Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#12 - Shana Carroll & Jesse Robb: Joining the W4E Circus

Water for Elephants swings into Tony season! Shana Carroll and Jesse Robb discuss combining dance and circus choreography to thrill Broadway audiences. We learn how learn how Grant Guston jumps from a train, Isabelle McCalla flies from a trapeze and performers give life to horses and elephants that steal our hearts... Read More

From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb

53 mins
5/22/24

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Water for Elephants swings into Tony season!

Shana Carroll and Jesse Robb discuss combining dance and circus choreography to thrill Broadway audiences. We learn how learn how Grant Guston jumps from a train, Isabelle McCalla flies from a trapeze and performers give life to horses and elephants that steal our hearts. Listen to find out how this show operates differently than any other show on Broadway.

Eila & Bruce also discuss Eddie Redmayne’s Oliver win for Best Actor in a Musical for Cabaret. Not to be missed is their coverage of the Drama League Awards including Sarah Paulson once in a career win.

SHANA CARROLL (Circus Designer & Co-Choreographer).Co-founding artistic director of The 7 Fingers, where she created over a dozen shows including Traces, Sequence 8, Cuisine & Confessions, Passengers. Other directing: Cirque du Soleil’s Crystal; circus component of Queen of the Night; Cirque du Soleil performance on 84th Academy Awards. Other circus design/choreography: Paramour (Broadway); Cirque du Soleil’s Iris; Sochi Olympics Opening Ceremony.

JESSE ROBB (Co-Choreographer) has worked at The Alliance Theatre, The Stratford Festival of Canada, Theatre Calgary, Ogun[1]quit Playhouse, Opera Philadelphia, Cirque du Soleil and MOMIX, among others. He is the movement director for the Cameron Mackintosh production of Les Misérables (U.S. national and South Korea) and was the associate choreographer for Miss Saigon (Broadway, U.S. tour, Vienna). Thanks and love to MF, PP, KZ, Les and Roberta Robb.

Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.

Connect with Eila and Bruce:

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Eila Mell: This is the dream. For me, this is the one. This was the part that I played when I was a kid at school. It was the thing that got my passion for theater really fueled. And getting to do it every night with that extraordinary group of people.

[0:26] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards. I'm Eila here with Bruce.

[0:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Hi Eila.

[0:31] Eila Mell: Hi, how are you today?

[0:32] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm good.

[0:33] Eila Mell: So what clip were we just listening to?

[0:35] Bruce Gotlieb: That was the Olivier Awards, Eddie Redmayne winning Best Actor in a Musical for Cabaret.

[0:42] Eila Mell: And he's nominated for that for a Tony right now. I mean, awards are plenty for that gentleman.

[0:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Really?

[0:48] Eila Mell: I don't know if he's gonna win this year. What do you think?

[0:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know. I mean, I know he was loved in London for it. I haven't heard anything necessarily bad about his performance. I just think as tight as the races are, there are just people that are shining a little bit brighter this season.

[1:09] Eila Mell: I mean, listen, who's gonna beat Merrily this season?

[1:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Nobody.

[1:12] Eila Mell: You know I keep saying this on our special episodes.

[1:15] Bruce Gotlieb: I know that we do.

[1:16] Eila Mell: So Bruce and I, if you don't know, we do these special episodes. They come out on Mondays, and they are our bonus episodes where we do deep dives into the nominees. And so, yes, I have been saying that Merrily is going to win. I don't think that's groundbreaking. I think everybody thinks that.

[1:33] Bruce Gotlieb: I think so too. And we're gonna touch on Merrily's winning streak a little bit, because I think we should unpack the Drama League Awards.

[1:42] Eila Mell: Yes.

[1:43] Bruce Gotlieb: So that's right. Bruce and I were at the announcements of the nominations for the Drama League, and then this week they gave the awards out.

[1:51] Eila Mell: Yes, along with our friends BB Newirth and Vanessa Williams.

[1:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, we were there to see them announce the nominees.

[2:00] Eila Mell: Go ahead.

[2:01] Bruce Gotlieb: I was just gonna say, you know, BB had a hell of a time because she had some really difficult names on that list.

[2:07] Eila Mell: That's true. That's very true.

[2:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Vanessa had the easier names. I wonder if that was because Vanessa was already slated, so she got to end up.

[2:15] Eila Mell: Oh, maybe.

[2:16] Bruce Gotlieb: That maybe, yeah. Because BB Newirth stepped in for Jordan Fisher who couldn't make the announcements at the last minute.

[2:22] Eila Mell: We don't know why.

[2:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Scheduling conflict. You know, things come up.

[2:26] Eila Mell: They do. Something suddenly came up, like on the Brady Bunch.

[2:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Well, why don't we go through the list of who won?

[2:32] Eila Mell: All right. So we had Outstanding Production of a Play went to Stereophonic.

[2:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Big surprise there.

[2:37] Eila Mell: Outstanding Revival of a Play went to Appropriate.

[2:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Again, very predictable.

[2:42] Eila Mell: Outstanding Production of a Musical went to Hell's Kitchen.

[2:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Now that is kind of surprising. Not because I don't think Hell's Kitchen was going to win. I don't know what's going to win anything in terms of musicals. There's so many. And you have shows on there that are off-Broadway. You have shows that are on Broadway. So you have like Teeth that have a cult following.

[3:01] Eila Mell: That's right.

[3:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Is going to New World Stages for, we can call it an extension, but you know, a life outside of their initial run.

[3:10] Eila Mell: Yes, yay Teeth.

[3:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, Dead Outlaw, which people were...

[3:14] Eila Mell: Dead Outlaw did amazing.

[3:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, Andrew Duran. We also had, you know, you had Harmony, you had The Notebook, The Outsiders. Like, so it was anybody's to win.

[3:24] Eila Mell: Yes, and let's point out for people because maybe not everyone is aware that the Drama League nominates many, many shows and many people in their categories, so it's not their traditional five or even ten. It could be up to twenty or in the performance category.

[3:42] Bruce Gotlieb: But in the performance category, there's only one performance award, and it encompasses men and women and supporting and leads and Broadway and Off-Broadway.

[3:51] Eila Mell: And it had like over fifty, I would say easily, right?

[3:54] Bruce Gotlieb: So then, of course, speaking of what got us here, Outstanding Revival of a Musical. Do you want to take a guess, Eila?

[4:10] Eila Mell: Could it be Merrily We Roll Along?

[4:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely is.

[4:10] Eila Mell: Of course it is. We had Outstanding Direction of a Play went to Daniel Aukin for Stereophonic.

[4:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[4:10] Eila Mell: Outstanding Direction of a Musical went to Maria Friedman for Merrily We Roll Along.

[4:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Shocker.

[4:16] Eila Mell: And then the fifty or eighty or so distinguished performances.

[4:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, so this is a real race because there are so many people.

[4:25] Eila Mell: So many, only one winner selected.

[4:27] Bruce Gotlieb: And you can only win it once in your life.

[4:31] Eila Mell: Exactly, right. So that's very interesting. So I know that there were people that they gave mention to that were not eligible, like Alfred Molina, because he's already won it. And BB Newirth, Liev Schreiber.

[4:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[4:42] Eila Mell: Those are a couple that were brought to attention even at the announcement of the nominees. But this year's recipient of the Distinguished Performance Award went to Sarah Paulson for Appropriate.

[4:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[4:56] Eila Mell: And so Jonathan Groff got an honorary award. And I heard that his speech was very, very moving.

[5:03] Bruce Gotlieb: How wonderful.

[5:04] Eila Mell: Yes. And Jessica Lange got an award. And who else? There are a couple more. Do you know?

[5:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Do you happen to have those?

[5:10] Eila Mell: Let me take a look here.

[5:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[5:14] Eila Mell: So Bruce will Google that for us. And in the meantime, I will tell people that we're very excited that Teeth is coming to New World Stages, especially because we're gonna have one of the co-creators, Anna Kay Jacobs, on our show soon. So that's exciting. The other special recognitions went to Candy Burris and Shelly Williams.

[5:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, great.

[5:37] Eila Mell: So those we knew going in, they were getting awards. So congratulations to all the winners. And can't wait to see what the next award handed out.

[5:46] Bruce Gotlieb: I think the next is the Cheetah Rivera Awards will be our next little news before we get to the Tonys.

[5:54] Eila Mell: Yeah, they're relatively new. I think maybe this is year six, I'm gonna guess.

[5:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I think if I remember correctly, they were something else before and then renamed for Cheetah a few years ago. So there is, if you look back a history of winners, but since it's been called the Cheetah Rivera Awards, it's relatively new.

[6:15] Eila Mell: Gotcha. Well speaking of dancing.

[6:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, I mean, we have some choreographers on our show today.

[6:22] Eila Mell: It's Shana Carroll and Jesse Robb, who did such a great job doing Water for Elephants.

[6:28] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, the choreography was interesting because, and we're gonna talk about it, that you know, you're intertwining your traditional choreography and your circus arts. And it's thrilling to watch. I went into Water for Elephants not knowing the movie, not ever having read the book, and just really not knowing what to expect, except that there were circus elements in the show. I didn't expect it to be as beautiful and as thrilling as it was. It just the choreography makes that show so special.

[6:57] Eila Mell: It really does. I can't stop talking about it.

[6:59] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. I especially love, you know, the horse choreography, but I'm gonna ask them about it. And I think you know that that's a testament to the craft and what they did was that you know, everybody who I've spoken to that has seen the show did enjoy the show, but the choreography just keeps being that center of conversation.

[7:19] Eila Mell: Yeah, it really was the standout. And so they're working together because Shana comes from the circus and Jesse comes from theater, and so this is a mix of the two elements. And so I'm really looking forward to them telling us how they work together and figured it out.

[7:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, let's get them in here.

[7:38] Eila Mell: All right, enough of us. Let's bring them on.

[7:44] Eila Mell: We are so excited at Behind the Awards to welcome Shana Carroll and Jesse Robb, the brilliant choreographers of Water for Elephants.

[7:53] Shana Carroll: Hi you guys.

[7:54] Jesse Robb: Hey there, good to be here.

[7:55] Shana Carroll: Hi there, lovely to be here.

[7:56] Eila Mell: We're so lucky to have you with us. We're in the throes of all kinds of Tony discussions. So we were so excited when you guys were able to come on.

[8:04] Jesse Robb: Yes, Tony nominees. That's amazing.

[8:06] Shana Carroll: It's hard to believe.

[8:09] Eila Mell: What was that morning like getting the... did you get a call? Were you watching?

[8:12] Shana Carroll: I didn't want to watch, and I was sort of refreshing a page that had it. And in fact, my page wasn't refreshing fast enough. My husband was watching in the other room, and he's the one who came out of the room screaming. And I immediately called Jesse Robb. He was my first call.

[8:26] Jesse Robb: Yeah, we didn't know. How about you, Jesse?

[8:28] Shana Carroll: We both had really funny situations.

[8:29] Jesse Robb: My husband actually was in Chicago, so he was on the feed, and I was on the feed, and we weren't linked. They weren't at the same time, about three seconds separate. So he started screaming. I was like, What's happened? What's happened? So I couldn't figure it out. So as he was screaming, Shana was calling, and I was hoping it was positive at that point.

[8:52] Eila Mell: Well, do you know what you're wearing yet to the awards?

[8:55] Shana Carroll: I do. Do you know what you're wearing, Shana?

[8:57] Shana Carroll: Oh god, no. I mean, a little stressed about that.

[9:03] Jesse Robb: Yes, but that's... I think we could do a whole other podcast.

[9:07] Shana Carroll: I know. I marched into the Brooks Brothers right next to the Tony Luncheon right after it. We basically walked out of the luncheon and I said, Oh gosh, I need something after walking in the luncheon. And so right next door of 30 Rock was the Brooks Brothers. And I said, I need a tuxedo help me.

[9:21] Eila Mell: Well, the luncheon is special because it's only for you guys. You're not even allowed to bring a plus one.

[9:26] Shana Carroll: Exactly. Yeah.

[9:27] Eila Mell: And it's, I mean, really, they definitely know how to celebrate their own. It's just there's so much joy, and everyone is just so generous and gracious, and those nominated all so honored. And so really it's just such a beautiful experience with many, many people that turn your head sitting close to you, and that's exciting too.

[9:50] Jesse Robb: And you get a pin, right?

[9:51] Shana Carroll: Yes.

[9:52] Jesse Robb: Yeah, that was lovely. And we were so used to interviewing together and being together in the rehearsal hall and doing everything together in terms of creation that it was the first time where they we walked in the room and they each gave us a little like place card for the table and our numbers weren't the same, and we had a panic.

[10:09] Shana Carroll: Oh my gosh.

[10:11] Jesse Robb: So we went and of course got to meet wonderful people, but it was really funny all of a sudden that it was like immediately you walk in the door and they separate you. So it was quite a neat experience.

[10:21] Eila Mell: Oh my gosh. Well, let's talk about Water for Elephants. Bruce and I both saw it and just the choreography is just so breathtaking.

[10:30] Shana Carroll: Yeah.

[10:30] Eila Mell: I have so many favorite moments, but let's just forget about me and talk about how you came to collaborate on this.

[10:37] Shana Carroll: I started a little bit earlier, sort of pre-pandemic actually, because, well, because for everyone, we had a big pause in the middle there. And when Jesse arrived, it was actually so wonderful for me because you know, when you've been on the same project for a while, you sort of circle around the same questions and don't always see straight at a certain point. And Jesse came in and he had such great fresh eyes, and I joked that it was like he had a machete and could just bushwhack through all the... and then it was, you know, very quickly, it was just such a perfect collaboration, and I think we both feel we just complement each other so well, and just both not only our voices and sort of styles, but our skill sets.

Soon we became really, you know, really reliant on each other and trusting of each other, and it was just a really beautiful, beautiful experience working together. So I'm glad the work reflects it. But honestly, the process itself was already just so gratifying and satisfying.

[11:41] Jesse Robb: Yeah, it kind of feels like the work is sort of the cherry on top, I think, in terms of, you know, the personal relationship that was developed. But we always laugh because I mean, I always say I was very lucky I got to see Shana's work before I sort of started on the project. And when I came on board, Shana had already started looking at some of the circus design, the choreographic elements of some of the storytelling pre-pandemic. And so I kind of got to take some eyes on it and sort of think about it and, you know, see this incredible, you know, sort of inventive and innovative work that Shana had already done. And it just sort of was like a springboard. It was a little bit literally like a bit of like a trampoline just for, you know, sort of ping off of to start trying things.

And then of course, I... we always laugh because, you know, we're the product of an arranged marriage that's very successful because it really took the stress and the pressure off of the two of us because we were put together, and so it, you know, it was sort of whether we liked it or not, we were together, and of course, you know, without the stress and pressure of being a team that, you know, was established and we had, you know, chosen each other and we had to prove ourselves together, it was sort of like, well, what can we find inside of this? And it just kept, you know, almost volcanically erupting with new ideas, and that made it very special and very unique and very exciting.

[12:57] Eila Mell: Jesse, did you have any circus experience before this show?

[13:01] Jesse Robb: I was very lucky about 20 years ago when I left college. I had actually been in musical theater to pay my way through college and get myself educated in dance and choreography. And when I left, I actually sort of auditioned and hooked up with Cirque du Soleil. So I was... I had worked with them a couple years opening a show called Zumanity out in Las Vegas.

[13:23] Jesse Robb: So one of the neat things that when Shay and I first sort of in this arranged marriage ended up in the room together, we found ourselves in this very similar vocabulary that we could both pull from, and we had ideas about certain things that are both very true to theater but also very true to circus and how those two things aligned because we kept finding ourselves, you know, trying to figure out ways to make both the circus acrobats and the circus troop and the circus members of the company and the actors in the company and the dancers all find a similar language that they all could understand and could find, you know, okay, we're all gonna jump on the eight. Well, what does that mean? How do we all find the eight?

And you know, this group of humans finds it a different way than that group of humans. But we had some tools to pull from that I thought was really neat very early on, which gave us like some sort of, I don't know, some a leg up in that way, I think a little bit. I think it was also very successful from a viewer's standpoint. Like you could see that one of the things that I and I both said to one another after seeing it was you didn't you couldn't, it was seamless to see where did the circus performer start and the dancer end and you know at what point you couldn't other than somebody who was literally flying through the air to say, oh that might have been a circus performer, but you wouldn't necessarily know from an audience perspective who was a true dancer and who was a true circus performer. So I think that speaks to the job that you guys collaborated on together that way.

[14:54] Shana Carroll: I also think it's a testament to our great cast, and I'd I have to say our great casting because we really did make a point. We knew for the fusion to be seamless, that we needed acrobats who, you know, some of them are excellent dancers, some of them, you know, hold their own and have learned and grown within that new skill. And then also likewise dancers who are very, you know, athletic and have the capacity to, you know, with even with more time, even could have learned more circus skills. So I think that helps, you know, that physicality that just is across the board, it really helps that feeling that you don't that the lines are all blurred.

[15:33] Jesse Robb: Yeah, I mean, I remember Diane Paulus did Pippin with and she used your same company.

[15:40] Shana Carroll: Yes, yeah. It's actually my so Gypsy, who is my well, co-funder. She's also kind of like my sister. We have connecting houses and have known each other since we were 15 and it has so during the creation of Pippin, I was quite, you know, quite present and aware of the whole process. So that was helpful for me too, actually, to have been able to witness that and learn from that as well. But even watching that, it was a different experience as an audience member because you could see very clearly who the circus performers were there. And this, it really was the circus performers were great dancers, and it really helped you be in the story in the world of Water for Elephants because you're not thinking about, well, this is an acrobat.

And it's I mean, and in Pippin, I think that was part of the goal and the design was that was it was a circus troop inside players. So just yeah, I think that that was that was their goal. Whereas ours from the start, it was, I mean, Jess says from the beginning, you know, we're all one company, and as you know, and as you know, our even our principals had to learn circus elements. And originally I think we were mostly lucky in that we cast, you know, our the first casting that we did for the residential, the regional version. It wasn't necessarily a requirement that, you know, Marlena would have to do tribes, but we realized, oh, she has the capacity, let's push this. And then as we continued casting for Broadway, it became more of a okay. So you know you're gonna have to get on the tribe.

[17:09] Jesse Robb: Yeah. It's I feel like it's one of the best compliments that we've received is the idea that this, you know, this group has fused together and become a very all in one, very encompassed sum of all parts human troop traveling trooper. But I don't know, I mean, I don't speak for you, I don't want to speak for you, Shana, but I feel like it's it's one of the best compliments we get is that the idea of these humans, and as Shane was saying, in terms of casting, again, I was very lucky to sort of see the acrobats that had been proposed by Shana in terms of their skill set and what they were going to bring to the storytelling and how that really sort of told the narrative, and then we sort of started looking at other humans that filled out some of the other roles that you would find in this traveling 1930 circus, and their skill sets really sort of complemented, as Shana was saying, you know, some have stronger dance backgrounds, some have stronger athletic backgrounds, some have stronger circus backgrounds.

And a lot of the vocabulary that way, sort of, as we talk about a little bit of game telephone, it became sort of this sort of general vocabulary that from each other pulling from each other and sort of pulling a physical language from each other based on their skill sets. And that was kind of neat. And then in the one scene in the show where you were actually under the tent, you feel like you're actually watching the real circus.

[18:29] Shana Carroll: Oh, that's great. It's funny because for that one, I actually I had to think when I first read the script. I said, I you know, let's have circus as the language to tell the story, but not when we're in a circus doing a circus, because that's just on the nose. And I really for a while was sort of putting my foot down that I didn't want to ever be that obvious. And then at one moment, not only was like, well, that's fun, but also it's a really essential moment in the storytelling to be able to actually live the show, both for you know the characters and what happens in that moment in the story, but you know, also for the audience sort of experience, just they're sitting in a circus. So in the end, we had a lot of fun doing that.

I mean, I tend to like my own work, usually is what we call more contemporary circus, and I sort of steer away from doing the purely traditional work. And in fact, I discovered I had a great deal of joy to be able to, you know, do things that I mean, it also tapped into my roots of when I first started in the Pickle Family Circus and you know, Spanish Web and all sorts of disciplines, you know, balancing ladder that are a little more vintage these days.

[19:32] Jesse Robb: It's interesting because you mentioned that number, Shane, in the show, and that's as you're saying, in terms of contemporary circus, it's very similar that a lot of the choreography I do is much more in sort of a contemporary language and a very diegetic language. So both of us kind of going back into a 1930s presentational language, it's one of the numbers that changed a lot in the show from where its origins and when we started in Atlanta, and probably one of the moments where we hold our breath the most for both Shannon, because there's so much happening simultaneously in that number. But it's interesting because we both often sort of pull away from that element choreographically of very presentational vocabularies and very on-the-nose vocabularies, and yet that end of act one was demanding it. It was sort of begging for it, and so we just kept creeping a little bit back into that world together.

[20:23] Shana Carroll: Well, as an audience member, it was kind of thrilling. I mean, I don't even, especially as a kid, I didn't love to go to the circus, but it was thrilling just to feel that in the theater because it's not an immersive show, you know, you don't expect to feel part of it, and you do at that moment. So that was a very successful moment.

[20:41] Jesse Robb: So you said that the show takes place in the 1930s. Did you look to any period style of dance for inspiration?

[20:49] Shana Carroll: Yeah, it's something that Shane and I have talked a lot about, and we sort of together with Jessica Stone, the director, sort of were always triangulating. Is that, you know, we went back into some of the styles of the 30s, and you know, as you move out of Charleston, the 20s, and you're sort of looking at Lindy Hop and Jive and Swing and where those styles were sort of going across the country. It became very evident that, you know, a traveling circus at that time, a lot of the languages they would have pulled from these social dances would have been their interpretations. They wouldn't have taken classes in these social dance forms and whatnot, it would have been sort of a chain of events a little bit like telephone.

And so one of the things that I kept saying to Shane is like, you know, how do we keep adding this third vertical element to social dance? And how do we basically then look at, you know, with these superhuman type elements of circus performers? What would they have done with a foxtrot? Or what would they have done with a step that they had found in a Lindy Hop? And how would that have transpired into the group? And then like we do today in a lot of social dance or social media forms of dance that you pick up on the internet, how do you interpret it yourself? And then people jump onto that train. So it was sort of that lineage a little bit, I think, in terms of sort of finding what kind of steps would have been, you know, true to a traveling circus going west in the 30s.

[22:13] Jesse Robb: And it was kind of neat for us because you know, you knew you have a very traditional step of the 30s that, you know, isn't maybe founded in Jive or you know, was founded in in Lindy Hop, but then it's sort of well, that was true to where it was, whether you know it was picked up in Chicago or where whatnot. But then what did it become when you know when you were basically isolated and you didn't have this ability to grab, you know, from all parts of the world instantly on the internet? What does it become physically in a small troupe that exists with each other? And that's where a lot of the steps and whatnot came from. Because these people, the story that you're creating, and these people that are the characters, they are they're in their own bubble. They're not, you know, running out to whatever on a Friday night to go and see what's going on. They're they are the show on a Friday night, and they're their own little community.

[23:07] Shana Carroll: So yeah, you have to kind of create your own version of whatever that.

[23:07] Jesse Robb: Yeah, exactly. That's a great point, actually. Also one thing that was interesting for us acrobatically was there actually was a language that, like Jesse was saying, sort of stemmed more from this acrobatic dance that was happening in social dance called swing and toss, where you sort of can pick someone up by their hands and legs and swing them across the stage. And what was funny is it was done a lot in the 30s and in fact wasn't really touched acrobatically for I mean, you know, 70 years. I don't know. It was it's really in the last 10 years that it started to become again fashionable in acrobatics and in circus, and so it was fun to use that language, knowing that we were also kind of giving an homage to that era, and sort of the full circleness of it all, and you know, for having it really mean something in that moment. So that was a lot of fun too.

[24:04] Shana Carroll: We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.

[24:11] Jesse Robb: By far my favorite moment in this show is the dance that the horse does. It's so beautiful. Oh, just all the white and the swing and oh my gosh, it's amazing. When you are choreographing for an animal and the elephant too, obviously, is that different than when you're choreographing the dance for you know the humans?

[24:35] Shana Carroll: Well, not different in that it's you know, it's a similar exercise, and you're trying to find what the language is, what the source of the movement is, okay. Okay, what if you, you know, put your leg more out diagonally and less forward. Um, I think what what made it diff really different I'd say was the combination of the aerial with the animal work. Yeah. It was really, really interesting as we started, you know, we sort of had the idea of doing making this an aerial piece and tried different types of aerial apparatus to see which worked best. And very quickly we realized that certain aerial moves are even just positions, just we lost the horse. And that, you know, aerial actually doesn't usually look very horse like.

Um contorted and all sorts of things. Um so you know, keep and yet if we just kind of, we we were always sort of, okay, let's try, oh no, that was too much this way, that was too much this way. And if we if we just kept the galloping, then we thought, oh, now we're losing some of the beauty of the aerial and and the metaphor of of him releasing pain or dreaming of his body being able to do things that it can. So it was really interesting the process of well, basically trying a combination of two things that have never been done before and and testing the waters as we went. Um, and also the restraint it took acrobatically. Um Antoine, who does the the piece now, um gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous aerialist.

I mean, if you could see he does an eight minute act where he does things you can't even believe in terms of, you know, splitting and tumbling and da-da-da. And it's just such a sliver of what his ability is in that act. And sometimes that seems so counterintuitive to hold back in that way, to not do your greatest tricks or your biggest splits. And yet it took away from the character of the horse, from the emotion of the moment from Marlena, who was singing, and that exercise of restraint and you know, just the right amount of aerial, the right amount of force, the right amount of emotion, the right amount of dynamic. That was what was really interesting. I think also the idea that we sort of talked a little bit about Shane and I in sometimes though, you know, we we worked very closely with the puppet designer and and the puppeteer, and you know, in a lot of scenarios and very often in theater, when you're looking at puppeteering, the emphasis is on the puppet, and the puppeteers are very much disappearing into the background, and we're very much focusing on what the actual puppet is doing in terms of the character.

[27:05] Jesse Robb: And here we were all we were also looking at what the performer was doing as manipulating the puppet, so that it was actually embodying the puppeteer as the physicality as well.

[27:16] Shana Carroll: So we were often looking at what that extension was of the human behind the puppeteering and how they reacted as the animal as well. And that's where we sort of, as Shana was saying, it's a very similar exercise to choreographing in terms of non-animal or non-umimal physical references, but it did mean that we were sort of looking at how a puppeteer was embodying and part of the puppet, which was interesting.

[27:41] Jesse Robb: And John, our Wrangler, the Wrangler, Joshua worked with the puppet performance, and he was really wonderful and open-minded because actually puppeteers tend to be very purist. And in fact, we were told by many puppet people that you know, no, no, the puppeteer has to be like a ninja. They have to disappear. They are making the puppet live. And when we said we wanted, oh no, we want the person also, the soul to be embodied in the dancer, to have a facial expression, to be living something simultaneous. Most people, most puppet people were allergic to that idea. And then in the end, just helpful and so inspired himself and really brought so, so, so much to that aspect as well.

[28:24] Shana Carroll: Yeah, he really, you know, you look at Caroline, who was the spirit under the soul of Rosie the elephant and manipulates the trunk, but you can see in her facial expression how she really sort of articulated that trunk, this combination of puppeteer and puppet being one. And yeah, as Shana said, Josh was very responsible for that in terms of being very open to trying this idea of including the puppeteer and the puppet maker, you know.

[28:52] Jesse Robb: Yeah, I think it's so interesting, yeah, how we can sort of see them both existing at the same time, but we accept it as one being.

[29:00] Shana Carroll: Yeah, and I think also, like you were saying, with you know, these moments, they become so beautiful. The audible gasps like with the aerial work from the audience, and I think it's twofold, one being the beauty and all that's going on and where the story is at that moment, but then the, you know, there's no expectation that this person is now going to fly out over maybe what five, seven rows of the orchestra, you know.

[29:28] Jesse Robb: So you're gasping for multiple reasons. Was that always once you decided this was how this was going to look, this aerial work, was then it always going to come out into the house?

[29:40] Shana Carroll: Yeah, that was always, I mean, there's people asking that, which is complicated right now. Right now he doesn't actually fly over people's heads. We have to be clear. We actually had to clear some rows because of New York state law. So that feeling, that impression that he does was always a goal. I mean, I come from circus where people are always flying over your head, and that's part of obviously part of the thrill, but importantly, we wanted, you know, a lot of what we talk about is trying to pair these moments of what this acrobatic element of the choreographic element is making us feel viscerally. You're trying to pair that with what the character is feeling, what the story, what the emotion of the story is.

So we wanted the audience to feel what the horse feels. And that's part of it is that you know that he's been confined and in pain and essentially trapped, and like the ceiling bursts off and the walls open up. And so for us to feel literally our fourth wall bursts open, then it's sort of you hopefully the audience is put in that same, not just emotional state, but really like physical state, you know, in terms of their pulse and their breath and all of those things.

[30:51] Jesse Robb: Yeah, it's unbelievably beautiful to watch. I hope everyone sees the show, if only for that moment. But there are so many other wonderful moments. It doesn't look like the circus performers are wearing any kind of harnesses or safety devices. Is that the case?

[31:04] Shana Carroll: Uh, that's the case, yeah. I mean, they're on when they're on certain apparatus like a Chinese pole, you know, their safety device is their own strength and their own skill. And in fact, with most of the work we do, a safety device or harness wouldn't work. It would actually be more dangerous and get in the way. So there's certain tricks that you train with a safety line with someone else holding it, you know, holding on the other end. And but then once you have it solid, take it out of the belt, as we say.

[31:36] Jesse Robb: So yeah. A lot of trust on that stage between, you know, performers and you know, people are just leaping into the air and just without not only I wouldn't say without regard but without any question in their mind that there's going to be someone on that other side it's just it's unbelievable.

[31:55] Shana Carroll: Yeah. And I often say it's true and I think it's when you do circus and have to experience that it's actually great for your psychology and your general what that's like to experience that trust but it's also just part of the training and you know it's like we all do it when we get in an airplane you know we'd make ourselves crazy if we asked every second whether that thing was going to keep us up in the air. So I think it's you know on a similar level you go into it. I was a trip user myself for 20 years and I remember that moment when I just said I have to trust that this equipment is solid and that my the person on the end of the line is going to keep me up and if my brain starts to question any of that I'm gonna make it even more dangerous.

[32:39] Jesse Robb: So yeah well thankfully we don't really hear about too many circus accidents.

[32:42] Shana Carroll: That's good. I was just gonna say I think true to what Shana was saying in the beginning in terms of casting is that it's been quite a morale exercise in terms of the collective and that you know we really see even this far along a year after you know the show was first done out in Atlanta the Alliance and a lot of these performers continued on to New York they still have this amazing rapport with each other in terms of the community and the camaraderie because of this idea of trust and the sort of bond that has been built a lot through a lot of these numbers because of the spacing and the timing is so imperative to all of these elements working each night and eight times a week.

[33:23] Jesse Robb: And in order to do that and you know almost be slightly robotic about being true to your spacing, your timing, your placement. I feel like that has really drawn the company together very closely in order to feel that trust and support, which is very neat. I think it's very unique.

[33:41] Shana Carroll: Is there a different kind of work ethic that you found in circus performers and theater performers?

[33:46] Jesse Robb: Oh, so different. There's so many that was part of the learning curve of the two troops sort of working together and learning how the other works. And they both had a lot to learn from each other. It's not as if, oh, this one has a better work ethic. I mean, ways in which they I think one thing that's really interesting is that circus has to or has to train. And training, I you know, it's really unlike I don't know, a singer who can warm up their voice in their dressing room, or you know, or the years of training kind of add up, and it's not as if they have to train vocals for three hours a day before they go on stage. There's an aspect of acrobatics that I mean, imagine going to the gym and you know, you can do 10 pull-ups the day you don't, the next day it's harder to do 10 pull-ups.

And that's it takes a lot to maintain it, and it takes your equipment and your partners. So that aspect of training, and then also that's I mean, that's part of that is time management, but sort of people understanding that, oh, this is a necessity and we need to leave space for this. But then what's interesting about the training is that because it's very high stress and high risk, it actually needs to be fairly low-key. Like it's actually we tend to get very like do our work seriously, and that's one thing that's wonderful, sort of about theater is the intensity and the intensity of the speed. But in the nature of acrobatics, you have to almost like de-dramatize in order to just, you know, get your blood pressure down, get your feet on the ground, know you're about to do something dangerous, take your time, breathe.

[35:17] Shana Carroll: And so that was interesting, trying to find that sort of relative calm in something that was so much more fast-paced by nature. On the flip side, what I'd say is that circus is really lawless. And a lot of the circus, whether it's just because you have to be to kind of get into this line of work where you think, I'm gonna jump from a trampoline and land on my head and all that stuff, that maybe you just need to be like rebellious by nature, or it's just pure training that you know, there's not the same sorts of education institutions that kind of teach you other types of you know, professional discipline. But it was sort of, you know, watching the discipline of the actors and singers and dancers and how much they knew how to you know, how to work professionally and watching the circus people and various levels of their arc of learning that type of discipline was interesting.

[36:10] Jesse Robb: I mean I think you know, sort of Shana has nailed it on the nose. It's interesting because I think in terms of talking a little bit back to what we were describing in terms of vocabulary and finding a similar lineage between the two, you know, or three or multitude of different humans in the room and how they professionally worked. You know, Shane and I were trying to navigate that language and that process, and at the same time we were watching the humans on stage navigate each other exactly like Shana was describing in terms of how to and when to, and when am I, you know, when am I warming up and when am I basically looking at my spacing and when am I doing this moment here or there?

[36:48] Shana Carroll: And it really was a bit of a reflection, I found for us. So that you know, we were behind the table were trying to navigate how to find this symbiosis, find this language, and they were of course finding the community, which really the show is really about, is it's about community, and they were in the process of it as they're trying to execute these, you know, acrobatic moments and choreographic steps and vocal lines and navigating text while there were acrobatic moments and choreographic moments, and we were sort of watching it unfold in front of us, and that mirror was quite neat for us because it was a good reminder that as Shane was saying, it's that they come from extremely different backgrounds, and yet had to create this very inclusive communal space that allowed for all of these different worlds and their different backgrounds of process to exist, and that was really neat.

[37:48] Shana Carroll: Jesse, you were talking about the type of I guess warm-up or training that someone goes through before they do this. So, in a typical show without acrobatics, you have people that either cover swings, what have you, that sometimes at the drop of a moment have to step in and take on a role that they've learned. But when you're dealing with the circus art of it, is that a different ask or a different, I guess, wheel set? Because if someone's covering multiple tracks, they could be covering multiple circus feats. And how do they, I guess, how do they prepare for that? If that, you know, do you do like a swing rehearsal or an understudy rehearsal the same way you would with a traditional musical for you guys?

[38:34] Jesse Robb: Um, well, yes and no. There are ways in which we do it more traditionally than I thought we'd manage to. And then that's sort of like supplemented with all sorts of other types of training and modifications. But I went into this thinking the notion of swings, I would thought this wouldn't work with circus, partly because it's not something common in circus. So, in fact, a talented circus artist, if you tell them they're gonna be on standby, it's not something that would go down well just because it's just it's really not something that exists. So I thought that would be hard actually to find people. We have wonderful wonder we have two swings who are wonderful and we're so lucky to have them.

But then mostly in circus circus tends to be very individuated in terms of skill sets. And in fact, already we're stretched thin in a way that we're so lucky we have an aerialist who can also fly bonking, a porter who can walk a tight wire and juggle and ride a unicycle. And we really found people very multi-skilled, which is often not the case. Usually, you know, you have your discipline, your specialty, and that's what you that's what you do.

[39:36] Shana Carroll: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.

[39:44] Jesse Robb: So already that's a challenge, and then on top of it, you need someone who can not only fill that one track that's doing five things, but maybe all these other tracks. There's a lot of training, you know, to make sure that you know the our swing does possibly a discipline he hasn't done before. And so instead of waiting for the day where you do a put in, you have to make sure you have trainings every week for during rehearsals, during previews, during tech, all of that, and because it takes months and months sometimes to get these skills.

[40:12] Shana Carroll: And then even then, there's some skills that just will not suit, you know, they can't check off every box. So then there's modification. And then what's interesting is we have this graph of A, B, C, D, E versions, and sometimes it's okay, this person will do this trick for them, and then they'll take this track and then they'll cover this and there's this whole sort of domino thing where we keep the show intact but it's a lot of kind of, you know, musical chairs with the acrobats to keep all the acrobatic elements covered where traditionally in theater the track is the character, you know, the track is the actual human and where they go and what they say and what they sing. And here the track has to do, it's a little more modular in order to keep the acrobatics intact.

[40:57] Jesse Robb: It must be insane keeping track of that. It's insane and luckily I did a bit of the, well, a lot of the preliminary work during rehearsals but now luckily we have an excellent stage managing team and excellent dance captains and circus captains, and so they are busy doing that for the most part and yes, I'm very grateful. It's been quite a process I think in terms of, as you were describing there, that you know, we didn't have the normal theatrical musical theater Broadway sort of, you know, structure of swinging especially the beginning and I think it's been, you know, now as Shana is describing, we, you know, there's a structure in place and when we started this, you know, we started off with, you know, moments in tech and whatnot where we all of a sudden, you know, as everyone's rehearsing and you know, doing long, long days we had multiple people covering for a certain track in the show or we'd have someone go out and you know, this dancer would take this moment in the show and then this acrobat would fill in for the specific storytelling moment in the show, and then all of a sudden we have this person coming on here to cover this acting text-based moment of the show.

[42:07] Shana Carroll: So we had a multitude of people covering sometimes for only one track disappearing in the show in the early days. And of course, that has sort of streamlined as Jesse was mentioning. And now there's this ability to now look at case scenarios A through E, which E gets a little wilder. But also what's tricky, I'll say really quickly, which we sort of had to figure out is that if you're gonna do, I don't know, a full twisting back on a bunking in the show, you need to warm it up before the show. You're not gonna get on a big bunkee. There's two other people who need to be in unison. You know, there's this moment where the idea is swings are on standby. So if something happens during the show, they're ready to jump into costume and get on stage.

But that means in our case that the swings have to warm up too, because they can't just go cold and suddenly jump onto a bunking, for instance, or get up on an aerial apparatus they haven't touched that day, or stretch their shoulders or however it is. So that's that I think adds an additional challenge because already it's a very short window, what you know would normally be fight call or lift call. We'd have circus warm-up, and it's so many disciplines to warm up in that amount of time. And on top of it, we want to make sure we warm up different versions, so you know everyone feels safe, and that can be challenging.

[43:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Of course, I know the answer to this, but what is a bunking?

[43:26] Shana Carroll: Oh, yes. So if two people, very two very strong people kind of put their wrists in a square formation, like imagine two wrists mirroring mine, and someone stands on their wrists, then you can throw them in the air and they can flip and you can catch them back or catch them in other versions or throw them across the stage. They do versions of it in cheerleading, it's a little bit of a different technique, but when you see people fly high in the air in cheerleading, often it's used, it's yeah, it's a similar technique. So it's like a very sophisticated way of giving someone a boost.

[44:01] Jesse Robb: Okay. Joe DePaul, who plays Walter in the show. Now, was he actually a circus performer in his career?

[44:08] Shana Carroll: And actually, well, we both know him from before. Jesse has a funnier story about knowing him from childhood, but I worked with him in Montreal. Well, worked in the same community in Montreal in the circus community there. So I know him through his clown work. And in fact, that was, you know, it was a random moment when we were talking about casting and, you know, it wasn't, you know, it wasn't the most obvious choice at first because he's up in Montreal and he's a circus clown. And oh my gosh, how lucky we are. And we're so fortunate because he actually has a theater background. So he also has that wonderful mix of knowing the two worlds, and he is an excellent clown. And I know this even, you know, prior to having worked on the show with him, he's known really as being one of the best. And I've seen, you know, many of his shows, and so we're extremely lucky to have the real deal.

[44:57] Jesse Robb: And how do you know him?

[44:59] Jesse Robb: Uh, a bit wild. We the first day of rehearsal back for Atlanta for the Alliance. We both got ourselves into sort of the meet and greet, day one. And I was looking across and I said, Oh gosh, I know this Joe. However, at that point you feel very confused because you've watched everybody's videos and audition submissions and thinking, oh, you know, it must just be from, you know, seeing the audition over and over and over again. And then we found ourselves together, you know, speaking a little bit after the meet and greet. And I said, Oh, you know, you're but you're from Montreal, Joe. It's lovely to meet you. You know, have you lived, you know, your whole life in my, oh no, no, no, Jesse. I'm from a very small town in Ontario called Burlington.

I said, Oh, Joe, I'm from a very small town in Ontario called Burlington. Oh, yes, yes, yes, no, but I went to a high school, Burlington Central High School. I said, Oh, Joe, I went to Burlington Central High School. Oh, I went to a theater camp that was run by a teacher who originated back in the 70s. I said, Oh Joe, I went to this. Oh Joe, you were my camp counselor. Oh my gosh. So it kind of unveiled itself little by little. All of a sudden we realized although we were about 10 years apart, Joe was the one who was putting stubble on me for Guys and Dolls back in the day when we were both in theater camp together.

[46:17] Shana Carroll: That's so crazy. And who did you, who were you in Guys and Dolls?

[46:21] Jesse Robb: I mean, I'm not sure. I mean, the very, the very well-known character of Stan, let's say.

[46:28] Shana Carroll: Okay. All right. So did Joe become a leader in the cast because he sort of had ownership of both worlds?

[46:36] Jesse Robb: I think he became a really solid reference. Like I think he, you know, he's also so, he's very respectful of the process. So, you know, I don't think he, he's one to, you know, he's not gonna jump in and say, Hey everyone, I have something to say. But when asked, he really was a wonderful, wonderful reference to have and someone people really look to for his expertise. Also it was fun just to have someone else who kind of bridged the world, even well, understanding the needs of both worlds, as we were saying, there was that learning curve, and even socially, you know, some of the cast members you knew from Montreal and some of the circus cast members, and so that helped kind of create those bridges. And even for me, I know that having another circus person in the cast when, you know, I mean, I had Jesse to talk to and my associate, but every now and then I'd say, Joe, what do you think?

[47:24] Shana Carroll: Yeah, someone who speaks your language.

[47:26] Jesse Robb: Exactly. So I know if this were a movie that insurance would be an issue because you're doing some dangerous things. Does that come into play when you're doing Broadway show?

[47:38] Shana Carroll: We talked about this just recently, actually. It's interesting. Insurance comes up. I mean, you have Grant Guston and he's jumping on top of trains and things like that. You know, I'm guessing he's athletic. But are you part of that process of training him how to do that?

[47:55] Jesse Robb: Yeah, and that was, I mean, that particular jump he does when he jumps on the train was something you know, we first tried with a group of acrobats to see the mechanics of it. And so then when Grant arrived, it was a question of sort of, you know, teaching him something that was already figured out. And of course he's also very physical and very talented. I mean, those things like that jump, for instance, is one of the safer things because it doesn't, you know, if we miss it, it won't look pretty. But he has two very strong people under him who are their job is spotting and catching people. And again, that's part of the safety is that's built in is the fact it's these people's profession to keep other people alive.

It's not like, oh I've learned this one move and I'll straighten my arm, and if it doesn't work, then I don't know what. You know, in fact, so often, you know, what porters do, the bottom people in circus is, you know, they adjust, they catch, they go over here that, you know, so that's that makes it inherently safe. And the fact Grant is talented. Same thing with the tripees. You know, we did it in steps and made sure, you know, he felt the strength. It's, you know, the calculated risks and the risks that are, that have safeties inherent inside them. I mean, those scare me less than many other risks in life. I don't, you know, not, you know, it's something when it's again when it's your, when it's the sole focus of your energy, that's its own safety.

[49:19] Shana Carroll: It takes it takes back to your planes, Jesse. It takes back it's high risk, low probability. It's structured. So what moments in the show thrill you both?

[49:29] Jesse Robb: Well, it's really interesting because I get thrilled by the audience being thrilled. It's contagious and also it makes me happy. And so there are things that I know are not the hardest trick and are pretty safe, but I hear the audience react, and so that makes, that's thrilling for me. There's other moves that I know are actually more difficult or sketchy that day, and yet maybe the audience doesn't capture that. And so then I'll feel personally thrilled with them. And actually back to the bunkings that you were saying, you know, that's something that I think people tend to react a lot to, you know, like someone, you know, sliding down the pole head first or the aerial moments that are fairly controlled.

And in fact, moves that are that are for me more, you know, that are more difficult are the ones that are dynamic, where you, you know, where someone is thrown and caught one way or another because there's so many variables, and in fact they're the riskier moves. So, you know, I think it those those are the ones I find thrilling because I'm, when they go well, I'm, I'm yes, I'm relieved as well.

[50:30] Shana Carroll: I probably, I think I exist sort of in musical theater threes. So it m for me thrilling, you know, tends to be there's three moments in the show, and the first one is anywhere where we see everybody at the end of anywhere when they all come down on the train. I think there's a bit of an adrenaline rush there, and sort of, um tailing on that, of course, is the top of act two. When we get to Zolston and all of a sudden you see the entire company at this, you know, summer barbecue type sunny day where they're all together, and you would literally see every single person in the company at that moment in some way in this sort of joyous, elated feel. And that that's a bit of a rush for me. And then that all sort of culminates when you get to the end of the show and you're in the dream sequence and you see Jacob up on the trapeze, and all these people drift in, and it's like one, it's another moment where it's the entire company again.

It's every single person in the show drifts on stage and they're all looking up, and there's just this, you know, palpable heart rush that comes on when you see what a family is like to sort of be on the ground and support this human in the air. And I think those three really are sort of like the guttural rush for me in terms of the show.

[51:40] Jesse Robb: It's funny because I think thrillers implied like an element of surprise, like when you actually get thrilled. So it's hard to get surprised by the thing you've been working on for years. You know what I was saying about seeing the audience? I think actually my thrill is watching the audience. I once did a, you know, sat in one of the box seats, the forward box seats that actually they don't sell because there's so much obstructed view, and spent most of the time watching the audience instead. And it was, and that's the thing that changes for us night by night. You know, the show has small differences, but it's really beautiful to see how much I think people respond definitely like I mean, sometimes like children to the exhilaration and the more spectacular moments, but then it also has it touches them deeply and emotionally, and to see those things happen simultaneously is really beautiful.

[52:29] Shana Carroll: Yeah, I mean, the absolute best part is that all of this spectacular work that you've done is so perfectly integrated into the story and the drama of the show, so that it's just one living organism.

[52:41] Jesse Robb: Well, that was the goal.

[52:42] Shana Carroll: So yeah.

[52:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, we will be cheering you on the night of the Tonies. I mean, you've already won because you have this amazing collaboration. I hope that you two will have another project to work on together.

[52:55] Jesse Robb: That would be lovely.

[52:56] Shana Carroll: We hope so too.

[52:57] Jesse Robb: Yeah.

[52:58] Shana Carroll: Thank you.

[52:58] Jesse Robb: Thank you.

[52:59] Shana Carroll: Thank you for the love.

[53:00] Jesse Robb: My pleasure.

[53:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Thank you so much for joining us. Everybody, please, if you want to see something out of the ordinary and just absolutely spectacular, go see Water for Elephants.

[53:10] Shana Carroll: We will see you next time at Behind the Awards.

[53:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Bye, everybody.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred