In the last episode we learned the importance of producing our own work as actors. Well today's guest, Joel B. New, will show us that just because you build it doesn't mean people will come... Read More
From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It
About
In the last episode we learned the importance of producing our own work as actors. Well today's guest, Joel B. New, will show us that just because you build it doesn't mean people will come. After the hard work of creating, then comes the daunting task of producing and promoting it, getting others to take notice and support that work. Learn how Joel found unique ways to get the word out on one of his own musicals.
"Strong Hands" - performed by Ernie Pruneda
"The Fort" - performed by Marita Stryker
Sign up for the WINMI Newsletter.
Follow Joel - Website / Instagram / YouTube
Joel's Birthday Concert - https://joelbnew.com/birthday
Season 5 offers ways to connect with me and the guests as well as other opportunities to grow as an artist:
- Members-Only Episodes like the Final Five
- Coachings and Consultations
- Monthly WINMI Newsletter
- Artist Resources and Offers
- Instagram and Twitter
Why I’ll Never Make It is a Top 25 Theater Podcast on Feedspot, and is also a part of Helium Radio Network and a member of the Broadway Makers Alliance.
Music in the episode by Borrtex is used under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: Last week we talked about the importance of actors producing their own work.
[0:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, in today's episode, I'm speaking with Joel B. New, who is a former actor who now solely focuses on composing and creating new musicals.
[0:16] Patrick Oliver Jones: However, just because you produce it and create it doesn't mean that people will listen to it.
[0:35] Patrick Oliver Jones: And the attendance is not proportionate to the amount of time and effort that went into it sometimes.
[0:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: Welcome to another episode of Why I'll Never Make It, a top 25 theater podcast featuring conversations on the realities of a career in the performing arts.
[0:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, an actor and singer for almost 30 years.
[1:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: The website is why I'll never make it.com, and there you can sign up for the monthly WINMI Newsletter.
[1:07] Patrick Oliver Jones: It'll let you know of upcoming guests, fill you in on how you can get special members-only episodes, and give you a peek behind the curtain of this podcast.
[1:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: So sign up today at why I'll never make it.com.
[1:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: It is always a special treat when I get to have a composer on the podcast.
[1:34] Patrick Oliver Jones: I mean, they are the ones who create what it is that I love doing in theater, singing songs.
[1:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: There's something really magical about the marriage between a perfect melody, the right lyrics, and putting them together and telling a story, creating an emotion, and really diving into the inner workings of what a character is going through.
[1:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: This is the reason why I love musical theater.
[2:04] Patrick Oliver Jones: And so I am so happy to have Joel B. New on the podcast today.
[2:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: And yes, that is his actual name, not some stage pseudonym.
[2:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: In addition to being a composer and lyricist, he's also a book writer, producer, educator, and he still performs, especially his own works.
[2:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: He's the proud recipient of the American Theater Wings Jonathan Larson grant and the John Wallowitz Award for his songwriting.
[2:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: And like so many songwriters that I've had here on the podcast, he made his way through the Tish School of Arts, receiving an MFA in musical theater writing.
[2:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: But before that, he attended college.
[2:44] Patrick Oliver Jones: And there was one big motivating factor as to how he picked the college he went to.
[2:55] Joel B. New: As far as musically, what I know about Oklahoma is that's where Kristen Chenoweth went to school.
[3:02] Joel B. New: Yep, that's where I went. I went to Oklahoma City University because of Kristen Chenoweth.
[3:07] Joel B. New: See? She is their brand ambassador for the musical theater.
[3:10] Joel B. New: Yeah, all these years later. And yeah, I was a musical theater performance major at OCU, and it was my training there that I was allowed and encouraged to explore writing musical theater as well as performing it.
[3:26] Joel B. New: And so it was the permission that that program gave me to lean into these other inclinations and encouraged me to.
[3:36] Patrick Oliver Jones: And that's what led me on the path that I'm on now.
[3:39] Patrick Oliver Jones: I would assume then, as you write, you're getting to perform these characters as you create them, as you write for them.
[3:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: So you're trying to embody them as much as you can so that when they actually get a real human being, it's gonna feel a little bit more natural, I assume.
[3:56] Joel B. New: I hope so. That's definitely the goal. I love, you know, it's a great exercise to say all of the lines that I've written out loud to see if and when I trip up, if they actually are organic, and the same with lyrics and melody and just like singing and playing at the piano, and because like you'll write the word shall, and then you know, as you're singing, you'll just organically say will instead of shall. And you just you gotta pay attention to that.
[4:23] Joel B. New: And like, so like that's really like the first workshop is like running it past myself as a performer. And so then hopefully the performer who's going to like be doing it for real is getting at least a second draft.
[4:36] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I've done that as a singer, and it's interesting, especially when the composer is in the room, that I'll be singing something and without even like meaning to, I change a lyric, you know, I'm gonna fly, or I gotta fly. I like I change a little something without even thinking. And the composer goes, you know what? I think that that does make more sense. Just in the moment, sometimes a flow can it just a certain word will make more sense as you go through the entire song. And obviously, my version of it's gonna be different from your thoughts. And I assume that collaboration once you bring people into the room really starts to bring things alive.
[5:13] Joel B. New: And I would say that that is a close that that that is a tie with the most enjoyable part of just like sitting by myself and making myself laugh. And the other, the other favorite part is being in the room with the performers and watching them bring it to life and make choices that I would never in a hundred years make because I'm not them. And so that's when the collaboration starts, and that is a really, really fun time.
[5:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: So much of what we've been talking about so far deals with the creative side. But obviously, there is the business side of show that comes with getting your name out there, with marketing, with reaching out to producers. You know, there's you have to like make the money, you have to, you know, put your product, it really becomes a product at that point that you're trying to sell.
[6:04] Patrick Oliver Jones: And I would assume that I know that for me, being in the business of an actor and you know, promoting myself as a sole business, that doesn't always come as easily or naturally to me. Do you find the same for you that that business side is not as natural?
[6:24] Joel B. New: Well, it's just not as fun.
[6:26] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, that's true.
[6:27] Joel B. New: It's you know, the old idiom of build it and they will come just isn't true. I don't know if it ever was, but it certainly isn't true anymore because I've built a lot of things and the attendance is not proportionate to the amount of time and effort that went into it sometimes.
[6:46] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, that that is often true. That is often true. A lot of work and a little result, you know?
[6:52] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. But like you're building something bigger, it's a marathon for sure. And um, but it's yeah, the business side of it, um not as much fun.
[6:56] Patrick Oliver Jones: Not as much fun.
[7:03] Joel B. New: Yeah, I would I would agree with you because for you, once you you're able to write a complete piece yourself, which is I guess somewhat of a benefit, it's more work for you, but then once you're done you have a complete product, a complete musical that you can then try to get a producer on board with. And so do you try to self-produce first to see what interest is there or do you try to go to the producer first and performance? What does that normally look like?
[7:03] Joel B. New: Yeah, well I I don't know if I'm doing it right but there is no right or wrong there is just the way.
[7:03] Joel B. New: There's just the way right it's it's a way or a way right it's it's a way away so so away for me is um I it's been my experience that um some people lack imagination like you'd be surprised how many um how many people who can help move your piece along kind of need to see it before they'll help you build it you know they they don't there's there's a lack of willingness to envision it with you and um I don't say that in any kind of shady way it's just it's been my experience and so what I do to you know and I I like to I like control I like you know to be in charge of my own destiny and my own creativity and so I I often will build it myself and then I will invite you I find it's easier to invite people to the party than ask if you can go to their party.
[8:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.
[8:54] Joel B. New: That makes sense.
[8:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: That makes sense.
[8:56] Joel B. New: Yeah. Because as much as they are in the arts, producers, and again, like you said, no slide on them, but they're they're thinking more business side. So a lot of times that's where their mind is. So for them to think outside some box or envision this part of this character or this scene, it can sometimes be a stretch for them when they're just trying to be like, well, are a thousand people going to want to see this?
[9:21] Patrick Oliver Jones: That's that's the question they're trying to answer.
[9:23] Joel B. New: Right. And I want to have fun making the piece as long as I can. I just want to extend and maximize the amount of fun for me because that will hopefully result in a more fun experience for the creative team that I build around me and the project. And then hopefully the more fun that the eventual audience will have with it as well. And so the like the more I can kind of like stay in my bubble of not having to think about, well, who is this for? And will, you know, and what age group and which genders, and you know, and you know, which which are all very important questions. Um, but especially in the development process, I before I'm ready to show something, I kind of like to shield myself from those questions and just write the thing that's gonna bring the most joy.
[10:15] Joel B. New: Pianos are like people, except they like when you correct them.
[10:23] Joel B. New: Pianos need strong hands, showing how much they care if played by the wrong hands.
[10:35] Patrick Oliver Jones: Are you still there?
[10:40] Patrick Oliver Jones: Do you write mostly with that story first, or does a melody come to you first? What what is usually your instigator for that song or a piece of music?
[10:51] Joel B. New: Usually the song typically is part of a bigger piece, it's part of a musical. And so I before I even touch song or character or even story, I think about concept. I think about what how is this piece different? How is this piece going to move in a way that something that I've written hasn't moved before, or is like pushing it a little more in this direction or that direction.
[11:18] Joel B. New: So like concept first. And so I'll research really deeply what I'm trying to do conceptually, genre wise, and all that kind of stuff. And then from there, um, it's definitely story. I'm I'm a hardcore believer in outlining. And there's a great screenwriting book called Save the Cat by Blake Snyder.
[11:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.
[11:41] Joel B. New: And it's just it's it's one of many tools. And it's I think it's a great blueprint to start with if you're feeling kind of lost, especially if you're not adapting something, if you're creating something out of out of nothing virtually. And, you know, I'll get that feeling pretty good before I even start to actually like write anything, write with air quotes. And then from there, then what I've done for the last couple of projects is I'll actually write, I'll write a play version of it first.
[12:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: And okay, so just get the book out of the way kind of thing.
[12:22] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah.
[12:23] Joel B. New: But just kind of like make sure that I really understand what I'm trying to say and like give the characters room to breathe and kind of make choices on their own. Because songs just they're harder to move, they're harder to move around. And you know, once you've got a version of the song, you know, you you can rewrite for sure, but once it's harder. It's it's easier to like rewrite a scene than it is to, you know, rewrite a song, in my opinion. So I'll write like the play version more or less, but I'm making notes along the way of like where I feel like the songs will be.
[12:56] Joel B. New: Because you know, as soon as like as soon as you like write a line for a character that's like more than five sentences long, you're like, well, that's probably a song.
[13:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.
[13:07] Joel B. New: If he has or she has that much to say, it probably needs to be sung.
[13:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.
[13:12] Joel B. New: So I mean, so like it's just it's it's making space and and actually I'm just I'm just making the work easier for me so that I'm especially if I'm not adapting something, then I'm kind of adapting my own work. If that may yeah. So that's that's kind of the order that I do things.
[13:30] Joel B. New: I do like to write chronologically if I can. I'll write from scene one to scene 17.
[13:37] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and so it works for me.
[13:39] Joel B. New: And so it sounds like in do the songs kind of start to fit in after that paragraph stage, or do they come in then as the book starts to take shape?
[13:49] Joel B. New: Sometimes sometimes it's pretty clear where the songs are gonna go or specific songs, you know, especially if you're following more traditional contemporary musical theater book structure, and you know you've got like the I want song, and you've got the welcome to the town song. You know, like if you if you kind of like follow, like I'm a big lover of clichés and tropes because I feel like there's a lot to learn from them.
[14:14] Joel B. New: And so if you if you kind of look at those, which I think I feel like Save the Cat lends itself to falling into grooves that we're all familiar with, for better or worse. And so you can lean on those, look at those, and be like, is that the direction I want to go or not? And so it just kind of gives you some guideposts.
[14:34] Joel B. New: So sometimes the songs are pretty evident as far as what they're gonna be accomplishing in the outline, but it isn't really until I start to work on the dialogue and the book scenes that I start to really get a better understanding of where the songs are going and like who we haven't heard from in a while and tracking tracking characters as well as story.
[14:56] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and so I assume it this is a several month-long process of that outline phase to getting to the book and then incorporating the songs.
[15:06] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. I mean, I've um I've been fortunate, the inspiration gods are smiling on me right now, and like I've I've written a new musical annually for just for the last two years. And, you know, once once I have a goal, you know, that's that's something with me.
[15:25] Joel B. New: You know, I will have a goal, I will book a venue months away, you know, nine, ten months away. And that that goal gets the fire started, and then I just kind of start to it's like that self-imposed deadline, like they have to be done.
[15:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.
[15:39] Joel B. New: Yeah, exactly. So then just like reverse engineer the project and be like, all right, well, if that's the performance date, here's when rehearsals should start, and here's where, you know, this is when a draft of the score should be done.
[15:52] Joel B. New: And you and then you just kind of get smaller and smaller until you're just until you're looking at, all right, well, if I just, if I write a scene and a song a week or every other week or something like that. And you just you build it incrementally in digestible bites so that you're not overwhelming yourself and um you're allowed to continue to live the rest of your life, which is yeah, yeah, exactly.
[16:18] Patrick Oliver Jones: Because during during those months you you still have to to make a living doing other things. Maybe you have other projects. So I assume several projects start to coalesce at the same time.
[16:28] Joel B. New: So you're you're writing one musical, you're writing this piece, that piece. And I'm curious though, as you go through this process, is there a particular part of it that you enjoy the most like you know that that initial phase all the way through to performance is there a certain place along there if you could just stop and be like this is where I want to stay.
[16:49] Joel B. New: I love this part. Let me just stay here is there one that you like the most that's a good question.
[17:02] Joel B. New: I went through the graduate musical theater writing program at NYU as a composer and a lyricist and we, you know, everyone took book writing classes as well. But it was it was kind of the for most of us no one was there to be a book writer.
[17:18] Joel B. New: It took a backseat to our I think to my detriment in the beginning because I was very focused on my lyrics and like music uh later as well. But book was just kind of like this thing that is it's like yeah we'll we'll get to it you know like that's not why they bought the ticket.
[17:35] Joel B. New: And and you know and and that's just my own personal experience um through that program and beyond. So the thing that I enjoy in like my my creative writing model right now is is that just writing the dialogue phase because it just feels like there's just like there's no stakes there's no stakes at all it's suit it's you know it's it's not it's not live or die I just get to throw words at the page and if they stick because I assume there's a lot of freedom with that because really these characters can go anywhere be anyone yeah no it's really fun and just kind of give them space and give myself some space just to just to play and have fun and um and I've been really embracing my comedic side the last couple years.
[18:22] Joel B. New: And so just like sitting like sitting and like making jokes and making myself laugh um what a great what a great gig that would be right yeah we could we could all use some of that right now that's for sure yes so it the the NYU Tish program uh there with the musical theater writing is a great program.
[18:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: I've I've been involved as as one of the singers and so and I've also had some of those writers on the podcast and and it's been some of them are lyrics book writer like that was their that was their main thrust others have been uh more on the music side there was actually only one that I've had where there was one composer one lyricist and one book.
[19:04] Joel B. New: So I I've only had one that actually had uh three people for those three jobs.
[19:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: And so with that with your experience you stayed solely with the the music first and then lyrics were added on, or were you a lyricist first and then music added?
[19:21] Joel B. New: Well, back in the day, um, the program would admit writers either as music lyrics or both. I don't believe they do that anymore, but there were only five composer lyricists in my class, and the rest were one or the other.
[19:31] Joel B. New: One or the other. But but most, but but oftentimes you were admitted as one, but you did the other one as well, or and so you were just focusing. And like my my second year, my thesis yeah, uh, I was lyrics and co-book writer with my collaborator Jay O'Connor Navarro, who is uh still yeah, still a uh collaborator to this day.
[20:00] Joel B. New: He's fantastic.
[20:01] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I I worked with him on one of the shows.
[20:03] Joel B. New: I think he was our music director.
[20:05] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh, yeah, yeah he's a fantastic music director.
[20:09] Joel B. New: Now, a musical theater writing program like the one at NYU's Tish School of Arts is very good at the art of making music, the craft of putting lyrics and songwriting together.
[20:24] Joel B. New: But of course, every artist is different. Their process of creating those songs will vary from one writer to the next. And one of the biggest habits, and I suffer from this too, that any artist, any writer has to overcome is that of self-editing, of being too critical too quickly in the very beginning stages of creating a song.
[20:52] Joel B. New: I definitely used to be a perfectionist on the the first draft, and you know, I would fill legal pads with structure and rhymes until like it was all perfect, and it would take forever to write like that.
[21:12] Joel B. New: And now, you know, now that I'm I'm currently writing at this what feels like a breakneck speed to like write a whole new show every year um you can't do that it's not realistic and so if so you just you gotta make a big mess of it if verse two has a few more syllables than verse one that's fine just throw it on the page singing at the piano maybe verse two is a couple of syllables more because verse one actually also needs to be a couple syllables more.
[21:44] Joel B. New: So like you know you're gonna learn something from every piece of it. And so don't like stop being so precious about it.
[21:53] Joel B. New: And like you you can care without it being precious if that distinction makes sense.
[21:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah yeah it's it's like yes it's your creation but it's not a tiny infant baby that has to be caught it you know you can you can let it breathe and let it figure out its own way.
[22:08] Joel B. New: Yeah yeah let it get its hands in the dirt and run around trip fall and you know I'm not gonna be the only parent you know like there's right especially once you get into the room with the producer director and all that have you found that they or do you sometimes have trouble letting go once they want to get their little hands in it.
[22:33] Joel B. New: Yes because I've been because I've been at this long pause. Yes the answer is yes uh because I've been at this for you know a healthy amount of time and there's been so many close yeses or maybe's or not now's or no's along the way um that when a yes does come along, it's um it is sometimes I would say it's it is often met first with like doubt and mistrust just within myself.
[23:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: On your on my part, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[23:13] Joel B. New: And that's just like it's it's ego and it's history and um trying to work through that and remember look, we all want the same thing. We want something, we want to make something really cool and special that a lot of people will see.
[23:28] Joel B. New: And so once, you know, once more hands are on the piece, you know, I'm I'm a big believer in transparency. And so I will talk at the be, you know, as close to whatever the beginning is with my teammates to my collaborators as possible, and just say, Hey, here's what I here's what I usually like.
[23:51] Joel B. New: I'm I'm used to doing this alone. Like I think I was actually just uh talking to some producers the other day, and and I said that to them, I was like, I'm I'm not really used to letting other people hold my babies.
[24:02] Joel B. New: And you know, some people have forgotten and like left them unattended somewhere, or maybe they dropped them, and I was like, so I'm gonna, you know, like please understand that handing my baby to you is um is hard.
[24:18] Joel B. New: And we're going, I was like, and as long as we keep the the lines of communication open about that, and you let me know what you need from me and vice versa, then we're gonna be fine.
[24:31] Joel B. New: So it's just it's just calling it, calling yourself out on it in, and you know, hopefully not in obnoxious way.
[24:39] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah.
[24:40] Joel B. New: Now, is there a a nervous part of you, a hesitancy in letting that first person or first group of people see something once it's done?
[24:53] Joel B. New: No.
[24:54] Patrick Oliver Jones: Okay.
[24:59] Joel B. New: And, you know, because I'm gonna, I'm gonna learn something. And the the point of my pieces, you know, in one shape or another is is to entertain.
[25:09] Joel B. New: And it's not gonna get better if no one else hears it. And I'm not gonna know, I'm gonna know what like I think is working, but it's not until I'm watching their faces and I'm hearing their reactions that I'll actually understand what's like quote unquote really working.
[25:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: So I can't wait to get it in front of people.
[25:30] Joel B. New: Not because, you know, I I want like accolades of praise. I mean, like, that's great too. But like that's not, you know, that's not the goal.
[25:38] Joel B. New: And I mean, I think it's just important to set those goals at the beginning. If it's like a table read, you know, in person or on Zoom these days, of just setting the expectations from the beginning and you know, saying, look, we're I'm gonna send y'all a survey later and you can give me feedback that way, or just saying, you know, this is not a feedback reading, this is a this is a victory lap because I wrote this in record time.
[26:04] Joel B. New: We will have another reading where feedback will be discussed and everything, but today is just a celebration.
[26:11] Joel B. New: And so just like setting those expectations and knowing that as I'm writing that there is like this celebration table read that's coming or whatever, then that propels me as well.
[26:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: How do you then find the people, find the producers, find the actors, find like how do you then bring people in, you know, people like me who are looking, you know, how do we find each other?
[26:39] Joel B. New: I think the short answer is just time. And you know, like doing the one-off concerts or, you know, like creating your own things and your own opportunities that then again it's about inviting people instead of asking to be invited. And so it's creating those, creating my own opportunities and my own spaces to make those connections happen, hopefully. And but then also to recognize when the spaces already exist and participate in those as well.
[27:15] Joel B. New: So, yeah, that's it. I mean, as far as like actors, you know, they start like my first troop of actors were, you know, like my best friends from undergrad at OCU, and many of them are still like my favorite people to work with. And so just like building that cohort of like-minded creatives and friends is really the best way to go. And you know, if I knew how to find producers, I don't know who knows where I'd be right now. But yeah, yeah.
[27:51] Patrick Oliver Jones: That's yeah, I mean, I mean, I'll let you know.
[27:54] Joel B. New: Yeah, us actors, we're always just groveling for any chance. I'll sing it. I'll do it. Yeah, you need me. Yeah, yeah.
[28:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: But producers are a bit more like arm's length.
[28:03] Joel B. New: Well, we'll see how I feel. Maybe, uh, who are you?
[28:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, there's yes, there can be a little bit harder reach.
[28:09] Joel B. New: Yeah, I once went to this like networking event, and you know, everyone had like their name and like their what they do under it. And you know, I had put writer producer because like I identify as a producer because like I produced my stuff all the time. Like I'm a producer. And some like a writer who just had the word writer on their name tag, saw the word producer on mine, and just like made a beeline and just started like before even introducing themselves, just started like pitching their show. And I was just it was such a learning and eye-opening experience for me because I was like, oh god, do I do that? Is that like no wonder producers are so scared to, you know, right, right? Because us artistic types with that they don't know what they're gonna get, the crazy one or the sensible one or the quiet one, yeah, you never know.
[29:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and I think the answer is we are all of them.
[29:03] Joel B. New: No, it depends on the day. Depends on the day. Depends on probably depends on the work. I assume you have to sell different works differently.
[29:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, yes, especially right now in these virtual theatrical times, you're pitching your project, but you're pitching a version of it that maybe you didn't write it with in mind.
[29:34] Joel B. New: Yeah. So I mean, I was pitching a virtual theater event to a streaming service, and I was really making it up as I was pitching it, which I think is super, super, super professional.
[29:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, of course. That's always the best path.
[29:56] Joel B. New: Yeah, they're like, how like so what is this and who's attached? And I'm just like, ugh, well, and then you just like you make it up as you go, fake it till you make it. Um, you know, spoiler alert, they did not end up picking up the project. But you know, it's fine, it's fine.
[30:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: Their loss to keep yourselves out of trouble.
[30:17] Joel B. New: You go looking for places to hide. You grab a sheet, you grab some chairs, four little feet take to the playroom upstairs. No use in scolding. I know you're holding called. Both of you crowned, both safe and sound in a fold.
[30:50] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now you have not only done full-length musicals, but you've also worked on solo projects. Your EP I found very interesting, the one that was based on Murder, She Wrote.
[31:01] Joel B. New: Yeah, right, right. Is that just a favorite show of yours? And you started being inspired with musical interludes.
[31:09] Joel B. New: Yeah, I mean, like I watched that show growing up, usually with my grandma, and I just have so many fond memories of that show, and just loving Angela Lansbury. I mean, what gay man doesn't love Angela Lansbury? And um, so it's just it's something that I love, and it's very specific, and not a lot of the younger kids these days know what it is, or they kinda know, or you know, so it's becoming more and more vintage by the day. And it was in like 2015, I was doing my first one-man cabaret at the Duplex, and there was a slot in the set list where we needed something. And uh, it was the whole evening was original songs of mine, and there was a slot, and so I went home and I wrote a new song called Cabot Cove, and it flowed, it was written fairly quickly and fairly easily, and it was received really well.
And from that one night of performing that song for the first time, I knew that that was a project that I wanted to work on long term. And so then I finished it and made a six-song EP that was funded through Kickstarter, and um, and then was picked up by the Broadway Records label, and four years later, here we are.
[32:36] Patrick Oliver Jones: As far as doing Kickstarter and basically being, like you said, being your own producer, was that enjoyable to a certain extent because you knew that the end result was gonna mean that was produced?
[32:50] Joel B. New: It was really stressful, especially in the beginning, because I didn't do a whole lot of research on how to crowdfund correctly. And so, yeah, yeah.
[33:03] Joel B. New: There's not again, there's not a wrong way per se, but there are better ways.
[33:09] Joel B. New: Yes, yes, absolutely. And so I again I was just kind of making it up as I went, and I, you know, I wasn't seeing a lot of traction. It was, you know, it was steady, but you know, I'm an all or nothing kind of guy, you know. You know, I didn't want to go the I believe it's Rocket Hub that you can you get to keep whatever you make, even if you don't make the goal. And I knew that that wouldn't be a hot enough fire for me. So I went to Kickstarter and I was like, all or nothing. We get to the goal, we don't get to it. And um, and that really helped me move along. And you know, it was just trial and error of like how to get people's attention. And it was maybe maybe two weeks. So a very short amount of time was left on the campaign where I came up with the hashtag dame it.
And um, if you donated, like I would dub you a dame like Dame Angela Lansbury. And so it uh like I would you would you would become an honorary dame and I would take your Facebook profile photo and I would superimpose the tiara and you know include the hashtag dame it in the corner. And so it just became it, it like it clicked very instantly. Like people got attention that are like, oh, I want to I want Tiara, I want a Tiara, and it was like the simplest thing. And um, like once I figured it out, once I figured out the gimmick of what I was trying to do in order to make the thing, then that became fun.
[34:40] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right. Right.
[34:41] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[34:43] Joel B. New: It's uh and and that that's what's so fun, but also what is so stressful about marketing, because it's again, it's another creative endeavor trying to figure out these ways that we'll connect with an audience that will get you likes and clicks and stuff like that. But at the same time, when it doesn't work, then you're not really sure how to fix it or what to do next, or if you should move on, or you yeah. Did you find a lot of those questions coming at you, especially that with that Kickstarter campaign?
[35:16] Joel B. New: Yes, because you don't know what is working, but you don't it's it's harder to understand why something isn't working.
[35:25] Joel B. New: Yeah when you're marketing. Because if you know the why, then you can correct or change it. But if you don't know, yeah, but I mean you just kind of have to keep sitting with it and leaning into what made you excited about the project in the first place and what makes it specific and what makes it weird, and um one of my campaign ideas was to reach out to all these other like existing dames to see if they would endorse it and endorse the project or something like that. Like, you know, uh Dame Angela Lansbury was very hard to get a hold of, you know. I have a couple of emails from her assistant, and you know, just kind of declined to comment, and that's fine. Um, I'm still, you know, I'm sure she would love it.
Uh so then I I kind of went around and I was I was like, well, you know, if I can't get Dame Angela Lansbury to endorse it, maybe I can get another dame. And so like I reached out to uh Julie Andrews people and I reached out to Dame Edna's people, and I reached out to like all the dames that I felt like the gay community could get behind, because you know, that is a big part of my following, I would say. Um, as they all kindly declined and or didn't respond. Um, I just I took it to the streets and it I was I was like, well, if I can't get official dames, I'm gonna dame people myself. And that was the idea that got me to the dame it part of the campaign. And it's just kind of just like paying attention to uh and and letting those, you know, I guess they're technically failures, like listening to those failures and letting them lead you down a path that could ultimately lead you to a yes or a success.
[37:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, now Cabot Cove, even though it had a theme around it, it was basically individual songs. There's really no, you know, dialogue scenes connecting them.
[37:32] Joel B. New: You know, I enjoy writing songs that are very deeply integrated into the plot, and I like writing songs that can be extracted. I mean, because you have to, I feel like you have to have both, because shows and development in particular for so long are in like this, you know, the circuit of like the development circuit of being in concerts and things like that. And so you've got to get to the point really quickly in those mo in in those presentations so that people lean in and want to know more. But I think it's useful to have songs in your shows and or your trunk that don't need a lot of setup. God, I hate setup in concert. Because again, that goes back to the marketing aspect of it of having a piece that or having a song specifically that can stand on its own, but yet still gives a hint of something more, so that an audience or producer will want to see more.
[38:42] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. Because if it takes you, if the time it takes you to explain what the song is about is longer than the length of the song, which I've seen those, I've seen those readings and those concerts. Um it's just it's just so painful. And I just feel so I just feel so bad for the writers. I'm like, uh, who who's who's not mentoring you to help you? Would you say this is true? Because I do think that a lot of what drives a particular musical, and certainly those individual songs, is how it plays out in those, you know, high school colleges, the auditions, the how it plays out in those that will be singing it day in, day out, and working on it and auditioning with it. Do you think that that is a very strong base of the success of a musical?
[39:33] Patrick Oliver Jones: I do see that is a trend. That's one way to get your songs out there for sure.
[39:38] Joel B. New: Yeah. For example, I was a part of uh the Adams Family musical, the uh the national tour, and "Pulled" was just a huge song. And you know, and for high school and colleges, Adams Family itself just became this juggernaut, done more so there than I think even regionally, it would just become this huge thing. And I think in large part because girls loved singing that song. So then they wanted to perform it and schools wanted to do it. So that that is certainly, I guess, one avenue, I guess a way of having a successful musical.
[40:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I would I would definitely say that's true. Among the many losses of 2020, one of the first here in New York was the loss of the New York Musical Festival, or Nymph as it's known. It's an annual three-week summer festival that has presented more than 30 new musicals in New York's Midtown Theater District since 2004 and has featured the work of more than 8,000 artists and attended by 300,000 theatergoers. I had the privilege of performing in one of those, a musical adaptation of the Swiss Family Robinson. The musical was still in development, but we had a great cast and a fun time putting it together. Joel also had one of his musicals, To Hell and Back, featured in the 2015 Nymph season. Unfortunately, in January of 2020, the festival ceased operations rather suddenly, and musical theater here in New York certainly feels its loss.
[41:20] Joel B. New: Yes, I agree with that. I think um I think their mission statement and what they initially set out to do is exactly the kind of nurturing that new musical works need. Watching my colleagues mount these massive productions of musicals that were underdeveloped and didn't, you know, it didn't need a six, you know, it shouldn't have gotten it didn't need a six figure check. It needed a six week workshop. And that's um, and that's tricky. It's a little cart before the horse. Like I talked earlier about needing to build the thing uh before someone else is willing to like help you build it again or build it better. Uh, but I feel like um yes, but no, you know, you kind of have to, there's a step missing there in understanding what your show really needs. And you know, and a lot of the writers from were from out of town, and so like um I'm I miss what nymph set out to be.
[42:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right. Yeah, they yeah, I th I think uh another correlation is like Sundance Film Festival. You know, it it it was this kind of like in the middle of nowhere. It was just this independent films that were just kind of getting a screening. It was just a way to kind of see what's what's happening in, you know, avant-garde, independent filmmaking, and and now it's basically another just Hollywood red carpet event because all it takes is one or two big movies that come out of it, and then and then it kind of became a juggernaut. Nymph came the same way. Some huge Broadway musicals eventually came out of Nymph. So then it's like, oh, well, well then I need to be on Nymph. Then I want to be and and I'm sure it it probably became bigger than they even thought it was going to be.
[43:41] Joel B. New: Yeah, no, and like they had really good intentions, and I'm really I'm I'm proud that that To Hell and Back um has Nymph among its credits. And none of that goes away. Like that is all. That is all very well and true. And it's it's it's all well and good for us to like you know be sitting here, you know, like I'm pretending I'm drinking some wine and just like ruminating about like all the good old days when Nymph was, you know, two chairs and a black box, you know. But like it's you know back in my day.
[44:13] Patrick Oliver Jones: Exactly, exactly. And you know, and like, you know, and shame shame on me for poo-pooing uh an organization from the sidelines for doing exactly what it set out to do. Now here's a brief timeline of some of Nymph's highlights. In 2008, the musical title of show became the first show to transfer from the New York Musical Theater Festival to a commercial Broadway production, when it opened in the Lyceum Theater in July of that year. However, it closed three months later after only 13 previews and 102 performances. In the following year, however, Next to Normal became the second show to transfer from Nymph to Broadway, and it became a smash hit, winning three Tony Awards, including Best Score and Best Leading Actress for Alice Ripley.
Next to Normal went on to win the 2010 Pulitzer Prize for drama, and that makes it only the ninth musical to be so honored in the history of that award. In 2013, Nymph won a special drama desk award for a decade of creating and nurturing new musical theater, ensuring the future of this essential art form.
[45:31] Joel B. New: So like Nymph did its job and um and per perhaps too well. I don't know. Like it did its job really well, and then people are like, oh my god, like you said, like, you know, now I have to have my piece in in that festival, otherwise it won't matter or it won't get seen, and it's yeah, it's it's one of those um perpetual truth-building things that aren't true necessarily.
[45:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: Exactly, yeah. And with the pandemic, that's been even more true of just trying to get seen, to get noticed. Have you found that your work because you had mentioned about writing for Zoom or not for Zoom, you know, in this virtual world. Um, have you found your work harder or having easier avenues since since everyone's just looking for something, anything online?
[46:21] Joel B. New: Um, well, I think people are more discerning than than looking for anything online. I feel it because we've been at this for a while now, and you know, I've I've I've made press releases, you know, I and few websites fewer websites pick them up now because you know, like online, yes, there are many options, but there's really just one stage. And you can't, you know, like so. We're all we're all clamoring for for the same microphone. And that um I found that to be harder. And especially because I think at the beginning of the pandemic, we were j we artists were just like giving it away. We were giving our art away because that's what we believed in our hearts the country needed. Like we like we as artists, we are we are the healers.
And so we, you know, a lot of us just like gave a lot of content away, which is beautiful. Um, but as we enter month seven, eight, nine, plus, you know, we kind of need to pay the rent. And it's it's hard. And now it's hard to kind of like, you know, I feel like we're we're now mid backpedaling and trying to remind consumers, because that's what audiences are, they're consumers, that um that we're worth we're worth spending your money on.
[47:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, because before it was on YouTube, or we were just kind of putting it up, you know, to to give give people that that that artistic uh flavor, juices that they needed to keep going. But then we want to start closing it off and say, okay, well, now we want you to pay for it. And people are like, well, I are I already have Netflix. You know, we don't want them to go away from it.
[48:18] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. But you're gonna run out of new content on Netflix eventually.
[48:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: Eventually. I mean, I mean, I've I found some stuff on there. I was like, Netflix made this, really. So I mean, I I don't know. It seems like Netflix is their their original content is never-ending and things I've never heard of. Like, how did this ever get approved? But yes.
[48:42] Joel B. New: All right. Well, this has been great talking to you. Thank you so much for sharing your process.
[48:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: It was my pleasure. Thank you for asking such um thoughtful questions.
[48:51] Joel B. New: That's my role. That's why I'm here. Apart from getting to talk about Joel's work and the actual process of his craft, I'm glad that we really got into the marketing, that business side of this profession that can be so daunting for us artist types, right? I mean, we're so creative and we love to embody these characters and get into music or directing or you know, really exercise our artistic muscles. Yet when it comes to that business side, when it comes to promoting ourselves, when it comes to the facts and figures and numbers, sometimes we just aren't the best at it. And so I think that my discussion with Joel was a good reminder that that's something that needs to be just as present and just as strong within us artists as the actual creative part is.
[50:40] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, in charge of writing, editing, and producing this podcast. Incidental music has been provided in this episode by Borrtex. Why I'll Never Make It is a part of the Helium Radio Network and a member of the Broadway Makers Alliance. Join me next week as I talk to Moonami Productions down in Miami, Florida, as we talk more about Why I'll Never Make It's the United States.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
