Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Peter Allen Vogt - Actor and Comedian on Weight Loss, Jealousy, and the Need to Reinvent Ourselves as Artists

As an actor, one of the more difficult attitudes for me to manage is that of jealousy and an elevated sense of competition for roles and status in this industry. I’ve particularly noticed this since theater has opened up again after the long pandemic shutdown and other actors, not me, are back onstage again... Read More

From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It

57 mins
10/18/21

Featured Shows

About

As an actor, one of the more difficult attitudes for me to manage is that of jealousy and an elevated sense of competition for roles and status in this industry. I’ve particularly noticed this since theater has opened up again after the long pandemic shutdown and other actors, not me, are back onstage again. My guest today, Peter Allen Vogt, is a talented actor in his own right but has struggled with this as well from time to time, especially considering he has a well-known identical twin who is also an actor and comedian.

I first got to know Peter Allen Vogt working for Disney. Both he and I worked at Tokyo and Orlando Disney. He has since moved on to Universal out in Los Angeles, and he is also appeared in such TV shows as Hannah Montana, Parks and Recreation, and American Horror Story. But our first love is theater. We talk about what keeps Peter going and the longevity of his career, as well as the importance of surrounding yourself with those who support and nurture you as an artist. Whether it’s classic shows or new musicals, Peter brings a larger than life quality to all of his roles. In fact, his size has been one of Peter‘s notable characteristics for many years. In our conversation today he gets candid and shares his weight loss journey and what that has meant for his career.

SUBSCRIBE TO WINMI

Final Five Episode with Peter Allen Vogt

Get access to Audition Stories and other bonus content by becoming a monthly or yearly subscriber to Why I’ll Never Make It. Producing this podcast is rewarding in its own way, but I’m essentially a one-man operation. So it is both costly and time-intensive to put together each episode. By subscribing you’ll be supporting these podcasting efforts, and have access to extended conversations and other bonus content. Your financial support of this podcast is greatly appreciated!

  • Subscribe to get access to bonus episodes and extra content
  • Make a one-time Donation to support transcripts and podcast production
  • If you’d like to support WINMI but have limited funds to do so, then contact me directly for reduced-price or even free access to the bonus content.

Follow WINMI: Website | Instagram | YouTube

Why I’ll Never Make It is an award-winning, Top Theater Podcast hosted by actor and singer Patrick Oliver Jones and is a production of WINMI Media. Background music is by John Bartmann and Blue Dot Sessions is used under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: As an actor, one of the more difficult attitudes for me to manage is that of jealousy and an elevated sense of competition for roles and even status in this industry. I particularly notice this as theater is opening up again after the long pandemic shutdown, and other actors, not me, are back on stage again. My guest today, Peter Allen Vogt, is a talented actor in his own right, but has struggled with this as well from time to time, especially considering he has a well-known identical twin who is also an actor and comedian. But after decades in this business, Peter shares with us how he changed that perspective and keeps envy in check.

[0:49] Peter Allen Vogt: Instead of being angry when I see people succeeding, I get inspired now. Or you see someone you're like, they don't deserve that. And it's like, well, it's not up to me to decide that. They worked really hard and look what they got. I'm being lazy. It's not going to be handed to me. I gotta earn it, right?

[1:07] Patrick Oliver Jones: Hello and welcome to Why I'll Never Make It or Win Me for Short, one of Feet Spot's top 25 theater podcasts. I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, an actor and singer for almost 30 years. Each week I talk with fellow actors and creatives as we explore the challenges we face trying to make it in this business. The website is Why I'll Never Make It dot com. There I would love for you to sign up for the monthly newsletter where you'll get podcast updates, bonus content, and info on other artist resources. Learn about all that and more at why I'll never Make It dot com or click on the link in the show notes.

[1:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: I first got to know Peter Allen Vogt working for Disney. Both he and I worked at Tokyo Disney as well as the theme park in Orlando. He has since moved on to Universal out in Los Angeles, and he also appeared in such TV shows as Hannah Montana, Parks and Recreation, and American Horror Story. But our first love is still theater. Whether it's classic shows or new musicals, Peter brings a larger-than-life quality to all of his roles. In fact, his size has been one of Peter's notable characteristics for many years. In our conversation today, he shares his weight loss journey and what that has meant for his career. You'll also hear quite a bit of name-dropping as well. Not because Peter has anything to prove, not by any means, but he has simply worked with so many amazing performers and creatives over the years who have inspired and motivated him.

So look for a cheat sheet of sorts in the show notes, in case there's a name or two that you aren't familiar with. But first we talk about what keeps Peter going and the longevity of his career, as well as the importance of surrounding yourself with those who support and nurture you as an artist.

[3:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Finally, right? Right? We've only been trying to do this for like a year and a half.

[3:18] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah.

[3:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: That pandemic ruined everything.

[3:20] Peter Allen Vogt: I know. How dare that?

[3:22] Patrick Oliver Jones: I'm glad it's over.

[3:26] Peter Allen Vogt: Right. Well, that's really one of the things I love about this podcast is that I can connect with people like you that I haven't seen in a while because it's been like 20 years since we've been in the same room. And so what would you say? I mean, because you were obviously acting before then, but what would you say has been your longevity that's kept you going, both as an actor on stage and on screen?

[3:46] Peter Allen Vogt: Wow, that's a good question. You didn't tell me you were gonna ask that. Um, I don't know. I think part of it is I've been lucky enough to meet some great people. I think that helps anybody in the industry, people that believe in you and get you work. I think I'm a weird actor who loves to get notes. So I'm always looking to improve. And then I feel like we have to always reinvent ourselves as things happen and change. You know, I've worked for the Disney Corporation, you know, we all worked at Disney and Florida together, and then I worked out here at Disney and I've done Japan Disney. Um, and I work for Universal, I do an improv show at Universal, but I also was a host for God, I've been at Universal here for 20 years, and I've been working as a host for them for 15 of those years, as well as hosting in different clubs here in LA, as well as performing in film and TV and movie, you know, doing all that other stuff.

But it's nice to have that like one core, because I remember when I was in Orlando for nine years, it's nice to have that core job that you have that pays the bills, and then you can bounce around and do these other gigs that fulfill your creative side.

[4:56] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, you know, it's funny, right from the people that we met at Tokyo Disney C, I connected with a couple of people from LA. So when I came back, I did not jump right back into the world of film and TV as much, but oddly enough, survived for almost two years doing professional theater in LA, which is rare.

[5:16] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, that's tough to do in LA.

[5:18] Patrick Oliver Jones: Not a huge theater town, but some of the connections I made from Disney, and that's the other thing is I'm ready to meet anybody, talk to anybody, just ready to just I'm a really bad networker in the sense of selling myself.

[5:32] Peter Allen Vogt: Right.

[5:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: But I certainly have enjoyed supporting other people, and from that have garnered some good friends. And one of the guys that saw us all performing there ran a Shakespeare company here in LA and for a few years kept me employed.

[5:46] Peter Allen Vogt: How about that?

[5:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: I will say that that's not one of my strong suits either is the networking.

[5:52] Peter Allen Vogt: So yeah, yeah, because it's difficult to sell yourself and not, at least for me, not feel like I'm coming across like an arrogant asshole, you know.

[6:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[6:00] Peter Allen Vogt: And so not to jump ahead, but why I'll never make it because I'm a bad networker.

[6:05] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right. Exactly.

[6:06] Peter Allen Vogt: Exactly. No, that's that's one of my deficiencies as well. But you mentioned it as far as part of that longevity is the people that you've networked with or people that have helped you along your career. So, in what ways, even though you're bad at it, in what ways have you been able to utilize that?

[6:23] Peter Allen Vogt: I think I've always believed in if you really work hard, it should pay off, right? I'm like one of those people. And I think that I was lucky enough, I guess lucky or you know, fortune smiled on me that there were certain people that I met that enjoyed that, that saw that in me, enjoyed my work, liked my dedication, and gave me that opportunity to keep moving forward, you know. I mean, Gary Marshall is a huge part of that. Um, not just putting me in movies, but I also performed at his theater a lot, doing plays and musicals, and my brother, which I know will bring up, my twin. I should have bring that in an awful way. But my twin and I, Paul, you know, um, Gary produced we did a two-man improv show with this amazing woman, Rachel Lawrence, who is she's funny, but she also is one of the top vocal coaches here in LA, and she's massively talented, and so she was our music director.

Paul and I put together a show. We would have a guest star each time. The one time we had Mo Collins, who was with all of us at Disney. And then the other was my friend Edie, who everyone knows from the Gemstones now. She's Judy Gemstone, but we've been close friends for years, and she was our other guest star for when we did the run. So Gary believing in you and supporting someone that high up. And when you do that show, the people that show up to see it, you know, and that gives you that credit, you know, when you do something, when you perform with somebody, when your name starts getting out there, all of a sudden people want to work with you and you haven't changed anything. It just it's the exposure, I guess, is the best way to put it, especially here in LA.

I know I think in New York it might be a little different because I feel like it's so compact there in New York, and everybody knows each other in a way. That theater is theater, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You know, we're here in LA, it's like we're so spread out that people are like, where'd you come from? Or they'll meet me and they'll be like, You're great. We love you. I've done a bunch of original shows and stuff, and then be like, Oh, you have a brother? Is he in the business?

[8:44] Peter Allen Vogt: A little bit, a little bit, a little bit, a little tiny bit. But I feel that happens more to us when, you know, I lived in New York for a while, lived in Queens and worked at Ellen Stardust Diner. There's a little tidbit for everybody. Um, in the very early days before before it is what it was now. But um, I did like a national tour out of New York and I did a lot of improv in New York and then actually came back to Florida. So I started in Buffalo, we're really from Buffalo, moved down to Florida. I went to New York, moved back down, and then came to LA. So I think it's just that I said before, like the reinvention, but it's also when I started out, I wanted I ran a theater company when I was like 19 at a theater company, and we did musicals.

We did, you know, Runaways, Liz Suedo's musical. She's from Buffalo. We did the first Western premiere of it. Um, I was in college at the time, but we were the first time that we used high school students, college students. We did all of this great stuff. My brother was the director, I produced it, I was in it. We kept doing stuff like that, but for some reason along the way, I lost that sight that you can do all of that. You can be a writer and an actor. I thought you just had to be a I can only be a performer, right?

[10:05] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I mean, there is something to be said for finding your lane and sticking with it, but I think over the last, I would say, especially 10 years or so, and probably even going back further, but definitely the last 10 years, there's just more of this emphasis on being able to do it all and having...

[10:05] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, yeah, not just that triple threat. That's always kind of been a thing, but now you want to be able to write and produce and improv, and there's so many different skills to keep acquiring.

[10:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, like what you're doing, doing your podcast, creating your own content that then people see this is your exposure. People see this, they're introduced to you, they discover you, and now you're gonna get other things from it. You know what I'm saying? Like that's the hope, right?

[10:46] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, exactly. But that's that wasn't when we started out in this industry. That's not anything that we knew. I didn't know that I had to learn how to work a computer, get my sound right, videotape myself for an audition.

[11:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: The whole self-tape thing, yeah.

[11:02] Peter Allen Vogt: It and even with the pandemic, it's just gotten crazier and crazier. Like I uh for voiceovers, you know, I had a great voiceover agent, and when the pandemic hit, they were like, you just don't have the right equipment. And now that we're in a pandemic, all these great amazing people have invested in home studios and we're dropping everyone who doesn't have one. So I have to now, you know, I'm regrouping, and I'm not I'm also a person who takes the punches and doesn't lay down. Like I'm regrouping, I'm gonna get myself back into that stream of performing again. I love doing voiceover work, but because of the pandemic, those of us who couldn't afford these, you know, hyperlinks and expensive studios and private rooms and stuff, they dropped a ton of us.

A lot of agents dropped a lot of people because it was at one time, it was the one thing that was surviving through the beginning, if you remember, was the one thing that people could do at home that they'd already been doing at home that everyone knew how to do at home. You know, I have several successful voiceover friends who have converted their garages into amazing studios and stuff like that. And I was doing the blanket over my head.

[12:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[12:15] Peter Allen Vogt: No, no, there was a while when I had this microphone in a closet surrounded by clothes, just trying to, you know, do the right sound.

[12:22] Patrick Oliver Jones: No, no, no.

[12:23] Peter Allen Vogt: No, it's uh it's taken me a while to, I guess, give in to this new way of auditioning, this new way of being my own technical and artistic director, so to speak, when it comes to auditioning.

[12:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, it's crazy, it's hard, but I think once you can accept that and start doing it, it's great. But it's still, you know, every time we try something like that, we're always starting at the bottom and having to work our way back up, right?

[12:50] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah.

[12:51] Patrick Oliver Jones: Like I wrote a kid's book and I'm trying to get it published, and people are loving the book, but I can't get it anyone to publish it. I've come up with some show ideas and concepts and I've written those out. Now I'm just trying to get them to the right people to get that stuff produced. But I'm nobody, you know.

[13:09] Peter Allen Vogt: It's it's it really is a crazy how how much we need each other in this business. I mean, I think you bring up a good point that there's always that someone out there, that someone that hasn't in, has an avenue that we just don't have access to. So there's there's always this need for someone else in our business.

[13:27] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, and I think I've learned instead of being angry when I see people succeeding, I get inspired now. And I think that's one of the biggest changes for me. Because I used to be angry. It's tough. It's new and jealous, of course.

[13:39] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and you're jealous, or you see someone, you're like, they don't deserve that. And it's like, well, it's not up to me to decide that. But I can say, wow, they worked really hard and look what they got. I'm being lazy. It's not gonna be handed to me, I gotta earn it, right? So even though I've written stuff and I'm doing video auditions and I'm trying to get myself back out there, it's up to me to do it. If one of my friends who have made it to a different level can help me and want to, that's great. But they didn't become famous to make me successful.

[14:12] Peter Allen Vogt: They became famous because that's what they chose to do and they were hardworking and they earned it.

[14:17] Peter Allen Vogt: I'm we, you know, we were talking about the networking thing. What I'm really bad at is reaching out to those friends who are successful that could possibly help me. And I refuse to ask them those questions because that's not why I'm friends with them. And I've just recently started doing that with some of the projects I've been trying to work on. And you know, I would start with look, I never do this. And if you don't want to continue this conversation, let me know. But I've written a thing. You know, because that's something that I've met people through this podcast, very well-known people, as well as people that I've worked with on stage and on screen. But when you've approached them, what is their usual response? Have you gotten the eye roll or have you gotten people willing to hear you out?

[15:06] Peter Allen Vogt: Um, I would say the majority of people have participated in some way, shape, or form. Some, it's taken a little bit, you know, we all want it tomorrow, you know. If I sent you my book for you to read, I want to know that you read it tonight. Right. And tell me about everything tomorrow. A five-paragraph essay, all the likes. How dare you have a life now that you've said yes to something? Um, so I think we need at least I've learned that people will do it in their time. If they say yes, then, and I've also learned to check back. Hey, it's been a week. You said you were gonna do this. Is it cool? You know, have you done it? Because I value their opinion. You know what I'm saying? It's like I want to know what they think because I think that they have insight.

And with the book that I wrote, it's really, really helped a lot. I've chose a few good people, and um only one person I approached the first time, totally helped me out. Second time, they literally ignored the question about the book and just went, so what's going on? How are you? And I went, message received.

[16:16] Peter Allen Vogt: Right. They pivoted. And you and they're an author, they're a playwright, someone I highly respect. So because I do respect them. Right, then you just move on. We just moved on, and we are still the best of friends, and I love him very much. And I I took the very polite subtle hint of I'm not reading your stupid book.

[16:47] Peter Allen Vogt: Certainly before COVID, you were actually involved with a couple of projects out there in LA. And there were two very different kinds of musicals. One was the classic, 1776, and the other was a new musical, Grumpy Old Men, the stage adaptation of that movie. And so how was it transitioning from one character type to another?

[17:08] Peter Allen Vogt: First of all, great question, Patrick Oliver Jones. Three names. Or P O J, as we call you. Yes, of course. Um what I loved about that is it was McCoy Rigby, who is an amazing group of people. It's Kathy Rigby. Honestly, fabulous people. They're wonderful, wonderful people. Tom McCoy, boy, he's a driven man. And Kathy Rigby couldn't be more sweet and fun. She's far more talented than I think anybody gives her credit for. Um, as an actress, as a performer. And then on top of that, she's an Olympian. Yeah. Like, what? So Glenn Casal was our director for 1776. Oh, he's wonderful. Yeah. He's a wonderful director. And it what was so sweet about him is that he I'd auditioned, as you said, I've auditioned a ton for them out there.

And when we say out there, for those who are listening, here in LA, we're in LA County, and this production is in Orange County. So it's about a 45-minute drive to get to them. But super worth it. So I've auditioned for him several times. Never quite got in. Tons of my friends have worked with them. And you know, tons of famous people. I mean, they get the Broadway people, right? So Glenn has always wanted to work with me and my brother together or separately, but he's always admired us, always enjoyed our work. So finally, this project came up. I went in. Of course, I wanted to be, you know, molested to run slaves guy because I'm that guy. And um I became uh the guy who kind of saves the day.

[18:49] Peter Allen Vogt: What was nice about it is the cast was this amazing, just everybody a lead. Do you know what I mean? Like, well, that's how 1776 is kind of built, that everyone has their standalone part. Yeah. Everyone has their standalone part. And the great thing about how Glenn directed it was that we really needed to identify and listen to each other. So we're not just sitting on stage waiting for our line, but we're really participating in the moment, right? And um, we all had our business, we all had our thing that we were doing. And uh, you know, our lead was he was so Andy was so amazing to watch, and uh the way it was staged, you know. The first god, the I think it's we're on stage for 45 minutes, maybe 50 minutes before there's a break, before there's a song, like we sit sing sit down, John, and then it's like 45 minutes of dialogue.

There's another song. You have to keep things going, but also you have to be active and listening, but not draw attention, right? And that's that was a beautiful thing. But what was amazing was that this cast was so amazing to watch. But my character I got to play was very much a um just a solid character. I do a lot of comedy, and 1776 isn't a comedy show, you know, it's not wacky wacky funny, like Franklin can be funny, but for the right reasons, because he's witty, not because he's a cartoon character. And what I what I was really um pleased by was that Glenn was able to see that I could perform that way, allow me to perform that way, and even though I had like bits where I had a turkey leg, like my character is always eating something, and I made a point of using the food in my actions and stuff like that.

But when you have these bigger stars, to use a term, coming up to you afterwards and saying, I can't take my eyes off of you. You're you're so amazing in this part. And even when reviews came out, I would get singled out as somebody to watch. Like if you're gonna watch the show, check out what Peter Allen Vogt is doing, his stuff is really solid, which was great. I'm not saying that to brag. What I'm saying is to add to what you're saying is I went from that where I was able to deliver this really nice solid performance to this really goofy character in you know, Grumpy Old Men that Blake Hammond played at El Gonquet, which is and Blake Hammond, I think is do you know Blake? I mean, he's yeah, I worked with him at his family, yeah.

Oh yeah, there you go. I mean, he's so amazingly talented, and just the fact that I mean, I'm so glad he was busy and he couldn't do the show, right? Right, but also to be in the same company as Blake is an honor to me because I think he is amazing, he's the sweetest, sweetest guy in the world, and so to be able to do this part with that the cast was unbelievable. And to be the comedy guy and go from 1776, where I'm being a serious character, although moments of humor, but being able to play that seriousness, which I'm not afforded a lot, back into my funny, funny, funny role of being able to this guy who can't feel anything because of this weird accident that he had, and his hands are getting smashed, and people are hitting with stuff, and he doesn't feel anything, and doing bits with like Ken Page and Mark Jacoby.

I mean, my God, singing a song with Hal Lyndon. Right. I was just an idiot through the whole thing, and everyone else is like, no, it's fun. I'm like, no, you don't understand. You know, no, is that what yeah, I'm sure you felt like you know, a kid at the playground. It's like everything was fun. Well, and God, you know, Ken Page, Ken Page, Ken Page, amazing, right? Me, Mark Jacoby. I shared a dressing room with that man. When we get to who do you admire, he's amazing, and he's he's a very stoic man, but when you make him laugh, that's the greatest moment. And I would make him giggle all the time, and it was wonderful. Wow.

[23:00] Peter Allen Vogt: So yeah, so that's that was the beautiful thing about playing these two different diverse characters, and the fact that the people at McCoy Rigby saw that in me.

[23:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I could see both sides of you.

[23:11] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah. That that says something about casting and the directors that they could pull out those different parts of you. I mean, because you you've you played uh a lot of comedic roles. That's been your bread and butter, so to speak.

[23:21] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, absolutely. So would you say that that is your favorite kind of character to play?

[23:29] Peter Allen Vogt: Um, it is. I mean, I don't mind I like playing dramatic stuff if it's the right stuff. Um, you know, I was lucky enough to get uh in the I'm in the first season of American Horror Story, and um I get to kill somebody.

[23:46] Peter Allen Vogt: Whoa, yeah, Eric Stone Street from Modern Family, right? I shoot him in the head. Um, and that day was an amazing day, and I wouldn't say like Eric and I are best buddies, but we've known each other for years, so the fact that we were able to work on a on a show together was really exciting. You know, sadly, the world of TV and movies, a lot of what I did got cut, but the fact that I got cast in the show and for what I did in that show opened up a whole new realm of auditions for me. As people saw on my resume, I did American Horror Story and had a darker side to me. I started getting these better opportunities to be the mean guy or the heavy and things, where you know, usually I'm like, hey, I'm wacky guy, you know, which I love, but I do like being able to to get back to those performing roots of Shakespeare and Chekhov and Ibsen, what I was trained in when I went to college and stuff like that.

But let me be Marcellus in you know, music man for the next 20 years, and I'm happy. No, I've done that role so many different times. So it's like it's fun, it's up, it's a positive show. I love that.

[24:59] Peter Allen Vogt: A lot of the roles, you know, especially these comedic roles, have used your weight as the punchline or part of the joke. Now, has has there ever been a time where a particular script or show took it too far, maybe?

[25:12] Peter Allen Vogt: Oh, do I answer this? Of course. Does Ryan Murphy listen to your show? If he does, welcome. Hello, Ryan. How are you? Um, I would, I mean, this is definitely not a slam to Ryan Murphy, but I was called a few times for Glee. My brother did an episode of Glee. And I have to say the great thing about the casting for them is even though my brother did an episode of Glee, that didn't cross me out of being able to go in and audition for them. But what happened was I started getting calls to be the sight gag for being so heavy. So it wasn't even about acting. It was just like, we need a fat guy, Peter's fun. Come in and read this part. It maybe was one line. Sometimes it was nothing. Sometimes it was just fat guy gets up from chair, Sue comes in and says, Oh, I like when I steal a fat person's chair.

It's always warm. Like that stuff, no, I'm not doing that. Um, I did a TV show called The Loop, which dealt with the fact that I was a heavy guy who was fighting for the rights of fat people on planes. And that writing was very funny. It did not bother me. It did not in any way, shape, or form degrade being a big person, but you needed a big big person to deliver the lines to make it funny. That makes sense. Yeah. Right. Like uh there's a diner scene, a dinner scene, and I'm ordering from the waitress, and I order, I ask what the vegetables steamed vegetables of the day are, and she lists a bunch, and I just look at her and I go, of the curly fries. And you know, it was well written and well delivered in great direction.

So um, but yeah, there have been times that I'm like, yeah, I'm not doing that just because I'm a big guy, I'm not gonna go in for that role, or where they're like, oh, we need someone fat to take their shirt off. I'm like, nope, no reason for it. I'm not gonna do it, you know. So I've been lucky enough that I can do that. Maybe I don't maybe I should have. And I would be sitting in my mansion, you'd be talking to my butler. I don't know.

[27:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah. Now, did that in any way lead you to want to lose the weight that you've lost?

[27:17] Peter Allen Vogt: In a way, I felt that with the way things were going in the world, and this is this is uh pre-pandemic craziness, but I'm a big believer in the diversity. I believe that everyone should have a chance at parts as a character guy, as the sidekick, as the best friend, as a secondary character. I felt like these characters are getting more replaced with diversity, which is fine, but I also feel like it's a safe choice. You know, I've always said, where's Leslie Odom Jr. as the music man? Right? Where's he as the lead? That'd be great. Yeah. Show me as the lead him, right? Not the secondary guy being a diverse character. Let's put the leads up there in these shows. Uh so I felt like I was getting to the point where as I got older, I mean, I'm 107 now.

I know. You look great though. Thank you. So I just felt it was time to lose weight. And as I lost weight, I mean, sadly, right before the pandemic, I, you know, I did Grumpy Old Men, and then I was able to do a movie.

[28:24] Peter Allen Vogt: And I got a new show on Netflix I was in as a guest star, and there was a Disney movie that was going to be done that I was being asked to do. So all these great things were starting to happen. And I think it's because with having lost some weight, it made me less of, you know, in Hollywood, I'm still the fat guy. I'm still a fat guy in Hollywood, right? I'm 5'11, 260. I don't mind saying that now. But that's still really fat in Hollywood, right? So imagine me 200 pounds heavier, like hold it, like they would be like, we don't know what to put you in. And I'm like, well, I don't wear a poncho. I'm not walking into auditions wearing like a garbage bag. A moulu. There are clothes for me. Right.

And uh, but I remember also feeling great when I went to the TV show to get my costume fitting, and some of the stuff they pulled was too big. And I was like, oh, like well, oh, this isn't it. Right. What a good feeling that is. So a lot of it is was for me. I wanted to feel better. I wanted to feel like I was making a positive move. Given this crazy time in our lives for everybody, this was my positive thing. Like I literally work out on a treadmill every day, do about five miles, and then a couple of days a week, I get on the elliptical, I swim. Because even if nothing else happens in the day. If I do that, I've accomplished something. Right. It keeps me positive.

[29:50] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, yeah. I mean, the just the need. Just the physicalness of those endorphins from working keeps you positive, but then also that sense of accomplishment, as you said.

[29:58] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, I feel like, okay, I've done something today. And then it makes me want to do more. You know, then I feel like I get more done. So I mean, I know some people are like, you don't need to work out every single day, but for me, that's what I need right now. I've been doing this for about this July, it'll be three years that I've started really, really focusing on this. And it's so funny because both Paul and I have yo-yoed our weight. We've done crazy things, not crazy things. And this is this is sounds so dumb, but this is the first time that I've done it where I've watched what I'm eating and worked out, kept a journal of what I'm eating, how many calories, thinking about how I feel after you eat certain things.

If I know I want to like if I know I'm gonna go out with a bunch of people and we're gonna have stuff to like when I was hosting and I wanted to have some wine, that was a day that I knew I had to work out a little bit more. Like I never understood that from friends who were always thin and said, you know, oh, if I'm gonna have fries today, I better do an extra three miles on the treadmill or something. I'd be like, why? Just have fries. Oh, I'm that guy. No, I'm that idiot. Yeah, like ice cream, hang on a second. Okay, I gotta swim eight more legs.

[31:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: No, I'm curious. Conversely, did losing the weight affect the kind of roles that you were being seen for?

[31:19] Peter Allen Vogt: Not yet, because most of the shots I had of me were from when I'm heavy, and of course, my reel is all from when I was heavy when I was in Hannah Montana and all the stuff I've done. So I think there are people that are still thinking on that guy. I have a lot of casting people who know me. Some even follow me on my Instagram and Facebook, but still haven't clicked in that, oh, you're not that heavy anymore. Because I've been getting auditions for parts where it's like, he's a really, really heavy guy who does who's fun. And I'm like, okay. Like I had an audition for they wanted him to be like John Candy big. And I was like, oh, I'm not. But like I said, I still think I still read big Hollywood big. I'm still a big guy. You know, I'm not, I don't think that I'm like, I'm not no Patrick Oliver Jones.

[32:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, believe me, COVID has put on a little bit of weight for me.

[32:18] Peter Allen Vogt: Oh, please. Well, well, no, I mean, just say we're all in our own space, you know, depending on. I always get mad at I always get mad at you thin attractive people when you say that.

[32:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: I get that. I get that.

[32:29] Peter Allen Vogt: But I've learned that you're right. It is what your world is. It's not my vision of what I think you should be, it's who you are and how you feel. And you brought up Paul a couple of times, and it must be interesting having someone who's, I mean, having an identical twin is one thing, but this identical twin does the same stuff that you do, is a comedian, is an actor. And so, have you ever been up for the same role?

[33:00] Peter Allen Vogt: Um, we have actually a lot. It's interesting because there's an ebb and flow to us when we do things that sometimes, you know, people think we're like around each other all the time and stuff. And I'm like, we don't, you know, he live he lived down the block, you know, he's right around the corner, but it doesn't mean that we talk all the time or see each other all the time. He has his life, I have my life. So there have been a few times that we've auditioned for things. I think there's been a couple of times that I know there was one thing that we both auditioned for, and I know I booked it, but I think at the time he was doing two-con, and that might have been one of the reasons that he wasn't like in town or able to do it.

I don't know, or I was just so much better. But also, you know, I mean, since we are bringing him up, you know, he's been so successful with doing Hairspray, you know, he did it on Broadway. Um, and then he's been like their go-to Edna for so many things. He's been all like he's done it up in Sacramento, he's done it in Texas, he's done it in St. Louis. They did this big celebration of the of Hairspray in Baltimore with John Waters, and he played Edna there. He was in Hairspray Live, and he was actually, you know, would stand in for Harvey Fierstein when he couldn't be there. And like he he's really established himself in that world, and it's an amazing group of people, and he's amazing, you know.

And then on top of that, Chicago. You know, he did Chicago twice on Broadway and has done the national tour of Chicago to the point where he even went to Israel with it when they did that right before the pandemic. So he's also been gone. It's been kind of nice, right?

[34:44] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[34:45] Peter Allen Vogt: It leaves for the other vote to take it. And they'll go, Who's Paul? And we're like, nobody. Shasha. But um, so yeah, there's been times that we've been up against each other. There are times because of his credits and his relationship with people, he's been called and I haven't. There's been times I get called and he doesn't. I mean, being identical twins doesn't guarantee you either one of us the part or the audition. I think sometimes it helps us, sometimes it goes against us. Um, way back in Orlando, we auditioned for a Visa commercial. I went in to the callback, they said, Oh, give it to us this way, and I did it. They're like, That's great. And then he went in and they said, 'Give it to us this way, and he did it that way.'

And they decided they liked that way better, but never gave either one of us the opportunity to do it the other way. So lucky for him, he ended up booking a national commercial because apparently I couldn't do it that way. Right. This is our business.

[35:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, exactly. So, and I think that happens with anybody. Like that could happen to any one of us. But yeah, there are times that uh I'm sure it's riled us, and I try to just be as supportive as I can. Again, it's difficult because you see this other person who looks just like you succeeding. Yeah, you're like, why isn't it me? But then you have to really identify. It's like because he has different work ethics and he has different contacts and he has different ways of doing things, and he's great. I mean, it's not like he's not great, he's great. So he just got into this great stream and boom, just took off with it, which is wonderful.

[36:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and you had mentioned before about seeing other people being famous. Was it harder with your brother seeing him succeed in these different areas?

[36:35] Peter Allen Vogt: I mean, yeah, honestly, there were times that were it was harder, but the underlying was always great. I mean, of course, it's like because you love him. I mean, they're there's still he's still your brother. Let's not go that far. Okay, well, you put up with him, he's your brother, you put up with him. We deal with each other well. Um, yeah, exactly. I mean, of course, I mean, I'm never gonna sit there and go, I'm a hundred percent happy that he is like that. Um, of course, we're humans. Of course, I would love to have done Edna on Broadway. I got to audition for the show as well for um the tour. I can't remember if it was before or after, I think it was before he did it or around the time that he got it.

But his stuff was so much better. I mean, he just he just knew how to audition better than I did. And and that's what I needed to learn watching him. And plus, he went to school. We went to two different schools in Buffalo. I went to the University of Buffalo, he went to the college, and he took directing. A lot of people don't know that. He's a really good guy, he's very critical. Boy, he sees stuff, and I think he learned to utilize that talent for himself in his auditioning. And I think that that's really been detrimental for myself, where I needed to really learn how to be more discerning and even more creative. Like sometimes he'll tell me about what he did in audition, and I'll be like, I would have never thought to do that.

Like it's really funny stuff. Right. Auditioning is really its own skill, and it's a way of you know, in the page or two that you get to pull something out that something else isn't gonna see. And he's really great at that. And he's and I've learned when he tells me those things, I don't go, oh, that's I'm so angry. I'm like, oh okay, next time I get an audition, I'm gonna start doing that stuff. So that's what I mean by being inspired instead of being angry. I can't be angry, that's his path in life. You know, you know. Uh, the comment that makes me crazy that anybody says is that was my part. You took my part. We all everyone said it, right? No, if it was your part, you'd be doing it, right?

Like, and also I don't care how many people you looked at before you gave me the role, you gave me the role now. It's my role, right? Right? It's as simple as that. Like you see all these stories about how many people audition to be Han Solo. You know, I'm saying, like, you have these audition tapes that you can look at out of all these people that auditioned for all these famous roles, and we all are that, you know. Rarely do you get somebody who just walks up to you and says, You're doing this role, I wrote this part for you.

[39:14] Peter Allen Vogt: We have that musical, we did have the fellowship parody. That was a show that um Joel McCreary and Kelly Holden were hanging out one day, and we started going back back and forth with each other saying movies that should should never, I don't know if it was movies that should be musicals or should never be musicals, and started throwing things back and forth. It was a game that you know, it's like an improv game. And when they got to Lord of the Rings, they started going, Wait, we could cast this, and started thinking of all the people that could cast. It was all of us that had known each other from Orlando, and a few of us that had gathered together here in LA and had been performing together, and literally wrote the show, the basic of the show, with all of us in mind for certain roles, and then as the show grew, we would come in and improvise our scenes based on the dialogue they'd already written, and then which I thought was kind of brilliant of them.

If you were in a song, then you were part of helping create that song, right? Because I see in the breakdown of the credits and everything, like there's all these lyricists, so that's so that's all the actors giving and collaborating on that particular song. 12 of us, it's a cast of nine, plus, and Kelly's in the cast. So it's a 12 of nine, but then Kelly, Joel, and Alan Simpson, who was our music director, and Joel was our director creator guy. We all have rights. So we all, and and it's to different degrees, obviously, Kelly and Joel own the biggest parts, but we all have rights in the writing because we all created the bits and stuff that we put down on paper. And then like I play Sam. So the four hobbits plus Joel and Alan wrote our Hobbit songs.

So you have those six people. And then I played the Balrog, which is just me. It's just a solo song, and I mess with the audience. It's like one of the best numbers, like it was a gift from God, and I send them every day for it. It was a number that probably should have lasted two minutes and always lasted about seven to ten. Um but I'm sure it brought the house down. It was very fun. People seem to enjoy it. Let's say that. But that was just Joel, myself, Kelly, and Alan. So just the four of us own the rights to that, you know. So it worked like that. But that's a great example of they saw this group of people, and the year that we did the show, we were these new upstarts and ended up winning all the awards in LA for it.

They used to do the LA Weekly Awards, and Sally Kellerman was the MC. She was in a show. They did the wild party. Oh, okay. Right. And they thought they were gonna win everything. Daisy Egan was in it, Sally Kellerman was in it. Um, I don't know if you know Eric Anderson, he was in it, and he and they were all hosting the show, and everybody assumed that this was the show that was winning everything, and every time the category came up, we would win. Eventually just got to the point where she was like, and the winner for this one is are you kidding me?

[42:31] Peter Allen Vogt: So it was just joyful, and it was such a great thing. But that to have a part that you originated, and then for almost 10 years, we did that show in different venues and different places, and we had different people coming in and out of the show. It was just the best, and just the best group of people. And when it comes to those kind of impromptu, you also did one on screen as well with The Fur is Gone. And this was uh, you know, backstage, you know. But so you're a group of actors doing a show, and basically the show was what happens backstage, right?

[43:08] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, it was um it was almost like a mockumentary of what happens backstage of a theater company, and um it was with this great theater company out here called the uh co-op, and we were doing a production of Edwin Drude, which you know it's so funny because I know one of the questions you have is um a dream role that you want to do, and one of them was the chairman, and I got to do it, and um, so I was the chairman in this amazing production with again an amazing group of people, but behind the scenes, everybody was so funny and stuff.

[43:42] Peter Allen Vogt: So they had done this. I forget the like they did a production just prior to this show. And it was Lend Me a Tenor was the original production of the channel. Yeah, so they did Lend Me a Tenor, and they did they found because everyone's so funny and great, they started doing this behind the scenes mockumentary thing, and a lot of the people from Lend Me a Tenor were in my in Edwin Drood. So they continued it and we were at it as characters. And basically they would just say, let's do this scene now. And we would create these made-up storylines. Very dramatic, very overblown drama.

[44:17] Peter Allen Vogt: I think I want to say somebody got murdered. I mean, we were coming up with ridiculous stuff, and it was so much fun because half the time it'd be like, oh wait, I have a cue, I have to get on stage. So it was literally during the show. Yes. Oh my gosh. So on top of me being an idiot backstage, we just would go crazy. So yeah, it's a very, very funny series. I think there's three seasons, and I think I'm mostly in season two and probably part of season three, I think. It was years ago. Again, I'm 107.

[44:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, I think it's great though that you've been able to balance this work as both an improv and kind of making up creating these characters and bits in addition to the more scripted work that you've done. Is there one that if you could like direct your path, is there one way you'd go over the other?

[45:17] Peter Allen Vogt: Oh, that's a good question. You're good at this. You should do this. You should make this a show. Um, I think I might. Um, it that's such a great question because what I do at Universal here at the theme park here is um we do this thing called New York window, and it's you know, it's what I it it's interactive improv, which means my definition, we have established characters, um, as you know, Streetmosphere, what we used to do in Florida, right?

[45:45] Peter Allen Vogt: Is we have an established character. I was here, we're New Yorkers. We moved from Brooklyn because we love the Dodgers, and the Dodgers used to be in Brooklyn, and now they're the LA Dodgers. We know we're in LA. Our building was taken by Universal to use on a movie set, and we came with it because it was rent controlled. So we're not people who live in the 50s who don't know it's 20, whatever. We know where we are and everything, but we live our life like we're you know, from the 50s.

[46:17] Peter Allen Vogt: So I'm in a t-shirt and I got the fedora on, and I'm like yelling out the window, and that's my wife over there, and we're like, hey, how's it going? What's going on? But everything is very much like we love those Brooklyn bums, you know, we do stuff like that, and that's fun. But when you're doing that seven days a week, you know, all the time, and someone hands you a script, and you're like, wait, I just have to do these words, right? I don't have to think up anything. It's nice.

[46:44] Peter Allen Vogt: Um, you know, the challenge for people who do things like the Groundlings when they do their shows and SAC Comedy in Orlando, you know, that constant when we used to do the Comedy Warehouse, that was five improv shows a night, seven days a week, and it's Disney, so you can't go blue, so you can't keep it clean, family friendly. And everybody, the easiest thing to do is to go blue, and people would shout horrible things out to us, and we had to take it and make it oh boy, it's fun.

[47:16] Peter Allen Vogt: Right. You know, so um that can get tiring. It gets, I call it heavy lifting sometimes. You know, sometimes it's too it it gets a little exhausting. So for me, what was great is as I started being able to get to do these shows at La Mirada and around town, it was nice to go and do a scripted show, but still be able to put in that energy and that the creation of character. That's the beauty of this interactive stuff that we do because my character is set.

[47:45] Peter Allen Vogt: I'm not looking, I don't look out my window and go, hey, give me a room in your house and give me three items that you wouldn't make pasta with. Right. Our improv is I am who I am. You know, I have a name, I'm this guy. Here's my history. But I look out the window and I'm like, hey, there's my cousin Vinny. Vinny, what's going on? How are you? And you have three different levels. People will be like, hey, what's going on? It's my cousin. To somebody who'll be like, mm-mm, don't talk to me.

[48:14] Peter Allen Vogt: Right, right. I'm not playing. Somebody who'll stand there and just be like, hey, you know, different some people want to watch, some people will kind of will answer, and some people want to be part of the cast. And that helps you with your creation, and that's your improv. Your improv comes from endowing other people with characters, endowing them with their creativity and their imagination.

[48:35] Peter Allen Vogt: And you have the base of your history. This is your wife. There's no question as to what's going on here. But then everything else is up for grabs. So it's a little bit different than what people think of, you know, for improv. When I was in New York, the greatest lesson I learned there, you know, there's a group Chicago City Limits, and I was a part of an offshoot of them. Uh and because I come from improv background, they were like, you can't be funny.

[49:01] Peter Allen Vogt: You can't go for the joke anymore. We want you to do everything as realistic as possible. And it turned out to be some of the best work I've ever done and some of the funniest scenes we ever had.

[49:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah. I remember when I was taking Upright Citizens Brigade, you know, improv training there. That was one of the first things in 101. It's like, don't go for the joke. Don't go for the punchline.

[49:22] Peter Allen Vogt: Right. Establish a character. And it could be an alien with wings. I mean, it can be outlandish. But but deliver the line, stay in character, stay in the scene as if an alien with wings would react. Don't go for those zany just because you can.

[49:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[49:38] Peter Allen Vogt: And then and it's even funnier, and there's more heart to it. So I think that's helped me, but it's hard to say which I like better, you know. Depends on the day.

[49:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[49:48] Peter Allen Vogt: Because once you've done a lot of one, then you relish going to the other.

[49:53] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, I love the challenge. And you know, I think, you know, I teach, I teach acting, uh, and I do classes and stuff. And I've worked a lot with a lot of young people. And one of the things that I always think is the beauty of what we do as actors is that recreation of a life, you know, eight times a week. And it has to be real every time because those people in the audience who paid $350 to see you, they don't know, they don't know the story, they don't know what's going to happen next.

[50:23] Peter Allen Vogt: And you have to play that character the same way, the realism, the honesty, the heart, the funny, the drama, as if it's never been said before. Every single time. And that challenge, that workout is what I love about it. So that opportunity to do a scripted show to keep that fresh, but also grow with the character.

[50:46] Peter Allen Vogt: You know, as we were doing Grumpy Old Men, we were all finding new different things to do. We were finding different fun relationships that we had with each other on stage. It didn't change the show, but it did create our relationships grew on stage. And things became there were some bits that we were doing that were like, oh, oh, boom.

[51:08] Peter Allen Vogt: I'm one of those guys that like all the way until the end of a show, I'm still finding new things about my character. I'm now I'm not one of those actors that's gonna turn and give you something, you're like, what the hell was that? I don't do that. But I definitely will be like, oh, okay, I'm gonna try this line. This is the same line I've always been doing, but you know what? If I pick up this scone, say the line, and then pop the scone in my mouth, that's gonna give it more importance.

[51:34] Peter Allen Vogt: And I remember doing that one time, and all of the guys that were across from me looked at me and were like, and afterwards they all came up to me and were like, What the hell was that? That was brilliant. Because they just saw the creep, you know, and the same right back at them, they were all doing the same thing.

[51:49] Peter Allen Vogt: That's what I'm talking about is like allowing yourself to grow with the character, but you don't you don't change it. It's not like all of a sudden every bit is yeah, yeah. It's it's that interesting balance of as you said, doing the same show, the same show that you do eight times, but newly each night. It's it's that balance, but then also growing with it.

[52:09] Peter Allen Vogt: I remember when I was doing The Producers and Michael Kostroff, I uh I had him. Oh my god, I love him.

[52:16] Patrick Oliver Jones: I know.

[52:17] Peter Allen Vogt: Yeah, he yeah, he was in the first season. And one of the things that I loved most about working with him is that from opening night all the way through to closing, he was constantly refining the jokes and figuring out the beats, the punchline, the the way to deliver it in a different way, and how he would deliver his performance on that particular night based upon the audience's reaction, but also based upon the actors that were with them.

[52:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I mean, one of the beautiful things about watching my brother do Hairspray was seeing him early on like he originally got the gig in Vegas. Harvey Fierstein had opened the show in Vegas and then Paul was the first one to take it over and take it to the end. But it was only the 90-minute version right so the challenge for everybody was they didn't know could Paul sustain the whole show on Broadway.

[53:07] Peter Allen Vogt: So he did it in North Shore and that's what proved them that he could carry the show. And he went from North Shore, boom, on to Broadway. So seeing him on Broadway from the beginning and then seeing those last shows that he did you know and and the guys that came in to play Wilbur, the different amazing talented men that came and worked with him each time it was different but it was still the show it was still Edna and Wilbur.

[53:31] Peter Allen Vogt: It was still beautiful touching but different because he allowed himself to match the energy of his Wilbur's and his different Tracy's and the different like it was great to watch that growth there's they did a production of it out here in LA and I was asked to audition and I said I wouldn't do it. I mean I'm not trying to sound like oh I'm such an honorable man but I'm not going to do that role my brother that's his role man and he established it he earned it and he did it.

[53:57] Peter Allen Vogt: Now I'll do Amos in a heartbeat he don't own that so if anybody wants anybody listening needs an angle I'm cheap but as far as as Edna goes I'm I'll never be able to touch it. But what I would love to do again going to one of these dream roll things was I would love to be a Wilbur to his Edna I've always thought that'd be interesting.

[54:16] Peter Allen Vogt: I just think we would be really, really I think we would be brilliant. I have to do that. Amazing. Hello, Harvey. Harvey do you hear me? Are you listening to this?

[54:26] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, we have Harvey Fierstein and Ryan Murphy both listening. Thank you.

[54:31] Peter Allen Vogt: Well, Michael Kostroff, look at Michael Kostroff. If we can get you to make a few calls, he's gotta know somebody.

[54:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: I know him.

[54:39] Peter Allen Vogt: You know him. Everybody I know knows Michael Kostroff. He's like a placemat at a diner.

[54:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: Everyone has seen it.

[54:48] Peter Allen Vogt: I'm gonna get a call from Michael Kostroff saying, did you just call me a placemat?

[54:52] Patrick Oliver Jones: No, no, I'll probably edit all this stuff out.

[54:54] Peter Allen Vogt: No!

[54:55] Patrick Oliver Jones: Or send it to him personally.

[54:57] Peter Allen Vogt: Right, right. I'll just say this is what Peter had to say about you.

[55:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh my god.

[55:05] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, this has been a joy to talk to you. Thank you so much for coming on the podcast. It's so great to reconnect with you.

[55:11] Peter Allen Vogt: Same, same.

[55:17] Patrick Oliver Jones: A big thanks to Peter for sharing with us not only his wit, but his wisdom as well. We were actually laughing and cutting up throughout the interview, so it was quite the task to edit this episode to under an hour. But don't forget the conversation continues with the final five questions.

[55:35] Patrick Oliver Jones: And that bonus episode can be found on YouTube or in the members only feed of the podcast. You can join today for as little as five dollars a month. Now, being a one-person operation, that financial support goes to help sustain the production and editing, as well as provide listeners like you with as many engaging guests and resources as possible.

[55:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Please go to why I'll never make it.com and click the support button. Well, I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, in charge of writing, editing, and producing this podcast. Publicity provided by Imagine PR Group.

[56:12] Patrick Oliver Jones: Incidental music featured in this episode is by Blue Dot Sessions. Why I'll Never Make It is a part of the Helium Radio Network and a member of the Broadway Makers Alliance. Join me next time as we talk more about Why I'll Never Make It.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred