In this very special episode of The Untold Stories of Broadway podcast, besties Jennifer Ashley Tepper and Eric William Morris dive into the fascinating history of Circle in the Square, one of Broadway's most unique theaters... Read More
From the show: The Untold Stories of Broadway
Featured Shows
About
In this very special episode of The Untold Stories of Broadway podcast, besties Jennifer Ashley Tepper and Eric William Morris dive into the fascinating history of Circle in the Square, one of Broadway's most unique theaters. While Eric has starred in Broadway shows including King Kong, Mamma Mia!, and Coram Boy, he has never played the Circle in the Square as an actor. At Circle in the Square, Eric spent years as a student... and then as the janitor! Tune in as Eric and Jennifer share stories of Spelling Bee, Godspell, Glory Days, The Norman Conquests, The Rocky Horror Show and more. Plus, what was it like to rehearse a Broadway show during the day and clean a Broadway theater at night?!
To view the slideshow of the Circle in the Square over the years, visit our YouTube page here: https://youtu.be/FAw1jSG_z4M
Produced by Dori Berinstein and Alan Seales.
A proud member of the Broadway Podcast Network.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: This is Jennifer Ashley Tepper, and you're listening to the Untold Stories of Broadway podcast.
[0:04] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Today, my guest is Eric William Morris, who's one of my very best friends and favorite actors.
[0:09] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: He's a Broadway actor who you might have seen in shows like King Kong, Coram Boy, Mamma Mia. But today we're going to be talking about some very special history he has with the Broadway house, Circle in the Square, where he had a very unique job that I'm excited for you to hear more about.
[0:44] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Hi, this is Jennifer Ashley Tepper with the Untold Stories of Broadway podcast. And I'm so excited about my guest today because he's one of my very best friends in the world, Mr. Eric William Morris.
[0:52] Eric William Morris: Oh yeah.
[0:55] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: We're so happy to be sitting here together right now. Just like it's just nice. So today we're gonna be talking about Circle in the Square Theater. And what's interesting about that that you'll learn is you know, Eric is a Broadway actor who's been in several Broadway shows at different theaters recently, King Kong, right around the corner from where we're recording at the Broadway. Eric hasn't actually played Circle in the Square, but you'll see he has a fun and storied history with it. Um and before we get into that, um, Circle in the Square, for those who don't know, was built in 1972. Um, one of the most interesting things about it to me is that really most of our Broadway theaters we've had since the early part of the 20th century.
Um, and Circle in the Square is relatively new. So Circle in the Square happened because when uh buildings were going up in Times Square rapidly in the 60s and 70s, the city issued um a rule that if you built a, you know, skyscraper of a certain level, you would get like special financial treatment if you built a theater in it. So that's how we got Circle in the Square and the Gershwin, which was then called the Urus and the Minskov. It was because um these buildings wanted the special tax treatment they would get from theaters. Um, worked out really well for us on Broadway. So yeah, isn't that cool?
[2:00] Eric William Morris: I did not know that.
[2:01] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Fun fact. Um I think we're both gonna learn things today. That's why we're here right here. So um Circle in the Square, you know, the theater company started downtown called Circle in the Square. Um, and it very much helped pioneer the off-Broadway movement. Um it was started, uh it was off Broadway. It was meant to um, you know, celebrate classic theater and classic plays and do them in the round and rep. And then when the city put up this building that Circle in the Square was in, they actually invited the theater company to like come to Broadway and and move in. Um so that's a little bit of the Circle in the Square Theater history. Um, and before we get any more of that, I just have to know, tell us about your history with Circle in the Square, Mr. Eric William Morris.
[2:39] Eric William Morris: Absolutely, Miss Jennifer Ashley Tepper. So I went to uh also another cool fun fact about Circle in the Square, it's the only Broadway theater that has a school attached to it. So I went to Circle in the Square Theater School, uh, which was started off actually uh in conjunction with NYU. You could go there and study, like um, like NYU now has Stella Adler as a part of it and Playwrights Horizons is a school within NYU. Uh Circle in the Square used to be one of those, so you could get your BFA and do a four-year program at Circle in the Square, or you could they had their own thing going on at the same time, which is uh called the Professional Acting Program, which was just a two-year intensive conservatory training without any academic uh at all.
I mean, you know, some of it's academic, but without any accredited um university attachments. It was just a place for actors to train. Uh, and so by the time I was looking to continue studying acting, because I went to Loyola College in Baltimore, I got a BA in theater, and then I was like, I'm gonna move to New York, I'm gonna be an actor, I need more training. So I looked into places and it seemed like the perfect fit for me. So I I went to the two-year professional uh actor training program. So that was uh from 2004 to 2006. Um and then after that, I kind of just like stuck around and became a part of uh like a part of the people who work there. I when I was going to school there, 25th annual Putnam County Spelling Bee was playing there, uh, which I was such a huge fan of just getting to watch it as a student.
Uh, and then they were looking for people who uh the position of a porter at a theater. Essentially, I cleaned up after the show. Uh so I got to do that, and then I stuck around there for that uh for a few years. And then I went back and did that again with the Norman Conquests. Uh, and I have been sort of like poking in and out of there for a long time. I still I just went back and talked to the students actually two weeks ago. Uh their their summer, they have a summer program as well. So I talked to the musical theater students uh about my experience. So I've just been a part of them for a long time.
[4:34] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, I love that. We're gonna get into that more, but one thing um I also thought it was interesting. There's actually been a history of Circle in the Square students that have played the theater. Like Philip Seymour Hoffman was a Circle in the Square student, and he made his Broadway debut in True West at Circle. What a Broadway debut. That's the coolest thing.
[4:48] Eric William Morris: Yeah, yeah.
[4:49] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: It's so cool. So um one thing I always found interesting, I worked on Godspell at the theater in 2011, 2012, and it's so crazy to walk in during the day, and there's like students warming up and like, you know, dancing, and then a couple hours later it's a Broadway theater.
[5:01] Eric William Morris: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And they they've changed the architecture of it a little bit where the the school offices used to be in the lobby of the theater. They've since been like, you know what, let's put the school underneath there's a basement level where all the classrooms are. So they switched it around so the students are mostly down there. But when I was going there, uh, there's a little locker area where people can put their coats when they're going to see a show or their bags, and that was where we'd just like hang out. So on early mat on early days and and in matinees on Wednesdays and stuff, we would just kind of be like, oh God, we gotta all move so that you can do a Broadway show here. Uh yeah.
And that's one thing like you taught me that I thought was so interesting was and uh apparently, and I don't know if this is still the case, when uh shows at Circle in the Square used the deck to like move a set piece up and down, the Shakespeare class would be interrupted because.
[5:51] Eric William Morris: That's like crazy.
[5:52] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: People don't think of Broadway as like interacting with and of course Circle is really unique because it's a school, but even you know, at the St. James the offices, you know, or the Stubert has the offices. So certain Broadway theaters have that dynamic, like especially the Wednesday matinees.
[6:04] Eric William Morris: Yeah, and so room 110 and room 103 are directly underneath the stage. So when something is happening and you're underneath it, like I used to remember going down there and during the uh the number pandemonium in Spelling Bee, everybody was jumping up and down on the stage and there was a rope swing that came out, and so you'd be in class, or I'd be down there by myself trying to learn lines for something while I was working, and you just hear like what is oh right, pandemonium, got it.
[6:29] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: That's amazing.
[6:29] Eric William Morris: Yeah, it's a fun thing to be a part of. So let's dig more into the space for people who like you know don't know it as well. Um it has those vomitoriums, which is like what you call, you know, the spaces where you walk into the stage. Um so Circle in the Square can be um in the round or it can be like a thrust. It's probably the only Broadway theater that you can do. You could do whatever you want with it, which is really cool. Pretty unique. Like how um and also near the lockers that you were talking about, you can kind of go um hit a door and then you're like backstage in the school or backstage, period. Or like in in uh when when Ted Mann, who who founded it was still there, that was his office. You'd be like, Oh, I'm I just walked into the president's office. Right by the bathroom. Yes, don't do it. If you go see a show though, be respectful.
[7:08] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, don't. Um, are there other things about like the theater space itself that people wouldn't know unless they know it as well as you?
[7:13] Eric William Morris: Uh yeah, yeah, yeah. There's there's uh there's a bunch of really cool things about it. Um, something that just popped in my head when you talked about the vomitoriums. Um, when they did um uh Rocky Horror Show there, uh Dick Cavett was the original narrator for that. And so there's an area right above the vomitorium where you can stand and there's no seats, and that was where they positioned him. So it's referred to by everybody in the school as a Dick Cavett box. So, like when somebody's like, Oh, put them up there. Because another cool thing about the space uh is that the space, the people like the administrators and the people who own the theater get along in a really wonderful way where they let the students use the stage to put on their student productions at the end of the year.
So, you know, you can during Spelling Bee, it was it was thrust, it wasn't full in the square. That's what they did with Spelling Bee, and there was a cutout on the stage that looked like um that looked like a school gymnasium, right? But they didn't want us scuffing up the thing, so we cut out carpet that fit the stage perfectly and rolled it out and did Waiting for Lefty and the Mousetrap and Saturday night, sometimes Saturday night on that stage. You know, we had two shows Monday and one Tuesday morning, and then it was like get everything off the stage because they need to do a show on Tuesday night. Um yeah, and then the entire another thing that people wouldn't know sitting there, uh, is that yeah, there is a full school two floors below where they're sitting that are there's about seven or eight classrooms uh and a full administrative office that's underneath there.
[8:40] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Uh yeah. And is it you'd probably know this actually, because you know a lot about the Gershwin theater as well. The Gershwin, is it underneath that parking garage?
[8:50] Eric William Morris: No, it's right next to it. And one of the things I always find really interesting about Circle, I spent years being like, there has to be a way to get to the Gershwin. And I asked everyone, and you know, it when Steven Schwartz is like, there's no way while you're working on Godspell to get from Godspell to Books. I'm like, I believe you, Steven. Um, so but you can get to um the I don't know what it's called now. It's like the cafe on the corner of 51st and Broadway that was a co see for a very long time and not something else. Um I'm obsessed with that space because I never went to Mars 2112, but it's like that was kind of where Mars 2112 was. But for many years, um, that was where Luch House was.
Luch House was like one of the most famous um, you know, theater restaurants of all time. For like a century, it was uh in Union Square, and like back when the Broadway theaters were in Union Square, and then it moved to right there, and they had like Broadway opening nights there, and you actually can get to that restaurant if you go out a door in the Circle in the Square lobby.
[9:39] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[9:39] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um it was also something called the pub theatrical for years, but um, yeah, this was something that I got to like research in my book. I love all the like, you know, obviously the restaurants and the stuff that's connected. That's but you can't get to the Gershwin.
[9:50] Eric William Morris: No, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[9:51] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, and then and yeah, I think those two theaters are like very isolated even though they're right next to each other.
[9:55] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[9:56] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah. It's weird.
[9:57] Eric William Morris: Um, so getting a little bit more into Spelling Bee, like what was that like working there during that time?
[10:03] Eric William Morris: It was it was such an education for me because I was in I was in my second year, and so my job was so as a porter, right? There was two separate porter positions on that on that show, where one person who was kind of like the lead person, uh, would work with a house manager, and they would take care of everything backstage and make sure everything was going okay. And then the job that I started doing was the infrared hearing aid devices, uh, for people who need assisted hearing devices. Part of my job was to uh hand them out to people and like you know make sure that they gave them back at the end of the show. So that's what I did before the show. And then during the show, I was free to do whatever I wanted.
And then after the show, I went in and I cleaned up the theater uh with a garbage bag and rubber gloves, and it took a couple of hours every day. But um because of Jose Lana's. Because of Jose Lana's because of my unfortunate erection, he would walk around the theater throwing candy at everybody, and it was hilarious. And look, it was incredible. But then I'd be like, Okay, so there's Skittles over there today, and I gotta go right, the gummy berries are over there. Um but but I ended up the special thing about it was I ended up seeing the show probably over 70 times because I I wanted to see it, and then what I realized, what I realized, what's like pretty well known about the show is that they developed it.
Uh the actors, the uh the most of the original cast members that developed it sort of like as an improv um exercise, and then they started developing it, and then they brought you know Bill Finn along to write the music afterwards. So a lot of these people have been working with these characters for years, and they were so so in tune with each other and good at it. And and they a part of the show is they would invite audience members up on stage to be a part of the spelling bee, like five audience members. So I got to see in the lobby when they picked the audience members, the audience members would go in and then the actors would file in through the lobby, and they'd each get pieces of paper about the person, the people the people in the audience, and like uh and how to like kind of riff off of who they were and what they looked like. So I got to see a new show every night, which was really cool.
[12:02] Eric William Morris: Spelling Bee was so special. I was so it's it was the longest running show ever at Circle.
[12:07] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, it ran for quite a long time.
[12:09] Eric William Morris: Um and really, you know, because Circle started with the theater company whose focus was on plays. Only I think 13 musicals have ever played Circle, and um at the time of Spelling Bee, it was obviously even less. So I think Spelling Bee really showed people like, you know, how to do a good musical in the space. Um the first musical to ever play there was Where's Charlie starring Raoul Julia? And I love Raoul Julia, so that's a fun fact. Um, but Spelling Bee was definitely the first show I saw there. And like, I mean, I didn't see it 70 times because I didn't work there, but I saw quite a few, and it was like everyone in that show was so special. That show was so great.
[12:41] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: So wonderful. And when one of them left to do something, like Jesse Tyler Ferguson got a sitcom and left, and his last performance, like you saw him go through it. Like this is the last time I'm doing this. He gets his little juice box at the end and he walks off stage, and you saw them all like really support each other.
[12:58] Eric William Morris: Such a tight-knit cast. I got to interview that a couple of them for my book. My one sad thing about Spelling Bee is I was always convinced that I was gonna be Marigold Coney Bear. Because you know how like pick someone to like sing to, and I'm like, I have red hair, and I was always on those front row student rush seats, and I was like, I never got to be.
[13:07] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Never got you never got how many times did you see it?
[13:19] Eric William Morris: I think I saw it like six or seven, probably. It's one of those shows that you absolutely get more from every time.
[13:22] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Totally.
[13:23] Eric William Morris: And the secret weapon of that, I mean, and this was a cool thing that Sarah Salzberg told me about, was you know, uh, Wendy Wasserstein, Sarah Salzberg was her nanny, and Wendy was best friends with Bill Finn and like kind of brought that up. That's how that was. Isn't that crazy?
[13:34] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Oh, that is so cool.
[13:36] Eric William Morris: Secret weapon.
[13:37] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah. So how um how what happened next? Like, so you're the porter at Circle.
[13:41] Eric William Morris: Yes.
[13:44] Eric William Morris: Um tell me about what I'm saying. So I'm the porter at Circle for a number of months. Uh, and I my shifts were Tuesday, Thursday, and then all day Sunday, because they had two shows, and I used to have to come in the morning and clean uh the bathrooms and the lobby and vacuum everything, and that was like a three-hour job. So my Sundays were like get in at 11, work for three hours, the theater opens, clean it after the matinee, uh do and then do it again for the second show and clean it. Pardon me. And then clean it after the second show. Uh so that was my my gig for Gee. Over a year, yeah. And then I ended up um getting my first Broadway show, uh, which was called Coram Boy. Uh and so I got cast in that and I was so excited about it.
Uh, but it happened so fast because I I got cast to understudy three different roles, and they were they had started the first week of rehearsal and I was jumping in the next week. So I I didn't want to just abandon my job, so I put in my two weeks' notice for so for a couple weeks I was I was rehearsing my Broadway debut during the day, and then I'd go in and clean up after the other show at night for a couple of weeks, which uh I have to say, no, it's like you know, I've interviewed a lot of people, I've grilled a lot of people about their theater histories.
[14:53] Eric William Morris: I have never heard of anyone doing that. So I don't want to say you're the only person because I don't know. There might be someone else, but I don't know of anyone else that was cleaning a Broadway theater and then also rehearsing a Broadway show. It was a very exciting time, but also, you know, I mean, talk about immersing yourself in something. You know, I really I moved to New York and I wanted to be an actor and I studied at a school that was associated with a Broadway theater, and then I got to watch one as I worked there and then audition for them, and now I'm rehearsing one and then cleaning up after one. It was yeah, it was very cool.
[15:24] Eric William Morris: Yeah, I'll take that. I'm sure somebody else has done it before, but let's say I'm the only one.
[15:28] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, yeah.
[15:29] Eric William Morris: We'll find it.
[15:30] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Okay.
[15:30] Eric William Morris: Um rare, definitely rare.
[15:31] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah.
[15:32] Eric William Morris: Um, so what happened next? Like, what was the Coram Boy experience?
[15:35] Eric William Morris: Coram Boy was great. It was I it was an incredible experience. It ran for a little over a month. Um, and so I started rehearsing in like February. We opened the beginning of May, and we're kind of closed by the end of May. And then I was back at Spelling Bee.
[15:54] Eric William Morris: Yeah, and then I did that again for a while because it ran for a little bit longer than that. Um, but Coram Boy was fantastic, it was at the Imperial Theater. Um, and it was uh originally a production by the National Theater over in London. Um, and it was an incredible story where there were 40 people, there were 40 people in the cast, and it wasn't a musical, right? So there were 20 people in the playing principal roles, and a lot of them were playing many different roles, and then there were 20 other people in an on-stage choir.
[16:23] Eric William Morris: Uh and it had a lot to do with Handel's Messiah, was built in and out of the story. Um, and so the people in the choir would sing parts of Handel's Messiah. So I was in the choir, but I was also one of five people in the choir who was hired to understudy three or four different tracks of the principal actors.
[16:39] Eric William Morris: So I was on stage every night in like this sort of loft over the stage watching the show, and at the same time I was like singing my role. I was trying to learn the three other tracks of the thing. Uh and it was it was so exciting and one of my favorite experiences, absolutely. It was also terrifying because I was right out of school and it was one of these things where I had to learn three different British accents for it, like three different regional British accents for these three different roles, and I never got to go on for any three for uh any of them.
[17:10] Eric William Morris: Uh which you know, I wish I could have, but at the same time, I don't know if I don't know. I don't know what would happen. It would have been great.
[17:17] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, it just would the whole show would have stopped.
[17:18] Eric William Morris: I would have been great. It was such a cool show.
[17:20] Eric William Morris: And I Jan Maxwell and Uzo Aduba and so many people.
[17:25] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yes, so Bill Camp was so great.
[17:26] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[17:27] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um not to like directly tie it back to Circle, but I remember because Uzo was in Godspell, um, and when the opening night tradition came around of like getting notes from the other shows, and we got Follies, and Jan Maxwell had written like a huge note to Uzo, and I was like, Yeah, Coram Boy, and also just I was a big Jan Maxwell fan.
[17:43] Eric William Morris: Yes, it's way what an incredible.
[17:45] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: They were so great in that show.
[17:46] Eric William Morris: Yeah, they were, and they're also just the kindest people in the world.
[17:48] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah.
[17:49] Eric William Morris: I'll never forget Uzo when we got our closing notice. She like didn't know that we were closing and came out on stage five minutes after we got our closing notice. And she was like, What is the meeting for, guys? And we were all like, uh, we're done next week.
[18:03] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah, that's like a memory I remember very specifically because we were all like, oh God, Uzo wasn't here for somebody's gonna have to break it to her.
[18:11] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[18:12] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: People don't Broadway's crazy.
[18:13] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[18:14] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um, that actually, and I again did not even mean to directly tie it back in, but one of my craziest circle memories is um I was a student at NYU walking by Circle in the Square to go see a show at Encores the day after Glory Days opened. And at the time, not knowing that it had closed.
[18:30] Eric William Morris: So I walked by in the and I knew, you know, like I was a theater nerd, I knew everything going on. I had seen Glory Days in Previews, and I didn't really know Nick Blaemire at the time. And I walked by as they were all getting to the lobby and finding out that their show wasn't good.
[18:43] Eric William Morris: And I like saw, I saw that a little bit, um, which just actually is so crazy. Those are some of the craziest, craziest moments is like, you know, you're just waiting, open-ended thing, and then it's like meeting on stage 45 minutes before a curtain, and you just that's that.
[19:00] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I know.
[19:00] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[19:01] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Theater is nuts.
[19:02] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[19:02] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um, it's interesting though, there are so many like musicals that I feel like are so important that played Circle. You know, Glory Days being one of them, and obviously Spelling Bee being one of them, but I remember being so obsessed with that Rocky Horror Show last recording.
[19:16] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[19:16] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um, I never got to see it, but I did get to interview a few people about it. And actually, I'm gonna read. Um, you have a story to read later, but I'm gonna read us some Raul Esparza about that Rocky Horror Show.
[19:28] Eric William Morris: Oh, that is awesome by um He was Riff Raff.
[19:31] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yes.
[19:31] Eric William Morris: Um, that cast recording is unbelievable.
[19:34] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I have not heard it.
[19:35] Eric William Morris: Oh my god, you will actually love it. Because I love that show, and I've seen a lot of different productions of it, but I've not heard that cast recording.
[19:40] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um, I was obsessed with it, and interviewing Raul was cool because he's one of the people I've interviewed where like he knows everyone who's ever been in a Broadway dressing room that he's been like he's like a super nerd.
[19:49] Eric William Morris: Nice.
[19:50] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um, but I think you'll get that from this.
[19:51] Eric William Morris: Good.
[19:51] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Okay.
[19:53] Eric William Morris: The first Broadway show I ever saw was Broadway Bound at the Broadhurst, and the first Broadway musical I ever saw was Into the Woods at the Martin Beck, which is now the Hirschfeld.
[20:01] Eric William Morris: I guess you know you're getting older when you call the theaters by their old names.
[20:04] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I sentimentally called Neil Simon the Alvin all the time, just because that's what the characters call it in Merrily We Roll Along.
[20:10] Eric William Morris: I know.
[20:11] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: It gets worse.
[20:13] Eric William Morris: I'm from Miami, and during my senior year of high school, I had come to visit some friends at Columbia University where I'd applied. I wanted to see Les Mis, but it was sold out, so I ended up seeing Broadway Bound.
[20:23] Eric William Morris: I remember thinking how small the Broadhurst seemed after being used to giant touring houses in Florida. I also remember Elizabeth Franz, who was spellbinding. Jonathan Silverman was in that show, and later on we did an episode of Law and Order together.
[20:33] Eric William Morris: So I got to tell him you were in the very first Broadway show I saw. You inspired me.
[20:38] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: When people say that to me now, I feel two things. I feel old, and I feel incredibly lucky to be part of that line.
[20:43] Eric William Morris: That's something you really feel in the theater, that strong sense of passing things down from generation to generation. You don't feel that with film and television work unless maybe you're on a legendary sound stage, like the old Warner Brothers lot, where you can say, Wow, this is where they shot Casablanca.
[20:57] Eric William Morris: The theater has a whole different sense of energy because wherever you go, you know. Look at what used to be done here. Look what I'm a part of. I've always felt a little like theater is a religious event. There's a sacred space between the actors and a sacred space between the audience and the actors.
[21:11] Eric William Morris: And what's sacred isn't the stage or the house, it's the space between people and the energy that lives there. The theater is a conversation. I can come up with a performance in my living room, but it doesn't matter if it doesn't bounce off other people.
[21:22] Eric William Morris: These theaters are the places where, for a century, conversations have happened. In theater, you're engaging with audience members who are right in front of you and you feel them. Whether it's a show like Rocky Horror, where they are responding vocally and physically, or a show where they're quietly listening, there's a human connection happening.
[21:37] Eric William Morris: And you can meet that person afterward at the stage door. You can see them walking down the block. Theater is unlike anything else for that reason. And Broadway is that. Plus, it's this incredible conglomeration of multiple spaces that house so much human energy every night.
[21:50] Eric William Morris: You know that within 10 or so blocks, so many people are having the same experience at the same time. The buildings seem to have a history of their own that the walls hang on to. I think each theater feels haunted in a good way by the shows that came before.
[22:01] Eric William Morris: During Rocky Horror Show, Jared Emmick said to me, if you want to get psyched and remember why you're here, walk through Schubert Alley every day on your way to work. I did, and every day I would see those posters of which shows were happening simultaneously with ours.
[22:13] Eric William Morris: I'd see people going to every show on Broadway, audience members and theater folks. I was in some way part of that, even though I wasn't in all of the shows. Every night I would remember that I was part of a town where theater had been done for over a century, and that's a lot to live up to.
[22:25] Eric William Morris: And while there are walls dividing us, every night at 8:05, all the curtains go up and all of these different stories are happening at once. Right now, where we are, I can see Phantom of the Opera and Bullets Over Broadway and Mamma Mia and Matilda, and tonight they'll all happen within a few feet of each other.
[22:39] Eric William Morris: There's an almost carnival atmosphere to it. The Rocky Horror Show was the first show I performed in on Broadway. The director, Christopher Ashley, said that part of the reason they hired me is because I sounded the most like Janis Joplin at the audition.
[22:51] Eric William Morris: Doing that voice eight times a week was insane. So while I was doing Rocky Horror Show, I really had to scream, sing or not sing at all. There was no middle voice available to me. At first I was scared of the show. I didn't understand the whole transvestite thing.
[23:04] Eric William Morris: I had seen Rocky Horror in Miami and it frightened me. Then after I got into it, I completely fell in love with it. Now I've done many shows where I've had to cross-dress, and it doesn't faze me. I learned first from Rocky Horror that cross-dressing on stage is all about power.
[23:16] Eric William Morris: Sexual power and also the power you get from playing with audience expectations about gender. You don't know how that's going to play on Broadway, but the uglier and more exposed you are, the more power you have over the audience. It can make you feel incredibly strong on stage.
[23:28] Eric William Morris: Rocky Horror is such a fun, sweet show, but you do have that undercurrent of the dark side of power. The backstage of Circle in the Square doesn't really feel like a theater. There's an industrial, almost jail-like quality to it.
[23:39] Eric William Morris: Plus you're underground, so there's no fresh air or light. It has a fortress-like quality which can get to you, but there's a lot to love about it too. It's such an intimate theater like the ones I was used to performing in regionally. 700 seats feels manageable.
[23:51] Eric William Morris: The last row is only a few feet away. You can really connect to the audience. For Rocky Horror, it was perfect. I was also surprised by how malleable the theater is. Every time I've seen a show there since, the space has changed.
[24:01] Eric William Morris: Our designer David Rockwell went all out and put mannequin body parts and red fabric on the walls, creating this old movie theater atmosphere. Circle in the Square may not have the grandeur and beauty that some of the other Broadway houses have, but there are things about it that are great.
[24:14] Eric William Morris: It can be a very transformative, exciting black box. I'll never forget Rocky Horror's Final Dress. It was one of the most exciting performances I've ever been at. It was less than a week before my 30th birthday, and I was feeling pretty buzzy that I was about to make my Broadway debut, and I didn't know how it would go.
[24:28] Eric William Morris: Rehearsals were very different from any other show I'd worked on, and I was really nervous. The people in that cast are among the finest people I've ever worked with. Leah Delaria and I did Broadway on Broadway together before we'd even started rehearsals, so she heard me sing before anyone else did.
[24:41] Eric William Morris: When I performed Time Warp for the first time in rehearsal, the whole cast jumped up, and Leah was like, What did I tell you? Who is this guy? The whole cast was so supportive of it being my Broadway debut, and going into that dress rehearsal, I just really wanted to show everyone what I could do.
[24:54] Eric William Morris: We hit the Circle in the Square stage for our final dress rehearsal, and nobody knew what to expect. We had been directed to perform the show like it was a train that just would not stop at the station, so the audience couldn't jump in.
[25:04] Eric William Morris: They had all brought their props, like they were going to see the movie version, and they were going to participate. There was toast flung and toilet paper thrown and all these things that were eventually banned because they were unsafe. The people at our dress rehearsal were total diehard fans.
[25:16] Eric William Morris: They were dressed up and they were going crazy for us. Jerry Mitchell gave me the best first entrance any actor could ever hope for. During Over at the Frankenstein Place, I rose up through the middle of the cast singing.
[25:26] Eric William Morris: Our musical director had created an obligato line that wasn't in the score for Riff Raff to hit a high B. And that was the moment when the whole set collapsed on itself. The proscenium smashed, the floor started to turn, the floodlights blinded the audience, the audience lost their minds.
[25:39] Eric William Morris: They started screaming like they were at a rock concert. I thought, holy shit, this is Broadway. Then I got to do Time Warp, and that blew off the place, blew the roof off the place even more. That dress rehearsal was the first time I performed on Broadway, and it was unforgettable.
[25:52] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Wow.
[25:53] Eric William Morris: Oh man.
[25:55] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Wow.
[25:55] Eric William Morris: That like he really paints the picture. Because I just was obsessed with that recording and like listening to that, I'm like, oh, I can picture that production.
[26:01] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I've never like watched a video of it or anything.
[26:03] Eric William Morris: So many things about me hit me that about that just hit me in such a great way. First of all, they made his Broadway debut when he was 30 makes me feel real good.
[26:10] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I know.
[26:11] Eric William Morris: It's you forget about that too.
[26:12] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I mean, look, we were just talking about Bill Finn, who, you know, didn't make his Broadway debut as a writer until later too. It's like there are those stories by some of our favorite artists.
[26:20] Eric William Morris: Oh my god, yeah.
[26:21] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah.
[26:21] Eric William Morris: That's fantastic.
[26:22] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Also, I love that the, you know, when that he feels such a sense of history that he goes up to people who are like, You were part of my first experience on Broadway.
[26:30] Eric William Morris: I do that to people all the time.
[26:33] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah.
[26:33] Eric William Morris: Who have you done that to?
[26:35] Eric William Morris: Um, I won't leave Bradley Dean alone about it.
[26:39] Eric William Morris: Bradley Dean, who's this incredible uh actor singer, who actually ended up giving me a few voice lessons. Uh, he's in um Bat Out of Hell right now. I think it just closed like yesterday.
[26:48] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Um but he was I went to go see Man of La Mancha, the Brian Stokes Mitchell uh one in 2002.
[26:58] Eric William Morris: Um and I was in college, I was at Loyola, and I was playing Don Quixote in my production at Loyola, and so for Christmas, my mom got me tickets to go see it.
[27:06] Eric William Morris: So we went to go see it, and we got to the theater and it was a matinee. And because um Brian Stokes Mitchell name was above the title, they had to come out before because he wasn't in that day.
[27:15] Eric William Morris: And they were like, hey, uh, if you want your money back, you can have it, or you can come see another show. And my mom and I were like, Well, we gotta see it. You know, we can't come back into the city for this because I grew up in New Jersey and now I was gonna go back to college soon.
[27:26] Eric William Morris: So we're like, great, we'll see it. And I saw like a mid to late 20s Bradley Dean play the role, and I was completely blown away by him because I was like 20 and I was like, This this is incredible that this guy is doing this.
[27:42] Eric William Morris: And then, fast forward to like the first reading I was ever cast in as a professional actor, is a musical about John Dillinger. I got to rehearsal and he was playing John Dillinger.
[27:51] Eric William Morris: And I was in a cast with like six other people, and I was just like, Hey, hey man, I have to like I have to like tell you something. And I told him the whole story. He's like, Oh, that's really great. I've like recalled that story to him about 15 times.
[28:02] Eric William Morris: Because I've gone on to do a bunch of different things with him.
[28:05] Eric William Morris: Um, and and so has my wife, Elise was in uh A New Brain with him. Like, I know him quite well now, but I must have told him that story like six times.
[28:13] Eric William Morris: And when somebody else doesn't know him, and they're in a cast with us, I'm like, you don't know what I know about this man right here.
[28:20] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: I think I embarrass him a lot.
[28:21] Eric William Morris: But I have such a sense of that when I see somebody who it almost was like a different life before I moved to New York. Like one of the I maybe saw seven or eight Broadway shows before I moved here, which seems crazy now that there was so few, but that when I see somebody that was a part of that, I like need to tell them.
[28:39] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Yeah.
[28:40] Eric William Morris: Yeah.
[28:43] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Thank you for listening to the Untold Stories of Broadway podcast, part one with today's guest, Eric William Morris. Stay tuned for part two of more exciting stories about Circle in the Square.
[28:53] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: Thank you to our producer Dori Berinstein, our editor Alan Seales, my publishers of The Untold Stories of Broadway, Barista Trincaro and Roberta Pereira, Zach Zadek for that theme music, and thank you to all of you for listening to the podcast.
[29:06] Jennifer Ashley Tepper: You can buy the Untold Stories in book version on Amazon.com.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
