QUESTIONS! ADVICE! STORIES! THEATRE! On this week's episode, we are joined by queer surrealist playwright and awesome human Hayley St. James! We talk celebrity encounters, sexual relationships, and so much more! You'll love it. Donate to Black Lives Matter here... Read More
From the show: The Dear Friends Podcast
Featured Shows
About
QUESTIONS! ADVICE! STORIES! THEATRE! On this week's episode, we are joined by queer surrealist playwright and awesome human Hayley St. James! We talk celebrity encounters, sexual relationships, and so much more! You'll love it.
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Write us a Question Here!
Inspired by Someone Else's Problem Podcast by Delaney Peterson & Erin Cholakain.
Social Media:
Email us at dearfriendspodcast@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Emily Socials
Christi Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Christi Esterle: The dear friends of the Dear Friends podcast may be experts on musical theater, but they are not behavioral experts.
[0:07] Emily Clark: And their advice should always be taken with a grain of salt.
[0:10] Jess McAnally: Their theater recommendations, on the other, those are pure gold.
[0:14] Christi Esterle: Without further ado, the Dear Friends Podcast.
[0:18] Jess McAnally: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family.
[0:24] Christi Esterle: Dear friends.
[0:25] Jess McAnally: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.
[0:32] Christi Esterle: And an awful cynical world.
[0:37] Jess McAnally: Dear friends.
[0:39] Emily Clark: Hi, I'm dear friend Emily.
[0:41] Christi Esterle: I'm dearer friend Christy.
[0:43] Jess McAnally: And I'm dearest friend Jess.
[0:44] Christi Esterle: And welcome to Dear Friends, a writing advice podcast for the musical minded.
[0:48] Jess McAnally: Today we have a special guest.
[0:50] Christi Esterle: Oh, I'm real excited for this. Um it is Queer Surrealist Playwright, an all-around good human being, Hayley St. James.
[0:56] Jess McAnally: Yay, Hayley!
[0:58] Hayley St. James: Queer and surreal. Come on. Those are two good U words right there.
[1:03] Hayley St. James: Ha, thank you. I mean, I didn't coin those. Abe Goldfarb did, but no, I took them. I love it. It's a great description.
[1:13] Christi Esterle: Um, and honestly, you we're on episode nine now. You get the flow. Let's not like let's get into the pleasantries and just dive into the questions.
[1:22] Jess McAnally: We're here to help, baby.
[1:24] Christi Esterle: Yeah. Um, Hayley, do you want to start with the first question?
[1:27] Hayley St. James: Oh, yeah, absolutely. Okay. Um, this first question is from Sam, whose pronouns are she, her. And Sam's question is.
[1:35] Hayley St. James: Dear friends, as a queer young person, I recently was outed by a close friend. I love her, but what she did hurt. Every time I try to bring a conversation up to talk about the situation, she closes down or seems to feel uncomfortable. Any advice?
[1:50] Christi Esterle: Uh she probably does. She probably does feel uncomfortable. Um, she's probably um she probably knows. I that's what what I would spend. That would be my guess, you know.
[1:59] Christi Esterle: I'm thinking this is a person who realizes they screwed up and is, you know, uncomfortable having this conversation because they feel terribly guilty about it. Now, obviously you still have to have that conversation, but it's you know, they're not it's not because it's not because they're thinking, oh, this is no big deal, you know.
[2:17] Hayley St. James: It was just like it's always hard when like a friend of yours kind of messes up in that kind of way. Because I I mean I'm I'm sure we've all been there. That thing where you like your mouth catches or your brain catches up with your mouth after the fact and you go, oh yeah, you know.
[2:31] Christi Esterle: And it seems to me you might be in an awkward place because maybe you're both feeling weird on both sides. Um I don't know the situation. I mean, who knows? It might have been a thing where sh you know they assumed that um they were out to everyone, um, and maybe maybe they made that wrong assumption.
[2:49] Jess McAnally: Uh I think hopefully if you're if you're good enough of friends, you you can power through that because the only way your friend is gonna learn is if you're really honest about it. And it doesn't seem like you're coming from an angry place. It feels like more of a hurtful place.
[3:04] Christi Esterle: Right. I'm assuming again. So maybe that would help you power through to just be like, I know this is hard for us to do, but I think it's important.
[3:12] Hayley St. James: Right. And I I think, you know, it's important to set those boundaries. It's okay to sit, you know, sit them down and say, okay, we had a problem here, but so it doesn't happen in the future. This is who I'm out to, this is who I'm not comfortable, you know, being out to yet, and you know, basically know what the what the ground rules are because I think there might be some miscommunication going on there.
[3:36] Christi Esterle: I don't mean to dive into this, but I'm I'm gonna take a little bit of the offensive side where it's kind of like I the the thing that sticks with me is whenever they try to bring it up, they try to change a subject, and that is what's like a real friend would want to try to make things right and not be like avoiding the awkward thing.
[3:53] Jess McAnally: That's what rings badly for me. And I know that we're all human and we all kind of don't react, but the fact that they aren't like, oh, I'm so sorry, I had no idea, as opposed to like Yeah, yeah, forget that.
[4:04] Christi Esterle: It doesn't say she changes the subject though, it says she closes down or seems to feel uncomfortable, which reads to me.
[4:09] Hayley St. James: Well, she says they should.
[4:11] Christi Esterle: Well, that's I agree with you. I agree with you. Um but but to me, that doesn't seem like brushing it off. That that again, speculating. That feels to me kind of like uh like this is awkward. This is uncomfortable. I don't know.
[4:24] Hayley St. James: I mean, yeah, I definitely have had friends who are like struggling to like come out or still not even out to like people they know or like their parents. And so like it's like tough to really talk about, and like obviously, like if I'm like meeting someone that they know that isn't that they're not out to, like, I gotta like, you know, keep it inside.
[4:43] Hayley St. James: I mean, I want to make sure that I don't overstep boundaries. I want to make sure that like they're okay and like when they're ready to come out when they do the feeling comfortable too, like I don't do anything by accident because I care about my friends and how they feel.
[4:54] Christi Esterle: So yeah. I mean, I I think this is a recurring theme on our show. Um, but communicate, um, even if it's even if it's hard, it's and the thing is communication is hard. It's why you give it as advice all the time. It's hard to just talk about stuff. This is why you're writing into like your musical theater to your friends for advice.
[5:16] Hayley St. James: But I I think to me, just your vibe in in the way you wrote this, it feels like this could be salvageable with a conversation and an education, and um, and hopefully both of you will come out of this better. I hope. I want you to. You know, but I feel like you need to be brave and I feel like your friend needs to be open and listening.
[5:38] Christi Esterle: Right. Yeah.
[5:40] Jess McAnally: Alright, I think it's time for songs. Um I I'm gonna force Emily to start this one and we'll do my little L circle.
[5:49] Emily Clark: Okay, all right. Um, so uh let's see. I had I had two that I thought would be good, but I think I'm gonna go with um easy to be hard from hair. Um just because it is easy to be hard, and it's uh it's it's it's easy to go that way. And um what's what's really um actually difficult is speaking up um on on both sides in this situation.
[6:15] Emily Clark: So I think that you gotta uh you gotta be tough and you gotta you gotta tell your friend where you're coming from and be honest about it.
[6:22] Christi Esterle: I agree. That that's a good one.
[6:23] Jess McAnally: Alright, Christy, you're up next.
[6:26] Christi Esterle: Alright, well, um I'm actually gonna go with a cut song from a musical, and that's Congratulations, which was cut from Hamilton, which is a great song about having, you know, a difficult conversation in front with somebody who's screwed up.
[6:43] Hayley St. James: Mm-hmm.
[6:43] Jess McAnally: Um yeah, that's a that's a fair one. Um I I I wanna do my role as the certified young on the group. So I'm gonna use Best Kept Secret from Bear, which is a song about like whether or not to out and when you come out you gotta out your partner and all that. It's a very complex musical, and I regret like kind of how I framed the the show on our musicals with cheese episode. I wanna say the music in that show is amazing and the things it's trying to say are great. Um we we were just we were down on it for no good reason in that episode. One of the things we will redo in the future. Um but that song is really good and kind of sums up like the the trouble of coming out, um, despite feeling it at in yourself. Um so that's what I'm going with.
[7:26] Hayley St. James: Alright, I mean is this hard for me? Because like I mean, I love musical theater songs. I listen to a lot of them, but it's hard for me to like immediately think of one that immediately fits the situation. But I mean, for me, like if I have to like think of one on the top of my head right now, like just making sure that like your friend is okay and making sure that like they're you know, they're ready to talk about things when they're ready to. Um I immediately was thinking Sony alone from Great Comet. Um I don't know, because Sonia really is looking out for Natasha and like Natasha's, you know, she's just you know about to do something really stupid, and Sonia just wants to make sure that she doesn't, you know, go ahead with that.
[7:59] Christi Esterle: And uh, I I miss great comment. I love Sonia.
[8:02] Hayley St. James: She's Sonya is Sonya is good. Sonia's the best friend in musical theater, I think.
[8:07] Christi Esterle: We all need a silly.
[8:12] Hayley St. James: Sonia deserves all the good things, and she doesn't get them, and that sucks. Especially in the book.
[8:17] Christi Esterle: If you if you keep going on in great comments, if you if you read more in peace, yeah.
[8:22] Jess McAnally: Alright. Um, ready to go on to the next one. That was that was a good starter. Like that that had me asking questions about my life and stuff.
[8:29] Christi Esterle: So deep this week.
[8:32] Jess McAnally: We got deep right away.
[8:34] Christi Esterle: Um, so Sam, if you got updates to your story and let us know, feel free to write us in and let we've had updates in the past, so that's that's we want you to be you and be happy and keep talking to your friends.
[8:45] Jess McAnally: Yes, tell us we solved your problem or that we screwed up your life.
[8:48] Christi Esterle: Or that you like or that the music got you through it.
[8:52] Jess McAnally: The music, the playlist made by Emily got you through it.
[8:55] Christi Esterle: Um, all right. So, Emily, you want to read the next one?
[8:58] Emily Clark: It's from Scott.
[8:58] Christi Esterle: Okay.
[8:59] Emily Clark: Alright, Sky. Skye, uh, she writes.
[9:03] Emily Clark: Dear friends, my best friend is in a really toxic relationship at the moment. Despite the fact that her boyfriend is a deadbeat, she's head over heels in love with him. I know this might not be my place, but I hate seeing her with someone so below her. What should I do?
[9:19] Hayley St. James: Oh, I've been there.
[9:21] Christi Esterle: Okay, well, is this I I guess we can't really tell from the question. Is this person toxic or do you not like them?
[9:29] Jess McAnally: That's a good that's a good distinction, and I think that's important to um because I definitely had friends who just have kind of guys I think are losers that they're with, but they end up perfectly happy and they're, you know, I'm proven wrong in the end, obviously.
[9:43] Christi Esterle: Um so I I think that's an interesting distinction to make. Um if it's an actual toxic relationship, then you know that's a different situation. Obviously, yes, you need to have that conversation. If he's kind of just like a bit of a bum Yeah, I don't know. Um, you know, it's it's hard when your friend is with someone you don't particularly like in any case.
[10:06] Jess McAnally: Um you have to it's it's a hard line to walk. It's a fine line to walk because you want to be there and support your friend, but also you don't like I sometimes I have a really bad poker face. Um I don't know if I'm the best person to give advice about the situations because when my friends date someone I don't like, they tend to kind of No. No, it's um I try to um I try to uh let's see, how do I put this?
[10:39] Christi Esterle: Uh my my husband is a good uh person for me to bounce my bad energy off of, so I get that shit uh shit out with him, and I can put on the brave face, but I don't know if I necessarily want to tell you to do that as advice.
[10:54] Hayley St. James: Uh here's a question to ask yourself. Um, and this is something. Um, so my brother does not get along with my significant other at all. They do not like each other there. Cats and dogs hate each other. Um and he just makes horrible mean comments.
[11:09] Christi Esterle: Uh I'm like, let's just say this. You may not like her, but uh have they ever done me wrong? Have they ever done things that would affect me? If the answer is no, you just dislike me.
[11:18] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[11:18] Christi Esterle: If the answer is if they are hurting her or your friend, like whatever, like that's the question to ask. But like he doesn't have a job or something, like that's not a reason to dump somebody.
[11:30] Hayley St. James: Yeah, we are a year into a pandemic. A lot of people do not have jobs right now.
[11:33] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and sometimes like I mean, I don't know how old you guys are, but like when I was in my 20s, a lot of the guys I dated were kind of a mess. And I was kind of a mess at times too.
[11:40] Jess McAnally: That's because you were in your 20s.
[11:44] Christi Esterle: Uh exactly. Like sometimes I mean the Peter Pan complex is real. It's a real thing. Or at least it was, you know, a good decade ago. Um, so maybe that's not so much the case anymore. But like, you know, sometimes you kind of sometimes your friends just kind of date some duds and you gotta sometimes you just get bad vibes off people, you know?
[12:05] Hayley St. James: Yeah, that's true.
[12:06] Christi Esterle: Yeah, that's true.
[12:06] Hayley St. James: I mean, I mean I've had, you know, you know, friends who have had significant others that are like, hmm, I don't really know how I feel about this person. Like, I'm happy for y'all, but like, unless like I see something that's like seriously like, you know, big red flags, um, I'll just be like, okay, like as long as they don't do anything to like hurt me, but if they do something that I know is hurting the my friend, then I'm gonna, you know, go completely all out.
[12:26] Christi Esterle: Yeah, so yeah, look out for those warning signs if they're say if the significant other is saying that you can't hang out with each other anymore or that's a big one you know is trying to control finances or personal movements or things like that or you know always talking over them um those are probably kind of where you're kind of getting into that you know serious problem that if it's just a personality clash it's just a personality.
[12:26] Hayley St. James: Yeah because like there's been definitely like historically with me like relationships have been interesting because I mean I don't really date men anymore but the few times I have like it's been you know if like the men have done anything that have made me feel like uncomfortable like if they're trying to like run my schedule like they have to plan everything around me.
[13:08] Hayley St. James: It's like, but I want free time myself too. Like, there has to be a good amount. I mean, consent in every way is the most important thing, but especially in how you handle each other's lives.
[13:17] Christi Esterle: Like, you can't run each other's lives, I guess.
[13:19] Hayley St. James: I don't know, in my experience anyway.
[13:22] Jess McAnally: Yeah, and the thing is, like, when I have a friend who is a significant other, I don't necessarily like, um, I find that group situations help. Other people are good buffers, um, or I try to be like, let's have, you know, if it's one of my girlfriends, you know, like, let's have a girls' night. Let's you and me, um, you know, friends at home, that kind of thing.
[13:41] Hayley St. James: Um, that kind of stuff helps, definitely helps me get through that kind of thing.
[13:46] Jess McAnally: Now, if this is actually a toxic relationship, you know, I had a friend who was in an actual toxic relationship a few years ago, and I lost her. I completely lost her as a friend. She cut me out of her life, um, and she cut a lot of people out of her life, and I genuinely don't know what, um, is going on in her life anymore.
[14:04] Hayley St. James: Um, but she had a long history of, um, bad, bad relationships and kind of relationships with people in general.
[14:11] Jess McAnally: And it was a thing where I probably could have handled it better, but I was, I was like, you are in an, you know, I, we straight up had fights about it, um, and rather than kind of her confronting it, she cut me off. So, um, and she was my friend since high school, so that was, um, very difficult, and, uh, it's something I kind of, I guess I kind of regret the way I handled it in a lot of ways, but on the other hand, I'm like, well, she was gonna do what she was gonna do. Like, she was gonna kind of make her choice, and that is, um, I know it, it's a pattern with people who are in actual emotionally or physically abusive relationships, um, to cut people off, um, to be isolated with that person.
[14:11] Hayley St. James: Um, it doesn't seem like you're in this place because obviously you're with this person all the time or you're seeing this person. It seems like, um, if the guy is giving you or the person, if the guy is giving you vibes, um, I guess keep an eye out, keep one eye open, just, just, and be available.
[15:11] Jess McAnally: Maybe talk a little, maybe talk a little bit, um, with, uh, the domestic violence assistants in your community because they'll be able to tell you, you know, what are the warning signs you should be looking for, how can I help this person, you know, how can I introduce this, you know, with a, um, in a way that's, you know, hopefully not gonna mess up our relationship.
[15:31] Hayley St. James: Yeah, yeah, and, um, if you just don't like the guy, if he's just kind of a bum and you don't dig him, like, you'll be fine.
[15:38] Jess McAnally: Like, she'll see the light or she'll marry him, and you'll find a way to, you'll find a way to get through it.
[15:44] Hayley St. James: I, I, that kind of thing, I, you know, I've had friends get with guys who I didn't like at first, and then I ended up really liking them.
[15:50] Jess McAnally: So keep one eye open, keep an eye on the stitch, and, and talk, and again, communication. Talk to your friend. Just communication is communication.
[16:02] Hayley St. James: Yes, yes. Talk to each other.
[16:05] Christi Esterle: Actually, yeah, for real.
[16:07] Hayley St. James: Alright, that was so good.
[16:08] Jess McAnally: Song. Um, I'll go first this time and do like an opposite album.
[16:13] Hayley St. James: Um, I'm gonna pick one from a musical that I think doesn't get enough love, and it may be a little too, too disconnected, but I connected it in my brain, and it's the title song from It Should've Been You, It Should've Been You, where like this guy shows up to his ex's wedding and like her family is like going up to him, it should have been you, and like dissing on her new fella, and it's a great moment where it's just like, oh ho.
[16:39] Jess McAnally: You know, no one likes him.
[16:42] Hayley St. James: So that, that rang true to me for this story. I don't quite know the connection, but it feels tangentially connected.
[16:48] Christi Esterle: Um, Christy, you're up next.
[16:50] Christi Esterle: Uh, yes, I am gonna go with, uh, Bill from Showboat because it's about a song for, uh, for loving somebody who maybe doesn't seem to have the most obvious lovable qualities.
[17:02] Hayley St. James: That's such a beautiful song.
[17:04] Jess McAnally: It, it's better than what's the use of wondering.
[17:04] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[17:07] Christi Esterle: Yeah, for real.
[17:09] Jess McAnally: Emily, you're next.
[17:10] Emily Clark: Well, I'm gonna come at it from, um, come from the friend angle because I want you to be there for your friend no matter what. And so talking about musical theater, best friends, we're gonna do bosom buddies from May.
[17:22] Hayley St. James: Aww, yes.
[17:24] Emily Clark: We'll always tell you the rotten truth. It was hilarious, and yeah, you gotta be there for your friend, no matter what, whether it's a crummy boyfriend or an actual, uh, bad situation, you're gonna be there through the thin.
[17:37] Hayley St. James: Mm-hmm.
[17:37] Christi Esterle: Alright.
[17:38] Hayley St. James: Haley, you're up.
[17:39] Hayley St. James: I don't know, but like, because when I'm thinking about like toxic relationships and calling out a person if like they're in a toxic situation, the first thing that came to mind was the great compromise from Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson.
[17:47] Jess McAnally: I don't know why that just popped into my head, but that's Rachel calling out Andrew for, you know, he's, I mean, obviously Andrew Jackson's ultimate toxic relationship with the whole country, but also his wife and, you know, everybody in his circle.
[18:00] Christi Esterle: Um, but he's just, you know, completely focused on, you know, his awful fucking politics instead of, you know, actually like caring about his wife and his child.
[18:08] Hayley St. James: So this is like right near the breaking point. She's calling him out. I don't know. That's the first thing that came to my head.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: I love Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: It is, that show is amazing, but also the only show that has made me feel nauseous watching it in like 20 different ways.
[19:11] Christi Esterle: Like the blood cutting and it's a lot.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: It's a lot. I mean, that would, that show was my entire personality in high school, so, uh, I can handle Sweeney Todd, but as soon as you're like mixing your blood together.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: I mean, yeah, as I said, it's a toxic relationship.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: Yes, it is.
[19:11] Christi Esterle: Uh, it's a beautiful, beautiful show, but yeah.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: I didn't think theater could like make me feel that way.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: That's the power of Alex Timbers, baby.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: Alex Timbers.
[19:11] Christi Esterle: You gotta have good theater that makes you feel gross.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: That's, that's one of the things you gotta see theater for.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[19:11] Christi Esterle: More, more, more great musicals, more, more edgy musicals.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: That was the OG Hamilton.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: I mean, yeah, true.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: I actually remember when Hamilton was first announced at the public, I was, I was reading like this synopsis like, wow, this is like 7076, yeah.
[19:11] Hayley St. James: Yes, I love 7076 too.
[19:11] Jess McAnally: I'm just like for me growing up, and like I remember when the public first announced they were doing Hamilton, I was like, wow, this just sounds like Lynn Manuel Miranda's Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson.
[19:20] Hayley St. James: That was, and that's still how I feel.
[19:23] Jess McAnally: Yeah, yeah, I understand that.
[19:26] Hayley St. James: Wait, it's just because we have like what, three or four musicals that are about, uh, actually, no, there's more than that.
[19:32] Jess McAnally: There's a couple musicals that deal with actual politics and presidents and things like that.
[19:32] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[19:37] Jess McAnally: The problem is you can't.
[19:38] Hayley St. James: I mean, there were all the topical matters, you know, back in the, you know, 20s and 30s and such.
[19:43] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I was in a production of, um, As Thousands Cheer when I was in high school.
[19:46] Jess McAnally: Like it was a summer youth theater.
[19:48] Christi Esterle: We did As Thousands Cheer and we like did the original book, so like it's like topical for like the 30s.
[19:48] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[19:54] Christi Esterle: I mean, it was, it was a fun, it was, it's a, it was a fun time.
[19:57] Hayley St. James: I, uh, oh, I missed that.
[19:59] Christi Esterle: That was a good time.
[19:59] Jess McAnally: Man, early Berlin did a large one.
[20:02] Hayley St. James: Yeah, but like it was that, that, that, that book is just all great topical Moss Hart comedy.
[20:08] Christi Esterle: So it's, it's a good one.
[20:09] Hayley St. James: It's in, um, there's a great, yeah, the great little vignette.
[20:09] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[20:12] Jess McAnally: I, I, I, I am concerned that we won't be able to do like many presidential revamps in the future because Hamilton became a meme and so ubiquitous.
[20:21] Hayley St. James: I feel like it's, we're kind of gonna be lost in the past.
[20:24] Jess McAnally: Yeah, um, because, uh, I mean the hip hop thing has been done now, but like there's a lot of different ways you can tackle it.
[20:31] Hayley St. James: We've done the rock star one, we've done the musical play, and then we've done the hip hop one.
[20:36] Jess McAnally: So, you know, what's it gonna look like in ten years?
[20:36] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[20:39] Jess McAnally: Trump exclamation point.
[20:41] Hayley St. James: Oh, dude, no, please don't.
[20:43] Jess McAnally: Please don't.
[20:44] Hayley St. James: I don't know.
[20:45] Jess McAnally: I don't think the, I'd be interested.
[20:47] Hayley St. James: I would be interested in Baron the musical.
[20:50] Jess McAnally: That would be the only Trump story I'd be like, what would it be like to see all that from like the kids playing Fortnite?
[20:55] Hayley St. James: You know, the Trump administration.
[20:58] Jess McAnally: That's, that's my only pitch for a Trump musical.
[21:00] Hayley St. James: If you do anything else, I'm not into it.
[21:00] Jess McAnally: Right.
[21:00] Christi Esterle: Um, alright.
[21:04] Christi Esterle: Christy, you're next to read the question.
[21:06] Christi Esterle: I feel like you're the most apt to understand this question.
[21:09] Christi Esterle: Possibly, yes.
[21:10] Christi Esterle: This is from Sharon, and she writes, "I'm Christian, but I haven't been going to church for a few reasons. Some of it is work-related, and some of it is because the area I live in is very conservative. People still have T— signs up, and I cannot handle the conversations they have. As such, it has kind of disillusioned me about church. Is it still okay to identify as Christian?"
[21:38] Hayley St. James: If you still believe it, then yes.
[21:38] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[21:40] Hayley St. James: I mean, isn't that like, I feel like I know so many actual real Christians who are the real Christians I know are liberal and progressive, and like, I'm, I mean, I don't know what kind of church, what churches you have, you know, in your very conservative area, but you know, in LA, we got the Methodist church with the big rainbow flag outside, and the Unitarian church, and so many other, so many options of churches that are actually inclusive.
[22:08] Christi Esterle: But I'm sure that might not be the case where you are.
[22:10] Hayley St. James: Yeah, so that's the first thing I would do is look for a church community that you are comfortable with.
[22:16] Christi Esterle: Uh, because I have had to leave, uh, church communities because they were going in an ideological direction that I couldn't support, and more importantly, because I was just becoming a mother at the time, I couldn't see I couldn't support my kids being raised into.
[22:32] Hayley St. James: So yeah, I mean, you know, all the evangelical mega churches, they get all the press and they make all the noise, but there I'm betting if you look, there are some good progressive communities, um, in your area, even as conservative as it is.
[22:46] Christi Esterle: Again, Unitarians are very good.
[22:48] Hayley St. James: Um, you know, most version, uh, some Episcopalian, uh, ELCA in some ways, so yeah, have a look at it.
[22:57] Christi Esterle: And, um, yeah, and you know, I think, I think people get hung up in the idea, uh, and again, this is coming from a churchy outsider, but you know, I've definitely been in my share of churches and sung religious music.
[23:09] Hayley St. James: I was like married before and I was married to a Catholic, so we had to do all that stuff.
[23:15] Christi Esterle: Um, but even, um, oh, I lost my train of thought.
[23:15] Hayley St. James: No, I, I, I, there are so many resources. I feel like people get hung up on the building, um, where you worship, and, um, I know that there's a community that comes with it.
[23:31] Christi Esterle: That's a big, um, appeal of it, but, um, I feel like even if you don't step into a church, if you believe the teachings of Christ and you follow them and, and you follow that mentality and philosophy, then there, there you go.
[23:44] Hayley St. James: I mean, you just are a Christian.
[23:45] Christi Esterle: Like, no one else can, I, I don't think other people, you know, church, how churches can define your religion or like what you want to follow or what you want to study.
[23:54] Hayley St. James: And if you are maybe a little lapsed, maybe, maybe you could look into maybe some other philosophies or theologies that maybe appeal to you.
[24:04] Christi Esterle: There's certainly no shortage of them.
[24:06] Jess McAnally: Mm-hmm.
[24:06] Hayley St. James: Right?
[24:06] Christi Esterle: I don't know, what do you guys think?
[24:06] Hayley St. James: Haley and Jess, I'm Jewish, so it's kind of interesting for me to come at this because I mean, I mean, I'm not even that religious.
[24:16] Jess McAnally: Like I have to, I was gonna say, are you culturally, culturally Jewish or?
[24:16] Hayley St. James: I mean, I'm very, I mean, I'm currently, um, actually I'm currently observing Passover for the first time, like legitimately in a couple years because for the past few years I was living in New York and I was living by myself, so I'm back home because of the pandemic, so I have to, I'm a bit more observant now that I'm home.
[24:35] Jess McAnally: Um, I mean, I've always been like a very reformed Jew.
[24:37] Hayley St. James: Um, I, um, I mean, I really haven't been like super, like observant observant since like I had my Bat Mitzvah, which was like 11 years, no, no, not a lot, wait.
[24:48] Jess McAnally: Thirteen years ago, yeah, so 2008, yeah.
[24:50] Hayley St. James: Um, I don't know.
[24:51] Jess McAnally: That was a while ago.
[24:52] Hayley St. James: Um, yeah, I don't know.
[24:52] Jess McAnally: Bat Mitzvah.
[24:55] Hayley St. James: Um, but for me, like as someone who's had to like study like other, you know, religions and, you know, you know, um, spirituality things, you know, throughout school, throughout like, you know, with their history class, mostly through history lens more than anything.
[25:08] Jess McAnally: Um, I mean, I just find that like if you find something that you know you believe in, like just stick to that.
[25:15] Hayley St. James: I mean, if it's like, you know, obviously like a good thing.
[25:17] Jess McAnally: Uh, I'm bad at words today, but, um, I don't know, like I mean for me, like I had to read, um, in high school for some reason, it was only my English section.
[25:25] Hayley St. James: We had to read the New Testament as literature, even though like I'm from a town that's like a city that's mostly Jews.
[25:30] Jess McAnally: So it was like really like, okay.
[25:32] Hayley St. James: I mean, I guess I'll take this as like a literature class.
[25:34] Jess McAnally: I mean, I had to take it as literature, I'm like, I'll read it as literature.
[25:37] Hayley St. James: And Jesus' teachings were, I mean, he was a, he was a rabbi.
[25:40] Jess McAnally: So, I mean, he was, I mean, so, I mean, if you just listen, I mean, Jesus, like from the text from what I remember, I mean, he's very much about peace and love and caring for your fellow man.
[25:51] Hayley St. James: And I mean, it's pretty simple as that.
[25:53] Jess McAnally: You would be surprised how much of the Bible is, um, you know, talking about people who saying, okay, you need to stop hoarding personal wealth, you need to, you know, stop, you know, kicking people out of your life, take care of, you know, the widows and the orphans and the immigrants in your country.
[26:13] Hayley St. James: Jesus is a democratic socialist. Yes, uh the Bible is hugely anti-capitalist, and I will die on that hill. Um, but there are some great authors um that I recommend um for progressive Christians, you know, kind of to study that uh for uh biblical study and personal growth. Uh one is Nadia Boltz Weber, who is a fantastic Lutheran pastor. If you've seen her, she looks like a biker librarian. She's got tattoos all over the place, you know, short haircut.
[26:43] Christi Esterle: Oh yeah.
[26:43] Hayley St. James: Um, but she has a fan, she's a fantastic preacher. And the other one who unfortunately passed away very young, but Rachel Held Evans um wrote some fantastic books on um re-evaluating um Christian faith after growing up in an evangelical um community. So I definitely recommend looking into her. Haley, I I'm like you. Um I had to read my freshman year of college. I had to read the Bible, the Quran, uh, like the Bhagavad Gita, like all this stuff. I still have them on my shelf just because I love being able like having a teacher being like, you have to read all these ancient texts. So here you go. And um you see the parallels and you see the similarities between them and this important stuff that shines through. And I think, Sharon, that's what you're going for here, and that's what you should strive for here.
[27:33] Jess McAnally: And then as per Christie's advice, you know, if you need that community, I think if you, you know, the internet's a great thing. Um, and maybe if you have to go a little bit to find something. Yeah, I know there is a website. Um, I can I don't know the name of it right now, but there is a website that uh does catalog LGBT friendly churches. That's usually a pretty good place to start if you're looking for a progressive community.
[27:57] Hayley St. James: There you go. Practical advice.
[27:59] Christi Esterle: Like we gave like legitimate like practical advice.
[28:04] Hayley St. James: We gave a place to go, and you can find it. Like authors.
[28:11] Jess McAnally: Um, exactly. And basically, my thought is like research it like you would research a therapist because that's as much effort as you would put into like that, you've got to put into your spirituality.
[28:22] Emily Clark: Yeah.
[28:22] Jess McAnally: For many of the same reasons, in fact.
[28:25] Hayley St. James: For some people, spirituality can be a form of you know therapy in a way.
[28:28] Christi Esterle: So absolutely.
[28:29] Hayley St. James: Oh my god. 100%. I mean, as an atheist, I still pray every night because I it's wired in me and I have guilt if I don't do it. So like it you've got the it's ingrained in some way.
[28:40] Jess McAnally: It says the therapeutic kind of thing. Prayer is like it's like talking out loud.
[28:44] Hayley St. James: Like I talk out loud to myself all the effing time, all the time. Sometimes I stop in my house because I'm by myself in my house, and I just go, why? Why are why are you doing this? And it's like a way to process, and it's it's like saying your wishes out loud or anything. Like it's it's just kind of it it's prayer, but it's it's it's uh it's universal, I guess.
[29:04] Christi Esterle: Like it and there's yeah, I mean, there's a lot of ways to do it.
[29:07] Hayley St. James: There is, you know, prayer, there is uh meditation, there's just um going out for a walk in your local nature area and just chilling out. Just doing the little things that like make you feel more at peace, more you know, spiritually fulfilled. I mean for me, I mean at this point, because um, as you know, uh my religion basically is theater in a way. I don't know, just because it's so much a part of my life, and I I just it's you know, it's some it's the thing I'm the most passionate about. So, like if I'm listening to like a you know, song that I really love, or you know, I'm like watching a show that I really love as just a way of just you know, this is how I'm spiritually feeling myself. I'm just gonna watch this because it's a comfort for me. It makes me feel better about myself.
[29:46] Christi Esterle: So yeah.
[29:50] Hayley St. James: Beautiful. Let's talk about some songs, guys. I I think I think we needed to give some songs alongside this. Um Hayley, do you want to go first?
[29:56] Hayley St. James: I mean, it's funny, going back to my religious here. That's literally a quote from my favorite musical of all time, Something Rotten. And the first song that came to my mind in this case is um We See the Light, which was um, you know, I don't know, it's um it's Nigel and Portia figuring out like what makes them happy is being together, and you know, even if her, you know, father who is a Puritan is very much against them being together because he's a theater because Nigel's a theater guy and Portia's a Puritan, oh, they can't be together. But you know, this is them kind of, you know, overcoming that. Even if it's a dream sequence, it's still just a really great Ugh I love Something Rotten. Nigel is my favorite fictional character of all time.
[30:30] Christi Esterle: So yeah.
[30:32] Emily Clark: Alright, Emily, what's yours?
[30:34] Emily Clark: Um, I'm gonna go, I'm I'm gonna pick an uh a more obscure religious musical that I remember seeing off Broadway in 06, 07 when I was living in New York, and it's this is a song from the show Altar Boys. Um Altar Boys was for for those youngs who um worked there. Um it's a parody on the late 90s, early 2000s boy bands, but um uh they're they're like a churchy boy band, and like there's like the lead guy, and then there's like the closeted gay guy, and there's the Jewish guy, and the guy it's got all the tropes.
[30:55] Hayley St. James: It's got all the tropes.
[31:12] Emily Clark: It's a fun time.
[31:13] Hayley St. James: Oh, it's a super fun time, it's hilarious.
[31:15] Emily Clark: Um, but uh there's a few songs from it that I want to pick, but I think I want to pick the song Church Rules because it gives all the different rules for what you do in church. And so if you're feeling that loss, you could just sing along at home and goes stand up and da-da-da-da-da-da. So it but that whole soundtrack will kind of make you laugh. You'll have a grand old time.
[31:36] Hayley St. James: It's a fun one.
[31:38] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[31:39] Jess McAnally: Okay. Um, I'm going to go with uh Day by Day from Godspell, which is That's why I picked this because I knew one of y'all was gonna pick Godspell well because it actually people actually sing it in churches because it is a very it's got a very simple message, you know. I all I want is to see thee more clearly, love thee more dearly, follow thee more nearly, and I think, you know, I think that's the ultimate um goal of the religious um of you know your religious journey, which however it is, and all the rest is just set dressing.
[32:10] Hayley St. James: It's a couple days.
[32:12] Christi Esterle: Easter's tomorrow.
[32:12] Jess McAnally: Easter's tomorrow.
[32:14] Christi Esterle: We're recording this.
[32:17] Hayley St. James: If I'm not mistaken, I read a thing recently that Steven Schwartz actually, like most of the lyrics in Godspell are just straight up taken from the gospels, and he just reset the city.
[32:26] Jess McAnally: A lot of it is, yeah.
[32:31] Christi Esterle: Prepare, yeah, prepare ye the way of the Lord, a last for you.
[32:35] Hayley St. James: All of that.
[32:35] Jess McAnally: Even Turn Back Old Man.
[32:36] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[32:37] Jess McAnally: Turn Back Old Man was actually gonna be my choice, but now I'm rethinking it.
[32:41] Hayley St. James: Um there's a couple other religious musicals.
[32:44] Christi Esterle: No, don't worry, I gotta back up.
[32:45] Jess McAnally: I had a backup.
[32:46] Hayley St. James: But Turn Back O Man is basically like uh a hymn about being anti-war and like and he reframed it to be anti-Vietnam war when he wrote Godspell, which is a very progressive view, and like using religion to show progressive views, and I thought that was a very effective way. But since Christy did Godspell, I'm gonna pick um Spark of Creation from Children's.
[33:07] Jess McAnally: That another musical done.
[33:09] Hayley St. James: That doesn't get enough love for one. Like I I enjoyed that like show a lot more than that.
[33:16] Christi Esterle: It is a fantastic, fantastic show.
[33:18] Hayley St. James: Steven Schwartz and Angeloid Weber have the religious musicals cornered.
[33:22] Jess McAnally: Truly.
[33:23] Hayley St. James: Truly.
[33:23] Jess McAnally: I almost they have their trilogy.
[33:25] Hayley St. James: They both have their trilogy.
[33:26] Jess McAnally: I almost I almost picked I don't know how to love him.
[33:29] Hayley St. James: Um, from Jesus Christ Superstar.
[33:31] Jess McAnally: Uh that could be interpreted as a few.
[33:32] Hayley St. James: I was thinking either had them on their minds or for Jerusalem, but those were those are kind of cynical more cynical than I was aiming for.
[33:40] Christi Esterle: Anyway.
[33:42] Jess McAnally: On that note, um, I think we need to embrace capitalism for a moment and go into some mid-show advertising.
[33:50] Hayley St. James: Umcialism up to this point.
[33:56] Jess McAnally: Listen to the these ads, kids.
[33:58] Hayley St. James: We'll be right back.
[34:01] Jess McAnally: Hey folks, how are you enjoying the show so far? It's been a lot of fun. Christi and Emily got a lot of fun things to say, don't they? I'm just here to ask you if you'd be willing to leave us a review on iTunes and also leave us a rating, because we're a brand new show, and the algorithm is very much helped by your ratings and reviews.
[34:16] Hayley St. James: And also, if you could, just send it to a few friends, and then they'll send it to a few friends, and it's just a pyramid scheme into us becoming the most famous podcast on Broadway Podcast Network.
[34:24] Christi Esterle: And you love pyramid schemes, don't you?
[34:27] Jess McAnally: I wanted to give a little bit of credit here in the mid-show. Our theme song was created by the amazing Robin Nash of IOU Music UK.com. She's amazing, and if you have interest in getting your theme songs made that sound as incredible as that, go check her out.
[34:30] Christi Esterle: IOU Music UK.com.
[34:45] Jess McAnally: And also, our show is an offshoot of Someone Else's Problem created by Aaron Shilochian and Delaney Peterson, who gave us permission to steal their show format and allowed us to revamp it into what this show is.
[34:56] Hayley St. James: So thank you to Erin and Delaney.
[34:58] Jess McAnally: And if you're enjoying these first episodes and just want more of these advice musical theater content, why don't you check out their episodes? They're still up and running on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, and all that. Get some more musical theater advice content.
[35:07] Hayley St. James: And if you don't quite have enough of Emily and Christi, you can find them on their own YouTube channels. Find Emily at Stealing Focus.
[35:14] Jess McAnally: And you can also find Christy at Musical Hell. They do wonderful content and you'll learn stuff at the same time.
[35:22] Hayley St. James: And I also have another podcast called Musicals with Cheese, where I try to show my friend Andrew that musicals are great one musical at a time.
[35:28] Jess McAnally: And you can find that on the Broadway Podcast Network.
[35:31] Hayley St. James: And you can catch all three of us on the musical theater Dungeons and Dragons show, Once More with Dragons, hosted by Tommy Nolan of Musical Theater MASH.
[35:40] Jess McAnally: Alright, guys, I think that's all we have to say here. Let's get back to the show.
[35:46] Hayley St. James: Hey, how are those ads?
[35:48] Jess McAnally: I bet you loved them all. Alright, let's get into this again.
[35:51] Jess McAnally: Um I think I'll do the next one.
[35:55] Hayley St. James: Um, from this is from Rachel, whose pronouns are she, her. Dear friends, I ran into one of my idols, name withheld for obvious reasons, and they were super rude and inconsiderate to me when I spoke to them. And it's kind of tainted my impression of their work since then. Do you have a good way to separate the art from the artist in a personal way like this?
[36:16] Christi Esterle: Um, it's you know, uh artists are people.
[36:25] Jess McAnally: Okay, in all their messy, wonderful, effed up glory, artists are people. So I'm kind of wondering, you know, is this did you catch them at a bad time? Were they busy? Were they dealing with a lot of crap in their life? You know, this could have just been, you know, they were having a bad day.
[36:43] Hayley St. James: So maybe what you need to do is, you know, kind of look to see for um, you know, talk to other people who've had encounters with them. Is this a habit that they have? Is this just a few years?
[36:51] Christi Esterle: Yeah, did you approach them at lunch in the middle of a meal?
[36:55] Jess McAnally: Or like a stage door situation where they were expecting people to be there?
[37:00] Hayley St. James: Um, and even at a stage door, you know, did they have to get out and get to their Uber like in two minutes and were their kids around them? I feel like when kids are around, you do not approach a celebrity ever.
[37:10] Christi Esterle: Like that's a taste of it.
[37:11] Hayley St. James: I've been in this exact situation.
[37:13] Jess McAnally: Yeah, I I I can tell you, um, first of all, I I think when it comes separating art from the artists is a little different conversation here. For me, I think it's a personal choice for everyone because everyone has different levels that they can take.
[37:27] Hayley St. James: You know, some people can some people can handle some people, some artists who have turned out to be problematic, and some of us can't. And I think you just have to kind of I I think it's gonna be different for every person.
[37:39] Christi Esterle: So if you personally are like this makes my mental health not so good, then you don't have to watch that person or be involved in this thing or see that thing because it's never gonna matter to them and like who cares.
[37:49] Jess McAnally: Yeah, right.
[37:50] Hayley St. James: The other thing I can say is, you know, uh, as you guys know, uh, you know, I went to an arts high school. I I know a lot of I know a lot of people who have become famous, and um, or I know people like in my theater community who are like kind of famous. And sometimes they've been awesome and have perpetually been awesome. You know, I went to high school with Josh Groban, I've run into him at least three or four times in my life, and every time he's always been like, Emily, you know, so that's always been great.
[38:17] Christi Esterle: Oh, that makes me happy, Josh is a guy.
[38:19] Hayley St. James: Oh yeah.
[38:19] Jess McAnally: Um and I have a lot of friends who um who got got famous and are like great. There are some people, some people I've dated who have gotten famous who I uh do not have good feelings about yeah, now I need to get some tea here.
[38:35] Hayley St. James: Oh no, I don't know if I can.
[38:37] Jess McAnally: But not right now, not right now.
[38:40] Hayley St. James: But um we don't need to gossip about Emily's famous explorers on this podcast.
[38:45] Christi Esterle: But that's kind of just life.
[38:51] Hayley St. James: Like, if I met a famous person on the street and they were kind of a jerk to me, I kind of would be like, oh well, they had a bad day. Like I, okay. If you have to know that you don't have, it's we've talked about this before, it's that parasocial relationship thing. It's like, yeah. Yeah, it's like you don't know them. You don't know what they were going through. They don't, and also they don't owe you. A lot of, yeah, a lot of artists are actually introverts when they are not performing. I'm, you know, one of those people. If somebody, you know, came up to me on the street and said, oh my god, I love musical hall, I'd kinda, I probably, you know, kind of, oh, Christy, I hate to judge into myself and probably come off as pretty rude because that is who I am. I do not function well with, you know, strangers coming up to me and starting conversations.
[39:34] Hayley St. James: Yeah, I always duck out. I try never to stage door whenever I'm in a show because I get really uncomfortable and I feel really weird about it. Um, and it's like I don't want to make offend anyone or come off as a jerk. I have like I'm that person who stage doored like everything. I mean, up until fairly recently. I was like, yeah, I have to stage door everything. Um, but there were points I would go into town, like when Something Rotten was running, I would go into town, like because I was going to school in New Jersey for, you know, for most of the time Rotten was running. I was not happy in New Jersey, so I'd just go to see Rotten every weekend. It was great.
[40:07] Hayley St. James: Um, but there was times where I wouldn't even be seeing Rotten and like I'm going to go to the Something Rotten stage door and say hi to the cast. Um, I mean, I am friends with a lot of people in the cast and that show that they're my, they're second family to me. Um, but the more I look back, I'm like, I really hope I didn't cross any boundaries with these actors. Like I always think I look back on a lot of my stage door situations and all the time I've been seeing theater, whether it's, you know, Rotten, Comet, I don't know, SpongeBob, prom, I don't know, all these shows that I love and I'm very vocal about. I know I know all these people in these casts, but I'm just like, I hope I never crossed any boundaries, made anybody in these casts uncomfortable.
[40:42] Hayley St. James: Um really just thinking about like these parasols, they're not like they're human beings. I mean, I'm a fellow artist now. Now I try to like I basically approach stage dooring is do I actually know these people? Like, like, do I actually have like a working, you know, professional relationship with them? No. Okay, then I'm just gonna like, you know, be very, you know, I'm gonna step back a little. I'm gonna give them their space. I treat them like humans, and that's how I've been trying to do with the internet too, because because of the pandemic, so much of like theater stan culture has gone become parasocial because they can't kids and people can't go see these shows and stage door like they normally could.
[41:14] Hayley St. James: I mean, I get that we have like cameo now and like all these like services that let you like do Zoom one on ones with them, which is nice and cool, and like there's definitely a way to help like break down the parasocial stuff, but even then a lot of the times these sites like will give you like in the guidelines about doing the zoom one on ones is don't make it about their personal lives, make it about the business, make it about like being going into the theater community, like as a career.
[41:36] Hayley St. James: Yeah, um, which I think is really smart because a lot of these actors, like they're not like they're not your best friends unless like like legitimately are like you actually they're human beings, they have lives. If you met them on the street and like screaming at them, like, oh my god, I love your work. Like, can you sign? Like, I don't know, pulls out random thing from your bag. Like, no, just like, well, and I always think about like how when people like people online will get really angry when someone didn't stage door, they'll be like, Ben Platt, why did you not come out? I paid all this money. It's like you made all that money to see the show.
[42:07] Hayley St. James: Stage, you know, but I'm not sure. Stage dooring is a not a right, it's a privilege. It's also it like I went to New York for the first time in 2000. Oh, it was 2001 because it was right before 9-11. It was crazy. And it was my first time in Ambroid, but you know, I grew up seeing theater out here in LA. My dad was an actor. Like, I saw a lot of theater, professional theater on all levels. Stage dooring was not a thing. Like, no one was at the stage door in 2001. Um, it you might have a couple people who were in the know who might like I remember I saw Full Monty, and um, and I remember it was right, it was the week that that woman in the original cast passed away.
[42:46] Hayley St. James: Um the Jeanette Chauvez lady, she passed away, and I remember there were flowers out front, and I remember seeing Patrick Wilson walk by, and I was like 20 or something, and I was like, oh my god, wow, you know, and then I lived in New York later, and then it's like, oh, there's, oh, there's, oh, there's like all the time and you know, especially like work in restaurants or anything. You know, yeah, I looked up and Bernadette Peters was there, and I had to just be like, well, I will give you your table, Miss Peters.
[43:11] Hayley St. James: Like, this way, this way. Yeah, it's it's and then, but then there's situations out here. We talked about this this in a previous episode. Like, I have a friend who writes for Variety, and sometimes she'll take her friends to like events. And I've met, you know, I talked about the Emily Blunt thing, you know, Hugh Jackman and I talked about Oklahoma. But these are situations where they are there to do publicity, they are there to schmooze, they are there to meet you. Same with the stage door. If they're at the stage door, they're if they don't want a stage door, they'll just leave.
[43:38] Hayley St. James: You know, like exactly if they're in these situations which are meant for the fans to be there, and they were there. It's not that sucks. Yeah. But if you approached them on the street or in a meal or at the, you know, in a situation where it wasn't appropriate, then I kind of am like, eh, yeah, yeah. Like, even then, you know, if you're like at a signing and it's like they've been out there, they've been there for like an hour and they're getting on their lunch break.
[44:02] Hayley St. James: I mean, that could be a good idea. The entitled feeling, I feel, and I'm not saying this is you, um, dear, dear friend, but uh I feel like there has been this entitled feeling when it comes to celebrities because of our access to them in this day and age. And I feel like we forget that they're just people who have bad days and make might say the wrong thing or just might not be in the mood for it. And I think it, it if that was the situation, I feel like take it with a grain of salt.
[44:30] Hayley St. James: Like I feel like that could be a funny story. Like, oh, I met, I don't know. Yeah, like I remember like to me. Yeah, I remember like for me, like I look back like like right before my 20th birthday. I was, um, my I was in town to see a couple shows, um, and I saw Cabaret with Alan Cumming, and like I'm big Alan Cumming fan, massive Alan Cumming fan, huge, he's incredible. Um, and I, it was like two days before my birthday, and like I was sitting in the orchestra, and I was really looking forward to like, you know, Alan being the MC, because I loved, I've loved him for like ever since like, you know, Spy Kids, and I, um, and so like during act the beginning of act two, he like comes out and he does audience participation with like random people in the audience, and he picked the girl next to me, and I was like, oh, okay, like I'm sad, but like happy for her, it's fine, it's fine.
[45:15] Hayley St. James: But then at the stage door, um, I was trying to say, hey Alan, um, it's my birthday, and um it was really cool getting to see a show. He just skipped over me. And I was like, hmm. It was it was very, very odd. Like the rest of the cast was lovely that came out, but like Alan, who like I was the most excited to see, like didn't even interact with me, like either within the show or at the stage door. But like at that point, I was like, wow, that was really rude. He was that it was but looking back, I'm like, he was probably just I think it was a two-show day. That was an evening show. He was probably tired.
[45:40] Hayley St. James: The MC is a really draining. You know, yeah. So at this point, I I don't even mind that he skipped over me. It's fine. I've seen him live in a bunch of things. It's cool. I've never actually really properly gotten to talk to him or anything. Maybe, maybe Scottish play stage door, but even then that was very brief. But I still love him. He's great. I don't know. The only like truly bad like I don't even really want to name it, but there was a person who was in the Charlie and Chocolate Factory who insulted my hat.
[46:09] Hayley St. James: I was wearing a Great Comet hat, and the actor was like, wow, that show sucks. And he just skipped over me at the stage door. Like, wow. It was like, okay. And I was like, why would you, why would you do that? Because this is the other thing. Some people are just jerks. And if that person was just a jerk, you don't understand. And it was what are you gonna miss if you don't support their content? Like, they're not gonna care. And you'll feel better about it. I mean, it was it was someone in the show. It's like it's not, it wasn't Christian. It's like I know Christian, but like it was it was someone else in the cast who like I was very looking forward to seeing live, and person turned out to, you know, be kind of a dick.
[46:16] Hayley St. James: And I was like, okay, well kind of a dick. Songs, guys. I don't even did we do songs already. I know we've not done songs yet. Let's do songs. I'll go first. Um I am going to pull out a song from all about or not all about Eve. Um, Applause, the musical version of all the time. Yes, yes. You see where my confusion was, and that's one Halloween, just because like that's kind of it's it's about the relationships and how they kind of go all over the place and how it doesn't work out. It's a good musical. Applause does not get enough love in the world. I can't wait to do it on Musicals with Cheese.
[47:20] Hayley St. James: Alright, Hayley. I have to think.
[47:26] Christi Esterle: Um, I'm gonna go with Normal American Boy from Bye Bye Birdie, um, which is a song about the disconnect between the what um a celebrity presents it to uh the public and more what their handlers present basically and what is really going on.
[47:44] Emily Clark: That's a good one. That's a really good one.
[47:45] Christi Esterle: Emily, how about Christine?
[47:47] Emily Clark: I had the same idea the idea of never meet your heroes, but uh I went with uh the second act one where he takes all the little children to go have an orgy, and that would be a lot of living to do because you should never meet your heroes because it turns out they're a creep that'll fill you up in a barn.
[48:04] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[48:07] Christi Esterle: I'm leaning into the uh celebrities are just normal people with lives, and uh they have, you know, they have their own, you know, artistic struggles, and I immediately yet again back with Something Rotten, but I immediately was thinking hard to be the bard.
[48:18] Hayley St. James: Um with hard to be the bard on it.
[48:23] Christi Esterle: I mean I say that I I was in the music video.
[48:28] Hayley St. James: So I was in the music video for that song.
[48:31] Christi Esterle: So yeah, no, it's it's a I mean, as a playwright, that song hits very, very close to home because you know, you know, you know, in our social media presence, you know, it's like, oh yeah, no, I'm writing, I'm doing so much stuff. Look at me, I'm a writer. Oh my gosh, then internally I'm like, what the hell am I doing? It's it's very relatable.
[48:49] Hayley St. James: That's that show. I mean, as I said, that show saved my life, and it's really just become my life, hasn't it?
[48:55] Christi Esterle: And that's not a bad thing.
[48:57] Hayley St. James: That is not a bad thing.
[48:58] Christi Esterle: Uh all right, let's go on to the next one.
[49:01] Christi Esterle: Um, duh, Emily, you want to read this one?
[49:03] Emily Clark: Sure. Okay, this is from Tom, and he writes, I've been with my significant other for almost a decade. I love them, and I can't imagine myself with anyone else. Up to recently, I thought they felt the same way. However, they sat me down recently and they said that they don't think that they're sexually attracted to me anymore. They don't want to leave me or anything, but they just don't feel that connection. I guess I'm wondering how important sex is to a successful relationship.
[49:30] Hayley St. James: If you are not asexual, I would say it's not the most important thing, but it's not nothing. It's it's it's definitely you need more than sex, but if you have sexual desires, that needs to be in the mix.
[49:46] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[49:47] Hayley St. James: Yeah, and I'm kind of wondering what, you know, what else is going on here? Is it just, you know, physical changes uh between the two of you? Um are they, you know, are they kind of reevaluating their own sexuality, kind of going into that um a row spectrum?
[50:04] Christi Esterle: Um, is it, you know Are they having hormonal changes?
[50:09] Hayley St. James: Because you get you get to be um not quite my age, but not too far from my age, and that does affect a lot of things. And you know, I I've been married before, and um when my marriage was coming to an end, there was no sex, like none, no, no, not really any of that going on.
[50:27] Christi Esterle: Um and now w and that's how I was in most of my relationships when they would start to fall apart, and I'm not saying this is for you, this is just my situation, and I just thought, oh, that's what happens with relationships. And I'm very lucky to take in as much time as I could to find my husband, because you know, we've been together for six, six or seven years or something like that.
[50:51] Hayley St. James: And we're still very sexually attracted to each other. I mean, we're not like woo, like we were at the beginning, you know, but like we still like very much want each other.
[50:59] Christi Esterle: It's normal, it's normal for you know the regularity of that to change.
[51:03] Hayley St. James: Oh, and there's definitely phases in life where you're just not having very much sex, like you got stuff going on, but um we've we've never had a moment, and that's how I know he's like my guy because um it was like oh this is what it's supposed to be like, and again, that's not how it has to be for you, but it took a while for me to figure out that if you're with someone you love and and you experience sexual attraction, um if you're with your partner and you still have that before each other, that's that's like the ideal for me.
[51:31] Christi Esterle: For me it is.
[51:32] Hayley St. James: Um I I think I would want to go back to what Chrissy was saying like what are the other what are the other things that are because it can't just be like I don't want to have sex with you anymore, let's keep staying married. What does that mean for you?
[51:50] Christi Esterle: Like it's just are you gonna accept it now?
[51:52] Jess McAnally: Like honestly, this is not enough this is not a fun thing to dump into somebody's lap is that I do not find you sexy anymore.
[51:59] Hayley St. James: I mean, I feel for you because that's gotta hit the ego pretty hard.
[52:04] Jess McAnally: Yeah, that I mean because you know, the first thing I'm I imagine the first thing you probably thought is, what's wrong with me? Did I gain too much weight? Did I lose too much hair? What what's what am I doing wrong? And maybe it could be that you're not doing anything wrong. So I'm thinking this might be something that the two of you need to take to a relationship counselor because I think there might be, you know, you might want to get to some underlying issues and see what this means for your relationship.
[52:31] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[52:32] Hayley St. James: Um Hayley, do you have anything to say?
[52:33] Hayley St. James: I mean, I'm I mean, my I mean, I'm in a position where um I've been in an open relationship for five plus years now. Um, and my partner is Ace. Uh my main partner is Ace. I don't I'm not currently seeing anybody else right now but um we're completely happy and I mean the question said that um how important sex is to a sex relationship sometimes it doesn't have to be at all um I mean at least in my experience it hasn't been I mean I'm I'm an open relationship so I can see other people if I am in the mood for something like that. But my main relationship is purely romantic and emotional and I'm just as satisfied just spending time with my partner and just going out to dinner with them and just spending time with them than you know anything else we could possibly do really.
[53:19] Hayley St. James: I mean and maybe down the line things will change but for now I mean we've been dating for five plus years and we're as happy as we can possibly be considering you know pandemic and stuff because it's never been quite long distance. It's been a weird mix of long distance and not long distance.
[53:33] Hayley St. James: Um but where are you happier and ace conversation comes in it's the ace conversation comes in because and if your partner is ace that's sort of looking as asexual doesn't mean does not want to have sex ever. It just means sex is not really a priority not always um some people I mean there are sex repulsed ace people um but it really just because asexuality is a spectrum.
[53:52] Jess McAnally: So yeah and and and you said that they're they're not sexually attracted to you. So does that mean do they feel sexual attraction at all or is this something sp do they want to have sex with someone else? And that's a whole other that's relationships and yeah if that's not what you sign up for and and this and also this is what happens with relationships in humans by the way we grow and we change.
[54:16] Jess McAnally: If you were where you were emotionally 10 years ago that that's not great. But um you know you might not have done anything wrong. They might have just figured something else out about themselves. But I do think it's somewhat unfair of them to say, like, we're gonna stay together, we're just not gonna have sex. And if you are wanting sex, then that's especially not fair. If you're like, okay, that's fine. I we're not really feeling sexual, then that's another story.
[54:41] Jess McAnally: But yeah, if it I think that's a big ask for you, and I think that's when you guys have to decide, well, what does this mean for us? And maybe we have to take it to marriage therapy or something like that, right?
[54:53] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[54:54] Jess McAnally: Alright. I think it's time to talk about some songs, guys, because that got deep.
[54:57] Christi Esterle: That got rolled out.
[54:59] Jess McAnally: I know. Um, Christi, do you want to start?
[55:03] Christi Esterle: Well, I'm gonna start with where I hope this relationship goes, and that's do you love me from Fiddler on the Roof?
[55:08] Jess McAnally: Or do you Do I Do you Love Me? Fiddler on the Roof.
[55:10] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[55:12] Christi Esterle: Because that's that's the ultimate, you know, we've been together forever, and it's changed so much, but we couldn't imagine life without each other.
[55:21] Jess McAnally: It's nice.
[55:22] Jess McAnally: Um, all right, I'll go next, and mine is gonna be now later soon from a little night.
[55:27] Hayley St. James: Oh, beautiful.
[55:29] Jess McAnally: Um you know, that that's kind of a sexy like with you y'all get it.
[55:35] Jess McAnally: You and I'm not gonna explain this. It's fantastic. It's three people dealing with different kinds of sexual frustration, and it's honestly the most intricate, magnificent thing Songtime has ever written. It's a beautiful song, and um, I think Christi might be coming up for our little night music podcast.
[55:53] Jess McAnally: Um that's it's either it's either gonna be that or Follies, because I know she doesn't like follies. One of those two, it's gonna happen.
[56:00] Hayley St. James: Alright, Hayley, you're up.
[56:01] Hayley St. James: I'm still thinking, because this is hard.
[56:03] Emily Clark: Uh, I'm gonna do There's a fine, fine line from Q.
[56:09] Emily Clark: Um just because there is a fine, fine line, and uh between a lover and a friend.
[56:15] Emily Clark: And you have to decide what it is. That is such a fantastic song, and I still can't believe it isn't the same song as um uh same score as a song about internet porn. There's so many really good songs in Avenue Q like really heartfelt hits you in that certain place if you remember kind of I remember it it came out right as I was graduating college.
[56:41] Emily Clark: What do you do with a BA in English?
[56:43] Hayley St. James: I wish I could go back to college.
[56:45] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[56:45] Emily Clark: These kids are so much younger than me.
[56:48] Hayley St. James: Um, Hayley, you got one yet?
[56:50] Hayley St. James: I hate that the first thing that came to my mind was um I'd do anything for love.
[56:55] Hayley St. James: They won't do that from bad out of the hell.
[56:59] Jess McAnally: Hey, bad out of hell, it's valid.
[57:02] Hayley St. James: I don't know. That's the first thing that came into the hell.
[57:04] Hayley St. James: Oh, I'm so sorry.
[57:05] Hayley St. James: I'm so sorry, Tom.
[57:08] Hayley St. James: That's the first thing that came into my head.
[57:10] Hayley St. James: I'm sorry.
[57:11] Hayley St. James: I just show I've ever seen in my life.
[57:13] Hayley St. James: It's ridiculous.
[57:15] Hayley St. James: I was gonna see it, then they canceled it.
[57:17] Christi Esterle: Oh, I had fun because I was drinking beers in the balcony and laughing at how stupid it was.
[57:21] Hayley St. James: The Usher had to shush me and Jeff twice, and we were like, I'm sorry, this was zombie teenager.
[57:26] Jess McAnally: What is it?
[57:28] Hayley St. James: I mean, I saw it when it was at City Center, and all I really remember from that show is Lena Hall doing Paradise by the Dashboard Light, and just it being the most ultimate gorgeous camp thing I've ever seen.
[57:42] Hayley St. James: I'm like, I this is what I paid to see. I paid to see Lena Hall belt meatloaf in my face, and that's what I got. I'm satisfied.
[57:48] Jess McAnally: The ABBA principle of Mamma Mia.
[57:52] Jess McAnally: I pay for ABBA, I got ABBA.
[57:54] Hayley St. James: I'm I'm satisfied.
[57:56] Hayley St. James: Let's go.
[57:57] Hayley St. James: Let's go day drink in the parking lot.
[57:59] Jess McAnally: Um, all right. Here's the last one.
[58:01] Jess McAnally: And Hayley, you're gonna read this one from our friend Layton.
[58:04] Hayley St. James: Okay.
[58:04] Hayley St. James: Uh Layton says, Dear friends, I'm non-binary and I want to change my name, but I don't know how to tell my family and my work. I'm scared that they won't use it because they're having a hard time using my correct pronouns since I came out as non-binary about three months ago. I don't want to bother them so much by correcting them because it feels like I'm nagging them. Any advice on how to be more assertive in this situation?
[58:25] Jess McAnally: Correct them, damn it!
[58:27] Christi Esterle: Yep.
[58:27] Jess McAnally: Yes, you are not nagging them.
[58:30] Christi Esterle: Yeah, look at it this way.
[58:32] Jess McAnally: If you got married and changed your last name, or you just decided, you know, I'm tired of my full name, I want to go by a nickname. Would this be an issue?
[58:41] Christi Esterle: I would probably not be, and odds are you should it, and you know, it should not be an issue in this case.
[58:47] Jess McAnally: Now you're gonna have people who are you're gonna have people who are still gonna mess it up, unfortunately. I have an aunt who still misspells my name, like 40, what am I, 43 year 44 years on, still thinks that there's an extra E or something in there.
[59:03] Jess McAnally: So unfortunately, there will be some people who will not get it right either because they refuse to change the habit or they're just being dicks about it. But sometimes it takes a little transition. I mean, it's been three months, and it's gotta be you've gotta be assertive about it.
[59:17] Jess McAnally: Because they're i unless they're being actively harmful about it, screw those people. But if it's like a thing that they're just used to doing, all you have to do is just say it's this in the moment, and then if you do that enough, it's it's gonna stick.
[59:29] Christi Esterle: You don't have to.
[59:30] Jess McAnally: You have to you have you have to run you have to remind yourself you have that right. You know, and you know, if you're you know, correct them gently, and if they care about you, they will get it.
[59:43] Hayley St. James: And even like people that are trying to be allies will mess it up.
[59:46] Jess McAnally: Um Hayley, I'm gonna tell the story that did not make it into the emoji land episode where I misgendered you and I felt like so guilty in the moment, and like it happens, and you just politely corrected me.
[59:56] Hayley St. James: It was wonderful.
[59:57] Hayley St. James: Because at this point, like I've been out for about three years now, and people still misgender me all the time. My parents still do.
[1:00:05] Hayley St. James: Um I don't know. It's just it's really just a matter of just consistently, you know, just reminding people, and like if it does get to the point where they're doing it on purpose, then you can be like ultra assertive about it.
[1:00:17] Hayley St. James: Um but as long as you're just really like, no, my pronouns are they them, or you know, whatever pronouns you may use. Um just you just gotta be, you know, understand that like right now there's I mean big generation gap between, you know, a lot of young I mean, unfortunately, because because of all the shit that happened in the nineties, um we lost a whole generation of queer people, and there is such a generation gap between, you know, boomer parents and you know, queer millennial and gen gen Z, you know, kids who are figuring these things out about themselves and more than any other generation really.
[1:00:48] Hayley St. James: So trying to be more patient with, you know, our older older people who are, you know, still trying to figure these things out and understand them.
[1:00:55] Jess McAnally: I mean, if they're not like if they're like intentionally like not understanding, because it's like, you know, it might be religious reasons or you know, um, you know, political reasons, usually a combination of both.
[1:01:05] Jess McAnally: Um it's just it's really just about respect and you know, just the more that you remind them that this is about respect, more than anything, respecting your identity, and just simple thing is just making sure he's the correct pronouns.
[1:01:17] Christi Esterle: It's really just about respect.
[1:01:19] Jess McAnally: Yeah, you're not bothered to be a good one.
[1:01:20] Hayley St. James: You're on the other side.
[1:01:21] Hayley St. James: If you're if you're on the other side and you find yourself kind of struggling with that with the gender thing, uh something I read online, which I think is a really good idea, is just when you catch yourself doing that, just repeat it, you know, a couple of times, you know, saying, Okay, their name is Hayley, they use they them pronouns, and you know, maybe think something nice about them, like they're a fantastic playwright.
[1:01:41] Hayley St. James: So, you know, just get that into your head and make a habit of working, focusing on it and working on it.
[1:01:50] Jess McAnally: I guess what you said.
[1:01:50] Hayley St. James: Haley was really right about like the older generation too, like about kind of the boomer generation, because they they they don't have this language uh at their fingertips as much as you know the the generations that have come after.
[1:02:03] Jess McAnally: I mean, even my generation didn't really have that.
[1:02:06] Jess McAnally: Um it takes a little bit of work, like Chris you go back.
[1:02:10] Christi Esterle: No, no, Christy and I were just doing Julius Caesar, and uh I was cast as Julius Caesar, and I sent like a mass email to like my family about it, just like oh watch this.
[1:02:19] Jess McAnally: And my my uncle, who's like a totally liberal guy, and he just wrote back and he's like, Oh, you mean Julia Caesar?
[1:02:25] Christi Esterle: And I just did it right back because I was like, uh, he's just what what am I gonna do? Explain to my uncle about like uh ever the history of pronouns right now in an email where he's making a one-off joke.
[1:02:34] Jess McAnally: Like, I mean, I was like, I was like, no, he thinks it's it's fine, like it's boomer humor. I'll just you know, next time I fight your good fight pick your battle.
[1:02:42] Christi Esterle: Yeah, exactly.
[1:02:43] Jess McAnally: Picking your battles for me for him to do that.
[1:02:45] Jess McAnally: Like, but yeah, it's true.
[1:02:46] Jess McAnally: I mean, you're talking like 30 years ago.
[1:02:49] Jess McAnally: I mean, we were still, you know, making, you know, look at the funny guy in the dress.
[1:02:53] Christi Esterle: We were still making bisexuals aren't real jokes.
[1:02:55] Jess McAnally: Like, well, yeah, we're still making Ace Venturo the first movie.
[1:02:59] Christi Esterle: My god.
[1:03:00] Jess McAnally: You know, you grow up around that, as Emily and I did, you know, it can take time to, you know, shift that mindset.
[1:03:06] Hayley St. James: Yeah, I mean, for me, like watching a lot of like theater and seeing how we've tackled these sort of like tropes and things, and we're we're starting to get a little more inclusive.
[1:03:15] Hayley St. James: I still get like a little not little a lot bitter about you know how Jag Little Pill handled things, but like I'm I'm I mean, I don't really want to get into that right now.
[1:03:24] Hayley St. James: But the last show I saw on Broadway before the shutdown was Mrs. Doubtfire, the first preview, and I was going in very nervous as a trans person because obviously the Tootsie musical was an affront to my existence and very well.
[1:03:36] Jess McAnally: And it's still the worst thing I've ever seen.
[1:03:38] Hayley St. James: Talk about talk about stuff from the 80s, stuff from the 80s, and like I mean, outfire's from the 90s, and like it's marginally better, but still kind of at least the movie, the marginally marginally better in the gender politics, but still very iffy in terms of he's you know, man in a dress.
[1:03:51] Hayley St. James: How are they gonna handle updating this for 2021 or 2020 post you know the you know Tootsie failing miserably because people were criticizing it, even though the critics didn't criticize it, like actual like the theater go into it.
[1:04:08] Hayley St. James: Um and I I also want to put this asterisk.
[1:04:12] Hayley St. James: We w you've been standing uh something rotten and it is.
[1:04:15] Hayley St. James: It's probably something wrong guys, but I was going in completely neutral as a trans person who is seeing a show based on a movie that I grew up enjoying but have understood to be like not as like howling up as great as it was.
[1:04:25] Hayley St. James: But um just from the first preview, I thought they did a really admirable job updating it and making it more about you know, family and you know, this is a guy who just wants to spend time with his kids and he's an actor and playing characters is what he does for a living.
[1:04:38] Hayley St. James: So this is just one of the characters he plays. So they weren't leaning into man in a dress tropes that much, as opposed to say show that must not be named.
[1:04:46] Hayley St. James: So even then, like I think they did a really admirable job, and I'm looking forward, like when things come back to seeing how if they change it any more since the shutdown, if they've like rewritten anything, because I thought it was really, really good so far, but um at least I mean, can I ask a spoilery question about and it's just a yes or no response? Does it end with the guy that's done shitty things the entire musical going to someone else on a bench and getting forgiven for everything because we no, it is not it is it is not pulling.
[1:05:20] Jess McAnally: No, it does not.
[1:05:20] Hayley St. James: It does not pull a dear broken arm drag queen.
[1:05:20] Jess McAnally: No, it does not.
[1:05:21] Hayley St. James: Because Deerman Hudson and Tootsie are basically the same show. I could go into a whole thing about that. But anyway, they are they are I think it's interesting how like you have especially with I did a whole rant on this Twitter the other day. You like you can only hold art in the context where it was written, and um and and then you have to um see whether it those themes are transferable to your modern sensibilities and um and art can you know progress is evolution, like you can't jump from maybe two gay characters on ski on stage to non-binary trans characters overnight. That took time to get there. That would a lot of time like Lakage, rent. It took these little steps, and you look back and you go, That's not progressive enough. And it's like, well, it but the time it was. It's it's time.
[1:06:05] Christi Esterle: Yeah, you have to under and then see how you can make those themes relatable to now. How can you or hold it in its historical context? I know we're deviating a little bit off the topic, but I think that's something to keep in mind when it comes to yeah, all art and um just brushing something off or being like, Oh, that was written back then, so it's maybe a little got some iffy racism. It's like, yeah, or sex yeah, sexist stuff.
[1:06:28] Hayley St. James: Yeah, yeah.
[1:06:29] Christi Esterle: And we can we can talk about mean atmosphere. Um but you know, you go all the way back to Jane Austen. Yeah, she has some questionable, you know, things about you know, women being ruined forever if they have an affair, but that was the nineteenth century, and in the same time, you know, she's got a lot of what was really progressive thoughts that like yes, a woman should have a to uh have a decision in who she marries. Yes, marrying for love instead of just for position is uh a very important thing.
[1:06:58] Hayley St. James: And yeah, you know, it's it's complicated. Again, we're we're complicated people, we live in complicated times and we have complications. Every time we live in is complicated. Like there it's never not. So, um, so so be be aggressive, be aggressive, and stick to your pronouns, and um I you know, I I've I've told this story on this podcast, but I'm gonna tell it again, um, because I really think it's a good analogy. Um, my my cousin has a trans kid, and her kid is like maybe 16 or 17, and he was a a girl, or we thought he was a girl when he was young, and now he is who he is. And the way my cousin put it was, you know, we all yell out the wrong names when you're yelling out for your kids. You go, here, Susan, you name you yell the dog's name. I just called I just called my husband by one of my son's names this morning. This is real. Sometimes you just I called Andrew by my girlfriend's name on a recording the other day.
[1:07:52] Hayley St. James: I think that and I think you can tell when someone is being deliberately malicious when it comes to your pronouns or your name, and just someone who's known you for a while and is trying to get used to it. Or just saying saying stuff really fast and not thinking about it and kind of rattling off the wrong name. Because sometimes when that happens, you correct yourself in the instant. And then if they don't, that's where you need to come in. My I do that with my students, and I will tell you, little kids will always correct you if you call them by the. I'll be looking at them in their eye and I will be saying the wrong name, and then they'll be like, mean mean Madison, you know, like and it won't get in there because I'm old and I have a million thoughts in my head.
So I I think correct them, correct them, correct them, correct them. Be who you are, be assertive. And if it doesn't feel malicious, it probably is just as easy as by the way, it's they dumb. And then usually I think nine times out of ten, they'll go, Oh, don't you? Sorry, yes. Sorry, thank you. And then moving on and moving on.
[1:08:48] Christi Esterle: And on a personal note, Leighton has been like one of my patrons on musical switch for a very long time, and I got to kind of be privy and watch them develop who they are as they go on. And I just want to say personally to them, since I have this chance, I'm proud of you. You're wonderful.
[1:09:03] Hayley St. James: Yeah.
[1:09:03] Christi Esterle: It's it's great to come together. What a wonderful journey you're on.
[1:09:07] Hayley St. James: Yes.
[1:09:07] Christi Esterle: Honestly, like yes, it's good. Now, songs. Come on, guys.
[1:09:13] Hayley St. James: Um I I d there's such an obvious one that I'm gonna try to avoid. So I'm gonna think for a moment and force Emily to go first.
[1:09:20] Emily Clark: I uh am going to choose expressing yourself from Billy Elliot. Um, because that's what you gotta do. If you want, you could also do Madonna's Express Yourself, but I I think express from the musical theme. So expressing yourself from Billy Elliott, because that's what you gotta do, baby.
[1:09:37] Hayley St. James: That's such a good one. Um, Christy, okay.
[1:09:39] Christi Esterle: I am gonna go with I am El Dolfo from the Drowsy Chaperone because that's what you need to do, is you just need to keep telling people who you are until they get it, and be proud of it. You know, sing your name out loud and long and fast and slow in all the ways you can because that's who you are, and it's wonderful. Another show I did my senior year of high school. Big yeah, fantastic show. It was so fun.
[1:10:01] Hayley St. James: It was really fun.
[1:10:02] Christi Esterle: I was Trixy Aviatrix, and I'm pretty sure the only reason they cast me is Trix and not as Jowsies because hi, I'm I was the only out lesbian.
[1:10:10] Hayley St. James: Yeah, they they do have that joke.
[1:10:12] Christi Esterle: They do have that joke. I was like, okay, that's why you cast me. Okay. But anyway.
[1:10:19] Hayley St. James: I don't know if this was the obvious one, but the one that I came to when I soon read the question was I am what I am from La Caj Offel. Um I I love that song. I mean, I love Lacage. It's a great show. I mean, I think Sunday Park should have won Best Musical that year, but I still appreciate I appreciate Lakaj for what it is. I think Harvey Feyrstein's the thing I should have won best score. That's the thing.
[1:10:40] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[1:10:41] Hayley St. James: Lakage won best score. And Jerry Herman's been writing the same musical score for like decades.
[1:10:47] Christi Esterle: Decades.
[1:10:48] Hayley St. James: But yeah. I mean, I I mean, for me, I remember the first time I heard that song, I didn't know it was from Lakage. I think I heard like the disco version or whatever. But I always love that song. It was always like a personal anthem for me when I was a kid, even though I because I was just, you know, I love being unique. I love being special. And okay, I straight I put the Linda Edder cover of it on my bot Mitzvah mixtape that I gave everybody as party favors. And now me looking back on a show that you know both is of its time, but at the same time was pretty progressive for it. Because you know, it's a sparse about you know, gay people trying to pretend they're not gay, but at the same time you have fantastic moments like that where you know Albin just stands up and says, This is who I am, and I want you to respect it.
[1:11:29] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[1:11:30] Hayley St. James: But for me, like now that I am, you know, out and in so many ways, it's become like even more in hindsight. Like, wow, of course I put that on my mixtape when I was 13. It all makes sense. It's a great song. It's it's a great anthem. Um earlier I was it late last year, I think. Um Chris Eber did a um like a virtual concert and he sang it and I just about died. It was so moving and powerful, and I love Chrissy for doing that. But I love I Am What I Am. It's great. It's kind of like the OG, like out and proud anthem for Broadway.
[1:12:01] Christi Esterle: And I mean Absolutely.
[1:12:02] Hayley St. James: I mean, really, just you know, it's just take that message for that song at heart. That's that's really all I gotta say.
[1:12:09] Jess McAnally: Um my song is gonna be from Kinky Boots, and it's Hold Me in Your Heart, which is like this incredible moment where it's just the specific one is like like where he's like, You missed out on the best part of me, which just made me sob. Like that song is the best part of that entire musical. Um, yeah, I I don't have much to say, but I Leighton, I hope you I hope you like those tunes. Rock out to them, Leighton. Rock your non-binary heart out!
[1:12:36] Hayley St. James: Yeah, absolutely.
[1:12:38] Jess McAnally: Alright. On that note, I think that wraps us up for the day. Hayley, do you have stuff you want to promote out for the week?
[1:12:43] Hayley St. James: Ooh, me right now? Hmm, not not I mean, I guess I'm having a uh play reading at the end of the month, beginning of May through a SUNY Plattsburg. Um I haven't I don't have all the information yet, but they're doing a zoom reading of one of my Zoom plays that I wrote last month. So that's gonna be fun. Um other than that, I mean I mean I'm on the emoji land episode of Musicals with Cheese, so please stream that episode and hear me and Jess and Andrew scream about Lucas Steele. It's great.
[1:13:09] Christi Esterle: Um also like I know like the gal who wrote it and like two cast members, so like that's so crazy that you guys did that. I did I did this show called the Art Couple with Laura like uh a few years ago. And then she like she was involved in my theater company, and then she's like, I'm off to New York. Laura's crazy's a gift. I adore that woman. She's so talented. So wonderful. Um, but yeah, I'm on that episode. Um other than that, like not really. I'm just you know, you can find me on Twitter at Hayley St. James. Please follow. Great Twitter. I I'm up to a lot of shenanigans. It's it's a good time. But yeah, that's me.
[1:13:43] Jess McAnally: Fantastic. Alright, Emily Christie, promote your stuff out there.
[1:13:46] Emily Clark: Yeah, uh I'm I'm uh what am I? Um I my show is Stealing Focus on YouTube. I talk about musical theater history. Um I'm going to grad school for that right now, so if you need history, I'm your gal. Um I I'm at Emily A. B. Clark. It looks like Emily Clark on pretty much everything on Twitter, Insta, TikTok. Um, and uh Patreon Stealing Focus and Christy.
[1:14:18] Christi Esterle: And I'm at Musical Hell, uh YouTube, Twitter, Patreon. Uh by the time this airs, I will have merch on Teespring. So yeah, check it out. I've seen it. It looks amazing. I'm on her Patreon, so I get to look at these cool things. It looks great. I've been I've been a fan of music of uh musical hell for eons, so I may just have to get some of that. Great stuff, great stuff. Um I'm on musicals with cheese. Look look up if you like the the the re rapport between Hayley and I. Emoji Land episode. Come on. Come on. It's like a great episode. You've all been on musicals with cheese, it's fantastic.
[1:14:52] Hayley St. James: Yes, everyone has.
[1:14:54] Jess McAnally: Oh my gosh. When am I in Jon again, you jerk?
[1:15:00] Emily Clark: In June too.
[1:15:01] Jess McAnally: Oh, June, June, June, yes.
[1:15:02] Emily Clark: In October.
[1:15:03] Jess McAnally: June, June.
[1:15:04] Emily Clark: June.
[1:15:05] Jess McAnally: Just bust it out all the time.
[1:15:08] Hayley St. James: Emily is coming back on soon. I just need to figure out her timeline because I know she's at grad school and like the time differences kind of throw us off. But it's gonna happen.
[1:15:16] Emily Clark: It's like after May, I'll have a lot more time. And I'll have a lot more shows in my head. Because, you know, right.
[1:15:24] Jess McAnally: Oh. Well, if you got one in your mind, always feel free to reach out. Like, I uh Hay Haley does that all the time. It's great.
[1:15:29] Hayley St. James: It's like every day. It's like, hey, have you done this yet? No. Okay.
[1:15:34] Jess McAnally: Alright. I guess guess we'll have you on eventually for that.
[1:15:37] Hayley St. James: Just bring me on to talk about the old things.
[1:15:39] Jess McAnally: All the old stuff.
[1:15:41] Hayley St. James: All the oldies.
[1:15:43] Christi Esterle: Or the like the very obscure ones. Like I love obscure ones and doing it on our show because that means Jim and Tomic won't get to it.
[1:15:51] Jess McAnally: No, but I might if it's bad enough.
[1:15:54] Hayley St. James: Yeah, you just did Superman. I was I had plans for Superman.
[1:16:01] Christi Esterle: You've got possibilities. I think you guys.
[1:16:05] Hayley St. James: That song's amazing.
[1:16:08] Jess McAnally: That score. Fully slaps.
[1:16:10] Christi Esterle: The score is fun, but they like the TV version, like this weird disco remix of it.
[1:16:15] Jess McAnally: It's yeah. On that note, thank you guys for listening. We're on iTunes Spotify Stitcher at DearFriend Podcast. Leave us some reviews. We need more reviews. We're on Twitter at DearFriendPod. Um Patreon. We all have our individual Patreons and on each of them. You can join any of them. It could be me, Christy, Emily. You will get the video episodes. You can see Hayley's wonderful face right now, looking right into the camera. Um we're on Instagram at DearFriendsPodcast. Email us at DearFriendspodcast at gmail.com. Send us in some questions. We love your questions and we want more of them. Um just go to our Twitter, click the link, you'll get there. Um, our show is an offshoot of someone else's problem created by Aaron Shilock and Delaney Peterson, who gave us permission to outright steal their format for this show. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform.
[1:17:03] Christi Esterle: Alright, you guys. Is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this on up?
[1:17:06] Hayley St. James: Take care.
[1:17:09] Christi Esterle: Be good to yourselves and stay awesome.
[1:17:12] Jess McAnally: Thank you.
[1:17:12] Hayley St. James: You've got to be a good idea.
[1:17:18] Jess McAnally: Alright, bye.
[1:17:19] Hayley St. James: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family. Dear friends, they will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom. And anecdotes in an awfully cynical world. Dear friends.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
