Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ *Cough!* *Hack!* *Eeech!* Hairball got you down? We've got the perfect solution: Andrew Lloyd Webber's mega-hit musical Cats. It's team Jimi (aka Cats Trash) vs team Tommy (aka the rest of the world)... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
Featured Shows
About
*Cough!* *Hack!* *Eeech!* Hairball got you down? We've got the perfect solution: Andrew Lloyd Webber's mega-hit musical Cats. It's team Jimi (aka Cats Trash) vs team Tommy (aka the rest of the world). Are we talking about high concept art? Or the lowest common denominator. The gloves are off in this cat-astrophe of an episode.
Cats (Original Cast Recording)
SHOW NOTES
Do you share Jimi's crush on Tony Vincent as Simon in Jesus Christ Superstar? You will soon…
Reminisce with this Independent article published the morning after Cats's record-breaking 6,138th performance."
We're rats. We're RATS! We're furry and forlorn!""Who out there is a fan of Stephen Ward?" Did you miss that Lloyd Webber flop? We've got you covered.
Wanna see an old-man theatre cat get scared out of his wits by the creepiest cat you've ever seen? Of COURSE you do…
Tune in to Broadway.com's backstage coverage of the Cats revival with the oh-so-handsome Tyler Hanes.
Want too much information about Cats (but nothing about it's critical reception)? Check out the Wikipedia page. Really – check it – it's a work of art.
Get your Elaine Page fix over at her BBC Radio 2 page. Do you think she's "The First Lady of Musical Theatre?"
Get a load of Ruthie Henshall (and Bernadette Peters and Julia McKenzie) doing "You Gotta Get a Gimmick."
A MISTRANSLATED QUIZ QUESTION…
What musical's title song's first lyric goes like this, when poorly translated: "Condone violence in the cloud from any location monitoring.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Tommy: Can I read you an excerpt from Andrew Lloyd Webber's's IMDB Internet bio?
[0:06] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[0:07] Tommy: First sentence says Andrew Lloyd Webber's is arguably the most successful composer of our time.
[0:15] Jimi: I mean somebody get us another drink.
[0:19] Tommy: I'm so excited.
[0:22] Tommy: It's it's we should talk about what show we're doing before we talk about Andrew Lloyd Webber's.
[0:30] Jimi: Yeah.
[0:30] Tommy: But as you may have guessed.
[0:33] Jimi: Talking about cats.
[0:34] Tommy: We are talking about them cats, them kitty cats.
[0:51] Jimi: I don't know if you've heard about this musical, Tommy, Cats.
[0:54] Tommy: Never heard of it.
[0:56] Jimi: Wild, wildly popular.
[0:58] Tommy: Yeah?
[0:59] Jimi: Um it no longer has the record for the longest running Broadway show.
[1:03] Tommy: I know.
[1:04] Jimi: It's fourth now, as far as I think.
[1:06] Tommy: So what's it?
[1:06] Jimi: It's if you include revivals, it's Chicago.
[1:06] Tommy: It's Chicago.
[1:12] Jimi: Phantom.
[1:13] Tommy: Lion King.
[1:13] Jimi: Lion King, of course it's Lion King.
[1:15] Tommy: And then cats.
[1:15] Jimi: And then cats.
[1:16] Tommy: And of course line.
[1:17] Jimi: That's when the good shows start.
[1:20] Tommy: Oh god.
[1:22] Jimi: Yeah. Cats, if you've avoided it, one, you're very lucky. Two, it's based on Old Possum's book of practical cats.
[1:31] Tommy: A series of poems by T. S. Eliot.
[1:33] Jimi: Mr. T. S. Eliot. With uh music and lyrics by the right honorable Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber.
[1:40] Tommy: I mean, you say music and lyrics, it's very much the music.
[1:40] Jimi: Very much the music, yeah.
[1:45] Tommy: It was it was part of the isn't it part of the T. S. Eliot st um oh, what's the word?
[1:51] Jimi: The people who control your estate.
[1:52] Tommy: The T.S. Eliot Estates agreement that there could be no new lyrics.
[1:56] Jimi: Yeah, pretty much.
[1:57] Tommy: So the only I mean the only one that's slightly different is obviously memory, but even then that's still pinched from two other poets.
[2:06] Jimi: Right.
[2:07] Jimi: And I I I want you, dear listener, to think about cats, even if you love cats and think about the name of another song in cats.
[2:15] Tommy: Or like go stop someone on the street who isn't Jimi and say, Hey, have you heard of the musical Cats?
[2:20] Jimi: They're gonna say yes, because who hasn't, and say, name a song from the show, and they're gonna say memory.
[2:25] Tommy: And then you say name another song, and then they're gonna stare at you like the crazy person you are, because it's the only song that made it out of this musical.
[2:33] Jimi: Right.
[2:34] Jimi: But then do you know I mean go up to we're starting already go up to someone and be like, name a song from Phantom.
[2:46] Tommy: Phantom of the Opera.
[2:47] Jimi: And they're gonna say Phantom of the Opera.
[2:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[2:50] Jimi: And then name another song.
[2:51] Tommy: They're not gonna be like, oh and masquerade, of course.
[2:53] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[2:54] Jimi: I mean you're that's number one. It's you're it's still we're we're all in the same bucket of Andrew Lloyd Webber's musicals that I don't like.
[3:02] Tommy: So Yeah, yeah, I know.
[3:03] Jimi: So for you that's a non-argument.
[3:05] Tommy: But for me, that's huge, because I I still don't like Phantom.
[3:08] Jimi: But I do like cats, Tommy.
[3:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[3:11] Jimi: Uh this is why we picked this show.
[3:13] Tommy: This is it.
[3:14] Jimi: Dear listener.
[3:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[3:15] Jimi: The glove like I say, the gloves are off.
[3:18] Tommy: Is that does he use that lyric in School of Rock?
[3:20] Jimi: Is he pushed that off?
[3:21] Tommy: I don't know.
[3:21] Jimi: Um and the gloves are off.
[3:23] Tommy: You hit.
[3:25] Jimi: I've tried to block most of that musical out of my mind too.
[3:27] Tommy: Fair enough.
[3:28] Jimi: Well, listeners let him know because I'm not gonna listen to it. Like like most tried and true musical theater fans, I have opinions about all sorts of musicals that I've never listened to.
[3:37] Tommy: Yep.
[3:38] Jimi: But you know, in your own words, tell me, you don't hate any.
[3:40] Tommy: I don't hate any.
[3:42] Jimi: Really?
[3:43] Tommy: Except cats.
[3:45] Jimi: I s uh well it's there's a lot to unpack there. Um so I only had a casual knowledge of cats before preparing for this podcast.
[3:54] Tommy: I've listened to the soundtrack too many times this past week and watched the it's is it just was it for television or for the cinema?
[4:02] Jimi: It no, it was it was released. I don't I don't think it was in the cinema.
[4:06] Jimi: They do call it a film, but I don't think it was in the cinema.
[4:08] Tommy: I had it on video cassette.
[4:10] Jimi: Yeah, like it's a straight-to-tape recording of an amalgamation of a bunch of different casts, is my understanding.
[4:17] Tommy: Yeah, pretty much from the late 80s or early 90s, maybe.
[4:22] Jimi: It's the 1998 it was filmed, and the casts kind of popped up in around in that time, basically.
[4:28] Tommy: Um and so I watched that yesterday, and it was a painful experience.
[4:32] Jimi: So okay, it yes, it absolutely wasn't. I was like, he's gonna watch it and it's gonna change everything.
[4:40] Tommy: I know I'm going into this with a with a whole bunch of cynicism.
[4:43] Jimi: I had full intent to try and find the thing I liked about this musical to latch on to.
[4:51] Tommy: Yep.
[4:51] Jimi: And I just couldn't.
[4:53] Tommy: I just couldn't across the board.
[4:58] Jimi: No fun, no good.
[5:00] Tommy: Out and out hate is what you have.
[5:01] Jimi: Yes, yes.
[5:02] Tommy: Wow.
[5:02] Jimi: Uh so the first of all, it took me like seven listens to actually understand that there is a little bit of a plot to this thing.
[5:11] Tommy: Yes, of course there is, of course.
[5:13] Jimi: Why did it take you that long?
[5:15] Tommy: Yeah, and and I, you know, I don't like I do this. I listen to musicals and understand them. Like I this is the thing that my brain is like tuned to do.
[5:27] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[5:28] Tommy: And this musical makes me feel stupid because it's so obtuse. Like, I was ready to go into this and be like, okay, so let me I'm gonna throw this out at you.
[5:37] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[5:38] Tommy: If if I were to summarize cats like this, I was saying cats is a music picture it, Jimi.
[5:43] Jimi: Yep.
[5:45] Tommy: Post apocalyptic society. Humanity is dead. Nuclear fallout mutations rampant. And the whole world has been taken over by a race of anthropomorphic cats who have mystical superpowers and live in a junkland waste world where they dance and fight with each other.
[6:11] Jimi: Now, I know that this is not the plot of the musical cats.
[6:16] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[6:17] Jimi: But you could watch the musical cats and be like, oh yeah, that's absolutely it.
[6:22] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[6:22] Jimi: There's nothing in it to refute that kind of plot.
[6:25] Tommy: Which.
[6:29] Jimi: Yeah?
[6:29] Jimi: I really don't like it.
[6:31] Tommy: I really, really don't like it.
[6:32] Jimi: Okay.
[6:32] Tommy: Well, I've written a beautiful succinct saying of what it is out there.
[6:38] Tommy: So I said, Cats is a musical telling the story of the lives of the jellic cats in the lead up to the Jellico Ball, where one of them will be chosen to go to the utopian heavy side layer.
[6:51] Jimi: And that's that's it.
[6:52] Tommy: That's literally it.
[6:55] Tommy: But even like if you just pulled those plot points out of the musical, there would still be like 80% of musical left that has nothing to do with it.
[7:05] Jimi: No, but that's it's the kind of thing. Do you know what? It's it's interesting that we've just done Assassins because it's really similar.
[7:12] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[7:13] Jimi: Go on.
[7:14] Jimi: Because it's pure, it's purely episodic. You get this bit at the start where they're like, hey, we're the jellic cats. This is what we do. Someone's gonna make the jellic choice. Um, and then these cats are like, pick me, pick me, pick me, pick me. Then, oh my god, our leader's been kidnapped. Um, always back, great. Pick me, pick me. I'm not gonna pick you, I'm gonna pick her, the end.
[7:38] Tommy: And that's it.
[7:40] Jimi: That is the plot. And as I said, it took me seven listens to actually understand.
[7:45] Tommy: Well, maybe that's a mark of your intelligence, Charlie.
[7:49] Jimi: I think that's a mark of Did you not find though when you watched the film that it was easier for you to understand?
[7:58] Tommy: I mean, I think was it not clearer then?
[8:00] Jimi: So I had seen I saw a high school production of cats when I was in high school.
[8:04] Tommy: Oh, see, there was your I think that's your mistake.
[8:07] Jimi: Of watching a production of cats, you're probably high school production of cats, high school product.
[8:13] Tommy: No, but like I had memory like Magical Mr. Mistophiles shows up and they steal the Shaggy Carpet cat whose name I can never they all have stupid names.
[8:20] Jimi: Oh, Deuteronomy.
[8:22] Tommy: Can I just can I just make this point right now?
[8:24] Jimi: Absolutely.
[8:25] Tommy: I I could tell you each of the cats's names if you showed me a picture. And I don't mean the main cats, I mean the entire company.
[8:33] Jimi: I don't know if you should tell people that.
[8:35] Tommy: I think that's I am proud. I am proud of that. And do you know what? There's not even a sparkle quiz for me to show off my knowledge.
[8:38] Jimi: Oh, dear Jim and Tomic listeners. If you have some time, make a sporkle to the cats.
[8:46] Tommy: Make a sparkle quiz just for me.
[8:48] Jimi: Name the cat.
[8:49] Tommy: Name the cat.
[8:50] Jimi: There's some out there that are alright. They give you a brief description, but I can do it by picture.
[8:55] Tommy: But anyway.
[8:56] Tommy: I had a sense that there was some plot. I had a like there there is some implied drama, but it's not. The whole thing's based on poems, and the poems weren't even originally published in the same work.
[9:10] Jimi: They were written by T.S. Eliot for his grandkids and sent to them in letters.
[9:15] Tommy: So like they're dislike. I think episodic is a kind word for disjointed sometimes.
[9:22] Jimi: Um there's disjointed little episodes for sure.
[9:28] Tommy: Like each self-contained, describing individual cats.
[9:32] Jimi: Yep.
[9:33] Jimi: There's put it publishing them all together is about as cohesive as that should have gotten.
[9:39] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[9:39] Tommy: Like here, these are all by the same author, vaguely about the same thing. Here they are in one book, the end.
[9:45] Jimi: Yeah.
[9:45] Tommy: But instead, Andrew Lloyd Webber's and his publicity machine turn it into one of the longest running musicals of all time.
[9:53] Jimi: That was so I didn't, I couldn't, I need to tell you, Jimi, I could not bring myself to watch this musical alone.
[9:59] Tommy: Um I just wouldn't finish it, so I forced some of my friends to watch it with me.
[10:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[10:05] Tommy: Um, who are fair weather musical theater fans, and I apologize profusely to them for for putting them through this.
[10:11] Jimi: But it's okay, it's this guy in Britain is forcing me to do it.
[10:15] Tommy: But they said halfway through, people like this thing.
[10:19] Jimi: Really?
[10:20] Tommy: Uh just I'm so sad.
[10:22] Jimi: I'm so sad.
[10:23] Tommy: It's just like I understand that people like it. I understand that it has some child appeal. I understand that there's a spectacle to it, and I think the spectacle one is what it wrote for its initial success, and is the thing that has aged the most poorly from it, because it relies on things that were new at the time, like environmental theatre and you know extravagant costumes and concept pieces, which are now the meat and potatoes of musical theater.
[10:53] Jimi: Um I get that, but there's something so it feels condescending to watch this musical.
[11:03] Tommy: That's so interesting.
[11:05] Jimi: It's so because I just feel like almost the complete opposite.
[11:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[11:09] Jimi: Like, so right. My stor my story.
[11:12] Tommy: Yeah, my cat's story.
[11:15] Jimi: Um, so I my first ever thing of seeing it was on the hey Mr. Producer concert video. That was the first, and it came on quite near the end.
[11:25] Tommy: Um, and they did, I think they just did the jellic ball in memory, and I was like, that was fun, that was cool.
[11:31] Jimi: Then did it say again, and then it was actually the first thing that I saw in a theater, the first musical that I saw in a theater, and I was just so blown away.
[11:42] Tommy: Like I remember because like you say, because of the spectacle, and it was unlike anything else I'd seen before.
[11:48] Jimi: It I remember like the specific moment where I was like hooked, and it was when in the in the addressing of cats, and not the addressing of cats, the naming of cats, when they come out into the audience and they're like whispering, and they're literally like in your ear.
[12:02] Tommy: And that was the first time I don't obviously ever experienced the breaking the fourth wall and all this.
[12:06] Jimi: And my like I feel that that was like the birth of me as a director.
[12:11] Tommy: Because I in most of my shows now, I pretty much I will at some point try and break the fourth wall because that's the kind of theatre I enjoy.
[12:18] Jimi: And I remember just that electric feeling getting that from this person who's completely in character, whispering in your ear, uh, and then going back up and then dancing away, and it was just it was such a spectacle.
[12:30] Tommy: And for being a young a youngster, there wasn't much that I needed to understand.
[12:36] Jimi: I I don't think I understood the plot then, right?
[12:39] Tommy: But I was just like, that was cool, that was really, really cool and exciting.
[12:43] Jimi: And I left and then was like obsessed with it, so uh I got given the Android Lloyd Weber box set of VHSs, which contained the 1988 film of Cats.
[12:54] Tommy: It contained uh I don't know when it was filmed, but the Jesus Christ Superstar stage version and Joseph as well.
[13:03] Jimi: So and I think I've watched Joseph once.
[13:05] Tommy: Uh-huh is it the Danny Asman one?
[13:07] Jimi: It's the Donny Osman one, yeah.
[13:08] Tommy: There's you know, right, exactly.
[13:11] Jimi: It's Joseph, it's Joseph, and then Jesus Christ Superstar I watched a lot more, but I purely because I had a really big crush on Tony Vincent who played Simon, understandable understandable, and Cats I like destroyed because I I watched it so much.
[13:26] Tommy: Now like basically from that, I I just became so obsessed with the choreography and the dancing, as well as the characters.
[13:35] Jimi: I that's these were the things that always kind of kept me coming back.
[13:40] Tommy: Now, when we decided to do this, I hadn't watched the film for a long, long time.
[13:45] Jimi: We're talking maybe like 10 years.
[13:47] Tommy: Okay, how did it how did it hold up?
[13:49] Jimi: So I was worried because I was like, oh god, what if he's right? What if I watched this and I hate it?
[13:54] Tommy: Um and I watched it, and I just all those memories came flooding back, and I was remembered all of the every single word I remembered.
[14:02] Jimi: I remembered all my favourite moments. They were still there, and they were still amazing.
[14:06] Tommy: I still remember a lot of the choreography.
[14:08] Jimi: Like it's just it's it's a pure utter part of me, and I I tried to look at it objectively.
[14:17] Tommy: Being like, okay, so it's the you know it's the 21st century now musical features change.
[14:24] Jimi: Exactly.
[14:25] Tommy: And I was like, no, do you know what? This choreography is still shit hot.
[14:29] Jimi: Like it's still really good.
[14:32] Tommy: The characterization is coherent.
[14:35] Jimi: Yeah.
[14:36] Tommy: And it's a really sweet little story.
[14:39] Jimi: So no, I'm still there.
[14:40] Tommy: I'm still there.
[14:41] Jimi: You didn't get me.
[14:42] Tommy: Okay.
[14:43] Tommy: This is and this is your bailiwick, and this is a question I had.
[14:46] Jimi: Um this cat's is absolutely Did you say my bailiwick?
[14:50] Tommy: Yeah, bailiwick.
[14:51] Jimi: And definition, please.
[14:53] Tommy: Oh, you don't use that word in Scottish?
[14:56] Jimi: I do not.
[14:59] Tommy: Uh, I wanna just Google it so I get it right, but it's like you're it's a it's it I bet you it's a very American word. It's like you're it's the the stuff that you do, it's the the area your area of expertise, your knowledge. I think it's a like it feels like it's some old taming the wild west, like your bailiwick is between your fences or something.
[15:20] Jimi: Right, okay. It's what you're in charge of. That's probably a hundred percent wrong, but you know.
[15:25] Tommy: Well no, it's the area of jurisdiction of a bailiff.
[15:29] Jimi: Oh, interesting. This is a this is a very British word.
[15:33] Tommy: Um, I preferred your definition to be honest. So this is your bailiwick, like choreography dancing stuff, and this is, you know, unquestionably a dance show. Um, there's and I've made this comment before. I think dance and musical theater is great, but to a purpose, if it's gonna be dan and I I love I do lighting for pure dance concerts all the time. Like I I have no distaste for dance, I love watching dance, but I think it there is a different assumption based upon what you're labeling your piece of art. Like this is Cats the musical. This is not Cats that dance extravaganza, right?
[16:14] Jimi: But and a lot of like the Jellicle Ball, the 10 minute long dance. Uh-huh. About I was I was trying so hard to focus on it and pay attention to it, and it was just dancing. And I don't mean to imply that like all art needs to have plot. Like, we you can do art that just evokes feeling, and I think a lot of dance just evokes feeling, but this kind of like weird hybrid where some of this dance in this show is very specifically communicating plot elements or story elements or character elements, and then some of this dance is just acrobatics, is just like impressive spectacle, gets you know at that point to me, one cartwheel is the same as 15.
[17:05] Tommy: Right, okay. I know I know you can do it, I got it, let's move on. It feels like you're you are you are wasting my time as a, you know, you're you are trying my patience as an audience member.
[17:16] Jimi: Yeah. And it doesn't like the whole Jellicle Ball doesn't seem to build in any kind of way or have like a flow of with peaks and valleys. It's it's like a water cannon just like constantly coming at you.
[17:30] Tommy: And I and I get that some of that contributes to the spectacle, like they maintained this fantastic acrobatic feat for 10 minutes. Ooh, wow, but then I'd just go to the circus. Like, like you know, there's something. I I feel and it's weird to say about Cats, but it feels like appropriation of an art form, which I realize is antithetical because it kind of defined the art form for several decades. But it's just maybe it all just comes down to personal taste, but it's not I wonder, yeah.
[17:59] Jimi: I wonder if at that point in the show you had already just kind of switched yourself off to it because I can fully see a plot in the Jellicle Ball.
[18:06] Tommy: Yeah. And like it's it's like it's like a balletic plot, you know. I mean, it's not a specific you're not watching the story of one person, it's like a very collective storyline. You're um feeling feelings and but yeah, but also it's you know, at the start, obviously the Jellicle Ball begins with this beautiful solo from Victoria, who's the white cat, um, and she kind of introduces the whole thing to everyone.
[18:32] Jimi: Um, and then everyone's like, oh great, it's Jellicle Ball time, let's get down to it. And then you have the guys' moment where they come out and they're all impressive, and then and then you have the girls' moment where they come out and they're all sexy as girls, and then they do some stuff together, and then you have the pas de deux between Alonzo and Victoria, which is kind of like cats coming together. Uh-huh. You know what I mean? Whether it's a sexual thing or not, who knows?
[19:00] Tommy: It's very sexual. Um, but we'll get into that later. Um, and then so you've got this beautiful pas de deux, and then that's when it all kicks off, and then they do their fun kind of crunchy granola sweet style stuff. Yeah, and then it's just mad celebration till the end. And then that little mad celebration bit is only about three minutes long. That's it's just maybe And that's the Jellicle Ball. Because it's a ball. They're dancing. They're celebrating together.
[19:26] Jimi: Yeah, there's still, you know, if I hadn't listened to it before and didn't have a summary right in front of me, like these are there, it's live theater. It's meant to be experienced once. Uh-huh.
[19:37] Tommy: And I think you're and I I no, I I would disagree with I would disagree with that because you can't say that there are many shows that are really complex and you can't. That's why I'm I'm going back in my mind saying that. But I I think there needs to be some there needs to be a middle ground. You can't make a show so obtuse that you can get very like there, you need to be able to understand a certain percentage of a show on first viewing, I think, for it to be for it to get the Tommy stamp of approval, I guess.
[20:09] Jimi: But again, I know I think I think you can. I think you can freely from Cats, because it's you know, if you take Jellicle Ball aside, you understand that you're seeing the stories of all of these different cats.
[20:22] Tommy: Yeah. One of them who has her little kind of redemption story gets picked at the end and kind of wins. Do you know what I mean?
[20:30] Jimi: So I feel that it is actually the most simplest musical to get. I wonder if people kind of try and look too deep, try and find you know, want to find something that that actually that actually just isn't there, that it is completely on the surface. Do you know what I mean?
[20:45] Tommy: Yeah. I mean, that would still to me that still makes it problematic. I want my art to be, you know, important as a loaded word. Um, but but to have import to like you you know what what do you want the audience to feel or learn, or like how do you want them to be different leaving the theater than when they entered, other than wow, or hey, theatre's cool. You know what I mean?
[21:11] Jimi: I know I'll tell right. So what I'll do is that I will agree with you that I think important theatre is my favorite thing, and I will like completely agree that Cats is by no means important theatre. Do you know what I mean?
[21:23] Tommy: Yeah. Cats has changed nobody's lives apart from Andrew Lloyd Webber's.
[21:26] Jimi: By millions and millions of dollars. And Elaine Page, I guess. But you know, you don't leave the theater from Cats being changed in any way.
[21:34] Tommy: But I think you do leave feeling roused, or you should. Um feeling feeling roused and just happy, which I think also has its place in the theater. It just kind of harks back to the 20s and the 30s when it all began.
[21:48] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know? I mean, if Cats was on then, yeah, my good lord, like they wouldn't know what's hit them because it's so so much.
[21:56] Tommy: Yeah. And I think that's what it is. And I feel that that kind of show still completely has its place in musical theater. It's just a different category.
[22:04] Jimi: I just think it's lazy to only have one. I think there are contemporary shows that are equally as rousing and spectacular as Cats that also have a, you know, what did we learn today, kids?
[22:16] Tommy: I don't think I'm trying I'm trying to think of something that it kind of falls into a Cats bracket.
[22:23] Jimi: Yeah. Um this was another thing I said. I am sub when I was watching this with my friends. All popular musicals spur copycats, all of them.
[22:32] Tommy: Yeah.
[22:33] Jimi: And like then the genre is reborn on stage. Like, you know, you you get the birth of the Euro musical or the birth of the review or things like that. There aren't really Cats copycats.
[22:48] Tommy: No, there's not.
[22:50] Jimi: But then it's I guess I mean, I've never seen like Jerome Robbins' Broadway.
[22:54] Tommy: Right.
[22:55] Jimi: Um, or like the Will Rogers Follies, for example. Like these ones that are did hugely well but were unconventional.
[23:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:04] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? But it's not like they're, you know, high concept animal musicals is not a genre. It's just Cats.
[23:12] Tommy: Yeah, but it doesn't need to be about animals. Do you know what I mean? You can still have a full-on like dance spectacle. Because even something like Fosse, obviously that's that's a review. So that's still a review based on like real things. Or, you know, even poetry-based musicals, like even just the individual parts of this, it's hard to find the echoes of them in the future of musical theater, which is why it's so it's such an oddity as being such a popular show to me.
[23:38] Jimi: Like well, let's let's talk about that. Let's think why why is it as popular as it is?
[23:44] Tommy: There's a great, I'll put it in the show notes. Everyone should read it. There's a great article from The Independent in 1996, um, written on the eve of Cats becoming the longest running musical.
[23:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[23:56] Tommy: It's called How Cats Conquered the World. Um, and it talks a lot about the marketing for Cats. Um, and how and it it's kind of you know, it's just an overview article. It does it certainly doesn't go in depth. But one of the things that Cats did that was very unique was it it I think I think this is where I find the success in Cats, and this is the thing I latch on to is the way it crafted what a musical is.
[24:19] Jimi: It made the musical an international brand.
[24:28] Tommy: Like you could have Cats, the West End production, and bring it over to the US and have it be exactly the same. With the same set and the same everything, and be like, look, we brought this production over. Before that, you'd bring something across the ocean and they would Americanize it, or the other way they'd, you know, Britishize it. And it like they talk a lot about turning Andrew Lloyd Webber's from a composer into a brand, which I find disgusting, but also think was very successful.
[24:54] Jimi: Yeah.
[24:55] Tommy: You know, that is it is absolutely true. Andrew Lloyd Webber's is a brand now. There are Andrew Lloyd Webber's musicals, quote unquote. He has a face, you know, even with his current rebirth of reality shows.
[25:05] Jimi: And I think Yeah, it's just for I think that really interesting because obviously he does he does have a company. He does have the Really Useful Group, but his name surmounts his company.
[25:14] Tommy: Yep.
[25:14] Jimi: Like that doesn't make any sense. Like just to any logical business sense. It's amazing.
[25:20] Tommy: It's very intentional how they marketed this. And like there were there were no previews of Cats outside of the the West End and Broadway productions. Like it was a secret before you went to see it.
[25:33] Jimi: Um that's the one, you know, that's a thing that live theater can always capitalize on is you can't see it before you see it. You can't experience it until you experience it.
[25:42] Tommy: You know, the poster doesn't advertise any star names in it. It doesn't even tell you, like, you know, it's about cats, maybe. That's it. Like the the mystery of the marketing for this absolutely worked to its success.
[25:57] Jimi: And then this is where I think it all becomes one big difficult to untangle ball because you you you know, picture Joe Theater Goer going on his first night to see Cats. Oh, you know, oh, co-workers, I'm going to see Cats. Oh, you'll have to tell us how it is, you know, next day at work. Well, how was Cats? Oh, it was great. What was it about? I can't really tell you.
[26:15] Tommy: Like, it's difficult to describe.
[26:18] Jimi: They were wearing bodysuits and leg warmers and dancing everywhere and the lights, and everyone's like, I don't understand. I'm gonna have to go see this for myself to understand it.
[26:28] Tommy: And suddenly you've sold another ticket.
[26:30] Jimi: Like it's not capitalizing on the no one is going to see Cats for the the moving plot. They're going to see it for the spectacle.
[26:37] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[26:40] Jimi: Which is why it's successful.
[26:41] Tommy: Yeah. And it's, I guess I would argue that that's okay.
[26:44] Jimi: But I guess you would argue that that's frustrating.
[26:46] Tommy: I would argue that I don't, you know, get that out of my musical theater.
[26:51] Jimi: I would think I would say it's okay because it's it's a spectacle of such high quality. Do you know what I mean?
[26:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:59] Jimi: The dancing is incredible. And I don't even think you could argue, you know, that's not one you can debate. Even as a, you know, I don't understand dance at all. It's amazing.
[27:08] Tommy: Right.
[27:09] Jimi: And uh the obviously the athleticism of the cast, yeah, again, is sensational.
[27:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:14] Jimi: Um at its time, the set lighting, you know, worked very was new. Was new and also very good. Do you know what I mean?
[27:25] Tommy: Um, and that I would say lasted till about the millennium.
[27:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[27:30] Tommy: And I don't doubt the reason that it closed is because it was about to get old very quickly.
[27:36] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? In 2000, like it's 2001, I think it closed.
[27:39] Tommy: Uh yeah.
[27:40] Jimi: But like the the set for Cats is what all Broadway sets look like now. Big extravagant, never-ending exactly.
[27:47] Tommy: Exactly.
[27:48] Jimi: It somehow worked for Phantom, but it wasn't gonna work for Cats.
[27:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:52] Jimi: Um, so basically, I think I can just get on board with that because there's kind of there's no let up in the entertainment value.
[28:02] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:03] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[28:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:04] Jimi: Um, and the thing is, is like, so we're talking about Joe Theatre, but the thing is, it's about like Joe. I don't know, non-theatre. I'm just trying to think of like the opposite of theater.
[28:17] Tommy: But not.
[28:18] Jimi: You know what I mean? Can go to Cats and enjoy it for what it is. Now, I'm gonna sound like the biggest mother hypocrite ever here.
[28:26] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[28:27] Jimi: Because I go on about all the time about how theatre's dumbed down and all this nonsense, right? And yes, I will agree that it, you know, it hasn't, and people are getting very lazy. I would never say that Cats was lazy.
[28:38] Tommy: I mean, even in this Independent article, they have I I wonder they they metalign their quotes, so it's hard to know who said what.
[28:46] Jimi: Oh, okay.
[28:47] Tommy: Um, but they call they say uh maybe it's Trevor Nunn who's saying it, that they were working on a populist musical, and he's certainly using it in more of a political sense, but the meaning's not lost. Like a a musical for the people, which is a fancy way of saying a musical for the lowest common denominator.
[29:07] Jimi: Like it it is a simple musical.
[29:10] Tommy: And they went really they went into it making a simple musical, though.
[29:15] Jimi: Like that to me, that is condescending.
[29:19] Tommy: It is condescending, but from our perspective.
[29:21] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? I don't think to Joe and on musical theatre, right? Or anyone listening to this podcast.
[29:29] Tommy: Um, but I think to them, it it probably wouldn't be because they're they're not looking necessarily for that. All these people that hate musical theatre, the idiots, do you know what I mean?
[29:40] Tommy: They will pro a lot of them probably wouldn't mind Cats while that's alive.
[29:44] Jimi: I don't think they'd go to see Cats. There's I mean, you you do you so there's a the old cartoon show, at least in the US called Hey Arnold.
[29:51] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[29:52] Tommy: It's got a big football head on Nickelodeon. Um, one of the characters, Helga, who's a very angry lady character, goes, she's like trying to bond with her dad in one episode. And they go to see the musical rats. It's great. There's a video of a bunch of people in like giant mice suits, and they go, "We're rats, we're rats, rats! We're not on, we're made into the hats are torn. We love We Crystal, we're singing Homo knee. I love her, but I love him And don't it he loves me? Oh Rats Rats Rats Right." And like halfway through the thing, they both just burst out laughing and they leave during intermission because they're like, that was so stupid. And like that's how, you know, if I brought my dad to see Cats, that would be his reaction.
[30:45] Jimi: Yeah. You know, who is this musical for? If the diehard musical theater people think it's trite, and if Joe Sports player is like not gonna get on board with Spandex cats on stage, who kept this show running for 18 years?
[31:03] Tommy: People who wanted to laugh at it? Like, this is the thing I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around.
[31:08] Jimi: Yeah, just to get survived through hate watching.
[31:10] Tommy: Yeah. Like maybe, you know, I understand popularity for one, two, three, maybe even five years based on the spectacle and the mystery of it all.
[31:18] Jimi: Uh huh.
[31:18] Tommy: But in year 16, 17, and 18, no one is going into this show not knowing what it is or having not heard "Memory."
[31:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[31:27] Tommy: Is it the people who very rightly have their nostalgia glasses on, who like remembered enjoying it as a kid? Is it just like thriving on the tourist machine of Broadway? Like, what is the thing that made this or is it the Andrew Lloyd Webber's marketing machine?
[31:45] Jimi: Which it very well could be.
[31:46] Tommy: It could be. Um, I don't know. It's just it and every time you kind of talk it, I still I still go back to it being a dance show, and that's that's the thing that I love so much about it is going and enjoying the dance, because I love watching, you know, give me a half an hour dance break and I will be the happiest little elf.
[32:10] Jimi: But I wonder I don't know.
[32:13] Tommy: I don't know.
[32:14] Jimi: I I I personally, even as a fan of the show, I'm surprised at how well it did. Because to me, you're right, it doesn't make sense.
[32:22] Tommy: Yeah, right. But then the thing is, it's like think of think of all the other successful musicals. Okay, so let's let's go through our top five, right?
[32:31] Jimi: Right.
[32:31] Tommy: So we've got Phantom, Chicago, Lion King, Cats, Chorus Line. So if we're gonna generalize their success down to one thing, Phantom strives on its spectacle of it all.
[32:45] Jimi: Um but also has a plot, like spectacle with a plot.
[32:48] Tommy: I am that wasn't that wasn't me saying uh spectacle, that was me just being like, where's the spectacle? To me, Cats has more spectacle than Phantom.
[32:56] Jimi: Well you know what I mean? Like, so the opening the opening setting is like well, apart from the the one after the the chandelier slowly drifts down onto the stage. Um but the the kind of opera scene is like that's very spectacular and that's huge. But even just even just the chandel, like it Phantom has a technical spectacle, much more than Cats. Cats has a person spectacle, like it's a dance spectacle.
[33:22] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[33:23] Jimi: But you know, we're we are not like shifting gigantic set pieces, we don't have a remote control gondola. We're not crashing a chandelier into the stage. Like, that's spectacular.
[33:37] Tommy: Yeah. Like, I think that's what, you know, I think Cats and Phantom derive a lot of their success from the same thing.
[33:44] Jimi: Yeah, I would agree with that. I would agree with that.
[33:46] Tommy: Chicago lives on star names, and because it's a cheap show to produce.
[33:50] Jimi: Exactly.
[33:51] Tommy: Um, and and good tunes, certainly, not to discredit that.
[33:54] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Sorry, yeah, that was actually very cool. Chicago is a good show. Chicago's a good show.
[33:57] Tommy: Um, Chicago remains a produced show because you can go see Paige Davis in it. Or, you know, who whoever is Usher, literally anyone, like everyone's I think I'm I'm lined up for it in a couple months, I think.
[34:12] Jimi: I I give them another two, three years tops, yeah, maybe just because it's kind of wearing out. Um Lion King, of course, runs on runs on the mouse's dime.
[34:21] Tommy: But I would also just say it's also the first one that's properly great.
[34:26] Jimi: I love Lion King.
[34:27] Tommy: But we're not here to talk about it.
[34:28] Jimi: I think it's beautiful.
[34:29] Tommy: And then we've got our little Cats and then Chorus Line, which is phenomenal. I think Chorus Line is the first one from there that strives on being that isn't just a populist musical.
[34:42] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[34:42] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't think Chicago and Lion King have reached the lowest common denominator, but there's certainly something about them that has a wider public appeal than I would say the vast majority of musical theater.
[34:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[34:56] Tommy: And definitely Cats and Phantom. You know, they're they're as complex as a soap opera. Like, it's not.
[35:03] Jimi: Yeah, we're not doing high art here.
[35:08] Tommy: Uh-huh. But but that's that's the anti-this is the thing I'm struggling to process. People describe Cats as a concept piece.
[35:15] Jimi: And they're No, I would never I would never say that. I would never say that.
[35:19] Tommy: I mean, as opposed to like a book musical. Like.
[35:21] Jimi: Right.
[35:22] Tommy: It's it's a piece structured around a concept. I mean, yeah, but it's not.
[35:28] Jimi: It's not high concept.
[35:29] Tommy: Right. Do you know what I mean? It's just.
[35:30] Jimi: But it's not high concept just because it's stupid. Like it's still high concept in achievability. It's still high concept in how distant it is from like actual concrete, you know, characters and conflict and you know storytelling. Like there is an elevated poetry. Like, that is already high concept, at least in form.
[35:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[35:55] Jimi: But then it, you know, we struggle to call it high concept because it feels like an episode of Teletubbies. Like you're just watching flashing lights, and you know, they redo the same thing again. You're like, ooh, pretty light. Like, I do I wrote a note, like, this feels like Teletubbies the music.
[36:11] Tommy: So interesting.
[36:12] Jimi: Yeah. But then again, I'd probably watch Teletubbies and enjoy it.
[36:15] Tommy: Right.
[36:16] Jimi: Like, that I don't think there's anything wrong with Teletubbies as a four-year-old.
[36:20] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[36:21] Jimi: But four-year-olds aren't buying the tickets. And I don't think everyone going to Cats is like, I'll bring my toddler to come see this.
[36:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[36:30] Jimi: Like, it's not that kind of thing. Cats is an Cats is an enigma to me, Jimi.
[36:37] ♪ Musical number: "The Old Gumbie Cat" — performed by Jimi ♪
[37:28] Jimi: Right, let's talk a little bit about the fans of Cats. Because I'm not I'm literally I'm not the only one on the planet.
[37:34] Tommy: Oh, I know. There's all sorts of wonderful.
[37:36] Jimi: I'm also I apologize to everyone out there who is a big fan of Cats. I still think you're a wonderful person in human.
[37:42] Tommy: That's it. Well, you're well, you know, you don't hate me. You're welcome. Everyone is welcome to their own opinions about these things. Um it's one of those things. I think with Cats, more so than any other musical, maybe Phantom um, maybe Hamilton aside.
[37:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:55] Tommy: Get the Hamilton in there. Um like I've never seen as much like Cats Trash.
[38:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:00] Tommy: I mean, there it's all of the all of the so-called Euro musicals, Cats, Phantom, Les Mis like you know, yeah, I suppose Les Mis as well. But I'm talking like, you know, people devoting like their Tumblr user names to you know, Cats or things like that.
[38:15] Jimi: To Cats, and like following the story of, you know, poor I don't know, you could tell me the name, whatever poor court. Anyone you remember cat that like sits in the background and doesn't actually have any character development.
[38:26] Tommy: Stop saying that.
[38:27] Jimi: Okay, maybe not develop but this is right, okay. No, we're gonna talk about the characters now, okay?
[38:32] Tommy: I'll just stab my candle.
[38:34] Jimi: Right. What I think is really lovely about Cats, and what some other shows actually kind of lack, okay, is the fact that every single cat on that stage has a character, okay? Has a specific and identifiable character that you can track and watch through the whole show that they stick to, right? Every single one of them. Now I think that is really great because a lot of ensemble shows nowadays, that's something that they lack. Do you know what I mean? And directors don't necessarily consider their ensemble and their chorus, and so they just be kind of become these people in the back, which is you know, it's fine, like that's what they were uh, you know, in the past, but I think it's so impressive and creates much more gives the show much more life and a lot more depth when they do have these identifiable characters because one of one of my favourite cats isn't even one of the main cats, one of my favorite cats is Etcetera.
[39:41] Tommy: And I bet you can tell me what's Etcetera.
[39:44] Jimi: Uh Etcetera is a fan of Rum Tum Tugger, uh, jailer and hyperactive.
[39:50] Tommy: Exactly. She's so cute and hyperactive, and she's like, she just you can see her at everything. She's got this massive big smile on her face, she's like zingy, she's like a little electric cat. Um Jimi.
[40:01] Jimi: Yeah, Jimi.
[40:03] Tommy: Yeah. You you might be Cats trash.
[40:06] Jimi: I am not Cats trash. I could be Cats trash if I decided to make a Tumblr cat. But I I can like judge Cats trash. Um but I am not Cats trash. No, like I think it I could be lots of musicals trash, I could be Les Mis trash, you know what I mean. But just because that was my first, do you know what I mean? I fixated on it. Yeah. And that that's okay. And also, I if I was Cats trash, I'd be fine with that. But Tommy, I'd be fine.
[40:37] Tommy: I I think I would, I would I would be your friend just the same.
[40:41] Jimi: Yeah. I wonder if this so like Cats is wildly popular and has these fans who are so you know, they're looking for every last, you know, drop of story they can get out of it.
[40:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[40:55] Jimi: I wouldn't agree with that. I would wonder I would want to talk to, you know, two years into Cats' premiere. Did all of these chorus members have names? Did they all have characterizations? Or is this, you know, a kind of weird type of fan service.
[41:12] Tommy: Um no, they they they do all have yeah, uh, right from the start, they all had a a specific that was a thing.
[41:18] Jimi: Okay.
[41:19] Tommy: I mean, there's been lots of cats that have kind of chopped and changed or changed names, which is a really weird one that I don't understand. But the the actual character and the characterization is is stayed.
[41:29] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[41:30] Tommy: But yeah, the names thing is a really interesting one. In fact, yeah, let's talk about that now. The the revisions that this show has gone through is crazy.
[41:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:38] Tommy: Now I I'm actually gonna put my hands up and you can laugh and be annoyed at me, but I actually don't really enjoy the original cast recording because that don't even know which version I listen to.
[41:49] Jimi: There's two.
[41:50] Tommy: Okay.
[41:51] Jimi: Is it?
[41:51] Tommy: Well, there's two American ones.
[41:53] Jimi: Well, there's two popular ones. So you've got the original cast recording and the film recording.
[41:57] Tommy: This is the original cast recording.
[41:59] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:59] Tommy: UK, yeah.
[42:01] Jimi: Yep.
[42:01] Tommy: So you've got all the old versions of the songs, basically. Um, and orchestrations and melodies have been significantly changed for the better. And I think that's the thing is I think originally I I wouldn't like it as much as I do now, because a lot of it seems very trudgy, very easy, yeah, very Andrew Lloyd Webber's.
[42:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[42:28] Tommy: Now with the revisions that they've made, I think it's less Andrew Lloyd Webber's and more fun, right?
[42:35] Jimi: I guess yeah, like fun. Less Andrew Lloyd Webber and more and more fun is my motto for life. I want my whole life to be less Andrew Lloyd Webber's and more fun.
[42:47] Tommy: Exactly. More 1998 film, less 1981. We we gotta be we gotta be careful, Jimi. We we now have a habit of um uh people who have written the shows that we talk about listening to our podcasts, and yes, we do, Tommy.
[43:02] Jimi: Shall we drop that in?
[43:02] Tommy: Uh I I doubt Dave Muller has listened to our podcast on Cats right now, but uh shout outs to to Mr. Dave, listen to our great comedy podcast.
[43:12] Jimi: Exactly. And uh I think preemptive shout-outs to uh Sir Lloyd Webber, who's probably listening to this podcast right now.
[43:19] Tommy: Exactly. Well, but this time Steven Sardine has probably tweeted it as being like he's probably created Twitter treating.
[43:29] Jimi: Well, no, I was gonna say just to let us know that Assassins was great and you'll be listening to them all from here on in. Um I think that's exactly what you think. And yeah, maybe just to bash Cats a little bit.
[43:39] Tommy: I can't I would be fascinated to hear what he thinks about Cats.
[43:42] Jimi: I like it. I would love to hear specific words.
[43:44] Tommy: I would want to know, you know, and this is the sort of thing he'd never say because it's his brand, and also he has a habit of being really sensitive about criticism.
[43:52] Jimi: Yeah.
[43:52] Tommy: Um, but like what his candid opinion is on Cats' success. Because there's a bunch of early interviews where he talks about they struggled to raise money to get the first production up, which I find unsurprising. Like it's a weird pitch if you haven't seen it. And like he's certainly benefited from like I would say more than anything else from Cats' success.
[44:11] Jimi: Yeah.
[44:12] Tommy: At least financially. Just between the you know, m 70 plus international productions, like on and on and on and on. And it's being revived again, which I'm sure we'll talk about in a do what to talk about in a second. I got a whole paragraph on that. Um, but I wonder, you know, what Andrew, you know, I wonder this about all musical theater writers, but a lot about Andrew Lloyd Webber's, because he, you know, is his own brand and seems so separate from the musical theater core. What he actually thinks about his place in the Broadway canon.
[44:46] Jimi: I think he must think he's good.
[44:48] Tommy: That you sound so mean.
[44:50] Jimi: But probably.
[44:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[44:52] Jimi: Because I mean, most artists do. We're all narcissists deep down inside.
[44:56] Tommy: Like completely, and no, you need to have faith in yourself.
[44:59] Jimi: Yeah. And like the thing is, there will always be people out there who will love your stuff.
[45:04] Tommy: Yeah. But I would want to know, and please tell us if you're out there, like who is a fan of like Stephen Ward?
[45:14] Jimi: Yeah. That was abysmal. That was a mistake. Do you know what I mean? That was a very expensive mistake.
[45:19] Tommy: Um, but it's someone's favorite thing.
[45:21] Jimi: It's someone's favorite thing. Uh, maybe School of Rock, you know.
[45:26] Tommy: I mean, a lot of people really like that.
[45:28] Jimi: Yeah. A lot of people really like Cats.
[45:32] Tommy: Yeah, they do.
[45:36] Jimi: If you offer me pheasant, I'd rather have grouse. If you put me in the flat, then I'd rather have a house. I wouldn't much prefer a mouse, then I only want a rat. If you set me on a rat, then I'd rather fit a mouse. And there isn't any need for me to shout it. And there's no doing anything about it.
[46:13] Tommy: I think in the 80s, like Andrew Lloyd Webber's did write what was needed.
[46:19] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? I mean, they're wearing leg warmers in the show before leg warmers were dance attire.
[46:26] Tommy: Wait, really?
[46:28] Jimi: Really? Um, that's one of the things they talk about in this Independent article.
[46:32] Tommy: Yeah.
[46:33] Jimi: But Fame, maybe right when it was starting, but it is definitely a fashion musical. Not in like outfit, but like in full-on style and existence.
[46:44] Tommy: Like, this is why Cats is important, because it made itself important. Because it was popular, it changed the dialogue of musical theater. Musical theater before Cats was proscenium style shows where the actors stayed in one place and they played people, and you couldn't do high concept things, and it's like a high concept, low concept musical.
[47:03] Jimi: Yeah, or well, it's like there were those, but they just didn't have the success.
[47:07] Tommy: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? And the penetration of Cats.
[47:10] Jimi: Yeah. Um, just penetrate.
[47:13] Tommy: Disgusting.
[47:14] Jimi: Absolutely. Put that away. That's gross. Take that as a soundbite. That'll be a big thing.
[47:20] Tommy: Just stop it again with another drink.
[47:25] Jimi: Oh, that'll be great. That's a cut song, actually, from the original, the penetration of Cats comes just after the addressing of that. Um, what was I gonna say?
[47:34] Tommy: Oh, I'll just talk about Andrew Lloyd Webber's.
[47:35] Jimi: Yeah, like I feel that he is trying to scrape to be contemporary, but just keeps flopping down. Like all the, there are not many reviews of this thing. Um, because it was before, rather, there are not many reviews that I can find online of this.
[47:46] Tommy: Right, uh-huh.
[47:51] Jimi: This was when papers would review things, and that was it. And that was it. And no one has bothered to like pull up the old papers and type them online yet. But most of the reviews I can find praise Lloyd Webber's eclectic score, and it makes me burn on the inside.
[48:11] Tommy: There are so many musical styles in this thing, and nothing against being able to master different musical styles. That's fine. But just because there are 96 crayons in the box doesn't mean you should use all of them. There's no focus to it, and there seems no or very little rhyme or reason as to which song gets what style other than just to vary it up.
[48:37] Jimi: Um, see, this is something that I would say got improved upon as the show developed.
[48:42] Tommy: Yeah.
[48:42] Jimi: Because remember, one of the ones that I had the biggest problem with when I first listened to the original was Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer's air. So that was like my favorite song, dance characters, everything from when I watched it on stage and the film and now. But the original is really, really bad.
[49:02] Tommy: It's awful.
[49:03] Jimi: Like, if I was gonna write a song, I would have written that because it's literally just here's the poem, and I'm saying it in rhythm. Right. To this really, really loose, I don't know, trying to be 1930s style jazz in the back, which just made absolutely no sense.
[49:22] Tommy: But now it's been, it's much more kind of in line with Cats, do you know? I mean, it sounds more akin to like the Jellicle Ball or yeah, more Skimbleshanks, just something like that.
[49:33] Jimi: Synthesizer-y, a little more rocky, would you say?
[49:36] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Exactly, that kind of pop rock 1980s ALW vibe. Um, and it sits nicely into that now, which fits it so much better. But then I think in terms of styles, like obviously to take something like Macavity, which is very, you know, kind of sexy and slinky and you know, snare drum brushed style, which I think fits it because it's being sung by these two kind of sexy cats about a mysterious sexy criminal.
[50:02] Jimi: So I think in terms of style, that fits that.
[50:05] Tommy: Yeah, I think some of them fit. I think it's, I think the things that do kind of jump out, because there are bits I don't like about Cats.
[50:14] Jimi: No way.
[50:15] Tommy: I know, I know, right? I have a really, really lot of beef with the opening of Act Two.
[50:23] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[50:23] Tommy: Which is Moments of Happiness.
[50:26] Jimi: Oh, is that with the old guy?
[50:28] Tommy: Yeah. So it goes like for some reason, and I do have a big problem with this. So you have basically, for Act Two, you have to wait for two songs before you get to feel happy again and then get back into it. Because you've got Moments of Happiness, then Gus, which are two really slow, not, you know, not pacey ballads.
[50:50] Jimi: Yeah, they're not.
[50:50] Tommy: Um, you get into Growltiger, which is, but it's not like welcome back, we're happy to have you back from intermission.
[50:56] Jimi: Right, exactly.
[50:57] Tommy: But so that is like, that's a thing that happened in like GNS days. Like that is operetta when you would come in and it would open with a ballad and a slow song.
[51:01] Jimi: Yeah.
[51:07] Tommy: For some, and I don't, I actually don't really understand why, and I did try to find why. Uh-huh. Um, but no one, I haven't been able to discuss. So again, people, listeners are very good at kind of letting us know this and giving us their knowledge that we don't have. So please fill in our blank. Like, why was that a thing? Why start with a ballad at the, like it makes more sense at least to our contemporary minds to start Act Two with an upbeat, hey, welcome back.
[51:32] Jimi: Exactly, or just something, yeah, something engaging.
[51:35] Tommy: Yeah. Whereas Moments of Happiness, which is a solo operatic ballad that's slow and quite dull, to be honest, because it doesn't really make much sense in the story.
[51:47] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? I want to know why that was that.
[51:51] Tommy: But then we get back into it and I'm fine.
[51:53] Jimi: Do you know what I want to know? This scared the crap out of me when we were watching the film. Macavity.
[52:00] Tommy: It's really scary.
[52:02] Jimi: Well, Macavity is scary, but in Moments of Happiness, Gus the Theatre Cat, the old guy cat.
[52:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[52:07] Jimi: And he's sitting there singing, and this red-eyed, superimposed apparition of a whatever is just like creeping around him, not related to the song at all, and is like, is he gonna kill him or is like he death and he's gonna follow him off, and then he just disappears in the, what the hell was that?
[52:26] Tommy: What the hell is that?
[52:27] Jimi: So that is supposed to be a thing, uh, Fire for Fiddle, the Fiend of the Fell.
[52:33] Tommy: Who's this?
[52:34] Jimi: The part that his greatest part they ever played. Now, that actually doesn't, it doesn't feature in the show. Do you know? I mean, if you watch the stage play, this creepy thing doesn't walk around the back. Clearly, like this is one of my other pet peeves about filmed musicals. Is like, don't you dare use special effects.
[52:46] Tommy: Right.
[52:49] Jimi: How dare you? I know this is a good idea. It admittedly, this video does do it a fair amount. And like it pisses me off in the filmed Into the Woods version, it pisses me off in all sorts of stuff.
[52:58] Tommy: Well, I was saying, oh, yeah, so that's who that is, and that is a very creepy, weird moment in the...
[52:58] Jimi: Are you okay?
[53:04] Tommy: Yeah. You look like a cat right now.
[53:07] Jimi: There's like a hornet flying outside my window, and I'm making sure it's not flying.
[53:12] Tommy: Do you get hot like hornets or just like a wasp?
[53:15] Jimi: No, like a hornet, like can—
[53:15] Tommy: Oh my god.
[53:20] Jimi: So I'm just making sure its nest isn't happening in my window or something.
[53:27] Tommy: The frontiers, that's what I was like to say there.
[53:29] Jimi: The frontiers, that's where you're the cat at the fiat door.
[53:37] Tommy: His name, as I ought to have told you before, he's really Asparagus.
[53:47] Jimi: But that's such a fuss to pronounce that we usually call him just Gus.
[53:56] Tommy: He's cold, very shabby. He's thin as a rake, and he suffers from palsy that makes his paw shake.
[54:09] Jimi: Yet he was in his youth quite the smartest of cats, but no longer a terror to mice or to rats, for he isn't the cat that he was in his prime, though his name was quite famous, he says in his time, and whenever he joins his friends at the club, which takes place at the back of the neighboring pub, he loves to regale them if someone else pays with anecdotes drawn from his palm days, for he once was a star of the highest degree, he has acted with Ernie, he's acted with Tree, and he likes to relate his success on the halls where the gallery once gave him seven cat calls, but his greatest creation, as he loves to tell, was Fire for Fiddle, the Fiend of the Fell.
[55:59] Tommy: This was my favorite part of the Wikipedia article. It's in the production history part. It says, due to the Elliott estate asserting that they write no script and use only the original poems as the text, the musical had no identified plot during the rehearsal process, causing many actors to be confused about what they were actually doing.
[56:18] Jimi: Exactly.
[56:18] Tommy: Which is totally fair.
[56:21] Jimi: Totally fair. And I wonder if that actually was a reason for them to be like, okay, let's work something out here. You have this character, you be this character.
[56:28] Tommy: I wonder that too.
[56:31] Jimi: If they're like, well, you develop your own character.
[56:34] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Because you know what, like that's everyone's favorite bit about Amdram is like, I'm in the chorus, I'm gonna, you know, I had cancer when I was three, and then I flew out to the jungle and lived there for 80 years, and now I'm singing this song about seven and a half cents.
[56:48] Jimi: And that's what's motivating me to march behind Dolly Levi in the brain.
[56:53] Tommy: Exactly.
[56:54] Jimi: Yeah, so I wonder if that's an element. I wonder if, yeah, if you're in the original Broadway cast of Cats, can you let us know the rehearsal process, please? Um, because that would be quite cool, wouldn't it?
[57:05] Tommy: If like the original cast originated their roles and created their roles.
[57:11] Jimi: If they, I bet you they did to an extent. I maybe this is a good transition. So they're reviving Cats.
[57:17] Tommy: So right, so it's, we've had it, we've got it over here.
[57:20] Jimi: Okay, I think as far as I can tell, it's the same production.
[57:22] Tommy: Okay, they keep saying there are new parts, and I don't know.
[57:22] Jimi: There are.
[57:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[57:26] Jimi: So this is where I come over to your side, and I hate Cats.
[57:31] Tommy: Because uh-huh, they have done some stupid, stupid stuff.
[57:36] Jimi: Yeah, like what? They're dogs now? They are all dogs, and still calling it Cats.
[57:42] Tommy: Why?
[57:42] Jimi: Um, no, so they basically, and again, this might all be moot if it comes out in the broader one, but I can't see right, like why it seems like a transit. The one thing that they've done that bugs me and annoys me to high heaven was kind of harks back to what I was talking about earlier about Andrew Lloyd Webber's trying to climb and be contemporary.
[58:06] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[58:07] Jimi: So Andrew Lloyd Webber has destroyed, has obliterated one of the musical's like best things.
[58:16] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[58:16] Jimi: And that is Rum Tum Tugger.
[58:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:19] Jimi: Okay. Now I think even you, as a hater would agree that his song is fun, and that's a fun little role.
[58:25] Tommy: His song is great. He's, it's, I think he's one of, I think all the characters have a lot of definition. I think Rum Tum Tugger is one of the most well-defined characters in the show.
[58:34] Jimi: Um, easy to get with an appropriate song for the character, yeah.
[58:38] Tommy: Completely great. So bye, bye to that, yeah, right. Now Rum Tum Tugger is a teenage kitten who wears like baggy, not jeans but cat version of jeans, a little leopard top, and he raps, Tommy.
[58:59] Jimi: Oh my god, no way he raps.
[59:01] Tommy: Now, this rap is very equivalent to, have you seen Fame the musical?
[59:06] Jimi: Not for a while.
[59:07] Tommy: Okay, very equivalent to we don't need no rich bitch to tell me which fox to use.
[59:14] Jimi: Ah, they—
[59:14] Tommy: Right, like that Fame rap that is so bad.
[59:17] Jimi: Oh my god, it's just as bad as that.
[59:20] Tommy: Are these the pictures of him here wearing like a backwards baseball?
[59:24] Jimi: Yeah, you'll see him. And also they've kind of gone back to what they did in the original days when the other cats would like sing it about them, which I'd never liked.
[59:37] Tommy: I like it when the cats sang about themselves, yeah.
[59:39] Jimi: Which again was something that kind of came in later, and it just shows that Andrew Lloyd Webber's has no concept of it.
[59:45] Jimi: It's like so out of touch.
[59:47] Tommy: Like completely.
[59:48] Jimi: It's like here let's let's pander to our invented demographic.
[59:54] Tommy: Right, exactly.
[59:56] Jimi: I'm only back, I'm like not only decisions, never come out to control because I won't listen. I'm a kid. The show is me. And then it's asking. I'm running the streets and see me to see me this one. I'm a special. You give me a bathroom. I'm not a peasant. You give me the biggest house now south. I'm a smoker flat line, a praticity fact. Forget the power on a LC.
[1:00:24] Tommy: It's like a, but so here, this is one thing I've wondered about cats too. There's something, now that I know all about pantomime, something very panto about the existence of cats. I was thinking I was thinking about this and I was like, oh like maybe it is a British American divide or something like that. Like this is just more part of what your performance art is than what American performance art is.
[1:00:45] Jimi: I mean, it definitely there is an element of that.
[1:00:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:00:48] Jimi: There is that sense of spectacle. Spectacle, the audience involvement, whether it's like explicit involvement or just being breaking the fourth wall.
[1:00:57] Tommy: Right.
[1:00:58] Jimi: Like there's I can I can see in like not, you know, kind of a vapid plot all about the characters and the individual episodic moments.
[1:01:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:01:06] Jimi: And like cutesy ballad.
[1:01:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:08] Jimi: Cutzy ballad.
[1:01:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:09] Jimi: Dance, dance, dance.
[1:01:11] Tommy: Yeah, I I think there's probably an element of that. And I think, well, I don't know. It's success in the UK.
[1:01:16] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:01:17] Tommy: Probably helped its success in the States because maybe in a similar Hamilton way.
[1:01:23] Jimi: Right.
[1:01:24] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? Uh everyone kind of knew. I know it's kind of pre-internet days, so.
[1:01:27] Jimi: Yeah, but it's still like that is where I think the Andrew Lloyd Weber marketing machine came in.
[1:01:31] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:32] Jimi: They somehow get that idea to transfer. But so um on the topic of the revival in the marketing machine.
[1:01:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:40] Jimi: As is the case in our Broadway.com day and age, there's uh I think it's called What's New Pussycat? The backstage, like Oh, is this the Broadway.com?
[1:01:49] Tommy: It's the Broadway.com vlogger, and it's by the guy who's playing Rum Tum Tugger, who's beautiful.
[1:01:54] Jimi: Yeah, really handsome. But have you watched any of these?
[1:01:57] Tommy: I've watched a couple. I haven't watched the latest one.
[1:02:00] Jimi: Maybe I'm just reading this into it, but every once in a while they'll be interviewing, you know, one of the actors or actresses, or they'll be talking about it, and they'll be like, Yep, we're doing cats. This is my life. Isn't this ridiculous? Help me. Like every once in a while, I see like this flicker of something like this is this is why am I here.
[1:02:25] Tommy: But I I think in this day and age, that that makes a lot of sense. I don't think it should have been revived. I just I don't understand why it was. I don't think it's gonna do well. I can't imagine it doing well.
[1:02:36] Jimi: Uh you think it's gonna it's doing alright over here, mate. Like, I mean it's not it's not blowing up as much as.
[1:02:43] Tommy: But it's not competing with Hamilton and Great Comet and Anastasia and Hamilton and but maybe that's the thing because people they're calling it let the memory live again. Maybe you're gonna get all the nostalgia.
[1:02:58] Jimi: I'm gonna say that. What you know, and you're if you're gonna see one Broadway show, maybe those people are gonna be like, Oh, I wanna relive my memories, and then go and they get smashed off the face by this new bloody Rum Tum Tugger.
[1:03:07] Tommy: Uh anyway. I mean, the rest of it, at least based on these Broadway.com backstage tours, the set looks the same, the cast looks the same, the costumes look the same, it looks like like that's the thing.
[1:03:17] Jimi: Mostly a remount. Again, that uh really annoyed me because when so when it was first announced that it was being revived, I actually got like weirdly excited about it. Because I was like, Oh gosh, I wonder what cats would look like in a 21st century setting. Like, what could you do with this? You could re-orchestrate it, you could you know, redo a lot of the songs, yeah, massively change up the set. Think of all the effects that you could use, you know.
[1:03:42] Tommy: I mean, and that's again, like that's not the kind of thing that I'm into as a director, but as an opportunity for people who are into that, I was like, God, wow, this is so great. The same way they did with like the revival of Lay Miz, like, which was amazing.
[1:03:55] Jimi: And oh my god, they went to town on that revival. That was so great.
[1:03:57] Tommy: That was amazing. That's what they should have done.
[1:04:01] Jimi: Yeah, but they've not they've just done it again, and that this is what makes me so angry. This is what makes me so angry, is that I'm like, you what a waste, you're just doing this for money. Like, you are literally doing there's no craft in what you are doing.
[1:04:14] Tommy: Yeah, you're doing this for money, and I will happily have this argument with Mr. Lloyd Webber himself, because I would love to s for him to tell me why in this day and age, with all of his money, that there would be any reason and any call for for not reviving it. He's just doing it for more money.
[1:04:31] Jimi: I mean, the the benefits I see, and this is where like these are the things, these are the reasons I don't in like I will never 100% pish posh cats, is because as an existence, it does a bunch of great things. Like two-thirds of the cats that cast, two-thirds of the cats cast, um, are new to Broadway faces. Like they are they are getting a very young cast of dancers, which is not the sort of thing that you know ends up on Broadway nowadays, and so like to pay these people's bills and get them on stage and get them a credit and you know in a pretty legitimate production. That's great. But as an artistic endeavor, it's bullshit.
[1:05:14] Tommy: Completely.
[1:05:14] Jimi: And uh but the thing is it's like so. You were saying about that the the cast being a bit like haha or dang cats. Yeah, they I don't blame them because if I was doing the old production, I'd be like, why is this still like this? Yeah, do you know what I mean?
[1:05:27] Tommy: Yeah, it's the reason why I think Phantom needs to close for at least three months and they redo everything. Like, why why is it still the same? Like, I I don't get it.
[1:05:36] Jimi: I don't get it. So they're obviously being like this is cheesy as hell.
[1:05:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:42] Jimi: Because it it is now, and I complet I completely agree. I love it in the context of what it is, the old version, but now I'm ready for something new. And it it seems so strange, at least as you've said, if they've been, you know, over however many decades revising and rewriting and changing and fixing, why you know, go whole hog? Like you can do that.
[1:06:03] Tommy: Like the reorchestrated lame is Reorc Street Lame is you can re-orchestre cats for goddamn it.
[1:06:08] Jimi: This is the thing that I loved. I would want that memory to live again, but I would want to see it with my 21st century glasses.
[1:06:15] Tommy: The memory reborn.
[1:06:17] Jimi: Yes, exactly. I want to it's gone up to the heavyside lair and it has been reborn as a new cat.
[1:06:24] Tommy: It's ridiculous.
[1:06:25] Jimi: To use a metaphor from the show, it's all ridiculous imagery. Then the escalator descends from the sky.
[1:06:32] Tommy: Like, I think, as far as I can tell, they're keeping that bloody staircase.
[1:06:36] Jimi: It's like that is a staircase that descends from the fly and goes back up again. If we can make her magically fly away, we make Mary Poppins magically fly away. Mary Poppins, Spider-Man, chang bang. Like there's so many things that fly out over the audience. Just do that.
[1:06:52] Tommy: Just do that.
[1:06:52] Jimi: Like take that tire that they're standing on and take it out. Clearly, there's no like we we are not trying to hold back the spectacle with this show.
[1:07:00] Tommy: No, and that's the thing is like for this audience, you need to add more. You need to lather it on. Because that, like, for this contemporary audience, that's the only thing that they're gonna latch on to.
[1:07:11] Jimi: Which is again, that's right. Like, we're talking about like obviously from like Spongebob, where we said that some of the projection stuff that they did was sensational. Do that.
[1:07:19] Tommy: Projection.
[1:07:21] Jimi: That's actually really easy to mount if you do it well. Like, but no, it doesn't look like it looked like it's gonna be the like they always this is in a bunch of the documentaries I point at, uh or I've seen, they talk about the the trunk of the car that's in the set, the boot.
[1:07:36] Tommy: Mm-hmm.
[1:07:37] Jimi: Well done, thank you. And that the license plate, the the license plate, at least in the film, says TSE one, which I assume is TS Elliott one, but in all the subsequent productions, it has the set designer's initials on it, and the number is the number of sets he has made that look exactly like that.
[1:07:56] Tommy: Really?
[1:07:57] Jimi: And on this revival, it's his initials and the number 70. And that is painful to me.
[1:08:04] Tommy: That is so bad.
[1:08:05] Jimi: Where's like where's the fun in that? Right? If you the the thing is, is like, so you're an actor on Broadway, say you've been in Wicked the whole time it's been on, right? That's great. You know, I mean, you get used to your track, because you know that I'm an actor, that's how I'm supposed to do. If I'm a designer, yeah, I do not expect to have to rehash and rehash and rehash. That is not what my job is.
[1:08:23] Tommy: Yeah, and it's it's not like cats takes place in a junkyard, that's about it. Like, there's not a lot of explicit set design requirements for this show.
[1:08:34] Jimi: Right.
[1:08:34] Tommy: The things need to be big.
[1:08:36] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:08:36] Tommy: Things need to be big. And even then, that's not even actually like a requirement. You could do this in a no, it is because the cats are smaller. But like you could do whatever. You could do whatever with this set. You could do whatever with this set. You could you could make it a cityscape. Make it a city, do it on a rooftop, do it in a countryside, like you know, or just do it in a slightly different junkyard. And like the the junk, I think's fine, and again, at the original, they used it to good effect, right? With all these like fun props, and then the um peaks in the polycle battle, has that made it with their carbon button. That's that's great. That's a lot of good fun. You know, look at it again. If they can reinvent the set for Greece, they can reinvent the set for cats.
[1:09:23] Jimi: I can smile at the things.
[1:09:28] Tommy: I must be a job then.
[1:09:34] Jimi: I remember the time I knew what happens.
[1:09:44] Tommy: Let the men relive again.
[1:09:52] Jimi: I don't know.
[1:09:53] Tommy: So, um, right, but cats. It used to be great, now it's awful.
[1:09:57] Jimi: Oh, they're making a film of it.
[1:09:59] Tommy: Did you know that?
[1:10:00] Jimi: Really?
[1:10:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:01] Jimi: Guess who's directing it?
[1:10:02] Tommy: Um Andrew Lloyd Weber himself.
[1:10:06] Jimi: Tom Hooper.
[1:10:07] Tommy: Tom Hooper. The director of the Lamez Musical film, is directing cats, the musical.
[1:10:15] Jimi: Now, even like this is me. This is cat's trash being like, this should not happen. This should not happen.
[1:10:21] Tommy: Have they released any information on it?
[1:10:22] Jimi: Absolutely not. Just that he's on board to do it, and he would like uh an actress called Suki Waterhouse to start.
[1:10:29] Tommy: I don't know who that is.
[1:10:31] Jimi: I didn't know who that was either. Apparently she's like huge.
[1:10:34] Tommy: Oh, she was in Pride and Purchasing Zombies.
[1:10:36] Jimi: Okay.
[1:10:39] Tommy: Completely. She was in Insurgent, which is I think the second of the Divergent.
[1:10:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:10:44] Tommy: Is that the newest one?
[1:10:45] Jimi: Don't know.
[1:10:45] Tommy: One of them.
[1:10:46] Jimi: Love Rosie.
[1:10:47] Tommy: Don't know what that is.
[1:10:48] Jimi: Um, she's an abfab the movie, but who isn't? Uh and then she's kind of set to be in a few more. But he wants apparently Tom Hooper wants her. And I'm like, I'm sorry, mate, you wanted Taylor Swift. Get out, in my opinion.
[1:11:02] Tommy: Like, can I make a long shot prediction?
[1:11:05] Jimi: Do it.
[1:11:06] Tommy: 3D animated cartoon.
[1:11:08] Jimi: With Tom Hooper, though, that isn't his style, mate.
[1:11:11] Tommy: I mean, it's it's this like cats is a kid's franchise nowadays.
[1:11:15] Jimi: Right, but I don't think I think he's gonna try and just like with people grit it up.
[1:11:19] Tommy: That's gonna be so weird.
[1:11:22] Jimi: I know.
[1:11:22] Tommy: Like But like a 3D animated wouldn't work because the thing is it's like they're not cats, they're people, they're gelical cats with like special cats that look like people.
[1:11:31] Jimi: Yeah, in the post-apocalyptic wasteland that is exactly, but like I d I don't think that would work. I just don't I think it would need to be people.
[1:11:40] Tommy: I think I don't I don't think it's gonna work at all.
[1:11:43] Jimi: Absolutely, like why are they doing it? There are so many other film musicals that haven't been turned into films that should. Like, obviously they've just announced Wicked, but you know, in the Heights is still in talks. Like, why is nobody picked that up? Someone like Tom Hooper picked that up. That's much better.
[1:11:56] Tommy: Because the really useful group is about maintaining the Android Warner brand. They're just I was just like, how much money have they offered him to do this? Because this is his name that will be attached to this.
[1:12:07] Jimi: Poor choice.
[1:12:09] Tommy: It's really poor.
[1:12:10] Jimi: Macavate's a mystery cat. He's called the hidden paw. For he's a master criminal who can defy the law. He's the powerful mentor Scotland Yard. The flying squad's despair. But when they reach the scene of crime, McCafferty's not there.
[1:12:40] Tommy: So it's when you mentioned Wikipedia.
[1:12:42] Jimi: Right.
[1:12:43] Tommy: I've never seen a more detailed Wikipedia for any show, any musical that other than cats.
[1:12:50] Jimi: They I enjoy that they don't list any critical reception.
[1:12:54] Tommy: Right.
[1:12:55] Jimi: Very true. Which, as someone who wrote the style guide for how to write about musicals on Wikipedia. That's like a like you should include a critical reception part.
[1:13:05] Tommy: It's right.
[1:13:05] Jimi: Right, exactly. But nope.
[1:13:07] Tommy: No.
[1:13:08] Jimi: Um, but there is so much information.
[1:13:11] Tommy: Oh, yeah.
[1:13:11] Jimi: There's like in that like Grisabella page, there's a list of every single actress in the world who has ever played her.
[1:13:18] Tommy: That is serious cats.
[1:13:20] Jimi: No, that is the cat's trash that I am not. I cannot do that. I did that for any part. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Like that is that's nuts.
[1:13:27] Tommy: Anyway, one of the things that I love in the film is obviously with Elaine Page.
[1:13:32] Jimi: Little a little Elaine. You have to love Elaine.
[1:13:34] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:13:35] Jimi: She's a she's a British National Treasure. She she's our Sethetsky. Do you know what I mean?
[1:13:38] Tommy: And in the sense that she has a radio channel about musical theatre.
[1:13:43] Jimi: She got lucky. She, I mean, it wasn't supposed to be Judy Dench.
[1:13:46] Tommy: Judy Dench.
[1:13:47] Jimi: What broke her actor or something?
[1:13:49] Tommy: I think she tore her Achilles.
[1:13:50] Jimi: Right, okay. Basically, yeah, like broke her leg or got amputated, something like that.
[1:13:55] Tommy: Yeah, she doesn't have a foot anymore.
[1:13:56] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. But she's got a tattoo. Have you seen that?
[1:13:59] Tommy: Judy Dench?
[1:14:00] Jimi: Judy Dench has a statue on her wrist saying Carp DM.
[1:14:03] Tommy: Good for you, Judy Dench.
[1:14:05] Jimi: Why? Anyway, um Elaine Page.
[1:14:07] Tommy: Elaine Page.
[1:14:08] Jimi: So she does this amazing thing, and I'm sure you loved it too. Because it's just so like Lady D.Va.
[1:14:14] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:14:14] Jimi: Um in memory at the big crescendo. She doesn't say any words, she just says, Tajala. Do you know what I mean?
[1:14:21] Tommy: It's great.
[1:14:23] Jimi: It's so great because it's awful. But in a great look diva way.
[1:14:27] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:14:28] Jimi: I think Elaine. I think Elaine Page is great. I'd I I mean, to be honest, I'm not the biggest fan.
[1:14:34] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:14:35] Jimi: She's she's wonderful in the radio because she's just so fun to listen to. I take it you you can't ever well, you probably could like on digital radio.
[1:14:42] Jimi: I could look it up. I feel like I've heard maybe one or two bits of her on some YouTube things, but never a full radio. She's so cute, and like she'll drop in these little tidbits and stuff. But like when you stack her up against the big guns, she doesn't sail up there, does she?
[1:14:59] Tommy: No.
[1:15:00] Jimi: But I mean, I don't think there are a lot of British born musical theatre divas.
[1:15:07] Tommy: Uh, maybe this is my Amerocentric.
[1:15:10] Jimi: I think that's it, because I can think of a few.
[1:15:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:15:13] Jimi: Like who?
[1:15:14] Tommy: Well, Ruthie Henshall.
[1:15:16] Jimi: Joe Ruthie Henshall?
[1:15:17] Tommy: Nope.
[1:15:18] Jimi: This is so it's my American.
[1:15:20] Tommy: Oh my god, right, okay, a hundred percent.
[1:15:21] Jimi: So like Ruthie Henshall is our like she's almost like our Sutton Foster.
[1:15:27] Tommy: Okay.
[1:15:28] Jimi: But she's older.
[1:15:30] Tommy: Okay.
[1:15:30] Jimi: Not like old, older. I'm trying to, well, what has she been in that I would know her from?
[1:15:34] Tommy: Well, she was at have you seen Hey Mr. Producer?
[1:15:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:38] Tommy: So she's in that.
[1:15:40] Jimi: Okay. How well do you know it?
[1:15:41] Tommy: Not very.
[1:15:42] Jimi: Oh, okay. Um, because I was gonna say she plays Tessie Tura in the gypsy section of that. Um, she also does, uh, like she was a really famous Fantine.
[1:15:55] Tommy: Okay.
[1:15:55] Jimi: I don't think she originated it in the UK, but she was like a significant one. Uh-huh. And just like Chicago, you know what I mean? She's done those, right?
[1:16:04] Tommy: She was an amazing, I think she might have, uh, I think she might have originated Roxy.
[1:16:09] Jimi: In the West End.
[1:16:11] Tommy: In the West End.
[1:16:12] Jimi: And then we've also got Jenna Russell. Do you know her?
[1:16:14] Tommy: See, and I'm gonna go Carol.
[1:16:19] Jimi: Do you know who I'm talking about?
[1:16:20] Tommy: Channing?
[1:16:21] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:16:22] Tommy: Bet.
[1:16:24] Jimi: Oh right, I see what you mean.
[1:16:25] Tommy: Yeah, okay.
[1:16:26] Jimi: And it's, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:16:27] Tommy: I know, but I'm just like, but that is, that I would say that is the Americ and actually, do you know what? This is really interesting. Um, and I'm gonna call her out she won't like this, but it doesn't matter.
[1:16:36] Jimi: Um, what video was it?
[1:16:38] Tommy: What have you done recently?
[1:16:39] Jimi: Not much.
[1:16:40] Tommy: Um, an In the Heights show of the week that was okay but stupid.
[1:16:44] Jimi: Um, I had, it was one of the Tony stuff, I had the live one.
[1:16:49] Tommy: It was In the Heights, it was In the Heights, and you said the thing about it.
[1:16:54] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:16:55] Tommy: This is our art form.
[1:16:56] Jimi: It's an American musical, right?
[1:16:57] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:16:58] Jimi: Now I agree with you because the musical as we know it started in America.
[1:17:03] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:17:03] Jimi: It just did. Like it just did. I understand that GNS is a thing, but that's operetta, that came from opera.
[1:17:09] Tommy: Right.
[1:17:09] Jimi: And it's kind of the halfway point between musical theatre, but the musical, the musical musical.
[1:17:15] Tommy: It's called the American comedy.
[1:17:18] Jimi: Yeah. Like the, depending upon who you talk to, the first one was called Oklahoma, which is a state.
[1:17:24] Tommy: Right, exactly.
[1:17:25] Jimi: But in many ways it was also Showboat. It was also the stemming straight out of vaudeville.
[1:17:30] Tommy: Right, and it's, it's not a judgment thing, it's just...
[1:17:30] Jimi: No, exactly. I give you that.
[1:17:38] Tommy: So I think that is, you know, why a lot of these things are American-centric.
[1:17:42] Jimi: Right.
[1:17:43] Tommy: And even in the sense that, you know, we know them all over here, all those divas. But I would say, I would say learn a bit some of these because like these people, these women are so amazingly talented.
[1:17:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:17:56] Tommy: And really, I don't know, kind of deserve it, deserve more.
[1:18:00] Jimi: And I fully acknowledge my American. And while it may have been the American musical, it is no longer.
[1:18:08] Tommy: Like this is now a global art form.
[1:18:10] Jimi: And really, maybe to bring it back, a lot and thanks to Andrew Lloyd Webber's and the Really Useful Group.
[1:18:16] Tommy: I know. And that's the thing is like we can't hate them because it's kind of like they're our sponsors, do you know?
[1:18:21] Jimi: Like we wouldn't be taught, we wouldn't have this podcast.
[1:18:24] Tommy: And we do, we have to owe a lot to it, but at the same time, oh well, it's like, why can't we have a...
[1:18:24] Jimi: I don't want to, I want a better sponsor?
[1:18:34] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:18:34] Jimi: And we all say, oh well.
[1:18:40] Tommy: I can't, something has magic compassed to stop these.
[1:19:19] Jimi: So what did they do? If Andrew Lloyd Webber hadn't existed.
[1:19:24] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:19:25] Jimi: Right. Musical theater would have died.
[1:19:27] Tommy: Do you think it would have died? Or do you just think it wouldn't be as big?
[1:19:31] Jimi: I think it would have died. I think, and it's a sad topic, and it's one I've danced around for a lot of musical theater videos that I can't quite get into the right words, but in the time when Cats came out, and in Stephen Sondheim's heyday, there wasn't a lot of other popular or good musical theater.
[1:19:50] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:19:51] Jimi: And I would wager that is 100% caused by the AIDS crisis.
[1:19:59] Tommy: Because musical theater and like the creation of musical theater rode on the coattails of gay culture.
[1:20:07] Jimi: And like the people who worked in musical theater were homosexual men, both writing it and performing in it, by and large. Again, you're gonna get a lot of people telling you that's not true.
[1:20:19] Tommy: Completely true.
[1:20:20] Jimi: You know, this is why it's, I haven't made a video about it, because it is definitely more nuanced than that.
[1:20:26] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:20:26] Jimi: But like it's very sad, but they all died. And we lost a generation of musical theater writers and musical theater performers with the AIDS epidemic.
[1:20:41] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:20:41] Jimi: And we are, I like legitimately think the 70s, the 80s and 90s, as we've talked about, you know, maybe not so much some of the hair of the 70s and that sort of stuff, the kind of the revolution part of this. If you look at the 80s and the 90s of musical theater, and we've talked about it, it's the dark ages.
[1:21:00] Tommy: Like there's, they were struggling to find people to nominate for best musical and talking about whether or not there should be nominated for best musical or best revival because there's not enough in the category.
[1:21:10] Jimi: I think because there just weren't the authors out there.
[1:21:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:13] Jimi: So it kind of kept it afloat almost.
[1:21:16] Tommy: Yeah, kept it afloat.
[1:21:17] Jimi: Andrew Lloyd Webber's and Sondheim, like that, you know.
[1:21:20] Tommy: Not that Sondheim would have done more poorly had there been other people around, but I do think Lloyd Webber may have if there were other Sondheims around.
[1:21:29] Jimi: Yeah, because that's the thing is like they're all, they're British exports.
[1:21:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:34] Jimi: And why would you export something unless you had a dearth?
[1:21:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:38] Jimi: That makes sense.
[1:21:38] Tommy: I never thought about it like that before, but that does make sense.
[1:21:41] Jimi: Like I think it is very, whether it is specifically the AIDS crisis or just kind of the general lull in musical theater of the 80s and 90s.
[1:21:51] Tommy: But I think there was a vacuum to be filled.
[1:21:54] Jimi: Yeah, and but I think like the AIDS crisis totally changed New York.
[1:22:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:22:00] Jimi: Like it, that was the thing that spun it around to be this new thing. Do you know what I mean?
[1:22:06] Tommy: Like post-Giuliani New York is a new beast.
[1:22:06] Jimi: And Andrew Lloyd Webber fits really nicely into that beast.
[1:22:14] Tommy: I mean, so do here does not.
[1:22:16] Jimi: So do a lot of the other musicals we've talked about.
[1:22:19] Tommy: Like post-Giuliani New York, like the cleaning and sanitization of the Great White Way, Broadway, is a lot to do with like Disney's presence on Broadway.
[1:22:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:22:31] Tommy: You know, you don't want to walk your family past all of these XXX bookstores to come see The Lion King.
[1:22:37] Jimi: Right.
[1:22:38] Tommy: And they're closed a lot for that reason.
[1:22:40] Jimi: Like a family New York.
[1:22:42] Tommy: To go see a family musical, yeah.
[1:22:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:22:50] Tommy: I mean, it's like let's all go together.
[1:22:51] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:22:52] Tommy: Either a raunchy showgirl musical or hair or, you know, family theater.
[1:22:58] Jimi: The family musical is Cats, is The Lion King, is all these Disney musicals.
[1:23:04] Tommy: Is even things like, I would say Evita, some of the other Lloyd Webber stuff.
[1:23:08] Jimi: Oh, okay.
[1:23:09] Tommy: I honestly, any Andrew Lloyd Webber's show, Andrew Lloyd Webber's has not done a deep show.
[1:23:14] Jimi: No.
[1:23:15] Tommy: Like he hasn't.
[1:23:15] Jimi: And I'm not saying that that means they're all bad.
[1:23:17] Tommy: Like, I guess we've said this before together.
[1:23:19] Jimi: Do we like Jesus Christ Superstar?
[1:23:21] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:23:21] Jimi: I mean, we like musical theater, which is perhaps one of the fluffiest pieces of arts in existence.
[1:23:27] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:23:28] Jimi: Well, you know, we would argue.
[1:23:31] Tommy: But exactly.
[1:23:32] Jimi: Yeah, I think he does completely fit that.
[1:23:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:23:36] Jimi: But I've never really thought about that before till now, but that makes, that does make a lot of sense.
[1:23:40] Tommy: Yeah, like it's definitely a very, you know, he found the perfect storm, happened to get some good marketing gurus, and then Cats got popular.
[1:23:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:23:52] Tommy: And then he completely keeps flushing his money away on School of Rock.
[1:23:56] Jimi: I know.
[1:23:56] Tommy: And the revival.
[1:23:58] Jimi: I know. It's, uh, yeah, a lot of people love School of Rock.
[1:23:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:23:58] Jimi: A lot of people, but I'm like, do they love it because of Alex Brightman? Or do they love it because they liked the movie?
[1:24:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24:10] Jimi: But then I, I don't know.
[1:24:11] Tommy: Because I, again, I've still not seen it, I've not even listened to it.
[1:24:14] Jimi: I'm gonna put my hands up and say it, but I don't want to.
[1:24:16] Tommy: Would you love it because of the movie, or would you be so annoyed at it because, I mean, it's almost like with like the revival of Cats, like it's, it's not a revival.
[1:24:25] Jimi: It's just the same.
[1:24:26] Tommy: And I'm like, uh, that, that annoys me.
[1:24:28] Jimi: Yeah, like let's do, we, I think there was a time in Broadway.
[1:24:33] Tommy: I would, I would generalize it to be art, but my world actually isn't big enough to speak authoritatively on that.
[1:24:39] Jimi: But I think there was a time in Broadway where we could put our nostalgia glasses on and hearken back to the good old days and do a, you know, a hoofer like let's do a tap dance show.
[1:24:51] Tommy: Yeah, and I think that time was the late 90s, the early 2000s, like let's remember the golden days.
[1:24:58] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:58] Tommy: I think that time is past.
[1:25:00] Jimi: Even something like Shuffle Along, which is what that was, as much as it was a great spectacle and so fun.
[1:25:06] Tommy: What Shuffle Along, I think was, uh, when it got revived, was almost a political statement and a very important and necessary political statement.
[1:25:15] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:25:15] Tommy: It wasn't, uh, it would never marketed well, uh, but not, yeah, it wasn't really as like come along and have a lot of fun.
[1:25:22] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, that's what it is, but it to the point where it was like let's represent these people on Broadway.
[1:25:28] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:25:29] Jimi: Like you look at even the most like white bread of revivals, like She Loves Me.
[1:25:34] Tommy: Right.
[1:25:34] Jimi: And it's still, you know, She Loves Me is not Hello Dolly.
[1:25:37] Tommy: She Loves Me still has like, still has some darker parts.
[1:25:41] Jimi: And it's, it's very, it's very tongue-in-cheek.
[1:25:43] Tommy: Yeah, it's, it's very tongue-in-cheek.
[1:25:45] Jimi: It very much survives also on its headlining roles.
[1:25:50] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[1:25:51] Jimi: Like it's not gonna last beyond Laura and Zach.
[1:25:55] Tommy: No, I mean they, I think they were a limited run the moment they opened.
[1:25:58] Jimi: Yeah, so the baby signal to the heavy side.
[1:26:23] Tommy: Oh dear.
[1:26:24] Jimi: Well that was good.
[1:26:25] Tommy: That was great.
[1:26:26] Jimi: That was a success.
[1:26:26] Tommy: And it's funny because even though I love Cats with me as Cats Trash.
[1:26:34] Jimi: Cats at the moment.
[1:26:35] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:26:35] Jimi: I don't like so, uh, you know, it's all kind of balanced out.
[1:26:38] Tommy: It all, it all balances out.
[1:26:39] Jimi: Well I feel I didn't put across there was my geeky knowledge of Cats.
[1:26:42] Tommy: So if anyone wants to quiz me, I'm ready.
[1:26:46] Jimi: I'm ready for you.
[1:26:47] Tommy: Send Jimi your most difficult Cats quiz.
[1:26:50] Jimi: Send us both your most difficult Cats quiz, and we'll see how poorly I do and how well.
[1:26:55] Tommy: And actually, do you know what? See if you're ever like a pub quiz person and you want a musical theater round and you're looking for some really tough questions, go to Cats because there's so much there that no one will know about.
[1:27:06] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[1:27:10] Tommy: So Jimi.
[1:27:12] Jimi: Yes, Mr. T.
[1:27:13] Tommy: I'm really proud of this question. I think we tried really hard.
[1:27:21] Jimi: We used our brains, we dug into the really recesses of our deep trivia knowledge.
[1:27:27] Tommy: Actually, we put one of the first lyrics from the title song of this musical through a, uh, bad translator online.
[1:27:36] Jimi: You know, like throws we did through a bunch of languages to totally mangle it.
[1:27:41] Tommy: Yeah, we've sold out, folks. Sorry, it had to happen.
[1:27:44] Jimi: And, uh, here is, um, one of the first lyrics from the title song of the musical we're doing next time.
[1:27:50] Tommy: Oh wow, I can't wait to hear it.
[1:27:51] Jimi: Are you ready?
[1:27:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:27:53] Jimi: Condone violence in the cloud from any location monitoring.
[1:27:59] Tommy: Condone violence in the cloud.
[1:28:02] Jimi: It doesn't really rhyme.
[1:28:03] Tommy: Kind of loses some of the meter, doesn't it?
[1:28:05] Jimi: Yeah, it's just, it's like a really progressive kind of idea ideology that they're going for there, I think.
[1:28:11] Tommy: Um, so yeah, repeat that for us, Tommy.
[1:28:14] Jimi: Uh, condone violence in the cloud from any location monitoring.
[1:28:19] Tommy: Interesting.
[1:28:21] Jimi: What could that be?
[1:28:22] Tommy: Who knows?
[1:28:24] Jimi: Who knows?
[1:28:25] Tommy: You'll know next time.
[1:28:26] Jimi: Yes, you will.
[1:28:29] Tommy: See you then.
[1:28:30] Jimi: See you then.
[1:28:43] Tommy: So a twonk, I think is like a modern gay slang for like an older twink.
[1:28:49] Jimi: Oh man, we live in different towns.
[1:28:54] Tommy: I know it's an Americanism, eh?
[1:28:54] Jimi: I know it's an Americanism.
[1:28:55] Tommy: Oh, right.
[1:28:55] Jimi: I would never use the word I think in that sentence.
[1:28:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:28:59] Jimi: I would be like, oh, that twonk walking by on the street.
[1:29:01] Tommy: This is a phrase I use in my everyday vernacular.
[1:29:04] Jimi: Oh wait, really?
[1:29:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:29:05] Jimi: No, wait.
[1:29:06] Tommy: Well, I'm confused.
[1:29:07] Jimi: What are you saying?
[1:29:08] Tommy: I'm, I like you're like, I think this is what a twonk is.
[1:29:11] Jimi: And I'm like, oh yes, I refer to people walking by on the street as twonks when I'm talking with my friends.
[1:29:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:29:16] Jimi: Oh.
[1:29:16] Tommy: So it's the second, that's the second time I've heard that word.
[1:29:19] Jimi: Really?
[1:29:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:29:20] Jimi: That's a, that's a new gay word to me.
[1:29:22] Tommy: I do live in a gay boyhood.
[1:29:24] Jimi: Like, this is...
[1:29:25] Tommy: That's true.
[1:29:25] Jimi: I don't.
[1:29:29] Tommy: Um, yeah.
[1:29:30] Jimi: So there you go.
[1:29:31] Tommy: Teach me, teach me your ways.
[1:29:33] Jimi: Twunk.
[1:29:33] Tommy: Someone who used to be a twink.
[1:29:35] Jimi: Twink twink twonk.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
