Today we're chatting about Stephen Sondheim and our top FIVE favorite Stephen Sondheim Musicals! What do you think our number one will be? Give a listen to find out... Read More
From the show: The Dear Friends Podcast
Featured Artists
Featured Shows
About
Today we're chatting about Stephen Sondheim and our top FIVE favorite Stephen Sondheim Musicals! What do you think our number one will be? Give a listen to find out.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Christi Esterle: Without further ado, the Dear Friends podcast.
[0:04] Emily Clark: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family.
[0:09] Jess McAnally: Dear friends.
[0:11] Christi Esterle: They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom.
[0:18] Jess McAnally: And cynical world.
[0:23] Christi Esterle: Dear friends.
[0:25] Emily Clark: Hi, I'm dear friend Emily.
[0:27] Christi Esterle: I'm dearer friend Christy.
[0:29] Jess McAnally: And I'm dearest friend Jess.
[0:30] Christi Esterle: And welcome to Dear Friends, a write-in advice podcast for the musical minded. And today we've got a very interesting write-in.
[0:38] Jess McAnally: Are you guys ready?
[0:38] Emily Clark: Oh my gosh, I'm so excited.
[0:40] Christi Esterle: I'm gonna do it.
[0:41] Jess McAnally: Okay, okay. So this is from Ambrose Kemper, who wrote in saying, Dear friends, what are your five favorite Sondheim musicals?
[0:51] Emily Clark: Good question. It's like asking like which one of my children do I love the most.
[0:58] Christi Esterle: Yes.
[0:59] Jess McAnally: Okay, so we gotta set some ground rules here. Are we talking are we including lyrics only or is it just full scores?
[1:06] Emily Clark: I will say in mine, I did not include lyrics only. So I did not include the gypsies in the West Side stories and do I hear a waltzes, though I doubt the latter would have made my list anyway.
[1:18] Christi Esterle: Okay, so pure Sondheim.
[1:20] Emily Clark: Alright, score and lyrics.
[1:22] Jess McAnally: Yes, yes. Do you want to start Emily?
[1:26] Emily Clark: Are we going five to one or one to five?
[1:28] Jess McAnally: Five to one. We're going from worst to best.
[1:31] Emily Clark: Okay, so um let's let me preface this by saying this is somewhat of a nebulous list. Um it has changed at various points in my life. It has changed at various points in my life. This is where we are with me, you know, in a year where I'll be turning 40. So do with that what you will. Um, I also think when you do a Sondheim show, I think sometimes that can bump something up. So I don't know. So um anyway, okay. So my top five. Um my number five, I think would have to be Merrily We Roll Along. Um it is a flawed show, um, but it holds a really special place in my heart. I did it when I was young. I did it. It was the first musical I did right after college with a bunch of old high school friends who were um theater kids, and we all put on a production.
Um, it took me like 10 years after doing that show to even get the joke of "collabor him collabor me," that thing. Um it took me a really, really long time to get that joke. Um, anyway, but I love Merrily. I think it resonates more the older you get, and um, yeah, I love it. I think the redo version, the remake, the revival version that I guess started in La Jolla, I think, and went to off Broadway is the superior version, um, in my opinion. So not to drive into a tangent. Have you ever listened to the Michael Arden Adam Walker, Wayne Brady version? Um they did an interesting thing. They had like the tether concept from uh the Spring Awakening revival, Death West revival, where they had their younger selves kind of watching them as they mess up and they slowly switch places, and then the adult tethers watch the younger tethers.
It was an interesting, interesting idea. I think it was very well executed, and it was very close to being the Broadway revival, and then some producers backed out. Um but Wayne Brady was uh Frank, or no, he was Charlie, and that was um interesting choices. I bet he was really good at doing "Franklin Shepard, Inc." though. He nailed it. Um but he did mess up some. There's one bootleg, and the one bootleg is the one where Wayne Brady messes up um the last number. Yeah, it's um OF. I was gonna say something and it went away from me. Um, I know what I was gonna say. Um it's also a great show to do. Um I've seen it in colleges, I've seen a couple community regional theater productions in LA. It works so well with a small ensemble of really good people who can play multiple roles, and it works really well in a black box. Um, yeah, uh I love it. It holds a special place in my heart. Um, and it has one of the best overtures ever written in a Broadway musical.
[4:24] Christi Esterle: Heart agree. All right, Christy, what's your number five?
[4:27] Christi Esterle: Oh, jeez. Um, well, I'm probably gonna get flack for putting this so low, but it would probably be Company. Uh, because it's one of those shows where I think I like the score a lot better than I like the story or you know, the concept. I'm I'm kind of, you know, I love the Sondheim, you know, the more conceptual stuff like Follies and Assassins and things like that, those are the things that I kind of love more for what they are rather than um what you know how I come away from them. But you know, Company is just uh top-notch score. It's got you know, "Being Alive," "Not Getting Married Today," "Ladies Who Lunch." There's a whole bunch of fantastic character pieces in it and patter songs and ballads, and it's just a magnificent score all the way around.
[5:19] Jess McAnally: That's fantastic. And um, have you looked into the new revival of Company at all? Like, how do you think that touches your fancy in comparison?
[5:27] Christi Esterle: I actually think it's a very interesting way of doing it. Um, you know, looking at, you know, being single and 35 from the perspective of a woman is, you know, a completely different social and mental thing from you know, looking at it from the man's perspective, because that's growing through the point where everybody's pressuring you to get married and pressuring you to have kids because that's a very limited window, obviously, and that's obviously not for everybody. So I think that's a great way of looking at it. Um I definitely do want to see um something where we do see some more same-sex couples, though.
[6:06] Emily Clark: Yeah.
[6:07] Christi Esterle: Do you do I spoilers for the Company revival if you care about things like that? But it was a very hard and fast rule that Bobby couldn't have a same-sex even intimate uh implication. So the ending is kind of ruined when Patti LuPone turns to Bobby and is like in the original version. Why didn't we ever get together? They don't do that. She's like, why don't you get together with my husband? He'll take care of you. And it just kills that moment so much.
[6:36] Jess McAnally: Yeah, Joanne's a swinger. Woo!
[6:38] Christi Esterle: Yeah. I I you know, I only heard the opening, I heard the revival's opening number. It popped up on a playlist, and I think it must have been the London cast. And it threw me a little bit because it was in the exact same key. And so Bobby was forced to have to sing these like really high notes that kind of made me go, like, okay. Like, I don't know. It just kind of was like, couldn't she just have opted down here? Like, I don't know. It was, it was weird. I I I don't know how I felt about it. It kind of was just like, this is distractingly high and piercing right now.
[7:12] Jess McAnally: Like I will say they did change that for the Katrina Lenk Broadway production. They brought it down because Katrina Lenk has a much lower register than it's not. Because I would feel if you're gonna swap genders, that's a place like where I I you know, to go back on that sudden argument from a few episodes. I think, yeah, like that's a place where you can forgive modulation because um, you know, tenor and um soprano and alto and bass, they're not the same.
[7:39] Christi Esterle: Yeah they're not the same ranges and registers, so and it doesn't land the same way.
[7:44] Jess McAnally: Yeah. No. Um sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. But yeah. Um that's a great choice. Um, yeah, um, I don't think anyone's gonna give you flack for putting it so low though, because it it is a more complicated. If you're not into like kind of a 70s character piece, you might not dig it, you know?
[8:03] Christi Esterle: Yeah, long, long ago, like decades ago, they did it at um the Arvada Center, and um I didn't get to see it, but my mom's had season tickets there forever, and she went and she is like, I just didn't care for it.
[8:14] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[8:15] Christi Esterle: And yeah, I can kind of see that reaction because it's a very nonlinear um story, and uh just saw these little character vignettes.
[8:23] Jess McAnally: Yeah, and it's snapshots like a lot. If you're looking for like, you know, a story that you know takes you from point A to point B to point C, that's you're not gonna get that.
[8:33] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[8:34] Jess McAnally: Yeah. In the days after Sondheim's death, where that was literally all I wanted to talk about, because you know, mourning and all of the things.
[8:40] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah.
[8:41] Jess McAnally: Um and processing is like, all right, then describe me every Sondheim musical. And I do. And she's like, all these concepts just sound painfully boring when said in like a three-sentence, like specific overtures describing that in three sentences. Like, why would you make a musical out of that? It's like, yeah, I promise it's good. You know, anything, you know, you can reduce it to, you know, it kind of sounds weird when you reduce it to like those few sentences, though.
[9:09] Christi Esterle: It it is, but it's also kind of like I'm I'm like really trying to sell on it. I'm like, no, no, no, it's really about the westernization of the stuff. It's really hard to do an elevator pitch on Company.
[9:19] Jess McAnally: Um, yeah. Um, I guess I can go next. Um, mine's a cheat because literally I could not pick one or the other of these musicals to put as my number five. Like they switched over and over and I couldn't make a justification. So they're both number five. So my number five is both Follies and Merrily We Roll Along.
[9:36] Jess McAnally: Um, Follies has like some of the best songs Sondheim has ever written, even if you're not a big fan of the interesting staging. But the staging is also probably one of my favorite techniques he's ever done, where you have the younger versions of themselves constantly haunting the older versions of themselves as like literal ghosts and recontextualizing where they're having the same fight as they did when they were younger and all that that and come on, I'm still here. Um, could I leave you? Losing my mind. Songs are like bangers.
[10:06] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah, or like bangers. The entire Loveland sequence is probably one of my favorite just plays. It's like its own little story inside of this musical. It is incredible. And Merrily, I cannot watch that show without crying. Um last time I saw Merrily live, it was just a community production um at the University of Michigan with Emily Kutacho, who is now the first black Christine on Broadway, and I like got to chat with her a little bit. I was like, You are incredible. You were, I forget the wife's character's name, and it was just incredible. I was like, you're going places. Next time I hear that name.
[10:39] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah, it's fantastic. Um, both those musicals can't rank one above the other. They're both equally amazing. Um Follies is such an interesting uh concept for a show because you have to kind of I I don't know if revivals do this, but I feel like they have to because you have to keep it in the 70s because that was the time when these follies former Follies. I mean, you can't do that now. They'd be all dead.
[11:06] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[11:08] Christi Esterle: But in the 70s, that was this time when um all you know, let's see, they would have been like in their sixties. It was a very popular time. It was a very difficult time for um, you know, Broadway theater as an institution. You know, a lot of the old houses were coming down. Times Square was, you know, basically where you went to get a hooker and some, you know, and some illegal drugs.
[11:33] Jess McAnally: So it wasn't, yeah.
[11:34] Christi Esterle: It's you know, you go there and it's a re it's a huge touristy place now, but you know, back in the 70s, it was a completely different world.
[11:41] Jess McAnally: Yeah, and to have this musical where Sondheim is writing these um kind of pastiches to early Broadway Ziegfeld Follies type Ziegfeld Follies style songs is pretty pretty amazing in the score because you get the Sondheim-y stuff, but then you get like uh like an amalgam of that is something like "Buddy's Blues," you know, or "The Rain on the Roof," or just the you know, the beautiful girls, like having them all enter and walk around, like um But then you've got like "Waiting for the Girls Upstairs," which is uh such a very complex number.
[12:17] Christi Esterle: Yeah. It it's so fascinating.
[12:19] Jess McAnally: Yeah, and I think it's interesting, Jess, that you juxtapose uh Merrily with Follies because those are both about, you know, kind of lot, you know, disillusionment and looking back on your past.
[12:30] Christi Esterle: Um Yeah, you're too young to be just would I have chosen differently? Could I have chosen differently, you know, based on who I am and what I knew. And you know, I mean Yeah. It's weird because I I agree. I'm sure these shows will only grow on me as I get older and look back, but I still kind of feel that way.
[12:50] Jess McAnally: But being in the first half of being like, I wanna make changes so I don't regret the change my life later. Like having the kind of foresight of like, that's the worst case scenario. So live like you don't want that. Don't live with regret right now.
[13:05] Christi Esterle: Yeah. Live for the now, kids. I know that's so pretentious and very 20s guy, but hey, I'm almost I'm almost at 30, so we'll find out how that goes for me.
[13:15] Emily Clark: Yeah. It's true though. I mean, you know, very little in my life went the way I thought it was going to when I was 21, but you know, it's like I'm not I don't regret what I did, you know. I learned a lot, I experienced some fun things, I learned a lot about myself, and yeah, it's cool. I mean, I get to hang out with you guys for my twenties. How can I really complain?
[13:34] Jess McAnally: Hey. Like, literally, I I'm blessed. Uh um, I can't can't be angry unless we like have a horrible falling out. We look back on this and we're like, how did we get here from there?
[13:44] Christi Esterle: Yeah, right. On that note, we're on number four. Chris or Emily, you want to start us off?
[13:51] Emily Clark: Yeah, yeah. Okay, so number four for me. Uh maybe you guys will be shocked this is so low, but uh would be the masterpiece, Sweeney Todd. Um what am I gonna say? It's Sweeney Todd.
[14:05] Jess McAnally: It's it's I'm gonna reveal this with you. Mine is my number four Sweeney Todd too.
[14:08] Emily Clark: Oh, is it? It's one of the best musicals ever written. You know, Mrs. Lovett is definitely a bucketless dream roll. Um I think it gets uh better and richer. Again, as the more I listen to it, the older I get, the more I'm able to analyze the score and the characters, just the better it gets.
[14:26] Jess McAnally: Um I I love it. It's a big insane concept of a show and a big heightened soap opera of a musical. I love it. It's amazing. And it's also like Sondheim's simplest premise.
[14:40] Emily Clark: It is kind of like story before like weird stage technique thing.
[14:46] Jess McAnally: Yeah. It's not like where you have it's just like the story is a subversive thing, not the weird things we're doing with the craft.
[14:52] Emily Clark: Right. Which also makes it seeming to be a good thing.
[14:54] Jess McAnally: Which has got the corner on Broadway was just a thing.
[14:57] Emily Clark: Yeah. It's and that's kind of the provenance of it. You know, it goes back to like, you know, a really, you know, the old Penny Dreadfuls where, you know, they weren't trying anything, you know, elaborate or deep, you know. They were just saying, here's the shocking tale of people getting murdered in the barber shop and their corpses are becoming pies. Woo.
[15:17] Jess McAnally: It's it's also interesting because it's that um that kind of thing that um I I guess happened with Shakespeare, is that you have this lowbrow art form in its time that eventually over the eras becomes this highbrow art form.
[15:32] Emily Clark: And um the inspiration is like Penny Dreadful trash story.
[15:38] Jess McAnally: Yeah. Um is, you know, picked up by by these guys who wanted to do something new in the realm of musical theater. I mean, there's there's a there's a reason why opera companies often do Sweeney Todd, even though it's technically not an opera.
[15:50] Emily Clark: It's a very operatic story.
[15:51] Jess McAnally: And um with operatic voices being used.
[15:54] Emily Clark: Yeah. I think yeah, you know, we also need to give credit to Christopher Bond, who wrote um the um straight play uh melodrama, which is what a lot of um the uh Sondheim Wheeler book is based off of.
[16:08] Jess McAnally: So he yeah, it's it's very fascinating the way this transitioned from sensationalist Penny Dreadful to you know, kind of this melodrama with a conscience to this commentary on you know hu uh good and evil and obsession and revenge and all these really huge things.
[16:27] Christi Esterle: Yeah. And a lot of people of my generation, this is their first Sondheim. Like this is really like their first dive into it, especially like edgy teens that really like I'm gonna do this.
[16:36] Jess McAnally: And say what you will about that Tim Burton movie.
[16:39] Emily Clark: Um it was a great gateway.
[16:41] Jess McAnally: It's a great gateway or worse.
[16:43] Emily Clark: Yeah, I mean, yeah, I will I I think it Yeah, I defend it for that reason. If it helped you get into it. It has its flaws, but you know, I think they did a lot of really good things with it.
[16:54] Jess McAnally: Um, he was they were doing a lot of creative things with visuals and the way they did Epiphany. I mean, we're seeing a lot more of that uh in the past year or so with musicals that are not afraid to say, okay, these people are gonna sing, so we're just gonna go a little crazy with um stuff for a second.
[17:11] Emily Clark: Yeah.
[17:11] Jess McAnally: Instead of being like, Oh no, God, they're singing. What are we going to do? I don't know if we can handle them singing. Everything's so heightened in the show that of course they should be singing.
[17:21] Emily Clark: It's it's right.
[17:22] Jess McAnally: It's yes. Murdering people and putting them into pies and revenge, deep seated revenge, you know.
[17:28] Christi Esterle: It's so great. Love it. All right, Christy, what's your number four?
[17:31] Christi Esterle: Okay, uh, my second is what I would consider the Sondheim Gateway show, and that is Into the Woods. Mm-hmm. Because it's up, you know, everybody knows the fairy tales. Um, you know, everybody it's ridiculously catchy, um, you know, singable music.
[17:47] Emily Clark: Um, you know, for everybody who thinks, you know, Sondheim is, you know, too, you know, that obtruse um intellectual stuff that you can't latch on to. I'm like, no, come on, you know, into the woods. It's time to get it's fun show.
[18:00] Christi Esterle: It's got great it's got some great solos um on the steps of the palace. I think Moments in the Woods is one of the best uh Sondheim character solos of all time.
[18:10] Emily Clark: Um, yeah, and then you know, it just it's plays with fairy tales for the first act, and then it turns everything on its head for the second act and really makes you think about it.
[18:19] Christi Esterle: And then that's what everyone does now. Like, look at Shrek um have a lot of things.
[18:23] Emily Clark: Yeah, this was a this was ahead of well, I not entirely asked. Disney does it now, that's why.
[18:28] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I mean, I mean, you know, this goes back to like the fractured fairy tales of you know, the Rocky and Bullwinkle cartoons, so it's so you know, that revision has been going on for a while, but I think And very much going to the source, or you know, not the sorcerers, but the grim source anyway.
[18:45] Emily Clark: Yes, absolutely, you know, going back to that pre-Disney thing and saying, you know, the stepsisters got blinded and they cut their feet, and you know, Jack, you know, Jack is kind of a thief when you think about it, and Rapunzel's Prince got blinded and she got pregnant and all that dark stuff that gets, you know, sanitized out of them when you try to tell them to kids.
[19:06] Christi Esterle: Yeah. And my favorite thing that it reading about this in the hat books and all that is sometimes like playing with audience expectations, meaning you don't need to see the story. You know the story. So we're just gonna tell you what happened after the thoughts going into it and focus on these three new characters I made the baker, the wife, and the witch.
[19:24] Emily Clark: Right.
[19:24] Christi Esterle: And really focus on them, and then these other people were gonna focus on the thematic side of them.
[19:31] Emily Clark: Right.
[19:31] Christi Esterle: And it's actually a very good way of doing that, you know, because that kind of you know, quest to, you know, solve your problem and you know, following the instructions from the mysterious old old witch is very much a fairy tale thing, and they just find it okay, you so you have to find Cinderella's slipper and you know, Jack's cow and all this other stuff.
[19:52] Emily Clark: Yeah, it's the baker, his wife, and the witch are taking these tropes that you see in these fairy tales. You know, the baker becomes the huntsman, um, the you know, the uh also where little red gets you know her treats and um the witch being Rapunzel's witch, but also being another witch for it's it it's it just shows how interconnected it is because the whole reason those fairy tales existed in the first place, even going back before the Grimms was um, you know, making sense of kind of this medieval world where kids die all the time, and like um uh you you can only the best you can hope for is like a magic cat to help you like get like a nice loaf of bread in a house.
[20:31] Christi Esterle: Like that's all they want. Like, you know, it's fascinating stuff, and um it it's it teaches these kind of lessons that have been shaped through the ages, and then by the time Sondheim got to them, it all became less about like how do you cope with your your kids dying young too, uh uh actions have consequences.
[20:32] Emily Clark: How do you cope with your parents being useless?
[20:55] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah. That's the other thing is there's a lot in there about you know, parent-child relationships, which you know, as a parent myself hits a lot differently, you know, the the witch's impulse to you know want to keep Rapunzel in her tower because you know the world sucks, yeah, and what's going to happen to you when you get out there and see that it sucks and then you know the bait the Baker's been abandoned and Cinderella's dad is useless and you know all those things you know just coping with you know that yeah your parents screw up sometimes but that doesn't mean that you're screwed up or you have to screw up.
[21:34] Emily Clark: Yeah and what is it gonna mean for Jack and Little Red who lose both their parents in the show by you know what is what are these repercussions going to mean for them.
[21:43] Christi Esterle: It's fascinating.
[21:44] Emily Clark: Yeah just actually what you do reverberates through the generations yeah and that children are always listening even if you don't think they are because that is boy they listen.
[21:56] Christi Esterle: Yep. They know what's up oh yeah.
[21:59] Jess McAnally: But my number four um Sweeney we said that before um Emily three.
[22:04] Emily Clark: Okay so my number three okay my number three is uh uh assassins um yeah yeah dark horse right um I to this day it's one of the best theatrical experiences I've ever had as an actor and musical theater performer I got to play Squeaky Fromme like I don't know I guess it was 2008 2009 something like that um and I just felt so fulfilled as a performer um doing that show um we were on stage pretty much the whole time and in an alley staging um and so we got to just like be in character for 90 minutes and it was so fun but that aside, it's one of my it's one of my favorite Sondheim scores.
[22:49] Christi Esterle: I think it's highly underrated.
[22:52] Emily Clark: His, because everything is um the music is all a pastiche of the era of the person singing it. Um it's Americana in 90 minutes and the dark side of Americana and like the subversion of um um hail to the chief and things like that, and how terrifying it all can be.
[23:14] Jess McAnally: Um, and how everybody has the right doesn't just apply to you pulling yourself up by your bootstraps, like even even the Loony Loons can do that and cause real damage.
[23:25] Emily Clark: Um I think it's it's just a fantastic show. It's a weird concept, and I like it. I like that it's just all these weird, horrible figures in history just kind of like hanging out with each other, and what ifing like if they would interact with no rhyme or reason? You don't have to explain it. It's theater.
[23:42] Jess McAnally: Um I love that.
[23:45] Emily Clark: Um, and it's just I don't know, it's just a weird fucking show, and I I really, really like it a lot. And I love doing it. Again, another really good black box college show that you could do anywhere.
[23:57] Christi Esterle: My production totally ripped off the Broadway revival when we had the Zapruder film projected on on uh Lee Harvey Oswald's shirt.
[24:06] Emily Clark: We also did the thing where Lee Harvey Oswald was also the balladier, um, and that worked really well.
[24:13] Jess McAnally: Um yeah, I just I just love it. It's it's one that I always kind of sometimes forget about, and then when I hear it and it's brought up, I go, oh yeah, yeah, I I fucking love that show.
[24:22] Emily Clark: So yeah, I'm going with that for my number three, baby.
[24:24] Jess McAnally: Good choice.
[24:25] Christi Esterle: Um not in my top five. I got I got issues with the book and the score and how they're connected or not connected, but amazing show still.
[24:33] Emily Clark: It's got it's also got one of the best creepy, you know, love ballads in the world.
[24:38] Jess McAnally: So yeah.
[24:38] Emily Clark: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[24:39] Christi Esterle: 10 out of 10.
[24:40] Jess McAnally: I'm worthy of your love, amazing.
[24:41] Emily Clark: Um great choice, Emily.
[24:43] Jess McAnally: All right, Christy, let's hear number three?
[24:45] Christi Esterle: Oh, geez. I am gonna go with Sunday in the Park with George, the Pulitzer winner.
[24:50] Emily Clark: Oh.
[24:50] Christi Esterle: Uh okay. So yeah, it's I this is kind of, you know, personally what I respond to rather than quality. I think it's probably, you know, one of the best constructed Sondheim shows. Just the way the score is reflected in reflects the art and um, you know, the parallels between, you know, Sorrow and uh George in the second act and everything that it says about you know art as an industry, both then and you know, in I guess in the like the 80s when it would have would have been current, I think is just it's just very fascinating.
[25:29] Christi Esterle: I agree with you. We'll get no top-notch stuff, and I love that we are able to, you know, projections, you know, CGI and projections in theater are kind of a mixed bag, but I love that we can have them for this show so we can actually have this painting come to life and start out with, you know, the white canvas and then just build it on top of that.
[25:55] Christi Esterle: It is really cool to see how different productions interpret that.
[25:59] Jess McAnally: Yeah, how they interpret that and how they bring this, you know, artwork to life.
[26:04] Christi Esterle: Because I've seen most of like small black box ones where they're limited, obviously, with their means, and so they make it work within their means.
[26:11] Jess McAnally: But then, you know, I think I told you guys I saw the Kennedy Center one with Raul Esparza ages ago, and that was at the point in the technology where they would bring these like flat screen TVs down for putting it together instead of cardboard cutouts.
[26:24] Christi Esterle: So it was like that in sync. I don't know if you ever saw that live in sync performance at the VMAs where it's their heads and they're dancing between them.
[26:31] Jess McAnally: I'm old but that's exactly what it was like it was like him walking behind Gary Lesparts.
[26:35] Christi Esterle: Yeah that's real that's a really cool way of doing that.
[26:38] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[26:38] Christi Esterle: Um yeah and yeah I love putting it together. Um there's you know Barbara Streisand on the Broadway album does a great um rewrite of that you know kind of as the leadoff song yeah um which is putting it together the fantastic did a I love the review version yeah yeah the one with um well I I I I know the original one with Julie Andrews did it but then the other one with Calvert Love was so good.
[27:06] Jess McAnally: Yes I think this show just gets better as time goes on. Like I feel like as technology will improve it'll get better.
[27:13] Christi Esterle: You know yeah and you know there's a great recording of the original cast of Mandy Patinkin and Bernadette Peters that everybody absolutely must like everyone's watch. There's also a fantastic recording from the Paris um version with Julian Ovenden um and that is also incredible shows you a more updated take on it.
[27:30] Jess McAnally: And there's a yoho bootleg of the Jake Gyllenhaal production which is also very different much smaller. A lot of choices made but still effective I don't I I think there's a lot of choice I would have really liked to see that one that's for sure.
[27:44] Christi Esterle: Yeah in the UK like that.
[27:46] Jess McAnally: Yeah and it inspired the best scene in tick tick boom how can you not love it exactly um all right um what number am I on three three oh into the woods we talked about that my number three is into the woods amazing show no no notes.
[27:46] Emily Clark: All right.
[28:01] Christi Esterle: Number two.
[28:03] Emily Clark: My number two is Into the Woods um for for No Notes. For most of my life, Into the Woods was number one. Um I think late I think as I've gotten a little older, it's bumped down to number two. Um, but it's my first Sondheim. I, you know, my mom got me into it when I was like six or seven. Um, you know, watching that PBS pro shot.
[28:25] Christi Esterle: Oh yeah.
[28:26] Emily Clark: I watched I an indefinite amount of time. I mean, I can't even tell you. I could probably just play it all in my head right now, uh, and and and be right. Um I I I went to that reunion they did at Segerstrom a few years ago.
[28:40] Christi Esterle: Um such a fantastic cat ensemble on that one too.
[28:44] Emily Clark: It's amazing. Unbelievable. It's uh and you know, I I've directed the junior version once. Um it's uh the junior version ends at the end of act one.
[28:55] Christi Esterle: Yeah, but they're middle schoolers, so it kind of it's fine.
[28:58] Emily Clark: It's fine. I wouldn't, you know, whatever. It's fine. As Orson Welles always said, you can always have a happy ending depending on where you end the story.
[29:04] Christi Esterle: Yeah, exactly.
[29:06] Emily Clark: That is true. Um, but it's I don't know, it's what I would it it's what I would give someone to kind of give them something for like their first Sondheim, maybe, um, because it is so accessible. Um, it is so great for kids.
[29:22] Christi Esterle: It's good for smart kids, smart kids who can handle uh kind of.
[29:28] Emily Clark: It's for Rick and Morty kids.
[29:29] Christi Esterle: Oh god.
[29:30] Emily Clark: Um kids who can handle nuance, and I think there's more and more of them these days. Um I it's a show I still haven't done, and I'm I I've I don't know why how, but um someday I'll do it. Uh I could probably do it up until I'm really old and be fine.
[29:48] Christi Esterle: Um it yeah, I mean, come on, we already just talked about it. It's it's one of the best.
[29:53] Emily Clark: So yeah, into the woods, my number two.
[29:54] Christi Esterle: All right. Uh Christy, number two.
[29:56] Jess McAnally: Uh, my number two is a little night music.
[29:59] Christi Esterle: Yeah. It's the score is oh my god, the score. It's beautiful. It's almost like like this little Fabergé egg where you just look at it and it's like the craftsmanship is just so beautiful. The way it is written, it's everything's like in the three-four tempo, and you know, the way the duets work, and it's I cannot say enough about it.
[30:24] Jess McAnally: It's amazing.
[30:25] Christi Esterle: I mean, you know, Desiree Armfeld and uh Madame Armfeld are both uh a couple of dream roles of mine. Such great characters, and you know, a great story about, you know, how love is, you know, kind of messed up and complicated and insane, and it's never like it is in the fairy tales, but still it's a wonderful thing.
[30:46] Jess McAnally: And you can age through it.
[30:48] Christi Esterle: There's a role for everyone. And go from Petra to Charlotte to Desiree to Madame Armfeld. I mean, you know, God, I mean, who is writing for women now that Sondheim is gone?
[31:02] Jess McAnally: Lynn, I think an I.
[31:06] Christi Esterle: Lynn writes, I think Lynn writes really good songs for women. Or at least good character pieces for women. I wish he'd come back to stage someday.
[31:15] Jess McAnally: That's my biggest one.
[31:17] Christi Esterle: Let's give him a couple years. It took him six years to write Hamilton, I think, you know, we'll probably wait until he did so much this year.
[31:22] Jess McAnally: Just let him take twenty two.
[31:24] Christi Esterle: Yeah, I mean, yeah. You've earned it, Lynn.
[31:26] Jess McAnally: I mean, I agree, but I don't think we're gonna get another stage show from Lynn Manuel Miranda until over a decade.
[31:32] Christi Esterle: Probably since the Hamilton.
[31:33] Jess McAnally: Yeah, that's entirely possible. And I think, you know, part of that is him coming to terms with like, okay, you know, I've written like the big thing that everyone's going to remember me for. Now what?
[31:42] Christi Esterle: Yeah, what do you do after you write thriller?
[31:44] Jess McAnally: You know, like it's yeah. What do you do after you know what's gonna be on your obituary? Which is, you know, better than any Disney score has a right to be.
[31:52] Christi Esterle: Yeah, yeah.
[31:54] Jess McAnally: Oh, well, a little night music, an amazing show.
[31:58] Christi Esterle: So good, so good.
[31:59] Jess McAnally: Yes. Very valuable number two choice. Mine is gonna be the Dark Horse number two choice.
[32:06] Christi Esterle: It is Passion!
[32:07] Jess McAnally: I knew who was gonna say.
[32:11] Christi Esterle: I fucking love Passion.
[32:13] Jess McAnally: You're not gonna be a little bit more.
[32:17] Christi Esterle: Tell us why. The show is just such it's unlike any of the other Sondheim. I think it might be his only one act show, unless you're gonna include something like Evening Primrose, which I don't.
[32:28] Jess McAnally: Umless Emily wants to correct me.
[32:30] Christi Esterle: I think that's Assassins is a one act.
[32:32] Jess McAnally: I was gonna say you just said Assassins, so yeah.
[32:34] Christi Esterle: Um, so Passion is based on a film, Passion Demore, um, by um some French filmmaker. It's just the perfect movie to stage adaptation where it's just like Sondheim watches this movie and he's like, you know what? I wanna do this.
[32:48] Jess McAnally: And this is the only other show aside from Sweeney Todd that Sondheim pursued himself. Reached out to James Lapine, and originally he was gonna do a sung through. He was gonna go full Andrew Lloyd Weber with this and put it sung through.
[33:01] Christi Esterle: And then he added like the incredible book by James Lapine. It's so dark, so mean, and so like the score is probably one of his more melodic, more dark, more probably the closest thing to Sweeney Todd since Sweeney Todd.
[33:17] Jess McAnally: As far as like the timbre of the score. And also, like the solos, the portrayal of a woman as like this this character that is very difficult to fall in love with. It is not an easy to like character.
[33:31] Christi Esterle: But then you've got these incredible actresses putting their own st staple onto it. Patty LuPone, Donna Murphy, um, Judy Kuhn, and every one of them knocked it out the park.
[33:40] Jess McAnally: And yeah, um, it gets better every time I listen to it, and I don't care what the haters say.
[33:46] Christi Esterle: You don't have to care what the haters say.
[33:49] Jess McAnally: Yeah. And I I don't I didn't know this was a show that most people didn't in Sondheim world didn't like because this was like probably my fourth Sondheim thing. I think it was like this Sunday sweet yeah, the passion.
[34:02] Christi Esterle: And I was like, oh, this is this is something I've never seen before. I get why it flopped. I understand I'm not sure.
[34:14] Jess McAnally: But it was it only like ran for 90 performances and something like that. And I forget what was like up against on the Tony. That might have been one of those weird years where they're like, fine, we'll just give it to this.
[34:26] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and uh it it it felt in a lot of ways like like Sondheim going, well, the 80s, you know. I just I wrote a lot of really like kind of introspective deep stuff, and then uh I don't know, uh let's try this let's try this mega musical thing, or let's try this kind of thing.
[34:44] Jess McAnally: It was more that was like style. It's like it's not a big show.
[34:48] Christi Esterle: Yeah, it's almost like his response to you know those bit the big melodramatic shows of the eighties and early 90s. Because it does have like a Sondheim.
[34:57] Jess McAnally: Um sorry, it does have like an Andrew Lloyd Weber, Boob Leal and Schoenberg, yeah.
[35:02] Christi Esterle: And yeah, and it has that, you know, Victorian romantic melodrama thing going on, but it's Sondheim. It's dark and it's complicated.
[35:10] Jess McAnally: Yeah, yeah. I I like to imagine like he saw something like Andrew Lloyd Weber or what and he was like, you know, no no, guys, this is how you do it.
[35:19] Christi Esterle: And I can easily see that. Like, I I think it's just unlike anything he's ever seen. It's strangely one of his more accessible musicals.
[35:28] Jess McAnally: Like, I'm very glad, and one of the most incredibly shot pro shots. I think it's a lot of people.
[35:32] Christi Esterle: Yeah, you have a pro shot, so you can see that. I think it was his only one of his original three pro shots shot on film.
[35:38] Jess McAnally: So it is like one of the most gorgeously shot. Like it looks like a movie as opposed to like a TV special.
[35:45] Christi Esterle: The way that Into the Woods and Sunday sadly looked.
[35:48] Jess McAnally: Yeah. Um, and I think there was just some weird staging choices that brought it down, like deciding just put Marin Maisie with her tits out in the first scene. You didn't need that.
[35:56] Christi Esterle: It was just who was complaining about that.
[36:01] Jess McAnally: Come on, she looked amazing.
[36:03] Christi Esterle: She looked like a painting.
[36:05] Jess McAnally: Yes, but this show it felt gratuitous.
[36:08] Christi Esterle: Oh my god.
[36:09] Jess McAnally: Yeah, well, come on, baby, it was the 90s.
[36:11] Christi Esterle: Yeah. I mean, it's like in Bridges of Madison County when Kelly O'Hara is buttass naked for no reason.
[36:18] Jess McAnally: I saw Kelly, I I've told you the story about how when I saw Dracula on Broadway. Dracula looks at Kelly O'Hara all sexy at the end of the first act, and her dress just gets vacuumed off.
[36:30] Christi Esterle: Like it just blink in her dress. It was one of the funniest things I had ever seen. And this was before she became like, you know, Kelly O'Hara.
[36:39] Jess McAnally: Kelly O'Hara. Every time I see Kelly O'Hara, I'm like, I just remember that time that I just remember her scenes getting sucked off.
[36:45] Christi Esterle: Like from the pit.
[36:47] Jess McAnally: It was so funny.
[36:48] Christi Esterle: It is hilarious.
[36:49] Jess McAnally: But I just remember in Bridges, like she did an interview like right after it opened. She's like, Yeah, I just had a baby, but then they insisted I still did the nude scene, so now I'm just doing these nude scenes every night.
[36:58] Christi Esterle: And it's just her getting out of a bathtub, showing like standing naked and then putting a towel. I'm like, you didn't need this.
[37:05] Jess McAnally: You didn't need to do that.
[37:09] Christi Esterle: All right, we're at number ones, guys.
[37:11] Emily Clark: I think no one's gonna be surprised by this, but my number one is Sunday in the Park with George.
[37:16] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[37:17] Emily Clark: Um it's mine too, so we can do that right now. It's always waffled, you know, kind of between Into the Woods and Sunday in the Park with George for me, but Sunday has surpassed it.
[37:26] Christi Esterle: Um I first of all, personally, I am a real sucker for the artist trying to figure out his place in the world story. I don't care if it's overdone. I don't care if you don't like it. I relate to it. I love it.
[37:42] Jess McAnally: Um I love it all that jazz.
[37:45] Emily Clark: I love tick tick boom. Um I I just I know they're self-indulgent, but sometimes we have to be self-indulgent. Artists are self-indulgent, it's fine.
[37:54] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[37:54] Emily Clark: Um with those, yeah, the problem with those stories is that very often they are done terribly.
[38:00] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and when they're done well.
[38:02] Emily Clark: You know, when it's done right, and Sunday in the Park in George is done extremely right. It is, you know, something that I think everyone relates to because, you know, we may not be, you know, artists, you know, starving in a garret, but we are all like, okay, what am I doing on this planet? Am I doing something that matters? When I'm gone, how am I gonna be remembered?
[38:22] Christi Esterle: Yeah, and I um there's I mean, there's so much I connect to.
[38:26] Christi Esterle: The score is brilliant. I mean, the whole thing is just an immaculate, perfect masterpiece of a score. Um, I relate to Dot and George in various ways. Um, the being all consumed by your art thing. I've been there, but then I've also been the like, oh my god, like just do this for you. I put it together has played in my head when I have been a producer plunging toilets while act two is going on. You know, like it's just the art of making art. Um, I don't know what else I can say about it. I think it's a great show. Um, I hate it when people used to say this to me growing up. I think people don't do it as much now, but people used to be like, why is the second act there? And it's like because it's making connections to the modern world.
And you're not sure. Okay, am I right? I think the second act is amazing. So I think the second act is better than the first act. I think it's more important. I mean, yeah, it's laying the ground. You can't have one, in my opinion, you can't have one without the other. It's not like Into the Woods, maybe where you could do a junior version of the thing. I think it's important to see the difference between the art world, you know, when you in the 18 whatever with Sorot was doing this for like exhibitions, and now in you know, the 20th century, when it's this institution.
[39:43] Jess McAnally: Yeah. And you know, it ha you know, we've kind of, you know, it's kind of framed in this way where you have to be doing something, you know, important and you know, meaningful instead of, you know, just trying to sell a painting to make a buck. And then like the idea that you have to, you know, George Serrat was just trying to get his work seen by anyone to be appreciated by anyone, but he just wanted to make it. Whereas George in the second act, he's successful doing the same shit over and over and over again. And now he's at a crisis where he's like, what do I do now? Um, how do I be new? How do I be new? Yeah.
[40:21] Christi Esterle: And um, I just I love it. I relate to it. That pro shot, I remember, you know, my I grew up watching Into the Woods, that pro shot. And then I think when I got into high school, my mom was like, you should watch this. I think you'll like it. It's with Bernadette Peters who was in Into the Woods. And I was like, oh, cool. And I remember just like falling in love with the show, and um, it kind of blew my mind that a show like that could even exist. And I don't think anything can compare to hearing Mandy Patinkin and Bernadette Peters singing "Move On" for the first time. It just like imprinted on my soul. Um, I love it. I think it's a masterpiece. Uh, it has the Pulitzer for a reason, and it came out the same year as "La Cage," so you know, it got overshadowed by the happy fun show. But you know, the same can be said of West Side Story and The Music Man. So it's um, it's my favorite, yeah.
[41:19] Jess McAnally: Yeah, yeah, mine too. Um, but Christi, you're right. Okay, I'm the odd person out because just because this is we I'm just because of the way I'm wired, I went with Sweeney Todd because I knew it. I am just a sucker. I am the Victorian melodrama sucker. I mean, you give me this, you know, traumatized man belting to the heavens about how he's going to slaughter his way through society to get back at losing his wife. I eat that up like candy. Um, but yeah, again, it's you know, it's a melodramatic story, but you know, it's done in a very, you know, thoughtful and brilliant manner. The score is just magnificent. It has, I believe, the greatest opening number of all time. Um, it is, you know, and some fantastic character pieces.
"Worst Pies in London" is one of my favorite female solos of all time. Um, yeah, and "Pretty Women," again, one of those songs which is just so gorgeous until you realize until you see it in context, and you're like, oh my god, this is freaky. And then you have "A Little Priest," which just has all these terrible puns and it's hilarious. So God, it's so good. Watching these characters just be so gleeful about how they're people, and you're just with them, you're like, yeah, yeah, dude. And then it cut, and then yeah, no, at the very end, it's like, yeah, you were rooting for this because this is this darkness inside you, and you're like, damn. Damn.
[42:44] Christi Esterle: But yeah, uh, only caveat is I have seldom seen Joanna played um well, you know. It's uh especially like on the Hearn at Lansbury. I don't know who's doing it, but she's just kind of got this crazy thing going on, you know. I love that Joanna is kind of like this, kind of like she's on the surface, she's this very typical, you know, Victorian melodramatic ingenue. It's like, oh, take me away from my terrible guardian, please. But when you dig a little deeper, it's like, yeah, there's you know, she's a little smarter and a little crazier than you know, people are letting on. Usually it's like opera companies that just cast like whatever basic soprano they have.
[43:24] Jess McAnally: Yeah. And um, I think you I would love to see a production, and I'm sure there are productions that exist because it's been done so much, but um, I'd like to see uh one that uh Joanna that where they really lean into like the Rapunzel's you know, unraveling and into the woods because that's what's happening to her. Of course, she runs away with Anthony, she lives with a creepy old man who wants to marry her. Yeah, that and then that, and then she spends the entire second act. She talks to Pirelli on a victim. Yeah, and then she spends the entire second act in a Victorian madhouse. I mean, if that does not, you know, that is, you know, you know, that's one of those places where if you're not crazy when you go in, you definitely are when you come out.
[44:03] Christi Esterle: I do want to say a word of defense to Betsy Jocelyn who did play Joanna. Um, she was very young, and she would later, about ten years later, play The Witch in Into the Woods very, very well. She is like one of the best witches in the original production of Into the Woods. I don't blame the girls. I blame the directors for not giving them the exact dude. I blame the script a little bit. I blame the score a little bit. I think it is. It's just a little like like um um kiss me, that whole sequence. Kiss me exactly. I mean, the entire time she's like going at a hundred miles an hour, and then at some point she's like, oh yeah, I don't even know your name. Yeah, I think there's something to be explored there that hasn't been mined as much as I think. But I think, you know, my favorite cast has got to be um the uh Lupone Hearn concert recording.
[44:52] Jess McAnally: That's hard agree. Yeah. Uh, I am a big fan of the John Logan uh revival with Michael Cerberus and Patty LuPone just for how bonkers off the wall and how strangely well the orchestration still works minimized. Yeah. Um, and I saw I was able to see the immersive production um they did off Broadway a few years ago. Um, there were several people I saw it with um Hugh Pinero and Carolie Comer uh Carmelo. Um, it was fantastic, it was amazing. I loved what they did with it, and they actually had fantastic pie and mash too. I saw Hugh Pinero play Anthony back at the Kennedy Center celebration. Yeah, so you know, he aged into uh he's aged into Sweeney.
[46:11] Jess McAnally: Jeez.
[45:34] Jess McAnally: I didn't tell you guys this, but yesterday I had one of my students singing "Worst Pies in London" for my musical theater club at the school where I teach.
[45:45] Jess McAnally: And she got up to sing, and I teach in this kind of really janky, kind of creepy little theater that's to the side and like no one can really find it.
[45:54] Jess McAnally: And she gets up and she is looking at the ceiling and she's like, "Sorry, I was just looking at the ceiling. There's so many tiles up there missing."
[46:01] Jess McAnally: And I was like, "Oh yeah, I wonder how long those tiles have been missing." And then she gets up to do "Worst Pies in London," and she finishes it, and then a tile falls right next to her.
[46:11] Christi Esterle: Jeez.
[46:12] Jess McAnally: I think it was a ghost, you guys. I think it was a ghost.
[46:14] Jess McAnally: I'm not kidding. I just had to tell you that because I'm pretty sure there's a ghost. People say it's haunted, and who's to say they're wrong?
[46:22] Jess McAnally: I think the ghost heard her do "Worst Pies in London" and was like, "Yes, tile."
[46:27] Jess McAnally: Yeah, that's what I want to hear, baby.
[46:29] Christi Esterle: Yeah.
[46:30] Jess McAnally: Times is hot.
[46:33] Jess McAnally: It literally was like that. It was so creepy.
[46:36] Jess McAnally: I have video. It's weird.
[46:39] Jess McAnally: Okay, I know for I would like to see this video.
[46:42] Christi Esterle: I'll show it to you. Um, all right. On that note, you guys, this was wonderful. And I just want us to recommend one Sondheim song because we like to keep our dear friends' roots before we wrap it up. It doesn't have to be a favorite or anything, just a Sondheim song you think people would go into their weekend enjoying. Um, Emily, you're on first.
[47:01] Emily Clark: Um, okay. Well, let's go with oh my god. My mind is swimming with suggestions. Um, okay, uh, since I picked Sunday in the Park with George, um, let's go with "Move On." Um, which is one of my favorite songs Sondheim ever wrote. Um, like I said, I highly recommend the Mandy and Bernadette version. There's just something about the way Mandy Patinkin sings and the life moving on that I've never heard another guy replicate. So uh yeah, yeah. "Move On."
[47:34] Christi Esterle: Okay.
[47:35] Emily Clark: Um, geez, I'm actually gonna go with my number two on A Little Night Music just because there are so many pieces from that that I love the construction of it. I think today I'm going to go with "Wonderful," which is you know, this fantastic passive aggressive, you know, solo where they're complaining about how Desiree is so perfect, and you know, the pro that's the problem because now they can't get rid of her, you know, they can't get over her.
[48:02] Jess McAnally: Yeah.
[48:03] Emily Clark: And just the passive aggressive, sir, sir. I just love that exchange. Um, yeah.
[48:09] Christi Esterle: And I'm gonna go basic. Come on. I'm gonna go with um "I Wish I Could Forget You" from Passion. More people need to listen to Passion. It's really good, guys. It's got that brilliant, brilliant, like kind of passive aggressiveness that Sondheim loves, where she's asking uh him to write dictate a letter for her so that she forever has a letter, a love letter from him in his handwriting, and it becomes a huge plot point later. The song is also just so gorgeous and self-deprecating, and like a poor Victorian child gaslighting a man into falling in love with her. This musical is so bonkers, I love it.
[48:46] Jess McAnally: Right.
[48:46] Christi Esterle: Um, promote you guys' wonderful content for them to find. I'm sure they know about it, but give come on, give it to them. Emily, you're on first.
[48:52] Emily Clark: All right. So you can find me uh on Stealing Focus on YouTube. You can find me at Stealing Focus on YouTube. That sounds better. Uh, and uh you can find me at Emily A. B. Clark uh on all the social medias, and we also A B. It looks like Emily A B C It looks like Emily A B C Lark. And we also have a Stealing Focus Patreon. So uh check it all out, baby. I'm on there. You both are on there. So am I.
[49:24] Christi Esterle: Alright.
[49:25] Christi Esterle: I am at Musical Hell on YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr. I also do um, you know, stuff shorter videos where I just talk about cool shows or the sources behind cool shows. And yeah, have a Patreon, have a Redbubble, check me out, subscribe, buy my merch, do whatever. Just watch a video. I just love it when you watch my videos. They're good videos. They're all good videos.
[49:51] Jess McAnally: We are so blessed with video content from incredible creators like these two. When I was your age, I had nothing. There was nothing. I had to make my own garbage.
[50:04] Christi Esterle: There was nothing on the internet when I was five or whatever. There was no YouTube channels.
[50:09] Jess McAnally: Yeah, what I would go on my computers and play Paper Boy. I would play the pinball thing on the Windows app, and that would be how and I'd said thank you for it.
[50:21] Christi Esterle: Um, I host Musical So Cheese. Yeah, you know, it's on the Broadway Podcast Network. We're gonna have the Patreon. Who gives a shit? Alright, you guys. We love you, Jess.
[50:32] Jess McAnally: None of you care. None of you care. None of you care. It's not as good as their stuff, so we have fun.
[50:44] Christi Esterle: We'll see you guys next time on the Dear Friends.
[50:49] All: Dear friends, spill your woes to your musical family.
[50:54] All: Dear friends. They will take your questions and turn them into nuggets of wisdom and anecdotes in an avoid cynical world, dear friends.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
