone had to prompt him.

[39:14] Dan Weschler: I think he just said, we don't have a bass, we need a bass.

[39:17] Dan Weschler: And so he started playing bass.

[39:19] Dan Weschler: It's it's I mean, uh this now will ever episode we'll release not directly after Sean's episode, but so much of what we're talking about with generosity in the stage, we you know, I sort of did a little takeaway on like what does this moment need right now?

[39:31] Dan Weschler: And something that you you know talk about often in a theater rehearsal of just like a lot of people are voicing a lot of strong opinions.

[39:36] Dan Weschler: Do I need to add one into the mix right now? Is that what this moment needs?

[39:38] Dan Weschler: You know, but like talk about an extreme example of like we need a bass. Can I be the person who fills that need? It's just like such a valuable skill set as an actor.

[39:47] Charlie Murphy: If you can go, I think I can learn, I can spend the time to do that. It's so cool.

[39:50] Dan Weschler: Yeah, yeah.

[39:51] Dan Weschler: No, it was definitely helpful.

[39:53] Charlie Murphy: What about the puppetry of it all, right?

[39:54] Charlie Murphy: So puppetry and and I'm sure there's also some other things that I'm I'm wouldn't necessarily have the language to speak to and what makes the unique the unique experience of a pig pen show with between the lighting and the puppetry and the movement and the music is really a pretty amazing experience.

[40:10] Charlie Murphy: But did that all just come from that playground experience?

[40:13] Charlie Murphy: Did many of you or from having watched that that international show? Where where does all that additional stuff that often is part of a pig pen show exist?

[40:22] Dan Weschler: Yeah, I think again, there were a few members of the company who had a just natural aptitude for puppetry and for really for movement and hyper specific controlled movement.

[40:35] Dan Weschler: And that means visual art too, right? Because you're creating the puppets.

[40:38] Dan Weschler: At the beginning, yeah.

[40:39] Dan Weschler: And I mean that still continues to be true in in pockets, but you know, I would be remiss in not calling out Lydia Fine, who's really acted as kind of like a sonographer for us, and that she had this kind of she kind of built our aesthetic.

[40:55] Dan Weschler: Uh, you know, the first show we did was just us, and I think everything after that, we brought her and a lighting designer, Bart Courtright, who really helped establish, you know, the world of our lighting, uh, and made all of these, you know, handcrafted weird lighting elements for us.

[41:16] Dan Weschler: So the two of them have have definitely you know done a lot to up our game in that department.

[41:22] Dan Weschler: But Ryan Melia is is a really good you know, visual artist.

[41:28] Dan Weschler: He he draws and he paints, and he's you know, good at kind of character design.

[41:32] Dan Weschler: So he was making a lot of the little shadow puppets in the beginning.

[41:38] Dan Weschler: And yeah, everyone had you know, you know, it was all kind of amateur-ish in that you know we had to Google how to make paper mache or something, you know, when we but you know, definitely some some of us have taken more of an interest and more spent more time with it than others, you know.

[42:00] Charlie Murphy: Well, and it's a very, it's a kind of deceiving thing about your aesthetic.

[42:03] Charlie Murphy: I remember this from school of like it feels handmade, it feels it's a cool the aesthetic still though remains very quotidian everyday walking around the streets of Brooklyn, and then all of a sudden it's like, oh my God, but the sound is it really blows you away.

[42:18] Dan Weschler: Well, that's really, you know, I think the real skill that we collectively have as a group is leaning into our strengths and adapting to our strengths, you know.

[42:29] Dan Weschler: Even when it comes to things like, you know, singing together, you know, not you know, we had varying levels of vocal talent, you know.

[42:37] Dan Weschler: Ryan Melia, for anyone who's heard him sing, you know, has the voice of an angel and always.

[42:43] Dan Weschler: I mean, it really sounds like he could be a rock star.

[42:45] Dan Weschler: Like he like if he did a different career, he could just be a choke.

[42:47] Dan Weschler: I mean, he is in some ways a pop star, but it's just like when you're in the middle of an acting degree, you're like, why are you here?

[42:52] Dan Weschler: Why aren't you in LA singing?

[42:54] Dan Weschler: Like well, the first time he pulled out a guitar and sang for us, that's kind of the reaction we all had.

[42:58] Dan Weschler: But but you know, the rest of us have, you know, ears and are relatively, you know, we we have decent ability to hear when we're on or off pitch, but you know, it was still a lot of like coming up with the harmonies together was you know, discovering, you know, where everyone's voice sits and and what's comfortable for people to sing and stuff that you know in the happens when you're working on a musical, but is not quite as flexible and not quite as bespoke to you know, a group of people singing together.

[43:34] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[43:34] Charlie Murphy: So, you know, that really has gone a long way.

[43:37] Charlie Murphy: It's just kind of you know so well said, leaning into your own strengths.

[43:40] Charlie Murphy: Okay, let's take a quick break.

[43:42] Charlie Murphy: And on the back end, we're gonna dive a little bit deeper into the generative creative process with you.

[43:47] Charlie Murphy: And we're also gonna play a very silly game.

[43:52] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we're back with Dan Weschler.

[43:55] Charlie Murphy: And I do want to dive a bit deeper into kind of this idea of creating your own work, especially in this group setting.

[44:01] Charlie Murphy: We have an upcoming podcast with uh a more traditional kind of playwright, you know, white blank page, begin to a play with dramatic structure.

[44:08] Charlie Murphy: But so I'm gonna be interested in hearing about that process as it relates to you too.

[44:11] Charlie Murphy: But especially in this, as you mentioned, group generative people are throwing out ideas and you're putting together a create your own work thing.

[44:19] Charlie Murphy: I'd love to get into this.

[44:20] Charlie Murphy: But before we we dive into the the exact process for you, I'd love to kind of hear just in general, for our listeners, many of whom are training to be actors and haven't gone to writing school, you know, or they're training for in theater if they've gone to a more general degree.

[44:35] Charlie Murphy: What sort of gave you and you, the collective you the audacity and the confidence to say, I am a creator, I am a writer, right?

[44:43] Charlie Murphy: I mean, obviously you are an awesome writer, all of you, but I think you especially. But did you ever struggle with some of that imposter syndrome of like I trained to be an actor? Like, what gives me the right to be this person who's writing these plays?

[44:56] Dan Weschler: Oh, you certainly. I mean, I still do, you know, I'm friends with lots of, you know, writers who are like writers. And you know, so the sense that, you know, I really in a lot of ways I consider myself more of a, I don't know, I've said like collage artist before. You know, the thing that I really like doing is taking like different ideas that kind of come from outside of me and trying to thread them together in a way that makes them feel like, you know, they emerged organically from each other. And so there's a bit of improvisation to it. But you know, I think we all have struggled with, you know, imposter syndrome born of, you know, the like jack of all trades master of none kind of, you know, which we've taken as a virtue in a lot of respects.

You know, I think, you know, the sum of the parts being greater than the parts themselves has always been, you know, just what theater is to us. You know, but then when you're contracted to do, hey, we're gonna write the music of a Broadway musical now, it's not you're not a jack of all trades now, you're a composer basically, right? You're Lin-Manuel at this point, like who himself I guess is a jack of all trades, but you're being contracted to do this specific thing.

[46:30] Dan Weschler: Yeah, yeah, I think you do have to kind of convince yourself that, you know, that there's some degree of, you know, broad principle that applies to everything you do that you bring to everything you do that doesn't rely purely on, you know, like technical depth I guess. You know, because, you know, every room I've been in working on this musical there have been at least four other people who have a depth of knowledge about music that just, you know, eclipses my own. And so, you know, I think I'm just starting to get to the point where I feel comfortable talking about music with these kinds of people and, you know, using my own language and not trying to, you know, I don't know.

[47:18] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, just kind of dropping that sense.

[47:20] Dan Weschler: Right. Not self-flagellating, like, well, I don't really know anything. Like, I've done that before in my life where I'm like, well, I'm not really a musical theater person. I'm like, but I have run a musical theater company for 20 years. So I guess like kind of, but like it's easy to be like, I'm an actor, like let's ask that to the music people or whatever, you know.

[47:33] Charlie Murphy: Exactly, yeah. But you know, that's not helpful to the people who are trying to, you know, facilitate your work. So you kind of just have to put the hat on and wear it.

[47:39] Dan Weschler: Put the hat on and wear it. All right, so let's talk about the process a little bit then. So for you, you know, for PigPen and for you as a contributor, how do you begin? Um, you know, I know you may all have different processes, you know, among the seven of you, but you know, if you were gonna start a new show, which I know you've now so many different projects in the hopper that may seem intimidating, but if you're gonna write the Old Man and the Moon part two or whatever, you're gonna write a new PigPen show. How does that happen? How does it get off the ground?

[48:11] Dan Weschler: Yeah. Well, it starts with usually starts with somebody having, you know, a strong kind of seed idea. You know, for The Old Man and the Old Moon, it was I think a story that Ryan told some summer camp theater students in high school or thereabouts about a giant whose job it was to fill the moon, you know, was this little fairy tale that he made up, and we all thought it was evocative, so we decided to bat it around for a while. And then it really is all of these different kind of disconnected bits of stuff that come together. So, you know, there's a lot of songwriters in the group. I mean, everyone writes songs, but there's some people who write songs consistently. And so, you know, we've got like a Google Drive just filled with all of this music that, you know, is kind of waiting to be plucked out any.

[49:15] Charlie Murphy: And is it you then who's doing more? Like, how does the listening, so if everyone's throwing it in, how do we then listen back and go, oh, that's cool, that might go before this. And that inspires me to do this. Like, how do you, just with seven too? I imagine with two, it's not that hard to go back and forth, but with seven and maybe four people are writing things. How's then doing the listening? Who's the audience if people are, you know, everyone's contributing?

[49:37] Dan Weschler: Yeah. You know, I think we're largely relying on people to be proactive, you know. There are, you know, in some ways, like Matt Nuremberger, who does a lot of things for the company, but one of the big things he does is he almost acts like a music supervisor in that like, as we're writing, you know, if you were to treat this like a TV show or a, you know, the way that music works in our at least our like traditional shows, the way that we make them is less in the style of musical theater, and more in the style of like a needle drop, you know, where something will be happening on stage, and then we have a song that accompanies a sequence that, you know, is maybe like obliquely related to what's happening in the story, but not, you know, not directly.

[50:31] Charlie Murphy: And do you distinguish, call them plays with music by the way? It's something I was like, do you call it a musical when you're what you're doing, or do you say this is a play that has music? Why does that matter to you as a distinction?

[50:42] Dan Weschler: It doesn't matter hugely to me. I think maybe it did at some point. I, we've published The Old Man and the Old Moon, and we're working on publishing a couple of other shows right now, and I can't remember what we landed on. I think we either said, I think The Old Man is subtitled A Folk Tale with Music. As opposed to a musical folk tale. Uh-huh.

[51:05] Charlie Murphy: Which seems appropriate because, you know, there's not quite enough, you know, songs.

[51:12] Dan Weschler: Right. And most of the music, to your point, is not carrying the story as much as it is the story. And then there's movement and music that is almost, yeah, to the side of the story. There's like one song. Some of it does, yeah. There's one song that is really a point of view song from the protagonist's perspective, and the rest of the show is much more soundtracky. But Matt listens to just tons and tons of recordings of stuff that we've done and is kind of like always like reorganizing them into different folders. And so he, I think has probably the most encyclopedic knowledge of, you know, all of this.

[51:49] Charlie Murphy: What's the thing you wrote? A couple, but maybe can that get here? And we, because it feels like there's so much generation with your seven of you, but then how does that get put into, yeah, in some ways that is the hardest part is, you know, we make all this stuff and then it kind of sits around because for whatever reason we haven't figured out an efficient fast way to just like get new songs out into the world.

[52:14] Dan Weschler: Well, it does feel like you're what you're using in efficiency, you're gaining in creativity because it does feel like it's easy to be like, okay, we're gonna write a song of this and do this, you know, but I'm like, but are you gonna get the same level of quality? But, uh, and are you, so you may have answered Mike's question already. Then is it that you're just generating art in general, not I'm writing for this to be an album or I want this to be a concert or want this to be a PigPen show? Is that generally true?

[52:37] Dan Weschler: I mean, I imagine for Water for Elephants, you we're not gonna randomly write Water for Elephants. So that had to be a, you know, I'm contracted, I'm working on this specific piece.

[52:45] Dan Weschler: Yeah, that was a little bit more, you know, we sat down with the book writer Rick Ellis and, you know, for, you know, several years we were in workshops with him, you know, doing song spotting, coming up with things, adapting to things as the book changed. And so that's been a very different process than our usual. But it goes both ways. You know, it is that, you know, kind of scrapbooky collage thing where we're just taking stuff and seeing if it works together. And it's also, you know, we really need a song right here that, you know, evokes this feeling or, you know, tells this part of the story. So, you know, we have to write it. But yeah, so it can, it could be either.

[53:29] Charlie Murphy: And then what about your personal creative process? So, uh, a little birdie, which is your wife MTCA coach Catherine Wheeland has told me that you are personally kind of writing a children's book. You know, it's gonna be a PigPen children's book, but that's something that you're taking on. How does that work now in terms of your creative process if you've made all this different kind of theater art writing kind of art? How do you then turn that into I'm gonna literally, it feels like anyone who's had a baby has thought to themselves I could write a kid's book. If you ever read these things, you're like there's 35 words I could write this. But like how do you then think to yourself I'm gonna put this together into what might be a PigPen children's book?

[54:01] Dan Weschler: Well when we say children's book I think what we've really been circling is what they call in the publishing business a middle grade novel, which is like a graphic novel. It's no, it's just a book that's for like middle schoolers, basically. So, you know, you any of the like, you know, Rick Riordan books or, um, there's just, it's a huge Encyclopedia Brown for my Encyclopedia Brown or, you know, A Wrinkle in Time, all of these books that are like for, oh I see kids who are on, yeah, this is not a board book that my daughter's gonna be reading in the next couple years.

[54:48] Dan Weschler: No, although that's on the list of the stuff. Advanced maybe. Yeah, I think Alex might be the one to, he as a new father, he has the most insight into that, so he'll probably come up with something eventually. I will say the secret trick, this is for Alex. I'm just gonna give him a hint. My daughter loves books that are songs. So, like we have Forever Young, we have What a Wonderful World. She's obsessed right now with Sweet Child of Mine, which is not in that's not Elizabeth May or me. That's neither of our skill set is being like singing sweet child, but she loves it. She just wants us to sing, and she can't believe the book makes us sing. It's so exciting, Joe. These are just books that are like illustrated, like song, like it you're like the Mickey Mouse ball, like reading singing along as you flip the pages from image to image. Full money grab. It's just like someone already wrote a song, and they're like, let's just illustrate it and make some more money off of it.

[55:41] Dan Weschler: Absolutely. So you guys can do that too. Just take Bremen or whatever. Take, pick a song that you love and just put it on the thing.

[55:48] Charlie Murphy: Noted. Speaking of songs, shall we get to our game? And we have a couple more questions after, but I gotta get to this game.

[55:56] Dan Weschler: Sure.

[55:56] Charlie Murphy: Because I've spent hours preparing this game technically. And we'll see how the technical parts of it go. We're having a little bit of internet lag, so we're hoping that I'm gonna succeed after all this. But this is a hurdle-based game. This is a name that tune style game.

[56:09] Dan Weschler: Okay.

[56:13] Charlie Murphy: Which have you ever played Hurdle? Do you know what I mean?

[56:15] Dan Weschler: This is like a H R D L.

[56:18] Charlie Murphy: Yes.

[56:18] Dan Weschler: Yes.

[56:19] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. My younger brother calls it a Hirdle, which I hate. But it's, yeah, if you hear it, it's like you hear a little bit and then you can hear a little bit more. We're not getting that technical. You're just gonna get a very short snippet. And you're gonna try to identify which PigPen song this is, because mostly gonna be PigPen songs.

[56:35] Dan Weschler: Okay.

[56:35] Charlie Murphy: But then a couple of them will not be PigPen songs too. So you have to either identify which song or you just, you don't have to tell me if it's not PigPen. But I'm gonna give you probably the starting three seconds of these songs. How do you think, before we play, how do you think you're gonna do at this game?

[56:49] Dan Weschler: I think I will, I think a 65% accuracy would be great.

[56:58] Charlie Murphy: Was that you said 55%?

[57:01] Dan Weschler: 65.

[57:01] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Just slightly over the 65.

[57:04] Dan Weschler: Okay, great. That's, yeah. That's pretty good.

[57:07] Charlie Murphy: Monkey would be 50, so you think you'll do 65.

[57:09] Dan Weschler: Exactly. I don't want to go way out on a limb here. I feel like I do know our music, but I've never just listened to the first few seconds.

[57:17] Charlie Murphy: So well, for any PigPen fans playing along, do your best. We're gonna try to see if we can identify. The real challenge is gonna be knowing what they're called, because you know, we've all of these songs have had like multiple titles over time. So hopefully, we will only accept the title on the albums that I purchased. These are some of the few albums in my life I've actually purchased to support you. So we're gonna have, um, what the actual album title is.

[57:43] Dan Weschler: All right, here we go. We're gonna start it off. It's an easy one. We're just getting a sense of how the game goes here, yeah?

[57:48] Dan Weschler: Yeah.

[57:49] Charlie Murphy: Okay.

[57:50] Dan Weschler: That's Bremen.

[57:52] Charlie Murphy: All right. Is that, that's Bremen? Is that too much time? Is that too easy?

[57:55] Dan Weschler: Well, that one had, you know, I, uh you could play the first two notes, and I would know that one. That was one of the first songs I wrote for the company.

[58:02] Charlie Murphy: Hey.

[58:03] Dan Weschler: And I wrote it on the piano. So it has a very distinctive non-guitar. You can tell it's not written for a guitar.

[58:10] Charlie Murphy: All right, let's try.

[58:15] Dan Weschler: Oh.

[58:16] Charlie Murphy: Oh.

[58:17] Dan Weschler: Is this one of the 35%?

[58:19] Charlie Murphy: Is this Lonely as Me?

[58:21] Dan Weschler: That is not correct.

[58:22] Charlie Murphy: It is not Lonely as Me.

[58:23] Dan Weschler: Oh no. I'm gonna give you a little more time on it.

[58:26] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yep, got it.

[58:28] Dan Weschler: You Woke, I Waited.

[58:30] Charlie Murphy: Okay. I waited. You Woke, I Waited. Okay, I gave you one. We're not gonna be so nice every time. I'm not gonna always give you a second chance at it, you know.

[58:37] Dan Weschler: I appreciate it.

[58:38] Charlie Murphy: Still, I don't know which one that counts as, but it's not it.

[58:40] Dan Weschler: Yeah, okay, great. Here we go.

[58:45] Dan Weschler: That's not us.

[58:46] Charlie Murphy: That is not you. Very good. Very good. I thought I'd try one, try an early one in there. Some band called Virginia Coalition.

[58:52] Dan Weschler: Oh, cool. We would never allow Arya to start a song with drums. It's just us.

[58:55] Charlie Murphy: That's it. That's it. It's just not, that's not how it works.

[58:58] Dan Weschler: Okay, great. Here we try another one.

[59:04] Dan Weschler: Uh that's Just Like the Sea.

[59:06] Charlie Murphy: Well done. Very well done.

[59:07] Dan Weschler: Okay, good.

[59:08] Charlie Murphy: Just Like the Sea.

[59:08] Dan Weschler: Very distinctive beginning. Is that also you because it's piano?

[59:13] Dan Weschler: Yes, although I believe Matt actually wrote that original riff. The Degan Dugata thing is him, and then I kept going from there.

[59:23] Charlie Murphy: I love it. All right, we try another one.

[59:30] Dan Weschler: Uh oh.

[59:32] Charlie Murphy: Hmm.

[59:33] Dan Weschler: Oh boy.

[59:35] Dan Weschler: That could so easily be a Ryan Melia song, but I don't think it is.

[59:41] Charlie Murphy: I don't think it's one of ours. Is it?

[59:43] Dan Weschler: Uh correct. That's one of my better fooling ones.

[59:45] Charlie Murphy: That's Passenger.

[59:46] Dan Weschler: That's it.

[59:47] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yeah. Well, that really sounded. I was like, this. I was trying to find one that could sound theoretically like you in my side.

[59:51] Dan Weschler: Yeah, no, that was good. Well said.

[59:53] Charlie Murphy: Okay, great. You're you're so far doing perfectly with the one one second strike hit here.

[59:58] Dan Weschler: Sure.

[1:00:01] Charlie Murphy: That's Mayfly.

[1:00:03] Dan Weschler: Mayfly.

[1:00:04] Charlie Murphy: A bonus track.

[1:00:05] Dan Weschler: Yes. Excellently done.

[1:00:06] Charlie Murphy: Which Ben wrote Ren Ferguson.

[1:00:08] Dan Weschler: Ben, congratulations, Ben. It's a fantastic song.

[1:00:11] Charlie Murphy: Um, here we go. Wow. That was so quiet.

[1:00:20] Dan Weschler: Again, I don't know if that was us.

[1:00:24] Charlie Murphy: Mumford and Sons.

[1:00:25] Dan Weschler: Mumford and Sons, which must be the most compared.

[1:00:28] Charlie Murphy: Now you're playing hardball.

[1:00:29] Dan Weschler: Yeah. Yeah, Mumford and Sons compared to you.

[1:00:31] Charlie Murphy: A very similar sound around that time.

[1:00:33] Dan Weschler: Oh, it was really a blessing when they like hit their like 80s wave. Because, you know, then we could carve out our own identity.

[1:00:42] Charlie Murphy: Yes.

[1:00:43] Dan Weschler: Correct. You're like, all right, fine. They got their own thing.

[1:00:48] Charlie Murphy: Is that we stand alone?

[1:00:50] Dan Weschler: We stand alone. You're doing perfectly with your song so far.

[1:00:53] Charlie Murphy: You actually have gotten perfectly for all the songs, but you're doing very, very well. You seem uncertain sometimes when it's not you, but so far you've been doing great.

[1:00:59] Dan Weschler: All right, a couple more.

[1:01:01] Charlie Murphy: Okay.

[1:01:02] Dan Weschler: Uh-oh. I take back what I said about not letting Arya start a song because that is all's well with Jose with which.

[1:01:08] Charlie Murphy: Come on, that's what I was trying to get you with the this is him. I thought maybe there's a chance on the ver the one.

[1:01:14] Dan Weschler: Doing great.

[1:01:18] Charlie Murphy: I think it's not us.

[1:01:19] Dan Weschler: I'm I mean, a lot of this is just if I can't immediately recognize the song, then I'm guessing it's not us.

[1:01:24] Charlie Murphy: So far, amazingly, you're crushing it.

[1:01:26] Dan Weschler: Yeah, that's the Lumineers.

[1:01:27] Charlie Murphy: The Lumineers, also a similar sounding that time.

[1:01:31] Dan Weschler: And our very last one, here we go.

[1:01:36] Charlie Murphy: Oh yeah, this is us. But what is the song called? I need to get you on one. You need to show that you're human and get one wrong.

[1:01:44] Dan Weschler: Well, I guessed this earlier, but I'm gonna guess it again. Is it as lonely as me?

[1:01:48] Charlie Murphy: It is as lonely as me. There it is. A perfect, a perfect round. Maybe minus the one for not uh getting it, but you've done wonderfully.

[1:01:54] Dan Weschler: If any of you enjoy those little snippets that you heard, please where where do you make the most money if people download? Apple Music, Spotify, what do you want?

[1:02:02] Charlie Murphy: I guess probably Apple music, but you know, honestly, we're happy for people to listen.

[1:02:07] Dan Weschler: We're not really yes, it's lovely to pay people for their music.

[1:02:12] Charlie Murphy: Too nice.

[1:02:13] Dan Weschler: Too nice, dad. I'm trying to get you the one-seventh of a penny you're gonna get from a download here.

[1:02:17] Charlie Murphy: I'm trying to cue up. You know, they need to write us for the $200 signed vinyl that we provide upon request.

[1:02:25] Dan Weschler: That's right. That's what they should do.

[1:02:27] Charlie Murphy: It's for the signed vinyl. It's the only way to listen.

[1:02:28] Dan Weschler: Yeah, I cut you off on a couple times during the game too. Was there some things you wanted to say in terms of what was the experience of listening back to songs that you've written?

[1:02:35] Dan Weschler: I made poor Cameron Adams, who's been in 13 Broadway shows. I made her do like lines from her lines she's understudied. She was like, This is killing me. I know somewhere in my brain. It is right.

[1:02:45] Charlie Murphy: Um, what was the experience of listening back to these ones that you know so well?

[1:02:48] Dan Weschler: Yeah, I haven't heard them in a while. You know, the past few years has been we haven't done much live music together, and a lot of what we have done is is new music, so you know it's uh yeah, it's fun to revisit.

[1:03:02] Charlie Murphy: Memory lane.

[1:03:03] Dan Weschler: Memory lane. And I didn't do some of your more recent stuff, partially also because uh these are the only two albums I've purchased, and so that's how I could play them for you.

[1:03:10] Charlie Murphy: What a world.

[1:03:10] Dan Weschler: Yeah. Let's talk a little bit about the industry itself. So you certainly have now, uh like so many people have navigated this pandemic and have been in some rooms with people. In in this case, kind of interestingly things seems like the same room in 2018, 2019, 2020, and then again in 2022.

[1:03:27] Charlie Murphy: Do you feel like do you notice a difference in rooms in general in the in the sort of industry post COVID and pre-COVID?

[1:03:35] Dan Weschler: Yeah. I mean, I think there's a lot less certainty about what's next. You know, I think that the first ten years we were out of school, we were sort of part of an apparatus that was humming along, you know, uh not necessarily functionally, but you know, predictably.

[1:03:58] Charlie Murphy: And um so much has happened in the last five years that has just changed the way that people think about well, everything. I mean, even before, you know, we got to the, you know the the last couple of months of, you know, AI generative stuff, it's been, you know, crazy and chaotic and you know, Broadway has you know, we went from w soon after leaving school, you know, we went from like the biggest musical hit on Broadway, you know, possibly ever with Hamilton to um, you know, this crazy cycle of you know, hits and misses and and you know, shutdowns and pop-ups.

[1:04:48] Dan Weschler: And so I think no one really knows what's coming next. And you know, there's still a real uh people are throwing themselves at at their work, you know. I think people are maybe a little bit more used to I don't want to say disappointment, but a little bit more used to things kind of falling apart and having to pick them back up again than they were previously.

[1:05:18] Charlie Murphy: So yeah, the rooms have changed, but uh the mood for us right now uh in our rehearsal room is really, you know, positive, and you know, everyone's just very excited to be working on a new musical, which most of the people in our room haven't done for a while.

[1:05:37] Dan Weschler: Yeah, I've heard that a lot actually, that the you know, the overwhelming sense of it's sort of gratitude to be back when you feel what is lost, um, even with some of the changes.

[1:05:45] Charlie Murphy: 100%, yeah. I'd love to talk a little bit about I know you had a great relationship with your parents who I got to meet at your wedding, which is wonderful last year.

[1:05:52] Dan Weschler: Yes.

[1:05:53] Charlie Murphy: But uh what what advice would you have for sort of parents, you know, is what do you feel like they did right in supporting you? And then any advice to other parent listeners out there in terms of what you would suggest people do to support their kids in the arts.

[1:06:06] Dan Weschler: Yes. Well, certainly, you know, if they're listening to this podcast, they're already doing a great job. Uh because thank you, plug, thank you. Download another music, exactly.

[1:06:17] Charlie Murphy: The level of interest in in your kids, you know, creative career that it takes to throw on a podcast about college auditioning is you know, I would say beyond the pale of commitment. So that's great. Congratulations. Well done.

[1:06:31] Dan Weschler: It's just it's just barely adequate, guys.

[1:06:33] Charlie Murphy: That's not true. Don't listen to Dan.

[1:06:35] Dan Weschler: That's the very bare minimum is listening to every episode to the end.

[1:06:38] Charlie Murphy: No, there's more. There's more. Stay tuned, and Charlie will tell you what else.

[1:06:41] Dan Weschler: Yeah. But yeah, I think, you know, I think fostering someone's interests and that it's that delicate balance of, you know, encouraging someone without without making it their entire identity, I guess, you know, because we all know the parents who see talent in their kids and then sort of crush them with the pressure of, you know, fulfilling that talent.

[1:07:08] Charlie Murphy: And I was lucky enough to have parents who, you know, absolutely were supportive and you know, drove me to, you know, all around the country for college auditions and and all of that stuff, but you know, they weren't like they gave me space to, you know, make my own mistakes and learn my own lessons.

[1:07:25] Dan Weschler: And uh, and yeah, I think maybe the only other thing I would say is that, you know, there's not, especially now, there's just not gonna be a single path, uh, a single kind of stable path or you know, game plan for an artist to take to, you know, reach, you know, the promised land of success and stability and all of the things that of course you want for your kid, you know, there's gonna be some crazy zigs and zags, and the industry is gonna change so much that you know.

[1:08:05] Charlie Murphy: I think for a lot of people who saw their kids, you know, sitting in front of a computer making these weird like YouTube shows in 2010.

[1:08:14] Dan Weschler: Mm-hmm.

[1:08:16] Charlie Murphy: N never would it have in their wildest dreams have turned into, you know, a profitable, profitable business or like a way to like live in this world.

[1:08:26] Dan Weschler: And I think everyone was pretty surprised by that. And you know, I would just keep your capacity for surprise uh open because it's gonna be it's gonna get very surprising.

[1:08:38] Charlie Murphy: So true. And that's pretty great advice to the young artists out there too in terms of the you know staying open to their own capacity for surprise.

[1:08:44] Dan Weschler: Um so we're gonna plug water for elephants. How would someone follow this if they wanted to to check out more on I w oh I wanna hear the music or I wanna go see you guys in uh you're out of you're starting out of town run right now?

[1:08:58] Charlie Murphy: So Water for Elephants is about to have its first production uh at the Alliance Theater uh in Atlanta. Um so you can go on, you know, their website, uh Alliance. I think it's Alliance Theater.com.

[1:09:11] Dan Weschler: They're gonna Google Alliance Theater, let's be honest. Nobody nobody does a typey typey.

[1:09:16] Charlie Murphy: That's fair.

[1:09:17] Dan Weschler: And that starts previews in mid or late May, I wanna say, but again, go to the website.

[1:09:27] Charlie Murphy: And you can follow us on Instagram, Pig Pen Theater Co. Um, you can visit our website, pigpentheater.com, um, where we, you know, put updates to things and just the way we've been doing this in this episode, isn't it amazing? He gives pig pens, but does not his own.

[1:09:42] Dan Weschler: Not his own social. Don't follow Dan, follow Pig Pen.

[1:09:47] Charlie Murphy: Well, you could try, but country above. I don't really have uh my own social media presence.

[1:09:53] Dan Weschler: Uh it's all through the company.

[1:09:53] Charlie Murphy: I love it.

[1:09:56] Dan Weschler: So a true culture that might change at some point, but I love it.

[1:10:00] Charlie Murphy: Well, Dan, thank you so much for the time today, man. This was such a joy to get to chat with you.

[1:10:02] Dan Weschler: Yeah, it's a pleasure. Thanks, Charlie.

[1:10:10] Charlie Murphy: Whoo, yeah. I hope you enjoyed listening to Dan. Uh, he is a really interesting mix of being one of the smartest people in every room he's in, but also incredibly humble and self-effacing, almost to a fault.

[1:10:23] Dan Weschler: Very hard to get that man to brag about himself.

[1:10:26] Charlie Murphy: Which leads me to my takeaway from today. It's about something we touched on briefly in that imposter syndrome or feeling like you don't belong in some rooms.

[1:10:35] I obviously don't know what everyone's experience is, but I know more people than not will have had this experience at some point in their lives where they feel like I don't belong in this room, right? Maybe they feel like I'm a fraud. These people are all geniuses. What the hell am I doing in this particular room?

[1:10:48] Dan Weschler: The obvious advice is that this is an instance of fake it till you make it. That everybody doesn't belong in certain rooms until they do belong. And that is definitely true. That with time and experience, you're gonna feel more comfortable.

[1:10:58] Charlie Murphy: But I also think that this is a cultivatable skill to some degree, in that the same way actors can work on actively taking up space on stage. And we talked about that in a recent episode about how to take up space generously, not apologizing when it's your moment, but not sucking up all the oxygen in the room when it's not.

[1:11:14] Dan Weschler: I do think as a human being, you can help yourself with some positive self-talk surrounding trust. Even when it's not easy to trust that you are not a fraud, which I certainly felt that way, you can trust the smart people around you who put you in that position.

[1:11:30] Charlie Murphy: You didn't get selected for this part out of a ping pong ball lottery. Somebody very smart saw something in you and put you in that position. And somehow to me, if you make it about that, it's easier to swallow.

[1:11:41] Dan Weschler: And for me, an easier objective to achieve invalidating someone else's trust in me and and trying to show up well for their sake, than if I tell myself, okay, really try to impress everyone in this moment, right?

[1:11:51] Charlie Murphy: To force a sports analogy, it's like when a coach makes you a captain on a team. If you can think of yourself as an extension of that trusted coach's voice, and then therefore confidently use your own voice because you trust and respect this person who chose you, you can focus a bit less on, hey, why me and not this other person who's also good, or you know, what do I need to say to them to prove that I belong in this position?

[1:12:13] Dan Weschler: Which I think those are less helpful thoughts than you know what what actually needs to be heard in terms of your voice in the room.

[1:12:18] Charlie Murphy: The comedic version of this that I often use on Elizabeth, if she's poking fun of me, you know, if I'm doing something weird or gross or worthy of mockery in some way, I'll often turn to her and say, Hey, you're the crazy person who's choosing to marry me. Whereas I, of course, am quite sane in my wonderfully choice selection.

[1:12:35] Dan Weschler: I've also done the same thing in rehearsal rooms too, and I invite you to do this, though maybe not quite so um audibly. But I remember uh a director friend who cast me in a few things once was kind of questioning a choice I made in rehearsal, which I made like a you know, one of those throwing paint against the wall, pretty free kind of choice, which after which I I knew it would not make its way into the production, but we were free, we were trying things, whatever.

[1:12:56] Charlie Murphy: And he was like, Charlie, what was that? And I turned to him and I said, 'Hey, you cast me, right? ' Implying that any craziness that came out of me was at least partially on him.

[1:13:05] Dan Weschler: And while, of course, it's not 100% the case that the director is responsible for everything any actor does, having that trust of, hey, this person wants all of my choices, good and bad, and the ones that we don't know about yet, right? It's a really freeing place to be as an artist.

[1:13:20] Charlie Murphy: That's true as an actor, as a writer, wherever kind of art you're trying to make. You know, if you can think I really respect this person who put me in this room, and I trust that they knew what they were getting in selecting me, and so they're gonna get my full best self as a result.

[1:13:33] Dan Weschler: And then we'll go from there with what works, what doesn't work, but it won't be all on me and the responsibility to prove why I belong. If I go, I'm just gonna trust that this person put me in this room for a reason.

[1:13:44] Charlie Murphy: And there you have it, another podcast in the books. This podcast was expertly produced by the wonderful Meghan Cordier. You can follow us at Mapping the College Audition on the gram or other places in our show notes, and you can head to mtca.nyc for help with your individual college prep.

[1:13:59] Dan Weschler: If you're moved to give us a little review, either on Apple Podcasts or a Google review for MTCA, we'd be endlessly appreciative.

[1:14:06] Charlie Murphy: But of course, we understand if you don't, your ears and your attention are gift enough. To my young artists out there mapping their journeys, go listen to some pig pen. I think you'll be inspired. We'll see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred