Skip to main content
BPN Logo
BONUS - The Great Gatsby a New Musical | Theatre in the D

Come join us as we take a walk through the world of new money and old romance as Jess and Miranda talk about "The Great Gatsby: A New Musical" now playing at the Fisher Theatre Tue, Nov 17 - Sun, Nov 29, 2026. Come along Old Sport. You can find tickets here!.. Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

27 mins
Nov 20

Featured Shows

About

Come join us as we take a walk through the world of new money and old romance as Jess and Miranda talk about "The Great Gatsby: A New Musical" now playing at the Fisher Theatre Tue, Nov 17 - Sun, Nov 29, 2026. Come along Old Sport.

You can find tickets here!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jess Moffat: Hello and welcome to another episode of Theatre in the D. I am joined by my partner in all things, Miranda Moffat. Hello, everyone. And this week, we walk toward the green light boats against the current in my younger and more vulnerable years, I wish to be a fool and whatever famous quotes we learned in English class, because we saw The Great Gatsby the musical. Miranda, tell us a little bit about it.

[0:43] Miranda Moffat: Yes, of course, we saw The Great Gatsby a New Musical book by Kate Kerrigan, based on the novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald, of course, which, you know, who knows, F. Scott Fitzgerald or Zelda, Zelda Fitzgerald, we'll never know. Music by Jason Howland, lyrics by Nathan Tyson. This is a story about what can go wrong when your landlord wants you to set up a meet cute with your cousin. Heterosexuality is a crime and needs to be outlawed is what I've discovered from this musical. Yeah. So, you know, I'm sure many people had to read this book in their high school English classes and know the general gist of it. But in F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, it's told from the perspective of our main protagonist, Nick Carraway, who is a soldier who survived World War One and has moved to New York from Minneapolis, I think, Minnesota.

That's in Minneapolis. That's in Minnesota, right? Geography is hard. From Minnesota and has settled in New York and is renting a cottage on a large estate that is near his cousin Daisy. Turns out that the gentleman that he is renting his cottage from, Mr. Jay Gatsby, is somebody who used to be a poor soldier in World War One also and was in love with Nick's cousin Daisy. They were in love when they were young. They got separated. He ended up amassing this fortune pretty much with the entire objective of impressing her and building a house near her in the hopes that he would one day get her back. They meet. Tragedy incurs. Marriage is awful. And spoiler alert, he dies in the end due to a large miscommunication mishap that happens at kind of the very end that you don't see coming.

It's a story that sometimes doesn't make sense, and I mean the original novel to me. You don't know why things are happening, and it is very style over substance. I could write a whole English paper about it, and I'm sure I did at some point. But yeah, I don't love the original content, and the musical is much the same.

[3:10] Jess Moffat: Do you know the history of this musical? I'm assuming you don't really know the behind the scenes, inner workings, and kind of, I don't want to say backstabbings, but internal machinations that kind of brought this specific musical to the stage on Broadway.

[3:23] Miranda Moffat: No, I do not. Why don't you tell us about it, Jess?

[3:27] Jess Moffat: So the Great Gatsby book fell into the public domain, I want to say in 2024, around there. And basically, it's like the Olsen Twins ticking clock, where a bunch of weirdos are really like, we've got to make the Great Gatsby musical. No one's done it. And about five different people were aching to it. And two of them actually kind of got made. The first one was one created by Florence Welch, Florence and the Machine, and it's apparently really interesting, really weird, taking big swings with the material, really leaning into the style over substance, but in the content, not just the flashy sets of it all. I have a YoHo bootleg of it, and I've just, I've not watched it properly, I've skinned it, but I think that it's definitely a little bit more great comedy than, that suits my taste, a bit more than, you know, classic Americana Broadway musical tap numbers, than Great Gatsby, an American tale, what is it, American musical?

They have some kind of subtitle to separate it from just being the Great Gatsby, the musical. I think that is part of the distinction of which one came to Broadway, because they're much like the two Wild Parties, where we had two Wild Party musicals being written because it came into the public domain at the same time, where in that case, I think the weirder, more theater-y one made it to Broadway, this case, the kind of more populous one made it to Broadway, which is what we've seen today. On stage, it starred Eva Noblezada and Jeremy Jordan, and somehow it's still running on Broadway to this day, like, I think they just got the guy from the Savannah Bananas to take over the role of Gatsby, so it's still kicking somehow.

And going into it, I was under the impression this is going to be a big, broad-y musical, and based on the cast recording, has one song that I really like, and yeah, lived up to it! That one song is really good! But the rest of the show, I'm not sure it really worked for me. Before we went in, we were talking to someone who will remain nameless, and I asked, and they had seen the show previously, and we asked, how is it? And they said, the set is really pretty, which led me to be like, oh no! What are we walking into? And yeah, that is about the best review I could give.

[5:58] Miranda Moffat: You are correct, though. The title is The Great Gatsby, A New Musical, so yes, that is true. Um, yes. I think, I think they are doing the best they can with the material. Like I said, I was never a fan. I'm so sorry, Mrs. Kessler. I was never a fan of The Great Gatsby. I read it in high school, and I read it in college, and I was bored both times. Um, just don't, I don't, I don't love it, and I don't really love most of its message. I can appreciate the general message of, you know, which is still very relevant today, that people with a lot of wealth and privilege tend to take advantage of their circumstances and leave behind a mess in their wake that they're able to just walk away from because their money affords them that option, and everybody else without that option is just sort of left in the wreckage and left to deal with the consequences.

And also, just like the sort of, you know, existing caste system that is still around that controls our lives, whether we want to believe it or not. I mean, America is like the land of new money and new opportunity, but like at the end of the day, there is still that division where like, when you have money, you're going to keep it, and it's very hard to get money. Like, there are some points being made in the book. There are some points trying to be made in the show. It doesn't do it very well.

[7:36] Jess Moffat: Yeah, it is, it is very pretty. Sort of similar to like Baz Luhrmann's The Great Gatsby movie. I feel very similarly about pretty much every adaptation of this book. Like, not a whole lot to work with, but very nice to look at. Really cool, like, tap numbers and musical numbers. Like, there are some good, fun moments in it, but when we got to the end of Act 1, and I was like, there's 12 songs in Act 2? Are you kidding me? It really overstays its welcome, I think. It is, it's too long, even for what it's trying to portray and what it's trying to say. I feel like if we had sort of tightened up the story and added a little bit more intrigue, like, I also have like a particular gripe with the fact that when you read the book, like, Nick Carraway is the narrator, and everything that happens in the book is what he was present for and what he would have seen personally.

And also, he's like, notoriously a very unreliable narrator. And also, maybe in love with Jay Gatsby? Like, there was none of that, none of that filtered. It very much focused on the love story between Daisy and Gatsby, which I feel like was not really the focus of the original book. It wiped away Nick Carraway's bisexuality. They were like, really like, oh no, he gave him like a proper, proper girlfriend. He's not gay, guys, I promise. It was probably the most baffling part of this is how much they focused on Nick and Jordan's relationship, which is kind of a thing in the book, but not to the level it is here. They never got engaged, are you crazy? That was just very much trying to follow the musical theater structure of, you have the main couple and the secondary couple, it's just like Oklahoma.

A lot of this musical, like, even when I was watching, I'm like, this is very competently done. The book writers, the composers, and everyone involved has done work I've really liked previously, like Shucked, Killer Party, the Little Women musical. So coming into this, I can see them using all the tricks of the trade to try to make this story fit into that, but it's kind of like trying to cram a banana into a Cheerio. It's just not gonna really fit.

[9:57] Jess Moffat: Yeah, there are really some things that are not meant to be made into other formats. And I think that extends to film, because I know you aren't a fan. I'm kind of a fan of Baz Luhrmann's take on The Great Gatsby, because it leans into the style over substance, and condenses really smart, and really highlights the things that I think work about the book, and really gets rid of the things that are kind of meandering, and restructures things so that they're more interesting, opposed to a big lore drop at the very end, then he dies. I think that he really took that in a smart way, and I think this was just like, isn't romance fun, and we're gonna make Daisy a girl boss.

[10:52] Miranda Moffat: Yeah, kind of. Yeah, that is really probably the biggest issue that there is, is it's not a lot to work with, in my opinion, to begin with. And trying to make an even longer form version of the story, yeah, it just did not focus on the good things. I will say, though, like, my issues with the musical itself aside, I think the cast did a good job. I really still enjoy, like, watching them play the characters, and listening to the music, and they all had really incredible voices. I think, like you mentioned, there was somebody, the Tom Buchanan character was somebody that you know. I'm a Starkid fan, Nerdy Proofs Must Die, it's Max Yeagerman, guys, and he played Tom, and frankly, I felt like he was the only one kind of playing to his age.

He felt, in the same way that kind of Jason Alexander was the only one that felt like a grown adult in the original Merrily production, he's the only one that truly feels like an adult, because we've got all these young'uns, fresh out of college, kicking butt and singing their faces off, but they look so young, and he's just playing much older than he really is in his works.

[12:11] Miranda Moffat: Another MVP I really want to highlight, and maybe you have her actual name, I did not think that this musical would give me, like, Myrtle being the best character by far. She gets a ballad at the end of Act 2, right before she goes kersplat, and it's, like, the most engaged I was the entire show, where I'm just like, yes, let an actor be on stage and command it for three minutes, and it is, it was probably my favorite three minutes of this, aside from the new money sequence, which is amazing. Yes, I can find this for you. I can find this for you. Yes, well, Tom Buchanan, that was the Starkid gentleman, that was Will Branner. Lila, Lila Coogan is the person who played Myrtle Wilson. She was very good. Her styling was, like, kind of, what was that Maggie Gyllenhaal movie that we didn't manage to get through? Bride? Yes, very, like, very Jesse Buckley-esque, specifically in that.

[13:49] Jess Moffat: Not so good. Translation into musical numbers also not so good. Interesting to watch if you have read the book as a high school student, maybe, maybe, maybe not. I think that there is no better form for The Great Gatsby than that book, um, for better and for worse. I know you talk about the sets, but I think it's a little reliant on projections, which I think can work really, really well as we saw with maybe Happy Ending. Whereas with this, it just kind of felt like I was looking at video game cut scenes. Well, uh, Jordan and Nick sang about their love and I'm getting frustrated. Um, I think that as far as the tour goes, I think they made some smart decisions compared to the Broadway. I think yesterday I showed you a compilation of the different Gatsby death sequences and I've always hated the staging on the Broadway version. It looks real bad and here it just stayed in a way that makes so much more sense and looks so much better.

[14:58] Miranda Moffat: It does. And also the thing that we have not talked about yet is there are full-on cars. There are full-on 1920s Model T style cars driving around on the stage like full size. It's nuts! Like there were several moments in this that did feel like every show has one where they feel like a magic trick, like Myrtle's dress quick change. No one reacted to that. That was so frustrating. I gave like a "oh" and no one in the audience did anything. That was frustrating on the audience because that was like one of those great magic trick moments.

[15:31] Jess Moffat: I agree. And everyone has one. I mean, watching a musical, whether or not it's your favorite thing, is like magic every time because you just don't know how it's happening and how it manages to happen every night. Um, but yeah, the Myrtle's dress quick change was incredible and just like having those full-size cars, a Rolls Royce just on the stage, like it looked, there are no tracks. I don't know if they were actually driving it. I don't know if they're remote control. I don't know how that whole thing went down. All I know is that it was really cool.

[16:08] Miranda Moffat: I agree and I want to know because I kind of hyped this scene up for you. It's the one song that I like listen to from this musical a lot, the new money sequence where we kind of introduced Gatsby's party and it's sung by Jordan and it's really, really difficult to sing and there's a lot of dance going on. It became a trend on TikTok where just people like, "Oh no, this is so much harder than I thought it was going to be." And that scene lived up to it and we had like practical sparklers at the end. That was like, that was peak. That was wonderful.

[16:39] Jess Moffat: That is kind of the only thing that you were like, "Yeah, that's one good song." There's one good song that you'll maybe like. I'm like, "Oh great, we're in for a good time." Um, was I right though? No, honestly, there were songs I liked better than that one.

[17:00] Miranda Moffat: Yeah, I could not tell you the name of it. There's a frick. Well, there's a lot of them. Um, yeah, I could not tell you what the name is. What song was it or what scene was it?

[17:07] Jess Moffat: I don't know, like there were some of the ballads that I just liked, like the one you're talking about with Myrtle's character, like that one was good.

[17:15] Miranda Moffat: Um, well the front, I don't know, some of the songs were a little on the nose where it's like, we're trying to give you the plot in a very convenient and sensical way. Um, a thing that I bring up in something like, um, the work of, oh God, the gentleman that wrote Chain Air, that I, Paul Gordon, um, he's very good at taking the text directly and communicating it into lyrics, um, in a way that it almost feels like it's highlighting it for you for your essays. And this musical kind of like highlights it in like sharpie instead.

[17:51] Jess Moffat: Somewhat, but there were some other songs that I did enjoy, but I did like the, um, I did like the new money sequence, um, whereas the opener of Gatsby's second party where it's like, we're all gonna stop and do a tap number. I know this is cliché of me, I was just kind of like, "Awesome, a tap number! I get to watch this!" But also, why? This is not reaching the heights of that previous thing and I'm not as emotionally engaged with it.

[18:25] Miranda Moffat: Another thing I was wondering how you felt about, I think Gatsby, especially in like the act one, should be like treated like the Phantom of the Opera. Like he's like this mythical creature and should have a reveal and like a big moment. Like we need the Phantom coming through the mirror moment and here he just kind of is on stage. He's like, "Hi, I'm Gatsby." No fanfare, nothing.

[18:46] Jess Moffat: I agree that that is one of the things that bothered me too is the general characterization of Gatsby. And maybe I'm just not remembering. It's been a long time. It's been like almost a decade now since I read the book for the last time. Um, but I kind of, I do remember more of his characterization being a bit more serious and yes, almost like he is kind of a mythical creature or like, you know, Jaws or something where like you really don't, like you talk a lot about this person and you never see them and you don't get to meet them until this like intense moment. But yeah, for real, he just gets called to like, "Hey, Gatsby wants to meet you," and then he's like, "Hey, how you doing? Yeah, just like I'm Gatsby. I'm a little goofy guy." And that was kind of strange.

[19:34] Miranda Moffat: I agree with you. I think that Gatsby should be somewhat of mythical proportions and that was not the kind of Gatsby that they were putting forward in this interpretation. Whereas in the Baz Luhrmann film, we hide his face, he's like having a full conversation with Nick and then, um, what was that? Rhapsody in Blue plays and in the bom bom bom bom boom fireworks? And we do the reveal where it's Leo DiCaprio gif of him raising the drink and perfect. That is a true blue reveal there. That is what I wanted.

[20:05] Jess Moffat: So Miranda, what are your overall thoughts on The Great Gatsby: A New Musical?

[20:21] Miranda Moffat: It's like, um, I think Wicked is technically their full title is Wicked: A New Musical for very similar reasons. Same with Gypsy. It's like, and yeah, it's weird when they just throw a musical fable. Now that is their official title either way, cheese.

[20:37] Jess Moffat: Oh God, um, what would be my cheese rating? Maybe like a slightly moldy piece of brie? You know, like brie is meant to taste kind of funky but in like a good way, but like you let it go a little too far and you tried to eat something that's been sitting out a little too long and probably should have been left alone and not touched again and not reinterpreted, you know? Just leave it alone.

[21:02] Miranda Moffat: Anyway, so like maybe a moldy piece of brie and I am giving it smoked gouda sitting in our fridge for a little longer. And you know, it's a little melty and kind of gross but you know what? There's something in it because at the end of the day, there's still some gouda in there.

[21:18] Jess Moffat: So you basically just said exactly what I said, but with a different form of cheese.

[21:22] Miranda Moffat: Isn't that the point of this fucking show?

[21:28] Jess Moffat: The point is that Gatsby is could be difficult. Generally, even it's in its original format and I think it would be difficult in any way to really adapt appropriately. And I agree. I think Baz Luhrmann probably did it in the best way that we're going to get it. Um, it has some really cool magical moments. It's got, it does have some sauce. It's got some moments. It's got some sparkle, um, but not really a fabulous interpretation in my opinion and not incredibly exciting unfortunately.

[21:58] Miranda Moffat: How do you feel about like what I've said about the Florence Welch one? Uh, because Florence and the Machine, people like her and she does a really interesting rock music. And I think if you're taking a swing at Great Gatsby doing classical Americana musical theater, I don't think that's the way to do it. I mean, I don't know. I feel like I would need to see it. I just, I don't love the original source material. So I feel like I can't be super unbiased and you know.

[22:29] Jess Moffat: You didn't like girl boss Daisy.

[22:31] Miranda Moffat: I understand where they are coming from and trying to, you know, like quote unquote update it in the same way that like Phantom in some versions gives Christine more agency than others. But it's kind of like the point is kind of that Daisy does not have agency in this world in this time and her wish is that her daughter will just be a fool who doesn't see that and just takes it for what it is and like kind of enjoys the ride of not making decisions and not having agency. At least that's my sort of take on it. Like that's kind of the point. I wouldn't say they did too much like whatever girl boss gatekeep gaslight, whatever.

[23:11] Jess Moffat: Um, but yeah, a little bit of that.

[23:11] Miranda Moffat: All right. What are we seeing next?

[23:20] Jess Moffat: Well, we could see Boop.

[23:22] Miranda Moffat: That'll be what we see next, Boop. The musical is coming to the Fisher Theater in Detroit, Michigan, December 1st through the 13th and I am actually, despite the fact that I feel like this did not get good reviews and did not survive long on Broadway, I am kind of excited to see it. I hear it's basically Barbie and I like Barbie and I like Betty Boop and I think like it is a career-making performance for Jasmine Amy Jones. I believe that was the actress's name and she is now like running the gamut on stage and I'm excited. I think it'll be like Funny Girl where it's like, "Oh, I see where people bump on this, but that lead performance though is something."

[24:00] Jess Moffat: So I'm gonna be, I'm actually very, very excited for that and what I've seen of it looks like theatrical magic in a way too.

[24:05] Miranda Moffat: That's my hope. That's my hope is that like, like in similar ways, I think I don't believe The Great Gatsby was very well reviewed in its time on Broadway, was it? What was the consensus there?

[24:15] Jess Moffat: Fairly negative.

[24:19] Miranda Moffat: But it has a very strong fan base. It is still running on Broadway. It is not a closed show like it, I mean, when you have celebrities in it like Reeve Carney and Jeremy Jordan and all those people, maybe that reveal of Gatsby works better when it's just Jeremy Jordan walks on stage and you pause for applause.

[24:39] Jess Moffat: Maybe, maybe star power is a big part of that that we're just kind of not getting. I don't know. I think there's a way you can do it to make him mysterious that does not rely on star power. I think it may be a matter of like staging. I don't know. Um, but I think like similarly both did not get particularly good reviews but both seemed to sort of rely on like a lot of the flash and pizzazz and like cool stuff about musical theater and maybe not necessarily on the sort of craftsmanship of the lyrics or music necessarily. Not that there aren't some really good songs that I did like a lot of the songs on Gatsby, but just not, um, not great at really telling the story.

[25:23] Miranda Moffat: So my hope is with Boop is that it has like a mix of those things where like the bad reviews just are because people are lame and don't like to have a good time and I'm hoping this is just going to be a really good time.

[25:34] Jess Moffat: Do you want me to sing half of the score to Gatsby for you right now?

[25:34] Miranda Moffat: Go on.

[25:43] Jess Moffat: That's most of this musical, you're not wrong.

[25:48] Miranda Moffat: Oh.

[25:50] Jess Moffat: We'll see you next time on Theatre in the D, but we could see Boop.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred