Skip to main content
BPN Logo
2020 Tony Award Nominees with Broadway’s Nate Patten

On this special bonus episode all about the recent Tony Award Nominations, I’m so happy to introduce music director, conductor, and fellow podcaster Nate Patton. Nate and I first met when he was associate conducting Charlie and the Chocolate Factory on Broadway... Read More

From the show: Why I‘ll Never Make It

45 mins
11/2/20

Featured Shows

About

On this special bonus episode all about the recent Tony Award Nominations, I’m so happy to introduce music director, conductor, and fellow podcaster Nate Patton. Nate and I first met when he was associate conducting Charlie and the Chocolate Factory on Broadway. And his podcast called Booked It.

The title to one of his episodes was “Broadway is broken and I alone can fix it.” And it's this kind of witty, tongue in cheek and knowledgeable opinions that I wanted to bring on the show as we talk about these Tony nominations:

  • The lone best actor nomination of Aaron Tveit
  • The complete snubbing of the lightning thief
  • Only plays being nominated for best original score

Nate and I will also get into these topics and more, including what these nominations in general say about the state of theater today, and even make a few Tony predictions.

Support WINMI and get access to a members-only private podcast feed.

Join the monthly WINMI Newsletter by going to whyillnevermakeit.com

Music in this episode provided by Chad Crouch and Admiral Bob.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Unknown Speaker: CFOs and controllers, there's a better way to manage cards, expenses, travel, and reimbursements. You need a unified spend platform from Brex that lets you control all your spend in one place, automate compliance, and close the books faster. Get started at Brex.com.

[0:20] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, well, surprise, surprise. Here I am today with a bonus episode all about the recent Tony Award nominations. Just consider this an early Christmas present. And actually, there will be some Christmas goodies coming your way this holiday season. To stay up to date with all things podcast happenings, you can join the WINMI Newsletter by going to why I'll never make it.com. I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, host of this podcast, and I am so happy to introduce you to music director, conductor, and fellow podcaster Nate Patton. Nate and I first met when he was associate conducting Charlie and the Chocolate Factory on Broadway’s. He also has his own podcast called Booked It.

[1:12] Nate Patton: I have joined the Broadway’s community so that the powerful can no longer beat up on people who cannot defend themselves. Nobody knows Broadway’s better than me, which is why I alone can fix it.

[1:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: And this is the kind of witty, tongue-in-cheek, and knowledgeable opinions that I wanted to bring on the show today to talk about these Tony nominations: the lone best actor nomination of Aaron Tveit, the complete snubbing of The Lightning Thief, and only plays being nominated for best original score. Nate and I will get into all of this as well as what the nominations in general say about the state of theater today, and we'll even make a few Tony predictions. Alright, so let's get down to it. Here is Nate Patton and myself giving our two cents on the 2020 Tony Award nominations.

[2:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, why don't we start off with just kind of the general overview? What was your general impression of the nominations when they came out? The timing, just what was your overall thought?

[2:20] Nate Patton: Well, first of all, they came out so late. Because they, um, well, I mean, obviously they were supposed to come out, you know, they would come out in May or something, but I'm saying even after they announced that there would be a Tony Awards, they made this big announcement over the summer. They said the Tonys will be in the fall, and then just there were months of radio silence. Nothing. So nothing. So already off the bat, I was like, are they even gonna do this? I was thinking that they were just gonna like pretend they never said it. So when they finally made the announcement, I said I was almost surprised they even actually did them. I thought there was a good possibility that they were just gonna scrap the Tonys altogether.

[3:02] Nate Patton: So when they came out, um, I think I said this on my own podcast. I'm normally so in touch with this stuff. I was always following the Tonys. I always, I, you know, I wake up to watch them normally. And this year, someone texted me at 11 a.m. on that day, and they said, you know, the Tony nominations come out at noon. And I said, they do? It was that no one knew. It was the first time in my life, uh, probably since I was a baby, that I didn't follow the nominations. So I think they were just so under the radar this year because of everything.

[3:38] Nate Patton: Well, I think that that also goes to the fact that they still don't even know when the Tonys are happening. They're like maybe December or like they don't, they're, I'm not sure exactly what they're waiting for since they're gonna be on Zoom. Are they waiting for Aaron Tveit's internet service to get fixed?

[3:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh my gosh.

[3:59] Nate Patton: Oh my gosh. They're not, it's not like they're waiting on Radio City.

[4:02] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, well, well, let's, I mean, since you brought up Mr. Tveit, let's just go ahead and go with that. So there is only one nomination for best actor. Is there ever? I was looking back, I think it was the uh, the 95 Tonys. The 95 Tonys are similar in a lot of ways to this one in the fact that there was only two best actress awards.

[4:24] Nate Patton: Nominees.

[4:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: Nominees, that's what, yeah, that's what I mean. It was Glenn Close and Rebecca Lucre.

[4:30] Nate Patton: Go ahead.

[4:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: It was a little worse then, I suppose, because at least we have the pandemic as an excuse as to why there's no nominees. Right. They had two nominees and they didn't have a coronavirus outbreak. So that was just a bad year of theater. This wasn't necessarily a bad year of theater, it was just this is just what happened. Now, what are your thoughts on that whole cutoff date of February 19th? It seemed very arbitrary to me, but they, you know, their line is well, we want to make sure that all of our voting members could have seen these shows.

[5:04] Nate Patton: I have racked my brain personally for a reason behind that exact cutoff date, and I can't find one. I've also asked everyone I've ever met in the business, where did that cutoff date come from? I've yet to hear an answer. Maybe there is one. I'm not saying they don't have a good reason because I don't want to be corrected like I just had no idea. But I, I, I'm not sure where that date came from. All I know is that it was the day before West Side Story would be eligible.

[5:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[5:28] Nate Patton: So had they done the 20th instead of the 19th, West Side Story would be eligible. So there was obviously a reason for that. It's hard for me to not imagine that West Side Story's eligibility was not in one way or another where the date came from.

[5:43] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yes.

[5:43] Nate Patton: Because it was so specific. The date that they even picked was in the middle of a week. It made no sense to me. So if you're asking my gut instinct, I do think it was based around either a distaste for people involved in West Side Story or controversy surrounding it. And yeah, I don't know. I'm not gonna, I'm not here to make that call, but it's really hard for me to think that it, there wasn't some personal investment in the date.

[6:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, for whatever reason, whether it was artistic or personal, the, uh, it, it, I think it would just be a very weird coincidence if they just picked happened to pick the day before West Side Story would be eligible.

[6:27] Nate Patton: So yeah, yeah. So obviously I, I think you're right that that had something to do with it. But, but also that would have meant it would have been the only potential nominee for revival. So then that would have meant that it would have likely have won outright. I suppose much like Aaron Tveit might win outright. I mean, let's hope he wins, because if he does, if, if he doesn't win, what a slap in the face to him.

[6:49] Patrick Oliver Jones: I know, and this is what I wanted to ask you because okay, this is just a weird year. I also think that it's, uh, that there should have been other nominees. They should have found a way that may, but I agree. Do you think that voters should or would take a stand and not vote Aaron Tveit to get the award since he's the only nominee, since this is a weird season, since there's so many shows that aren't eligible?

[7:18] Nate Patton: Well, I, I certainly can't speak for anybody else, but what I can say is that if I were fortunate enough to be a Tony voter, I would definitely give him the award. If I were voting myself, I would.

[7:28] Patrick Oliver Jones: Okay.

[7:29] Nate Patton: Um, for a few reasons. First of all, I, I think he was really good in the show. But second of all, it's just, it would be truly a slap in the face to not award him, I think, because you can't fault him for being in this precarious situation.

[7:47] Patrick Oliver Jones: Definitely not his fault.

[7:48] Nate Patton: It's, it's just, it would, I feel like all it would just be a really embarrassing, humiliating situation to him if he lost a Tony to himself. So I would never want, I don't think anybody should be subjected to that humiliation, especially when this isn't his fault. Like he did, it's, he had nothing to do with this. So why, why should he be publicly humiliated by becoming the person who lost a Tony to himself? With that said, if they had nominated somebody that I really felt was, it was ridiculous that that person was nominated for a Tony, whether because of the size of their role, you know, for whatever reason, then maybe I wouldn't vote for them. But in this particular instance, I would vote for, I would, I would vote to give him the Tony because remember, he has to get 60% of the vote, right?

[8:35] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[8:35] Nate Patton: So they do legitimately have to vote for him to give it to him. So if he doesn't reach the 60% threshold, then he doesn't. And, and, and you talk about a slap in the face, and I think the biggest one goes to The Lightning Thief, which got no nominations. It also was the only original musical within that eligible season, as they gave it, and wasn't nominated for original score. Basically, just nothing. Now, what are your thoughts on that?

[9:05] Nate Patton: I mean, my thoughts are that it would never have been nominated if it was in the regular season. Well, uh, because it wasn't even nominated this time. So, but I, I've said that it is a big slap in the face to them. And I suppose it's just that it just sucks for The Lightning Thief. I don't necessarily think that anyone did wrong to The Lightning Thief. I don't necessarily think that The Lightning Thief deserved 12 Tony nominations. But I do think that it was just, it just was an unfortunately embarrassing situation for them. If all the other shows had been not been eligible and they didn't get any nominations, that might be disappointing, but it wouldn't be humiliating. I think the, because there was no competition and they still didn't get any nominations, that was really embarrassing for them.

And I feel bad for them because it's, it's, I've looked, I've been a part of shows that didn't get nominated for anything, but in a big season, and you know it, you're like, oh, whatever, but it's not humiliating because there were other great shows. It's just that in this particular year there was no other competition, so it's really embarrassing, I think.

[10:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I never got to see the show. I was out of town whenever it was playing this last December. But yes, it got very mixed to bad reviews as far as the Broadway’s production. The off-Broadway production got rave reviews. However, once it moved to Broadway’s, then it didn't fare so well. Not sure how that makes any sense, but unless it's being reviewed by different people. Or maybe they just did some weird changes that literally blew up when they went to Broadway’s. But, um, but I did read that the lead character himself did get some fairly good reviews within the context of a badly reviewed show. Now, do you think that he at least could have been pulled out? I mean, it would have given Aaron Tveit some competition, quote unquote.

[10:54] Nate Patton: I didn't see The Lightning Thief either. So, which is why I'm really just speaking about this hypothetically about it being a slap in the face as opposed to weighing in my opinion. So I really can't, I can't weigh in on how good somebody's performance was if I didn't see the show. I'm not gonna be the person. People do this a surprising amount, they'll be like, oh, well, you know it was terrible. I'm like, okay, well, did you see it? No. But I'm like, but don't say it was terrible, and don't say it was good either. You know, I, but I do stand by that this is a Tony award, it should carry with it a great distinction and a very high honor. And I don't think it should be given to someone by default.

[11:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: So, uh, if they don't think that this person was deserving of a Tony nomination, then I say good for them for holding up the standard. Now, do you think that this year's award, though, are gonna hold that standard, or do you think that all of these awards, like Aaron Tveit's will get an asterisk next to it?

[11:51] Nate Patton: I don't know. I think that whether there's an asterisk next to it or a proverbial asterisk next to it will be a different thing. That's a great question because why would they put an asterisk next to it? I mean, I know why, but that doesn't seem fair to someone who was deserving of the Tony anyway.

[12:13] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[12:14] Nate Patton: I can think, I mean, for example, uh, Mary Louise Parker in The Sound Inside. I th, I, I thought that performance was just so absolutely brilliant. So she deserves a Tony for that. She deserves a Tony if there were 500 shows nominated. So why would she get an asterisk next to her name for this Tony Award? It's not right. I understand what you're asking, of course.

[12:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[12:38] Nate Patton: Because going back to the 95 Tonys, The Lightning Thief is kind of where the parallel really strikes. Because Sunset Boulevard was the only original musical that whole season. Again, that was just a very sparse season, had nothing to do with a pandemic. But it was the only original. And suffice to say, Sunset Boulevard is not Andrew Lloyd Webber's best musical. And some people think he doesn't have a best musical. But that being said, that is certainly not his best work, but yet it was the only original work. And so it was up for best original score and best book, because it was the only musical in that category. And it won both of those.

[13:18] Patrick Oliver Jones: So there is something to be said that simply because of this weird truncated season, very arbitrarily set as far as the February 19th date, that The Lightning Thief could have for sheer being the only one, could have risen up and be like, okay, well, vote on it if you think this is the only one eligible. Vote on it if you think again it would have to reach the 60% threshold. That's a possibility. That's why I say slap in the face, because it was basically saying to The Lightning Thief, we won't even nominate you when there's no other choice.

[13:55] Nate Patton: That's what I'm, again, I haven't seen it, but that's why it's a slap in the face.

[13:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[14:00] Nate Patton: Because I'm, I'm hearing from people who did see it that they're like, we see why it wasn't nominated, even in this shortened season. So you know, yeah, because it still carries with it a very high honor. The Pulitzer Prize, for example, the Pulitzer Prize has on multiple occasions not given out a Pulitzer Prize on a certain year. They just said, you know what? You all suck, and they don't give one out. So I I've always respected the Pulitzer Committee for that in a really great way because they said, yeah, like you just because it's your, just because it's a year where there's not a lot of competition doesn't mean we're going to give one to a play that really doesn't deserve it.

[14:42] Patrick Oliver Jones: So do you think then that they should have just not had a best original score category?

[14:48] Nate Patton: Um, I think that they should have had one as they did, because I do think that some of the writing for the plays, which would be eligible in that category, were really outstanding.

[14:58] Nate Patton: So I don't think some of those were Tony nominee worthy. So to have the category completely eliminated would imply that none of those plays were deserving of any accolades. But it's certainly very rare that a play is ever nominated, so it's not like it would have been as much of a snub as it is toward Lightning Thief.

[15:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: Correct.

[15:20] Nate Patton: That's exactly correct. So I'm curious, do you think that original musicals are dying off? Because the three musicals that are up all used jukebox or previously found music. So do you think original musicals are in a flux right now?

[15:40] Nate Patton: Uh, no, I don't. I don't think that they're in flux any more than the theater business just being closed in general. If you look at what audiences have really responded to as far as buying tickets in the past, in the most recent years, you had Hamilton, was obviously the biggest, and then Dear Evan Hansen. Completely original, no star, not a jukebox, original score. This is what people are spending hundreds of dollars a ticket for. Gentleman's Guide falls into that as well.

[16:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Sure.

[16:16] Nate Patton: But I mean, Gentleman's Guide, of course, it absolutely does. And that was a great show. But that was not like a hit. I'm talking about like these mega hits.

[16:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: The juggernauts, yeah.

[16:24] Nate Patton: But I hear people say, well, Broadway’s, it's you know, it's Vegas, it's becoming it's all jukebox. I'm like, yeah, but the audiences really do still crave, and they are showing this with what they're paying for an original musical. Hamilton and Dear Evan Hansen, those are the two juggernauts of the past few years. So I don't buy the argument that audiences only want movie musicals. I actually think that there is a yearning from the audience for original material that's well written. Because look at there when it's done well, Hamilton and Evan Hansen, people are willing to come out of the work to come see it. So I don't, I think the narrative that they only want jukebox musicals is false. And also it's not really fair. I think that's not correct. But I do think that producers are putting out more jukebox or well-known material instead of original musicals. I do think there's an imbalance there.

[17:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: It's much safer.

[17:23] Nate Patton: Yeah. Because Dear Evan Hansen was an incredible gamble. When they were doing that show originally, there was no one—Ben Platt was not famous in that show. It was a creative team that we knew in the theater community, but was not known internationally like maybe they are now. And it was a show about teen suicide. I mean, there were so many risks. There was so much at stake to put that on Broadway’s. Like that really could have bombed. Not because it wasn't good, but because you could look at that as a producer and say, we have no one famous. We don't have a title anyone's heard of, and it's about kids killing themselves. I mean, who the hell wants to go to that? So it involves a good amount of risk. I just I don't really think it's that the musicals dying off. I just think that there aren't that many good ones that people are willing to spend that kind of money for. It's really, really hard to write a good musical, as is been.

[18:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, and it takes a long time to do it.

[18:27] Nate Patton: Correct. Now, with that date in mind, could they have stuck with, you know, March 12th, which is when actually everything shut down? Could they have stuck with that and used video footage or had the previews and made that count? Is there a way that they could have made it work with a March 12th date?

[18:50] Nate Patton: Um, I don't think so because how you can't guarantee that Tony nominating committee saw it. The Tony nominating committee is a very elite group of people in that it's not a huge group. Well, according to Variety Magazine, there are more than 850 Tony voters, but the actual nominating committee only has 54. You can find that full list of committee members on my Twitter account at WINMI podcast. But that's a group of like previous Tony winners, and it's people from all departments. Yeah, lighting design, Tony past winners, and set design and orchestrator. You know, there's a pretty great group of people in the Tony nominating committee. So if they didn't get to see it, then it's just not fair, you know.

[19:41] Patrick Oliver Jones: But do you think they could have used video or recordings or anything like that?

[19:45] Nate Patton: No, because you can't you can't judge someone's lighting design off of a video.

[19:49] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah, that's true.

[19:50] Nate Patton: And you also shouldn't really, and for that matter, you shouldn't really judge someone's live performance off of a video either. But you're evaluating this is it's the Tony Awards. It's the awards for live theater. It's not right to show it to someone on a video and expect them to evaluate it for a Tony Award. It's just it otherwise you'd be giving them an Oscar or an Emmy. It's not meant to be done on screen and it can't be evaluated on screen. So I don't know what the solution was. This was a really hard situation because I think a lot of people were deserving of accolades, especially that had opened.

[20:25] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[20:26] Nate Patton: Like absolutely people were deserving of awards. At the same time, though, it just sucks that it was like winning the gold medal in the Olympics when all the other athletes' buses broke down.

[20:37] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[20:38] Nate Patton: Yeah. It doesn't matter how slow you ran, you still got the gold medal. And that, you know, what do you do? You can't cancel the race.

[20:46] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, true. So what do you think this is gonna say for next year's Tonys if there is one? Because as of right now, it doesn't look like Broadway’s's gonna open up till fall of 21, maybe summer, fall of 21, which would be after the season anyway. So that means that we're talking June of 2022.

[21:09] Nate Patton: Right, would be the next Tony Awards, and they're certainly not going to go back and pick up any shows that opened or were part of this season, unless they open again, right?

[21:19] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, unless, right, unless they reopen. Like I think, you know, if Six and the Company revival and Girl from North Country, and I think if all of those shows come back, then of course they will be eligible for the next one.

[21:33] Nate Patton: Right.

[21:34] Patrick Oliver Jones: Given the cast may be dead from old age.

[21:37] Nate Patton: But I think that, yeah, of course, everyone will be eligible if you open a railway for the Tonys. But the awards won't be for the till the following June.

[21:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah. It's also why they had to do something now for this one, because otherwise you would be voting on Tina Turner the musical in June of 2022. I mean, like it people would be like, what did I see that, you know what I mean? Like it would be so it would be two years after the fact.

[22:09] Nate Patton: So you definitely think they should have had the Tony Awards this year?

[22:13] Patrick Oliver Jones: Like maybe they should have done the summer whenever they actually set that February 19th date.

[22:18] Nate Patton: I don't think they should have had them. I think that they should have done some acknowledgement of what they thought was excellent. I think it's an unprecedented situation, and I think it should have been handled in an unprecedented way. Like most, they postponed their awards at first, but once they realized the shutdown wasn't going to be temporary, they decided to move forward in a way that was respectful to both the theater industry and the outside world. Quote, by creating a sense of communal joy at a time when we all need it most. So the Outer Critics Circle, also celebrating their 70th anniversary, made the decision to forego the competition aspect and have the organization's members determine up to five names in each of their twenty-six categories.

There would be no winners, only a list of honorees. And they ended up announcing these honorees on their original reveal date back in May. Now, one way the Outer Critic Circle differ from the Tonys is that they include both Broadway’s and off-Broadway shows. But this year there was another key difference. The Outer Critic Circle eligibility date was set at March sixth, allowing for almost a hundred and seventy productions to be considered, including a host of those not eligible for the Tony, like West Side Story. However, just like the Tonys, the Lightning Thief was once again shut out completely.

[24:05] Nate Patton: I gotta tell you, I would love to have been a fly on the wall as the Tony nominating committee was figuring out their own approach to these awards. I think it would have involved a lot of discussion, but I think if it was like not that it would ever be up to one person. I'm sure that they all didn't agree on this, by the way. Like we're all sort of we're like, shame on you, Tony committee. But I'm like, do you think they all agreed? You know they were in the, I mean, I'm sure they couldn't agree on anything about how to do this. I'm sure, I'm sure there were plenty of Tony nominating committee. Plenty that said, Don't do it. There's no way that at least half of them probably didn't want to even do this in the first place.

And I'm sure half of them disagreed with nominating one person for best actor. Like, you know, it must have been a mess. I think if I were on the Tony nominating committee, I would have voted to give some recognition to the people that deserved it, but not do a whole Tony Awards.

[25:01] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, a Tony citation or something.

[25:03] Nate Patton: Something. I don't know. But again, I really I keep saying this, but I feel for them because it's a really it's a no-win situation. If they had done nothing, that wouldn't have really been right either. So I don't envy the position they were in to have to figure this out. Normally the announcement of Tony nominees is met with excitement and predictions. But did you see the headlines after this year's nominations came out? I mean, some of them used words like erratic and shocking. The Washington Post, for example, said the Tony nominations have been announced, and they are the weirdest ever. Theater Mania wrote, the Tonys point a middle finger at the Lightning Thief. Boy, did they ever? The New York Post simply put it the 2020 Tony Award nominations were weird and sad.

[26:02] Nate Patton: And that's so, you see, that's part of the reason why I think the instinct to do it in the first place was wrong. Because that's so unfair to someone like Danny Bernstein, who is going to win a Tony this year and has, by the way, deserved to win a Tony about 600 other times and never has. And now he's nominated, and they're like the sad Tony nominations. I'm like, you know, F off. Because it's just not, and I also felt the same way. Mary Louise Parker, Adrian Warren, they all deserve to win Tonys. Oren Patton, all of them. I mean, like, I, you know, and I just don't think it's right to say it's the lame Tonys when they deserve to win a real one.

[26:43] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right. There's been a hashtag going around called the tiny awards instead of Tony Awards.

[26:47] Nate Patton: I actually thought maybe Aaron Tveit, it would have been really interesting. I know he's not going to do this. I'm sure he probably isn't allowed to if he wanted to. What would have happened if he said I'm declining this nomination?

[26:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah.

[26:59] Nate Patton: I thought about that too. If he just said, I'm honored, I'm, you know, I'm so honored to have the nomination, but I'm going to decline it. I think that actually would have propelled him further. I think if I think he would have been so in the news for being the great American hero to theater if he just said, Thank you so much. I won't, I can't accept this, and to not take the Tony. That would have been insane, but it would have been so I think classy and elegant and just made him look great. By the way, I like Aaron Tveit a lot. So I'm not saying I love him. And next to normal, he was fantastic. So I love his work. And he's also a good human being too. Like he's a good guy. People like working with him.

And I know him, but you know, sort of. We're not close friends, but we have worked together. Yeah, like he's a really good guy. So I refuse to ever speak ill of him because he, as I said when we started this conversation, he doesn't deserve to have anything said bad about him for this.

[28:06] Patrick Oliver Jones: When the nominations came out, Aaron Tveit and all the nominees released their statements and reactions. Tveit said, It's a huge honor, and I am so grateful to be nominated. It's also vitally important to highlight that this recognition represents collectively thousands of hours of work by hundreds of individuals working on Moulin Rouge the Musical. All the brilliant craftspeople, technicians, stage hands, and crew that run our show night to night, those in the front and back of the house, inside and outside our stage doors, our incredible audience and fans, and of course the cast, creative team, and producers. A day hasn't gone by since the shutdown began that I haven't missed the theater, and I look forward to when we can all return.

[29:12] Nate Patton: Now that was a very nicely worded sentiment. Gracious and acknowledged the full team of people that went into making Moulin Rouge happen.

[29:29] Patrick Oliver Jones: Like a publicist wrote that.

[29:31] Nate Patton: I mean, he's the only nominee worth mentioning, maybe. It was just a little too verbose and robotic in its language. Like it could have been written any old year. Like it's just a regular Tony Award season. Did you read all of the responses from everybody? They all sounded like that.

[29:52] Nate Patton: Yeah, they all sounded like someone else wrote it in another time. That's exactly correct. And I just didn't believe that any of them actually said what they wrote. The rest of the response I've read them in the past, and normally they're like, I'm freaking out, I'm in the bathroom screaming, you know, like something like that. And this year, they were like, I just want to take a minute to acknowledge the American Theater Wing and how grateful. It was very formal and very, it was weird. It seemed like the American Theater Wing wrote them.

[30:24] Patrick Oliver Jones: That's, I think that they did.

[30:26] Nate Patton: And I think that they probably signed it. You know, it's like what it's like when Mike Tyson writes an autobiography. Someone wrote it and then he said, okay. Yeah, it just seemed strange.

[30:39] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, I thought so too.

[30:42] Nate Patton: So I guess we should get to who do we think is going to win these. You know, we talked about it. Aaron Tveit.

[30:48] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right, right.

[30:49] Nate Patton: That I think that's the only one that we can almost certainly guarantee. But as far as the musicals that are up, it's Tina Turner, Moulin Rouge, and Jagged Little Pill.

[30:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: There you go.

[31:00] Nate Patton: To me, there's no, I don't see too many surprises happening in any of the categories. Well, the design categories, I have no idea because that's always a tough one to call. But the major categories, directing, and I think there's no question. I mean, best musical will be Moulin Rouge, actress will be Adrienne Warren without a doubt. Um, actor will be Aaron Tveit. I think um featured actor will be Danny Burstein as sure as the day is long. There's no zero percent chance for anybody else. And um, best featured actress is a little more complicated, but I would say 98% Lauren Patton. Uh who's not my sister, by the way. People ask me for related. We look nothing alike. Lauren Patton for Jagged Little Pill. I would be shocked if she did not win.

[31:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[31:54] Nate Patton: So yeah, so plays kind of outweighed musicals this year, as far as nominations, as far as, you know, great stuff that came out. Even with Apple Serving, even without the other plays that were supposed to open this fall, there was a really good category.

[32:09] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, yeah, it was a strong category. Like there were some performances in plays that I saw that were totally deserving of a nomination that didn't get nominated this year because the category was so intense.

[32:20] Nate Patton: So it was definitely a strong year for plays, even though it was shortened. If it had, if the plays this spring had opened, it would have been the most insane year for plays ever. Because it was already an insane category, and we didn't get half of the nominations available. We didn't even open Laurie Metcalf in Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, who you know she was gonna win the third Tony in four years for that, right?

[32:44] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[32:44] Nate Patton: It's the Laurie Metcalf repertory theater. She was in a play on this on 45th Street every spring, and she wins a Tony. Deserving, if she's listening, she's always deserving if she's listening, she deserves all of them, and then one more after that. The sheer fact that she wakes up every day should get a Tony Award as just a thank you. Just brushing her teeth is a nomination, right?

[33:08] Patrick Oliver Jones: And speaking of someone who's always nominated, Audra McDonald, of course.

[33:12] Nate Patton: Frankie and Johnny, yeah. Do you think that she got the nomination because of who she is?

[33:17] Patrick Oliver Jones: No, she was brilliant.

[33:18] Nate Patton: I saw that. I would app she could win. I mean, she always could win. Um, she was superb in that show, and very different. That production was beautiful. And she was transformative in that performance. It was nothing, she completely shed her normal elegance and regal quality that she sort of has when she's on stage as a singer. And she was sort of gritty and down, and she was unbelievable. The fact that Michael Shannon did not get a nomination, I don't know who else is in that category, but that should indicate also how ridiculous that category must have been because he was also amazing.

[33:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: So, you know, it's a crazy, that was a really must have been a great year.

[34:03] Nate Patton: And do you think that the nominations that were there, particularly in the play category? Because along with the pandemic, there had been a lot of social and racial unrest and issues that have come up, both in the country but also in theater. Do you think these Tony Awards gave an acknowledgement of that in some way?

[34:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: I mean, their Slave Play, obviously, which racked up, you know, the most of any play ever. But beyond that, do you think?

[34:29] Nate Patton: No, I don't think so. I mean, I think that they just picked who they thought were the strongest ones. I don't think there was any affirmative action when it came to Tony votes, and there weren't enough nominees for the musicals for anybody to argue anything. Of course, no one was gonna say, oh, why weren't there more of X, Y, and Z when they nominated everything that was open? I don't think the Tonys do that. You know what I mean? I think that Tony, I think this is made up of a committee of other Tony past Tony winners and theater artists, and I think that they really go with their with who is deserving. And I think, as we've seen many times, the people that are most deserving are women and people of color.

[35:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[35:14] Nate Patton: So we don't have to give them the leg up because they don't need it. You know, they're, I mean, they are absolutely deserving of any awards that they've gotten. Is anyone gonna, I mean, Audra McDonald has the most Tonys of any living actor.

[35:27] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[35:28] Nate Patton: Is anyone gonna say she got them because she was black? Or a woman?

[35:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: No.

[35:33] Nate Patton: No one's saying that. Trust me, because it's also, it's just not true.

[35:36] Patrick Oliver Jones: No.

[35:39] Nate Patton: So no, I don't think so. I don't think, especially not this year. I don't think anyone catered to that. Nor did they really need to, because as you said, there was a strong showing of plays that had a list of nominations that could have gone out to even more than they had.

[35:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah, of course.

[35:59] Nate Patton: Yeah.

[36:02] Patrick Oliver Jones: Do you think that the reaction so far of Broadway’s of, well, it'll be January?

[36:08] Nate Patton: No, it'll be spring, summer, and now fall is when it's looking. Do you think that it's right that it keeps pushing it?

[36:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: What do you mean, is it right?

[36:17] Nate Patton: Do you agree with that response? That's basically what I'm trying to say.

[36:20] Patrick Oliver Jones: Um, not entirely. I think that there could be much more proactive work happening than there is as opposed to just saying, shut down, shut down, shut down. They're not taking any steps to reopen. None. They're just delaying until you can just go back in full capacity. No one's talking about ventilation systems. I mean, it's just, or I mean, if they are, they're not talking about it publicly. Maybe they're happening in closed meetings, but there's no, where is the community? Where is the head of our industry getting out there being like, here's the plan, here's what we're doing, here's the steps. Here's option A, here's option B. It's just, it's dead silence. There's nothing, there's no conversation about it.

[37:04] Nate Patton: I really believe after this last announcement that it's gonna be until June 30th. I think a lot of people left the business that day. I really do.

[37:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: Um, not me, but I do think a lot of people left.

[37:21] Nate Patton: Because I think that was the point they said, I'm gonna have to do something else in the interim. And if I'm gonna do something else, I may as well just do something else.

[37:33] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[37:34] Nate Patton: So do you think that the pandemic itself will affect how shows are produced or made once we do reopen again? Or do you think it's just gonna go back to the same old, same old normal once we're back?

[37:46] Patrick Oliver Jones: I mean, I feel like you have to know what I'm gonna say, which is that it's gonna change it in every capacity. And I think it's gonna change it more than we think. Not only is it gonna change it, I think it's gonna be beyond. I don't know how it's going to change yet. A lot of people, of course, think that they know, but I don't think we will really know how it's gonna change it until we look back in history, you know, 25 years from now. We'll say here's what, here's the direction it went.

[38:14] Nate Patton: Yeah.

[38:15] Patrick Oliver Jones: My instinct right now tells me that people are going to want comedies and happy shows when we're coming out of this. I don't think people are going to want um overly woke political theater. I think that we have been so overly satirized with that in the media and the news and social media, we're gonna really want theater to be an escape. That's just my gut instinct, but there's no way of knowing.

[38:47] Nate Patton: You know, Mama Mia, a lot of people say was an international phenomenon because of 9/11. Mama Mia opened like about a week before 9/11 or something like that.

[38:59] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right, right.

[39:00] Nate Patton: And that show just became a huge, huge hit. And people have always speculated, was it because of 9/11 that Mama Mia just took off? Because it required, it was not political, it required no critical thinking. It didn't have any agenda politically. People went insane for it. It was, it was what it was just a party. That was it.

[39:20] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[39:21] Nate Patton: And it was such a relief. So, uh same with the, you know, the producers opened a little bit like that, but that spring before 9/11.

[39:30] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[39:30] Nate Patton: Yeah, yeah. People just wanted the producers. They wanted Mama Mia. Those were the two hits of that year. I wonder if we'll see the same thing. They're gonna want a Christmas Carol. I think they're gonna want Music Man, honestly. I think they're, I think these are, these, I think Music Man will be huge when it, they'll be ready.

[39:49] Patrick Oliver Jones: Oh, yeah.

[39:50] Nate Patton: It was going to be huge regardless. But I think it might be really huge now. For me, I hope that the pandemic will show producers two things that maybe it doesn't need to cost 30 million to put on a musical, that maybe there's a way that we can cut these costs. And, you know, because I think that's one of the things that's keeping shows from, yeah, it's, it's not being able to sell tickets, not being able to make a million dollars a week to keep a show running. So they're just not gonna do it.

[40:21] Patrick Oliver Jones: So I think that's part of it.

[40:23] Nate Patton: And then secondly, um, I hope that video, as we're now having to do with online stuff, that video will start to incorporate and equity and SAG will get their act together and be able to work together and make theater have a video component when it's, it's services and when it's, uh appropriate.

[40:45] Patrick Oliver Jones: It's interesting.

[40:46] Nate Patton: But when theater has a video component, is it still theater or is it now video?

[40:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, I think that the music industry, that a song, a pop song, is still a musical piece, even though it has a music video. It's still, it's still that the song, the lyrics, the composition of the melody is still the essential element, even though you've now added a video part to it.

[41:12] Nate Patton: Yeah, I'm really, I really I was asking that, that wasn't rhetorical. I mean, I wonder, yeah, what I, I don't know. I mean, people still go to football games, even though you can watch one on TV.

[41:23] Patrick Oliver Jones: Yeah.

[41:24] Nate Patton: It never televising sports never stopped people from going in person. I agree with you that there is something special that is a stage production that isn't TV or film.

[41:35] Patrick Oliver Jones: So yes, that is correct.

[41:36] Nate Patton: And I don't think that's ever going to change.

[41:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: No.

[41:39] Nate Patton: But I hope that equity in particular can start to embrace when things can be on video, when things can be, you know, performed in New York, but yet someone in Iowa can see it, or vice versa.

[41:53] Patrick Oliver Jones: It's gonna change for sure.

[41:55] Nate Patton: Yeah, you're, I agree with you. It's because this is happening whether we like it or not.

[42:00] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[42:01] Nate Patton: So we just gotta figure out how it's gonna work. There's, we've opened up, we've uncorked the bottle. You know what I mean? It's, it's, we're not going back.

[42:11] Patrick Oliver Jones: So I'll be curious to see.

[42:13] Nate Patton: Yep, exactly.

[42:14] Patrick Oliver Jones: All right. Well, were there any other like final thoughts that you had about the Tonys themselves?

[42:18] Nate Patton: No, I'm curious to see when they schedule them for. I think it's the fact that they gave the nominations and they're like, uh, I got around to it. I suspect what's going on is that they're trying to get performances.

[42:32] Patrick Oliver Jones: And uh good luck.

[42:34] Nate Patton: Because nobody's gonna want to pay for that when you can't sell a ticket.

[42:38] Patrick Oliver Jones: Right.

[42:39] Nate Patton: No, no show wants. I mean, first of all, the shows are gonna be lucky if they reopen, let's be honest. And now you're gonna ask them to pay money to advertise when they can't sell? No. This is why there's a, this is why they haven't picked a date. It's like when you haven't picked the date for the wedding because you're not really sure if you love the other person.

[42:58] Patrick Oliver Jones: It's, it's, they can't commit to this because they don't know what they're gonna do for the ceremony.

[43:06] Nate Patton: Yeah, but yeah, because it was just remarkable to me that they gave no notice of the nominations, but then along with that, no hint of when the show's gonna be. It's just very telling, I think, of the whole process this year of theater.

[43:22] Patrick Oliver Jones: I know it's, it's insane.

[43:24] Nate Patton: It's insane, it's literally insane.

[43:31] Patrick Oliver Jones: 2020 continues to be a strange year, full of the unexpected and unprecedented. What do you think of the Tony Awards? Uh, how did you react? Excited, ambivalent, somewhere in between. Connect with me on Twitter at winMe Podcast and not only check out the articles I've mentioned in today's episode, but share your own response to these nominations. I'm so curious if you agree with Nate and I or have a completely different perspective on these nominations. A big thank you to Nate for sharing his thoughts today, and I am certainly grateful to you for joining our conversation.

[44:10] Patrick Oliver Jones: Well, I'm your host, Patrick Oliver Jones, and coming up on the podcast is a month-long series of bettering ourselves and bettering our careers. You'll hear from psychologists, a publicist, a marketing, branding coach, and even a professional athlete. They'll be giving their own perspectives on how we can better manage our own lives and the work that we do, especially in this downtime for theater in the arts. So join me and these special guests as we talk more about why I'll never make it.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred