Skip to main content
BPN Logo
The Outsiders | Theatre in the D

This week Jess and Miranda talk about the National Tour of "The Outsiders" based on S.E. Hinton's novel of the same name. You can see the show at the fisher theater from Mar 3 - 15, 2026. You can buy your tickets here... Read More

From the show: The Dear Friends Podcast

22 mins
Jul 18

Featured Shows

About

This week Jess and Miranda talk about the National Tour of "The Outsiders" based on S.E. Hinton's novel of the same name. You can see the show at the fisher theater from Mar 3 - 15, 2026.

You can buy your tickets here.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:35] Jess McAnally: Hello and welcome to another extra special episode of Theatre in the D. I am joined as always by my favorite person in the world, Miranda Moffat.

[0:42] Miranda Moffat: Hello, everyone.

[0:43] Jess McAnally: And today we were invited to go see The Outsiders at the Fisher Theater. Thank you to ATG in Detroit for making it happen. And what an experience this was.

[1:05] Miranda Moffat: And like actual physical things happening on stage that made me feel in awe.

[1:10] Jess McAnally: I agree with that. And just to give you some background on this, so for The Outsiders, the book was by Adam Rapp with Justin Levine. Music and Lyrics by Jamestown Revival, which comprises of Jonathan Clay and Zach Chance, as well as Justin Levine. And it was directed by Dana Taymore. Also, The Outsiders is based on the novel by S.E. Hinton and Francis Ford Coppola's motion picture, which is probably more well known.

[1:36] Miranda Moffat: For me personally, I had absolutely zero background knowledge on The Outsiders. I have never read the book. I had never seen the movie before, and I think as we discussed before we saw it, it's something that I generally just lump in with 80s movies about white boys. I get them all mixed up. Like I think I mixed this one up with The Lost Boys and The Goonies, and like I literally thought that Josh Brolin was... I was convinced that Josh Brolin was in this movie, but he's absolutely not. It's all just white boys from the 80s for me. So I had no context for what this was, but I agree with you. I think its major point of strength is the staging. The thing it has things that you have never seen before on a musical theater stage, I think.

[2:21] Jess McAnally: Um, and I think it was, you know, as far as the story is told, very well presented. Now I did read The Outsiders in high school, Miss Hill's eighth grade English class. And I also watched the film, the Francis Ford Coppola film. And here's my shocking, shocking remark. I did not like either of those experiences. I was not a fan of this book. I was not a fan of that film. I had a thoroughly good time watching this stage musical though, which was shocking to me. It is in that same vein of 80s white boys are upset about the world that they were given. But it having removed from that and having it presented in this way, and from this very point of view narration from our lead character Pony Boy, I don't think I've seen direct to audience communication done so effectively in a stage musical in a very long time where it is done for both dramatic effect and comedic effect in equal measure, and it works so well. I truly believe the best form for this story is on stage.

[3:33] Miranda Moffat: Obviously, I cannot confirm or deny that perspective as I have not seen either. I would be very interested to see the movie itself now that I know who's in it, like a young Tom Cruise and God, who else was in the movie?

[3:47] Jess McAnally: Who?

[3:47] Miranda Moffat: Patrick Swayze.

[3:48] Jess McAnally: Patrick, oh yes, Patrick Swayze. Rob Lowe, like, you know, a lot of components of the brat pack there. I would be very interested to see how it translates. Because from what you have told me at least, it seems like maybe the book and movie had a slightly more sort of like homoeroticism almost. Is that a fair take?

[4:10] Jess McAnally: I just think it's more subtext than it is me. That's me reading into it because this really is a romance between Johnny Cage and Pony Boy. And when you watch it on screen and you have the intimacy and living in a church, it's just like, ooh, these boys are in love, and there's like that vibe. We're on the stage. It kind of gives that air of removal and that kind of third wall break where it doesn't hit as much in that same way.

[4:36] Miranda Moffat: That's what I was gonna, yeah. That would be my take is that there's, you know, you kind of set me up with that as a potential thought for what I could expect, and it definitely was not that in my take. I'm sure that you know you could very appropriately and soundly say like have an interpretation of that way. But you know, from my reading of it, it was just more like very close friends who are sort of bonded, you know, trauma bonded also almost by their experiences growing up in this time period in this very difficult, you know, area in being sort of, you know, downtrodden both economically and also socially as part of, you know, kind of a class system that exists in that era and then in that area specifically, I think in Oklahoma, if I'm remembering correctly.

[5:21] Jess McAnally: Um, so yeah, I thought those things were very well represented. One of the things that I thought was interesting is that in the playbill itself, they give a little bit of a excerpt from one of S.E. Hinton's, so I guess was Susie Hinton's op-eds that she published in the New York Times in 1967, called Teenagers Are For Real. And I'll just I'll read you a small excerpt of it because I thought that it was I think relevant to the show and also just to like context of the time period. But it says all we hear is how teenagers are rebelling against authority, against country, against parents. This is partly true. It is more true that all we are doing most of the time is asking why and getting as an answer because it's always been done that way.

If there were more stopping and explaining why it's always been done this way, there'd be more understanding. Understanding breeds communication. There we are back at the root of the matter. And I think that that is a very poignant sort of excerpt that goes back to like the heart of the story itself and also just like the time period itself of having a lot of, you know, a lot of angst and a lot of questions about society, which I think is pretty well represented in the musical.

[6:35] Miranda Moffat: Uh and also just a question for like the boomers, where did that energy go?

[6:35] Jess McAnally: Um, where did that energy go?

[6:43] Miranda Moffat: It went to their $800 house they're selling for 2.6 million dollars today.

[6:47] Jess McAnally: Yeah, they bought that thing for a penny and a few raspberries, and now they're able to sell it for 1.1 million. So, you know, they were willing to give up their soul in that exchange, maybe. What do you think the plot for those that have never seen The Outsiders, if you had to give a general summary, would be?

[7:02] Miranda Moffat: For me, I thought it was kind of untraditional in the sense that it felt almost like a slice of life type movie, sort of like a Juno almost, where there's not, well, maybe not Juno particularly, but it's just sort of like the focus is just on like the, you know, relationships and the lives of these few people giving sort of a slice of what their individual lives look like. But I think definitely it got a little bit more plot heavy in the second act.

[7:27] Jess McAnally: Um, but I would say generally it's almost like a West Side Story type dynamic where you've got, you know, two sections of town, the east side and the west side, that are, you know, the more posh socias on one side, and then you've got the greasers on the other side who are more low-class blue-collar folks. And there's just basically the dynamic of infighting between those two groups for survival, and also just like a basically just like a portrait of life at that time and the difficulties that came with it for me.

[8:01] Miranda Moffat: And then you also have the core relationships of these, this found family, which we have in the Greasers, where and this blood family where you have Pony Boy, his brother Soda Pop, and his eldest brother, who I am forgetting the name of, and for some reason I feel like it's Daryl or something.

[8:18] Jess McAnally: It is Daryl.

[8:19] Miranda Moffat: Daryl. And the domestic side of that really feels compelling to me. And the movie especially does not dwell on that, and I remember that was really the thing that I felt connected to in the books, and here I am very glad. Maybe to a fault in Act Two, they really leaned into that being the emotional core, opposed to the Johnny Cage and Pony Boy connection.

[8:45] Jess McAnally: Um, I do want to highlight while this is a slice of life kind of story, it is visually impressive at every turn. It is an extravaganza, it is something to be seen. So much that the fight scenes are the most impressive part of this. There is no real dancing, there is no like real choreography outside of these really intense, beautifully staged, well-lit fight scenes.

[9:16] Miranda Moffat: And I don't talk about sound design in a musical very much. Here, that is almost what is at the forefront is the sound, um, and how it is used to tell the story narratively. And I've never seen like flashlights being used, both as narrative tools for searchlights as well as lighting. The actors are lighting the other characters on stage, and there's stuff I've never seen before as far as stagecraft goes, and that's not even bringing up the Act Two climax, which is rain on stage used for a fight scene, and I'm just like trying to figure out the logistics of microphones and trying to figure out when they got turned off and when they were removed and when they get put back on. It is a logistical nightmare, I imagine, behind the scenes, but such theatrical magic on stage.

[10:11] Jess McAnally: Yeah, I use this turn of phrase a lot when I discuss musicals, but I think it's accurate to say that it's a magic trick, and there are more and less elements in certain shows, but this one definitely has a lot of magic tricks. And also something I thought of frequently while I was watching it, is only young people could do this. There are definitely a lot of things that the main actors are doing on stage that it is incredibly risky in my mind for actors to be doing, to be, you know, climbing on sets without clear supports and flipping over each other and, you know, hopping off of things, all of that stuff. The choreography was very impressive. You know, as far as the songs go, I like them, and there were a few numbers that I did really enjoy.

[11:00] Jess McAnally: I think the "Great Expectations" song was probably my favorite moment with all of the different harmonies kind of coming together at one. That's like a very intense moment where it feels very appropriate to have that kind of song be used. Um, so I did enjoy the songs. Um, but I think more impressive than that was, yes, the choreography, the use of the lighting, you know, using things to tell you where you are in time and also in story and in emotion. Um, I will say if you're a fellow visual snow syndrome sufferer, this may not be for you. Um, they do flash lights into your eyes very frequently, and it also can be very dark at times. That would be my one complaint, but that's like a very, very personal complaint.

Otherwise, I think, yeah, the sound design and also the lighting choices were very, very effective to tell the story and also to tell you who the characters were. I know I'm often the negative one between us at these, and I hate being it, but this is a pet peeve with me in modern musical theater. I don't love when people that aren't musical theater writers write for musical theater. Every one hundredth time it happens, you get a Sara Bareilles who really understands it with "Waitress." Most of the other times, the songs kind of stop the story as opposed to tell the story. And here that was very much the case, aside from maybe two songs. Um, and both of them belong to the gentleman that leads the Greasers, who is probably the MVP.

If I had to pick an actor, I would say that both of his songs really kind of stopped the show in a good way. Whereas the rest of the songs were so let's stop and have a song, and then we're gonna have the plot, then we're gonna stop and have a song, that part of me was truly wondering if I would have enjoyed it more if it was a play, like a straight play with the same effects. Um, but the songs were good, they just weren't pushing the story, so I was like frustrated almost. That is a pet peeve of mine where I'm just like, maybe if we found someone that was trained in musical theater writing to kind of judge these up a bit, because the songs are there, the storytelling just wasn't for me.

[13:29] Miranda Moffat: I would agree partially. I think the songs were a bit of a mixed bag in the sense that, you know, as I've said multiple times, I think often musical theater does have songs that are musical theater-y, that sort of like we had a story that we decided we had to tell in song that wasn't necessarily meant to be in song, like that. There's just the quality of it. I always use like "Legally Blonde" or "Mean Girls" as an example sometimes of those songs where it's just like those ones. Those are fine. Let let's not be, I'm not a hater. Um, they're fine, and there are a lot of things about those that I like, but there is a specific quality to musicals sometimes where it's so musical theater-y that it almost takes you out of it.

Um, and there were some of those in here. Uh, and I agree that sometimes the songs do sort of stop the progress of the show itself. Um, and that's a problem I see all the time. So it did have a little bit of that, but I think it also had enough that it was still very enjoyable and very other moments were very redeeming of those things for me personally. So I overall liked them, and like I said, "Great Expectations," I think, and a lot of the harmonies that they were able to achieve were some of my favorite parts when they were all sort of singing in tandem, and that moment in particular felt like the emotion was big enough that it needed a song, needed to be said in song.

[14:51] Jess McAnally: But yes, I think as you said before, the most impressive moment to me is that fight scene in the rain, and I think it is meant to be that's the big climax sort of of the whole production where it's raining and also something we haven't mentioned yet, is that the entire floor is all this sort of like rock, like almost like you'd be on a playground with like some very loose rock. So every time they would dance around or move or run, they would be, you know, sliding around or kicking up these rocks. And so that was used to great effect in that fight scene, which was, yeah, like basically a choreographed dance of them sort of like it looked very brutal, very brutal. Brutal and beautiful, brutal.

It did look very brutal and very fight-like, um, as well as being very like choreographed and like gorgeous in movement. I remember at the Tony Awards they performed that like as opposed to performing a proper song, which I kinda did, they performed that fight scene at the Tony Awards. And I that was what most people went away with, and I was just entering, like, there's no way we're getting that. There's no way. I think I had a conversation with you beforehand. I'm like, there's no way we're getting that rain machine fight. It's not happening.

[16:01] Miranda Moffat: Um, it leaves me to wonder if when "The Notebook" tours, if we're gonna get their rain sequence too. We'll see. Um, I do want to talk Tony's for a brief moment because this one best musical at the Tony's the 2024 Tonys, but lost best book and best music to a show we'll be seeing in a few weeks, "SUFs" by Shana Taub. And Shayna Taub is a proper musical theater writer, in my opinion. However, I think the book in this is a lot more impressive than the book to "SUFs." But it's also confusing. Like they picked this for best musical, but did not award either its book or its score. What it's like, are you impressed by the actual stagecraft or are you impressed by the time you had? Explain, Tony Voters, explain.

[16:50] Jess McAnally: Um, I wanna say a few more things. This cast, as young as it is, absolutely perfect in what they're doing, like and building camaraderie and making it feel honest, and I know they're on the road together and spending all these days together, um, but it often doesn't translate, and here it really, really does. You feel the connections of people that are related, sh feel related. I would say, without a doubt, if you can go see this, go see it. You're gonna have a good time and leave feeling so many feelings, heartbreak, joy, all the things you want in a theatrical experience.

[17:25] Miranda Moffat: Um, Jess, what is your overall thoughts on your cheese rating?

[17:29] Jess McAnally: My overall thoughts is that coming in with absolutely no context and zero expectations, I had a very good time. Um, I very much enjoyed it, and despite them flashing lights in my eyes 24/7 while I was seeing the show, um, I think everything about it is used to the greatest effect to tell the story in the best way possible. I think it would be hard to beat as far as the other adaptations, so I'm excited to see kind of how those compare. Um, but overall, very enjoyable, as you said, the cast, absolutely amazing, 10 out of 10. I just I cannot believe some of the things they were doing. The general talent, of course, in singing, but also the dancing and the general athleticism required for those roles is a very, very high bar.

So I'm, you know, I was just like very impressed. It's just very impressive and enjoyable to watch. I think my cheese rating would be like, you know, those I don't know if they still make these, they must. Those old Kraft singles, like the individually packaged American cheese Kraft singles.

[18:32] Miranda Moffat: Yes.

[18:33] Jess McAnally: That would be my cheese rating for this, because it does feel like it is kind of a slice of life Americana from that particular, you know, period in time. Um, so yeah, that would be my rating. Go see it if you can.

[18:46] Miranda Moffat: I agree.

[18:46] Jess McAnally: And if I'm to bring one more bit of criticism onto my overall thoughts, the romantic plot between Pony Boy and Cherry never works for me in any adaptation. Um, she feels like, you know, just a connection to like the Socs and a piece of not gay, so you don't think Pony Boy is gay. Um, but aside from that, I had a great time. I'm giving this government cheese because they're too poor to afford real cheese.

[19:17] Miranda Moffat: Now, correct me if I'm wrong. Our next show we will be seeing is "The Lion King" at the Detroit Opera House on March 12th. And this is going to be, I believe, my third time seeing "The Lion King."

[19:28] Jess McAnally: Is it your second?

[19:29] Miranda Moffat: It might also be my third time, third or fourth. Because I think I saw it. I know I saw it when I was a kid, and I think we saw it together a couple years ago. So yeah, this is gonna be my like third or fourth time.

[19:40] Jess McAnally: So I'm still excited for it. It's always a good time. "Lion King" is always a good time. That is baby's first vague theatrical.

[19:48] Miranda Moffat: Like we are taking the big ideas of avant-garde theater and breaking it down to a Disney digestible way.

[19:55] Jess McAnally: It is the most financially profitable thing Disney has ever made. That musical has made more money than any film they've ever done. It is effective for a reason, and already, like, you don't have to wait for our opinions. I've done an episode with Andrew on it. It's a good show, and I can't wait to see it and talk about it more. Um, I hear they've cut it down a little bit for timing, so a couple songs might have gotten cut. So I'm curious to see how that implements.

[20:22] Miranda Moffat: I hope not.

[20:22] Jess McAnally: I mean, this is sometimes that's a good thing. Sometimes that's fine. Less so in "Shrek the Musical," though.

[20:29] Miranda Moffat: Um, Miranda, anything else you want to say before we wrap on up?

[20:32] Jess McAnally: No, just thank you again to ATG in Broadway, and I hope that you all enjoyed the episode. Thank you very much, and we'll see you next time on "Theatre in the D."

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred