Today we're joined by our KEEPER OF THE CHEESE Juliet Antonio, who ranks the Top Ten episodes of Musicals with Cheese. It's a blast, and you can compare your notes to theirs!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Featured Shows
About
Today we're joined by our KEEPER OF THE CHEESE Juliet Antonio, who ranks the Top Ten episodes of Musicals with Cheese. It's a blast, and you can compare your notes to theirs!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Andrew: Hello and welcome to this extra special bonus episode that wraps us all up for the year.
[0:11] Bree: Yeah.
[0:12] Andrew: Um, it's me, Andrew and Bree, and today we are joined by you've heard the name a bunch of times. It's probably one of the first times you're hearing the voice is Juliet Antonio, our keeper of the cheese.
[0:24] Juliet Antonio: I have arrived. I have come from my cheesy lair to visit you and bring you gifts.
[0:29] Bree: Hell yeah.
[0:30] Andrew: Excellent. Now what are we doing today?
[0:32] Juliet Antonio: So you asked me, I think about maybe a couple of months ago at this point, if I could come up with a top 10 list of the top Musicals with Cheese' episodes of all time, plus a list of the best cheese ratings of all time. And this was a lot. Uh, if you're listening to this and you're wondering, where's my favorite episode? Absolutely no worries. You can do what I did. Listen to all 169 episodes of the show and create your own top 10 list and DM it to me on Twitter. I will gladly read it. Uh, I do want to put the caveat on it right now. Um, while this will be coming out after episodes 70 and 71, which I believe are the little mash girl and West Side Story. Um, they might be the best episodes ever or the worst episodes ever. They're just not included yet because of timing reasons.
[1:18] Bree: Yeah.
[1:19] Juliet Antonio: Yes. Absolutely no worries. I feel like I had one more caveat to say, but now I got brain dead.
[1:23] Andrew: Sorry to interrupt.
[1:26] Juliet Antonio: It's all right. Thank you, Jess. Very productive.
[1:31] Juliet Antonio: All right. Um, so this was I tried to create like a little bit of a balance. I wanted equal episodes where it's just you two guys having fun shooting the shit and equal parts of constructive criticism. So I looked back through the spreadsheet, tried to remember what I could, and these are the results that we have. So, Andrew, Bree, and Jess, are you ready?
[1:52] Andrew: I'm ready.
[1:53] Bree: Yeah.
[1:54] Juliet Antonio: First, I want to see if Andrew has any predictions of what he might think is number one.
[1:58] Andrew: Oh, I want to hear this.
[1:59] Andrew: Oh, good lord. Um, I don't know. I I I would I would put our dear of enhanced episodes up there. So I'm hoping to see those on the list.
[2:08] Bree: What about you, Bri?
[2:10] Bree: Oh god. Um, I'm trying to think. I you know, I listen to a lot of them too. I think at this point, I've listened to what, 70 oh 71 episodes?
[2:21] Andrew: 71.
[2:22] Bree: Wow. Oh god. I mean, Juliet's got you top here with like 171.
[2:30] Andrew: True.
[2:31] Bree: True. Let's listen to the hundred, the hundred worst episodes, though. I'm trying to what's up there. I really liked your guys' A Christmas Carol. I think A Christmas Story. I really liked A Christmas Story.
[2:47] Andrew: Okay, yeah. Um, and then I mean Tarzan was pretty good that we did the other week. Just just what do you put up there? You're the head ringmaster here.
[2:57] Juliet Antonio: I don't know. Probably one of my favorites, and it's no one else's favorite is the time you and I reenacted A Christmas Carol. But I don't want I thought Brie was referring to when she said Christmas Carol. I was like, oh, deep cut. Nice.
[3:10] Andrew: No, that's my deep cut. I just we we're putting it out next week um as a bonus just to get it out there. And I did a new edit of a new mix of it. Um, it's still probably one of my favorite things I've ever heard.
[3:20] Bree: He edited out all of his own jokes.
[3:21] Andrew: He's why haven't I seen this yet?
[3:26] Juliet Antonio: Please send it to me.
[3:27] Andrew: I will, I will. Um, but Juliet, it the ball's in your court.
[3:28] Juliet Antonio: All right, but I'm gonna say that's gonna be a new Christmas tradition of my household. I'm gonna force everyone to listen to this version of A Christmas Carol and that version only. That in the Muppets. It's so fun. I love it.
[3:40] Andrew: All right, so let's get things started. So, number 10. People I think are gonna go, what? But when I explain, I think I think you'll see why. So, number 10 for top 10 episodes of Musicals with Cheese' is episode number 58, Jekyll and Hyde.
[3:56] Bree: Really?
[3:57] Juliet Antonio: There's a reason that I listed this.
[3:58] Bree: Okay.
[3:59] Juliet Antonio: Okay. So it's a great episode for just joking around, but I include it because we get to learn about Frank Wildhorn's place in Broadway history, how fans versus critics respond to his shows and why he writes songs the way he does, because I didn't know that um he got started in just writing pop music. I knew he wrote one song for Whitney Houston, but I didn't know how long his career in that was. And I also like this episode because we get into guilty pleasure theater and how it's not necessarily a bad thing while still being able to critique it.
[4:27] Bree: I agree.
[4:28] Andrew: I remember absolutely nothing from this episode. I remember Mandarin not liking the uh the show very much, but I do remember that the episode was decent and, well, I think it was well received. I remember it being one of the few good ones because we were just so stressed that entire Halloween season, and we were just trying to get as many Halloween episodes out there. Like I just feel like that was the only good one out of that bunch.
[4:53] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, I think that was also the first episode that Mina Miniri suggested that you cover, or am I wrong with that?
[4:59] Andrew: I think she's she suggests Wildhorn's pieces a lot.
[5:01] Juliet Antonio: She suggested uh Wildhorn's pieces, but I think she I think I tricked her a little bit. Um, she originally was gonna ask us to cover Jekyll and Hyde, and I was like, hold off on that. It's already being recorded, so pick another one.
[5:16] Bree: Gotcha.
[5:17] Juliet Antonio: So I kind of framed it as if it was, but I didn't want to charge her for it since it was already on our schedule. This episode also made it onto my uh my list because um the only version of Jekyll and Hyde I'd seen before this was the um uh the David Hasselhoff version, which I watched years and years ago. And I and I I think I just forgot most of it, but this episode is the sole reason why I have Murder Murder on my musical theater playlist because of Jess's dramatic reading. And I was like, that's that's no way those are the real lyrics. It was like when I listened to the Diana episode, I was like, there is no way in hell that those lyrics are real, but oh they are, and they are sung with glorious operatic style. I was like, perfect. I am adding that to my playlist. So that's why it's on there. But if you ever get a chance, check out the ri new rendition of it for the Constantine Marulas version where they made it even worse.
[6:07] Andrew: Yeah, you know, I feel bad because like my mom kind of became a fan of Constantine Rules. She was like, I kind of like his voice, but at the same time, I don't, and I can't figure out why. And so she was sending this to all these people, and I think with Constantine Morulus, it's like sometimes he misses the note, either he overshoots it or he undershoots it. And with Jekyll and Hyde, it's like uh, you know, he has the rock voice, but I don't think that he could do the duality really well. And also the projections, are they really as bad as I think they are in my head?
[6:42] Bree: Yeah.
[6:43] Juliet Antonio: Oh dear.
[6:45] Andrew: Oh god.
[6:46] Juliet Antonio: See, the original staging was fine. One of the problems with Jekyll and Hyde wasn't the staging. They had a good stage.
[6:51] Andrew: I don't know, Andrew hated the staging.
[6:52] Bree: Oh, like the oh, really?
[6:54] Andrew: Oh, yeah, you did, you did. I thought it was very bland.
[6:57] Juliet Antonio: All right, well, all right, we gotta move on. Number nine.
[7:00] Andrew: All right, number nine.
[7:01] Juliet Antonio: Number nine is episode 104, Phantom, an American musical sensation with Angelina Meehan. Uh, in my opinion, the best of the Phantom episodes as a fan, and we make a great comparison, which I never thought of. Jerry Herman's Phantom of the Opera. I heard that and I was like, yeah, that makes sense. It does feel like if he wrote Phantom. And we dive into how this musical found its place in the Phantom Cinematic Universe, why some people prefer to uh ALW and others don't. And we have the best improvised recap of a musical theater piece I have ever heard in my life. I could not breathe from laughing. I was like, perfect. Do you ever want a summary of the Yesin Copit Phantom? Go listen to that episode.
[7:41] Bree: I don't even remember what we said how we summarized it.
[7:43] Andrew: Um, you played the dad. You played the dad.
[7:44] Juliet Antonio: Skior Carrier. Um, and Angelina was Christine and she she nailed it. I love Angelina. We should have her on again.
[7:52] Andrew: Oh yeah. Angeline Vidaheads was a great guest and uh when she came on for Great Comet as well. But I don't know. I just feel like this episode had like a little bit of the edge. And I I don't know if I should. I'm gonna ask this because it's like the Phantom Universe is very deep, and I know that there's a couple more musical adaptations. There's three that I can think of. Are you going to cover those or are you just done with the Phantom Universe at this point? Because if you were, I wouldn't blame you.
[8:19] Juliet Antonio: It's it's it's fine. I mean, can we really not talk about Phantom of the Paradise? Like that one's great.
[8:23] Andrew: Oh no, Phantom of the Paradise is fine, but I was thinking of like, oh my god, Andrew's gotta sit through Ken Hill and David Stellar and the dinner theater one where the Phantom has a long blonde wig and it looks really weird.
[8:36] Juliet Antonio: I think we're more likely gonna cover the Goosebumps Phantom of the Auditorium than any of those.
[8:41] Andrew: Oh yeah, okay, good, good. Because if Andrew has to sit through David Staller, I'm like, we did cover the uh the horror movie one as well, which I like. Robert England, that's on Patreon.
[8:50] Juliet Antonio: That's on Patreon. That was a really good uh yeah, really good. That must be fun. I think we'd probably do a Patreon thing for David Stallworth. It's like an hour and 14 minutes. Like it's real short.
[8:57] Andrew: Oh wow. It must feel long though, because like I seen the clips from that and went, oof.
[9:02] Juliet Antonio: It's oof, but it's so short, like it was rushed together just to mark it off Android Weber. It's who cares? It's fun for some reason.
[9:09] Andrew: I guess. All right, so number eight.
[9:12] Juliet Antonio: What?
[9:13] Andrew: Oh yeah, number eight.
[9:14] Juliet Antonio: So number eight is episode 62, Hello Dolly with Adam Walter.
[9:19] Andrew: So you're picking the weird ones.
[9:22] Juliet Antonio: Like I I was not expecting these ones. I'm very happy.
[9:26] Juliet Antonio: Well, we're getting it, we're gonna get into like the ones that I think you're gonna be expecting a little bit later. They're higher up on the list. I mean, this is a good episode, but yeah. So my reasoning for this is it's my favorite of the Adam Walkter episodes, and it's the first legit Jerry Herman episode. I say that um having referenced him earlier, but it was the first time you covered Jerry Herman. And what I love about this episode is how we point out the things you love about Hello Dolly, as well, you giving your critiques across various versions of this musical from the Carol Channing original to the Barbara Streisand film to the Bet Midler revival slash the tour, because I think Adam said that you saw the tour with Betty Buckley, which must have been incredible.
Um, and Adam was also perfect for this episode because I feel like this is the one where he vibes with all of you the best because all three of you are talking about a musical you all really have fun watching. And we have the unique possession of the two of you, Jess and Andrew, being the the sort of newbies, because Jess, I think you said you hadn't watched Hello Dolly yet at this point, and it's the guest that provides the great insight and analysis. And of course, I thought I'd mention this as a tribute to uh Adam's friend Austin, who also went Hello, Dolly.
[10:32] Bree: Oh my god, that was so funny, and he was such a sport for being willing to joke about that so much.
[10:38] Juliet Antonio: Oh my god. Uh, that was that was just like, oh, this is cute, his friend. And then Adam's like, and then he died the year later, and I went, oh.
[10:47] Andrew: Oh dear.
[10:48] Juliet Antonio: Because it came up so naturally because I was like, hey, did Austin turn out to be gay too? And then he was like, I don't know. He died later. And I was like, oh.
[10:58] Bree: What a great, what a great moment.
[11:01] Juliet Antonio: Well, then he also joked about um Austin really loving I put my hand in there. Then we made jokes about fisting, and it was great.
[11:10] Bree: Yeah, it was great.
[11:11] Juliet Antonio: And classic guys. It's a very classy show, Brie. We're on the Broadway podcast network now. We can't be bullshit like that.
[11:17] Bree: Extremely classy.
[11:20] Andrew: I'm drinking out of a plastic cup. That's as classy as you get here, folks.
[11:24] Juliet Antonio: I mean, come on, how do you name a song I put my hand in there and then not make jokes about fisting?
[11:28] Bree: Yeah.
[11:29] Juliet Antonio: And then we also got into um, because it this actually tied back to episode zero, your Tony episode, where you got to watch uh David Hyde Pierce perform I put a penny in my pocket, and I never knew because they only did like a snippet of it, that that song references him possibly murdering his wife. So now I can't look at Horace Vandergelder the same way ever again.
[11:50] Andrew: Well, I think I brought that up and no one else agreed with me. Nobody agreed with me on that that that episode. They're like, nah, Jess, you're reading too far into this.
[11:59] Juliet Antonio: No, because if he says that he murdered his wife with a long, awkward pause, it's like, oh yeah, how'd she die, Horace? How tell us, please? But then he just moves past it like nothing happened. I'm like, I think just is a legit theory there. I will I'm glad I'm right. So ding.
[12:14] Andrew: All right. Um seven.
[12:18] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, yep.
[12:19] Juliet Antonio: All right, I can't remember what number we're on.
[12:21] Andrew: Oh, don't worry about it.
[12:22] Juliet Antonio: It's okay. So number seven is episode 40, Sunday in the Park with George with Tommy of Musical Theater MASH. So in my opinion, this is the best of the Sondheim episodes. We have three people with very different opinions of Sunday. Jess, I know it meant a lot to you when you first heard this piece. Andrew was sort of in the middle, and Tommy had his video essays on his channel explaining why he felt about Sunday the way that he did.
[12:45] Juliet Antonio: And this episode prompted a great discussion about artists and their art, mental health.
[12:50] Juliet Antonio: But what I loved about this episode was there was a really serious discussion about Steven Sondheim as a person and the range that he had from his justified confidence in his ability to his moments of crippling self-doubt.
[13:04] Juliet Antonio: And because that was the episode that sort of humanized him and his work the most, especially when, as Tommy mentioned, this was the musical he made right after Merrily when he came so close to quitting.
[13:14] Juliet Antonio: I was like, I'm putting this on the list.
[13:16] Juliet Antonio: And this was I had this on the list potentially even before we got the news they passed away in November.
[13:20] Andrew: Yeah, that was really yeah.
[13:21] Andrew: That was a good episode.
[13:22] Juliet Antonio: And it felt important because I felt like I'm probably not gonna get Tommy on the show again.
[13:26] Juliet Antonio: Like that was the vibe I had when it happened.
[13:28] Juliet Antonio: So I was like, we've gotta make this one count.
[13:30] Juliet Antonio: Because the only reason why we got Tommy on that show is someone who's like, hey, you should have musical theater mash uh tag and he tagged him uh on the show and talk about Sunday.
[13:38] Juliet Antonio: I was like, hey, if he's in, I'm in.
[13:40] Juliet Antonio: And then he's like, I'm in.
[13:41] Juliet Antonio: And then I was like, all right, we got got my one shot here.
[13:44] Juliet Antonio: Let's go.
[13:45] Juliet Antonio: Let's go for it.
[13:46] Juliet Antonio: And honestly, it was it was if that was the only musical that you could get Tommy on to discuss, it was a great discussion for him to be on.
[13:53] Juliet Antonio: It was it was a good episode.
[13:54] Juliet Antonio: Plus, it also gave us the iconic, oh, I miss Mandy Patinkin, which always plays in my head now.
[14:00] Juliet Antonio: Uh okay.
[14:02] Juliet Antonio: Episode number six.
[14:04] Juliet Antonio: Uh so for the sixth episode, we have episode number eighty one.
[14:08] Juliet Antonio: God bless you, Mr. Rosewater, with Ethan from Sideways.
[14:11] Andrew: Oh, I like that one.
[14:12] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, that was nice.
[14:17] Andrew: Classic Andrew.
[14:21] Juliet Antonio: Episode seven through ten.
[14:22] Andrew: Nothing.
[14:23] Juliet Antonio: Episode six.
[14:24] Andrew: Oh, yes, the one that I liked.
[14:25] Juliet Antonio: I like that one.
[14:26] Andrew: Yeah, that was pretty good.
[14:27] Juliet Antonio: Great.
[14:29] Juliet Antonio: So I'm gonna get into this uh a little bit later, but I can tell that when Ethan made his debut, um, he's now on episode three with you guys, I believe.
[14:37] Juliet Antonio: He understood the vibe of the show immediately, which is always nice when you have guests on the show.
[14:41] Juliet Antonio: And when I first listened to this episode, I remember kind of being worried at first because um at first uh it seemed like no one quite knew what to make of God bless you, Mr. Rosewater, and I thought, oh no, they're gonna hate this.
[14:54] Juliet Antonio: But as the episode went on, it was clear that you treated this piece with respect, as James L. Joe's would want you to.
[15:00] Juliet Antonio: Everyone deserves love, everyone deserves respect.
[15:02] Juliet Antonio: And I know a lot of fans, me included, were really grateful for this episode because when we all think of Howard Ashman's body of work, you just mostly think of the uh his Disney stuff and you think of Little Shop of Horrors.
[15:16] Juliet Antonio: But then you have this early obscure show that really reminds you what a genius he is.
[15:22] Juliet Antonio: And for me, when I listened to the cast recording after the episode, it was like hearing his work for the first time, which is wonderful.
[15:27] Juliet Antonio: And like also, what the hell else are you gonna listen to?
[15:30] Andrew: Smile?
[15:30] Juliet Antonio: I don't think so.
[15:31] Andrew: I like Smile.
[15:32] Andrew: I don't hate Smile.
[15:34] Andrew: I mean, I love Disneyland from Smile.
[15:37] Andrew: I haven't really dove that far into it, but I like Disneyland enough to say that I probably would like the rest of it.
[15:42] Juliet Antonio: Gotcha.
[15:42] Juliet Antonio: I the only thing I know about Smile is just what I learned from the Howard Ashman documentary, which is on Disney Plus, which if you have access to Disney Plus, check that documentary out.
[15:50] Andrew: It is very, very good.
[15:52] Juliet Antonio: Yeah.
[15:52] Juliet Antonio: I agree.
[15:53] Juliet Antonio: And I agree with you uh about Ethan.
[15:56] Juliet Antonio: Um that was, I think, our first episode when we were on BPN.
[16:00] Juliet Antonio: I think that was our first, like, all right, we're transferred onto it.
[16:04] Juliet Antonio: We're we're here.
[16:05] Juliet Antonio: Um, so we knew we wanted something big.
[16:08] Juliet Antonio: And if you look at the thing, it was our first guest in a very long time.
[16:12] Juliet Antonio: Um we had taken a big break from guests because we had some not so great experiences with some periods.
[16:19] Andrew: Um, so we took a break, and then he was our first like, let's see if we can make this work again and see if we can still get this.
[16:27] Juliet Antonio: And it was perfect.
[16:30] Andrew: Yeah.
[16:31] Andrew: It really reinvigorated the show into okay, we can still do this.
[16:34] Andrew: We're not just going through the motions of doing this every week.
[16:37] Juliet Antonio: So I agree with you.
[16:38] Juliet Antonio: This is a very seminal episode in how we develop both in the BPN sense, the guest sense, and our attitude toward the show and tire.
[16:45] Andrew: Yep.
[16:45] Andrew: Does that mean we're halfway through the list already?
[16:47] Juliet Antonio: We're halfway through already, yeah.
[16:49] Andrew: Wow.
[16:50] Andrew: Wow.
[16:51] Andrew: Wow.
[16:54] Juliet Antonio: Okay, uh, number five on our list is uh a recent one, and we have a I'm just gonna check my list.
[17:01] Juliet Antonio: Oh, we have one other recent one in here.
[17:03] Juliet Antonio: Okay.
[17:03] Juliet Antonio: So number five is episode 164, Bat Boy with Brent Black, aka Brental Floss.
[17:10] Andrew: All right.
[17:11] Andrew: Ah, yes.
[17:13] Andrew: The one that's longer than the show.
[17:16] Juliet Antonio: Okay, Bree did a good job cutting it.
[17:18] Andrew: Um, Andrew probably thinks that, but yeah, that was I think a two-hour recording that should cut down to like an hour 30.
[17:24] Juliet Antonio: This is one of this this would be.
[17:26] Juliet Antonio: I haven't listened to the rest of Brent's episodes in a long time, but for an hour and a half, that would be one of his shorter ones, wouldn't it?
[17:31] Andrew: Yep.
[17:32] Andrew: Yeah, okay.
[17:33] Juliet Antonio: No, Brent Brent gives us a lot of material.
[17:36] Juliet Antonio: Which means he gives us a lot of good material, but it's a lot.
[17:40] Andrew: Yeah.
[17:40] Juliet Antonio: Brent has never given us bad material, it's just oh no.
[17:44] Juliet Antonio: We can't keep it all.
[17:48] Andrew: You talk about a show for two hours, eventually it's gonna have to get cut down.
[17:51] Juliet Antonio: Oh, yeah, absolutely.
[17:52] Juliet Antonio: Um, I think this was the episode for me that really solidified why Brent is a great guest for the show, because it took a piece of musical theater with a I is it substantial cult following, I feel like is fair to say, or just cult following?
[17:52] Andrew: Substantial cult following.
[18:06] Juliet Antonio: Okay.
[18:06] Juliet Antonio: And analyzed it not just for what it is, but also kind of for what it could be.
[18:12] Juliet Antonio: And the great thing about Brent being a musical theater composer is we're made aware of all these tiny little details that escape our notice the first time around.
[18:21] Juliet Antonio: But are fun to think about.
[18:22] Juliet Antonio: Like, I remember him, I don't remember who brought this up, but there was the discussion of if the West End were to mount this show for some reason.
[18:28] Juliet Antonio: I think I would like it over there given like the West End stuff you covered on this show.
[18:32] Juliet Antonio: How would the accents for it change considering that Edgar speaks with a British accent in the American version in the standard version?
[18:39] Juliet Antonio: And my personal favorite episode with Brent, side note is the bonus episode where he went up against Jess in musical theater trivia and the with cheese portion saved his ass.
[18:48] Juliet Antonio: But if you want to listen to uh Brent's Brent's best episode in terms of like the ones that come out every week, it's this one just enough of balance of ranting and structure.
[18:57] Andrew: Hell yeah.
[18:58] Andrew: Yeah.
[18:58] Juliet Antonio: I I agree.
[18:59] Juliet Antonio: This was a fun episode.
[19:00] Juliet Antonio: Um, Brent is always a joy to have on, and uh, it's great when we agree with him.
[19:06] Andrew: That that is oh you don't ever want to be on the wrong side of uh disagreeing with Brent.
[19:10] Andrew: It's a losing argument.
[19:12] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, he'll talk you under that box.
[19:15] Andrew: Um see La La Land episode.
[19:15] Juliet Antonio: See the La La Land episode, yeah.
[19:21] Juliet Antonio: Okay, episode uh we're in the uh number four.
[19:24] Juliet Antonio: We have this top four here.
[19:25] Juliet Antonio: Top four, guys.
[19:26] Juliet Antonio: So for number four on the list, we have episode 163, which I was looking back and I was like, oh, episode number five is 164, uh number four is one sixty-three.
[19:37] Andrew: Is that Dear Evan Hansen?
[19:39] Juliet Antonio: It's Dear Evan Hansen, yes.
[19:41] Juliet Antonio: That was a good night of recording.
[19:43] Juliet Antonio: Yeah.
[19:44] Juliet Antonio: Because I remember listening to the first time that you reviewed Dear Evan Hansen, the stage show.
[19:49] Juliet Antonio: And uh it was on a long car ride, and I was thinking, wait, is that really what the show is about?
[19:53] Juliet Antonio: Because the year before that, I sang It's Only Us at a Cinema Theater Showcase that I was in is like a solo number.
[20:01] Juliet Antonio: So that was all I knew of the show, and it was a beautiful song.
[20:04] Juliet Antonio: And then I thought, oh, but it wasn't until the two of you did the movie that I was shocked by the information revealed in in the episode about the show's backstory because Pasek and Paul knew what they created and they weren't allowed to stop it.
[20:18] Andrew: And what the—
[20:18] Juliet Antonio: No, seriously, because when you talked about what was it?
[20:23] Juliet Antonio: Did they realize that when they were doing like the out-of-town trial in Washington, DC?
[20:27] Andrew: Okay, yeah.
[20:29] Juliet Antonio: And you know what musical historians will think of Dear Evan Hansen when we're all dead and gone.
[20:34] Juliet Antonio: That can only be told with time, but I can easily guess.
[20:37] Juliet Antonio: And I think this episode will be referenced someday if people were to write scholarly articles or papers.
[20:42] Juliet Antonio: I'm not even joking with that.
[20:44] Juliet Antonio: And I also like how this broke down what was wrong with the movie on a technical level, and also offered an alternative for a movie with the same storyline, the Robin Williams movie that you suggested, Jess.
[20:55] Andrew: Fantastic.
[20:55] Juliet Antonio: World's Greatest Dad.
[20:56] Juliet Antonio: Watch that movie.
[20:57] Andrew: That movie's good.
[20:58] Juliet Antonio: What's that?
[20:59] Andrew: I still have to watch it.
[21:00] Juliet Antonio: But yeah, it's a little harder.
[21:02] Juliet Antonio: I haven't watched it since Robin Williams died, though.
[21:04] Juliet Antonio: I will say that.
[21:05] Andrew: Um, so it probably will hurt hit differently now.
[21:08] Juliet Antonio: Yeah.
[21:08] Juliet Antonio: Well, it sounds like it's already a tough watch, but yeah.
[21:10] Andrew: Yeah, it is.
[21:11] Andrew: It is.
[21:11] Juliet Antonio: Bobcat Goldthwait is uh he makes very dark films.
[21:15] Andrew: I do want to watch it though.
[21:16] Andrew: Yeah.
[21:17] Andrew: You like Happiness, you'd like that one.
[21:19] Juliet Antonio: Yeah.
[21:19] Juliet Antonio: So um, but yeah, this episode was the one that me and Andrew knew like it was gonna be big.
[21:26] Andrew: Yeah, yeah.
[21:27] Andrew: We we went into it with the information because I don't know if you were watching us when we first started, but when our first year of enhanced episode hit, we got a lot of angry, angry hate mail and angry comments, and very met some from the buttons I wasn't on Twitter at the time, so I wasn't aware of that.
[21:46] Juliet Antonio: But I remember like discussing that with the person that I was sitting in the car, and I was like, I think they might be right.
[21:52] Andrew: And he was like, Yeah, I think they might be right too.
[21:55] Juliet Antonio: But you know, with that, that episode probably came out.
[21:58] Juliet Antonio: Trying to think of when I started listening to it, that was probably about 2018 when that episode came out.
[22:03] Andrew: December 2018, yeah.
[22:04] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, and Jared Hansen had only been up for what, maybe about a year.
[22:08] Andrew: Yeah.
[22:09] Andrew: So yeah, I I'm not saying that I agree with the people who are like attacking you guys for that, but I could see why they would be thinking that way at the time of like, oh, how dare you, how dare you massacre our boy.
[22:20] Juliet Antonio: But uh, you know, I think now you know, if they if they're not at least willing to listen, then that that then I have an issue with.
[22:31] Andrew: I don't know.
[22:32] Andrew: I I think that media a lot of younger people in their media think that their media reflects their personality, and if people dislike their media, that means you dislike them too.
[22:41] Juliet Antonio: And that is a problem in society as a whole.
[22:44] Andrew: Fix that world.
[22:45] Andrew: Society.
[22:46] Juliet Antonio: You really want something that'll screw with your brain.
[22:49] Juliet Antonio: Look up the concept of the spectacle of capitalism, and then you'll feel the impending sense of doom.
[22:54] Andrew: Oh boy, death is just around the corner.
[22:57] Andrew: The Joker.
[22:58] Juliet Antonio: And then you're gonna dance down some stairs.
[23:03] Andrew: All right.
[23:03] Andrew: What are we on?
[23:04] Juliet Antonio: Number two.
[23:04] Andrew: What are we on?
[23:05] Andrew: Three?
[23:05] Juliet Antonio: Number three.
[23:06] Juliet Antonio: Top three.
[23:07] Andrew: I was about to say four.
[23:08] Juliet Antonio: Top three.
[23:10] Juliet Antonio: Top three.
[23:10] Juliet Antonio: Top three.
[23:12] Juliet Antonio: The triple crown.
[23:13] Juliet Antonio: Okay.
[23:13] Juliet Antonio: So number three is episode 147, A Strange Loop with Cam Blackwell.
[23:19] Andrew: Um I like this.
[23:21] Juliet Antonio: Yeah.
[23:21] Juliet Antonio: This episode filled in a lot of blanks for me and for a lot of listeners out there because uh who we previously only had like the original cast recording, the Wikipedia page, and then I only found like an accessible PDF of the book.
[23:35] Juliet Antonio: It was it was up on like a uh a library legitimate website.
[23:39] Juliet Antonio: I'm not bootlegging anything.
[23:40] Juliet Antonio: Hi, Michael R. Jackson, if you're listening.
[23:41] Juliet Antonio: This was a legitimate copy of the scripts.
[23:43] Andrew: Hi, Michael R. Jackson.
[23:44] Juliet Antonio: I did bootleg it.
[23:47] Juliet Antonio: Um I think this was, I'm not gonna lie, this was the episode that I was slightly worried about going into because you know, Jess and Andrew, you're not creators, you're not creators of color.
[23:57] Juliet Antonio: And I was wondering if this review would still work even with bringing Cam on as a guest, because I think on another podcast, having him on, he could have easily been tokenized, if you know what I mean.
[24:07] Juliet Antonio: Which is always a concern when I have people of color on the podcast.
[24:10] Juliet Antonio: I never want them to be like, come talk about the color purple.
[24:13] Andrew: Come on.
[24:13] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, yeah.
[24:14] Juliet Antonio: Talk about what you care about.
[24:15] Andrew: Yeah, but I think as soon as this episode started, I realized it was going to be okay because of the vibe that was going on as soon as you introduced the show.
[24:23] Juliet Antonio: And just you made sure that this was treated very seriously, and you made it clear from the beginning, you didn't want this to be dismissive or as ignorant as other white podcast hosts who covered this.
[24:31] Juliet Antonio: And that's why I appreciated how you listened to Cam explain um the meaning of the song Inner White Girl.
[24:37] Juliet Antonio: And you also made it very, very clear as to what the black gay boys who chose to go on Back to the Lord meant with that one lyric in particular.
[24:45] Andrew: Yeah.
[24:45] Juliet Antonio: But there was still humor in it with your encounter with Michael R. Jackson over Facebook, thanks to your cat, Tyler Perry's um threatening comment that may or may not have been the shit.
[24:55] Juliet Antonio: And I do have to say at the end of the episode, um, you mentioned look up Cam on Instagram.
[25:01] Juliet Antonio: His coral outfit was better than the entire Cruella movie.
[25:04] Juliet Antonio: And I looked up that photo, and I have to say that outfit was way better than the live action movie, and I didn't even see the film.
[25:10] Juliet Antonio: But Cam is an excellent dresser.
[25:12] Juliet Antonio: Wow.
[25:13] Juliet Antonio: Cam is a great actor too, one of the best.
[25:15] Juliet Antonio: Um I've seen him perform.
[25:17] Juliet Antonio: Um I got a chance to work with him recently, and he's he's fantastic.
[25:21] Juliet Antonio: Cannot recommend that enough. Um, very, very talented person, very, very good guest. Yeah, it was a that was a good episode. I remember that one. I remember that but the problem with like a lot of episodes, like I think we were like the first, like, uh now a lot of people are talking about A Strange Loop, but I think we were the first one to be like talking about it and bring like other voices of color onto it. I know a lot of other people did talk about it, and I listened to it and had issues with it, but um, yeah, um, I don't know. It just felt very close to Detroit, and I wanted to not fuck it up.
[25:53] Andrew: Well, I also remember it's funny that you bring about like how other people were talking about this. I remember when I was getting my uh when I was getting my theater degree, and you know, I'd the videos of it were just the clips were just starting to come out, like the promo clips online, and I started doing research into it, especially after you two started like talking about it on Twitter. You hadn't done the episode yet. And so I was talking with some stupid fellow students, and we were like, Oh, what are some new shows that you're listening to? And I said, Well, I'm listening to A Strange Loop. And the person looked at me and went, What's that? This was just after it had won the Pulitzer, and I was like, I'm in a theater program where people don't know what this musical is. Oh god.
[26:34] Juliet Antonio: Well, yeah. What can you do? Oh well. Let's go on to number two.
[26:37] Andrew: Number two.
[26:41] Juliet Antonio: All right. So, number two is episode 122, The Prom with Princess Weeks.
[26:46] Andrew: Oh.
[26:47] Juliet Antonio: Oh, that was great. It was. This was an excellent episode because of the discussion about what can be lost in a movie musical adaptation if someone doesn't really understand the source material, which Andrew nailed. You nailed when you emphasized why it's important for the Broadway actors to start out as narcissistic assholes who grow and change over the course of the story instead of just being perfect and absolute angels out of the get-go. But on the other hand, it showed how movie musicals' adaptations that aren't the best can also have their own great moments, like Harry Washington and her monologue that she gives to Ariana DeBose in the movie. And also, this is what I was referring to earlier with Ethan.
With Princess's debut episode, it was the first time in a long time my sides hurt from laughing while listening. Because again, Princess understood the vibe of the podcast right away, and that was what makes her a great guest like Princess, Brent, Ethan, Grace Aki, Emily Clark. The list goes on and on and on. But you know what? Only Princess and Ethan made it onto and Brent made it onto the list.
[27:45] Andrew: So well, we don't know.
[27:48] Juliet Antonio: Okay. To be fair, I had a lot of episodes that I was debating. Uh, Waitress with Grace was on there. La Cage aux Folles was on there. It's like you had me like, and it's I just want to be clear. Making this episode, if there's a certain guest who didn't make it on here, that is not a reflection of my feelings towards that guest. I love Grace Aki, I practice.
[28:06] Andrew: She hates them all equally.
[28:10] Juliet Antonio: You guys just didn't, you didn't put in the effort.
[28:13] Andrew: Didn't try hard enough.
[28:15] Juliet Antonio: Emily Clark, musical theater historian, you didn't try at all.
[28:20] Andrew: No, I'm uh well, obviously. Grace was a very Emily is great. The Prom is just a hard episode to be. Very good episode. It's a hard episode to be. I remember really liking doing that one. Yeah. Um, I'm I'm interested in what number one is because yeah, you've gone through a lot of great ones here.
[28:36] Juliet Antonio: Okay, so I'm just gonna, it's it's a good episode. This episode is two words. You're gonna hear the first word and you're gonna go, what? But then you're gonna hear the second word, and it's gonna all make sense.
[28:48] Andrew: Okay.
[28:49] Juliet Antonio: So I think I know what it is now.
[28:51] Andrew: Oh no.
[28:53] Juliet Antonio: Uh, okay, so the top episode of Musicals with Cheese' and the Keeper of the Cheese''s opinion is episode 121, the week before Princess.
[29:01] Andrew: Rent Revisited with Kelly McKay.
[29:03] Juliet Antonio: Yeah. All right. So I chose this episode because for me, this was the tectonic shift for the show. Okay. Because you had a guest who gave one of your earliest episodes legitimate critiques, and Kelly added some great in-depth analysis about Rent's legacy and why we shouldn't be so quick to dismiss it. And you gave them the space to make their case. And it also sparked a great conversation about how beloved shows aren't necessarily set in stone, which I think sometimes we often forget in theater. We always say it's a living, breathing art form, but we kind of lose sight of that a little bit. And it can be even made better when regional playhouses or any playhouse for that matter gets their chance to update the script and even edit a little bit.
Like I'm thinking about how they portrayed um, is it in Out Tonight where I think Rent Live, they made her kind of it kind of made her more tragic when she was dancing as opposed to her being really happy. It was uh the Hope Mill Playhouse where they made it that she was like tripping on drugs while that was going on. Yeah, but even with the back and forth that you had, there was still a lot of fun going on. And I remember thinking, oh my god, they've really grown and they're gonna make stuff that's even better. So for this reason, Rent Revisited is number one. And then the next week we we we make so many stupid jokes and we go back to our we're back on our bullshit in the Prom episode.
[30:19] Andrew: Well, like I was saying, I wanted a list that had equal amounts of you know, legitimate analysis and equal instances of all of you having fun, but it also being a great time.
[30:28] Juliet Antonio: Hell yeah.
[30:29] Andrew: I I see that as a good good judgment. Um I I love Kelly. They're wonderful. I would have them back on as soon as I figure out our schedule.
[30:39] Juliet Antonio: Thanks, Andrew. Um wait, what's wrong with our schedule?
[30:44] Andrew: Um, I don't know. There was like a month where nothing happened for some reason or another.
[30:49] Juliet Antonio: Oh man.
[30:51] Andrew: I don't think I ever explained that, and I'm not sure I should at this point.
[30:54] Juliet Antonio: You never explained it, so let's never do it.
[30:56] Andrew: No, but I remember when because I was subscribed to your YouTube channel at the time, back when you were uploading the episodes just to YouTube, and I got the notification months later that you that I was like, Oh, they're back. Okay. And I just went back to listening. Like nothing happened. But yeah, that's that's how I was like, Andrew, let's do this. And he's like, I'm done for five months.
[31:16] Juliet Antonio: All right. And then when we came back and we came back monthly or weekly and never stopped. I think that was was that with what episode did you come back with?
[31:26] Andrew: Uh it was like around the time you did 21 Chump Street.
[31:28] Juliet Antonio: Then I know Twisted was our first episode back. We recorded as one of the video episodes, and then our first one recorded for it to be a podcast proper was Little Shop of Horrors, the original.
[31:39] Andrew: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Before you did the redo.
[31:42] Juliet Antonio: Okay, so that's the episodes, and now we're getting into my wheelhouse. Let's talk about the best cheese ratings of all time.
[31:46] Andrew: Alrighty. Let's go let's let's speed run these cheese ratings.
[31:52] Juliet Antonio: Let's go. Let's do it. Yeah. I'm gonna go in the order of the spreadsheet. So, just first up, your best cheese rating is from episode 126 when you covered both versions of The Wild Party. For Lippa, you gave it, quote, a party cheese platter, but cheaply made full of cheeses I like, and all of them are good but badly made. And for LaChiusa, you gave it a fancy cheese assortment, but of cheeses I don't like that are produced way better, which I felt encapsulated the what why both of these musicals are so different. I was like, you know what? That's good. I remember that that was probably one of my favorite episodes we've ever done because I remember being like, no one else has done this, let's do this right now and be the first, Andrew. It'll take a lot of work, but we should do it.
[32:32] Andrew: Yeah, it came up pretty well. I'm pretty happy with that episode. Also, give Toni Collette a movie musical now. Anyway.
[32:40] Juliet Antonio: All right, Andrew, since you're next up on the spreadsheet, your best cheese rating of all time is from episode number 98 for We Will Rock You, and that is the only context We Will Rock You will be on this list. So, Andrew, your cheese rating is and I quote, if someone took regular cheddar cheese that was pretty good, and they threw it in a dumpster and let it get moldy, and they took it out and said, Yeah, you want to have some of those cheddar cheese? I know how much you love cheddar cheese. Isn't cheddar cheese delicious? And I go, wow, that cheese looks moldy and like it's fed in the garbage.
[33:13] Juliet Antonio: Andrew, why do you get to be so goddamn funny?
[33:16] Andrew: Look, excellent. I think that that's pretty good. I mean, you like queen music? You like queen music when it's bad?
[33:28] Juliet Antonio: Yeah, it was it was descriptive and perfect to tea. All right, so Brie, skip it around a little bit. Uh, your best cheese rating is from episode 124 where you covered Fame. You gave the musical quote vegan almond cream cheese sitting in my fridge for two months that I haven't tried and never will, which is how I also feel about Fame.
[33:47] Andrew: I don't remember that episode.
[33:54] Juliet Antonio: Perfect cheese rating. Oh my watch the TV show with Debbie Allen though at some point just because I'll check it out.
[34:02] Andrew: Okay, so next, the best from the guests is episode number 82 with Chess, and it's from Brent, where he gave it stinking bishop. I just like the pot, and I laughed when I read it, so I put it down there.
[34:14] Juliet Antonio: He thought of that all night.
[34:15] Andrew: Yeah.
[34:17] Juliet Antonio: He had four different drafts of it, thought of different.
[34:19] Andrew: Yeah, he worked hard.
[34:21] Juliet Antonio: How do I deliver this? Do I do stinking bishop or stinking bishop?
[34:26] Andrew: Bishop, yeah.
[34:27] Juliet Antonio: It's actually little known fact. Every episode with Brent is fully scripted.
[34:34] Andrew: Okay, and the best cheese rating of overall of all time isn't from one of the official episodes. It is from one of the live streams. The best cheese rating of overall goes to Jess's mom, Mama Mackinally for The Grinch when they gave it a cheese rating of blue cheese, because they blew it. Because that made that whole terrible special well worth it for that one cheese rating alone. I laughed my ass off when I heard it, and I was like, that is going on the list.
[35:01] Juliet Antonio: Oh, that was such a blast. I'm glad my mother made it onto this list. She she will be very happy.
[35:08] Andrew: She's on it twice, but for what other one I can't recall off the top of my head right now.
[35:12] Juliet Antonio: Oh. Oh, for the Tonies.
[35:13] Andrew: For the Tonies, when you covered this year's uh Tony.
[35:15] Juliet Antonio: Oh, yeah, that was fun too. Yeah. Um, yeah, that was great. Um, what was her rating for the Tonies?
[35:22] Andrew: I don't think she gave one. I think she just kind of chimed in every now and then.
[35:25] Juliet Antonio: Um no, she did. Do you want me to pull it up on Sheese right now? I have my Google up.
[35:30] Andrew: Okay, go for it.
[35:31] Juliet Antonio: I don't remember any of this. Uh the Tonies. We might have blacked out that night.
[35:36] Andrew: That was a bit the sad part is I don't remember any of Annie Live, and I don't think I drank on Annie Live. I think I was just exhausted.
[35:44] Juliet Antonio: Oh, yes. I remember none of it. I had to miss Annie Live. I'm sad you had to miss Annie Live too, because I would have remembered it if you were there. Because I just have two professional gentlemen on Annie Live with me, and it was Brent and Ethan. So it's like these two professional gentlemen and me just like, man, Annie sucks.
[36:03] Andrew: Okay, so for the Tonies, your mother gave it two cheese ratings. She gave it Limburger, and that she also gave it peppermint cheese. Didn't say no justification.
[36:12] Juliet Antonio: All right, good job, Moss. Bare minimum, you did it. Juliet, thank you for continuing to be the best cheesekeeper anyone could ever ask for.
[36:22] Juliet Antonio: I know.
[36:22] Andrew: Oh, my pleasure. Um promote your wonderful content for the world.
[36:27] Juliet Antonio: Um, I'll let you decide which ones you want to promote. Thank you. Uh so I am on Twitter and on Instagram if you want to follow me there. Instagram, Juliet Antonio, Twitter, Juliet Antonio9. I am the co-host of three podcasts. The first one is My Dad Listens to This. You can find it on YouTube. We review albums in his music collection. The second one is Where's the Director? Where my friend Aaron and I discuss existentialism and musicals. Our latest episode is Fiddler on the Roof, that is also on YouTube. And my third podcast is Burn Victims on Twitch, where my friends Mills, Cam, and Jaden, and I just talk about whatever's been going on that week. And when I'm not podcasting, I am also a script writer for the wonderful voice actor Darien Audio on YouTube. You can find all of my scripts there on his channel. He is wonderful to work for, and I'll probably be writing another script for him soon. So yeah, that's all my stuff.
[37:13] Andrew: So much great stuff. Thank you for doing this, Juliet. This is a lot of fun.
[37:16] Juliet Antonio: Thank you. I'm so happy to do this for you every week. I'm glad I can contribute.
[37:21] Andrew: We we love it. We love I I love looking at that list because sometimes I forget it. And Andrew will sometimes just say cheddar four weeks in a row, and I won't even notice.
[37:29] Juliet Antonio: Look, I've gone, I've gone out of my way to never use cheddar again.
[37:33] Andrew: Have you though?
[37:34] Juliet Antonio: I have. I'm looking at this list, but I appreciate you doing it consciously.
[37:40] Andrew: Thank you. Thank you guys so much. Um, this was a great night, Juliet. Thank you for your time tonight. And we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese'. Have a happy new year. I think this is our last thing we're posting this year. So enjoy. See you in 2022, guys.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
