Skip to main content
BPN Logo
 55 - James Lapine

James Lapine is an American stage director, playwright, screenwriter, and librettist. He has won the Tony Award for Best Book of a Musical three times, for Into the Woods, Falsettos, and Passion. He has frequently collaborated with Stephen Sondheim and William Finn... Read More

From the show: The Producer's Perspective Podcast with Ken Davenport

44 mins
1/18/16

Guests

Featured Shows

About

James Lapine is an American stage director, playwright, screenwriter, and librettist. He has won the Tony Award for Best Book of a Musical three times, for Into the Woods, Falsettos, and Passion. He has frequently collaborated with Stephen Sondheim and William Finn. Lapine has also directed dramas, including Dirty Blonde, which ran Off-Broadway and on Broadway in 2000. Lapine was nominated for the Tony Award and Drama Desk Award, for Best Direction of a Play. Lapine directed the 2012 Broadway revival of Annie. In 1991 he directed his first film, Impromptu, which has a screenplay by his wife, Sarah Kernochan. The story revolves around the romance of George Sand and Chopin. He followed with Life With Mikey with Michael J. Fox for Disney. He wrote the screenplay for Disney's film version of Into the Woods (2014), directed by Rob Marshall.

Listen in to today’s Podcast to hear this Master Theater Artist talk about everything from:

  • How not worrying about whether his first show would “make or break” his career is what led to its success.
  • Why Sunday in the Park with George made be the best evidence we have for the legalization of marijuana.
  • Why he doesn’t do outlines.
  • The difference between collaborating with Stephen Sondheim and William Finn . . . and which one he prefers.
  • How he comes up with ideas for shows.

Keep up with me: @KenDavenportBway

www.theproducersperspective.com

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Ken Davenport: I wanna be a producer with a hit show on Broadway. I wanna be a producer.

[0:09] Ken Davenport: Hey everybody, Ken Davenport here. Eight performances left of Spring Awakening. Eight. That's it. Last week and it goes away. Catch up before January 24th, Spring Awakening The Musical.com.

[0:21] Ken Davenport: Hello, everybody. Welcome back to the Producer's Perspective podcast. Now look, I know a lot of people listen to this podcast while doing other stuff, running on the treadmill, making dinner, but I'm gonna tell you right now to stop whatever it is you're doing so you can give this podcast your undivided attention. That's how special our guest is today. Ladies and podcast listeners, I'm thrilled to have as my guest today, Mr. James Lapine. Welcome, James.

[0:43] James Lapine: You don't say that for every podcast?

[0:46] Ken Davenport: Not everyone, just you. Just you. Uh so look, they say the book to a musical is uh the hardest nut of uh show to crack. Well, James has won the Tony Award for the Book of a Musical three times, three times Into the Woods, Falsettos and Passion. Uh, in addition to his incredible contributions to the theater as a writer. Uh by the way, he also wrote Sunday in the Park with George, which won him a Pulitzer. Uh James is also an acclaimed Broadway director for Falsettos, the recent Annie Revival, that production of Sunday in the Park, and 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, among others. Written and directed movies as well, but nominated for a billion awards. I'm in his office right now and there's all sorts of plaques on the wall. Uh I'm gonna stop right here so you can just go to his playbill vault or his Wikipedia page to read the lengthy credits. But James, let's start at the beginning. How did you get bit by the theater bug? Where did this all begin for you?

[1:42] James Lapine: Well, it's kind of a long story. Um I didn't really get bit, as it were, till well in my twenties. I was a uh graphic designer uh for the Yale School of Drama, and I did their I began by doing their magazine called Yale Theater. And uh Bob Brewstein, who was the dean then loved my design and invited me to a full-time position uh at the Yale School of Drama, uh teaching a design course and doing all the graphics for the theater, the L Rep as well as the magazine. So I it began then I guess uh because I was surrounded by theater and doing the magazine. I was constantly kind of reading plays and reading about the theater, and um once I was in New Haven, he ran the place sort of like a conservatory, and in January he had take a couple weeks where everyone in the school, including faculty and staff, um had to participate in something outside their own particular realm.

Uh my design students suggested I I direct a play, and a friend of mine who was a stage manager produced it, and I um said to the students, Well, find me a play to direct, and they came up with this very wacky Gertrude Stein play, which was um three pages long and five acts. So uh I tackled that. It was called Photograph because photography was really my main interest in life, and um we put in a put up a very uh avant-garde production of this Gertrude Stein play, and uh people seemed to really like it, and the local paper wrote it up and um s was suggested maybe I could do it in New York, and uh some people got on that, and uh a friend of mine said, gee, Jasper Johns is a huge fan of Gertrude Stein's I don't you know I got his address and wrote him and he sent me a check for twenty five hundred dollars and we put it on in in a little loft down in Soho and another friend said, What can I do to help?

And I said, Well, I don't know how you go about getting critics. Maybe you could get somebody to review it in New York. And um she just picked up the phone and called the lead critic of the Tim at uh who's Richard Eater, which is bizarre when you think about it now. And she convinced him to come down to see it, and he wrote a kind of half-page rave review, and that's how I sort of started in the theater.

[4:16] Ken Davenport: It all sounds so easy.

[4:17] James Lapine: I know, ridiculous, right?

[4:18] Ken Davenport: Well, I'm sure it wasn't as easy as it sounded.

[4:21] James Lapine: No, it was pretty easy.

[4:24] James Lapine: One letter, you raised some money, one call, you got a New York Times critic.

[4:28] James Lapine: I know, I won an Obi Award. It was um really, you know, I think it's interesting when you don't have that much uh really emotionally associated with that you're doing it, you're just doing it for fun, and was it was kind of um strange enterprise and uh so um here were all these people paying all this money to go to the drama school, and I was somehow overnight, you know, getting offers to direct things.

[4:54] Ken Davenport: Well, that's a very interesting comment. You said you didn't have this all this emotion, you were just doing it for fun. Had you even when you were directing it here in New York, we were like, Oh, this is gonna be my career now, so this is very interesting.

[5:05] James Lapine: No, no, no, no, no. Never thought I just figured it would all go away one day and I'd go back to being a graphic designer or a photographer, you know. So no, it was uh not like I had some burning desire to do it.

[5:18] Ken Davenport: And that reduction of stress and pressure and maybe actually freed you up to do even better work.

[5:23] James Lapine: Well, you know, I'm of a certain age when we were of the sort of hippie generation, and you didn't really think of yourself as a careerist and you just kind of went I just bounced around, you know, I had lots and lots of different kinds of jobs and uh you know, I as I said photography was my main interest, but I found I didn't really enjoy uh doing that as a living. Um I was doing, you know, journalistic kind of things, so I turned to graphic design, something else I didn't know that much about. I had a little training. So it's just I was sort of open to whatever life blew at me.

[5:59] Ken Davenport: So you get a rave in the times, people are going to see the play. What happens next?

[6:03] James Lapine: Oh, it closed pretty quickly 'cause the lady who ran the loft had something else coming in. Uh and it's so funny, I always thought, well, gee, I Joe Papp should come and see this and put it on and bring it to his theater, but it never dawned on me to like do anything about it, which was kind of ironic when I met Joe Pap, you know, a couple of years later. Um, someone else came to me uh with an offer to direct something, so I did that. Uh Lynn Austin, Mary Silverman had a little group called Music Theater Group or something like that. And I had this idea based on uh Jungian case history, so I did a very abstract kind of, you know, again avant-garde kind of thing, and but I was still teaching and and designing and um and then I thought, uh, well, you know, I didn't really wasn't a great teacher and what I didn't like about designing was that I didn't have final say, you know, 'cause you're working for somebody, and I really think I in my heart want to just work for myself.

So I got a little stint at a writer's colony, the Malay colony, and I said, I'm gonna sit down and see if I can write a commercial something so I can make some money and actually, you know, see if that would pan out. And it sort of did. I wrote a play called Table Settings, which was sort of a arty farty Jewish comedy. And uh it got a commercial, ended up getting a commercial one, and uh that's when I really thought well I could actually like not be in debt and do this thing. Which is pretty funny because it's pretty hard to not be in debt and start out in the theater.

[7:45] Ken Davenport: So your writing career starts to flourish.

[7:48] James Lapine: Right.

[7:49] James Lapine: You have this directing career as well.

[7:52] James Lapine: Well let's see I hadn't directed uh no I had just directed I didn't have a career. I directed a couple of things that were my own creation. So uh after table settings, you know it it ran a while. I don't know what I did next. Oh I you know what happened? Um Bill Finnrights Horizons which was uh a great opportunity for our several of us of a certain of the age then of being in our late twenties, early thirties and uh Bill came after me to direct a show of his so that was the first time I directed something that wasn't uniquely my own. Only the third thing I directed. And it was uh March the Falsetto's that little show.

[8:38] James Lapine: That little show. Yeah another one that was just like thrown up together you know just uh Andre Bishop kind of put us together, and Bill had like five songs, you know, of something, no real sense of what it was, and uh there were no workshops. Andre said, Okay, I'll do it up in the upstairs little ninety-nine seat theater, and you know, we just put it together and uh yeah, you know, sold tickets at an audience come and opened it, um which was pretty pretty wild. You know, I think it was so special that way because it was very organic. You know, we had no set design. So I just say to the set designer, oh, get me a table, get me a couch, get me a this, you know, put some wheels on it, you know. Just kind of built it together. Say to Bill, go write a song about this, write a song about that, let's get a little kid in it. And you know, it kind of grew that way and became very special.

[9:31] Ken Davenport: Is that the first production where you wrote the book and directed at the same time?

[9:37] James Lapine: I didn't realize I was writing the book at the time, perfectly honest. I guess I was in conjunction with Bill. They were very much Bill's characters, but he didn't quite know there wasn't really the drama of it was kind of undeveloped. You know, he had this idea that a guy leaves his wife for a guy, and that was about, you know, and he had some great love songs and this and that, but there really wasn't a drama in it, and he had the psychiatrist that said, Well, what if the psychiatrist gets together with the wife, you know, and let's give them a kid, and you know, so it kind of I guess I was book writing and not realizing it at the time.

[10:15] Ken Davenport: So a lot of people say, and you may have just described it, but in simple words, many people email me and say, Oh, there's no there's no dialogue in that show. Uh how how is there a book to it? What do you think the primary job of a book writer is?

[10:32] James Lapine: Well, I think what um people don't go to a musical for the book, you know, they go for the music. So I think primarily on a very basic level, structure is what a book writer does with a musical. But, you know, it can be varied, and uh every person I've worked with has been a little different. But I would say that structure is the key to a successful musical. And um, you know, the funny thing about musicals is when they're good, they just look really easy. That's why everybody thinks they can do them, and they're really so difficult to do. And I think book writers are are underappreciated, certainly. Because you have to also know what needs to be sung and what needs to be spoken, and that's a big big decision to make.

[11:18] Ken Davenport: If you could only choose one of the disciplines to do for the rest of your life, write or direct, which one would you choose?

[11:25] James Lapine: Oh god. Probably directing because it's easier. I think writing is a more um satisfying thing to do, but when you say the rest of your life, if I had to have a term of it, I think a directing's easier.

[11:42] Ken Davenport: Who has more control in modern Broadway? A writer or a director today?

[11:47] James Lapine: Well, it's a good question. Uh, and and you're talking musicals versus plays. I certainly think the writer in a play is is is where the buck stops. I think musicals get a little bit more uh complicated because there's particularly when there are many collaborators, then I would say it probably falls to the director.

[12:08] Ken Davenport: Has it always been that way? Do you have you seen a change in the um well I don't know. I would say probably in the era of Jerry Robbins, it was the director, even though he was working with Sonnheim and you know, uh Lawrence and Bernstein, but I mean he was such a driving force that I think he probably would have been the person that pulled that together. But I'm I'm a writer myself, and I really feel what's great about the theater is primarily it's a writer's medium and should remain so. So sometimes musicals can be more director driven because they're so hard to pull together.

[12:48] Ken Davenport: So speaking of Mr. Sondheim, how did that collaboration begin? Obviously a frequent collaborator of yours.

[12:54] James Lapine: Uh again, another freakish kind of uh uh situation after I worked with a uh a fellow named Luis San Jorjo, who was one of the producers of table settings, and he he had an office with someone named Lewis Allen, and I had this idea. Uh also I was working with a fellow named Stephen Graham, who's not producing anymore. And Steve said, Let's do something else, and what do you want to do? Uh after table settings. I said, Oh, I have this idea, and there's this book, A Cool Million that I really love by Nathaniel West, and I thought it would be a cool musical. And um he said, Well, who who should write the music? And I went, Oh, Randy Newman, you know. So next thing I knew, I was in Randy Newman's house having a chat with Randy Newman, and Randy Newman told me the material was too dark for him.

So that gives you some idea. If Randy Newman is saying it's too dark, how dark it was. And then Lewis happened to be in a discussion, and Lewis said, What about Stephen Sondheim? And to be perfectly honest, I didn't really, because I'm not from the theater, of course I knew he was a big wig, but I had only seen one show of his, which was Sweeney Todd. Uh and um I said, sure, you know, and he's he sent it to Steve, uh, Cool Million, and then Steve uh had come to see Table Settings and March of the Falsettos and said he'd like to meet me. And uh so we were introduced, and um that was right after Merrily We Rowlong had failed on Broadway, so he was kind of down in the dumps, and I think it was a turning point for him. So we came to meet one another at that point.

[14:34] James Lapine: What was the first show you did together?

[14:36] Ken Davenport: Sunday in the Park, yeah.

[14:38] James Lapine: It's funny. He read the Cool Million, he said, gee, it reminds me too much of Candide, which he'd already worked on, but he said, you know, to be happy to discuss other projects, and um, uh, so that's what we did, and somehow Sunday was born.

[14:54] Ken Davenport: And where did that idea come from?

[14:57] James Lapine: Where was it in the Well to go back? I, and when I did the Gertrude Stein play called Photograph, I used the image of Le Grand Jatte as one of the inspirations for the play. Um, that play was like a theme and variation, and I did that little three-page play like 15 different times with different kinds of motifs, and one of them was Sunday in the Park because it was one of my all-time favorite paintings. Uh, so when Steve and I were talking, uh, you have to again remember I was not schooled in the theater arts, so I'm more a visual person. I brought over lots of different images and just things to chat about rather than chatting about story. We were just chatting about images, you know, and looking at things, and I brought that over, and um, I say, well, that looks like a stage to me, you know, and we talked about it, and uh, and then I went off and just started writing.

[16:01] Ken Davenport: So talk to me about that part of your process, the just starting writing. You're inspired by an image. Where do you start with something like that?

[16:11] James Lapine: Well, um, it's a long time ago. So I, uh, I'm very much of the free association school. So, uh, I'm sure I smoked a joint and sat at a typewriter and started typing. Literally. Um, if ever there was a case for the legalization of marijuana, that was it. Smoke a joint, out pops Sunday in the Park with George. Well, you know, if you look at that show, it's pretty stoned. So, um, you know, I like to not know where I'm going, actually. To me, that's a pleasure in writing. Uh, I'm not a big, uh, outliner and researcher. I didn't do any research on the painting. I didn't want to know about it. I wanted to just have it come from my own imagination rather than be stuck with a lot of facts which would hem me in.

I mean, the conceit of it was that the painter was a character, so that gave me somewhere to go. And as I went along, I remember again being kind of a visual guy, I put a, uh, a piece of tracing paper over the image and started identifying characters and just saying this guy looks like a boatman, this person looks like another artist. Uh, and playing around, uh, just what I imagined the mentality of a person who would make that painting, because it's the more you look at it, the more fascinating it is. If you notice nobody is ever looking at anybody else in that painting, uh, the proportions are completely bizarre if you look carefully. Um, the, uh, repetition of certain images of the women, and, uh, I just started becoming the artist, really, in a way, the way he became an artist to make the painting, I became, you know, an artist to make something for the stage.

[18:03] Ken Davenport: You've obviously, in addition to Sondheim and Bill Finn, you've worked with a bunch of different folks. What's your tips for working with a composer and a lyricist? It seems like the ones that I've spoken to, they seem to have the rules of, well, I'm, uh, from what I've heard, Sondheim doesn't like to write a song until the scene is done.

[18:24] James Lapine: Right, correct.

[18:25] Ken Davenport: Right. I've heard the opposite from other composers.

[18:28] James Lapine: Yeah, Bill Finn is somebody who sits down and writes a song before he has a show, in a way.

[18:32] Ken Davenport: Well, he works sort of a little bit more like I work in a way. I don't know that there are any rules because you're dealing with people and everybody is unique, and I think the rule is that you have to, um, bend, you know, you have to find how to get the best out of your collaborator and how they get the best out of you. And I haven't done it that much. I mean, I know I sometimes get criticized for directing my own stuff, or why don't I let somebody else direct it? But in a funny way, I find the one time I let somebody else direct something of mine in its initial stage, it wasn't very successful, and it was mainly because I realized through the directing process I learned what I'm writing. And, um, the other nice thing about working with a Bill Finn or Sondheim is just two of us, which is a lot easier than a room full of four people, you know, or five people.

Um, but I don't know that there's any prescription for successful collaboration other than, uh, Steve had a really great saying. Uh, here's a man I worked with for, you know, 30 years and we've never had a disagreement. I mean, we've disagreed about things, but we've never had any kind of fight, and, uh, his feeling is whoever cares most wins, and I think it's a good adage because whoever's most passionate about it, if you're not, if your ego isn't engaged and you're really artistically arguing for something, then that should be the way you go. And, uh, not that it's necessarily all always correct, but, um, you have to give in to some artistic impulse, and it can't really be about whose idea it is, it has to be about who cares most about the idea. I think a lot of collaborations get kind of botched up by ego, understandably.

[20:21] Ken Davenport: Yeah, I know, uh, producers who solve their disagreements by saying, I'm jumping up and down about this, and that is the signal to the rest of the group, I'm so passionate about this, I'm never gonna give up.

[20:33] James Lapine: And once they hear that, the others go, okay, you win.

[20:35] Ken Davenport: Yeah. It's about knowing when to let that.

[20:37] James Lapine: Well, I think the interesting conversation is what is the producer's role and where does the producer get involved in the artistic decisions? And, um, you know, that's changed so much from the days when producers really had ideas that they then hired writers for. I think what's so interesting about all these movies being adapted into musicals is they're, some of them just are a little bloodless because they're not being driven by the artist, they're being driven by the producer. And if you're gonna go out and hire somebody to do this and hire somebody to do that, you're not necessarily getting somebody who has a passion to do it. You know, it's so hard to make a living in the theater, and somebody comes and offers you a job, you know, often they'll take it because they need a job or they want a job. It's not the same as them going, I've got to write about this or write about that. And I've done that myself. I've adapted a movie, uh, and I realized it's a different, a different kind of animal.

[21:33] Ken Davenport: So, how do you like to work with producers? What's the, you've worked with a lot of them?

[21:36] James Lapine: A lot of different ones, yeah. So, what are your favorite characteristics of your favorite producer?

[21:43] James Lapine: Well, you know, part of it is just learning along the way. Um, and I have a system which I think works rather well, which is I welcome, uh, feedback from producers. Now, when I started, there was only be, you know, two producers on a project. Now there seems to be a kind of little village there. Uh, but, uh, I always only want to talk to one person, and I always ask that notes come to me in written forms because, uh, you know, when you're in previews, so many things need to be addressed. Uh, and I'll have my list, and my general finding by doing this is that half the things that I hear from producers I'm totally in agreement with, and it's on my list as well. So that's kind of my method, and also it allows me not to have to engage, I can engage the notes when I'm in a state to be, um, relaxed, and, uh, you know, usually I'll get them and I'll sit down over a cup of coffee the next morning, whatever.

And I always answer them to the producer so they can see where my thinking is on it. Um, I've done that with actors too, actually, where rather than give them notes, I'll write them notes and send them. Um, so, um, I'm pretty collaborative. I think what's great about the theater is you have this preview process, and little by little every day gets clearer and clearer what works, what doesn't. And you have to make mistakes, you know, to find solutions. So I don't know. But I think again, like I said about collaborators, every producer's different too. Comes with their own sense of their own aesthetic and what they're looking for.

[23:36] James Lapine: So the problem what you get a lot is, um, you know, you just start hearing so many opinions, as I'm sure you know. And I would imagine being a lead producer and having to listen to all the other producers is difficult, and then you have audience members and you know, everybody calling you to tell you what they think. Everybody has an opinion. I blame it all on that those TV guys with the thumbs up, thumbs down. When they came on the scene, suddenly everybody had an opinion.

[24:08] Ken Davenport: So it's Siskel and Ebert's fault.

[24:10] James Lapine: Yeah, well, I understand it. It's like, uh, yeah, yeah, I understand the impulse.

[24:16] Ken Davenport: So you talked about getting criticism sometimes for directing and writing your own work. Obviously, you've done it unbelievably successfully. How do you maintain your objectivity when you are also, when you're that director in a musical and you're like, uh, no, I, this is how it should go.

[24:35] James Lapine: I, I want it to be this way from Mrs. Well, that takes learning on, you know, in general for anybody. Um, I think one thing is I leave the writer out of the room, you know. I'll come into a rehearsal room and I'll say the writer's not here today, so don't talk to me about changing lines or doing this or that. You know, at some point as a director, you have to take what the writer gives you and make it work. And I had to kind of have a split personality to realize like when I did table settings, I spent half the time rewriting it with the actors in the room rather than directing it. And then I thought, wait a minute, you know, uh, uh, I realized maybe not in that, but from that that you have to kind of disassociate yourself as the writer to be a good director.

[25:23] Ken Davenport: What do you think about, uh, today's musical theater writers, the next generation of them? You think that we're on a, we've, the future is good for us?

[25:31] James Lapine: Oh, I think the future's amazing, actually. I'm very envious of a lot of, a lot of the talent that's out there. It's fantastic. Yeah. I think the theater's thriving, actually. You know, I came through when theaters were closed and the commercial theater in particular. I, I was sort of on board kind of more of the birth of Off-Broadway and, um, with Playwright's Horizons and then I worked at the public, which was already obviously more established. Uh, but I think, um, I think it's very bright. I, I, I'm excited by the new work.

[26:04] Ken Davenport: How is writing movies different from writing plays or musicals?

[26:09] James Lapine: Um, well, that's interesting, because I've just been in a sort of writing movie phase. Um, and in fact, after doing Woods Adapted Sunday, and I just wrote an original movie of my own, which I made this past year. Um, that's also been a learning curve for me. I feel, I feel like I'm just now really at the point of being a good screenwriter. Um, you have to think imagistically. One of my strengths is not prose writing, which is hard because screenwriting is a lot about description. But you've got to, in a movie, paint a kind of enthusiasm and a visual that you don't really have to do in playwriting or writing librettos, I think. You know, they like to do three acts in movies, so it's just slightly different structure. I think you, you don't have the gift of language that you can have in film and in theater, and I think also, uh, you can't write a scene really, it's more than a couple of pages. Whereas, you know, plays and are all about just the opposite.

[27:17] Ken Davenport: Well, the Into the Woods movie is one of the best musical to movie adaptations I think I've seen. I learned a lot from Rob Marshall. It was really wonderful to work with him on that. Very liberating, and he had a real sense of visually how he wanted things to look and be, and it was very collaborative, and it was kind of terrific.

[27:37] James Lapine: You've been a part of such monumental musical productions and obviously plays and movies as well. Uh, in fact, I will just tell you a side story. Falsettos, I was at NYU when Falsettos was here, and well, you're not gonna like half of this because I second acted it like 27 times because I was so in love with that production.

[27:56] Ken Davenport: Wow.

[27:57] James Lapine: Uh, and I want to ask my, was one of my James Lipton questions. So if the Smithsonian called you today and said, we have room for one of your shows in the institute, we're gonna put one here, and you can choose which one that would be. What's the one show you'd want to really be remembered for?

[28:18] James Lapine: Well, I don't know. I mean, I love Sunday, and I would say Sunday, but other shows I think, I think Passion is a great show. I love Passion. I think it's our perfect collaboration. Um, but I think Sunday, I like Sunday just because it was my birth, you know. I mean, it was, uh, a moment of, uh, artistic and creative, I don't know, freedom and vitality that you can only have when you're starting out in something and you know you're a bit of a virgin.

[28:49] Ken Davenport: So, but it's funny you talk about Falsettos because you know, I'm, we're going to revive it and I'm going to direct it. And that's one of the ones I think people probably say, well, why is he directing it again? You know? And I say to myself, why am I directing it again? I'm not even, it's like your baby, you know, it's kind of your baby, but, uh, like when I did the revival of Into the Woods, I thought I could make it better, which is why I did that.

[29:17] James Lapine: And the irony was at the end of the day, I realized it was just fine the way it was. It's imperfect. There's no question about it being imperfect, but it is what it is, you know. Um, Falsettos, I'm just curious to do again because, well, there are a couple of people I thought would do a great job of it that weren't interested in doing it. And I thought it was the best thing I ever directed. So, you know, the challenge for me now is to rediscover it and, you know, see how I think about it today and see if that will change the way it comes out, I guess.

[29:57] Ken Davenport: So my previous question about your objectivity, and I just witnessed you say it. You just talked about Into the Woods being imperfect.

[30:04] James Lapine: Yeah.

[30:05] Ken Davenport: What about it do you think is imperfect? Like just tell me what w a moment that like, ah, that bugs me. That that didn't work out the way I thought it would.

[30:11] James Lapine: Well, like, uh, what I love about the movie is there's no narrator, you know. And I don't know whether that narrat narrator that that mightn't have been a more interesting show without a narrator on stage. Um, it's lumbering a little bit Into the Woods. You know, what's great about Steve and I is we have so many ideas. I mean, like that's the crazy hard part for us because we just were like blah blah blah blah blah blah blah with ideas and having to reduce them was tough. Um, when I say imperfect, I just ah, you know, it's got it like three ballads at the end and I mean, you know, you can pick it apart. Uh, w you know, it was funny when I s we did the movie and Cameron McIntosh came to the movie.

I said, Well, Cameron, if we cut no more, you know, 'cause he kept telling us to cut no more, cut no more at that point in the show, nobody wants another ballad and no one wants to hear from them, you know. Uh, of course I hate that it's out of the movie. And you know, to some thinking it's it's a shortcoming of the show, but that's the show, you know, and God knows the show's been done endlessly, so hey, you know, that's uh that's okay with me.

[31:30] James Lapine: Well, everything is imperfect. I think that's what makes things. Passion's kind of perfect, but as perfect as you can get. Uh, you're right. Everything is. I don't know, you know, some shows are perfect.

[31:43] Ken Davenport: Um, Gypsy's perfect.

[31:45] James Lapine: And I think there's some definitely perfect shows that I wouldn't touch. I wouldn't even imagine making a change to, you know.

[31:53] Ken Davenport: Uh, so a show you want to direct?

[31:56] James Lapine: Oh wow. Um, I'm asking this also as a producer. Not offhand, tell you the truth. You know, they're shows I love, but I don't know that I would want to direct them. Um, I don't know. It's funny, nobody's ever asked me. I very rarely get asked to do anything, so it's funny. You know, you know, I've read uh the famous article that asked Steve about what songs he wished he wrote.

[32:26] Ken Davenport: Right.

[32:26] James Lapine: What books to musicals do you wish you all there's tons of those. Gypsy and I think Spring Awakening is perfect. I love Spring Awakening. And I think the recent revival of it proved what a great show it is that it could be revised soon after what I thought was a really terrific production and have a completely different production of it that illuminated the show, and, uh, I mean that's really what stands the test of time. I think Sweeney's a pretty perfect show.

[32:58] James Lapine: Um, I mean, there's tons of them, you know, really Gypsy, though, I think is a masterwork.

[33:05] Ken Davenport: So to your own admission, you had a pretty easy beginning of your incredible career.

[33:11] James Lapine: Uh-huh. Wow.

[33:11] Ken Davenport: Well, yeah, it didn't feel easy at the time. You know, Sunday was one of the I thought was going to put me in my grave.

[33:19] James Lapine: So, you know, uh, that was just a horrific experience, actually, in many respects, you know.

[33:25] Ken Davenport: So what made it so difficult?

[33:28] James Lapine: Well, I was so inexperienced, you know. You have to realize I had only worked on one other musical, which was March of the Falsettos, which hello, it's a little one act with five people. I'd never done a Broadway show. I'd never really written a real book for a musical. I'd never really directed, you know, I mean, you go down the list, and there suddenly I was on Broadway. Um, just totally unprepared. I'm so naive, you know. I had this idea, first of all, we ended up going into the booth because I'd only done little off-Broadway shows in 99 C 150 seats was the largest thing I'd done. And when we looked at these theaters, they were enormous to me. So I picked the smallest one on Broadway. And the producers kept saying, It's I don't know if we make any money in this theater, you know, why don't you go over to the this one and that one?

And I sort of s you know, I guess it was a pretty stubborn. I said, No, I really want it to be a little jewel box, you know, and then I had this stupid idea because I thought, well, they never, you know, amplified musicals till, you know, technology came to bear. I said, We're in the smallest theater, let's not use any amplification. So, uh, and then Steve didn't finish the score.

[34:46] James Lapine: So suddenly we were previewing with half of a second act, you know, and I had written these uh monologues to put in the place of where songs went because something had to go there. And, uh, the very uh we were so far behind teching the show that we hadn't lit it by the time the first audience arrived.

[35:09] Ken Davenport: So the first audience arrived, it was must have been April, and there was a horrible heat wave, and they hadn't any air conditioning on in the theater.

[35:18] James Lapine: So we put this show on. Um, you couldn't hear it, you couldn't see it because there was no lights up. It was endless, and there was like three songs in the second act, and it was so long, and people were pouring out of that theater, and I thought I was gonna have a heart attack, and I was hoping I did, so I didn't have to come back the next day. But um, you know, it was a real trial by fire, and the producers are like, what the fuck's going on here? You know, so that was tough, and the actors were not uh on my side, you know, because I didn't really know how to direct actors, and so it was a real tough ride that one.

[36:00] Ken Davenport: And how did you write the ship in that short period of time?

[36:05] James Lapine: Well, the next day I said to the line designer, put on all the lights, and I said, get sound equipment in here and get mics on everybody, and I think what you have to do is be fearless, and I think I have that quality where I don't I don't mind making huge changes. I think you just I think the worst thing is when people make these little tiny things that they think is really gonna fix everything. And I I'm very in the good way of being a writer, I'm not precious about anything. At one point I had to have uh Steve Sondheim come in and talk to the company because they were so discouraged. And um, I also remember Michael Bennett, who I'd met, um, saying, Part of your problem is the producers have sold all these previews to um benefit and group sales, and they're just not the audience for this show.

So we had a really kind of you know audience that was coming to because they were supporting you know, Sloan Kettering Hospital. They just really weren't in the mood for that kind of a piece, particularly the second act. So, but you know, it's every day, and the last song came in literally, I think a day before the critics came, and I I think the orchestration came in the day the critics came, and the thing that happened was we really were in the trenches together, and this cast that was sort of hostile towards me came around, you know, and I learned from them. And when I say hostile, the only one, Bernadette Peters, a saint. A saint. And I remember one night when we were doing Move On, Mandy and Bernadette said, we are not leaving this theater until we crack this number.

And we stayed there. We like everybody left, and we kind of had a ghost light on the stage, and the three of us were there to the wee hours of the morning, figuring out the blocking and the staging and every little moment of it. And when you work, I think they raised my game so much because they taught me what it was like. They don't fuck around, you know. Mandy is was really intense, but it was always in in service of the work. And I realized that actors need to have a strong director. If they don't feel, you know, I'm a sort of passive and uh kind of laid back guy, and I had to learn to instill confidence in people and be definitive, and you know, uh, and that was sort of where I learned how to rise to an occasion and take it over.

[38:49] Ken Davenport: Yeah, great.

[38:50] James Lapine: It's not my nature. Great collaborations, I think everybody raises everyone else's game.

[38:55] Ken Davenport: Exactly, yeah.

[38:56] James Lapine: And you know, being in trouble isn't a bad thing. I mean, the bad thing is when it creates a kind of panic or but you know, to this day, people ask me questions. I'll say, I don't know the answer today. I'm not gonna bullshit you with an answer. The question is a good question, and we'll answer the question, but you know, you have to go into things. That's part of the excitement of what we're doing. If you know you want to you should do revivals then if you just want to do things where you're not making something new, because then you don't have those questions. But you know, finding our center and and and the reason it's so good a show is because Steve took all that time to write it, you know.

He always said to me, Look, I can't I don't want to write the wrong song, I don't want to write the wrong song. I want to just wait till I know exactly what I'm doing and what needs to be done, and then and that's what he did, and we went kind of successively. And man, each time a song came in, you could just feel that second act pulling together, you know.

[40:03] Ken Davenport: So tips for young writers and directors starting today that are frankly super passionate and have such high emotions of success, very opposite of the way you started.

[40:16] James Lapine: Well, I would say, you know, don't wait for somebody to do your work, do it yourself, you know, like I put on that Gertrude Stein play. I mean, the great thing about theater is, you know, you can put it on, get it up, work on it, don't wait for people to do it for you. You know, people seem so running around with this material, and it's hard to read, you know, off a page. I've turned down some really great shows because I just can't read them on the page. You know, if somebody had done a reading of it or whatever, I might have actually gotten involved. So, uh, you know, I would say, you know, you gotta get it up, and if nobody's getting it up for you, get it up yourself, you know. Crowdsource it, whatever you need to do, get a room and put it up and get people in to see it.

[41:06] Ken Davenport: Okay, my last question, which has been known now as my genie question.

[41:10] James Lapine: Oh, okay.

[41:11] Ken Davenport: I want you to imagine that the genie from Aladdin comes to see you.

[41:16] James Lapine: Does it have to be the one from Aladdin?

[41:18] Ken Davenport: Yeah.

[41:19] James Lapine: Any genie is any genie, okay. I wish all of you could see uh have seen James Face when I—

[41:21] James Lapine: No, no. I happen to love Aladdin the musical. It's just uh I don't know that I want that guy in my room.

[41:31] Ken Davenport: And I love that actor who by the way, I take credit for bringing into the world because he was in Spelling Bee in San Francisco.

[41:38] James Lapine: He's so talented.

[41:39] Ken Davenport: Yes.

[41:40] James Lapine: So imagine any genie comes to you and says the one from TV and the bikini.

[41:46] Ken Davenport: Okay. Perfect.

[41:47] James Lapine: And says, uh, I want to thank you for your incredible contributions to the musical theater by gear granting you one wish. Just one. And I want you to think about the one thing that drives you so crazy about Broadway. It makes you angry. You can't sleep at night, is so frustrating to you that you would ask this genie to wish away. What's the one thing you'd ask?

[42:11] James Lapine: That's a complicated wish. Um. Well, if if I had to wish one thing for Broadway, it would be that there was a Broadway house that wasn't driven by commerce somehow. You know, that these young people, there's so many talented young people have a chance to work in a big theater like Broadway every year, you know, and that there would somehow be, I know there have been attempts to create a venue for new work. I'd like to see that happen. I don't know whoever would do it, but you never know. But it's true, it's you learn by doing, and if you don't get a chance to do, you don't learn, you know?

[42:54] Ken Davenport: So it's that simple.

[42:56] James Lapine: Very true, and thank you very much for being here.

[43:00] Ken Davenport: Wow, we chatted a long time, didn't we?

[43:02] James Lapine: And I'm very much looking forward to that revival of Falsettos.

[43:05] Ken Davenport: Yeah. I can't wait till it happens.

[43:07] James Lapine: We can come to both acts.

[43:08] Ken Davenport: I'll get you in. Don't forget, only eight more chances for you to see Spring Awakening as of today, Monday, January 18th.

[43:16] James Lapine: If it's after the 18th, you have even less.

[43:16] Ken Davenport: Spring Awakening The Musical.com. Don't miss it. I promise, if you like the podcast, you're gonna love the show.

[43:28] James Lapine: Look out Broadway here, come here.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred