Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Matthew LaBanca Creates a One-Man Show After Being Fired From a Private Catholic School

A couple of months ago, I talked with a friend and fellow actor Dominic Thrasher about his experiences with a catholic church and the criticism and harsh accusations he faced for being gay and married... Read More

From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It

43 mins
11/6/24

About

A couple of months ago, I talked with a friend and fellow actor Dominic Thrasher about his experiences with a catholic church and the criticism and harsh accusations he faced for being gay and married. Well, another friend and fellow actor of mine also heard that episode and reached out to me with his own story to tell about being fired from his teaching job for the same thing.

Matthew LaBanca has starred on Broadway in the original companies of Young Frankenstein, White Christmas, and A Christmas Carol. We touch on auditioning or both onstage and on-camera roles as well as the importance hair brings not only to our type and castability as men but how it also influences the way we carry ourselves and the confidence we bring into the room. A confidence that Matthew once had as a teacher as well at a private catholic school, but he shares how and why he no longer has that job.

----------

  • Subscribe to get ad-free access to the full conversations, which include auditions stories.
  • Donate to WINMI and support podcast production with a one-time or ongoing contribution.
  • Contact me directly if you'd like to support WINMI but have limited funds to do so, then I can offer you reduced-price or even free access to the subscription.

Follow WINMI: Website | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube

Why I’ll Never Make It is an award-winning, Top Theater Podcast with actor and singer Patrick Oliver Jones and is a production of WINMI Media. Theme music created by Patrick Oliver Jones, and background music is by John Bartmann (used under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License).

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Patrick Oliver Jones: A couple of months ago, I talked with a friend and fellow actor, Dominic Thrasher, about his experiences with the Catholic Church and the criticism and harsh accusations he faced for being gay and married.

[0:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, another friend and fellow actor of mine also heard that episode and reached out to me via email with his own story about being fired from his teaching job for the same thing.

[0:27] Matthew LaBanca: Hi, my name is Matthew LaBanca.

[0:29] Matthew LaBanca: I was born in New Fairfield, Connecticut, but I live in New York.

[0:33] Matthew LaBanca: I've lived here for, oh gosh, almost 30 years now.

[0:37] Matthew LaBanca: And I'm an actor, a writer, a teacher, and a musician.

[0:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: Matthew has starred on Broadway in the original companies of Young Frankenstein, White Christmas, and A Christmas Carol.

[0:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: And in our conversation today, we touch on auditioning for both onstage and on-camera roles, as well as the importance even hair can bring not only to our type and castability as men, but how it also influences the way we carry ourselves and the confidence we bring into the room.

[1:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: A confidence that Matthew once had as a teacher at a private Catholic school.

[1:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: But he shares with us how and why he no longer has that job.

[1:23] Matthew LaBanca: And to me, it was quite a moment of ambush and uncertainty.

[1:29] Matthew LaBanca: And I wondered, do I need an attorney present here?

[1:32] Matthew LaBanca: And then I also wondered about the First Amendment of the Constitution, which allows for religious liberty.

[1:38] Matthew LaBanca: Because in New York, you're not allowed to be fired for being gay.

[1:46] Patrick Oliver Jones: Welcome to another episode of Why I'll Never Make It, an award-winning theater podcast.

[1:52] Patrick Oliver Jones: I'm Patrick Oliver Jones, a New York actor and singer, and each week I talk with fellow artists about personal setbacks and professional hardships with lessons we can all learn from.

[2:04] Patrick Oliver Jones: The website is why I'll never make it dot com, where you can donate, subscribe, and find past episodes.

[2:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: Again, that's why I'll never make it dot com.

[2:29] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, welcome, Matthew.

[2:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: It is so great to reconnect with you again.

[2:33] Patrick Oliver Jones: I'm so glad that you're on the podcast today.

[2:36] Matthew LaBanca: Thank you, Patrick.

[2:37] Matthew LaBanca: It's good to reconnect with you.

[2:38] Matthew LaBanca: It's been, oh gosh, seven, eight years.

[2:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right, right.

[2:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, we first met doing a show called Civil War Voices, which is a musical I'd never really heard of before.

[2:48] Matthew LaBanca: Did you know anything about that show before we did it?

[2:51] Matthew LaBanca: The only thing I knew was that my old friend Laura Bergquist was involved with the off-Broadway run of it.

[2:58] Matthew LaBanca: And she was a music director for that.

[3:00] Matthew LaBanca: She was ours, and that the arrangements of those tunes that everybody knows, all public domain, were just so beautiful.

[3:08] Matthew LaBanca: And it was really a pleasure.

[3:10] Matthew LaBanca: And it was fun to work with you and see your Abraham Lincoln.

[3:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, I actually had to grow up my beard for that.

[3:17] Matthew LaBanca: Yes.

[3:17] Matthew LaBanca: It was a lot of fun doing that up in Gretna, which is a small little town.

[3:23] Matthew LaBanca: It was really actually quite nice, a respite from the city life.

[3:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, for sure, for sure.

[3:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: And then it's now it's back to reality.

[3:31] Matthew LaBanca: Yes, exactly.

[3:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, it's always interesting where people get their start, and I think you were the first person to have had a family magic act as your introduction to the stage.

[3:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: So your whole family was involved with this.

[3:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: How did this get started?

[3:47] Matthew LaBanca: My father, I come from a whole family of educators.

[3:51] Matthew LaBanca: My father is a retired teacher from the New York City school system.

[3:56] Matthew LaBanca: My mom taught nursery school.

[3:57] Matthew LaBanca: My brother is a principal now at a school in Connecticut, and I'm also a teacher.

[4:02] Matthew LaBanca: But in the downtime and needing to make more money in like the 70s, 80s, my father had a family magic act, and my mother was involved.

[4:13] Matthew LaBanca: He sawed my mother in half.

[4:15] Matthew LaBanca: He made my brother and I disappear.

[4:17] Matthew LaBanca: I mean, you name it, we did it.

[4:19] Matthew LaBanca: It was all the vacation money, and it was my first experiences on the stage, the LaBanca Family Magic Act.

[4:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: How about that?

[4:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: How fun.

[4:29] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, what age did you start joining the Family Act?

[4:34] Matthew LaBanca: I was five years old.

[4:35] Matthew LaBanca: I remember truly, this is my first memory of being on the stage.

[4:40] Matthew LaBanca: I remember being hoisted out of what we call the metamorphosis trunk.

[4:45] Matthew LaBanca: My right hand, my mom, my left hand, my dad.

[4:48] Matthew LaBanca: They picked me out because I appeared out of thin air.

[4:51] Matthew LaBanca: I was waving an American flag.

[4:53] Matthew LaBanca: It was like the show finale, and there were red, white, and blue footlights, and I remember like taking the bow.

[4:59] Matthew LaBanca: We did it for like the Lions Club at a local auditorium.

[5:03] Matthew LaBanca: Love it.

[5:04] Matthew LaBanca: But we had a trailer on the side yard.

[5:07] Matthew LaBanca: We weren't trailer trash, but we had a trailer.

[5:10] Matthew LaBanca: We would put all the big illusions in the trailer and go to these different corporate events.

[5:16] Matthew LaBanca: And growing up, as I got older, instead of mowing lawns, I was doing birthday parties for local kids as like 11, 12, 13 years old.

[5:25] Matthew LaBanca: And I would do like the card tricks and the little all the different sleight of hand things.

[5:30] Matthew LaBanca: And yeah, that was my growing up.

[5:33] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, you would do that by yourself, or was that also with the family?

[5:36] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, dad would book the gig.

[5:40] Matthew LaBanca: I would go to like some kids' house for a birthday party.

[5:43] Matthew LaBanca: Work the party.

[5:44] Matthew LaBanca: Do your magic.

[5:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: That's absolutely wonderful.

[5:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, being that this was a family act, though, are you still beholden to the rules and the secrecy of never revealing your secrets?

[5:54] Matthew LaBanca: That's very funny that you talk about secrets because yes, we were always taught how was that how was that done?

[6:01] Matthew LaBanca: How did you do that trick?

[6:02] Matthew LaBanca: We were always supposed to say, very well, we did it very well.

[6:06] Matthew LaBanca: And there was in my bedroom growing up, I had two closets.

[6:11] Matthew LaBanca: There was the closet for my clothes, but then the other smaller one over the downstairs area was the magic closet.

[6:18] Matthew LaBanca: And like all the tricks were kept in that closet, and we weren't supposed to like share any of the secrets.

[6:25] Matthew LaBanca: And I think it's just very apropos that as a gay man, I had a closet in my bedroom where I literally was not supposed to share any of the secrets.

[6:35] Matthew LaBanca: And those secrets I still have not.

[6:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes.

[6:38] Matthew LaBanca: You know, it's good that you've kept that closet closed your whole life.

[6:43] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes, yes, for sure.

[6:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, going on to story number one.

[6:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: This is, you wanted to talk about some religious discrimination that you faced as a performing artist and as a teacher in the Catholic Church after you married your husband.

[6:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, for a little background, were you a Catholic yourself?

[7:02] Matthew LaBanca: Did you grow up in the church?

[7:04] Matthew LaBanca: I did.

[7:05] Matthew LaBanca: I grew up, I was baptized at infancy, and my mom taught nursery school in the basement of our local Catholic church, and she was actually my first teacher.

[7:16] Matthew LaBanca: We would go there.

[7:18] Matthew LaBanca: I that's where I received my, I went to regular public school, but I also did see what they called CCD, your catechism, and did all the sacraments and grew up in a church where I felt very welcome and embraced.

[7:35] Matthew LaBanca: When I went away to college, I went to the University of Connecticut, and that was one of my, that was my job at school, aside from being a student.

[7:45] Matthew LaBanca: I was the music director for all the student masses that they would have on Sunday nights at the local Catholic church there, all the Jesuits, and I worked there for like four or five years.

[7:56] Matthew LaBanca: And when I came to New York, I found myself looking for a solvency work again.

[8:03] Matthew LaBanca: So I've always been in the Catholic Church, the church I had opportunities to work basically my whole life.

[8:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: And so was it, was it difficult for you to come out to your parents?

[8:16] Patrick Oliver Jones: I mean, how religious were they?

[8:18] Patrick Oliver Jones: How did they take that?

[8:20] Matthew LaBanca: It was in the mid-90s, the time, what was the different time?

[8:26] Matthew LaBanca: I didn't grow up.

[8:29] Matthew LaBanca: I mean, I grew up seeing the AIDS crisis and seeing the AIDS quilt and being aware of all of that.

[8:34] Matthew LaBanca: It didn't quite affect me to the extent where I said, Oh, it's going to happen to me.

[8:40] Matthew LaBanca: That happened to people, you know, five, ten years before me, I would think.

[8:45] Matthew LaBanca: So that wasn't on my radar, but for my parents and especially my mom, it was.

[8:51] Matthew LaBanca: And she was so nervous that her son was gonna get AIDS.

[8:56] Matthew LaBanca: So that was a difficult process.

[8:58] Matthew LaBanca: My father had was, I when I came out to him, I came out to both of them at the same time.

[9:05] Matthew LaBanca: And he took it a little bit more easily than my mom did.

[9:10] Matthew LaBanca: She reacted more emotionally to it.

[9:12] Matthew LaBanca: I never ever doubted that they were in my corner and that they loved me, and that I had to leave the room with the magic closet.

[9:24] Matthew LaBanca: Like I was still able to stay at home, you know.

[9:27] Matthew LaBanca: That was, that was always I come from a very tight-knit Italian family.

[9:35] Matthew LaBanca: And I think that idea of when you're an immigrant and you like my grandfather came through Ellis Island, and when you're an immigrant and immigrant family, like through the generations, like traditions and closeness has really stuck.

[9:47] Matthew LaBanca: Like I feel very fortunate that as somebody in show business, I didn't have to, like probably a lot of your listeners came from other areas of the country.

[9:56] Matthew LaBanca: Like I grew up an hour and 15 minutes outside of New York City.

[10:00] Matthew LaBanca: So I didn't, I would look at people like you, you're from Alabama, is that right?

[10:04] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right, Alabama, yeah.

[10:05] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, and I look at people like you and other friends from Iowa and Washington.

[10:09] Matthew LaBanca: I'm like, and they would, you would, it was this pilgrimage to New York.

[10:13] Matthew LaBanca: I'm in awe of you all, because I don't know that I could have done something like that as much as I love my artist and as much as I love my career, and as many blessings as my career has given me, that's a real, that takes real strength.

[10:29] Matthew LaBanca: And I'm fortunate to this day to still have my parents and my family.

[10:34] Matthew LaBanca: Like my inner circle is still with me.

[10:37] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[10:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: And as you were growing up and started actually dating boys, did you bring them home?

[10:43] Patrick Oliver Jones: Did you show them to your parents?

[10:46] Patrick Oliver Jones: Look at him.

[10:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: Look at this one.

[10:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: What do you think?

[10:51] Matthew LaBanca: Um, I did.

[10:53] Matthew LaBanca: I did.

[10:54] Matthew LaBanca: And it was something that I wanted.

[10:56] Matthew LaBanca: And I, you know, we, it was definitely one step, one foot in front of the other.

[11:02] Matthew LaBanca: But I did, and I introduced them to different people that I have, and eventually to my now husband Rowan.

[11:08] Patrick Oliver Jones: And it was with your husband once you became married that it became a problem within the church that you were teaching at.

[11:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: What exactly were the first hints of problems happening?

[11:20] Matthew LaBanca: Right.

[11:20] Matthew LaBanca: So I'd been working at Corpus Christi Church in Woodside for about nine years.

[11:25] Matthew LaBanca: And I'd become very friendly with all the staff there.

[11:29] Matthew LaBanca: And one of the staff members came to the choir room where I had a little office area.

[11:34] Matthew LaBanca: He said, We were married August 1st.

[11:37] Matthew LaBanca: And maybe three weeks later, he said, Matt, there was a, I want you to know there was a phone call about you to the diocese or from the diocese of Brooklyn.

[11:46] Matthew LaBanca: Like somebody saw something about your wedding online.

[11:50] Matthew LaBanca: I said, Really?

[11:51] Matthew LaBanca: I said, is the pastor?

[11:52] Matthew LaBanca: No, he said, the pastor, no, the pastor meaning my boss, who's under the diocese.

[11:58] Matthew LaBanca: And you know, it's like a whole hierarchy, if anybody's familiar with how that sort of thing works.

[12:02] Matthew LaBanca: And he said, you know, you're nothing's happened and everything's fine.

[12:05] Matthew LaBanca: We think it's like just like a little blip on the radar.

[12:09] Matthew LaBanca: A month later, I had a music planning session because I played the organ and I directed the choirs there.

[12:16] Matthew LaBanca: And I saw we were gonna plan Advent music, and I was called into a meeting with my boss, and unbeknownst to me, there was another representative from the diocese, a nun who was there.

[12:31] Matthew LaBanca: They sat me down and they said, This is now a month later, in the middle of September, that somebody reported my wedding to the diocese that same-sex marriage was not approved by the Catholic Church.

[12:42] Matthew LaBanca: And that they wanted to hear my side of the story.

[12:48] Matthew LaBanca: And to me, it was quite a moment of ambush and uncertainty.

[12:54] Matthew LaBanca: And I wondered, do I need an attorney present here?

[12:57] Matthew LaBanca: And then I also wondered about the First Amendment of the Constitution, which allows for religious liberty, because in New York, you're not allowed to be fired for being gay.

[13:07] Matthew LaBanca: But if you're labeled as a minister in a religious institution, that institution is allowed to legally discriminate and terminate your employment.

[13:20] Matthew LaBanca: So that happened.

[13:24] Matthew LaBanca: And a month after that, where I was saying, Sai, this was during the pandemic.

[13:30] Matthew LaBanca: This was during 2021.

[13:33] Matthew LaBanca: And I had basically disappeared from the church where I was working.

[13:37] Matthew LaBanca: I basically disappeared because I was also working at a school down the street, also a Catholic school.

[13:43] Matthew LaBanca: I wasn't teaching there anymore, although I started the academic year.

[13:46] Matthew LaBanca: I was there for like two, three weeks, and then suddenly I wasn't there.

[13:50] Matthew LaBanca: I'm getting texts left and right.

[13:52] Matthew LaBanca: Where are you?

[13:53] Matthew LaBanca: Where are you?

[13:54] Matthew LaBanca: And I wanted to show them that I could be discreet because this job was my solvency job as an actor.

[14:02] Matthew LaBanca: We all need that.

[14:04] Matthew LaBanca: And I was, this was my health insurance.

[14:09] Matthew LaBanca: I was vested in the pension plan.

[14:11] Matthew LaBanca: It was three blocks from my house.

[14:14] Matthew LaBanca: And I was working as a performer.

[14:16] Matthew LaBanca: I was singing. I was making music. It was like, and I grew up knowing all that it was community-based. I was now in my 40s. I wanted community, all these amazing elements to it. Yet always in the back of my mind, it was a little seed of what if. And well, it bloomed in a way that I hoped that it wouldn't, but it did because a month later, uh, the representative from the diocese of Brooklyn, who is known in the diocese among employees as the angel of death. He's the bishop's right hand man. And he came and he uh offered me a severance package, saying, um, we're gonna give you $10,000. If you'll stay quiet and not say anything about this, no disparagement, non-disclosure for your parish job as the organist, and another $10,000 for your job as a music teacher down the street.

But if I sign these, I said, then I can't say anything to anybody ever. Yeah, you can't. You can't. We'll just say that Mr. Labanka is no longer with us working here. And I decided that I couldn't sign it because we all know, as your listeners, I'm sure also feel this way that you're trained to be an artist, you're trained to express yourself, to be the most authentic person that you can be and bring that into your work. And I couldn't live with myself, I don't think. If I I mean, here I was in this community with over a thousand people that were probably affected by this, between my choir, my students, the family, the neighbors. And Rowan would always laugh. He'd say, Matt, we walk a block to go get a get a burger somewhere.

And everybody's like, Hi, Matt. Hi, Matt, how are you? And I loved that. I loved that. And I think that was probably the biggest difficulty was letting that having that community taken away from me in the middle of that. And knowing that I could never say anything to those people if I signed these papers. And luckily, we were in a position financially where I did not have to take that money. I made a video to explain what I thought was going to be one time to the community, this story about what happened, because I said you deserve to know what happened in doing that. I evidently turned their uh their severance agreement down. The video went viral. And when all was said and done, the story went viral.

It was picked up by the New York Times, by the Daily News, by all the local news media channels saying, How could this happen? And when the dust settled, I realized that I had a story to tell, and I had the freedom to tell it. And that story has been turned into a solo show called Communion that's making its world premiere off Broadway this November, November of 2024.

[17:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: Now, someone who grew up in the church myself, so I I certainly understand this, and and my pastor knew about my my own attractions and the fact that I was I was bisexual. And so I felt supported by him, even though it was still something that as a as a pastor, he would try to just encourage me to continually seek God in this way, and you know, trying to make sure that I was I was on the right path. And so did you ever get a sense of that? Was there any ever push of you to go one way or the other?

[18:03] Matthew LaBanca: No, I didn't. Um I my whole experience growing up in the church.

[18:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: What church did you grow up in?

[18:11] Matthew LaBanca: Presbyterian.

[18:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: Presbyterian. Okay. Which I believe does allow for same-sex marriage now.

[18:17] Matthew LaBanca: Um depends on there's the liberal branch and there's the conservative branch. I was a member of the conservative branch.

[18:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: Okay. Um, well, it's funny to say about liberal and conservative, because within the Catholic Church, you often think, oh, it's just the institution of the Catholic Church. And while that's true, and while we do have, you know, papal infallibility, so to speak, with the Pope, um, there's also all these different orders. You have the Jesuits and the Franciscans and all these different conferences, where there's there's so many. And different institutions, different orders will kind of, you know, play on it in a different way and be more open and more accepting. Like in college, my the Jesuit priests there, they were they knew I was gay. And in fact, my parish priest over here knew I was gay as well.

And nobody ever made me feel guilty about it. Nobody was ever trying to save my soul, whatever that means, right? And it was just that basis of love one another, as which is so present in so many of the great religious and spiritual traditions in the world. Just love one another as you would be loved. And that's what I got.

[19:31] Matthew LaBanca: So up, but all it takes is one person. Do you think that had that person not called the diocese that you would probably still be there today?

[19:40] Matthew LaBanca: Uh very possibly. But you know, it's the whole premise where uh if God closes a door, he opens a window. And as someone who's experienced religious discrimination, it's not easy, it leaves scars. But I took the pain and I took the experience, and I wanted to turn it into you take your pain and you turn it into art sometimes. Art doesn't always come from pain, but a lot of times it does. And um I wanted to turn those lemons into lemonade, not only for the my own healing, but this story.

[20:43] Matthew LaBanca: I found a lead producer, if you can believe it, on playbill.com. I said, How do you find a producer? A wonderful producer, Alyssa Orlando, who is working on Kristen Chenowitz Queen of Versailles as a co-producer. She's working on, she was an investor in the notebook, and she took a liking, a shine to my piece. And you know, we want to take it on tour. There's a lot we want to do with it. So we're doing our best to birth it well at the cell theater on 23rd Street in November. And I'm curious with this play, but also just in your experience of it in general, was there a sense of you wanting to change the church and kind of be an activist there? Or did you more just want to kind of change yourself, work on yourself, heal yourself, and express it that way? Which side of that did you fall on, or maybe somewhere in between?

[21:38] Matthew LaBanca: I I it's honestly it really is bold because um, you know, you I wanted to, when you speak your truth, when you're an actor and you say it to their faces, like there's no question that it's empowering for you. But I also wrote this um with the hope that it will inspire people uh in places of religious authority to reconsider the pain that's they inflict at the hands of being so discriminatory. Not every church does that. There are many Christian churches that are open and affirming, and then there are some that are not. Um we're having an event about a month before we open, and it's we've invited, I cannot tell you the number of yeses that we've gotten from gay church group leaders, from Catholic priests, from employees who've been fired, from Baptist, episcopal different uh, and also people from my teaching union, they're all coming in order to help spread the word about this.

People really want to aid in this assistance because they realize that um, you know, the that the fracture that occurs in the life of a gay person of faith is very unnecessary and is very unfair, and that it's okay and important to hold up a mirror to religious institutions whose discriminatory practices are doing clearly more harm than good.

[23:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: This is something that, as I said, since I grew up in the church, it's something that I've thought about myself. And I've fallen on the side of well, there are churches that accept it, there are churches that don't, and people can choose the church that they want to be a part of, and not disparaging either either one of those, you know, because they both have a different ideology, a different belief of what the right thing to do is. And for me, I sometimes have a hard time calling it discrimination because I think of it as, well, that's their belief, and then these others have a different belief.

[23:50] Matthew LaBanca: Yes. Was that ever something that you wrestled with as well?

[23:53] Matthew LaBanca: Absolutely, of course. And it's one of the themes that runs through the show because what's very important to me, I work with elementary students, I'm an elementary music teacher, and one of the joys of being an elementary teacher and living in the neighborhood where they where they live is that you see these students grow up from their childhood through adolescence and and you know what's inside them. I mean, it it means so much to me to see that. And also knowing that I was a child growing up within this faith. I didn't choose the faith. They didn't choose the faith. You can say, Oh, you choose to be confirmed. I don't know any any 13-year-old who's gonna say no to their parents, right? So a Catholic elementary school, Catholic high school, and a lot of them say, Oh, now I'm going to St. John's. Now I'm going to uh uh Georgetown, wherever they're going, they're going to a Catholic, going to Notre Dame, I'm going to Catholic college.

Is that really their choice? And does as grown adults like you and I, yes, you it becomes a choice for sure. But I have a real soft spot. Having worked with children for so many years, and knowing that I, you know, Gaydar is real, and you just know, you know, young and old, um, very often, not always, but sometimes you know what's um who your students and who are the children that you might know, what they're going to um mature into and who they'll be. And I always want the best for all of them, and I never want them to have to inherit any pain as a result of choices that were made for them.

[25:45] Matthew LaBanca: When it comes to this show communion, what are you hoping people take away from it?

[25:50] Matthew LaBanca: Well, so I know it sounded very serious this whole time that we've been talking, but one of the things that we wanted to do, my director, her name is Kara Simring, and she is the artistic director at the Cell Theater, and she's brilliant with new works. She was my director for a solo show that I wrote about 10 years ago that um that won an award at the United Solo Theater Festival at Theatre Row, which is a great solo festival for people who who like that sort of thing. She said, Matt, you're a teacher, you're a choir director. I want singing in this play, and I don't just want you sing, I want everybody singing. Say, here, is that gonna work? She said, It's gonna work, and we're gonna make it work.

And it did work. Because when you've been teaching for so long, you know what works to draw things out of people, and you know how to phrase things and you know what techniques to use. So we wrote that into the script. And when I walk in, I'm carrying a Glockenspiel, kind of like you hear in the opera house, right? And you hear that minor third, the ding dong. And it's not that the show is starting. Well, the the audience unbeknownst to them is my choir, and we're in a rehearsal, and it's the last Sunday before our last choir mass, and we're learning the closing hymn, and I sit at my piano and we do some call and response. And before you know it, you have communion. And you have communion of an audience, of singers, of a choir.

And it really, it's not that big of a leap if you have theater audience in New York City to sing, right? It's folded and and into a lot of the show, not all of the show, just here and there, right? Um, and there's a lot of humor. There's a lot of calling out of the hypocrisy of the church, and I use a lot of humor for that. I mean, you work with Mel Brooks for a little while, and that'll happen for you, you know. Um, and so we um then take a sharp turn. Because, you know, just like in that advent planning session that I thought was just gonna be run of the mill, it was not. And you're uh blindsided. And so that's part of the show. It's about an hour long, and it takes people on a journey of heartbreak and of humor, and hopefully, and I believe to a hopeful place of resilience.

[28:22] Patrick Oliver Jones: Do you feel that you have become that hopeful, resilient person?

[28:27] Matthew LaBanca: Oh, yeah.

[28:29] Matthew LaBanca: I mean, it's not like pure every day. You know, there's plenty of days where I'll walk by and like doubt. I'll see some of those old church ladies sitting on the bench, like where I live, and I know that they still go to that church where I used to work. And some of them won't make eye contact with me. And some of them are like, hi Matt, how I mean, everybody's different. And you just have to kind of hold your head up and move forward and you know let people be where they are with their beliefs and share your story and hope that it makes an impact for healing and for hope in the world that people can be accepted and loved for who they are and for who they love.

[29:20] Matthew LaBanca: Well, getting into story number two, we're going to take a slight turn from religious discrimination and to maybe hair discrimination. Because certainly men sometimes have to deal with whether they have a head of hair, whether they don't, being bald. You know, these kind of things can affect, especially as an actor. They can affect the roles you're cast in, how you see yourself, how you perceive yourself as an actor. And so for years you wrestled with whether or not to have a hair piece. Now, when did you start losing your hair? This is such a turn from being four. But I mean, it's something that you think about, right? I started losing my hair when I was about 20, 21 years old. I was I was a kid, really.

I was still in college. And I did the whole rogue thing, and I did the whole propecia thing, and whatever I could do, please, please keep it. And uh it hath left me. So I had to decide like what do I want to do? There was this um, there was this stuff called topic. It was like in a can, right? Yeah, you just like dabble it on your head, right? It was my pepper shaker, and uh and I did that. I did that for a long time, you know, because you're right, it does affect your um your work, it affects your archetype, and it affects um if you're gonna get callbacks, all of those things. And I'll never forget when I went to my agent's office, and I had just come from it was this, it wasn't a hair club for men, but it was a place called the penthouse.

Well, that's something else entirely, isn't it though? Uh loads of fun. So we were at the penthouse, it was near the Empire State Building, and this guy, I'll never forget him. Um, he had a very thick accent. And he when I first showed him my hair with the with the topic, he's like, Oh, that's a lot of topic. That's a lot, that's a lot. And he said, I said, it is. We need to do something about this. And so we I got a hair piece, and why and my whole thing was, you know, can you make it natural? And it took a while, but um I actually felt pretty good about the way it looked for the most part. You know, nothing's perfect, but for stage work and for auditions and everything, it was great. And then it started like bleeding over into my personal life.

I'm like, oh maybe I look cuter with this. And I should years, years of all that until I finally got to a place where I said, I don't want to wear this anymore. I'm at these dance auditions, because that was my bread and butter for a long time as a as a song and dance man. And you know, it's just sweating off my head, and those commercials where they go swimming in the pool. That's can you swear on this podcast? You could say what you want to say. It's bullshit. But you know, you you come to terms with yourself and and uh to self-acceptance for who you are. And the hard part was that I said, Well, how is this gonna affect my auditions and my work as a younger type? You know, you think of somebody who's bald often as an older type.

I think how old are you by this point? Now I'm 49. So I've embraced like yeah, but but I mean now back then when I took it off. Yeah, oh, this was maybe about 10 years ago, maybe maybe a little less. But you know, I um I was always a bit of a late bloomer, and um, you know, I looked a little younger than than my age and stuff, so but now I think I'm where I belong, and et cetera, and the grace are coming in. So um I'm kind of glad that chapter's over. Although I have to say that I did book a TV show, and the first thing that they did was like, so we're gonna bring in hair and makeup. And they did like so. But that's also the beauty of theater. It's like whether you have a head of hair or not, they can cover it up and do whatever they want to.

[33:44] Matthew LaBanca: That's right. That's right. Sometimes you have to prompt their imaginations a little bit. And I'm sure any anyone listening or any of your uh female listeners, especially like how they get their blowouts and get their hair done and do the makeup just right, like you have to, or get it colored a certain color because that's their brand, right? Right. You know, it's um it's definitely a real thing, and well, it's a new brand. It's a new, it's a new day. What was that first audition like going from you know a head full of topic to like, okay, this is me, bald and beautiful. I was petrified. I was petrified, and I was so self-conscious. And I said, I gotta get over this because you know, you can't walk into an audition room with a lack of confidence or belief in yourself.

And I mean, eventually now, all these auditions, I'm doing a lot more on-camera auditions than I am theater auditions. And it's just, I know, yeah, do I know people who have hair pieces for on camera? I mean, I had one for that recent job, and it works, but it's just so much easier. It's just just go. You're you're ready out of the box. Yeah. Well, now what's interesting is that back in the day, Patrick Stewart was dubbed sexiest man alive with his bald head. So I mean, there is a place for it. Yes, make it so.

[35:13] Matthew LaBanca: The three stories shared in this episode are only part of the conversation. Subscribers get early access to the full interviews with guests, not only including these stories, but audition stories as well. Join Why I'll Never Make It and help support this podcast. Go to why I'll never make it.com and click subscribe or find the link in the show notes. And another benefit of being a subscriber, you won't have to listen to any ads either.

[35:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: All right. Well, getting into story number three. You had mentioned doing more on-camera auditions these days than theater auditions. And there was a time when your management pushed you to study and pursue this on-camera work more, but it it made you feel like a failure at first. Well, why was that?

[36:04] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah. Um, I had no technique. Everything I had learned was all. I mean, I was a voice major in college, so everything was opera and grand. And um, I booked a lot of that type of work when I first came to the city, choral work and stuff at the like uh at the Met and these different choral societies. That was the training. So when I went, I remember my first on-camera class that I went to. The the coach, it was like a one-off, you know, actors connection, that kind of a thing. And they were like, You're enunciating way too much. Oh my gosh. Okay. Got it, got it. But it takes a while to get those things and old habits die hard. And um, I just something about being in front of a camera, it was different back.

Like cameras are so prevalent. There, we hold them in our hands. They're glued to our bodies at this point. And back then it wasn't the case. And I would see a camera and freeze a little bit, which was so unusual to me because I would get on the boards and be under a spotlight and it would just like open up. So I'm like, I want to feel that when I'm in front of a camera. And um, I remember my manager at the time, her name was Brianna Benjamin, and she's she's since passed away quite a while ago at this point. But she she was wonderful. And she also said, you know, we can work together, and and I know you want to work in town. At the time I was doing Young Frankenstein, and she saw me go on for the lead.

She signed me, and I said, I want to do more things in town. I don't want to go away for work anymore. I want to build some roots. And she said, okay, that's fine. But a career like that has to include on camera work. I said, no problem. I got this. I got it. And um it took a while to figure that out and to not get get those nerves when you're in in with casting, all the memorizing that I had to do when because I didn't want to be looking at sides the way you could do that in a theater audition. And um, and just to figure out what that was. And, you know, I went back to school, like not like a master's program or anything, but I I found an acting studio and a number of acting studios, and I was in class.

I'm a huge proponent of of staying on top of your technique. And it just keeps your artist alive, you know. You know, you find a community, you find a home of other like-minded people. And that's what I needed to kind of bridge that gap.

[38:46] Matthew LaBanca: Will that gap ever be bridged? I mean, you know. Well, I mean, we we have our we have our tendencies, our talents lean in one direction, but we can broaden it out. I mean, it's the same for me. I'm a theater person, I enunciate, I I sing and speak to the back wall, you know. But bringing that down for this intimate camera type of technique is uh, yeah, it's it's always something I have to kind of adjust my brain every time I go into those auditions. Although I will say I'm not a big fan of self-tapes, but when it comes to on camera, it makes more sense to me because you're in front of a camera. And so those kind of auditions make more sense to me. And since we're doing like everything on camera now, these self-tapes, then it seems like that type of technique is even easier to hone in on because you have to do everything small because you're in an eight by eight bedroom with the camera right there in your face.

[39:39] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, yeah. So having all that practice has has made a huge difference. And just feel more comfortable, but it wasn't always the case. Well, you know, you stick with things. Was there a particular either moment, a particular word that someone said to you when you were in class that that kind of clicked that light bulb for you?

[39:58] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, something about um, you know, we're always worried about looking good. And it's when you don't worry about that, when you're just yourself. That's when you look good. Oh, I gotta look this way, I have to be this way. And sure, there is always going to be technical things about, you know, don't move your head so much, your eye line don't all of that stuff, which is very important. But I think that there's a certain essence that if that you bring of who you are. Why are they gonna cast him and not him? Why are they gonna cast her and not her? And a lot of that is because of just being yourself and not trying to look so good, because then people can tell that you're doing them. It's just be yourself, and then you will look good.

[40:46] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, and and in camera, you know, when all they see is like from your chin to your forehead, then being real, I mean, yeah, you know if someone's faking it or not. It's it's it's really hard to fake that. But yeah, on stage, you have to have 2,000 people see you from the front row to the back row. And so it it is more of a performance. There is more shtick, more you know, kind of bits that you have to do.

[41:13] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, and some of my favorite things were shows where there was shtick built into it and all those 1930s musicals. That was another thing. It was like that technique and fast, louder, faster, funnier, and and Frankenstein. Yeah. Yeah, physical comedy and and sight gags, and it was just fabulous, you know. And I love doing all that. This is just another side of who we are.

[41:35] Matthew LaBanca: Yeah, you just gotta strip all that away and just have a conversation with the camera.

[41:40] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it's a it's it is definitely something that I've had to learn myself.

[41:45] Matthew LaBanca: Well, you look good on camera, kid.

[41:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: Thanks.

[41:49] Matthew LaBanca: Thanks, appreciate it.

[41:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, thank you so much for joining us today. And remember, you can get early access to our full conversation by going to why I'll never Make It dot com and click subscribe, or just look for the link in the show notes.

[42:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, that about does it for this episode. I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, in charge of writing, editing, and producing this podcast. Background music is from John Bartmann and the theme song that was created by me. Stay tuned for the next episode when I ask the final five questions and we talk more about why I'll never make it.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred